NOMINATIONS OF HON. BRADFORD WILSON, HAL DUNCAN, BRIAN CAVANAUGH, DAVID CUMMINS, CAMERON HAMILTON, DON R. BERTHIAUME, JR., CHARLES BALDIS, JAMES WOODRUFF, JEFFREY BRODSKY, WILLIAM GALLO, AND CHARLTON ALLEN

Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Senate June 17, 2026

Witnesses (11)

  • Hal Duncan to be Deputy Director, Office of Management and Budget Biographical and professional information
  • Brian Cavanaugh to be Under Secretary for Management, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Prepared statement
  • David Cummins to be Administrator, Transportation Security Administration, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Prepared statement
  • Cameron Hamilton to be Administrator, Federal Emergency Management Agency, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Prepared statement
  • Charles Baldis to be Special Counsel, Office of Special Counsel Prepared statement
  • Hon. Bradford Wilson to be Archivist, National Archives and Records Administration Prepared statement
  • Don R. Berthiaume Jr. to be Inspector General, U.S. Department of Justice Biographical and professional information
  • Jeffrey Brodsky to be Governors, U.S. Postal Service Prepared statement
  • William Gallo to be Governors, U.S. Postal Service Prepared statement
  • James Woodruff to be Chairman, Merit Systems Protection Board Prepared statement
  • Charlton Allen to be General Counsel, Federal Labor Relations Authority Prepared statement

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- NOMINATIONS OF HON. BRADFORD WILSON, HAL DUNCAN, BRIAN CAVANAUGH, DAVID CUMMINS, CAMERON HAMILTON, DON R. BERTHIAUME, JR., CHARLES BALDIS, JAMES WOODRUFF, JEFFREY BRODSKY, WILLIAM GALLO, AND CHARLTON ALLEN

[Senate Hearing 119-474]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-474

 NOMINATIONS OF HON. BRADFORD WILSON,
 MR. DUNCAN, MR. CAVANAUGH, MR. CUMMINS,
 MR. HAMILTON, MR. BERTHIAUME, JR.,
 MR. BALDIS, MR. WOODRUFF, MR. BRODSKY, 
 MR. GALLO, AND CHARLTON ALLEN
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 COMMITTEE ON
 HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 ---------- 

 JUNE 17, 2026

 ---------- 

 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov

 Printed for the use of the
 Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs

[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-122 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
=======================================================================

 COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

 RAND PAUL, Kentucky, Chairman
RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin GARY C. PETERS, Michigan
JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma MAGGIE WOOD HASSAN, New Hampshire
RICK SCOTT, Florida RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania
BERNIE MORENO, Ohio ANDY KIM, New Jersey
JONI ERNST, Iowa RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ELISSA SLOTKIN, Michigan

 William E. Henderson III, Staff Director
 Christina N. Salazar, Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel
 Harry Kazenoff, Assistant Counsel
 David M. Weinberg, Minority Staff Director
 Christopher J. Mulkins, Minority Policy Director
 Claudine J. Brenner, Minority Deputy General Counsel
 Laura W. Kilbride, Chief Clerk
 Ashley A. Gonzalez, Records Clerk

 C O N T E N T S

 ------ 
Opening statements:
 Page
 Senator Paul................................................. 1
 Senator Peters............................................... 2
 Senator Johnson.............................................. 5
 Senator Moreno............................................... 8
 Senator Hassan............................................... 10
 Senator Scott................................................ 12
 Senator Slotkin.............................................. 15
 Senator Ernst................................................ 17
 Senator Blumenthal........................................... 18
 Senator Moody................................................ 20
 Senator Gallego.............................................. 22
 Senator Hawley............................................... 23
 Senator Kim.................................................. 25
Prepared statements:
 Senator Peters............................................... 47

 WITNESSES
 WEDNESDAY, JUNE 17, 2026

Hal Duncan to be Deputy Director, Office of Management and Budget
 Biographical and professional information.................... 51
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 69
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 72
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 84
Brian Cavanaugh to be Under Secretary for Management, U.S. 
 Department of Homeland Security
 Prepared statement........................................... 134
 Biographical and professional information.................... 136
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 154
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 157
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 170
David Cummins to be Administrator, Transportation Security 
 Administration, U.S. Department of Homeland Security
 Prepared statement........................................... 180
 Biographical and professional information.................... 181
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 198
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 206
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 217
Cameron Hamilton to be Administrator, Federal Emergency 
 Management Agency, U.S. Department of Homeland Security
 Prepared statement........................................... 226
 Biographical and professional information.................... 228
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 245
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 249
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 260
 Letters of support........................................... 284
Charles Baldis to be Special Counsel, Office of Special Counsel
 Prepared statement........................................... 287
 Biographical and professional information.................... 291
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 310
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 312
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 326
Hon. Bradford Wilson to be Archivist, National Archives and 
 Records 
 Administration
 Prepared statement........................................... 339
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 341
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 470
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 474
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 488
Don R. Berthiaume Jr. to be Inspector General, U.S. Department of 
 Justice
 Biographical and professional information.................... 498
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 516
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 519
Jeffrey Brodsky to be Governors, U.S. Postal Service
 Prepared statement........................................... 532
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 534
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 562
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 570
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 590
William Gallo to be Governors, U.S. Postal Service
 Prepared statement........................................... 614
 Biographical and professional information.................... 616
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 632
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 639
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 654
James Woodruff to be Chairman, Merit Systems Protection Board
 Prepared statement........................................... 679
 Biographical and professional information.................... 681
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 701
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 704
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 719
Charlton Allen to be General Counsel, Federal Labor Relations 
 Authority
 Prepared statement........................................... 734
 Biographical and professional information.................... 736
 Letter from U.S. Office of Government Ethics................. 755
 Responses to pre-hearing questions........................... 760
 Responses to post-hearing questions.......................... 776

 APPENDIX

Chart submitted by Senator Peters................................ 805
Charts submitted by Senator Hawley............................... 806
Chart submitted by Senator Gallego............................... 809

 
 NOMINATIONS OF HON. BRADFORD WILSON,
 HAL DUNCAN, BRIAN CAVANAUGH,
 DAVID CUMMINS, CAMERON HAMILTON,
 DON R. BERTHIAUME, JR.,
 CHARLES BALDIS, JAMES WOODRUFF,
 JEFFREY BRODSKY, WILLIAM GALLO, AND
 CHARLTON ALLEN

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, JUNE 17, 2026

 U.S. Senate, 
 Committee on Homeland Security 
 and Governmental Affairs,
 Washington, DC.
 The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:02 a.m., in 
room 324, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Rand Paul, Chair 
of the Committee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Paul [presiding], Johnson, Scott, Hawley, 
Moreno, Ernst, Moody, Peters, Hassan, Blumenthal, Kim, Gallego, 
and Slotkin.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PAUL

 Chairman Paul. The hearing will come to order.
 Today the Committee meets to consider 11 nominations. We 
will begin today with our first panel of nominees. Hal Duncan 
to be the Deputy Director of the Office of Management and 
Budget (OMB), Brian Cavanaugh to be the Undersecretary of 
Management at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), David 
Cummins to be the Administrator of the Transportation Security 
Administration (TSA), Cameron Hamilton to be the Administrator 
for the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), and Charles 
Baldis to be the Special Counsel to the Office of Special 
Counsel (OSC).
 The witnesses' written statements have been submitted for 
the record and I ask unanimous consent (UC) to submit letters 
of support received for the nominees.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The letters of support appear in the Appendix on page 284.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 In the interest of time, I will forego any opening remarks. 
Senator Peters.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PETERS\1\

 Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome to the 
nominees and certainly thank you for your willingness to serve 
and congratulations on your nominations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The prepared statement of Senator Peters appears in the 
Appendix on page 47.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 We have a record setting 11 nominees before the Committee 
today, each for roles that impact people as well as communities 
across our Nation. I am very disappointed with this process 
that has been unnecessarily rushed. An overcrowded lineup today 
severely limits our ability to have transparency for the 
American public.
 Members of this Committee should have the opportunity to 
hear from and thoroughly question each nominee in front of the 
American people. The Chairman is not even bothering to let the 
nominees make public opening statements and Members of the 
Committee have not received their written testimony. Even more 
troubling, the Chairman has disregarded this Committee's long-
standing basic requirement for nominees appearing before us.
 Two of the nominees, Mr. Brodsky and Mr. Baldis, have not 
completed financial disclosures and ethics agreements certified 
by the Office of Government Ethics (OGE). Two nominees, Mr. 
Baldis and Mr. Hamilton, have not completed the Federal Bureau 
of Investigation (FBI) background investigations, always the 
minimum requirement for this Committee. The FBI review can 
provide a more complete picture of the nominee's background and 
integrity, and the ethics review certification process is 
essential for providing transparency into nominee's financial 
interest as well as potential conflicts of interest.
 This is even more critical when nominees, like some here 
today, have significant financial holdings. To my knowledge, it 
is completely unprecedented for this Committee to proceed to a 
hearing before these very fundamental vetting steps are 
complete. It has always been that way, always should be that 
way and the American people expect it to be that way. I 
recognize that timing is out of the nominees' control. However, 
it does a disservice to these nominees as well as to Members of 
each and every one of this Committee.
 Unfortunately, it seems like these nominees are being 
treated as basically just a box checking exercise rather than a 
core constitutional duty. I take our responsibility to 
thoroughly evaluate each nominee's qualifications seriously. I 
have supported and opposed nominees based on what I have 
learned through this Committee process. I know that my 
Committee colleagues on both sides of the aisle also want to 
thoroughly consider each nominee before us.
 But when the process is this haphazard and rushed, it 
certainly looks like this Committee's Republican majority is 
simply rubber stamping the President. The Constitution is very 
clear of our oversight responsibilities of the Congress and 
it's very clear that this checks and balances system doesn't 
work if the Congress simply is a rubber stamp for the 
President. That's what we are seeing here today. Somebody who's 
shirking basic constitutional responsibilities. People who 
claim that they protect the Constitution and yet they will 
watch it get trampled here today.
 Today we are considering nominees for 10 different 
agencies, any one of which could warrant its own hearing. 
Hearings from nominees is even more critical as this Committee 
has been ignoring its obligation to conduct public oversight of 
administration officials after they are confirmed. Since the 
start of this Congress, we have had only two oversight hearings 
where administration officials appeared as witnesses. We have 
abandoned, abandoned our duty to conduct oversight of our 
homeland security apparatus by skipping annual hearings that 
were conducted by this Committee for decades, including the 
annual threats hearing or hearing on the DHS budget request.
 We are considering two nominees to the Postal Service Board 
of Governors today and I hope to hear detailed explanations of 
how they plan to uphold the Postal Service's independence and 
public service mission if confirmed. I am also concerned that 
the President has failed to consult with the Senate minority 
and nominate any Democratic members of the board. Instead, he 
has nominated four members of one party. The board is 
designated by statute to be bipartisan in nature and lopsided 
political representation undermines public confidence in the 
board's ability to serve the public above, above partisan 
views.
 We are also considering nominees for several agencies that 
Congress has charged with providing independent oversight of 
the Executive Branch. The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) 
and the Office of Special Counsel are both critical to 
protecting whistleblowers and ensuring the Federal workforce is 
free from political coercion. The Federal Labor Relations 
Authority (FLRA) ensures Federal workers collective bargaining 
rights are upheld.
 The Department of Justice (DOJ) Inspector General (IG) 
leads efforts to combat waste, fraud, and abuse across the 
Department of Justice. As this administration continues to 
attack and dismantle independent oversight bodies and erode 
protections for non-partisan public servants, it's more 
important than ever that we have principled independent leaders 
in these critical roles.
 Similarly, this administration has resisted and undermined 
all forms of transparency and accountability, taking 
unprecedented steps to keep information and records hidden from 
Congress and the American public. Even more troubling are 
actions to rewrite history through a partisan political lens. 
The National Archives protects our national records and ensures 
that the American people have a complete and an accurate 
account of our shared history as the American people. I hope to 
hear an unwavering commitment of transparency in leading the 
National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) in a 
nonpartisan manner from Professor Wilson.
 Mr. Duncan, the Office of Management and Budget has been at 
the center of many of these administrative-wide efforts to 
evade transparency, oversight, and accountability. Throughout 
the nomination process, you have emphasized your view that 
OMB's chief purpose is to serve the President and his agenda. 
Since returning to office, this President has made clear that 
he does not respect Congress's congressional role as a co-equal 
branch of government. So far, many of my colleagues are OK with 
that. They don't believe they are a co-equal branch of 
government. They believe that they are a rubber stamp. I get 
that.
 But flaunting spending laws, ignoring oversight, and 
manipulating all aspects of government for personal and 
political gain. Today you will have an opportunity to explain 
your involvement and views on OMB's actions. To the nominees to 
serve at the Department of Homeland Security, including FEMA 
and TSA, unfortunately, because of the way this Chairman has 
stacked this hearing and made transparency and accountable next 
to impossible, I may not have time to ask questions of each and 
every one of you today. But I would like to thank you all for 
your engagement through this process. I appreciate that each of 
you have expressed a willingness to examine and reevaluate some 
of the decisions made by the department's prior leadership.
 Mr. Cavanaugh, I particularly appreciated your commitment 
to reviewing the severe staffing cuts at DHS Office of Civil 
Rights and Civil Liberties (CRCL) and ensuring the office can 
effectively carry out responsibilities that Congress signed 
into law. Thank you again for all of you being here today. I 
look forward to hearing more about your nominations.
 Chairman Paul. Comments are well received and listened to. 
But it is a fact that we will only vote on these nominees after 
all of their ethics reports are complete, after all of their 
FBI backgrounds are complete. I would say the comments are 
rather rich coming from people who shut down United States 
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and U.S. Border 
Patrol (USBP) and wouldn't fund $1 for it. We can have 
different opinions here, but I would certainly think that it's 
irresponsible to have no border security and not to pay them.
 It's the practice of the Homeland Security and Governmental 
Affairs Committee (HSGAC) to swear in witnesses. Will the 
nominees please stand and raise your right hand? Do you swear 
that the testimony you will give before this Committee will be 
the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help 
you, God?
 [Witnesses answer in the affirmative.]
 It's a standard practice of this Committee for the Chairman 
to ask the nominees the following question: Do you agree 
without reservation to comply with any request or summons to 
appear and testify before any duly constituted committee of 
Congress, if you are confirmed? Let's do it one at a time. Mr. 
Duncan, do you agree to that?
 Mr. Duncan. Yes, subject to the advice of counsel.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Cavanaugh.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. Yes, subject to the advice of counsel.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Cummins.
 Mr. Cummins. Yes, subject to advice of counsel.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Hamilton.
 Mr. Hamilton. Yes, subject to the advice of counsel.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Baldis.
 Mr. Baldis. Yes, subject to the advice of counsel.
 Chairman Paul. We will now proceed to questions where each 
Member will be given five minutes. I will reserve my time and 
at this time recognize Senator Johnson.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR JOHNSON

 Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Duncan, we heard your hearing yesterday in the Budget 
Committee and I just thought is rich the right word--certainly 
hypocritical, of the comments from the other side, questioning 
how grant money might be apportioned to, oh, I don't know, 
things that President Trump actually ran on, his causes. Like 
President Biden, President Obama didn't do the exact same 
thing.
 I know they made a big to do about changes in the Code of 
Federal Registers (CFR), something that you Are really 
concentrating on to eliminate the waste and fraud that we have 
been seeing. The stats I used yesterday was at a minimum $250 
billion per year, in the Government Accountability Office (GAO) 
up to a trillion dollars according to LexisNexis. It's 
impossible to prosecute that and recover those funds. You have 
to prevent them from going out to the front end.
 Can you first of all just address the accusations of 
partisan allocation of grant money? Elections matter and 
obviously you are going to provide grant money to the issues 
that duly elected President are going to want to support. But 
then also just talk about what we need to do to rein in fraud 
and prevent money ever going out the door.
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, I certainly appreciate the question 
and I would note as it relates to the adherence to 
administrations and the disbursement of grant money, I was kind 
of struck by some of the comments because during the 
rescissions process, there were folks that were saying, hey, 
don't rescind this money, just spend it on things that the 
administration agrees with. It might have been spent on things 
that you didn't agree with in the past, why don't you just 
spend it on administration priorities now? I thought that was 
something that struck me during that process.
 But as it relates to 2 CFR part 200 and the updates, it's 
fundamentally about getting our arms around the grant 
enterprise which is at a trillion dollars a year, ensuring that 
we have accountability. As it relates to the fraud aspects of 
it, we want to mandate the use of the Do Not Pay system. If you 
are on a list that is an individual that is not able to receive 
Federal financial assistance, we require the agencies to check 
that list. If you are someone that is on the death master file 
(DMF) or something like that, we want to ensure that we are 
stopping that on the front end. Because to your point, if we 
don't stop fraud on the front end, it becomes much more 
difficult on the back end.
 We also want to ensure that these grants aren't going out 
in a way that advances divisive Diversity, Equity, and 
Inclusion (DEI) ideologies, woke gender ideologies, illegal 
immigration as we saw in the past administration and want to 
ensure that there are additional steps to ensure accountability 
so the folks that the President appoints and puts in power when 
he is elected by the American people, are able to review grant 
issuance decisions.
 Senator Johnson. The example I used yesterday was Dr. Oz, 
apparently through information systems--again we are trying to 
set up an artificial intelligence (AI) system in OMB to scan 
the data to look for potential fraud. But he identified that a 
third of all hospice centers in America are located in Los 
Angeles. That is just an astonishing fact. Which of course as 
an auditor you start drilling into that going how can this be 
possible?
 Apparently through those investigations they determined 
that they were not going to fund 400 of these hospice centers. 
They cutoff funding. I would kind of like you to describe that 
process. But having cutoff funding, not one of the 400 centers 
complained. Which speaks volumes, right? I mean if you were a 
legitimate hospice center, you would be relying on that funding 
and you'd be screaming bloody murder, saying we need that fund. 
Not one of 400.
 So it just gives you a sense of just the pervasiveness or 
fraud within so many of these programs. But just talk about the 
process of what we have to do to prevent money going out.
 Mr. Duncan. Thank you, Senator. In order to prevent money 
from going out, you need to make sure you have the data to 
understand who these funds should be going to. In a lot of 
cases we aren't provided with that data and we have limited 
decisionmaking space. We also need to ensure that, like I said, 
files like the Do Not Pay system are being checked, that we 
have endpoint verification. In many instances when something 
goes to the States and is block Granted to the States, that's 
kind of the end of the line for Federal Government oversight. 
At that point, the States are the ones that are distributing 
the money.
 To your point, it's become incredibly difficult to get it 
on the back end. The Fraud Task Force and the work that it's 
doing has been kind of twofold in the sense that they are 
trying to stand up and ensure that agencies are using tools 
that are on the books. When we need additional tools, let's ask 
Congress for those to stop money from going out to fraudulent 
payments on the front end, but also trying to attack the fraud 
on the back end.
 Senator Johnson. So just real quickly, can you also talk 
about the resistance this administration is getting from 
Governors of States that refuse to provide the information that 
you need to prevent the fraud?
 Mr. Duncan. Absolutely, Senator. We have seen this in the 
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), particularly 
States--some States have been more than willing to provide 
their SNAP data to the administration so we can verify 
compliance with the program's terms. Others have not. Others 
have filed lawsuits against us. That is a microcosm of a 
problem that exists across the board. That's certainly a place 
where we need additional tools from Congress to be able to 
ensure compliance and ensure the Federal taxpayer dollars are 
being spent wisely and in a manner that's fiscally responsible.
 Senator Johnson. Appreciate your efforts. Thanks.
 Chairman Paul. I think this brings up a point that is 
probably, we talk about oversight, maybe one of the most 
important points we will get to. We have lots and lots of 
programs where the States sign people up for it and the Federal 
Government pays for it. There's no oversight because then the 
States resist the oversight. But we are letting the State sign 
people up so everybody and their brother might be signed up for 
food stamps, able bodied people, people working people, not 
eligible.
 But we can't review it because California will resist or 
New York will resist. This is probably the biggest oversight 
problem we face in all of the payment programs we have in our 
country. Senator Peters.
 Senator Peters. Mr. Hamilton, under President Trump's 
second administration, nearly 90 percent of Republican States' 
disaster assistance requests have been approved. That compares 
to only 23 percent of Democratic States' requests since the 
establishment of FEMA, no, and let me highlight--no other 
president has created such a disparity in States that receive 
Federal disaster aid. Denying over 75 percent of requests from 
States that are led by representatives of another party is 
unconscionable.
 We have a chart\1\ here. I'll just show you the chart here, 
which is pretty stark data. Pretty stark data from Trump. Stand 
up please. High Republican States, boom, a collapse in 
Democratic States. Given this stark data, what other 
conclusions can one draw other than the President is using 
Federal disaster assistance to punish States that elect 
Democrats?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The chart referenced by Senator Peters appears in the Appendix 
on page 805.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 My question for you, sir, is does a disaster survivor in a 
blue State deserve less support than a survivor in a red State?
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, thank you for your question. What I 
can tell you is I care deeply for survivors and I believe the 
President does as well. I believe all survivors who have faced 
high consequence events deserve the proper care, support, and 
resources of the U.S. Government brought to bear.
 Senator Peters. How do you explain this discrepancy here?
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, I certainly appreciate your concern. 
What I can tell you is that if confirmed, my focus will be to 
ensure that FEMA is objective, is fair and reasonable, follows 
the law, and is consistent in the approach to be--how we 
adjudicate and process claims and requests for disasters.
 Senator Peters. I am going to cut back to that. I would 
just want to say, and I seem to recall my colleagues on the 
other side of the aisle here were absolutely incensed by 
several instances during President Biden's tenure where FEMA 
representatives skipped houses with Trump signs. I called that 
out as well. I thought that was unaccountable. I am on the 
record condemning that. My Republican colleagues are condemning 
that.
 Now that the Federal Government is deciding not to skip a 
few homes but entire States, I would hope my colleagues would 
join me with that outrage that they had when a few houses were 
skipped. I hope that comes. I hope we hear that today. But it's 
concerning to your point about doing something different, which 
I hope that's the case.
 But you were involved in this process for five months last 
year and are now back at DHS now, but you still can't answer 
questions about what happened while you were there, why this 
huge cliff of Democratic States being denied disaster 
assistance, survivors being denied disaster assistance. I am 
not satisfied with that answer. I don't trust that that's what 
you are going to do because it didn't seem like you did it when 
you were there before or were not involved in it or don't now 
talk about it. I certainly hope that we get further 
explanations of how you are going to go forward. Certainly Mr. 
Duncan as well, I will be asking for information regarding this 
written.
 Senator Peters. Mr. Duncan, as we discussed yesterday, OMB 
is refusing to cooperate with at least 14 GAO audits, including 
10 audits required by law, you are ignoring them--and four 
audits that I requested as the Ranking Member of HSGAC. As I 
hope you know, GAO is Congress's independent, nonpartisan 
watchdog. Now, I know that drives this administration crazy to 
have a watchdog, especially if they are independent. They are 
used to people standing around them, just rubber stamping 
whatever they do.
 But these are independent watchdogs and their work has 
literally saved billions in taxpayer money from fraud, from 
abuse, and you're ignoring those. OMB is ignoring them. Will 
you commit without reservation to full cooperation with every 
GAO audit?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, I appreciate the question and I 
appreciated the opportunity to meet with you and your team 
yesterday. We have received that list of audits that your team 
flagged for us last night. I sent it to our team this morning 
first thing and asked them to review. We are going to have a 
conversation about those specific audits right after this 
hearing.
 As it relates to inquiries we get from GAO, I would note 
that GAO has seven times the number of employees that OMB does. 
At one point, we had 50 open inquiries from GAO mid last year. 
We try to respond to GAO inquiries in a responsible time while 
still maintaining our ability to carry out our duties in 
support of the administration. I certainly commit to being 
apprised of every GAO request and discussing next steps with 
counsel and understand the importance of the responses to the 
audits that you flagged for me yesterday and the responses 
there as well.
 Senator Peters. I hope you will be. I appreciate that you 
will do that. I look forward to your quick response. I 
appreciate you mentioning the resources GAO has. They have it 
for a reason because they actually save billions of dollars. As 
I recall, Congress has given OMB $100 million in the Big 
Beautiful Bill. There are plenty of resources in your 
department. If you could dedicate some of those to independent 
oversight and actually save billions of dollars in taxpayer 
money, I would certainly welcome that and we hope to see that 
if you are confirmed.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Moreno.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MORENO

 Senator Moreno. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There were some 
concerns about the five of you not having your background 
checks and FBI pieces. Maybe we can do a little vetting here 
this morning, if you guys don't mind. Maybe we can assuage some 
concerns that people may have legitimately about your 
backgrounds.
 Starting with you, Mr. Duncan, if you could just say yes or 
no quickly. Do any of you have a Nazi tattoo?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, as I mentioned yesterday, I do not 
have any tattoos, especially not a Nazi tattoo.
 Senator Moreno. Mr. Cavanaugh.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. I do not have any tattoos of that nature.
 Senator Moreno. Mr. Cummins.
 Mr. Cummins. Do not have any tattoos, Senator?
 Senator Moreno. Mr. Hamilton.
 Mr. Hamilton. No.
 Mr. Baldis. No.
 Senator Moreno. Have any of you ever said that women 
deserve to be raped and should take accountability for being 
intoxicated?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, absolutely not.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. No.
 Mr. Cummins. No.
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, I have had family members sexually 
assaulted in very egregious ways, so absolutely not.
 Mr. Baldis. No.
 Senator Moreno. How about that black people don't tip well. 
Would that be in your background?
 Mr. Duncan. No, Senator.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. No.
 Mr. Cummins. No, sir.
 Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely not.
 Mr. Baldis. No.
 Senator Moreno. Have any of you fantasized about raping men 
who broke into your homes?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, absolutely not.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. No, Senator.
 Mr. Cummins. No, sir.
 Mr. Hamilton. No.
 Mr. Baldis. No.
 Senator Moreno. Have any of you fantasized about 
masturbating in public bathrooms?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, absolutely not.
 Mr. Cavanaugh. No, Senator.
 Mr. Cummins. No, sir.
 Mr. Hamilton. No, sir.
 Mr. Baldis. No.
 Senator Moreno. I am glad that you clarified that for us. I 
mean, you wouldn't be qualified to be the Democrat nominee for 
the U.S. Senate in Maine, but certainly glad that we got those 
questions out of the way. Mr. Hamilton, I ask you one last one 
that the Democrat nominee for Senate of Maine, that's been 
endorsed by Senate Democrats. What do you think about the idea 
that he called people who got killed in Afghanistan losers to 
somebody who served? How does that make you feel as somebody 
who was in the military?
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you for the question, Senator. As a 
combat veteran, former Navy seal, I have served with some 
amazing men and women overseas, some of the most incredible 
Americans. I take that with grave personal offense. I have lost 
friends who have been buried in that soil. I have had great 
Americans that I have worked with that I have had to save their 
lives for. I think it's a reprehensible statement that strikes 
at the very heart and nature of American character.
 Senator Moreno. If any of the people here that we are 
looking to confirm for these positions had any of these things 
in their background, would you fault us for not voting for 
those people and disqualifying them right away Mr. Hamilton, 
from just your position,
 Mr. Hamilton. I would not support an individual with 
statements such as that if I can speak on a personal matter, 
Senator.
 Senator Moreno. Perfect. I appreciate that.
 Mr. Cummings, you are looking to take over the TSA. We are 
sitting here in June. TSA has been shut down by the Democrats 
three times just this Congress alone. There is absolutely no 
doubt in my mind that the Democrats are plotting again not to 
cooperate with appropriations and shut down the government 
again in September. Tell me how difficult it is to you to be in 
that job knowing that your workers may once again not receive a 
paycheck. Not because they didn't do a good job, not because 
they didn't show up for work, because of pure, raw, 
unadulterated politics. How difficult does that make your job?
 Mr. Cummins. Thank you for the question, Mr. Senator. It is 
clear that going without pay for months is not something that 
any American should have to put up with, least of which the 
ones that are protecting our skies and our transportation 
systems. I think I would hope that this Congress keeps that in 
mind for future appropriations and spending bills that we 
should care about the essential workers, we should care about 
those that are protecting our borders, those that are 
protecting our airports, our transportation systems, and quite 
frankly, their morale that I have encountered is quite low 
right now. It's something that I am going to have to put as my 
No. 1 priority my first day on the job.
 Senator Moreno. We should do our job and fund the 
government, right?
 Mr. Cummins. Yes, we should.
 Senator Moreno. Mr. Hamilton, how important do you think it 
is for us to pass Senator Johnson's Shutdown Fairness Act that 
would say in the inevitability that the Democrats decide that 
it's politically wise for them to shut down the government, 
that government employees would continue to get paid so that 
they don't get used as pawns?
 Mr. Hamilton. I would state, Senator, that it's reasonable 
for us to pass legislation to ensure that all the Federal 
executive actions can be achieved properly and are properly 
funded.
 Senator Moreno. Real quickly, Mr. Cavanaugh, there's about 
$65 billion owed to the U.S. Government by Chinese solar panel 
companies that lost the lawsuit. They owe that money to the 
Customs and Border Patrol Department for tariffs that they did 
not pay. Do I have your commitment that you will go after them, 
chase them down, and hunt them down for every last cent?
 Mr. Cavanaugh. Senator, you absolutely have my commitment 
to do that. If confirmed, I look forward to taking advantage of 
several developments in technology to close loopholes that 
countries have been using.
 Senator Moreno. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Hassan.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HASSAN

