FIXING FRAUD AND FAILURE IN FEDERALLY FUNDED HOMELESSNESS SERVICES

Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · Subcommittee on Delivering on Government Efficiency House September 15, 2026

Witnesses (3)

  • Hon. Karen Bass (Invited), Mayor, City of Los Angeles Mr. Jonathan Choe, Senior Fellow and Journalist, Discovery Institute
  • Mr. Paul Webster, Executive Director, Los Angeles Alliance for Human Rights
  • Ms. Samantha Batko (Minority Witness), Senior Fellow, Urban Institute

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- FIXING FRAUD AND FAILURE IN FEDERALLY FUNDED HOMELESSNESS SERVICES

[House Hearing, 119 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 FIXING FRAUD AND FAILURE
 IN FEDERALLY FUNDED
 HOMELESSNESS SERVICES
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON DELIVERING ON GOVERNMENT EFFICIENCY

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM

 U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 SEPTEMBER 15, 2026

 __________

 Serial No. 119-76

 __________

Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 Available on: govinfo.gov, oversight.house.gov or docs.house.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-572 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
=======================================================================
 
 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM

 JAMES COMER, Kentucky, Chairman

Jim Jordan, Ohio Robert Garcia, California, Ranking 
Mike Turner, Ohio Minority Member
Paul Gosar, Arizona Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of 
Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Columbia
Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts
Michael Cloud, Texas Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois
Gary Palmer, Alabama Ro Khanna, California
Clay Higgins, Louisiana Kweisi Mfume, Maryland
Pete Sessions, Texas Shontel Brown, Ohio
Andy Biggs, Arizona Melanie Stansbury, New Mexico
Nancy Mace, South Carolina Maxwell Frost, Florida
Pat Fallon, Texas Greg Casar, Texas
Byron Donalds, Florida Jasmine Crockett, Texas
Scott Perry, Pennsylvania Emily Randall, Washington
William Timmons, South Carolina Suhas Subramanyam, Virginia
Tim Burchett, Tennessee Yassamin Ansari, Arizona
Lauren Boebert, Colorado Wesley Bell, Missouri
Anna Paulina Luna, Florida Lateefah Simon, California
Nick Langworthy, New York Dave Min, California
Eric Burlison, Missouri James Walkinshaw, Virginia
Elijah Crane, Arizona Christian Menefee, Texas
Brian Jack, Georgia Ayanna Pressley, Massachusetts
John McGuire, Virginia Rashida Tlaib, Michigan
Brandon Gill, Texas
Richard McCormick, Georgia

 ------ 

 Mark Marin, Staff Director
 James Rust, Deputy Staff Director
 Ryan Giachetti, Chief Counsel
 Peter Warren, Senior Advisor
 Jack Furla, Counsel
 Mallory Cogar, Director of Operations and Chief Clerk

 Contact Number: 202-225-5074

 Robert Edmonson, Minority Staff Director
 Contact Number: 202-225-5051
 
 ------ 

 Subcommittee on Delivering on Government Efficiency (DOGE)

 Tim Burchett, Tennessee, Chairman

Michael Cloud, Texas Melanie Stansbury, New Mexico, 
Nancy Mace, South Carolina Ranking Member
Pat Fallon, Texas Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of 
William Timmons, South Carolina Columbia
Lauren Boebert, Colorado Stephen Lynch, Massachusetts
Anna Paulina Luna, Florida Maxwell Frost, Florida
Eric Burlison, Missouri Greg Casar, Texas
Brian Jack, Georgia Jasmine Crockett, Texas
Brandon Gill, Texas Suhas Subramanyam, Virginia
 James Walkinshaw, Virginia
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page

Hon. Tim Burchett, U.S. Representative, Chairman................. 1

Hon. Melanie Stansbury, U.S. Representative, Ranking Member...... 3

 WITNESSES

Hon. Karen Bass (Invited), Mayor, City of Los Angeles

Mr. Jonathan Choe, Senior Fellow and Journalist, Discovery 
 Institute
Oral Statement................................................... 5

Mr. Paul Webster, Executive Director, Los Angeles Alliance for 
 Human Rights
Oral Statement................................................... 6

Ms. Samantha Batko (Minority Witness), Senior Fellow, Urban 
 Institute
Oral Statement................................................... 8

Written opening statements and bios are available on the U.S. 
 House of Representatives Document Repository at: 
 docs.house.gov.

 INDEX OF DOCUMENTS

 * Statement for the Record from Samantha Batko; submitted by 
 Rep. Stansbury.

 * Statement for the Record from Kingdom Warriors Foundation; 
 submitted by Rep. Burchett.

 * Article, Washington Post, ``How One Billionaire's Crusade 
 Against Homelessness Became Trump's Playbook''; submitted by 
 Rep. Frost.

 * Article, Mother Jones, ``Palantir Billionaire's Passion 
 Project Is Criminalizing Homelessness''; submitted by Rep. 
 Tlaib.

 * Statement for the Record from National Homelessness Law 
 Center; submitted by Rep. Tlaib.

The documents listed above are available at: docs.house.gov.

 
 FIXING FRAUD AND FAILURE
 IN FEDERALLY FUNDED
 HOMELESSNESS SERVICES

 ---------- 

 TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 15, 2026

 U.S. House of Representatives

 Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

 Subcommittee on Delivering on Government Efficiency

 Washington, D.C.

 The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:08 p.m., in 
room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Tim Burchett 
[Chairman of the Subcommittee] presiding.
 Present: Representatives Burchett, Cloud, Mace, Fallon, 
Boebert, Burlison, Jack, Gill, Stansbury, Lynch, Frost, and 
Walkinshaw.
 Also present: Representatives Sessions and Tlaib.
 Mr. Burchett. This hearing of the Subcommittee on 
Delivering on Government Efficiency will come to order.
 I want to welcome everyone.
 Without objection, the Chair may declare a recess any time, 
and I recognize myself for the purpose of making an opening 
statement.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF CHAIRMAN TIM BURCHETT

 REPRESENTATIVE FROM TENNESSEE

 Good afternoon. The plight of our Nation's homeless tugs at 
our heartstrings. It is painful to see people living on the 
streets or in shelters. Those caught in the cycle of 
homelessness are often drug-addicted, mentally ill, or both. 
They need help. But the homeless services provided today in 
many of our largest cities are not working. In fact, they are 
making the problem worse.
 There are 745,000 homeless Americans, according to a recent 
Federal report. Two-thirds live in emergency shelters, and the 
other quarter million live on the streets. The situation is 
only getting worse. Homelessness is up 27 percent since 2013, 
and street homelessness is up 36 percent. Why?
 It is not due to lack of funding. The Federal Government 
spends about $8 billion annually to prevent homelessness, and 
states and localities spend even more. Yet, homeless 
encampments keep spreading especially in cities like Los 
Angeles and Seattle where left-wing political leaders are 
digging in on failed policies. These jurisdictions enable crime 
and chaos, allowing public housing units to become more drug 
dens and even subsidizing the so-called safe injection of 
dangerous narcotics by addicts.
 Los Angeles is the epicenter of America's homelessness. It 
has the Nation's largest homeless population, and it spends the 
most to combat the problem. Yet, the number of homeless in L.A. 
has recently risen to 50,000 people. Another 75,000 homeless 
live in the surrounding L.A. County. L.A.'s Skid Row is a sad 
testament to the abject failure of this city's approach to 
homelessness.
 Under Mayor Karen Bass, law and order in the neighborhood 
has collapsed. Addicts inject needles in open drug markets 
controlled by gangs. The remaining businesses, typically small 
minority-owned establishments, struggle to survive in the 
streets where lawlessness reigns.
 So, who benefits from the billions spent combatting 
homelessness in L.A.? Look no further than the network of local 
nonprofits raking in Federal, state, and local dollars to 
provide homeless services. Most of these entities got grants or 
contracts from the Los Angeles Homeless Service Authority, or 
LAHSA, a public authority jointly controlled by the city and 
the county of Los Angeles.
 LAHSA is the main L.A. area conduit for public funds for 
homelessness services, and LAHSA is ripe with corruption and 
financial mismanagement. This outfit is housed in a luxury 
high-rise in downtown L.A., with a private helipad and 
Mercedes-Maybach car service for tenants.
 If you do not know, Maybach is the high end of the Mercedes 
brand.
 Mayor Bass controls many appointments to LAHSA's 
government's board. She appointed herself to the board back in 
2023, but has not shown up for most board meetings. Despite her 
poor attendance record, her fingerprints are all over LAHSA.
 The Authority gave a $40,000-per-month contract to a former 
Bass campaign manager who it then hired as its CEO. Once in 
charge, the advisor gave a two million LAHSA contract to her 
husband's employer, an L.A.-based nonprofit. LAHSA also 
provided $25 million over five years to a nonprofit whose CEO 
received $1.6 million in compensation over a recent two year 
period while living in Hawaii.
 LAHSA recently doled out funds to an L.A.-area nonprofit 
whose CEO had just been indicted for fraud by the Justice 
Department.
 This is the tip of the iceberg, folks. A court-ordered 
independent assessment of LAHSA's finances found alarming 
financial control weaknesses that leave the door open to 
rampant fraud. Yet, the chair of LAHSA's audit committee, an 
advocate of greater scrutiny of LAHSA spending, was recently 
removed from his post by Mayor Bass' handpicked LAHSA board 
chair, Stephanie Graves, another former campaign advisor.
 Finally, just last week, after inviting her to appear at 
this hearing, Mayor Bass suddenly removed herself from the 
LAHSA board. She also declined to appear at this hearing. She 
said this hearing and document request was a waste of time and 
money.
 Mayor Bass seems intent on evading accountability, but she 
knows we will not let her off the hook. Her office has agreed 
to provide dates when she is willing to appear before our 
Subcommittee this year because she knows I will work with 
Chairman Comer to use every tool at our disposal to secure her 
appearance if she does not cooperate.
 Meanwhile, we are going to take a good hard look today at 
homelessness on the streets of Los Angeles and the big leftist-
run cities.
 After this hearing, I will introduce the Recovery First 
Housing Act, which requires federally funded housing services 
to offer substance abuse treatment. But I have also introduced 
legislation to codify President Trump's work in crime and 
disorder on America's streets and ensure our tax dollars only 
support housing services for U.S. citizens.
 Before I close, I am going to play a brief video clip of 
the reality of homelessness on Skid Row.
 [Video shown.]
 Mr. Burchett. I have in my hand one of those packets, and I 
just found a crack pipe in there; first one I have ever held.
 But with that, I will yield to Ranking Member Stansbury for 
her opening remarks.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF RANKING MEMBER

