Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- A SON AND DAUGHTER'S APPEAL TO XI JINPING TO RELEASE THEIR FATHER, JIMMY LAI [Joint House and Senate Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] A SON AND DAUGHTER'S APPEAL TO XI JINPING TO RELEASE THEIR FATHER, JIMMY LAI ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ SEPTEMBER 16, 2026 __________ Printed for the use of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available at www.cecc.gov or www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-578 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA LEGISLATIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS Senate House DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska, Chair CHRIS SMITH, New Jersey, Co-chair TOM COTTON, Arkansas ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon ELISE STEFANIK, New York TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois DALE STRONG, Alabama ANDY KIM, New Jersey JEN KIGGANS, Virginia LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware JAMES P. McGOVERN, Massachusetts THOMAS SUOZZI, New York SUHAS SUBRAMANYAM, Virginia JAMES WALKINSHAW, Virginia EXECUTIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS To be appointed Scott Flipse, Staff Director Mary Vigil, Deputy Staff Director (ii) C O N T E N T S ---------- Statements Opening Statement of Hon. Chris Smith, a Representative from New Jersey; Co-chair, Congressional-Executive Commission on China.. 1 Statement of Sebastien Lai, son of Jimmy Lai and leader of the #FreeJimmy Lai campaign........................................ 4 Statement of Steve Yates, Senior Research Fellow for China and National Security and Chung Ju Yung Fellow, The Heritage Foundation..................................................... 5 Statement of Mark L. Clifford, President, Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation and author, ``The Troublemaker,'' a biography of Jimmy Lai......................................... 7 APPENDIX Prepared Statements Lai, Sebastien................................................... 17 Yates, Steve..................................................... 18 Clifford Mark L.................................................. 21 Sullivan, Hon. Dan............................................... 23 Smith, Hon. Chris................................................ 24 Submissions for the Record Submission of Alex Chow, democracy activist and Secretary-General of the Hong Kong Federation of Students during the 2014 Umbrella Movement.............................................. 27 Submissio of Megan Khoo, Policy Director, Hong Kong Watch........ 35 Letter to the Chairs from Dr. Jianli Yang, Citizen Power Initiatives for China, and Dr. Mary Moran, Department of Education (retired)............................................ 37 Letter to the Chairs from Jodie Ginsberg, CEO, Committee to Protect Journalists............................................ 39 Submission of Chi-Sang Poon, Ph.D., founder and editor-in-chief, Hong Kong Rule of Law Initiative, entitled ``Jimmy Lai and Two Problems Lord Sumption Identified: Sedition and NPCSC Interpretation''............................................... 41 Submission of Thomas E. Kellogg and Ignatius Luk, Georgetown Center for Asian Law........................................... 47 CECC Truth in Testimony Disclosure Form.......................... 53 Witness Biographies.............................................. 55 (iii) A SON AND DAUGHTER'S APPEAL TO XI JINPING TO RELEASE THEIR FATHER, JIMMY LAI ---------- WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 2026 Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Washington, DC. The hearing was held from 9:36 a.m. to 10:24 a.m., in Room 2255, Rayburn House Office Building, Washington, DC, Representative Chris Smith, Co-chair, Congressional-Executive Commission on China, presiding. OPENING STATEMENT OF CHRIS SMITH, A REPRESENTATIVE FROM NEW JERSEY AND CO-CHAIR, CONGRESSIONAL- EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA Co-chair Smith. The Commission will come to order. First of all, I want to thank our very distinguished witnesses for being here. And I want to thank C-SPAN for being here. You know, they have the sole authority to pick what they cover, when they cover it, and they have been kind enough and gracious enough to come here today because they want to hear, especially from you, Sebastien, on behalf of your father, but also from our other very distinguished witnesses. So thank you to them for getting this message out to the American public, especially in this very timely fashion on the eve of the summit with President Trump and Xi Jinping. Today's hearing is about Jimmy Lai, and an earnest appeal to Xi Jinping from Jimmy's children to set him free on humanitarian grounds. They are grateful, the family, that President Trump has personally raised Jimmy Lai's release with Xi Jinping, and they respectfully ask him to do so again at the upcoming summit. We will hear directly from Jimmy Lai's son, Sebastien, speaking for himself and on behalf of his sister Claire, who was initially scheduled to join her brother today. Sadly, Claire was recently diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and has begun treatment. We are thinking of her, we are praying for her, and wishing her a full recovery. Sebastien, who has been tenacious on behalf of his dad, testified on behalf of his father back in 2023, and he will speak to us again momentarily. He says in his prepared statement, and I say in part, ``My father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from a maximum security prison. He cannot hold her hand. She wants nothing more than to have him with her for this fight. We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her and for a 78- year-old man who has already suffered enough. . . . Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment.'' Jimmy Lai is 78 years old, as we all know. He has spent six years in detention. In February a Hong Kong court sentenced him to 20 years in prison following his conviction under the national security law. It was the longest sentence thus far imposed under that law. For a man of Jimmy Lai's age and given the seriousness of his health concerns, a 20-year sentence carries an obvious and deeply troubling humanitarian consequence. His son Sebastien has described it as a death sentence. And that is why time matters. Jimmy Lai is not being imprisoned because he committed any act of violence whatsoever. His son has emphasized that his father has never, never advocated violence. Rather, Jimmy Lai used his voice, his newspaper, and his public platform to support freedom and democracy. As we all know, he founded Apple Daily, a newspaper that became one of Hong Kong's most prominent pro-democracy publications. The newspaper was forced to close in 2021 after authorities arrested its senior executives and froze its assets. Jimmy Lai himself was arrested in August 2020 and subsequently prosecuted under Hong Kong's national security law. His case therefore raises fundamental questions about the meaning of freedom of expression and freedom of the press in Hong Kong today. It also raises very serious questions about the rule of law. Hong Kong was promised a high degree of autonomy and preservation of its existing legal and social systems under the one country, two systems framework. Matter of fact, in the Sino-U.K. agreement they promised for 50 years that the Basic Law would remain in effect. And the Basic Law looks a lot like our own Bill of Rights. It's an amazing law. The British were able to come to an agreement when they handed over Hong Kong that all of these protections would be preserved for at least 50 years. It's not 50 years, unfortunately. Our Commission has investigated this very vigorously. The Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act, which I sponsored, was written by our staffer over here, Scott Flipse. We introduced it in 2014, as the Umbrella Revolution was taking hold, and 5 years later or so it became law. Marco Rubio played a key role on the Senate side. We did it on the House side. And it's the law. And it recognizes that, yes, we want that special character of Hong Kong. I'm surprised Xi Jinping doesn't see that this is in his own interest, in terms of economics. But they are choosing a different path, regrettably. Jimmy Lai's case is an embodiment of what has happened to so many of the best and the brightest in Hong Kong. Joshua Wong and all of these other great people who--and I've met with him. He's now going to be sentenced, and very severely so. What an amazing guy, as are these others, who just say--in a nonviolent way--we want freedom and democracy for Hong Kong. And we want it for all of China, really, but Hong Kong, let's start there. So it's very, very troubling. This is all about whether or not journalists can report freely, when the government can shut down a newspaper and prosecute its publisher. It's about whether a society can retain meaningful freedom of speech, when criticizing those in power becomes a national security offense. It's about whether courts can remain generally independent, when so-called national security laws are used against political opponents and critics. And it's about whether the promises made, again, to the people of Hong Kong, will have meaning. We should also remember the human dimension of this case. For more than five years Jimmy Lai's children have had to live with the reality that their father is in prison thousands and thousands of miles away. Sebastien has spoken publicly and with great eloquence and grace about his father. I mean, what a chip off the ol' block, you know, the love and the compassion that he shows for his dad. And the same goes for Grace Jin Drexel [and her father, Ezra Jin Mingri]. So my hope--our hope, as a Commission--the Congress's hope, because we passed a resolution calling for his release, is that Xi Jinping will see clear to do it when he meets with our president. Claire has spoken about her father's deteriorating health as well, and the increasingly limited information about his medical condition. Claire has also spoken about something I think is so important to understand, about his faith, his faith in God. He's a Catholic. She said that her father is not in prison because he's a Catholic, but that his faith has been a major source of the courage that he has shown throughout this ordeal. She gave me a print of a wonderful picture that he painted, drew, of Our Lady, and it's hanging very prominently in my office. And every day that I see it, I pray for his release. The combination of faith and courage is part of Jimmy Lai's story, and it should not be left out. And why do they persecute someone because they believe in the Almighty? It's just too much. Yesterday, Senator Sullivan, who is the chair, I'm co- chair, of this Commission--and he's a great, great senator and cares deeply about Jimmy Lai. We introduced the Hong Kong Political Prisoner Accountability Act of 2026 to establish a clear framework for accountability if Hong Kong political prisoners were to die in custody as a result of inadequate medical care, abuse, inhumane conditions, or other actions or omissions by detaining authorities. Who can forget Liu Xiaobo, who suffered so horribly from cancer and couldn't even go and receive his Nobel Peace Prize, and died in prison? Well, we need to work on that really, really strongly. Without objection, my full statement will be made a part of the record. I want to thank our witnesses, and I would now like to introduce our panel. We are joined first by Sebastien Lai, who leads the international campaign to secure the release of his father, Jimmy Lai. Sebastien has worked tirelessly to ensure that his father's case remains a priority for the governments, and that includes the U.K. government because he is a U.K. citizen, and legislatures around the world. He is no stranger to this Commission. As I said, he testified with great eloquence and compassion in 2023. And we welcome him back today. We will also hear from Mr. Steve Yates. Thank you, Mr. Yates, for being here. He's a senior research fellow for China and National Security and Chung Ju Yung fellow at The Heritage Foundation. Mr. Yates brings decades of experience in national security and China policy, including service in the White House as a senior national security advisor to Vice President Dick Cheney, and as president of Radio Free Asia. He will also help us consider how the U.S. can use diplomacy and other policy tools to press for Jimmy Lai's release and hold Beijing and Hong Kong authorities accountable. And then we'll hear, and we welcome, Dr. Mark Clifford, president of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation, and author of ``The Troublemaker,'' his biography of Jimmy Lai. Dr. Clifford knows him, Jimmy, personally, and has served as board director of Next Digital, publisher of Apple Daily, when Hong Kong authorities forced the newspaper to close. He brings both a personal understanding of Jimmy Lai's story and deep experience in Hong Kong journalism, press freedom, and the rule of law. I would like to turn the floor over to you, Mr. Lai, for such time as you may consume. STATEMENT OF SEBASTIEN LAI, SON OF JIMMY LAI AND LEADER, #FREEJIMMYLAI CAMPAIGN Mr. Lai. Thank you, Co-chairman Smith, as well as other members of this Commission, and Chairman Sullivan. As you mentioned, my sister Claire was to testify beside me today. A few weeks ago, she was diagnosed with cancer. I was with her in London last week as she began chemotherapy. My father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from a maximum security prison. He cannot hold her hand. Claire wants nothing more than to have him with her for this fight. We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her and for a 78-year-old man who has already suffered enough. I want to thank America, President Trump--who has been a true champion of my father's--his administration, and the senators and members of both parties whose support has never wavered and only gotten stronger. This is moral courage and my family does not take it for granted. By the end of this year, my father will have spent six years in a maximum security prison, in solitary. At 78, he is the oldest political prisoner in Hong Kong. With a 20-year sentence looming over him, if he's not freed soon, he will most likely die in prison. But the real question is, for what? Three times in his life my father has already paid dearly for freedom. The first time it cost him his childhood. He was a porter at the Guangzhou Railway Station when a traveler from Hong Kong tipped him a bar of chocolate. He figured that if this came from Hong Kong, Hong Kong must be heaven. At 12, he hid in the bottom of a fishing boat to get there. And for the first time in his life, he tasted freedom. The second time, it cost him what many thought was his life's work. He started on a factory floor and ended up with a clothing empire. Then came Tiananmen. My father wrote what he thought of the man who ordered the massacre. And Beijing gave him a simple choice, your stores on the mainland or your conscience. He sold the company, walking away from the largest market on Earth and built a newspaper instead, on the principle that information is choice, and choice is freedom. Its first editorial asked, Are we not afraid of 1997, of the handover? Of course we are, but we refuse to be intimidated by fear. The third time it cost him everything. In 2020, the National Security Law was imposed in Hong Kong by the Chinese government, criminalizing overnight any form of democratic expression past and present. So 60 years after that fishing boat, my father again faced the decision he faced as a boy, to stay or to run. Only now he had far more to lose by staying, and far more to protect. He stayed for our beliefs, and he stayed to protect others. That is the man they have in prison. What happens now is no longer a test of my father's courage. It is a test of ours. America understands in its bones that freedom dies with the last man willing to defend it and that the cost of not standing up for liberty is not felt until it is too late. In my father, this nation has found a kindred spirit. A week from now, President Xi will be a guest in this city. Our appeal to him is simple. My father poses no threat. His imprisonment makes him a symbol of injustice. His death in prison would be a disgrace. Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family, and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment. Co-chair Smith. Thank you very much, Sebastien, for that testimony, and for the appeal that we hope will be heard at the White House as well as in Beijing. And if anyone can persuade both parties, and I know the President will raise it. And having a guy like Marco Rubio, who used to co-chair this Commission--you know, he gets it 100 percent. I know it will be elevated, and your voice will be heard. We are joined today by Paul Protic. Paul is in the back. Paul was the chief of staff for the China Commission for years, and did a wonderful job. And Jonathan Stivers also--great job-- and he continues to do that work on the other commission. And we want to thank him for his leadership, bipartisan, working for Nancy Pelosi, for so many years. And, of course, Paul Protic had worked on my behalf as chief of staff. I want to thank them both for their leadership. I'd now like to yield the floor to Steve Yates. STATEMENT OF STEVE YATES, SENIOR RESEARCH FELLOW FOR CHINA AND NATIONAL SECURITY, AND CHUNG JU YUNG FELLOW, THE HERITAGE FOUNDATION Mr. Yates. Thank you very much, Chairman, distinguished members of the Commission, especially to Sebastien for his personal witness. A son's testimony for his father is an incredibly powerful witness. I hope that, humbly, I can make a small contribution to talk a bit about the man, about the policy history, and about the summit. I'll try to be brief. My name is Steve Yates. I serve as Senior Research Fellow for China and National Security at The Heritage Foundation. I appear in my personal capacity, and the views expressed are my own. First, the man China cannot abide. I first met Jimmy Lai in the late 1990s as a young policy analyst, in the period immediately following Hong Kong's transfer from British to Chinese sovereignty. In the years that followed, I was privileged to meet him at his home in Hong Kong, in Taiwan, and during visits to the United States. Conversations with Jimmy always combined substance and character. They ranged across his extraordinary personal journey in business and public life, faith, China's evolution under the Communist Party of China, Hong Kong's historical role at the intersection of opportunity and control. He rose from poverty as a migrant child to great success, twice, in entirely different and highly competitive industries. I've never met anyone like that. He carried a deep and visceral identification with the hardships borne by Chinese people under the Party's economic and political policies. As documentaries before his imprisonment make plain, he has a heartfelt desire for the genuine liberation of the Chinese people to fulfill their potential. The truth is, Jimmy Lai is the highest-profile political prisoner in Party custody not because of what he has done, but because of who he is. He represents a form of genuine Chinese identity the Party cannot abide, a citizen who lifted himself and many others from poverty to success entirely outside the political patronage system, a citizen who places his faith in his fellow man above the Party, in that vision that is widely shared by traditional Chinese families. The foundation of America's approach to Hong Kong rests on a series of geopolitical wagers--the opening of China after the Cultural Revolution, the promises of reform and opening in the Deng Xiaoping era, the sunset of the British Empire marked by the Sino-British Joint Declaration, and the post-Cold War conviction that engagement and integration would bring China into alignment with widely held international norms. The promises of one country, two systems, and eventual universal suffrage, enshrined in Hong Kong's Basic Law rest on those wagers. Many, including me, held those assumptions in good faith. The evidence from the 1990s to the present argues overwhelmingly against their wisdom. Reality intervened. Original policy assumptions premised on Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy within the People's Republic have given way to the need to treat Hong Kong as one country, one system. Unfortunately, the Sino-British Joint Declaration is now treated as a historical artifact. In practice, the international covenants are disregarded. Appeals to or by international institutions or Great Britain have minimal effect at this stage. Congress, with the support of the executive branch, has made a meaningful adjustment in Hong Kong policy with the Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act and the Hong Kong Autonomy Act. Together, those statutes include a range of penalties for those who undermine the commitments of the Joint Declaration and the Basic Law. President Trump has twice raised the case directly with Xi Jinping, appealing for Mr. Lai's release, citing his age and health after a long trial, and suggesting that a release would serve bilateral relations and China's standing. I believe the President was moved to raise this case by Jimmy Lai's extraordinary life, and still more by the absolute devotion of Jimmy's children in making the case for their father's release. That case is more compelling today, with Claire Lai having shared her cancer diagnosis publicly. As a father who held his daughter's hand through truly terrible circumstances and ultimately lost her, I can attest there has been no greater pain in my life. Not being permitted to hold her hand through those times would have been unimaginably worse. Xi Jinping, China, should not be making a dying man and a daughter confronting grave illness endure additional cruelty in the service of a political trophy. This is no longer principally an appeal to law, foreign or domestic. It is a litmus test of whether there remains any reason to believe there is a future in Xi Jinping's China for the kind of man that Jimmy Lai is--a child of God, a lover of the real China, and one of China's greatest entrepreneurs. The loss of that hope is what broke the wagers on which policy was founded. This may be one of the last tests of whether that break is a temporary defect or an enduring feature of the system. A release would not restore 1997. It would not revive the Apple Daily. It would tell the world, and it would tell President Trump, that Chairman Xi can still choose mercy when the world is watching. That is a signal about leadership. It is a signal about whether any understanding with this counterpart is worth the paper on which it is written. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Co-chair Smith. Thank you so much, Mr. Yates, for that very eloquent testimony. I'd now like to yield to Dr. Clifford. STATEMENT OF MARK L. CLIFFORD, PRESIDENT, COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM IN HONG KONG FOUNDATION, AND AUTHOR OF ``THE TROUBLEMAKER,'' A BIOGRAPHY OF JIMMY LAI Mr. Clifford. Well, thank you very much, Co-chair Smith. I also want to thank the honorable members of the Commission for the opportunity to testify today, and above all, for your support for Jimmy Lai in the cause of Hong Kong freedom. Now, when President Trump hosts Chinese Communist Party General Secretary Xi Jinping next week, the General Secretary is expected to bring along a large entourage of business leaders. But it's ironic that perhaps the greatest business entrepreneur that we've seen in the postwar period, Jimmy Lai, will be sitting in solitary confinement. He won't be joining President Xi. He won't be helping develop China's economy. He won't be creating the thousands of jobs, the millions of dollars of wealth that he previously created. And I think it's very telling that Xi Jinping would rather have one of the greatest businessmen of his generation in jail than helping develop the country. My predecessors on this panel have talked about how Jimmy's in prison, the story of freedom in Hong Kong, how freedom was crushed as China broke its promises to the people of Hong Kong and to the world. But I think it's important to underscore that it wasn't just the existing way of life. Hong Kong people were to throw off the colonial yoke after Britain left. They were to be masters of their own house. They were to have universal suffrage, as was mentioned before. And Jimmy is in jail because he wanted to hold China to these promises. I'm proud to have known Jimmy since 1993. As Co-chairman Smith mentioned, I served on the board of directors of his media company. And I was there as the government crushed-- illegally crushed--the company. I think it's important to put Jimmy in a historical context. He's a man. He's a father. He's a fantastic host. He's a wonderful person. He is one of a kind. None of us will ever meet anybody else like Jimmy. But he's unique in Chinese history. Few people, of course, have had the courage to stand up against the Chinese Communist Party. One of those who did, Co-chairman Smith, you mentioned, Nobel Peace Prize winner Liu Xiaobo made the ultimate sacrifice, paying for his principles with his life, dying while in Chinese custody. We're here today because this may be our best last chance to ensure that Jimmy doesn't suffer the same fate. Jimmy is unique in that he has principles, that he's willing to sacrifice for them, and, of course, he had financial resources and he had a media empire, which the Party found intolerable. And Jimmy knew what he was doing. I remember seeing him on the stage of the Grand Hyatt Hotel in June 1997, a few weeks before the handover, where Al Neuharth, founder of USA Today, did a session with him and asked him about what would happen after the handover. And Jimmy started crying. I mean, he's a very emotional guy, but still, to be crying on stage in front of a packed ballroom of 500 or so people. And he said he expected to go to jail. So Jimmy knew what he was up against. As some of the previous speakers mentioned, he came out of absolute poverty. He came out of famine. He left China at a time when 45 million people or so were dying during the so- called Great Leap Forward. So Jimmy knew what he was up against. And yet, for decades he kept fighting. He gave up his clothing empire just to invest more heavily into media. But it's also important to remember--and it really shows us, I think, the cruelty of the Chinese Communist Party--to remember that not only was Jimmy nonviolent, not only did he always eschew the violence that sometimes broke out on the streets of Hong Kong, but he has no personal political ambitions. We're not talking about someone who would be the next Nelson Mandela, or the next Navalny. We're talking about a man who believes in freedom, who wants to be reunited with his family, with his daughter, with his son, with all of his children--and enjoy the last years of his life. I think it's important to remember how singular he is in embodying both free markets and the freedom that we think of, civil liberties, free speech, freedom of worship. And, of course, President Trump has been a terrific supporter. He promised two years ago on the campaign trail that he'd free Jimmy. He said it would be very easy. Of course, it hasn't proven to be so. That's nothing to do with President Trump. That's to do with General Secretary Xi Jinping. Now, President Trump, I hope, should realize that he can, and should, and must--I would argue--free Jimmy Lai. It would help cement his reputation as someone who's able to do the hard deals, to get people out of prisons and unimaginably dark places. He has a terrific record on this, almost unparalleled. I do think Jimmy is a very, very tough case. And we can only hope that the President continues to push ahead. I also want to underscore one of the points that was made about Jimmy's relation with America. He is in jail mostly because he believes in American values, American principles, and because he had the temerity, in the eyes of the Chinese Communist Party, to come and meet with officials in Washington, with some of the people in this room, back in 2019. And that was seen as collusion with foreign forces. I think that's arguable, under any kind of international or any kind of common law. Jimmy is not in jail legally. But he is in jail because he believed that the United States embodied the sorts of values that Jimmy embodies. So of course, while this hearing focuses on Jimmy, I'd just like to finish by reminding people that Jimmy is just one of hundreds of political prisoners being held in often appalling conditions. Key members of the Hong Kong Alliance, Chow Hang- tung, Lee Cheuk-yan, Albert Ho, have just last week been sentenced for using the phrase ``end one party rule.'' Student activist Joshua Wong, whom Co-chairman Smith mentioned, is about to be sentenced under more bogus charges. Hong Kong's prisons, as my colleague Frances Hui, behind me, and other colleagues have recently revealed, remain dangerously overcrowded, intensely surveilled, and structurally abusive. We did a report on this a year ago. Frances and the team came out with an update earlier this week, and among other shocking findings, found that guards in Stanley Prison are rehearsing--are doing mock drills for what to do if and when Jimmy Lai dies in prison. I mean, this should be a real--a clear warning sign to all of us that time is running out. In closing, I'd like to emphasize that the release of Jimmy Lai would be something President Trump, Republicans and Democrats, indeed, freedom-loving people around the world, would applaud. It would be a unifying event at a time when the world really needs it. Of course, I'd be happy to answer any questions, particularly about recommendations for congressional-executive action to help Jimmy Lai. But I would like to thank you for introducing the Jimmy Lai Accountability Act. I think that will go a long way toward letting the Chinese know that there will be consequences if their repression of Hong Kong, and of Jimmy in particular, continues. Thank you. ------ Co-chair Smith. Dr. Clifford, thank you very much for your testimony, your recommendations. The legislation has been introduced by both of us, Senator Sullivan and me. It's bipartisan, as it should be, as this whole effort has been. There's