NOMINATIONS OF HON. JAMES A. CROWELL IV, HON. STUART G. NASH, CHRISTOPHER M. DEBONO, MICHAEL C. DILORENZO, SHARON E. GOODIE, CRAIG E. LEEN, CHRISTINE M. MACEY, AND JOHN B. TIMMER

Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Senate June 23, 2026

Witnesses (8)

  • Hon. James A. Crowell IV to be Associate Judge, District of Columbia Court of Appeals Prepared statement
  • Hon. Stuart G. Nash to be Associate Judge, District of Columbia Court of Appeals Prepared statement
  • Christohpher M. DeBono to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement
  • Michael C. DiLorenzo to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement
  • Sharon E. Goodie to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement
  • Craig E. Leen to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement
  • Christine M. Macey to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement
  • John B. Timmer to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the District of Columbia Prepared statement

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- NOMINATIONS OF HON. JAMES A. CROWELL IV, HON. STUART G. NASH, CHRISTOPHER M. DEBONO, MICHAEL C. DILORENZO, SHARON E. GOODIE, CRAIG E. LEEN, CHRISTINE M. MACEY, AND JOHN B. TIMMER

[Senate Hearing 119-475]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-475

 NOMINATIONS OF HON. JAMES A. CROWELL IV,
 HON. STUART G. NASH,
 CHRISTOPHER M. DeBONO,
 MICHAEL C. DiLORENZO, SHARON E. GOODIE,
 CRAIG E. LEEN, CHRISTINE M. MACEY, AND 
 JOHN B. TIMMER
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEOFRE THE

 COMMITTEE ON
 HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 NOMINATIONS OF HON. JAMES A. CROWELL IV AND
 HON. STUART G. NASH TO BE ASSOCIATE JUDGES, DISTRICT
 OF COLUMBIA COURT OF APPEALS; CHRISTOPHER M. DEBONO,
 MICHAEL C. DILORENZO, SHARON E. GOODIE, CRAIG E. LEEN,
CHRISTINE M. MACEY, AND JOHN B. TIMMER TO BE ASSOCIATE JUDGES, SUPERIOR 
 COURT OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

 __________

 JUNE 23, 2026

 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov

 Printed for the use of the
 Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs

[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-123 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
======================================================================= 

 COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

 RAND PAUL, Kentucky, Chairman
RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin GARY C. PETERS, Michigan
JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma MAGGIE WOOD HASSAN, New Hampshire
RICK SCOTT, Florida RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania
BERNIE MORENO, Ohio ANDY KIM, New Jersey
JONI ERNST, Iowa RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ELISSA SLOTKIN, Michigan

 William E. Henderson III, Staff Director
 Christina N. Salazar, Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel
 Harry Kazenoff, Assistant Counsel
 Vijay Menon, Legistlative Director, Office of Senator Hawley
 David M. Weinberg, Minority Staff Director
 Christopher J. Mulkins, Minority Policy Director
 Claudine J. Brenner, Minority Deputy General Counsel
 Laura W. Kilbride, Chief Clerk
 Ashley A. Gonzalez, Records Clerk

 C O N T E N T S

 ------ 
Opening statements:
 Page
 Senator Hawley............................................... 1
 Senator Kim.................................................. 2
 Senator Blumenthal........................................... 15

 WITNESSES
 TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 2026

Hon. James A. Crowell IV to be Associate Judge, District of 
 Columbia Court of Appeals
 Prepared statement........................................... 21
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 22
Hon. Stuart G. Nash to be Associate Judge, District of Columbia 
 Court of Appeals
 Prepared statement........................................... 53
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 54
Christohpher M. DeBono to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of 
 the District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 75
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 76
Michael C. DiLorenzo to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the 
 District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 97
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 98
Sharon E. Goodie to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the 
 District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 119
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 120
Craig E. Leen to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the 
 District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 147
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 148
Christine M. Macey to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the 
 District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 180
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 181
John B. Timmer to be Associate Judge, Superior Court of the 
 District of Columbia
 Prepared statement........................................... 202
 Biographical and professional information with attachments... 203

 
 NOMINATIONS OF
 HON. JAMES A. CROWELL IV,
 HON. STUART G. NASH,
 CHRISTOPHER M. DEBONO,
 MICHAEL C. DILORENZO, SHARON E. GOODIE,
 CRAIG E. LEEN, CHRISTINE M. MACEY, AND
 JOHN B. TIMMER

 ---------- 

 TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 2026

 U.S. Senate, 
 Committee on Homeland Security 
 and Governmental Affairs,
 Washington, DC.
 The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:17 a.m., in 
room SD-342, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Josh Hawley, 
presiding.
 Present: Senators Hawley [presiding], Lankford, Scott, 
Moreno, Ernst, Moody, Kim, Hassan, and Blumenthal.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HAWLEY

 Senator Hawley. Good morning. Let me welcome everybody to 
this hearing of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental 
Affairs Committee (HSGAC). Today, the full Committee will be 
considering eight nominations to the D.C. Superior Court and 
the D.C. Court of Appeals. I want to thank the nominees for 
being here, but it's a full docket we have in front of us. We 
look forward to hearing from you. Despite the fact that my 
colleagues are fleeing the room, believe me, they are they are 
eager to ask you questions. It's great to have Ranking Member 
Kim here with me today, and I look forward to a terrific 
hearing. The children are welcome in the room as well, so the 
more the merrier.
 Let me just say a word about the significance of today's 
hearing. We have many open spots vacancies, both on the D.C. 
Court of Appeals and the D.C. Superior Court. These are vitally 
important courts to the safety of the capital city, to the 
well-functioning of the capital city. I think one indication of 
that is we have with us in attendance today the chief judge of 
the D.C. Court of Appeals, as well as the Chief Judge of the 
D.C. Superior Court. We welcome both of you. I think your 
presence attests to the significance of this hearing, and the 
significance of the panels that we are going to be hoping to 
fill with these nominations today.
 There are significant backlog currently pending in the 
Superior Court, for example. More than 100,000 cases, were 
pending in the Superior Court at the start of the last year. 
Tens of thousands of those remain unresolved this year. 
Criminal trials are now running months longer than they did 
just before the pandemic. Some homicide and violent felony 
cases, which are the most serious matters the city faces, won't 
see trial until 2027. You just think about the number of 
victims' families that are waiting for answers, defendants who 
are sitting in jail without their day in court, and 
unfortunately, all too often, dangerous people back on the 
street while the docket sits untouched.
 The Court of Appeals has its own vacancy problems, ones 
that has gone unaddressed for years. Every empty seat on either 
court is a case that does not get heard in a timely manner, a 
docket that does not move, a family that is left without 
answers, and that is why this hearing really matters.
 Here's our order of procedure today. I am going to turn it 
over to Ranking Member Kim to make his opening statement. Then, 
I am going to swear in and introduce briefly each of our 
nominees. With the consent from my colleagues, which I hope 
that they will give, we are going to enter your opening 
statements into the record,\1\ and then I am going to give you 
a chance in lieu of a lengthy opening statement, we will put 
those into the record for you, but I want to give you a chance 
to introduce any family members or other special guests you may 
have with you today, and then we will jump right into 
questions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The opening statements appear in the Appendix on page 21.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 But first, let me turn it over to Ranking Member Kim.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR KIM

