A TIME FOR TRUTH: OVERSIGHT OF META'S FOREIGN RELATIONS AND REPRESENTATIONS TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS

Senate Judiciary Committee Senate April 9, 2025

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-193]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-193

 A TIME FOR TRUTH: OVERSIGHT OF META'S
 FOREIGN RELATIONS AND REPRESENTATIONS
 TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME AND 
 COUNTERTERRORISM

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 FIRST SESSION

 __________

 APRIL 9, 2025

 __________

 Serial No. J-119-14

 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 www.judiciary.senate.gov
 www.govinfo.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
61-882 WASHINGTON : 2026
=======================================================================
 
 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

 CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California

 Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director

 Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism

 JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri, Chair
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
 CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey

 John Ehrett, Republican Chief Counsel
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel

 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page

Hawley, Hon. Josh,............................................... 1
Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 2
Grassley, Hon. Charles E......................................... 4
Klobuchar, Hon. Amy.............................................. 7
Blumenthal, Hon. Richard......................................... 5

 WITNESS

Wynn-Williams, Sarah............................................. 8
 Prepared statement........................................... 34
 Responses to written questions............................... 38

 APPENDIX

Items submitted for the record................................... 45

 
 A TIME FOR TRUTH: OVERSIGHT
 OF META'S FOREIGN RELATIONS
 AND REPRESENTATIONS
 TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, APRIL 9, 2025

 United States Senate,
 Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism,
 Committee on the Judiciary,
 Washington, DC.
 The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:34 p.m., in 
Room 226, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Josh Hawley, 
Chair of the Subcommittee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Hawley [presiding], Blackburn, Durbin, 
Klobuchar, and Blumenthal.
 Also present: Senator Grassley.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOSH HAWLEY,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI

 Chair Hawley. The Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime 
and Counterterrorism is called to order. I want to welcome 
everybody to today's hearing, the title of which is ``A Time 
for Truth: Oversight of Meta's Foreign Relations and 
Representations to the United States Congress.''
 Let me just say as we begin, this is a hearing that 
Facebook has tried desperately to prevent.
 Facebook is one of the most powerful companies in the 
world. It is one of the most powerful companies in the history 
of the world, and they have stopped at absolutely nothing to 
prevent today's testimony. They have absolutely gone to war to 
try to prevent it.
 Our witness today is a whistleblower, and not just a 
whistleblower, but a longtime executive at Facebook. She worked 
directly with Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg--and the 
Facebook brass. She was a part of the Facebook brass. And they 
have gone scorched earth to prevent her from telling what she 
knows.
 They have sued her. They have sought a gag order against 
her. They have begged courts to take her book off of the 
shelves. They tried to get it stopped from being printed in the 
first place.
 They have threatened her, get this, with $50,000 in 
punitive damages every time she mentions Facebook in public--
$50,000 every time she mentions Facebook in public, even if the 
statements that she is making are true.
 And even as we sit here today, Facebook is attempting her 
total and complete financial ruin. They are attempting to 
destroy her personally. They are attempting to destroy her 
reputation.
 And I think the question is, why? Why is it that Facebook 
is so desperate to prevent this witness from telling what she 
knows? What is it that they are so afraid of?
 Well, we are going to find out today. And I think that we 
have already got a sense of it. Sarah Wynn-Williams knows the 
truth about Facebook. That is what they fear.
 She knows that while Mark Zuckerberg now claims to be a 
champion of the United States and claims to be a free speech 
warrior, he, in fact, worked hand-in-glove with the Chinese 
Communist Party for years.
 He, in fact, made censorship his business model.
 He, in fact, developed censorship tools for the Chinese 
Communist Party to use against its own people.
 He, in fact, made Americans' own user data available--was 
willing to make it available to Beijing.
 The truth is, Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg have lied to the 
American people repeatedly. And I think as we will see today, 
they have lied to Congress as well.
 It is time for this to stop. That is why this Committee has 
launched a full-scale investigation into the potential illegal 
behavior of Facebook.
 Today's hearing is one step in that investigation. Ms. 
Wynn-Williams' testimony is absolutely essential to that 
investigation. That is why we invited her to be here today, and 
it is why she accepted.
 Facebook does not want you to hear what she has to say. I 
dare say China probably doesn't want you to hear what she has 
to say. But we are going to get the truth. And we are going to 
get the truth starting now.
 I am delighted to have with me the Ranking Member both for 
the Subcommittee and for the Full Judiciary Committee, Senator 
Durbin, and I will turn it over to him.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS

 Senator Durbin. Thanks, Chairman Hawley, for holding this 
hearing. Thank you, Ms. Wynn-Williams, for agreeing to testify, 
particularly under these circumstances.
 You join other whistleblowers, including Frances Haugen and 
Arturo Bejar, who have bravely come before Congress to detail 
how Meta, aka Facebook, one of the biggest companies in the 
world, consistently chooses profits and growth over people and 
safety.
 Meta chooses to target vulnerable teenagers to drive 
engagement and increase ad spending, knowing the risk it poses 
to teen mental health. Meta chooses to feed its users 
inflammatory content to drive engagement and increase ad 
spending, knowing the harm it can cause. Meta chooses to put 
human rights concerns aside if it means access to more users, 
more growth, more dollars.
 During the timeframe that Ms. Wynn-Williams documents in 
her book, I was pressing Facebook on its potential cooperation 
with the Chinese government. I was Chair, in this room, of the 
Human Rights and Law Subcommittee, working with a staunch 
Republican conservative, the late Tom Coburn. We held hearings 
on the human rights implications of Big Tech operating in 
countries with repressive governments and sent interrogatories 
to Facebook on the issue.
 The company flatly declined to appear, claiming they had 
nothing to say on the issue. Here is what I said in the hearing 
room at the time. Quote, ``We asked Facebook to testify, and 
they said we have no business operations in China, and for that 
matter, in most of the countries of the world,'' end quote. In 
retrospect, these comments from Facebook were disingenuous at 
best.
 In one chapter, Ms. Wynn-Williams describes a board meeting 
where the company discussed ways to head off regulation and 
change the narrative surrounding Facebook. She writes that the 
board, quote, ``gets into conversation about what other 
companies or industries have navigated with similar challenges, 
where they have to change a narrative that says they are a 
danger to society, extracting large profits, pushing all the 
negative externalities onto society and not giving back.''
 Guess what model they chose? Big Tobacco. That analogy is 
apt.
 Like Big Tobacco decades ago, Big Tech tells us their 
products do no harm.
 Like Big Tobacco, Big Tech tells us they can be trusted.
 And like Big Tobacco, they fight to prevent any regulation 
that might make them pay for the cost that their products 
impose on society.
 We have seen it time and time again in Congress. Any effort 
to regulate Big Tech is met with millions of dollars in ad 
campaigns, lobbying, and other opposition.
 But Congress has fought this battle before, and we have 
won. Almost 40 years ago, I was a Member of the House of 
Representatives. I introduced legislation to ban smoking on 
airplanes. The tobacco industry fought it tooth and nail. Once 
that smoking ban went into effect, it wasn't long before 
smoking was banned in restaurants and public places.
 That one little law finally turned the tide against smoking 
in America. And it ultimately saved millions of lives.
 Thanks to people like Ms. Wynn-Williams, I believe we are 
at a similar tipping point with Big Tech. The word is out. The 
shine is off. We can all see the harm Big Tech has caused--from 
enabling the spread of CSAM and harming teen mental health to 
facilitating repression in places like China and Myanmar.
 Last Congress, the Senate Judiciary Committee, which I 
chaired, unanimously--unanimously, and that is a big deal in 
this Committee, reported five bills to regulate Big Tech and 
require online platforms to protect kids. This is no easy feat 
in these polarized times.
 One of these bills was STOP CSAM, which I introduced with 
Chairman Hawley, and we are reintroducing it very soon. We will 
do what it takes to get this bill to the President's desk so he 
can sign it.
 But we can't stop here. As Ms. Wynn-Williams makes clear in 
her book--companies like Meta won't do the right thing unless 
they are compelled to do it.
 That is why I also joined with Chairman Hawley, Senator 
Graham, and others to introduce a bill to sunset Section 230 of 
the Communications Decency Act. For nearly 30 years, Section 
230 has shielded Big Tech from liability for the harms they 
cause.
 Only by removing that liability shield will Big Tech 
finally have to take the steps companies and all other 
industries have to take to protect their customers. Unless and 
until Congress imposes accountability on these companies, 
nothing will change. Children and society will continue to pay 
a price.
 I hope this hearing and Ms. Wynn-Williams' testimony can 
once again shine a spotlight on the need to regulate Big Tech 
and build momentum. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you. We are delighted to have the 
Chairman of the Full Committee, Senator Grassley, with us. And 
so I am going to turn to Senator Grassley for an opening 
statement. Thank you, Senator.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF IOWA