 Senator Hassan. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Senator Moreno, I 
would look forward to your review of Senator Lankford's and my 
Prevent Government Shutdowns Bill. It has strong bipartisan 
support.
 I want to thank the witnesses for being here today. I 
normally ask all nominees this question, and I am going to ask 
it for the record so we don't spend time with your answers this 
morning. But the question will be, if the President orders you 
to violate the law, whether you are going to follow the law or 
follow the President's directive.
 Now I will move on to my first question, which is to Mr. 
Hamilton, I am going to followup on the line that Senator 
Peters was asking you because I too, am concerned that the 
report came out earlier this year that FEMA under the Trump 
administration had approved 89 percent of disaster funding 
applications submitted by Republican led States, but only 23 
percent from Democratic led States.
 As you and I discussed in our meeting, and I appreciated 
that meeting, this is unacceptable. The idea that Americans who 
need help in the wake of a tornado or a flood or a hurricane 
should be treated differently based upon politics is shameful. 
It is un American. Mr. Hamilton, do you agree that politics and 
partisan considerations should play no part in approving 
disaster assistance?
 Mr. Hamilton. I do, ma'am.
 Senator Hassan. Thank you. If you recommend that disaster 
assistance should be approved and the President disagrees based 
upon his political or personal considerations, what would you 
do?
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you for the question, ma'am. I think 
that every disaster has to be adjudicated and evaluated on 
their own merits. So we would take the consideration of the 
public assistance--individual assistance team, formulate what 
we believe to be an appropriate course of action, and strong 
recommendations to the President. My goal will be to make that 
process, if confirmed, as clear and objective as possible.
 Senator Hassan. Right, but what would you do if he says, 
look, it's led by a Democratic Governor, but I want to punish 
the Democrats so they are not getting it. What would you do?
 Mr. Hamilton. That's a very odd hypothetical. I don't 
believe the President would do that. But I will tell you that 
my oath of office requires that I follow and obey the law.
 Senator Hassan. I do believe, given the evidence that we 
are seeing right now, that the President would do it, because 
that's the only explanation for that kind of gap between the 
awards of disaster assistance. We have a President who does 
some outrageous things, to Senator Moreno's earlier questions, 
including making incredibly derogatory comments about veterans 
and Senator John McCain.
 We have a President who daily gives us examples of breaking 
the law. You all are going to have to think about what you will 
do when he reverses your decision completely based on politics, 
which, as I said, would be immoral and un American. I 
appreciate your commitment to following your oath of office, 
but I hope you will give this serious thought.
 Now to Mr. Cavanaugh. Secretary Noem put Corey Lewandowski 
in charge of the day to day operations of the Department of 
Homeland Security. Mr. Lewandowski then reportedly abused his 
position to personally profit from blatant corruption. During 
the Presidential transition, Mr. Lewandowski reportedly 
demanded bribes in exchange for DHS contracts. At DHS, he 
handed out no bid contracts to his cronies and fired employees 
who stood in his way.
 Mr. Cavanaugh, as undersecretary for management, you would 
be the top contracting official at DHS. Will you commit to 
conducting a review of DHS contracts that might have been 
approved by Mr. Lewandowski for potential self-dealing and 
corrupt pay to play schemes?
 Mr. Cavanaugh. Senator, thank you for the question. I would 
like to start by saying Secretary Mullin, after being 
confirmed, has already began that process, and if confirmed, I 
commit to following up and providing additional support into 
the process of reviewing all contracts.
 Senator Hassan. Including the contracts that might have 
been approved by Mr. Lewandowski for potential self-dealing and 
corrupt pay to play schemes?
 Mr. Cavanaugh. Correct.
 Senator Hassan. Secretary Mullin, will you personally also 
oversee that process?
 Mr. Cavanaugh. As the undersecretary for management, yes 
the delegation would be down to that role.
 Senator Hassan. Will you commit to giving Congress the 
information it needs to conduct its own investigation into Mr. 
Lewandowski's corruption, such as routing sheets and other 
documents that show Mr. Lewandowski's role in DHS contracts?
 Mr. Cavanaugh. Senator, I commit to being open and 
transparent and accountable with the oversight committees and 
look forward to that relationship.
 Senator Hassan. All right, thank you very much.
 Mr. Duncan, I'm seeing that I am almost out of time, Mr. 
Chair, so I will ask this question for the record. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Scott.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SCOTT

 Senator Scott. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you each of you. 
Congratulations. Thank you for being here. Congratulations on 
your nominations.
 Mr. Hamilton, FEMA is a pretty big deal for Florida, right? 
When I was Governor, we had four major hurricanes and FEMA was 
an unbelievable partner in our State. Tell me how you would 
handle this. So right or wrong, I never understood it, it never 
made any sense to me. But the Federal Government would pay 75 
percent of things like shelter and debris pickup and things 
like that. So on debris pickup, here's what happened.
 So a county would have a contract for $7 to $8, $8.50 a 
square foot or cubic yard. Then the Federal Government, just 
out of the graciousness, they would pay 75 percent of it, the 
State would pay twelve-and-a-half percent, and the county would 
pay twelve-and-a-half percent. I got all these calls as soon as 
major storm happened, said, you need to turn that over to the 
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). Because if you turned 
over to the Corps of Engineers, they supposedly do it way 
better. Right?
 I always assumed when I got those calls there's money 
involved, right. Here's what happens. As soon as I turned over 
to the Corps, 90 percent by the feds for whatever reason, then 
I paid five as the State, counties paid five. Good deal, right? 
For the State, not a great deal for the Federal Government. 
What's better is, guess what the contract was with the Corps. 
What's your guess?
 Mr. Hamilton. I couldn't guess, Senator.
 Senator Scott. $72. Same unit, $72 a cubic yard. Guess 
what, it's the same companies. If these companies would decide 
they didn't want to--if I wouldn't turn over to the Corps, and 
they wouldn't, they just say, oh, I am not going to pick it up, 
then they would say, oh, I want $20. Then the government like 
that they'd say, OK, we will pay 75 percent of that. Does that 
make any sense to you?
 Mr. Hamilton. No. I think, Senator, you have identified 
some unique challenges that would have to be resolved within 
FEMA. The Corps of Engineers they utilize contract vehicles 
through the Department of War, through the Economy Act, they 
allow and leverage other Federal Government agencies to take 
advantage of their contracting capability. It's fairly 
ubiquitous throughout the U.S. Government.
 What I will say is there's definitely concerns about trying 
to find ways to reduce the administrative cost of some of these 
projects. I think that my role, if confirmed, will be to ensure 
that States have enough information possible to understand the 
programs better and to encourage cost reasonableness. Fair, 
reasonable, and justifiable have to be the measurements through 
which we approach all contract activity.
 If confirmed, my focus will be to ensure that our 
procurement processes and everything that FEMA does to 
facilitate payments and reimbursements are fair, are within 
market rates, and are reasonable so that the American people 
feel that not only they are getting the best bang for their 
buck, but that we are also being wise and diligent with 
taxpayer dollars as good stewards.
 Senator Scott. So why does the Federal Government pay 75 
percent of a lot of this? Why? What's the argument?
 Mr. Hamilton. Much of that is written within the Stafford 
Act and other legislative actions that have occurred that 
stipulate the balance between Federal and State investment. 
States then commute some of that investment down to the local 
level. This is the unique paradigm that is always in 
fluctuation within various disasters.
 The hurricanes that we saw with Helene and Milton, there 
was 100 percent cost share. The Federal Government pays for the 
entirety of the disaster. That is a discretion that the 
President may have at times, or a 90 percent cost share in the 
event that the devastation is more particularly egregious and 
cataclysmic that clearly transcends a State's ability to 
respond. These are balances that have to be struck. This is 
ultimately a decision space as in law, for the commander-in-
chief.
 My job, if confirmed, will be to represent to him all the 
objective facts and to ensure that as we liquidate and expense 
dollars in accordance with his decision that we do so with 
reasonableness and that we are wise with those dollars to go 
further. My focus is to help as many disaster survivors as 
possible, which means we have to be responsible with how we use 
those funds.
 Senator Scott. If the State and the county have less and 
less skin in the game, do you think they are going to watch the 
money?
 Mr. Hamilton. I will be transparent with you, Senator. I 
think many States and local officials have had incentives to 
drive up costs. I think this is also a unique challenge within 
disaster management response. Now, yes, they are entitled to 
support. We, as the agency have confirmed we would need to 
strike a new balance to encourage cost reasonableness and cost 
savings.
 So yes, there are direct incentives for States to escalate 
costs because they bring home more resources and 
infrastructure. We have quite a bit of deferred maintenance. 
This is always an issue with FEMA grants where States will then 
request that reimbursements be made to cover other disaster 
related devastation that wasn't directly connected to the one 
which was requested. It's never an easy battle.
 My goal is to be transparent and to partner with States so 
that we can ensure that those dollars go further and that we 
can ensure that States are also being responsible with us. I 
think the President very clearly cares to ensure that States 
have their own skin in the game as well, so that they are 
paying their apportionment. The Stafford Act in the second 
paragraph stipulates State responsibilities to respond to 
disasters. Federal responsibility then to come in and support 
those efforts.
 Senator Scott. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Scott, I think you have hit the nail 
on the head on oversight. I think to have true oversight, if 
you had a 50/50 split and we stuck by it, I'm guessing there 
would be less disasters declared.
 Senator Scott. What Senator Hassan brought up this idea 
that a President could pick and choose, whether it was a 
Republican or Democrat prison. Then somebody can waive and get 
100 percent? This is crazy. I mean, we are running $2 trillion 
deficits. No, I don't get why there's so little incentive for 
the local government to watch the money.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Hassan, you want to say anything 
since you referred to it?
 Senator Hassan. As a former Governor who has worked closely 
with my local communities, especially one right now which has 
been devastated for the third time in two or three years by 
heavy rains, I think they watch their dollars very closely, at 
least in my State. Thank you.
 Senator Scott. You must not do debris pickup like I have 
to.
 Senator Hassan. I am happy to work with you on reforming 
disaster relief, but I don't think this is the time or the 
place.
 Chairman Paul. But the same principle of the 50/50 split 
goes to things like Medicaid. Do you think we would be taking 
care of the poorest and the neediest if the split were 50/50 or 
if the Federal Government pays 90 percent? All of these things 
make a big difference. We let the States make these decisions, 
but then the Federal Government picks up the check. You can't 
have the people determining the cost separated from the people 
paying or you get a disastrous $2 trillion deficit.
 Senator Hassan. There are parameters and rules that States 
have to follow if they are going to get that 90 percent 
reimbursement and the oversight could be improved if we improve 
our government processes, to be sure. But I think the 
assumption that our deficit right now is the result of that as 
opposed to the result of tax cuts to billionaires is pretty 
rich. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Yes, I think it's a great discussion and a 
debate because the thing is when you don't pay for it, there's 
not a financial disincentive to add more people. So what 
happens since the Federal Government pays 90 percent of 
Medicaid now healthier, richer people are on Medicaid than used 
to be. The people that were added had higher incomes and we are 
healthier and more able bodied than we had previously because 
the States do have to be more judicious when they are paying a 
higher percentage of what Medicaid costs.
 Senator Hassan. I will just note it's something around 
$16,000 is the limit for a single adult in my State to get 
Medicaid expansion. That's not a high earner. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Slotkin.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SLOTKIN

 Senator Slotkin. Thank you for being here. Thank you to a 
couple of you who I met in my office yesterday and for taking 
the time.
 Obviously, you have heard a lot, Mr. Hamilton, about 
concerns about politicization. I think the thing that you heard 
from my colleague from Michigan was it's just hard to 
rationalize just how many disasters have been approved for aid 
in Republican States versus Democratic States. In Michigan, 
we're a swing State, we're a purple State. I think particularly 
the ice storm that we had a year and a half ago has really felt 
like we have had to use an incredible amount of influence and 
power, both Democrats and Republicans working together in our 
delegation to get reimbursement.
 I think the total damage from that storm was $440 million. 
If we don't get help, then the average rate payer--because we 
had electric co-ops go down--is going to be charged an extra 
$4,500 per household. It is pretty existential for people in my 
State. I know you are someone who's worked in and around FEMA 
for a long time, but I just want to double tap the idea that we 
can't have stats coming out of your office when and if you get 
confirmed that demonstrate that you get more of a payout if you 
are in a Republican State and a faster payout if you are in a 
Republican State.
 That should go without saying. Republicans would be 
screaming bloody murder if the stats were reversed and if it 
was easier to get money if you were a Democratic State under a 
Democratic President. Let's please keep disasters apolitical.
 I want to ask to Mr. Duncan, you have had an interesting 
couple of days up here on the Hill, made some news, gone viral 
a couple of times. I just feel like this idea that to get a 
Federal grant, the rules have been rewritten so that you can 
reject any organization that represents, ``anti-American 
values'' and anyone who, ``damages the reputation of the 
government.''
 You are going to be in an important position of power. You 
want the big job, you answer the big questions. If a university 
that was receiving Federal dollars for a research grant into 
cancer, but they allowed a peaceful protest of the Iran war on 
their campus, would that be, ``damaging to the reputation of 
the government?''
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, I appreciate the question. As you 
know, with 2 CFR, it's signed off by all 41 agencies----
 Senator Slotkin. Right. But in your mind, you are asking to 
be a decisionmaker. Right? I understand there's a chain. I was 
a Federal Government employee for a long time. But you are 
asking, you're up here for Senate confirmation. It's a big job. 
Is a protest, a First Amendment peaceful protest on a college 
campus threaten the Federal dollars that they are getting for 
cancer research under the rules that you will be enforcing? Yes 
or no, Senator?
 Mr. Duncan. You are asking a hypothetical question. But I 
would note that this----
 Senator Slotkin. We have protests. We do. I mean I have 
University of Michigan and Michigan State. There are protests 
from time to time, that's for sure. So it's not hypothetical. 
This is something that literally in 15, 20 days you could be 
dealing with. Is a First Amendment protest on a college campus 
enough to be, ``anti-American'' or ``threatening the reputation 
of this administration?''
 Mr. Duncan. In the hypothetical question that you are 
asking related to grants for cancer research, this 
administration is committed to gold standard science and wants 
to advance the best cancer research that we possibly can.
 Senator Slotkin. If they can have a protest on their 
campus--and I would just say slashing cancer research and 
slashing our science institutions around the country and making 
us have to be literally one-tenth of the medical research 
that's going on in like, places like China and Europe is not a 
way to uphold a gold standard for cancer research. I say that 
for a woman who's got cancer in her family.
 If a domestic violence shelter receives a Federal grant, 
but they also post complaints about this administration's 
cutting of domestic violence funding, will that put them at 
risk of being labeled anti American or threatening the 
reputation of this administration?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, again, you are asking hypothetical 
questions. The ultimate deciders of these grants will be the 
political employees at the agencies. I would imagine in this 
situation it would likely be Department of Health and Human 
Services (HHS) and so----
 Senator Slotkin. The political employees. The political 
appointees like yourself?
 Mr. Duncan. The political appointees. OMB does not issue 
grants. We issue guidance, uniform guidance on grants. I would 
not make decisions on a specific grant----
 Senator Slotkin. But if someone calls you--I mean, again, 
this is like, you can't want the big job, but then not answer 
the big questions. I think the idea that, First Amendment 
activities would be, ``anti-American'' or ``threatening the 
reputation of this administration.'' You understand that you 
are creating a climate of fear around things that are 
actually--it's the opposite of anti-American. It's the most 
American thing in the world, the First Amendment.
 I think you have raised a lot of concerns in your testimony 
over the last couple of days. But the idea that the 
administration would put that kind of language out there to 
intimidate and scare people out of freedom of speech is 
something that is the most anti--American thing I have seen in 
a long time.
 Yield back.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Ernst.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ERNST