not much that unites us here on Capitol Hill these days. The cause of Jimmy Lai and the cause of human rights and democracy in Hong Kong, and in China--mainland China--does. And I think that speaks a lot about how much we care. I mean, it's really important. You know, I've chaired 107--and this is the 108th--hearing on human rights abuse in China. Like Marco Rubio and a few others, I can't go there anymore. I want to go. And I want to go badly, to talk to people there, talk to officials. And it occurred to me while you were talking, Dr. Clifford, that Xi Jinping himself is violating the National Security Law by collaborating and meeting with President Trump. I mean, it shows you the foolishness of a law that says mere contact is actionable under that egregious law. And, you know, when they are making a deal, oh, they'll talk day and night. But when you're talking about respecting the dignity of their own people, and that--you know, we care about their people. We want the people of China to flourish and to thrive. And we want the Chinese Communist Party to recognize they have a responsibility. These are universally recognized human rights. These are not something that we just came up with in the still of the night somewhere in Congress or at the White House. These are universally recognized human rights. And again, I hope that Xi Jinping realizes that when they break, as they have, the Sino-U.K. agreement, that's a treaty. And you promised. And if you don't honor that treaty, why should we have any anticipation and hope that you'll honor other treaties? It brings, I think, with all due respect, dishonor to the government of China. We want them to matriculate to being more of a democracy. And that can happen. Jimmy Lai's case is one of--and that's why this is an appeal. What we're doing today is saying--we're appealing, based on the humanitarian issue of a man who is very, very elderly, 78, has a number of problems, illnesses that need to be addressed. And now added to that--and as you said so eloquently, Mr. Yates, when you talked about--``as a father who's held his daughter's hand through truly terrible circumstances, and ultimately lost her, I can attest''--and that's you, of course, just a moment ago--``that there has been no greater trial in my life. Not being permitted to hold her hand through those times would have been unimaginably worse. Xi Jinping's China should not make a dying man and daughter confronting a grave illness endure that additional cruelty in the service of a political trophy.'' So well said, and just right from the heart. And you said it too as well, Sebastien. So I ask you, you know, if you wanted to elaborate, especially on followup, Dr. Clifford. Again, we do have this bill, which we will push very hard to try to get enacted into law. But, you know, the Chinese government--you know, someday people are going to look back in China and say, what did Xi Jinping do? You know, why did he do so many of the things that he does, especially to a man like Jimmy Lai? I mean, he is an icon of goodness. And to get a trophy for holding a political prisoner, who's he trying to impress? You know, fellow communist leaders or what? So maybe you wanted to speak to some of those consequences that you think we should follow up with, Dr. Clifford. Mr. Clifford. Well, thank you very much, Co-chair Smith. I would just like to add that the administration has not only sent the wrong signals, but seems to be being played by the Chinese. So, first of all, in July, we let the national emergency under an Executive order expire, which meant that nine Hong Kong officials--nine Hong Kong and Chinese officials who had been sanctioned-- were no longer on the sanctions list, including the secretary for justice, who I see has just been invited to a closed-door session with the American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong. So these guys are out of the box. We have to start holding Chinese and Hong Kong human rights abusers personally responsible. And I think an indication of the--I don't know if it's the temerity or the freedom with which China thinks it can act, came last Friday. I mentioned that Chow Hang-tung and the other members of the Hong Kong Alliance were just sentenced. This is on the eve of Xi Jinping's state visit to the U.S. They didn't even have the decency to wait until the General Secretary was back in China. At least the hapless Keir Starmer, when he was prime minister, they gave him--they humiliated him in Beijing in many respects--but they gave him the face of waiting until he'd been back 9 or 10 days before they sentenced Jimmy. To sentence the Hong Kong Alliance people on the eve of this trip, to me, looks like a slap in the face to the administration. I think until we start holding the Chinese accountable personally--but I would also say through economic and other measures-- accountable, there's not going to be any change. They feel increasingly emboldened, and I think the entire world should be worried. Not just Jimmy Lai's family and those of us who know and love him, but really the entire world, because China thinks that it can act with impunity. Co-chair Smith. You know, on the issue of the business community, one of the biggest disappointments I and others have had over the years has been their unwillingness to speak out with even a less than bold voice on behalf of human rights in China and Hong Kong. I remember in the early 1990s when we were arguing MFN and human rights linkage. The administration under Bill Clinton actually hosted, in the mid-nineties at the White House, the guy who ordered the tanks. Chi Haotian was his name. I met with the Chamber of Commerce in the early 1990s when this battle on MFN was surging. And I said, you guys can make the biggest difference in the world. It was a two-hour meeting. It was the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in Beijing. And they were just touting the talking points from the Chinese Communist Party. It was very disturbing. They even told me that religious freedom was flourishing. And I said, Where? You know, that's not what I hear. You know, I meet with people who suffer for their faith. And it's the communist model. We saw it in the Soviet Union. We saw it in Romania. We saw it in the East bloc countries. We see it everywhere, North Korea. So what are you talking about? If somehow we could get them engaged--the summit that was held in San Francisco was another opportunity for the business community to really assert themselves. They ought to be speaking now about Jimmy Lai. You know, the Chamber of Commerce should put out a strong statement: Let this great man go. For humanitarian purposes, let him go. So I remember leaving that meeting in Beijing. There was one very lonely human rights officer from the State Department at that meeting, and about five people from the economic section who kept telling me how wrong I was that we ought to link--genuinely link--human rights with trade, and if they achieve significant progress--and we had the votes! People forget this. We had the votes. Again, it was bipartisan. I worked with Nancy Pelosi and Frank Wolf. We had the votes to truly take away MFN unless there was serious and significant progress. And I wrote an op-ed for the Wall Street Journal on this. And Bill Clinton said, Give me a year. He did an Executive order, a great Executive order. They ripped it up. I think that was the business community, again, that said, Somehow they'll matriculate from a dictatorship to a democracy if we just trade more. Now I think the onus is on the business community. Right now they can speak out on behalf of Jimmy Lai, on the eve of this summit. So we appeal to the business community. The next deal, okay, but how about saying this great man should be free to join his son and daughter? So--next steps, or anything you think we should be doing on this? My colleagues are really in accord. I mean, Democrat and Republican. The problem is this is the last day of the session. We didn't know that was going to be the case when we set this hearing up. So there's a lot of people on the floor doing floor speeches with bills and all. This is the last day, maybe tomorrow, but before the midterms. We were supposed to have two more weeks, and that went away. I just say that [by way of explanation) as to why some of the members, who care deeply, are not here today. Like Moolenaar, the chairman of the China Select Committee. You know, he sends his best to you, and you know how much he cares. So anything else you would like to add? Yes, Mr. Yates. Mr. Yates. Well, I would just try to punctuate that many of us have lived through this narrative that held out the prospect of what China is, how it can be engaged, and what would lead to meaningful change. I would like to appeal to the businessman in President Trump's mind that no businessman goes into successive meetings without having an accounting of what was discussed in the first and the second meeting, what are the measurable changes that occurred, what was promised, what was delivered. And you wouldn't have a succession of three, four, five meetings without holding yourself and your counterpart accountable--I came and this is what I promised, and this is what I did. You came, this is what you promised, and this is what you did. There's a broad menu. And I would make no bones about it. Having worked for presidents and vice presidents, there's a full menu. And China has made the menu more full by helping fuel the Russian war machine, by making the Iran situation more difficult, fentanyl still comes into our country. There are a lot of issues, and some might say, well, why this? I would say, why this, because all other avenues are exhausted. We are at, I think, a true threshold point of trying to decide what exactly is the kind of country and leader we're having to deal with. And what can I reasonably expect in return for engaging you? We showered you with wealth, technology, access, and opportunity, to the point where the only sentient thing you had to do was say yes. They did nothing to lift people out of poverty. We did that. And they didn't even give a thank you in return. They took more. And we are now at a point where we opened up trade. We opened up access to our universities. We opened up wide- ranging engagement. And are we safer? Are they more responsible? Is the world better off with this arrangement? Oddly, now the world is more dependent on the unreformed regime. And so why this now? I think we're left with an acid test example of, if you don't have it within your system or within your character as a leader to give a humanitarian release to one of your citizens, supposedly--I think that's ambiguous--but one of the people in your Party's custody to go through this dark period where no reasonable person could say he poses a threat at this point. If you can't do that, then there is no reason to believe there will be a deliverable on a trade negotiation, on easing the support for murder against innocent Ukrainians, or innocent people in the Middle East, or innocent Americans who have been protected from the flood of fentanyl largely by what we've done on our southern border, enforcement on the high seas, and other areas, and with treatment against overdoses. It is not because the Chinese have shut down more factories. And so the reason why now is because we've tried these other baskets. We've linked human rights. We've unlinked human rights. We've come into the WTO. We've engaged. We've had broad trade agreements. We lived through COVID and haven't really held you accountable. And still we ask, What can we expect in return? And I think at this point, this president, the businessman and the one who--only one--who has really raised this sole case at the absolute highest level, this is the last test of what America, and maybe the world, can reasonably expect from Xi Jinping's China. That's why I think this matters. And I think it's even more crystal clear in 2026 than the debates we lived through in the 1990s about whether to link human rights and democracy, whether to have normal trade relations, all of those things. Now we've been mugged by reality for a generation. And this is where we are, this acid test. So that would be my humble appeal to everyone on the Commission, and those that used to be on the Commission who now may have the President's ear. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Co-chair Smith. Did you want to talk about any further things that we should be anticipating? Mr. Clifford. Well, at the risk of going slightly outside this Commission's remit, I would like to underscore what Mr. Yates said. Hong Kong is the world's most important node for ensuring that military technology gets into the Russian war machine and the Iranian war machine. Again, Xi Jinping could shut this down tomorrow. I think it's very important to remember that during this period of engagement, during everything that has happened during these last three or four decades, when we've helped bring China into the world economy, we've seen things ranging from Jimmy Lai's imprisonment, the imprisonment of hundreds of other brave, peaceful Hong Kongers, to the Uyghur concentration camps--the largest civilian internment since the Nazi period. I just want to underscore what Mr. Yates said. You know, we're in a period--this is really an acid test. And I think Jimmy's freedom is emblematic of whether the General Secretary of the world's largest dictatorship can agree to at least let this man live his last years in freedom? Or is he determined to have a political trophy that he can mount on his wall and, you know, see Jimmy die in prison? I mean, the stakes really couldn't be higher. And again, I just want to say, I don't know if this is our last chance, at the summit, but it's our best last chance. Co-chair Smith. You know, Sebastien, you last saw your father, what, in August 2020? If he were here today, exactly what would you say to him? Mr. Lai. I mean, it's been five years since I've seen him. I hear about his health declining every single day. And it's sometimes a painful realization of thinking that if I saw him again, he would physically look different. I don't know how he would be mentally. And it's really sad. It's really sad. It's really worrying. But then I remember one of the things that he said--when he was first arrested. He was let out the first time, and someone asked him, Jimmy, knowing that the last 30 years of all the work, all the resources you put in, has led to you ending up in this little Hong Kong jail cell, do you regret it? And he replies, ``You know, I had a lot of time to think. They give you a thin little blanket. You can't really sleep. So I thought about the last 30 years and I realized that I wouldn't have changed a damn thing.'' So I'd probably tell him how incredibly proud I am of him. How incredibly proud so many people are who hear his story, of a man who is willing to sacrifice everything that he has for these liberties that many people around the world believe are human rights. And that--you know, that there's many people fighting for him. And I believe that if enough people tell President Xi that it is not to his benefit to kill this man-- this symbol of the liberties that we love and treasure--that hopefully