 Chairman Grassley. Thank you for exposing all this, or will 
be exposed. Thank you very much.
 In my 50 years as a Member of the United States Congress, I 
have seen all kinds of whistleblower retaliation. I have seen 
it across all industries. The United States tech industry is no 
different.
 These tech companies sitting in those ivory towers in 
Silicon Valley look to silence whistleblowers. They want to 
keep these brave men and women from telling Congress, 
Government regulators, and the entire American public about 
alleged wrongdoing at their companies.
 I have fought for whistleblowers my whole congressional 
career as an author of updates to the False Claims Act, the IRS 
Whistleblower Program, many other whistleblower laws.
 Whistleblowers are key to rooting out fraud, waste, and 
abuse, whether it is in Government or in the private sector.
 Recently, I wrote to OpenAI about their efforts to silence 
whistleblowers. To address this, I am working on bipartisan 
legislation to implement whistleblower protection in the 
artificial intelligence industry.
 Sadly, our witness, Ms. Sarah Wynn-Williams, is facing down 
the barrel of a gun. Ms. Wynn-Williams is a former employee of 
Facebook. According to her attorneys, Meta is threatening her 
with fines of $50,000 each time she makes a disparaging comment 
about the company. This can be easily abused to silence her for 
telling the truth. Thank you for bravely being here.
 This isn't the first time I have investigated a tech 
company for exposing America's data and sensitive technology to 
our adversaries.
 On September the 13th, 2022, as Ranking Member of this 
Committee, I, along with Senator Durbin, held a hearing on 
those very issues.
 A Twitter whistleblower named Peiter Zatko testified at 
that hearing. He disclosed to this Committee that Twitter 
shared user information to foreign intelligence agencies, 
including the government of China. His disclosures made public 
that the FBI notified Twitter of at least one Chinese agent in 
the company.
 Now, what is different here now? Well, the Chinese didn't 
have to infiltrate Facebook. Facebook went to China.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams has disclosed very troubling allegations. 
For example, she told my office that C-suite executives at 
Facebook rolled out the red carpet for the Chinese Communist 
government.
 According to our witness, Facebook executives agreed to 
provide the Communists in China with access to user data and 
build data storage facilities in China. This would obviously 
involve America data.
 Allegedly, Facebook also built censorship tools to block 
certain content from Chinese users. According to Ms. Wynn-
Williams, Facebook also gave the ruling Communist Party and its 
People's Liberation Army briefings on artificial intelligence 
software. These briefings were done with the knowledge that 
they would assist the Chinese government in advancing its 
artificial intelligence program. These actions have and can 
have dire consequences.
 These disclosures to Congress are exactly how it ought to 
be done. This whistleblower, in my view, has absolutely done 
the right thing.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams, I often say that whistleblowers are 
treated like skunks at a picnic. Unfortunately, you have 
experienced that already.
 Thank you for your courage and bravery for coming forward 
to Congress. We will be conducting a thorough investigation and 
ask Meta to fully cooperate.
 I will be in and out because of votes on the floor of the 
Senate, but I want to come back and ask a few questions.
 Chair Hawley. You bet, Mr. Chairman.
 And now let me turn to my good friend, and someone who has 
been a great friend of whistleblowers, and also has been a 
champion of going after Big Tech, Senator Blumenthal.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD BLUMENTHAL,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF CONNECTICUT

 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Senator Hawley, and thank 
you for your leadership on this Subcommittee and having this 
hearing. And also on the Subcommittee that we chaired together 
on Technology and the Law. And I am still hoping we will 
continue our work on AI.
 But your experience as a former law enforcement official, 
as Attorney General of your State, as I was of mine, gives you 
a solid backing and interest, and I think it reflects the 
importance of this Subcommittee's work that both the Chairman 
and the Ranking Member of the Full Committee are here and that 
we have a bipartisan--a bipartisan group determined to get the 
truth.
 And let me just say right at the start, I just so 
tremendously admire your courage, Ms. Wynn-Williams, in 
standing up to Meta, a gigantic economic and political force--
and to China that would like to see you silenced as well and is 
cheering from the sidelines, or maybe not even from the 
sidelines, what Meta is doing.
 And what it is doing is absolutely despicable. It is 
disgusting and the height of hypocrisy for a supposed free 
speech champion, Mark Zuckerberg and Meta, to use a campaign of 
threats and intimidation to try to silence you.
 But it is part of a pattern. Meta is trying to buy and even 
bribe and pander its way out of any accountability. It has 
donated $1 million to Trump's Inaugural Fund. It started 
ripping up its policies on hate speech, and letting fraud and 
abuse run rampant on its platforms.
 And appallingly, according to The Wall Street Journal, 
Zuckerberg has recently visited the White House three times to 
get the President to order the Federal Trade Commission to drop 
its antitrust case.
 Meta will stop at nothing to dispel and disguise and 
deceive. And it has done it to Congress. It has done it to 
Congress and to the American people.
 Meta lied about the generational harm it was doing to young 
people--suicide, eating disorders, and depression.
 In fact, as we know from another brave whistleblower who 
came to the Commerce Committee, one document provided to us 
showed that it was part of the Facebook Meta business model to, 
in effect, addict kids to toxic content and destroy their 
lives.
 One document you provided to us shows that Facebook's 
advertising division was developing tools to target teens that 
were insecure and depressed. It was literally attempting to 
profit from the pain of young people.
 When it was caught lying about these harms, Senator 
Blackburn and I introduced the Kids Online Safety Act, KOSA, a 
bill that passed the Senate on a 91-to-3 vote. We are hoping it 
will pass again, and this time pass the House.
 The American people ought to be asking, has Facebook done 
anything to clean up its act? And the answer is no. It actually 
diverted its millions of dollars to try to stop KOSA. And it 
spent millions of dollars in lobbying to argue that antitrust 
and AI regulations harm national security.
 And unfortunately, all of this deception and pandering and 
buying, and you might even say bribing, has been effective so 
far.
 But the American people are going to be pretty outraged 
that Mark Zuckerberg sold out America to China. That he 
imperiled our national security for a buck. That he compromised 
a highly significant American corporation for personal gain and 
profit.
 And your allegations and testimony matter tremendously 
because you have credibility. You have nothing left to lose. 
You have your integrity. Mark Zuckerberg has lost his through 
his deception.
 And he oversaw and personally approved of plans that 
undermined American national security because his own engineers 
warned him that operating in China would expose Americans to 
Chinese surveillance and censorship.
 So he not only risked our national security, but the 
individual security of everyday Americans. And they ought to be 
downright angry, outraged that he sold them out, as well as 
America.
 He hid those risks from Congress. He and other Facebook 
executives provided testimony in hearing after hearing after 
hearing that was misleading at best and false at worst. Meta 
has attempted to dismiss these allegations as just old news, 
nothing to see here, nothing new.
 Well, people watching and listening to you, Ms. Wynn-
Williams, will know the importance and impact of what you have 
revealed to the American people and to the world.
 I have opened an investigation with Senator Ron Johnson on 
behalf of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, and we 
have demanded documents from Meta regarding its operations in 
China. The Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations is 
determined to use whatever tools and instruments and powers we 
have to get to the bottom of all of the facts here.
 And I really appreciate Senator Hawley's support for that 
investigation. He has joined our efforts. He is a member of the 
Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. And I look forward to 
our bipartisan--and it will be bipartisan effort to continue 
this effort for truth. And again, thank you for being here. 
Thank you for your courage.
 Chair Hawley. And now let me introduce someone who has been 
a champion for privacy and for antitrust and standing up to 
these corporations, Senator Klobuchar.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. AMY KLOBUCHAR,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MINNESOTA

 Senator Klobuchar. Thank you very much, Senator Hawley.
 And of course, thank you to Senators Durbin and Blumenthal.
 I was listening to all of you, and I was thinking how when 
we first started on this journey, it was pretty lonely.
 I think the first bill we did, that I remember, was the 
Honest Ads Act with Senator McCain at which we simply tried to 
get disclaimers on political ads that were on the platforms. 
Facebook initially opposed it and then did support it at the 
end. It still hasn't been passed, of all things, because of all 
the lobbying.
 But since then, there has been this big coalition of 
people, I think based in part on--I haven't read your book yet, 
but from what I understand, some of the things that you have 
pointed out that have brought people with us of all political 
stripes.
 And part of this is just the pushback whenever we try to do 
anything on antitrust when it comes to self-preferencing 
products--and this is, of all of the platforms together, the 
intense lobbying against any kind of movement, even for things 
the companies agree to do in other countries.
 Or, when we try to do something as simple as fentanyl to 
try to put in place bills to make that be reported when it is 
being sold on the platforms.
 Senator Cruz and I lead the Take It Down Act that has 
gotten support from a number of the platforms, not originally, 
that I believe is going to pass through the House. It has 
already passed through the Senate for nonconsensual porn, both 
AI-created and actual.
 But there is so much more to do. And I just keep nearly 
every hearing saying, you know, if you want this to stop, then 
why don't you work with us in supporting some of these major, 
major bills outside of some of the ones that I mentioned?
 For too long, they have turned a blind eye when kids, as 
pointed out by the other Senators, joined their platforms, used 
algorithms that would spread harmful content, and, of course, 
provided a venue for drug dealers to the point where the former 
head of our Drug Enforcement Agency said that the cartels in 
China and Mexico had basically harnessed--those were her 
words--harnessed the platforms.
 We know about the risks of mental illness, addiction, 
exploitation, even suicide for these kids that have their 
images. They put it out looking for a girlfriend or boyfriend, 
and they are so mortified and they are so young that we have 
had over 20 suicides in 1 year, according to the former FBI 
Director.
 As you observed in your book, it really didn't have to be 
this way. They could have chosen to do it all differently and 
fix so much of what has been destructive. But they didn't, so 
we must. Thank you.
 Chair Hawley. Now, let me introduce our witness. Sarah 
Wynn-Williams is the former director of Global Public Policy at 
Facebook. She is a former New Zealand diplomat and 
international lawyer who first joined Facebook after pitching 
her own job.
 After leaving the company, she has continued to work on 
tech policy, including artificial intelligence. Now, all of 
that you can learn from reading the back of her book. But there 
is more to it than that.
 She worked at Facebook from 2011 through 2017. She 
witnessed Facebook's rise from a niche tech company to a global 
superpower, capable of bullying nation-states. And she wasn't 
just some mid-level functionary.
 She worked closely with Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl 
Sandberg. She arranged their meetings with world leaders across 
the globe. She heard their plans for China. She is no ordinary 
whistleblower. And she comes to tell us not merely about what 
has happened, but also what is coming.
 Now, it is our practice, Ms. Wynn-Williams, in the 
Judiciary Committee and its Subcommittees, to swear in our 
witnesses before they testify. So if you would, let me invite 
you to rise and raise your right hand, and we will get started.
 [Witness is sworn in.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much. We would love to hear 
your opening statement.
 Take as long as you need.

