Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- HEARING EXAMINING THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES WITH IMPLEMENTING THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT [Senate Hearing 119-461] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-461 HEARING EXAMINING THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES WITH IMPLEMENTING THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT ======================================================================= HEARING before the SUBCOMMITTEE ON FISHERIES, WATER, AND WILDLIFE of the COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ MARCH 18, 2026 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Environment and Public Works [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-090 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia, Chairman SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island, Ranking Member KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina MARK KELLY, Arizona DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska ALEX PADILLA, California PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska ADAM B. SCHIFF, California ROGER F. WICKER, Mississippi LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas ANGELA D. ALSOBROOKS, Maryland JON HUSTED, Ohio Adam Tomlinson, Republican Staff Director Dan Dudis, Democratic Staff Director ---------- Subcommittee on Fisheries, Water, and Wildlife PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska, Chairman ADAM B. SCHIFF, California, Ranking Member KEVIN CRAMER, Maryland BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS. Wyoming MARK KELLY, Arizona DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska ALEX PADILLA, California JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas ANGELA D. ALSOBROOKS, Maryland JON HUSTED, Ohio SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia (ex officio) (ex officio) C O N T E N T S ---------- Page MARCH 18, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Ricketts, Hon. Pete., U.S. Senator from the State of Nebraska.... 1 Schiff, Hon. Adam B., U.S. Senator from the State of California.. 3 WITNESSES Thomas E. Riley, P.E., Water Resources and Environmental Consultant, Riley Consulting, Inc.............................. 5 Prepared statement........................................... 8 Brian Yablonski, Chief Executive Officer, Property and Environment Research Center.................................... 21 Prepared statement........................................... 23 Jake Li, Vice President of Conservation Policy, Defenders of Wildlife....................................................... 37 Prepared statement........................................... 39 Responses to additional questions from: Senator Schiff........................................... 49 Senator Whitehouse....................................... 54 ADDITIONAL MATERIAL Letter to Senator Capito and Senator Whitehouse from Associated Builders and Contractors....................................... 73 Letters to Senator Ricketts and Senator Schiff from: Stands for American Steel.................................... 74 Western Governors' Association............................... 76 HEARING EXAMINING THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES WITH IMPLEMENTING THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT ---------- WEDNESDAY, MARCH 18, 2026 U.S. Senate, Committee on Environment and Public Works, Subcommittee on Fisheries, Wildfire, and Water, Washington, DC. The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:05 a.m. in room 562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Pete Ricketts (chairman of the subcommittee) presiding. Present: Senators Ricketts, Schiff, Lummis, Capito (ex officio), Whitehouse (ex officio). OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. PETE RICKETTS, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF NEBRASKA Senator Ricketts. This subcommittee of the Environment and Public Works committee on Fisheries, Water and Wildlife hearing entitled Challenges and Opportunities with Implementing the Endangered Species Act will come to order. I appreciate the witnesses being here, and the Ranking Member, Senator Schiff, as well. Before we get started, I want to recognize that Nebraska is currently experiencing wildfires that are the largest that we have had since statehood. The fires have impacted more than 750,000 acres of land in my State, and that roughly, it is over 1 percent, approaching 2 percent of our total State land area. I want to extend my gratitude to and appreciation of the entire State to our brave first responders. We have firefighters from across Nebraska, we have Federal firefighters, we have National Guard, we have neighbors from Iowa who are helping out. I appreciate everybody who is helping out trying to control this fire. I certainly want to pray for all those who are impacted by these terrible wildfires. We will continue to ensure that these impacted communities know that we are there to support them and get them resources to be able to help them recover. As wildfires spread throughout the U.S., rebuilding communities is a big part of the aftermath. I am concerned that the Endangered Species Act, as well as other environmental laws, can hinder recovery after a natural disaster. The Endangered Species Act, enacted in 1973, was written to conserve, protect, and ultimately recover endangered species. However, after more than 50 years, the actual recovery metrics for species raises concerns about whether the law is achieving its goal. Since the ESA was enacted, 57 of the more than 1,700 listed species have been delisted. That means roughly 3 percent of the species ever listed as endangered or threatened have recovered. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has reported that only 4 percent of the listed species are improving. A 3 or 4 percent success rate does not sound very good to me. The agency projected 300 species to recover by now, yet only 57 have met that benchmark. These numbers are concerning and raise concerns about whether the ESA is effectively delivering to recover species. The ultimate goal of the law is to recover species to the point that Federal protections are no longer needed. Yet the available data suggests that the current framework is not consistently achieving that outcome. In many cases, the process has also created uncertainty that can delay or complicate infrastructure projects without creating significant recovery outcomes. In Nebraska, the listed species that we focus on include the pallid sturgeon, the whooping crane, the piping plover, the least tern, and the American burying beetle. Detecting, protecting and recovering these species requires State-led conservation efforts. Nebraska is a great example of successfully implementing the programs to do so. When I was Governor of Nebraska, I led the Platte River Recovery Implementation Program. This program is considered a major success story for its collaborative, basin-wide efforts between Nebraska, Colorado, and Wyoming and the Department of the Interior to recover listed species in the river. It successfully increased species populations, particularly the whooping crane, to historically high levels. However, this species still has not fully recovered. Overall, Nebraska's experience shows that conservation rules are most successful when implementation is collaborative, science-based, transparent, and predictable for all stakeholders involved. While all States represented on this committee have some local success stories, there is a lot of work that needs to be done to improve the implementation of the ESA. First, the focus should remain on recovery. The purpose of the ESA is not simply to list species, but to recover them to the point where Federal protections are no longer needed. Efforts have been made to improve clarity in ESA implementation. For example, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service during this administration took steps to provide additional regulatory clarity by rescinding the blanket rule and providing clearer definitions of habitat. Another critical issue is transparency and accountability from the Fish and Wildlife Service. In Nebraska, State agencies collect data that is used alongside Federal information to inform listing and recovery decisions. State experts often have the boots on the ground and a direct understanding of local species and habitats. Improving coordination, communication, and transparency among Federal agencies, States, and other stakeholders should be a central part of ESA's implementation moving forward. Programs like the Platte River Recovery Implementation Program demonstrate that collaborative conservation can work, but similar models have not been consistently applied elsewhere. Ultimately, the ESA has not consistently achieved its intended goal of recovering species and removing them from Federal protection. Congress needs to be at the forefront of these discussions and improve the law that has created more regulatory uncertainty than tangible success. I look forward to a discussion with our witnesses on the Endangered Species Act and what opportunities, challenges, and policy recommendations are needed to better support species recovery. Now, I will recognize the Ranking Member, Ranking Member Schiff, for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ADAM SCHIFF, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Senator Schiff. Good morning, and thank you, Chairman Ricketts, for calling this hearing today. It is really a pleasure working with you on this subcommittee. Thank you to our witnesses for coming today and sharing your expertise. The Endangered Species Act, maybe more than any other law, represents the ideal of trying to leave the world in a better place than we found it. In 1973, Congress came together and observed that species were going extinct as a result of economic growth and development untampered by adequate concern and conservation. To address this, Congress declared that all Federal departments and agencies shall seek to conserve