 Senator Kim. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you 
Chairman Paul, for moving forward with these nominees. I am 
appreciative of filling in for Ranking Member Peters, for 
allowing me to step in today for this really important hearing. 
While this should not be a spectacular thing, I also want to 
take note that the nominations before us today came through the 
proper channels via the D.C. Judicial Nominations Commission, 
as required by law. To the nominees, congratulations, and thank 
you for your dedication to public service.
 For years, D.C. has struggled to fill local judicial 
vacancies. That is because, unlike States, they have their own 
process to place people on the bench. In D.C., we must follow a 
Federal process of Presidential appointment and Senate 
confirmation, despite the fact that these are not Federal 
judges. Unfortunately, this has historically led to long delays 
in confirming new judges, and the D.C. legal and public safety 
systems have suffered as a result. Still, it's critical we move 
forward in this process to place forward and confirm judges who 
demonstrate that they are qualified during the vetting process.
 Filling the vacancies on the Superior Court and the Court 
of Appeals will allow D.C. to tackle its case backlog and give 
people timely access to their day in court. This is a unique 
role of this particular committee, and I think it's important 
for the Members that we take this seriously, that we on top of 
what we are trying to do with legislation, with Federal level 
confirmations, the ability for us to be stewards and look after 
our capital is so important to play our role and to be able to 
lift up those that will be doing this work day in and day out.
 Again, thank you for stepping up, and I look forward to 
this hearing.
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Thank you, Senator Kim. It's the 
practice of the Committee to swear in our witnesses. I will ask 
you now to rise and raise your right hand. If you would and 
respond to me. Do you swear that the testimony you are about to 
give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, 
so help you, God?
 [Witnesses answer in the affirmative.]
 Let the record reflect all the witnesses answered in the 
affirmative. Now, let me, without objection, enter each of your 
opening statements into the record.
 Now, we will just go down the line here. We will start with 
you, Mr. Crowell. I will have a brief introduction for each of 
you, and once I do that, we will give you the opportunity to 
introduce any family members or other guests you may have with 
you.
 Our first nominee is James Crowell.
 The Hon. Judge James Crowell. Judge Crowell is an Associate 
Judge (AJ) in the civil division of the Superior Court of the 
District of Columbia. He previously served in leadership roles 
at the Department of Justice (DOJ) and as a United States 
Attorney in the District of Maryland. Judge Crowell has a long 
and distinguished career as well in the United States Army 
Reserves. Thanks for being here today.
 Next is Mr. Stuart Nash. Mr. Nash is a partner at Holland & 
Knight, where he practices in the White-collar Defense and 
Governmental Investigations divisions. He previously served as 
an associate judge on the Superior Court of the District of 
Columbia from 2010 to 2016. Before that, he had a long tenure 
as a prosecutor at both the Department of Justice and the 
United States Attorney's Office here in the District of D.C. 
Welcome, Mr. Nash.
 Mr. Christopher De Bono, Senior Counsel at the DOJ's Office 
of Legal Policy (OLP), where he leads efforts to develop and 
implement DOJ's policy objectives, including those concerning 
drugs, firearms, violent crime, and digital assets. Before his 
service at OLP, he was a senior attorney with the Drug 
Enforcement Administration (DEA's) Office of Chief Counsel, and 
he's worked in private practice at multiple firms. Welcome, Mr. 
De Bono.
 Mr. Michael DiLorenzo is a Deputy Chief in the National 
Security Section of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District 
of Columbia, where he investigates and supervises matters 
relating to national security. Mr. DiLorenzo has a long career 
as a prosecutor. Before his current role, he was a prosecutor 
at the Department of Justice, the U.S. Attorney's Office for 
the District of D.C., and the State of Maryland. Welcome, Mr. 
DiLorenzo.
 Next, we have Hon. Sharon Goodie. Judge Goodie is an 
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) for the District of Columbia in 
the Office of Administrative Hearings, where she has served 
since 2005. She hears matters involving public benefits, 
homeless shelters, nursing homes, and mental health group home 
issues. She's also a commissioner on the District of Columbia 
Access to Justice Commission. Before becoming an ALJ, Judge 
Goodie was a prosecutor in the D.C. Attorney General's Office. 
Thank you for being here, Judge.
 Next, we have Craig Leen. Mr. Leen is a partner at K&L 
Gates. Before joining K&L Gates, Mr. Leen served as Director of 
the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) at 
the Department of Labor (DOL). He also previously served as the 
city attorney for the city of Coral Gables, Florida.
 Two more. Christine Macey. Ms. Macey is a Deputy Chief in 
the Felony Major Crimes section at the U.S. Attorney's Office 
for the District of Columbia. Before her current role, Ms. 
Macey served as a Senior Assistant United States Attorney 
(AUSA), investigating and prosecuting homicide cases in the 
D.C. Superior Court and fraud cases in the United States 
District Court for the District of Columbia. Welcome, Ms. 
Macey.
 Finally, last, but certainly not least John Timmer. Mr. 
Timmer is a Senior Trial Counsel in the Enforcement Division at 
the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Before 
joining the SEC, Mr. Timmer served as an Assistant U.S. 
Attorney in the U.S. Attorney's Office for D.C., where he 
investigated and tried cases in the Superior Court of the 
District of Columbia, ranging from assaults to homicides.
 Again, welcome to all of you. Thank you again for being 
here. Now, I will just give you each a chance to introduce any 
family members or other guests you may have with you. we will 
start with you, Mr. Crowell.
 Mr. Crowell. Thank you, Senator. Good morning, to all 
Members of the Committee. I am joined this morning by my wife, 
Michaeleen, our son, Jac, who was, I believe, 14 the last time 
we appeared before you, Senator. He's grown up a little bit, 
but we are grateful to be back before you and our daughter 
Elliotte, who is viewing from afar. She's on a service trip 
abroad. Then I am also joined by Chief Judge Anna Blackburne-
Rigsby of the D.C. Court of Appeals, as well as Chief Judge 
Tony Lee from my current court, the trial court here in the 
D.C. Superior Court. Thank you, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. Fantastic. Welcome to your family members. 
Again, welcome to both of the chief judges. It's terrific to 
have you. Mr. Nash?
 Mr. Nash. Thank you, Senator. Good morning. I am joined 
here today by my wife, Mary, and my son, Christopher. I have 
two other children who are working, one outside the United 
States, and one up in New York City (NYC), and were not able to 
be here, but I think are watching remotely. I am also joined by 
two of my work colleagues at Holland & Knight, Bill Gould and 
John Brownlee. We started together in the U.S. Attorney's 
Office for D.C. in 1997, and have worked together on and off 
ever since. I also have family friends, Mike Flanagan and 
Jocelyn Dyer with me.
 Senator Hawley. Terrific. Very good. Mr. De Bono?
 Mr. De Bono. I am joined today by my wife, Alissa Kempler, 
and then my two children are here as well, my son and my 
daughter. My parents came to see the hearing today, and my 
father-in-law is here as well. I have a ton of friends and 
colleagues that I hope are watching.
 Senator Hawley. Fantastic. Mr. DiLorenzo?
 Mr. DiLorenzo. Good morning, Senator, and good morning, to 
the Members of the Committee. I would like to thank my family 
who have been supportive of me throughout my legal career, 
including my mother, who's watching from above, Marion, my 
father, Henry, my wife, Paula, and our two boys, Michael and 
Christopher. Unfortunately, they can't be here due to a family 
