AMERICA 250: INDUSTRIALIZATION AND THE RISE OF SMALL MANUFACTURERS

Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship Senate May 13, 2026

Witnesses (3)

  • Mr. Edward "Ned" Hill, Ph.D., Senior Research Associate, Ohio Manufacturing Institute, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
  • Ms. Danielle M. Petrak, Curator, Watts Museum, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia
  • Mr. Bill Zoeller, CEO, Zoeller Pump Company, Louisville, Kentucky

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- AMERICA 250: INDUSTRIALIZATION AND THE RISE OF SMALL MANUFACTURERS

[Senate Hearing 119-431]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-431

 AMERICA 250: INDUSTRIALIZATION AND THE RISE 
 OF SMALL MANUFACTURERS
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS
 AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP

 OF THE

 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 MAY 13, 2026

 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on Small Business and 
 Entrepreneurship
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 
63-970 WASHINGTON : 2026
======================================================================= 
 
 COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP
 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 ---------- 

 JONI ERNST, Iowa, Chair
 EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts, Ranking Member
JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho MARIA CANTWELL, Washington
RAND PAUL, Kentucky JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire
TIM SCOTT, South Carolina CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
TODD YOUNG, Indiana CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
TED BUDD, North Carolina JACKY ROSEN, Nevada
JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER, Colorado
JAMES C. JUSTICE, West Virginia ADAM B. SCHIFF, California
JON HUSTED, Ohio
 Meredith West, Republican Staff Director
 Sean Moore, Democratic Staff Director
 
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 MAY 13, 2026
 Opening Statements

 Page
Jon Husted, U.S. Senator from Ohio............................... 1
Edward J. Markey, U.S. Senator from Massachusetts................ 2

 Witnesses

Mr. Edward ``Ned'' Hill, Ph.D., Senior Research Associate, Ohio 
 Manufacturing Institute, The Ohio State University, Columbus, 
 Ohio........................................................... 5
 Prepared Statement........................................... 8
Ms. Danielle M. Petrak, Curator, Watts Museum, West Virginia 
 University, Morgantown, West Virginia.......................... 29
 Prepared Statement........................................... 31
Mr. Bill Zoeller, CEO, Zoeller Pump Company, Louisville, Kentucky 33
 Prepared Statement........................................... 35

 
 AMERICA 250: INDUSTRIALIZATION AND THE RISE OF SMALL MANUFACTURERS

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, MAY 13, 2026

 United States Senate,
 Committee on Small Business
 and Entrepreneurship,
 Washington, DC.
 The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:30 p.m., in 
Room 428A, Russell Senate Office Building, Hon. Jon Husted, 
presiding.
 Present: Senators Husted [presiding], Ernst, Paul, Young, 
Hawley, Justice, and Markey.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HUSTED

 Senator Husted. I would like to call the Committee on Small 
Business and Entrepreneurship to order. And I am Jon Husted, 
and I want to thank Chair Ernst for giving me a chance to chair 
the hearing today, on the Committee on Small Business and 
Entrepreneurship.
 It is a special year, 250th year of our Nation, 250th 
anniversary. And it's not possible to overstate the importance 
and critical role that small businesses, but in particular, 
American manufacturing, have played in transforming America 
into the economic envy of the world. And the underlying 
principles of free markets, competition, which are so important 
to our prosperity, that our system of government has enabled 
over that period of time it.
 Put simply, manufacturing matters. Growth in manufacturing 
and the manufacturing sector disproportionately drives new 
investment in research and development, that drives innovation 
and productivity. Two words that I use a lot: innovation and 
productivity. Despite accounting for just 12 percent of the 
total economy, 55 percent of the total American R&D spending is 
financed by manufacturers. This productivity can be seen not 
just in the manufacturing sector, where employers earn 13 
percent more than the rest of the private sector, but in the 
economy as a whole.
 Manufacturing has one of the largest multipliers of any 
industry in the United States, with every dollar invested in 
manufacturing leading to $2.69 of growth in the broader 
economy. Every dollar in manufacturing wages produces $4.33 in 
income for the overall economy. Put in simple terms, 
manufacturing drives new capital investment and innovation, 
which raises take-home pay for all Americans. It is not a 
coincidence that manufacturing has thrived in America. Our 
foundation of free markets, limited government, private 
property rights, the rule of law, and entrepreneurship have 
fueled our continued industrial dominance.
 These values have facilitated the competition and free flow 
of capital that are essential, for capital investment, 
innovation and productivity that raise American wages and the 
standard of living. Importantly, our system of free markets has 
allowed small manufacturers to thrive. As of 2025, 98 percent 
of all manufacturing firms in the United States are small 
businesses with fewer than 500 employees.
 The American system of freedom and limited government 
ensure that all small manufacturers can compete on a level 
playing field. That's what we aspire to with large incumbents, 
or compete on a level playing field with large incumbents and 
spur innovation that raises American wages.
 Throughout our history, Ohio has led the way in American 
manufacturing. I often say you can't do Made in America without 
Made in Ohio. And I firmly believe that one of our guests 
today, Dr. Edward Hill, Ned Hill, as I know him, from the Ohio 
Manufacturing Institute, who is here with us today can confirm 
that fact.
 As Dr. Hill will detail in his testimony, Ohio owes its 
strength in manufacturing to a virtuous cycle of 
entrepreneurship and innovation, with new generations of 
manufacturers adapting new production methods to boost 
productivity, with growth driven by small manufacturers 
connected through supply chains and technical expertise, which 
are so essential. That kind of system only is possible in a 
system that encourages investment and innovation and the 
results are clear in this respect.
 Ohio has the fifth largest manufacturing output in the 
Nation at $137, or $137.9 billion, even though we're the 
seventh largest in population and the third highest amount of 
manufacturing jobs overall, at 687,345, with 96 percent of this 
growth driven by small manufacturers, and the Ohio 
manufacturing worker is paid on average $76,493, which is far 
above the average wage of most workers in our State.
 As with the broader economy, the success of the 
manufacturing economy in Ohio shows how free enterprise 
promotes innovation and boosts wages and the standard of living 
for the families in our State, who make up the middle class of 
America.
 With the Working Families Tax Cut Act, that Congress 
passed, enacted pro-growth policies that will make it easier 
for the American manufacturer to expand full and immediate 
expensing of investments in machinery and equipment through the 
bonus depreciation and expanded limits for section 179 
expensing, full and immediate expensing for research and 
development, expanded deductions for interest and full 
expensing of new factories as well.
 Factories will, as Mr. Zoeller will note in his testimony, 
be rocket fuel for the economy and boost take-home pay for hard 
working Americans. And I firmly agree with that. I am grateful 
for that. We are joined by all of you on the panel today, and I 
want to again thank Chair Ernst for giving me the chance to 
chair this hearing. And with that, I'll recognize the Ranking 
Member, Senator Markey.