 STATEMENT OF SARAH WYNN-WILLIAMS, FORMER DIRECTOR, GLOBAL 
 PUBLIC POLICY, FACEBOOK, LONDON, ENGLAND

 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, 
and distinguished Members of the Committee, thank you for the 
opportunity to speak with you today.
 My name is Sarah Wynn-Williams, and I served as the 
director of Global Public Policy at Facebook, now Meta, for 
nearly 7 years, starting in 2011.
 Throughout those 7 years, I saw Meta executives repeatedly 
undermine U.S. national security and betray American values. 
They did these things in secret to win favor with Beijing and 
build an $18 billion business in China.
 We are engaged in a high-stakes AI arms race against China. 
And during my time at Meta, company executives lied about what 
they were doing with the Chinese Communist Party to employees, 
shareholders, Congress, and the American public.
 I sit before this Committee today to set the record 
straight about these illegal and dangerous activities.
 Meta's dishonesty started with the betrayal of core 
American values. Mark Zuckerberg pledged himself a free speech 
champion. Yet I witnessed Meta work hand-in-glove with the 
Chinese Communist Party to construct and test custom-built 
censorship tools that silenced and censored their critics.
 When Beijing demanded that Facebook delete the account of a 
prominent Chinese dissident living on American soil, they did 
it. And then lied to Congress when asked about the incident in 
a Senate hearing.
 The willingness to censor was not the only troubling thing 
I witnessed. I watched as executives decided to provide the 
Chinese Communist Party with access to Meta user data, 
including that of Americans. Meta does not dispute these facts. 
They can't. I have the documents.
 As recently as this Monday, they claimed that they do not 
operate their services in China. Another lie. In fact, they 
began offering products and services in China as early as 2014. 
That hasn't stopped.
 Their own SEC filings from last year show that China is now 
Meta's second biggest market. Meanwhile, Meta's AI model, 
Llama, has contributed significantly to Chinese advances in AI 
technologies, like DeepSeek. Facebook's secret mission to get 
China was called Project Aldrin and was restricted to need-to-
know staff.
 There was no bridge too far. Meta built a physical pipeline 
connecting the United States and China. Meta executives ignored 
warnings that this would provide backdoor access to the Chinese 
Communist Party, allowing them to intercept the personal data 
and private messages of American citizens.
 The only reason China does not currently have access to 
U.S. user data through this pipeline is because Congress 
stepped in.
 Meta started briefing the Chinese Communist Party as early 
as 2015. These briefings focused on critical emerging 
technologies, including artificial intelligence, the explicit 
goal being to help China outcompete American companies.
 There is a straight line you can draw from these briefings 
to the recent revelations that China is developing AI models 
for military use, relying on Meta's Llama model. Meta's 
internal documents describe their sales pitch for why China 
should allow them into the market by, quote, ``helping China 
increase global influence and promote the China dream.''
 The truth about what has gone on in China matters. I filed 
a shareholder resolution asking Meta's board to investigate its 
activity in China. And I filed whistleblower complaints with 
the SEC and the DOJ. The measure of how important these truths 
are is directly proportionate to the ferocity of Meta's efforts 
to censor and intimidate me.
 I relied on the commitment given in 2018 that they would 
waive their rights to pursue forced arbitration. Despite that 
public commitment, they have brought a case against me for 
hundreds of millions of dollars. Now they have a legal gag 
order that silences me, even as Meta and their proxies spread 
lies about me. This order is so expansive that it prohibits me 
from speaking with Members of Congress. The gag order was 
sought by a company whose CEO claims to be a champion of free 
speech.
 The American people deserve to know the truth. Meta has 
been willing to compromise its values, sacrifice the security 
of its users, and undermine American interests to build its 
China business.
 It has been happening for years, covered up by lies, and 
continues to this day.
 I am here at considerable personal risk because you have 
the power and the authority to hold them accountable. Thank 
you.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. Wynn-Williams appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Ms. Wynn-Williams.
 We are going to have 8-minute rounds of questioning, and I 
will start. Let me just start with something that you 
referenced, Ms. Wynn-Williams, a moment ago.
 Facebook Meta issued a statement, again, last night saying 
that they don't do business in China. Now, is that true? 
Facebook Meta is not doing business in China? Is that accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is not accurate, Chairman Hawley. 
And Facebook has a $18.3 billion business in China. And to give 
just one example, in 2014, it launched Oculus in China with a 
strategy of playing dumb, and Oculus has continued to grow as a 
significant part of their business.
 Chair Hawley. In fact, they have--since 2014, 2015, they 
have launched multiple apps in China, often without--always 
without seeking authorization from this Government, not 
informing their shareholders, not informing Congress, not 
informing the public.
 And now they have employees in China. Is that accurate? 
They have a partnership with Tencent in China. Is that 
accurate? Their Oculus VR business is in China. Is that 
accurate?
 So tell me this, why has Facebook Meta been so obsessed, if 
I can use that word, with breaking into the Chinese market? 
What is this all about?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. It is incredibly valuable for Meta.
 Chair Hawley. Monetarily?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely.
 Chair Hawley. So really, we are talking about profit at the 
end of the day?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. We are absolutely talking about profit.
 Chair Hawley. Profit and power.
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley. Let's talk about what Meta has been willing 
to do for profit and power.
 You said just a moment ago that Meta's dishonesty started 
with the betrayal of core American values, and you mentioned 
that Mark Zuckerberg has pledged himself as a free speech 
champion.
 I notice he talks a lot now in the American media about 
free speech. I notice he talks a lot when he goes to the White 
House about free speech and how Facebook won't censor, and 
Facebook will protect the rights of all. Have you ever known 
Mark Zuckerberg to censor on behalf of China?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Chairman Hawley.
 Chair Hawley. Let's talk about a few specific instances. In 
2017, the Chinese dissident Guo Wengui suddenly had his 
Facebook profile shut down.
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley. Now, Facebook at first said that this was a 
temporary glitch. Was that true to your knowledge?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. No, Senator Hawley.
 Chair Hawley. In fact, Facebook shut down this dissident's 
page--this dissident, as you pointed out a moment ago, was 
living on American soil at the time. Facebook shut down that 
page based on pressure from the Chinese Communist Party. Is 
that accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is accurate.
 Chair Hawley. Let's just take a look here at the documents. 
Here are some meeting notes taken shortly after a conversation 
with a Mr. Chow, who is a Communist Chinese Party member, a 
government official.
 Here, Mr. Chow asks Facebook and says to Facebook that they 
want Mr. Guo's Facebook page dealt with. The notes say that 
Chow wants Facebook in China, but there are others who don't, 
so we--Facebook, ``need to take measures and do more in such 
situations to demonstrate we can address mutual interests.''
 And then they go on to list, here is what we could do: We 
could do nothing; we could say we can do something; or we can 
do even more than expected. But we need to ``provide a 
response'' to the Chinese Communist Party ``on what we can 
do.''
 So here, we have evidence of high-level contacts between 
Chinese Communist Party officials and Facebook asking for this 
dissident's page to be taken down, Facebook acknowledging this 
pressure, saying we need to do something if we want to get the 
Party's cooperation, the government's cooperation. And what 
happened next?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Well, Senator Hawley, one thing the 
Chinese Communist Party and Mark Zuckerberg share is that they 
want to silence their critics. I can say that from a personal 
experience. So I think they came to the right man.
 This led to a series of events where eventually this man on 
American soil was kicked off the platform.
 Chair Hawley. So in April 2017, following these 
conversations, Facebook takes down the profile, bans it of Mr. 
Guo. Then in September, they make that ban permanent.
 Now, here is the really interesting thing. When Facebook's 
general counsel was asked about this directly under oath in a 
Senate Intelligence Committee hearing, he sang a different 
tune.
 Senator Rubio asked him directly, ``Was there any pressure 
from the Chinese government to block his account? '' ``Was 
there any pressure to block his account? ''
 The general counsel, Mr. Stretch, ``No, Senator. We 
reviewed a report on that account and analyzed it through 
regular channels using regular procedures.'' Was this truthful 
testimony, Ms. Wynn-Williams?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. No, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. It is in fact an outright lie. Is it not?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. It is, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. We just saw the documentation. Facebook 
received not just a request.
 Facebook received direct pressure from the Chinese 
Communist Party and bowed to it and discussed it internally and 
planned it and then lied about it to Congress.
 Let's talk about what else they have been able to do--been 
willing to do in order to get this access to the Chinese 
market.
 Let's look at some more meeting notes. Here is a readout of 
a group of Facebook engineers----
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. Offering to create a censorship 
regime that will allow Facebook to block all traffic the 
Chinese Communist Party doesn't want.
 ``Phase zero''--this is an internal chat. ``Phase zero, we 
identify all traffic that are currently blocked in China and 
we, Facebook, block them. This is a test for us to see whether 
we can actually identify all traffic from China.''
 And then the chat continues, ``Yes, good way to build 
trust.''
 And another conversant says, ``Great stuff, guys. Let's do 
it.''
 What is--what is--give us some context here, Ms. Wynn-
Williams. What are they talking about doing here? When they 
say, ``block all content that China wants, we, Facebook, do it 
for them''--what are they talking about?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They are talking about activating their 
censorship tools on behalf of the Chinese Communist Party.
 Chair Hawley. So Facebook creates censorship tools that 
will allow them to assume the burden, if you like, of 
censorship, where they will do all of the censoring that the 
Chinese government was doing, Facebook would do it on their 
behalf. Is that right?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is my understanding, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And here you have Facebook employees 
celebrating it. ``Good way to build trust.'' They mean build 
trust with the Communist Chinese Party. Right?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And ``Great stuff, guys. Let's do it''--
meaning they greenlit this and went forward to see if they 
could make it happen. Is that accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is my understanding, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. All of this, let's be clear, for a murderous 
regime in China--the most barbaric, most evil regime on the 
face of the planet. And our free speech champion, Mark 
Zuckerberg, is here with his team of engineers actively working 
to make Facebook censor on their behalf.
 Let me ask you this. What about user data, Ms. Wynn-
Williams? Facebook has said publicly many times we would never 
compromise user data. It is a red line in the sand. We would 
never do that--never, never, never. Was Facebook ever willing 
to share user data with the Chinese Communist Party?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator.
