Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- SNAP: EXAMINING EFFORTS TO COMBAT FRAUD AND IMPROVE PROGRAM INTEGRITY [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] SNAP: EXAMINING EFFORTS TO COMBAT FRAUD AND IMPROVE PROGRAM INTEGRITY ======================================================================= JOINT HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ JUNE 9, 2016 __________ Serial No. 114-100 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 22-990 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ____________________________________________________________________ For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, Internet:bookstore.gpo.gov. Phone:toll free (866)512-1800;DC area (202)512-1800 Fax:(202) 512-2104 Mail:Stop IDCC,Washington,DC 20402-001 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama ------ Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Ryan Hambleton, Senior Professional Staff Member Katie Bailey, Subcommittee Staff Director, Government Operations Willie Marx, Clerk Subcommittee on Government Operations MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina, Chairman JIM JORDAN, Ohio GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia, TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Vice Chair Ranking Minority Member TREY GOWDY, South Carolina CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina Columbia KEN BUCK, Colorado WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts ------ Subcommittee on the Interior CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming, Chairman PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan, BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas Ranking Minority Member KEN BUCK, Colorado, Vice Chair MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands GARY J. PALMER, Alabama C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on June 9, 2016..................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. Kevin Concannon, Under Secretary for Food, Nutrition, and Consumer Services, U.S. Department of Agriculture Oral Statement............................................... 5 Written Statement............................................ 8 Ms. Kay Brown, Director, Education, Workforce, and Income Security, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 19 Written Statement............................................ 21 Ms. Mary Mayhew, Commissioner, Maine Department of Health and Human Services Oral Statement............................................... 43 Written Statement............................................ 45 Mr. Mike Carroll, Secretary, Florida Department of Children and Family Services Oral Statement............................................... 59 Written Statement............................................ 61 Ms. Stacy Dean, Vice President for Food Assistance Policy, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities Oral Statement............................................... 65 Written Statement............................................ 67 APPENDIX April 26, 2016, letter from Connie Derr, Council 18 Exeutive Director, American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, to Bill Ludwig, Southwest Regional Director, U.S. Regional Director, Submitted by Rep. Lujan Grisham............. 126 October 13, 2016, Letter from Kevin W. Concannon, Under Secretary, Food Nutrition and Consumer Services, U.S. Department of Agriculture, to Chairman Mark Meadows of the Government Operations Subcommittee, Submitted by Chairman Meadows........................................................ 128 Florida State Agency Notification of Major Changes in Program, Submitted by Chairman Meadows.................................. 130 SNAP: EXAMINING EFFORTS TO COMBAT FRAUD AND IMPROVE PROGRAM INTEGRITY ---------- Thursday, June 9, 2016 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Government Operations, joint with the Subcommittee on the Interior, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittees met, pursuant to call, at 2:05 p.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Mark Meadows [chairman of the Subcommittee on Government Operations] presiding. Present from Subcommittee on Government Operations: Representatives Meadows, Jordan, Walberg, Massie, Palmer, Carter, Grothman, Connolly, Norton, and Plaskett. Present from Subcommittee on the Interior: Representatives Lummis, Palmer, Lawrence, Cartwright, and Plaskett. Also Present: Representative Lujan Grisham. Mr. Meadows. All right. The Subcommittee on Government Operations and the Subcommittee on the Interior will come to order. And without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. I want to thank you for coming, and I thank my other chairman here and ranking members for their willingness to embark on this topic. For many individuals and families, the SNAP program is a vital lifeline to ensure that there is food on the table. And I think we can all agree that no one in America should go hungry. While most individuals and retailers in the SNAP program are honest participants, unfortunately, some do indeed take advantage of the system. We will hear examples today of various ways individuals and retailers commit fraud in trafficking such as swapping SNAP benefits for other cash or illegal drugs. There was a raid in the Florida flea market just last month that was the largest SNAP trafficking bust in the program's history. And so far 22 owners of SNAP retailers at that flea market have been arrested or charged with over $13 million in fraud just for the past year. We will also hear about the connection between SNAP trafficking and the ongoing opiod epidemic in Maine and across this country. American taxpayers deserve to know that their tax dollars are being spent effectively and wisely, and when someone abuses a system, they defraud the American taxpayers. They hurt individuals and families that are truly in need. Despite improvements in prior years, OMB designated the SNAP program as a high-error program due to the estimated $2.6 billion in improper payments for fiscal year 2015. So we are here today to examine how the SNAP program can better serve families, more efficiently utilize taxpayer dollars, and prevent fraud and trafficking of SNAP benefits. Innovative efforts to leverage technology and analyze data such as Florida's identity verification process and Maine's effort to analyze out-of-state SNAP usage can provide real helpful insights. And so I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about how we can improve the SNAP program to better ensure that the right benefits get to the families and individuals that need them most. Mr. Meadows. I now recognize my good friend, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on Government Operations, Mr. Connolly, for his opening statement. Mr. Connolly. I thank you, Mr. Chairman, and welcome to our panel. And I want to thank you for holding this hearing. I support the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which I think has proven to be an effectively managed program that does, in fact, reduce fraud and misuse. Individual and isolated examples of problems notwithstanding, there is very little evidence of widespread SNAP fraud. Actually, the evidence suggests that the Department of Agriculture investigates potential fraud pretty aggressively. State antifraud efforts are also functioning as effectively as possible, despite difficulties in conducting fraud investigations due to reduced funding and staff levels. Those antifraud efforts are important because SNAP benefits are a vital part of the national safety net. SNAP provides people at or below 130 percent of the poverty line, which is currently an annual income of $26,100 for a family of three--good luck in living on that--$127 a month toward an affordable, adequate diet. About 70 percent of SNAP participants are families with children, and 25 percent are in households with seniors and people with disabilities. SNAP also protects the overall economy. Because SNAP is an entitlement and provides money to people who need it, they spend it directly on food. CBO found that among policies implemented by Congress to stimulate economic growth and create jobs during the economic recession, SNAP had one of the largest increases in economic activity and employment per budgetary dollars spent. That is to say if you want a direct injection into the economy to stimulate, this is a great way to do it. According to the Census Bureau, SNAP kept 5 million Americans out of poverty during the recession, which followed the 2008 financial crisis. That is an extraordinary number. Since then, SNAP spending has fallen--as you would expect as the economy recovers--by 7 percent in 2014, and the Center of Budget and Policy Priorities reports that reduced caseloads will continue in 2016 because of the growing and stronger economy. I understand the concerns my friends on the other side of the aisle to ensure the SNAP program continues to work efficiently, and I think we have common ground on that. I too want to eliminate the small percentage of bad actors who misrepresent facts about themselves and cheat people in need. In fiscal year 2012, over 100 FNS analysts and investigators around the