 STATEMENT OF SENATOR MARKEY

 Senator Markey. Okay. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. 
Thank you for this hearing. Well, Massachusetts is very proud 
because the Industrial Revolution was born in Lowell and 
Lawrence, Massachusetts, in Dover, New Hampshire, all along the 
Merrimack River, they figured out how to capture renewable 
energy. They put a dam across the river. And somehow or other, 
the word went to some village in Ireland and Thomas Markey 
said, maybe there's a job there. I think I'll take off. See 
you, mom, and dad.
 I'm heading for the Industrial Revolution, being born in 
Lawrence and Lowell and Dover, New Hampshire. And that's why 
I'm here, right now. It's just a product of that job creation, 
that opportunity. Now, they did swipe the technology actually 
from England, but that's another story. They did sign a non-
disclosure agreement, but they did violate it. But nonetheless, 
we're here.
 And Lowell is still known today as the Mill City and the 
Spindle City. And many Massachusetts cities and towns carry 
nicknames from their 19th century industrial era. Winchendon is 
the toy town, Holyoke is the paper city, Athol is Tool Town, 
Taunton is Silver City, Waltham is the watch city, Gardner is 
the chair city.
 So, each of these cities then became amongst the wealthiest 
communities in the history of the United States, as they became 
the center for this incredible economic growth. And we proudly 
wear our industrial roots. My relatives, came here, and in 
fact, in 1912, my grandfather was in Lawrence in the mills when 
20,000 textile workers walked out of the mills. It was called 
the Bread and Roses strike.
 So, my grandfather was there trying to figure out what's 
going on in terms of the rights of workers who are being 
exploited, by the way, we have to make sure that AI doesn't 
turn workers into robots in factories, too. We've got to put 
protections in place for that. And there were brutal working 
conditions, but it took the dedicated actions, like those 
workers at the time and better part of a century to secure what 
we now consider basic fundamental rights for the people who 
build things in this country.
 Workplace safety protections, child labor standards, eight-
hour work day, two day weekend. My grandfather got off one day 
a week and one week off a year. And those are hard jobs. I know 
it because I never met one of my grandparents. They had all 
died, before I got to meet them. They had hard lives working in 
these factories.
 So, the lesson for every generation is you don't beg for 
your rights. You got to fight and organize if you're going to 
take them. And Trump is taking a one two punch approach to 
tearing down America's manufacturing. He's rolling back worker 
protections, driving up costs for manufacturers.
 And even after the Supreme Court ruled President Trump's 
tariff taxes illegal, this administration doubled down 
implementing new tariff taxes that make it more expensive to 
build things in the United States, and creating a refund system 
that benefits the big corporations, not the small businesses, 
not the workers, not the families, and not the consumers.
 And despite the President's outlandish promises, we have 
lost 80,000 manufacturing jobs since January 20th of 2025. Job 
openings with manufacturers are down 10 percent. Trump's tariff 
taxes are making it harder and harder for small manufacturers 
to compete. And for too many small U.S. manufacturers, MAGA 
stands for manufacturers are going abroad, MAGA.
 The President's chaotic tariff policies, and his illegal 
war of choice with Iran have made life more expensive for 
manufacturers and consumers. President Trump has sabotaged our 
economy with rising gas prices, skyrocketing electricity rates, 
soaring costs for raw materials with nothing to show for it.
 His harmful trumponomics have turned Main Street into Pain 
Street across our country. And what is the President doing to 
help curb these costs for small businesses? He's gutting the 
Small Business Administration. The president's budget proposes 
an unbelievable 67 percent cut for the entire Small Business 
Administration, slashing resources that help small businesses 
navigate financially difficult times. He's destroying the 
Federal science programs and eliminating Federal investment in 
scientific research, forcing innovative small businesses to lay 
off workers and scramble to find new work.
 He's eliminating the National Institutes of Standards and 
Technologies Manufacturing Extension Program, which as two of 
our witnesses today point out in their testimony, is vital to 
so many small manufacturers across the country. And we'll try 
to work on a bipartisan basis to make sure that program stays 
intact for our witnesses.
 Trump's policies have not brought a new golden age. 
Instead, he's brought about an industrial era gilded age of 
robber barons, bloated ballrooms, inequality, political 
corruption.
 So, I'm glad we have an opportunity today to celebrate this 
American Revolution. I'm here because of it. Lowell and 
Lawrence and Dover, New Hampshire. And all of you, thank you 
for being here. Thank you for what you do every single day.
 Senator Husted. Thank you, Ranking Member Markey. And yes, 
we are indeed celebrating America 250 the industrialization and 
the rise of small manufacturers today. And I want to thank all 
of you for being here and being present to share your stories 
and traveling to our Nation's capital and on this historic year 
to share your insights.
 So, I'm going to introduce the three witnesses, and then 
we'll give you a chance to each offer your testimony. First, 
I'm going to introduce Mr. Edward or Ned Hill, as I know him, 
and he is a faculty emeritus at the Ohio State University, 
where he taught economic development policy, public policy, and 
public finance.
 Mr. Hill also serves as a Senior Research Associate at the 
Ohio Manufacturing Institute, where he has published academic 
research on Ohio economic history and manufacturing policy. Mr. 
Hill holds a doctoral degree in economics, urban and regional 
planning and a master's degree in city planning from 
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. I know Senator Justice, 
couldn't be here, and he was going to introduce our next 
witness. I will do that.
 We have, second, Ms. Danielle Petrak, from Morgantown, West 
Virginia, and she is the curator of the Watts Museum at West 
Virginia University. The museum is committed to sharing and 
interpreting the history of West Virginia's mineral resource 
industries. Ms. Petrak earned her PhD in history from West 
Virginia University, with her research focusing on the 
interpretation and exhibition of coal mining history in Central 
Appalachia. And one of the things you have in common is you 
both work for universities in which Gordon Gee was the 
president of, Ohio State and West Virginia.
 And now, I'll introduce Senator Paul to introduce our final 
witness.

 STATEMENT OF SENATOR PAUL

 Senator Paul. Thank you. I'm honored to introduce our 
witness from Kentucky, Mr. Bill Zoeller. Mr. Zoeller is the 
Chief Executive Officer and fourth-generation owner of Zoeller 
Pump Company, which is headquartered in Louisville, Kentucky. 
The Zoeller Pump Company was founded in 1939 by August Zoeller 
in Louisville and for over 85 years has grown into one of North 
America's leading manufacturers of submersible pumps with 
products distributed across the world.
 For the past 15 years, Mr. Zoeller leadership has 
significantly contributed to the company's success, including 
navigating the coronavirus pandemic. Today, their products are 
known to be the industry standard and are renowned for their 
reliability and durability.
 Prior to his time at the Zoeller Pump Company, Mr. Zoeller 
spent over a decade in public accounting and energy sector. He 
started his career at KPMG as a senior auditor while earning 
his credentials as a CPA. Mr. Zoeller also earned his 
bachelor's degree in accounting from Bellarmine University and 
an MBA from Indiana University Southeast.
 Mr. Zoeller, thank you for coming before the committee 
today. I look forward to hearing your testimony.
 Senator Husted. Thank you, Senator Paul. To our witnesses, 
your written testimony has made been made part of the record, 
and the committee asks that you limit your oral remarks to 5 
minutes. And with that, Mr. Hill, you are recognized for 5 
minutes.

