CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS

Senate Judiciary Committee Senate June 25, 2025

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-199]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-199

 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL 
 APPOINTMENTS

=======================================================================

 HEARING

 before the

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 FIRST SESSION
 __________

 JUNE 25, 2025
 __________

 Serial No. J-119-27
 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary

 [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 www.judiciary.senate.gov
 www.govinfo.gov
 ______
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE

61-888 WASHINGTON : 2026 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

 CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman
 
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California

 Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director

 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page
Grassley, Hon. Charles E......................................... 1
Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 4
Booker, Hon. Cory A.............................................. 10
Moody, Hon. Ashley............................................... 7

 VISITING INTRODUCERS

Scott, Hon. Rick, U.S. Senator from Florida...................... 8

 NOMINEES

Artau, Edward L.................................................. 50
 Questionnaire................................................ 68
 Responses to written questions............................... 123
 Additional materials......................................... 210

Bove, Emil J., III............................................... 11
 Questionnaire................................................ 233
 Responses to written questions............................... 268
 Additional materials......................................... 433

Dudek, Kyle Christopher.......................................... 51
 Questionnaire................................................ 467
 Responses to written questions............................... 514

Moe, Anne-Leigh Gaylord.......................................... 53
 Questionnaire................................................ 578
 Responses to written questions............................... 633

Pratt, Jordan Emery.............................................. 52
 Questionnaire................................................ 697
 Responses to written questions............................... 755

 APPENDIX

Items submitted for the record................................... 841

 
 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL 
 APPOINTMENTS

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, JUNE 25, 2025

 United States Senate,
 Committee on the Judiciary,
 Washington, DC.
 The Committee met, pursuant to notice at 10:16 a.m., in 
Room 216, Hart Senate Office Building, Hon. Charles E. 
Grassley, Chairman of the Committee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Grassley [presiding], Lee, Cruz, Hawley, 
Kennedy, Blackburn, Schmitt, Britt, Moody, Durbin, Whitehouse, 
Klobuchar, Blumenthal, Hirono, Booker, Padilla, Welch, and 
Schiff.
 Also present: Senator Scott.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF IOWA

 Chairman Grassley. Good morning. I'd like to welcome 
everyone to today's hearing. Our first panel features Emil 
Bove, nominated to the U.S. Court of Appeals Third Circuit. 
Then on panel 2, we'll hear from four district court nominees; 
Anne-Leigh Gaylord Moe, Kyle Dudek, Jordan Pratt, each 
nominated for the Middle District of Florida, and Edward Artau, 
nominated to the Southern District of Florida.
 Before we begin, I'd like to address a few matters upfront 
that will likely come up today. First, Mr. Bove has been the 
subject of an intense opposition campaign by my Democratic 
colleagues and by their media allies. While it's fair to 
criticize a nominee, I think that this Committee owes this 
nominee a fair shake and respect at this hearing.
 This is hardly the first time this Congress that we've come 
into a nomination hearing against a backdrop of breathless 
claims that one of President Trump's nominees is uniquely 
unqualified or unfit. Notwithstanding the noise, this Committee 
gave those nominees a fair hearing, weighed their 
qualifications and ultimately considered them on their merits, 
not on media portrayals. This Committee will do the same thing 
for Mr. Bove.
 Second, as a senior attorney in the executive branch and as 
a former attorney in private practice, Mr. Bove may be bound by 
recognized privileges such as executive privilege, deliberative 
process privilege, and attorney-client privilege. This 
Committee will respect those protections not as a courtesy, but 
because the law demands it.
 Third, I'd like to note that some of the rhetoric aimed at 
Mr. Bove by the media, and even by Members of this Committee 
has, has crossed the line. One Member of this Committee called 
Mr. Bove, ``coward and a fool.'' This sort of language, this 
sort of personal tact is just not appropriate and cheapens the 
process.
 I'd like to admonish my colleagues to follow Senator 
Welch's advice from last week's hearing, ``--not to turn debate 
into personal accusations of motivations, of coverup, of 
conspiracy, of bad character, of demeaning folks who disagree 
with us. We will get nowhere with that approach.'' Common sense 
coming from Senator Welch.
 Turning every nominee into a political punching bag isn't 
advice and consent. It's smear and obstruct, and that's not a 
distortion of the constitutional design. It is a distortion.
 Now, if my Democrat colleagues want to talk qualifications, 
let me not forget, let us not forget the nominees that they 
rubber stamped during President Biden's administration. I want 
to start with Charnelle Bjelkengren who came before this 
Committee with absolutely no Federal court experience and 
couldn't answer a basic constitutional question. Even the press 
said it was a disaster, but she received the support of each 
Member of my Democrat colleagues.
 Or Nancy Abudu, nominated to the 11th Circuit, her 
background with a group that labeled Republican Senators, 
``White supremacists,'' made her one of the most defensive 
nominees we've ever seen. She received the support of every one 
of the my Democrat colleagues. Then there is Kato Crews, a 
magistrate judge who didn't know what a Brady motion was, even 
though as a sitting judge had a legal obligation to inform 
parties of their obligations under Brady v. Marilyn. He all 
also received the support of every one of my colleagues on the 
other side of the aisle.
 These aren't cherry picked examples. They're part of a 
pattern. The Biden White House repeatedly sent us nominees who 
lacked the experience traditionally given for lifetime 
appointments, and my colleagues voted to confirm them. Now, 
let's compare these nominees to Mr. Bove. I have the privilege 
of introducing him this morning, so I'd like to take a moment 
to highlight his background.
 Mr. Bove graduated summa cum laude, Georgetown Law, earning 
Order of the Coif at the top of his class. He also graduated 
magna cum laude with a 4.0 GPA from the State University of New 
York at Albany. He clerked for Judge Wesley of the Second 
Circuit and Judge Sullivan of the Southern District of New 
York, both well respected jurors.
 Mr. Bove spent nearly a decade as a Federal prosecutor 
taking on national security and narcotics cases. This high 
stakes work demands sharp legal judgment and steady resolve. 
Day in and day out, he was in the trenches putting terrorists 
and drug traffickers behind bars. He helped bring the Chelsea 
Bomber to justice, the same terrorists who planted bombs across 
North Carolina and New York, injured dozens of Americans, and 
shot New Jersey police officers before he was captured.
 Mr. Bove wasn't just reading reports. He was on the ground 
at the FBI's Joint Operations Center when the attacks happened, 
and he jumped to action and helped secure a conviction and a 
life sentence. For that work he rightly earned one of DOJ's 
highest honors the director's award for Superior Performance by 
a Litigative Team.
 Mr. Bove also led the prosecution of Cesar Sayoc, the 
domestic terrorists who mailed 16 bombs intending to kill 
prominent Democrats, including Senator Booker, President Biden, 
Secretary Clinton, vice-President Harris, and others. Mr. Bove 
also prosecuted another pipe bomb terrorist, Hezbollah 
operative, and an FBI employee accused of spying for China.
 Now, these are not theoretical threats. These are real 
national security cases, and Mr. Bove took them head on. Mr. 
Bove's colleagues praised his tenacity, his legal skill, and 
his principal commitment to the rule of law. And it's not just 
words. Thirty-six former senior Justice Department employees 
and twenty State attorneys general have sent letters supporting 
his nomination. They know firsthand what kind of a lawyer and a 
public servant Mr. Bove is.
 But his excellent credentials do not end there. In private 
practice, he represented clients at all levels of the Federal 
court, including briefings before the Supreme Court, and now 
he's in one of the most senior legal roles in the Justice 
Department. Put very simply, Mr. Bove checks every box; 
academic distinction, Federal clerkships, complex trial and 
appellate litigation, senior Justice Department leadership. His 
experience isn't just sufficient. It is very exceptional.
 He's also served the people of the Third District, both as 
a Federal prosecutor prosecuting their safety and in private 
practice representing their interest. He lives in the Circuit. 
He's practiced in the Circuit.
 I've heard complaints about the lack of consultation, but 
let's set the record straight. I've been informed that since 
February, the White House has consulted with my colleagues from 
New Jersey. The White House interviewed or attempted to 
interview all of their suggested candidates, some of whom 
didn't want the job. The White House also ensured that my 
colleagues from New Jersey had the opportunity to meet 
personally with Mr. Bove.
 And even when consultation happens in good faith as it did 
here, opposition doesn't automatically carry a veto. The 
Committee's recent practice makes that clear that home State 
opposition doesn't disqualify a nominee. And let me give you 
some recent reminder of that. Just look at what happened with 
the Sixth Circuit last year. Every Democrat on the Committee 
voted to advance Kevin Ritz, even after allegations and 
evidence of prosecutorial misconduct surfaced. This happened 
over the objections of both home State Senators from Tennessee.
 There have been several others as well. Embry Kidd in the 
11th Circuit opposed by Florida Senators. Karla Campbell to the 
Sixth Circuit opposed by the Tennessee Senators, and Ryan Park 
to the First Circuit opposed by North Carolina Senators.
 Which brings me to another point. Let's not pretend that 
nominees with ties to the President are somehow suspect. The 
Biden administration didn't hesitate to nominate vocal 
partisans like Dale Ho, who attacked Republicans and dismissed 
conservative legal thought entirely. If Democrats could look 
past that, they can give Mr. Bove a fair hearing.
 Once again, we see a double standard. The qualifications of 
President Trump's nominees are ignored by the same voices who 
rise to confirm less qualified, and often overtly partisan 
nominees during the last 4 years. It's time to hold everybody 
to the very same standard.
 The breadth of support Mr. Bove has earned from the legal 
community affirms what his record makes clear; he has a deep 
command of the law and a steady commitment to public service, 
not political agendas. He's ready to serve on the Third Circuit 
with distinction. Our district court nominees are also highly 
qualified, and we look forward to hearing from each of them 
today.
 So, now to Senator Durbin, Ranking Member.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS

 Senator Durbin. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. And 
congratulations to the nominees, their families, and friends.
 First, a matter of record. For the last 4 years before this 
one, I was Chairman of this Committee. We considered 235, 235 
judicial nominees that were sent to us by the White House. 
Those nominees were all approved by this Committee and by the 
U.S. Senate. Eighty percent, 80 percent of the nominees 
received bipartisan roll call support. So, I want to make that 
record very clear.
 Today, we'll hear from Emil Bove, who has been nominated 
for a lifetime appointment to a New Jersey seat on the Third 
Circuit Court of Appeals. Over the years, especially during the 
first Trump administration, I've disagreed with many nominees 
who appeared before this Committee on matters of constitutional 
interpretation.
 President Trump's judicial picks during his first term were 
largely legal conservatives. This nominee is in a category all 
of his own. A former personal defense attorney of President 
Trump, Mr. Bove has led the effort to weaponize the Department 
of Justice against the President's enemies. Having earned his 
stripes as a loyalist to this President, he's been rewarded 
with this lifetime nomination.
 Mr. Bove has fired dozens of career Federal prosecutors who 
worked on cases related to the January 6 insurrection, the 
cases that were assigned to them. In Mr. Bove's memo ordering 
the termination of these prosecutors, and we have a copy here 
for those who have any question about it, he cited President 
Trump's false and outrageous claim that the prosecution of 
January 6 rioters was, ``--a grave national injustice that has 
been perpetrated upon the American people over the last 4 
years.''
 For the record, 169 of these January 6 rioters who attacked 
our capital were convicted of assaulting law enforcement 
agents. The married men and women who stand behind you, and in 
the hallways risking their lives for your safety and my safety, 
were the victims of this January 6 attack. One-hundred-sixty-
nine were convicted of crimes related directly to that 
question. President Trump gave them, and over 1,000 other 
rioters, a full pardon as one of his first acts of office. Mr. 
Bove called these convictions, ``--a grave injustice.''
 Mr. Bove also ordered the FBI to compile a list of all 
current and former FBI employees who were assigned ``at any 
time'' to a January 6 investigation ``to determine whether any 
additional personnel actions are necessary.'' Political 
retribution at this high level of our government has seldom 
been seen. This was done and executed by the nominee.
 There's more. Mr. Bove personally intervened to strike a 
corrupt bargain with the New York City Mayor Eric Adams. You 
read about it. We've all heard the quotes. He wanted to drop 
the prosecution of Mayor Adams in exchange for Adams promise to 
cooperate with President Trump's immigration policies. In 
response, several professional prosecutors resigned, including 
the U.S. attorney herself, a staunch conservative who clerked 
for Justice Scalia and was appointed by President Trump. She 
resigned over Mr. Bove's suggested deal.
 The lead prosecutor in the Adams case also resigned Hagan 
Scotten, who earned two bronze stars in Iraq, clerked for Chief 
Justice Roberts and Justice Kavanaugh wrote to Mr. Bove and I 
quote, ``I expect you will eventually find someone who is 
enough of a fool, enough of a coward to file your motion. But 
it was never going to be me.''
 And according to a whistleblower complaint the Committee 
received yesterday, Mr. Bove has suggested that the Justice 
Department might need to say ``F you'' to Federal courts and 
ignore Federal court orders with which this administration 
disagrees. Ladies and gentlemen, this gets to the heart of our 
democracy and the rule of law. As Senator Kennedy of Louisiana 
has rightly reminded previous nominees, and I quote, ``Don't 
ever, ever take the position that you're not going to follow an 
order of the Federal court. Ever.''
 These serious allegations against Mr. Bove came not from 
the ACLU, but from a career Justice Department lawyer who was 
promoted by the Trump administration and is best known for 
defending the first Trump administration's immigration policies 
in court. He has now put his reputation on the line to inform 
this Committee on The Judiciary of what Mr. Bove's wrongdoing 
was. And predictably, he's being attacked by the President's 
MAGA lap dogs.
 In addition to Mr. Bove's unethical conduct, there are 
serious questions about his temperament. According to public 
reporting, Mr. Bove was the subject of an internal 
investigation over his, ``abusive bellicose management style,'' 
while serving as a Federal prosecutor in the Southern District 
of New York. Just what we need in a Federal judge with a 
lifetime appointment.
 His fellow prosecutors noted that Mr. Bove has a quick 
temper and he belittled his coworkers. In one instance, his 
poor management contributed to a botched case in which an 
individual convicted of serious charges related to evading 
foreign sanction was allowed to go free.
 My Republican colleagues may brush these examples aside. 
They may say Democrats have an axe to grind against Mr. Bove 
because of the role he's playing in the President's agenda. But 
the fact remains that complaints about Mr. Bove's temperament 
and candor long predate his association with President Trump.
 I'd also like to address the process by which Mr. Bove was 
selected for this New Jersey seat. The White House engaged with 
Senator Booker and Senator Kim on this vacancy for only 3 
months before announcing Mr. Bove's nomination. And notably, 
the White House did not indicate it was considering Mr. Bove 
until 2 months into that process.
 Compare that to Biden White House's approach with 
Republican Members of the Committee. The Biden White House 
discussed two Sixth Circuit vacancies and a Fourth Circuit 
vacancy with home State Senators for 7 months, 9 months, and 6 
months respectively, before making a selection.
 The White House also initially indicated that Senator 
Booker would be able to interview candidates other than Mr. 
Bove before then reversing course. Notably, Mr. Bove hardly has 
ties to New Jersey for this New Jersey-based seat. Don't take 
my word for it. His formal nomination before this Committee 
identifies him as, ``Emil J. Bove III, of Pennsylvania. He's 
not even admitted to practice before the court to which he's 
been nominated.
 As a former Chairman of this Committee as said, with 
respect to judicial nominees, ``Elections have consequences.'' 
So, I expect to see conservative judicial nominees coming from 
this administration. But in recent weeks, President Trump has 
criticized Leonard Leo and the Federalist Society for ``bad 
advice they gave him in recommending legal conservatives during 
his first term.''
 He's upset that his own judicial nominees had the audacity 
to rule against the administration's illegal actions. With Mr. 
Bove we see a sign of what is to come. President Trump cares a 
little about statutory interpretation and the original meaning 
of the Constitution. He is looking for loyalty. He's looking 
for fierce retribution. He's looking for someone who will 
instill fear in his opponents. It seems he has found such a 
nominee in Mr. Bove. I yield.
 Chairman Grassley. Before I go to the Senators from 
Florida, I have to address the allegation that you just made 
about Mr. Bove suggesting that the department should violate 
court orders. As initial matter this statement would be 
inconsistent with what President Trump said back in February 
11, ``I always abide by the courts. Always abide by them, and 
will appeal.''
 This initial unconfirmed whistleblower report that Senator 
Durbin referred to was leaked in a New York Times article the 
day before Mr. Bove's hearing, and the Justice Department was 
only given 15 minutes to respond before the article was 
published. The timing alone indicates that this was a 
coordinated political strike.
 And there are other reasons to be skeptical. The Times 
completely failed to mention that the whistleblower who alleged 
that the Justice Department removed alien pursuant to the Alien 
Enemies Act in violation of court orders, himself signed a 
brief affirming to the court that the Government had complied 
with all court orders in the case.
 The Deputy Attorney General has also unequivocally denied 
these allegations in a public statement, and I'd like to read 
that, and we have a poster here, but I'm going to read it 
anyway. ``The New York Times article describes falsehoods 
purportedly made by a disgruntled former employee and then 
leaked to the press in violation of ethical obligations. The 
claims about the Department of Justice leadership and the 
Principal Associate Deputy Attorney General are utterly false, 
which is likely why the author gave the Department of Justice 
15 minutes this that morning to respond.
 They wrote that we did not immediately respond to the 
comment before releasing this garbage. Note that not a single 
individual except the disgruntled former employee agrees with 
the statements cavalierly printed by this purported news 
outlet. I was at the meeting described in the article, and at 
no time did anyone suggest court orders should not be followed. 
This is disgusting journalism. Planting a false hit piece the 
day before the confirmation hearing is something that we have 
to come to expect from the media, but it does not mean it 
should be tolerated.'' Senator Moody.
 [Poster is displayed.]
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, may I respond?
 Chairman Grassley. Yes, you may.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, let me make it clear. This 
was sent to the Committee, both sides of the Committee, both 
sides of the Capitol, yesterday. It wasn't leaked, it was 
signed. Attribution was clear. The individual who made these 
charges made his name clear, and he also made clear his 15-year 
career record with the Department of Justice and the promotions 
he's received.
 Chairman Grassley. Okay. Senator Moody.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ASHLEY MOODY, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF FLORIDA

 Senator Moody. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. Let me first 
by saying welcome to my new colleague, Senator Rick Scott, who 
is in front of the Judiciary Committee today to make 
introductions of some great folks from Florida who we will be 
conducting hearings on. I want to thank him for working with me 
as one of the newest Senators in the U.S. Senate that has the 
privilege of conducting these hearings on the Judiciary 
Committee, but also voting on these well qualified candidates 
for Federal district court judges.
 As someone who practiced in the courts in which they have 
been nominated to serve, and as someone who served as a judge 
in the great free State of Florida, it's certainly an honor, 
and I asked for the privilege of introducing them quickly. I 
know my colleagues don't want to sit through full introductions 
by both of the Senators, but I wanted each of them to know how 
grateful Senator Scott and I are to have such well qualified 
candidates.
 At this point, I am grateful to President Trump for making 
such quick nominations and moving on some of these vacancies. 
Certainly, it will serve Florida well and our Nation. I also 
have personal connections to many of them.
 I'll start with Anne-Leigh Gaylord Moe, who was a judge in 
the 13th Circuit where I served for over a decade, now serves 
as an appellate judge in Florida, which is our intermediate 
appellate court. She is in incredibly qualified. She came on as 
a judge after being a lawyer for some time, well-respected in 
our community, the community in which I grew up in and served 
well there.
 In fact, she came in as a judge just as I was leaving to go 
be the attorney general. And I was sad we didn't get to 
practice together longer. But I am certainly proud and honored 
to introduce you today, and I'm sure Senator Scott will do a 
better job in listing out your numerous accomplishments in the 
State of Florida.
 Jordan Pratt, he is an amazingly qualified individual. He 
was nominated, obviously, by President Trump to serve in the 
Middle District of Florida. I would like to point out, if I 
may, as a Triple Gator, he is a Double Gator where he was the 
valedictorian at the University of Florida in undergrad, and 
then served as the editor of the Law Review in law school. 
Which as you can probably imagine, his career just went on from 
there, arguing very important cases protecting rights, served 
as a deputy solicitor general in the Florida Attorney General's 
Office before going on to serve as an appellate judge. We are 
so proud of him. He will make an excellent addition to the 
judiciary.
 And I would like to say Kyle Dudek, who is being nominated 
to also serve in the Middle District of Florida, as someone who 
practiced in front of all of those district court judges and 
the magistrates there, I have to say, not only did you earn the 
respect of President Trump and my colleague, Senator Rick 
Scott, all of the judges there have such great respect for you. 
They are excited to work with you, and I think you will make an 
incredible addition.
 And Ed Artau, who his experience in terms of years of 
experience and breadth of experience, it's hard to match. He 
also taught at Florida's Judicial College. So, those of you 
that don't know what that is, I did that as well. It is someone 
that is thought of it is schooled enough in the art of being a 
judge and that they ask him to teach the judges, and he did 
that for a long time.
 In fact, everybody that I spoke to about Ed Artau kept 
calling him the dean. So, I love that description. I think 
having judges with that kind of background, and I know you've 
served as an appellate judge for some time. We're very excited 
that you've been nominated, and we wish you well.
 I wanted to do that briefly, just giving a flavor to the 
background of these nominees. And I know Senator Scott has 
their backgrounds fully laid out and is prepared to introduce 
them more fully.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Scott.