 MELANIE STANSBURY, REPRESENTATIVE FROM NEW MEXICO

 Ms. Stansbury. All right. Well, thank you Mr. Chairman. I 
do have to say that, once again, this Committee has 
deteriorated over the last several months.
 I was hopeful at the beginning of my partnership with the 
Chairman that we would actually move forward in a serious 
manner in addressing the issues that are affecting our 
country--to deal with real waste, fraud and abuse, to deal with 
real accountability of our government and the officials who are 
actually taking advantage of our Federal system, to actually 
reduce waste in our government, and to actually improve the 
services and programs that actually serve our people. But 
instead, we are here, once again, after our last hearing on the 
Smithsonian, in a deeply unserious and political show, 
targeting the lowest income and most vulnerable people in the 
United States.
 And let me just make clear: Our people are not political 
props. Their dignity is not negotiable. Housing is a human 
right, and we are not going to sit here while you use the 
housing and homeless crisis of this country to try to prop up 
whatever you are trying to do politically before the midterms.
 So, I want to know what this hearing is actually about. 
Ostensibly, it is supposed to be about housing and 
homelessness, strangely in Los Angeles, as we sit here in our 
Nation's Capital. Ostensibly, it is supposed to be about waste, 
fraud, and abuse, as it was literally reported yesterday that 
the President's son had his wedding parties hosted by a Russian 
oligarch tied to Vladimir Putin, as literally we have not had a 
single public hearing on the Epstein files, as we have not even 
had Todd Blanche in front of this Committee in a formal 
hearing.
 So, what is this hearing actually about?
 We are two days before the Speaker is going to call it 
quits before the midterms, and basically this hearing is being 
called to attack unhoused people, to talk about the failed 
policies of this Administration.
 Because if you were actually serious about helping low-
income people, you would not have passed the big ugly bill last 
year, because what that bill and that policy is doing is making 
poor people even poorer. In fact, it increased taxes on the 
lowest income Americans out there. Like, that is not an 
exaggeration. The lowest earning Americans had their taxes go 
up under the big ugly bill.
 It gutted food assistance for millions of Americans, the 
vast majority of whom are seniors and children. It gut health 
insurance. Starting on January 1st, Medicaid and Medicare is 
going to be cut for tens of millions of Americans. It gutted 
educational assistance for students all over the country.
 And why? Why was it done? To give a permanent tax break to 
billionaires.
 Right now this country is experiencing the highest 
inflation it has experienced since COVID. Because your 
President, who you refuse to hold in check, is waging an 
unmandated, unfunded war in the Middle East that is driving up 
gas prices to the highest level they have ever been during a 
Labor Day weekend in the history of the United States, which is 
driving up housing costs, construction costs, food costs, 
transportation costs, literally every cost across the board. In 
fact, we are about to see an increase, likely from the Fed, in 
our interest rates because of skyrocketing inflation.
 And the only housing legislation that has passed this body 
of substance in years--in fact, it was the most comprehensive, 
bipartisan, housing legislation passed probably in three 
decades in this body just a few months ago--the President of 
the United States, Donald Trump, refused to sign, because he 
was having a temper tantrum.
 Now, it took effect, but it would not have happened if it 
had not had been from the leadership particularly of our Senate 
Democrats and the Ranking Member of the Financial Services 
Committee here in the House.
 And so, what is this hearing actually about? Cannot be 
about the stellar housing policies of HUD. They have literally 
been gutting Housing First programs. Y'all have been gutting 
behavioral health programs to deal with addiction problems. In 
fact, Donald Trump proposed to cut a billion dollars in grants 
to help people that have addiction problems.
 And, meanwhile, the grifter in chief is over there on the 
other side of Pennsylvania Avenue literally tweeting out AI 
images of himself insider trading and making money off the 
backs of the American people. That is the waste, fraud, and 
abuse.
 So, if you are serious about housing, we invite you to 
work, again, on a bipartisan basis, on affordable housing 
policies, on investments in behavioral health and helping 
people who are struggling, to actually reverse the harmful cuts 
that this Administration has put into effect, to reverse the 
tax increases you put into effect that are harming our people, 
to hold the President accountable and end this war, and to 
actually help the people that you are trying to claim today you 
actually care about. Because housing is a human right, and we 
are going to continue to fight for it.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, ma'am.
 Without objection, Representative Sessions of Texas and 
Representative Tlaib of Michigan are waived on to the 
Subcommittee for the purpose of asking questions at today's 
hearing.
 And I would like to welcome our witnesses. First, we have 
Mr. Jonathan Choe. Mr. Choe is a senior fellow and journalist 
at the Discovery Institute.
 Thank you for being here.
 Next, we have Mr. Paul Webster. Mr. Webster serves as the 
Executive Director of the Los Angeles Alliance for Human Rights 
and a Senior Fellow at the Cicero Institute.
 And, last, we have Ms. Samantha Batko. Ms. Batko serves as 
a Senior Fellow at the Urban Institute.
 I want to thank you all for joining us, and I look forward 
to your testimony.
 Pursuant to Committee Rule 9(g), the witnesses will please 
stand up and raise their right hand.
 Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony that you 
are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing 
but the truth, so help you God?
 [Chorus of ayes.]
 Mr. Burchett. Let the record show that the witnesses 
answered in the affirmative.
 Thank you, and you may take a seat. We appreciate y'all 
being here today and look forward to your testimony.
 Let me remind the witnesses that we will have read your 
written statement, and it will appear in full in the hearing 
record. Please limit your oral statements to 5 minutes. As a 
reminder, please press the button on the microphone in front of 
you so that it is on and the Members can hear you. When you 
begin to speak, the light in front of you will turn green. 
After 4 minutes, the light will turn yellow. When the red light 
comes on, your 5 minutes have expired, and we would ask that 
you please wrap up.
 I now recognize Mr. Choe for his opening statement.
 Hit your button.

 STATEMENT OF MR. JONATHAN CHOE

 SENIOR FELLOW AND JOURNALIST, DISCOVERY INSTITUTE

 Mr. Choe. My apologies.
 Thank you, sir, for this opportunity to talk about 
America's homeless drug crisis. I would like to begin by 
playing a short video before my testimony.
 [Video shown.]
 Mr. Choe. Once again, my name is Jonathan Choe. I am a 
journalist and Senior Fellow at Discovery Institute based in 
Seattle. I cover America's homeless drug crisis, after spending 
more than 20 years in corporate media working for ABC, NBC, 
CBS, Tribune, and several other networks.
 If you did not know already, you just witnessed a snapshot 
of what happens in and around many of these Housing First 
facilities across America, especially in West Coast cities like 
Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, and Los Angeles.
 And this is the PG-13 version. Law enforcement data shows 
these facilities are magnets for crime, chaos, and death, 
triggering an inordinate amount of 911 calls for drug 
overdoses, fights, and other disturbances.
 Once these men and women move in, there are no requirements 
to find jobs or enroll in drug addiction treatment. So, for the 
addicts, most of them spend their day chasing the next high on 
the streets, in many cases, committing crimes like stealing and 
then selling items for pennies on the dollar to get their next 
fix. Making matters worse, in some cases, violent felons and 
notorious drug dealers end up as residents on the same floor as 
vulnerable people. And some women even become targets for 
sexual assault or human trafficking.
 One man I interviewed told me he felt like his Housing 
First building turned into ``New Jack City,'' a reference to a 
movie about a drug kingpin taking over an entire apartment 
complex in New York City.
 Problem is, life is now imitating art, and the cycle 
continues with more taxpayer dollars being wasted on 
questionable public health policies tied to Housing First. Most 
of these buildings are considered low barrier. That means drug 
use is allowed behind closed doors, and staff look the other 
way. Then on top of that, you can pick up these so-called harm 
reduction kits at the front desk. Let me show you briefly what 
is inside.
 Mr. Burchett, you referred to the meth pipes that you can 
easily get, but this baggy given out at King County Public 
Health just minutes from the Seattle Space Needle is called a 
``party pack.''
 You can get a free meth pipe. You can get a tourniquet. You 
can get countless needles inside. You can get fentanyl test 
strips. You can get cookers. They are giving away free drug 
supplies like candy in the name of harm reduction and 
preventing disease, with zero oversight and rarely any offers 
for addiction treatment.
 In reality, critics say that this is enabling instead of 
helping, and now people are dying at higher rates, behind 
closed doors, of fentanyl overdoses----
 Mr. Burchett. Mr. Choe, we are going to have to cut it off 
there at 5.
 Mr. Choe. Okay.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, sir.
 Mr. Choe. Thank you.
 Mr. Burchett. Mr. Webster.
 I apologize.