country reviewed more than 15,000 stores and conducted nearly 4,500 undercover investigations. Over the last 10 years, more than 8,300 retail stores were permanently disqualified because of fraud. I find the House majority's recent proposal in the war on poverty troubling. The answer to completely eliminating fraud in the SNAP program is not by converting it into a block grant program. Actually, block granting step is probably the first step to eliminating SNAP. That could be the fate of a number of safety-net programs such as child welfare services and elderly services. They were put together into the social services block grant. This year, the Republican budget eliminates them. I would welcome the opportunity to work with my friends on the other side of the aisle to find ways to improve the SNAP program seeing as it actually serves more constituents often in their districts, rural districts than actually their Democratic counterparts. The absence of widespread fraud and the tiny potential savings from SNAP belie the purported interest sometimes in oversight. So I look forward to the common ground. We want to make sure this program is effective and as clean as possible, but we don't want to harm in the process the people who rely on this program and use it to get back up on their feet and become productive citizens. With that, I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair now recognizes the chairwoman of the Subcommittee on Interior, Mrs. Lummis, for her opening statement. Mrs. Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to waive my opening statement so we can listen to our witnesses, and I want to especially thank you all for being here today. The representatives and witnesses from Maine and Florida, I believe, are particularly to be recognized for traveling all this way to provide their guidance and expertise on this subject. Having come from the executive branch of State government, I know how hard you work, and you are on the frontlines. We really appreciate what you do, so thank you for being here today to share your expertise, one and all. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentlewoman from Wyoming. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman, Mrs. Lummis, for her opening statement, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on Interior--Lawrence, I am sorry. Mrs. Lawrence. Sister from another mother. [Laughter.] Mr. Meadows. My apologies. Twins separated at birth. Mrs. Lawrence, go ahead. Mrs. Lummis. Go ahead, sis. Give them a good one. [Laughter.] Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would like to thank our witnesses for being here today. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, SNAP, is our country's most effective and important tool for fighting hunger. In 2015 there were over 45 million SNAP participants. While this number sounds extremely high, the Great Recession drove many to depend on SNAP. My home State of Michigan was hard-hit by the recession, as many of you know, and SNAP was there to help. Michigan received over $2.5 billion in SNAP benefits, 198 percent higher than the national average. And 1.6 million residents depend on SNAP benefits to survive. In my district, 49 percent of SNAP participants were in families with children, 27 percent were families with elderly, and 48 were working families. Ladies and gentlemen, understand the qualification income levels to receive SNAP, and 49 percent were working families. In other words, they were working poor. SNAP is not easy to get. The average monthly benefit is $126 per person. That is less than $32 per person a week. How many of you can live on $32 a week to feed yourself? Not a luxury, food is a human basic need. Recipients must go through a rigorous application process where they meet specific qualifications and prove their eligibility. SNAP recipients must reapply every 6 to 12 months and inform the State of their income changes. There are even minimum periods of disqualifications ranging from 1 to 6 months, which may be increased by the State SNAP agencies. States even have the option to disqualify an entire family for up to 180 days if the household head fails to comply with work requirements. So a child could be penalized if the parent does not comply. I would like to enter into the record the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services application booklet, which includes the types of forms families must fill out to get public assistance. And I want you to look at this. This is what a person is given in Michigan, 40 pages they must fill out in order to apply for SNAP. The SNAP benefit can only be used to purchase approved foods sold by authorized SNAP retailers. There is a restaurant option for populations that have difficulty preparing food such as elderly and veterans, and in a few States, including California, Arizona, and Michigan. I feel the allegations of fraud and abuse are overblown. SNAP has been one of the lowest fraud rates in any Federal program. Of the past several years, USDA has taken aggressive steps to improve SNAP oversight and to work with States in rooting out waste. USDA have seen declines in the rate of trafficking from 4 percent down to a little over 1 percent of benefits in the last 20 years. While no amount of fraud or waste is acceptable, we must not throw out the baby with the water. You would not shut off the water for an entire street or entire city if a few households leave their hoses on for an entire day. You would not stop buying groceries for your family because the oldest child drank up all of the milk or spilled it. We should not make the majority suffer for a few bad apples. But this is exactly what we are dealing with today. This year, Speaker Ryan's Task Force on Poverty, Opportunity, and Upward Mobility is proposing to transfer SNAP into a block grant. The 2017 budget, ladies and gentlemen, call on eliminating another block grant of social services for children and elderly. I am worried that some future actions by my colleagues on the other side of the aisle will call for eliminating a block grant that they are now trying to put into SNAP. And I yield back my time. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentlewoman from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence, for her opening statement. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, sir. But my sister and I, we are still good. Mr. Meadows. Well, we appreciate that. And I will hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. I will now recognize our panel of witnesses, and I am pleased to welcome Mr. Kevin Concannon, Under Secretary for Food, Nutrition, and Consumer Services at the U.S. Department of Agriculture, welcome; Ms. Kay Brown, director of Education, Workforce, and Income Security at the U.S. Government Accountability Office. Welcome, Ms. Brown. Ms. Mary Mayhew, commissioner of Maine's Department of Health and Human Services. Thank you, Ms. Mary Mayhew for your traveling and your willingness to be here. Mr. Mike Carroll, the secretary of the Florida Department of Children and Family Services. Thank you, Mr. Carroll, for making the special effort to be here. And Ms. Stacy Dean, vice president for food assistance policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Welcome to you all. And pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify, so I would ask that you please rise and raise your right hand. [Witnesses sworn.] Mr. Meadows. And let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. And in order to allow time for discussion, I would ask that you please limit your oral testimony to 5 minutes. However, your entire written testimony will be made part of the record. And I would go ahead and now recognize Mr. Concannon for 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF KEVIN CONCANNON Mr. Concannon. Thank you very much. Chairmen and members of the committee, I appreciate the opportunity to explain directly FNS's efforts to assure the integrity of the SNAP program. Integrity is essential to SNAP's success, and so it's paramount to me personally and to the agency. And as I've said many times, we have zero tolerance for fraud in SNAP. SNAP provides essential food assistance, nutrition education, work-support services to 44.3 million low-income individuals. In 2014, 64 percent of recipients were children, seniors, and those with disabilities, and 42 percent lived in a household with earnings. To those who claim that SNAP discourages work, I say that the data clearly states otherwise. In SNAP, those who can work must register to do so and accept a job if offered. This core program requirement cannot be waived by a State. In 2015, 13.6 million SNAP recipients were registered to work. USDA funds SNAP's employment and training programs to support States in helping recipients find and keep good-paying jobs. In 2015, SNAP EBT served more than 1 million recipients. Unfortunately, some State agencies do too little to use the Federal funding, technical assistance, and support available. So USDA has expanded its capacity to help States meet their E&T responsibilities through the newly established Office of Employment and Training, staff of the team with long experience at both the Federal and State level. They're building