commitment, but they are watching. But thank you.
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Judge Goodie?
 Ms. Goodie. Thank you, Senator, I am joined by my son, 
Daniel, sitting right behind me, and family friends; Sarah 
Hagigh, John Greco, and Ellen Witman.
 Senator Hawley. Fantastic. Mr. Leen?
 Mr. Leen. Good morning, Mr. Chair, Senators. I am joined 
today by my wife, Dr. Ana Maria Muniz-Leen, my college 
sweetheart. We met at Georgetown in 1994, and I am joined by my 
son, Pierce Leen, who attends the School Without Walls here in 
the District. I did want to mention my daughter, Alexandra 
Leen. She's not here today. She's autistic with intellectual 
disability. She attends St. Coletta of Greater Washington, but 
we will celebrate with her tonight.
 Senator Hawley. Fantastic. Ms. Macey?
 Ms. Macey. Thank you, Senator. Good morning. I am joined 
today by my husband, Shaun, seated behind me, as well as my 
parents, Denise and George McIntyre, who traveled from Michigan 
to be here today, as well as my son, who's made some vocal 
appearances, and hopefully, that will stay at a minimum.
 Senator Hawley. It's most welcome. Any interventions are 
very welcome. Mr. Timmer?
 Mr. Timmer. Good morning, Senator, and Members of the 
Committee. I am joined here today by my wife, Jennifer, my 
aunt, Barbara Timmer, and my aunt, Catherine Benkaim. Watching 
from afar is my mother in California, Susan Timmer, and our two 
daughters are at summer camp right now, so they are nowhere 
near a screen.
 Senator Hawley. It's probably a good thing. They will come 
home to good news, hopefully. I am going to defer my questions. 
We will begin questions. Now, we will do five-minute rounds, 
and we will begin with Ranking Member Kim.
 Senator Kim. Yes. Thank you, Chairman. Again, thank you, to 
all of you, for joining us here. I want to really be able to 
use this to hit home what the impact of these vacancies are to 
the District and to help people understand, especially here at 
the Federal level, why it's so urgent that we move forward, to 
be able to move forward with this panel, but just writ large to 
be able to make sure we are doing better, to be able to keep up 
with the needs.
 In particular, Mr. Crowell and Mr. Nash, I wanted to start 
with the two of you. You are certainly aware of just the 
challenges that we are facing right now when it comes to the 
judicial vacancies. Currently, there is over roughly 20 percent 
vacancy rate on both the D.C. Superior Court and the Court of 
Appeals. The failure to replace these nominees has meant that 
the city cannot effectively administer justice. Can you help us 
help explain what the problem is when it comes to this growing 
number of vacancies, how does that impact public safety in 
D.C.? Mr. Crowell, I would like to start with you.
 Mr. Crowell. Thank you, Senator. With respect to the impact 
of the unfilled vacancies, first, we are so grateful. As a 
sitting trial judge on the D.C. Superior Court. I am especially 
grateful. I know Chief Judge Lee is as well for you considering 
the nominees here today for both the Court of Appeals and the 
trial court.
 With the lack of judges, it decreases, that Senator Hawley 
observed, the number of cases we can hear, the average judicial 
officer in my civil division that I am currently in. I spent 
the four years in the criminal division. I spent three years in 
our family court division. The numbers are skyrocketing. They 
are quite, quite high, and I work as absolutely hard as I can. 
But there are only so many hours in the day, and we can't get 
to all the cases, and it does create that backlog. Those 
numbers are real. Those cases are real, the litigants are real, 
and those delays are felt by those who are not able to get 
justice.
 Senator Kim. Mr. Nash?
 Mr. Nash. Thank you, Senator. On the one hand, I feel a 
little bit odd talking about the difficulty in moving 
nominations through the process because, Judge Crowell and I 
were nominated just this month, and so, this Committee has 
moved with great alacrity to put us on this panel and to do 
this hearing. Certainly, everyone sitting on the dais this 
morning and the staff behind, has nothing to do with the delay 
in filling the Court of Appeals slots, because you all have 
been nothing but gracious in moving our nominations along at 
quite a great clip.
 But, Senator Hawley, I think in his opening remarks, really 
put the statistics to this problem. I guess the seat that 
technically that Judge Crowell was nominated to has been open 
now for 13 years. It has been at least 13 years since the Court 
of Appeals has had its full slate----
 Senator Kim. Thirteen years. Wow.
 Mr. Nash [continuing]. Of judges. I know Judge Crowell by 
reputation myself. I know, both of us are really looking 
forward to rolling up our sleeves, getting to work. Given our 
experience in the Superior Court, I think we are in a position 
to hit the ground running when we hit the Court of Appeals. If 
we are fortunate enough to be confirmed, going forward, to 
doing our share to try to drive those numbers down and get to 
the point.
 I mean, right now, I am a consumer of justice in the 
District of Columbia. I am a practicing lawyer. It takes a long 
time to get a decision, both in the Superior Court and the 
Court of Appeals, and we are committed to do what we can to 
meet that challenge.
 Senator Kim. That challenge, it's something that makes 
everything not just slower, but more expensive, and just more 
difficult to be able to navigate for everybody. Is that right?
 Mr. Nash. There gets to be a point, honestly, on the civil 
side, where litigants will decide that they are just going to 
settle their matter rather than wait interminably for a trial 
or for the court of appeals. It wasn't that way when I was 
serving on the Superior Court 10 years ago. This is a problem 
that has, for whatever reason, become more of a problem in 
recent years and----
 Senator Kim. Yes. If it has that impact, I mean, it makes, 
as you said, people start to not believe in the system in terms 
of its ability to function. This is by virtue of the values 
that our country has in terms of giving people their day in 
court and being able to do that in a timely manner. I just 
think at a time when there's such distrust in government, we 
need to show that we are doing the nuts and bolts, and be able 
to deliver in that type of way.
 I am very grateful to Chairman Hawley, as well as Chairman 
Paul, of the full Committee, for moving this forward, for 
recognizing that this is an important function of this 
Committee and necessary for our capital. With that, I'll turn 
it over.
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Mr. Nash, if I could just start 
with you. You wrote an opinion piece in the Washington Post in 
which you state, ``The D.C. Court of Appeals has become a 
substantial and underappreciated obstacle to reducing the 
city's high rate of violent crime, regardless of who has 
control of the police.'' Could you just elaborate on what you 
meant by that, and what perspective you might bring to this 
position in light of your views here?
 Mr. Nash. Thank you, Senator. My opinion piece related to a 
specific case that came to my attention because, as you know, 
the Court of Appeals sits in three judge panels, and the Court 
of Appeals rendered a decision in a criminal case where two of 
the three judges who were on the panel, a unanimous decision 
overturning a gun conviction. Two of three of the judges on the 
panel said in writing in their opinions that they were 
uncomfortable with the way that they were coming out. They 
believed that their decision was inconsistent with Supreme 
Court precedent, and yet, they felt compelled by the precedents 
of the D.C. Court of Appeals to come out the way they did.
 I have practiced law for a long time. I had never seen a 
decision come out unanimously, with two of the three judges 
saying they didn't agree with their own decision, and I thought 
that that was, an interesting enough phenomenon that it was 
worth writing about. I looked at the case. I came to the 
conclusion that the judges who had expressed reservations about 
the opinion were right. That's what I wrote in the opinion 
piece.
 It turns out, that I wrote that last August. This winter, 
the U.S. Supreme Court weighed in on the decision and reversed 