endangered species and threatened species. It may surprise some to learn that this historic legislation passed the Senate by a vote of 92 to zero. We can not do that for anything other than a post office naming these days. [Laughter.] Senator Schiff. The House agreed to the conference report by 355 to 4. President Nixon, a Republican, signed it into law. Can we imagine everyone coming together in such unison to pass legislation of that magnitude today? It is hard to imagine. This is how serious the situation was in the 1960's and 1970's, in terms of species and extinction. We would do well to take stock of just how far we have come since 1973, of all the species that have ever been listed as endangered or threatened, 99 percent of them have been saved by the Endangered Species Act. That is a remarkable track record. The bald eagle, that proud, fierce symbol of our Nation, is around today largely because of the Endangered Species Act. There are numerous other success stories, such as the peregrine falcon, the American alligator, and the California condor. Today, I am gravely concerned that we are no longer providing our Fish and Wildlife Service with what it needs to effectively implement the law. Since January 2025, almost 25 percent of the agency has left Federal service. The Center for Biological Diversity found that approximately 530 biologists have left the agency. We really can not do the science required for species status assessments, Section 7 consultations, or listing decisions without proper expertise. Simply put, there is a staffing crisis. It is well known that Fish and Wildlife Service has been under-resourced for years. This precedes the current administration. An analysis by Defenders of Wildlife found the agency receives about 50 percent of the funding required to properly implement the Endangered Species Act. A 2016 analysis by the Center for Biological Diversity found that Congress only provides about 3.5 percent of the funding that Fish and Wildlife Service, their scientists, estimate is needed to recover species. The recent loss of staffing makes a bad situation even worse. According to documents obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests, more than half of our Nation's wildlife refuges currently lack the resources and staff needed to fulfill their missions. According to the agency, national wildlife refuges provide important habitat for more than 380 threatened or endangered species. With a total of 20 Senators, I led a letter to Secretary Burgum and Director Nesvik in December to raise the alarm and ask them to provide Congress with a plan to address the issue. Like with almost letter I have sent, we are still waiting for a response from the Department of Interior. We are here today because we all want to see the Fish and Wildlife Service move faster. We want more species to become fully recovered. That is what makes delisting possible. I think this is a bipartisan goal. I truly believe that Chairman Ricketts and my Republican colleagues want species to be successful and reach recovery, as I do. We may differ in how we get there, but we all want to get there. Nevertheless, I am confident we can not get there if the Service does not have the experts and the resources that it needs. I am encouraged by some of the ideas our witnesses are bringing to the table today. Contrary to popular belief, I think there are many bipartisan avenues to explore for improving the implementation of the Endangered Species Act. We can all get behind proposals to modernize the Service's work, automate processes with machine learning and AI, provide greater flexibility to private landowners who are being good stewards and doing the right things, and promote greater collaboration with the States to harness their expertise. I am very interested in embracing some of the innovative approaches of States, including the State of California. The Golden State is moving beyond the dichotomy of choosing between infrastructure development and environmental protection, and showing that you can do both with smart policy. California uses habitat conservation planning to cover whole regions with a strategy to protect species. The State can use that plan to clear projects within the plan area instead of it going through individual review. California also uses a tool called consistency determination, where the State can approve a project if it has already gone through Federal approvals. We need to think more outside the box. To do it, we need proper resources at the Federal level. The scientists and experts at Fish and Wildlife are a truly dedicated bunch who are being asked to do a lot with very little. I hope for greater collaboration between the Service and Congress, and this hearing is a great place to start. Once again, thank you to our witnesses, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, for bringing us together for this hearing. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much, Ranking Member Schiff, and I agree, I think there are common ground on things we do want to improve and make sure that we are actually recovering species, which is kind of the point. Thank you. All right, now we will turn to our witnesses for their opening remarks. Our first witness is Tom Riley, Water Resources and Environmental Consultant, testifying this morning on behalf of Riley Consulting. Mr. Riley was the director of the Nebraska Department of Natural Resources while I was Governor. It is good to see you again, Tom. Thank you for testifying to the subcommittee today. At the department, Mr. Riley oversaw statewide water allocation, permitting compliance and stakeholder coordination across agricultural, municipal, environmental and governmental sectors. He also serves as a lecturer at the University of Nebraska, Lincoln, where he teaches courses on water resources and environmental policy. He has experience implementing state-led conservation efforts, combined with his private experience and expertise and academic background, making him uniquely qualified and capable of speaking on the challenges and opportunities for ESA reform. Mr. Riley, you are recognized for your 5 minutes, we give 5 minutes to all the witnesses, 5 minutes, for an opening statement. STATEMENT OF THOMAS E. RILEY, P.E., WATER RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT, RILEY CONSULTING, INC. Mr. Riley. Chairman Ricketts and Ranking Member Schiff, and members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to come here today and talk about the challenges and opportunities with the ESA. My perspective comes from several roles, as the Senator noted. I am a professional engineer, and I specialize in water resources and environmental restoration. I previously served as the director of the Nebraska Department of Natural Resources, where I represented Nebraska in interstate water management and collaborative recovery programs, including the Platte River Recovery Implementation. I also teach college level ecological engineering classes. From that perspective, many ESA challenges in the western United States are fundamentally systems management challenges, balancing river ecology, water infrastructure, and the working landscapes, those landscapes that support agriculture, communities and regional economies, places where human use and ecological function must operate together. Across much of the west, species recovery occurs where water is scarce and heavily managed. Large systems, such as the Platte River and the Missouri River in Nebraska, support irrigation, municipal water supply, flood control, hydropower and navigation. ESA implementation therefore requires coordinated management across States and agencies. Nebraska's experience shows how ESA implementation can function effectively within these working landscapes when programs provide transparency and long-term certainty. One example is restoration of the Eastern Nebraska Saline Wetlands and the habitat of the Salt Creek Tiger Beetle. These wetlands occur in soils that are difficult to farm and develop. Restoration has proven to be the most sustainable long-term land use, supporting species recovery while providing flood storage, ecological function, and open space for people. A second example is the Platte River Recovery and Implementation program. This cooperative effort among States and Federal agencies, water users, and conservation organizations takes a basin-scale approach. It combines habitat restoration, water management and scientific monitoring across the river system, rather than addressing the ESA obligations project by project. Equally important, the program was structured with defined increments extending through 2032. That structure provided clear planning horizons and allowed States and water users to commit resources with confidence with a goal to achieve a program that becomes one of maintenance, not continually looking for more. That planning horizon matters. In western water systems, infrastructure investments and habitat restoration are planned over decades. Stakeholders know that agreements will remain stable long enough for those investments to succeed, and that the goal line does not change. Transparency and regulatory certainty are therefore essential to maintaining the trust required for these programs. Nebraska's experience also reflects the perspective shared by many western States, where species recovery must operate within highly managed river systems and interstate water agreements. These experiences suggest several principles to strengthen ESA implementation. First, species recovery in the west must occur within the working landscapes that support agriculture, communities and economies. Second, conservation should be grounded in local science, the hydrology, soils and ecological processes. Third, ESA implementation should coordinate with existing State water management and interstate governance. Finally, transparency and clearly defined milestones are essential for long-term participation. Based on discussions with Nebraska stakeholders, there are several practical actions Congress could consider right now. Congress could codify key elements of