a more robust foundation of monitor, improve, and promote SNAP EBT. I believe strongly that the public's concern over high SNAP participation must be resolved in the right way, by getting people jobs. The wrong way is to reduce cost, is to kick people off SNAP, or worse, block grant it, which would also erode the national standards and accountability that helps make SNAP effective. Let me turn now to program integrity. USDA's focus on identifying, penalizing, and excluding those who seek to defraud SNAP has reduced trafficking from 4 percent to 1.3 percent over the last 20 years. While this is real progress when almost $70 billion total are involved, there's no acceptable level of fraud, and complacency is never an option. Continuous attention, energy, and diligence are required. This administration is pursuing an energetic anti- trafficking strategy. First, we've organized SNAP retailer management into a single centralized business structure that targets resources to high-risk areas. Second, we use data analytics to closely track EBT transactions and identify stores most likely to traffic. Third, we've upgraded our alert system with state-of-the-art technology to better detect suspicious activity and are strengthening policies to combat misuse of benefits and impose stronger penalties against retailers who break the rules. Store owners that traffic are disqualified for life. And on the GAO report, we're in mutual agreement and support both the findings and the recommendations of the GAO audit. These efforts bring real results. In 2015, we issued almost 2,700 sanctions against violating retailers, a 21 percent increase over the prior year. More than 1,900 store owners were permanently disqualified for trafficking or falsifying applications, and over 700 are sanctioned for other violations. We believe that predictive data analytics, combined with related information such as excessive requests for card replacements can be real game-changers in targeting the most likely trafficking recipients. Unfortunately, very few States really take advantage of this option, so there's much room for improvement. While the Federal Government is responsible for controlling retailer trafficking, action against recipient trafficking, the other side of the same crime, is a State agency responsibility. States conduct investigations of recipient fraud, disqualify violation of SNAP, and make claims to recover improperly received benefits. That said, I must caution that while some States see photo EBT cards as a solution to trafficking, it does not work as well as they may think. Let me explain. SNAP is a household benefit, so any member of that household may legally use that card. Putting one person's photo on the card simply creates confusion at the point of sale. A card with a photo cannot and will not prevent two bad actors from breaking the law, case-in- point, the 2001 audit in the State of Missouri. But it is an option for States, and our main concern is that States that implement photo EBT comply with Federal law and regulation. That's part of our oversight duties. One final but very important point I want to make, the majority of SNAP recipients honor the rules, play by the rules, as is true of the majority of retailers as well. The Nation entrusts USDA and our State partners to administer SNAP with accountability and integrity. Americans expect and deserve their government to manage hard-earned tax dollars. Without that, we simply cannot sustain public confidence. That's why we are committed to tough action to find and punish fraud. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Mr. Concannon follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you. Ms. Brown, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF KAY BROWN Ms. Brown. Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Lawrence, and members of the subcommittees, I'm pleased to be here today to discuss our work on Federal and State efforts to combat fraud by SNAP recipients. My remarks are based on our 2014 report with updates on USDA actions on our recommendations. We studied the efforts of 11 States to prevent recipient fraud and detect recipient trafficking. First on preventing recipient fraud, States are responsible for investigating possible intentional program violations such as whether applicants have made false or misleading statements in order to obtain benefits. All 11 selected States were using well-known tools either required or recommended by USDA for detecting fraud. States were operating fraud hotlines and comparing information provided by applicants with data from various sources to check for accuracy. Some States were performing additional checks such as paying private companies for data to confirm the income information provided by applicants. However, most of these States reported difficulties in conducting fraud investigations in part due to steady or even reduced staffing levels at a time when the numbers of SNAP recipients had grown significantly. Further, the size, range of duties, and programs covered by the investigative units varied widely by State. We recommended that USDA explore ways that Federal financial incentives could better support cost- effective State fraud prevention efforts. Regarding detecting recipient trafficking, concerns had been raised that recipients may be trafficking their benefits by exchanging them for cash or goods and services on e-commerce and social media sites. In response, USDA recommended States use certain free Web-based automated tools to help detect such trafficking. However, State officials reported problems with these tools, and upon testing them, we found them to be of limited use. In fact, we found that manually searching e- commerce Web sites produced more positive results than were detected by the automated tools. We recommended that USDA reassess its guidance. We also reviewed USDA's guidance to States regarding recipients who requested multiple EBT card replacements. This can be but is not necessarily an indication of trafficking. We found that States had limited success detecting fraud using USDA's approach. Instead, using data we obtained from three States, we developed a more targeted and efficient approach. By combining data sources, we identified households that had requested multiple replacement cards and, at around the same time, had also made purchases considered to be potential signs of trafficking. This type of approach can help identify households at higher risk of trafficking for benefits. And we recommended that USDA revisit its guidance in this area. Finally, we also studied USDA oversight of State antifraud activities. We reported that USDA had increased its oversight in recent years. It issued new regulations and guidance and commissioned studies on recipient fraud. Also, in fiscal year 2013 for the first time, the Department examined all 50 States' compliance with Federal requirements governing SNAP antifraud activities. Despite these efforts, we found that USDA did not have consistent and reliable data on States' activities. Its reporting guidance lacked specificity, and States did not have a uniform understanding of what should be reported. As a result, USDA could not compare activities and performance across States. We recommended the Department take steps to enhance the consistency among State reports. USDA officials agreed with all of our recommendations and are taking substantive steps in response. As you have just heard, they have made progress in studying improved anti- trafficking approaches, and they have redesigned the forms States used to report investigations. However, they have yet to finalize actions that would fully address all of our recommendations. Given the significant size of the program, the reality of constrained public resources, and the constant advances in technology, it's particularly important that USDA make every effort to make sure SNAP funds are used for their intended purposes. This concludes my statement. I'm happy to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Ms. Brown follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Ms. Brown. Ms. Mayhew, you are recognized for 5 minutes, but before you start, I wanted to just say it was interesting to hear from your Governor about really leaving the home in an unbelievable age of 11 to go out and--so someone who has experienced poverty firsthand and now has raised to the highest level of the executive government in the State of Maine is a great story about American greatness. So, Ms. Mayhew, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF MARY MAYHEW Ms. Mayhew. Thank you, Chairman Meadows and members of the subcommittees. I appreciate the invitation to be here today to share some of our key welfare reforms that have helped to deter fraud, protect benefits for the truly needy, and guard against waste of precious taxpayer dollars. When Governor LePage took office in 2011, he prioritized reforming Maine's welfare programs to help lift families and individuals out of poverty and away from welfare dependency. Program integrity and accountability are critical to those reforms. There is no doubt that fraud exists in these programs, and every dollar that is diverted through fraudulent and criminal activity is a