Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ HEARING HELD IN WASHINGTON, DC, JANUARY 14, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-42 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Education and Workforce [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: edworkforce.house.gov or www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-596 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Chairman JOE WILSON, South Carolina ROBERT C. ``BOBBY'' SCOTT, VIRGINIA FOXX, North Carolina Virginia, GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania Ranking Member GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut ELISE M. STEFANIK, New York FREDERICA S. WILSON, Florida RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon JAMES COMER, Kentucky MARK TAKANO, California BURGESS OWENS, Utah ALMA S. ADAMS, North Carolina LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan MARK DeSAULNIER, California MARY E. MILLER, Illinois DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey JULIA LETLOW, Louisiana LUCY McBATH, Georgia KEVIN KILEY, California JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio ILHAN OMAR, Minnesota JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam HALEY M. STEVENS, Michigan ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri GREG CASAR, Texas RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington JOHN W. MANNION, New York MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona MARK B. MESSMER, Indiana RANDY FINE, Florida R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director ------ C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on January 14, 2026................................. 1 OPENING STATEMENTS Walberg, Hon. Tim, Chairman, Committee on Education and Workforce.................................................. 1 Prepared statement of.................................... 4 Scott, Hon. Robert C. ``Bobby'', Ranking Member, Committee on Education and Workforce.................................... 6 Prepared statement of.................................... 9 WITNESSES Nayak, Ms. Chaya, Head, Cerifications and Jobs Platform, OpenAI..................................................... 11 Prepared statement of.................................... 13 Khan, Mr. Adeel, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Magic School AI.................................................. 17 Prepared statement of.................................... 19 Reeve Givens, Ms. Alexandra, President and Chief Executive Officer, Center for Democracy and Technology............... 25 Prepared statement of.................................... 27 Frazier, Mr. Kevin, AI Innovation and Law Fellow, University of Texas, Austin School of Law............................. 45 Prepared statement of.................................... 46 ADDITIONAL SUBMISSIONS Ranking Member Scott: Article dated March 28, 2024, from the Economic Policy Institute, entitled ``Unbalanced Labor Market Power is What Makes Technology--Including AI--Threatening to Workers. The Best `AI Policy' to Protect Workers is Boosting Their Bargaining Position''................... 145 Article dated January 14, 2026, from NPR, entitled ``The Risks of AI in Schools Outweigh the Benefits, Report Says''................................................. 178 Takano, Hon. Mark, a Representative in Congress from the State of California: Letter dated January 13, 2026, from the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)............................................... 111 BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA ---------- Wednesday, January 14, 2026 House of Representatives, Committee on Education and Workforce, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:16 a.m. in Room 2175, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Tim Walberg, (Chairman of the Committee) presiding. Present: Representatives Walberg, Wilson, Foxx, Thompson, Grothman, Allen, Comer, Owens, Miller, Kiley, Rulli, Moylan, Onder, Harris, Messmer, Fine, Scott, Courtney, Bonamici, Takano, Adams, DeSaulnier, McBath, Hayes, Lee, Mannion, and Grijalva. Staff present: Vlad Cerga, Director of Information Technology; Solomon Chen, Professional Staff Member; Maren Emmerson, Legislative Assistant; Halle Graeenbaum, Staff Assistant; Amy Raaf Jones, Director of Education and Human Services Policy; Libby Kearns, Press Assistant; Katerina Kerska, Legislative Assistant; Isaiah Knox, Policy Advisor; Trey Kovacs, Director of Workforce Policy; Kyle Kuhlers, AEI Fellow; Campbell Ladd, Clerk; R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director; Jack Leonard, Staff Assistant; Danny Marca, Director of Information Technology; Brad Mannion, Professional Staff Member; John Martin, Deputy Director of Workforce Policy/ Counsel; R.J. Martin, Professional Staff Member; Audra McGeorge, Communications Director; Kevin O'Keefe, Professional Staff Member; Ethan Pann, Deputy Press Secretary and Digital Director; Kane Riddell, Staff Assistant; Sara Robertson, Press Secretary; Katherine Anne Russo, Director of Member Services and Coalitions; Heidi Schneider, Professional Staff Member; Isabel Soto, Professional Staff Member; Brad Thomas, Deputy Director of Education and Human Services Policy; Ann Vogel, Director of Operations; Thomas White, Deputy Clerk; James Whittaker, General Counsel; Amaris Benavidez, Minority Professional Staff; Phoebe Ball, Minority Senior Counsel; Rashage Green, Minority Director of Education Policy & Counsel; Christian Haines, Minority General Counsel; Emanual Kimble, Minority Professional Staff; Stephanie Lalle, Minority Communications Director; Jessica Schieder, Minority Economic Policy Advisor; Raiyana Malone, Minority Press Secretary; Kwesi Matthews, Minority Einstein Fellow; Marie McGrew, Minority Press Assistant; Eleazar Padilla, Minority Staff Assistant; Alexandra Pernie, Minority Intern; Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director; and Banyon Vassar, Minority Director of IT. Chairman Walberg. The Committee will please come to order. A quorum is present. The Committee meets today pursuant to notice. Without objection, the Chair may recess the Committee at any point. Artificial intelligence is scaling rapidly and as a result, it is increasingly shaping how we learn, how we work and how we prepare for the future. Today's hearing examines AI and its growing role in education, workforce development and the future of work itself. Artificial intelligence is often described as a sudden disruption, but many of its underlying technologies have existed for decades. What has changed is the scale and the accessibility of these tools. Rapid advancements have made AI systems easier to use and more widely available, reaching classrooms, workforce training programs and workplaces across the country. AI's potential benefits are significant. AI tools are already helping teachers reduce administrative burdens, better personalize learning and free up more time, to engage directly with students. For workers, AI can help build new skills, increase efficiency and accelerate on-the-job learning. As a result, employers can expect productivity gains that contribute to economic growth. An estimated 40 percent of GDP could be significantly affected by generative AI, which could mean a permanent increase in economic activity. That said, AI growth is not without challenges. Models can make mistakes. In education, that raises concerns about academic integrity and overreliance. In the workplace, early evidence suggests AI may change how tasks are performed, particularly for entry level roles, which underscores the need for strong pathways into the labor market and strong skills development. It is also important to recognize that many labor laws and regulations have not kept pace with how quickly work is changing, and they too often make it harder for businesses to offer benefits and flexibility. With a rapid pace of technological change, workers are seeking greater freedom and flexibility in how they work. This highlights the need for clearer standards for independent work and more flexible benefit models to better serve a modern mobile workforce. Today, more than 70 million workers operate as self-employed independent contractors. The Federal Government too often does not provide the statutory, statutory clarity that these workers need and deserve. In our current age of rapid technological growth, including AI related development, our policies must adapt to the growing role of independent work. As this Committee considers AI, we must recognize that many existing education and workforce policies were designed for a different era. The goal should not be to rush into sweeping new rules and regulations, but to ensure schools, employers and training providers can keep pace with innovation, while maintaining trust and prioritizing safety and privacy. U.S. leadership in AI is pivotal to the Nation's economic success and security. The Trump administration understands that this leadership requires an AI-ready workforce supported by strong classroom instruction and on the job learning, that make the most of cutting-edge technologies. Today, we have the opportunity to better understand how AI is being and could be used in education and workforce systems, where it is delivering value and where challenges remain. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses and with that, I yield to the Ranking Member. [The opening statement of Chairman Walberg follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to our witnesses for being with us today. From chatbots to programming to grocery lists, artificial intelligence is rapidly integrated into our daily lives, with millions of Americans transforming how we interact with technology and the world around us. Due to the rapid rise of AI technology, scientists and researchers have had relatively little time to study its impact on American lives. We must act carefully and methodically when implementing new technologies, particularly in settings where they may have long lasting impacts, such as our schools, workplaces and healthcare settings. This is a time of incredible change and possibility. It is up to us to shepherd this new technology with caution and responsibility that the situation demands. As we discussed at an Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education Subcommittee hearing earlier this year, AI is already present in our schools. Many educators have found that generative AI systems allow them to offer more personalized instruction to students, streamlined assignments and provide real time feedback. This has led to a rise of AI literacy in which students and teachers have learned to use AI responsibly for the benefit of their education and futures. It is not without risks. There was a piece this morning on NPR titled ``Report: The Risks of AI in Schools Outweigh the Benefits.'' While the prospect of this new technology is exciting, we do not have enough data right now to understand the full impact on Americans lives. AI tools are created by humans and humans are flawed. This can lead to AI tools exhibiting biases and unfairness due to biased training data, other kinds of discrimination and lack of diversity in AI development. This can also result in unfair decisionmaking about what students need to learn and how. Discrimination by way of AI has also had ramifications in our workforce. A Society for Human Resource Management survey found that nearly 80 percent of its members use AI for recruiting and hiring. Multiple studies have found that some of these recruitment tools have demonstrated biases against women and black applicants. It is important to recognize that AI is not infallible technology, and it is not neutral. We must take proactive steps to ensure that AI technology does not perpetuate existing disparities and erode civil rights. Concerns about AI in the workplace does not stop with the hiring process. As AI proliferates, we have been begun to see employers use sophisticated automatic technology to monitor and evaluate workers. This includes tracking workers' physical activities on the job, such as how often they go to the bathroom using facial recognition to assess their attention to computer screens and others. Still worse, employers have used data to estimate potential union organizing activity. I do not think anyone on this Committee would want their personal activities tracked by an employer, so we should not expect less for the American worker. Unfortunately, the Trump administration's actions to dismantle the Department of Education have hamstrung much of our existing capacity to study and regulate AI's effect on education. Decimation of the Office of Education Technology and the Institute of Educational Sciences has diminished our ability to comprehensively research student safety related to artificial intelligence. One of our strongest institutions to fight discrimination, the Office of Civil Rights, has had almost half its staff fired and seven of its 12 regional office closed. While the Trump administration has started rehiring some of the staff, the chaos has clearly disrupted the office's operations to the detriment of parents and students. Today, 33 states have released official guidance or policies on the use of AI in K through 12 schools. Virginia, for example, has issued guidance on integrating AI and education, and among other things provides recommendations for teacher professional development and AI literacy programs. Without clear, consistent Federal leadership from the Department of Education, states have largely been left to navigate this complex landscape on their own, creating inconsistencies and exacerbating achievement gaps. AI also poses significant risk risks to data privacy and child safety. For example, a nonprofit group, AI Forensics, found in a recent analysis of 20,000 images created by Grok that 2 percent depicted a person who appeared to be 18 or younger in bikinis or transparent clothing. A study by Brown University researchers found that AI chatbots routinely violate mental health ethics standards, including failing to refer users to appropriate resources and responding indifferently to crisis situations, including suicidal ideation. Open AI recently launched a controversial ChatGPT Health app, which can review users' health records and generate personalized advice, raising concerns about privacy and accuracy of chatbots. The Meta is currently fighting allegations in court that have downplayed the risks of its platforms to children. The Center for Missing and Exploited Children also reports seeing a dramatic increase in generative AI technologies that are capable of creating child sexual abuse material, and a rise in other disturbing trends related to AI chatbots. The organization received approximately 7,000 reports through its cyber tip line in 2024, and nearly half a million in just the first half of 2025. Despite these very real risks, it is become alarmingly clear that the Trump administration is eager to grant large technology companies unprecedented access to American's data. In December, the Trump administration issued an executive order attempting to block states from regulating AI on its own. The Congress seriously considered doing that by legislation, which I think is necessary to override State laws. Congress should not, however, stand idly by while the Trump administration may be ingratiating itself to big tech CEOs, and preventing states from protecting Americans against dangers posed by AI. This is why Congress must take an active role in shaping how AI is integrated into our lives, and develop thoughtful regulations that balance protecting students, workers, and families and, fostering economic growth. Today, we stand at another crossroad of technological advancement. It is up to Congress to ensure that AI takes us forward but not backward. I look forward to the conversations today, and yield back the balance of my time. [The opening statement of Ranking Member Scott follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(c), all members who wish to insert written statements into the record may do so by submitting them to the Committee Clerk electronically in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m., 14 days after this hearing. Without objection, the hearing record will remain open for 14 days to allow such statements and other extraneous material noted during the hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record. I will now turn to our four witnesses, our first witness, Ms. Chaya Nayak, the Head of Certifications and Jobs platform at OpenAI from San Francisco, California. Welcome. Our second witness is Mr. Adeel Khan, the founder and CEO of Magic School AI from Boulder, Colorado. Welcome. Our third witness is Ms. Alexander Reeve Givens, the president and CEO of Magic School AI--excuse me. My view shifted there, I guess. I gave you another title. The president and CEO for the Center for Democracy and Technology from Washington, DC. Welcome. Our last witness is Mr. Kevin Frazier, an AI Innovation and Law Fellow from the University of Texas Law School from Austin, Texas. Welcome. We thank the witnesses for being here today. Pursuant to Committee rules, I would ask that you each limit your oral presentation to a 3-minute summary for your written statement. The clock will count down from 3 minutes. As Committee members have many questions for you and we would like to spend as much time as possible on questions. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(d) and Committee practice, however, will not cutoff your testimony until you reach the 5-minute mark. I would also like to remind the witnesses to be aware that their responsibility to provide accurate information to the Committee is their responsibility. I will first recognized Ms. Nayak for your testimony. STATEMENT OF CHAYA NAYAK, HEAD OF CERTIFICATIONS AND JOBS PLATFORM, OPENAI, SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Chairman Walberg, Ranking Member Scott and members of the Committee. My name is Chaya Nayak, and I lead OpenAI's work on certifications and our jobs platform. These efforts are focused on helping people build AI skills and connect those skills to real economic opportunity. At OpenAI, we believe that AI will make workers more productive and unlock more opportunity than any technology in history. It will help people do their jobs better, help businesses operate more effectively and give anyone the power to turn ideas into income and outcomes, and create jobs that do not even exist today. We know that work will look quite different. Some jobs will actually be lost. We want to do our part to help workers actually prepare and get ready for this AI driven economy. Doing this will require us to acknowledge a simple reality. These tools can do far more than workers, small businesses and communities are currently using them for today. If we do not close that gap, a select few will capture most of the benefits of AI, while others will be left behind. That gap is what we call the capability overhang, the distance between what AI can do and what people are actually using it for today. Our goal is to close that so AI can work for all Americans. Employers are being clear about the value that they place on AI skills. More than 70 percent of business leaders say that they would hire a less experienced candidate that has AI experience versus a more seasoned one without it. Other research shows that workers with AI skills can actually earn up to 50 percent more than their nonAI skilled counterparts. At OpenAI, our starting point is ChatGPT itself. For many people, ChatGPT is not just a tool, it is actually a place to learn. Workers use it to practice real tasks, get feedback and build skills, and it is really dynamic and super personal. That learning matters, but only if it helps workers and employers be able to actually acknowledge the skills that they are getting from the use of AI. This is where a certifications program comes in. It begins with AI Foundations. We are building a course that actually helps people learn AI skills, and apply those skills across industries and different outcomes. With additional coursework, they are going to progress to a full OpenAI certification and that broader credential will show employers that a person can actually apply AI effectively in real world work settings. Our goal is to certify 10 million Americans by 2030 with AI skills. From there, we are working to close the loop with our OpenAI jobs platform. This platform will launch very soon. The jobs platform is designed to connect employers with job seekers across every industry, and our goal is to use AI to help people get prepared, get matched and to actually get hired. We are launching our jobs and certifications effort with a broad coalition of partners, employers like Walmart, State systems, universities, because each of those organizations brings unique insight into what workers need and what employers actually value. We think there is still time to prepare people for this new AI era, but there is not time to wait and kind of not build programs and systems that we need to make people successful. That is why at OpenAI, we are acting right now and we are helping them by building the tools and technology to support them and make it easier for employers to actually hire them. Thank you so much for the opportunity to testify today and I look forward to all of your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Nayak follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Walberg. Thank you. I now recognize Mr. Khan for your testimony. STATEMENT OF ADEEL KHAN, FOUNDER AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, MAGIC