 Senator Ernst. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thanks to all of 
you for being here today and being willing to step forward and 
serve. I will focus most of my questions this morning on you 
Mr. Duncan, if I could, please. You have worked with the OMB. I 
do a lot of work with the GAO and the OMB on my fraud, waste, 
and abuse within the Federal Government work and we do require 
a healthy dialog back and forth between the Legislative and 
Executive branches so that we can effectively serve our 
constituencies back home.
 The Legislative branch conducts oversight, and this is one 
of the most foundational parts of the back and forth between 
the Executive and the Legislative branches. The Government 
Accountability Office conducts different in-depth 
investigations. A lot of that work is done on behalf of a 
number of us that will request certain reports, investigations, 
and they will then make recommendations back to us based on 
those reports. I am currently working with the GAO on a number 
of projects and they have reported that OMB has been very slow 
to respond to some of their investigations.
 Mr. Duncan, if you are confirmed to this position, will you 
work to ensure that OMB responds to investigations and 
oversight efforts from Congress?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator yes, absolutely. We will work with our 
legal counsel on that matter and offer the same commitment that 
I offered to the Ranking Member on that front as well.
 Senator Ernst. Yes, and I thank you so much for that and 
for the rest of the members on the panel as well. Because there 
has been such an issue with fraud within the Federal 
Government, we hope that all of you within your respective 
positions are constantly evaluating your departments, your 
agencies to make sure that every taxpayer dollar is actually 
going to the very programs or reasons that it was intended.
 We have uncovered so much fraud within the Federal 
Government. What we have discovered is that every single day 
our Federal Government loses $1.4 billion to fraud every single 
day and even Federal Government workers--I'm going to highlight 
two here because it will kind of lead into my next question--
but we have uncovered several of these. It's kind of shocking. 
I just want to share them because we have tens and tens of 
people watching C-SPAN today.
 There are many Federal workers that will claim to be 
working for multiple agencies at the same time. This was 
enabled by telework that went on during the Biden 
administration and that President Trump finally put an end to. 
But we had one woman that claimed she was working for TSA, for 
the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), for 
the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), oh, and God bless 
her for her service the Air Force Reserves. She was working all 
of those jobs at the same time and she was turning in a time 
card for 120 hour work weeks. That's just one example. There 
was another one that was working for AmeriCorps, HUD, and the 
National Institutes of Health (NIH). Again, three full time 
jobs all at the same time, turning in time cards to the Federal 
Government.
 Please be aware that fraud exists out there and use the 
tools at your disposal to out these fraudsters. We have a lot 
of lazy bureaucrats that are out there trying to scam the 
Federal Government for all they can. We have a lot of great 
workers, too, but we need to ferret out the fraud, waste, and 
abuse.
 Again, Mr. Duncan, last year, when congressional Democrats 
shut down the government in October, I sent a letter to OMB 
Director Vought detailing a number of prime spending cuts that 
I thought he should pursue. Mr. Duncan, one of those 
suggestions was to stop giving government bureaucrats bonuses 
when we are massively in debt and they don't do their jobs. 
Amazingly, many of them still get bonuses.
 So can you speak to any actions that OMB has taken this 
Congress to reduce the amount of bonuses the Federal Government 
is paying to these lazy bureaucrats?
 Mr. Duncan. Senator, I appreciate the question. As it 
relates to the specifics on bonuses, I would have to circle up 
with our management team on that. But the President's 
management agenda is very clear in the sense that we want to 
ensure that the Federal workforce is working efficiently and 
that we are optimizing the use of taxpayer dollars in the 
workforce. I am happy to continue to work with you on that 
matter as well.
 Senator Ernst. Yes. I appreciate it. I do want to say, too, 
that in your current previous roles at OMB, you have been very 
helpful to me and my team as we are trying to ferret out that 
fraud, waste, and abuse. We really do appreciate that. Thank 
you so much, Mr. Chair.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Ernst, the mention of people working 
two and three jobs in the government reminds me of an assistant 
director under the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) 
under Obama who was pretty high in the organization. But he 
also said he worked for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) 
and he didn't get paid by the CIA, but he would take six months 
off at a time. They said, where is this guy? Oh, he's on 
assignment with the CIA. They finally had a shutdown. They 
caught him and I think he went to jail and had like $8 million 
in back payments. But in a government with this many millions 
of people, you are absolutely right. We need to look at it.
 Senator Blumenthal.
 Senator Ernst. Thank you.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR BLUMENTHAL

 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you all 
for being here today and your willingness to serve.
 Mr. Hamilton, when you were in the position of, I think it 
was acting director, you wrote a memo advocating that the per 
capita indicator that is necessary to qualify for receiving 
disaster relief be raised to $7.56 per person. That's almost 
quadrupling the threshold cap, which would, in effect, 
disqualify a lot of communities, including some in Connecticut 
perhaps, as might have happened just last August 2024 when we 
experienced a catastrophic rainfall and flooding in parts of 
the State, a 1 in 1000 year extreme rainfall event.
 Thankfully, after a disaster declaration was issued. 
Connecticut was able to get the assistance that we needed to 
rebuild. But the kind of policy that you advocated in your memo 
might well have disqualified Connecticut raising that threshold 
from $1.94 to $7.56. Do you still support raising the per 
capita indicator per person outlined in your April 12, 2025 
memo?
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you for the question, Senator. I would 
say that I diligently care for all Americans facing disasters 
and want to ensure that resources are provided promptly. That 
was a memo written last year which was part of a deliberative 
pre decisional process. It was not intended for any immediate 
action. It was part of a series of conversations that we had 
had with different elements of the Federal Executive to look at 
areas where disaster assistance might be reformed.
 Senator Blumenthal. So that is not your position currently?
 Mr. Hamilton. That is not my position, and that is not a 
position that was ready for implementation or adoption.
 Senator Blumenthal. Let me ask you about the current 
staffing of FEMA. Can you tell me how many people are currently 
working in FEMA Region 1?
 Mr. Hamilton. FEMA Region 1? Well, yes, that's obviously up 
in the Northeast, in your area.
 Senator Blumenthal. It's our region.
 Mr. Hamilton. That's correct. They have several hundred 
employees. They also have various personnel that are deployed 
to FEMA Integration Teams (FIT). I don't think I have the exact 
number of employees stationed within the FEMA FIT teams, but I 
would be happy to provide the Senator with more----
 Senator Blumenthal. The precise number. I have tried 
repeatedly to get this question answered from Secretary Noem. 
In fact, on July 14, 2025, I sent a letter to her asking a 
series of questions about staffing levels for FEMA's Region 1 
that serves Connecticut. I received no response to my letter 
until February 20, 2026, and that response did not include the 
requested information. Can you give it to me now?
 Mr. Hamilton. I don't have that right at this moment, 
Senator, but I would commit to following back up with you to 
ensure that you have that information.
 Senator Blumenthal. Are you aware that that number 
represents cuts of anywhere from 20 to 30 percent of staff over 
the last year?
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, I am aware that there have been many 
cuts and reductions in staff. Yes, sir.
 Senator Blumenthal. Don't those cuts jeopardize the 
responsiveness of FEMA to the kinds of disasters that we 
suffered in August 2024 and other parts of the country have 
suffered?
 Mr. Hamilton. I think certainly FEMA operates in a unique 
environment where there are challenges and setbacks that impact 
our ability to respond. What I can tell you is I have full 
faith and confidence in the FEMA workforce. I believe they are 
an exceptional group of public servants.
 Senator Blumenthal. They are an exceptional group of public 
servants, but there need to be enough of them to be on the 
ground as they are in a very dedicated and conscientious way. I 
have walked with them literally from house to house, business 
to business. I am very confident in their ability and 
dedication. But there are simply not enough of them. You will 
lose more of them unless you are adequately staffed. Do you 
agree?
 Mr. Hamilton. I would agree that the FEMA workforce needs 
to be scalable in such a way to best meet the needs of the 
agency in the execution of the program and mission.
 Senator Blumenthal. Doesn't it need to be increased, in 
other words, to restore the staff levels essential to their 
morale as well as their responsiveness?
 Mr. Hamilton. I do want to praise Secretary Mullin with his 
approval and under his leadership, there's been roughly just 
shy of 350 positions that were made available again to fill 
critical vacancies in key program offices and key 
responsibilities. I believe Secretary Mullin is a man of 
principle and cares very deeply about ensuring that the 
workforce is sufficiently staffed, commensurate to the 
responsibilities.
 Senator Blumenthal. My time has expired, but I would like 
staffing levels for Region 1 and for other regions in the 
country, as well as what those numbers represent in terms of 
cuts over the last year and what plans you have to restore 
those numbers. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Moody.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MOODY

 Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to all 
our nominees for being here today and your families that are 
sitting behind you, standing behind you as you have answered 
the President's call to serve this country in your respective 
critical roles. We very much appreciate it.
 I am somewhat surprised to hear my Democratic colleagues 
now charging in on making sure that FEMA is politically 
neutral. Of course it should be politically neutral. We should 
all expect that. As many of you know, I am the most junior 
Senator on this Committee. For Florida, the State of Florida, 
which experiences disasters from storms routinely, back to back 
storms, and in the aftermath of some very devastating storms, I 
was forced as Attorney General (AG) in Florida to bring a 
lawsuit against President Biden's FEMA administrator and a FEMA 
supervisor after it was uncovered that the supervisor had 
instructed disaster relief workers in Florida to, ``avoid homes 
advertising Trump.''
 To be clear, these instructions were not merely sent and 
forgotten, they were carried out. FEMA personnel canvassed Lake 
Placid, Florida and in the aftermath of Hurricane Milton, they 
intentionally skipped homes with Trump signs and flags. Members 
of the community were reeling after that storm, trying to 
figure out how they were going to provide for their family, 
safeguard their property. Yet FEMA employees were instructed to 
avoid homes that advertised support for the President.
 This FEMA supervisor who sent that message later claimed 
that the practice was not isolated to Lake Placid or even to 
Florida, and that the political discrimination within FEMA was 
far more widespread. I am happy to hear that my Democratic 
colleagues now are saying that politics have no place in 
disaster response. But I am disheartened to hear numbers thrown 
around without examining where those numbers come from. In 
fact, when I got here to be the United States Senator, having 
been the Attorney General and uncovering that, litigating 
against that, pushing back on political discrimination within 
FEMA, I realized after hearing from so many of my constituents 
around the State that there were many claims outstanding that 
had not been paid from storms and going back into the Biden 
administration that were just sitting there.
 Thankfully, I worked with Secretary Noem and now Secretary 
Mullin, and we have seen engagement and trying to push forward 
these things so that folks in Florida, communities in Florida 
can recover from these storms. But when I tell you it has been 
over a billion dollars I have had to push to get released on 
storms that went back into the last administration.
 I am grateful that we are seeing such progress. I am 
grateful that that money is now flowing into Florida. I don't 
like the fact that I had to become a Senator in order to get it 
done, but proud of my new role and glad to serve the great 
State of Florida and the people of Florida.
 I want to talk to you, Mr. Hamilton, about ensuring that 
politics does stay out of disaster response. We can all agree 
that is the case. In fact, I'm proud to say I worked with a 
colleague across the aisle, Senator Alsobrooks, to just pass 
and get signed into law a TRACK Act which would provide 
accountability for these claims and more efficiency so that 
people can actually track these.
 Can you tell this Committee what your plans are to make 
sure, No. 1, that we do a thorough review on a politically 
neutral basis, making sure these are claims that are vetted 
claims, that they are real claims, that they are monies that 
should be paid according to our statutes and our regs, and 
approach these in an efficient way and comply with the new law 
as the new administrator.
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you for the question, Senator. I would 
tell you that I deeply care about the needs of your 
constituents and all Americans across this country in getting 
timely assistance. They deserve to have a government that is 
devoid of politics, that is able to execute the mission first 
and foremost.
 What I will state is that some of the tools and technology 
that FEMA uses is a bit antiquated that would help facilitate 
this with better care and would actually provide the customer 
service that I think is appropriate for every survivor. Right 
now there's a lot of difficulty with survivors understanding 
where they fall in that FEMA circle of death that I talk about 
with where their claim is and how it's adjudicated.
 Senator Moody. As well as cities and counties?
 Mr. Hamilton. That's correct.
 Senator Moody. Do you believe that you can use that new 
law, that TRACK Act, the accountability that's built into that 
and implement that in a way that will help in this?
 Mr. Hamilton. I believe that right now FEMA is currently 
taking steps to implement some of those same approaches and it 
would be my focus, if confirmed, to ensure that we remain 
consistent. Yes, I do believe that additional legislation, as 
you have mentioned, would be exceedingly helpful in doing that. 
If confirmed, I am planning to do a significant information 
technology (IT) overhaul of the entire agency for better 
accountability.
 Senator Moody. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Gallego.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR GALLEGO