dollar taken away from a child or a family in need. The programs we have put in place to reduce fraud and abuse help to ensure that taxpayer dollars are reaching those in need, not fueling criminal activity. Our program integrity efforts have focused on data analytics, engagement with law enforcement, and commonsense measures to guard against fraud and abuse. I want to share a few of our efforts and make some suggestions for further improvements in the SNAP program. We have provided a number of recommendations attached to my testimony. Working with local law enforcement officials, we found regular instances of multiple EBT cards recovered in drug busts. In most cases, the cards are not issued to the suspects who are holding them. We know there is an unfortunate connection between benefits trafficking and the drug trafficking world, but current Federal SNAP regulations often create barriers to pursuing these traffickers. FNS rules provide that if someone has the EBT card and the PIN, they are considered an authorized user of the card. Regulations should require authorized users to register with the welfare agency and be limited to no more than three per case, similar to WIC. Under Federal law, States have the option of placing photos on EBT cards. Maine pursued this option to help address the trafficking in EBT cards for drugs or cash. When someone's picture is on their card, it follows that they are less likely to sell it or trade it. Maine's photo EBT program is voluntary, and we currently have about 60,000 cards with photos out of 101,000 SNAP cases. While this is a legal option for all States, myriad regulations and rules place a chilling effect on States that may be considering photos. This basic protection against fraud and abuse should be streamlined so States can implement this reform without undue burden. It would also be a reasonable step to require States to place photos on their EBT cards to deter fraud. In 2011, Maine had more than $15 million in welfare benefits spent outside of Maine, including significant amounts in places like the Bronx, Brooklyn, Philadelphia, and Worchester, Massachusetts. Our drug enforcement agents in Maine have been clear that these cities are hubs for heroin trafficking and other drugs which flow up the I-95 corridor to Maine. Our data system identifies anyone using a Maine EBT card exclusively in another State for 2 consecutive months. We then follow up to confirm Maine residency and appropriate use of the benefit. Our efforts have reduced out-of-state use, but the data still shows uses of SNAP benefits in places all over the country like New York, California, and Florida. Federal regulations don't currently allow States to restrict SNAP benefits to certain geographic areas. We believe there should be some reasonable restrictions on the mobility of EBT cards. Often, what SNAP benefit cards are trafficked, it is in conjunction with a SNAP-approved retailer who's helping turn the card to cash that can be used to purchase things other than food. In a recent Maine case of suspected retailer fraud, a small store with just one cash register had SNAP reimbursements totaling nearly that of a large local Hannaford grocery store with 18 cash registers. We found numerous purchases of $300 and above in this small store that had no grocery carts. This same store is suspected of trading cash for EBT cards and helping SNAP participants commit tax fraud. States do not have the authority to remove noncompliant or fraudulent stores from SNAP participation. To assist with this problem, States should be given the authority to investigate and remove offending retailers similar to WIC. All States should operate robust welfare fraud investigation units. To incentivize this, States should be allowed to retain 50 percent of funds collected from welfare fraud overpayments instead of the current 35 percent. Additionally, Federal rules should require that recipients cooperate with State welfare fraud investigators if there is a credible allegation of fraud or risk losing their benefits. Maine is determined to address the issue of fraud and to protect benefits for our neediest residents. States need additional tools. Federal laws and rules should allow and encourage States to pursue meaningful program integrity efforts without unnecessary barriers. Today, policies that combat fraud are too often sacrificed in the name of convenient and expeditious access to welfare benefits. We hope that Congress and the Federal Government will give serious consideration to our suggested reforms and will work to ensure that laws and regulations give States a fighting chance against fraud and criminal activity. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Ms. Mayhew follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Ms. Mayhew. Mr. Carroll, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF MIKE CARROLL Mr. Carroll. Thank you, Chairman Meadows. It's an honor to be here with you today and share some insights from Florida. The SNAP eligibility process has changed significantly over the past 20 years. Today, Florida is a leader in the modernization of our social services system. Virtually every State in the Nation has come to Florida to study our model. Today, we receive 93 percent of our applications online. Eligibility staff was reduced from 7,000 to 4,000. Cost-per- eligibility transaction dropped from $30 per application to $7, all while maintaining accuracy rates at or above 99 percent. All of these are at benchmark levels on a national level. Our experience is testament to how government can run an operation that is cost-effective, efficient, and optimizes access to services in a simplified way for customers. We do have a new fight on our hands, however, and it's identity theft and EBT trafficking. Our challenge now is to balance the need to continue being efficient with the need to maintain the integrity of this program going forward, and I am not talking about the individual who may fudge their income or their household composition. We're talking about major criminal enterprises with ties to drug sales, prostitution, and human trafficking. We have to work together and we have to work quickly to invest in the right technology, integrate fraud detection in every level of our process, and coordinate more effectively a response that's much more urgent than we currently have. In Florida, we've implemented effective front-end detection systems and commonsense legislation to address obvious fraud and abuse at the roots. We banned EBT card transactions at all adult entertainment and gambling venues and in the purchase of alcohol, we've created a fraud reward program, we've enhanced criminal penalties for fraud, and we've revised the definition of EBT trafficking in Florida law to include swapping food benefits for weapons or controlled substances. Last year, our Office of Public Benefits Integrity conducted more than 23,000 investigations, which resulted in cost avoidance of $27.6 million of benefits that would have been otherwise administered to folks who were not eligible. How can we improve the system? Florida has demonstrated the success of advanced technology with our automated identity verification tool and the complete automation of the system. We think we need to continue to invest in technology like this both at the front end and the back end of the system. We also would like to work with our Federal partners to build on these capabilities and eliminate the one-size-fits-all approach. We have to give States the flexibility and the space to implement and execute these programs and policies while still being able to come up with innovative solutions that meets the needs of the citizens in their State. We also suggest that we consider changing the current burden of proof of recipient fraud from a clear-and-convincing standard to a preponderance of the evidence, the same standard that's used for retailer fraud. Right now, it is easier to arrest a recipient than to disqualify them from the SNAP program. When it comes to retailer fraud, and this is where we feel a real sense of urgency in Florida, we need a much more comprehensive and urgent approach. FNS must start immediately suspending a SNAP retailer upon a criminal arrest. We need to require that retailers repay trafficked amounts in administrative sanctions that rarely happens now. SNAP retailer applications must be scrutinized more closely before vendors become authorized retailers. And we have to change the way we provide incentives to States and move away from a pay-and-chase model and start focusing on an upfront prevention model. I do want to talk briefly about the case that you mentioned, Opa-locka. It was the largest food stamp trafficking bust in Federal programs history. Twenty-two retailers were arrested. Investigators found cash and guns. They found storefronts that were actually drug sale operations, human trafficking, and prostitution operations. They found empty storage rooms, rotten produce, empty display boxes, plastic fruit and vegetables on display. One store owner was an illegal alien who used someone else's Social Security number to get FNS authorization. Another owner was here on a work permit. Another failed to disclose they were a convicted felon. Since 2011 when DCF first reported the fraud, nearly $89 million in SNAP transactions have taken place at this location. DCF now has to review 41,000 SNAP recipients just since July, and that number is growing, to find cases that might rise to the level of clear and convincing evidence. And today, we've not been able to disqualify one SNAP recipient who was involved in that. The trafficking continues. At least eight retailers continue to operate in that location. In fact, the 2 weeks following the arrest, they did over $163 in EBT redemptions. Clearly, we can do better than this. In the State of Florida we're absolutely committed to making sure that folks who are eligible to receive these free services receive them in the most accurate and timely fashion possible, but we are equally as committed to making sure that we maintain the integrity of this program. And we do want to work with our Federal partners to make sure that happens. [Prepared statement of Mr. Carroll follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Carroll, for your illuminating testimony. Ms. Dean, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF STACY DEAN Ms. Dean. Thank you. Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Lawrence, thank you for the invitation to testify today. I'm Stacy Dean, vice president for Food Assistance Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a nonpartisan policy institute. I'm really pleased to have the opportunity to talk to you today about program integrity in SNAP. I've worked on SNAP for more than 20 years, and one of the most rewarding parts of my job is to work directly with State officials on improving the program at the local level, and that includes policy and operations related to program integrity. SNAP is the Nation's most important anti-hunger program. It currently helps about 44 million low-income Americans, or 1 in 7 Americans, to afford a nutritionally adequate diet each day at the more than 200,000 retail store outlets that take the benefits. Despite its modest benefits which average only $1.41 per person per meal, it has powerful short- and long-term impacts. It helps family and communities weather tough economic times, it reduces poverty and food insecurity, it improves health, and it does support work. SNAP's successes can largely be attributed to its national entitlement structure, it's relatively uniform eligibility standards, its standards for program administration and integrity, and the fact that it's a food-based benefit. SNAP does operate with efficiency and has relatively sound program integrity. As I've outlined in my testimony and as you heard from Under Secretary Concannon, SNAP has a strong track record on issuing benefits accurately and identifying and preventing fraud. Critics who claim that caseload growth in recent years has been driven by waste, fraud, and abuse are just simply incorrect. Program integrity has two fundamental components. One is reducing errors, which is ensuring that benefits are issued to the correct people in the correct amount, and most error in the program resulting under--around error is a result of human error meaning basic mistakes, not fraud. States actually report that the majority of error in--that occurs through payment-- through payment accuracy measurement is their fault and not clients'. By contrast, fraud is when clients or retailers collude to exchange benefits for nonfood items or some of the unfortunate activities you've heard of already today, or intentionally lie to the program for personal benefit. Each of these issues, error and fraud, merits their own solutions. Identifying and proving a retailer is trafficking is quite a different problem than ensuring State workers throughout the country understand program rules and are applying them correctly. We support the ongoing effort to maintain and improve SNAP's program integrity. As new technology becomes available and as awareness of how problems are arising, there will just continue to be opportunities to improve SNAP accuracy and prevent fraud, and that's why the most recent farm bill included several new initiatives. We encourage you to assess new ideas against several criteria. The first question is always does it work? USDA and States have a strong history of testing and trying new ideas to assess impacts in order to determine the potential effectiveness nationally, and I think the Florida demo is a great example of that. This--another question is what's the scope and scale of the problem under discussion? Some of the most egregious examples of fraud are highly isolated incidences. They are completely unacceptable, but they may be so infrequent such that they shouldn't drive the programs fundamental approach to addressing more common everyday program integrity issues. Building processes based on the assumption that everyone who uses this program is a criminal just simply isn't an effective way to run the program. Obviously, we need to look at what are the proposed--or proposed solutions, projected costs, and benefits. I do think it's important to--even though this seems obvious, when a proposal is promoted as an anti-fraud activity, some are really reluctant to rigorously weigh its benefits and costs out of fear of being perceived as soft on fraud. And data-matching, I think, is a very good example. High-quality focused matches to test the veracity of client statements against available data is a terrific tool both for access and integrity, but expanding matches to--against data that may be completely irrelevant to a household's current circumstances is a waste of resources and could undermine integrity. Will the proposal have any negative consequences? Any new program integrity proposal needs to consider the implications on access and whether all individuals, particularly individuals with disabilities or other special needs, could navigate them. And finally, who's promoting the change? Often, private vendors selling program integrity solutions are some of SNAP's biggest critics. Their self-interest in promoting the perception of a program in crisis really has to be considered. Cost, not a lack of interest or new ideas, is often our biggest obstacle to addressing fraud and error. While the Federal Government shares in the cost of administering the program, State budgets are often the limiting factor to ensuring the best systems and technology are deployed nationwide. Many States have downsized their program operations during the recent recession and have not yet rebuilt the capacity to take full advantage of new technology options or the staff resources that could improve their efforts. So I look forward to the discussion today. Thank you very much. [Prepared statement of Ms. Dean follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Ms. Dean. The chair recognizes the vice chair of the Subcommittee on Government Operations, the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Walberg. Mr. Walberg. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to the panel for being here. This week, my colleagues on the Republican side of the aisle began unveiling a policy, as was mentioned earlier, an agenda that is intended to tackle some of our country's biggest challenges. The first plank of our initiative looks at ways to address poverty, and SNAP is a key part of our safety net to serve and support the most vulnerable and make sure that that is the population we really and intentionally meet the needs of. Our initiative is aimed at lifting people out of poverty and onto the ladder of opportunity, and so, Commissioner Mayhew, I was especially struck in your testimony, your personal testimony, about the lessons your family passed on to you about the value of hard work, depression-era, not you ---- Ms. Mayhew. Thank you. Mr. Walberg.--though my parents had the same story, but they were the ones in the depression era, so I came from that. And they had similar lessons, again, from that experience that I think have benefited me well and apparently you also. If you would be so good, Commissioner Mayhew, as to talk in more detail about the Federal SNAP regulations that create barriers, as you mentioned, barriers to your efforts to pursue those who traffic in benefits. Give us some more insight on that. Ms. Mayhew. Thank you. I appreciate the opportunity to elaborate. Certainly, we care deeply. The Governor cares deeply about the success of these safety net programs. And it is critical that we are constantly evaluating whether or not our limited resources are being used effectively to support vulnerable individuals and families. I also have the privilege of overseeing our child welfare agency, and I want to make a point and a connection about what we are seeing in terms of the challenges and truly destruction of our families when 60 percent of the children today who are coming into protective custody are doing so as a result of parental substance abuse. We know we have a serious challenge in our State with drugs, with substance abuse, and certainly, as I mentioned in my testimony, we know there's a connection with trafficking and EBT cards for drugs and for cash. So as we look at ways in which to deter, we do feel strongly that the opportunity to use photos on EBT cards, we've been very clear that the