 STATEMENT OF MR. PAUL WEBSTER

 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

 LOS ANGELES ALLIANCE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS

 Mr. Webster. Thank you, Chairman Burchett, Ranking Member 
Stansbury, Members of the Subcommittee. Thank you very much for 
holding this hearing. It is long overdue.
 Last year's point-in-time count found nearly 70,000 
homeless people in Los Angeles; 44,000 were unsheltered, 27,000 
were chronically homeless, and six of them die on the street 
every day.
 No region in America has more unsheltered people, and no 
region receives more Federal homeless assistance. Los Angeles 
has taken in $2 billion in Federal funds since 2005, including 
$220 million in 2024 in Continuum of Care awards. Its awards 
are up 213 percent. The city and county have budgeted another 
$4 billion of their own money since 2022. Here is what that 
bought.
 Since 2009, the year the HEARTH Act reformed Federal 
homeless assistance programs, overall homelessness in Los 
Angeles doubled. Unsheltered homelessness grew 130 percent, 
chronic homelessness rose 20 percent, and homelessness among 
people with serious mental illness rose 90 percent.
 There is more money than ever before, more capacity than 
ever before, and more and sicker people on the streets than 
ever before. That is the record.
 Why homelessness grew is not a matter of funding. It is not 
about adopting the favored evidence-based approaches. L.A. has 
tons of money and adopted all the data-driven approaches. Why 
homelessness grew, and is growing, is about accountability, and 
there is absolutely none.
 The Los Angeles Homeless Service Authority, LAHSA, is the 
region's Continuum of Care. A 2024 audit found LAHSA has wasted 
millions, has unreliable contract and service records, and 
cannot verify whether the services it paid for had been 
delivered.
 It got worse. A May 2026 review found LAHSA could not 
produce complete financial statements, had not properly 
recorded $145 million in county advances, and carried duplicate 
entries overstating cash by $47 million. LAHSA has not 
completed an internal audit in several years.
 HUD is right in suspending funds for LAHSA, but it is not 
just untraceable funds, paid-for units and beds that go empty, 
or corrupt CEOs that feed the homeless instant ramen, governed 
by an imaginary board of directors and use taxpayer dollars to 
enrich themselves. It is not just sweetheart deals from Mayor 
Bass' office that green-lit $227 million--I'm sorry--$27 
million in taxpayer grant funds to buy a property from a 
business, purchasing almost simultaneously for $11 million. It 
is not just LAHSA's own chief executive that signed $2.1 
million in contracts with the nonprofit that employs her 
husband, after telling the public she was completely recused 
from such dealings.
 It is the poorly crafted, expensive, and unworkable system 
Congress created that was supposed to end homelessness in 2023.
 This is what happens when billions flow to a network of 
nonprofits over which no state or local government has 
authority that measures inputs, beds, salaries, and services 
billed, rather than on whether anyone left the street.
 It took HUD roughly a decade to determine that Los Angeles 
was wasting its awards. Thousands of homeless people died in 
the meantime. Suspension after ten years is not oversight. I 
urge Subcommittee Members to reform the Continuum of Care 
Program in three ways.
 First, stop funding and empowering entities that voters 
cannot reach. Route homeless assistance through states and 
their agencies which answer to an electorate, rather than 
through unaccountable regional nonprofits. Nonprofit 
consortiums have failed to solve homelessness for the last ten-
plus years and, when challenged, demand more money to continue 
their ineffective research-based programs.
 Second, direct HUD to monitor and to act. Audit findings of 
mismanagement should not sit for a decade. Performance should 
be demanded annually because lives are on the line.
 Third, fix the definition. Federal law and regulation 
redefines a person as no longer homeless when their names 
appear on a subsidized lease. Advocates claim they know how to 
end homelessness, but it is this definitional gimmick that is 
the basis for that claim.
 Ending homelessness should mean earned income, sobriety, 
mental health stability, family reunification, and completing 
rehabilitative programs and progress toward self-sufficiency, 
not a signature or eligibility for a government program.
 Los Angeles is not an outlier. It is the poster child for 
an expensive, socialist, no-conditions-attached right to 
housing agenda that can only work by raising taxes, ending 
private property, and implementing a guaranteed basic income 
scheme, while turning a blind eye to addiction, untreated 
mental illness, crime, and civil disorder.
 Thank you.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, Mr. Webster.
 Ms. Batko, you are recognized.

 STATEMENT OF MS. SAMANTHA BATKO (MINORITY WITNESS)