that will mean that he will one day be free. Because for Xi Jinping, it's a phone call away, and then there's a 78- year-old man on a plane, and he's back home with his family. Co-chair Smith. Would either of you like to add anything before we conclude? That was beautiful. Sebastien, again, know that your sister is in our prayers. And not just mine, but our Commission members who really are so concerned about her, and your--did you want to say something else? But your father is such a brave man, one of the greatest men ever. I just--you know, to give it all up, to risk it all, for everyone else. I mean, that's the greatest example of selflessness that one can have. He is truly a hero. That word is thrown around so often it almost becomes cheap. Not in his case. He is a true hero of democracy and freedom, and of goodness. And we in Congress will never cease trying to effectuate his release, and that of the others that are, sadly, languishing in the gulags of China. But thank you for your steadfastness. You are just an amazing son. Like I said, a chip off the ol' block. Thank you. The Commission's hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 10:24 a.m., the hearing was concluded.] ======================================================================= A P P E N D I X ======================================================================= Prepared Statements ------ Prepared Statement of Sebastien Lai Chairman Sullivan, Co-Chairman Smith, Members of the Commission-- thank you. My sister Claire was to testify beside me today. A few weeks ago, she was diagnosed with cancer. I was with her in London last week as she began chemotherapy. My father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from a maximum security prison. He cannot hold her hand. She wants nothing more than to have him with her for this fight. We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her, and for a 78-year-old man who has already suffered enough. I want to thank America, President Trump, who has been a true champion of my father's, his administration, and the Senators and Members of both parties whose support has never wavered and only gotten stronger. That is moral courage, and my family does not take it for granted. By the end of this year my father will have spent 6 years in a maximum security prison in solitary. At 78 he is the oldest political prisoner in Hong Kong. With a 20-year sentence looming over him, if he's not freed soon, he will most likely die in prison. But the real question is: for what? Three times in his life, my father has already paid dearly for freedom. The first time, it cost him his childhood. He was a porter at the Guangzhou railway station when a traveler from Hong Kong tipped him a bar of chocolate. He figured that if this came from Hong Kong, Hong Kong must be heaven. At 12, he hid in the bottom of a fishing boat to get there and for the first time in his life he tasted freedom The second time, it cost him what many thought was his life's work. He started on a factory floor and ended up with a clothing empire. Then came Tiananmen. My father wrote what he thought of the men who ordered the massacre, and Beijing gave him a simple choice: your stores on the mainland, or your conscience. He sold the company, walking away from the largest market on Earth, and built a newspaper instead, on the principle that information is choice, and choice is freedom. Its first editorial asked: Are we afraid of 1997? Of course we are. But we refuse to be intimidated by fear. The third time, it cost him everything. In 2020, the National Security Law was imposed on Hong Kong by the Chinese government, criminalizing, overnight, any form of democratic expression, past and present. So sixty years after that fishing boat, my father again faced the decision he had faced as a boy: to stay, or to run. Only now he had far more to lose by staying--and far more to protect. He stayed for our beliefs, and he stayed to protect others. That is the man they have in prison. What happens now is no longer a test of my father's courage, it is a test of ours. America understands, in its bones, that freedom dies with the last man willing to defend it and that the cost of not standing up for liberty is not felt until it is too late. In my father, this nation has found a kindred spirit. A week from now, President Xi will be a guest in this city. Our appeal to him is simple: my father poses no threat. His imprisonment makes him a symbol of injustice; his death in prison would be a disgrace. Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment. ______ Prepared Statement of Steve Yates Chairman, Co-Chairman, and distinguished Members of the Commission; Mr. Sebastien Lai; Mr. Mark Clifford: I thank the Commission for the invitation to appear today. My name is Steve Yates. I serve as Senior Research Fellow for China and National Security and as Chung Ju Yung Fellow at The Heritage Foundation. I appear in a personal capacity. The views expressed in this testimony are my own. This hearing convenes 8 days before President Trump is scheduled to receive Chairman Xi Jinping in Washington on September 24, 2026. That meeting will shape the next chapter of United States-China relations more decisively than any set of prepared talking points. The case of Jimmy Lai is not a peripheral human-rights item to be appended to a trade-and-security agenda. It is a test of character--of Xi Jinping's leadership, of the President's relationship with his counterpart, and of whether there remains any credible basis for the assumptions on which American policy toward Hong Kong was long constructed. I. The Man Beijing Cannot Abide I first met Jimmy Lai and his colleagues at Apple Daily in the late 1990s, as a young policy analyst at The Heritage Foundation, in the period immediately following Hong Kong's transfer from British to Chinese sovereignty. In the years that followed, I was privileged to meet him at his home in Hong Kong, in Taiwan, and during his visits to the United States. Conversations with Jimmy always combined substance and character. They ranged across his extraordinary personal journey in business, public life, and faith; China's evolution under the Chinese Communist Party; and Hong Kong's historical role as the gateway at which China encountered the free world--the intersection of opportunity and control. I have been fortunate to meet many world leaders, chief executives of global enterprises, and leaders across the major religious traditions. Jimmy Lai is, nonetheless, extraordinary. He rose from poverty as a migrant child to great success, twice, in entirely different and highly competitive industries. He carried a deep and visceral identification with the hardships borne by Chinese people under the Party's economic and political policies. As the documentaries produced before his imprisonment make plain, he held a heartfelt desire for the genuine liberation of the Chinese people so that they might fulfill their potential. In geopolitics, political prisoners are typically leaders of parties, dominant industries, or labor movements; candidates for office; or religious and cultural authorities. Jimmy Lai's accusers attempt to force him into those categories. The truth is that he is the highest-profile political prisoner in the Party's custody not because of what he has done, but because of who he is. He represents a form of genuine Chinese identity that the Party cannot abide: a citizen who lifted himself and many others from poverty to success entirely outside the political patronage system, and a citizen who places his faith and his fellow man above the Party, in a vision widely shared by traditional Chinese families. My colleague Mike Gonzalez of The Heritage Foundation captured the confrontation with precision: both Jimmy Lai and Xi Jinping are ``obsessed with liberty''--Jimmy with expanding it, Xi with crushing it. After other publications bent the knee following the 1997 handover, Apple Daily kept advocating Hong Kong's free way of life. That, and not espionage or violence, is the offense. A newspaper, and a life, that refused to kneel before the Party. II. The Foundations of Policy--and the Record That Followed The foundations of America's approach to Hong Kong rest on a series of geopolitical wagers: the opening of China after the Cultural Revolution and the promises of ``reform and opening'' in the Deng Xiaoping era; the sunset of the British Empire marked by the Sino- British Joint Declaration; and the post-Cold War conviction that engagement and integration would bring China into alignment with widely held international norms. The promises of ``one country, two systems'' and eventual universal suffrage, enshrined in Hong Kong's Basic Law, rest on those wagers. Commitments under the International Covenants of the United Nations were treated as confidence-building measures against stalling or backsliding after the transition. Many, including me, held those assumptions in good faith. The evidence from the 1990s to the present argues overwhelmingly against their wisdom. Reality intervened. The principal checkpoints are public record. In the early 2000s, a proposed national security bill under Article 23 of the Basic Law would have amended the Crimes, Official Secrets, and Societies Ordinances to cover treason, secession, sedition, subversion, and state secrets. In 2014, a directive from Beijing constrained the process for selecting the Chief Executive and forming the Legislative Council. In 2018 came the first formal ban on a political party. In 2019, the extradition bill communicated to every resident that a person could be transferred north for prosecution. In 2020, Beijing imposed the national security law that produced a generational wave of political prisoners in Hong Kong, of whom Mr. Lai is the most widely recognized. Original policy assumptions premised on Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy within the People's Republic have given way to the need to treat Hong Kong, with respect to national security, human rights, and increasingly, financial measures, as ``one country, one system.'' The Heritage Foundation reached a related conclusion in its own research products. For twenty-five consecutive years, Hong Kong ranked first in the world in the Index of Economic Freedom. In 2021, after the imposition of the national security law, the Foundation removed Hong Kong and Macau as separately ranked economies, stating that developments had unambiguously shown the relevant policies are controlled from Beijing. An institution that had held Hong Kong out for a quarter-century as the world's model of economic freedom could no longer do so in good faith. The Sino-British Joint Declaration is treated as a historical artifact. In practice, the international covenants are disregarded. Appeals to, or by, international institutions or Great Britain have minimal effect at this stage. That assessment is not cynicism. It is the record. III. What the Executive and Legislative Branches Can Still Do Congress, with support from the Executive branch, made a meaningful adjustment in 2019 with the Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act and in 2020 with the Hong Kong Autonomy Act. Together, those statutes introduced a range of penalties for those who undermined the commitments of the Joint Declaration and the Basic Law. The proposed Jimmy Lai Hong Kong Political Prisoner Accountability Act of 2026 is a welcome addition to that toolkit. It would strengthen the Executive branch's negotiating position with Chinese counterparts. I respectfully urge its introduction and enactment. Executive branch leaders have raised Mr. Lai's case on multiple occasions. The prior administration issued statements condemning his prosecution and calling for his release. Senior officials raised Hong Kong's national security law and human-rights concerns in general terms. Those statements did not produce his release. The present administration has gone further. Secretary Bessent, acting on the President's instruction, is the first official of this administration to raise Jimmy Lai's case with Chinese counterparts in the course of United States-China trade negotiations. President Trump raised the case directly with Xi Jinping in October 2025, appealing for release, citing Mr. Lai's age and health after a long trial, and suggesting that a release would serve bilateral relations and China's standing. The President raised the case again in May 2026. He subsequently observed that Chairman Xi had described it as ``a tough one for him to do,'' and that he, the President, was ``not optimistic.'' I believe the President was moved to raise this case by Jimmy Lai's extraordinary life, and still more by the absolute devotion of Jimmy's children in making the case for their father's release. That case is more compelling today, not only because of the decline in Mr. Lai's health after years of solitary confinement, worsening medical conditions, and advanced age. Claire Lai has now shared her own cancer diagnosis publicly. As a father who held his daughter's hand through truly terrible circumstances and ultimately lost her, I can attest that there has been no greater trial in my life. Not being permitted to hold her hand through those times would have been unimaginably worse. Xi Jinping's China should not make a dying man and a daughter confronting grave illness endure that additional cruelty in service of a political trophy. This is no longer principally an appeal to law, foreign or domestic. It is no longer principally an appeal to policy or strategy. When the President next meets Chairman Xi, this should be an appeal to raise the case a third time--and to state that a refusal to permit the humanitarian release of a dying man to be with his daughter through the darkest challenge of their lives will affect the way the President regards Xi Jinping as a leader and as a counterpart. A release would better position the President to advocate policies aimed at strategic and economic stability. A denial would leave Congress prepared to impose consequences on those responsible, in ways they will feel. IV. A Litmus Test for Leadership and for the Relationship This is not solely a case about the terminal imprisonment or humanitarian release of one man. It is a litmus test of whether there remains any reason to believe there is a future in Xi Jinping's China for the kind of man Jimmy Lai is: a child of God, a lover of the real China, and, it may fairly be said, one of China's greatest entrepreneurs. The loss of that hope is what broke the old wagers on which policy was founded. This may be one of the last tests of whether that break is a temporary defect or an enduring feature of the system. A release would not restore 1997. It would not revive Apple Daily. It would tell the world--and it would tell President Trump--that Chairman Xi can still choose mercy when the world is watching. That is a signal about leadership. It is a signal about whether any understanding with this counterpart is worth the paper on which it is written. A refusal tells a different story. It says the Party would rather permit an elderly Catholic publisher to die in isolation than concede that a free Chinese life is not a threat. If that is the story Chairman Xi brings to Washington on September 