photo on the EBT card is to discourage fraud, that when we speak and work with local drug enforcement agents and they tell us about the number of EBT cards that they are confiscating from drug raids, and since we have implemented photos, they have not confiscated an EBT card with a photo on it. The challenge has been, as we have implemented, we've received numerous concerns and communications from the USDA regarding our implementation of this federally permitted option. And again, we've done it on a voluntary basis. Mr. Walberg. I was going to bring that up again. I think you mentioned it was voluntary. Ms. Mayhew. It is voluntary. Okay. We certainly offer to individuals the ability to put their photo on the EBT card ---- Mr. Walberg. So what is the problem the Federal Government is giving on that then if ---- Ms. Mayhew. They have raised a number of barriers. When we first decided that we were going to implement, we had provided a number of documents to the USDA to provide all of the background to how we intended to implement responding to all of their questions. We were told to stop, to not go forward. We felt very strongly, the Governor felt very strongly that, again, this is federally permitted, that we had addressed the questions that had been asked of us, provided detailed plans of how we were operationalizing this and again felt strongly that this was a significant tool. More recently, we have developed a partnership with our Bureau of Motor Vehicles to more conveniently access the driver's license photos. We are getting authorized consent from each of the individuals to use their driver's license photo, and we recently received another letter telling us to basically cease-and-desist between two State agencies that have agreed to do this, and we now have the USDA asking us to stop. Mr. Walberg. To not do it even though you were permitted to do it by law? Ms. Mayhew. We are. And again ---- Mr. Concannon. They must do it, though, within the framework of Federal law and regulations, and that was the issue in Maine. Mr. Walberg. Well, I guess that is ---- Mr. Concannon. Poorly implemented, and I want Mr. Walberg. Excuse me. Excuse me. Mr. Concannon.--the record to show that. Mr. Walberg. Excuse me. Excuse me. I was asking Ms. Mayhew. I would like a full or description then if I could, Mr. Chairman, of what the pushback was. It indicated in the constraints of the law itself, but what were you violating according to them? Ms. Mayhew. We have not--in all of the letters and the back-and-forth we have not seen any verified, documented issues where we have poorly implemented or--you know, we can make a lot of these issues complicated. I oversee a large State agency. I know how quickly government can make things complicated. We are trying to protect this safety net program. We see the trafficking in these cards that is taking away a vital resource for a vulnerable child, from a family, and we have identified this as a meaningful tool to discourage trafficking. It has felt as though--you know, and I struggle a little bit with hearing that it's an option and then hearing all of the reasons why they don't believe that it's an effective tool. So it does feel as though we're constantly receiving all of the reasons why we can't move forward. And this is an option that we have elected to pursue. We have done it in consultation with the USDA. We have responded to their questions. We have met with their staff. This dates back to the spring of 2014 that we have been working with the USDA, responding to their questions, but we want to do it in partnership with the shared goals. Mr. Walberg. I appreciate that. My time is expired, but, Mr. Chairman, I appreciate you giving me that extra time because it is frustrating to hear of a State that is attempting to do something that seems to be having some positive impact, trying to do an option that they have available from Federal Government, continually push back. And again the perspective seems to have come already even in testimony that while it is an option, yet the feds don't want it to be an option. So I hope we get further information as we move along, but thank you. Mr. Concannon. Mr. Chairman, I'd like the opportunity to respond ---- Mr. Meadows. Hold on just a second. Mr. Concannon.--to some of that. Mr. Meadows. We are going to go to the ranking member real quickly, and he probably will give you a chance to respond. If not, when I get my time, I will, okay? Mr. Connolly. Mr. Concannon, we just heard the State of Maine, my goodness, all they are trying to do is make sure there is not fraud and trafficking, and they are trying to do the right thing while preserving the program and the benefits and the safety net. And Ms. Mayhew runs a big program in a small State and a big bad Federal Government is just apparently, for no reason whatsoever, preventing them from doing this commonsense thing. You weren't given an opportunity to respond. I want to give you that opportunity. Mr. Concannon. I very much appreciate that. And just incidentally for the record, I'm a legal resident of the State of Maine, very familiar with what goes on ---- Mr. Connolly. You sound it. Mr. Concannon.--in that State and ran this very same department for a number of years. So it's not news to me. First of all, it is an option to the State. We want the State, if States so elect, to adopt it, perfectly fine, but it has to be done in ways in which, for example, Maine, the business community was advised and trained on what to expect. There was a lot of confusion right at the outset by various--some other people in the retail business in Maine. They felt they were not really adequately trained, addressed about it. Consumers were confused about it. Was it--we sent people up to a regional office. They were unclear whether it was an option or mandatory. So we simply want it done properly. We're not opposed to it. So some of what I've heard today, you know, really greatly overstating some of these things. Mr. Connolly. So there is another side to the story? Mr. Concannon. There's a considerable other side to the story. Mr. Connolly. And did at any point your office of the Federal Government preclude Maine from pursuing this option? Mr. Concannon. No, we did not. Mr. Connolly. Did you advise them they should not use the option even though ---- Mr. Concannon. We did not. Mr. Connolly.--it is an option? Mr. Concannon. We asked them, though, before they proceeded to make sure that they had done their training and so on, and they insisted on going ahead. Mr. Connolly. Okay. Mr. Concannon. And so we had a problem. Mr. Connolly. Let the record show, Mr. Chairman, that we had contradictory testimony in that matter. Apparently, there is another side to the story. Mr. Connolly. Ms. Dean, what would happen if we took this program and just made it a block grant? What is wrong with that? Ms. Dean. Well ---- Mr. Connolly. Please, please microphone. Ms. Dean. Thank you. I think the single most powerful element of the program is its entitlement structure. It responds to increased need whether that's at the national level when we have the kind of significant and deep recession that we had several years ago, the State level due to a downturn, or a community or even an individual family household level. When folks, when their income goes down, they can apply for benefits, and the program is available ---- Mr. Connolly. Why couldn't they do that if it were a block grant program so that Ms. Mayhew or Mr. Carroll could manage it and decide ---- Ms. Dean. Across the board ---- Mr. Connolly.--who qualifies? Ms. Dean.--block grants come with capped funding and that funding ---- Mr. Connolly. With what? Ms. Dean. Capped funding, fixed capped funding that does not increase every year. Mr. Connolly. Oh, so the fine print in block granting is we also cut the program? Ms. Dean. Absolutely, both in terms of ---- Mr. Connolly. Ah. Ms. Dean.