the D.C. Court of Appeals. Not in the specific case that I 
wrote about, but in another case on that same issue, saying 
that the issue that I wrote about, the D.C. Court of Appeals 
should be reversed.
 Senator Hawley. This was D.W. v. The United States, I think 
was the case. Is that correct?
 Mr. Nash. That's the one I wrote about. The one that the 
Supreme Court later wrote is, confusingly enough, called United 
States v. R.W., but same issue, different case.
 Senator Hawley. We are sticking with the D.W. case. This is 
the Court of Appeals panel, as you said, threw out a 
defendant's gun crime conviction, even though, if I remember 
correctly, you correct me if I am wrong, the defendant's 
lawyers admitted at trial that the defendant illegally 
possessed a firearm.
 Mr. Nash. That's true. That's not an unusual circumstance. 
The defense was that the police had acted inconsistently with 
the Fourth Amendment. It's not uncommon for lawyers to 
challenge the Fourth Amendment issue if they lose on the Fourth 
Amendment issue----
 Senator Hawley. Not to interrupt you, but just be mindful 
of the time here--this is because the D.C. Court of Appeals had 
previously held that running away from officers unprovoked--
this is a quote from the controlling precedent, ``does not 
provide a reasonable basis for suspecting that individual being 
involved in criminal activity.''
 You said in the op-ed most non-lawyers would, I think, 
concede that unprovoked flight provides an officer with 
sufficient reason to establish whether the fleeing individual 
might be involved in criminal activity. That seems very 
commonsensical to me. Here's my question, here's really what I 
am driving at. What does this mean for your approach to the 
role? If you are confirmed to this court that you have written 
about, does that mean that in cases--let's abstract from this 
particular precedent, in cases where you think that the court's 
precedent or previous cases is wrong, will you push to have 
those reviewed in bank? I mean, what give me a sense of what 
this means about your approach to the job.
 Mr. Nash. I guess I would say, to begin with, Senator, that 
I am not seeking this position because I plan on bringing a 
particular agenda to the court. My theory of judging is that 
every case should come before a tribunal that has an open mind 
and is going to hear the evidence, both the facts and the law, 
and apply them in an unbiased fashion. I do not want anyone to 
suggest that my editorial that talked about a single case that 
I thought was wrongly decided is reflective of me trying to 
bring an agenda to the court.
 That being said, I think what the editorial demonstrates is 
that when I see something that I think is unjust or not 
consistent with precedent, I am not shy about making my 
feelings known on that. I get to be fortunate enough to be 
confirmed and I get to the court, if I am on a three-judge 
panel and two of the judges disagree with me, I am not going to 
be shy about expressing my opinion. I think as my editorial 
did, I think I do it in a respectful fashion. I anticipate I 
would continue to do it in a respectful fashion. I served on 
the Superior Court for six years, and I think I had a 
reputation of being a measured and respectful judge, and I 
would hope to continue that, if I am fortunate enough to be 
confirmed to the court.
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Judge Crowell, let me just ask 
you before I return to Senator Kim. Before you became a judge, 
you had a long career as a prosecutor. Drawing from your 
experience, both as a prosecutor and now your years on the 
bench, do you think that D.C.'s criminal laws are being under 
enforced, over enforced, enforced about the right amount. 
What's your sense of it?
 Mr. Crowell. Senator, I appreciate the question. I think 
that the restrictions on me that wades into public policy, I 
would be reluctant as a sitting judge to speak to matters of 
public policy. The Judicial Canons greatly restrict me from 
commenting on matters of public policy. What I can tell you is, 
as a Federal prosecutor, I fought against violent crime. I 
sought justice for victims, and I woke up every day fighting 
for those victims, seeking justice for those victims, whether 
it was Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO), 
violent crime cases. That was my bread and butter. What I have 
experienced when I served on the in the criminal division of 
the Superior Court, the volume of cases is significant, and 
there are issues that need to be addressed.
 Senator Hawley. In your experience, and as a general 
matter, do tough sentences help deter violent crime or no?
 Mr. Crowell. My experience is they do. I believe that 
there's a statute that provides what courts must consider in 
determining sentences. Amongst those factors in deciding a 
holistic fashion is specific deterrence as to that offender, as 
well as general deterrence as to the community, there's 
rehabilitation. There's also the nature and circumstances of 
the offense. In crafting a decision, a judge is statutorily 
required to consider each of those factors in balancing a 
decision. But absolutely, specific and general deterrence has a 
significant factor.
 Senator Hawley. Senator Kim, anything further?
 Senator Kim. I would actually like to build off of that, 
but I would like to ask this to the nominees for the D.C. 
Superior Court. That issue about balancing that issue, about 
trying to weigh and using your judgment on that on these cases 
that could be before you. I try to think through the challenges 
when it comes to crime committed by younger individuals in 
Washington, DC, a trend that, unfortunately, we have been 
seeing on the rise. I wanted to ask each of you to just give me 
a sense of how do you balance that importance of accountability 
when it comes to our rule of law with the potential of 
rehabilitation, with the potential of continuing to try to 
shape young people who have their whole lives ahead of them. 
How do you, each of you, think through that and will approach 
that if confirmed, into these jobs? Mr. De Bono, why don't we 
start with you and we will go down the line.
 Mr. De Bono. Judge Crowell said, that as a judge, I will be 
confined to the D.C. Code and Provisions on sentencing and the 
factors that I will have to consider, which is specific 
deterrence, general deterrence, rehabilitation, and education 
that can be provided to the defendants. I think that that is 
important. I think it's important to keep individuals that are 
a threat to the community out of the community, and then I 
think it's also important that before individuals are returned 
to community, they don't pose a threat, particularly for 
younger individuals that are likely to reenter the community, 
that they are in a position where they can do so, and that they 
are fully rehabilitated, and no longer in a position where they 
are going to cause harm to the community.
 If I am fortunate enough to be confirmed, I will look at 
sentencing based on the criminal history, the specific 
defendant, any pretrial sentencing recommendations, statutory 
penalties, and then try to craft a penalty that accomplishes 
all the goals of sentencing.
 Senator Kim. Mr. DiLorenzo?
 Mr. DiLorenzo. Great. Thank you. The sentence really has to 
be crafted to the individual, and that's the judge's role, as I 
would agree with my fellow nominee. By doing that, you look at 
each case on its own, and you look at the seriousness of the 
offense, the characteristics of the accused, which would 
include the age of the accused, and their record as well.
 You also look at the impact on the victim, and the 
sentence. Another factor would be protecting the public, and 
again, deterring this defendant from committing that offense in 
the future. That may very well be punishment or it may be 
rehabilitation. Another factor is to deter others from 
committing that offense.
 Senator Kim. Ms. Goodie?
 Ms. Goodie. I concur with my fellow nominees that it has to 
be done on a case-by-case basis. Certainly, what I look for is 
community safety. If this person is on release, is this person 
going to be safe in the community? Sometimes, yes. Sometimes, 
no. Particularly, I prosecuted juveniles, we would have the 
pre-sentencing report. We would get sometimes psychiatric 
reports so we could get a better sense of what was going to 