 SENIOR FELLOW, URBAN INSTITUTE

 Ms. Batko. Chairman Burchett, Ranking Member Stansbury, and 
the Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to 
testify.
 My name is Samantha Batko. I am a Senior Fellow, and I lead 
the Preventing and Ending Homelessness Team at the nonpartisan 
Urban Institute.
 For more than two decades, I have researched and evaluated 
homelessness programs and worked with communities trying to 
reduce homelessness.
 The views I express today are my own and should not be 
attributed to the Urban Institute, its trustees, or its 
funders.
 I want to begin with a point on which I believe that we can 
all agree, which is that the status quo is unacceptable. As was 
noted earlier, more than 745,000 people experienced 
homelessness on a single night in 2025. More than 266,000 were 
living outside in cars or in other places not meant for human 
habitation, and that included more than 22,000 children living 
outside on a single night.
 Communities are spending enormous amounts of money managing 
this crisis. Voters are upset that there are people, sick and 
sometimes dying, outside on their streets and sidewalks. 
Taxpayers rightfully expect that resources spent on 
homelessness will produce visible, measurable results. Grantees 
should be held accountable for the resources that they receive, 
and Federal policies and programs should be guided by evidence 
of what works.
 Decades of rigorous research show that homelessness is 
predominantly driven by challenges extremely low-income 
households have affording housing. And affordable housing 
trends have been worsening, putting more households at risk and 
increasing the number of people entering homelessness.
 Rises in cost burden for renters have been observed over 
the last five years in 44 states, and one in five renters ages 
18 to 64 reported that they did not pay the full amount of rent 
or were late with a rental payment at some point in 2025. Yet, 
only about one in five households eligible for Federal housing 
assistance receives it.
 As has been discussed today, mental health disorders and 
substance use are serious concerns for some people experiencing 
homelessness, and access to treatment must improve. But they do 
not explain homelessness by themselves.
 Research also shows that many people experiencing 
homelessness work. More than half of people in shelters and 
about 40 percent of people living unsheltered had earned income 
during the year they experienced homelessness.
 The fundamental problem is that too many people cannot 
sustain housing and, once homeless, cannot reenter the private 
rental market.
 So, what should the Federal Government do? Ultimately, 
ending widespread homelessness will require more affordable 
housing, rental assistance, adequate incomes, and accessible 
healthcare and treatment. In addition to that, the Federal 
Government should learn from communities producing visible, 
measurable reductions in homelessness.
 I lead the evaluation of Denver's All In Mile High 
Initiative. Denver has reported a 64 percent reduction in 
unsheltered homelessness over three years. Our evaluation found 
a 93 percent reduction in encampments in downtown Denver.
 Denver did not achieve this by mandating treatment, passing 
an anti-camping ban, shifting from focusing on permanent 
housing to transitional housing, or by moving people from one 
block to another. The city used real-time data, coordinated 
across agencies and service providers, expanded accessible 
shelter, connected people to housing, and maintained cleared 
encampment sites.
 Other communities, including Dallas, Philadelphia, Houston, 
San Diego, and Indianapolis, are also reporting reductions in 
unsheltered homelessness using similar strategies.
 Federal policy should be guided by, and incentivize, these 
effective practices, not undermine them.
 Over the last 40 years, Federal homelessness programs have 
evolved through local innovation, rigorous evaluation, and 
Congressional action. That process has produced interventions 
with substantial evidence behind them.
 By contrast, for many of the strategies discussed so far 
today, I am aware of no rigorous, replicable studies that they 
reduce homelessness.
 Treatment should be available and accessible to people who 
need it, but the homelessness system cannot substitute for 
lacks in availability or effectiveness of substance treatment, 
and mandatory treatments cannot correct a shortage of 
affordable housing.
 Congress and Federal agencies should require clear 
performance measures, careful monitoring, and meaningful 
consequences when grantees misuse funds or fail to perform. At 
the same time, major policy changes should be tested and 
evaluated before being implemented nationwide.
 But communities do not have to wait to make progress. They 
can reduce homelessness today by helping more people return to 
housing, prevent avoidable entries into homelessness, and 
improve access to treatment and employment.
 As I conclude my remarks, I want to reiterate that we do 
not have to live with widespread homelessness. We should invest 
in strategies that visibly and measurably reduce homelessness.
 Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, ma'am.
 I will now recognize Representative Cloud of Texas for his 
questions.
 Mr. Cloud. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I want to thank you 
for holding this hearing.
 Once again, we find ourselves discussing an important 
topic. And the focus of this Committee has been really on 
waste, fraud, and abuse, and I appreciate what we have kind of 
come--we thought this was going to really be a bipartisan 
effort. Everybody has long said we are against waste, fraud, 
and abuse. But as we begin to dig into these issues, what we 
find as a common theme is, much of what has been going out as 
taxpayer dollars is being funneled through these 
Nongovernmental Organizations (NGOs), and they are 
unaccountable, many of them. We are finding a lot of waste, 
fraud, and abuse, and it has really turned into what we found 
to be almost the largest money laundering scheme in human 
history.
 Does that mean every person working at these is negligent 
or--no. There are probably some people doing some good work, 
but what we have seen is a lot of waste, fraud, and abuse in 
this.
 And, once again, politicians kind of get to pat themselves 
on the back by how much money they send out as opposed to are 
we accomplishing the goals and initiatives and objectives that 
we set them out to accomplish.
 You know, one thing that is clear from the data--and I will 
admit, the data is kind of sketchy. That is probably one of the 
things we can talk about, is how to improve the data on this--
but there is no direct correlation to spending more money and 
more people coming off the streets and not being homeless.
 You can look at just comparing the entire State of Texas to 
Los Angeles. Los Angeles gets $20 million more than the entire 
State of Texas, yet has roughly three times the homelessness 
problem. And so, there is a lot of work that needs to be done.
 Mr. Choe, you did not get a chance to finish your opening 
statements. Could you speak to--finish speaking to what our tax 
dollars are going to?
 You would think that it would be pretty broad agreement 
that tax dollars should not be going to fund drug use and 
paraphernalia, but yet that is not what is happening, is it?
 Mr. Choe. Yes, sir. Our position is that you cannot build 
your way out of this crisis, and a common theme that we are 
seeing is the total lack of accountability. It is an absolute 
free-for-all in many of these West Coast cities that I cover, 
such as Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, and Los Angeles.
 A lot of this money, once it is doled out, ends up in a 
black hole, and you do not know where the dollars end up going. 
And the lack of measurable results is stunning, and that must 
change immediately.
 Mr. Cloud. Yes. In Texas, I know we work to provide a 
business-friendly environment, which means bringing jobs in. We 
seem to find that that is a better path forward. Getting people 
jobs helps them provide for a home, for their families, and 
those sort of things, as opposed to L.A. who is handing out 
drug paraphernalia.
 Mr. Webster, one of the issues is how the data is 
collected, and part of it is how we define success, how we 
define homelessness. Sometimes the definition of solving 
homelessness is actually when you kind of become a ward of the 
state, in a sense, like the Federal Government is paying for 
you to exist. But you are not really having any sort of forward 
momentum in life. You are not, you know, growing up or becoming 
more prosperous. You are not, you know, being able to lay down 
the legacy for your family or these things that we would hope 
for people.
 Could you speak to some of that and what we could do to 
improve that?
 Mr. Webster. Yes, sir. Thank you for the question. I think 
one of the challenges is what the objectives are for the 
Continuum of Care Program. The Continuum of Care Program had 
certain purposes; for example, to coordinate a region-wide 
response to homeless, to prevent homelessness, and to do some 
other things.
 I think one of the challenges is that there is kind of a 
difference in terms of what we are trying to measure. On the 
one hand, there is a whole host of research that really tries 
to measure housing stability, whether or not people are going 
to be able to stay in the housing that is provided them. But 
then there are other folks who are interested in objectives to 
say, is the money that we are spending to reduce homelessness, 
is it actually reducing homelessness?
 And so the challenge is when you get very difficult-to-read 
data sources, when you have pretty complex kinds of reporting 
from HUD about demographics instead of how many people are 
actually coming off the street or how many people are actually 
in permanent, supportive housing, the main intervention for 
housing, and how many of them--and I know Ms. Batko has 
actually studied this--how many people actually stay in that 
housing?
 And the challenge is, is that we are just not connecting 
the dots between the money that we spend, the services and the 
provisions that we provide, and what that impacts in terms of 
actual people who are living and dying on the streets. And what 
kind of behavioral health, what kind of economic challenges, 
what kind of earning potential, what kind of criminality, all 
weaves into this thing.
 So, I agree with you, I think we need much better 
accountability and much better measures that we actually 
monitor.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, Mr. Webster. Thank you.
 Mr. Lynch, you are recognized, from Massachusetts.
 Mr. Lynch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 You know, if this hearing was really about--I want to talk 
about homelessness and substance abuse and the problems we got 
in this country, but to do so under the, you know, the premise 
that this hearing is about waste, fraud, and abuse is 
ridiculous.
 If we were really after waste, fraud, and abuse, and money 
laundering and scams, I know the address, I know where we could 
go; you know, fraud central, scam central, you know, over $2 
billion raked in since January 2025, and that address is 1600 
Pennsylvania Avenue, and the main perpetrator is Donald Trump.
 So, if we were really interested in that line of 
investigation and oversight, then it would be really easy, but 
this Congress does not have the appetite to do that under its 
current leadership.
 The other point about accountability, most people forget 
that President Donald Trump granted a full and complete pardon 
to former Honduran President Juan Orlando Hernandez who was 
convicted in the United States of--he was convicted on drug 
trafficking and weapons charges, bringing drugs into this 
country, and the President of the United States gave him a 
sweetheart deal.
 If we were going to hold people accountable, that was a 
good place to start--someone who had already been convicted, 
and instead of holding them accountable, they got a pardon, a 
complete pardon, by the President.
 So, there are a lot of instances here where I think we 
could have introduced accountability and we failed to do that.
 Ms. Batko, I am really interested in, you talked about the 
success that Denver has had in reducing unsheltered 
homelessness. And I, in my own district, in the Boston area, I 
have actually founded a couple of residential drug 
rehabilitation facilities, one of them for children, actually, 
because the kids were so young we could not co-locate them with 
adults.
 I am just wondering what percentage or what element of, you 
know, drug rehabilitation and substance abuse services, how 
much of that played in the success of what you did in Denver?
 Ms. Batko. To clarify, I am evaluating Denver's work, not 
the person actually doing it in Denver----
 Mr. Lynch. Okay.
 Ms. Batko [continuing]. But----
 Mr. Lynch. Well, in your evaluation, what do you think----
 Ms. Batko. In our evaluation, yes.
 Mr. Lynch [continuing]. How do you think it went?
 Ms. Batko. Just to speak to something that Mr. Webster 
mentioned about how many people have been housed. Denver has 
housed over 9,000 people since 2023, and is tracking housing.
 I do not have the numbers directly in front of me on the 
percent of people that in Denver had substance use challenges, 
but they do have a robust response for substance use, including 
their Roads to Recovery program and also available residential 
treatment programs for people.
 Mr. Lynch. I see. That is one of the key pieces. You know, 
we have had a couple of these homeless enclaves. Mass and Cass 
is the one that is closest to my district. It is on the border 
between myself and Ms. Pressley, and, you know, there is a lot 
of open drug dealing on the street while that is going on. And 
we are trying to get at the homeless issue and it has been 