SCHOOL AI, BOULDER, COLORADO Mr. Khan. Chairman Walberg, Ranking Member Scott and members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name is Adeel Khan. I am the founder and CEO of Magic School, a generative AI platform built for schools. Before this, I spent my career in public schools as a teacher, assistant principal, principal and district leader. I have held nearly every job in a school building. There are over seven million educators using Magic School's AI worldwide, representing nearly every school and district in the U.S. teachers are some of the widest adopters of AI in any profession. Many educators are using it in practical ways, like saving time on routine work, lesson planning, personalizing instruction for diverse learners and communicating with families. That reality is not the problem. The problem is that we do not yet have shared standards and safe purpose-built tools as a default for classrooms. Without clear guardrails responsibility fragments, and districts struggle to protect students and learn what works. The most promising early uses are educator-facing. AI delivers the most value when it strengthens not shortcuts teacher judgment. Used well, it helps the teacher prepare faster, differentiate for students and provide timely feedback while decisions stay firmly in their hands. K12 schools are different. Students are minors. Schools hold sensitive data. Instruction shapes learning outcomes. Responsible use should be anchored in a few simple principles, tools purpose built for education. Humans stay in the loop, student protections by design and transparencies so districts and families understand data use and controls. Education policy is primarily State and local. The most constructive Federal role is to support capacity and protections for children, while investing in educator training, evidence building, procurement guidance and funding, so districts can adopt responsibly. I will close with a story from last year that sums up why learning about AI in schools from your teacher is so important. Recently, I was spending time with a friend and his daughter, who is in the 10th grade. As we caught up, she had known me from my former life as a teacher and a principal. She found out about my new work in Magic School and excitedly said ``I use that in school.'' She went on to share with me that in her history class, her teacher uses the writing feedback tool with them. She gets personalized rubric, aligned AI feedback on her essays that she wrote by herself, not with AI. From Magic School. She was grateful for the chance to get AI feedback and revise her essay before being graded by her teacher. Even as a high school student, she was able to so clearly articulate the value of the feedback and how without the AI tool, it would have been nearly impossible for her teacher to give meaningful formative feedback on each individual child's essay before it was turned in. Naturally, I inquired more. What do you think about AI in general? How are you and your friends using it? She shared an eloquent, nuanced answer, both acknowledging that some use it to cheat, but saying she's made the choice to use it sparingly. She explained that she knew that she could use it as a shortcut like some of her friends did, but did not want to because she did not want to offload too much of her own thinking. She reminded me that her brain is still in a really important development phase, and she would be tested without AI anyway, so what is the point? The conversation was inspiring. Not only did she clearly know the value, but just as importantly, she knew the risks and had agency to make an informed choice about hey, how she would use AI in and out of the classroom. The first thought I had was wow, what a thoughtful, intelligent, savvy young lady. I was nowhere near as thoughtful as a 10th grader. The second thought was, wow. She must have had a great teacher that helped her learn about the risks and benefits of AI, to make great choices about her own future. Every child deserves a teacher in a school like this. Thank you. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Khan follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Walberg. Thank you. Now I recognize Ms. Reeve Givens for your testimony. STATEMENT OF ALEXANDRA REEVE GIVENS, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, CENTER FOR DEMOCRACY AND TECHNOLOGY, WASHINGTON, D.C. Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I lead the Center for Democracy and Technology, a nonpartisan organization focused on how technology impacts people's rights and futures. We have specific projects on workers' rights and the evolving use of data and technology in K through 12 classrooms, the research for which informs my testimony today. AI is already shaping how Americans learn, work and are evaluated. AI can support educators and workers in meaningful ways, but without guardrails, transparency and accountability, it can just as easily deepen inequalities and undermine progress. Building an AI ready America means more than accelerating adoption. It means ensuring that AI lifts up all communities for sustained social and economic growth. Congress has an important role to play through legislation, by ensuring the proper functioning of the Department of Education, Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and other Federal agencies, and by providing the resources that workers, educators and families need in this transformational time. Turning first to the workforce, employers are increasingly relying on AI in hiring, management and oversight. While AI tools can create efficiencies, they can also exclude workers and violate U.S. employment laws. For example, AI tools used to screen resumes have automatically rejected applicants over 55, downrated female applicants and filtered out resumes with employment gaps, which may be due to medical leave or returning from military service. Risks also arise from AI powered interviews or tests, which claim to test traits like a person's appetite for risk or emotional stability. In one study, a researcher completed an English language AI interview in German and yet was still determined to be a 73 percent match for the job. Workers often have little visibility into how these tools work or what they are actually testing. The harm is felt not just by workers, but by employers who are investing in ineffective tools that may break the law. This is why it benefits everyone to acknowledge these risks and address them through rigorous testing and transparency. AI is also being used to manage and monitor workers, with impacts for their rights and safety. As one factory worker put it, any slack is perpetually being optimized out of the system and with it any opportunity to rest or recover. Workers also report losing privacy, independent judgment and professional expertise as they become micromanaged in every facet of a task. My written testimony lists several enacted and proposed laws to address these risks, including the proposed No Robot Bosses Act and Stops Spying Bosses Act. Research shows workers' strong support for these types of rules. Federal agencies also have an important role to play. The EEOC, Department of Justice, Department of Labor and National Labor Relations Board previously developed valuable guidance for employers, to help ensure their use of AI tools is fair and legal. These documents have now being removed from the agency's websites. Congress should encourage these agencies role guiding employers and supporting workers at this critical time. In education AI use in K through 12 schools has now reached record levels, with 85 percent of teachers and 86 percent of students using generative AI last school year. Each year, CDT conducts nationwide polling that asks students, parents and teachers about their experiences with AI and how they feel about it, from which I will share four relevant trends. First, students are turning to AI for social and emotional purposes. This year, 42 percent of students reported that they or a friend have used generative AI for mental health support, and 42 percent reported using it as a friend or companion. This raises pressing questions about students' emotional development and safety, and the urgent need for privacy protections as these companies that make these tools learn so much about our and our children's lives. Second, deep fakes and nonconsensual intimate imagery are a serious problem in schools, but less than a quarter of teachers say their schools have clear policies to respond, and responses often focus solely on discipline rather than prevention and victim support. Third, more than half of special ed teachers now use AI to help develop IEPs. While most parents and students support this, it requires dedicated efforts to comply with student privacy and disability laws. Fourth, most public schools are now using AI powered software to monitor students' online activity, even on personal devices and outside school hours. These tools are not just used to support kids in distress. They are also being used for discipline. Among teachers we surveyed, 25 percent knew of a student who was contacted by law enforcement as a result of student monitoring. Five in ten students agreed ``I don't share my true thoughts or ideas, because I know what I do online is being monitored.'' Despite these risks, only a third of teachers have guidance on how to use these systems privately and securely. As in the workforce, AI's potential in education can only be realized if we are clear-eyed about the risks and help educators and families to address them. Congress and this Committee have an important role to play, and I look forward to your questions. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Reeve Givens follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Walberg. Thank you. Last, but not least, I recognize Mr. Frazier for your testimony. STATEMENT OF KEVIN FRAZIER, AI INNOVATION AND LAW FELLOW, UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN SCHOOL OF LAW, AUSTIN, TEXAS Mr. Frazier. Chairman Walberg, Ranking Member Scott and distinguished members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name's Kevin Frazier. I am a senior fellow at the Abundance Institute and the AI Innovation and Law Program Fellow at the University of Texas School of Law. The economic normal in the age of AI is and will be marked by flexibility. Future generations of Americans will not associate traditional work with 9 to 5 employment. The career ladder will be replaced by a career flywheel, in which individuals succeed due to their capacity to adapt and willingness to learn. In short, we will soon see more and more Americans participating in what I call the portfolio economy. Workers will maintain an array of skills that they offer to a range of employers on a project-to-project basis. This transition will put pressure on New Deal era laws, such as the Fair Labor Standards Act. My written testimony makes three points. The transition to the portfolio economy must be data-driven, worker-focused and flexible. Absent more data about how the economy is evolving, Congress may lack the information necessary to assess whether existing laws are functioning as intended. Many of the current sources of labor market data are infrequent, imprecise or inaccurate. The Contingent Worker Survey, for example, is issued on an irregular basis and does not accurately capture the number of Americans in non-traditional jobs. It is also unlikely that Congress has up to date and comprehensive information on AI adoption. According to recent polls, just 10 percent of workers use AI daily and a mere 9 percent of small firms have picked up AI. This information, though, is akin to learning that LeBron James played 47 minutes in a basketball game. It is better than nothing, but it really does not tell you anything. It is missing what really matters, like how many points he scored or to return to AI, whether its use is increasing productivity and altering hiring decisions. Updating and expanding the sources of information on AI progress will become all the more important as the technology continues to evolve. While most experts agree we should expect ongoing advances in AI, they diverge when it comes to pinpointing the specifics. The so-called jagged frontier of AI will cause firms to preserve the option of automating and augmenting certain tasks and roles. Consequently, they will prioritize finding workers with specific skills for finite projects. In turn, workers will need to be ready and willing to learn new skills and fast. With a better understanding of AI advances and adoption, I recommend Congress analyze laws such as the Fair Labor Standards Act with a focus on two aspects. First, to what extent does the law rely on frameworks and definitions that clash with the portfolio economy? Second, does the law incentivize workers to engage in the career flywheel, to study, to shadow via apprenticeships and to work in non-traditional arrangement? Thank you again for the opportunity to testify. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Frazier follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Walberg. I thank each of the witnesses. You have whetted our appetite, and I guess also given us a question, were your testimoneys produced by AI? We will leave that. Under Committee Rule 9, we will now question witnesses under the 5- minute rule. I will recognize myself for 5 minutes of questioning. Ms. Nayak, I guess the key question I would ask you is what distinguishes high-quality credentials in an AI-driven market from one that is well-intentioned and low value? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Chairman. What I think distinguishes high value credentials from lower value credentials is actually doing the work to make sure that the credentials are psychometrically valid and backed. What that means is that we are not just creating courses that people take passively and not really testing their outcomes, or maybe testing their outcomes through really simple assessments, but rather we are working toward actually training AI to be able to assess people and do so against a common standard. We are partnering with organizations like ETS, to actually validate that the courses are actually leading to outcomes. We are partnering with our econ research team that is actually following students throughout their learning journey, to ensure that they are seeing the outcomes from taking the course. We think it is both a pair of making sure that the course actually has value and content that is worth learning, but then ensuring that the students that take those courses actually can apply those in their roles, and then validating that in order to issue the credential rather than just having them passively observe it. Chairman Walberg. Whole, well-rounded immediate evaluation? Ms. Nayak. Correct. Chairman Walberg. Both sides of the equation. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Khan, there are hundreds, perhaps thousands of vendors and more will be coming all the time, I am sure, selling AI products to schools. You mentioned that policymakers should help districts and I quote ``ask the right questions'' before buying AI platforms. What are some of those questions? Mr. Khan. A few really important questions that a district buyer should wonder about when bringing on an AI platform to their school or district is first and foremost, how do you protect student data? What data do you record? Are you training models with our students' inputs and their outputs into the platform? Other questions you might ask or how do you evaluate your platform for things like bias, safety, ensuring that we do not see some of the negative parts of generative AI become a part of our district. Magic Schools put out several white papers around how we approach AI safety for students. One highlights the idea that AI can be used potentially for companionship. Students sometimes will turn any tool into something that can be a companion if it is an open-ended chatbot. What are the guardrails that you put in place to ensure that, those kinds of things do not happen, in a public school setting? Then finally, how do you ensure that the student is using it for the purpose that has been given in the classroom and not for other purposes? How do you build your guardrails into the platform so that when a student asks a question that is outside the bounds of what you want to be happening in a classroom, it responds appropriately. What kind of controls do you give the teacher and the school district to remedy those things and create their own guardrails for the platform? We know that schools and districts are different State to State, and we want to make sure that there are--there is an empowered district leadership to make the right decisions for how generative AI will be used in their school or district. Chairman Walberg. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Frazier, when we discuss AI in the workplace, we typically put it in the two buckets. First, its ability to augment work performed by humans to produce higher levels of productivity. Second, its ability to automate certain tasks completely and replace human effort. With the initial wave of AI in the workplace, what has been the net impact of augmenting work? Mr. Frazier. Thank you for that question, Chairman. I think it is important to, as you did, distinguish between task automation and task augmentation. We are seeing that even when tasks are automated, when AI is completely taking over a specific function, there are still a number of tasks that must involve some degree of human intervention. We had some people who were predicting, for example, the end of certain professions, because they thought that AI would automate just one or two of those tasks. Those professions are still alive and well today. Radiologists, for example, are seeing higher numbers of employment, not the end of their profession as a whole. As we look at the initial introduction of AI into the economy, No. 1, I would first point out adoption is still very low. No. 2, even where there is adoption, we are seeing that the bottlenecks that remain even after some tasks are automated result perhaps in even more job creation, or higher wages for those workers in those industries. Chairman Walberg. Okay. Thank you. Thanks for answering my second question without me asking it. I appreciate that. Now I recognize the gentleman from Connecticut, Mr. Courtney, for his 5 minutes of questioning. Mr. Courtney. Thank you Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses for being here today. You know, I want to go back to Mr. Scott's opening comments regarding the explosion of tips and calls into the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Again, the numbers bear repeating. In 2024, the number of tips that have been--that came into the system was 6,800. In 2025 the number was 440,000 was made just in the first half of the year. Again, the Center's been around for 40 years. This Committee actually authorizes its operation and funding year in and year out. We just actually enacted the latest update in 2024. Clearly, the system has just been rocked and by an avalanche of, you know, incidents that are happening. You know, Ms. Reeve Givens, I mean you alluded to this in your testimony. I mean what do you--what is the response that Congress needs to make here, to hold technology companies accountable, help victims and assist these organizations to deal with? Really, I think is clearly a crisis. Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you for the question and for highlighting this important issue. This is an issue not only for young people and their parents, but it is also showing up in school communities as well. Our survey data this year showed that 12 percent of students knew of non-consensual intimate imagery depicting somebody in their school community. That is one of their peers, it is one of their teachers. Right now, we really have a lack of resources for teachers knowing how to respond. Some schools are leaning into discipline. Of course that is part of the equation, but we also need to make sure that people are talking rigorously about prevention and support for victims, including mechanisms for taking this stuff down. There are some laws on the books that can be helpful. When imagery depicts minors, it is illegal content that must already be taken down. Companies can be held liable for keeping it up and for generating that content. In addition, Congress recently passed the Take It Down Act, to make it easier for people to take down these images of themselves by filing a request. Just yesterday, the Senate passed the Defiance Act, which has now made its way over to the House for consideration, which makes it easier for people to sue when they are a victim of this. Again, putting it just on the shoulders of individual victims is not a solution. We also need companies really leaning into their obligations here. This involves a couple different things. One is about the capacity of your tool to generate these images in the first place. What are the tools in check around the creation of nude images, around the uploading of images of real people and how you allow those to be manipulated. Second is around the detection. When those outputs are coming out, where are you stopping it, and how does that work? Then third, of course, are social media platforms and other places where these images can be disseminated. Oftentimes, it is already a violation of the terms of service for that to happen, but we see that companies are not rigorously enforcing those terms. We advocate directly to the companies to do that, even where it is not necessarily illegal content, but is still deeply inappropriate. They should be creating a safe community for their users and living up to the promises they are telling their users about what they do. Mr. Courtney. Thank you for that answer. You know, when we enacted that, that recent update for the Center's work, there was, you know, basically a budget sort of trajectory which was fairly steady. Obviously, the work that they have been taking on really just within the last year has just completely been overtaken. You know, clearly there is a cost here. You know, there is a social cost to AI which, you know, we again as a society have to sort of figure out who pays, in terms of dealing with that. You know, this is a completely consensus issue in terms of the Center's authorities. It goes back 40 years, I think as I mentioned earlier. It should be frankly in my opinion, a consensus issue for industry, as well as the political parties here in Washington. Again, at some point it is--comes down to the question of who pays, and it seems that industry has an obligation here, given the fact that there is a direct connection to, you know, the scaling rapidly I think was what the Chairman said about AI at the opening, and really what is also rapidly happening in terms of negative fallout. Ms. Reeve Givens. No. I very much agree, and I think the question here is both the technological development. What are those safeguards that should be embedded into the tools and then the will to actually follow through. It is one thing to write a good terms of service, saying that you do not allow this on your platform. It is another to rigorously enforce it. One of the problems we have right now is lack of visibility into how platforms are complying with their terms of service. Some of them do kind of disclosures about it, but it is not a common practice, and we have actually seen some pullback in recent years. When we think about accountability, when we think what it is to make good on the promise you make to your customers and your users about the community that you are building online, about the value of these tools, how can we get far more information and honest disclosures around how these issues are being addressed in a rigorous way? Mr. Courtney. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize the esteemed gentleman from South Carolina. Mr. Wilson. Thank you. Yes, South Carolina. Chairman Walberg. Lexington. Mr. Wilson. Anyway, the bottom line, I am just grateful to be here. Thank you, Chairman Tim Walberg, and it is really great to see the bipartisanship with Ranking Member Bobby Scott and Joe Courtney, the whole team. It is because what we are dealing with is just so important. Then thank all of you for your testimony today on such an important issue. Mr. Khan, with this in mind, and you have hit on this already, but how can we promote that the presence of AI and K through 12 education is not diminishing the student's ability to think critically, particularly children who are not aware of the risk? Additionally, how can we ensure that protection of minor students' data when they utilize AI? Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question. I think that there are a couple things that we believe as an organization. One is that if a student is not introduced to generative AI in the school building, they will inevitably be introduced to generative AI in a different way. That might be that, you know, you open Snapchat and you see My AI at the top of it. You might open Instagram and see an AI chatbot in your search function. I think that everyone in this room would agree that you would prefer the first time that a child interacts with generative AI, it is under the guidance of a teacher who is teaching them about how it works, the risks and benefits of using generative AI, the purposes with which they could find value, and also the risks associated with, the use of the technology. One of which I did not mention in my testimony, which is offloading too much of your own thinking. We do not want students in primary school having AI write for them. We want students having the writing done by themselves. I was an English teacher, and I think so much about how, you know, writing is beyond the finished product. It is the construction of thoughts, right? It is you are developing your own ideas, your own opinions when you put your pencil to paper. We want students doing that, and we do not want them offloading that to AI. That starts with teaching students about the technology and the risks and benefits of it, and actually engaging with it to understand how they can be productive users of it in the now and in the future. Mr. Wilson. I appreciate your thoughtfulness. Ms. Nayak, with about a third of Americans reporting that they are using ChatGPT, developments like OpenAI's jobs platform has immense potential to affect the community. Could you elaborate on how you see this job platform working and what outcomes you are hoping to see? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. Yes. Our goal is to certify ten million Americans by 2030. With that certification, what we are trying to do is build a jobs platform that can then connect those Americans to roles across the economy. Our goal here is first when we launch, we will start with a product that is focused on users of ChatGPT and helping them get career advice, helping them understand where their skills are, what gaps they may have, helping them actually get AI skills if they so choose through our certifications effort. Then finally, helping them connect with employers that really value those skills. Certifications is really the through line for this whole effort, because we believe that we can actually have employers trust those certifications, and then be able to use them to help them, identify roles for different people in the economy. Mr. Wilson. Well again, all, all of you, your expertise is going to be so helpful. Professor Frazier, you wrote in a recent oped quote ``The AI debate is being framed by questions that have distracted us from the practical policy challenges we need to address, to bring about a better future.'' Will you expand on that point and explain how you think that we should be talking about AI's potential impact on the workplace? I have a practical problem that I have seen, in that I have found out that a number of young people do not know how to read cursive. I am concerned as they are so AI focused that I am having difficulty communicating with people who cannot read cursive. Mr. Frazier. With respect to cursive, sir, I think I will leave that to the English professor about the merits of, of writing in that style. I will instead focus on the question of how do we make sure that Congress prioritizes the issues that really matter in this AI debate? I think, to my colleague's point, making sure we focus on AI adoption and AI literacy is incredibly important. Right now, many people have access to these tools and our polls that we issue ask them do you use, for example, ChatGPT? Well sure, but you may be creating a meme. That is like asking someone if they have ever driven, and they say yes, Mario Kart all the time, right? It is not a meaningful metric of whether you actually know how to use the tool. We need to have a far greater focus on making sure we are paying attention to literacy and true skill development. Mr. Wilson. Well, I wish you well and I have seen the good and the bad. A political candidate actually made fun of me doing the Macarena, which I do not know how to do, but it made me look good. Then, and then--and I do not think they meant for it. Then recently, I got a beautiful picture about a--me showing a picture of a beautiful lake and so that I was not there. What an interesting time we all live in. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman for his Macarena. Now I want to recognize the gentlelady from Oregon, Ms. Bonamici. Ms. Bonamici. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses. Special welcome to Professor Frazier, who is in Texas now but via Oregon, an Oregonian. We know that AI is rapidly reshaping classrooms and workplaces. I am very concerned about the minimal, if any, professional development on how to responsibly use AI in classrooms. Mr. Khan, thank you for your mention of guardrails and the human elements, and I appreciated your story. The last time I spoke with high school students, they told me they are terrified that their classmates are going to use their images in a way that is violating their rights. I am a member of this Committee, Education and Workforce. I am a member of the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology, where I will note there is also an AI hearing happening right now, and I also served as bipartisan member of the AI Task Force. I have heard and raised questions for years about security bias, the ethical use of AI and also the challenges of enforcing violations of civil rights and privacy rights in the context of the use of AI. It is important to note that AI literacy is not just about how learning to use the tools, but also how to critically evaluate them, to critically evaluate AI through the lens of ethics, humanities, linguistics and other fields and perspectives that are often underrepresented in these conversations. Ms. Reeve Givens, first thank you for mentioning my bipartisan No Robot Bosses Act, which we have reintroduced in this Congress. Thank you to Representative Moylan of this Committee for cosponsoring that. It is H.R. 6371. I invite all my colleagues to sign on, to require employers who use automated decision systems to provide the specific disclosures. My question today is about the need for a broader perspective in AI, and what we need both in the short term and in the long term. I submit that it is not just technology skills as I mentioned. We need people with backgrounds and fluency and ethics and history, linguistics, humanities and other fields that develop. As Representative Wilson was saying, critical thinking skills. How will these perspectives and backgrounds help to equip students and workers and employers to better develop, but also responsibly use AI and navigate its challenges, but also its opportunities? Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you so much for that question and for your leadership on these issues. I think the way that you frame it is exactly right. To make good on the promise of this technology, we have to have a long view on what some of the immediate--both what some of the immediate and long term risks can be, and have that grounded in the people with appropriate subject matter expertise. The subject matter expertise is not just AI; it is learning science. It is student emotional well-being. It is privacy and security. Then in different domains, when workers are now having automated management systems, those workers also have domain expertise, where the AI can be used to enhance their skills. They need a voice in how it is being deployed for them to really make good on that specialization and that promise. Just to reinforce some of the concerns that you are raising about the use of AI in schools, I will say that our survey data very much reinforces what you are saying, which is that, you know 72 percent of parents, 71 percent of teachers do worry that AI will diminish students' critical thinking skills. They are really thinking actively about what training is needed for teachers and teachers are asking for more. Of course, it is about how to use these tools and how it can help them in the classroom. It is also necessary to underscore what the potential risks can be, and how teachers can play a role in mitigating those harms. Ms. Bonamici. You actually anticipated my next question, which was about how the lack of educator professional development, which you established. I mean I have read the statistics in your testimony. It is pretty concerning. How does that increase the risk of students not only improperly using AI, but experiencing privacy and security violations? Ms. Reeve Givens. Well, in two different ways. First of all, Mr. Khan put it perfectly when he said that teachers really can play an important role helping steward students through this transition, helping them understand how to use these tools, how to think critically about them. The teachers need to be prepared to do that. One of the I think things that is important to emphasize here is right now just the lack of transparency in a lot of the ed tech products around how they address some of these concerns. Mr. Khan also spelled out what some of those considerations can and should be. Are these tools grounded in learning science? Have they been tested for bias? Are they--do they have appropriate guardrails for use by young people? What are their security and privacy protections? Right now, we do not have a standardized rubric. I will say that CDT has published one. We have an a rubric of eight factors and have assessed a hundred ed tech vendors against it. We are still just not seeing disclosures around this. That is stopping educators both at the teacher level, but also at the school administrator level, making informed decisions about what tools to use and have a much more evidence-based conversation around this progress. Ms. Bonamici. I appreciate that very much. I also note that this administration is trying to shut down the Department of Education and eliminate or extremely cut funding for things like Title II, which is professional development for educational research. We need that more than ever, especially in the age of AI, because we know we cannot achieve an AI-ready workforce without a national strategy, without a dedicated investments. We cannot lead, the world in AI by leaving students and educators and workers as an afterthought. As I yield back, Mr. Chairman, I am developing a comprehensive legislative framework to strengthen the teaching, learning and dignity of work in an AI-enabled economy, and I look forward to working with my colleagues on, I hope, on both sides of the AI literacy and workforce readiness, while protecting privacy and security rights and I yield back. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady. I recognize the Chairwoman Emeritus of this Committee, Ms. Foxx from North Carolina. Ms. Foxx. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and I want to thank our witnesses for being here today. This really is an important topic that we all need to be concerned about. Ms. Nayak, based on your work leading certifications and the jobs platform of OpenAI, what is one major misconception policymakers often have about how AI will transform credentialing and hiring? Why does that misconception matter for workforce and education policy decisions? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congresswoman. I think one major misconception is the speed at which jobs will be impacted by AI. What we are really seeing right now in terms of the trends that we are looking at is rather than jobs being lost immediately, rather jobs are being augmented, and we are seeing people start to introduce AI tools into their everyday workflows, like getting writing advice, guidance, rather than kind of taking over their whole roles. What that means for certifications and our jobs platform is now is the time to give AI worker skills, and we think we can do that through our certifications effort. Then, if we are able to build on the fact that people are already coming to AI to learn, we can certify them to learn, then we can actually work with the economy, work with employers to actually then connect them to opportunities that leverage those skills. I think that will help us transition, and I think it will be a lot less of just this kind of rip of the band-aid, where people, you know, lose their jobs immediately. Ms. Foxx. It is unfortunate. We were not able to pass a bill yesterday that would employees the opportunity to work more on their skill development using AI, without it impinging upon their employer. I have another question for you. There are many conversations happening around automation versus augmentation in an AI-enabled workplace. Could you speak on what you believe will be the durable skills workers need to develop--to succeed in an AI future, and how AI technology can help develop those skills? Ms. Nayak. Yes. One of the things that we are doing with our certifications effort is we are building a series of courses called AI Foundations. We think those will be the foundational skills that people need to be able to effectively use AI. Our coursework starts with AI Foundations. This one is focused on ChatGPT, which is how do you actually prompt engineer a model? How do you work with a model to co-develop outcomes? Our second course will focus on applied AI skills. How do you actually use models in being able to create AG agentic workflows? I spent a lot of time with frontline workers, and that is actually the course they are most excited for because they see it as being able to take on parts of their job that they really do not like doing. I spoke to people unloading trucks at kind of large department stores, and they really want to automate the workflow of choosing which truck to kind of offload first. Rather than having to, you know, decide themselves and then make the wrong decision and cost the company money. The third course will focus on how do you actually teach others around you AI, and I think this speaks a lot to, what Mr. Khan was saying about leveraging AI in the classroom and being able to enable people to train others. We are looking at an AI leadership and training course, where people actually learn skills like responsibility in AI and how do you effectively train others around you to co- leverage AI with you. We think those are the three foundational courses, and then our hope is to actually build those out to more specialized courses for industries. Ms. Foxx. Great. Thank you very much. Mr. Frazier, your written testimony points to several sources of information for data on AI's impact on the workforce. You say these sources point only--paint only some of the picture. Should robust information gathering and information sharing on AI's impact begin in the private or public sector? Mr. Frazier. Thank you very much for that question, Congresswoman. I think that we need to put a all hands on deck mentality approach to data gathering at this point. If you talk to any good economist, they will tell you first they do not know what is going on in the economy, because we do not have enough information about who is adopting which tools and to what ends. Having updates to our information-gathering techniques, starting with, for example, the Contingent Worker Survey at the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This is issued on an ad hoc basis. There was a gap from 2017 to 2023, for example. We know that the gig economy in that window transformed tremendously. Let us start both with issuing more frequent calls for information, and also making it easier for companies, private sector entities to submit and share information. I believe that AI will facilitate that process, and I believe that we can make sure that we aggregate and anonymize that data, such that compliance rates are pretty high. Ms. Foxx. I have a short followup, and I will ask you to just submit the information later. Please let us know if there are ways we can encourage information sharing that will benefit both sectors. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady, and I recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. Takano. Mr. Takano. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. Mr. Frazier, I would like to begin with you. In your testimony, you predict that AI will generally accelerate workforce trends that were ``already underway before ChatGPT.'' You predict that the future of work will look far more like a gig economy than a multi-decade career at a single firm. Can you expand on the workforce trends you described that will be accelerated by AI? Mr. Frazier. Yes. Thank you very much for that question, Congressman. I want to start first with the trend that we're seeing called fissuring. Fissuring was coined by David Weil, who is a member of the Department of Labor, last administration. This is the idea that we are seeing more and more lead companies think massive Fortune 500 company segmenting off certain tasks and skills to what he labels subsidiary organizations. That janitorial service that used to work at Alphabet, for example, is now purely done on a contractual basis, not housed within Alphabet itself. As we see this fissuring of the economy, the result is that these subsidiary organizations are held to high standards of efficiency and effectiveness, which means they need to find laborers who can come help out on a project to project or short term basis and fulfill that very specific niche skill portfolio. As workers adjust to this fissuring concept, and as they adjust to the fractionalization of work generally, they will need to maintain a portfolio of skills so that when the next opportunity pops up or that new project arises, they are able to find a organization that wants to hire them for that purpose. Mr. Takano. This is what you mean by the gigification of work, that there is a series of gigs? Mr. Frazier. I am not sure if I use that term, but if I did, yes. The gigification will result more or less in people not working for a single entity for multiple years. I will point out we are already seeing this, for example, among Gen Z. The average job tenure of a member of Gen Z within the first 5 years of their career is 1.1 years. They are not sticking around for a very long time. Mr. Takano. Well so to clarify, you are saying that with the integration of AI into workplaces, American workers will have much more varied employment structures and arrangements and less of the traditional 9 to 5; is that correct? Mr. Frazier. Very much correct. I think we already see, for example, that there are 71 million workers who have opted into independent work. Mr. Takano. Okay. Well, given those rapid changes to the labor market and whether Americans thrive or not will depend on whether labor laws and protections evolve alongside the economy. This graph that I have behind me shows the trends of in the U.S. labor productivity, about labor productivity over the last 50 years, with this orange line here, you know, showing that productivity, it shows an increase. Mr. Frazier, what would you project that orange line, that orange productivity line to look like over the next 50 years if we continue on our current trajectory with the implementation of AI? Mr. Frazier. I would project that we continue to see increases in labor productivity over time. As we have noted previously, economists are looking at the integration of AI into the workplace, and we are seeing that in many regards it is augmenting work, increasing productivity, because AI is not at a point where it is automating every single task. Instead, it is leaving a number of tasks that require human in intervention, making those tasks more valuable and more remunerative. Mr. Takano. Well, so we can expect that productivity to increase potential, some would say even exponentially. The line that I am concerned with, however, the most is the blue dotted line, which represents real hourly compensation. As you can see, workers' wages have not kept up with the increases in their productivity. In fact, they have increased only about 30 percent in 50 years, while productivity has increased by nearly 90 percent. This huge disparity has been a major factor in the increase of wealth inequality in the United States. As we speed toward a future in which AI is a standard feature of the workplace, we must ensure that the benefits of this increased productivity are reaped by the workers, not just tech executives in the shareholder class. Although AI presents an enormous opportunity, the real risks of worker displacement and increased wealth inequality must be addressed head on. Mr. Chair, I ask for unanimous consent to enter this letter from AFSCME on behalf of 1.4 million of their members, underscoring this point. Chairman Walberg. Without objection. [The letter of Mr. Takano follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Takano. Now one clear solution is through the strengthening of labor protections, a higher minimum wage, increased overtime threshold, and protected right to organize will be key to ensuring that AI benefits all of us, rather than making this gap, this gap here larger. My 32-hour work week proposal, my 32-hour work week bill, addresses the need for greater work protections in the new economy, the new American economy. My bill, which will be reintroduced this year, would amend the Fair Labor Standards Act to make the standard work week 32 hours rather than the 40 hours with no reduction in pay. If the future of work is one with much higher output per worker, varied employment arrangements and a trend toward a gig economy, then our baseline labor laws must adapt as well. AI presents an enormous opportunity for American workers, but AI should be seen as a tool that works for workers and not--instead of against them. Thank you, and I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlemen. Just to make sure I took notes correctly, Mr. Frazier. Fissuring or fittering? Mr. Frazier. Fissuring. Chairman Walberg. Fissuring. Mr. Frazier. Fissuring, yes. Chairman Walberg. I am still hurting from Michigan's loss to your school, so I was not---- Mr. Frazier. Blame Arch Manning on that one. Not, not my fault. Chairman Walberg. Okay. Fissuring. Thank you. Now I recognize the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman. Mr. Grothman. Yes. Ms. Nayak, you talk a little bit about credentialism. How do you view a credential, or what does that mean? I mean if I am looking to hire somebody and I want to know if they are familiar with this new certifications, who determines this? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. For the credentials that we are building here at OpenAI, what we are hoping to do is create several credentials, an AI Foundations credential and then credentials that are focused on industries. Mr. Grothman. Who runs these things? Ms. Nayak. OpenAI is running it, but with a partnership of employers, NGO's, as well as universities. We are kind of partnering across a coalition to build a credential. Mr. Grothman. Okay. How do you envisualize that I succeed in that credential? Do I have to take a class? Does my employer just say ``Glen knows how to do this? He does it very well. We think he's okay.'' I mean credentialism is always a potential problem, I think. I do not like it, but I just wondered how say 5 years from now, how do you get an AI credential? Going to college, you know? Being trained at work? How do you envisualize that? Ms. Nayak. Yes. Thank you, Congressman. The way that we think about credentials is we have a course that is structured, and it is actually accessible on ChatGPT. ChatGPT is actually taking that curriculum, personalizing it to the user, understanding their needs and then it is actually judging them on their ability to retain the material, similar to how a teacher would in a class. The difference is that it is immensely scalable, because anyone can access it and, you know, it is personalized to them. Mr. Grothman. Therefore, it is something that is unrelated to say what we have a formal college degree today? Ms. Nayak. It could actually be related. A lot of credentials. Mr. Grothman. It would not have to be, I will put it that way. It would not have to be. Ms. Nayak. It would not have to be. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I will ask the other company. We will move over one. Do you think we need more credential in this field? I will put it this way. When you see people being hired, is the employer looking for some sort of credential or is it just I am looking at your resume, and you say you are Mr. An Expert in AI. That is good. You must be doing in your current job. Right now, how is an AI skill being determined? Mr. Khan. Yes. Internally, we are a fast-growing company, and we are hiring folks and we certainly value certain skills, like potentially the use of generative AI. One component of all of our interviews and our processes is doing on the job work as a part of the process. We pay prospective employees for that work, and we do not prohibit them from using generative AI in that work. Rather than saying you can or cannot use it, we are saying what is the quality of the final outcome? If you use generative AI a lot and the final outcome of that product is really high quality, fantastic. If you did not use it at all and it is super high quality, fantastic. The focus is on the quality of the work, rather than whether or not you use generative AI. Mr. Grothman. Okay. You have--there is no credential right now and it does not affect how your business operates. Mr. Frazier, kind of same questions down that line. Mr. Frazier. Yes. Something I think that is important to add to this conversation Congressman, is the importance of thinking about alternative ways for firms to experience bringing on a new employee, for example, through apprenticeships. Right now, we have about 600,000 apprenticeships across the U.S. I think we could drastically increase that number, to make sure that folks have an on ramp to demonstrating and showing their capacity of certain skills. I would also argue that in this context, we always have to be asking compared to what? Right now, our main credentialing approach is through 4 year universities. I am not going to talk about my own curve that I have to apply to my test, but I will tell you that at other universities, you will find at the end of the term, a professor has one of two options, A or B. When everyone has a 4.0, it is very difficult to assess if that 200 grand in higher education was worth the signaling costs. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Now I will give you another question. On AI, as we generate things, there can be a viewpoint with what is generated. It could affect how one looks at religion. It could affect how someone looks at politics. It could affect how someone looks at history. One of the things that scares me as people get a hold of this, that you will affect or you will push a politically correct view on all these topics. Is this a concern, and how do we deal with it? Mr. Frazier. Briefly, I will say this is very much a concern. I think that how you make a cake is the same way you make AI. It involves a lot of ingredients, it then involves a lot of taste. The different taste of certain individuals will manifest in that outcome. The best way forward, though, is not to impose certain top-down views on what models have to do or what they must be trained by, but in my opinion fostering competition. In the same way you walk down a movie aisle and you can find a movie for every taste or for every genre, we should make it so that American consumers have access to a wide range of tools with a wide range of perspectives. Chairman Walberg. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the gentlelady from Georgia, Ms. McBath. Ms. McBath. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. There are few issues that stand to be as impactful to our society as AI projects to be in the coming decades. From our schools to our job sites and hospital systems and everything in between, AI is already changing not just the activities that people do in these places, but how we do them. We are living through another Industrial Revolution, so to speak, and Congress must provide clarity, which I hope we are able to do today for states and ensure that Americans understand how to make AI work best for them. In Gwinnett County in Georgia, where I reside, the largest school district in Georgia, kindergartners at some schools have already begun to use AI combined with Legos in classroom to solve some problems. At five and 6 years old, they may not understand what AI stands for just yet, but they know how to use it already and they understand that it will also be a big part of their future. Programs like Gwinnett's Computer Science for All ensure that children are made comfortable with using AI at a very young age, and that they understand how important it is. These applications can also be used to make funny videos, but it is so important that we cut out the noise for our students and help them understand how our world is changing and what it really means for them. AI has incredible potential to be a positive force in society, but that does not happen on its own. Congress must ensure that people who lose work and possibly their only source of income because of these changes, they cannot be left behind. We have seen this before. We cannot allow what happened to the factories and the mills across this country to happen to other parts of our economy as well. When these jobs die, the communities that rely on them they die a slow death as well, drawn out deaths alongside them. The disappearance of good paying jobs that did not require people to go into huge amounts of debt to get them is why the American worker makes less today than they did in the 1990's, is why there is so much frustration in this country about the cost of living, about how difficult it has become just to afford the things that used to be commonplace for middle and working families across this country. This cannot be the norm when it comes to automation, and dare I say innovation. It has only become more expensive for people in this country to get the skills necessary to afford a decent life. I am deeply concerned that if not implemented correctly, AI might not achieve its full potential to make life better for people. Instead, it could make it even more difficult for people just to provide for themselves or just to put food on the table. There are millions of Americans who have done everything right and have nothing in this country to show for it despite going to school, paying for a degree of some kind or learning directly on the job. Many Americans find themselves no closer to the financial freedom and independence they put all of their effort toward to begin with. With that comes feelings of shame, feelings of resentment toward only our, not only yourself but the system that you put faith in. Ms. Reeve Givens, what sectors of our economy and occupations are the most at risk for displacement? Can you give your best estimate for when we might begin to see major disruptions or significant drops in the numbers of jobs that are going to be available for real people? Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you for your question. I think one of the things that ties together nicely from every witness down this dais, I think we're hearing that improved training in AI skills really matters, but it is only one piece of the pie. If Congress only focuses on that piece, they are overlooking ways that we really can have an AI ready economy and society. To answer your question specifically on worker displacement, this is less the focus of my organization. We follow the research closely, and a lot of the research does focus on tasks such as in the office and administrative occupation sector. One of the unusual turns that we are seeing is that this is less about the changing of jobs in kind of the factory worker space, although I think that may come as well. Most immediately with generative AI, we are seeing displacement of tasks for things that do relate to kind of office administration, et cetera. Research from the Brookings report says that 30 percent of all workers could see as many as 50 percent of their occupational tasks disrupted over time. While that does not necessarily mean full displacement and as Professor Frazier said we are still seeing how the evidence bears out, this does point to significant changes, including in this class of administrative occupations, which have been the pathway to upward mobility for many people across our society, including those without college degrees and overwhelmingly women as well. It is a new group of people for whom we have to think about the significant transformational change. Those also tend to be communities that are not organized as a union or have representation. Again, we need to think about how we protect those rights. Ms. McBath. Thank you very much. I am out of time. Chairman Walberg. The gentlelady's time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from the Master's Golf Tournament and Chair of the HELP Subcommittee, Mr. Allen. Mr. Allen. Thank you, Chairman Walberg for holding this hearing. I want to thank our witnesses for your expertise on this important topic today. Ms. Nayak, from OpenAI's perspective, and we are talking about worker skills and credentials here, what would it take for these skills and credentials to be more transferrable across jobs, industries or regions? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. What we think will make these credentials really transferable and certainly the way that we are building them is we are building a foundational set of courses that we are calling AI Foundations. Then we are making it so that they can be adapted by industry. As an example, we have our AI Foundations course, but we are partnering with employers like Walmart and Lowe's to think about how can we adapt that course to frontline workers. How can we adapt it to administrative workers and office workers? How can we adapt it to AI builders who are actually using AI to build tools for those workforces? The way that we approach it is you build the foundation, but then with AI you can truly make those courses adaptable to different industries. Mr. Allen. Mr. Khan, I have long believed in the importance of the family and education. Parents should make the final decision on their child's education, and responsible parents are key to making sure students get the education, their children get the education they need. That principle is especially important when it comes to AI, because these tools can often be accessed in the home. What advice would you give to parents who want to make sure their students are using AI responsibly? Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question, Congressman. For families, I think it is really important that they are having the conversation at the kitchen table, you know. What are the ways that you are seeing generative AI affect your life as a child in school? Some of the dangers that we have heard of generative AI today in the hearing are things that should be brought up and questioned and understood. I think that having generative AI be a topic of conversation and an education that is granted not only for teachers, but also for families. Literacy for generative AI is incredibly important for schools and teachers, those who are, you know, imparting this wisdom upon kids about how this technology works and the risks and benefits. You know, second to the teacher in the school, the family also is a really important part of a child's, success in the future. I will speak to just, I will try to make this as quick as possible, but a story from when I was a teacher. This was right when social media was taking off. We were seeing cyber bullying rampant in our schools, and families didn't know what to do. Their kids were coming home crying, you know, worried about, you know, are they going to get bullied on Instagram or Snapchat. I actually held at our school building an information session for families, to teach them about the social media tools that their children were using, that they were just happening under the feet of parents. They did not even know that these--this is before Instagram had really taken off and, you know, helping parents become informed guardians of how they choose their own children's use or not use of technology. My recommendation was you probably should not have your middle school child using these apps. You know, when you do not even know what those apps are, it becomes really, really challenging. The school building ends up again being a really powerful place for families to learn about this technology, and to make their own informed choices about how their kids will or will not engage with technology. You know, so many years later, we are seeing cell phone bans in schools. We knew this 20 years ago. We knew this should not have been something that was a part of the school environment. We cannot repeat the same mistakes of the past with generative AI. Mr. Allen. Right. Mr. Khan. We need to get families informed, schools informed, teachers informed and we can write a different script for the future of how this technology plays out for our children. Mr. Allen. That is great. Well, thank you for sharing that story. Mr. Frazier, according to a poll published in October, 40 percent of American voters cite cost of living concerns as the No. 1 issue in the upcoming midterm elections. You have made the case that AI will make life more affordable for everyday Americans. How do you believe this technology addresses affordability concerns? Can you give some current examples, or examples that come--will come in the near future? We got about 22 seconds, sir. Mr. Frazier. To describe the full benefits of AI in terms of affordability in 20 seconds is quite the tall order. I will direct you to an oped from me and Adam Thierer in The Hill on affordability in AI. For right now, I will just bring one very short story. The University of Texas at Houston Health System used AI to predict when folks were going to miss their appointments. They saved $250,000 in one quarter. Many Americans cannot afford healthcare. We should be exploring, for example in healthcare, how we can automate and improve scribing and so many activities that increase our medical costs. Mr. Allen. That is a great example. Be--feel free to submit more in writing that would benefit the Committee. Mr. Chairman, I apologize for running over. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I recognize the gentlelady from Pennsylvania, Ms. Lee. Ms. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I represent Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania, a region that reflects both past innovation and manufacturing and steel, and of course future advancement and technology as an emerging artificial intelligence hub. My district embodies the evolution of industry and adapting to new technologies, and also represent communities that were left behind by innovations in industry, communities that are still reeling from harms in the legacy of redlining and underinvestment. I am here today to urge us to not repeat some of the errors of the past. AI's algorithms are trained with human data, right? We know and we can recognize that. They learn every bias and every inequity that is already entrenched in our society. It is the responsibility of this body to ensure that AI is not weaponized as the next tool to streamline systemic discrimination. Republicans love to talk about the cost of regulation, that businesses will be bogged down when spending on compliance standards that will hinder innovation. What about the cost to say a child who was traumatized by a police encounter because their clarinet or a bag of chips was mistaken for a gun, by their AI's, the school's AI weapon detection system, or the child that will have AI generated images of themselves living on in the perpetuity on the Internet, that folks would be able to see for the rest of that child's life. What about the person who is misidentified, and then docs because a facial recognition system cannot tell black people apart? What about a person who does not get a job because of the AI screening tool being used discriminates against their application? How do we quantify those costs? Nearly 90 percent of companies are using some form of AI for initial job candidate screening. Ms. Reeve Gibbons, are these companies required by Federal law to conduct ongoing audits of algorithmic bias or testing for compliance for civil rights law? Ms. Reeve Givens. Not yet. They are liable if they are discriminating against candidates. This is why it is in the interest of employers, as well as workers, for us to have a far more rigorous approach to auditing requirements, to transparency requirements, so that employers too are not buying snake oil products or products that are inadvertently or intentionally discriminating against people that are applying for jobs. Ms. Lee. Definitely. I appreciate that. I agree. For those who are not, you know, how are we to be sure that the tools that they are using are not exacerbating systemic inequities in hiring? Ms. Reeve Givens. There are a couple different pieces to this story, and one is the urgency with which employers need to understand what is at stake when they are using these tools, the need for them to use them responsibly. Not just say that as a hand wavy statement, but genuinely take concrete actions. My organization and others have set out a good list of best practices. The EEOC, the Department of Labor have also put out similar guidance for employers, on how to be compliant with employment laws and not discriminate. The things that they require are things like notice to workers so you know how you are being tested, and knowing how you are being evaluated. Have you done appropriate auditing? Are you checking the system after it is being used in the workplace? All of these are very common-sense things. It is not burdensome red tape. It is simple things to make sure that these tools actually work in the way that they are intended, and all workers can be considered equally. Ms. Lee. Thank you. If I could add to that, the AI Civil Rights Act, the bill I introduced with Congresswoman Yvette Clarke and Senator Ed Markey, and then the Eliminating Bias in Algorithmic Systems Act is a bill that I am going to be introducing this week with Senator Markey again. It will put real guardrails in place that demand action toward transparency and accountability and strong civil rights protections, because we cannot afford to do nothing here. Mr. Khan, last summer Common Sense Media identified racial bias in Magic School's AI generated behavior intervention plans. In light of these findings, of course, you all said that you were going to work to improve your bias detection systems, yet your website still lists both behavior intervention suggestions and behavior intervention generator under all teacher tools. If I could ask, why has Magic School not removed the behavior intervention tools as you work to ensure they are not racially biased? Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question, Ms. Lee. I was in Pittsburgh recently, meeting with educators who love Magic School. One, we attempted to replicate the findings in that study around racial bias in those tools. We were unable to replicate those findings, but we did request from Common Sense their data. We still do not--we still stand behind our tool. We do not believe that there is racial bias in our tools. We do receive feedback. We serve schools and districts all over the country. I have worked in schools and districts all over the country, and we value equity and strive to remove bias in any of our tools. Ms. Lee. Thank you. I can appreciate that, and I just hope for, you know obviously for the sake of the students, that that is true. What was found there could be concerning, but it also replicates some of the findings that we had just in every-- everyday interactions with students, that students who are black or brown or poor or students with disability are more likely to be punished more harshly. I would not be shocked, but I appreciate you all looking into that with urgency, and also, of course, trying to innovate in ways that will be helpful in the future. It is important that we continue this work. It is important that we do it in responsible ways. With that, I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady, and I recognize the Vice Chairman of the Committee, as well as the Subcommittee Chair for Higher Education and Workforce Development, very interested in this topic, Mr. Owens. Mr. Owens. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, I appreciate this very timely hearing, as we embark probably one of the more exciting times in our history, in our country's history. Before I get started, I just wanted to talk about preparing for our much needed and robust workforce, to highlight the Department of Education launch The Connecting Talents for Opportunity Challenge yesterday. It marks a crucial first step in modernizing our workforce by connecting the worker skills and credentials to education and job opportunities. I want to thank President Trump and the secretary McMahon for their support on this initiative, and look forward to seeing its further development. Ms. Nayak, and from your work on certification of job platforms, how important is interoperable learning employment records for making AI-enabled hiring actually work at scale? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. At OpenAI, we think interoperability is essential for our credential work, as well as for our jobs platform, because it will mean that people can leverage multiple platforms. They can get educated, get skilled, but they can take it with them. One of the things that we are doing for our certifications platform is we are connecting to technologies that allow people to take their credentials with them, and then they can use across their resumes, across their portfolios with employers, and employers will be able to also validate those skills. We believe that interoperability is quite important. Mr. Owens. I think that term should be highlighted as something that the American people need to be educated on, because we hear that, we talk about it. We have no idea that the reason we can now talk from iPhone to Android is because of interoperability. Very, very important point. Mr. Khan, I understand the immense potential that AI presents in classroom for teachers and students. However, I know there are concerns when teachers utilize tools that they are not experts in. When students employ AI outside the educational uses, I think you kind of touched on this a little bit earlier, but how can schools better protect and prepare educators and students to use AI safely and constructive purposes on scale? Mr. Khan. We believe that it starts with, training educators, investing in educator literacy around generative AI, both you know, how the technology works, the risks and benefits of the technology. An informed educator, one who is equipped to answer questions for students who are in, you know, are experiencing this technology, whether they have chosen to or not through platforms not only like the generative AI platforms that we are talking about today, but also AI as it is embedded in their daily lives on platforms that they might not associate with this AI revolution, things like TikTok, Instagram, you know. How are algorithms, you know, incentivized to keep you on the platform? You know, how are you experiencing generative AI in your daily life? I am a big believer that a rich life is not staring at your cell phone 24-7. A rich life is engaging in the world, and sometimes when we can educate educators and they can inform students on how, you know, sometimes involuntarily you are finding yourself glued to a screen and it is because of AI algorithms that are powering this, it empowers a student to make better choices about how they engage with technology. We think that it starts with educators and bringing that to the forefront of an education. Technology is so embedded in our lives today. Often, as mentioned, it is involuntary. We need to give students and teachers the information that creates agency for their own lives. Mr. Owens. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Frazier, your written testimony recommends that Congress thoroughly examine AI usage across the economy to create evidence-based policies. What are some of the recommendations that you would offer to strengthen our data-gathering efforts? Mr. Frazier. Thank you very much for that question, Congressman. I think first and foremost, we need to make sure we are gathering data on a more frequent basis. We are seeing that AI tools of greater degrees of sophistication are being deployed at a faster and faster pace. Making sure that our data collection keeps up or at least attempts to keep up with that pace of AI development makes a tremendous amount of sense. I would also say making sure we are collecting data from across the entire private sector. Right now, there is a lot of focus on how major Fortune 500 companies are using AI, but we have long known that small businesses are the main driver of economic opportunity and job creation in our country. Better understanding the fact that, for example, right now, just 9 percent of small firms are using AI. We are missing out on tremendous potential to help these entrepreneurs and innovators scale up their opportunities and hire more Americans. Then finally, I would make sure we are doing it in a way that is standardized and anonymized. Companies should not be punished for champion innovation and by leaning into AI. We need to make sure this data is stored and maintained and shared in a way that champions innovation and does not punish those leading in. Mr. Owens. Thank you. I agree. The small business owners, that is where we drive our culture. We need to make sure they are part of this process. Thank you so much, and I yield back, Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlemen. I now recognize the gentlelady from North Carolina, Ms. Adams. Ms. Adams. Thank you Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our witnesses for being here. Artificial intelligence is already reshaping our classrooms and our workplaces, whether we are ready for it or not. Students are using it, employers are using it and the Federal Government is still trying to catch up. In North Carolina, universities are racing to launch AI majors and research centers, not just to meet the workforce demand, but out of fear of being left behind. That urgency raises an important question. Are we building sustainable pathways for students or simply chasing the next academic gold rush? Today, I want to recognize Ms. Verjeana McCotter-Jacobs, who is the CEO of the National School Board Association in the audience. I thank her for being here. She is leading the charge to ensure that school board members are also prepared to create AI policies in K12 schools, and thank you so much for being here. Building an AI-ready America is not just about speed. It is about trust. It is about fairness and who gets left behind when decisions are automated without guardrails. That is where this conversation matters. Let me just turn to our witnesses. Ms. Reeve Givens, a recent survey found that 62 percent of higher education leaders estimate that fewer than half of their faculty are using AI tools, while students are adopting them rapidly, often without guidance. From your perspective, what risk does this uneven adoption create for students and educators, and how should institutions and the Federal Government think about supporting responsible AI use without forcing adoption or lowering academic standards? Ms. Reeve Givens. When we think about how to make sure that AI brings everybody along across our society and economy, I think there are two different ways to think about this. One is about equitable access. Who can use these tools, who are getting the skills and the benefits? Two is making sure that these schools are not unintentionally creating greater divides, either through discrimination or bias, or harmful uses of this technology, and we need to make sure we are focusing on both. The first about equitable access, our research shows that even as we studied K through 12 schools, 85 percent of teachers and 86 percent of students are using AI, there are big discrepancies when you start going in on a geographic basis and on an income level as well. How do we think about the digital divide, and I guess addressing those gaps. On the difference that you described in colleges, of students getting more familiar with this technology than their professors may well be, all of this comes again to the notion of how do you prepare educators to be teaching the workers and the citizens of tomorrow, and realizing that they do need to become familiar with this technology? Again, the point I made earlier, this is not just about the tips and tricks to make AI help you do your job better, although that is very important. It is also taking a more sophisticated understanding of how AI is transforming learning and mitigating potential risks. Ms. Adams. Right. Thank you. The Center for Democracy and Technology has been tracking the use of automated decision tools, systems that make high-stakes decisions about hiring, promotions or access to credit, often without human review. What concerns you most about the use of these tools in the workplace, and do you believe that the Federal Government has a role in setting baseline protections so that that automation does not quietly reproduce discrimination or shut out workers in terms of opportunity? Ms. Reeve Givens. The use of AI in hiring and other decisions about employment is rapidly proliferating, and of course there are efficiency reasons why employers are motivated to use these tools. If the tools are not rigorously examined and tested, there are real risks of them perpetuating discrimination, because they are learning based on the historical data of who has been employed or also perpetuating snake oil. In my testimony I talked about in AI video interview. This is a real example, where the person spoke in German instead of English and was still deemed a good match for the job. This tells you that employers do not necessarily know what they are buying. Workers definitely do not know what they are being tested about. Transparency, rigorous testing and then avenues for redress are hugely important. Ms. Adams. Thank you. Quickly, how should policymakers think about preparing students for an AI-driven economy in a way that emphasizes AI literacy, critical thinking and ethics, rather than narrow technical skills that may quickly become obsolete? Ms. Reeve Givens. I am not an educator, but my impression is parents, teachers and students care about this a lot. One of the things we need to focus on is realizing AI is a tool. You are still the person that needs to be engaging in critical thought. Understanding that comprehensive approach of when AI can help, but also its inherent limitations and the need for safeguards to make sure that it is being used responsibly and well, that is the complete package, that we need to make sure teachers are being resourced, to provide to their students as well as, of course, using these tools responsibly themselves when they are using it in an education setting. Ms. Adams. Great. Thank you very much. I am out of time, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady and I recognize the Subcommittee Chairman of the Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education, the gentleman from California, Mr. Kiley. Mr. Kiley. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I wanted, Ms. Nayak, to ask you a little bit about the certification, program that OpenAI has, which I think is really interesting, in equipping people with, you know, the skills to effectively use AI tools in the workplace. It seems that one of the challenges you face is that, you know, the capabilities are continually increasing and, you know, you guys are always putting out new models and new features. You know, what a certification certifies today may, you know, not necessarily reflect what use can be made of your tools, you know, a week from now, a month from now, a year from now. How do you manage the certification program in light of the ever increasing capabilities of your models? Ms. Nayak. Congressman, this is something that we talk about quite a bit internally, and there is two modes that we are going to use to address this. One is you are certainly correct that, you know, we release new models, we release new tools and technologies pretty much on a weekly basis. We talk a lot internally about how we can make sure that our courses can actually adapt as we actually introduce these new tools. AI is actually helping us do that, where we are working rapidly to leverage AI in building these courseworks, just like we put it in the hands of teachers, to be able to build these courses, to be able to adapt as fast as possible to the new products that we are putting out. That is No. 1, is actually having the course grow with the technology. No. 2 is when we think about actually giving someone a certification, how do we make sure that that certification follows them as technology changes rather than, you know, they get the certification once and then they are done, and then 3 months from now they no longer have that skill. The way that we are thinking about it is unlike certifications today, which are a course that you take, an end post that you get and then you get that certification, our certifications will actually grow with the user as they use ChatGPT. Our north star there, we are not there yet, but we are hoping to get there as fast as possible, is actually enabling people to get certified as they are leveraging the platform so that certification will actually assess over time that they are actually building the new skills as the technology is changing. We are really hopeful about that. We think that we can use AI as a tool to actually grade and certify people along the way, so that it is actually pretty nimble to the technology as well. Mr. Kiley. Yes, very interesting. I know what a challenge that must be. You talked about the capability overhang when it comes to adoption in industry. I think there is also something, maybe a more extreme overhang when it comes to the policy side of things, where a lot of the debates we have are about, you know, a State of the technology that we have already passed. On the Education Subcommittee, we have been looking at AI and education, and I am very optimistic about the opportunity. I will bring you into this as well, Mr. Khan, of AI in education to close achievement gaps and to really transform learning. You know, sort of by definition, we are only able to look at what current tools are being used to do. I will start with you, Mrs. Nayak and then would love to hear your thoughts, Mr. Khan. Does OpenAI have a vision for sort of 5 years from now, given what the capabilities, the new modalities we might have, the different interfaces rather than the chatbot interface, what education might look like in an AI, you know, with the progression of AI tools? Then I would love your thoughts as well, Mr. Khan. Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. Yes. We think that AI will augment the systems and structures that we have in place and ideally make them a lot more personalized and a lot more focused on the individual learner. I think that we are already certainly seeing this with efforts like Magic School. What we are doing is in a couple of lanes. One is that we actually need to teach teachers how to use our tools, so that they can actually design curriculum that leverages AI and help their students learn AI as well. If we do that, then we can have certifications courses or even students can bring their curriculum from their schools into AI, and they can get personalized support. We think with that, we can actually grow the ability of teachers to impact so many more students, because it is like every student can get a personalized tutor. I think in the past, you know, that was only accessible to the select few who had the means to be able to do that. With workers and with students, again we think that AI will be able to support them in personalization. We are already seeing this trend. 30 percent of conversations today are people actually going to ChatGPT to learn and that is across workers, students. What we see is that we are actually allowing access to education at a level never seen before. Then if we can capture what people are learning as they have access, we think that we will have kind of a microscope into what people actually know in a way that we never had before. Mr. Khan. I know we are running short on time. I think, you know, the example I gave earlier around personalized learning feedback for every single student at scale can move outcomes for students. We have seen test scores improve when a student gets personalized writing feedback, rather than, you know, in the moment that they finish writing something, rather than waiting two or 3 weeks for their teacher to get them feedback on the essays that they have given. We have this personalized learning AI tutoring type aspect that is true today. I think the way schools look, you know, 5 years from now is a lot more project based, where students can be equipped with generative AI tools and be centered in the classroom as builders. They are building and manifesting their own creative work, because they have these tools of the future alongside them. They can build their own apps, they can help their--my dad was an HVAC technician. I would have helped him build his website for his business and maybe the CRM that helped him to keep track of his clients. Lots of builder experiences we see in the future. Mr. Kiley. Thank you. I think it is very exciting if we get it right. I yield back to the Chair. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlemen. I recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. DeSaulnier. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you so much for this hearing. I am filled with possibilities and anxiety about our testimony. I appreciate all of you. I also want to point out to the Chair and thank you for--two of your witnesses are graduates of the University of California and Berkeley and neighbors. I do not know if you were---- Chairman Walberg. We planned that. Mr. DeSaulnier. Yes, and Ms. Nayak is a constituent who does not live far from me. In the context of the apprehension, Pew says that one in five American jobs will be displaced by AI. I think Rand--well, I know Rand did a study that said one in eight adolescents asked for mental health advice through chatbots, and that 50 percent of students feel disconnected from their school room environment and their teachers because of AI. That creates my apprehension. A proud representative of Bay Area district, which happens to be the fifth wealthiest in the country, a lot of that driven by technology and people like Ms. Nayak who live where a lot of this is happening. I also grew up in Lowell, Massachusetts, listening to my grandparents tell generational stories about working in the mills and technology and both how that was beneficial. It took a long time for America to catch up to some of the downfalls and enact minimum wage standards and child labor laws. I feel like we are in one of those moments. I have a lot of young people tell me about ghost jobs. Ms. Givens first, are we remotely prepared in your opinion--sorry to use that word-- just in terms of our social safety net, our workforce development? I can see it happening right now when I hear young people talk about ghost jobs, that they just--they are applying and the algorithms are just dismissing them. We know from research that up to half of those jobs are not real, that they are just people collecting data. Social media is protected by section-- by being immune from Section 230, amongst other reasons, this is exponentially getting worse. Ghost jobs and how young people are so disaffected from just trying to get jobs, particularly people who have taken on large student debt because they have been promised if they get a good education, there is great opportunity for them. Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you for the question. I think one of the things to focus on here is just the incredible rate of change. Mr. DeSaulnier. Right. Ms. Reeve Givens. It took over two decades for personal computers to be widely adopted. The adoption of generative AI by people has been significantly faster more, you know, over a billion users in the first 4 months of rollout in ways that speak to the promise of the technology, but also the speed with which we need to adapt. Pulling on a couple of the threads in your question, this role of, you know, AI in hiring. Yes, ghost jobs are one part of the problem. Also people, you know, you throw your resume into a pile and have no idea how you are being evaluated, even when it is a real employer at the other end of the funnel. How are you being evaluated? How are you being assessed? These video interviews where you are just being interviewed by an AI system without having any sense of what the outcome is going to be? That is one significant piece. It is also a clear intervention point. The U.S. has employment discrimination laws. We have robust laws here, but we need a lot more transparency for those laws to actually be enforced as well as a functioning Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The other part that I will add is the world that Professor Frazier was describing about gigification and what the future of the economy is going to look like. There are real tradeoffs when you think about career pathways, what professional development looks like, the community and identity that we get from being part of a workplace, and of course the questions around worker power. What does it mean to have a fair wage and to be able to negotiate when, as is already happening in some places, you are bidding for a job, you are bidding for a shift. The person that agrees to either take the most immediate uncomfortable time or to be paid the least as the person that gets that job. This is where our social safety net and our employment laws really have to accelerate rapidly, to be able to keep up with that new world order and make sure that we are thinking not only about productivity gains for the economy, but what does a resilient, self sufficient independent workforce look like? What is it for workers to have dignity and what are the safeguards that we need to help empower them in that way? Mr. DeSaulnier. Ms. Nayak, because you are a constituent, I want to ask you a question. I think of Emily Bender's work from the University of Washington. Her book is titled ``AI Con,'' and she gives the history about how private equity gets most of the benefit historically in our country. I have worked with the tech companies, I have worked with Facebook, but the promise in not inhibiting innovation, that challenge I have always felt, but self-regulation has not worked either. Could you address that very briefly? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. Yes, we do agree that there could be a capability overhang, where you do have this distance between the haves and the have nots that can leverage AI versus those that cannot. We think we are actually at a very critical moment to address that overhang, and that certifications and the ability to upskill people to be able to leverage AI, whether they be a small business owner, whether they be a student, whether they be, you know, someone working in big tech, is critical and that is what we are invested in. I think that the summary is that yes, you are 100 percent correct. We need to make sure that this technology is accessible to everyone. We think one of the ways that we can do that is by providing them the tools to learn about it, to use it in their everyday lives and then hopefully to profit from it not just, you know, the large corporation. Mr. DeSaulnier. Now that I know you are a neighbor, we will finish this conversation. You probably will regret meeting me, but---- Chairman Walberg. Thank you. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Onder. Mr. Onder. Thank you Mr. Chairman, and thanks to all the witnesses for appearing before the Committee today. I am very interested in what AI might have to offer to improve education. AI, I think, has an enormous potential in various areas of our economy to improve productivity. For example, as a physician, one of you alluded to radiology. Pathology is another area where AI can make the radiologist, the pathologist more productive and, you know, and let us face it, not miss some things that if it were just the naked eye, as well as decreasing administrative burden. It seems like more documentation is required by the year to make the electronic health records happy. I am concerned though, about potentially unintended consequences of AI, specifically in education because we are dealing here with young people. You know, a teacher recently told the New York Times ``The amount of time my students are inclined to work on something that challenges them has become much shorter over the past few years. There was a time when a typical student would wrestle with a concept for days before getting it. Now, if that student does not understand something within minutes, they are more likely to give up and look for an alternative, i.e. asking a chatbot.'' You know, the Ranking Member Scott cited an article from NPR today. It was citing a study by Brookings. Brookings did focus groups around the country, around the world, 50 different countries, of parents, students, educators and tech experts, as well as a literature review of hundreds of research articles. It found some positives and negatives. One of the positives was that AI can help children learn to read and write and that is, of course, great. At the same time, the study concluded in part AI poses a great threat to children's cognitive development. The concern was a ``doom loop'' of AI dependence, where students increasingly offload their own thinking onto technology, leading to the kind of cognitive decline or atrophy more commonly associated with the aging brain. They have commented that other technologies can do that too, for instance, word processors. It is on steroids with AI, you know. My concerns, I do not mean to pick on my AI experts here because I have similar concerns about Smartphones, about social media. You know, Steve Jobs in 2010 was asked by the New York Times ``How do your children like the iPad?'' He said ``My children don't have an iPad.'' We know many technology executives, Bill Gates, Neal Mohan, others, have limited their kids' use of technology. I would ask my witnesses, I would start with you, Ms. Nayak. How do we harness the potential benefits of AI and education, and yet protect our kids from the risk of overdependence and of--I even have concerns just if the computer is in front of the child every day, you know it seems almost 24-7, how do you how do you protect kids from all the horrific stuff we know is on the Internet? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. First, I want to start that OpenAI agrees with you, that we do really need to invest in protecting our youth and making sure that they use our technology for their benefit versus their harm. We are putting a lot of work, that is not my area of expertise, but we are putting a lot of work as a company into making sure that there are those guardrails. I do want to address kind of your statistics on AI usage and the harm it could cause. We are also seeing that it could cause immense benefit. We are seeing that one quarter of 18-to 24-year-olds use AI every day to help with their learning. That is about just general questions, tutoring, schoolwork. We are also seeing that, for instance, the study from Harvard University found that a physics class that actually had a tailored curriculum that was focused on using ChatGPT, found that students actually doubled their engagement and actually improved their problem-solving skills. I think you are right, that if teachers inadvertently kind of have students using AI, there could be ways where they cheat or they use it in ways that were not kind of meant for the course. If teachers can actually augment their curriculum to integrate it, I do think that there is promising ways that they could actually increase engagement, increase critical thinking and problem solving. Mr. Onder. Thank you. I do want to also point out, I continue to be concerned about political and ideological bias in AI. President Trump, on July 23d issued an executive order preventing woke AI in the Federal Government. As of this week, in fact as of yesterday, I did an AI search. I was very, I was pretty darn clear about what I was looking for, and it returned results biased against what I was looking for. Unfortunately, I would love to hear your response, but I am out of time. Thank you so much. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I recognize now the educator from Connecticut, Mrs. Hayes. Ms. Hayes. Thank you, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. Advanced technologies like AI are rapidly being integrated into the classroom and can enhance teaching and learning. It can also be difficult for teachers and administrators to navigate evolving AI technologies and to use them safely and effectively. Ms. Reeve Givens, in your testimony you State that ``Fewer than half of teachers and students report they have received some training or information on AI use in class, well below the reported use of this technology.'' Mr. Khan, in your testimony, you State ``Teachers need support to understand where AI is helpful, where it can fail and how to supervise its use effectively.'' I agree with both of you, and I was listening just now to you, Ms. Nayak, when you talked about teachers getting training to get certified in AI. I have to frame my questions with the caution, that while I understand this is important, I mean I am a certified classroom teacher. We had a component in special education, now a layer on AI and we are having conversations where we do not even want to pay teachers what they deserve to begin with, but continue to add on all of these layers. I did chuckle a little Mr. Khan, when you said students have to wait two to 3 weeks for feedback on an essay. For the record, no student in my class ever had to wait two to 3 weeks for feedback on an essay, and that time where I gave feedback, not just what my comments were but why I made them in a one on one setting was valuable and promoted student interaction. I would set a day aside and either call students up to my desk one at a time or go around the classroom and talk them through the edits, not just make edits on paper. I understand that this is technology that we have to embrace and kind of learn and grow with it. I do have serious concerns though about the expectation of classroom teachers to integrate these things. My question, Ms. Reeve Givens or Mr. Khan, whoever, what are the most beneficial professional development and training tools to support teachers and administrators in effectively integrating AI technology and schools? Where do we need to allocate more attention or resources to support the educators who will now be tasked with not only the technology, but the integrity, the ethics surrounding it and all of those components that come with it? When I went--all of my degrees are in education, history, curriculum and instruction, educational leadership. This is literally a whole area all by itself that classroom teachers are going to be expected to be responsible for. Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question, Congresswoman. Respectfully, all my degrees are also in education. I was also a high school English teacher---- Ms. Hayes. You get it. Mr. Khan. I do get it, in public schools. I recognize that, you know, teachers already have an immense amount of burdens and training that they are already needing to be equipped with in their daily work as educators. I think to answer your question, the things that they can benefit the most from are, you know, the way that we work with schools and districts that we partner with is first we give them kind of a baseline education on how this technology works. Here are some suggested use cases on how this could be used powerfully. Here are the risks associated with those things. We also empower the local district's leadership, the champions, maybe the technology leaders in the district, maybe a department chair in English, and they can talk about how, to your point, you know, it is still really important that the student is hearing from the teacher about, you know, how the strengths of their essay, the areas that they have to grow and how can AI be a part of that story rather than the full story. Ms. Hayes. Realistically, how often would that training need to be updated because this technology is evolving so quickly? Mr. Khan. Yes, I do not think---- Ms. Hayes. Literally you would have to have professional development every week. Mr. Khan. Yes. I do not think it is a singular training. I think it is just like, you know, in our work as educators, we had department meetings every--you know, for me in the school that I worked in, we had a department meeting every month. Here is what is new. Here are some things that you can use in your classroom. I think forcing this on teachers in terms of how you utilize it in your classroom has never worked topdown. In terms of a baseline education around it, helping you understand what you can and cannot and should not do, and then equipping you with the agency to make your own choices as a teacher is, I think, something that I have always advocated for as a teacher. We trust teachers. We empower them with knowledge and then we trust them to make good decisions. That is what I would encourage. Ms. Hayes. Well, I guess just like 5 minutes is not enough time to question witnesses on this topic. I do not think we are adequately positioned to require teachers to be responsible for this in the classroom. I am sorry, Ms. Reeve, I have ran out of time. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady. I recognize now the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Harris. Mr. Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all of our panelists today and the witnesses for your expertise and what you have been able to share and some very important insights, I think and a lot of food for thought that we have heard today. Mr. Frazier, I want to just start with you. I hear predictions, it has been mentioned even here today, that AI could replace millions of jobs in the next decade. Some lawmakers and a number of pundits say that we should impose a tax on employers who adopt AI to replace workers. Now I know from my research, you have publicly opposed this so called robot tax, and I want to just take a moment and give you an opportunity to explain why you think a robot tax is a bad way to protect American workers. Mr. Frazier. Thank you for that opportunity, Congressman. I think that a robot tax is very well intentioned like a number of economic policies, making sure that Americans, as we have heard throughout this hearing, thrive in an era of new technology. The American way has never been to be scared of technology, nor to prevent investment in the technologies of the future. If we want to not only create a thriving economy but also to realize that we are competing in an international space where we are not seeing China, for example, impose attacks on its robots. What are they doing? They are investing in creating the next generation of robots that are going to lead to new innovations, new economies and new sectors. On the domestic front, we need to similarly recognize that when productivity increases, yes, we may see differences in whether that allocation is going more toward capital, more toward labor. A net increase in productivity over time increases the whole economic pie, and that is what we should be focused on. There is no clause in the Constitution that says everyone has a right to the specific job they were born in, just as the horse pooper scoopers, right? They do not still walk around the streets of New York cleaning up. What we need to focus on is creating mechanisms and pathways for opportunity. Mr. Harris. Do you have any specific ways that you might suggest that Congress, steps we could take to protect workers instead of this tax? Mr. Frazier. First and foremost, I think that we need to empower American workers by moving toward a portable benefit system. Right now, there is a real sense of what economists will refer to as job lock. Folks feel stuck in their job because that is predominantly where they get their benefits from. If we want to make sure that Americans can thrive in this more fluid and dynamic economy, then it is important that they are able to take their savings, their time off from job to job. In that way, we can facilitate that economy. Mr. Harris. Gotcha. Thank you very much. Mr. Khan, I know you have had direct engagement with the White House AI Education Task Force, which has made a notable effort to thoughtfully engage educators, parents and Federal leaders. In fact, in July 2025, as already mentioned earlier, the administration released America's AI Action Plan. I want to just give you a few moments. From your perspective, what stood out about how this administration is approaching AI literacy and safety, especially in preparing young people for the future? Mr. Khan. Yes. In the Committee, I heard the folks around the table really focused on protecting children. There was a lot of conversation around the idea of how we have seen technology affect children. In recent memory, with things like the way that social media has affected children in negative ways, the way that we have now seen, you know, full circle schools banning cell phones in schools. There was a remark made about how we do not think that kids should be staring at their laptops every single day. We think that technology is inevitable. It will be in our children's lives. You know, there, there is a lot of conversation of how can we make sure that both educators and families are equipped with the knowledge to make decisions about how they use technology. You know, freedom is only freedom when you have information, when you have agency, when you understand something. That is what I heard the focus being on in that meeting, which I was heartened by. Mr. Harris. Excellent. Well, thank you very much, and to all of you for your time that you have shared. Mr. Chairman, I will yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman, and I recognize the gentlelady from Arizona, Ms. Grijalva. Ms. Grijalva. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The rapid advancement of AI necessitates an acknowledgement of the profound ripple effects this emerging technology creates across society. While these issues may transcend the immediate scope of this Committee, we must address the exploitation of intellectual property privacy violations stemming from mass data collection and the spread of misinformation. Furthermore, the integration of AI introduces significant security risks, a lack of algorithmic transparency and severe environmental consequences due to excessive consumption of energy and water. As we navigate these changes, it is essential to remain vigilant regarding the risks and inequities that AI can introduce into our foundational systems. In Tucson, Arizona, we had a proposal for an AI site and overwhelmingly the community rejected it and will not be being built within Tucson, Arizona, but it is moving on to other areas. I think it is important for us to think about all of the things I just mentioned. Pima Community College, also in Tucson, Arizona, serves as a critical workforce pipeline for first generation students and working adults. Through partnerships with regional employers, the college provides the job-aligned training required for a landscape where AI is reshaping everyday work. To ensure resilient future, we must support these institutions in delivering the skills necessary for a modern economy, while remaining focused on the risks inherent in the hiring process and in the classroom. This would be a question for Ms. Reeve Givens. What specific Federal investments would most effectively enable community college colleges like Pima to quickly expand AI related certificates across fields such as health care, manufacturing and IT, and how can institutions ensure they are balancing the potential benefits of these tools with the risks of using AI for sensitive educational tasks such as tracking student progress or developing individualized education programs? Ms. Reeve Givens. Thank you for the question. Mr. Harris alluded to some of the energy that is coming out of the current administration, including a focus on ramping up AI adoption in education. That creates an important opportunity, provided we are thinking about distributing that opportunity fully and equally across the country and reaching communities that really need it most. It is also an important moment to think not only about AI adoption, but responsible AI adoption. In 2025, the Department of Education put out principles for responsible AI use that have a lot of good content in there. We have advocated for the administration to follow those own guidelines put out by its own Department of Education in the rollout of those plans and opportunities. The other piece that I would add here, you were very right in your opening to touch on some of the other issues not raised by the Committee yet today. Cybersecurity threats that schools are facing, the privacy concerns. Just to pause for a moment on the cybersecurity threats, in our recent research, 23 percent of teachers reported that their school experienced a large scale data breach. In the last school year alone, cybersecurity analysts report 4,000 schools experiencing data breaches in a particular week. As AI use increases, we are sharing even more data about students, even more personal information that becomes vulnerable to that harm. Right now, the administration has pulled back its funding for CISA, the government agency that supports this work and ended the multiState information sharing program that helps schools, school districts respond to these threats. Those are the types of places that might not be top of mind, but really need to be when we think about school readiness, school preparedness and making sure that educators, again not only are learning about the potential of AI and thinking about its use in the classroom, but actually are equipped to navigate this transformation and get the full benefit that they deserve. Ms. Grijalva. Thank you. Did anyone want to add anything to that question? Okay. I do not know. What safeguards should Congress include to ensure AI workforce investments are broadly accessible to community colleges, outside of major technology hubs like Pima in Tucson? Given the active litigation against Workday involving allegations that algorithm-based screening tools systematically discriminated against applicants, what can be done to the algorithms underlying these tools to ensure that they do not have a disparate impact on our graduates because of their age, disability, race, gender or other protected characteristics? Ms. Reeve Givens. Sure. I am happy to talk briefly about some of the lessons from a litigation that Workday is facing right now about discrimination through hiring tools that it was used, without specifically commenting on the merits of that case which continue to be ongoing. It is a really important wake up call, not only to employers about how these tools can perpetuate discrimination, and also the role of the vendors that are developing these tools as well. This includes questions like how easily and rapidly people are being dismissed based on protected characteristics. One of the things that I think is important for Congress to know is yes, we do have existing employment laws that can be brought to bear in these cases. It is very hard to actually discover these instances and to prove these cases because of the lack of transparency and visibility. It used to be there was a bad apple in H.R. and you could maybe trace back how an interview went badly or, you know, what might have happened just from studying the results of one company. Here, when you are just, as the Congressman was saying earlier, throwing your resume into a void with no idea what is happening next. In the Workday case, a person submitted hundreds of resumes and had them all rejected almost instantly and that was how he began to connect the dots. What we really need is transparency around what these tools are assessing, how they are being used and then an empowered Equal Employment Opportunity Commission that can be a cop on the beat to protect workers, and make sure that employers are making responsible choices when they are deploying these tools. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady. Ms. Grijalva. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Walberg. Time has expired. I recognize the gentleman from Florida, Mr. Fine. Mr. Fine. Well, thank you Mr. Chairman and, you know, usually when I prepare for my Committee meetings, I do research, I understand what is going on. Today, I had an expert that I could go and talk to about the use of AI in education and that is my son, Jacob, who is a senior in high school and who actually uses these tools and uses your product quite a bit. Not to cheat, at least that is what I think. I will tell you as a parent, I have to ask him. Like wow, that was really well written. Like, did you write it yourself and he often gets upset. He has shown me himself tools that none of us had, and frankly even students 5 years ago never had. The first question is a question he asked me to ask, so I am interested in your perspective on this. He says AI can be very helpful to him in a whole variety of ways that you focused on. However, because of negative effects of AI and other technologies, particularly social media, schools are now banning the use of technology in class. Like he cannot use his phone during the school day. How can you leverage your product, build your products and technologies to sort of allow it to push back and say ``Hey, we're going to come up with ways where you can use our--the good stuff in school, but keep the bad stuff out.'' Are there ideas that are being bandied about in order to be able to do that? Whoever wants to answer. Mr. Khan, looks like you are raring to go. Mr. Khan. Yes. We actually built our product in this way. That does not mean that the child always has to have their laptop out in class or always has to have a device. Rather, there are specific use cases that the child can use generative AI in the classroom under the supervision of their teacher in a way that is prescribed by the teacher for a specific purpose and or use case. There are tools in the platform. An example would be a teacher has a research paper that students are doing in their senior year, and Magic School has a great AI research assistant tool that students can use as a support for them as they are working through their research papers. A teacher launches that to their students. The student joins that activity, and they can now use this AI tool as a part of their assignment. They are still responsible for the final product, but they can use this tool that has been built with guardrails informed by what the actual task is that they are asked to be doing in class, so that it does not write the essay for them. It does assist them in the way that the teacher intended them to be assisted, used in kind of a specific time period with which the teacher has prescribed for them to use it, and then it can be closed up when it is not supposed to be used. Mr. Fine. Well, my advice to all of you is this. Really, the issue is Smartphones more than laptops, where Smartphones have simply been banned. This cannot happen. If I was all of you, I used to be a software guy, did not have AI, I would be trying to work with some of these providers to come up with modes where phones can be disabled to do the bad stuff, but they can be enabled to do the good stuff. Right now, we are having to throw out the good stuff, because frankly the bad stuff is pretty bad. We do not want kids on Snapchat and TikTok all day, and that is the problem. They cannot access the good things because of that. My other question also actually is for you, Mr. Khan. You talked about how teachers can use AI to help grade and assess students. You know, you can understand how this will help teachers save time, but it is also easy to imagine how this can go horribly wrong, having a computer assess a grade. How do you make sure that the AI tools are fair and accurate when they are being used for things like grading? Mr. Khan. Yes. First and foremost, we do not grade with the platform. Mr. Fine. Okay. Mr. Khan. We do not assign a specific letter grade and or a score for a student on an assignment. We keep it to things like formative feedback for the child. We do inform the teacher with sometimes a suggested grade. The platform has an idea that it could suggest if the teacher elects to get a suggested grade for an assignment. The way we control for that is we require every educator to review that suggested grade. We have kind of responsibility flags that are held up to the teacher saying, you know, you are the teacher of record in a classroom. If you have ever been a teacher in a public school, you understand this term ``teacher of record.'' It means that you are responsible for that child's grade in your class and it is like your name signed to it. Magic School will never supplant the teacher of record. They are the ones who are making the decision about the final grade. We think of that as a high-stakes decision. It is about educating teachers on how to use this and making sure that they are using it in a responsible way and not as a way to replace their own thinking or assessment of a child's work. Mr. Fine. Well, thank you. Well, look. I think the challenge for us is this. I often talk about certain drugs, you know. Severe painkillers allowed us to do surgeries that could never be done before, and has had extraordinary effect on people's lives. Misused, they have horrible effects and they are killing Americans. I think most new cutting edge technologies fall into this situation, where they can be used for real good or they can be used for real bad. I would say the challenge for all of you and for all of us is to figure out how we harness the good without unleashing the bad. I know that is something we will be continuing to work on. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I recognize now the gentlelady from Illinois, Ms. Miller. Ms. Miller. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. With how fast AI is developing, it is essential that Congress develop policies that promote educational opportunity, workforce and workforce development, while upholding user safety. It is also a matter of national security that the U.S. win the AI race. I appreciate the work that the Trump administration is doing, using AI to ensure students are prepared to enter the workforce while preventing it from being used for woke indoctrination. AI has become especially effective in the classroom, as it can personalize learning experiences while also helping students with special needs and learning disabilities. AI is equally beneficial to teachers as it helps create lesson plans, saving teachers hours of work per week. Over the course of a school year, this adds up to nearly 6 weeks of saved work time. AI is also beneficial to businesses and their employees, as it can teach valuable skills at a fraction of the cost. However, as AI continues to develop and progress, we must address how it may disrupt the job market, as well as teacher- student relationships in the classroom. Mr. Khan, I am especially concerned about AI's effects on children concerning chatbots imitating human relationships. How can we address these issues while still using AI effectively in the classroom? Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question, Congresswoman. We share in your concern about the inappropriate relationship that a student could have with a chatbot in the classroom. The way that we guard against that is we make sure that any interaction with generative AI through our product and the way we believe all products should be used or AI products when used in schools, should be under the supervision of a teacher. Teachers have monitoring dashboards where they are flagged for inappropriate content, or maybe an inappropriate interaction that the child might be having in the experience. Then, of course, the experiences themselves are academically focused. They are not intended to create a relationship between a chatbot and a child. More importantly than that, certainly there are technology safeguards we put into the products. We equip teachers with understanding the risks that you just described. We help them before they even use this technology with their students in the classroom. They are introducing the technology with letting the child know about what this is, what this is not. This is not a companion. This is not something that you should be building a relationship with. Human connection is still the most important part of the educational process. The center of our work, you know, we have a slogan, it is teachers are magic, but that is very much the ethos of the company too, is that the greatest learning happens with the relationship of a teacher and a child, and a parent and a child. We keep that the center of our work, and only use AI to augment their ability to serve the needs of the children in the classroom and avoid the negative effects. Ms. Miller. I am glad that we agree on the danger that children could access that. I know in a school in Illinois recently, the kindergartners were working on a Chromebook and pornography just popped up on it. You know, we just need layer, layer, layer of protections, to make sure our kids' minds are protected. Mr. Khan. Absolutely. Ms. Miller. Okay. Then also for Ms. Nayak, how can Congress develop policies that will use AI to promote workforce development without sacrificing jobs? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman or Congresswoman, excuse me. We think that Congress should think about how all of the programs that already exist, unemployment programs, programs to help upskill and educate people, they should think about how those can also add AI skills into those trainings. What we are doing is we are providing a foundation of certifications. We are partnering with governments, we are partnering with employers to think about how those certifications can enter into their workflows, to think about how those certifications can lead to jobs. We would love to work with Congress to think about how our certifications could also be used in workforce development programs at the State level as well as federally. Ms. Miller. Would any of those certifications be available to students while they are still in high school, so that--OK. Ms. Nayak. Yes. That is our intention. Students, teachers, as well as the workforce. Ms. Miller. Okay, great. My final question is to Mr. Frazier. Oops. Well Chairman, you want me to finish? Chairman Walberg. 16 seconds. Ms. Miller. Can you talk more about needed safeguards for AI policy in light of student privacy? Mr. Frazier. Yes. First and foremost, very quickly I would say we also have to be attentive to the fact that today's AI is the worst AI we will ever use. If we want more AI tools to be safe and reliable in a student context, we also have to talk about updating and gathering student information. We cannot have one without the other. Better data leads to better AI. Ms. Miller. Thank you, and I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlelady, and I recognize the gentleman from Pennsylvania who is wondering how AI will help produce better whole milk. Chairman of the Ag Committee, Mr. Thompson. Mr. Thompson. I have got a lot of thoughts on that. Great applications in agriculture. Let us talk education today, which is a foundation of everything actually. Mr. Khan, you had reflected already on how K through 12 schools currently integrate AI-based assistive technology in the classrooms. I want to focus on students who are learning with various disabilities. What do you see as the, the opportunities there? You know we--you know, the reauthorization of the Individuals With Disabilities in Education Act is long overdue. Actually, this could be good timing. Mr. Khan. Thank you for the question, Congressman. As a former special education teacher, this is near and dear to my heart. AI can be an incredible assistive technology in supporting students with learning disabilities. Within our platform and many AI tools, one of the incredible advancements is in speech to text and text to speech. Often students with Individualized Education Programs, IEPs, students with disabilities will have a read aloud accommodation. AI can read aloud and in a natural voice that continues to have the child engaged in their education with a compelling narrator individually in the classroom, rather than having a teacher kneel down next to them to have to do that. Perhaps, you know, that is great for the individual child the teacher is with but, you know, when I was a special education teacher co-teaching, I could not get to every child in the classroom to give them that accommodation. There was a physical barrier for me to be able to, you know, implement the required accommodations that the children in the classroom that I was supporting had, and AI breaks down that barrier. It gives them the ability to have read aloud in the moments that they need it. In addition to that, when AI is informed with the needs of the child, especially when they are individualized needs that are state-mandated or federally mandated through an IEP, then the interaction that they have with the technology can be even more personalized to the needs that they have. Another example I might give is, you know, when I was teaching 9th grade English, there were students who were many grade levels behind in the class and students who are well advanced of their classmates. AI can give them personalized feedback across their ability levels if informed by their zone of proximal development. You know that that is the idea, that you do not want to give a child, you know, work that is so challenging that they disengage. You want to give them to them in a way that is like just stretches them just enough to help them grow to the next level, and AI can help get them into that zone of proximal development based on no matter where they started. When we can use the data that we have about kids and their needs, then AI can be something that increases the capacity of the educator to serve the diverse needs of the students in front of them in a way that has never been possible before. That gets me really inspired. Special education's probably the thing that, you know, is again near and dear to my heart, but also one of the most incredible ways that we can support the real needs of schools and districts right now. You know, special education is a designation, but every child learns differently, right? There are students who are multiple language learners in schools who can be served with this technology and translating in and out of English in their native language. There are so many incredible applications, for the specialized needs of learners in classrooms. Mr. Thompson. Very exciting, very exciting. Great for the kids, great for the teachers as well. Ms. Nayak, how is AI technology being integrated into workforce development to enhance skill acquisition and support career transitions? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. We are seeing a lot of enterprises actually very excited for AI skill development. When we actually speak with our enterprises who are adopting our tools, one of the biggest things that they ask us for is actually certifications and skills-based training that they can provide to their workforce, so that they can leverage these AI tools. The way that it is being integrated is at OpenAI, we are partnering with enterprises to actually build out coursework and curriculum and certifications that will teach their workforce the skills that they believe that they need in order to be successful in their jobs in the AI era. Over the course of the next several months, we are going to be releasing several courses that we have built in partnership with these organizations. Mr. Thompson. Very good. How is AI being used at this point in career and technical education or CTE programs? Mr. Khan. CTE is a emergent use case in a really, really powerful way. We found that a lot of CTE educators are coming from industry. They are folks like my father, who are an HVAC technician, welders. They did not get a traditional training and education. They are learning how to use AI to lesson plan and build all of these really incredible resources where curriculum does not exist, to bring this technology in a way that helps folks build these working class or whatever I would call living wage jobs, right? They are getting access to these living way jobs, and the teachers of those jobs can actually learn how to be a teacher a lot faster, because they are able to utilize this technology to build things like lesson plans as nontraditionally educated educators. Mr. Thompson. Very good. Well, thank you. My time's expired. I call them essential workers actually. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. Now since we have discussed AI with whole milk, I suppose we ought to discuss AI's impact on bourbon. Mr. Thompson. Absolutely. Chairman Walberg. I recognize a gentleman from Kentucky, Mr. Comer. Mr. Comer. Well, thank you Mr. Chairman, and I thank our witnesses for being there today. I am very excited about what AI could mean for my district in rural Kentucky. In my congressional district in Paducah, Kentucky, a former Department of Energy site that once supported nuclear weapons production is now being redeveloped for advanced energy projects and AI data center uses alongside uranium enrichment facilities. Just last week, I am very happy to announce that one company in Paducah received a $900 million task order from the Department of Energy to enrich uranium and power America's nuclear future. At the same time, local workers are preparing to reskill and upskill to meet the needs of companies reindustrializing the Paducah Department of Energy site. For a lot of folks back home, this isn't theatrical. This is--it is about whether they can save their communities and move into good well-paying jobs as technology changes. Paducah and the surrounding communities in west Kentucky have a skilled workforce built around energy manufacturing and national security, and they're now being asked to transition into this next generation of infrastructure. I see this as a real opportunity for Kentucky to be a part of the future of AI, not left behind. Ms. Nayak, how do you see AI-driven industries creating new kinds of jobs in places like Paducah, Kentucky? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman, and I think Paducah is a really exciting example for how AI could actually move with industries and kind of transition them over time. I think the example that you gave of data centers and being able to leverage their skills to power the next generation of this technology is a very exciting one. What we are doing with the jobs and certifications effort is we are actually leveraging our AI foundations courses to build curriculum for specific industries like the ones in your district, to enable them to actually gain the AI skills, but also leverage the skills that they already have in this new era. We are very excited to see that enabling workers to actually transition with the times and then actually lead to much more economic growth and new industries or industries that are just transitioning with AI. Mr. Comer. Well, that is great, and we talk about it a lot in this Committee and I think we are all in a majority agreement, that it is a new type of job training in America. I guess Ms. Nayak, what specific kinds of training or specific certifications would help average workers that want to re-skill move more quickly into these new types of jobs? How does OpenAI think about supporting those pathways? Ms. Nayak. Congressman, we are investing in several different styles of courses that will lead to an OpenAI certification. Our first one is something that we think can be valuable to everyone from a teacher to a student to a worker, which is AI Foundations, which teaches them how to use tools like ChatGPT, teaches them how to build agentic workflows and then also teaches them how to bring their community along and actually train the trainer and teach others around them to use AI. That is our kind of first set of courses, and we are already starting to roll those out. We will finish that full curriculum series this month. The second set of courses are focused on AI builders. Those are the ones who are technologists or even, like the examples that you give, who are operating data centers or operating energy facilities, where they are actually leveraging AI to build tools for others to use. We are going to start to build out an AI builders curriculum and coursework that will empower those individuals to be able to use our tools. Over time, we see that we would love to partner with every industry to think about how we can take those types of courses and then adapt them to their industries. Examples of that is we have already released a AI teacher course, which takes our AI Foundations course and actually augments it and implements it for teachers. We are hoping to do that in the health care space as well. We think it is very exciting. We think that this foundational curriculum can lead to a lot of benefit for many different industries. Mr. Comer. Well, thank you very much for your insight. I am very eager, Mr. Chairman, to see how AI can unleash workforce development opportunities for my constituents in Kentucky. Thank you all again for being here. Mr. Chairman, look forward to working with the Committee to see that we can achieve this goal of retraining a new workforce to be able to quickly adapt into the bright future that AI has. With that, I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize the gentleman from Guam, Mr. Moylan. Mr. Moylan. Chairman Walberg and Ranking Member Scott, thanks for hosting today's important hearing and thank you today to our panel for providing your expertise. The rapid advancement of AI deployment through the workforce and schools and it is provided untapped opportunities, of course. While we have an unlimited potential, we should also be cautious about irresponsible use and the threats of our adversarial nations, what they can pose with the new technology. That is why I work consistently with my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to ensure that appropriate guardrails and strategic planning are in place to generate jobs, ensure AI dominance and protect our Nation and its people. Ms. Nayak, oftentimes certain areas can be left behind in innovative workforce development. To maintain America AI leadership across the globe and in all corners of the country, what approaches can ensure that no community is left behind, particularly in the territories, rural areas and remote locations where AI applications can solve critical infrastructure, logistics and economic development problems? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. We share in your concern that AI could leave people behind or it could actually help to accelerate rural communities or communities that normally wouldn't be reached by technology. We are hopeful that it will be the latter. What you are talking about is something we call the capability overhang, where we want to make sure that people can actually use AI to its fullest and we need to be able to skill them to be able to do so. What we are doing here at OpenAI is a couple of things. One is we are leveraging certifications and those certifications are available on ChatGPT. Really anyone could access them. The beauty of that is that with ChatGPT as well, you could actually personalize a course toward different communities. You mentioned territories. You could actually take a course and you could translate it to different languages or, you know, different levels of education or understanding. I think that that will actually make this more adaptable, so that it can actually be personalized to those communities rather than something that's only focused on kind of urban areas in the U.S. Mr. Moylan. Thank you for that. Also, another question for you. As AI transforms professionals like finance services, supply chain management and healthcare, what mechanisms would you recommend for enabling colleges and universities to rapidly redesign programs and deploy industry, recognize credentials that meet immediate workforce needs while students and families are demanding these changes? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. We have been working quite a bit with universities, not only kind of large universities but also community colleges. We have been talking to them a lot about how we could leverage our certification programs within those universities. One way is that we actually need to skill up the professors and teachers in those universities. We are building coursework for those teachers to actually understand how do you build AI-based curriculum. That is part one. Part two is we are building coursework for students. Right now, we have a student AI lab, where as we are building this course curriculum we are actually having that lab give us feedback, both positive and negative, as to how it is actually helping them, where we are actually missing the mark. That has been super useful for us in developing this course, to make sure that it actually applies to our students and universities. Then third, we are also working with enterprises, so that they can tell us where they are seeing the biggest gaps and then ideally, we can take that back to the universities and community colleges and actually partner with them to close those gaps. We really see this as a virtuous loop, and we are excited that AI can actually help create and connect that loop in ways we never saw before. Mr. Moylan. That is terrific. Going on that line with the commercial enterprises, how can Federal policy support small and medium sized businesses, local governments and public institutions like schools and public health systems, in adopting AI tools and upscaling existing workforces, particularly where expertise and training is limited? Ms. Nayak. Thank you, Congressman. We are actually seeing that around 40 percent of small businesses are already reporting using AI today, and the majority of small businesses actually see this technology as increasingly important to their industries. We are actually very excited about the impact that this could have on small businesses from, you know, businesses that could not afford to have specific services, where they were kind of stringing together work themselves, now maybe they could use AI to augment it so that they have to spend less time doing things that they don't love and spend more time building their business. What we are doing here is again with the certifications effort, we want to give small businesses the tools to be able to adopt AI really rapidly and to be able to prevent that capability gap, so that they can actually use it to increase their businesses. Mr. Moylan. Thank you so much. Thank you to the panel. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman. I recognize the very patient gentleman from Virginia, the Ranking Member Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Givens, we have talked about bias and you mentioned guidance on websites from Federal agencies. Can you say a word about the status of that guidance? Ms. Reeve Givens. Absolutely, and it comes up in both of the topics of today's hearing. In the hiring and employment space, over the past 5 years the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Department of Justice, Department of Labor and National Labor Relations Board did extensive work to put out guidance for employers and workers about how to use AI in a way that complies with existing employment laws. Unfortunately, all of those pieces of guidance have been removed from their websites. I do provide links to them in my written testimony from people who preserved that record. Unfortunately, that pullback is just a very troubling sign about the leadership those agencies are showing right now for workers and employers. In the education space, I will just note that the Department of Education, through its Office of Education Technology and the Office of Civil Rights, also put out very important guidance on how to ensure the use of AI in education spaces complies with existing civil rights laws. It is important that that continues to be available to people as well. Mr. Scott. Thank you. Can you, on that discrimination guide, discrimination cases, can you talk about the importance of disparate impact analysis? Ms. Reeve Givens. Yes. One of the foundational tenets of our civil rights laws is acknowledging that one form of discrimination can best be captured through assessing the disparate impact that it has on protected populations or people based on their protected characteristics in our society. If that protection is removed, then anybody who is trying to say they have been treated unfairly under the law has to make a very difficult case about what was in the mind of the person that hired 99 percent white people into their workforce, just to give one example. That is incredibly difficult to do, and it ends up essentially making our laws almost impossible to enforce. Disparate impact for a long time has been a tenet of how we actually address inequality in these key features of people's lives, and making sure that people with protected characteristics, that they are not being judged on that basis, but on their ability to contribute to a job in question. Mr. Scott. If a businessman has off the shelf software that turns out to be discriminatory, who is responsible for--who is accountable for the discrimination? Ms. Reeve Givens. Under the law, the employer is. Right now, it is difficult to bring those cases because of the lack of transparency and visibility into how those tools are affecting the workforce, which is why we need not only enforcement of existing law, but also additional protections provided by Congress to have there be more transparency and testing in when these tools are used and deployed. Mr. Scott. In professional development, are there problems we need to be sensitive to in providing professional development with AI, rather than the industry providing itself if there is embedded bias in the software? Ms. Reeve Givens. I think in any tasking and other training materials, it is important to think about what is being taught and the quality of what is being taught. One hopes that that is the hallmark of effective learning and effective teaching materials. One of the areas we have been focused on in the ed tech space is how to make sure that ed tech vendors, just to give one example, are much more transparent about their grounding in learning science, so that teachers, educators, school administrators can be making informed decisions when they turn to these tools and are asking not only how are you trained, what is the science, but also how are you evaluating your impact over time? Some are starting to do this, but the paperwork around it, the disclosures, the standards, as Mr. Khan was saying, are not there yet and it is an important area to focus on right now. Mr. Scott. Thank you. Mr. Frazier, you pointed out the importance of collecting data. You did not say what data we needed to be collecting on. Mr. Frazier. In 72 seconds, I think that there is a tremendous need to focus on adoption, what tools are being adopted, focusing on the intensity and novelty of that adoption. Not only do you have access to a tool, but how are you using it and in what ways are you using it? Then I also think we also need to pay attention to which tools are explicitly being used in which institutional settings, getting an understanding of whether a company, for example, is using last year's iteration of a certain model or the latest technology can give us real insights as well. It is really an extensive effort that has to be maintained, to get a true picture of how AI is diffusing across society. It is one we must pursue if we want better policy. Mr. Scott. Let me try to get another question in. Florida has a proposed AI bill of rights for Florida. Can you say whether or not it is important for states to control the situation or Federal Government? Then, while you say that executive orders do not override State laws, statutes do, is that right? Mr. Frazier. That is correct under the supremacy clause, that Federal law can overrule State laws that conflict with it. I would say also that in the domain of AI, states have a very real and very acknowledged role in governing AI use cases by end users. If and when we see states try to regulate beyond their own borders, however, that infringes upon our Federalist system in which Congress, you all, are tasked with governing interState matters. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentlemen. I thank the--the panel. I hope you noticed the extent of the numbers of members on both sides of the aisle that showed great interest in making time to leave other committees, et cetera and be here to ask questions. This is something that we will continue as well. Thank you, each of you, for sharing your expertise and we know where to find you if we need more answers. I now would recognize the Ranking Member for his closing remarks. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would first ask unanimous consent for a report from the Economic Policy Institute entitled ``Unbalanced labor market power is what makes technology, including AI, threatening to workers. The best AI policy to protect workers is boosting their bargaining position.'' Chairman Walberg. Without objection. [The report of Mr. Scott follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Scott. The other, the article that was mentioned a couple of times, ``The Risk of AI in Schools Outweigh the Benefits, report says''--it is a National Public Radio piece. Chairman Walberg. Without objection. [The report of Mr. Scott follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Scott. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I think this has been a great panel. It is very, very, very, very instructive. We have heard a lot about what is going on, the need for--I think we have heard one need, that we need some standardized oversight of what AI programs are. We have heard the importance of asking the right questions. The problem is if you do not have some independent analysis, you do not know what to do with the answers. How is your program on privacy? Oh, it is great. Now, what do you know? We need some independence and also like we have with registered apprenticeships, the certification of programs with a registered apprenticeship, if you have a registered apprenticeship that you completed in Washington, DC. and Washington State, they know what you can do. We need to make sure that certifications in AI have the same kind of standardization. There is a lot we have learned today and a lot we need to continue to work on, particularly with the sinister opportunities for discrimination that are way below the radar that we need to be looking into. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I yield back. Chairman Walberg. I thank the gentleman and yes. Today it was very clear. Dangers? Yes. Innovations and expansions of opportunity, yes. Both. Job and process changes and eliminations? Yes. Job and process enhancements? Yes. It is all there. Policymakers must transparently highlight and expose violations and concerns, but with as light touch, I believe as possible, to foster innovation and not fall into the same trap we fell in with net neutrality. The objective is, I think, very bipartisan that we have a system, we have AI that works for all of us and expands opportunity with caution, but that we do not stand unnecessarily in the way either. Priorities, as has been said, are literacy and true useful development of what goes on. AI will bring about changes in education and the workforce. It has to if we are going to keep up and lead the world. Full stop. A brave new world has always brought more benefit than had we not bravely moved forward with the dangers, the potential pitfall pitfalls, but also the amazing successes that it can bring. How we encourage education and the business community to partner together in the best use of AI is something that we need to continue thinking about and do it as quickly as possible. We do not have time to just wait and waste, but need to move forward. The U.S. will lead in AI or the Chinese Communist Party will. I am not lying, am I? Hence, quality and innovative education is a must that is also fostered by a morality that builds its freedom. That comes from information. I think I heard that said, and of course, factual information that builds on that. Optimism is what I feel. AI could help produce more sincere and unified bipartisanship through AI clarification of how often we may be on the same side, but we are unable to clearly articulate our ideas and concerns. I am optimistic that AI can even help in the legislative process and move us forward on a track that says America will succeed and our kids will grow in their education endeavors in different ways, in unusual ways from what has been in the past, but on a trend upward with a freedom that we espouse here in the United States that brings about success and achievement. Again, thank you so much for participating with us. With that and without objection, there being no further business, the Committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 1:07 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [all]