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley. In fact, they had a plan for that. Didn't 
they?
 Here are some documents--internal documents: ``Update, I 
spoke with the China team yesterday. They flagged a potential 
complication arising from our negotiations with the Chinese 
government.''
 I emphasize this is a Facebook document now. These are 
Facebook executives. ``In exchange for the ability to do 
operations in China, Facebook will agree to grant the Chinese 
government access to Chinese user data.''
 There it is in black and white. ``Facebook will agree to 
grant the Chinese government access to Chinese user data, 
including Hong Kongese user data.''
 And then they talk about they are going to have to get 
their Hong Kong citizens to re-agree to terms of service so 
they can slide this right by them. This is extraordinary.
 Can I just ask you, Ms. Wynn-Williams, was Americans' user 
data ever compromised? Do they ever plan to compromise American 
user data in any way? Do you know?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. One of the challenges with servicing a 
market as big as China was the internet infrastructure that 
would underpin that.
 So I mentioned the cable that they joined between the U.S. 
and China, and that would be very helpful, but they--in 
servicing this market. But it would still mean that the service 
would be slow.
 So they contemplated using POP servers. And POP servers is 
a technical data center that brings the data closer to the end 
user.
 The challenge with POP servers is that you can't segregate 
data. It would have American data. It would have Chinese user 
data. And it would be on Chinese soil.
 Chair Hawley. So I want to just be clear about this. Here 
in this document, Facebook is talking about making Chinese user 
data available to the Chinese government because they are going 
to store that data in China. Is that correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct.
 Chair Hawley. But when you store that data in China, 
Americans who exchange messages or other information with 
Chinese Facebook users, that would mean the Chinese government 
could get access to the American data as well. Is that correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Through the POP servers, potentially, 
yes.
 Chair Hawley. And Facebook was willing to take that risk?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes. There was a lot of discussion about 
this. And ultimately, yes.
 Chair Hawley. I mean, this is--this is extraordinary. This 
is exactly contrary to what Facebook has represented for years.
 Here they are willing to build data centers, store data in 
China. They are willing explicitly to give the Chinese 
government access to it.
 And if that means that American user data is also 
compromised, they are willing to do that, too. All for profits 
in China. There was virtually nothing they weren't willing to 
do.
 Chairman Grassley.
 Chairman Grassley. Thank you. And I am only sitting over 
here because of your chart.
 I take very seriously adversaries having access to critical 
technology, such as artificial intelligence. And I noted in my 
opening statement, you made allegations about Meta's efforts to 
help China's government in that field.
 In your opening statement, you said that Meta's goal was to 
help China outcompete American companies. Can you explain why 
they would want to do this? And is there any documentation on 
that point?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Thank you, Senator. They saw, I guess, 
part of the value proposition that they could provide the 
Chinese Communist Party was their expertise in helping Chinese 
officials.
 So they explicitly--and I would be happy to provide you 
with the documentation--called out, you know, U.S. firms. They 
said, you know, we can help you, China, not have to rely on 
firms like Cisco or IBM because we can help you with the 
technical expertise.
 So they were offering, you know, things like how to build 
more efficient data centers. Or, how to ensure that engineers 
could better understand technology, like photo tagging.
 Chairman Grassley. Okay. And then--and by the way, that 
documentation would be appreciated.
 What was Meta's ultimate goal when they briefed Chinese 
government on artificial intelligence technology? And what 
information and technology did they provide?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. So I think it links to this value 
proposition. Meta has some of the best minds of a generation. 
They have employed the smartest graduates working on cutting-
edge technologies, like artificial intelligence. So who better, 
if you are the Chinese Communist Party, to teach you about 
these technologies than Meta?
 And, in terms of understanding the extent of this, I think 
this is a really great area for your investigation.
 Chairman Grassley. Now that Facebook has changed its name 
to Meta, is Meta currently providing the Chinese government 
with access to artificial intelligence technology?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. So, it has been well reported that 
Chinese researchers have used the Llama model--both for AI 
weapons and also that Llama is part of what powers DeepSeek.
 Chairman Grassley. Please describe for the Committee how 
Meta planned to share data from American citizens with the 
Chinese government.
 And, for example, did Meta have any agreements with the 
Communist Chinese government to provide them with the data? And 
if so, do they still have those agreements, as far as you can 
tell, that you have been gone from the company?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. So part of the challenge, as I 
mentioned, was building, like, the internet infrastructure to 
support their China ambitions. And it was through that internet 
infrastructure that they would gain access to potentially 
American citizens' data. I think, again, this is another very 
good area to investigate and get further information directly 
from the company.
 Chairman Grassley. Who at Meta facilitated these 
conversations? And what officials in the Chinese government did 
Meta staff meet with?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. So there were many meetings between the 
Chinese Communist Party and Meta, so right from the top, you 
know, Mark Zuckerberg met with Lu Wei.
 The most--there were lots of visits back and forth between 
Beijing and Menlo Park.
 There were lots of meetings with senior Politburo, senior 
CCP members, and I would be happy to provide more documentation 
on this to the Committee.
 Chairman Grassley. Okay. Then my last question follows on 
where Chairman Hawley left off. If there is anything that you 
can add to this, you don't have to repeat what you told him, 
but describe to the Committee how Meta planned to share data 
from American citizens with the Chinese government. And for--
and, I don't think I am going to ask that question. I think you 
covered it well.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Thank you, Senator.
 Chairman Grassley. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. 
Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. Thank you for 
being here. Thank you for these questions.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams, can I just go back to something you said 
a moment ago in response to Senator Grassley. And maybe let's 
just start at the beginning.
 So is it your testimony that Facebook executives and 
employees cultivated relationships with members of the Chinese 
Communist Party?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And this happened over a period of years?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. This happened over many years.
 Chair Hawley. And did members of the Facebook executive 
team or other employees at Facebook, Meta, ever brief members 
of the Chinese Communist Party?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator, regularly.
 Chair Hawley. Exchanged information with them?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. What are some of the topics that they covered 
in these briefings?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I mean, it is incredibly broad. So you 
had meetings at the top executive level, so Mark and Sheryl, 
and you had meetings, you know, all the way down to, you know, 
regular engineers who would be providing briefings on cutting-
edge technology, like facial recognition--which is obviously 
very helpful to the Chinese Communist Party.
 You know, Facebook Live, as I mentioned, photo tagging, 
internet infrastructure, so how to build effective data 
centers. You know, Facebook has a project called the Open 
Compute Project, which has five Chinese companies as a member 
of it. So it was at every level, on every aspect of the many 
different technologies that Facebook has.
 Chair Hawley. You testified a moment ago that one of the 
things that--part of their value proposition to China was that 
they would help them--Facebook, that is, would help China 
outcompete other American businesses.
 Can you just say more about that? I mean, that seems like 
an extraordinary thing to me. Here you have an American company 
going to our chief foreign adversary, on whom we currently have 
tariffs of, like, 10 billion percent, and saying, hey, we would 
love to help you. We would love to help you beat all of these 
other American companies. That is extraordinary. I mean, what 
can you tell us about that?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I mean, I would be happy to provide the 
documentation. I mean, literally, the documents in which they 
were writing this were called, ``Our Value Proposition,'' to be 
put before the CCP.
 Chair Hawley. So was information related to artificial 
intelligence part of these briefings? I know you said that 
there was sort of informal discussions.
 But, did Facebook actually brief members of the CCP on 
artificial intelligence, to your knowledge?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And again, was that a once-off, or was this a 
regular thing?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, I think this is a great area of 
investigation for your Committee.
 Chair Hawley. So, why--why--you were at Facebook a long 
time.
 Why would Facebook want to help China with artificial 
intelligence? I mean, what--what is the strategy there, do you 
think? What do you define the intent to have been?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think there are lots of--so I think we 
have talked about the general focus of the company of wanting 
to help China.
 You know, this is over a period of time where China was 
rapidly trying to increase its own technological expertise and 
trying to grow its own home-grown technology company.
 So it is incredibly valuable to have the brightest minds in 
the world show you how that technology works if that was.
 And then, I think there is a--at the moment, as you are 
aware, there is a debate in the AI community around whether 
open source models or closed models are more appropriate. And 
one of the considerations around that is national security.
 But it is not clear at this moment whether open source 
models or closed models will ultimately prevail. And there is a 
lot of money on the line.
 In some ways, you could say it is helpful if you want open 
source to prevail to have a strong threat from a Chinese model 
so that you can say it is really important that America wins 
this, and we are the American open source option. And I think 
you can see the way that strategically plays out.
 Chair Hawley. So what you are saying is Facebook's AI 
model, Llama, I think it is called, that is an open source 
model. Is that right?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct.
 Chair Hawley. And I think they just released Llama 4--or 
something just recently, the last few days. So that is an open 
source model.
 Many of the other American competitors, Sam Altman's 
company, for example, OpenAI, is a closed source model, closed 
source code.
 So Facebook has a fundamentally different take, an open 
source model. They are briefing the Chinese government, 
including CCP officials, on this model, on their information.
 And then, we get the revelation of DeepSeek just a few 
months ago, China's sort of breakthrough on AI. Do you think 
that Llama had something to do with DeepSeek? Do you think that 
that information sharing helped lead to DeepSeek?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think it has been widely reported that 
the DeepSeek model is in part based on Llama.
 Chair Hawley. And so just playing this out, if China's 
DeepSeek model, another open source model, I think, right, 
becomes the chief competitor to these other models in the 
United States, what you are saying is that it stands to 
reason--and this is something for us to look into certainly--
but it stands to reason that, in a way, Facebook would benefit 
from that because you have got this threat in DeepSeek. 