--erosion due to inflation, not responding to need, and ---- Mr. Connolly. Well, let me ask a different question because, you know, I come from northern Virginia, and while we love all Virginians and we love our General Assembly, we do tremble when our fate is in the hands of Richmond. And we sometimes describe Richmond as 300 years away. And when someone wants to block grant something or give the authority to regulate to Richmond rather than directly to the recipients, say, in my corner of the world, northern Virginia, we get nervous because formulas change and urban and suburban populations often end up paying a price. Now, if we block grant this program, could it also affect who receives benefits, not only the finite amount but could we find that States start finagling with who qualifies and who might receive what benefits? Ms. Dean. Absolutely. I don't actually think you even need to describe it as finagling. Mr. Connolly. I can't hear you. Ms. Dean. Yes, you don't need to describe it as finagling. States would--typically, under a block grant they're given the authority and power to set eligibility rules and standards. Mr. Connolly. Which is different than the current--the status quo today? Ms. Dean. Yes, it's a national program. Mr. Connolly. So the feds under the national program decide who is entitled and who qualifies? Ms. Dean. Yes, the Congress sets the rules. Mr. Connolly. Right. And so if we block grant it, that transfers that right and that authority to the States? Ms. Dean. Yes, it does. Mr. Connolly. And that is a mixed bag from a recipient's point of view? Ms. Dean. Yes, it is, and we've seen it be a mixed bag under cash assistance. Flexibility allows States to try and test new things, some of which can be terrific positive innovations, but the other--the incredible downside with flexibility is the fact that States have balanced budget requirements, and frequently, when they face a test against their budget, they need resources, say, because they've had a downturn. We've seen them turn to block grants as a way to divert funds from those--that core purpose, which in the case of SNAP is food, to other purposes to meet their shortfalls. Mr. Connolly. Thank you. Votes have been called, and I thank your indulgence, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. They have called votes, which is an unfortunate aspect for each one of you. Unfortunately, it looks like we have got three votes. I don't anticipate that we will be back before 3:30, so that will give you--you know, you can go get coffee, do whatever you need to do, but we will stand in recess until 3:30. [Recess.] Mr. Meadows. The joint committee will reconvene. Thank you all for your patience. We apologize. They were actually swearing in a new Member, so it took a little longer than normal. We are now up to an official 435 and so--the chair recognizes the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Palmer, for 5 minutes. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to go back to a couple of things that were brought up earlier. Mr. Concannon, in your written testimony you say that 42 percent of SNAP benefits lived in a household with working adults. Can you positively affirm that the working adult in the household is the SNAP participant? That is a yes or no. Mr. Concannon. The earnings ---- Mr. Palmer. No, sir. Let me rephrase it. Mr. Concannon. Okay. Mr. Palmer. Can you positively affirm that the working adult in those households is the SNAP participant? It is a yes or no. Mr. Concannon. Yes. Mr. Palmer. You can positively affirm that? I find that answer ---- Mr. Concannon. Yes, because anybody living in the household, their income is included in the SNAP benefit. Mr. Palmer. Well, it doesn't indicate that the income is from that participant because it could be another adult in the household. And I bring this up because ---- Mr. Concannon. Anybody in the household is included in the benefit. Mr. Palmer. Excuse me. Your own information says that in 2013 three-quarters had no earned income meaning they were not working at all. That is from USDA. That is your number. Mr. Concannon. I'm not sure what number you're referring to. Mr. Palmer. I am referring to the food and nutrition service characteristics of supplemental nutrition assistance program households, fiscal year 2013, U.S. Department of Agriculture. Mr. Concannon. Yes. So your--if you're talking about children, for example, almost half of the folks on food stamps are children, then seniors and people with disabilities ---- Mr. Palmer. No, I am talking about ---- Mr. Concannon.--and parents working for ---- Mr. Palmer.--you said ---- Mr. Concannon.--very young children. Mr. Palmer.--42 percent of SNAP participants lived in a household with a working adult, and then your 2013 report says that 75 percent had no earned income, and I just want to point out that inconsistency for the record. Ms. Mayhew ---- Mr. Concannon. I would be happy to provide you with clarification. Mr. Palmer.--you may be aware that in some--I beg your pardon? Mr. Concannon. We'd be happy to provide you with clarification on that in writing. Mr. Palmer. I would appreciate that, and I believe the committee would, too. Mr. Palmer. Ms. Mayhew, earlier when Mr. Concannon indicated that he had run the Maine program, it appeared that you wanted to make a clarification. Would you like to do that now? Ms. Mayhew. No, I appreciate ---- Mr. Palmer. Would you turn on your ---- Ms. Mayhew.--Mr. Concannon's response. Clearly he was a commissioner of the--of a Department of Human Services. Since that time, the agency has certainly changed somewhat. It merged. It created a much larger agency. But certainly I appreciate the history that Mr. Concannon has particularly with this program in Maine. Thank you. Mr. Palmer. I appreciate that. I am staying with you, and we touched on this a little bit before we had to break away. Do you believe there is a growing epidemic of SNAP benefits exchanging their cards for drugs? Ms. Mayhew. I do. And it is--certainly as we look across all of our programs within the Department and our desire to evaluate holistically our efforts to improve the lives of the individuals that we're serving, and certainly as I said, both looking at these welfare programs and their support of vulnerable families in my oversight of child welfare, I am incredibly concerned about the impact of drug abuse in Maine and the role that EBT cards are playing, being trafficked in for drugs and certainly for cash. Mr. Palmer. This past February, my own State of Alabama started to allow individuals with previous drug convictions to be eligible for benefits such as food stamps, and it is coming at a time when Alabama's monthly average SNAP enrollment has almost 20 percent more Alabama enrollees than we have in K through 12 public education system. So we are giving out food stamps, SNAP benefits faster than we are educating children to prepare them to join our workforce. Why shouldn't we be able to require drug testing in the program to ensure that taxpayer money is going toward the recipients it was intended, and why should the State be obligated to fund those programs if the individual engaging in activity that is harmful to them is not conducive to their reintegration into society? Ms. Mayhew. Congressman, we support drug testing. We have worked to increase drug testing in Maine. We have been met with resistance. We share your observations that these safety net programs are in fact intended to certainly help individuals out of poverty onto that pathway of prosperity and employment and that any amount of substance abuse is detracting from their ability to succeed and to be self-sufficient and again on that pathway to employment. It is clearly counterproductive to those goals. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Chairman, with the indulgence of the committee and the chair if I may, I would like to make one other point and that is in regard to Ms. Dean's comment that we went through a recession and apparently believes that our economy has recovered. I would wonder if our economy has recovered why there are almost 5 times as many people on food stamps as there were in 2008 and three times as many as in 2009. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman from the District of Columbia, Ms. Eleanor Holmes Norton, for 5 minutes. Ms. Norton. I just want to mention that the issues you are running into with drug testing is we can't just drug-test people. There has to be some predicate laid in a constitutional system to doing that, and that is why I think courts have cast some doubt on doing drug testing as drug testing. I do want to note, especially the GAO report where no new recommendations were made, I put them in that the program is making some progress. And I note that the GAO report does note some continuing challenges, and the first one it notes is inadequate staffing levels. You know, if we want more of something, then we have to do more of something else. So I want to congratulate all of you involved in the program for what you have been able to do at a time of sequestration with what resources you have. Congress is quick to chastise programs for what they haven't done but offers very little self-criticism of what its obligation is, so I do want that for the record to be known. I also want to say for the record some of us have a tradition of trying to live for a week on SNAP benefits. All I can tell you, it took me close to starvation when I tried to adhere to it for a full week, so I am pretty convinced that they are not extravagant rewards here for needing what we used to call food stamps. I was interested in this very low fraud rate because it is among the lowest if not the lowest in the Federal Government. You might expect it to be the highest given what we have just gone through in the Great Recession and the like. And so I am trying to get to the bottom of what is left. I am not sure anybody can get it to zero, and I compliment you for trying to do that. But I want to know if the main part of SNAP's improper payments are administrative or are they fraud? Mr. Concannon. If I may, Congresswoman, on the improper payment rate for the SNAP program, this refers to when consumers come into the program, 60 percent of that problem are mistakes made by State or county ---- Ms. Norton. So give me examples of the kind of mistakes in the course ---- Mr. Concannon. Well, they may not correctly record the income of the consumer. Forty percent is on a--the mistake is made by the consumer, occasionally deliberately but often it may be, hey, I didn't properly