 STATEMENT OF MR. EDWARD ``NED'' HILL, PH.D., SENIOR RESEARCH 
 ASSOCIATE, THE OHIO MANUFACTURING INSTITUTE, THE OHIO STATE 
 UNIVERSITY, COLUMBUS, OHIO

 Mr. Hill. Thank you very much, Senator Husted. Chair Ernst, 
Ranking Member Markey, members of the committee, thank you for 
the privilege of allowing me to appear before you in the 
Americas 250th year.
 Today's hearing is fitting. The Republic was barely a year 
old in 1790, when President Washington and his first annual 
address to Congress, called for establishing an industrial 
policy as a foundation of national defense. The same year, 
Samuel Slater brought the Industrial Revolution to Pawtucket, 
Rhode Island.
 Today, I draw my research for an upcoming book on Ohio's 
manufacturing economic history, and my experience working with 
manufacturers through the Ohio Manufacturers Association. I 
note for the record that Wyatt Newman, co-founder of 
RoadPrintz, a company I will discuss shortly, is a close 
friend. Additionally, my testimony does not reflect the views 
of the Ohio Manufacturers Association, the Ohio State 
University, or the Ohio Manufacturing Institute.
 I begin by introducing you to Ohio's economy. Ohio is not a 
manufacturing farm or services State. Instead, Ohio is a 
portfolio State that competes globally with goods and services 
produced across eight regional labour markets in numerous rural 
communities. Within that portfolio, manufacturing leads in 
exports to the rest of the Nation in the world. Manufacturing 
accounts for 16.5 percent of the State's GDP, more than any 
other private industry. As of 2024, Ohio ranked fifth in 
manufacturing GDP and a near dead heat with Illinois and 
Indiana. Ohio manufacturing workers earned an average annual 
wage of approximately $76,500 in 2023, supporting families in 
their communities.
 More recent data shows that Ohio has 677,500 manufacturing 
jobs in 2025. While Honda, GE aerospace, whirlpool, Lincoln 
Electric, Goodyear, among many others, are the economy's 
anchors, anchors need chains to hold their boats fast. Ohio 
supply chains are disproportionately composed of smaller 
manufacturers. The fabricated metal shops, precision machining 
firms, plastics and rubber plastics, specialty suppliers that 
fill Ohio supply chains make those businesses viable.
 When a large Ohio plant thrives, dozens of smaller 
suppliers thrive with it. When one closes, the supply chain 
feels it first. One statistic is particularly relevant to the 
committee's purpose. 88 percent of Ohio's 13,000 manufacturing 
establishments employ fewer than 100 workers. These 
establishments populate main streets and business parks and 
sustain rural communities.
 Ohio's industrial story, however, begins with President 
Washington's first address to Congress in January 1790, which 
contains a sentence that most Americans don't know. American 
President Washington refers to, a free people, riding their 
safety and interest require they should promote such 
manufactories as tend to render them independent of others for 
essential, particularly military supplies.
 President Washington's first policy proposal to Congress 
was to build American industry. It was the Nation's first 
industrial policy. Coincidentally, as I mentioned earlier, 1790 
was also the year that Samuel Slater built his mill in 
Pawtucket, launching the Industrial Revolution in the United 
States. The President's proposal led to the establishment of 
Federal armories in Springfield, Massachusetts, in 1794 and in 
Harpers Ferry, Virginia, in 1798.
 Washington's logic was vindicated in 1814, when British 
forces burned the Capitol in the White House. The torching of 
our capital city also ignited a 40-year commitment to 
manufacturing rifles with interchangeable parts, shifting 
defense policy into industrial policy. By 1851, British 
observers named it the American System of manufacturers, and 
one historian interpret that as meaning the American system of 
interchangeable parts.
 That system crossed the Appalachian Mountains in the heads 
and hands of mechanics, becoming visible in Whiteley's Reapers 
in Ohio's Springfield and Thomas White sewing machines in 
Cleveland. Ohio's early machine tool makers gave the State's 
factories the capacity to cut, shape and stamp steel at scale. 
When Henry Ford introduced the moving assembly line in 1913, 
Ohio's manufacturers were positioned to supply it.
 Today, Ohio's entrepreneurs are building companies to join 
the next manufacturing wave. I'll give you two examples. There 
are others in my written testimony that I've submitted. One 
founded in 2017, the other a turnaround that was founded 99 
years earlier. RoadPrintz, headquartered in Cleveland, built an 
operator driven truck mounted robotic road making system. It 
was founded in 2017 by Wyatt Newman, a Case Western Reserve 
University robotics professor, and Sam Bell, a master mechanic 
who closed his auto repair shop, the infamously named the Lusty 
Wrench, to join the business.
 RoadPrintz started with a motor man robot from Dayton, a 
fabrication support from Q.T Equipment, a family-owned truck 
upfitter in Akron, and its paint comes from Aexcel in Mentor. 
Today, RoadPrintz has five full-time employees, five patents, 
paying customers from Missouri's Department of Transportation 
to the City of Houston, and its founding and early growth were 
supported by NSF's Small Business Innovation Research Grants. 
The founders thought they were selling road striping efficiency 
and precision. They were wrong.
 A blue-collar Cleveland Public Works employee told them his 
wife liked it when he was inside the cab painting, instead of 
walking next to traffic, because she knew he'd be coming home 
that night. RoadPrintz built a worker safety device. The 
founders learned the value of their invention from someone who 
used it.
 Mike Garvey, CEO of Youngstown's M-7 technologies, 
describes his factory as a place where the Flintstones meet the 
Jetsons. Garvey's grandfather started a bronze factory in 1918, 
serving Youngstown steel mills. But after the mills collapsed, 
and the fire destroyed the facility, Garvey rebuilt around 
measurement, science, and digital manufacturing.
 Today, he operates one of the world's largest 3D printers 
and produces parts with micron level tolerances for aerospace 
and defense. M-7 grew from three employees in 1985 to 50. These 
companies represent what the next wave of manufacturing looks 
like; digitally connected production systems that solve 
problems, that matter to American industry and American 
workers.
 RoadPrintz's product is a digital production system, while 
M-7 uses one. Both are Ohio born, a century apart. These 
companies exist in part because of federal investments in the 
NSF, patient capital from public grants, and technical 
assistance from the Manufacturing Extension Partnership that 
made them all possible.
 As President Washington's armories demonstrated, technology 
without appropriate management is expensive and ineffective. 
The Springfield Armory seated America's first industrial 
cluster, and it housed America's first version of the 
manufacturing extension partnership. Springfield, Ohio, reaped 
the reward. The Federal Government shaped Ohio's industrial 
revolution, and entrepreneurs and engineers created the 
products that built a competitive economy. Now, their 
descendants are forging their futures.
 Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Hill follows.]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Husted. Thank you, Mr. Hill. Ms. Petrak. You are 
recognized for 5 minutes. Just hit your button there.