work best for this particular individual in the community.
 Also, look at potential for rehabilitation and what it 
would take to rehabilitate this particular individual. Also 
look at deterrence, if this particular individual is out in the 
community, what's that going to say? If this particular 
individual is locked up, what's that going to say? So, a number 
of things and it's going to vary with each defendant or 
respondent.
 Senator Hawley. Mr. Leen?
 Mr. Leen. I would follow the standards in the statute. For 
a violent crime, it's important that you treat it very 
seriously. In the end, the goal of sentencing, when you look at 
all the standards, I have always taken it to be to make sure 
that this person does not commit another crime. That can 
include rehabilitation, but that also sometimes includes a 
sentence that's commensurate with what they have done.
 Ms. Macey. I concur with the sentiment of my fellow 
nominees in terms of each case needing to be looked at in the 
particulars of that particular defendant and the particular 
facts of that case. Working in the legal framework, I would, of 
course, start with any sort of requirements. If there's a 
statutory mandatory minimum at play, that of course, has to be 
considered in the sentencing and followed.
 I would also look at the sentencing guidelines that provide 
a parameter for judges as a starting point, to consider what is 
assessed as a fair and reasonable sentence, that you can then 
apply the specifics of the case to that particular case, and 
determine what the appropriate sentence is by looking at the 
factors in the D.C. Code to include the nature and 
circumstances of the offense, the criminal history of the 
defendant, their personal circumstances. To your question, 
their youth, their particular background, those considerations, 
and I would say that I would employ this approach as a judge 
very consistently with how I have done as a prosecutor for 
almost 14 years.
 Mr. Timmer. I just think is such an important issue. As a 
parent, here in the community, it's so important to be mindful 
of what you are raising. I echo a lot of what my fellow 
nominees have said about judging each case and each defendant 
on their own merits, and applying the factors that are laid out 
by the code.
 I will add that the D.C. Code, as it relates to juvenile 
justice, talks about some of the purposes of that code, and 
there are two--they are to rehabilitate and also to hold 
juveniles accountable for their actions, and I am convinced 
that holding somebody accountable for what they have done is 
part and parcel of rehabilitation. Unless you have understood 
that you have done something wrong, you can't move forward. I 
think that those are important goals that I would keep in mind 
if I am fortunate enough to be confirmed to handle cases like 
that.
 Senator Hawley. Let me just ask now, the superior court 
nominees, so starting with you, Mr. De Bono, and just as 
Senator Kim did, I just want to go down the line and give you a 
chance to respond to a question or two. Let's come back to this 
notion of deterring violent crime. What is your understanding 
of what your role would be, each of you, if confirmed to this 
court, what your role would be in deterring violent crime? Go 
ahead, Mr. De Bono, we will start with you. Everybody will have 
a chance.
 Mr. De Bono. My idea of my role, if I am fortunate enough 
to be confirmed, is to set a punishment a sentence for an 
individual that's committed a crime that is commensurate with 
the crime, commensurate with the individual's criminal history, 
and is appropriate enough to deter that individual from 
committing further crimes to protect the public safety and to 
prevent others from engaging in similar activity.
 Senator Hawley. Very good, Mr. DiLorenzo.
 Mr. DiLorenzo. I would agree with my fellow nominee. I 
mean, as a prosecutor, I have made recommendations for 
incarceration. As a judge, you are better suited because you 
see at the sentencing, you see the whole picture and should be 
should look at the whole picture. And you know, part of that is 
to, impose a sentence that will deter this individual. Part of 
that is sometimes giving a stiff sentence, but a piece of that 
is oftentimes to provide some sort of rehabilitation to get to 
the motive of what may have caused the crime and that's getting 
some piece of rehabilitation. It may be drug treatment. It may 
be sort of some mental health treatment. So, it's to fashion 
appropriate sentence that deters this individual and deters 
others as well.
 Senator Hawley. Judge Goodie?
 Ms. Goodie. I concur with my fellow nominees on the need 
for deterrence. I remember when I was a prosecutor, there was a 
level of recidivism that was getting frustrating. What I would 
be looking at, if I am fortunate enough to be confirmed, is has 
this person done this once or has this person done this more 
than once? What was put in place on that first time? Did it 
work? What can I do for this person to hopefully prevent 
recidivism for that one person? Let the community know that I 
am trying to prevent recidivism in a larger sense. I would be 
looking at their past record. Is it the same thing over and 
over again, or is it different things? I would look as as many 
reports as I can get on psychiatric, psychological. If I am in 
a juvenile delinquency court, I would want to know how I can't 
make sure, but how can I come closest to making sure that this 
person is not going to do it again?
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Mr. Leen?
 Mr. Leen. Judges play a critical role in deterring crime. 
The way I would approach it is to apply the standards in the 
code, as mentioned. Ultimately, it's to avoid outlier sentences 
to make sure you are applying a standard that's equal across 
the people that you see, obviously looking at the individual 
circumstances. But in the end, it's important that people know 
that if they commit a crime, they will be punished.
 Senator Hawley. Ms. Macey?
 Ms. Macey. I spent several years as an Assistant U.S. 
attorney focused specifically on homicide cases, and that was 
just a fraction of my time in the office. I also spent other 
years focused on other violent crimes. Violent crime I have 
seen up close, and I realize how significant of an impact it 
has on the defendants, the victims, the victims' families, the 
defendants' families, and the community as a whole. It's a 
matter that's very important to me.
 As a judge, if I am so fortunate to be confirmed, I would 
approach my role to addressing violent crime by proceeding 
fairly in the cases before me, by handling them efficiently so 
that defendants get their day in court, victims get their day 
in court, and ensuring that the rights of both perpetrators and 
victims are addressed and considered in crafting appropriate 
sentences for the particular case before me.
 Senator Hawley. Mr. Timmer?
 Mr. Timmer. I would echo what my fellow nominee, Ms. Macey, 
said. During my seven and a half years at the U.S. Attorney's 
Office, I practiced exclusively in Superior Court, first as a 
line attorney and then as a supervisor. I saw firsthand the 
impact that the judges had on crime in the community agree with 
her I think the steps I could take are one, to follow the D.C. 
Code to impose sentences in accordance with the law and the 
sentencing guidelines, and to work efficiently to ensure that 
if somebody commits a crime, is arrested, is charged, that they 
have their day in court, and that that day comes swiftly so 
that it's the community can see for themselves that justice has 
not been denied and has not been delayed.
 Senator Hawley. Judge Judy, let me just ask you, if I 
could, just on the same topic. In 2022, you were on a panel at 
Brandeis University in which you said, among other things, 
there is no rehabilitation in prison. Just help me understand 
your thinking here, and here's where I'm going, as you can 
probably imagine. Does that mean that you would be hesitant to 
send a first-time offender or someone who you think, well, 
maybe this person could benefit from some rehabilitation? The 
sentencing guidelines call for or strongly suggest prison time, 
but I don't want to do that because there is no rehabilitation 
in prison. I want to do everything I can to avoid sending 
people there. I mean, take me inside your mind here and explain 