24, Congress should answer with the Accountability Act and with every instrument already enacted. Officials who jail, prosecute, and isolate should be identified and made to bear costs. Recommendations to the Executive Branch. Place the case of Jimmy Lai on the agenda for September 24 as a standalone humanitarian item, not a footnote to commercial or security discussions. State publicly, in advance of the meeting, that a humanitarian release would be read as a measure of Chairman Xi's seriousness as a counterpart. After the meeting, report what was asked and what answer was received. Recommendations to the Legislative Branch. Introduce and pass the Jimmy Lai Hong Kong Political Prisoner Accountability Act of 2026 before the summit if possible, and if not, immediately thereafter. Keep the Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act and the Hong Kong Autonomy Act in active use--through reports, designations, and visa restrictions-- rather than as statutes of record only. Treat the condition of other political prisoners in Hong Kong as part of the same account. Mr. Lai is the name the world knows. He is not the only prisoner in the system. This matter should not be outsourced to London or to international bodies that have already had their opportunity. It is now an American conversation with Chairman Xi, in the capital of the United States, eight days after this hearing. Conclusion Jimmy Lai left poverty without a Party card. He built enterprises. He built a newspaper that told the truth when others fell silent. He remained in Hong Kong when he could have departed. He prays in a cell. His children appear before this Commission to ask that a great power permit their father to die at home, or to live a little longer in the open air. That is not a complicated request. Chairman Xi is coming to Washington. President Trump has already asked twice. He should ask a third time. The cost of refusal should be made real. The meaning of assent should be made clear: a leader still capable of the decent act when a father and a daughter are out of time. If Chairman Xi cannot do that, the United States should cease telling itself stories about the future of this relationship that the facts will not support. I thank the Commission for its attention. I thank Sebastien Lai and the Lai family for their steadfastness. I thank Mark Clifford for keeping the historical record honest. I ask this body to treat September 24 as the deadline that it is. Prepared Statement of Mark L. Clifford Chair Sullivan, Co-Chair Smith, and Honorable Members of the Commission, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. When President Trump hosts Chinese Communist Party General Secretary Xi Jinping for a state visit next Thursday, September 24, the Chinese leader is expected to bring a large group of Chinese business leaders. Yet one of China's most creative and visionary entrepreneurs isn't going to be on that trip. That's because 78-year-old Jimmy Lai sits alone in a Hong Kong prison. He's a man who created tens of thousands of jobs and untold riches for the workers and investors in his many companies--first making sweaters, then starting one of the earliest fast-fashion retail chains, and finally emerging as the world's most influential independent Chinese-language newspaper publisher. The story of why Jimmy is in prison is the story of freedom in Hong Kong--and how that freedom was crushed as China broke its promises to the people of Hong Kong and to the world. Under British colonial rule Hong Kong counted as one of the world's freest places in many international surveys. As part of the 1997 handover deal that saw China take over the territory, Beijing promised to let Hong Kong keep those freedoms. The 1984 Sino-British Declaration, an international treaty lodged at the United Nations, pledged that Hong Kong's free way of life would continue for 50 years after Britain left under a novel ``one country, two systems'' arrangement. In 1990 China went further, promulgating a mini-constitution (the Basic Law) that enshrined in law a wide range of freedoms--freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, freedom of religion, and many more. Indeed, China went even further. It promised that universal suffrage was on the way. Hong Kongers would no longer be colonial subjects. They would be ``masters in their own house.'' ``Hong Kong people ruling Hong Kong'' (gang zhi gang), went the slogan. They would be able to elect the mayor (known locally as the chief executive) and the city council (the legislative council). Jimmy Lai is in jail because he wanted to hold China to those promises. I'm proud to have known Jimmy Lai since 1993. I served on the board of directors of his media company, Next Digital, and am his biographer. I have a good sense of what makes Jimmy tick--and why the Chinese are so afraid of this aging man that they have kept him in prison for more than 2,000 days, mostly in solitary confinement. Jimmy is unique in Chinese history. Few people have had the courage to stand up to the Chinese Communist Party. One of those who did, Nobel Peace Prize winner Liu Xiaobo, made the ultimate sacrifice, paying for his principles with his life, dying while in Chinese custody. Jimmy has principles but he has something more. He has money, and for three decades he had a newspaper and magazine empire. There's been no one with Jimmy's wealth and media platform in China who has dared to call for freedom in Hong Kong and in China so loudly and for so long. For more than four decades, until he was jailed, Jimmy called out the Chinese Communist Party's lies, its corruption, its hypocrisy, and its cruelty. Beijing's 1989 democracy protesters awakened Jimmy's hunger for political freedom. He had escaped famine in China as a young boy, making his way to Hong Kong where he focused on business. He supported Deng Xiaoping's economic reforms. Seeing the protesting students in Tiananmen Square was ``like my mother calling,'' he remembered later. It sparked something in him. Inspired, he used his Giordano retail chain to sell t-shirts featuring the young activists and sent the proceeds to them in Beijing. Lai resolved to go into the media business after the June 4, 1989, killings, when hundreds, probably thousands, of protesters were slaughtered in Beijing and across China. From the start his goal was to end communist rule. He thought that the scrutiny free media brought would enable change in China. In 1990, he started Next magazine. In 1994, he used his weekly magazine column to excoriate Premier Li Peng, known as the ``butcher of Beijing'' for his role in the 1989 massacre, during Peng's first visit to a Western democracy since the killings. He termed Li a ``son of a turtle egg'' (a bastard), and worse. The Chinese government responded by shutting his Giordano store in Beijing. They figured he'd choose profit over principle, as virtually every businessman had done since the 1949 communist takeover, and tone down his political attacks. Jimmy chose principle. He fired back with another column, apologizing for his bad language but doubling down on his belief that the Communist Party should and would be relegated to the dustbin of history. With the authorities going after his retail business, he sold his stake in Giordano, using the money to start the Apple Daily newspaper. He knew he risked prison after the Chinese takeover if he didn't back down. Just before the handover in June 1997, in a discussion with USA Today founder Al Neuharth, he broke down in tears as he told the crowd he expected to go to jail. Yet he continued fighting. In 2003 Apple Daily and Next led the campaign against a proposed national security bill. A crowd of 500,000 people took to the streets; the government withdrew the bill and Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa resigned. In 2014 the paper splashed out in yellow ink to support the pro- democracy Umbrella Movement, with its signature bright yellow umbrellas. Jimmy joined the students, pitching his tent among a sea of thousands of others for the 79-day occupation. In 2019, the paper again supported massive pro-democracy protests. Yet Jimmy has no personal political ambitions. He has never wanted to be the next Nelson Mandela or Alexei Navalny. He has neither the temperament nor the desire for political power. He's even rather shy personally, happier hosting a small group for dinner at his house or out on his boat than leading a protest march. But he's committed to freedom. And he refuses to back down. He's fearless. He has a deep sense of right and wrong. Put bluntly, he's rich, he's principled, he's fearless, and he has an international voice. Any one of those things could make him a target of the Chinese Communist Party. The package makes him uniquely dangerous from the party's standpoint. President Trump promised 2 years ago on the campaign trail that he would free Jimmy Lai. It would be ``very easy,'' Trump claimed. It hasn't proven to be. After he met with General Secretary Xi in May and pressed for Jimmy's release, President Trump reported that it would be a ``tough one'' for Xi to free the aging newspaperman. Trump claimed that Jimmy had caused ``bedlam'' in China. The reality is quite different. Jimmy is in jail because he represents freedom. China needed to imprison Jimmy because it needed to show the 7 million people of Hong Kong that even a man of Jimmy's wealth and stature could be locked up. From the party's perspective, Jimmy needed to be subdued because the people of Hong Kong needed to be subdued. Jimmy is in jail because he believed China's promises that Hong Kong's way of life would remain unchanged for 50 years. Jimmy is serving a 20-year sentence for ``collusion with foreign forces,'' stemming from his calls for targeted Magnitsky-style sanctions against Hong Kong and Chinese human rights violators. We will leave aside the legality of this charge--in fact, it is not a crime under common law to call for sanctions, but protected free-speech activity. We will leave aside the fact that prosecutors didn't even manage to show that Jimmy called for sanctions after the National Security Law came into effect June 30, 2021, making the charges against him baseless. Jimmy is in jail because of his decades-long fight for freedom. But the charges against him stem from his meetings with U.S. officials-- Members of Congress and the administration--to ask for help in protecting Hong Kong's freedom. He came to the United States because he wanted help in protecting Hong Kong's freedom. Members of Congress and the Executive branch thus have a special responsibility to help free Jimmy. This hearing focuses on Jimmy Lai. But Jimmy Lai is just one of hundreds of political prisoners being held in often appalling conditions. Key members of the Hong Kong Alliance--Chow Hang-tung, Lee Cheuk-yan, and Albert Ho--have just last week [note: September 11] been sentenced to seven years and three months, seven years, and five years and two months, respectively, for using the phrase ``end one-party rule.'' Student activist Joshua Wong, already in prison for the past 6 years, has just pled guilty--almost certainly under pressure--to a new round of national security charges. Hong Kong's prisons remain dangerously overcrowded, intensely surveilled, and structurally abusive 1 year after the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation documented these conditions in its groundbreaking September 2025 report, ``We Were Made to Suffer: Systemic Abuse and Political Control Inside Hong Kong's Prisons.'' Since then, the Hong Kong government has tightened the legal and administrative architecture around prisoners, deepening isolation and political coercion, particularly for those held over protest-related and national security offenses. These practices continue to breach the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (Nelson Mandela Rules), both of which remain binding on Hong Kong through Basic Law Article 39. The Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation is now updating this research and would be happy to provide commissioners with more information about prison conditions in Hong Kong. I'd be happy to answer further questions, particularly about the recommendations for congressional and Executive action to help free Jimmy Lai and other Hong Kong political prisoners. ------------------ Mark L. Clifford is the president of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation. He is the author of ``The Troublemaker: How Jimmy Lai Became a Billionaire, Hong Kong's Greatest Dissident, and China's Most Feared Critic.'' He holds a PhD in Hong Kong history from the University of Hong Kong. ______ Prepared Statement of Chair Sullivan Sebastien, thank you for being here. You have spent years doing something no son should ever have to do: fighting for your father's freedom and, increasingly, for his life. Your sister Claire has stood with you in that fight. She cannot be here today, but please give her our best and let her know we're praying for her. Like the families of many political prisoners, your family has already endured far too much. I want to be clear today to you and to those listening--America has not forgotten Jimmy Lai, nor any of the other political prisoners languishing in China. We know them by name. In the case of Jimmy Lai, he has become something more than a political prisoner. He has become, in a very real sense, the Dalai Lama of democracy in Hong Kong--a living symbol of a people's peaceful claim to freedom, and of Beijing's fear of that claim. Our fight for his freedom is a fight for the internationally recognized rights of all Chinese. The Dalai Lama once said that ``truth is the best guarantor and the real foundation of freedom and democracy.'' Jimmy Lai has lived that belief. He was a businessman who became a publisher. He built Apple Daily into one of Hong Kong's most influential independent voices. And when it became clear what Beijing intended to do to Hong Kong, Jimmy Lai had every opportunity to leave. He knew the danger. He knew the consequences. He stayed. When they came for his newspaper, he stayed. And when they came for him, he stayed. Today, Jimmy Lai is 78 years old and serving a 20-year prison sentence. Hong Kong authorities call his case a matter of national security. But at the center of that case are journalism, publishing, political advocacy, and speech. And that is why his imprisonment matters far beyond one newspaper or one man. It tells us something about a political system that fears a free press, independent churches, human rights lawyers, an open internet, and an honest examination of history. Jimmy Lai does not command an army. He does not threaten China. What he demonstrates is something far more unsettling to an autocratic government: That a Chinese person can be free. Free to succeed, free to think, free to speak. For years, Hong Kong demonstrated that freedom, rule of law, open markets, and prosperity could exist on Chinese soil. Jimmy Lai is a product of that Hong Kong. His imprisonment tells us what has become of it. Consider this astounding fact: Hong Kong today jails more than 1,000 political prisoners. A city once celebrated as a bastion of freedom and the rule of law now finds itself in the grim company of Belarus, Burma, and