the critical habitat exclusion analysis and a withdrawal of the blanket section 4(d) rule to improve transparency and regulatory clarity. For example, considerations of economics and national security. Congress could expand incentives for voluntary conservation on private lands which are essential to species recovery across much of the United States. Congress could invest more in proactive conservation under the ESA Section 7(a)(1), incorporating ecological considerations early and helping prevent new listings. From an engineering perspective, designing ecological function in the projects early is also much better than retrofitting them later. When implemented with collaboration, transparency, grounded in current science, real-world ecological performance, and regulatory certainty, the ESA can protect species while supporting our communities across the west and the working landscapes and water systems that sustain our farms and our ranches that are working to feed the world. Thank you for the opportunity to testify and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Riley follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Ricketts. All right. Thank you very much, Mr. Riley. I remember, I think that Platte River Implementation Program was first talked about like in 2005, 2006. It was very controversial at the time. To your point about the long-term nature of it, I think it was signed up for 13 years, and we got another 13-year extension or something like that. That long- term commitment made it possible for a lot of people to have certainty around that plan. All right. Next, we will hear from Brian Yablonski, the CEO of the Property and Environment Research Center, PERC. As CEO of PERC, Mr. Yablonski helps lead national conservation issues ranging from national parks management and national forest restoration, help migrations on ranch lands, endangered species recovery to the great Salt Lake Conservation and Market-Based Private Lands Stewardship. Before moving to Montana, Brian served as chairman of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the State agency directed to conserve and manage Florida's wildlife and marine resources. Mr. Yablonski, you are recognized for your 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF BRIAN YABLONSKI, CEO, PROPERTY AND ENVIRONMENT RESEARCH CENTER Mr. Yablonski. Chairman Ricketts, Ranking Member Schiff, and members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to testify on ways to promote species recovery under the Endangered Species Act. My name is Brian Yablonski, and I serve as the CEO of the Property and Environment Research Center, based in Boozman, Montana. For more than 45 years, PERC's work has been premised on a simple idea: incentives matter for conservation. When people benefit from stewardship, they will do more of it. Before coming to PERC, I spent 14 years on the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. In that role, I worked alongside biologists, landowners, hunters and anglers and conservation groups on recovering species, including the manatee, Florida panther, and gopher tortoise. Time and time again, I saw that conservation works best when done with people, not to them. The Endangered Species Act sets an ambitious goal of recovering all at-risk species. After 50-plus years, I like to describe the ESA as a tale of two cities, it was the best of times, it was the worst of times. In the best of times, it has largely succeeded by preventing extinction, with 99 percent of imperiled species persisting to this day. In the worst of times, it has recovered only about 3 percent of all listed species. Indeed, PERC examined the government's own recovery plans and found that the Fish and Wildlife Service failed to recover 96 percent of the species it predicted to recover by 2023. These results, while disappointing, should not be surprising. The ESA provides too many sticks and too few carrots. Rigid regulations are tools for preventing extinction, not for spurring recovery. To recover species, we must encourage and reward, make species an asset, not a liability. As the late Sam Hamilton, former director of the Service under Obama, summed up, ``The incentives are wrong here. If a rare metal is on my property, the value of the land goes up. If a rare bird occupies my land, its value disappears.'' We simply cannot achieve the ESA's ambitious goal of recovering species without a new mindset and new tools that change the incentives. Across the Country, private lands provide habitat for two- thirds of our at-risk wildlife. States are the principal wildlife managers for the Nation. An ESA listing can bring resources to each. How those resources are deployed matters. Every dollar spent navigating the notoriously complex consultation and permitting process is a dollar not spent on restoring habitat. Those who bear the cost of recovering species need support, not red tape. Fortunately, there is a lot we could do to supercharge species recovery without sacrificing the ESA's effectiveness at preventing extinction. I offer three ideas. First, we should consistently reward recovery progress with regulatory relief. The promise that recovery effort may someday be rewarded by species delisting is not enough. As species improve, we should reward success gradually by giving agencies, States and landowners more flexibility. For instance, instead of the current one-size-fits-all approach, regulations for threatened species should incorporate incremental recovery goals and automatically provide regulatory relief as they are met. Recovery need not be an on-off switch. Second, we should shift from top-down mandates to bottom-up conservation by fully engaging the States. To date, no recovered species transferred to State management has backslid. I have seen first-hand how States can find novel and effective ways to recover species. The ESA encourages such creativity by offering to any State with a comprehensive conservation program the authority to decide whether Federal take prohibitions apply. This is akin to how we implement the Clean Water Act. This robust federalism provision in Section 6 has been hollowed out by agency policy into a mere grant-making program. We should restore Congress' original intent by embracing conservation federalism. Finally, we need to lower the temperature around recovering species. Too often, recovery news has provoked a race to the courtroom, rather than a celebration. To fix this, we need a cooling-off period, requiring litigants to wait for the Service to complete its post-delisting monitoring period. At the end of the day, conservation works best when it brings people together. If we align incentives and power bottom-up conservation and reward success, we can dramatically improve the recovery of imperiled species across America's landscapes. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Yablonski follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Ricketts. Thank you, Mr. Yablonski. Next, we will hear from Jake Li. Mr. Li is the Vice President of Conservation Policy, at the Defenders of Wildlife. Mr. Li previously served as the Assistant Director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Ecological Services program, which leads the agency's national work on endangered species conservation and environmental review of Federal projects. Jake has also served in the Biden administration as a deputy assistant administrator in EPA's Chemical Safety Office, where he worked with industry, environmental advocates, and States and others on chemical regulation. Mr. Li, you are recognized for your 5-minute opening statement. STATEMENT OF JAKE LI, VICE PRESIDENT OF CONSERVATION POLICY, DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE Mr. Li. Good morning, Chairman Ricketts, Ranking Member Schiff, and members of the subcommittee. Thank you very much for inviting me to testify today. As you noted, I am Jake Li, the Vice President of Conservation Policy at Defenders of Wildlife. You also noted that I was previously the Assistant Director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Ecological Services program, which leads the agency's work on the Endangered Species Act. I see two ways that Congress can help the service and other Federal agencies advance the purpose of this hearing, which is, more recoveries, more transparency and more accountability. First, Congress can encourage the agencies to identify new policies and new approaches that improve how they implement the ESA. The ESA is flexible enough to accommodate these types of improvements, I do not think legislation is actually needed here. Second, the Service absolutely needs the capacity to do this work. None of the recovery and permitting outcomes that I think we all want to see happen without agency staff to do the hard day-to-day work. Unfortunately, the Service's capacity is more diminished than ever. When I worked there, I heard example after example of how staff were trying to juggle 20 balls at once, only to have more balls thrown at them. This was all before the agency lost a quarter of its staff within the last year. This is an incredible depletion of capacity, expertise and relationships with States, with private landowners, with businesses and with many others. This loss includes nearly 40 percent of the senior executive team, myself included, and hundreds of scientists and program managers with unique knowledge about how the ESA is implemented within the Fish and Wildlife Service. The agency has lost several centuries worth of institutional knowledge overnight. Having lost so much capacity, the Service will absolutely struggle to meet expectations for recovering species and its other mission work. Congress can actually help fix this deficit through targeted investments in how the Service implements the ESA, in at least three areas. One, more recoveries; two, more flexibility for landowners; and three, better ways to authorize projects under Section 7 and Section 10. Let me start with recovery progress. Here I will highlight two opportunities. One, if the Service were to receive targeted funding for recovery actions, it could