Facebook is the only other really major American open source 
model out there. The others aren't built on that platform.
 So, you know, Facebook's profile is raised, the 
significance of their model is raised, and maybe they become 
more important than ever. I mean, does that stand to reason?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think it is a winner-takes-all 
situation, and I think that that would set up Meta in a very 
strong position.
 Chair Hawley. And it is, as usual with Mark Zuckerberg and 
Meta, they intend to win and take all.
 Senator Blumenthal, if you are ready, I will turn it over 
to you.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thanks very much, Mr. Chairman.
 In order to operate in China, the Communist Party requires 
American companies to register with authorities and host 
servers inside the country. And I think it is pretty well known 
that Chinese law requires that security services are allowed 
access to any data hosted within the country.
 Did any of Facebook's security team or its engineers raise 
concerns to management about Americans' private information 
being exposed to Chinese spying?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator, they did.
 Senator Blumenthal. How did they do that?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They documented their concern in a 
number of ways. They noted that this would happen, that the 
Chinese would get access to the data. And they also noted 
this--their concern in other discussions and other 
documentation saying, you know, my red line as a security 
engineer is to not be comfortable with this, but my red line is 
not Mark Zuckerberg's red line.
 Senator Blumenthal. Maybe you can explain what you mean by 
that.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. The engineer was saying that they were 
not comfortable with the way the China project was structured 
that would allow the Chinese Communist Party to potentially 
access American citizens' data, and--but in saying that, they 
noted that, you know, that is a red line for me as a security 
engineer. That is not Mark Zuckerberg's red line.
 Senator Blumenthal. Did you sense he had any red line?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I did not.
 Senator Blumenthal. If he did, you don't know what it was.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I don't.
 Senator Blumenthal. If you have more information related to 
the spying risk, would you be willing to share it with the 
Committee?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I would, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. And Mark Zuckerberg was knowledgeable 
about the planning. And do you know whether he was 
knowledgeable about the risk as well?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. My understanding is that the risk is the 
hardest part of the plan. So it is unthinkable that he was not 
aware of the risk.
 Senator Blumenthal. Nothing happened here without his 
approval and knowledge?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. This was a project unlike any other 
project I worked on during my time at Meta in that it was so 
centrally led by Mark Zuckerberg. And he was so personally 
invested in this project.
 He learned Mandarin. He traveled to China more than any 
other country. He had weekly Mandarin sessions with employees. 
This was--it is hard to overstate how different this project 
was to any other project I experienced in my many years at the 
company.
 Senator Blumenthal. So there would be no credibility to his 
denying that he knew about the risks, he knew about the 
concerns raised by his engineers and his China team, and he was 
intimately involved in not only the planning and the 
engineering, but also in taking those risks.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, he was traveling to Beijing.
 Senator Blumenthal. In the documents submitted to the 
Subcommittee, Facebook appears to have been willing to provide 
the data of users in Hong Kong to the Chinese government at a 
time when pro-democracy protesters were opposing Beijing's 
crackdown. Is that impression correct? And how did Facebook 
treat Taiwan or Hong Kong?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. So that impression is correct. And one 
of the more surprising things is that, as part of the 
censorship tool that was developed, there were virality 
counters. So anytime a piece of content got over 10,000 views, 
that would automatically trigger it being reviewed by what they 
called the chief editor.
 And what was particularly surprising is that the virality 
counters were not just installed, but activated in Hong Kong 
and also in Taiwan.
 Senator Blumenthal. Let me ask you. I raised in my remarks, 
and I know that a number of other colleagues did as well, the 
record of misrepresentation and deceit.
 One of our former colleagues, Senator Leahy, asked Mark 
Zuckerberg in 2018 whether Facebook would comply with Chinese 
censorship and surveillance demand. He even asked if Facebook 
had built censorship tools to enter the Chinese market, and 
Zuckerberg responded--I am quoting, ``because Facebook has been 
blocked in China since 2009, we are not in a position to know 
exactly how the Government would seek to apply its laws and 
regulations on content were we permitted to offer our service 
to Chinese users.''
 Ms. Wynn-Williams, was that accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is not accurate. You know, hundreds 
of decisions had been made. And by 2018, they had been in 
dialogue directly with the Chinese Communist Party for 4 years.
 Senator Blumenthal. The fact is, by 2018, Facebook built 
it--even turned on censorship and surveillance tools that it 
developed--it developed for Chinese security officials. 
Correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. It developed, and those Chinese 
Communist Party officials tested, the censorship tool, and 
would give feedback and say, this needs to change, or we need 
this, or we need confidence that you can capture images and 
filter images we don't want seen.
 Senator Blumenthal. You know, we talk a lot about ``1984.'' 
Facebook developed a virality counter tool that directed any 
posts of over 10,000 views to be reviewed by an Orwellian-
named, quote, unquote, ``chief editor.'' Is that correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct.
 Senator Blumenthal. And was the chief editor's geographic 
reach limited to mainland China? Or, did they plan to cover 
other locations?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They planned to cover Hong Kong and 
Taiwan, is my understanding.
 Senator Blumenthal. So their surveillance operation was 
directed at Taiwan?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is my understanding, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. And Hong Kong?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is my understanding.
 Senator Blumenthal. Was the chief editor's power limited to 
reviewing viral posts?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Oh, no, it is extensive power. The chief 
editor would be able to turn off the entire service in specific 
regions, for example, Xinjiang? Or, would also be able to turn 
off or manage the service on significant anniversaries like the 
anniversary of Tiananmen Square.
 Senator Blumenthal. So the chief editor, a creation of 
Facebook, was an Orwellian censor that applied to locations 
outside mainland China to Taiwan and Hong Kong to people not 
within the legal jurisdiction of China, but also, obviously, 
the Chinese themselves. And it was designed and implemented by 
Meta and Mark Zuckerberg?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. Even though its very existence was 
denied before this Committee in 2018?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. Silicon Valley companies are famous, as 
you know, for their moonshot programs, such as Google X.
 In recent years, Mark Zuckerberg spent billions of dollars 
on the metaverse and AI. He even named--or, renamed the company 
as part of a pivot to focus on that technology. Did Facebook 
engage in any moonshot efforts in China? And were these efforts 
walled off or protected from the Communist Party?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They did, Senator, and I would be happy 
to follow up with the Committee on this point.
 Senator Blumenthal. You would prefer to follow up 
privately.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. Just one last question. I am interested 
in how much of a national champion Meta actually is for the 
United States. Did Facebook share information about its facial 
recognition, artificial intelligence models, and other 
sensitive technologies to Chinese security officials? In other 
words, did it share that significant technology regarding 
facial recognition and other surveillance methods?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Look, the greatest trick Mark Zuckerberg 
ever pulled was wrapping the American flag around himself and 
calling himself a patriot and saying he didn't offer services 
in China while he spent the last decade building an $18 billion 
business there.
 Senator Blumenthal. And he wrapped the flag around himself 
even as he disclosed sensitive technologies that enabled the 
Chinese to gain the upper hand on surveilling its citizens--but 
also the upper hand in engaging with us.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. And he continues to wrap the flag around 
himself as we move into the next era of artificial 
intelligence.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Senator. Senator Blackburn.
 Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am delighted 
that we are having this hearing today. I thank you for this.
 And Ms. Wynn-Williams, I want to thank you for stepping 
forward and for speaking.
 Senator Blumenthal and I last year brought forward the Kids 
Online Safety Act, and this is a piece of legislation we have 
worked on for years. It came through the Senate on a 91-to-3 
vote. It failed in the House.
 As you would imagine, Meta spent millions of dollars 
lobbying against us and against the legislation, while at the 
same time they were claiming how much they cared for children 
and how they wanted to take care of children.
 And, of course, one of the problems, as we have heard these 
heartbreaking stories from parents of trying to reach out to 
Meta, no response, of the cyberbullying that was taking place, 
the pleas from principals and child psychiatrists to do 
something. And yet, they would not do it.
 And I noted in your book that you talked about Meta 
targeting children with ads based on their emotional state. And 
if you want to talk about something that is cruel, I am a mom 
and a grandmom, and to kick a kid when they are down--that, in 
essence, is what it is, is kicking them while they are down. 
That is completely disgusting.
 And I find it so interesting that Mark Zuckerberg has said 
he has turned over a new leaf. My response to that was, 
``Leaves change color with the seasons of the year.''
 And I am curious as to whether this is a season for him, or 
if it is something that is truly going to be making a 
difference. And I think he should explain to us--he has been 
before this Committee before--where he truly--where he truly 
is.
 Now, one of the things we found out from other 
whistleblowers, and you mentioned in your book, that Meta's 
statement denying it engaged in targeting children was a flat-
out lie. And the company had refused to audit these activities.
 We have heard that from other whistleblowers, that they 
were doing research and they knew what was happening. But they 
were so given to the dollar and having children as the product 
that they themselves, children were addicted.
 But also, Facebook and their leadership team had become 
addicted to the power that they held and to the money that they 
were making.
 But talk to me a little bit about your experience with Meta 
and how they would choose to cover up or deny that they were 
harming kids.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Thank you, Senator. And, one example is 
that Facebook was targeting 13- to 17-year-olds. It could 
identify when they were feeling worthless or helpless or like a 
failure.
 And they would take that information and share it with 
advertisers. One of the things about advertising is advertisers 
understand that when people don't feel good about themselves, 
it is often a good time to pitch a product.
 You know, people are more likely to buy something--and so 
what the company was doing was letting these advertisers know 
that these 13- to 17-year-olds were feeling depressed and 
saying, now's a really good time to serve them an 
advertisement. Or if a 13-year-old girl would delete a selfie, 
that is a really good time to try and sell her a beauty 
product. Or if a 13-year-old girl is----
 Senator Blackburn. So let me interrupt right there. If she 