the world's other authoritarian regimes. Few could have imagined such a transformation before the imposition of the National Security Law. A government can have courts without having the rule of law. It can have laws without having justice. And it can call censorship ``national security.'' The distinction between the rule of law and rule by law is actually quite simple. Under the rule of law, government is constrained by law. Under rule by law, government uses the law to constrain and jail the people. Jimmy Lai's case puts this distinction in plain view. This is why his case matters to the United States. Congress has spoken repeatedly and on a bipartisan basis. This Commission has spoken. The President and Secretary of State have made Jimmy Lai's case part of U.S. diplomacy. Yet he remains in prison, despite his deteriorating health. As a nation, we need to do more to help him and other political prisoners in Hong Kong. This is why the Co-chair and I have introduced the Jimmy Lai Hong Kong Political Prisoner Accountability Act of 2026. The legislation would require the State Department to report on the health and treatment of Jimmy Lai and other Hong Kong political prisoners. It would also mandate sanctions if a Hong Kong political prisoner dies in custody because of abuse, denial of medical care, or inhumane conditions. Jimmy Lai is 78 years old. Serious concerns have repeatedly been raised about his health and the conditions of his confinement. He has already spent more than five years in prison. He has now been sentenced to 20 more. Time matters. Jimmy once said that Hong Kong gave him everything--and that he had a responsibility to give something back. He gave Hong Kong his fortune. He gave it his newspaper. And ultimately, he gave it his freedom. What happens next will say something not only about Hong Kong or about Beijing. And it will say something not only about the fate of Jimmy Lai. It will speak volumes about what we can expect of Xi Jinping's China and what kind of relationship we can have with it. The CCP put Jimmy Lai in prison to silence a journalist. Instead, they gave the world a champion of democracy and free speech. Sebastien, thank you for carrying your father's story here today. His name will not be forgotten. ______ Prepared Statement of Co-chair Smith Today's hearing is about Jimmy Lai--and an earnest appeal to Xi Jinping from Jimmy's children to set him free on humanitarian grounds. They are grateful that President Trump has personally raised Jimmy Lai's release with Xi Jinping and respectfully ask him to do so again at the upcoming summit. We will hear directly from Jimmy Lai's son, Sebastien, speaking for himself and on behalf of his sister Claire, who was initially scheduled to join her brother today. Sadly, Claire was recently diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and has begun treatment. We are thinking of her, praying for her, and wishing her a full recovery. Sebastien, who testified on behalf of his father in 2023, will tell us today: ``My father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from a maximum security prison. He cannot hold her hand. She wants nothing more than to have him with her for this fight. We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her, and for a 78-year-old man who has already suffered enough. Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment.'' Jimmy Lai is 78 years old. He has spent six years in detention. In February, a Hong Kong court sentenced him to 20 years in prison following his conviction under the National Security Law. It was the longest sentence, thus far, imposed under that law. For a man of Jimmy Lai's age, and given the serious concerns about his health, a 20-year sentence carries an obvious and deeply troubling humanitarian consequence. His son Sebastien has described it as a death sentence. That is why time matters. Jimmy Lai is not being imprisoned because he committed an act of violence. His son has emphasized that his father has never advocated violence. Rather, Jimmy Lai used his voice, his newspaper, and his public platform to support freedom and democracy. He founded Apple Daily, a newspaper that became one of Hong Kong's most prominent pro-democracy publications. The newspaper was forced to close in 2021 after authorities arrested its senior executives and froze its assets. Jimmy Lai himself was arrested in August 2020 and subsequently prosecuted under Hong Kong's national security regime. His case therefore raises fundamental questions about the meaning of freedom of expression and freedom of the press in Hong Kong today. It also raises questions about the rule of law. Hong Kong was promised a high degree of autonomy and the preservation of its existing legal and social systems under the ``One Country, Two Systems'' framework. Yet since the imposition of the National Security Law in June 2020, our Commission has documented the imprisonment of democracy advocates, journalists, former legislators, and civil society figures; weakened procedural protections; concerns regarding judicial independence; and a broader chilling effect on speech and political activity. Jimmy Lai's case is emblematic of those changes. It is about whether a society can retain meaningful freedom of speech when criticizing those in power becomes a national security offense. It is about whether journalists can report freely when the government can shut down a newspaper and prosecute its publisher. It is about whether courts can remain genuinely independent when national security laws are used against political opponents and critics. And it is about whether the promises made to the people of Hong Kong still have meaning. We should also remember the human dimension of this case. For about six years, Jimmy Lai's children have had to live with the reality that their father is imprisoned thousands of miles away. Sebastien has spoken publicly about the possibility that he may never see his father again. Claire has spoken about her father's deteriorating health and the family's increasingly limited information about his medical condition. Claire has also spoken about something that I think is important to understand about Jimmy Lai: his faith. She has said that her father is not in prison because he is Catholic, but that his faith has been a major source of the courage he has shown throughout this ordeal. She described his trust in God and divine providence as something that has not wavered even as his physical condition has deteriorated. That combination of faith and courage is part of Jimmy Lai's story. He is a businessman who built a successful enterprise. He is a publisher who believed that people should be free to read, write, criticize, and debate. He is a Catholic who has spoken openly about his faith. And he is a father whose children are asking for the chance to have their dad home. This hearing comes at an important moment. The Commission's announcement notes the planned summit between President Trump and General Secretary Xi Jinping. That makes the appeal from Jimmy Lai's children especially timely. They are asking that their father's freedom be addressed directly. This hearing also comes at a moment when Congress is considering concrete steps to address the treatment of political prisoners in Hong Kong. Today, I am introducing, along with Senator Sullivan, the Jimmy Lai Hong Kong Political Prisoner Accountability Act of 2026 to establish a clear framework for accountability if a Hong Kong political prisoner were to die in custody as a result of inadequate medical care, abuse, inhumane conditions, or other actions or omissions by detaining authorities. Under the bill, the Secretary of State, in coordination with the Secretary of the Treasury, would be required to determine whether such a death resulted from those circumstances and identify foreign officials responsible for or complicit in the conduct. Those officials could then face mandatory sanctions under existing authorities, including the Global Magnitsky Human Rights Accountability Act and the Hong Kong Autonomy Act. The bill would also require the State Department to report to Congress on the health status of Jimmy Lai and other Hong Kong political prisoners, including any denial or restriction of medical care, legal access, consular access, or family contact. And that broader requirement is important because many Hong Kongers remain imprisoned or targeted for exercising fundamental freedoms. The National Security Law has had consequences affecting journalists, political candidates, legislators, activists, lawyers, religious figures, and ordinary citizens who have expressed views considered unacceptable by the authorities. Most recently, we witnessed the brave 29-year-old democracy advocate Joshua Wong pleading guilty to collusion with foreign entities, a charge that carries a maximum sentence of life in prison under Beijing's National Security Law. The result of this law has been a profound change in Hong Kong's civic and political environment--and not for the better. I want to close by returning to where I began: Jimmy Lai's children. Sebastien and Claire have continued to speak because their father cannot. Today, we have an opportunity to listen to their appeal for their father's freedom. Jimmy Lai should be home. He should be with his family. He should be by his daughter's side as she fights cancer--not behind bars, separated from the people who need him most, at a time when they need him now more than ever. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today and for sharing your testimony. Submissions for the Record ------ Submission of Alex Chow Chair, Co-Chair, and Members of the Commission: I submit this statement to bear witness to a lived reality: Hong Kong's human rights crisis is also a crisis of public accountability, with consequences that reach beyond its borders. By imprisoning those who challenge power, dismantling civic institutions, and placing political obedience above professional judgment, the regime weakens society's ability to recognize failures and correct them. Transnational repression extends that pressure to Hong Kongers abroad and their families, threatening the freedom to speak and organize even after leaving the city. That reality is reflected in Joshua Wong's imprisonment; the persecution of the Hong Kong Alliance and the suppression of June Fourth remembrance; the loss of student institutions; and restrictions on academic exchange and independent journalism, including pressure on the diaspora newsroom Pulse HK. The Wang Fuk Court fire and the treatment of those seeking answers in its aftermath show why people must remain free to demand accountability. Overseas, bounties, election- related targeting, sexualized harassment, and pressure on families show why protecting that freedom also requires action beyond Hong Kong. I ask the Commission to press for prisoners' release, extend protection and humanitarian pathways for Hong Kongers at risk, support sustained funding for civil society and diaspora media, and protect advocates and their families from transnational repression. Sustained pressure matters: protecting these freedoms also preserves the people and institutions capable of holding power accountable when the next major crisis comes. Political Imprisonment and Hong Kong's Future On 3 May 2017, I sat in the Commission's hearing room and listened to Joshua Wong speak. He was twenty. He acknowledged me in the audience as he addressed this Commission about Hong Kong's future. Nine years later, I return to that moment in this written submission because the years since then have changed both his life and the possibilities for public life in Hong Kong.\1\ Joshua is now twenty-nine and has already spent more than six years in custody. He has been continuously detained since November 2020. The prison terms in his cases add up to seven years and two and a half months before accounting for overlap between cases. On 2 September 2026, he pleaded guilty in a further national- security prosecution for conspiracy to collude with foreign or external elements. Sentencing was adjourned. A lengthy additional term could keep him imprisoned into his forties or beyond.\2\ For much of his twenties, Joshua has been kept from participating freely in public life. The closure and weakening of civic institutions also diminish the opportunities available to younger generations. June Fourth: Memory and Responsibility Joshua and I belong to a generation shaped by those who kept the memory of June Fourth alive. Before it was forced to close, the Hong Kong Alliance organized annual candlelight vigils for three decades, making remembrance a shared public responsibility. Among its persecuted leaders are Lee Cheuk-yan, who was in Beijing during the crackdown, and Albert Ho, a former pro-democracy legislator. Both helped sustain the Alliance across the decades. Chow Hang-tung began attending its vigils as a child and later became one of its leaders. Today, she speaks forcefully against the regime, its lies, and the use of the courts to suppress dissent. Their imprisonment reaches across generations, punishing people who preserved that memory and those who took up the responsibility of carrying it forward.\3\ June Fourth helped shape me while I was still a secondary-school student. I remember my history teacher crying in front of us as he shared his experience. He had been a student in 1989 and had watched the massacre unfold live on television. His tears are part of my memory of June Fourth, and part of why its commemoration matters to me. Public remembrance allows an experience to reach people who did not live through it themselves. It gives another generation the opportunity to listen, ask questions, and decide what responsibilities that history places upon them. The Hong Kong Alliance sustained a public setting for that exchange. In my recent research at Britain's National Archives, I found a diplomatic record showing how early its activities had been treated as a threat. A British telegram dated 22 February 1990 records a meeting the previous day with He Wei, an official in the Chinese Foreign Ministry's Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office. She accused the Alliance's planned April-June activities of aiming to subvert the Central People's Government and the mainland's socialist system, and called on the British to act.\4\ I read the Chinese warning as an early expression of the political logic confronting us today: independent organization for democratic change could be treated as a threat to state power. The danger expressed in that warning has become part of Hong Kong's reality. The Alliance voted to disband in September 2021, and the government ordered it struck off the Companies Register the following month. On 11 September 2026, Chow Hang-tung, Lee Cheuk-yan, and Albert Ho received prison sentences of seven years and three months, seven years, and five years and two months respectively for incitement to subversion. The charges concerned activities after the national security law came into force.