 STATEMENT OF HON. RICK SCOTT, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF FLORIDA

 Senator Scott. Thank you, Chairman. And I want to recognize 
our newest Senator Ashley Moody. She's been great to work with. 
She's hit the ground running and she brings a lot of talent 
here, especially when it comes to finding, helping the 
President pick qualified judges. She's been a great, great 
person to work with, as was Marco Rubio.
 So, today, I'm honored to introduce Judges Edward Artau, 
Kyle Dudek, and Anne-Leigh Gaylord Moe, and Jordan Pratt. They 
have been nominated by President Trump to serve as judges in 
the great State of Florida. We have a long tradition of law and 
order, and one of the most critical features of our success has 
been our outstanding judiciary at both the State and Federal 
levels.
 Our four nominees before us are great picks for Floridas' 
judicial seats. As Governor, I had the opportunity to point 
hundreds of judges to the bench. I worked with Pam Bondi quite 
a bit to come up with great picks. I'd ask each of the judges 
if they understood the role of the judiciary in applying and 
following the laws of our Nation, not legislating from the 
bench. I have full faith that these phenomenal and qualified 
individuals understand and respect that role.
 I'm honored to claim them as constituents and have utmost 
confidence in their ability to get the job done. I'd like to 
welcome them and their families here today. For the Southern 
District of Florida, President Trump has made a great choice 
with judge Edward Artau. He worked in private practice for 16 
years before serving as general counsel for the South Florida 
Water Management District. Not an easy job.
 In 2014, I had the opportunity to appoint him as a trial 
judge in the 15th Judicial Circuit where he presided over a 
wide variety of cases before being elevated to the Fourth 
District Court of Appeal. He received his Bachelor of science 
from Nova Southeastern University, and his law degree from 
Georgetown University, where he served as a law review editor.
 For the Middle District, President Trump has nominated 
Judge Kyle Dudek, who currently serves as a magistrate judge. 
Before joining the Federal bench, he was a shareholder at the 
law firm of Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt as a litigator. 
He frequently represented law enforcement officers and 
defendant clients in critical constitutional cases.
 He earned his undergraduate degree from Cornell University 
and his law degree from George Mason. After law school, he 
clerked in various Virginia courts at the State and Federal 
levels.
 Also in the Middle District of Florida. President Trump has 
nominated Judge Anne-Leigh Gaylord Moe, who currently serves as 
a judge on Florida's Second Judicial Court of Appeals. And by 
the way, Ashley Moody can't say enough good things about her. 
As Governor, I had the opportunity to appoint her to serve the 
13th Judicial Circuit. She earned her Bachelor of Arts from 
Furman University and her JD from Arizona State University, 
where she was editor-in-chief of the Law Review.
 She began her career in the Middle District of Florida, 
clerking for Judge Covington. After Clerkship, she joined the 
law firm, Bush Ross, where she became a shareholder and 
developed a strong reputation in commercial litigation and pro 
bono service.
 Again, in the Middle District, we have President Trump's 
nominee Judge Jordan Pratt. He served as on the Fifth District 
Court of Appeals since 2023. Before that, he was a senior 
counsel at First Liberty Institute. Also served in various 
roles in State and Federal government, including the DOJ, SBA, 
and the Florida Attorney General's office. A Double Gator, not 
a Triple Gator.
 Judge Pratt earned his bachelor of arts and his juris 
doctorate from the great University of Florida, which just won 
NCAA basketball championship.
 During law school he was a law review editor, and was a 
president, of both the Federal Society and Christian Legal 
Society. He clerked in the Middle District of Florida and on 
the Fifth Judicial Circuit. I'm clearly proud, as I know Ashley 
Moody is, to support each of these nominees today. Their 
excellent work shows their commitment to the rule of law.
 These nominees will not take it upon themselves to be 
activists in robes. They will do their constitutional duty 
given their strong records of service. I'm confident that they 
will exercise judicial humility and respect the proper role of 
the judiciary in our system of government. I'm confident they 
will be impartial and faithful as they serve the people of 
Florida and the United States. To the nominees President Trump 
has confidence in you, and I have confidence in you, and I know 
actually Moody does. I also thank you for your willingness to 
serve on the Committee. I urge your swift and speedy 
confirmation. Thank you, Chairman
 Chairman Grassley. As a courtesy to him, I've agreed to let 
him speak now. Go ahead.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CORY A. BOOKER, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY

 Senator Booker. Mr. Chairman, I'm grateful for the 
courtesy. I'm frustrated because this is not the normal process 
we have seen from either side of the political aisle over 
recent years.
 The White House nominated Mr. Bove over my and Senator 
Kim's strong objections while we were in the process of 
actually interviewing the other candidates the White House 
itself proposed. Senator Blackburn and Tillis raised similar 
concerns last Congress, but this nominee, as I said, sets new 
precedent.
 Before their nomination, all Judiciary Committee Democrats, 
including myself, had submitted a professional misconduct 
complaint against Mr. Bove with the New York State Bar. There 
is no scenario under which the White House counsel could 
believe that this nomination would be acceptable.
 Moreover, Mr. Bove record makes clear that he has no 
business serving a lifetime on the Federal bench. As was 
discussed by Mr. Durbin, Mr. Bove has a complete disregard for 
the rule of law. Yesterday, a DOJ whistleblower--something our 
Chairman values a lot is whistleblowing--revealed that Mr. Bove 
said in a court that any court that tried to stop the President 
from deporting people would be told, ``expletive you.''
 Mr. Bove then instructed the DHS to ignore any court order 
not to deport anyone. Again, he said with an expletive, F court 
orders. I don't even understand how we are seriously 
considering someone for a lifetime appointment on the Federal 
bench who has such disregard for court orders.
 But again, to characterize this as Democrats having 
problems with this nominee is a wrong characterization. We are 
seeing more and more respected conservative leaders coming out 
against this. This is a bipartisan, common bipartisan coming 
out against this nominee.
 Ed Whalen from the National Review said he has serious 
doubts that Bove has the character and integrity to be worthy 
of confirmation as a judge. Greg Nunziata, the Society for the 
Rule of Law. A former GOP Chief nominations counsel came out 
and said that Mr. Bove's record at the Justice Department, 
including manipulating prosecutions for political or policy 
ends, is deeply incompatible with a lifetime appointment to 
Federal judicial services.
 The Wall Street Journal's editorial board said, ``By every 
account, Mr. Bove was an unethical prosecutor who didn't play 
by the rules. He violated his constitutional obligations to 
provide a defendant with exculpatory evidence, his Brady 
obligation. It was the biggest scandal of prosecutorial 
misconduct at the SDNY. He abused his staff and he abused 
power.''
 The Wall Street editorial board says, ``Mr. Bove's 
reputation lately is as a snapped mouth partisan who wielded 
the law as a weapon.'' This is a conservative editorial board. 
Our job as a Committee is not to simply rubber stamp nominees 
because the President nominated them. We should understand that 
the respect for our legal system, the respect for the rule of 
law is vital.
 We are hearing time and time again from people across the 
political spectrum and nonpartisan people, that this nomination 
is violative of the shared values we have for who should be on 
the bench, what their temperament should be, what their respect 
for the rule of law should be. Mr. Bove should not be before us 
today in an oversight hearing on the useful on the unlawful 
acts of the Justice Department. He should be before us in an 
oversight hearing on the unlawful acts of this, the Department 
of Justice. He should be before us to account for what we have 
seen going on in a very unusual way. He should not be before us 
for a lifetime appointment to the Federal bench. I appeal to 
the Chairman of this Committee for us to have before us this 
whistleblower who as Senator Durbin said, ``He should come 
before us and add testimony for the record.'' Thank you, Mr. 
Chairman.
 Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Mr. Bove, would you please 
come and stand before you sit so I can swear.
 Do you swear that the testimony you're about to give before 
this Committee will be the truth the whole truth and nothing 
but the truth so help you God?
 [Witness is sworn in.]
 Chairman Grassley: Please be seated. And you can give your 
statement and you're welcome to introduce family and friends, 
whatever you want to do now.

 STATEMENT OF EMIL J. BOVE, III, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED 
 STATES CIRCUIT JUDGE FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT

 Mr. Bove. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. I appreciate the 
kind words in your introduction and I'm grateful to you, 
Ranking Member Durbin, and the rest of this Committee for 
holding this hearing today. It really is a privilege to be here 
and I understand that we have some serious work to do.
 I also appreciate the opportunity to say some words before 
we get started. First, I want to start by thanking President 
Trump for the honor of this nomination. I'm also grateful for 
the opportunity to serve in this Justice Department under his 
administration and under the leadership of Attorney General 
Bondi, who's been a wonderful friend and mentor to me during 
that process. I also want to say thank you to some family and 
friends who have supported me throughout my life, especially 
over the last several years. That's a long list, but there are 
a couple people that I'd like to call out specifically.
 I'm going to start with my dad who I love very much and is 
watching me from home right now in Seneca Falls, New York. I 
also want to thank my wife who's here today. She's been a rock 
of support in my life for almost two decades at this point. I 
want to thank my brother who's serving in the Navy's submarine 
service right now. I expect he would be here today, but he's 
deployed. His service and the sacrifices of his family and 
connection with that service really are an inspiration to the 
work that I do.
 Lastly, I want to say thank you to Todd Blanche and his 
wife who are also here today. Suffice it to say we've been 
through a lot and I'm very grateful for the way that they've 
welcomed me into their family.
 Now, I'd like to say a little bit about me. I am someone 
who tries to stand up for what I believe is right. I'm not 
afraid to make difficult decisions. I understand that some of 
those decisions have generated controversy. I respect this 
process and I'm here today to address some of your questions 
about those decisions, but I want to be clear about one thing 
up front.
 There is a wildly inaccurate caricature of me in the 
mainstream media. I'm not anybody's henchman. I'm not an 
enforcer. I'm a lawyer from a small town who never expected to 
be in an arena like this. Not until Todd called me and gave me 
an opportunity to participate in some of the most historic and 
significant legal battles of our lifetime.
 I'm proud of what Todd and I accomplished as part of 
President Trump's defense team, but I think that because some 
of that happened so recently, it might be easy to overlook the 
fact that I've spent most of my life in public service. I have 
taken an oath to uphold the Constitution of the United States 
more than once and I have honored that oath.
 These experiences collectively as a paralegal, a law clerk, 
a prosecutor, and a defense lawyer have left me with deep 
respect for the rule of law. That is a system that is in place 
to protect everyone and the Federal courts play a critical role 
in that process. Those are the first principles that would 
guide me every single day if I'm fortunate enough to be 
confirmed.
 Thank you again for this opportunity to give some remarks 
at the start and I look forward to your questions.
 Chairman Grassley. Thank you. We'll now start our 
questioning. Five-minute rounds.
 Mr. Bove, on the eve of your hearing, we witnessed a 
coordinated political attack in the media claiming that you 
advocated disobeying court orders. Never mind the hypocrisy we 
have from the other side. Two days ago, a left-wing Biden judge 
said he would defy a Supreme Court order. All the Democrats on 
the Committee voted for that judge and don't seem to be 
concerned about his decision. There are serious reasons to 
question the legitimacy of these allegations against you.
 This initial unconfirmed whistleblower report was leaked to 
the media and the Justice Department was only given 15 minutes 
to respond to the story. The Deputy Attorney General has 
unequivocally publicly denied the allegations and indeed the 
alleged whistleblower previously signed a brief affirming the 
Justice Department did not violate court orders in its use of 
the Alien Enemy Act.
 I want hear from you directly how do you respond to these 
allegations and did you ever advise the Department of Justice 
to defy court order?
 Mr. Bove. So, to get to the last part of that question 
first, Chairman, no, I have never advised a Department of 
Justice attorney to violate a court order. And if I could 
elaborate a little bit. I'm respectful of the whistleblower 
process, and I understand that there's protections in place 
around that, and also that there are valid contributions made 
to good government through that process.
 I don't want to disparage that whistleblower in this 
proceeding, but I also have to address to some extent the 
allegations. As you noted at the outset, I'm also bound by 
privileges that the whistleblower did not consider himself 
bound with in leaking that report to this Committee just 
yesterday.
 But there are a few things I'd like to say and confirm. I 
will reiterate I did not advise any Justice Department attorney 
to violate court orders. The Deputy Attorney General, as you 
made clear in your opening remarks, Chairman, has confirmed 
that the account in that whistleblower complaint is not 
accurate.
 But even if that account is taken at face value, the 
whistleblower acknowledges that he left the meeting on March 14 
of this year with the understanding that of course the 
department would advise clients to abide by court orders and 
then as you noted, the whistleblower signed a brief filed in 
the District of Columbia just weeks later explaining all the 
legal reasons that in the J.G.G. case, the department and the 
parties, excuse me, the department and the parties the 
department represented had complied with court orders.
 And so, for all those reasons, I don't think there's any 
validity to the suggestion that that whistleblower complaint 
filed yesterday calls into question my qualifications to serve 
as a circuit judge. I also think what's clear in the three 
cases that the whistleblower accounts for is that this is 
fundamentally a dispute about the challenges posed by the 
unelected bureaucracy to the unitary executive and to the 
people that elected the President and put him in office.
 And what I mean by that is throughout this complaint, 
there's a suggestion that a line attorney, not even the head of 
the Office of Immigration Litigation was in a position or 
considered himself to be to bind the department's leadership 
and other cabinet officials. I don't abide that line of 
thinking in my management style and I'm not apologetic of that.
 Chairman Grassley. I'm going to not give my lead into this 
question, but how do you respond to the criticisms you received 
regarding Mayor Adam's case? I'm not describing the case, but 
you know what I'm talking about.
 Mr. Bove. I do, Chairman, thank you. I think that this 
answer has to start with the fact that the motion to dismiss 
those charges was granted and it was granted after the ethics 
complaints that were referenced earlier today. It was granted 
because the motion reflected a valid exercise of prosecutorial 
discretion.
 Now, there's been some criticism including this morning 
suggesting that there was some kind of illicit quid pro quo in 
connection with that motion. That's simply false and it's 
refuted by the record. Mayor Adams' lawyers filed a letter on 
the public docket in that case that stated explicitly there was 
no quid pro quo. One of those lawyers, and they're both 
respected members of the bar, stood up in court at a hearing in 
the case and said the same thing.
 And then, critically, Mayor Adams himself was sworn under 
oath at the hearing and he explained there were no agreements 
outside of what was committed to writing. And so, the 
suggestion that there was some kind of quid pro quo is just 
plain false.
 There's also been criticism about the Department's decision 
to seek dismissal without prejudice in the motion that we 
filed. That decision was made for two reasons. First of all, 
dismissal without prejudice is the default under the applicable 
rule. That would've happened. It's a normal course in any case. 
In addition, with respect to Mayor Adams, a dismissal without 
prejudice would've allowed the permanent U.S. attorney to 
reevaluate the case without the weaponization concerns that the 
department had, without the risk of interfering with the 
ongoing mayoral election and without the need to interfere with 
Mayor Adams and governance of the city after that election took 
place.
 Those are the considerations that drove the determination 
to seek dismissal without prejudice and Judge Ho's decision to 
proceed on another path by dismissing the case with prejudice 
certainly does not call into question my ethics or my 
decisionmaking. It's a legal difference of opinion. Thank you.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Durbin.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Bove, you were deeply involved with the 
Justice Department's decision to drop federal corruption 
charges against New York City Mayor Eric Adams. You were 
personally involved in this. Multiple Federal prosecutors 
resigned rather than to dismiss the indictment against Mayor 
Adams. These individuals made it clear that they believe you 
had engaged in a quid pro quo with Mayor Adams in order to 
secure his cooperation with President Trump's immigration 
priorities.
 Following these resignations, you reportedly held a video 
call with dozens of attorneys in the Justice Department's 
Public Integrity Section. Do you remember that call?
 Mr. Bove. I do.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Bove, why did you move forward with 
this case over the objection of the U.S. Attorney's Office, 
including the lead prosecutor?
 Mr. Bove. I made a decision and the department made a 
decision to proceed with that motion because in the 
determination, it was a determination of the senior leadership 
of the department that policy reasons made it appropriate to 
dismiss the charges.
 Senator Durbin. In order to get Mayor Adams to cooperate 
with President Trump's immigration policy, you were prepared to 
drop the charges against him?
 Mr. Bove. That's completely false. And I just explained 
why.
 Senator Durbin. Well, it is not completely false. That's 
exactly what happened, but the judge foiled your plans with 
prejudice dismissal of the case. You could no longer have the 
mayor on a leash making sure that he follows the President's 
immigration policies.
 Mr. Bove. Ranking Member Durbin, there's objective evidence 
in the record in that case that completely refutes the claim 
you just made.
 Senator Durbin. And there's objective evidence to the 
contrary. On your call with individuals in the Public Integrity 
Section. Did you state, suggest, or imply that the section's 
career attorneys could be fired if none of them agreed to sign 
the brief dismissing Mayor Adams's indictment?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Durbin. Do you know the two individuals who signed 
the brief?
 Mr. Bove. I do.
 Senator Durbin. Edward Sullivan one of them?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Durbin. Antoinette Bacon another?
 Mr. Bove. That's correct.
 Senator Durbin. Did you state suggest or imply that any 
individual who agreed to sign the brief would be rewarded?
 Mr. Bove. I'm sorry, I don't follow the question.
 Senator Durbin. Well, you needed somebody to sign that 
brief and those two stepped forward, was there any suggestion 
they be treated any differently because of it?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Durbin. Have either of these attorneys been 
promoted since this occurrence?
 Mr. Bove. Not to my knowledge, no.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Bove, in January 2022, you co-authored 
an article for Law360 in which you described domestic terrorism 
as, ``A national security issue.'' You then cited charges 
brought against attendees of the August 2017 Unite the Right 
white supremacist rally in Charlottesville and against members 
of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers relating to the January 6 
insurrection at the Capitol.
 You describe these prosecutions in the article as, ``Recent 
examples that illustrate the asymmetry between international 
terrorism statutes and the patchwork of narrower laws that can 
be used to address domestic terrorism.''
 Mr. Bove, do you stand by your characterization of the 2017 
Unite the Right rally and January 6 as domestic terrorism?
 Mr. Bove. I stand by what I said in the article.
 Senator Durbin. You directed Ed Martin, the failed nominee 
to serve as U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia to fire 
dozens of line prosecutors who had worked on the January 6 
case. You also sought the names of thousands of FBI employees 
who'd worked on investigations into January 6 rioters, accused 
these career public servants of, ``weaponization'', of the FBI.
 Mr. Bove, did you order the removal of anyone who 
investigated or prosecuted rioters who assaulted law 
enforcement officers on January 6?
 Mr. Bove. Ranking Member Durbin, with respect to the 
prosecutors that you just referenced, there was a decision that 
was made in response to moves by the prior administration to 
embed temporary assistant United States attorneys who were 
brought to the district for purposes of the January 6 cases 
into that office as permanent employees in many instances after 
the 2024 election.
 When I found out about that, I found it to be unacceptable 
from the perspective of the management of that office and the 
need for the permanent U.S. attorney put forth by the President 
and by Attorney General Bondi to manage the office and to staff 
it. The attorneys that were terminated were on probationary 
status.
 I was advised and did not make this decision alone that----
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Bove, this doesn't square with your own 
words. I have in my hand here the memorandum that you prepared 
on January 31, 2025, to U.S. attorneys and others in which you 
made it clear this was about more than provisional employees 
being dismissed.
 Let me read what you wrote. ``In an Executive order issued 
on January 20, 2025, President Trump appropriately 
characterized that work as having involved a grave national 
injustice that's been perpetrated upon the American people over 
the last 4 years.''
 This is not about provisional employees, it's about January 
6 prosecutions. You call them a domestic terrorism event in 
this article that you have written, most people, those of us 
who lived through this ordeal understand it was such a domestic 
terrorist event and now you're trying to have it both ways.
 You're saying you dismissed the people who prosecuted those 
who beat up on our law enforcement officers and it had nothing 
to do with January 6. Your words defy that.
 Mr. Bove. That's not correct, Ranking Member Durbin, most 
respectfully, because both things can be true. I did and 
continue to condemn unlawful behavior, particularly violence 
against law enforcement. At the same time, I condemn heavy-
handed and unnecessary tactics by prosecutors and agents. Both 
of those things I submit are characteristic of these events 
that we're talking about.
 Senator Durbin. These people paid for your strategy with 
their careers. They lost their jobs in the Department of 
Justice and in the FBI because you identified them as being 
involved in January 6 prosecution. You cannot call on one hand 
that prosecution as a grave injustice as you did in your own 
memo here, and then on the other hand, tell me how seriously 
you feel about people assaulting police officers.
 Mr. Bove. I have to disagree, again, most respectfully. No 
FBI agents, to my knowledge, were terminated in connection with 
the list that's referenced in that memo. What I requested was 
some information about who had participated so that I could 
begin, and the department could begin a process of reviewing 
the events to identify whether there were the types of heavy-
handed tactics that I just referenced. That process----
 Senator Durbin. I have one last question here. Do you 
support President Trump's full and unconditional pardon of 
January 6 rioters who violently assaulted law enforcement 
officers?
 Mr. Bove. It's not for me to question President Trump's 
exercise of the pardon power any more than it would be for me 
to question President Biden's commutation of death sentences or 
his pardons of drug traffickers.
 Chairman Grassley. Before I go to Senator Lee, I'd like to 
address the quid pro quo allegation head on by entering into 
the record the official court transcript from Mayor Adams' 
case. This is in speculation or secondhand reporting. These are 
sworn statements under oath in Federal court. As you can read 
in the transcript, Mayor Adams under oath flatly denied any 
improper arrangement. In his own words, ``There was no deal, no 
quid pro quo, and I did nothing.''
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Lee.
 Senator Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Bove, 
for being here and for your willingness to serve in the 
capacity as a judge on the Third Circuit.
 As a Federal Appellate Court judge, you'll be called upon 
to interpret Federal law under countless circumstances. When 
you're interpreting a provision of the Constitution or of the 
U.S. Code, where do you start and what does that process 
entail? Tell me to what extent you would consider things like 
committee reports and the subjective musings of individual 
Senators and Representatives as they're debating Federal law 
before it's enacted.
 Mr. Bove. So, if I could start by differentiating between 
some comments about judicial philosophy, which I think go to 
the heart of your question, Senator. From the practical reality 
that if I'm confirmed in any case, I would consider and 
evaluate the arguments of the parties as they're presented.
 That said, with respect to my philosophy, whether it's 
constitutional interpretation or statutory interpretation, I 
would begin with the text of the operative provision that 
drives the party's dispute. I don't think that in most 
instances, committee reports or legislative history has a lot 
to say about what the meaning of that text really is for 
purposes of the dispute. And that is because I think in the 
main, the legislative history has not gone through the process 
of bicameralism and presentment to become law.
 And a judge's job, in my view, is to declare what the law 
is, not what it should be, or ought to be, or someone on a 
committee thought it sounded like. It's to focus on the 
operative words and interpret them as they're written.
 Senator Lee. What do you do in circumstances where it may 
appear that one or more lawmakers had a subjective intent 
surrounding a particular word or phrase that differed from that 
at the original public understanding at the time of the 
enactment of that provision?
 Mr. Bove. From a philosophical perspective, in my view, it 
is that the public meaning at the time of the enactment, at the 
time of bicameralism and presentment, that would govern.
 Senator Lee. Great. I think that's an important 
distinction. It's impossible to run the subjective mindset of 
any individual through bicameralism and presentment. That's a 
kind of notice we're required to have. We're entitled to have 
as American citizens before we're subjected to a new provision 
of Federal law, it has to go through that gauntlet, otherwise 
it's not in a duly enacted law.
 What are the contours of the President's authority to 
appoint and remove, particularly to remove executive branch 
officials?
 Mr. Bove. So, there are Supreme Court precedents on this 
issue, Senator, that I would apply faithfully if I'm confirmed. 
There's also litigation around these issues. So, I have to be 
careful about how much of the details that I get into here.
 But generally speaking, under the Seila Law case, the 
executive power, and I think the Court, I'll paraphrase, but I 
think the Court used the phrase all of it is committed to the 
President of the United States. That type of broad commitment 
of power pursuant to the vesting clause in Article II could be 
read, and it's been said by some that it is the case, vests in 
the President a power to remove any official in the executive 
branch. And I think that's tied up in academia, in research and 
writing around the unitary executive theory.
 As I said, there's ongoing litigation right now relating to 
this administration's position regarding these issues including 
the head of, for example, the Merit System Protections Board or 
the National Labor Relations Board.
 Senator Lee. Yes. Is it proper for a lower court judge, 
let's say a Federal District judge, to flagrantly disregard a 
direct order from the Supreme Court of the United States?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Lee. In circumstances where you are reviewing as a 
judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, 
should you be confirmed, the myriad circumstances where you'll 
be asked to review the disposition by a lower court of a 
dispositive motion, for example, Rule 12(b)(6) motion to 
dismiss, Rule 56 motion for summary judgment.
 In your view, is one worse than another between a case in 
which in a close case somebody grants a non-meritorious 
dispositive motion or denies a meritorious dispositive motion, 
is either one worse than the other and if so, why?
 Mr. Bove. So, Senator, that's obviously a philosophical 
question that I think different people would answer in 
different ways based on their values and judgment. For me 
personally, because of my experience with jury trials, I prize 
the jury system that's enshrined in the Constitution. And so, 
from my standpoint, to the extent, I guess the way I would 
frame it is, to the extent that there's a close question in a 
12(b)(6) motion in a civil case or in a motion to dismiss, 
well, I'll leave it to the civil cases.
 Senator Lee. If it's summary judgment, you were going down 
the summary judgment, right?
 Mr. Bove. Right. It would seem prudent to me to allow the 
case to go to a jury, which is really just, to me, a core part 
of our history and tradition that allows people in our local 
communities to make decisions and participate in the process.
 Senator Lee. That's a fair point. And the fact that a judge 
in that circumstances in doubt or experiences pause when 
deciding whether there's a genuine issue of material fact 
suggests that there is. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Whitehouse.
 Senator Whitehouse. Mr. Chairman, before my time begins, 
may I take a moment to make a point of order?
 Chairman Grassley. Yes.
 Senator Whitehouse. You indicated, Mr. Chairman, in your 
opening remarks that the Committee should be constrained by the 
deliberative process privilege.
 Chairman Grassley. Yes.
 Senator Whitehouse. And by the attorney-client privilege in 
our examination of this witness. It's my understanding that 
Congress has never accepted the constitutional validity of 
either such privilege as an inhibition of our constitutional 
congressional oversight responsibilities.
 And so, I don't intend to follow that direction because I 
don't think it's correct, and I think it abdicates really 
important oversight authorities that we have. Moreover, 
particularly when we are in a nominations process and somebody 
has affirmatively put themselves forward to then have them seek 
the shelter of deliberative process and attorney-client 
privilege puts us in an even worse position.
 So, I think if we were ever going to do this, nominations 
are the low ebb of any justification for that. It gets even 
worse when the nominee faces questions about official 
misconduct as a lawyer. Among other reasons, privileges tend to 
fall when misconduct is alleged. And so, for all of those 
reasons, I just as one Senator, reject the proposition that 
this Committee must yield in its questioning and in its fact-
finding in an oversight or nominations matter to those 
executive privileges.
 I don't think Congress has ever taken the position that 
they supervene our constitutional oversight authority, and I 
think it was an unfortunate occasion that that happened this 
morning.
 Chairman Grassley. If Senator Whitehouse is asking this 
farmer to listen to more lawyers, I'll be glad to consult.
 Senator Whitehouse. I'd be delighted to followup on this 
because I think it's a really bad position for this Committee 
to put itself in with respect to nominees or other oversight 
matters, particularly when we oversee the Department of Justice 
that is stuffed with lawyers who can easily cook up an 
attorney-client privilege defense or a deliberative process 
defense, and then we are now in a no-fly zone with respect to 
our oversight responsibilities.
 Nobody takes oversight responsibilities more seriously than 
you, Chairman, so I hope we can come to a better accommodation 
on this than your opening statement suggests.
 Chairman Grassley. Right now, I can't say more than I have.
 Senator Whitehouse. That's fine. That's fine. And I'd also 
like to ask unanimous consent to put into the record, to the 
extent that has not been done so far; the whistleblower report 
that has been discussed, the resignation letters of the career 
officers in the Adams prosecution, the resignation statement by 
Denise Cheung in the GGRF matter, the article that I have here 
from Politico related to the nominees' management character, 
and The Wall Street Journal editorial describing him as a 
smashmouth partisan who wields the law as a weapon.
 Chairman Grassley. Without objection.
 [The information appears as a submission for the record.]
 Senator Whitehouse. Okay. With that, thank you. I guess my 
clock got started already.
 Mr. Bove, what was your role in Ed Martin's plan to create 
an unpredicated criminal investigation as the basis for trying 
to seize greenhouse gas reduction funds? Were you engaged with 
him in that plan?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not aware of such a plan, Senator, but I did 
participate in the matter that you're referring to.
 Senator Whitehouse. Plan, matter. Okay. Okay. Did you know 
that before he took office, he had expressed private opinions 
about the--I'll call it GGRF, for time purposes, before he came 
in?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not sure what you're referring to.
 Senator Whitehouse. Okay. Did he consult with you regarding 
his efforts to get a document together to present to a 
magistrate judge to provide a basis for freezing and seizing 
the GGRF funds?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, like many nominees before me who come to 
testify before this Committee and are at the same time 
simultaneously serving in the department, this includes Justice 
Kagan, Justice Kavanaugh, Judge Katsas, all at various times, 
but were serving or served previously, I'm not going to be able 
to comment on the specifics of matters like that. I will----
 Senator Whitehouse. I'm asking you at this point. I'm 
asking you, were you consulted regarding that?
 Mr. Bove. And my answer is limited to I participated in the 
matter, and if there's public information about the matter that 
you'd like me to try and address, I'm happy to do my best to do 
that.
 Senator Whitehouse. The chief of the criminal division was 
removed after she refused to sign off on the proposal on the 
proposed pleading. Were you involved in her removal?
 Mr. Bove. I've read public reports about that, and to my 
recollection of those reports, I believe she resigned.
 Senator Whitehouse. Did you approve the U.S. attorney 
demanding her resignation and pressing her out of her office?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not able to go beyond the fact that I 
participated in the matter that you're referring to, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Were you aware that U.S. Attorney 
Martin went into court alone without any other career attorney 
or any other attorney in the office willing to sign off on the 
pleading in which he sought the freeze or seizure?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not sure if that's true or not, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. We can look at the pleading. Nobody 
else signed. He ran out the criminal chief for refusing to 
sign. Presumably, he went shopping for somebody else who would 
sign. Nobody did so he went in alone. Will you agree that it's 
very unusual for a politically appointed United States attorney 
to file a pleading without the support of a single career 
prosecutor in the office?
 Mr. Bove. No, I don't agree with that.
 Senator Whitehouse. Okay. Well, were you aware that when he 
did go in alone without the support of a career prosecutor in 
the office, he was shot down by the magistrate judge in 
pursuing the order?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I'd refer you to my previous answer. I'm 
not able to go beyond the fact that I participated in the 
matter.
 Senator Whitehouse. Would you agree that, ordinarily, the 
Department of Justice does its very best to make sure that its 
pleadings are sufficiently well-prepared that they're not shot 
down by magistrate judges?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, of course.
 Senator Whitehouse. After it was shot down by the judge, 
did you participate in shopping the matter to other offices so 
that the effort to seize or freeze the GGRF funds could be 
pursued despite the U.S. attorney's failure?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I'd refer you to my previous answer. I'm 
able to confirm I participated in this matter. Based on public 
reporting, I am aware that there are certainly other districts 
with grantees who receive funds from these programs where under 
the law that applies to venue, it would be appropriate for 
similar investigations to take place.
 Senator Whitehouse. Did you contact them?
 Mr. Bove. I refer you to my prior answer, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Did you let them know that the effort 
by interim U.S. Attorney Martin had been shot down?
 Mr. Bove. I apologize, Senator, I'm not trying to be 
difficult, but I must refer you to my prior answer.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Kennedy.
 Senator Whitehouse. Just if I may, Chairman?
 Chairman Grassley. Yes, proceed.
 Senator Whitehouse. This is not further questioning. I know 
my time is expired. Do you see my point now? We have an 
individual here who is here seeking confirmation to one of the 
highest judicial offices in the land. I'm asking quite 
legitimate questions about potential misconduct in office. Some 
of it has nothing to do with the substance of pleadings, but 
has to do with administrative matters like seeking the removal 
of a criminal career chief prosecutor. Some of it has to do 
with administrative matters like case assignment. And the fact 
that I can't get anything resembling a straight answer in the 
circumstances that we're in right now, I think signals a really 
bad moment for this Committee, and I hope we can reconsider.
 Chairman Grassley. I said I would be glad to discuss that 
with you. Senator Kennedy.
 Senator Whitehouse. Can we get him back then once the rules 
are clear?
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Kennedy.
 Senator Kennedy. Well, thank you Mr. Chairman. Mr. Bove, 
I'm looking at your resume. It's Bove, right?
 Mr. Bove. Bove Senator like the bow.
 Senator Kennedy. I apologize, sir.
 Mr. Bove. No worries. Thank you.
 Senator Kennedy. Mr. Bove, you spent a lot of time at the 
Justice Department. I look here, you were a paralegal there for 
2 years in the early 2000's. You served from 2012 to 2021. How 
many times have you seen a Justice Department employee act on 
the basis of his or her act predominantly, act predominantly on 
the basis of his or her political beliefs as opposed to the 
law?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I would say that as a prosecutor in my 
time at SDNY, I'm not sure that I did see that. It should be 
and it must be.
 Senator Kennedy. Have you seen it other than as a 
prosecutor?
 Mr. Bove. I believe that I have.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. When?
 Mr. Bove. During my representation of President Trump.
 Senator Kennedy. What'd you see?
 Mr. Bove. I witnessed members of the special counsel's 
office taking positions about the need to go to trial quickly 
before the election. The amount of time that President Trump 
would be allotted to review discovery and prepare motions that 
I found, in my experience, to be completely inconsistent with 
normal practice which led me to draw in inferences of the 
nature that you're suggesting, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. Counselor, you sent a memo directing one 
of your underlings--I don't mean that in a pejorative sense--
but somebody under you in the hierarchy directing that the 
prosecution against Mayor Adams be dismissed. Is that right?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. Who made that decision to dismiss 
the charges?
 Mr. Bove. I think that's set forth in the memo that I 
participated in the decision with the authorization of the 
Attorney General of the United States.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. So, the Attorney General of the 
United States made the call?
 Mr. Bove. She was a part of the decision. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. Who else was involved?
 Mr. Bove. Beyond what's in the public record on that 
matter, I'm not able to get into the internal deliberations on 
that, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. But there were others involved?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Kennedy. At the department?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Kennedy. Anywhere else?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. You're under oath. Why did you folks 
dismiss the charges against Mayor Adams?
 Mr. Bove. For the reasons set forth in the motion that 
you're referencing. There were two concerns, Senator. One was 
based on the weaponization of the criminal justice system, and 
that concern was substantiated----
 Senator Kennedy. What do you mean weaponization of the 
political justice system?
 Mr. Bove. Abuse.
 Senator Kennedy. I know that. But I mean, can you be more 
specific?
 Mr. Bove. In this particular case----
 Senator Kennedy. You think the charges were brought against 
Mayor Adams for political reasons?
 Mr. Bove. Again, I'm just right now drawing on what we said 
publicly in the briefs. And I signed those briefs because I 
believe in the arguments that were made. I believe that 
irrespective of what happened at the outset of that case, what 
the former U.S. attorney did to promote the ongoing prosecution 
at a time when there was at least an appearance that he had his 
own personal political objectives resulted in the weaponization 
of that particular criminal justice process.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. So, you dismissed it because of the 
weaponization. Any other reason?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, there was a second independent basis set 
forth in the motion, and that was concerns about the effect of 
the ongoing prosecution on Mayor Adams' ability to govern and 
protect the public in New York City and also to campaign in the 
ongoing mayoral election.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. Do you believe in a higher being?
 Mr. Bove. It's a very personal question, Senator, but I do.
 Senator Kennedy. I want you to look me in the eye and swear 
to your higher being when you answer this question. Did you 
make a deal, a political deal, to dismiss the charges against 
Mayor Adams?
 Mr. Bove. Absolutely not.
 Senator Kennedy. Did anybody else, did you witness make a 
political deal to dismiss the charges?
 Mr. Bove. Absolutely not.
 Senator Kennedy. You swear to your higher being,
 Mr. Bove. I swear to my higher being and on every bone in 
my body.
 Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Klobuchar.
 Senator Klobuchar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Bove I was 
just listening to my colleague Senator Kennedy's questions, and 
one of your answers was that you felt that these charges should 
be dropped against the mayor because he was campaigning. It 
would interfere with his campaigning. It would interfere with 
his ability to do your job.
 So, then is it your position that that's the reason that 
you shouldn't be able to ever prosecute any elected officials 
regardless of party because it might interfere with their 
campaigning, if they commit murder, if they are committing a 
major white-collar crime, if they are taking bribes, that the 
reason is that they're campaigning, because they're always 
campaigning Mr. Bove. So, I was just stunned by that answer.
 Mr. Bove. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to be stunning, Senator. 
I think it's a fact in circumstances, determination. It's case-
specific. In that particular case, based on the charges and the 
manner in which the case was pursued, I did think that there 
was, and the department thought for the reasons we laid out in 
our brief, that the prosecution placed an inordinate burden on 
the mayor's ability to protect the city and to campaign in an 
ongoing election cycle.
 Senator Klobuchar. I just think this would be a reason. 
It's like there would be two classes of justice, one for people 
who are on office and one for everyone else if that's an 
argument you use.
 And isn't it true on February 10 that you ordered the 
bribery case against the mayor be dismissed, and I quote your 
letter to then-acting U.S. Attorney Sassoon, ``--without 
assessing the strength of the evidence or the legal theories on 
which the case is based.'' That's what you said, correct?
 Mr. Bove. The determination was based on the policy 
considerations that I've outlined and did not rely on that.
 Senator Klobuchar. By your own written admission though, 
you failed to assess the merits of the case and ordered that 
the bribery charges be dismissed entirely for these reasons so 
he could campaign?
 Mr. Bove. That's not true, Senator. That's inaccurate. I 
did look at the evidence and that's why I spent extensive time 
reviewing the case file, meeting with the prosecutors alone, 
meeting with them with the defense counsel. In the department's 
decisionmaking, we chose to proceed based on the policy 
determinations that I've outlined and not the strength of the 
evidence or concerns about the legal theory.
 Senator Klobuchar. In your letter to then acting U.S. 
Attorney Sassoon, you ordered her to drop the case because you 
were, ``--concerned about the impact of the prosecution on 
Mayor Adams' ability to support'' the President's immigration 
agenda. Is that correct?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay. When you appeared in court to file 
your motion to dismiss, the court stated that your efforts to 
dismiss the case were unsupported by any objective evidence and 
``--fundamentally incompatible with the basic promise of equal 
justice under law.'' Is that what the court said?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall the court saying that at the 
hearing that I attended. To the extent the court wrote 
something like that and the opinion, that was an opinion that 
granted the motion. And I think the context is really 
important, Senator. The context is that Rule 48 doesn't require 
the department to provide any evidence. It requires a non-
conclusory explanation by the prosecutors of the reason for 
dismissing a case.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Well, let's go over what Hagan 
Scotten, who was the--he was the lead prosecutor on the case. 
Is that right?
 Mr. Bove. I think that's right. Yes.