begin recovering species soon after a listing, rather than waiting years for a recovery plan to be drafted first. We usually actually know how to begin saving a species soon after a listing. The problem is that the funding is not there to carry out these interventions. Another recovery opportunity is that in its recovery reports to Congress, the Service can actually improve its reporting on which species are progressing toward recovery and by how much. Even if that progress does not rise to a level of a downlisting or a delisting. Why is this incremental progress important? It is important because it can open up new ways to give landowners regulatory flexibility and incentivize recovery. Here is one vastly underused example. Under existing ESA regulations, the Service can offer regulatory flexibility to landowners who demonstrate meaningful progress toward recovery, even if downlisting or delisting is nowhere on the horizon. This approach would offer landowners a far stronger incentive to help recover species, because they would not need to wait decades for a delisting before benefiting from regulatory relief. The Service has actually applied this approach only a handful of times, notably with the Department of Defense. I know of two examples, one of which I was personally involved in, in which a military installation gets fewer ESA requirements on its training activities if it can demonstrate recovery progress for species on the installation. Rather than treating ESA regulatory flexibility as a binary on-off switch at delisting, we can think of it more as a dimmer switch that adjusts as the species shows recovery progress. My final topic is Section 7 consultations. My remaining testimony describes five opportunities here. For now, I will just quickly underscore that I think there is no better return on investment than continuing to fund the Service's IPaC system, which is an online tool that streamlines Section 7 consultations. It has already saved the equivalent of over 37 full-time salaries annually. This is to say nothing of the time and cost savings for permittees. If Congress invests in these and other improvements, I really think we will see real progress toward recovery in the coming years. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Li follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Ricketts. Thank you, Mr. Li. I think we are already hearing some common ground ideas on things. That is a great start. Again, thank you to all of our witnesses for joining us here this morning. Now, we will start off with a round of 5-minute questions. I will lead off here, then we will turn to the Ranking Member. Let us start with, one of the challenges with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is that decisions are often made without historical scientific data. In many cases, we simply do not have data that dates back 100 or 80 years. For example, in Nebraska, the habitat of the American burying beetle has been difficult to find with certainty. The Endangered Species Act requires decisions to be based on the best available science and data. Those decisions should not rely on speculation when clear evidence does not exist. This lack of evidence consistently defaults to regulation. In addition, agencies' interpretation of environmental baseline has created challenges. In places like the Platte River, we already have decades of real-world data showing how species respond to current conditions. Policy makers should rely on that existing science, rather than assuming the river must be restored to an uncertain historical State. Mr. Riley, Mr. Yablonski, how can we encourage U.S. Fish and Wildlife to utilize the best available science? Mr. Riley, we will start with you. Mr. Riley. Thank you, Senator. You are spot-on that we need to use local, available science and recognize that that often is the best information that we are going to have. I have experienced a couple of times where that is not the case, though, that the Service in some instances will recognize their own data or maybe use something from a site far away. A lot of times the data is prepared by an applicant or the stakeholders themselves. I think we need to then build on this transparency and trust and collaborate to make sure that that data is available and used in the decisionmaking process and not necessarily dismissed. Senator Ricketts. Let me interrupt you there for just a second. What you are saying is what your experience has been in the past is, say we are looking at something in Nebraska. The Service is using data maybe from somewhere else in the Platte River that is not in Nebraska and applying that, saying, hey, these two things are similar? Is that accurate? Mr. Riley. I think that is accurate. It is not good enough just to grab the latest and greatest paper somebody wrote if it is not applicable to the area that you are looking at. These sites and rivers are very unique. One of your other thoughts on the baseline issue, we need to really incorporate the idea of our landscapes are already built. Especially in the west. They are highly managed. Those areas that include dams and other entities like that need to be considered. We just can not consider those as not being there in a baseline analysis. Mr. Ricketts. Mr. Yablonski? Mr. Yalonski. Yes, Mr. Chairman. I actually think that how the agency applies rulemaking and planning for species should be more science-based as well. We have something called the 4(d) rule. The 4(d) rule is the playbook. It is kind of the rules of the road for an individual species. As you mentioned in your opening comments, if we apply that rule as a blanket rule, where just strict regulation is done across the board, it disregards, it kind of dismisses science- based recovery for species. The beauty of a more creative use of the 4(d) rule is to have tailored science-based rules for each specific species as opposed to applying sort of a blanket strict regulation across the board. I think that is a way to encourage the agency to do more on the 4(d) side, especially for threatened species. It is going to lead to more science-based decisions in the future. Senator Ricketts. Mr. Riley, I want to get back to something else you talked about. Talk about the environmental baselines. Have you run across situations where that has created some false assumptions? What can we do to address that? What directives are needed to fix that? Mr. Riley. One example, even though we have talked about how successful it is, the PRRIP program, the Platte River Recovery Implementation Program, we can not start with not recognizing that we have these working landscapes in place. To be successful with these programs that baseline has to recognize that if a project comes along, it can not be bearing the entire weight of what the baseline is. It has an incremental impact, not the impact that you have to go back to the baseline. We need to do a better job of that. I think there is an opportunity within the rules and within the Service's ability to look at that in a different light. Senator Ricketts. What I think I hear you saying is that if a new project is coming along, it is not fair to say we have to take it back to 300 years ago, where the Platte River was then. You think about where is the Platte River today, and what kind of incremental impact is it making on the working lands that we have right now with the Platte River, not something that was 300 years ago, which frankly, we do not even have the data for. Mr. Riley. Maybe a finer point, that if a new project comes along and it should not have to bear the entire weight of that existing baseline condition be compared to it. Its impact is incremental. It can not fix everything that has already been there for many, many years. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you, Mr. Riley. Senator Schiff? Senator Schiff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for the testimony. Really very helpful. It seems like one area of overlapping interest and agreement is the idea of providing incentives and rewards for progress with flexibility. I wonder if we can drill down a little bit more on that. Mr. Yablonski, I would ask you, what concretely do you have in mind? What kind of incentives? Mr. Li, I would love to get your reaction to that. Then maybe at the risk of stirring up a hornet's nest, is there any applicability of that idea to grizzlies or gray wolves, or are we stuck in the binary delisting or not delisting debate? Mr. Yablonski. Yes, thank you, Mr. Senator. I think you heard me say in my opening statement that recovery does not have to be an on-off switch. I can fully say I plagiarized that from Jake Li next to me. [Laughter.] Mr. Yablonski. It is a pretty good way to look at life. I think one thing that can be done, delistings will happen or not happen. Oftentimes, especially in the case of grizzly bears or wolves, they get thrown to the judicial roulette wheel that exists out there. Alongside that, we talked about the 4(d) rule being sort of the playbook. You could establish a 4(d) rule with specific recovery goals and as those recovery goals are met by States and landowners, you could shift incrementally more flexibility to the States and the landowners. Over time, as they are hitting those markers and more management authority is shifting to the States, by the time you get to the end, they will essentially be delisted. They will be managed as if they are delisted, except they would be sort of Federal oversight through that graduated process. It is not to diminish delisting, because delisting needs to occur. I think the 4(d) policy is almost an insurance for delisting, because delisting will go to courts and a lot of times they get knocked out. A 4(d) I think is a more gradual path and can get you to the same place and should be sort of the baseline for a lot of these species. Senator Schiff. Explain what you mean by 4(d) process. Mr. Yablonski. The 4(d) process is, again, it is the section of the ESA that actually establishes the management plans for each of the species. It tells the States and landowners what they can and can not do. One of the