that to me.
 Ms. Goodie. Yes, I did say that. Let me first specifically 
answer your question and then go back.
 Senator Hawley. Yes.
 Ms. Goodie. There's a difference between juveniles and 
adults, first of all. For juveniles, the standard is 
rehabilitation, so there is a focus on providing services. My 
concern about what happens in prison arose from when I was in 
law school and I actually taught at the Lorton Prison. We used 
to house our prisoners in Lorton. They are now housed in the 
Federal system, and I saw that conditions were not great for 
rehabilitation. That's where that came from.
 Your question was, would that make me hesitate to put 
someone in prison? No. Community safety is my No. 1 thing. If 
we can craft a rehabilitation package that makes someone safe 
to be back in the community, let's do that. But if somebody 
can't be made safe in the community, then the only place to go 
is prison
 Senator Hawley. Let me ask each of you now, again, just the 
Superior Court nominees. In view of the backlog, the huge 
backlog that the court is currently facing, just give me your 
sense of what you would do to help address this huge backlog, 
how important do you think it is, and what your role would be 
in making sure that these cases are heard? Defendants get their 
day in courts, but also victims get the redress that they 
deserve. Let's start with you, Mr. De Bono.
 Mr. De Bono. If I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed, my 
role will be to efficiently move my cases, to set clear 
expectations for the parties, set clear deadlines, be clear 
from the front about what I expect them to do, and be prepared 
to do when they come to court. Then to show up with the same 
effort and to be prepared to handle the matters that come 
before me when they do appear. That way, the cases are quickly 
handled. They are quickly and efficiently resolved and we are 
able to get justice for victims and appropriate sentences in 
place for offenders.
 Mr. DiLorenzo. It's necessary to strike a balance between 
efficiency and fairness. I have appeared before many judges. I 
have learned a lot from good habits and bad habits in order to 
move things along. What I would do if I were fortunate enough 
to be confirmed, is I would be the example to everybody in the 
courtroom. I would go in--and I learned this to during my 
clerkship. My judge, William M. Jackson, who said on Superior 
Court, I saw him do this. He was a career prosecutor, and he 
was on a family calendar. What he did and what I would do is 
prepare. He was often--and I would be the most prepared lawyer 
in the courtroom law; I have read the pleadings and I'm ready 
to go.
 But in addition to being an example, it is essential as my 
co-counsel--as my fellow nominee said, that expectations are 
set. I found that, in my experience, the best way to set 
expectations is to have a standing order. I found courts with 
standing orders where it's clear what the expectations move 
efficient courtroom, you know, courtrooms run efficiently. 
There is that fairness. Then also when there are egregious 
violations, the court has to be willing--must be consequences 
when there are repeated egregious violations.
 Ms. Goodie. I have drawn experience from when I clerked at 
Superior Court as well. I watched how Judge Harriet Taylor made 
sure to move a couple of dockets. She had a child abuse and 
neglect docket, and she had a criminal docket. I watched the 
systems that she used to keep up with new case law. We would 
get slip opinions, she'd read it, she'd file it, and she'd file 
it in her head. I'm still using that to this day.
 I also have learned as an administrative law judge, how to 
figure out which cases can move quickly and which ones need 
more time. Put the ones that move quickly out soon so we can 
get them resolved as soon as possible without thoroughly 
delaying the ones that are more complicated. Sort of going back 
and forth between the more easy ones to resolve and the more 
difficult ones to resolve. Right now, we have some of our 
highest caseloads that the Office of Administrative Hearings 
ever had. I am working on that right now. Most and I schedule 
hearings every 20 minutes, every 15 minutes so I can move 
through those, make sure I can get to trials as quickly as I 
can.
 The other thing that I will be focusing on, should I be so 
fortunate to be confirmed, is courtroom civility. What I found 
is if I can be the role model for being civil to everybody in 
that courtroom, then people will follow. When it gets uncivil 
is when it slows down. Making sure that everybody is polite 
with each other, respectful with each other, but getting to the 
facts and getting to the law.
 Mr. Leen. Mr. Chairman, when you mentioned the 100,000-case 
backlog, that is an enormous number. I would come into the job, 
if I get confirmed, seeking to be efficient and effective. I 
have come into several jobs where I had a big backlog when I 
came in, both at OFCCP, and when I was city attorney, and I put 
a number of norms together right away with my staff. I sought 
to address cases quickly, fairly and quickly. I wrote a lot of 
decisions. I tried to rule on everything at once where I could. 
I published a lot of decisions so people could have an idea 
where I am coming from and could cite to precedent, and I would 
also be an internal advocate within the court system to move 
cases. It's extremely important to move cases so that everyone 
gets their day in court.
 Ms. Macey. In terms of my role, if I am so fortunate to be 
confirmed, of addressing the backlog, I think it has to start 
with preparation on my end of taking the bench, being ready for 
the cases before me, knowing the facts, having an agenda of 
what should be covered that day, and holding the parties to 
that same standard of coming prepared and setting the tone that 
you expect your courtroom to be run efficiently, and for them 
to be prepared and make progress so that the hearing 
accomplishes as much as possible.
 I would draw on my experiences both as a law clerk in D.C. 
Superior Court. I clerked for the then-chief judge, Lee 
Satterfield, and was able to see firsthand a sort of process 
and ways to set up systems to approach cases efficiently. Also, 
as an Assistant U.S. Attorney with very heavy caseload, I have 
had to learn how to balance giving the cases the attention they 
deserve, but also moving efficiently and knowing how to 
prioritize things. I would use all those experiences and create 
a system on the court to move my cases efficiently.
 Mr. Timmer. I draw on similar experiences to my colleague, 
Ms. Macey. Walking in at the U.S. Attorney's Office, I joined 
the Domestic Violence Misdemeanor Section and was confronted 
with an enormous caseload, each one of which was deeply 
important to the person who had been a victim in that case. 
Quickly, I learned how to identify which cases needed work 
urgently, work efficiently through them, and ensure that 
justice was done in each case.
 If I were to be so fortunate to be confirmed, I think my 
fellow nominees have identified a number of very important 
steps to take, which I would share. I think one very important 
thing to do is to communicate with litigants in advance of 
hearings. What is the judge interested in hearing about? What 
are the key issues? So that is not just me as the judge, but 
the litigants, the parties have had the opportunity to consider 
the issue, come prepared to talk about it, hopefully deal with 
it all at once, and so one hearing doesn't turn into two, or 
three, or more.
 Senator Hawley. I will turn to Senator Blumenthal here in 
just a moment. But I have been advised repeatedly that unless I 
ask each of you the following question, the sky may fall in, 
your nominations may not move, hell may freeze over, and the 
Senate may get nothing done. Although, wait, that's already 
happening. Maybe we will risk it, though. Here's the question 
that I have got to ask each of you: do you agree without 
reservation, to comply with any request or summons to appear 
and testify before any duly constituted committee of Congress, 
should you be confirmed? Let's just go right down the line. We 
will start with you, Mr. Crowell.
 [Witnesses answer in the affirmative.]
 Senator Hawley. Senator Blumenthal.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR BLUMENTHAL