 STATEMENT OF MS. DANIELLE M. PETRAK, CURATOR, WATTS MUSEUM, 
 WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY, MORGANTOWN, WEST VIRGINIA

 Ms. Petrak. Thank you, Chair Ernst, Ranking member Markey, 
Senator Husted, and distinguished members of the committee. I 
am Danielle Petrak, curator of the Watts Museum and Industrial 
History Museum in the Statler College of Engineering and 
Mineral Resources at West Virginia University.
 Our museum is named after Royce Watts, who retired from WVU 
in 2017, after more than 60 years at the university. Like many 
West Virginians, Royce was born into a mining family. He did 
not pursue a career in mining, but as a child, Royce made money 
chopping logs and selling them to miners for a few cents each, 
to use as roof supports in the mines.
 Sadly, in 1942, when Royce was 13, his father, a coal 
miner, was killed in a mine roof fall in southern West 
Virginia. At this time, the early 1940s, the West Virginia 
mining industry was booming, as coal production revved up to 
meet the Nation's needs during World War II. The 
industrialization of West Virginia is nearly always associated 
with coal, in particular, the start of large-scale commercial 
coal mining in the late 19th century.
 But as we commemorate America 250, it is important to note 
that West Virginia had a strong, diverse industrial economy 
well before the birth of its commercial coal industry. In 
popular culture, the media and other narratives, West Virginia, 
both past and present, is often portrayed as a remote place, a 
place of isolation. The vitality of its antebellum industries 
however, shows that the State, although rugged and rural, was 
in fact well connected to much of the United States via trade 
networks and regional economies, long before King Coal boomed 
onto the scene.
 Nicknamed the Mountain State, West Virginia is known for 
the abundant natural resources in its hills and valleys, coal, 
as well as natural gas, salt, silica, sand, clay, limestone, 
oil, timber and more. Before the arrival of railroads, West 
Virginia was also home to important transportation networks. 
The National Road, for example, completed a main travel route 
to the west in 1818 by linking the Potomac River in Cumberland, 
Maryland to the Ohio River in Wheeling.
 In 1840, as covered wagons journeyed along the National 
Road, a 22-year-old Mifflin M. Marsh carried baskets full of 
hand-rolled tobacco filled Conestoga's, or stogies, that he 
sold to wagon drivers as they approached the banks of the Ohio 
River. Later, owning a company that made up to three million 
cigars per week, Marsh launched a cigar industry in Wheeling 
that grew to nearly 100 manufacturers in the city by the late 
19th century.
 Wheeling's location and access to fuel sources also helped 
to sustain multiple nails making factories in the mid-1800s, an 
industrial legacy that inspired the name of the city's minor 
league hockey team, the Nailers.
 Thanks to extensive high quality clay deposits in West 
Virginia, commercial pottery manufacturers popped up throughout 
the State in the late 1700s. Thompsons pottery in Morgantown, 
spearheaded the area's transition from earthenware to more 
durable, non-porous stoneware in the 1850s. Their techniques 
and designs trickled over the State line, influencing the work 
of Pennsylvania potters.
 In 1901, Smithsonian curator Walter Hough, a West Virginia 
native, recognized the significance of Thompson's work, and 
collected most of the surviving examples of their pottery and 
tools, which are now in the National Museum of American 
History. Abundant deposits of other natural resources, namely 
silica, sand and natural gas, fueled the State's glass 
industry, with its first glass manufacturer opening in 1813, 
followed by roughly 400 more over the next 150 years. Based in 
Moundsville, Fostoria Glass made the longest produced glass 
pattern in U.S. history, the ``American'' line, for 71 years.
 Marsh Wheeling Cigars, LaBelle Cut Nails, Fostoria Glass; 
these businesses were not small per se, but they also were not 
comparable in scale to the energy corporations often associated 
with industry in West Virginia. Importantly, these companies 
were founded by West Virginia natives and residents. They 
employed skilled union workers, and they created products using 
their State's natural resources, to inject wealth and add value 
into the local economy.
 As we think about ``Reindustrializing'' America and 
Appalachia from a small business perspective, we should look 
back to West Virginia's early industrial history, taking 
inspiration from this past era and investing in today's smaller 
scale, diverse and local industries, and businesses.
 Senator Justice, as Governor, you made manufacturing a 
cornerstone of West Virginia's economic growth, and your work 
in the Senate continues that focus, through your advocacy for 
domestic manufacturing, workforce pipeline development, and 
Federal investments that help West Virginia employers hire, 
train, and grow.
 Both WVU and Marshall University play an important role in 
this effort, supporting small and medium sized manufacturers 
through the West Virginia Manufacturing Extension Partnership 
at WVU, and Marshall's Advanced Manufacturing Center, 
strengthening competitiveness across the State.
 Thank you. I greatly appreciate this opportunity to share 
with you some history of West Virginia, a place whose people 
and natural resources I care about very deeply.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. Petrak follows.]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Husted. Thank you very much, Ms. Petrak. And now, I 
would like to recognize Mr. Zoeller for 5 minutes. And thank 
you for being here.

 STATEMENT OF MR. BILL ZOELLER, CPA, CEO AND GREAT-GRANDSON OF 
 FOUNDER, ZOELLER PUMP COMPANY, LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY

 Mr. Zoeller. Thank you, Chair Ernst, Ranking Member Markey, 
Senator Paul, for your kind opening remarks. My name is Bill 
Zoeller, and I'm the CEO of Zoeller Company and the proud great 
grandson of August Zoeller, who founded our family business in 
1939 in Louisville, Kentucky. And it is an honor to testify at 
today's hearing celebrating America's 250th birthday.
 Zoeller is a family of manufactured water solutions. Our 
family of water solutions, brings clean water to a facility, 
moves that water around a facility, collects the dirty water, 
and removes it from the facility. We manufacture pumps, 
containers, and controls to provide the solution.
 These products support the infrastructure of our great 
country. We manufacture quality products that are serviced by 
the best manufacturing reps in the business, many of which are 
multi-generational family businesses as well. These products 
are sold through our fantastic wholesale partners and then 
installed by hard working plumbers. This activity happens every 
day, and we are honored to be part of the plumbing industry.
 Our story is one of humble beginnings that grew by faith 
and grit. We were founded in my great grandparents' basement 
and sold six pumps the first year. However, we have grown 
significantly since our founding, acquiring other companies to 
expand our product offerings. This includes Flint and Walling, 
which was founded in 1866 and is based in Kendallville, 
Indiana. We also operate Zoeller Custom Molding in Boonville, 
Indiana, Wolf Pump in Abernathy, Texas, and Sencillo Systems in 
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
 Flint & Walling was founded over 160 years ago and has a 
unique history of its own. Producing windmills that powered 
groundwater pumps, these pumps provided irrigation and crops 
for water and livestock. These products help support America's 
westward expansion in the late 1800s. During World War II, 
Flint & Walling was called upon once again and pivoted from 
making pumps to producing shells and aircraft components for 
the U.S. Navy.
 Regardless of location, our core values of quality, 
service, innovation, and integrity have served us well over the 
past 87 years. Our team members understand these values and 
demonstrate them every day. I'm so proud of the work that they 
do and the quality products that they manufacture. The Zoeller 
brand is well known in the industry, and in fact, our core 
product, the 530001, was awarded two trademarks; one on its 
unique shape and one on its color. These trademarks prevented 
offshore knockoffs from tarnishing our brand.
 As Zoeller, we are proud to have ``Made in the USA'' label 
on our Zoeller Pump Main Line products. In 2012, our motor 
supplier moved production to Mexico and we lost our ``Made in 
the USA'' mark. So, we invested in our people, decided to 
manufacture those motors internally. This created 35 jobs in 
Indiana and we could put ``Made in the USA'' back on several 
products.
 But the Zoeller story is just one part of Manufacturing's 
legacy in America. America's story is a manufacturing story, 
from 1776 to today. Congress and the Trump administration are 
doing their part to drop policies, which in turn reduce the 
cost of doing business in the United States. For example, this 
Congress preserved the 21 percent corporate tax rate, and 
provided immediate expensing of R&D activities. These actions 
prevented tax increases and paved the way for our continued 
expansion.
 Beyond the tax bill, Zoeller has also benefited from the 
Trump's administration reforms to reduce the cost of Federal 
regulations and ensure that rules are practical and workable. 
As a leader, I fully believe that you will never get anything 
100 percent right, but you get close, and you keep fine tuning.
 So here comes some opportunity for fine tuning to ensure 
that the next 250 years are even stronger for manufacturing in 
America. First, Congress and the administration should keep up 
the work to right size the burden of Federal regulations. 
Manufacturers spend $350 billion every year on regulatory 
compliance.
 Second, Congress should double down on the infrastructure 
bill, which is set to expire later this year. Manufacturers 
need robust highways, bridges, ports, waterways to make and 
move products across the country. Third, manufacturers need 
permitting reform that cuts red tape and clears out roadblocks. 
Fourth, we need strategic trade policies to ensure 
manufacturers have easy and reliable access to the inputs and 
machinery we need to make things in America. And finally, we 
need policies that support our industry efforts to upskill and 
train the manufacturing workforce. Currently, we have more than 
400,000 jobs open across the sector.
 The 2025 Tax Bill is the foundation, and if backed by the 
right policies, manufacturers like Zoeller will be ready and 
proud to drive the next 250 years of American manufacturing. 
Thank you for your time.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Zoeller follows.]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Husted. Thank you very much, Mr. Zoeller, and thank 
you all for being here today to celebrate America 250, and the 
industrialization and the rise of manufacturers in our country. 
And I know we want to want to keep it that way for the future. 
But let me start with some member questions, and let me turn to 
our chair of the committee, Senator Ernst. I'll give you the 
chance to lead us off.
 Chair. I appreciate that, and thank you, Senator Husted for 
chairing today's activities. This is great to be able to 
celebrate our Nation's 250th in regards to our small 
businesses, which really are the backbone of the United States.
 So, Mr. Hill, your testimony discussed the new businesses 
that are leading the re-industrialization of Ohio and America. 
Alongside Senator Coons, I am leading the Made in America 
Manufacturing Finance Act, and this will raise the SBA loan 
limit for manufacturers from $5 million up to $10 million. And 
how will greater capital access for small manufacturers support 
investment in America's industrial capacity?
 Mr. Hill. Senators, thank you very much for the question, 
and I appreciate the attention that the staff has given to 
bring this testimony along. The reality of manufacturing over 
the past 5 years and going forward is that capital intensity is 
increasing.
 So, we've looked at the ratios of the number of jobs per 
dollar invested in manufacturing, and it's been going up. So, 
one of the real challenges that manufacturers and small 
manufacturers has is the capital constraints. So, raising the 
lending limits, especially the way in which you do it so that 
the banks make certain it's a good credit, is fiscally 
responsible and I think economically necessary.
 The largest challenge that I've seen with small 
manufacturers is actually--along with the cost of the 
equipment, is the ability to integrate it in their production 
processes. And that's where another barrier exists because most 
of the system integrators now because of industry 4.0, AI, and 
cyber have hurdle rates, minimum contract amounts that many of 
our small manufacturers cannot afford to pay.
 And that's one of the reasons why with our historical 
research, we've seen that operations technologies, the stuff 
that used to make stuff, has a long lag if the management 
systems can't keep up. So, one of the large challenges that our 
small firms have, is to not only be able to afford the capital, 
but afford the advising around how to deploy that capital so 
that their costs go down rather than up.
 So, I applaud you for your thoughtfulness, your strategy 
and I think that making it possible for small firms to invest 
in their future is essential for the economy.
 Chair. Well, thank you.
 Mr. Hill. Not that I have an opinion at all.
 Chair. I think many do share thoughts on that as well. And 
we really appreciate the input. So, thank you for being here. 
Mr. Zoeller, the Working Families Tax Cuts Act that was passed 
by Congress last year is encouraging a lot of our small 
businesses to invest in their operations and allowing American 
workers to keep more of their hard-earned dollars in their own 
pockets. That's really important.
 So how have you, in particular, been able to take advantage 
of this act that was passed last year? And what impact have you 
seen for your employees?
 Mr. Zoeller. Thank you for the question. First and 
foremost, the no tax on overtime is great for our employees. We 
run a union shop, we have mandatory overtime, we have spikes in 
demand. And for them to be able to take more take-home pay is 
great. We love to take care of our employees. And that's been a 
big help. We're currently expanding. We're trying to bring on 