challenges you have today is that recovery goals and recovery plans are often outside of the 4(d) rule. If you put recovery goals within the 4(d) rule, there is more incentive for States and landowners to respond to that, knowing that they could get some flexibility on the back end. Senator Schiff. Mr. Li, does that sound good to you? Mr. Li. Yes, as a general matter, I have written in the past about opportunities to use 4(d) rules to loosen some of the ESA regulations as species demonstrate progress. Let me also just highlight two other opportunities that complement the use of 4(d) rules. One is what I mentioned earlier, the use of Section 7 consultations, in particular for species on Federal lands. I gave the example of the Department of Defense and how this winding down of regulatory requirements is working really well for certain military installations that are voluntarily helping to recover species. I think that approach could apply to more types of Federal agencies and Federal lands, including BLM, Forest Service, to create stronger incentives for those agencies to help recover species. The other example I will offer is the use of what you mentioned earlier, habitat conservation plans, of which California has more than any other State. I can imagine approaches to habitat conservation plans in which as a species moves toward recovery, the mitigation requirements in habitat conservation plans are more flexible, or the process for getting an HCP approved is more expeditious because a species is doing better. You can imagine the need for less review, easier NEPA, and just easier permitting requirements as a species demonstrates progress. To wrap up, there are a number of tools that the Service actually has to do this. Senator Schiff. Mr. Yablonski, is this something to incentivize a program that incentivizes incentives and rewards? Is this something that requires a legislative fix? Or is this something already fully within the discretion of the agency, or would legislative ideas help prompt the agency in that direction? Mr. Yablonski. I think it is already existing in the law. This is something, as Jake Li has mentioned, that the agency could do today. I remember having a conversation a couple of years ago with a chief scientist at the Fish and Wildlife Service, and we were talking about legislation that could potentially encourage this, or nudge this. He said, but we can already do this. I said, well, the point is you do not already do this. Maybe there would be legislation needed to move this along. It is within the authority of the agency to use this creative way to move the 4(d) rule. Senator Schiff. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Ricketts. Senator Capito? Senator Capito. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is nice to be here. Thank the folks on the panel, and the witnesses. Certainly coming from a State like West Virginia, we are very, as every State is, familiar with the Endangered Species Act and some of the pluses and some of the minuses. In some cases, the ESA has, at times, been used to kind of unnecessarily kind of slow down progress, and particularly in our timbering and our energy industries, and actually some of our construction on our highways going through the mountains. It has inhibited our ability to build, or really build, I would not even say build quickly, I am talking like decades here. Those impacts are felt everywhere. I guess, I was really pleased to hear, I have heard all three of you say, at least several words, seems like there is a lot of agreement on the panel on directions that can make for improvements to alleviate some of these, but also help us understand how the process is. I am curious to know, I think, Mr. Yablonski, you mentioned that the States could play maybe a bigger role here. Could you elaborate on that a little bit, and what kind of capacities? I know you live in Montana, but you were in Florida, so you have been in several different States. Mr. Yablonski. Yes, I am a former State wildlife chairman from Florida. I am a little partial to States being able to manage wildlife. There is something like 200,000 species, domestic species in North America. The States probably manage 99 percent of those species, and they do it pretty well. I think there is another provision in the ESA under Section 6 that allows for ESA cooperative agreements that could be used more robustly. Essentially think of it as how we delegate authority under Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act to the States. The States have, within the statute, it lays out sort of five requirements that the State would have to hit in order for the Fish and Wildlife Service to shift management of species, oversight of species, take permitting of species to the States. I think in a State like Florida, all five of those are very doable. Some of those are like habitat acquisition programs and public process, and an agency to actually do this. Senator Capito. Why do you think that is not occurring? Why do you think that, is there lack of trust, that the States do not have the capacity, or they not going to oversee properly? Why is it still so Federalized? Mr. Yablonski. I would say part of it is a mindset at the agency itself. It is hard to just kind of shift something directly back to the States. The other is litigation. We actually tried this in Florida in 2012. The Service at that time actually, under President Obama, actually agreed to do it, but the State of Florida was sued, the agency was sued right away, and Florida ended up backing off it because of the litigation. Senator Capito. I see. You know, one thing I have always been curious about, the northern bat, the northern eared bat, I think. It has white-nose syndrome, it has an illness that is making it, the species, die out. Yet it is on a list, so you have to watch it. How do you see that as conflicting when you have a species that has an inherent disease that is killing it, and it has nothing to do with the development around it, or the environment or the habitat or any kind of activity, how do we balance that? This has been an issue for us. I do not know. Mr. Li, you are shaking your head. What would you say about that? Mr. Li. Thank you for that question, Senator Capito. Actually this is very close to me because one of the last things I did at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service was to sign the policy that gives flexibility in that very situation. The example there is that we know the Northern Long-Eared Bat Senator Capito. Yes, the Long-Eared. I called it the Northern Eared. Thank you. Mr. Li. Many other bat species are listed because of white nose syndrome. If it were not for white-nose syndrome, they would not be on the ESA list at all. Senator Capito. Right. Mr. Li. The policy we signed was actually to allow, in this case, wind energy companies to fund mitigation measures for white-nose syndrome as a way to meet the ESA requirements for mortality from wind turbines. That is an example of flexibility. You are actually funding the most important needs of the species, i.e., white-nose syndrome, even though your take is actually from something completely different, which is wind turbine operations. Senator Capito. Right. Mr. Li. That gives a lot more flexibility to energy companies. Senator Capito. Well, I mean, I think there has to be some flexibility here. In the end, even if the bat is still suffering from a terminal disease, it is going to naturally, the habitat, the numbers are going to go down whether it is getting hit by a windmill or not. I do not know. I have always kind of wondered about that, like, how do you solve that problem? I am sure if we went back 200,000 years ago, there are species that are no longer here because of the evolutionary nature of life, I guess. The other question I am going to ask--well, I am out of time. Well, I was going to ask, because I am from more the east coast. Senator Whitehouse is more east coast. You guys are western, California, Midwest. What do you see in terms of differences as we go? Just really generally. Is there a big difference in terms of looking at species compared to the east, Midwest or west? I have always thought it is more of an issue out west. Maybe it is because there are more Federal lands. I do not know. Does anybody have an answer to that? Mr. Yablonski. I think it is interesting, one of the commonalities is large, charismatic species. Whether I was in Florida dealing with the Florida panther or manatee, I woke up the next day I was dealing with grizzly bears and wolves out in Montana. They tend to get all the attention and suck all the oxygen out of the room. It also drains a lot of the resources for the agency, where some of these species should be coming off list, and we should be putting resources toward other species that really need it. Senator Capito. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Ricketts. Senator Whitehouse? Senator Whitehouse. Thanks very much. I have in mind an image of sort of a graph that shows the biomass of mammals on planet Earth and the whole graph is filled with images of cattle and of goats and of sheep and of horses. Then all human-managed livestock. Then down in the corner is this tiny little remaining quadrant for all other living species. We are really running wildlife off of the planet. That, I think, creates a real value to avoiding unnecessary extinction of species that exist. Mr. Li, how successful has the ESA been at protecting species when they are listed? Mr. Li. I think it has been incredibly successful. I think there are hundreds of species that would be extinct by now without the ESA having been in place over the last 50-plus years. You think about islands like Hawaii that are at the epicenter of extinction. Without the funding and the protections of ESA, I think we would have lost many, many species in States like Hawaii. Senator Whitehouse. There is a tendency, and it is a particularly acute tendency in this building, to only see value in money, and to look at any question in terms of how it can be monetized. It is hard to monetize the extinction of a species. How should we take into account just the moral and environmental value of not crushing that remaining tiny corner of wildlife that exists on our planet through extinctions, if there is no immediate monetary gain to somebody from that? Mr. Li. Yes, it is a great question. I personally think there is a lot of intrinsic value to all the species that are protected under the ESA. There also, many of you have heard this before, the next possible cure for a disease in a plant or an insect or a fish that scientists have yet to discover. Even if there is not a monetary value, I think there is utilitarian value to humans from a lot of these species that we have yet to uncover. Senator Whitehouse. Even that is monetizable. I think as human beings we can appreciate that there is value even beyond that. I went to Delaware Bay some years ago to witness the arrival of the Red Knot, which is a little bird that comes to Delaware Bay for the smorgasbord of crab eggs that are available to it. The remarkable thing about that is that it has flown up from the tip of South America, kicked off from Brazil, flew over the water from Brazil all the way to Delaware Bay. It is such an arduous flight that the bird actually has to physically morph during the course of that flight in order to make that journey. I flew down to Brazil for the COP in a jet plane. This little bird has to do it on its own. It is kind of one of the miracles of nature that a creature can do this. If we screw things up so that those crabs are not there when that bird lands, and the Red Knots all starve when they need to be feasting in Delaware Bay because the timing has gone askew because we have warmed things up and screwed things up, I am prepared to argue that even if it makes exactly zero dollars difference in any person's life, just to know that there is a species out there that does that kind of a thing, we kind of have to defend that stuff. I hope we can steer away from the monetization fetish that current shadows our environmental protection. I am about out of time, so I will leave it there. Thanks. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much, Senator Whitehouse. We are going to go ahead and do another round of 5-minute questions. I will go ahead and kick us off here. The Flood Control Act of 1944 authorized the Army Corps of Engineers to develop and manage the Missouri River system for several purposes, including flood control, navigation, power generation and water supply. After the Endangered Species Act was enacted in 1973, the way the Corps operates the river changed significantly as the agency began incorporating species protection requirements into its management decisions. When species such as the pallid sturgeon and piping plover were listed, the Corps was required to modify certain river operations to support habitat for those species. For example, adjustments in the flows from Gavin's Point Dam have been used to help create and maintain sand bar habitat used by the piping plovers for nesting. In addition, river engineering features, such as dikes and habitat structures, have been constructed to improve spawning conditions for the pallid sturgeon. Manipulating river flows and altering river structures can have complex consequences. Those decisions must carefully weigh both ecological goals and the potential risk to people and infrastructure. These changes can protect species, but sometimes at the cost of human life, when we have terrible flood events, which we have had on the Missouri River in the past. Mr. Riley, how should the Corps balance its flood control mission with species protection requirements under the Endangered Species Act? Mr. Riley. Well, they are in a tight spot, in that they have to balance all of those items, flood control, habitat, water supply, together. One way to do that is to recognize that system has to deliver all those, and they have to be able to measure and understand the metrics of success to what you do. I worked personally on a design project for some restoration that was part of the Corps' mission. That restoration was wiped out by the first big flood. Trying to manage those different dichotomies and understanding that there is a lot of cost involved, but you have to balance everything together, and do that within the landscape which we have. We need the dams for flood control. We need to have some ability to protect our farmland and our ranches, especially along the Missouri River. As you well know, Senator, our devastating floods from 2011, 2019, it is hard to come back from those things. Measurable success from the biological standpoint is really important. Senator Ricketts. Well, let me just dig into that a little bit more. Can you speak to the benefits and disadvantages of habitat modifications if these changes are producing measurable recovery metrics? Getting back to, you are talking about measurements. What was your experience with the Corps as far as measurements with regard, I am going to make something up, you can talk to anything you like, but think about the pallid sturgeon and its breeding habitat. Did the Corps have good measurements when it was creating these programs in place? Were they able to measure what happened after those big floods? Just tell me a little bit about kind of your experience with regard to those types of metrics. Were there other metrics besides just species recovery but also like flood control and things that the Corps used? Mr. Riley. There is a lot of data they collect for the pallid sturgeon. My own personal opinion is that they have been around for a long time, the pallid sturgeon, not the Army Corps. They have figured it out, to be able to survive on their own. You do not see, after a large flood, a bunch of pallid sturgeon gasping for air like carp in a farm field. They know when to move and when not to be there. I think the data shows some of that element. We continue to collect data. I am not sure if we are really deciding what we are doing with that data. I am going to give you one example. The Platte River Recovery Program has a connection to the pallid sturgeon. The connection is this, that program, which is really defined in the Central Platte Valley of Nebraska, that any action taken for water should not impact, downstream, pallid sturgeon. I worked on a study that looked at this, and in my own personal opinion and the science, the connection is not there. Yet we go on, to try and make a connection. I think there is a time and a place, and I think Mr. Li said it, where we need to move on, when we have the defined science, and say, we are good enough. That is a place where pallid sturgeon is not being affected by at least the PRRIP program, in my opinion. Let us move on and take it off of that system. Senator Ricketts. What you are saying is, look, you think what the science is showing is what was going on in the Platte River was not impacting the pallid sturgeon in the Missouri River, so stop looking there for the impacts and focus on the things that are going on in the Missouri River about the impact to the pallid sturgeon. Is that a fair summary? Mr. Riley. That is a great summary. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much. Senator Schiff? Senator Schiff. Mr. Yablonski, in the north and east of my State, I am hearing increasingly from constituents who are concerned about gray wolves, that they are seeing more and more gray wolves, they have children outside at play, they are losing horses and cattle and pets to the wolf population. How do you approach that need to be safe, and to be able to protect its investment with the desire to make sure that we protect the species? How should we approach this? How have you approached the issue? Mr. Yablonski. Thank you, Senator. The gray wolf has actually been a real recovery success story. I am from the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem Area, is where some of the initial wolves were transplanted from Alberta, Canada. They have thrived there and they dispersed. We started with something like 1,000 wolves, and we are up to 6,000 wolves right now. As those wolves move along, and as you recognize, there are costs that come with that, and the cost oftentimes relates to conflict, especially with cattle, cattle ranchers, and livestock ranchers. Credit to organizations, one of the models we have picked up on is Defenders of Wildlife, when the wolves were reintroduced in Yellowstone, they stood up a private compensation fund to offset depredation of cows and sheep, and did a very good job monitoring that. We think that is, as species start to move out, two things, one, we should try to offset the cost that that imposes to landowners who are providing the habitat for species as they move. Then the other thing is, as species disperse, they may have, like in the Rocky Mountain West, were delisted in Wyoming and Idaho and Montana with the gray wolf. As those wolves start to move into other States, which is successful, they all of a sudden get endangered species protections. It sort of flips the incentives a little bit. We should be encouraging that, rather than creating a situation where all of a sudden there is strict regulation of wolves, or moving into Washington or Oregon or Utah. Senator Schiff. Mr. Li, first of all, apologies for mispronouncing your name. What are your thoughts on this same subject? Mr. Li. Yes, so I think some overlapping sentiments. In particular, I want to underscore the importance, in your State, with the California wolf situation, of adequately staffing the human-wolf coexistence work. My organization thinks that is really the most important thing to do. Examples include, at the State department level, conflict reduction specialists to work with landowners, in particular ranchers, on conflict reduction tools like fladry. Another example would be the use of range riders in large allotments to help reduce depredation of wolves of livestock. These are all things that we actually know how to do. It is not rocket science. The unfortunate killing of the four wolves last year we think was largely because there was not enough funding and there was not enough deployment