 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would like 
to ask each of you how you will stand up to the administration, 
which is appointing you, if your independence is somehow 
challenged or at stake. What kinds of standards and self-
discipline you would impose on yourself? Maybe we can just go 
right down the line.
 Mr. Crowell. Senator, as a sitting trial judge, there are 
significant restrictions with respect to how I might opine on 
matters of public policy. What I can tell you is I first took 
my oath at age 19 as a young private at Fort Benning, Georgia. 
I have repeated that oath as a soldier multiple times as rank 
increased. I have repeated that oath as a Federal prosecutor in 
my multiple tours with the Department of Justice, and I have 
repeated that oath when I first appeared before this Committee 
seven years ago and received your approval. I will, and my 
promise then remains my promise today, which is to be a 
faithful servant of the Constitution, and I will continue to do 
so.
 Mr. Nash. Senator, I guess first and foremost, I'm a 
patriot. I believe that we are fortunate--all of us, who are 
citizens of this country, are fortunate that we have inherited 
some wonderful, and really unique in the world institutions to 
protecting our liberties. One of the most important of those 
protections is judicial independence, the separation of powers 
that creates the judiciary, is a real bulwark for liberty in 
this country. If I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed, I would 
exercise that authority in the same way that I did my first 
tour of duty as a judge, which is with independence and 
applying the law in the manner that I believe it should be.
 Senator Blumenthal. Let me just ask both of you: who won 
the 2020 election?
 Mr. Crowell. Senator, Joe Biden was certified as the winner 
by this body of the U.S. Senate, as the President of the United 
States, as has been the practice since 1804.
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Nash?
 Mr. Nash. I concur with that answer.
 Senator Blumenthal. Let me go down the line on that 
question, because I think it's a sign of your independence. Who 
won the 2020 election?
 Mr. De Bono. Senator Biden was certified as the winner of 
the 2020 election.
 Mr. DiLorenzo. I concur with my fellow nominee's answer.
 Ms. Goodie. I concur as well. Joe Biden was certified as 
the winner of the 2020 election.
 Mr. Leen. I concur.
 Ms. Macey. I concur.
 Mr. Timmer. I concur.
 Senator Blumenthal. You all concur. That's your 
independence with the script that the White House has given you 
that Joe Biden was certified. Who won the popular vote, Mr. 
Crowell?
 Mr. Crowell. Senator, I'm going to take a page from Justice 
Jackson when she appeared before the Senate Judiciary. I am a 
sitting judge, and I am deeply restricted by----
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Nash?
 Mr. Nash. My understanding is that the Judicial Canons 
apply to me as a candidate for judicial office, and that 
weighing in on that question would be inappropriate.
 Mr. De Bono. I am prohibited under Canon 4 of the D.C. Code 
of Judicial Conduct from answering a question about that and 
wading into political matter.
 Mr. DiLorenzo. That's correct. Canon 4 of the Judicial Code 
prohibits me from answering that question.
 Ms. Goodie. As a sitting administrative law judge and as a 
nominee----
 Mr. Leen. I concur.
 Ms. Macey. I concur.
 Mr. Timmer. I concur.
 Senator Blumenthal. You all concur. Do you know how 
pathetic and absurd you sound to the American public. You know 
how absolutely unacceptable this kind of answer is where you 
deny what the facts are. Let me ask you, Mr. Crowell: was the 
Capitol attacked on January 6?
 Mr. Crowell. Senator, I was here in the city. I live right 
here on Capitol Hill. There was a breach of the Capitol. It was 
violent. There was law enforcement that was attacked. There was 
a violent breach of the Capitol. Yes, sir.
 Senator Blumenthal. There was violence and the Capitol was 
attacked. Correct?
 Mr. Crowell. The Capitol is a structure. What I would say 
is there were there were individuals that were attacked to 
include our law enforcement officers, the people that protect 
us here in the United States Capitol.
 Senator Blumenthal. But you are unwilling to say the 
Capitol was attacked?
 Mr. Crowell. I think that goes into a political question.
 Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Nash?
 Mr. Nash. Senator, my only knowledge of what happened on 
January 6 was media reports that I have seen.
 Senator Blumenthal. You have watched those reports. The 
Capitol was attacked, was it not?
 Mr. Nash. It appears to me clear that there were crimes 
that were committed on that day.
 Senator Blumenthal. What's your answer, sir?
 Mr. De Bono. I witnessed violence against law enforcement, 
which I do not condone. As a political nominee--or as a nominee 
for a judicial vacancy, I'm prohibited from the Judicial Canons 
from characterizing the events of that day any further.
 Mr. DiLorenzo. There was public reporting that there were 
assaults on police officers. I, too, absolutely would not 
condone that conduct. The Senator used the word, ``attack.'' 
Any type of political characterization would be inappropriate 
for me to comment on under the Judicial Canons.
 Ms. Goodie. My knowledge is also confined to what I saw 
through the media. There were attacks on police officers which 
is reprehensible.
 Mr. Leen. There was violence and attacks on police officers 
and that was wrong.
 Ms. Macey. It is a matter of public reporting, and I 
personally have seen police body-worn camera from January 6, 
2021. I certainly do not condone violence against law 
enforcement, and that did happen that day. But beyond that, the 
Judicial Canons would prohibit me from characterizing the 
events of January 6.
 Mr. Timmer. Like Judge Crowell, I watched the events from 
my home here on Capitol Hill, and I saw absolutely wanton 
violence against officers, other people who were sworn to 
protect the Capitol, and----
 Senator Blumenthal. I understand you all condemn violence. 
We all abhor attacks on police. Not one of you is willing to 
say that the Capitol was attacked. Again, pathetic, and 
ridiculous. For anyone, but for a nominee for judicial office, 
I began asking how we can be sure of your independence. Nothing 
you have said here today provides me with any reassurance that 
you are going to be independent, that you are willing to stand 
up to the President when he or a member of the administration 
asks you to do something that is a violation of your judicial 
duties.
 This Nation depends on the independence of our judiciary. 
We are seeing it now as a bulwark of our rights and democracy, 