 Senator Gallego. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Ranking Member.
 Mr. Hamilton, the FEMA Review Council has recommended 
raising cost thresholds and create a new minimum annual 
standard extension requirement before Federal--kind of we 
talked about that already. Specifically, what I worry about 
because this makes it very hard for western States, we are low 
density western States like Arizona, to qualify for a lot of 
this support. This could be very difficult, especially when 
disasters hit our rural counties and our tribal lands or even 
smaller communities with limited tax bases. The reason we have 
limited tax bases is because we are surrounded by Federal land. 
There's not really much of any way for us to actually raise the 
threshold that we need to meet to get the match.
 How would you ensure that FEMA's declaration criteria does 
not disadvantage States like Arizona where the damage may be 
severe locally spread across a large geographic area? We saw 
this recently with the towns of Miami and Globe in Arizona.
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, thank you for the question. I think 
you have indicated a really unique facet of emergency 
management that has to be looked at and evaluated. What I can 
tell you is that my objectives, if confirmed, will be to work 
with both Senators, Members of Congress, as well as the 
American public to better understand how to serve the needs of 
Americans facing these high consequence events.
 My approach would be to be very deliberative, if any 
reevaluation on thresholds were discussed and entertained and 
much of those parameters have been going back for decades 
without evaluation and updating. I do believe in a prorated or 
a per capita basis. That should also take into consideration 
rural communities in addition to high population density 
communities.
 Senator Gallego. But even rural communities, just to be 
clear, like rural communities east of the Mississippi are 
entirely different than rural communities west of the 
Mississippi. East of the Mississippi you have very little 
Federal land. Rural communities west of the Mississippi are, my 
State for example, is 65 percent tribal and Federal land. If 
you go up to Utah, Nevada, they can get up to 90 percent.
 Even when you guys do set FEMA parameters, it's a very east 
coast bias or even a west coast bias, but certainly not a 
western, bias where we have a lot of Federal land that's 
locking up our ability to actually expand our tax base. But 
thank you for at least looking deeper into that to actually 
trying to understand that.
 The FEMA Review Council's recommendations focus heavily on 
event-based disasters like hurricane or earthquakes. But our 
biggest risk in Arizona is wildfire, post fire flooding, 
drought, extreme heat, and cascading infrastructure impacts 
that come from all that. There's a huge gap between 
recommendations and what such as often look again for western 
States.
 Do you believe the Stafford Act and FEMA proven to be 
better account for slow onset and compounding disasters? We 
should support reforms that explicitly preserve fire management 
assistance grants, straighten post fire mitigation, and improve 
eligibility for drought and heat related impacts. So post fire 
mitigation for you non westerners is if we have a forest fire 
that we could take care of the forest fire, we would have FEMA 
come and help us out. Then also we have to go and replant 
reseed before the rain comes because then we could get massive 
flooding that comes in.
 Sometimes FEMA does not pay for the replanting and 
reseeding of our forests which end up causing even greater 
disasters a year from now. So that's specifically kind of what 
I am thinking about when I talk about that.
 Mr. Hamilton. Senator, another excellent question. I think 
you bring up a unique context that many don't fully understand 
on the West Coast. I grew up on the west coast so I very much 
appreciate what you have identified. I have had family who've 
lost homes from fires and other significant natural disasters 
out west. It is a unique paradigm.
 My approach, if confirmed, will to ensure that disaster 
assistance flow quickly and rapidly and that the objectives are 
clear. I see resilience as an operational arm of what the 
agency can achieve. Those pre disaster grants to actually 
engage in risk reduction and readiness activities should be 
uniquely suited to handle the challenges and threats facing 
each State on the nuanced issues that they face.
 Senator Gallego. Those grants matter. But just have to 
remember, you are dealing on scale of like, for example, 
compare me to like Connecticut. I could fit almost 12 
Connecticuts in Arizona. I have one county that is bigger than 
New England. Right? So like you have to kind of keep the scope 
of that in mind.
 I guess just to close up for my time, like, I just want to 
make sure I emphasize the one size fits all approach to 
disaster response just is not working for the West. This is not 
a red State versus blue State or anything like that. It's a 
western State, especially western States that are largely 
occupied by Federal land.
 We need to make sure that there's a system that takes 
account kind of the differences of our States, the 
characteristics we have to take into account what that means 
and provide really transparent, timely feedback about how we 
could both comply for the grants as well as to be able to bring 
down some of the FEMA matches specifically dealing with the 
fact that we do not have the tax base that you are going to see 
in most parts of any other part of this country.
 Thank you and I yield back.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Hawley.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HAWLEY

 Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. 
Congratulations to the nominees and thank you for being here.
 Mr. Hamilton, I want to show you a picture, if I could, 
just to get started here. It's over my shoulder. This is St. 
Louis. This is a neighborhood in St. Louis, Missouri, last May. 
This is following a series of massive tornadoes in the St. 
Louis region. We also had quite a few tornadoes in southeast 
Missouri.
 As you can see, the devastation is absolutely unbelievable. 
I walk these streets myself. You have buildings completely 
destroyed, homes absolutely razed to the ground, churches whose 
roofs were lifted off, whose sanctuaries were completely 
destroyed, streets that were ripped up. The problem is, is that 
many of these neighborhoods don't look a lot different now 
because in some cases they are still waiting for relief.
 I am glad to say that the President approved Missouri's 
disaster relief for FEMA and it did go out the door, which is 
terrific, but we had to wait a long time for it. The reason for 
that was FEMA at the time was very slow in getting on the 
ground, in doing their damage assessments, and then making the 
recommendations to the White House that under the statute are 
the necessary prerequisite for unlocking that aid.
 I wish I could say that this was a one off, but it's not in 
my experience. In my experience in the State of Missouri, when 
we have a natural disaster, FEMA is slow. FEMA is often ill 
informed. FEMA does not interface well with residents.
 I remember one incident when we had severe flooding in the 
State a few years ago where FEMA not only took forever to get 
on the ground and get a disaster declaration ready to go for 
the President, but also when it came to awarding individual 
aid--which was needed in these tornadoes too, by the way--when 
it came to awarding individual aid to some farmers whose houses 
have been completely destroyed and then later tried to claw it 
back.
 I kid you not, went to the farmer and said, actually we 
know that you applied and we approved it and we gave it to you 
several months ago, but we have changed our minds and we want 
it all back. I mean, you can't make this stuff up. It is 
absolutely ridiculous.
 So here's my question to you. I think what your agency does 
is hugely important. We know it is in the State of Missouri. By 
the way, we just had a bunch more tornadoes just a few weeks 
ago for which we need aid and relief. My question is, will you 
come in and take the reins of this agency and make it actually 
work for the people of my State and every State who when they 
are facing these disasters, they need quick relief, they need 
quick responses. Our citizens need to know what's available to 
them, how to apply, how to get the relief they need. Will you 
take the reins on this agency and stay start making it work?
 Mr. Hamilton. Yes, Senator, it would be my privilege and 
honor to serve the American people and to do just that.
 Senator Hawley. Good. I think it's absolutely vital and I 
can't emphasize enough to you how important it is in my State. 
I just want to ask you before I move on, I wrote to the 
President along with every other member of the Missouri 
delegation just a week and a half ago supporting my Governor's 
request for disaster relief for those April tornadoes that I 
mentioned. This is in process now, I believe, with the agency.
 Will you work to expedite this, to cut red tape, to get 
these disaster declarations when they are requested, to get 
them approved, to move them on up the chain so that this relief 
that is statutorily available can flow to neighborhoods like 
this who need it desperately?
 Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely, Senator. I think the disaster 
declaration process and also the Federal mentorship that goes 
into it needs to be improved. I believe States need to receive 
better customer service. I have full faith and confidence in 
the FEMA workforce. But we can do better. There's a significant 
amount of areas where that process should be simplified, better 
understood and we owe you answers, I think much faster.
 Senator Hawley. Good. That's music to my ears and I know it 
will be to the citizens of Missouri. We do need, we need better 
service, we need it faster, we need clearer direction. Folks 
need to be able to apply for their individual assistance, 
understand what they are getting and when they are going to get 
it. I am counting on you to make changes in all of those areas.
 Mr. Cummings, it's great to see you. Thank you for being 
willing to do this job. I just want to give you a chance to 
respond to something that the Biden administration was doing 
that at the time, a year and a half ago now, two years ago, 
that at the time I thought was so ridiculous. I actually wrote 
to the administrator at the time of TSA about this.
 The Biden administration was allowing illegal aliens who 
did not have ID to use warrants for their arrest--to use actual 
civil immigration arrest warrants as a valid form of 
identification to get on commercial flights. Let me just say 
that again. They were allowing illegal aliens to use 
immigration arrest warrants as a form of ID to get on 
commercial flights.
 Meanwhile, your everyday law-abiding citizens who maybe 
don't come from a State that had real ID or what have you, they 
are having to wait in absurdly long lines. They are having to 
go through all kinds of process which your administration, 
assuming this Congress confirms you, your administration was 
having to process. Your agents are having to do all this extra 
screening because somebody doesn't have a real ID tag.
 But if you are an illegal immigrant and you have an arrest 
warrant right up to the front of the line, I mean, that's just 
absurd. Wouldn't you agree? No. 1. And No. 2, tell me about how 
you intend to make this agency work better for the American 
people.
 Mr. Cummins. Thank you for the question, Mr. Senator. I do 
agree, and I thank you and your office and the Chairman's 
office for investigating the weaponization that was going on in 
TSA, for investigating these fraudulent ID verification that 
was happening. That is definitely going to stop and has already 
stopped under this administration. We will continue to work 
with you all in the oversight of our agency.
 Senator Hawley. Very Good. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Kim.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR KIM