 Senator Klobuchar. Decorated Iraqi war veteran, clerked for 
then Judge Kavanaugh on the D.C. Circuit, and then Justice 
Roberts. So, in his letter he says that, ``Damian Williams role 
in the case somehow tainted a valid indictment supported by 
ample evidence and pursued under four different U.S. 
attorneys.''
 This was your reasoning because you said you felt that the 
former U.S. attorney somehow tainted this case, but yet as 
Hagan Scotten pointed out, it was pursued under four different 
U.S. attorneys. He said that, ``--this reasoning is so weak as 
to be transparently pretextual.''
 Why do you think he said that?
 Mr. Bove. So, I'd like to begin by just confirming that I 
respect Hagan's military service, and his public service, and 
the fact that we disagree on this particular issue is not meant 
to disparage him in any way.
 However, the department filed a brief explaining and 
elaborating on the basis for a motion. In that brief. We 
outlined private communications and comments on documents by 
the prosecutors including Mr. Scotten, one of those 
communications, private communications, Mr. Scotten said that 
he found it plausible that Damian Williams proceeded based on 
political motivations.
 So, what he said publicly is not consistent with what the 
trial team was thinking privately, contemporaneous with these 
events.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay. I will again go back to the fact 
that I don't think that the reason that someone is running for 
office, or has some policy agreement or disagreements with the 
administration should be a reason to bring or dismiss charges.
 And he also added, ``--no system of ordered liberty can 
allow the government to use the carrot of dismissing charges or 
the stick of threatening to bring them again to induce an 
elected official to support its policy objective.'' He then 
ended, as I'm sure you realize, he ended with, ``I expect 
you'll eventually find someone who is enough of a fool or 
enough of a coward to file your motion, but it was never going 
to be me.''
 So, my concern with what happened here and then also with 
the decision to fire January 6 prosecutors is basically the 
same. I am a former prosecutor myself, I ran the biggest 
prosecutor office in our State, and every single day you're 
confronted with issues of ethics and maybe you know someone 
you're prosecuting, maybe someone knows someone you're 
prosecuting, maybe they agree with you, maybe you don't. And 
you have to make a decision based on the law and the facts and 
not on whether or not they agree with your administration.
 [Gavel tapping.]
 And when I look--we heard from former prosecutors who were 
dismissed because they'd simply done their job in looking at 
what happened on January 6, I just think it's part of the same 
threat. It's politics over the law, and it should be law over 
politics.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Moody.
 Senator Moody. It's a good thing I wasn't holding that 
gavel. Good to be with you. Thank you for being here. Thank you 
to your family for being here, colleagues from the office, the 
Department of Justice that are here to support you. We are 
excited about your nomination, and thank President Trump for 
making this important nomination.
 I'm guessing from some of my colleagues on this hearing 
that they forgot that there are some Democratic judges that 
were escorting people out of the courtroom in secrecy because 
they didn't believe with what law enforcement was trying to 
achieve. And some Democratic-appointed judges that are ignoring 
the Supreme Court orders at the moment.
 The hypocrisy continues to shock me. I've been here a hot 
second on this Judiciary Committee and I think it's important 
that we all go back to the ideal judge as one that is 
impartial, that has integrity, and understands that their job 
is to apply the laws given to them through the representatives 
of the people faithfully and without prejudice. And we are very 
excited about your nomination.
 And personally, let me just say, as a former Federal 
prosecutor myself, I was grateful that someone with that 
background that both had extensive experience in Federal 
courts, not only prosecuting within the district court but in 
appeals as well was being nominated.
 I believe those that are charged with the responsibility of 
taking cases brought to them by law enforcement and they are 
charged with pursuing justice in a court of law, which may mean 
someone's liberty is taken away, that that is very a heavy 
responsibility and one that after they are charged with that 
does not take lightly.
 And I heard you previously explaining how you took that 
very seriously and you believe that justice is sometimes the 
consideration of making sure it's not heavy-handed when it 
wasn't intended to be. I thought it was interesting, one of my 
colleagues' remarks, they thought it was important to point out 
that someone described you as a partisan that wields the law as 
a weapon, when in fact you have spent a lot of time fighting 
against that as many of us watched in horror as the justice 
system was turned into a political weapon.
 And I thought I might just give you and I wanted to go back 
to who you are in your background. You've got thrown into the 
limelight in a very politically charged situation, not of your 
own making, but one that you were willing to fight against. And 
prior to that, I think it's important that not just my 
colleagues, but the American people understand your background.
 You clerked for a Federal judge, you clerked a district 
court judge, you clerked for an appellate judge. You served as 
an intern in different capacities. You were the lead prosecutor 
in numerous Federal trials. I would like for you to take a 
moment and tell us how you background would repudiate all of 
the aspersions and accusations that have been charged against 
you this morning.
 Because again, as someone who is also served in that 
capacity where you're given the responsibility to on behalf of 
the people on behalf of the United States of America, seek 
justice and potentially removing, taking away someone's 
liberty, tell us about your background and how that bears on 
your respect for the court, its need to be impartial, and your 
background and how that will prepare you to faithfully apply 
the rule of law.
 Mr. Bove. Thank you, Senator, and I appreciate the kind 
words. It's, I believe, a very solemn obligation to accept a 
position on the Federal bench, especially an appellate position 
because of the obligation to enforce the rule of law without 
fear of favor and declare what the law is but exercise 
restraint and not make policy decisions.
 And I think that I'm equipped to do that because over the 
course of my career, as you suggested, I have studied just 
about every single angle of a courtroom as a paralegal, a law 
clerk, a trial lawyer, and an appellate lawyer. If I were lucky 
enough to be confirmed, I would understand as an appellate 
judge what things look like at a trial.
 But I also understand from having been inside an appellate 
judge's chamber, having been privileged to do that, how the 
appellate decisionmaking process can work and what it's like to 
have to build consensus with a panel and a group of people. And 
I think all those things would sort of bear on my judgment and 
my practice if I'm lucky enough to be confirmed.
 But I think really the most important thing is the ability 
to exercise independent judgment in the face of great scrutiny 
and criticism. And I'm doing my best to explain why I've 
endeavored to do that throughout my career today. And I think 
there's one moment in my life where I was really called upon to 
do that and make a hard decision that I'm glad I did. And that 
was to join Mr. Blanche to help represent the President at a 
time when my friends and even some people in my family, my work 
colleagues told me that there was every reason to think I would 
get fired. I would be bankrupt, we would be indicted, all 
manner are of evil.
 And negative consequences were sort of foisted and thrown 
at Todd and I regularly as we had to make a decision that many 
others didn't have the courage to make to stand up for what was 
right. And people comment on that as some kind of political 
decision. That's not what that was in the summer of 2023 at 
that time for me. And I think for Todd, that was a decision to 
fight for what was right and fight for the rule of law. And if 
I am fortunate enough to become a judge, I'll abide by that 
standard applying the rule of law every single day.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Blumenthal.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Before I begin 
my questioning in the clock starts, I'd like to add my voice on 
the point that Senator Whitehouse raised, this so-called 
deliberative process privilege.
 First, this Committee and Congress have never accepted that 
kind of assertion as a basis to evade questioning in this kind 
of confirmation hearing. But I'd like to point out also that 
this witness has no right to invoke that privilege. It's a 
privilege for the government of the United States to invoke.
 Now, I notice that the Deputy Attorney General is sitting 
right behind the witness. I didn't hear the Deputy Attorney 
General invoke this privilege on behalf of the government of 
the United States. And I might point out also that the witness 
is invoking it selectively. When he wants to answer the 
question, no privilege. When he wants to avoid answering the 
question, he says he's not at liberty to answer it.
 We've never accepted that kind of tactic on the part of a 
witness. Yes, nominees have sometimes said they can't comment 
on a case or an issue because it may come before them as a 
judge, but this kind of selective invoking of a privilege, 
smacks of evasion and defiance, and I think reflects on us as a 
Committee if we accept it in this context, Mr. Chairman.
 So, I hope that the witness may be instructed to answer 
these questions or we can have a resolution somehow on the 
legitimacy of this kind of privilege and ask the witness to 
come back. Let me begin my questioning.
 Senator Whitehouse. Mr. Chairman, I think the clock was 
started on Senator Blumenthal while he made his point of order. 
It might be a courtesy to allow it to be--thank you. There it 
is.
 Senator Blumenthal. I hadn't noticed that Mr. Chairman, but 
I thank Senator Whitehouse for pointing it out. Thank you.
 Chairman Grassley. Let me say, in the future----
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Bove----
 Chairman Grassley. I think Whitehouse made very clear the 
issues you're bringing up, and I said I'm willing to discuss 
them.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you.
 Chairman Grassley. But we can't take the time of this 
Committee to hear a repeat of everything from every Member that 
would disagree with what I said in my opening statement. Go 
ahead, Senator Blumenthal.
 Senator Blumenthal. I appreciate your point, Mr. Chairman. 
I'll begin my questioning.
 Mr. Bove, you responded to Senator Kennedy's questions 
about who was consulted about the dismissal of charges against 
Mr. Adams. Did you ever talk to Steven Miller before you filed 
the memorandum on February 10, ordering the dismissal of the 
Adams' charges?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I responded to Senator Kennedy's 
questions based on a publicly filed document that described the 
Attorney General's----
 Senator Blumenthal. Did you talk to Steven Miller?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not going to describe the participants in 
conversations.
 Senator Blumenthal. So, you won't answer that question.
 Mr. Bove. No, I will not, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. Why?
 Mr. Bove. Because it is not appropriate for me to discuss 
it.
 Senator Blumenthal. It is appropriate for you to tell us 
whom you consulted before taking action on behalf of the United 
States of America. You have no basis to avoid that question, 
Mr. Bove.
 Mr. Bove. Respectfully, Senator, I'm answering that 
question in a manner similar to several nominees before me, 
including Judge Katsas.
 Senator Blumenthal. Did you talk to anyone in the White 
House, including the President, about dismissal of the Adams 
charges before the February 10 memorandum?
 Mr. Bove. I respectfully refer you back to my answer, 
Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. I am absolutely flabbergasted that you 
would come before this Committee and refuse to tell us basic 
facts about a case that is at the core of the challenges to the 
appearance of impropriety that should disqualify you. You have 
the opportunity to clear the air, to come clean with the 
American people as well as this Committee, and you are evading 
and avoiding these questions.
 Mr. Bove. Senator, if you have a question about the 
position that I took in public with respect to the Mayor Adams 
case, I'm happy to address it, and I have addressed several 
today.
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, I have asked you a question that 
bears on the appearance of impropriety. Let me go on. Mr. Bove, 
in court, you represented first that there was no quid pro quo, 
but you said that the decision, even if there were a quid pro 
quo, was unreviewable, unreviewable by the court. Do you stand 
by that?
 Mr. Bove. I don't think that's what I said, Senator, 
because it's not consistent with the rule which explicitly 
provided----
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, you said it not only once, but 
you said it a number of times, and the judge observed, Judge Ho 
said that your position was, ``Fundamentally incompatible with 
the basic promise of equal justice under law.'' That's what he 
said about your position, that the decision to dismiss these 
charges was unreviewable. Do you stand by that assertion?
 Mr. Bove. I never made that assertion. And the judge 
granted the motion, Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. He granted the motion, but he disagreed 
with your premise that it was unreviewable. Let me ask you, are 
decisions to dismiss cases as with that one unreviewable?
 Mr. Bove. The text of Rule 48 requires in the instances 
presented by the Adams case, that dismissal only be provided 
for with leave of the court. That's as near a quote as I can 
give you. And the entire brief that I submitted acknowledged 
that point because we were seeking the leave.
 Senator Blumenthal. You know Mr. Bove, Mr. Bove, I am 
concerned about the quid pro quo that the judge concluded had 
been done. In fact, he said, ``Everything here smacks of a 
bargain.'' Everything here smacks of a bargain. But the quid 
pro quo that really concerns me is the one that brings you here 
today. You were virtually the only attorney in the Department 
of Justice willing to go to court and make a claim that career 
prosecutors said violated their basic standard of ethics.
 The quid pro quo was a nomination to the Court of Appeals. 
That's the appearance that the American people can take away 
from your sitting before us with that nomination. And I think 
it does grave damage to respect for the rule of law 
notwithstanding your assertions about your adherence to it, for 
you to be here as a result of that stand by you.
 Let me ask you about a separate issue; the firing of 
prosecutors and investigators who were involved in the January 
6 prosecutions. You were involved in purging prosecutors who in 
good faith and an exercise of their prosecutorial judgment, 
they went to court, they brought charges, you purged them. 
Isn't that correct?
 Mr. Bove. I don't agree with the use of the word purged, 
Senator.
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, you fired them.
 Mr. Bove. I authorized the termination of probationary 
employees at that U.S. Attorney's Office. Yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. Because they prosecuted the January 6 
rioters?
 Mr. Bove. No, because I was concerned about efforts in the 
prior administration to embed those prosecutors as permanent 
employees at the U.S. Attorney's Office.
 Senator Blumenthal. And you also fired the FBI 
investigators involved in the January 6 prosecution, correct?
 Mr. Bove. No, that's not accurate.
 Senator Blumenthal. You worked with Director Patel in 
firing them, correct?
 Mr. Bove. No, that's not accurate.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Schmitt.
 Senator Schmitt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to 
pivot away from the Democrats fake outrage on lawfare and talk 
about real lawfare. How has your representation of President 
Trump in the biggest weaponization of the justice system 
against a single individual because they didn't want to go get 
back into office and lawfare shaped your view of the justice 
system?
 Mr. Bove. Well, from the perspective of a prosecutor, 
Senator, it turned me into a person who wanted to get that 
building back on the right track, a track where people are in 
fact doing the right thing for the right reasons. I think 
there's many, many, many people, career civil servants, in the 
department who are doing just that. But I also think that there 
are parts of the department that lost sight of that obligation, 
and I saw that in my experiences as a defense lawyer.
 And so, what I would say is that that experience gave me, 
it provided me with intense focus on reform efforts to make 
sure that the unelected bureaucracy at the department was not 
in a position to subvert the political will of the 
democratically elected President.
 Senator Schmitt. Let's take a little time machine back to 
2023, in your previous testimony talked about decided to join 
Todd Blanche in the legal team. That was at the time many 
people in this country sort of wrote off President Trump as a 
candidate. The Democrats didn't think he was ever going to win.
 I certainly endorsed him very early. I thought he would and 
was hoping that he would, but the lengths to which nonprofits 
and other organizations went to punish anyone who was involved 
in either defending President Trump or had worked for President 
Trump trying to deny them employment. I mean it's well 
documented. To take that on, I would agree with your character. 
I think that took a lot of courage for you to do it.
 In hindsight now, it looks like obviously a very smart 
decision. You guys were very successful in the defense and he 
went on to win the election and the popular vote in a 
landslide, but at the time that wasn't the case. I want to ask 
you in some of this lawfare, Matthew Colangelo left, he was the 
number three guy at DOJ, and left to join the New York District 
Attorney's office in the prosecution of President Trump. Is 
that unusual for someone to leave that kind of position to go 
to a DA's office with prosecuting a political opponent?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I have to be very careful here because 
of the judicial canons that bind me as a nominee.
 Senator Schmitt. Let me ask it this way. Have you ever 
heard of something like that happening before?
 Mr. Bove. To my understanding, there was a pretty unique 
set of circumstances.
 Senator Schmitt. Let me speak about another set of unique 
circumstances. Is it unusual for like an assistant district 
attorney in a Georgia case to be meeting with the White House 
counsel's office about a prosecution of President Trump? Would 
that be sort of an unusual set of circumstances to be visiting 
the White House? Have you, let me ask you this. Have you ever 
heard of a scenario like that previously?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, if I could frame it this way, there's 
publicly filed briefing signed by myself and other defense 
lawyers when we were defending President Trump that regarded 
the circumstances that you just described as part of a 
discovery violation.
 Senator Schmitt. Letitia James, the attorney general in New 
York, ran on like ran for office saying she wanted to go after 
and prosecute President Trump. I ran for Attorney General in my 
State. Have you ever heard of anyone campaigning on the idea in 
the United States of America, I'm not talking about a Third 
World banana republic, but in the United States of America 
prosecuting criminally, prosecuting a political opponent. That 
was their pitch to the voters. Have you ever heard of anything 
like that?
 Mr. Bove. I've got to be very careful here about getting 
too close to politics under the judicial canon, Senator.
 Senator Schmitt. Okay. Jack Smith was appointed special 
prosecutor to try to, again, imprison President Trump for the 
rest of his life so he couldn't run for office. Could you 
speak--were you involved in the legal team defending President 
Trump in that prosecution as well?
 Mr. Bove. Both in the District of Columbia and in the 
Southern District of Florida.
 Senator Schmitt. Yes. Could you just rattle off a couple of 
things that you think were unusual departures from how 
prosecutors would normally handle cases like that that again, 
has informed your position now to make sure that that never 
happens again to somebody in this country?
 Mr. Bove. I will Senator and I referenced some of these a 
moment ago, and I just want to be clear what I'm doing is just 
referencing public arguments that I made as a defense lawyer.
 Senator Schmitt. Yes, yes not personal musings, these yes 
absolutely what were filed with the court.
 Mr. Bove. These are legal arguments that we presented that, 
for example, in a case as complex as the case in Florida with 
the allegations that were set forth in our judgment as defense 
lawyers, we argued to the court that it was highly unusual to 
try and proceed to trial as quickly as those prosecutors 
initially proposed.
 Senator Schmitt. Anything else you that, that struck you as 
unusual that you can recall from the public filings?
 Mr. Bove. I think just to be safe and to stand on the side 
of----
 Senator Schmitt. Sure. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I 
just want to make the point that while the Democrats are trying 
to manufacture something here, like we are on the other side of 
the most political prosecution of a political opponent this 
country has ever seen, and I hope to God that never happens 
again. And your experience, I think, will make you a better 
judge. So, congratulations.
 Mr. Bove. Thank you, Senator.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Hirono.
 Senator Hirono. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I ask every 
nominee who comes before any of the Committees on which I sit 
the following two initial questions that go to fitness to serve 
by the nominee. I'll ask you, Mr. Bove, since you became a 
legal adult, have you made unwanted requests for sexual favors, 
or committed any verbal or physical harassment, or assault of a 
sexual nature?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Hirono. Have you ever faced discipline or entered 
into a settlement relating to this kind of conduct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Hirono. In the February 23, 2025 report in 
Politico, the title was, ``Before he became Trump's bulldog, 
Emil Bove was nearly demoted for bellicose management style.'' 
According to this article, which was put into the record, when 
you served as a unit chief at the Southern District of New 
York, and I'm again quoting this article, ``Mr. Bove quickly 
garnered a reputation as a manager who was sharply critical of 
the people who worked for him and unable to control his anger. 
His conduct was abusive according to one former member of the 
unit.'' Are you familiar with this article?
 Mr. Bove. I am.
 Senator Hirono. So, going on according to this article, 
``In 2020 or early 2021, the Executive Committee of the U.S. 
Attorney's Office opened a formal inquiry into Bove's 
management style. They interviewed prosecutors who worked for 
him about his behavior, and they decided that he should be 
removed from his role as a supervisor.'' Of course, you are 
aware of this inquiry and their recommendation. Yes, no?
 Mr. Bove. As well as the fact that I was not removed.
 Senator Hirono. Yes?
 Mr. Bove. I was not removed Senator.
 Senator Hirono. Okay. Can you speak into the mic so we can 
all hear your answers, please?
 Mr. Bove. I apologize. I was not removed, Senator.
 Senator Hirono. I know you were not removed because the 
article goes on to say that when this Committee decided to 
demote you and remove you, you pleaded with them to allow you 
to remain in your job, and you pledged that you would commit to 
improving your behavior. Did you do that? Did you request they 
not remove you? Did you plead that you not be removed, and that 
you would change your behavior?
 Mr. Bove. That characterization----
 Senator Hirono. Hello?
 Mr. Bove. That characterization is not accurate, Senator.
 Senator Hirono. So, you did not change your behavior at 
all, or did you?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I'm not perfect. And so, when I get 
constructive criticism, I absolutely----
 Senator Hirono. Speaking to the mic, please.
 Mr. Bove. When I get constructive criticism, I absolutely 
take account of that and try and be better at my job. And I did 
that in that instance. But the characterization in that article 
by anonymous sources from a whisper campaign from SDNY alums is 
not accurate.
 Senator Hirono. The fact of the matter is though this 
Committee did talk to people who worked for you and they 
concluded that you engaged in abusive behavior and that you 
should be removed, but you got to stay. The article, you 
disagree with the characterization, but why would they go 
through all this trouble to investigate and all of that and 
they let you stay? Unless I hope that you had said, well, you 
would change your behavior because the attitude, the behavior 
of a judge, I think, is important for us to understand.
 During your time as a supervisor in the Southern District 
of New York, you supervised a team that prosecuted US v. Ali 
Sadr, you supervised them?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Hirono. In that case, prosecutors failed to 
disclose evidence to the point where even though there was a 
judgment there of guilty, so it resulted in the jury's verdict 
being overturned and the charges dropped and the district court 
wrote, which I think is pretty unusual, that there was, and I 
quote the district court, ``Insufficient supervision.'' You 
acknowledge just now that you were the supervisor. 
``Insufficient supervision of disclosure obligations by the 
USAO's unit chiefs.''
 Do you recall the court making that assessment of your 
supervisory capability?
 Mr. Bove. I do, Senator, and I respect Judge Nathan, and I 
think that what she was trying to accomplish in that decision 
was to make sure that there were protections in place.
 Senator Hirono. I am running out of time. I just wanted 
to--you had said that the January 6 prosecutions were a grave 
injustice. So, does that mean that you agreed with President 
Trump's pardon of all of the convicted felons?
 Mr. Bove. I'm not in a position as a nominee, Senator, to 
comment on any President's use of the pardon power, which is 
committed to President's----
 Senator Hirono. Once again, I should think that because you 
can characterize those prosecutions as a grave injustice, I 
would think that you would be happy that the President pardoned 
everybody. Thank you.
 Chairman Grassley. Senator Hawley.
 Senator Hawley. Mr. Bove, nice to see you. I enjoyed our 
conversation the other day. Congratulations on your nomination.
 If I could, let's turn the focus of the discussion back to 
the law. I want to talk to you for just a second about your 
approach to the interpretation of statutes, which is something 
that we discussed when you and I had a chance to speak earlier.
 When you encounter, as you will constantly on the Third 
Circuit, when you encounter an ambiguous statute, what's your 
general approach? What do you consult? What's your approach to 
interpreting the text? Give us a sense of how you'll tackle 
this. What will be a daily occurrence should you be confirmed?
 Mr. Bove. In the face of an ambiguity, Senator, I would 
consult the context of the operative phrase, consider the 
statutory structure, look at usages of similar terms by the 
operative legislature at the time in question because I think 
that matters, as I said earlier, with respect to enforcing 
bicameralism and presentment, and try to garner as much as can 
be from those sources, those textual indications.
 In the event that I think that those textual considerations 
don't resolve the matter philosophically, I would be inclined 
to exercise restraint and not insert myself or a panel of the 
Third Circuit, if I was confirmed, into a position of declaring 
what the meaning of an ambiguity is as opposed to deferring 
back to the legislature on that topic.
 Senator Hawley. You just used the word text or textualist 
about three or four times. Do you consider yourself a 
textualist? Is that a fair assessment?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. Let's just think about a controversy that 
exists among those who call themselves textualists. Some 
textualists say that the statute ought to be interpreted an 
ambiguous phrase ought to be interpreted according to the 
public understanding at the time that the statute was enacted.
 Other textualists, self-identified textualists, say that a 
text meaning sometimes only becomes clear over time, so there 
needs to be an elapse of time you can consider what's happened 
in a space of time rightly to interpret an ambiguous phrase. 
Both camps call themselves textualists. Where do you fit?
 Mr. Bove. In the first one, Senator. I think that an 
interpretive methodology that allows the meaning of a statute 
to shift over time, potentially over the course of 
interpretations by different judges under different 
circumstances or at the whims of policy or political 
considerations can be very problematic.
 If I were confirmed, part of my philosophy would be to do 
this job pursuant to the limited powers in Article III in a way 
that enhances the democratic features of the political 
branches, and by that, I mean focusing on the text, what it 
meant at the time it was put on the books and deferring to 
those political branches on the other matters.
 Senator Hawley. Good. So, I hear you to say that you reject 
the idea that an Act's meaning can only become clear over a 
number of years. You think it ought to be interpreted as 
understood at the time it was enacted by the public meaning at 
that time. Have I got that right?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Hawley. Good. Let's talk about substantive due 
process for just a moment. What's your understanding of that 
doctrine?
 Mr. Bove. I think there's a basic test set forth in Supreme 
Court precedent that I would apply faithfully, if I'm fortunate 
enough to be confirmed, that seeks to identify certain 
fundamental rights as a matter of substantive due process. That 
precedent for that test, as I understand it, basically requires 
consideration of whether the right at issue is implicit in the 
concept of ordered liberty, and also consistent with deep 
history and traditions of the republic.
 There's a lot of academic writing about the merits of that 
test that I think for judges, particularly me, if I'm 
confirmed, is sort of beside the point because on the Third 
Circuit I'd be bound by Supreme Court precedent, like the 
Glucksberg case, to apply that test in the context of arguments 
presented to me by the parties.
 Senator Hawley. What is the leading Supreme Court precedent 
on substantive due process to your knowledge?
 Mr. Bove. There's several cases that lay out and address 
the tests that I just described in the context of discussing 
different fundamental rights. Dobbs is one of them. I mentioned 
the Glucksberg case, which is an older formulation of that 
test.
 Senator Hawley. In fact, the Supreme Court has used 
different tests over time. The substantive due process has two 
branches. It has the incorporation branch and it has the 
fundamental rights branch. You've been describing the 
fundamental rights branch.
 The court has used different tests over the years, frankly, 
to describe what counts as a fundamental right. Those tests are 
quite divergent if we're being honest, but this court seems to 
have settled on one recently, and I think you just put your 
finger on the decision that most recently draws these themes 
together, these strands together. That's the Dobbs decision. Do 
you regard the Dobbs decision as settled law?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Hawley. As controlling law?
 Mr. Bove. That is what I mean, is that is a binding 
precedent of the Supreme Court that I would be required to 
apply faithfully, if I'm confirmed.
 Senator Hawley. And so, you'll apply the Dobbs decision not 
only in the context of life and abortion, which was the 
immediate context, but also for its instruction on the meaning 
of fundamental liberties under the substantive due process 
head. Is that correct? Is that fair to say?
 Mr. Bove. I think it's fair to say that a judge endeavoring 
to be bound by the rule of law, which is certainly what I would 
be trying to do, applies all relevant Supreme Court precedents 
in a faithful way. And that would be my mission for life, if 
I'm confirmed.
 Senator Hawley. I want to be clear on this, just on this 
last point, this is important because there's lots of Supreme 
Court precedents that conflict with one another over the years. 
You'll apply the current and controlling precedent to the 
matter at hand. Is that fair to say?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, without hesitation.
 Senator Hawley. Which in this case you recognize to be the 
Dobbs case. Is that fair to say?
 Mr. Bove. Yes. I think Dobbs is a recent formulation of the 
substantive due process test that we're talking about.
 Senator Hawley. That would bind you?
 Mr. Bove. Of course.
 Chairman Grassley. Before I call on Senator Booker, Senator 
Moody has agreed to Chair the rest of this hearing. Senator 
Booker.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, can I make one point?
 Chairman Grassley. Yes.
 Senator Durbin. We know we are operating under a 5-minute 
rule, but you've given some latitude, for example, to the last 
Senator, and I'm not objecting to it. I'm saying the time to 
speak has been 5 minutes established. We've gone over that as a 
convenience to our colleagues, and I hope we'll continue that.
 Chairman Grassley. Okay.
 Senator Booker. In 2018, Mr. Bove, a group of Federal 
Criminal Defense attorneys and former SDNY prosecutors in 
Manhattan were so alarmed by your pattern of unethical conduct 
that they wrote your supervisors at SDNY to warn them about 
you. I'd like to enter into the record a letter that I sent to 
acting U.S. Attorney, Jay Clayton, of SDNY requesting more 
information about any internal or external complaints about you 
as a prosecutor.
 The letter contains the full text of that 2018 email from 
lawyers in which they describe you, and I'm quoting here, they 
describe you as, ``Vindictive, always looking for leverage and 
power. A prosecutor version of a drunk driver, completely 
reckless and out of control, needing adult supervision.''
 One attorney said that whatever due justice is supposed to 
mean, it doesn't apply to Bove. A former Federal prosecutor who 
later litigated against you said, ``What Mr. Bove enjoyed most 
as a prosecutor was wielding power,'' a quality they described 
as the single worst possible trait for a public servant.
 Now, I read these because they're important that these 
complaints are not an attempt to derail your nomination. This 
is from 2018, person after person. These complaints come from 
attorneys who practiced in Federal court, some former Federal 
prosecutors warning a U.S. attorney's office that one of their 
prosecutors was, ``--a real recurring problem,'' and that you 
were not representing the office in a way that they thought the 
office would want it represented. Your conduct was so beyond 
the pale back in 2018 that they wrote your supervisors to say 
you were a liability for the office.
 I think this is important because it shows a pattern of 
behavior. The allegations align with reports about your abuse 
of power now at the DOJ. I want to followup in this pattern 
with what Senator Durbin's questions about the mandatory Teams 
meeting you scheduled for all remaining Public Integrity 
Section attorneys on February 14, 2025. We already know that 
you're refusing to tell this Committee whether you talked to 
Stephen Miller or others at the White House.
 All the chiefs and supervisors had resigned at this point, 
so all of the remaining and available attorneys were line 
attorneys in that meeting. Is that correct, approximately 20 
attorneys were on the Team's call?
 Mr. Bove. I do hope, Senator, that at some point I'll have 
an opportunity----
 Senator Booker. You were trying to find two attorneys to 
sign a motion to dismiss the Adams case without prejudice. Is 
that correct?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Booker. During the meeting, you told attorneys that 
it is their job to implement the President's agenda, and that 
they have to follow orders from the President, and that there's 
no room for dissent in the chain of command. Is that correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Booker. You told them that they had 1 hour to find 
two attorneys to sign the motion, they weren't allowed to ask 
questions. Is that correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Booker. You started the meeting by emphasizing to 
the line attorneys that Danielle Sassoon and Hagan Scotten had 
failed to follow orders and that Ms. Sassoon was going to be 
reassigned before she resigned. Correct?
 Mr. Bove. I'm sorry, I didn't understand the last part of 
that question.
 Senator Booker. I will state again. You started the meeting 
by emphasizing to the line attorneys that Danielle Sassoon and 
Hagan Scotten had failed to follow orders and that Ms. Sassan 
would was going to be reassigned before she resigned. Is that 
correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Booker. Okay. You also told them that whoever 
signed the motion would, ``emerge as the new leaders,'' of the 
Public Integrity Section for doing so. Correct?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall saying that.
 Senator Booker. So, you don't know if you said that or not?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall saying that.
 Senator Booker. Edward Sullivan volunteered to sign the 
motion. As promised, Sullivan was promoted to acting chief of 
the Public Integrity Section for dismissing that case. Is that 
correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Booker. So, you are saying that as a leader of the 
DOJ, you don't know who's in charge of public integrity?
 Mr. Bove. No. I'm saying that the causal relationship that 
you implied in your question is not accurate.
 Senator Booker. Okay. We have you on the record on all of 
those points. You worked on January 6 cases while a prosecutor 
at the SDNY. Correct?
 Mr. Bove. A supervisor, yes.
 Senator Booker. An FBI agent described you as treating the 
January 6 cases as a priority when you were prosecuting those 
cases, but then you fired dozens of prosecutors and eight 
senior FBI officials working on the case. Is that correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Booker. Mr. Bove, I am hoping that more evidence is 
going to come out that showed that you lied before this 
Committee. I'm wondering where the lines are for you. What's 
the line in the sand when you wield awesome power of 
government? What is that line for you? Because clearly lying to 
a court isn't a red line. Refusing to follow court orders isn't 
a line. Doxing judges and government officials isn't a red 
line. Intimidating attorneys you supervise into doing things 