very, very difficult. We have struggled. We have struggled, 
multiyear struggles in trying to clean that up. And I was just 
trying to figure out if there are any lessons learned for us in 
Boston from what you went through or what you evaluated in 
Denver.
 Ms. Batko. Sure. I think that one of the most important 
things is that there are people who are struggling with 
homelessness and there are people who are struggling with 
substance use, and sometimes there are people struggling with 
both.
 And people who are struggling with substance use need a 
treatment intervention that is effective, and people who are 
struggling with homelessness need a housing intervention, and 
that is one of the things that we have learned. And also, that 
in Denver, tangible offers of resources to people who are 
living outside, including shelter and real housing, help people 
to move in and serve as a platform for working on other things 
in their lives, like substance use and employment.
 Mr. Lynch. I do not have time, but there is also the mental 
health issue where we have, you know, deinstitutionalized a lot 
of things and, through cost reasons, but that is another 
element to this as well.
 Thank you for your testimony.
 Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, sir.
 I now recognize Mr. Burlison from Missouri.
 Mr. Burlison. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 I want to start with a simple question. Is the program 
working?
 We are $40 trillion in debt, and we are trying to evaluate 
how every dollar is spent. But I think what we are recognizing 
here is that the more money we spend, we are not getting any 
better outcomes out of this.
 If you spend more money every year, add more beds every 
year, and hire more people every year, unfortunately, the 
streets seem to get worse, and the program is not working.
 In Los Angeles, Federal Continuum of Care awards have risen 
213 percent since 2005. The city has budgeted about $4.4 
billion since 2022, and there has been little to almost no 
accountability. The system pays for inputs, beds, salaries, 
contracts.
 We know that there is waste and there is fraud and that it 
is widespread. Spencer Pratt, who ran for mayor, showcased this 
on a national stage. He said that every dime of the homeless 
industry complex is money laundering, and the people are 
getting rich off of misery.
 This is backed up by data. It is backed up by reports by 
Cicero Institute and the review of Form 990s, showing provider 
compensation among the Continuum of Care award nonprofits grew 
about 118 percent from the year 2013 to 2024.
 So, to put that in context, during that same period, 
inflation only grew 34 percent. So, these entities grew in 
their revenue nearly four times inflation. So, it is clear 
companies are making money off of this--off other people's 
misery.
 And to that, Mr. Choe, I want to ask a question. You have 
mentioned that we have a homeless industrial complex. Would you 
agree with that statement? Is that what you have said in the 
past?
 Mr. Choe. Yes, sir. And so has HUD Secretary Scott Turner.
 Mr. Burlison. First, in your firsthand investigations, what 
are you seeing in that way?
 Mr. Choe. Could you repeat your question one more time?
 Mr. Burlison. So, in your investigations, are you seeing 
people--like, are you seeing entities or these nonprofits, are 
they getting rich off of providing these services?
 Mr. Choe. Absolutely, especially their top CEOs and 
executives. Many of them are making high six-figure salaries, 
and the staff are also making six-figure salaries, and they are 
holding fundraisers where they are raising millions of dollars. 
Yet, as this Commission has noted, we do not see the results. 
There is record homelessness on the streets, record drug 
overdose deaths. Meanwhile, these nonprofits are lining their 
pockets.
 And, of course, there are good ones out there as well, 
especially the faith-based nonprofits, where they take a 
different approach from Housing First and harm reduction. And 
the focus, again, should be more on recovery and treatment, and 
that is where we are seeing a lot of success on the streets.
 Mr. Burlison. Right. Mr. Webster, I am going to ask you--I 
am going to name this quote, and I am just going to ask if you 
know who said it. ``Since 1987 when I first proposed an 
overhaul of the welfare system, I have argued that welfare 
recipients should be required to work.''
 Any guesses?
 Mr. Webster. I am going to pick Bill Clinton for 200.
 Mr. Burlison. It was Joe Biden, but you are close. Bill 
Clinton said in both campaigns, in 1992, in 1996, he said, 
``Real reform should impose time limits and require work and 
provide childcare so that people can actually--can go to work 
without hurting their children.''
 Is that the view today of the Democratic Party?
 Mr. Webster. Well, I cannot speak for the Democratic Party, 
and I do not want to, but I do think that what we are missing 
in the Continuum of Care Program is a more robust and 
accountable answer to these kinds of wrap-around services that 
actually meet people where they are at and move them to a 
different place. I do want to be fair, though. There are a 
number of Continuums of Care that are showing results and that 
are doing a good job.
 I think that when you understand that, you know, more than 
50 percent of all the homelessness is in the West Coast--
Oregon, Washington, and California--we have some real 
challenges over there that dwarf the successes of some of the 
more local and smaller organizations and efforts. And I think 
that all those wrap-around services are a part of it.
 Mr. Burlison. Is handing people these drug care packs, is 
that helping them achieve their goal of getting a job?
 Mr. Webster. Not in my view.
 Mr. Burlison. Thank you.
 Mr. Burchett. Mr. Walkinshaw.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Well, this Democrat believes the American people are 
working pretty damn hard. They are working hard, they are 
paying more, and they are getting less. And unless they are 
members of the Trump family, they do not have Russian oligarchs 
to fund their weddings or taxpayer dollars to fund their 
tungsten mines in Kazakhstan.
 Mr. Choe, just a question for you, and we will go down the 
line. When housing becomes more expensive, do you agree that 
more Americans are then at risk of becoming homeless? Yes or 
no? Mr. Choe?
 Mr. Choe. No.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Mr. Webster, when housing becomes more 
expensive, do you believe that makes more Americans at risk of 
becoming homeless?
 Mr. Webster. Potentially.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Okay. Ms. Batko, yes or no?
 Ms. Batko. Yes.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Okay. I think it is basic economics. If 
housing is more expensive, more people are going to be unable 
to afford that housing. And right now, housing is way too 
expensive.
 People in this country who do everything right, who work 
hard, play by the rules, are struggling to rent or buy a home. 
Young people in this country do not believe they will ever be 
able to buy a home. High interest rates, which are skyrocketing 
as we speak, exacerbated by the obscene--obscene--deficits this 
Congress has run up, lock people into existing homes and lock 
other people out of the market completely.
 So, yes, we should root out the waste, we should 
investigate the fraud. It is too bad the actual DOGE, the 
namesake of this Committee, failed so abysmally to do any of 
that, as the GAO has recently documented.
 But if we care about homelessness, why are we making 
housing more expensive?
 President Trump's tariffs are adding $17,500 to the cost of 
a new home. The result of that is 450,000 fewer homes being 
built. Fewer homes being built, more homelessness. Think about 
it.
 Just when we need more housing--and all of our witnesses 
today have expressed their concern about homelessness--just 
when we need more housing, President Trump and this Congress 
are making it more expensive.
 The lumber and steel tariffs are a tax on housing. We are 
taxing the thing we most need at the moment we most need it. 
And if we want fewer people to be without a home, maybe we 
should not make the homes more expensive. A simple thought.
 Ms. Batko, I want to just delve into one of the topics that 
I think is inherent in all of the testimony we have heard 
today, and it is a connection between housing costs, substance 
abuse, or other challenges people are facing, and homelessness.
 Are there parts of the country, are there states, are there 
communities that have high rates of substance abuse and low 
rates--relatively low rates of homelessness?
 Ms. Batko. I am sorry, sir, I do not have those numbers off 
the top of my head, but I am happy to come back to the office 
with that. What I can tell you is that the GAO released a 
report indicating that for every $100 increase in rent, 
homelessness goes up nine percent.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Got it. I think it is the case that there 
are parts of the country that have very high rates and have 
suffered through real epidemics of drug use and substance abuse 
but still have low rates of homelessness because housing costs 
are low in those communities. I think when you go back and look 
at the data, you will find that.
 Can you just talk us through--we have heard about the 
perceived failures in Los Angeles. Can you talk us through some 
of the other success stories.
 You have talked through your success in Denver--because 
there are communities in this country succeeding in addressing 
this issue and having success--can you give us a couple of 
those?
 Ms. Batko. Yes, sure. I think one of the most important 
things about talking about whether or not the program is 
working is to understand that homelessness is a dynamic. And 
so, the numbers that we heard earlier, the 755,000 people, over 
the course of the year, between 1.2 and 1.5 million people 
experience homelessness, and really Congress should think about 
homelessness as a math equation.
 People are coming into homelessness constantly, and the 
system is trying to get people out of homelessness. And if 
those numbers are not in balance, homelessness grows even if 
the number of exits from homelessness grows.
 And so, to your point, in places that have seen success, 
like Denver, you are seeing where they have ramped up housing 
placement.
 So, in Dallas, they implemented a street-to-home model 
which focused on resolving encampments in the downtown area. 
They reported an 89 percent reduction in daily street counts.
 Mr. Burchett. Your time is up, ma'am. Thank you.
 Next, I recognize Ms. Mace.
 Ms. Mace. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and you did a wonderful 
presentation on the price of diesel today, by the way, on the 
Floor.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you.
 Ms. Mace. One of your best.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you.
 Ms. Mace. Speaking of data, I would encourage my colleagues 
across the aisle to go back and look at data, look at the 
number of illegals that we house in this country that make the 
price go up because that is housing that does not go to actual 
citizens of this country.
 It seems to me that the more money we spend on combatting 
homelessness, the more homelessness we have in our country.
 Blue cities in the country appear to be particularly 
afflicted, like those of L.A.--there is a reason why Karen Bass 
did not show up today--spending more and accelerating their 
homelessness epidemic, while giving the homeless drugs and 
allowing them to shoot up.
 Interesting take on how to handle homelessness. It is 
really not what we should be doing in any other city in the 
country.
 But the worsening homelessness problem, particularly in 
L.A., it is shameful that the Mayor of Los Angeles, Karen Bass, 
refused to show up today, but no one should be surprised. She 
did not show up when California was burning. The people of L.A. 
needed her, and she was nowhere to be found. You can just ask 
the wildfire victim, Spencer Pratt, and all of those whose 
homes burned to the ground, because she was in Africa, putting 
Africa first and not her own American citizens.
 We will do the work to uncover the fraud. That is what this 
Committee is for.
 So, my first question goes to Mr. Webster today. Since 
2025, how much money has Los Angeles spent on combatting 
homelessness over the last year?
 Mr. Webster. So, since--thank you for the question. So, 
since 2025--well, in 2024, $240 million were provided by the 
Federal Government to Continuum of Care. 2025 was just a little 
bit more than that, but they did not do it through a 
competition because there was a lawsuit involved.
 The city of Los Angeles provides its own money and----
 Ms. Mace. How much is that?
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. I testified a little earlier, it 
is about $4 billion between the city and the county.
 Ms. Mace. Of all the money that has been spent since 2025 
on homelessness or combatting homelessness--what did you call 
it? To continue care? Is that what you?
 Mr. Webster. Continuum of Care Program is the chief program 
in the Federal Government to provide----
 Ms. Mace. That is the name of the program? Continue with 
care? Like it is healthcare for drug addicts, I guess.
 So, over $4 billion and change, how much is that per 
homeless person in L.A.?
 Mr. Webster. I do not have that number off the top of my 
head, but it is a lot.
 Ms. Mace. I think my staff said it is somewhere in the 
range of $30,000 per person.
 Mr. Webster. Sounds about right.
 Ms. Mace. However, they are using a $2.3 billion number and 
another number, so it actually might be higher than that. That, 
to me, seems like a studio apartment for a year in a high and 
in a very expensive maybe blue city or blue town.
 The tens of dollars--tens of thousands of dollars spent per 
homeless person are being spent through the homeless industrial 