 Senator Kim. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Hamilton, I think you are hearing from a lot of my 
colleagues just the importance that FEMA plays and the concerns 
that we have when it comes to disaster response. As you 
mentioned, we have the FEMA Review Council moving forward on 
some recommendations saying full well that FEMA should exist, 
that it's important that it exists, but that there are real 
reforms that could happen.
 I wanted to ask if you can commit to this Committee that 
you will work with Congress, work with us even for some of the 
things that don't necessarily require legislative fixes, but 
that we can make sure we are doing this together and to be able 
to make sure that it is in line with congressional intent.
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you, Senator. It would be my honor to. 
If confirmed, I plan to release a 30-day report on my analysis 
and recommendations for the future, areas where FEMA can 
reform, as well as also to take insight from both Senators and 
Members of Congress on potential avenues for collaboration for 
this partnership. Then in addition to that, I plan to have 
regular meetings and intervals with meeting with members and 
Senators to ensure that they have their questions answered in a 
timely basis.
 Senator Kim. We have dealt with a lot of issues over the 
course of the time that I have been in the Senate so far. But I 
will say I really do believe that even in this time of great 
political divisiveness, that the issues about disaster response 
and about FEMA remain one of the ones that I feel most hopeful 
that we can find some bipartisanship here. We have had a number 
of good conversations amongst the senators in a bipartisan way. 
It remains top of so many people's agendas.
 I just share that with you because I get it, there are a 
lot of problems that are out there. But when I think about what 
is it that government can do that no one else can do or that 
its priority should be, I can think of nothing really more 
important than being there for Americans on their hardest days. 
When I hear from these families, those that survived Superstorm 
Sandy and other problems that we have encountered in New Jersey 
and around this country, I think that this is just so important 
that we get right and we can't wait for some future Congress or 
some future administration to be able to take action on this, 
given the dynamics. I just urge you on that front.
 When it comes to different programs on this, I wanted to 
raise a nonprofit security grant program in particular and ask 
you do you feel like that is resourced to the level that is 
needed or do you think that there's additional funds that are 
needed for us to respond across this country?
 Mr. Hamilton. Thank you for the question, Senator. The 
nonprofit security grant program that you are specifically 
referring to supports churches, nonprofits, faith based 
institutions. I think that it has some challenges with the 
execution. It also has some real opportunities and it's 
significantly blessed certain communities with the ability to 
harden their own resilience. I think all of that needs to be 
taken a look at and that would be an apportionment of that 30-
day report that I would hope to release to you and to all 
Members about recommendations for the future.
 What we found is that there's a significant amount of 
feedback from these specific communities asking for additional 
help and assistance and also to ensure that when the grant 
programs are approved and awarded that the money flow 
relatively quickly so that they can execute.
 Senator Kim. Right now it's funded last year, this past 
fiscal year (FY), around 300 million. Do you think it'd be wise 
for us to take that up? 500 million, 700 million. Do you have a 
thought where we should land?
 Mr. Hamilton. Before I give you a dollar amount, my hope 
would be to survey and query all the different affected parties 
to have a better understanding of the metrics and data as far 
as how far that can go. Then that will be a deliberative 
process where you, sir, would play a role in that, in the needs 
of your constituents, whereby the President would develop his 
budget, Senate and the House would develop their budgets, and 
then we would come to an agreement for execution.
 Senator Kim. Look, I just want to say I will work with you 
on this, but I just want to convey to you the urgency with 
which I hear from my constituents. I mean, and it's not just 
mine. I mean we see the rise of anti Semitism surging across 
this country. I visited a temple that also has a school 
attached to it. I mean they are so worried about what's going 
to happen.
 It's not just our Jewish communities, just more broadly 
that we are seeing so much fear right now. I just wanted to 
convey that to you because I heard it directly from my 
constituents. The concerns that they have honestly, it's 
persistent. That's something I think we have to think through 
when it comes to the nonprofit security grant program (NSGP).
 It's not like just that these are needs that they will have 
once every five years or seven years to be able to upgrade 
cameras. This is now the highest line item on the budget of so 
many of these institutions, whether it's anti Semitism, 
Islamophobia, or other things that are out there that people 
are worried about. I think that just the sheer amount that our 
Nation spends when it comes to national security abroad, and I 
worked counterterrorism work before, where is the urgency that 
we put behind it here at home to try to make sure that people 
are safe? Is that something you promise you work with me on?
 Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely, Senator. I had a conversation 
with Senator Slotkin yesterday about her community, 
specifically on this topic, about finding avenues that we could 
approach to ensure that these faith based institutions that are 
eligible grant recipients, that they can use those resources in 
the most effective way possible so as to stretch dollars even 
further.
 Senator Kim. But also on that persistent need, right?
 Mr. Hamilton. That's correct.
 Senator Kim. OK, with that, I yield back.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Cummins, I have never won the lottery, 
but I seem to defy the odds with getting random searches. 
Sometimes I get them both coming and going, coming from 
Tennessee, going back home. It's amazing. It's incredible how I 
defy the odds. They assure me that it's nothing personal, that 
it's random. My concern is not for me, but it's really for 
everyone.
 If you want to do random searches and you are catching 
terrorists, by all means, let's do it, but you should give us 
some statistics. I have met with the acting director several 
times. I have been asking for statistics. So you go through the 
magnetometer, doesn't go off because you don't have any metal, 
but you have been selected. The cheerful smile, you have been 
selected. You get to go to the advanced imagining technology 
(AIT) machine. So you go through the AIT machine and do you 
know what percentage of people are selected to be patted down? 
Up until a month ago, 50 percent of the people going through 
the machine were patted down. You might as well flip a coin. 
It's a completely worthless test if 50 percent of the people 
are being selected.
 When you get selected, you get patted down. Here's my 
question. You go through the magnetometer, you have no metal, 
you go through the AIT, it selects you. How many people that 
got picked for the random searches actually have something of 
danger, something that we really, Oh my goodness. The random 
selection was really good because we found they had a plastic 
gun or they had a plastic knife or they had plastic explosives.
 I have asked them that and they said they don't have the 
statistics. They don't know. Because now we have an increased 
risk. We are increasing the random searches. They are just 
every other person going through. You see the bot going up, you 
have been selected, and then you go through a machine that 50 
percent of the people are being selected.
 The machine, the AIT is, I think, is a worthless machine. 
Now, they fixed the algorithm recently, now it's a third. I 
don't know why they didn't fix it before. They finally went 
from 50 percent to 30 some odd percent, but here's what the TSA 
responds. They say, well, oh, well, we felt something. There 
wasn't anything there, but it was a fold in your clothing. 
That's a false positive. Oh, no, no, no. There was something 
there.
 So they count everything detected as a real thing. No, a 
real thing is when you find a real thing. Most of these pat 
downs are for a fold in your clothes, a piece of paper in your 
pocket. Those are false positives. But we have to study these 
things. They have indicated maybe they will. But I have gotten 
nowhere. I have gotten no studies. I still want to know, and 
this may be a classified number, but I don't think it's a big 
number. I think it's probably less than 10. How many plastic 
guns, how many plastic explosives were found last year? From 
that, we could also ask, where were they found? Were they found 
going through the machine with the luggage, or were they found 
on the person?
 Really, you should ask the question. You should have some 
kind of ability to collect data so you find out how many are 
collected randomly. I think the number is zero. I really think 
for the millions of people selected, I don't think you have 
ever found a knife or a weapon on me because it would be found 
in that magnetometer if it's metal. The only thing you would 
find is you select someone randomly out of a needle, out of a 
haystack, and then you find that they have something plastic.
 So I don't know if you know anything about this subject, 
but I would appreciate somebody looking into it because, almost 
everybody goes to the AIT gets patted down. 50 percent were 
being patted down, which means it's not a very good test, but 
it's also just harassing the traveler and these aren't the 
people that you are worried about.
 I would spend more time studying the manifest to see who's 
traveling and what kind of characteristics they might have to 
be a threat to the country. Do you know anything about the 
random selection program?
 Mr. Cummins. Thank you for the question, Mr. Chairman. I 
know as someone with a background in transportation, 25 years, 
and technology, it's one of the reasons I was nominated was my 
background both with hardware and software implementations in 
transportation. What you are describing is concerning that you 
in particular are called out so many times randomly.
 Chairman Paul. It really isn't about me. It isn't about me, 
but I am an example of a frequent traveler.
 Mr. Cummins. Understood. What I would say is that every 
instance that someone is patted down is an inefficiency if they 
are not a security threat, correct? The new technology that is 
going to be implemented hopefully will have much less false 
positives, much greater fidelity than what exists today.
 Chairman Paul. But we have to study it and find out. I 
mean, 50 percent of people being patted down is an unacceptable 
number, one. That means everybody, because the general 
screening, everybody's going through the AIT and if it finds 
something, when it finds a little yellow box and it if it's on 
your body, you get a pat down.
 Talk about slowing traffic and what a waste of effort if 
you are not finding anything. So really you should say, OK, 50 
percent of people got patted down and they are not going 
through a magnetometer. Now how many times did you find a gun 
or a knife? I think it's close to zero. That's good that it's a 
very small number. I think actually most of those are found 
with luggage going through, they are accidents or people who 
made a mistake.
 But you know, will you help us? Will you study the 
question? Will you get back with us? The classified numbers I 
asked for just a couple of weeks ago, but that should take a 
day and they should send them back to me. I want to know 
because I think it's going to be a very small number. They 
indicated it probably is a small number, but we shouldn't be 
patting down 50 percent of the people walking through general 
screening. That's probably a bigger problem than the random 
selection.
 Randomly selecting people out of the only thing that's made 
travel OK for business travelers was precheck. Before precheck, 
it was a misery. Precheck was the best thing they ever did and 
it allowed people to travel all the time who are not risk to go 
through quicker. But if all the people going through the 
general are being patted down, it's just not efficient. Did you 
have anything to add to that?
 Mr. Cummins. I will commit to you today to look into this 
if confirmed and communicate it back to you personally.
 Chairman Paul. We are going to go to the next panel, but I 
will ask Senator Peters two or three minutes, one question. Do 
you have anything else on this panel?
 Senator Peters. No.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you, panel. Do I have a concluding 
remarks here? OK. With that, this concludes our first panel. I 
would like to thank our witnesses for participating in today's 
hearing. We will now transition to our second panel. I invite 
the next panel of witnesses to please come forward and take 
their seats. We will proceed immediately.
 We are going to go ahead and get started. We will now 
resume consideration of the remaining witnesses. Bradford 
Wilson, to be the archivist for the National Archives and 
Records Administration. Don Berthiaume to be the Inspector 
General for the Department of Justice. Jeffrey Brodsky to be 
the Governor of the U.S. Postal Service (USPS). William Gallo 
to be a Governor of the U.S. Postal Service. James Woodruff II 
to be Chairman of the Merit Systems Protection Board. And 
Charlton Allen to be the General Counsel (GC) for the Federal 
Labor Relations Board (FLRB).
 The witnesses' statements have been submitted for the 
record,\1\ and I ask unanimous consent to submit letters of 
support received for the nominees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The letters of support for Mr. Hamilton appears in the Appendix 
on page 284.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 It is the practice of the Homeland Security and 
Governmental Affairs Committee to swear in the witnesses. Will 
the nominees please stand and raise your right hand. Do you 
swear that the testimony you will give before this Committee 
will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, 
so help you, God?
 [Witnesses answer in the affirmative.]
 It's a standard practice of this Committee for the Chairman 
to ask the nominees the following question, and we will do it 
individually. Do you agree without reservation to comply with 
any request or summons to appear and testify before any duly 
constituted Committee of Congress if you are confirmed? Mr. 
Wilson?
 Mr. Wilson. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Berthiaume?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Brodsky?
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Woodruff?
 Mr. Woodruff. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Allen?
 Mr. Allen. Yes, sir.
 Chairman Paul. We will now proceed to five minute 
questions, and we will start with Senator Johnson.
 Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Berthiaume, I 
appreciate the coaching there. I think you are probably aware 
that Senator Grassley and I have been investigating the whole 
Crossfire Hurricane investigation. We have been trying to 
obtain the written transcripts from the report titled, Review 
of the Four Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) 
Applications and Other Aspects of the FBI Crossfire Hurricane 
Investigation.
 It's our understanding, there are over about 170 
transcripts. We got zero from the Biden administration. We 
wrote to Attorney General Bondi and FBI Director Kash Patel to 
obtain those. Now we have obtained 19. Do you have any idea why 
we have the hang up? Why we don't have all of them? And will 
you commit to making sure that we do get all of those?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Sure. As an initial matter, Senator, I am 
committed to getting all those transcripts to you and Senator 
Grassley. One of the struggles that we have been dealing with 
is there's multiple agencies that have to review those 
transcripts before we can release them. OIG does not have the 
ability to declassify transcripts or identify other people's 
equities. We have to rely on other agencies to review the 
transcripts and identify any equities that they may have. 
That's been something that we have been working on overcoming 
over the last several weeks, developing a process to get those 
to you more quickly and more efficiently.
 Senator Johnson. We do a pretty good job of working for 
accommodations, that type of thing. But we really want to 
prioritize. The priorities for us are the transcripts of James 
Comey, James Baker, Andrew McCabe, Peter Strzok, Joseph 
Pientka. So again, if confirmed, I would like you to work very 
closely with my staff to prioritize those, get those, go 
through that interagency process of reviewing their equities.
 But, bottom line, we are Congress. We have rights to this 
information unredacted, and we really will expect that you do 
provide those to us.
 Mr. Berthiaume. Absolutely, Senator, it's certainly a 
priority already. We are aware of that. We are working closely 
with your staff, and we are exerting the amount of pressure 
that we can in our position to help those folks move them along 
more efficiently for you all.
 Senator Johnson. I appreciate that. No further questions.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Peters.
 Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is for Mr. 
Gallo and Brodsky to both of you.
 We will start with Mr. Brodsky first. Do you support 
privatizing the mail and package delivery operations of the 
Postal Service? Just a yes or no answer.
 Put it closer to your mouth, please.
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes, I don't really have a view on whether or 
not privatizing it would make any sense or not.
 Senator Peters. You have no view of that at this point?
 Mr. Brodsky. No. I have heard people talk about it, but I 
really have not reviewed that as a possibility.
 Senator Peters. It has been a major issue for a long time. 
But even though you are appointed for or being nominated for 
this, you have not thought about it? It's OK. Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. I am not for privatizing the post office. I 
think it's fixable.
 Senator Peters. So you are opposed to privatizing?
 Mr. Gallo. Did you say something?
 Senator Peters. Did you say you are opposed to privatizing?
 Mr. Gallo. No, I would not privatize the post office.
 Senator Peters. You would not?
 Mr. Gallo. No.
 Senator Peters. I just want to be clear. So that's a no for 
you. Mr. Brodsky, I represent a very diverse State, including 
many very rural communities. The Postal Service is a lifeline 
for those communities, without question. Vital goods, 
prescriptions, all the things that happen. Most folks believe 
that privatizing basically means we are going to have it very 
difficult for our rural communities to get the kind of service 
they are getting right now.
 Do you think those consequences are unacceptable? That if 
rural folks are hurt as a result of privatization, that you 
would think that that is probably as a strong argument against 
privatizing?
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes, I would. Look, there's other reasons why 
privatizing may be difficult, too. I mean, just look at the 
financial condition of the Postal Service with all the unfunded 
retiree benefits. It's a huge amount of money. You would have 
to pay somebody to take it. I don't think that's necessarily 
practical. I think you also lose control over this 
organization. Somebody who's running it as a private enterprise 
would look to cut unprofitable routes, and clearly----
 Senator Peters. That would be rural routes.
 Mr. Brodsky. As Vice Chairman Taub said at the Postal 
Regulatory Commission this past couple weeks ago, June 4, that 
we have to get together and talk about what the universal 
service obligation is and what it should be.
 Senator Peters. I appreciate that. Question to both of you, 
too. We will start with you Mr. Gallo. We will go start back 
and forth here. Does the Postal Service have the authority to 
refuse to mail absentee ballots that are sent to voters by 
election officials?
 Mr. Gallo. No.
 Mr. Brodsky. I agree. No.
 Senator Peters. Pardon me?
 Mr. Brodsky. No.
 Senator Peters. No. OK, good.
 Mr. Woodruff, Congress established the Merit Systems 
Protection Board as part of the same 1978 law to ensure that 
the President and political leaders in the Executive Branch 
cannot fire or punish Federal employees for political, 
arbitrary, or personal reasons. In your view, is it the job of 
the Merit Systems Protection Board to determine when the 
Executive Branch needs to actually follow civil service laws 