they believe is unethical is not a line. What's your red line?
 I really wonder what could the President ask you to do that 
wouldn't do? What wouldn't you do to win? A judge has to uphold 
core values and principles, independence, impartiality, 
integrity, diligence. A judge must be free from undue 
influence. A judge must decide cases fairly without prejudice 
or favor. A judge must ensure that anyone who appears before 
them in court will get a fair shake.
 [Gavel tapping.]
 Senator Moody [presiding]. Thank you, Mr. Booker.
 Senator Booker. Everything we're hearing you say makes me 
believe that you're incapable of that. The pattern didn't just 
begin when you were nominated by this President. Peers of 
yours, prosecutors, attorneys who served with you, and judges, 
in your past year have again and again cited you as someone who 
is not capable or qualified of doing this job in which you're 
nominated for. Thank you, Madam Chair.
 Senator Moody. Ms. Britt.
 Senator Britt. Mr. Bove, thank you so much for being here 
today. Thank you for your willingness to serve, and 
congratulations on your nomination.
 I heard you in the last exchange say, ``I wish I had an 
opportunity to respond.'' I'd like to give you that opportunity 
when we've heard a number of my colleagues levy attacks what I 
believe in many cases to be false claims. I'd like to just turn 
the mic over to you for a second and give you an opportunity to 
respond.
 Mr. Bove. Thank you, Senator. I appreciate that. With 
respect to the 2018 email referenced by Senator Booker, that 
email contains a series of wildly inaccurate claims about me. I 
categorically reject any claim of unethical or improper 
behavior by me. Period.
 You know that the claims in that email are false for two 
reasons. First, I got that job. I received the promotion the 
next time the seat was open. Second, attorney's leveling ethics 
obligations like that have their own ethical duties under Rule 
8.3 of the New York Rules to report those things if they take 
them seriously, if they believe them to be true, that never 
happened.
 Those attorneys who leveled those claims, which were false, 
also had obligations to their clients' obligations to advocate 
zealously on behalf of people that I was prosecuting. That was 
the role of those lawyers in the criminal justice system, a 
role that I respect.
 So, if they believed the things in that email to be true, 
they would've been under an obligation to file motions in the 
courts where those proceedings were taking place. I'm not aware 
of any such motion, and I'm certainly not aware of any relief 
granted with respect to the types of claims in that email.
 More generally, if I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed, I 
understand that there are questions about what kind of 
temperament that I would have as a judge. I think I would be 
tough, but fair. Litigants and colleagues would feel respected 
by me. They would understand that I take the job very 
seriously, and that I work very hard at it. And I don't think 
that there needs to be a lot of guesswork about why that's 
true.
 I've appeared in court regularly and frequently since 2012. 
I've participated in 12 criminal trials. I've argued 10 
appeals. There's more criminal prosecutions that I've 
participated in than I could count. And I think if you talk to 
the judges who presided over those cases, and some of them were 
high profile, there were a lot of people there.
 The President's trial in New York, the proceedings in the 
Southern District of Florida, what those judges would say is 
that they didn't agree with every argument I made. And 
sometimes they didn't agree with every word I used, but they 
did feel personally respected. And I think that's what's 
important.
 As I said in response to one of the other Senator's 
questions, I'm not perfect. I'm not here to tell you that I do 
learn from mistakes. I take constructive criticism seriously. I 
did with respect to that 2018 email. That's why I got the job 
the next time it was open. And I've done so throughout my 
career, and I think that's prepared me to be the type of judge 
that I just described. Thank you, Senator.
 Senator Britt. Thank you for responding. Also, just give me 
a little bit of insight and to the lessons and experience 
you've learned. Looking at your resume, it is quite impressive. 
You have been a clerk both at the district court and circuit 
court level. Your time as a prosecutor, your time at Maine 
Justice, your comprehensive resume both with private practice 
and public service, I think, makes you poised to be excellent 
on the court.
 Talk to me a little bit about those experiences and what 
you think has best prepared you for as your confirmation as and 
when you're confirmed to do a great job on the bench.
 Mr. Bove. Thank you, Senator. I think one of the most 
important responsibilities, and there are many of a judge, is 
to be able to put aside personal opinions and decide cases 
based on the facts and the applicable law. And I think that the 
time that I've spent my career on both sides of being a 
prosecutor and a defense lawyer has given me some experience 
with getting used to seeing both sides of things, setting aside 
personal views.
 There's certainly cases that I prosecuted that one could 
hold up a terrorism case or a drug trafficking case and say, 
how is a person responsible for those kinds of prosecutions and 
turning around and representing criminal defendants charged 
with fraud, or I did have other clients beside President Trump.
 It's that kind of work and focus on the ethics of 
representing clients zealously, and being focused on justice, 
and getting to righteous outcomes regardless of which side of 
the case I'm on, that I think would inform a lot of my practice 
and approach to the bench, if I'm fortunate enough to be 
confirmed.
 Senator Britt. Thank you so much for your willingness to 
serve, and congratulations again on your nomination.
 Mr. Bove. Thank you.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Britt. And as Chair, I 
would like to welcome the United States Attorney General, Pam 
Bondi, to the hearing. We are glad to have you here. Thank you 
for attending.
 I would also like to followup on Senator Britt's 
questioning by entering two letters into the record from 91 
former Senior Justice Department officials, including 52 former 
United States attorneys. They urge the Committee to support Mr. 
Bove's nomination. The letter from the U.S. Attorney says, and 
I'll quote, ``Mr. Bove's professionalism, integrity, mettle and 
experience or expertise make him an outstanding candidate to 
serve as a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third 
Circuit.''
 Senator Moody. And with that, I will turn it over to 
Senator Welch.
 Senator Welch. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Welcome. 
This question of temperament obviously is relevant. You'd 
acknowledge that?
 Mr. Bove. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Welch. Okay. You made a comment in response to 
Senator Booker asking you questions, and I'll ask these as 
well; that complaints were never made ethically and there'd be 
a responsibility of an attorney to make those ethical 
complaints under the judicial code. I just have to say I 
disagree with that.
 I mean, I was a defense attorney, worked with many 
prosecutors, had enormous respect for those prosecutors, so the 
temperament issue doesn't always get into the question of 
whether it's an ethical violation, but it does get into the 
temperament and why that, in my view, is very important, 
whatever our job is, but particularly for a judge where you've 
got that incredible power.
 So, I do want to go through some of these questions that 
have been raised by that letter that was sent making some 
complaints about you. You were described as vindictive. There 
was references to abuse of power, a refusal to engage in any 
discussion about the case and there was one in particular that 
stood out to me. One of the attorneys in a case involving 
someone who was detained, had information that the person had 
in fact reported as required. And he was trying to provide you 
with this information because the hearing about his client's 
well-being was to take place soon.
 And it says that you, ``--snippily told me that he would 
not even try to call the PO,'' I assume that's probation 
officer, ``--on such short notice after I suggested he could at 
least try to reach out, and then you might get lucky and catch 
him.'' Is that true?
 Mr. Bove. No, Senator, it's not true. And that's exactly 
the type of issue raised in that email where it's an allegation 
about an abuse of power that if true----
 Senator Welch. You did make the phone call?
 Mr. Bove. No, the whole episode as described in that email 
is not accurate. And if any----
 Senator Welch. I'm not going to know that and I'm not sure 
you do, but the basic point here is that you could have made a 
phone call that would've resolved the situation, whether that 
his client had in fact reported or had not and you wouldn't 
make it, so you're denying that that's true.
 Mr. Bove. I do deny, and I think the paragraph describes 
that one of my colleagues stepped in.
 Senator Welch. All right. Let me go on to the next one. 
Thank you for giving me your answer. The prosecutorial 
misconduct scandal that is of concern to me and presumably 
would be of great concern to you and your job as a prosecutor, 
what the judge found that errors were so severe that following 
a jury verdict in his favor, the government determined that 
further prosecution of the case would not be in the interest of 
justice.
 This is a case where there were prosecutorial assets were 
used, there was a conviction, and then the prosecution had to 
end it. Right?
 Mr. Bove. Right. And I was one of the supervisors who 
participated in that decision because I was so disturbed by the 
violations that had taken place.
 Senator Welch. Well so, what the judge said, as I 
understand it, is that you offered little in the way of 
supervision.
 Mr. Bove. And so, as I've said, I respect Judge Nathan's 
decision, that aspect of the opinion.
 Senator Welch. He said that?
 Mr. Bove. He, said that but it was always difficult for me 
to square that with the fact that during the operative weekend, 
on both days, I was with the prosecutors, the record reflects 
that. I spoke to the prosecutors at 10 o'clock on Saturday 
night at 10 o'clock on Sunday night. Well, here's--so again, 
I'm not perfect, but I did do my best there. My best wasn't 
enough. And I acknowledge that, but I don't think it's true 
that I didn't work hard on it.
 Senator Welch. Let me go on to a third thing. In 2021, the 
Southern District's Executive Committee initiated a formal 
investigation into your conduct. And my understanding is that 
after that happened, that's when you shortly thereafter left 
the Southern District. Is that correct?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Welch. When did you leave the Southern district?
 Mr. Bove. December 2021.
 Senator Welch. December 2021?
 Mr. Bove. Yes.
 Senator Welch. Well, that's shortly after the 2021 
investigation. Have you ever been asked or had to take anger 
management or behavioral management at the Southern district?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Welch. All right. Who won the 2020 election for 
President of the United States?
 Mr. Bove. President Biden was certified as the winner of 
that election.
 Senator Welch. So, you give the standard answer. You can't 
say that he won because he got the majority of votes and also 
got the electoral college victory.
 Mr. Bove. I think the characterizations that you just made, 
Senator, are both political, and so I can't address them under 
the canons. And they're also tied up in ongoing litigation.
 Senator Welch. Help me understand how it's political to 
state who got the most votes in any election.
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I'm just trying to be precise. The 
process by which our country declares the victor and election 
is a certification process. President Biden was certified.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Welch.
 Senator Welch. I yield back. Thank you.
 Senator Moody. Senator Blackburn.
 Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Madam Chairman, and 
congratulations on your nomination.
 Madam Chairman, I want to talk for a few minutes about 
process. I have found it stunning that my Democratic colleagues 
have had such objections to process. So I thought I might 
revisit a little bit of this Committee's history over the last 
few weeks. I think it would be instructive for the nominee and 
those that support him to be aware of this.
 Now, let's just go back to the Biden administration and 
point out a few things that happened not only to me, but to 
some of our Republican colleagues. Over the objections of 
Senator Hagerty and me, the Biden administration nominated, not 
one, not two, but three nominees that we opposed. Now, some may 
like to say, ``Well, you could have worked with White House on 
this,'' and we tried to, or, ``You could have presented 
Democrat nominees,'' and indeed we did repeatedly.
 But in the case of one of those nominees, Mathis, Chairman 
Durbin scheduled a hearing without even sending Senator Hagerty 
and I a blue slip. Now what happened? The Democrats voted in 
lockstep to move him out of the Committee. Another nominee, 
Karla Campbell, misled the Committee during her confirmation 
hearing about her involvement with a radical far left group 
that she worked with. And again, the Democrats were united in 
their support of that nominee.
 Then with Kevin Ripps, there were serious accusations of 
prosecutorial misconduct. And what did my colleagues on the 
other side of the dais do? They voted in lockstep. Now, they 
want to complain today and some have spent their time 
complaining and griping about the way the Committee has been 
handled, but they're forgetting about these. They forget about 
Senator Rick Scott and Senator Rubio who opposed the nomination 
of Embry Kidd, but the Democrats moved forward with that. They 
were pleased to move forward with it.
 Senator Tillis and Senator Budd opposed the nomination of 
Ryan Park, but the Democrats chose to keep moving forward. And 
again, I would remind everyone the Senators were bringing 
forward Democrats that could have been the nominee, but instead 
my friends across the dais decided, they wanted those that were 
farther to the left, those that were activists, those that did 
not have judicial experience. They were looking for activists 
to put on the court.
 I'm going to read Senator Tillis's quote as we were 
approaching the markup of Mr. Park. He said, and I quote, ``I'm 
going to tell you the same thing, that when the rules are 
reversed and they're going to be reversed, you're either going 
to make my job harder by doing the right thing and respecting 
your colleague today, or you're going to make my job easier 
because I'm going to go right down the line with the 
administration.''
 Now, this is important to remember as we talk about process 
and as we discuss these nominees that are coming before us. 
There was very little respect that was shown the members on 
this side of the dais, and very little respect that was shown 
to the nominees, and basically, no consideration for the 
ability of a home State Senator to weigh in on those that were 
being brought forward.
 So Mr. Bove, I look forward to supporting you. I look 
forward to your confirmation, and my hope is that my colleagues 
across the dais will begin to think that it would be a good 
thing for them to reconsider, rewind the video and play it, so 
that you are refreshed on how you conducted yourselves during 
the Biden administration. I yield back.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Blackburn. Senator 
Padilla.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you, Madam Chair. Because I want to 
begin with a couple statements not specific to the nominee 
before us, Mr. Bove, but general observations as we've had 
hearings of nominees and on issues since the beginning of the 
year to become clear that President Trump clearly has one 
litmus test when selecting people to appoint. It's not 
experience. It's not dedication to our country or the rule of 
law. It's whether or not the potential nominee is willing to 
bend or ignore the law to satisfy the President's whims.
 Now, I understand that elections have consequences and one 
consequence is that a President who is elected will get to 
nominate judges for the duration of his term or her term, but 
selecting someone with such a deep track record of vindictive, 
duplicitous behavior, of abuse of power that is and must be 
treated as unacceptable. From Mr. Bove's time with the Southern 
District of New York, to his time representing Donald Trump, to 
his time at the Trump Justice Department, it's been 
demonstrated that he will not let the law stand in the way of 
doing what he wants.
 That's why as soon as Mr. Bove joined the Justice 
Department in an acting, unconfirmed capacity, he began an 
effort to purge the Department of Justice of perceived 
``enemies'' like the January 6 prosecutors. He even called the 
January 6 prosecutions, ``a grave national injustice,'' and 
ordered the FBI to produce a list of everyone involved in them.
 Never mind the fact that he had previously worked on 
January 6 prosecutions while at the Southern District of New 
York, and that's why he ordered Southern District of New York 
prosecutors to dismiss criminal charges against New York Mayor 
Eric Adams in exchange for Mayor Adams helping to implement 
President Trump's radical immigration enforcement plan.
 Mr. Bove's actions in this case let eight prosecutors, 
eight, including the interim U.S. Attorney, Danielle Sassoon, 
who had clerked for Justice Scalia to resign. But instead of 
firing him, Donald Trump plans to give him a lifetime 
appointment to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in New 
Jersey, the State that Mr. Bove has very, very little ties to.
 Now, it's not just Democrats who are concerned, 
conservative judicial activists and former Republican staff 
Member of this Committee, Ed Wallin who wrote that Bove has 
been called, ``A savage,'' and likened him to, ``--a Mafia 
henchman,'' not my words, just quoting what's been submitted to 
this Committee for consideration.
 The Wall Street Journal published an editorial urging this 
Committee to ask questions about Bove's qualifications for this 
seat. They wrote, ``Does Emil Bove have the right judicial 
temperament? Does he have a judicial philosophy?'' It's 
seemingly clear that the more we learn the answer is no.
 But we're here to ask questions and I do have a couple of 
questions in my time remaining. Mr. Bove, can you share with us 
how many of the prosecutors assigned to the Capitol Siege 
Section were fired after you sent your memo on staffing at the 
Department of Justice?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall.
 Senator Padilla. Ballpark?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall.
 Senator Padilla. All right. Well, I'll submit that in the 
form of a question for the record to allow you time to jog your 
memory banks and try to give us a number, at least an estimate.
 Senator Padilla. Can you tell me how many January 6 rioters 
President Trump pardoned?
 Mr. Bove. No, I don't recall.
 Senator Padilla. Okay. Well, that actually kind of makes 
sense because I don't think when asked the President himself 
couldn't give an exact number. When asked his response was ``it 
would be very, very cumbersome to go and look how many 
people.'' We're talking about 1,500 people.
 To think that on the first day in office he would have 
considered case by case that volume of files to make the 
determination that they should be pardoned. That's clearly not 
believable. And we know that dozens of those pardoned had prior 
criminal records including rape, sexual abuse of a minor, 
domestic violence and more. Yes, I'm talking about the January 
6 rioters.
 I'm going to end with this, Madam Chair. I can tell you 
that a long serving prosecutor with the D.C. United States 
Attorney's Office thought that it sent a message that, 
``Political violence toward a political goal is acceptable in a 
modern democratic society.'' Mr. Bove, you contributed to these 
actions. What do you think the mess this--what kind of message 
do you think this sends to the American people?
 Mr. Bove. I think that the President in his exclusive 
discretion under the Constitution----
 Senator Padilla. My question is, what message is this sent 
to the American people, the pardoning of January 6 writers many 
with prior criminal convictions? And you can answer briefly.
 Mr. Bove. I think that's a question that calls for 
political views. And under the canons, I'm not able to take a 
position
 Senator Padilla. I thought that we're talking about public 
safety and the rule of law. Thank you, Madam Chair.
 Senator Moody. Senator Schiff.
 Senator Schiff. Mr. Bove, I want to turn to the meeting 
that Mr. Reuveni, the whistleblower has written an extensive 
complaint about. The hearing started with the Chairman reading 
a social media post by the Deputy Attorney General Blanche, who 
is present today, but not under oath, nor is that social media 
post under oath.
 Let me ask you, since you are under oath, in the complaint, 
it says, ``Bove stated that DOJ would need to consider telling 
the courts `fuck you' and ignoring any such court order.'' Did 
you say anything of that kind in the meeting?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, I have no recollection of saying 
anything of that kind to the extent I used the----
 Senator Schiff. Would you recall, Mr. Bove, if you said or 
suggested during a meeting with Justice Department lawyers that 
maybe they should consider telling the court `fuck you'. It 
seems to me that would be something you'd remember unless 
that's the kind of thing you say frequently.
 Mr. Bove. Well, I've certainly said things encouraging 
litigators at the department to fight hard for valid positions 
that we have to take in defense of our clients
 Senator Schiff. And if you frequently suggested that they 
say `fuck you' and ignore court orders, is that also something 
you frequently do such you might not remember doing it in this 
occasion?
 Mr. Bove. No. And as I explained, I have never directed----
 Senator Schiff. So, did you or did you not make those 
comments during that meeting?
 Mr. Bove. Which comment, Senator?
 Senator Schiff. You really need me to repeat it? Did you 
suggest, as Mr. Reuveni wrote that DOJ would need to consider 
telling the courts `fuck you' and ignore any such court order?
 Mr. Bove. I did not suggest that there would be any need to 
consider ignoring court orders. At the point of that meeting. 
There were no court orders to discuss.
 Senator Schiff. Well, did you suggest telling the courts 
`fuck you' in any manner?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall.
 Senator Schiff. You just don't remember that? Well, let me 
ask you this. It also says in the complaint, ``Bove indicated 
and stressed to all in attendance that the planes needed to 
take off no matter what. These are the planes that a judge was 
ordering not be used to render people to a maximum security 
prison outside the country.''
 Did you say during that meeting? Did you stress to all in 
attendance that the planes needed to take off no matter what?
 Mr. Bove. Senator, your characterization is not accurate.
 Senator Schiff. It's not my characterization. It's the 
characterization of a decorated prosecutor who was in that 
meeting. Are you saying that he's lying?
 Mr. Bove. As I said at the beginning of the hearing----
 Senator Schiff. No, no, I'm not interested in what you said 
at the beginning of the hearing. I'm interested in whether you 
stressed to people in attendance that the planes needed to take 
off no matter what. Did you say that?
 Mr. Bove. I certainly conveyed the importance of the 
upcoming operation.
 Senator Schiff. Well, don't don't paraphrase here. Did you 
tell people in attendance the planes needed to take off no 
matter what?
 Mr. Bove. I don't recall the specific words that I used.
 Senator Schiff. Wouldn't you recall saying that if you had 
instructed that the planes needed to take off no matter what, 
including whether the court ordered otherwise, you wouldn't 
remember that?
 Mr. Bove. This is a mischaracterization, Senator? There 
were no court orders at this point?
 Senator Schiff. Well, there was a court order wasn't there?
 Mr. Bove. No.
 Senator Schiff. Wasn't there a court order by Judge 
Boasberg? If not in this specific case, then in related cases 
that people not be sent out of the country until the court 
could rule? Wasn't there a court order?
 Mr. Bove. Not at the time of that meeting, Senator.
 Senator Schiff. Did you participate in the decision not to 
disseminate that oral court order prior to the written court 
order to other agencies so those planes would not take off, so 
those planes would turn around? Were you involved in the 
decision to withhold that court order from the responsible 
agencies?
 Mr. Bove. I think it's clear that I participated in this--
--
 Senator Schiff. Yes or no.
 Mr. Bove. I participated in this matter, and I'm not going 
to get into the contents of legal advice. I did over the course 
of time, as many lawyers have provided advice about the scope 
of court orders.
 Senator Schiff. I'm interested in whether you participated 
in the willful violation of court orders as alleged in this 
complaint.
 Mr. Bove. Absolutely not.
 Senator Schiff. Let me ask you this, Mr. Bove. If there are 
notes of that meeting, will you provide them to this Committee?
 Mr. Bove. I defer to the Committee and to the executive 
branch on the procedure.
 Senator Schiff. And if the Committee requests them, will 
you provide those notes to the Committee?
 Mr. Bove. I defer to the executive branch on the handling 
of that request.
 Senator Schiff. And let me ask you about notes from another 
meeting, which you're contesting here, and that is the meeting 
over the decision to dismiss the case in New York, the 
corruption case against the Mayor of New York.
 According to Ms. Sassoon, the U.S. Attorney at the time 
during the meeting with Adam's attorneys, where she described 
Adam's attorneys repeatedly urging what amounted to a quid pro 
quo, that you admonished one of the lawyers in the room to stop 
taking notes. Is that true?
 Mr. Bove. I don't believe I instructed that attorney to 
stop taking notes. I did remark on the fact that he was taking 
extensive notes. Yes.
 Senator Schiff. And why did it concern you that he was 
taking notes of that meeting?
 Mr. Bove. Because at that point in the meeting we were 
discussing who was responsible for media leaks. And I was 
making the point that only the prosecutors had created an 
extensive record that could support detailed leaks.
 Senator Schiff. And you were concerned, were you, that 
information about this potential quid pro quo might become 
public. Was that the concern?
 Mr. Bove. I've explained that there was no quid pro quo.
 Senator Schiff. Will you provide the notes of that meeting 
which you, according to the U.S. attorney, instructed be 
collected at the end of the meeting?
 Mr. Bove. I think a member of my staff may have given that 
instruction outside my presence, and I defer to the Committee 
and the executive branch on records requests and how they 
should be handled.
 Senator Schiff. Well, I would request that we seek these 
records, which go to the truthfulness or lack of truthfulness 
of this witness. There's a reason why, if I may, my colleagues 
have gone over at least as much as this. There must be a reason 
why prosecutors quit rather than following orders from you they 
considered unethical.
 There must be a reason why prosecutors complained about you 
in your own office, why defense attorneys complained about you 
in your own office. Why the judge in the case involving the 
dismissal of the charges in New York said, ``everything here 
smacks of a bargain.''
 You testified earlier that the objective evidence 
overwhelming made it clear that it was not a bargain. There 
must be a reason why everyone disagrees with you, Mr. Bove, and 
people feel it necessary to give up a job they love at the 
Department of Justice and quit because they won't go along with 
what they consider unethical and immoral orders from you. There 
must be a reason why that is so true of so many and this court 
needs to get to the bottom of it. I yield back.
 Senator Moody. Well, as a former judge, I like being 
referred to as ``the court,''. But as the Chair, I will turn it 
over to Senator Cruz.
 Senator Cruz. Thank you, Madam Chair, and I think robes 
would look damn fine on you.
 Welcome, Mr. Bove. Congratulations on your nomination. Your 
record is exceptional prosecuting terrorists and spies and 
cyber criminals and major traffickers. You've dedicated your 
career to protecting the American people and upholding the rule 
of law. Your nomination reflects exactly what our judiciary 
needs, serious, experienced rule of law-oriented individuals 
who understand the limited role of the courts in our 
constitutional system.
 You are President Trump's second appellate court nominee in 
this second term. You and Ms. Hermandorfer, President Trump's 
first appellate nominee, share the distinction of being tapped 
to fill appellate seats that remained vacant, not because of 
delay or inaction, but because President Biden's nominees were 
simply too extreme for the Senate to confirm them.
 In your case, the seat had previously been offered to Adeel 
Manji, a nominee whose radical affiliations made clear that he 
was unfit for the Federal bench. Manji was tied to a law center 
that hosted terrorists, that promoted anti-Semitic rhetoric and 
that attacked, repeatedly, law enforcement. When given the 
opportunity to repudiate those views, he declined. His 
nomination failed, and rightly so.
 Now, rather than own that failure, Democrats are reaching 
for innuendo, rumor, and political theater. They're trying to 
paint mainstream Trump nominees as ``controversial'' to 
distract from the fact that their own nominees were so out of 
step with basic standards of judicial temperament and 
constitutional fidelity.
 The contrast is obvious. President Trump is restoring 
normalcy to the judiciary, nominating judges who will apply the 
law, who will respect the constitution, who understand that 
justice is not a tool for activism. That's especially true and 
important at the appellate level. Circuit judges serve as a 
critical check on activist district judges who seek to override 
national policy and impose their own ideological will. They 
also stand as a safeguard against prosecutors who are willing 
to politicize justice.
 I will say I find myself amused listening to my Democrat 
colleagues as they clutch their pearls in utter horror that the 
Department of Justice is deporting violent, criminal, illegal 
aliens. ``Oh, my goodness. Murderers, rapists, child molesters, 
Venezuelan gang members. How dare you remove them from 
America.''
 Don't you know that wife-beating gang members are 
appropriate to have daiquiris with in El Salvador? Don't you 
know that America hating antisemites you should dance in 
celebration with, come back to our campuses and terrorize our 
Jewish students? That's what the Democrats on this Committee 
stand for. More criminals, more murderers, more rapists, more 
child molesters, and more Venezuelan gang members.
 Democrats on this Committee got up on their high horse that 
the MS-13 gang member deported El Salvador must come back to 
America. Well, you know what he did. And he is being prosecuted 
for human trafficking. I've read every word of the indictment; 
10 years of human trafficking with MS-13. This is the poster 
child for who the Democrats want more of in the United States 
of America.
 And somehow, you're the villain because you are a real 
prosecutor, willing to enforce the law and remove dangerous 
criminals from being in a position to threaten American 
citizens. Let me say on behalf of 31 million people in Texas; 
thank you. Thank you for answering the call. Thank you for 
stepping forward and fighting to keep American citizens safe.
 Let me ask you, in your view, if you're confirmed as a 
judge, what is the importance of the Constitution and what is 
the importance of the rule of law?
 Mr. Bove. Singularly important, the Constitution defines 
the mechanism for the entire republic. Adherence to it could 
not be more important. Article III and its restraints would 
guide me in the exercise of judicial power. And I would do 
everything that I could to enforce the Constitution faithfully 
based on the rule of law.
 Senator Cruz. So, I commend you for that answer. I also 
commend you for knowing what Article III is. I'll point out 
that President Biden nominated to be an Article III judge, an 
individual who did not know what Article V of the Constitution 
was, and stunningly, did not know what Article II was either.
 I will say in the annals of unqualified judicial nominees, 
the Biden administration managed to take the gold, and it is 
refreshing to have someone who is actually qualified nominated 
to the court. Thank you.
 Senator Schiff. Madam Chair, before we recess----
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Cruz.
 Senator Schiff [continuing]. May I make a Parliamentary 
inquiry?
 Senator Cruz. Go ahead, sir.
 Senator Schiff. Thank you, Madam Chair. I've requested the 
notes from two pivotal meetings that go to the heart of the 
nominee's credibility, the meeting over the decision to drop 
charges against the mayor of New York, and the meeting in which 
the whistleblower alleges that the nominee suggested ignoring 
court orders and telling the courts essentially, ``Fuck you.''
 The witness has said that the decision whether to turn over 
those notes will determine or depend I guess on whether there's 
an assertion of privilege of some kind, and we have the great 
good fortune at this moment to have the Attorney General and 
the Deputy Attorney General here with us today. We can resolve 
this right now.
 I would ask through the Chair whether the Attorney General 
and the Deputy Attorney General will approve the provision of 
these notes to the Committee. They could be provided to the 
Chair and the Ranking Member on camera if necessary, so that 
the question that Senator Kennedy asked about whether there was 
some illicit bargain, and that my colleagues have asked can be 
resolved. If there are detailed notes of these meetings, it 
will give us an answer to who's telling the truth here.
 So, I would ask the question through the Chair of the 
witness. Given we have the Attorney General and Deputy Attorney 
General here, will the Attorney General and Deputy Attorney 
General make these notes available to the Committee so we can 
determine who's telling the truth here?
 Senator Moody [off mic]. For the record, and certainly, any 
request for information can be submitted to this Committee and 
they will ask for those. Thank you so much.
 Senator Blumenthal. Madam Chair.
 Senator Moody. We're also going to turn it over to Ranking 
Member Durbin who had some letters I believe he wanted to 
introduce for the record.
 Senator Durbin. Well, I'd like to join Senator Schiff in 
his request. I think that if these notes exist, they would 
answer the questions which the witness was unable to answer. 
And I think that would be a lot of clarity in that situation.
 Senator Moody. Well, that would be noted, Ranking Member, 
and we will add you to that request, and you may submit those 
through the notes. Did you have additional documents?
 Senator Durbin. I do.
 Senator Moody. To introduce for the record?
 Senator Durbin. I ask consent that a letter from Senator 
Kim of New Jersey be entered into the record.
 Senator Moody. Without objection.
 Senator Durbin. I ask consent that a letter from the Rule 
of Law Institute, a group of conservative lawyers opposing this 
nomination be also entered into the record.
 Senator Moody. Without objection. Senator Blumenthal.
 [The information appears as submissions for the record.]
 Senator Blumenthal. Yes, Madam Chair. I'd like to enter 
into the record--I believe that Senator Grassley may already 
have included it, but page 23 of the record of this nominee's 
appearance before Judge Ho which relates to his stating, and 
I'm quoting, ``in an exercise of prosecutorial discretion, is, 
I think, as your Honor alluded to earlier, virtually 
unreviewable in this courtroom, especially where guided by an 
Executive order and direct guidance from the Attorney 
General,'' referring to dismissal of criminal charges.
 He said that he never said it. And in addition to asking 
that this being included in the record, I'd also like to ask 
for another round of questioning.
 Senator Moody. We're not going to proceed to another round. 
Is there any objection that it be included. Without objection. 
It'll be included for the record. And if you have additional 
questions, please submit them to the Committee and we'll make 
sure they're forwarded on.
 [The information appears as a submission for the record.]
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you.
 Senator Moody. Thank you. All right. This concludes panel 
1----
 Senator Booker. May I submit some things for the record, 
please? I was beaten.
 Senator Moody. I'm so sorry. You have additional things to 
submit for the record.
 Senator Booker. I do.
 Senator Moody. Go ahead.
 Senator Booker. Madam Chairwoman. First of all, I want to 
thank you and the Ranking Member for submitting Andy Kim's 
statement for the record. I had meant to--intended to do that, 
but given some of the aspersions that were made about Adeel 
Manji, I want to resubmit into this hearing letters from 
numerous Jewish groups as well as independent legal groups 
testifying to his character, and the honor, and again, the ill 
way in which he was treated.
 Senator Moody. Do you have those with you for submission?
 Senator Booker. I, I do have those with us for submission 
and we'll put them before the Committee.
 Senator Moody. Without objection, they'll be admitted.
 [The information appears as a submission for the record.]
 Senator Moody. All right. We will now turn to panel 2. 
Thank you for your testimony here today. Mr. Bove, thank you 
for the Attorney General, Pam Bondi, for being here today, as 
well as our Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, and all of--I 
see your colleagues from the Department of Justice and former 
colleagues that are present. We appreciate you being here and 
being a part of this process.
 And I would now ask the four district court nominees to 
please come forward and take your places at the witness table.
 [Pause.]
 Senator Moody. All right.
 [Voice heard off microphone]. You have to swear them in.
 Senator Moody. I will. All right you did that faster than I 
anticipated. Thank you for being so expedient. I will now 
administer the oath. Would you all raise your right hand please 
and answer this question.
 Do you swear that the testimony you're about to give before 
this Committee will be the truth the whole truth and nothing 
but the truth so help you God?
 All right, go ahead and have a seat. It is our normal 
process, if you desire, to introduce people that are with you, 
including your family, and then you may give your opening 
statement. We'll start with Judge Artau, and then go to Judge 
Dudek, Judge Moe, and finally to Judge Pratt.
 [Witnesses are sworn in.]
 Judge Artau, the floor is yours.
 Senator Kennedy. Madam Chair. May I ask a question?
 Senator Moody. Yes, sir.
 Senator Kennedy. I assume the introduction of guests is 
included in the time for their opening statement.
 Senator Moody. Yes. I will ask that it be.
 Senator Kennedy. Thank you.