additional equipment to increase our U.S. manufacturing or 
production.
 So, obviously, the bonus depreciation is beneficial today 
and into the future, and you know those things are critical to 
make sure we have the capital to keep deploying those things. 
We're a conservative family business. We don't take out debt. 
So, we need to kind of manage our cash flow appropriately. And 
by having a little more tax savings in the pocket to invest, 
that's a good thing for us.
 Chair. Thank you so much. And to our small business owners, 
thank you so much. And Ms. Petrak, thank you for telling the 
history behind so many of West Virginia's small businesses. We 
are so glad to celebrate our 250th year here in the United 
States of America. And you're all part of this incredible 
journey. So, thank you very much for participating today. Thank 
you very much, Senator Husted.
 Senator Husted. Thank you, Chair Ernst. I'll start with a 
question for you, Mr. Hill. I know that I love economics 
because it's like a puzzle, you're trying to figure it out all 
the time. Like what is the best way, what are the right 
incentives?
 And I was interested in your George Washington reference 
because, there wasn't a central planner for the American 
economy over those 250 years. But there were some goals. There 
were some things that we wanted people to achieve, but we had 
created an environment where there was essentially a freedom to 
achieve that. And the structure of the rule of law, protect 
people, encourage investment, those things are protected in our 
Nation, but you also have the freedom to expand. And that has 
been sort of the underpinning of the driving of our success.
 But we've also, being an Ohioan too, have seen ups and 
downs. We've seen creative destruction. We've seen government 
get it wrong. We've seen the manufacturing economy. It's ironic 
that we're here at a moment when President Trump is in China, 
because we saw a lot of our manufacturing head to China over 
the years, but now we're trying to get it back. We're trying to 
do ``Made in America.'' We're trying to reindustrialize, and 
we've had some success with that.
 So, as we look forward, what policies--we think about this, 
we really want manufacturing economy to take root in America 
and make the things that are essential for our economic and 
national security. What policies should we put in place going 
forward, as you see it, to ensure that that happens?
 Mr. Hill. Senator Husted, thank you for the very easy 
question. Going back to President Washington and the three 
armories, it's a wonderful example. You're right. There is, no 
central planning works. But the American Industrial Revolution 
started with those three armories.
 Senator Markey and I can have a wonderful conversation 
about what side of Massachusetts had the largest impact. But 
Springfield, Massachusetts, helped create Springfield, Ohio. 
So, what was it that took place? There was sustained investment 
in basic defense technology, to make interchangeable parts for 
rifles, and that took 40 years.
 It was a bureaucrat in the Department of Ordnance that 
continued issuing those contracts despite the technological 
hurdles, the machines, and the accounting systems, which by the 
way, came out of West Point. That made America's factories in 
the 1850s and beyond the most productive in the world, were a 
product of investing Federal money into creating public goods 
that were transferable into industries, and created the 
management systems along with operations technologies.
 So, the secret sauce in this is to invest in public goods, 
so that businesses could take them to make services that 
respond to customers. So, my fear is that if we hollow out the 
ability to create that shared public knowledge, as it has 
happened in Springfield, Massachusetts, that stretched down the 
Connecticut Valley into Hartford and north up into Vermont, 
went over to the Naugatuck Valley in Connecticut, where it 
powered the watch industry, the bicycle industry.
 Well, that was the same production system that was invented 
in Springfield, crossed the Appalachians, and created Ohio's 
economy.
 Senator Husted. So, let's fast forward into history, and we 
know how that planning worked with the arsenal of democracy, 
where American industry responded during World War II.
 Mr. Hill. Correct.
 Senator Husted. But then we also had this experience 
starting, I would call it, in the 1960s and the 1970s, 
certainly in the 1980s into the 1990s, where in places like 
Ohio, we saw the manufacturing economy collapse. And so, what 
are the factors that when you learn from that history that can 
teach us about how we preserve that going forward?
 Mr. Hill. Well, Senator Husted, I'm delighted to have, Dr. 
Fran Stewart with me. She's one of the co-authors on the book, 
and we're wrestling with that as we look at Ohio's economic 
history. And, in that book, what we found out, is that we were 
subject to something called the product cycle.
 The product cycle is when a new product is born, a new 
technology enlivens a product. You go through a period of very 
rapid growth. Then once when the markets get saturated, the 
number of competitors shrink, growth rates tail off, and then 
once one demand disappears or slackens or gets closer, then the 
growth rates drop.
 What happened to Ohio from 1968 through the 1970s, is that 
all of our core industries had the exact same product cycle 
age, and they all went into decline together. What do we learn 
about this?
 Well, what we learned is public policy; that when you were 
speaker of the House, you were endorsing and you still endorse. 
And that is we had to take a State that grew complacent out of 
the power and the incomes and stabilities of the jobs that came 
out of 1913 on, and what happened was entrepreneurship in our 
State died. We spent from the 1990s and 2000 in the traditional 
manufacturing towns of Ohio to recreate the spirit of large-
scale entrepreneurship.
 So, one of the things that we have to do is always be 
humble. When your products are at the top of the world, 
understand that they're going to age. Make certain that you 
always have those entrepreneurs trying to figure out the new 
ways of doing things. So that's the reason why in my testimony, 
I highlight four firms. I said one of them would turn around, 
three of them startups, that are really leading the way for 
inventing new products, out of public intellectual property 
that is creating new products.
 Senator Husted. Okay. Well, I'm going to come back to you 
later. I'm going to let my colleagues ask their questions now, 
but we'll put a pin in entrepreneurship and we'll come back and 
talk to you in a second. Senator Paul.
 Senator Paul. Mr. Zoeller, thank you for coming. It's great 
to have someone from Louisville up here. We need more people 
from Kentucky up here so I can feel at home when I'm away from 
home. I enjoyed reading through your testimony, and it sounded 
like virtually every facet of the Tax bill had some advantage 
for your business, which is great because that's what it's 
supposed to do, help American businesses keep more of their 
income and thrive. You know, from the Death Tax to the 
Corporate Tax to the expensing to the pass through, everything 
seemed to be something that was just set up perfectly for you 
guys.
 I was intrigued by your testimony, though. When we get to 
the idea of trying to bring things home because everybody's 
like, well, let's build an America and you're proud, you make 
things in America, and so am I. That's great. But people have 
to realize to make things in America, we are not an island. And 
that often we need stuff that comes from other countries.
 And what you're saying about sometimes needing equipment 
from Germany and Japan is what I hear from so many other 
people. Like, yes, we want to make things in America. But if 
you tariff the things that were, you know, the machinery that 
we need, we're going to have a problem. So there really does 
need to be somebody looking at these tariffs and saying, hey, 
should we really be tariffing equipment that helps us build 
things here?
 Can you tell us a little bit about the equipment you're 
needing and how it will help you bring manufacturing here, but 
that you actually have to buy the equipment somewhere else?
 Mr. Zoeller. Yes. I appreciate the question, Senator. As I 
kind of also talked to my testimony, we are ``Made in the 
USA.'' So, we definitely appreciate the tariffs from a 
standpoint of keeping the knockoffs out, specifically to the 
equipment that we need. Yes, most of that equipment is 
specialized outside of the U.S.
 Our current situation to try to increase capacity, we have 
three tarmac machines on order from Germany, ones landed that 