deleted a selfie, then Facebook was, in essence--or Meta, 
Instagram, they were, in essence, tracking her activity online?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely.
 Senator Blackburn. Okay.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That was taken as a signal and then 
shared with----
 Senator Blackburn. Okay.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams [continuing]. Advertisers.
 Senator Blackburn. So they didn't stay given specifically 
to their app. They traveled in the child's phone?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely, Senator.
 Senator Blackburn. Okay, excellent. Thank you. Thank you 
for that. I think it points up some of the harm that is there.
 One of the things I wanted you--we have talked about China 
and their launch of apps--of Facebook's apps in China. I wanted 
to see if you could elaborate on the type data that would be 
found on Facebook servers located in China and the broader 
implications of allowing the CCP to have access to that data.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, I mean, we have just spoken in 
your last question about, you know, just one example of the 
amount of information that this company has.
 Senator Blackburn. Yes.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. It is unfathomable. It is very, very 
hard to wrap your mind around the amount of data that this 
company has on each person who logs on to its servers. It is, 
you know, private messages--but so much data, and all of that 
would channel through a POP server.
 Senator Blackburn. So then it is not just limited. The data 
Facebook holds, or Meta holds, is not just limited to the Meta 
applications?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Not at all, Senator.
 Senator Blackburn. So basically, Meta has the ability to 
build what I call a virtual you of an individual--where they 
go, the transactions they have, the different apps that they 
rotate from one to another. Is that accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely, Senator.
 Senator Blackburn. Okay. Thank you. I have got one other 
question I want to come to you on. And we have heard, not only 
from you but from others, that Mark Zuckerberg would veto 
recommendations from his team when it came to improving 
practices that would protect children or would protect data. 
And he would do this because he would say it was too costly. 
And I just find that astounding.
 In the physical world, we have laws that protect an 
individual's privacy. We have laws that protect children and 
protect them from being exposed to certain harms, like alcohol, 
tobacco sales, meeting predators, pedophiles.
 So I wanted to know if you had witnessed that he, or the 
other C-suites, were actually vetoing recommendations that 
would have provided consumer protection and protection of 
children in the virtual space.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator. And as a mother of three 
children, that is one of the more difficult aspects to 
reconcile with this company. That, that it is not a company 
that looks after users, particularly those 13 to 17, which they 
regard as vulnerable--yet very valuable.
 Senator Blackburn. And then, how long were you employed at 
Facebook? And when was your last day?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I was employed from 2011 and my--I mean, 
it is slightly complicated. But I finished in the end of 2017.
 Senator Blackburn. 2017. Okay. Thank you very much.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Senator Durbin.
 Senator Durbin. Thanks for being here.
 That reference that I opened up with--that you made in your 
book, to a strategy, a message strategy for Meta, and someone 
suggested tobacco as kind of the guideline that you might want 
to follow, some dangerous product that was lessened in 
intensity to the public by misrepresentations.
 As I mentioned at the outset, I was part of the effort to 
bring them down. I didn't realize I had reached a tipping point 
with smoking on airplanes, but it turned out to be one. And 
things changed.
 You make a reference as well in the book that a lot of the 
executives at Facebook protected their own children from what 
might have been an exploitation, which you have described here.
 The algorithm that analyzes your activity on the board and 
says, well, just deleted a selfie, good time for an ad. 
Somebody had put that together. So these executives at Facebook 
protected their own kids from that kind of exploitation. 
Correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, that was one of the things that 
shocked me when I moved to Silicon Valley is that it is a place 
full of, you know, wooden Montessori toys.
 And, you know, executives would always speak about how they 
have screen bans in the house or, you know, they--I would say, 
you know, oh, has your team used the new product we are about 
to launch?
 And they are, like, my teenager is not allowed on Facebook. 
I don't have my teenager on Instagram. Like these executives, 
they know. They know the harm that this product does. They 
don't allow their own teenagers to use the products that Meta 
develops. I mean, the--the hypocrisy is at every level.
 Senator Durbin. So I wanted to just tell you a follow-up to 
that story.
 Eventually, the children of tobacco executives became my 
greatest fans and supporters.
 And they would basically shame their parents by saying 
that, you know, the kids at school are saying this, or I just 
heard something, or I read something. Dad, tell me that you 
aren't part of that tobacco conspiracy to keep the truth from 
the American people.
 They became a force, a moral force in the conversation. It 
would just be speculation, but I hope that that is the case 
here as well.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I hope you are right, Senator.
 Senator Durbin. I read these things, and so I want to ask 
you a question that is more generic. But I am just curious as 
to the decision process at the highest levels.
 When there is a decision being made about what you are 
going to turn over, what Facebook, Meta is going to turn over 
to the Chinese, all their demands that you said the company 
denied to so many other countries, but for China they made an 
exception.
 When the decision is being made about exposing American 
privacy material and data so that the Chinese would have access 
to it, Americans not knowing that.
 The security questions that you raised, the AI information 
that is given to the Chinese that makes them, quote, ``more 
competitive.'' But also means that they have sources of 
information that could compromise the security of the United 
States.
 I mean, when you consider each one of these, they kind of 
grow in gravity and magnitude. Are these decisions being made 
strictly by Zuckerberg himself? Or, by boards? Or, by open 
discussion? How much sensitivity was there to the fact that the 
decisions were historic in nature--and maybe even criminal?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. It is a really interesting question. I 
mean, you asked me in part about China. You know, to give you 
just one example, and the--at the governance level, which is 
what you are asking me.
 The lead independent director on Meta's board was also on 
the payroll for the China project.
 Senator Durbin. So that they had dual loyalty?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think the question around 
accountability and governance of this company, and of tech 
companies more generally, there needs to be a lot more 
accountability. I don't think the current governance structures 
are anywhere close to being sufficient.
 Senator Durbin. Tell me there were people at that company 
that you worked with that didn't sell out.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely, absolutely. There are, you 
know, there were amazing, amazing people. And there are people 
who were horrified and had very strong moral conscience.
 And there are--there are many of these people who have been 
in touch who, since the book--since these revelations have come 
out, have said, yes, I was in those meetings, I remember this. 
You know, there were people who spoke up. There were people--I 
regret to say that many of the people who spoke up are no 
longer at the company. But there are good people there, and 
there are people who have moral beliefs. And there certainly 
were.
 But that wasn't happening at the top of the company. That 
wasn't happening at the executive level. And what was striking 
was the absence of those types of discussions at the top of the 
company compared to what was happening with your average people 
who were working at the company.
 Senator Durbin. And you say Mr. Zuckerberg himself prides 
himself on being a loyal American?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think Mr. Zuckerberg would say he 
does.
 Senator Durbin. Yes.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. But I don't want to speak for him.
 Senator Durbin. No, of course not.
 But I think the evidence that you have given us points in 
the other direction. Lying to Congress may be in the realm of a 
mortal sin, depending on your faith conviction.
 But certainly, selling out the security and privacy of the 
United States is about as low as they go when it comes to Big 
Tech.
 Have you been in any conversations involving Section 230?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. No, Senator.
 Senator Durbin. All right. Well, that is certainly a law 
that we are taking a close look at here, which shields 
companies like this from personal, civil liability.
 Many of us believe--the Committee has voted accordingly, 
that if they could be held accountable for their decisions in a 
court of law and find damages, money to money, that this would 
have more impact than some of the best speeches we could put 
together as Members of Congress. So we are going to work on 
that.
 Mr. Chairman, I thank you for this hearing.
 But I particularly thank you because you have referred to, 
in your testimony, what you call in the book ``three pistols,'' 
which I think is your reference to your three children.
 You have done a great thing for them and for kids all 
across the world. Thank you for testifying today.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Thank you, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. Ms. Wynn-Williams, let me ask you a little 
bit more about the censorship tools that you have been asked 
about today, you have testified about, that were actually 
deployed in Hong Kong and Taiwan. And if we can, let's just 
look again at the privacy team email. Not that one. That one.
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley. Yes. So this is--and just--just so members of 
the press understand, the Committee is in possession of this 
document. We--we have blacked out, as you can see, we have 
blacked out the names of individuals here. But in the 
documents, we have those names.
 Of course, we will follow all appropriate legal procedures.
 But just so the press understands, the Committee is 
committed to doing a full investigation. We do understand and 
know who the people are on this chain. We can see who they are, 
and we can see the full course of the discussion.
 But I just want to emphasize something here. The update is 
they ``spoke with the China team. . .They flagged a potential'' 
course of--of--a ``potential complication,'' of course, in 
negotiations with the Chinese government.''
 Let's just stop there for a second.
 Someone pointed out to you that Mark Zuckerberg testified 
under oath that he didn't know what the Chinese government's 
terms would be to operate Facebook in China because they were 
banned, quote, unquote, ``in China.'' So, he just had no idea. 
He was saying this as late as 2017, 2018. He just had no idea 
what the terms would be. That is just categorically false. 
Isn't it?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Absolutely, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And this email shows that it is false. 
Correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct.
 Chair Hawley. In fact, what this email shows is, Facebook 
is in very regularly close contact with members of the Chinese 
government down to specifying how they want the censorship 
tools to work. They are giving feedback on it, back and forth, 
and back and forth. And here they have agreed on a set of 
censorship tools to deploy in Hong Kong down to the fact that 
they say, we are going to have to actually, ``re-TOS.'' Does 
that mean terms of service?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Correct.
 Chair Hawley. So, in other words, they are going to have to 
push out to Hong Kong users a new click thing, for them to 
click on, which they won't, of course, really understand or 
know because it is almost impossible to decipher. But in fact, 
what they are doing is it is allowing Facebook to stand up new 