\5\ Chow Hang-tung's published mitigation text makes clear what is at stake. She wrote that citizens have a responsibility to put state power ``back inside the cage of democracy'': to control it and hold it to account, seeking justice for past harm while preventing greater disasters. She warned that feeding a state apparatus beyond their control in the name of national security would erode humanity and conscience, making tragedy only a matter of time. She also insisted that ending one-party dictatorship was an inescapable responsibility for Hong Kongers and Chinese people of her generation to fulfill themselves; no outsider could do it for them.\6\ After the sentencing, her mother urged those outside the courtroom to carry on: ``Do not lose heart, and do not feel guilty, because guilt is a poison that divides us.'' She asked people to live well. Her words speak to the responsibility of those of us who remain free to act.\7\ Today, I can commemorate June Fourth only outside Hong Kong, with other members of the diaspora. Remembrance continues there, but the institution that helped sustain it publicly in Hong Kong has disappeared. To me, the imprisonment of its leaders reveals the reach of this effort to erase public memory. The regime is also removing people from the public life in which they could speak the truth, organize others, and hold it accountable. Student Institutions and Academic Freedom Alongside imprisoning those who have kept the memory of 1989 alive, the regime relentlessly suppresses emerging voices and younger generations. Its dismantling of student unions strikes at institutions that helped nurture successive generations of civic leaders. As these institutions close, Hong Kong loses places where young people can learn to take responsibility for public life. I served as secretary-general of the Hong Kong Federation of Students during the 2014 Umbrella Movement. Student representation was part of my own path into public life. Through student institutions, young adults could learn to organize, negotiate, choose representatives, and answer to those they represented. From the 1960s into the 2010s, student institutions offered routes from campus participation into wider civic life. That experience could matter long after graduation, whether someone became a doctor or nurse, a lawyer, an engineer, an accountant, a businessperson, a civil servant, a politician, a civic leader, a nonprofit professional, or a cultural worker. The habits of listening, taking responsibility, and questioning authority belong throughout society. By August 2026, according to Amnesty International UK, student unions at six of Hong Kong's eight publicly funded universities had disbanded or stopped functioning. Recognition was withdrawn at the University of Hong Kong; the Chinese University of Hong Kong described its union's operations as effectively disbanded; Baptist University suspended its union's operations; and Lingnan's union announced its dissolution. City University of Hong Kong's union moved its services off campus in 2023, while the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology's union retained a formal university role.\8\ The pressure on student life has also fallen directly on students who took part in the 2019 protests. By 31 July 2021, 4,009 students had been arrested and 1,102 prosecuted in related cases, according to government figures. These figures show the scale of arrests and prosecutions affecting a generation of students.\9\ The pressure extends to the exchange of knowledge beyond Hong Kong. In December 2025, I participated in a Hong Kong Studies conference at Academia Sinica in Taiwan. I knew that Hong Kong institutions had barred scholars from attending and threatened them with dismissal or other punishment if they did so. The freedom at stake was the ability to exchange knowledge and ideas with other scholars. I regard attempts to control who may take part in such discussions as an attack on academic freedom, inside Hong Kong and beyond it. The Freedom To Question Authority Elected representation is one way the public can demand answers from those who govern. The 2021 electoral restructuring left only 20 of the Legislative Council's ninety seats allocated to direct geographical elections. In the 7 December 2025 general election, turnout in those geographical constituencies was 31.90 percent. By comparison, turnout in the 2019 District Council election was 71.23 percent. I see this stark contrast in public participation, alongside the removal of meaningful electoral choices, as evidence of a profound erosion of the legislature's democratic legitimacy. Hong Kongers need meaningful electoral choices as well as the freedom to organize between elections. The weakening of these channels makes independent public scrutiny still more important.\10\ Public accountability also depends on people being able to find out what those in power are doing. The dismantling of independent news organizations has weakened that capacity. Apple Daily published its last edition on 24 June 2021 after police raids and arrests; Stand News shut down following a police raid on 29 December that year. Each closure removed reporters, editors, and an institution through which scrutiny could reach a wider public.\11\ The pressure reaches overseas newsrooms as well. In August 2025, a Ta Kung Pao commentary singled out the planned Pulse HK newsroom, accused it of ideological warfare against China and Hong Kong, and urged pressure on its funding. In June 2026, Reporters Without Borders reported failed cyberattacks against Pulse and described its cofounder's account of fundraising disruption. The report did not establish who was responsible. These pressures make dependable support for diaspora media especially important. These newsrooms keep Hong Kongers informed and keep questions about the city in public view.\12\ Wang Fuk Court and the Freedom To Demand Answers The fire at Wang Fuk Court on 26 November 2025 took 168 lives and made international headlines. The public should have been free to grieve, express anger, hold peaceful rallies, and demand answers. Thousands gathered to mourn, but Beijing's national-security authorities warned against using the disaster to disrupt Hong Kong. The response to people seeking accountability showed how dangerous it could become to turn grief and anger into organized action.\13\ Miles Kwan, a student at the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK), helped organize a petition calling for an independent inquiry and accountability. He was detained on 29 November and released on police bail on 1 December. In February 2026, CUHK terminated his studies. He had completed his credits but was still awaiting confirmation that he could graduate. Kwan said the disciplinary panel had added demerits for breaching confidentiality and for his conduct toward the panel; he disputed the process. CUHK declined to discuss the individual case. His experience shows how a student who sought answers after the fire could face police action and then see his university studies end before graduation.\14\ The formal response to the fire must remain open to scrutiny. By August 2026, the Independent Committee had held thirty days of evidential hearings involving eighty witnesses and had invited information from the public twice. It expected to submit its report by the end of October. In September, the Buildings Department brought charges against four individuals and two companies over the estate's major repair works. These proceedings are part of the response whose results the public must be able to examine.\15\ The conditions for that examination matter alongside the proceedings themselves. The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) reported that Beijing's Office for Safeguarding National Security in Hong Kong summoned international journalists on 6 December 2025 and warned them over coverage following the fire. Officials objected to what they called false information; CPJ characterized the encounter as intimidation. Residents need answers, and journalists need the freedom to pursue questions that official accounts leave unresolved.\16\ An inquiry can gather evidence and make recommendations. Its contribution to accountability also depends on what happens around and after it: whether people can challenge its explanations, identify omissions, and press for recommendations to be implemented. The capacity to question authority must survive the announcement of a formal process. Transnational Repression: Extending Fear Beyond Hong Kong The suppression of scrutiny does not stop at Hong Kong's borders. Since the national security law was imposed in 2020, the regime has used national-security powers to silence, punish, and threaten people at home while pursuing advocates overseas. Leaving Hong Kong does not necessarily free people from that pressure. The legal framework helps extend its reach. The 2020 law claims jurisdiction over certain acts committed abroad, including by people who are not Hong Kong permanent residents. The 2024 ordinance implementing Article 23 added measures against designated overseas ``absconders,'' including passport cancellations and restrictions on funds and property. China's Law on Promoting Ethnic Unity and Progress, effective from 1 July 2026, adds a further assertion of overseas legal responsibility through Article 63. U.N. experts have warned of its potential use for transnational repression. This new assertion of legal reach follows a pattern of pressure that began years earlier.\17\ In December 2024, Hong Kong police announced HK$1 million bounties against six more people, including Joe Tay and Carmen Lau. During Canada's 2025 Federal election, when Tay was a candidate, Canadian authorities documented coordinated amplification of his arrest warrant and bounty, attacks on his competence, and suppression of searches for his Chinese name on certain PRC-based platforms. This brought the threat of punishment into his participation in another country's democratic process.\18\ Lau has described another form of intimidation: AI-generated sexual images depicting her, mailed to her neighbors in Britain. Reuters reported in December 2025 that Thames Valley Police were investigating images they believed had been digitally altered. The report did not establish who sent them. The abuse she described shows how public advocacy can be met with attempts to humiliate and isolate a person in the community where they have sought safety.\19\ Families also face consequences. On 26 February 2026, Anna Kwok's father, Kwok Yin-sang, was sentenced to 8 months in prison under the 2024 national-security ordinance for attempting to withdraw funds from an insurance policy the court treated as her assets. Anna disputes that she owned or controlled the policy and describes the prosecution as retaliation for her advocacy; the magistrate rejected the characterization of collective punishment.\20\ Overseas activists have told me directly that relatives in Hong Kong and mainland China have received calls seeking the activists' whereabouts and personal information. Such calls can make people fear that speaking publicly will expose their loved ones to harm. The uncertainty over who is watching, and what might happen next, can itself become a means of intimidation. Pressure can also reach people's resources. In December 2020, Hong Kong police asked banks to freeze accounts belonging to Ted Hui and his family on suspicion of money laundering. An April 2026 China Strategic Risks Institute report documents Christopher Mung's disputed retrospective tax demands, including an assessment of profits from a business he says he never operated. He has challenged the demands; his appeal was still unresolved when the report was written.\21\ I see a system that seeks to govern through fear, intimidation, and the expectation of surveillance. That fear reaches beyond those directly targeted, as others begin weighing civic participation against danger to themselves or their families. Democracies must protect the freedom to hold the regime accountable, and the people who continue to exercise it. What Sustained Pressure Can Achieve The loss of these freedoms, and of the people and institutions that defend them, calls for a sustained U.S. response. The Commission's mandate to monitor human rights and the rule of law, gather evidence, and recommend legislative and executive action provides a basis for keeping both individual cases and institutional changes before Congress and the Administration. I ask you to pursue four priorities.\22\ First, press for the immediate and unconditional release of Joshua Wong, Lee Cheuk-yan, Albert Ho, Chow Hang-tung, Jimmy Lai, and others imprisoned for peaceful political participation, remembrance, or journalism. I ask the Commission to urge the Administration to make their release a sustained priority in its engagement with Hong Kong and Chinese authorities.\23\ Second, give Hong Kongers at risk the security to rebuild their lives. I ask you to urge the Administration to extend Deferred Enforced Departure (DED) before its current expiry on 5 February 2027, and the Department of Homeland Security to ensure uninterrupted employment authorization for those covered. The Administration should also consider updating the eligibility cutoff to reach more recent arrivals who face danger on return. DED offers temporary protection from removal; people need a future beyond repeated extensions. Congress should legislate a durable humanitarian pathway to permanent residence for qualifying Hong Kongers and their families.\24\ Third, fund the institutions that allow Hong Kongers to remain informed and connected. I ask you to urge Congress to authorize multi- year operating support for Hong Kong civil-society groups, especially diaspora media, and to sustain that support through dependable appropriations. Funding should be administered through the State Department or independent grant-making bodies with appropriate authority. Newsrooms need to pay reporters and editors, investigate stories, obtain legal assistance, and maintain secure publishing systems. Community groups need staff and places to sustain their work. Support should help newsrooms reach audiences inside Hong Kong as well as across the diaspora. The Commission's 2025 report already recommended facilitating diaspora-led news outlets and investigative journalism; Congress should turn that recommendation into dependable support. Grants should protect editorial independence and confidential sources, with oversight of grant spending that respects those protections.\25\ Fourth, protect advocates and their families from transnational repression. I ask the Commission to urge the Administration to coordinate law-enforcement, diplomatic, and immigration responses with democratic partners, universities, and community organizations. People exercising their civic freedoms need confidential reporting, timely risk assessments, investigation of threats, and practical legal, digital, and physical protection.