first one. We did have to pay a tariff on that. We have two 
more that are coming this summer, from Germany as well. 
Hopefully, those will be online in October, so we can increase 
our capacity. But both of those are currently scheduled to be 
hit with the tariffs as well.
 So, in order to increase capacity in the U.S., I believe 
that we're going to need equipment to do that, and some of that 
equipment is just not made here. It's just the fact.
 Senator Paul. Is any of the knockoff equipment that you're 
concerned with illegal because of their infringing either on 
trademark or patent?
 Mr. Zoeller. Yes, these are specific to our finished goods. 
And as I've talked about, we have professional plumbers at one 
point that would put the knockoff Zoeller pumps inside our 
boxes and return them to us because, professional plumbers 
couldn't tell the difference between what we made and what the 
offshores product was until we could open them up and notice 
that those weren't our motors and components.
 Senator Paul. So, who's the law enforcement, there? Who do 
you complain to and who enforces this? Is it a either trademark 
or patent.
 Mr. Zoeller. We'll start with the Trade Compliance, you 
know, can help us with some of that type of stuff.
 Senator Paul. Is that part of the FTC?
 Mr. Zoeller. FTC is who we dealt with in the early 2020s, 
late 2019.
 Senator Paul. And have they been helpful?
 Mr. Zoeller. They're very helpful, on those two pieces. 
Yes.
 Senator Paul. Because, that's something that I would just 
offer that if you have problems, we're more than happy to 
engage and try to say, hey, let's enforce the law on this 
stuff, because that is absolutely against the law to steal 
someone's intellectual property and then try to sell it as your 
own. But, thank you for coming, thank you for what you're 
doing. And let us know if we can help in any way.
 Mr. Zoeller. Thank you, Senator.
 Senator Husted. If I can ask a follow up on Senator Paul's 
question. What country do you see the most of the knockoffs 
coming from?
 Mr. Zoeller. They were coming from China.
 Senator Husted. China. Okay. Thank you, Senator Justice.
 Senator Justice. Okay. Thank you so much. And, first of 
all, Danielle, I'm sorry I wasn't here to introduce you. It had 
been a big-time pleasure for me to introduce. But I've known 
you forever, and I know the good stuff you do. And I thank you 
guys for being great witnesses and being here for one purpose. 
And that is you want things to be better. You want things to be 
remembered, and all that is so absolutely genuine to me.
 If I could just say a couple things about Danielle Petrak, 
you know, she naturally is a curator of the Watts Museum at 
West Virginia University, and West Virginia University does all 
kinds of wonderful, wonderful stuff.
 But the thing that's really unique about her is how much 
she cares. She cares about West Virginia's industries and all 
that and the acknowledgement that we'll remember. But she 
absolutely, deeply cares about what the fabric of West Virginia 
is all about. And that's about families. It's about craftsmen. 
It's about faith-based people. It's about the real thing that 
this country has been made of.
 And West Virginia stepped up and stepped up forevermore and 
did so much stuff, it's unbelievable and we should be very, 
very, very proud. I know Danielle is and I know right now, when 
we're honestly right on the cusp of celebrating our 250 years 
in this country, it is amazing what West Virginia did and what 
West Virginia contributed. But now I want to switch channels 
with you, and I want you to just stay with me, just one second.
 Today, China is an unbelievable competitor or an 
unbelievable country that is doing so much stuff that in a lot 
of situations we don't like, and we would like it to be so much 
better. We want to build more stuff in America, I get that, but 
it's harder than just saying we want to build more stuff.
 It's just like our chairman up here just said a few minutes 
ago, it's harder than just saying that's what we want to do, 
and then it just happens. Let me tell you just this, though. 
Here's how silly we are in so many different ways. In the State 
of West Virginia and many States, whether it be Pennsylvania or 
Vermont or wherever it may be, Kentucky, whatever. You know, we 
abound in hardwoods that are second to none. It's phenomenal 
beyond belief. You know, West Virginia always when we think 
about natural resources, we think about coal and oil and gas, 
but we have water and we have unbelievable timber.
 Now, just think about what we do when we cut a log. Here's 
what we do. We dry keel it, and then we put it in a truck 
instead of making something right there in America, we put it 
in a truck and we drive it to Newport News and missions going 
everywhere.
 Then we put it on a boat, same thing. And it goes to 
Vietnam or China or Mexico goes somewhere, and then something 
is made out of it there. And then we put it back on the boat, 
back on the truck, and bring it back to the U.S. to put it to 
market. It is the silliest thing in the history of the world.
 In some way, somehow, we have migrated completely out of 
our flooring and cabinetry and all the different things that is 
so available to us in these great States. And it's just gone 
away. And Ohio is another great State for just that. Now, why 
can't we do something about it? At the end of the day, that's 
where I really salute all of y'all, and all this great 
committee, because the fabric of all of us is the small 
businesses that have made it work. That's a fact. And Danielle, 
I could never say enough about you because really and truly, 
you bring to life just our history and all the goodness that 
we've done.
 Now listen, everybody, I just speak plain words when I just 
tell you just this; We got challenges. Sure. We just can't flip 
our fingers and then all of a sudden, boom, boom, boom, we're 
going to have all kinds of stuff more Made in the U.S., but we 
can do it. We can solve the riddle. If we'll just work at it a 
little bit, we can solve the riddle.
 There could be all kinds of different ways to solve just 
the riddle that I just said to you, and we got to do it. And 
now's our chance, right this minute. We got to do it now. We 
got to not just talk about it. This place is unbelievable. This 
place drives me completely crazy about the frustration of just 
talking about stuff. It's almost like we don't want to really 
get something done. We just want to keep it going.
 If we can keep it going, we can have 18 more fundraisers, 
we can do whatever it may be, and it just keeps going round and 
round and round and round and round, and we forget something 
that is so important, that Danielle will never forget. And I'm 
sure y'all won't. And I'm sure this great man right up here, 
Jon, is a good, good man.
 But I can tell you the thing we forget at the end of every 
single thing we do, there's a name and there's a family. That's 
what we're supposed to be doing. I didn't come here with white 
hair to just sit around. I didn't come here with white hair to 
keep it going. Let's solve the riddle, everybody. Okay? Thank 
you all so much, Danielle. Sorry I wasn't here; I'm going 15 
different directions all at the same time. Sorry.
 Senator Husted. Thank you, Senator Justice. So, I know 
Senator Hawley will be back, and he wants to ask a question, so 
I'm going to take the chance here to come back to you, Mr. 
Hill, because we put a pin in entrepreneurism, is that we had 
stagnation that occurred, product maturity. And then we were 
competing on price. And then we couldn't do that anymore 
because lower wage nations, things that Senator Justice was 
talking about couldn't compete. And so, our mature industries 
sort of died.
 And then that means we have innovation and entrepreneurship 
and creative destruction and the next cycle of businesses to 
come around which we want to create that environment, which in 
my world, you know, the more capital will flow where it's most 
appreciated and it will succeed.
 And so now, I think the dilemma that that Senator Justice 
was kind of talking about and what we're all saying is that, we 
want to do Made in America for our economic and national 
security, because we've realized that, hey, we have 700 drugs 
right now that we couldn't make in this country because the 
pharmaceutical supply chain is in China, or rare earth 
materials that we couldn't make a bomb or a battery if we 
didn't have access to, if we were cut off from these things.
 The chip supply chain, all of these things we're learning 
that our economy, our national security is vulnerable because 
the manufacturing supply chain for the things that are 
essential have left our country, that we need to nearshore, 