censorship tools on behalf of the Chinese government. Is that 
correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct.
 Chair Hawley. Now, here is another interesting point. Back 
in 2012, the FTC--here in this country, the FTC entered a 
consent decree with Facebook about privacy.
 Do you remember, Ms. Wynn-Williams--this would have been 
early on in your time at the company, but do you remember 
roughly any of the terms of that FTC consent decree? Because 
they are relevant here.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I do, Senator. They were intended to 
prevent Meta from deceiving people about the extent to which 
they collect and share their data.
 Chair Hawley. Yes. So the part of the order is, and let me 
just quote, Facebook shall, quote, ``shall not misrepresent in 
any manner expressly or by implication the extent to which it 
maintains the privacy or security of covered information,'' end 
quote--which is user data.
 Now, Facebook is under a consent decree with the FTC on 
this basis, and yet they are deliberately misrepresenting 
across the world the security of user data.
 They are--they are negotiating with the Chinese government 
to turn over user data, give--grant the Chinese government 
access to Chinese user data, including the Hong Kongese, 
including Taiwan.
 And yet, they are representing to American Government 
Officials, no, no, no, we don't do that. We don't do that. In 
fact, they testified--they testified under oath we don't make 
user data available. All of that was just lies. Is that fair to 
say, Ms. Wynn-Williams?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, many, many decisions have been 
made, and they were all premised on the basis that Meta would 
hand over Chinese user data to the Chinese Communist Party.
 Chair Hawley. So in addition to lying to Congress on what 
seems like a fairly regular basis, lying about suppressing 
dissidents, lying about setting up censorship tools, they have 
also arguably violated FTC consent decrees.
 And we have the documentation. This isn't just Ms. Wynn-
Williams' opinion. This isn't just her recollection.
 We have the documentation with the Facebook employees, who 
I might add are high-level, executive-level employees, who are 
planning this and doing this. It's--it's really, it is quite 
extraordinary. This was a pattern of operations at Facebook, 
over and over and over.
 We will come back to that, Ms. Wynn-Williams. But if you 
are ready, Senator Klobuchar----
 Senator Klobuchar. Of course I am.
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. I will turn over to you.
 Senator Klobuchar. Thank you. Thank you very much. And I 
just, again, appreciate that you have come forward.
 In your book, you wrote that ``Facebook remade American 
news media by inserting Facebook at the center of it, driving 
down ad rates for newspapers, and distributing their stories 
using their content to boost time spent on Facebook.''
 Senator Kennedy and I, as a side, have a bill to push 
negotiations for the price of content, which I think is really 
important.
 But, could you explain how Meta uses news content to boost 
time spent on Facebook? And how that allows Facebook to sell 
more advertising without paying publishers their fair share?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I mean, the key thing that Meta is 
obsessed with is engagement, is keeping people's attention on 
the services that Meta owns for as long as possible, using 
whatever tools it can--so definitely the work of publishers and 
the work of many dedicated journalists. And also, increasingly, 
they are utilizing AI to keep engagement, often, AI based on 
the work of journalists and authors.
 Senator Klobuchar. Mm-hmm. Exactly. And when discussing 
ways to promote a healthy news market, you quoted Mr. 
Zuckerberg as saying, quote, ``You are compromising with a 
dying industry rather than dominating it, crushing it.'' What 
do you see with your experience as a consequence if Facebook is 
allowed to dominate and crush an independent news media?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think every citizen has seen the 
consequences of these actions. And I think we are all the 
poorer for it.
 Senator Klobuchar. Mm-hmm. Thank you.
 When discussing the role that political ads play in 
Facebook's business, you observed that peddling outrage and 
stretching the truth were just part of the game, and that 
outrage is a lucrative business for Facebook.
 I care about this a lot, just being in this business of 
politics and how we know how negativity is awarded online--not 
just Facebook, in all of the algorithms in these companies. And 
it has actually completely changed the ecosystem that we work 
in.
 Can you elaborate more on how stoking political outrage is 
profitable for Facebook and ramifications for democracy?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think we are all living with the 
consequences of this every day. As I said before, what this 
company wants is to dominate as much time and attention as it 
can of every, you know, not just in this country, as many 
billions as they can.
 And what they have learned is that outrage is a really good 
way to do that. But whatever it takes, whatever it takes to 
have people glued to these services in their power, in their 
thrall----
 Senator Klobuchar. Mm-hmm.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams [continuing]. They will do it.
 Senator Klobuchar. The major focus of this hearing, of 
course, on China, and I have to say that I found that whole 
piece of this ironic because when Senator Grassley and I were 
trying to pass our bill about the self-preferencing, which 
also, of course, got the ire of Google and Amazon and these 
other companies.
 You remember that day well, when we had the hearing, 
Senator Hawley, the markup on this bill. Well, one of the 
things that keeps--kept being thrown in my face, and in those 
of others that work on this, is China, you are actually going 
to destroy us, and then China will dominate. And at one point, 
another Senator actually said that that was what national 
security officials said.
 And anticipating that, I had actually gone around to the 
then-head of the FBI, the head of the CIA. I would called them 
all or seen them at things. And while they were getting in the 
business of endorsing, they said, no, this idea of doing 
something about putting consumer protections in and saying you 
can't put your own product all the time at the top of the 
search engine, that did not hurt our national security vis-a-
vis China.
 But that is what they claim. And that is what is so 
interesting about your experience and your testimony.
 And your book actually reveals the extent to which Facebook 
was willing to put growth over the U.S. national interest to 
gain favor with the Chinese Communist Party, as you pointed out 
in your testimony today.
 In fact, and I know Senator Grassley asked you about this, 
you wrote, ``Meta started briefing the Communist Party as early 
as 2015''--you talked about this today--``the explicit goal 
being to help China outcompete American companies.'' Could you 
elaborate on that?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I think, to pick up on your point, 
Senator, Meta is very quick to say, don't do anything that can 
hurt us because you will let China win. You know, you will let 
China win on AI. You will let China win and gain the 
technological advantage.
 And the whole time, the company that has done the most to 
help China gain a technological advantage is Meta.
 Senator Klobuchar. Mm-hmm. So do you believe Facebook is an 
honest broker--this is called a softball--when it claims 
competition reforms would harm the U.S. ability to compete with 
China? Because I am telling you, we hear this all the time, 
so--every time we try to bring up any of these bills.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. I hope what we have discussed today, 
Senator, helps you push back very firmly and gives you 
something to create some real accountability.
 Senator Klobuchar. And then finally, Senator Cruz and I 
mentioned we have this bill Take It Down that has passed the 
Senate.
 And just your view that if Meta puts its considerable 
engineering expertise toward the problem of removing 
nonconsensual intimate images that have the power to ruin lives 
or even the selling of fentanyl or some of these other things, 
do you think they could do it?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, they have shown to the Chinese 
Communist Party that when they are motivated to get something--
to remove something, they can be absolutely expert in it, very 
fast.
 Senator Klobuchar. All right. Thank you very much.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Thank you, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. Senator Blumenthal.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 I would be interested in knowing, Ms. Wynn-Williams, when 
Meta first tried to silence you, when they first contacted you, 
what was said to you, and I assume it was in the nature of a 
threat and a warning of some kind.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, Senator. I have had some very--I am 
trying to find the right words--aggressive threats from this 
company, and the last 4 weeks have been very difficult.
 Senator Blumenthal. Apart from the threats in a judicial 
setting, have there been others?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. There have been a number of things, 
Senator, yes. And--yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. Would you prefer to tell us about that 
in private?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. No, it is okay. I can--sorry, it is 
hard, but I can talk about it, yes. So--well, so Meta has 
said--so even the choice to come to speak to Congress was 
incredibly difficult. Maybe it is helpful if I read what they 
told me.
 Senator Blumenthal. Please do.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They said, the purpose of--sorry, they 
said, if the respondent--well, if me--if I were permitted to 
communicate with legislators, that is you, ``such actions would 
create an exception to non-disparagement, that it would eat the 
rule. In such circumstance, nothing would limit or prevent 
those legislators or their aides from parroting to the public 
any disparaging statements.''
 And I just want to pause here because a disparaging 
statement is a true statement--so it is telling you the truth.
 ``Respondent is barred from disclosing.'' So they were very 
clear that even coming to speak to you about the truth and 
about the concerns of national security and protecting our 
children and sharing these truths with you, that would have not 
only $50,000 for each truthful statement, actual damages for 
breach of confidentiality, actual and punitive damages for 
fraud and other claims.
 Senator Blumenthal. So let me just be clear. In effect, 
they are warning you against what we might say publicly based 
on your comments to us, even though they might not hold you--
or, bar you from coming here.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They have said that is a potential 
consequence. That is the order they have secured.
 Senator Blumenthal. That, in effect, you would be held 
responsible for what we might say as a result of your truthful 
testimony.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Not just you, Senators, something your 
aide might say. I mean, they frame it as something your aide 
might parrot.
 Senator Blumenthal. In other words, what these folks in 
back of us might say, as well as what we might say.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Even though it is factual and true.
 Senator Blumenthal. Even though it is factually true. In 
effect, I mean, now that you mention it, it creates pressure on 
us not to tell the truth to the American public, is the way I 
view it.
 It is, in a sense, threatening you, and thereby putting 
pressure on us, that we could have to worry about harming you 
as a result.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Please don't worry about harming me.
 Senator Blumenthal. And when did--when did they first 
contact you? I guess when they became aware of your book or----
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Well, that is right. They put out public 
statements when they first became aware of the book.
 But they also effectively tried to--I mean, I don't know 
very--I am learning very fast about the system of arbitration, 
which seems incredibly unjust.
 But they sought to game that. They said that they had 
notified me of an arbitration. They didn't--they have my email 
on file. They have my--they have so many ways to contact me. I 
worked for them for a long time. Most of the senior executive 
have emailed me. But they chose not to notify me through that 
email address. So I was not able----
 Senator Blumenthal. They issued a public statement. So 
they----