passed by Congress and when it can just ignore them?
 Mr. Woodruff. It is up to the board to protect those 
protections that have been brought. That's what we look at when 
we are deciding these cases and having them brought before us 
is what did Congress give us as far as authority goes and 
within that small jurisdiction, whether or not we have the 
authority to act. That's really how confined we keep it.
 Senator Peters. If it's in the law, you don't have the 
ability to make a decision whether or not it's constitutional.
 Mr. Woodruff. That's correct.
 Senator Peters. Because certainly I agree with you that's 
the duty of the board to enforce civil service laws as passed 
by Congress. But I am troubled by the procedural ruling in 
March 2026, where actually the board made the decision that 
they can determine what law is constitutional or not. You would 
agree that the board does not have that authority under our 
U.S. Constitution, that they get to determine what's 
constitutional, what's not?
 Mr. Woodruff. Senator Peters, which specific case are you 
referencing?
 Senator Peters. It is Jackler and Jaroch v. DOJ.
 Mr. Woodruff. As far as that case goes, it's ongoing 
pending litigation with the Federal Circuit, and therefore I 
can't really comment on that.
 Senator Peters. Professor Wilson, at the end of his first 
term in office, President Trump unlawfully took Presidential 
records, including classified information, to his private 
residence. How will you work to ensure that such violation of 
the Presidential Records Act (PRA), which is a very clear 
violation, does not occur at the end of his second term if 
confirmed?
 Mr. Wilson. Thank you for that question, Senator. I am a 
rule of law man, and I intend to follow the law, including on 
the subject of the disposition of Federal records, sir.
 Senator Peters. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. I see in attendance more kids than I have 
ever seen for a nomination hearing, and I want to know who's 
responsible for them. [Laughter.]
 So alright, if I see some fingers pointing to Professor 
Wilson, we have some time, so I am going to let Professor 
Wilson if you remember everybody's name, you can introduce them 
all, or you could introduce if it's more than one family who's 
here to support you.
 Mr. Wilson. Thank you, Senator Paul. I want to thank you 
for being willing to meet with me before this. Yes, I have my 
three children with me. Nathan, Lauren, and Julia. They have 
all of their children with them, so I won't name them all.
 Chairman Paul. How many grandkids do you have here?
 Mr. Wilson. So let's see. Four for Nathan, five for Lauren, 
and two and one on the way for Julia.
 Chairman Paul. Awesome. Thank you for helping to populate 
the earth. That is good.
 [Laughter.]
 Since we did it for one nominee, does any other nominee 
have found family here that they would like to introduce? We 
will just go down the row. If anybody has a wife, family.
 Mr. Berthiaume. None for me, Senator. Thank you.
 Mr. Gallo. None.
 Mr. Woodruff. Dr. Paul, I would like to thank my family 
who's watching. They could not be here today. My wife 
Stephanie, and my three sons. I am also helping populate the 
earth. James, William, and Jack.
 Chairman Paul. Wonderful.
 Mr. Woodruff. They are very busy and they keep us all going 
all the time, so.
 Chairman Paul. Great.
 Mr. Allen. Thank you, Dr. Paul. My wife Beth and my 
daughter. We're not doing as well with populating the earth.
 Chairman Paul. You are trying. That's good, but thank you. 
Senator Hawley.
 Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. 
Congratulations to the nominees. Thanks for being here. I want 
to start by talking a little bit about the Postal Service. But 
let me start with a concern, a long-standing concern that my 
constituents and I have, and it's been expressed time and time 
again. Large parts of Missouri are serviced only by the Postal 
Service. Private entities don't come to many rural parts of my 
State. 68 percent of my State is rural. 68 percent of it is 
serviced by the Postal Service and in many cases, the Postal 
Service alone.
 It is absolutely vital to me that the Postal Service 
remain, continue its commitment to servicing all parts of the 
Nation, including rural areas. They not be disadvantaged vis-a-
vis urban areas. Let me show you a poster here.\1\ This is the 
plan put forward by the last Postmaster General (PG), 
supposedly a reform plan, the Regional Transportation 
Optimization Plan. I get very nervous, by the way, anytime 
bureaucrats start talking about optimization, that usually 
means cutting out people who can least afford.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The poster presented by Senator Hawley appears in the Appendix 
on page 806.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 In this case, if you look at the yellow areas, the yellow 
areas would receive regular service and delivery. The blue 
areas would see their own delivery services reduced. In fact, 
by the Postal Service's own estimate, the number of first-class 
pieces of mail that would be available and would flow on a 
regular basis to these blue areas would be reduced quite 
significantly. The problem is, as you can see, if you look at 
my State of Missouri there, it's almost all blue. It's almost 
all blue.
 Which is one of the reasons why the Missouri Farm Bureau, 
among many other organizations that represent rural Missouri, 
oppose this plan. Let me just start by asking those of you who 
are nominated to the Postal Service, to the governing board, 
will you support the continuing mandated mission of the Postal 
Service to serve the entire country, including the mandate to 
deliver the mail to rural America, rural Missouri included? 
Will you protect that and make sure that that's a top priority? 
Go ahead. We can start with you, Mr. Brodsky.
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes, Senator Hawley. Absolutely. I think that 
again, as Postmaster General Steiner said, he's rolled out 
these systems, but they need to figure out how to operate it 
properly. But I can tell you that if confirmed, I view very 
strongly that all the rural areas should be served properly and 
I will request that management focus on making that happen.
 Senator Hawley. Good.
 Mr. Brodsky. I understand that service levels have declined 
as they rolled out Delivery for America (DFA). I think we have 
to figure out why and what they are going to do to fix it.
 Senator Hawley. Good. Mr. Gallo.
 Mr. Gallo. I totally agree that the rural area should be 
served, without a doubt.
 Senator Hawley. Good. That's absolutely vitally important 
to me. I can tell you, I think it's vital for all of us who 
represent States that have rural areas. Can I just ask you, 
since I have you both here, just another question in this vein 
about the expenditures of the U.S. Postal Service. I mean, 
everybody knows the Postal Service lost about 25 billion over 
the last three fiscal years despite internal reports that would 
only run a $17 billion deficit.
 The current management of the Postal Service projects a 
loss of I think $8 billion for Fiscal Year 2026. This has 
become quite routine. Here's what I want to ask you about. Over 
the last three years that the last postmaster general was in 
office, Mr. DeJoy, the Board of Governors approved $567,000 in 
bonuses for him. Why is that?
 I mean, why is it that when the Postal Service as a 
corporation, as an entity is missing its internal projections, 
when my constituents are being asked to accept deliveries that 
are slow, that are not on time, there's no accountability, when 
I have rural postmasters who are fearing for their jobs, but 
yet the Postmaster General is getting bonuses. Why is that? I 
mean, tell me what you think about that.
 Mr. Brodsky. I can't tell you why the board previously 
approved those kinds of bonuses, but I can tell you that under 
my view, management's going to be held accountable. We have to 
come up with a new plan, long term plan. I know that Postmaster 
Steiner indicated he's prepared to do that. I think that they 
are probably working on it right now. I think there needs to be 
goal set. In the event they don't hit their goals, they are not 
going to get those bonuses. At least I won't support them.
 Senator Hawley. OK, good. So you are saying that you would 
not support additional compensation and bonuses----
 Mr. Brodsky. No.
 Senator Hawley [continuing]. If the Postal Service 
continues to run these deficits. Let me just put a finer point 
on this. So long as my State continues to suffer the kind of 
incredible backlogs that it is suffering--and I have mentioned 
rural Missouri, but it's our cities too. It's Kansas City, it's 
St. Louis on the east and west parts of the State, and then 
it's all of rural Missouri. I mean, they are suffering massive 
delays three, four, five, six days in rural Missouri. Sometimes 
it's weeks. It's outrageous. It's been going on for years now.
 Frankly, I think it's indefensible that we are paying out 
these bonuses when my constituents, who are paying their taxes 
faithfully, and they are paying their postal service, the 
stamps and everything else, all the rates, they can't get the 
mail. I guess my question to you is, will you cease to vote for 
bonuses for management until the mail gets delivered on time to 
the State of Missouri and everywhere else, Mr. Brodsky?
 Mr. Brodsky. I would support putting in place metrics that 
management must perform to, and I would not support paying 
bonuses at those levels. It might be a much lower level. That's 
acceptable. I don't know if it's zero. I think it's something 
we have to look at on a case by case basis. But if they don't 
meet their goals, they shouldn't be getting paid.
 Senator Hawley. Why should there be any bonus? We are not 
talking about withholding their salary. Why should they be 
getting bonuses if people aren't getting the mail delivered?
 Mr. Brodsky. But there's compensation theory that you have 
to look at in terms of you have to pay people appropriately.
 Senator Hawley. You don't pay them to not do the work. If 
people in Missouri aren't getting the mail, why should the 
Postmaster General be getting a bonus?
 Mr. Brodsky. I agree with you that if they are not meeting 
their objectives, they should not get bonus.
 Senator Hawley. The objective is to deliver the mail. I 
will just say for the record, so long as the people of Missouri 
aren't getting their mail, I don't want the Postmaster General 
or any other bureaucrat in Washington getting a bonus. I want 
the mail delivered to Missouri on time in every community that 
we are entitled to by law. Until that happens, I don't want 
anybody getting a bonus. Will you commit to that, Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. Absolutely. It makes no sense to be giving a 
bonus to him or any of the management people if they are not 
performing the services, if you are losing money, it makes no 
sense to me. In private industry, that would not happen.
 Senator Hawley. That's exactly right. That's exactly the 
standard I want to see. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. We had this discussion years ago, and the 
response they gave me, Senator Hawley, was well, to have 
talent, you got to really pay people to have talent, and my 
response was, how much talent does it take to lose $9 billion a 
year? [Laughter.]
 I agree with you. There's no reason. You don't give people 
a bonus for losing $9 billion. We shifted $107 billion to the 
general fund. That was the reform. We just took it from one 
account, put it in another, and they are still losing 9 
billion. It's an absolute and utter failure. Senator 
Blumenthal.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. I think we have 
bipartisan agreement, no bonuses for failure. Would you agree 
with that principle, Mr. Brodsky?
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes. Yes, sir.
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. Yes, sir.
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Berthiaume, you are nominated for 
one of the most critical jobs in the U.S. Government, which is 
to assure the independence integrity of the Department of 
Justice. Would you agree with me that independence is 
absolutely essential in that role?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Independence is absolutely essential to the 
Office of the Inspector General's role, yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. You have served as Inspector General, 
or you have been involved in Inspector General activities in 
other departments, correct?
 Mr. Berthiaume. I have been part of the inspector general 
community for almost 16 years now.
 Senator Blumenthal. You would agree with me that resisting 
weaponization or politicization of the Department of Justice 
will be a critical part of your role?
 Mr. Berthiaume. I think it's a critical part of the Office 
of Inspector General's (OIG) role to assess and evaluate the 
department's functioning of its responsibilities, yes.
 Senator Blumenthal. So let me test your independence. Who 
won the 2020 election?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Joe Biden, as certified by the Senate.
 Senator Blumenthal. No, Mr. Berthiaume, who won the 2020 
election? We have seen that script, by the way. You should 
check with the White House. That script has been abandoned. 
They have a new one.
 Mr. Berthiaume. My understanding from the 2020 election is 
we had an election.
 Senator Blumenthal. And who won?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Joe Biden was certified the winner of that 
election. That is a fact.
 Senator Blumenthal. Who won the popular vote?
 Mr. Berthiaume. From what I recall and reporting at the 
time, that was Joe Biden.
 Senator Blumenthal. Who won the Electoral College in the 
2020 election?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Again, my recollection and he served as 
President, Joe Biden would have been certified the winner of 
the Electoral College vote as well.
 Senator Blumenthal. Did you discuss your answers to these 
questions with the White House before coming here today?
 Mr. Berthiaume. No.
 Senator Blumenthal. Let me ask you. Was the Capitol 
attacked on January 6th?
 Mr. Berthiaume. I don't know if I would use the term 
attack. I mean, we had activity outside the Capitol, protests 
and such, and there was violence on the Capitol grounds.
 Senator Blumenthal. You have to be now the author of the 
most obvious understatement, that there was activity outside 
the Capitol on January 6th. Was it attacked? You have seen the 
videos. You are supposed to be the Inspector General. Capitol 
police were injured, some died. Was the Capitol attacked?
 Mr. Berthiaume. So again, it's more a term that you are 
using, attacked. There was protest activity. There was violence 
on Capitol grounds. Those people were prosecuted.
 Senator Blumenthal. There was protest activity?
 Mr. Berthiaume. There was protest activity. People went to 
the Capitol grounds. People entered the Capitol building, which 
is contrary, as far as I know, to law.
 Senator Blumenthal. But you wouldn't agree with me that the 
Capitol was attacked?
 Mr. Berthiaume. I just don't agree with the term attack.
 Senator Blumenthal. Were police officers attacked on that 
day?
 Mr. Berthiaume. There was physical violence outside the 
Capitol that day.
 Senator Blumenthal. But the Capitol Police weren't 
attacked? What is it about that word that so troubles you?
 Mr. Berthiaume. It's not that I'm troubled by it. The term 
attack, to me seems to imply, like there was a coordinated 
effort to attack specific things.
 There was physical violence associated with protest----
 Senator Blumenthal. I regard these kinds of questions as a 
test of your prospective independence. So far, I think you are 
failing that test.
 Mr. Berthiaume. OK.
 Senator Blumenthal. I hope my colleagues will agree that 
the Inspector General of the Department of Justice should 
recognize reality and facts for what they are and be willing to 
call them out for what they are. Let me ask you, can you assure 
me, if you are confirmed, that your office will conduct a 
thorough investigation to allegations that Director Patel 
engaged in drinking and absences that have interfered with his 
ability to do his job?
 Mr. Berthiaume. What I can commit to is to assess the 
allegations, run them through the analysis that we do, and we 
are going to decide whether or not to open up a case. We will 
see if there's work to do in that arena.
 Senator Blumenthal. Will you commit that you will complete 
the audit and inquiry that has begun into the concealment of 
the Epstein files? You will recall that Senator Murkowski and I 
wrote you asking for the audit. You will commit to do it?
 Mr. Berthiaume. We will finish our audit of the Epstein 
files Transparency Act.
 Senator Blumenthal. When will it be done?
 Mr. Berthiaume. My goal is one year from when we announced. 
That is a goal, we are going to push for that. Obviously, 
there's things that could pop up on occasion that slow things 
down, but we are going to push through that as well. Our goal 
is to be as efficient and as accurate as possible in that 
audit.
 Senator Blumenthal. Will you agree to engage in 
investigation of the retaliatory firings of agents at the FBI?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Again, what I will do is we will assess 
whether or not there's an arena for there to take action. As we 
have done----
 Senator Blumenthal. Will you respond to that question after 
you review it if you are confirmed?
 Mr. Berthiaume. I am happy to talk to your office after we 
have reviewed and analyzed and assessed those cases----
 Senator Blumenthal. What about loyalty tests at the FBI? 
Will you review any and investigate the use of loyalty tests 
there?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Again, we will assess all allegations and 
we will run them through our process and see if there's work 
for us to do there.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Professor Wilson, you and I talked in the 
office some about, normally you don't think of the archivist as 
being a really controversial position, but there was a 
controversy in recent years talking about whether the archivist 
had the power to enroll or certify that an amendment to the 
Constitution had occurred. Particularly with the Equal Rights 
Amendment (ERA). The debate was over. I think the enrolling 
document or the initiating document had a timeline.
 Some of the States approved it outside the timeline. Some 
of the States had taken away theirs. We asked the previous 
archivist and she answered that she did not have the power to 
make that decision or to say the ERA had passed. Do you agree 
with that opinion or just give me your opinion on that?
 Mr. Wilson. Thank you. Thank you, Senator, for that 
question. The Equal Rights Amendment, was passed back in 1972. 
The proposing resolution, which had a number of procedural 
requirements for the amendment to be considered ratified, 
included a deadline for ratification of seven years. That 
deadline passed and a number of States continued to vote to 
ratify after the deadline. A number of States rescinded their 
vote previously to ratify.
 This question came before the Archivist of the United 
States, who I imagine shares my view, that--unfortunate the 
archivist should ever be in the position to settle 
constitutional controversies. But in this case, the archivist 
agreed with--who was appointed, by the way, by President Biden 
and whose President Biden's Justice Department argued that it 
had not been ratified because of the deadline that had passed. 
She agreed with that decision and said she could not certify it 
for legal, judicial, procedural reasons.
 The deputy archivist, who was a career civil servant, 
agreed with that opinion. They stated their opinions publicly. 
I agree with their opinion and I intend to stick with it. Thank 
you.
 Chairman Paul. The other issue you and I talked about is I 
am interested in reading the classified annex to the Church 
Committee report from the 1970s. It just goes to how, the over 
classification thing. I don't know that you will have the power 
to help me, but I would just like to hear on record that things 
that are 50 years old that the law allows you to declassify, 
that you will pursue declassification within the law.
 Mr. Wilson. Thank you, Senator. The National Archives is 
charged with collecting, processing, and making available to 
the American public, to researchers, to the government the 
records of the national government. Those records obviously 
include both classified and unclassified documents. There's a 
process for dealing with both those kinds of documents.
 That some documents are classified is a product of agency 
decisions and congressional decisions. The archivist can be a 
nudge, I suppose, and try to get action taken to declassify 
documents that are wrongly classified. There are many of them. 
I understand. I would be happy to work with you, Senator, with 
your team to see if we can advance the declassification of the 
church documents.
 Chairman Paul. Mr. Gallo, I commend you for your optimism 