friendshore, onshore them if we want to have that security 
back.
 However, we're also fighting this other issue of 
affordability, where we like the less expensive product. Why, 
Mr. Zoeller, do they buy a pump from China rather than yours? 
Because they probably make it cheaper. Right.
 Mr. Zoeller. Correct.
 Senator Husted. And so how, as we approach these dual goals 
of making more things in America and wanting to keep prices 
under control, what are the solutions? And I'm going to give 
you all a chance to address this, but I will offer something 
and you can build on this, Mr. Hill. It's productivity gains. 
It's the innovation. It's the technology that we can do things 
just better and more effective in a higher quality than they 
can in these other countries. If we have those productivity and 
innovation gains.
 And I'm interested in what you think about that as being 
the thread that can weave these two goals of onshoring and 
affordability together. And please share your thoughts.
 Mr. Hill. Well, thank you for another easy question. 
Senator Husted, you're on a roll. Productivity is the sword 
that cuts the Gordian knot. But we have to understand where 
productivity comes from. So, when most people think about 
productivity, we'll invoke the words of Senator Voinovich, who 
would always if you so much as look at him cross-eyed, he'd 
just say, ``Better, faster, cheaper, smarter.'' Well, as we 
look at how productivity is defined, it's less what happens on 
the shop floor and much what happens with the company itself.
 Productivity is value added for just a rough measure, for 
every hour worked. Where are the largest parts of value added? 
It comes from the top line of the income statement. Meanwhile, 
when we talk about productivity, we start figuring out how to 
squeeze those middle lines. So, the way to get a company more 
productive more quickly is to invent new products or services 
that generates higher operating revenue. So that's part step 
one.
 Step two, is looking at those middle lines and that's where 
the faster, smarter, cheaper Voinovich solution exists. And now 
we have an opportunity with the spread of digitally integrated 
operations technologies on shop floors, being tied into the 
rest of management, to realize that that's where the second 
step of productivity improvement is going to come from.
 For the smaller employers, those employing from 100 to 10 
or lower, they cannot afford the management help to get them to 
do it, because the hurdle rates are too high. That's the reason 
why the Manufacturing Extension Partnership is so important to 
me as being part of the solution. Because what we have to do is 
just what George Washington's armories did, was to make those 
management solutions public goods, not that you pay for the 
consultants, but you make certain that people know how to 
manage these new technologies. We have data from 2016 showing 
that industry 4.0, two thirds of all companies that invested in 
industry 4.0 in 2016 lost money. Why? Because the management 
systems weren't there. They didn't know how to work it. It was 
an engineering toy that we were trying to figure out.
 So, what we do consistently wrong is we believe that there 
is going to be a machine-based operations technology silver 
bullet that's going to increase productivity. That's only in 
one chamber. The other is how do you manage it? How do we get 
rid of non-compete clauses so that that knowledge can flow 
freely throughout the rest of the economy. How can we make 
certain that our smaller employers are engaged in sharing 
knowledge across with each other to figure out how this stuff 
works? The barrier to acquiring technology and using it 
effectively is real.
 Senator Husted. Okay. Thank you. Ms. Petrak, do you want to 
share some thoughts on that particular topic? If you don't, 
that's fine. I just want to give you the opportunity.
 Ms. Petrak. No, I would just prefer to share the history 
with you all, and I'm grateful that you've let me do that.
 Senator Husted. I appreciate that. Mr. Zoeller.
 Mr. Zoeller. Yes. Thank you for the question. I can't talk 
in the broad sense of the industry, but I can specifically talk 
about our company. As a family-owned business we operate and 
plan in decades. We don't plan in quarters.
 This recent investment that I talked about earlier was a 
big investment for us. And our management team talked, and a 
lot of the reasons why we did the investment was because we 
were going to have productivity gains. We're going to increase 
capacity. The productivity gains can be making, our pumps 
faster, but also be reducing the scrap out on the shop floor.
 So, all that stuff comes into play. Our sales team right 
now, they know this capacity is coming and they need to get out 
and sell it, because we got to be able to make more inside our 
footprint, to be able to reduce the overall cost, and that also 
will increase our sales. But it's a cycle.
 And like I said, you've got to have the productivity one, 
and then that capacity, you got to be able to sell it. So, 
whether that's domestically or internationally, so I guess 
coming back to some of the trade policies that we might need to 
take a look at as well.
 Senator Husted. And I'm going to follow up on your point 
about the pumps that are coming in from China. How much are 
they undercutting you on price on those?
 Mr. Zoeller. It's probably about 40 percent.
 Senator Husted. And they're violating all kinds of standing 
agreements that we have?
 Mr. Zoeller. Yes. I can't speak to the FTC laws and stuff 
like that. But obviously when we find out about them, the fact 
that we were able to get the two trademarks with the trademark 
office, we're able to shut them down relatively fast with the 
help of the government and FTC and stuff like that. But they're 
out there. Our customers are the ones that most of the time 
make us aware of something like that.
 Senator Husted. You mentioned in your testimony, Mr. 
Zoeller, that the working Family Tax Cut plan has no tax on 
overtime. You work your folks overtime a lot. How is it 
affecting them? Because I remember I visited a manufacturing 
facility in Findlay and was talking to a young man who had 
decided that he was going to work his 55 hours a week of 
overtime and take it the whole year. And the amount of money 
that he would save was going to be enough to put a down payment 
on a house. Are some of your employees thinking like that? Do 
they realize this or is it not a factor to them?
 Mr. Zoeller. Yeah, I would love to talk about our 
employees. So high level. A couple of things just to kind of 
give a little background. So, we work two shifts, both are ten-
hour shifts. So, we don't work on Fridays historically. We got 
a lot of lakes in Kentucky and our employees like to go out and 
enjoy those lakes on the weekends and especially nice days like 
today.
 So, when we do have overtime, they work on Friday, and 
they're able to do that. And on top of that, we also try to do 
education with our employees from a standpoint of whether it's 
financial education, wellness education, mental health, 
education, all those pieces to make them a better individual so 
they can take that home to their families as well.
 I can't say that any individuals, is getting enough 
overtime to buy a house because we don't like to work them that 
hard, but they are maybe able to do something nice with the 
family, with those. And we do communicate that we have a 
relationship with a credit union bank that's right around the 
corner from us. They come in and do those financial literacy 
things and we have pretty good participation.
 Senator Husted. Great. I want to thank all of you for being 
here today and serving as witnesses and offering your 
perspective on American manufacturing. I do think the 250th 
anniversary of our Nation is a very special occasion.
 It's also an occasion to look back and understand what made 
us successful and then use those lessons to determine a path 
forward so that we can support small businesses in our Nation 
for the future and certainly those in manufacturing, because we 
know that manufacturing jobs just are so important, not only 
because they pay higher wages, but the trickle down or trickle 
throughput that they have in the whole supply chain and the 
jobs that they create in addition.
 So, with that, I ask unanimous consent that the record of 
today's hearing remain open for 2 weeks for members to submit 
questions, or revise and extend their remarks, and to submit 
additional information into the record. Without objection, so 
ordered.
 With that, the Committee on Small Business and 
Entrepreneurship stands adjourned. Thank you.
 [Whereupon, at 3:37 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]

 [all]