of these intervention tools early on. In other words, we know what to do, we just need a bit more money to actually get the work done immediately. Senator Schiff. Mr. Li, you mentioned in your testimony that the Fish and Wildlife Service has an online tool that helps with endangered species consultations, allowing projects to get an answer in minutes regarding whether they need to go through more formal consultation process. How can this tool be replicated? How can we make use of AI to expedite ESA reviews without sacrificing environmental safeguards? Mr. Li. Great question. This tool is called IPaC. Right now it handles about a quarter of all the Section 7 consultations that I mentioned, and there are about 10,000 Section 7 consultations every year. It is an enormous workload for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Right now, IPaC actually streamlines a whole bunch of Section 7 processes. For example, if I am a project developer, I can go into IPaC, I can enter where I want my project to occur, I can enter some of the details of the project. For a lot of the projects, IPaC in 15 minutes will tell me whether I am done with Section 7 consultations or I actually need to talk to a Service biologist. Every year, there are tens of thousands of projects that get resolved really quickly through IPaC like this. That is why I mentioned earlier it is an enormous return on investment. If we can continue building out IPaC with more information on more species and more types of projects, we can get a lot more project developers using IPaC and taking advantage of this expedited online process. I can imagine in a few years using AI, for example, to go through all the mitigation measures in IPaC, and to figure out, what is the most cost effective and biologically effective set of measures that people can cut to the chase of. All of that information, I think, is there. We need a bit more capacity to actually just do the work. Senator Schiff. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Ricketts. Senator Whitehouse? Senator Whitehouse. On the subject of resources for enforcement of the Endangered Species Act, what has happened during the Trump administration to those resources? I have heard stories of as many as 530 staff biologists either fleeing or being thrown out by what I call the DOGE boys, or being fired and driven out of the agency. What is your report on what the staffing and funding and morale of the agency looks like right now? Mr. Li. It is a fairly dismal one. I will put myself as Exhibit A of those hundreds of people. I believe I was illegally pushed out of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service at the start of this administration. The program I used to run, Ecological Service, which oversees ESA, has lost nearly 25 percent of its staff. This is hundreds and hundreds of people. You can not have staff losses like that overnight without huge morale hits to the very, very difficult work of implementing the ESA. Senator Whitehouse. A lot of empty desks to walk by on your way, that---- Mr. Li. A lot of empty desks. Senator Whitehouse [continuing]. the White House does not seem to want accomplished in the first place. Does not seem to appreciate at all. Mr. Li. Yes, exactly. Yet there is the expectation to expedite permitting, too, right? You can not have both at the same time. You can not have staff that are really sort of down- beaten and then expect them to do their most brilliant work when, again, 25 percent of their colleagues just disappeared overnight. That is a real issue. Again, I think that can be addressed with more investments in how the Service does it work. Senator Whitehouse. We were talking about wolves a moment ago. I commend anybody who is watching this, a maybe four-or 5- minute-long YouTube video, that you can find quite easily by searching ``when wolves return to the Yellowstone.'' It is quite a beautiful piece of film about what happens when a top species, predator species, returns to an environment where it had not been, and the cascade of that to the great benefit of the Yellowstone River environment. It is worth four or 5 minutes of your time to watch that, and of course, you see the same thing with sharks returning to reefs and other apex predators being allowed to rebound. Thank you all very much. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much, Senator Whitehouse. I take it that since you did not use up all your time, you need to take off, is that accurate? Okay. Great. Thank you very much for being here. Appreciate it. Well, I think Senator Lummis is coming. I am going to stall for just a little bit longer and give her a couple more minutes to show up. Really quickly, I am going to ask one last question, and then if Senator Lummis gets here, we will take her questions, then we will conclude the hearing, unless there is another Senator who shows up and wants to ask questions. We have seen situations where local stakeholders develop practical solutions to protect species, but regulatory uncertainty makes it difficult to move forward. In Nebraska, Lake McConaughey is one of the State's most popular recreational attractions. This lake serves as a habitat for the piping plover, which nests along the shoreline. The species is protected under the ESA. Water levels fluctuate with inflows, rising water can sometimes flood nests during breeding season. Local dam operators worked to protect the nests by marking them and carefully moving protective boards as reservoir levels rose, allowing the birds to continue nesting while preventing the nest from being submerged. However, there were initial concerns that these actions could violate Federal rules because approval had not been formally granted. Even though the approach was ultimately allowed, the uncertainty created confusion and concern for those trying to do the right thing. This example highlights the importance of clear guidance, better communication and greater flexibility, so that practical, on-the-ground conservation solutions can move forward without unnecessary delays or threats of enforcement. Mr. Yablonski, have you seen other examples like this in the Service? How can we better ensure collaboration among our State and Federal stakeholders? Mr. Yablonski. Yes, thank you, Chairman. Specifically with grizzly bears, where I come from, there has been some uncertainty with how policy is applied. As we know, grizzly bear populations in the Greater Yellowstone ecosystem have rebounded dramatically and do warrant delisting. We were, at the time of the ESA, something like 100 bears, and now we are over 1,000 bears there. The science is pretty settled. The agency recognizes the science is settled. At the same time, there is another species of grizzly bear up in the northwest part of the State, the Northern Continental Divide ecosystem. What has been happening is those bears have been recovering very successfully as well, over 1,000 bears there. Both of hose populations have actually met their recovery goals and should be delisted. What has now happened, and it was just a matter of about a year ago that this happened, is that those two populations have been creeping closer together and started to intermingle between the two. The Service made a decision not to delist either of those two grizzly bear populations, because what they said is those distinct population segments were no longer distinct, because they had been merging. In other words, we were being penalized for too much success because the bears were dispersing too much and then becoming its own distinct population segment. I think that uncertainty sends the wrong message to landowners and States that, well, wait a second, we were told that if this distinct population segment reached this recovery goal, we could have a delisting, and now you just changed the rules of the road. Senator Ricketts. Mr. Riley, do you have any thoughts on this? Thinking about that piping plover example. Mr. Riley. Yes, Brian makes a great point. The goal line ca not change. This is the frustrating component, when we work on these successful programs. I will use the Platte River Implementation recovery program as an example. We are coming up on another increment. We have done a lot of great work. There has been a lot of recovery. The least tern has been delisted. The plover, we are doing great work to protect. Whooping cranes are more than we have ever had. Again, in my opinion, the pallid sturgeon should not be a player in that program. I think as we come up and start to negotiate this next round, if there is one, it feels like there is a lot of pressure to add more, more water, more land, more species. When you have a collaborative effort, it is really difficult for those that are participating, the water users, the stakeholders, to know what they are getting into if the goal line is going to change. I think that is something where we need to stick by those. Once you have reached a certain limit, a certain recovery, recognize that that is it, we have done our work, and we should be at a maintenance level for those programs. Senator Ricketts. Mr. Li, I know Senator Lummis is here, but I am going to continue on for just a moment. Getting back to the example of the piping plover and putting up the boards to protect their nesting sites without having the okay from Fish and Wildlife, you were there, what can we do to, again, here we have the power company trying to do the right thing to protect the nests, within the spirit of it, but not having the official sign-off. Is there anything we can do to make sure that collaboration is such that they do not have to worry about an enforcement action afterwards to do the right thing to be able to protect them? Mr. Li. It is a great question. I will say, I can imagine the Service adopting more policies and guidance that streamline approval of these positive conservation actions. I know the Service has been trying to do this for over a decade now in various regional offices. It can only move so fast. As more and more of these examples come up, I think the Service is aware of them and can think about nationwide guidance. For example, in situations like this, to say, if someone is trying to do something good for a species, and it is a positive benefit for the recovery, let us figure out a way to streamline the approval, or almost make it automated. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you. Senator Lummis? Senator Lummis. Thank you, Chairman Ricketts, for assembling the subcommittee today. Thank you, witnesses, for being here to talk about the Endangered Species Act. Being from Wyoming, I know how helpless people can feel when Washington makes decisions to list a species as endangered or threatened, and then that species never comes off the list. In my office, we call those zombie listings, because even if recovery goals are met, they remain on the list. A perfect example is the grizzly bear. The original goals, when grizzly bears were listed back in 1975, was a target of 500 bears. Today, we have over 1,00 grizzly bears. The frustration of Wyoming ranchers, and individuals, is heightened. Every year, people are killed by grizzly bears in my State. Every year. They do not fear humans. My office gets videos of grizzlies chasing ranchers while they are working their cattle. I have a bill, it is S. 315, the Grizzly Bear State Management Act, to ensure that State expertise drives species management moving forward. I still think for grizzly bears that that is the appropriate approach. Then I want to pitch another bill that I have. It is so simple, it just changes the name of the Endangered Species Act to the Endangered Species Recovery Act. Our focus should be on recovery, not on listing, on recovery. Another issue, it has always kind of vexed me over the years, with regard to the ESA, is that certain science was viewed as paramount, and science that was generated at the State level tended to be ignored. That is where I want to take my first questions. I want to pose these to Mr. Riley and Mr. Yablonski. Welcome, gentlemen. Do you believe all the best available science should be included in ESA listings and delisting decisions? Do you think that is currently being done? Mr. Riley. I will start off. I think in general, there is an appreciation to take into consideration what science is there. I am going to give a very specific example. In my understanding of this issue in Nebraska, there is a power district near Columbus, Nebraska, that recently had to go through a biological opinion and had an order issued in the last decade or so. There was science that the applicant had put together that clearly showed, there was a concern about river temperatures in the Platte River, clearly showed that there was no statistically different temperature downstream, so that there would not be a challenge to that. Now, the Service, in the end, disregarded that data, that local science that was conducted, and decided that there should be a temperature differential. What this did was give the Fish and Wildlife Service, and this is my opinion as a former director of the State water management program, give them their own water right to decide who and what got water. Now, that was a mistake. The first time that this rule was implemented, because temperatures downstream were too high, this owner of the system was not able to divert water. Water went downstream that was supposed to make everything better. In reality, it killed many, many fish, because the temperature changed the wrong way. The study was already done by the applicant to show that that would be the case. It was disregarded in the final biological opinion and the rule that was set up. Senator Lummis. Was the final biological opinion written by employees of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service? Mr. Riley. That is my understanding, yes. Senator Lummis. Thank you. Mr. Yablonski, any thoughts on this? Mr. Yablonski. Yes. To the credit of the agency, sometimes they get the science completely right. I think in the case of the grizzly bear, the science is spot on. Prior to delisting of the grizzly bear, the Yellowstone Grizzly in particular, those have really been sort of bipartisan science based delistings. You have had administrations from both sides of the aisle moving that forward. What happens is there is a distinction between biological recovery and political recovery. Biological recovery is when the science says it should come off the list, which is the case of the grizzly bear today. Political recovery is when special interest groups deem it acceptable to come off the list. We have not gotten there yet. Oftentimes, the agency will move forward with the States with a science-based decision. Then you have a judge replacing his or her own opinions with the actual science that the agencies concur on. Senator Lummis. Great point. I wonder if it would be advisable, once the science is set on a recovery goal, that as soon as that recovery goal is hit, and then maintained for a period of a few years, that a species would automatically either drop from endangered to threatened, or drop off the list entirely, just as a ministerial function. Mr. Li, what do you think of that idea? Mr. Li. I think the rulemaking process that is currently in place is still necessary in particular to give States and the public an opportunity to comment. A lot of times, the Service gets the analysis right, and sometimes it needs additional data from States and from others. The rulemaking process is actually what allows members of the public to provide additional information that the Service may not have. I think it is really important to retain that rulemaking process. Senator Lummis. Mr. Chairman, would you indulge me? Senator Ricketts. Absolutely. Senator Lummis. Thank you. What are the highest priority changes that could be made to improve the credibility of the Act? I pose that to anyone who wishes to take it on. Yes, sir? Mr. Yablonski. Thank you, Senator. I go back to something that actually Jake and PERC and Defenders probably agree on, which is, and you had mentioned this in your comments, can we structure sort of metrics where as the States and landowners meet those metrics, flexibility and management slides more and more in their direction, so that eventually, as all the metrics are met, because recovery is the goal of the Act. It is not funding, it is not staffing, it is not ideological. It is recovery. That is what we should always look at. Administrations come and administrations go, and budgets go up and budgets go down. That recovery number has been stuck at 3 percent for an awful long time. Senator Lummis. Yes. Mr. Yablonski. We have to change the incentives here. We have to do something different. We can not be doing the same thing we have been doing for 53 years. I think taking the 4(d) rule that would manage species, and having clear goals for States to meet, and as those States meet those goals, more management shifts to them. At the end of the day, to your point, it would essentially be delisted, because you would get there, you would hit all the check marks and be there over a period of time. Senator Lummis. Thank you. Mr. Riley, any comment on this? Mr. Riley. Senator Lummis, I appreciate your comment on maybe changing the Act's name. One of the successes for the Platte River Recovery and Implementation program is that it is just that. It is not a restoration program. We are not trying to restore. We are trying to recover. We have seen great, great work in that direction through the collaboration and interest of stakeholders and the Federal Government and other folks involved, including NGO's. I think focusing on that is really important. When you get to that level and achieve it, your comments on check marks, let us make it a maintenance program. This is exactly where PRRIP is very close, the Platte River Recovery and Implementation Program. To be in a maintenance program, and for your State, which participates in it, I think some of your stakeholders would agree that we are very close, and we need to know that the goal line is not going to change on the program, that once we achieve that, we are there and we can maintain it and do the work that it takes to maintain the program and not change it. Senator Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank our witnesses for bringing your expertise to bear today. Thank you. Senator Ricketts. On that last question, Mr. Li, do you have any other comments about the credibility? Mr. Li. I would just say this, very briefly. I think about the next 10, 20 years of the Endangered Species Act, and what types of issues may come up in hearings like this. I think about how to get ahead of some of the challenges. I expect that we are going to need to really invest in how to get infrastructure development and endangered species conservation right. I think about all the energy, the transmission lines, the highway projects, the housing development that is going to happen over the next one to two decades. There will be tension with recovering endangered species. I think if we can really invest now in figuring out how to get mitigation right, how to, for example, conservation banks, where we can have actually private companies invest in the recovery of endangered species as a way to offset unavoidable impacts from energy development. I think that is one of the low-conflict ways that Congress can actually help the Service help the American public get infrastructure done faster and better. There are a number of ideas around Endangered Species Act authorization and mitigation that I think really would help lower the temperature over the next decade. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much, Mr. Li. With that, no further questions. I would like to thank the witnesses and all my colleagues for participating in today's hearing. Senators who wish to submit written questions for the record have until 5 p.m. on Wednesday, April 1st, to do so. The witnesses' responses to those questions are due back to the committee no later than 5 p.m. on Wednesday, April 15, and will be submitted for the record. With that, this hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:22 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]