\26\ Safeguards must also prevent international cooperation from becoming a means of persecution. The United States and its partners should coordinate their policies toward China to defend democratic sovereignty against authoritarian interference. My concern is that authoritarian regimes exploit friction among democracies over monetary, fiscal, trade, and security policy to consolidate their power and suppress dissent. I do not expect these measures to transform Hong Kong or end China's aggression against democratic countries overnight. Sustained pressure matters because it preserves a record, keeps people and institutions from disappearing from international attention, and builds the relationships and policy options needed when circumstances change. Preparation takes time, and the moment when action becomes possible may arrive before governments feel ready. My concern is that threats to public accountability have been accumulating since 2019, with roots reaching further back. A future crisis could expose weaknesses allowed to grow because criticism was suppressed or professional warnings went unheard. Joshua, the Alliance, free press and free speech, and the student institutions that shaped me are part of how Hong Kong passes on memory and responsibility. Protecting the freedom to participate and question authority protects that capacity--including the ability to recognize failures, correct mistakes, and hold power accountable before the cost becomes irreparable. ---------------- [Endnotes begin on the next page.] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Submission of Hong Kong Watch Chairman Sullivan, Co-Chair Smith, and Members of the Commission, thank you for the opportunity to submit this statement for the record, to complement the testimony of Ms. Claire Lai and Mr. Sebastien Lai. This statement (I) reviews the case of Jimmy Lai; (II) documents the broader deterioration of the rule of law and civil society in Hong Kong; (III) flags the recent, unexplained lapse of the national emergency underlying Executive Order 13936; (IV) situates all of this as a direct U.S. strategic and financial concern; and (V) recommends that the Commission support legislation that would codify differentiated treatment for Hong Kong so it cannot lapse or be traded away absent a presidential certification that autonomy has been restored. I. The Case of Jimmy Lai Jimmy Lai, 78, founder of the shuttered pro-democracy newspaper Apple Daily and a British citizen, was arrested in August 2020 within weeks of the imposition of the Hong Kong National Security Law (HKNSL). After a 156-day trial, he was convicted on December 15, 2025 of two counts of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces and one count of conspiracy to publish seditious material. Lai was sentenced on February 9, 2026 to 20 years, the longest HKNSL sentence to date, and, given his age, effectively a life term. The court's 855-page verdict rested substantially on Mr. Lai's lawful meetings with senior U.S. officials during the 2019 protests, treating protected diplomatic engagement as evidence of criminal collusion. Mr. Lai has spent over 5 years in detention, much of it in solitary confinement, with repeated concerns raised about his declining health. Mr. Lai's legal team confirmed in March 2026 that he will not appeal, a decision left unexplained, which some analysts read as an attempt to preserve a possible diplomatic resolution, though none has been confirmed. In a separate case, Hong Kong's Court of Appeal overturned an earlier fraud conviction against Mr. Lai on February 26, 2026. This was a rare judicial rebuke of the prosecution. We urge the Commission to continue pressing for his immediate and unconditional release, especially on humanitarian grounds. II. The Broader Pattern of Human Rights Violations in Hong Kong Mr. Lai's case is the clearest example of the HKNSL's function, but the pattern is accelerating across the board, including in just the past month. Criminalizing Tiananmen commemoration: On August 21, 2026, Chow Hang-tung and Lee Cheuk-yan, leaders of the now-disbanded Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China who organized the Victoria Park vigil, were convicted of incitement to subversion. The conviction centered on the Alliance's slogan calling to ``end one-party dictatorship,'' after nearly 5 years already on remand. Both face up to ten more years' imprisonment. Dismantling civil society: Lingnan University's student union dissolved on August 6, 2026, leaving independent unions at only two public universities in Hong Kong; the University of Hong Kong is replacing its open ``Democracy Wall'' with a managed digital display; and the Hong Kong Secretary for Security has publicly challenged the legitimacy of the Hong Kong Journalists Association. Transnational reach: A Hong Kong Watch survey (Aug. 25, 2026) found 93 percent of Hong Kongers with UK settled status were refused withdrawal of their Hong Kong retirement savings; an overseas activist's bank accounts, including those funding a diaspora media outlet, were abruptly closed. These moves follow a widening and ongoing campaign of transnational repression that now spans arrest warrants and bounties on 34 overseas activists, the jailing of a wanted activist's own father, and the targeting of a U.S. citizen on American soil: Anna Kwok, executive director of the Washington-based Hong Kong Democracy Council, has a HK$1 million ($127,500) bounty on her head, and in February 2026 her 69-year-old father was convicted and sentenced to 8 months in prison merely for attempting to access a childhood insurance policy in her name. This was the first prosecution of a wanted activist's relative under the HKNSL. Joey Siu, a U.S. citizen and human rights advocate based in Washington, DC, likewise carries a HK$1 million bounty and became the first American ever wanted under the HKNSL for activity conducted entirely within the United States. III. The Lapse of the Hong Kong National Emergency We ask the Commission to treat the following as urgent. Since 2020, the national emergency underlying Executive Order 13936, the legal foundation for Hong Kong sanctions authority and the withdrawal of Hong Kong's preferential trade and export-control treatment, has been renewed by the President every July, as the National Emergencies Act requires. This year it was not. The emergency lapsed on July 14, 2026, and we have since confirmed this was a deliberate decision, not an oversight: China's Commerce Ministry announced it before Washington did, in the context of ongoing U.S.- China trade talks, and the Department of the Treasury confirmed it days later. On July 17, 2026, Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control removed from the Specially Designated Nationals list every individual designated solely under EO 13936/IEEPA authority, including Hong Kong's Justice Secretary, its National Security Department chief, and two former Police Commissioners. Those independently sanctionable under the Hong Kong Autonomy Act were shifted to a lesser, non-blocking list rather than dropped outright, and previously blocked assets remain blocked, but no new EO 13936-based designations can now be made. The Administration has offered no public explanation. We ask the Commission to press the Administration to confirm, on the record, whether Hong Kong sanctions relief was extended as consideration in the broader trade negotiations, and to account fully for which protections have lapsed as a result. This episode is itself the clearest available evidence for why Hong Kong policy must be codified in statute rather than left to annual executive discretion. IV. Why This Is a U.S. Concern, Not Only a Human Rights Concern Hong Kong remains the People's Republic of China's (PRC) principal gateway to international capital and a major U.S.-dollar clearing hub, even as it has been fully absorbed into Beijing's national security architecture. It is also a documented transshipment node for sanctioned and dual-use goods, including inputs reaching Russia's war in Ukraine, infrastructure that would be equally available to Beijing in any future crisis, including over Taiwan. The lapse described above shows how easily that leverage can be traded away administratively. Codifying it in statute would remove that ambiguity for Beijing, for Hong Kong's remaining independent institutions, and for U.S. businesses and persons still operating there. V. Legislative Recommendations 1. Support New Legislation to Close These Gaps We urge the Commission to support new legislation that would codify differentiated treatment for Hong Kong so it cannot lapse or be traded away absent a Presidential certification that autonomy has been restored; authorize targeted sanctions against those responsible for the repression above; and establish pre-authorized financial contingency measures, including suspension of unrestricted USD-HKD conversion and blocking sanctions on the Hong Kong Monetary Authority's clearing infrastructure, triggered automatically by certified PRC aggression against Taiwan or another neighbor. 2. Demand Accountability for the EO 13936 Lapse We urge the Commission to formally request that the Department of State and Treasury explain the decision not to renew the national emergency, disclose whether it was linked to trade negotiations, and report in full which individuals and protections it affects. 3. Protect Hong Kongers in the United States We encourage the Commission to examine retirement-savings and financial-access barriers facing Hong Kongers abroad, including in the U.S., and to raise them with UK and Hong Kong regulators and UK- headquartered institutions operating in U.S. markets. 4. Maintain Sustained Oversight We urge the Commission to treat this hearing as the start of continued oversight, given how quickly this landscape is changing, and would welcome the opportunity to keep the Commission updated. VI. Conclusion Jimmy Lai's case is not an aberration within a functioning legal system. It is that system's clearest product, and it now sits alongside an accelerating set of prosecutions, institutional closures, transnational pressures, and a quiet unwinding of U.S. leverage. We thank the Commission for its attention and stand ready to provide further information or assistance. Letter Submitted by Dr. Jianli Yang and Dr. Mary Moran ______ September 15, 2026 To: Congressional-Executive Commission on China Senator Dan Sullivan, Chair Representative Chris Smith, Co-Chair Commission Members Re: Urgent appeal to raise the conviction of Cardinal Zen along with fellow appellants with President Xi. A priority for President Trump's human rights agenda when talking with President Xi must include the recent conviction by the Hong Kong court of Cardinal Zen and fellow appellants. As concerned citizens, we ask that this letter and the linked Hong Kong court ruling be placed in the record at the September 16th Commission hearing along with the examination of Jimmy Lai. If China is for human rights, President Xi must bring justice and restore the reputation of 94-year-old Cardinal Zen! We ask that President Trump raise this case to President Xi when he visits Washington. The conviction of Cardinal Zen that just came out on September 3, 2026 should be condemned globally as an unacceptable restriction of the freedom of association. Cardinal Zen, a longtime advocate for religious and political freedom in China, led the Diocese of Hong Kong from 2002 to 2009. In May 2022, Cardinal Zen, along with four other defendants, was arrested on suspicion of collusion with foreign forces under Hong Kong's national security law. The cardinal was fined over an unregistered fund, called the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund. This fund paid the legal and medical bills of prisoners, along with compassionate donations to immediate family members of any person who died in a public protest. On September 3 of this month, Hong Kong's Special Administrative Region Court of Appeal upheld Cardinal Zen's conviction for failing to register a fund that aided the 2019 Hong Kong protesters. While many would call the fund a work of mercy, the Hong Kong court has called it an ``unregistered society.'' The 122-page court ruling of the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Court of Appeal issued on September 3, 2026 upheld Cardinal Zen's conviction. (See link below.) Cardinal Zen, though retired, is still seen as a strong spiritual leader, not only among Catholic activists but non-Catholics as well. Cardinal Zen has always been one of the first persons identifying the traps and dangers in new social legislation and policies that endanger the rights of the people and the Church. These legislative actions usually cloak themselves in attractive promises. The Cardinal's voice is always strong. But he never neglects charity, e.g., visiting the prison and supporting activists facing prosecution. He requires Catholic schools to admit children without residence papers who otherwise would be denied education by the Government--to mention only a few. Thank you for your attention to this critical issue. Dr. Jianli Yang Dr. Mary Moran Citizen Power Initiatives for China U.S. Dept. of Education (Retired) Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Ph: 857-472-9039 Ph: 202-494-4036 Link to September 3, 2026 ruling upholding the conviction of Cardinal Zen and others by the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Court of Appeal: https://perma.cc/RX8B-F94X [THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Witness Biographies Sebastien Lai, son of Jimmy Lai and leader, #FreeJimmyLai campaign Sebastien Lai is Jimmy Lai's son and the leader of the international #FreeJimmyLai campaign. He has become a principal public advocate for his father's release, pressing governments and legislatures to keep the case at the center of their engagement with Beijing and Hong Kong authorities. Sebastien previously testified before the Congressional- Executive Commission on China in 2023 about his father's imprisonment and the erosion of the rule of law in Hong Kong. In December 2021, he accepted the WAN-IFRA Golden Pen of Freedom award on behalf of his father and the newsroom staff of Apple Daily after Hong Kong authorities forced the newspaper to close. Steve Yates, Senior Research Fellow for China and National Security Policy and Chung Ju Yung Fellow, The Heritage Foundation Steve Yates is Senior Research Fellow for China and National Security Policy and Chung Ju Yung Fellow in the Asian Studies Center at The Heritage Foundation. He previously served as Deputy Assistant for National Security Affairs under Vice President Dick Cheney; as president of Radio Free Asia; and as head of the China Policy Initiative at the America First Policy Institute. He also served earlier as a senior policy analyst at Heritage and holds a master's degree in China Studies from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies. Mark L. Clifford, President of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation and author of ``The Troublemaker'' Mark L. Clifford is President of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation and author of ``The Troublemaker: How Jimmy Lai Became a Billionaire, Hong Kong's Greatest Dissident, and China's Most Feared Critic.'' Clifford holds a Ph.D. in history from the University of Hong Kong and was a Walter Bagehot Fellow at Columbia University. He lived in Asia from 1987 to 2020 and held senior editorial positions at the South China Morning Post, The Standard, BusinessWeek, and the Far Eastern Economic Review. He also served as a director of Next Digital, the publisher of Apple Daily, when Hong Kong authorities forced the newspaper to shut down in 2021. [all]