complex, I am going to call it, enough to actually house every 
homeless person for a year, as I said.
 Why are we spending so much money and getting so little out 
of it? Why is homelessness growing for every extra dollar we 
spend? Why is that?
 Mr. Webster. Well, I think in Los Angeles, it is pretty 
clear that the Continuum of Care, the Los Angeles Homeless 
Services Administration, has done a very, very poor job in 
managing its contracts, living up to the law and regulation in 
terms of having sufficient financial oversight, providing money 
to entities that do not provide services, and also to 
underwriting----
 Ms. Mace. How much of that goes to organizations that are 
not providing services, do we think? Do we know?
 Mr. Webster. It is really a case-by-case basis. I would 
look at something, like, I just read in Politico this 
afternoon, that there is an organization that took over the 
Skid Row Housing Trust, and because of the significant 
challenges in, like, operations--and it is the fact that a lot 
of homeless housing just does not scale. It----
 Ms. Mace. It cannot.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. It does not make----
 Ms. Mace. Yes.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. It does not make it pencil out.
 Ms. Mace. Yes. So, I was reading, too, earlier that there 
was almost $2.3 billion meant for combatting homelessness, and 
they do not know where it went or it was misused?
 Mr. Webster. Well, there were two analyses.
 Ms. Mace. Okay.
 Mr. Webster. One of them was for the State of California, 
where----
 Ms. Mace. Okay.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. $24 billion over the last five 
years, the State of California actually did an audit and asked 
their homelessness administration, and they could not tell 
where the money went for five years, from I want to say it was 
2021 to 2024.
 In Los Angeles, I am also the Executive Director of an 
organization called the L.A. Alliance for Human Rights. We sued 
the city and the county of Los Angeles, and through that 
lawsuit, there was the first ever audit.
 Ms. Mace. One last question. I got 10 seconds.
 How much drug paraphernalia is given out in these programs?
 Mr. Webster. I could not tell you that, but I could tell 
you what we see on the streets of Skid Row, and it is tons and 
tons of drug paraphernalia.
 Ms. Mace. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, Ms. Mace.
 Mr. Frost, you are recognized.
 Mr. Frost. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair.
 So, our country has made significant progress in lowering 
the percentage of homeless veterans over the past 15 years. I 
want to talk about that real quick.
 Veteran homelessness has decreased by about 56 percent 
since 2010. Programs like Department of Housing and Urban 
Development-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing, HUD-VASH, and 
supportive services for veteran families have helped play an 
important role in that.
 Ms. Batko, VA homeless programs, following a Housing First 
approach, getting veterans into stable housing and then 
providing the services they need to remain housed, why has that 
approach worked so well for veterans?
 Ms. Batko. This is correct. The veteran homelessness has 
decreased substantially and remained low despite changes in the 
economics of the country. This has been driven by two programs 
primarily, the HUD-VASH program, which is a supportive housing 
program that is administered jointly by HUD and the VA, where 
people receive a housing voucher and VA healthcare and 
treatment services. And then the Supportive Services for 
Veteran Families Program, which is a homelessness prevention 
and rapid rehousing program. And the reason that these programs 
are so effective is that they were scaled to the size of the 
problem that they were trying to solve.
 Mr. Frost. So, more resources and making sure we had that 
wrap-around work was important. And it followed the Housing 
First policy, correct?
 Ms. Batko. Correct.
 Mr. Frost. Veterans are not the only vulnerable population 
that experience homelessness. What lessons do you think we can 
take from the VA's model?
 Ms. Batko. Well, I think that we have see that when the 
resources are available on both the housing side and the 
services side, that people can stabilize in housing and thrive. 
This is a struggle that has been pointed out for supportive 
housing programs that are funded by other funding streams as 
being able to meet the highest supportive services needs.
 I think the other thing that we can learn from this is that 
prevention and rapid rehousing assistance are helpful in making 
sure that people who have temporary financial hardship and fall 
into homelessness or at risk of homelessness need not spend 
long periods of time in homelessness experiencing the harm 
associated with it and potentially eventually experiencing 
chronic homelessness.
 Mr. Frost. Ms. Batko, is arresting the homeless veteran a 
part of the program?
 Ms. Batko. No.
 Mr. Frost. Mr. Webster, same question, is arresting 
homeless veterans a part of the successful program to help 
eliminate veteran homelessness?
 Mr. Webster. I am sorry. I do not understand. Are you 
asking me if the Veterans Administration----
 Mr. Frost. It is just a yes or no. Yes.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. Arrests people?
 Mr. Frost. Do you know if that is an official part of it? 
Yes.
 Mr. Webster. No, I do not think----
 Mr. Frost. No, it is not.
 Mr. Webster. I do not think that is a serious question.
 Mr. Frost. Well, it is a serious question. And the reason I 
ask, Mr. Webster, is your organization advocates for arresting 
the homeless if they sleep on the streets. Is that correct?
 Mr. Webster. No, it is not correct.
 Mr. Frost. That is not correct?
 Mr. Webster. No.
 Mr. Frost. Mr. Chair, I have a UC to put in, a Washington 
Post article, ``How One Billionaire's Crusade Against Homeless 
Became Trump's Playbook.''
 Mr. Burchett. Without objection.
 Mr. Frost. I put that in because, quote, ``cities should 
make it a crime to sleep outside.'' It is the official position 
of the Trump Administration, version of the Cicero's proposals, 
that are law in 15 states, with 11 making it a crime to sleep 
outside. This is a policy that the Cicero Institute has been 
pushing in states across the country, and cities across the 
country as well, to make it a crime to sleep outside and make 
it a crime for people who are experiencing homelessness.
 Suppose someone loses their job, they fall behind on rent, 
they become homeless, they have nowhere to sleep and so they 
sleep outside. Under the policies your organization supports, 
that person can be removed from public spaces and potentially 
face criminal penalties for sleeping outside.
 How exactly does somebody being put in jail and receiving a 
criminal charge or a fine, how does that help and impact their 
ability to get their life back on track and get into housing?
 Mr. Webster. I am happy to respond. In Jacksonville, 
Florida, where Florida has a statewide camping ban, 
Jacksonville does arrest people, but it is not our--it is not 
because of our policy. It is because that is what the State of 
Florida determined what to do.
 What is great about the program----
 Mr. Frost. But this is something your organization is 
pushing for, so how does it help somebody?
 Mr. Webster. What is great about the program is that 
nonprofit organizations that work on diversion then go into the 
jails and they say, would you prefer to stay in jail or would 
you like to engage in our diversion program on the condition 
that you will be released from jail? And so, it actually has 
been a successful program to get people into diversion and get 
them out of jail and get them out of sleeping on the streets.
 Mr. Frost. It has not been a successful program. And, in 
fact, when you actually go and you speak with people that are 
experiencing this, what you find is that people who are already 
having a hard time to get their life back on track, to get into 
housing, get arrested, they get fines put on them, and it makes 
it even harder to get into housing. I do not know how you could 
sit here and say that arresting someone and putting a fine on 
them, adding to their criminal record is going to help them 
find a place to live. You are not interested in ending 
homelessness, you are interested in hiding it, and that is the 
difference.
 And so, thank you. I would like to yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Your time is up. Thank you, sir.
 Next, Ms. Boebert.
 Ms. Boebert. Thank you, Chairman Burchett, and thank you to 
the witnesses who actually showed up today. Mayor Karen Bass 
was absolutely invited, she is a former Member of this House, 
and she should understand how disrespectful it is to not attend 
an invite like this.
 Los Angeles has taken $2 billion in Federal homeless funds. 
She appointed herself to the board that spends it, then she 
skips more than half of those meetings, and skipped this 
hearing as well. That is not a scheduling conflict. That is 
contempt for the taxpayers who are paying for her failure.
 Mr. Webster, 45,000 people in the streets of L.A., county 
numbers are even higher, RAND and LAHSA undercounts by nearly 
40 percent. Would you say that Los Angeles homeless policies 
are a failure?
 Mr. Webster. I would indeed.
 Ms. Boebert. Bass gave herself a seat on the commission 
that distributes $241 million in Federal funds this year. Do 
you believe, Mr. Webster, that writing her own checks creates a 
conflict of interest?
 Mr. Webster. I cannot comment on that.
 Ms. Boebert. I think it is pretty dirty. I will comment for 
you, I think it is pretty dirty when a mayor appoints herself 
to a board that she does not show up for most of the meetings 
and then is using Federal tax dollars to pay herself extra 
money.
 Mr. Webster, should Congress investigate whether LAHSA is 
putting Federal homeless dollars in the hands of people who are 
here illegally?
 Mr. Webster. Absolutely. In fact, there is a University of 
Chicago working paper that demonstrated that in four 
jurisdictions of the United States, that noncitizen asylum 
seekers contributed to a significant portion of the increase of 
homelessness in, I think it was between, just in the past like 
four or five years.
 Ms. Boebert. Yes. And in this homeless industrial complex 
that is being created by the taxpayers of America, don't you 
think that those resources could actually be beneficial if they 
were only going to American citizens and not to illegal aliens?
 Mr. Webster. I do think that there should be a 
prioritization for folks who are citizens and who are in the 
country legally----
 Ms. Boebert. I agree.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. To who receives Federal benefits.
 Ms. Boebert. Yes, sir. Mr. Webster, final question for you, 
is there a financial incentive for Los Angeles to keep Housing 
First going when the streets are getting worse?
 Mr. Webster. It is an interesting question. There kind of 
is a financial incentive, and it has to do with state law. In 
2016, California passed a state law that every state dollar 
that goes toward homelessness must be Housing First. So, if you 
are a local entity, or a city, or a county, and you are 
applying for the State of California for homelessness 
assistance, yes, there is an incentive that you must follow 
Housing First. And that used to be the policy of HUD on its 
notice of funding opportunity, there was kind of a scorecard or 
a checklist that basically made sure that in applying for 
Federal funds, your program was, quote/unquote, Housing First-
compliant.
 Ms. Boebert. Got it. Thank you very much, Mr. Webster.
 Mr. Choe, Housing First became official Federal policy in 
2013. More than a third of the homeless abuse heroin, fentanyl, 
or meth. Colorado lost 1,800-plus people to overdose just last 
year.
 How many billions have gone out the door since 2013 when 
Housing First became this official Federal policy?
 Mr. Choe. That is a great question. I do not have access to 
that number, but it is in the billions, plural, as you stated.
 Ms. Boebert. Billions of dollars, yes, sir. What should 
this Committee write into law so another--excuse me--so a 
mother seeking help actually gets sobriety and safety and not a 
hotel room and a needle?
 Mr. Choe. Well, the issue that we are seeing is not just a 
lack of affordable housing necessarily. It is the lack of 
requirements, and that is the problem with Housing First right 
now. We are essentially giving away apartments, studios on 
waterfront properties, with zero requirements to find jobs, 
zero requirements to go into recovery and treatment. There has 
to be some type of incentive in order to live in any taxpayer-
funded facility.
 Ms. Boebert. Agreed.
 Mr. Choe. At the same time, we should measure, then, 
results.
 At the end of the day, we are not interested in just 
warehousing homeless drug addicts. We are interested in saving 
lives and restoring lives so they can start contributing back 
into society, and that is what any decent bill should be 
measuring.
 Ms. Boebert. Thank you very much.
 Ms. Batko, really quick, Denver hired you. You advertised a 
45 percent drop in unsheltered PIT and a 98 percent drop in big 
encampments. How many of those people are even in permanent 
housing or off drugs or still housed?
 The truth is, you just see less tents in Denver because you 
put them somewhere else and you did not have an actual 
solution. The auditor says that Denver spent about $170 
billion, hid $20 million, and cannot track unique outcomes.
 Did Urban Institute audit the books or stamp the city's 
talking points?
 Ms. Batko. Should I answer the question?
 We were hired as the City of Denver's independent 
evaluator. We are still conducting the evaluation. Denver has 
rehoused over 1,000 people--or 8,000 people, and we are 
examining the cost associated with it----