 STATEMENT OF HON. EDWARD L. ARTAU, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED 
 STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

 Judge Artau. Thank you very much. I would like to thank 
Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and of course, acting 
Chair Moody, and all the Members of the Senate Judiciary 
Committee, as well as my home State Senators Rick Scott and 
Ashley Moody for this incredible opportunity. I also want to 
thank President Trump for the great honor of this nomination. 
Most importantly, I want to thank the Almighty God who makes 
all things possible.
 I am humbled by the President's nomination, but also proud 
that so many have traveled here today to support my nomination. 
First, I would like to introduce my ex-wife, Donna, who is here 
to support my nomination, together with our son, Christian. I'm 
very grateful to both of them for their support.
 Next, I would like to introduce a group of lawyers and 
community leaders who are here to support my nomination, 
including representatives from the Trial Lawyers Bar, the 
Defense Bar, the Hispanic Bar, and other community-based 
groups. We have here today; Bradford Cohen, Fred Cunningham, 
Jason Gonzales, Howard Weiss, Robert Harvey, Charbel Baracott, 
Gordon Deiterly, John Anthony, Braulio Rosa, and last but not 
least, Sean Dominic.
 I'd like to point out that Sean Dominic is the immediate 
past president of the American Association for justice. Not 
just the local president, but very impressively, he's the 
president of the Association for Justice throughout our Nation. 
I'm very, very honored to have such a diverse group of 
community leaders and leaders from all aspects of the Bar 
Association here to support my nomination. I also want to thank 
my law students from St. Thomas University where I teach as an 
adjunct professor, for tuning in today to watch this hearing.
 Before I conclude, I would like to say something about my 
parents who could not travel to attend today, but who are 
watching from home. They came to America with only the clothes 
on their back, to flee the tyranny of communism that had 
gripped their native Cuba in 1962.
 My father worked hard in a manufacturing job as a tool-and-
die maker. After, arriving from Cuba in pursuit of the American 
dream. But when he lost his job because the manufacturing 
sector left America, he did not give up on the American dream. 
He worked even harder in any job he could find in the hope that 
his children would experience the fruit of his hard work and 
determination.
 The American dream is part of our unique American story, 
founded on the concept expressed in our Declaration of 
Independence, that all have been created equal, endowed by our 
Creator with certain unalienable rights, among which our life, 
liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. I'm here today as a 
testament that the American dream is alive and well because 
only in America can the son of Cuban exiles who arrive with 
nothing more than the clothes on their back, have an 
opportunity to attend one of America's finest law schools at 
Georgetown University. And only in America can the son of a 
displaced tool-and-die maker have had the opportunity to serve 
the State as an appellate judge, a trial judge, and as general 
counsel of a significant agency.
 And lastly, only in America can a first-generation American 
like me be nominated to serve on the Federal judiciary and have 
an opportunity to appear before the world's greatest 
deliberative body. Thank you, Senators, for the opportunity to 
provide you with my opening remarks. I'm happy to answer any 
questions you may have.
 Senator Moody. Thank you. Judge Dudek.