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That's right.
 Senator Blumenthal [continuing]. First went public and then 
contacted you----
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Well, they didn't contact me, but--yes, 
Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. And what did they do to start the 
arbitration process?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They just--they started it without me. 
They secured the order without me.
 Senator Blumenthal. Without any representation?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct because I was not aware 
that they had sent it to an email address from 2007.
 Senator Blumenthal. And my understanding is that you were 
regularly communicating with Meta. But they still used a 
defunct email address to serve the notice of the emergency 
arbitration. You were provided no notice of the proceeding, the 
appointment of an emergency arbitrator without your legal team 
knowing or having opportunity to object. And the initial 
hearing took place without anybody from your legal team 
participating.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes, I didn't know about it, so I 
couldn't participate in it.
 Senator Blumenthal. And once they had an emergency gag 
order in hand, they knew how to reach you. Correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, I was--honestly, I was trying 
to get my toddler to eat some oatmeal, and the door went--the 
doorbell went.
 And it is a little embarrassing, but it was just after the 
book had published, so I thought it might have been someone 
delivering flowers. No. It was a gag order.
 Senator Blumenthal. So Meta's flowers were a gag order. And 
they knew where you were.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. They had no trouble reaching you with 
the emergency gag order. They didn't bother letting you know 
about the arbitration process--or anything, before they got 
what they wanted.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. They obviously knew where my home was 
the entire time.
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, Mr. Chairman, I think that this 
experience is kind of a textbook example of the kind of 
problems that we hear from our constituents relating to forced 
arbitration.
 I happen to be the lead Sponsor in the Senate of the Forced 
Arbitration Injustice Repeal Act.
 You know, it is the FAIR Act, which would end these kinds 
of abusive clauses that enabled them to do what they did with 
you, Ms. Wynn-Williams.
 And just so we are absolutely clear, they are trying to 
force you to pay them this $50,000 in liquidated damages for 
each so-called disparaging comment--true comments, which they 
regard as unfavorable to them even when you tell the truth 
about their misconduct. Correct?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Senator.
 Before we let you go, Ms. Wynn-Williams, just one other 
line of questions, if I could--just one other subject.
 You actually touched on it with Senator Blackburn. She was 
talking to you about the kind of research that Facebook has 
done and the kind of advertising that they are willing to sell.
 And to me, what is so interesting about this is, we have 
seen, frankly, the moral bankruptcy of this company and its 
leadership when it comes to China.
 And we have seen them be willing to lie to Congress, lie to 
the American public. We have got the documents in black and 
white.
 We have seen them be willing to give away American user 
data.
 But they were also trying to find out a way to make a buck 
on Americans, teenagers, children in times of distress--right 
here in the United States.
 And I just want to give you an opportunity to comment on 
this. Here is an internal Facebook chat where a policy--where a 
Facebook policy director asks----
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. ``Is it really accurate that 
Facebook is doing research into young mothers and their 
emotional state? Is it your understanding that there is other 
research related to young mothers? '' Answer, ``Yes. I looked 
at one list of research topics and saw one about young mothers 
and their emotional state.''
 Coming down, the person says, ``I am wondering about asking 
my apparently morally bankrupt colleagues if they are aware of 
any more.''
 This is about Facebook's program to target ads to people 
when they are in emotional distress. Is that right? Is that 
what we are seeing here?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is correct, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. And that included teenage girls, as you were 
discussing with Senator Blackburn--those who had maybe recently 
deleted a selfie, maybe not feeling very good about themselves, 
and Facebook said, oh, oh, fantastic opportunity. We can sell 
this to advertisers.
 It apparently also included young mothers who are in 
moments of distress. I mean, who knows what that might include? 
Everything from the spilled oatmeal you were trying to put into 
your toddler's mouth. I have three children, I understand. Or 
who knows what much, much worse things.
 So Facebook is--is constantly looking for opportunities to 
sell to advertisers, to make a buck, even on their own users. 
And they are doing it by tracking their users all over the 
place--tracking their emotional state. I mean, have I got that 
accurate?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. You have got that accurate. And beyond 
that, it is things like--things that often do concern teen 
girls like body confidence, you know, that is something else 
that they use to target, you know, weight loss or other things 
on, you know, children, really, 13- to 17-year-olds.
 Chair Hawley. So did--to your knowledge, did Facebook--
after this email exchange, you know, where another user says, 
``I think it is a slippery slope here,'' and then there is the 
admission, ``There is a level of behavioral targeting.''
 I mean, just to be clear, I want everybody to see this. 
``There is a level of behavioral targeting.'' I mean, these are 
Facebook executives. Again, this is a policy director in this 
chat acknowledging that this is what Facebook is doing. Did it 
stop? Did Facebook stop doing this?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Not to my knowledge, Senator.
 Chair Hawley. Yes, in fact, we know they didn't because 
other whistleblowers came forward to show that at Instagram, 
owned by Facebook, there was explicit targeting that goes on.
 There was explicit knowledge that the Instagram product was 
causing, in some cases, severe emotional distress, particularly 
to young girls. Facebook kept right on doing it anyway. Is that 
just because it made them a bunch of money?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, you know, as a mother of three 
children, it is very hard to say this, but yes, the--you know, 
one of the discussions I had with one of the business leaders 
was, like, we just don't need to do this.
 Like, as a company, you know, Meta is now a trillion-dollar 
company. It is not short of money. It doesn't need to do this.
 And what he explained to me is, like, you know, we have got 
the most valuable segment of the population, you know. 
Advertisers really want to reach 13- to 17-year-olds. And we 
have them. We should be trumpeting it from the rooftops.
 Chair Hawley. It is really just extraordinary. I think what 
we have seen here is the evidence that you presented, the 
evidence that we have in black and white, is a company and 
leadership that is willing to do anything--anything, work with 
America's chief competitor, work with our chief adversaries, 
sell out other American businesses, sell out American user 
data, lie to Congress, lie to the public, anything in order to 
amass more power and make a buck.
 Can I just ask you, you know Mark Zuckerberg very well. You 
spent a lot of time with him. He has recently tried a 
reinvention in which he is now a great advocate of free speech 
after being an advocate of censorship in China and in this 
country for years after suppressing the Hunter Biden laptop 
story, after talking--after working hand-in-glove with the 
Biden administration to suppress content on COVID, to suppress 
content on masks, to suppress content on election questions, on 
vaccines, all of that. Now that is all wiped away.
 Now he is on Joe Rogan and says that he is Mr. Free Speech. 
He is Mr. MAGA. He is a whole new man. And his company, they 
are a whole new company. Do you buy this latest reinvention of 
Mark Zuckerberg?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, there are two things.
 If he is such a fan of freedom of speech, why is he trying 
to silence me?
 And the other thing is that, this is a man who wears many 
different costumes.
 When I was there, he, you know, wanted the President of 
China to name his first child. He was learning Mandarin. That 
was, you know, he was censoring to his heart's content.
 Now his new costume is MMA fighting or, okay--whatever, you 
know, free speech.
 We don't know what the next costume is going to be. But it 
will be something different. It is whatever gets him closest to 
power.
 Chair Hawley. If he were here, is there anything you would 
like to say to him?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. Senator, I have a lot of questions for 
Mark Zuckerberg. But he has proven time and time again that you 
cannot believe his answers.
 He has lied to Members of Congress.
 He has lied to his employees.
 And he has lied to Americans.
 And that is why I am asking this Committee to hold him 
accountable.
 Chair Hawley. Well, we are going to do that. And I just 
have to say, I don't trust his latest reinvention at all.
 He sat where you have sat, in front of this Committee, 
multiple times in my short time in the Senate.
 Every time, it is a different answer.
 Every time, it is a different facade.
 But every time--the one consistent throughline is, every 
time, it is something misleading.
 Every time, it is something other than the truth.
 Every time, it is about Mark Zuckerberg--not the American 
people.
 It is about Mark Zuckerberg--not what is good for this 
country, not what is good for his users, not what is the truth.
 And I, for one, am very tired of it.
 So I have a message to Mark Zuckerberg as well, which is 
that: It is time for you to tell the truth. You should come to 
this Committee and take an oath and sit where Ms. Wynn-Williams 
is sitting now and answer this evidence.
 Stop trying to silence her. Stop trying to gag her. Stop 
trying to hide behind your lawyers and millions of dollars in 
legal fees you are trying to impose on her.
 Stop threatening other whistleblowers.
 Come to this Committee. Take the oath. Sit there. Let us 
question you, and give the American people the truth. We will 
be waiting for you.
 Senator, anything further?
 Senator Blumenthal. Well said, Mr. Chairman. I associate 
myself with your remarks.
 And what I would say to him is, stop silencing Ms. Wynn-
Williams, for starters. And I go along with you that he ought 
to come here and tell the truth.
 I just want to clarify that the statement on speaking to 
Congress was from the arbitrator. Is that right?
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. The arbitrator that Meta sought.
 Senator Blumenthal. The arbitrator that Meta obtained and 
the gag order is still in effect.
 Ms. Wynn-Williams. That is right, Senator. This may be the 
last time I am allowed to speak.
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, it is not going to be the last 
time you are allowed to speak, if we have anything to do with 
it.
 What I would say to Mark Zuckerberg is stop gagging Ms. 
Wynn-Williams. Let her speak the truth. And you come here and 
tell us your version of the truth--if you have the guts to do 
it.
 Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. I can promise you, Ms. Wynn-Williams, that 
this will not be the end. This is just the beginning. We are 
going to get the truth. And you have done a great service to 
the American people by telling the truth here today. Thank you 
for being willing to do it.
 With that, this Committee is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 4:21 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 [Additional material submitted for the record follows.]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 A P P E N D I X

The following submissions are available at:

 https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61882/pdf/CHRG-
 119shrg
 61882-add1.pdf

Submitted by Chair Hawley:

 ``Meta's Statement to Axios,'' poster displayed during hearing... 2

 Facebook leaders' meeting notes, poster displayed during hearing. 3

 Facebook engineers' messages, poster displayed during hearing.... 4

 Facebook internal document, excerpt 1, poster displayed during 
 hearing....................................................... 5

 Facebook internal chat, poster displayed during hearing.......... 6

 [all]