 Ms. Boebert. Permanently rehoused or they are just living 
off the tax dollars in these----
 Mr. Burchett. Time is up.
 Ms. Boebert [continuing]. Hotels?
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield.
 Mr. Burchett. Did you get your question answered? More or 
less? Okay.
 Ms. Tlaib, you are recognized, ma'am.
 Ms. Tlaib. Thank you so much.
 I do want to start off with requesting unanimous consent to 
enter into the record a statement by a coalition of housing and 
homelessness lawyers and advocates led by the National 
Homelessness Law Center.
 Mr. Burchett. Okay.
 Ms. Tlaib. I would like to read from it.
 During today's hearing, Subcommittee Members will hear from 
individuals who purport to share our belief in the need to 
address this urgent crisis. However, we expect their testimony 
be premised on deeply harmful misconceptions about 
homelessness. We submit this statement to ensure the 
Subcommittee Members receive accurate information about the 
causes of and solutions to homelessness.
 So, I hope my colleagues do read this.
 I want to start asking you questions, Mr. Webster. In what 
ways will your organizations and partners benefit from creating 
a reality where large-scale homelessness continues to grow?
 Mr. Webster. I am sorry. Could you repeat that?
 Ms. Tlaib. How will your organization benefit by watching 
homelessness numbers increase?
 Mr. Webster. It will not.
 Ms. Tlaib. Oh, really? Because your institute, Cicero, 
where you work, has ties to defense contractors in private 
prisons--let me finish--private prisons, and your billionaire 
founder stands to make a fortune off of locking people up. You 
can sneer all you want. I am telling you the truth.
 I would like to submit for the record a Mother Jones 
article, ``The Palantir Billionaire's Passion Project is 
Criminalizing Homelessness.''
 Mr. Burchett. Without objection.
 Ms. Tlaib. So, you are telling me arrest the unhoused, fine 
them, and then put them in detention camps that you can profit 
from. These are your donors. It is a record of donors. You have 
donors that will benefit from imprisoning and arresting 
homeless neighbors.
 Mr. Webster. I think the more useful question is not 
whether Joe Lonsdale is unpopular in certain circles.
 Ms. Tlaib. No, do not tell me how to question you. You are 
not elected. I was elected. I am telling you----
 Mr. Webster. I think it is whether----
 Ms. Tlaib. You know what my residents ask me to do in 
Detroit? You know what they ask me to do? They say, Rashida, 
how do people profit from these policies. Your organization 
will profit. Your donors will profit.
 Sir----
 Mr. Webster. We are not a nonprofit organization.
 Ms. Tlaib. If I am not mistaken, I am not mistaken, your 
organization actually pushed, was a major player in Texas to 
adopt a statewide camping ban in Texas. Oh, you are so proud. 
What do we do with those individuals? We put them in the 
prisons and jails that your donors benefit from financially, 
correct?
 Mr. Webster. That is not correct.
 Ms. Tlaib. Well, your donors say otherwise.
 Mr. Webster. The camping bans that we advocate for are 
class C misdemeanors, many of which are penalized by citations, 
which can be adjudicated----
 Ms. Tlaib. Mr. Webster, we all know your donors.
 Mr. Webster [continuing]. When they receive housing 
services.
 Ms. Tlaib. Your donors benefit from for-profit prison 
schemes. We know that.
 Mr. Webster. We cannot make a profit.
 Ms. Tlaib. You want to arrest them and you want to make 
money off of our homeless neighbors.
 Now, Ms. Batko, the Cicero Institute claims that the rates 
of homelessness have continued to increase despite increasing 
budgets for homeless services providers and proposed expanded 
bans on camping or sleeping and increased law enforcement as 
solutions, right? But, the period between 2006 and 2019, 
national data shows camping bans increased by 92 percent, 
correct? And law enforcement's spending more than doubled. It 
cost so much more to police and imprison than to house and 
support, correct?
 Ms. Batko. It does cost more to police and imprison than it 
does to support----
 Ms. Tlaib. Look it up. It costs more.
 Ms. Batko. In Denver specifically, they failed.
 Ms. Tlaib. You cannot police away homelessness. You cannot 
arrest away homelessness. The only people that benefit are the 
people that actually own the prisons. And in many cases, they 
are the donors of the Cicero Institute. They benefit.
 There is absolutely no credible evidence for anything 
Cicero and Discovery are pushing here today. They have 
literally no credibility with people that actually talk to our 
homeless neighbors.
 And they can shout and all they want about it, but, 
Chairman, with all due respect, I wish we had a person that had 
gone through homelessness as a person that would actually 
testify here. Somebody that was successful, because we know, we 
know, while Republican witnesses here may try to sell 
otherwise, we know the Housing First approach, not only in my 
district, but in everyone's district, means getting people 
housing they can afford alongside supportive services that they 
need.
 And I can tell you right now, even in my own district, 
housing is becoming literally unachievable. Right now, many 
homes are turning into rental properties where they are paying 
over, over 40 to 50 percent of their own income. These are 
working people. And instead, they are living out of their cars, 
and they become homeless, or in transit, and they cannot find 
affordable housing.
 But you all can huff and puff and say all these things, but 
at the end, at the end, it is not a homeless neighbor that is 
before us telling us what worked for them, how they literally 
were able to get housing and so forth, and they will tell you, 
it is probably a HUD program. It is probably a program that, 
again, over and over again has shown us, if funded properly and 
if implemented properly, can be incredibly successful.
 With that, again, I want to apologize to many of those that 
work with our homeless community. Shame on us for not, again, 
bringing them to the table and actually listening to them.
 Thank you, and I yield.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, ma'am.
 Mr. Fallon, out of Texas, you are recognized.
 Mr. Fallon. Mr. Chairman, thank you.
 Ms. Batko, you work for the Urban Institute. Is it a fair 
description that your mission is to combat homelessness, give 
or take?
 Ms. Batko. The Urban Institute's mission is to inform 
policy and practice to improve communities and lives.
 Mr. Fallon. So, one of those would be falling under that 
umbrella, combatting homelessness, and at least mitigating, if 
not eliminating it?
 Ms. Batko. Yes.
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. And how long have you been in this career 
field, roughly?
 Ms. Batko. I have been at the Urban Institute for over nine 
years.
 Mr. Fallon. Have you been in this career field for 10, 15, 
20 years?
 Ms. Batko. More than 20.
 Mr. Fallon. More than 20. Okay. Do you think over the 20 
years you have done a good job in better outcomes in combatting 
homelessness? And also, do you feel the Urban Institute is 
doing the same?
 Ms. Batko. I am sorry. Could you repeat that second half of 
the question?
 Mr. Fallon. You are combatting homelessness, you are making 
communities better, you are looking for good outcomes, you and 
the Urban Institute?
 Ms. Batko. I cannot speak for the Urban Institute, but----
 Mr. Fallon. Do you think the Urban Institute is effective 
in their mission?
 Ms. Batko. Yes.
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. Do you think that enough taxpayer dollars 
have been spent to mitigate the homelessness issue? Do you 
think there has been enough spent of taxpayer dollars or you 
think there should be more?
 Ms. Batko. I think that tax dollars are determined by 
Congress in the appropriations process.
 Mr. Fallon. Right. Would you want more?
 Ms. Batko. But I think that tax dollars should be guided by 
the evidence and what we know.
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. More or enough? Do you have a choice?
 Ms. Batko. I think that we have seen that the scale of 
resources currently with regard to homelessness and housing 
are----
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. So, you are not going to answer. All 
right. Thank you.
 Mr. Chairman, Mr. Chairman, I reclaim my time.
 So, I find it interesting that the Federal Government over 
the last--since 2007, HUD--that is the first year that HUD had 
fully comparable national figures. And they have spent, the 
Federal Government, in answer to Ms. Boebert's question, $51 
billion to combat homelessness since 2007.
 The State of California, their own auditor, said they spent 
24 billion between 2018 and 2023. So, a fair estimate, if you 
want to go back to 2007, it was probably about, just in 
California, $40 billion. In L.A. county and city, about another 
$10. So, that is $100 billion, and that is not including the 
other 49 states. So, a pretty fair estimate would be probably 
in the neighborhood of a quarter of a trillion dollars.
 So, let us go back to the earliest year that HUD says we 
should be able to compare. In 2007 to 2025, Ms. Batko, do you 
think homelessness rose or fell?
 Ms. Batko. Can you repeat the years?
 Mr. Fallon. 2007 to 2025.
 Ms. Batko. It rose.
 Mr. Fallon. It did rise by 15 percent. We dropped a quarter 
of a trillion dollars, and what do we get for it, 15 percent 
increase in homelessness.
 Ms. Batko, you are working for a 501(c)(3). Is that 
correct?
 Ms. Batko. Correct.
 Mr. Fallon. What is your salary? What is your total 
compensation?
 Ms. Batko. I do not understand how that is pertinent to 
this.
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. So, you are not going to answer. We 
estimate it is probably in the neighborhood of $200,000.
 Do you know how much your CEO, Sarah Wartell, makes?
 Ms. Batko. Not off the top of my head.
 Mr. Fallon. I do. It is $971,063.
 How about your senior VP of research and programs? 
$407,826. VP and Executive Director of WorkRise, $397,461. 
Chief Operating Officer, $377,915. Senior VP, Impact and 
External Affairs, $376,572. Institute of Fellow Research, 
$349,939. VP Comptroller and Treasurer, $292,576.
 So, yes, some people have been very successful in the last 
18 years combatting homelessness. They are getting rich off of 
it. If your CEO, we want to take those numbers back to about 18 
years, she has probably made in the neighborhood of $15 
million.
 Ms. Batko, is it a good or bad outcome for a human being to 
do crack cocaine?
 Ms. Batko. Bad.
 Mr. Fallon. I agree. Good or bad outcome to use heroin?
 Ms. Batko. Bad.
 Mr. Fallon. Agree as well. So, you would agree that it is a 
negative outcome if this human being does any hard drugs for 
themselves, the community, and society as a whole? Agree?
 Ms. Batko. I believe that drug use is damaging to people in 
communities.
 Mr. Fallon. So, a negative outcome for those three, I would 
think. I do not want to put words in your mouth.
 So, is it a good use of taxpayer dollars to fund crack 
pipes?
 Ms. Batko. I am not an expert on substance use treatment 
and I----
 Mr. Fallon. It is a really simple question. I think you got 
trillions of brain cells between your ears the good Lord gave 
you. Do you think it is a good or bad use of taxpayer funds to 
buy crack pipes for homeless people?
 Ms. Batko. Congress determines what money is spent on----
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. So, we are not going to get an answer 
there.
 How about fentanyl needles?
 Ms. Batko. What is the question?
 Mr. Fallon. Do you think it is a good or bad use of 
taxpayer dollars to fund fentanyl needles for the homeless?
 Ms. Batko. I think that Congress decides----
 Mr. Fallon. Okay. So, I would say--well, I am in Congress, 
and I say that is a horrible use of taxpayer money. You are 
exacerbating the problem. You are not mitigating it. I find it 
disgusting that in your 5 minutes that you opened with you 
never used or mentioned drug use once.
 The core fundamental issues of homelessness revolve around 
drug addiction, alcohol abuse, and mental illness. Those are 
the things to be treated. And for my colleague to sit there and 
say that these folks, if they are treated, are going to end up 
in prison. No. The most successful outcome is for them to get 
off the crack, get off the hard drugs, get their lives 
together, because the government is not going to do it for 
them, they have to do it for themselves.
 Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, Mr. Fallon.
 Mr. Gill, you are recognized.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thanks for your 
leadership on this Committee and keeping the conference 
together here and fighting to cut waste, fraud, and abuse from 
the Federal Government. We certainly really appreciate that. 
And thank you to the witnesses for taking the time.
 Ms. Batko, do you support defunding the police?
 Ms. Batko. I have not been asked to come here to speak 
about police appropriations.
 Mr. Gill. That is fine. Do you support defunding the 
police?
 Ms. Batko. I do not.
 Mr. Gill. You do not. Do you remember tweeting in June 2020 
that you do?
 Ms. Batko. No.
 Mr. Gill. DEI Petty tweeted, quote, ``today we are calling 
for the immediate cutting of all police budgets by at least 
half.'' You responded to it and said, ``thank you for your 
staff's leadership.''
 That sounds like you were advocating for defunding the 
police, does it not?
 Ms. Batko. I cannot see the tweet that you are holding up, 
and I am not DEI Petty.
 Mr. Gill. I know, but you responded to DEI Petty saying, 
thank you for your staff's leadership, whenever DEI Petty was 
advocating for cutting police budgets.
 Ms. Batko. I do not currently have a Twitter account, and I 
cannot see what you are holding up.
 Mr. Gill. You do not currently have one, but did you have 
one? Is this your--was your Twitter account Samantha Batko?
 Ms. Batko. No.