 STATEMENT OF HON. KYLE CHRISTOPHER DUDEK, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS 
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

 Judge Dudek. Thank you, Senator Moody. And thank you, 
Chairman Grassley, and Ranking Member Durbin for holding this 
hearing. And thank you to Senator Scott for the warm 
introduction. I would also like to thank President Trump for 
the nomination and the opportunity to be here today. It is an 
honor to be nominated to a district court seat on the Middle 
District of Florida, which has become my adopted home.
 I'm joined today by several members of my family who I 
would like to briefly recognize. My wife, Casey, who's been my 
biggest advocate and supporter. I certainly would not be here 
without her encouragement. My parents, Bob and Cindy, who have 
both sacrificed so much to help me reach my goals. And finally, 
my brother and sister-in-law, Eric and Emily. For the sanity of 
everyone here, I've left my children at home, but I know 
they're cheering for me from there.
 Like many of the past judicial nominees you've heard from, 
I'm here only through the support of others. There are far too 
many to thank, but I did want to recognize a few who have been 
kind enough to invest their time and energy into my nomination 
today. They include Ed Sheffey, Tom Grady, Fred Poseshkin, 
Jesse Benall, and Mark Boyle.
 There is also my court family who spent countless hours 
helping me assemble materials for the hearing today. They 
include Bridget Willauer, Courtney Ward, Dylan Mayer. I cannot 
thank each of you enough for your encouragement and help.
 And finally, I'd like to thank the judges who I was lucky 
enough to clerk for early in my career. They include Judge 
Jonathan Thatcher, Judge James Cacheris, and Judge Stephen 
Agee. Each of you taught me to respect the rule of law and the 
role a judge plays in it, and I hope to continue those values 
if I am confirmed on a seat in the Middle District of Florida.
 And thank you. And with that, I look forward to your 
questions.
 Senator Moody. I said Judge Moe would be next, but we'll 
start with Judge Pratt. You can skip her if you'd like.

 STATEMENT OF HON. JORDAN EMERY PRATT, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS 
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

 Judge Pratt. Thank you, Senator. Thanks also to all of the 
Members of this Committee, including the Chairman and Ranking 
Member for holding this hearing on my nomination. It is an 
honor to be here before you. I thank President Trump for the 
honor of this nomination and this opportunity. I, too, just 
want to limit my opening remarks to thanks. There are far too 
many to mention, but I'm going to mention as many as I can in 
the short time that I'd like to spend.
 First, I want to thank God. It is through his hand, and his 
hand alone, that I can appear before this Committee today. But 
of course, I have seen his hand in my life through the work of 
others, and I have some of those people here today. First and 
foremost, I want to thank my wife Christine, whose intelligence 
and beauty are matched only by her patience and grace as she 
has endured all of the job changes and moves that we have 
experienced as a family. And we're now happy to be back in our 
home State of Florida.
 I also want to acknowledge my three children, who I'll 
share a little bit. I think that they're really relishing this 
opportunity. Like many during the Covid pandemic, we had an 
opportunity to try our hand at a bit of home schooling. Our 
civics lessons, however, I felt like were not complete until 
today. So, they are very much enjoying this field trip and 
learning a lot, and I know very excited to be here.
 I want to thank my parents, Eric and Jill, who are here 
also today, and their advice to me now as always has been to 
pursue what brings me fulfillment and what allows me to serve 
others and do the most good. That is why I'm here today. And I 
thank them for that lesson. My siblings, Josh, Jillian, and 
Hunter are all here, and I couldn't think of a better cohort to 
grow up with.
 I also want to thank Senators Moody and Scott for their 
support. I want to thank my current colleagues on the Fifth 
District Court of Appeal, including our Chief Judge, Jim 
Edwards and our soon-to-be Chief Judge Harvey Jay, who have 
been mentors for me on the court.
 And I also want to thank Attorney General Bondi and Senator 
Moody as well for the opportunity to serve as their deputy 
solicitor general during my time in Tallahassee. I think that 
was a formative experience and part of the road that has 
brought me here.
 And then finally, I want to thank the judges for whom I had 
the blessing to clerk. I clerked for Judge Schlesinger, who 
sits on the Middle District of Florida and I believe that he's 
watching from home. I also clerked for now Chief Judge Jennifer 
Walker Elrod of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth 
Circuit. From both of them, I had model judicial role models 
who really exemplify I think the very best of the judicial 
calling. And I am very proud to have clerked for both of them 
and I hope that they can feel the same way about me and my 
service.
 So, thank you very much. I look forward to your questions.
 Senator Moody. Thank you. And finally, Judge Moe.

 STATEMENT OF HON. ANNE-LEIGH GAYLORD MOE, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS 
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