despite the politicization and weaponization of the Department 
of Justice. I am deeply disappointed that you are unwilling to 
say the truth that you all saw on that day. The Capitol was 
attacked, not just police officers. The Capitol of the United 
States was attacked in an effort to stop the lawful transfer of 
power.
 This goes beyond violence to any individual. It goes to the 
essential functioning of our democracy, and you are willing to 
apparently kowtow to the canned script that has been given to 
you about certifying Joe Biden, about violence on January 6, 
but not willing to say that Joe Biden was elected President of 
the United States, won the popular vote, and the Capitol was 
attacked on January 6. I don't know how to put it more plainly, 
but I am really ashamed and so deeply disappointed. Thank you.
 Senator Hawley. Anything else, Senator Kim?
 Senator Kim. No.
 Senator Hawley. I have just one more thing. Mr. Leen, if 
you could help me with something. In the fall of 2020, 
President Trump issued an Executive Order (EO) that sought to 
prohibit Federal contractors from engaging in unconscious bias 
training that perpetuated racial stereotypes. That was his 
order. You were the leader, I believe, of DOL's Office of 
Federal Contract Compliance Programs at the time. Is that 
correct? Do I have that right?
 Mr. Leen. Yes, that's correct.
 Senator Hawley. I am told that you, in that role, however, 
did not advise contractors to stop unconscious bias training, 
but you advised instead that contractors should still engage in 
the bias training despite the President's Executive Order based 
on, ``the human condition that every person has certain biases, 
or stereotypes, or prejudices.'' Could you just help me 
understand what's the distinction there? Did you, in fact, urge 
them not to comply with the Executive Order? Just clear up the 
record for me, if you could.
 Mr. Leen. The Executive Order 13950, prevented sex or race-
based stereotyping, or stigmas by Federal contractors, and it 
was intended to focus on trainings. It did not directly address 
unconscious bias training. Of course, there is the First 
Amendment right of contractors to be able to have training. I 
did work within the administration, with the Secretary of 
Labor, who I reported to come up with an approach that would 
comply with the Executive Order, which we faithfully executed, 
while also responding to many contractor questions about what 
trainings they were allowed to do and what they could not do.
 The concern I saw with unconscious bias training under the 
Executive Order was when it was focused on people of only one 
race or one gender, such as White males, which it was often 
focused on. That was not right. That violated the Executive 
Order. But if you were going to do unconscious bias training, 
and I didn't advise companies to do it, what I said was, if you 
are going to do it, you can do that, but you have to give the 
training to everyone and it cannot be exclusive.
 Senator Hawley. Did you say that you think that there's a 
First Amendment right to unconscious bias training?
 Mr. Leen. What I said was there's a First Amendment right 
for contractors to have trainings and to have messages. Of 
course, they cannot violate that.
 Senator Hawley. Tell me about the scope of that. What would 
that right be?
 Mr. Leen. Corporations have messages that they state all 
the time, press releases, things like that. What they can't do 
is violate Federal anti-discrimination law. That is not viewed 
as lawful speech. That's viewed as----
 Senator Hawley. I am just trying to understand your answer. 
A corporation has a First Amendment right to require its 
employees to engage in unconscious bias training.
 Mr. Leen. No, I was--and forgive me if I wasn't trying to 
be that specific. The advice that I received from the 
administration, at the time, which was the first Trump 
administration, was that Executive Order 13950, was challenged 
in court. We were seeking to put out guidance that would allow 
it to be upheld, and that would allow it to be enforced.
 What I was informed was we have to balance the focus on 
anti-discrimination with the rights of companies to be able to 
have a message. This was the guidance I received. I tried to 
apply it faithfully within the administration. With unconscious 
bias training, in particular, what my understanding, both from 
legal advice and my own research, was that any unconscious bias 
training that focused on a particular race or sex with a 
stereotype about that race or sex would be illegal and would 
violate Federal anti-discrimination law. That's what I focused 
on.
 Senator Hawley. Is it your view that that companies have a 
First Amendment right to require their employees to engage in 
political speech, to listen to certain political speech, to 
accept political speech.
 Mr. Leen. No, I would not go that far. I mean, I respect 
the decision in Citizens United, that corporations do have 
First Amendment rights. They do not have a right to dictate to 
their employees, in my view, political views. I have always 
taken that position.
 Senator Hawley. Yes. I have never heard it said that 
there's a First Amendment right to unconscious bias training. I 
was curious about that.
 Mr. Leen. Forgive me, I was being more general, I wanted 
you to know how we approached it because I wanted to give you a 
good faith answer.
 Senator Hawley. Good.
 Mr. Leen. That's how we approached it, but I am not saying 
there's a First Amendment right to unconscious bias training.
 Senator Hawley. Yes. Good. Because I think there is no such 
right, and I would think that that opening up that Pandora's 
box will take you well beyond Citizens United. If you have 
concerns about Citizens United, as I do, I think to suggest 
that corporations have broad and sweeping free speech rights 
over their employees in that manner would be far beyond 
anything the U.S. Supreme Court has said.
 In the area of race, which is what we are talking about 
here, I mean, this Executive Order pertained to racial 
stereotypes. To suggest that the First Amendment permits a 
corporation to sidestep restrictions on engaging or refusing to 
engage in racial stereotyping, I think would be quite 
extraordinary. I hope that's not your position.
 Mr. Leen. It's not. Mr. Chairman, I agree with what you 
just said, strongly.
 Senator Hawley. Good. Senator Kim, anything further?
 Senator Kim. Nothing further.
 Senator Hawley. All right. The record will remain open 
until Friday the 26. With that, this meeting of the Senate 
Homeland Security Committee is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 11:16 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.]

 A P P E N D I X

 ---------- 

[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 [all]