that the Post Office can be fixed. We should put that and frame 
that. I hope you are right. But it's looked for 30 years like 
an unfixable problem. We are going to have the Postmaster 
General come in in the next couple of weeks, and what I have 
asked him to present to us is if you could fix it, what will 
you do?
 Because most of the things to fix it are either unpopular. 
Everybody wants the mail least, if not once a day, twice a day, 
if not five days, six days, nobody wants to give up anything, 
but something has to give. A big part of the cost is 80 percent 
of the cost of delivering the mail is labor cost. In United 
Parcel Service (UPS), which is unionized, but it's not a 
government union, it's a private union, it's about 50 percent 
cost for labor. Federal Express (FedEx), which is non 
unionized, it's about 38 percent. So that gives you an example 
of one of the big problems we face.
 I think another big problem we will go over this with him 
as well, is just insourcing versus outsourcing. DeJoy decided 
he would add 120,000 employees. Government employees cost more 
than private employees. They are not as good because they don't 
have a profit incentive. And so the bigger the Post Office 
gets, the more money they will lose. I thought DeJoy would 
understand that. He never understood it and got worse, and the 
losses got worse.
 They were losing four billion a year 10 years ago. Now we 
are losing nine billion a year. So you are welcome to comment 
then I have a specific question, but if you have ideas for it, 
we would love to hear your ideas on how we are going to fix the 
Post office.
 Mr. Gallo. As a businessman, it's hard for me to understand 
that the Postal Service has $80 billion in revenue, has the 
network to deliver mail directly to households all over this 
country and business entities, has the ability to borrow up to 
$15 billion and you are losing money. It's crazy. Why I think 
it's fixable is because you are losing $10 billion. You have to 
raise the revenue by $5 billion and you have to reduce your 
cost by $5 billion. That all has to be looked at.
 You have the Delivery for America program that was 
established in March 2021, and I read it and many of the points 
that they made made sense to me. But you are six years into 
this program. You are supposed to make it a break even over a 
10 year period. You are six years into it and you are still 
losing the same amount of money. Obviously all of those points 
that were made in the Delivery for America program has to be 
looked at. What's working, what's not working.
 From there you have to really dive into why it's not 
working and change it. Obviously the workforce at over 600,000 
people is too high. You need to figure out who's performing, 
who's coming to work and who's not, who's getting paid and not 
coming to work. All of this has to be looked at. That's why I 
say I think it's fixable.
 Chairman Paul. All I would say is be bold. Trimming around 
the corners isn't going to do it. So be bold. We have to try to 
fix it. We have to try to do something better. Senator Slotkin.
 Senator Slotkin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Welcome to the 
panel everyone. For those who are seeking to be on the Board of 
Governors for the Postal Service, you have heard bipartisan 
interest in getting this right and the importance that so many 
of us who live in rural places have on the Postal Service and 
wanting it to be successful.
 The questions I have are related to some things that the 
President has said about mail in voting and the role of the 
Postal Service. Just this month, the President has tried to put 
out rules following an Executive Order (EO) where he's trying 
to frankly prevent mail in voting. But he's trying to say that 
the U.S. Postal Service should have a role in deciding who gets 
to vote by mail.
 He's said over and over that he thinks mail in voting isn't 
safe, even though there are States where the entire State votes 
by mail. I just want to ask, do you believe that the U.S. 
Postal Service has a role in adjudicating who gets to vote in 
this country? Mr. Brodsky, do you want to start?
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes. I think the Postal Service needs to 
receive the ballots and deliver them as quickly as possible.
 Senator Slotkin. Should I have to get your approval as 
Board of Governor members to vote in my own State?
 Mr. Brodsky. We will follow the law, and as far as I know, 
that's not yet the law, and I understand that there was a 
proposal made, and I assume that that'll be clarified and we 
will do whatever is required under the law.
 Senator Slotkin. Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. I read the Executive Order by President Trump 
and it created a lot of legal disputes and public debate. As 
far as I am concerned, you have to have the courts and Congress 
make the decision.
 Senator Slotkin. Do you believe that mail in voting now is 
safe and secure?
 Mr. Gallo. That's a very good question. I would say under 
the proper guidance and monitoring, yes, I do.
 Senator Slotkin. I mean, for instance, President Trump won 
my State in 2024, and there was a ton of mail in voting. Was 
that voting for President Trump safe and secure, or no?
 Mr. Gallo. It was safe and secure.
 Senator Slotkin. Have you ever voted by mail?
 Mr. Gallo. Never.
 Senator Slotkin. Mr. Brodsky, have you voted by mail?
 Mr. Brodsky. Yes, I have.
 Senator Slotkin. Presumably you feel the system was safe 
and secure.
 Mr. Brodsky. It was a wonderful way to vote, and I did it 
three times.
 Senator Slotkin. OK, great. Love to hear that. I think the 
President has just made very clear, including in the State of 
the Union, where we were all in the room, that if his side 
doesn't win in November, then the election was rigged and he's 
using every which way he can to figure out how to swing the 
election his way. The latest round is to say that you all will 
have to approve who gets to vote. I have a fundamental problem 
with that and hope that you push back in the spirit of 
democracy.
 Turning to our Department of Justice nominee here. You 
know, I am interested in the fact that you are up for the 
inspector general, which is the watchdog of the Department of 
Justice, and you have been serving in the office as a senior 
advisor or in some capacity for the past year-and-a-half. Is 
that right?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Only since October.
 Senator Slotkin. Only since October, OK. So you have seen 
there. I was investigated by the Department of justice for a 90 
second video that I produced with Senator Kelly and four 
others. It went to a grand jury where they tried to criminally 
indict me for 90 second video that quoted the Uniform Code of 
Military Justice, and a grand jury unanimously said, no, that 
was ridiculous.
 This is on top of the Department of Justice going after and 
failing to prosecute Letitia James, Lisa Cook, James Comey, 
Mark Kelly, and myself, a bunch of others. You passed the bar 
in New York and D.C. where there is a ban on frivolous 
lawsuits.
 Have you received any information in the capacity that you 
have been serving in of either waste, fraud, and abuse for 
these repeated and failed lawsuits or any complaint of any kind 
for the weaponization of the Department of Justice against 
people like myself?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Sure, it's a fair question. We do not have 
jurisdiction over the conduct of attorneys at the Department of 
Justice. That actually belongs to DOJ's Office of Professional 
Responsibility (OPR). That's a carve out in the law that says 
any decisions that a DOJ attorney makes in the course of acting 
as an attorney for the Department falls under their 
jurisdiction. That's not something that would come to us.
 Senator Slotkin. I guess the question is, do you believe 
that, going after the President's opponents and filing failed 
lawsuit after failed lawsuit after failed lawsuit qualifies for 
waste, fraud, and abuse of taxpayer dollars? In general.
 Mr. Berthiaume. So general----
 Senator Slotkin. You would be disbarred for doing it, or it 
would be under investigation if you were a practicing attorney 
in New York or D.C. for over and over and over again launching 
failed lawsuits that fail in front of a grand jury unanimously, 
which I understand is hard to do. Do you believe that repeated 
and consistent failed lawsuits by the Department of Justice is 
something that qualifies in your capacity as waste, fraud, and 
abuse?
 Mr. Berthiaume. So again, those are very fact specific 
questions. And again, we do not analyze decisions that are made 
by Department of Justice attorneys. Just doesn't come into our 
bailiwick. We also do not have authority to review or assess 
rather how the Department makes its policy decisions on how it 
chooses cases. That's not within the Act.
 Senator Slotkin. So if someone came to you with a complaint 
claiming waste, fraud, and abuse or weaponization, you wouldn't 
be able to hear that complaint? You would choose not to hear 
and deal with those complaints?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Not that we would not choose to do it. It 
just wouldn't fall within our jurisdiction. That would go to 
OPR.
 Senator Slotkin. I see. What do you do and what do you 
believe the job description is for the job that you are 
applying for?
 Mr. Berthiaume. We look at fraud, waste, and abuse in the 
Department's operations. All right? It would be things like how 
are contracts handled by the department? We also look at how 
the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) is doing its job to ensure that 
it's doing better. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and 
Explosives (ATF), Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), FBI. 
We look at the way the Department operates in its 
functionality. So if there's misconduct, let's say, related to 
the way any of those agencies are acting.
 For example, when we did the FISA abuse case, we were 
looking at how the FBI executed its FISA authorities. Because 
of that specific carve out with attorneys, it limits our 
ability to look at the way the department is exercising its 
prosecutorial functions.
 Senator Slotkin. Yes, it seems hard to believe that someone 
who's asking to be or seeking nomination and confirmation to be 
the inspector general of the Department of Justice has 
seemingly no role in accountability on how the time and money 
is spent in weaponized prosecutions of American citizens. I 
certainly think predecessors of yours would maybe have a 
different definition of the job, but I appreciate that you just 
have to follow the law.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Gallego.
 Senator Gallego. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 Mr. Allen, in the 1990s, you founded a conservative campus 
publication called the Carolina Review. If you look behind me, 
you will see the front cover of an edition of the Carolina 
Review depicting Aaron Nelson, a Jewish candidate for student 
body president. Your magazine altered Nelson's photo depicting 
him with the horns and a pitchfork. Inside the article says, 
``The difference between Aaron Nelson is simple. He's Jewish.'' 
Yes or no, Mr. Nelson, do you stand by this depiction?
 Mr. Allen. Sorry. I'm Mr. Allen, not Mr. Nelson. But in 
terms of that cover, if I were 30 years ago advocating for The 
Review, I would say don't run that cover. I think it was a 
mistake. That said, if you look at full context of the article, 
you are taking a quote out of context.
 Senator Gallego. OK, so may take the quote out of context, 
but that's not being taken out of context, right, the pitchfork 
with the horns?
 Mr. Allen. Right.
 Senator Gallego. Is that because that's kind of hard to get 
out of context?
 Mr. Allen. In terms of the University of North Carolina at 
Chapel Hill, our chief rival was the Blue Devils, still are the 
Blue Devils. The cartoonist's intention was to make an analogy 
to that.
 Senator Gallego. Everything happened was just a total 
coincidence that the Jewish candidate happened to have a 
pitchfork and horns and that also at the same time inside the 
context of the difference with Nelson is simple, he's Jewish. 
The difference being between them and the Blue Devil. So the 
difference is that he is a Jewish versus a Blue Devil. Is that 
what your defense is?
 Mr. Allen. No, sir. The point is this, Mr. Nelson voted not 
to fund a Christian group. He voted to fund the Jewish group. 
He voted to fund the Pagan group. But on two separate times he 
voted not to fund InterVarsity Christian Fellowship. It raises 
a conflict of interest when he was a member of a group that he 
voted for.
 Senator Gallego. You certainly remember in detail this 
incident in question for someone who wants to forget it. Do you 
stand by the statement that was made of that time period 
regarding Mr. Nelson then?
 Mr. Allen. What statement are you referring?
 Senator Gallego. I would say overall, this anti-Semitic 
statement and depiction of this gentleman.
 Mr. Allen. I would not say that it's anti-Semitic. We were 
the group that was calling for the equal treatment of all 
student religions.
 Senator Gallego. So it's not anti-Semitic to say the 
difference with Nelson is simple, he's Jewish. The difference 
between a Blue Devil and Nelson is the fact that he's Jewish. 
You stand by that, then?
 Mr. Allen. The point was this, he voted for the Jewish 
group, and on two separate occasions, he voted not to fund the 
Christian group. We said the Jewish group was entitled to be 
funded. I stand by that.
 Senator Gallego. What's your official title you are going 
for?
 Mr. Allen. Pardon?
 Senator Gallego. What is the official title here that you 
are interviewing for?
 Mr. Allen. The official title?
 Senator Gallego. What's the official title, what you are 
interviewing here? What are you here answering questions for? 
You are here to be the Federal Labor Relations Authority 
General Counsel. Is that correct?
 Mr. Allen. Correct.
 Senator Gallego. What is under the purview of your job as 
general counsel for the Federal Labor Relations Authority?
 Mr. Allen. That's spelled out in Title 5, Chapter 71, 
7104D. The general counsel is to investigate potential unfair 
labor practices and make a determination whether an Unfair 
Labor Practice (ULP) has occurred and then prosecute that 
before the authority if there is a prima facie case.
 Senator Gallego. Got you. So after hearing this and seeing 
this, why would I trust that you are going to be able to take 
care of our Jewish community? Because there seems to have been 
something that happened 30 years ago, if that's the right time 
period, that certainly made you justify being able to do this 
to a private citizen, even though you were a private citizen 
then.
 Mr. Allen. Senator, in all due respect, I would encourage 
you to look at my record as a chief judicial officer and chief 
executive officer of the North Carolina Industrial Commission, 
where at all times I treated all parties before me with 
fairness, dignity, and respect without regard to any personal 
characteristics.
 Senator Gallego. Now, Mr. Allen, just one more time to 
explain to me the quote is, ``The difference with Nelson is 
simple. He's Jewish.'' What was exactly trying to be 
communicated there? Because I think that seems to be fairly 
blatant anti-Semitic.
 Mr. Allen. I don't agree that it is anti-Semitic. It was a 
quote that you are taking out of context about his voting 
record where he voted not to treat the Christian group with the 
same respect as his own group.
 Senator Gallego. I yield back.
 Chairman Paul. We are getting close to the end. I am going 
to ask another question or so, and then I think Senator Peters 
has another question or two, and then I think we will be 
finished up.
 Mr. Berthiaume, my office has asked the DOJ IG to 
investigate some of the confidential human resources (HR) with 
regard to Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Origins, 
Crossfire Hurricane, Quiet Skies. Some of these people that 
were paid by the FBI. What's come to light is that, we pay 
experts for their opinion sometimes, but if we are paying 
experts that were actually involved with the action, then maybe 
we are not paying the right people. But we need to know who was 
paid and how much. The IG is investigating that.
 We would like to ask that we will have a completion of that 
and that we will get that information. With now the CIA, the 
Department of Energy (DOE), and the FBI all concluding that the 
virus originated in a lab in Wuhan, we really wouldn't want our 
experts to be people who actually were receiving money with and 
working with the lab in Wuhan.
 These are important things, I think, for a conflict of 
interest and just for the historical record so this doesn't 
happen again. Will you commit to complete those investigations 
that we have asked for?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Yes, sir. I believe we are working with 
your staff on that as well.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you. Senator Peters.
 Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Berthiaume, President Trump violated the Inspector 
General Act When he fired 19 inspector generals--the most 
recent just about a week ago--without submitting to Congress 
the required 30 day notification with a substantive rationale. 
So my question for you, sir, is yes or no, do you acknowledge 
that President Trump violated the requirements of the IG Act?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Yes, I believe a court recently came to 
that same conclusion. Storch v. Hegseth determined that the 
President violated the IG Act, but also held that there was no 
irreparable harm to the IGs by his----
 Senator Peters. But you agree that he violated the Act?
 Mr. Berthiaume. Yes, I agree with the court's decision on 
that one.
 Senator Peters. Mr. Gallo and Brodsky, the Postal 
Regulatory Commission, as you know, is an independent body that 
provides oversight to the USPS and ensures that their product 
pricing complies with the law. Earlier this year, though, the 
Postal Service petitioned the PRC to change its regulations and 
to grant the Board of Governors the authority to unilaterally 
set postal pricing for a five year period. The petition I know 
is pending right now, but I am sure you are both aware of that 
because it's been pretty big issue.
 My question for both of you is, if confirmed, do you commit 
to support and maintain the mission of the Postal Regulatory 
Commission to provide independent regulation and oversight over 
the Postal Service to ensure that they don't abuse their 
monopoly on market dominant mail?
 Mr. Brodsky. Absolutely. I have great regard for what work 
they are doing. I was very impressed by them and I think that 
we have to work with them cooperatively. They have a great team 
there and a lot can be done to help fix what we got here.
 Senator Peters. Thank you. Mr. Gallo?
 Mr. Gallo. I agree. We need to work very closely with the 
PRC. I have no issue with it at all.
 Senator Peters. So both of you will support their mission. 
I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you all\1\ for appearing today\2\ and 
for your answers.\3\ The nominees of both panels\4\ have filed 
responses\5\ to biographical\6\ and financial 
questionnaires,\7\ answered pre hearing questions\8\ submitted 
by the Committee,\9\ and had their financial statements\10\ 
reviewed by the Office of Government Ethics.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The information for Mr. Duncan appears in the Appendix on page 
51.
 \2\ The information for Mr. Cavanaugh appears in the Appendix on 
page 136.
 \3\ The information for Mr. Cummins appears in the Appendix on page 
181.
 \4\ The information for Mr. Hamilton appears in the Appendix on 
page 228.
 \5\ The information for Mr. Baldis appears in the Appendix on page 
291.
 \6\ The information for Mr. Wilson appears in the Appendix on page 
341.
 \7\ The information for Mr. Berthiaume appears in the Appendix on 
page 498.
 \8\ The information for Mr. Brodsky appears in the Appendix on page 
534.
 \9\ The information for Mr. Gallo appears in the Appendix on page 
616.
 \10\ The information for Mr. Woodruff appears in the Appendix on 
page 681.
 \11\ The information for Mr. Allen appears in the Appendix on page 
736.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Additionally, the Committee has received letters of support 
for the nominees. Without objection this information will be 
made part of the hearing record with the exception of the 
nominees' financial data which are on file with the 
Committee.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \12\ The letters of support appear in the Appendix on page 284.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Chairman Paul. The hearing record will remain open till 5 
p.m. on Friday, June 19. The hearing is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 11:19 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.]

 A P P E N D I X

 ---------- 

[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 [all]