 Judge Moe. Thank you, Chair Moody, and Ranking Member 
Durbin, the Members of this Committee. I want to begin by of 
course thanking President Trump for the tremendous honor of 
this nomination, and for the trust and confidence he's placed 
in me. I want to thank Senator Scott, and again, Senator Moody, 
for your support. It means the world to me as your former 
colleague on the 13th Circuit for a very brief period of time, 
to have your support today.
 I want to thank my husband, Ben. If you could understand 
the extent to which my husband does real, serious, stressful, 
difficult work, and yet he still finds time on a day like today 
to have flown across the country to pick up our boys from 
summer camp, flown through the night to bring them here, to 
make sure that they're dressed, their hair is combed and their 
behavior is good during this hearing.
 There are few men in the world who are like my husband, and 
I think that I would be terribly remiss if I did not begin by 
emphasizing the great respect that I have for him as a man. I 
also want to thank my boys. They've done a great job here 
today. They've gotten to see some interesting things. I'm proud 
of them as I always am and as their father always is as well.
 I want to thank my mom and dad. My mom and dad would be 
here for any reason if I ask them to. There is nothing that 
I've ever done that was of any significance at all to me that 
they have ever missed. And it's no surprise to me that they're 
here because they don't miss anything that matters to my 
brother and I. I want to thank them for their love and their 
support, their counsel, and their guidance throughout all my 
life, and I am very grateful to have their support here today.
 My older brother, Blake, is watching with his children in 
Tampa from their law firm, along with their law partners. His 
support and encouragement has always been a tremendous blessing 
in my life. I'm very proud of him as well. My mother and 
father-in-law, Tim and Carrie Moe, are watching online. I love 
them very much. I'm so incredibly blessed to have married into 
their family and to have their support throughout the years.
 I want to thank the person who I trace much of what we're 
here today back to, and that is Judge Virginia Covington. She's 
traveled to be here to support me today. Judge Covington took a 
chance on me right out of law school. I'll never forget it. 
I'll be forever grateful for the opportunity she gave me, 
number one, but also the chance that I had to watch someone who 
takes this job so seriously, and who works so hard, and applies 
herself to the rule of law so faithfully. To have learned from 
her for the first 2 years of my career is tremendous.
 I also want to thank former Justice Bell. I interned for 
him in law school, also Judge Jeffrey Hotham of the Maricopa 
County Superior Court. Both of them were also excellent 
examples early in my life of what a good judge does and how 
they behave.
 I want to thank my aunt, Peggy, who traveled here from 
Texas to be here today. I also want to thank my friend, Kelly, 
who's joined us today. I have many family and friends who are 
watching online and supporting me through distance, but I just 
want them all to know how much I appreciate them, and my 
failure to name all of them individually can only be explained 
by the fact that I can't take up the entire hour.
 I want to thank my colleagues on the Second District Court 
of Appeal, my former colleagues on the 13th Circuit, and my 
former law partners at Bush Ross, as well as my judicial 
assistant, Julie Forgus and my law clerks Tyler and Dean.
 I thank you all for your time.
 Senator Moody. Thank you so much. And I'm going to go ahead 
and defer to Senator Kennedy to kick us off.
 Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Madam Chair. Judge Dudek, did I 
say that name right?
 Judge Dudek. That's correct, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. All right. What's the warrant requirement?
 Judge Dudek. Well, before the court would issue a warrant, 
you have to assess to make sure that there's probable cause to 
either search the place----
 Senator Kennedy. When's the warrant required?
 Judge Dudek. Excuse me?
 Senator Kennedy. When is a warrant required?
 Judge Dudek. The general rule is a warrant is required 
anytime that the Government wants to search a person, place or 
thing.
 Senator Kennedy. Could you speak into the mic?
 Judge Dudek. Oh, I'm sorry, Senator. Yes, I said the 
backdrop or backdrop rule is that a warrant is required anytime 
the Government wants to search a person, place or a thing.
 Senator Kennedy. And to arrest you. Right?
 Judge Dudek. There are some exceptions to that, but 
generally, yes.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. And there are exceptions to the 
warrant requirement for searching and arresting people. Are 
there not?
 Judge Dudek. Yes, Senator there are.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. Suppose the Florida Supreme Court 
ruled that here in Florida, we're not going to recognize any 
exceptions to the warrant requirement. You have to have a 
warrant to search someone. And you have to have a warrant to 
arrest someone, no exceptions. Can the Florida Supreme Court do 
that?
 Judge Dudek. Well Senator, under the Supremacy Clause, they 
be bound by what the Fourth Amendment dictates. Of course, 
they're free to make their own requirements as it----
 Senator Kennedy. What if the Florida Supreme Court did it 
under the Florida Constitution and not the Federal 
Constitution?
 Judge Dudek. Well, they would still, Senator, have to apply 
with what the Federal Constitution said under the Supremacy 
Clause.
 Senator Kennedy. No, they wouldn't. Do you know what 
adequate and independent State grounds means?
 Judge Dudek. Sure, of course I would understand that they 
could have independent and adequate State grounds for State 
law, but they----
 Senator Kennedy. No, they don't. As long as you don't take 
away rights but add to them a State can do whatever it wants to 
under State constitution. Can't it?
 Judge Dudek. Yes, sir. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. That's not what you just said. You think 
the Supremacy Clause applies. The Supremacy Clause applies.
 Judge Dudek. Well----
 Senator Kennedy. You want to change your answer?
 Judge Dudek. Senator, I would like to change my answer to 
the extent that I agree with you that the Florida legislature 
or Florida could do exactly what you said. I meant in my 
statement is that----
 Senator Kennedy. Trust me, it can. Judge Prutt? I'm sorry, 
I can't see that far.
 Judge Pratt. It's Judge Pratt, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. Judge Pratt, I apologize. I can't see that 
far. Can a State legislature pass a law that discriminates 
against a group of people over another group of people for 
inferior treatment?
 Judge Pratt. Well, Senator, the Federal Constitution, and 
the State constitution both contain protections against various 
forms of discrimination.
 Senator Kennedy. I know that, but can a State legislature 
say we're going to treat this group of people differently than 
another group of people?
 Judge Pratt. So, I think, Senator, an example where a 
legislature could----
 Senator Kennedy. But tell me first if a State can do that.
 Judge Pratt. Yes, a State can, for example, require a 
driving age which discriminates on the basis of age to say, for 
example----
 Senator Kennedy. When can a State legislature not do that?
 Judge Pratt. When it's seeking to do so under a basis that 
is protected under the State or Federal Constitution.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay, good. Judge, tell me about the 
Privileges and Immunities Clause.
 Judge Moe. The Privileges and Immunities Clause, there's a 
Privileges and Immunities and a Privileges or Immunities 
Clause. There's one of each. One of them really----
 Senator Kennedy. Privileges and is what I'm asking you 
about.
 Judge Moe. I believe you're referring to what came through 
in one of the Reconstruction amendments, in discussing the fact 
that the Privileges and Immunities of Citizenship would be 
extended under those.
 Senator Kennedy. Well first, what article is it in?
 Judge Moe. I believe it's in the 13th Amendment.
 Senator Kennedy. No, fourth, Article IV. What does it do?
 Judge Moe. Senator, you have pinpointed a question that in 
my 9 years as a judge in my decade of private practice before 
this, my 2 years as a law clerk, my 2 years on Law Review in 
law school, including a year as editor-in-chief, didn't ever 
come up.
 Senator Kennedy. You telling me you don't know?
 Judge Moe. So, it's an interesting question.
 Senator Kennedy. Yes ma'am, I know it's interesting. That's 
why I ask it.
 Judge Moe. Yes, so----
 Senator Kennedy. But if you don't know the answer, just 
tell me. I got a lot of ground to cover here.
 Judge Moe. I would be very happy to research it and----
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. Do you know what the Privileges or 
Immunities Clause is?
 Judge Moe. With respect to--my answer would be the same on 
that.
 Senator Kennedy. You don't know. You don't know it either?
 Judge Moe. Well, with respect to the Privileges and 
Immunities of Citizenship, my recollection is that----
 Senator Kennedy. Privileges or immunities.
 Judge Moe. Yes. My recollection is that that was discussed 
in one of the Reconstruction Amendments.
 Senator Kennedy. Which one? Do you know?
 Judge Moe. I believe it was the 13th or the 14th.
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. All right, Judge, what's Title VI of 
the Civil Rights Act of 1964 do?
 Senator Moody. Which judge are you referring to?
 Senator Kennedy. Ma'am?
 Senator Moody. Which judge?
 Senator Kennedy. This judge down here on the far end----
 Senator Moody. Artau?
 Senator Kennedy. I can't see that far.
 Senator Moody. Okay. Just making sure because there's four 
judges there. Judge Artau, I'm going to let you answer that 
briefly.
 Senator Kennedy. Hey, I want to reclaim my time, Mr. 
Chairman.
 Senator Moody. You can answer that briefly.
 Senator Kennedy. Judge, what's Title VI of the Civil Rights 
Act do?
 Judge Artau. I believe that that ensures that people are 
treated equally in any places that they would be, that they 
would not be discriminated against.
 Senator Kennedy. In all cases?
 Judge Artau. I mean, refresh my recollection as to what you 
were referring to, Senator.
 Senator Kennedy. I'm referring to Title VI of the Civil 
Rights Act of 1964, which you're going to see every other 
Thursday as a Federal judge.
 Judge Artau. So, I believe that that's under the Commerce 
Clause. They wanted to make sure that there was not any 
discrimination going on with regard to race, and that was----
 Senator Kennedy. Okay. It prohibits discriminating on the 
basis of race, or color, or national origin. Under what 
circumstance? Do you know the answer?
 Judge Artau. Under any circumstances where you're providing 
services to people, and----
 Senator Kennedy. No. It's only if you're getting federal 
money. You need to brush up on that one. I'm way over my time. 
Thank you, Madam Chair.
 Senator Moody. Thank you. Senator Kennedy. Senator Durbin, 
Ranking Member.
 Senator Durbin. It's been a long time since I took a bar 
exam and I remember getting the envelope that said with good 
news that I had been accepted. And I breathed a sigh of relief 
to think I'd never have to face another test.
 Well, you've just gone through the Senator Kennedy Bar 
exam. It's been a tough one for a lot of nominees. And lucky 
for us, he doesn't ask his colleagues these questions, only the 
nominees. So, I wish you well, and I acknowledge you asked some 
tough questions, Senator.
 Mr. Pratt, just a few weeks ago, you----
 Senator Kennedy. It's only a position for life, Mr. 
Chairman.
 Senator Durbin. Understood. Mr. Pratt, a few weeks ago you 
wrote an opinion in which you held that a Florida law allowing 
minors seeking abortions without parental consent, but with 
judicial waiver, was unconstitutional. The case involved an 
appeal from the trial court's denial of a 17-year-old's 
application to obtain a judicial waiver of the parental 
notification and consent requirements for an abortion.
 Under Florida law, judicial waivers in this context have 
been permitted. However, your decision held that Florida's 
judicial waiver procedures were unconstitutional and violated 
the parents' due process right. This wasn't something you wrote 
in an op-ed piece, nor was it a case you argued zealously on 
behalf of a client. This was last month and you wrote this 
opinion as a State court judge. In commenting on your opinion, 
one lawyer said, ``Judicial override doesn't even begin to 
describe what this judge did.''
 There are also serious concerns with your decision's 
potential impact on victims of incest or abuse. So, should a 
minor who is sexually assaulted in your State be forced to give 
birth if her parents do not consent to her having an abortion?
 Judge Pratt. Senator, my opinion on behalf of our court 
expressly made clear that that was not a situation that was 
presented in the case. The case concerned a waiver request on 
the basis that the minor asserted that it would be in her best 
interest not to include her parents, not to allow her parents 
to be notified of her contemplated procedure.
 And as the opinion explains, I mean, I think, I don't want 
to go behind the face of the opinion, but I'm happy to explain 
the opinion. The opinion holds that the parents have at a 
minimum a due process right to notice and opportunity to be 
heard, and this is presumptively fit parents, have a right to 
notice and opportunity to be heard if the State seeks to 
abridge or to remove their right to be involved in the medical 
decisions of their children. So, that is the basis of the 
opinion.
 Senator Durbin. I think you went further than that. As I 
understand it, your decision held that Florida's judicial 
waiver procedures were unconstitutional and violated the 
parents' due process rights. Unconstitutional, I don't know the 
Florida constitution obviously, but your argument was that it 
was unconstitutional under State constitution or Federal?
 Judge Pratt. Senator, it wasn't my argument, but the 
reasoning of the opinion that I authored on behalf of the court 
is that the due process clause of the 14th Amendment to the 
United States Constitution requires, as with any other 
circumstance when someone's substantial rights are at issue, 
notice and opportunity to be heard.
 Essentially, an opportunity to provide an explanation to 
the court why the court should or should not take the 
contemplated action. And there is a body of precedent that the 
opinion cites regarding the fundamental requisites of the due 
process clause being notice and opportunity to be heard.
 Senator Durbin. Different States have different laws and 
certainly the judicial waiver is put in place so that when 
there's a question of parental consent, there's an option for 
the victim to petition the court for permission to apply the 
waiver. And as I understand it, you found that petition to 
apply the waiver unconstitutional. That's the way I read this.
 Let me ask each of you. We've had a recurring question here 
about the impact of a court order. How seriously should a party 
to a conflict take a court order? Judge Artau?
 Judge Artau. Very seriously.
 Senator Durbin. And do I have the right, if I'm in your 
court or any court for that matter, and a decision is reached 
to say that I just don't agree with it, I don't have to live by 
it, or am I bound by that order until I've exhausted rights of 
appeal, for example?
 Judge Artau. Well, Senator, there are stays that can be 
pursued. Of course there's appeals that may be able to be 
exhausted. You may be able to post a bond to exhaust such 
things. You may be able to move for rehearing on it. There may 
be some exceptions, but for the most part, court orders are 
court orders.
 Senator Durbin. Well, and I think you just heard, you sat 
through several hours of questioning on a potential nominee for 
the Circuit Court as to whether or not he was following the 
court order, oral or written, I'm not sure, when it came to 
launching a plane with detainees in it to another country. So, 
this is a serious question, which is going to recur frequently 
here, I'm afraid, under this administration.
 I yield at this point.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Ranking Member. Senator 
Whitehouse, do you want to go ahead and go?
 Senator Whitehouse. Sure. Thanks, Chairman. If you don't 
mind, could I start my questioning in just a moment and make a 
point of order or an observation? I didn't want to interrupt 
the questioning of Mr. Bove. The Chairman had signaled that he 
didn't want any further interruptions, but I did want to point 
out with respect to my concern that Mr. Bove was failing----
 Senator Moody. You don't have a point of order regarding 
this panel?
 Senator Whitehouse. No. The previous one.
 Senator Moody. If you would just hold that until we're 
through this, and you're more than welcome to do it at the end 
of the hearing.
 Senator Whitehouse. Do you mind if I do it now? I'm here. 
It'll just take a minute.
 Senator Moody. Go ahead and start your questioning so we 
can keep the record clean. So, go ahead and ask your questions.
 Senator Whitehouse. Mr. Pratt, is it true that you were a 
fellow at Claremont Institute Center for Constitutional 
Jurisprudence, founded and run by John Eastman?
 Judge Pratt. I was a John Marshall fellow. I believe that 
you're correct. I believe that's correct, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Are you aware of Mr. Eastman's role in 
supplying Donald Trump with the false argument that vice-
President Pence could overturn the 2020 election?
 Judge Pratt. So I don't have personal knowledge of the 
situation you're describing. I'm aware generally of news 
reports and headlines, but I would say that my knowledge is 
very limited, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Your knowledge on that is limited to 
what you've read in the public media?
 Judge Pratt. That's correct.
 Senator Whitehouse. You haven't had conversations with 
Eastman about it?
 Judge Pratt. No, I don't. I've not had a conversation.
 Senator Whitehouse. Is it true that you were a senior 
counsel at First Liberty Institute, an institute overseen by 
Kelly Shackelford?
 Judge Pratt. Yes, that's right, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Are you aware that in December 2020, 
Kelly Shackelford signed a letter urging United States Senators 
to try to overturn the 2020 election?
 Judge Pratt. So I don't recall the content precisely of 
that letter, Senator, and I'm not prepared to speak about the 
characterization of that letter. I do know that he signed a 
letter in about that timeframe concerning the general subject 
matter of the election.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you discussed that letter with Mr. 
Shackelford?
 Judge Pratt. No, I have not.
 Senator Whitehouse. Do you know Ken Klukowski, who was also 
senior counsel at First Liberty?
 Judge Pratt. I believe I have met him twice.
 Senator Whitehouse. Are you aware of his role in helping 
Jeffrey Clark draft the letter that Clark wanted the Department 
of Justice to send to States, specifically Georgia, in an 
effort to overturn the 2020 election?
 Judge Pratt. I'm not, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. And have you had any conversation in 
those two meetings with Mr. Klukowski, with him regarding that 
letter or that effort?
 Judge Pratt. I don't recall ever having a conversation with 
him about that, no.
 Senator Whitehouse. Do you know Jeffrey Clark, who wrote 
that letter?
 Judge Pratt. He worked at the Department of Justice during 
the same timeframe that I was there. I believe that I had been 
in maybe a couple of meetings where maybe his staff was present 
and I saw him in the hallway, but I don't know him well, 
Senator. No.
 Senator Whitehouse. And you did not discuss with him that 
letter?
 Judge Pratt. No, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Okay. You were a fellow at the Leonine 
Forum, which I guess is not Leonard Leo and the Number 9. It's 
as in like a lion. Do you know Leonard Leo? He's involved in 
that group.
 Judge Pratt. I have met Mr. Leo on a couple of occasions. 
It's been a while since I've seen him, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Do you agree with President Trump's 
comments that he is a sleazebag who hates America?
 Judge Pratt. Senator, I understand that you're asking me to 
comment on posts that the President has made on social media. 
As a sitting judge and as a nominee to a federal vacancy, it 
would be inappropriate for me to comment on the content of the 
President's social media feed. The canons preclude me from 
stating a position on matters of public and political 
controversy.
 Senator Whitehouse. Okay. Let's turn to experience. How 
many cases have you personally tried to verdict or final 
judgment in court before a judge or jury?
 Judge Pratt. My judiciary questionnaire should list the 
cases. I believe as lead counsel, that would be two, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever drafted a complaint?
 Judge Pratt. I have, Senator, yes.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever drafted an answer?
 Judge Pratt. Yes, I believe so. Maybe not in total, but 
certainly in part.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever conducted pretrial 
discovery?
 Judge Pratt. Depends on what you mean by conduct. I have 
been on teams that have been involved in discovery matters and 
have supervised trial teams, and I have argued in opposition to 
a motion to compel.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever conducted a voir dire?
 Judge Pratt. I have not, Senator, no.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever conducted a direct 
examination of a courtroom witness?
 Judge Pratt. So, Senator, during my time as an attorney, I 
have focused on appellate matters, issues, and appeals. The 
concentration----
 Senator Whitehouse. So, the answer would be no to that?
 Judge Pratt. I believe the answer is no, Senator.
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever conducted a cross-
examination of a courtroom witness?
 Judge Pratt. Again, Senator. It's the same answer. My 
practice did not focus on matters----
 Senator Whitehouse. Have you ever argued a motion in 
limine?
 Judge Pratt. No, Senator. I don't believe that I have. 
Again, my practice is centered on issues and appeals. I have 
practiced at every level of the State and Federal Court system. 
I've handled matters in Federal and State trial Courts, Federal 
and State Appellate Courts, and the U.S. and Florida Supreme 
Courts. Again----
 Senator Whitehouse. My time has expired.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Whitehouse. Senator 
Blumenthal.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Artau, if 
the Secretary of Defense were sued in your courtroom, as a 
district court judge, if you are confirmed, and you issued an 
order, would you expect him to obey it?
 Judge Artau. If I had jurisdiction over the matter, if I 
decided that it was----
 Senator Blumenthal. But you wouldn't issue an order if you 
didn't have jurisdiction. It's a yes or no question. Would you 
expect him to obey it?
 Judge Artau. I would expect all parties to obey my orders 
no matter who they are.
 Senator Blumenthal. Because an order is an order as you 
just said. Correct?
 Judge Artau. Yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. So, the Secretary of Defense ought to 
obey a district court order. How about you Mr. Dudek, what do 
you think, Judge Dudek?
 Judge Dudek. I would expect, as Mr. Artau said, all parties 
before me to follow my orders pending any appeal.
 Senator Blumenthal. Including the Secretary of Defense or 
any other cabinet secretary. Correct?
 Judge Dudek. Any party that appeared before me outside of a 
stay or an appeal, yes, I would expect that.
 Senator Blumenthal. Judge Pratt?
 Judge Pratt. I'd give the same answer as my friends.
 Senator Blumenthal. Judge Moe?
 Judge Moe. Same.
 Senator Blumenthal. Judge Artau, as you know, the President 
sued the Pulitzer Prize Board for defamation and conspiracy 
based on their awarding of a prize to journalists who reported 
on the Trump-Russia collusion during the 2016 election. You're 
familiar with that lawsuit. Correct?
 Judge Artau. Yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. You sat on the court that dismissed it.
 Judge Artau. I sat on a court that found jurisdiction--on a 
three-judge panel that found jurisdiction.
 Senator Blumenthal. And you wrote a concurrence where you 
took a somewhat less measured approach. You essentially 
parroted the litigant, Trump's talking points, incorrectly, 
calling the Russia story, ``now debunked allegations,'' and you 
called into question the seminal Supreme Court decision in New 
York Times v. Sullivan, a landmark case protecting free speech 
and freedom of the press.
 Given that concurrence and the false information that you 
included in it, should litigants have any expectation that you 
can be unbiased, especially if the Federal Government is 
involved as a party?
 Judge Artau. Senator, I've been a judge for 11 years. 
Nobody's ever questioned my integrity. With regard to--I know 
that what you're getting at in terms of the issue, but I had no 
communications or expectation that I was even under 
consideration by the White House when I issued that opinion, 
and I followed the canons, I followed Canon 3, which is the one 
that applies in Florida, very carefully. It requires me to take 
cases as they come.
 Senator Blumenthal. Well, let me just ask you because my 
time is limited. That court ruling was issued on February 12 of 
this year, correct?
 Judge Artau. Correct.
 Senator Blumenthal. Had you before that date ever spoken to 
Senators Moody or Scott about the possibility of being 
considered for a judicial vacancy?
 Judge Artau. I had talked a few years ago with Senator 
Scott because Senator Scott during the last administration had 
me on his list, and his general counsel is a friend of mine. 
And when I came into town in November to attend the Federal 
Society, I just basically paid him a courtesy visit like I do 
every year because he is a close friend from Palm Beach County, 
where he used to work as an assistant State attorney. I had no 
expectations of anything other than the fact that I knew 
Senator Scott had me in high regard.
 Senator Blumenthal. So, the answer is yes, you had spoken 
to Senator Scott through his staff about the possibility of a 
judicial vacancy?
 Judge Artau. For the last several years.
 Senator Blumenthal. Repeatedly you had discussed with 
Senator Scott's staff the possibility of a judicial vacancy.
 Judge Artau. I was aware that they considered me in high 
regard and that if there was an opportunity that they might 
consider me for it. I was asked if I had any interest in it, 
and I had indicated that I did. But of course, Senator Scott 
did not have a case before me and I was not communicating with 
the White House or anybody else. You know had the timing been 
differently, then I may I'd have handled it differently.
 Senator Blumenthal. Why didn't you recuse yourself from a 
case involving the President when you had spoken to Senator 
Scott's staff about the possibility of a judicial vacancy that 
would involve an appointment by the President, who was a 
litigant?
 Judge Artau. Because Canon 3(b) requires that a judge hear 
and decide matters assigned to the judge except if this 
qualification is required by 3(e), and 3(e) has only four 
different bases that could possibly apply to me. Personal bias 
or prejudice, I didn't have any personal bias or prejudice in 
the case. I did not serve as a lower court judge, and I had no 
economic interest in the subject controversy itself.
 Senator Blumenthal. You can repeat that canon 20 times, but 
the fact is that you had spoken to Senator Scott's office about 
the possibility of a judicial vacancy knowing that Senator 
Scott would hear about it, and then sat on the case.
 Let me just ask you another question----
 Judge Artau. I had done that, Senator, when Joe Biden was 
President, and that's the timing that we're talking about. I 
can't indefinitely not take cases because of the fact that I 
might have aspirations for higher office. That's not the way it 
works in terms of the canons.
 Senator Moody. And Senator Blumenthal, your time has run. 
Did you have one more quick question? Go ahead.
 Senator Blumenthal. I have one more question. Had you 
spoken to anyone else, including Senator Moody, about the 
possibility of a judicial appointment, Federal bench?
 Judge Artau. I never spoke with Senator Moody----
 Senator Blumenthal. Or anyone else?
 Judge Artau. Senator, I think I passed on--I think Senator 
Scott passed on my resume perhaps. And I indicated that I'm 
available if they have any questions, but I did not hear back 
from Senator Moody's office because Senator Moody was just 
coming into transition at the time.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you.
 Senator Moody. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Blumenthal. 
Senator Padilla.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon now 
to all of you. Appreciate your patience. Appreciate you being 
here today.
 The first couple questions I have I believe are pretty 
straightforward. So, I'm going to in the first one ask for a 
yes or no answer. It's a subject area that some of my 
colleagues have raised, but I'm going to be as direct as I can. 
The question is this, are members of the executive branch 
required to follow court orders? We'll begin with Mr. Artau.
 Judge Artau. I think, as I answered before, generally 
speaking, all parties that are subjected to a court order are 
required to follow orders. There are----
 Senator Padilla. That's a yes?
 Judge Artau. There are a few exceptions, like appeals, 
stays----
 Senator Padilla. I'll get to that in a second.
 Judge Artau. Yes.
 Senator Padilla. Let's go down please.
 Judge Dudek. Senator, outside of the exceptions that were 
mentioned, then that's a yes.
 Judge Pratt. Same answer, Senator.
 Judge Moe. My answer's the same.
 Senator Padilla. Right. And I've been hearing, well, 
there's exceptions. What is the appropriate way or options for 
a litigant to respond to a court order they think was 
incorrectly decided? And I'm talking district and circuit court 
level. What are the options if you disagree with the ruling or 
finding?
 Judge Artau. Would you like me to start, Senator?
 Senator Padilla. Yes.
 Judge Artau. To seek a stay, to seek rehearing, to seek an 
appeal, to explain why it would not be possible to perhaps put 
in some evidence to that regard a possibility.
 Senator Padilla. Not just explaining to the general public, 
right, the judicial process. Seek the stay, seek an appeal. 
There's mechanisms for registering your disagreement and 
fighting another day in court. Let's continue.
 Judge Dudek. I agree with Judge Artau's statement. Those 
exceptions are the appropriate mechanisms to----
 Senator Padilla. Thank you.
 Judge Pratt. I'll keep my answer short. Yes, there are 
various mechanisms to seek review or stay of a court order with 
which a party disagrees.
 Judge Moe. And I agree with those answers.
 Senator Padilla. Right. So, I didn't hear any of you say 
that just disregarding or dismissing court orders is an option. 
I don't want to speak for you. If anybody disagrees with that, 
my interpretation from your answers is dismissing or 
disregarding court orders is not an option. You can register 
your objection at this point. Seeing none. Thank you for that.
 So, this next question is, I'm a Member of the Senate 
Judiciary Committee and you're judicial nominees before us. But 
my motive for asking you this question is actually just at a 
basic human level. We're living at a time where the President 
of the United States has not been shy about expressing his 
disapproval of so many figures in our country.
 But Members of the Judiciary, judges and justices are not 
an exception to that. When there are cases that are found 
against his interest, against his agenda, against his favor, he 
has on multiple occasions either directly or indirectly 
criticized, some say harassed, or directly or indirectly 
suggested others, maybe his supporters, to do that, focusing 
their ire on members of the bench. This is not news to any of 
you.
 What I'd like to know is whether before you were reached 
out to for a potential nomination or subsequent to outreach to 
you for a potential nomination, did you consider this new 
dynamic in the American political environment, and did you have 
discussions with your spouses and your families about how you 
would handle it if you became the target of such criticisms 
and/or harassment or anything to that effect? Mr. Artau, and 
we'll go down the line.
 Judge Artau. I mean, this job I've always thought requires 
courage. It requires judicial courage. I think it's a quality 
that I have. As I said, I've been a judge for 11 years, and I 
have not been shy about ruling on cases that I need to rule on. 
And it comes with the territory. So, I understand that I may be 
criticized, and I'm likely to be criticized, and I was willing 
to take that risk because I love my country, and I want to 
serve my country.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you.
 Judge Dudek. Senator, I would just add to that, that I do 
believe this is a very public-facing job. That criticism is 
part of it. In litigation, in general, someone generally leaves 
unhappy with your decision and have accepted that. And I 
believe it's the responsibility of a judge to apply the law to 
the facts as they stand before you, regardless of the outcome 
that it may be. So, that's what I would do if, moving forward, 
if I was confirmed.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you.
 Judge Pratt. I agree. A judge needs to be willing if the 
law requires to issue an unpopular decision. And I think it's a 
great feature of our country that individuals have a First 
Amendment right to express their thoughts you know about 
judicial decisions. I think that my concern when I look at a 
case isn't any criticism that might come my way, it's only what 
does the law require to the case that's in front of me? And I 
think that anyone who takes the judicial oath needs to have the 
courage to do that in any case, regardless who the party is, 
regardless of what the issue is. And that's my answer, Senator.
 Judge Moe. Senator, I agree. I think this is a tough job 
and only tough people should do it. Criticism comes with the 
territory. My job is to follow the law and not concern myself 
with what someone might say and not get my feelings hurt about 
what they might say.
 Senator Padilla. Look, I appreciate your answers. Y'all 
focused on criticism, willingness to be criticized comes with 
the territory. The times we're living in is, I wish it was just 
contained to that. Not a hypothetical. There's been instances, 
multiple instances where the rhetoric is beyond just criticism. 
It does fall into the areas of harassment. Some suggest even 
threats. And I pray that none of you become victims of that, 
should you be fortunate enough to be confirmed. Thank you for 
your time.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Padilla. Senator Schiff. 
Good timing.
 Senator Schiff. Thank you. I want to followup on the line 
of questioning many of us had for Mr. Bove since you were 
present for that and ask you all the same question. Judge 
Artau, I'll start with you. Would it ever be appropriate for 
the Justice Department to take the position that they should 
effectively tell a district court to pound sand and ignore a 
court order?
 Judge Artau. Well, I just think that there are exceptions. 
As I indicated before, there's stays that can be pursued. 
There's motions for rehearing, appeals.
 Senator Schiff. Yes, that's not my question. Would it ever 
be appropriate for the Justice Department to tell the court, 
``We're going to ignore your order''?
 Judge Artau. I mean, Abraham Lincoln did that with the 
Dredd Scott case and----
 Senator Schiff. I'm hoping we're not going to go back to 
the Civil War or Dredd Scott. You seem to be having some 
hesitancy about this question. Would you have difficulty if the 
Government ignored your order in holding them in contempt?
 Judge Artau. Senator, I would not have any difficulty 
enforcing any court order that I enter. Obviously, if I enter a 
court order, I would expect it to be followed----
 Senator Schiff. Including----
 Judge Artau.[continuing]. No matter who the party is.
 Senator Schiff. Including by the Justice Department under 
the Trump administration?
 Judge Artau. Including the Government as well, yes.
 Senator Schiff. Okay. And Mr. Dudek, same question.
 Judge Dudek. I would expect the parties in a case before me 
to follow the order regardless of who they are.
 Senator Schiff. Okay. Same question.
 Judge Pratt. Yes, Senator. I, too, would expect orders to 
be followed. And of course, if I suspected that there were a 
problem or an issue with that, there is a process for 
ascertaining whether a court order has not been followed, and I 
would follow that process.
 Senator Schiff. And that process involves an order to show 
cause why they shouldn't be held in contempt. And there are 
judges holding those hearings contemporaneous with this one. 
Let's say you hold that hearing and you find that the Justice 
Department has been in willful contempt, knowing in willful 
contempt. What kind of sanctions would you entertain under 
those circumstances?
 Judge Pratt. Senator, it's hard to answer in the abstract. 
I know that there are a host of sanctions that can be entered 
on a finding of contempt. I would not hesitate to enter an 
appropriate sanction. Whatever the case would require, I'd have 
to look at the particular kind of matter, the severity and 
extent of the violation of the court order. And those would all 
be things that would be considered in such a hearing.
 But what I can say just as a general matter is I would 
expect that any lawful order that I issue with jurisdiction 
over the case and the parties should be followed, unless or 
until stayed or reversed or disturbed otherwise on appeal.
 Senator Schiff. Well, and building on that answer, Ms. 
Gaylord Moe, let's say that the contempt involved rendering 
someone out of the country to a maximum security prison in 
violation of their right to be heard, in violation of habeas 
corpus. What kind of sanction would you order if you found 
after a hearing and an order to show cause that the Government 
was willfully in contempt?
 Judge Moe. Well, Senator, I'm obviously not going to 
comment on any pending cases, and I'm not going to weigh in on 
political controversies. I can tell you that the answer to your 
question is do I expect the parties in a case that's pending in 
front of me to comply with my orders, and the answer is yes.
 Senator Schiff. And you would expect that, notwithstanding 
the fact that they may choose to appeal or choose to disagree 
with your order, in the absence of a higher court judgment that 
stays your order, you would expect and you would indeed compel 
the Government to comply. Would you not?
 Judge Moe. As a judge, I follow the law, and I expect the 
parties to do the same.
 Senator Schiff. Okay. That doesn't really answer my 
question. So, in the absence of an appeal from your order, in 
the absence of a stay of your judgment, if the Government 
refuses your order, would you hold them in contempt?
 Judge Moe. If the elements that would make contempt 
appropriate under the law were met and I held a hearing that I 
felt satisfied that at the conclusion the law compelled the 
entry of contempt sanctions, then absolutely I would do that.
 Senator Schmidt. Okay. Thank you. I yield back.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Schiff. And thank you so 
much for our nominees for being here with us today. I know 
people traveled far and wide to join you. That means they 
support you and wish all the best in your future careers.
 Certainly, it is an honor for me. I often take over this 
gavel from the Chair and serve as acting Chair. And it's such 
an honor that I got to do that today especially, as we had 
nominees from the great free State of Florida and specifically 
nominees that I know respect the rule of law and respect their, 
if they are in fact confirmed, their Article III powers are 
limited, and the public confidence in our judiciary and the 
impartiality of our judiciary is incredibly important for the 
success and stability of our great nation.
 So, thank you for being here today. Thank you for your 
testimony. Written questions for the record may be submitted 
until July 2 at 5 p.m.
 Senator Moody. The hearing is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 1:59 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 [Additional material submitted for the record follows.]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 A P P E N D I X

The following submissions are available at:

 https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61888/pdf/CHRG-119shrg
 61888-add1.pdf

Submitted by Chairman Grassley:

 A Hearing with Sanctuary City Mayors, transcript 119-11.......... 2

 United States of America, v. Eric Adams, hearing transcript...... 116

Submitted by Ranking Member Durbin:

 Kim, Hon. Andy, statement........................................ 172

 The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, letter...... 174

 The League of Conservation Voters (LCV), letter.................. 179

 National Women's Law Center (NWLC), letter....................... 180

 People For the American Way (PFAW), letter....................... 185

 Reproductive Freedom for All (RFFA), statement................... 190

 Society for the Rule of Law Institute, letter.................... 193

Submitted by Senator Whitehouse:

 Before he became Trump's No. 2 at DOJ, Emil Bove, Politico, 
 article....................................................... 197

 Cheung, Denise, statement........................................ 208

 Government Accountability Project and Gilbert Employment Law, 
 P.C., statement............................................... 211

 Sassoon, Danielle R., resignation letter......................... 246

 Senate Questions for Emil Bove, How will he explain the Adams 
 mess, as he seeks a lifetime judicial seat?, article.......... 254

Submitted by Senator Booker:

 American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists, letter....... 256

 Interfaith Sign On, letter....................................... 257

 Jewish Organizations, letter..................................... 259

 Mistreatment of Adeel Mangi (ADL), statement..................... 261

 National Council of Jewish Women (NCJW), letter.................. 263

 Questioning of Adeel Mangi (AJC), statement...................... 265

 [all]