 Mr. Gill. This was not your Twitter account?
 Ms. Batko. No.
 Mr. Gill. You are telling me this is not your Twitter 
account?
 Ms. Batko. My Twitter handle was not Samantha Batko.
 Mr. Gill. No. It is TheSamanthaAB. That is the Twitter.
 Ms. Batko. AB?
 Mr. Gill. We will come back to that then. We will revisit 
that after this hearing, if that sounds good to you.
 Ms. Batko. Happy to.
 Mr. Gill. Let me ask you this. Do you think that police 
should be the first responders to emergencies?
 Ms. Batko. To emergencies?
 Mr. Gill. Whenever somebody calls 911, do you believe that 
police officers should be the first responders?
 Ms. Batko. I think it depends what type of emergency it is.
 Mr. Gill. Okay. You think it depends on what type--could 
you elaborate there?
 Ms. Batko. Sure. If I am having a heart attack, I would 
like a paramedic.
 Mr. Gill. Right. If somebody is robbing a home, let us say, 
do you think that police should be the first responders?
 Ms. Batko. Sure.
 Mr. Gill. Okay. I am glad to hear that.
 We are going to come back to this Twitter history because I 
find that really interesting, and I think we will have a lot to 
say about this in the future.
 And with that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, Mr. Gill.
 I do not see Pete Springer [sic], is he coming back? I mean 
Sessions.
 Would you like to go or would you?
 Ms. Stansbury. Sure.
 Mr. Burchett. Okay. You go right ahead.
 Ms. Stansbury. Are you guys done?
 Mr. Burchett. Looks like. You tell me, but you go right 
ahead.
 Ms. Stansbury. All right. Well, oh, my goodness. As per 
usual, it is a very strange hearing. I guess one takeaway I 
take from this hearing is that my colleagues across the aisle 
should actually spend more time at home in their communities 
talking to local leaders and organizations that actually work 
with unhoused populations and with people who have addiction 
challenges.
 But I am actually interested, Mr. Webster, in your opening 
statement, you said that the goals of housing programs should 
be employment, sobriety, family reunification, and long-term 
housing, amongst some other things, and I completely agree with 
you. And, in fact, I think that is a really important point.
 But I think one question I have that I am confused about 
kind of the argument that you are making here is that yourself 
and others who have testified and asked questions today seem to 
be attacking the Continuum of Care Program that the Federal 
Government funds, which is the program that provides emergency 
housing, that provides long-term stable housing for people who 
have addiction, that provides wrap-around services, and so I do 
not understand what your point is.
 Can you--like, who do you think should be providing these 
services if it is not the nonprofits who are on the ground 
working in these communities?
 Mr. Webster. First of all, the Continuum of Care Program 
does not provide emergency services. That is the Emergency 
Solutions Grant, which is another fund--another program from 
HUD, which is formula funded.
 Ms. Stansbury. But the question I am asking you is who--is 
it the government? Are you a big government guy? Do you think 
the government should be providing these services?
 Mr. Webster. I think that states and localities should be 
empowered by the Federal Government to determine and to create 
the flexibility that best provides the outcomes.
 Ms. Stansbury. But who? Like state agencies?
 Mr. Webster. I think some state agencies--I will tell you a 
great example.
 Ms. Stansbury. I am not asking about examples.
 Mr. Webster. In Los Angeles, in California----
 Ms. Stansbury. No, no, no. Sir, I am asking, do you--
because you are arguing essentially to defund one of the most 
important Federal programs that actually puts resources 
directly into our communities to address----
 Mr. Webster. No, I am not.
 Ms. Stansbury [continuing]. The housing crisis immediately.
 Mr. Webster. I am not advocating to defund the Continuum of 
Care Program. I am acting to reform it.
 Ms. Stansbury. Okay.
 Mr. Webster. Because it has done a very poor job in meeting 
its outcomes of reducing people who are living and dying on the 
streets. And I think instead of allowing unaccountable and 
unelected nonprofit consortiums, I think there should be 
greater monitoring and accountability.
 Ms. Stansbury. So, who provides those services instead of 
the nonprofits?
 Mr. Webster. I am sorry?
 Ms. Stansbury. Who provides the services instead of the 
nonprofits then?
 Mr. Webster. I think there is----
 Ms. Stansbury. Because let me just----
 Mr. Webster. I think there is a variety----
 Ms. Stansbury. Let me just make clear, the nonprofits are 
shelters, they are housing programs.
 Mr. Webster. Some are.
 Ms. Stansbury. They are drug rehabilitation programs, they 
are hospitals, they are clinics.
 Who is going to provide those services if you cut that 
funding and you reform the program to take that funding away 
from nonprofits?
 Mr. Webster. I am not advocating for cutting funding and I 
am not advocating for getting rid of nonprofit organizations.
 Ms. Stansbury. Well, who is going to provide--sir, I am 
asking you a simple question. Who is going to provide the 
service?
 Mr. Webster. I think you should have organizations that are 
accountable to----
 Ms. Stansbury. Who? What organization?
 Mr. Webster. It could be a nonprofit organization. It could 
become a county health--behavioral health department.
 Ms. Stansbury. Oh, so it is nonprofit organizations, just 
not the ones you do not like.
 Mr. Webster. No. I am saying--well, that is true, it is the 
ones that do not produce outcomes. I do not want them funded.
 Ms. Stansbury. Okay. All right. I am going to reclaim my 
time here.
 Mr. Choe, I just--I really--I am fascinated by your 
approach to all of this and especially your comments that you 
made about addiction. And I really am not trying to attack 
anyone or anything. I come from a place that is very low income 
where a lot of people struggle with addiction. And so, I wonder 
if you yourself or anyone in your family has ever struggled 
with a major addiction.
 Mr. Choe. I have had friends, very close friends who are 
currently struggling with drug addiction, several who are 
addicted to fentanyl. I have also experienced loss.
 Ms. Stansbury. Yes. And so, I mean, I guess--I am sorry to 
hear that, actually.
 Mr. Choe. Thank you.
 Ms. Stansbury. I am sorry to hear that. And I think all of 
us in this society have experienced family members and friends 
who have struggled from addiction.
 I guess what I do not understand about the argument that 
you are making is--I do understand the idea that there should 
be incentives to get people into housing, but knowing, for 
example, the people you know who are struggling with addiction, 
like, they do not just get sober. You do not just snap your 
fingers and one day you are sober.
 And so how do you reconcile this idea that you should not 
give people housing to get sober in? I do not understand that. 
The people that you know, if they lost their home because of 
something that happened, if they lost a family member or 
somebody, like, you would deny them a place to live?
 Mr. Choe. No. And that is a great question. I want to make 
a distinction very clear right now. There is no one-size-fits-
all to the homeless drug crisis on the streets right now. If 
there is a single mom who just lost her job and has, you know, 
needs six months to get back on her feet and find a job, I 
think giving her an apartment to, you know, take that next step 
is perfectly fine. But what I am talking about, and what I have 
covered now for the past six years in Seattle, San Francisco, 
and Los Angeles----
 Ms. Stansbury. Mr. Choe, I am going to reclaim my time 
because I am----
 Mr. Choe [continuing]. Are the people causing the most 
crime, chaos, and death on the streets.
 Ms. Stansbury. Mr. Choe, I really appreciate it, but this 
is my time. Let me just say, you proved our point, there is no 
one-size-fits-all, it is Housing First, people do need 
assistance.
 And with that, I yield back.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you, ma'am.
 Mr. Choe, why does the big media not show--why do they not 
show the stark realities of street homelessness in cities like 
L.A. and Seattle that we have seen in the videos? I know you 
have worked in major network television.
 Mr. Choe. Yes, that is a question I still ask every single 
day, especially when it comes to left-wing corporate media like 
CNN and MS NOW.
 We are seeing a devastating homeless drug crisis on the 
streets that has taken thousands of lives. An entire generation 
of Americans have been killed due to the deadliest drug in our 
history called fentanyl. If we had 747 jets crashing every 
single day, I think it would be the lead story on every single 
network. But because it comes down to homelessness and drug 
addiction, it is what the network executives call not brand 
safe.
 It is hard to sell diapers or tea or back-to-school gear 
next to somebody overdosing on the streets. But what that has 
done, is a disservice to our democracy, because the average 
American likely has no idea what is happening on the streets, 
unless they live next to it. And when you do not have all of 
this information, you cannot make the right call when it comes 
to voting, especially for lawmakers who are pushing the correct 
policies.
 Mr. Burchett, we are in an information war. And what I have 
seen in my time working in corporate media is the sin of 
omission. Whenever we talk about homelessness, we would go to 
the experts who would keep saying that in order to solve it, 
you have to build more housing. What we rarely ever hear are 
the root causes of homelessness, which are drug addiction, 
mental illness, and broken relationships. And that is what I 
have been able to finally see. For the past six years, after 
leaving corporate media, I started reporting on the front lines 
seeing the raw realities for myself. I always like to say the 
video don't lie.
 And if you talk to the vast majority of the people on the 
streets--and I have done that for six years in San Francisco, 
L.A., Seattle, Portland--and the homeless people on the streets 
will say that they are on the streets not because they cannot 
afford the housing, it is because they have an addiction.
 So, I encourage other fellow lawmakers and our mainstream 
media to start going into these communities and also taking the 
risks to show what is really happening on the ground.
 Mr. Burchett. Is the Federal Government funding the 
injection of fentanyl and other illegal drugs?
 Mr. Choe. Did you ask is the Federal Government funding 
that? In some cases, in some cities, yes. They are called safe 
injection sites.
 Mr. Burchett. What portion of the homeless people you 
encounter living on the streets are drug addicted, mentally 
ill, or both?
 Mr. Choe. I would say eight out of ten.
 Mr. Burchett. Okay. Do these individuals simply lack 
affordable housing?
 Mr. Choe. No, not at all.
 Mr. Burchett. All right. When you are in these 
neighborhoods that seem to be overrun with homelessness, is 
there a police presence?
 Mr. Choe. Unfortunately, in Seattle, we are down hundreds 
of police officers. And there is a corner in Chinatown-ID 
(International District) in Seattle known as 12th and Jackson. 
It has turned into a containment zone with virtually no police 
officers. And what has been allowed to happen is that homeless 
drug addicts, including dealers and other criminals, have 
turned it into a black market of stolen goods and have 
essentially turned the businesses into a blight. And that is 
the problem we are having in these West Coast cities due to 
these harmful policies like Housing First and harm reduction; 
the streets near these facilities have turned into human 
dumping grounds.
 Mr. Burchett. Do you feel like the politicians in cities 
like L.A. and Seattle are sympathetic to these folks' plight or 
do you think it is--let me back up.
 To the small businesses, do you think they are sympathetic 
to them? It seems like in those areas they are just kind of 
overrun with trash and filth and folks that are just laying on 
their curbs.
 Mr. Choe. Yes, I cannot get into the hearts and minds of 
these politicians who are presiding over these issues right 
now. But I do know that many have no solutions, no immediate 
solutions. All they are doing is doubling down on the current 
plan, and the current plan is not working.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you.
 That gets to my next question for Mr. Webster. Do you feel 
like these entities that are not solving or reducing these 
problems, shouldn't their funding be tied to some sort of 
performance, and how would that be measured? You have to do 
that pretty quick.
 Mr. Webster. Yes, sir, I do believe it should be tied to 
performance. The performance should be measured by various 
outcomes, such as increased incomes, successful referrals and 
completions to treatment, mental health stability, reductions 
in arrests or engagements with law enforcement. Family 
reunification is a great metric that covers a whole number of 
challenges.
 Mr. Burchett. Thank you all very much. My time is up.
 By unanimous consent, I would like to offer the statement 
from the Kingdom Warriors Foundation, an L.A.-based nonprofit. 
They have struggled to obtain funding from LAHSA, but due to 
the widespread fraud, they have not been able to gain that.
 Without objection, so ordered.
 Let us see, what have we got here?
 In closing, I want to thank our witnesses once again for 
their testimony.
 And with that, and without objection, all Members have five 
legislative days within which to submit materials and 
additional written questions for the witnesses which will be 
forwarded to the witnesses.
 If there is no further business, without objection, the 
Subcommittee stands adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 3:42 p.m., the Subcommittee was adjourned.]

 [all]