report my income or my spouse or somebody else considered in the household had some part-time income. So--but 60 percent of it is a State mistake. When we look at improper payments, the chair referenced the $2 billion or so estimate. That's the combined underpayment as well as overpayment because about two-thirds of it is an overpayment on the part of the State, but about one-third of it is we underpay consumers based on the--and the convention has been the requirement--this used to drive me crazy when I was a State director--we have to count both of them as though they were aggregated together. Ms. Norton. I don't know why you have to count both numbers. They are not the same numbers. I tell you one thing, if you are undercounting, you never get that money back, so I don't even understand how it helps us to understand what is happening to say lob it all together, who cares? But that ---- Mr. Meadows. Will the gentlewoman yield for just a second? I will be glad to work with her on that particular issue. Ms. Norton. I thank the chairman very much for his intervention, and he is in a position to do it. I know he means it when he says it, my good friend. I understand when you see this low level, wow, that the program has very strict eligibility requirements and a rigorous application process. You know, people don't like what you have to go through to apply for anything in government, but is that the case? And how do you facilitate people getting their benefits when the eligibility requirements are so strict and apparently adhered to? Mr. Concannon. Well, I might point out something that was referenced earlier to the deep recession we have just come through. Prior to that deep recession, again, I spent 25 years as a State director in different States. Across the country, typically, about half of the people who are eligible for the program were receiving it. They met the income eligibility, they were citizens of the United States who are here legally. Only about half were receiving it. During the deep recession, more people came forward but also States on a bipartisan basis, Democrats and Republican Governors, simplified the process still within the law. And now, about estimated 85 percent of people who meet the eligibility requirements receive the benefit. Ms. Norton. Well, it took a recession to do it but I congratulate you for bringing forward people who are hungry and apparently needed the program all along. Look, I don't see a lot to complain about in this program with your low eligibility rate, with the GAO who loves to tell people what they are doing wrong, saying they don't have any current recommendations at this time, so you deserve the commendation of the committee as well. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Meadows. I thank you. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman, for 5 minutes. Mr. Grothman. Thanks much. I think we are eventually going to call on Ms. Mayhew to ask questions, but I will just make a little comment first. I think there is probably no program in my district that people come up and talk to me about more. People are aware almost anywhere that they sell food stamps or whatever, SNAP, for 50 cents on the dollar, and of course if you needed every dollar on food, you wouldn't be selling your food for 50 cents on the dollar, so that by itself indicates that there is--you know, people are getting these things who don't need them at all. You know, I know somebody whose sister runs a grocery store, and she says you can tell just by what is in the cart who has got the SNAP and who is paying their money, and I think that is routine, which also shows there is something fundamentally wrong program. It is one of many welfare-related programs that our employers attribute to having a hard time getting employees to work because of course the more you work, the more you lose the benefits. And finally, it is something more and or we are hearing over time that discourages people from raising children in wedlock because, of course, if you raise children in wedlock, like many other welfare benefits, you lose your SNAP. I think that is probably, of all the bad things about the program, the worst. It is one more inducement to raise children out of wedlock, which is unfortunate. But we are going to start with Ms. Mayhew. Could you comment on after you went through the wonderful things you did are SNAP benefits still being sold for 50 cents on the dollar in Maine? What is the going rate as far as you know? Ms. Mayhew. Well, certainly, we have, as I indicated, partnered with local law enforcement to both train them on the misuse of EBT cards to provide assistance with them. We certainly continue to have cases where EBT cards are trafficked in. It's unfortunate for the Congressman from Alabama. There was a very high-profile case about a year ago where--very similar to what you are describing, rampant trafficking and EBT cards selling at 50 cents on the dollar, significant engagement with retailers. I think, you know, certainly, we all have shared the same goals of improving the integrity of this program. There are need--there was a need for additional fraud investigators. For the New England region there's one fraud investigator for the USDA. I mean, I think that alone would indicate that we're under-resourced. Mr. Grothman. Right. I will just give you the question. In Maine what is the going rate for SNAP right now? Are they selling it for 50 cents on the dollar, 60 cents on the dollar? What is the going rate? Ms. Mayhew. I honestly can't comment on--I think that just varies on the individual who's trying to get cash. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Well, I will ask Ms. Dean. Do you live here in the Washington, D.C., area? Ms. Dean. I do. Mr. Grothman. When you ask your local ---- Mr. Meadows. Put your mic on, please. Mr. Grothman. What is the going rate for SNAP benefits in the Washington, D.C., area? Ms. Dean. I'm not sure that that--like Commissioner Mayhew, I don't think that there is a common understanding or a shared understanding of it. It is a very rare occurrence. Mr. Grothman. Wait a minute. Whenever I talk to people in the food stores or people of the class that good food share, they don't think it is uncommon. They tell me about these 50- cents-on-the-dollar sales all the time. In Florida, Mr. Carroll, what is the going rate for SNAP in Florida? Mr. Carroll. I can't answer that definitively. I will tell you what made the Opa-locka flea market so popular to draw folks not only from Florida but around the Nation was they were purchasing food stamps at 80 cents on the dollar. And we know that because on several of the stores that were rated, they actually--it was like a sale sign that you go in and you would see all the things and then you would see the 20 percent off sale. It was right on the registers, how much $30 would be converted into, how much $600 would be converted into, so it was right there. Folks saw it. It was posted. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Mr. Concannon, when you get out and talk to people in the underclass, what are they selling their SNAP benefits for? Mr. Concannon. I travel across the country, including Florida, Maine, I was in Michigan earlier this week. As has already been noted, it is a rarity. I want to be very clear on that, that there are 44 million people in the country. The vast majority of them abide by the rules. Just as there are 260,000 authorized retailers, most of them abide by the rules, but we have a proposal out these days to strengthen the requirements for convenience stores. That's where much of this happens. I do want to make a comment on something you mentioned because I think it's a misunderstanding. One, there is no penalty in the SNAP program if you're married or not married. If you live in the same household with somebody, you share the meal, we count that whether you're married or not, so there is not a marriage penalty. And I just want to be clear about that because when that's expressed, people don't understand that. They think, hey, that's a problem. Mr. Grothman. No. No, no, no. Mr. Concannon. It's not part of the SNAP program. Mr. Grothman. No, can I finish up because he is just saying something I don't think is true or he is ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, we will save that for a second round -- -- Mr. Grothman. Okay. Mr. Meadows.--if we can at this ---- Mr. Grothman. You want to give me a second round. Mr. Meadows. Okay. So the chair recognizes the gentlewoman from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence, for 5 minutes. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, sir. SNAP provides critical support to people seeking to enter into the workforce by providing services to people who are looking for employment or training to become self-sufficient in contrast to the stereotype that if you are on SNAP, you are at home not working. Mr. Dean, some critics of SNAP believe that participation in SNAP discourages work, yet your testimony states that the SNAP participants want to work and do work. Can you explain in more detail how SNAP helps people when they are unemployed and how it helps to support and encourage work? I am sorry, I am sorry. Mrs. Dean, I am sorry. Ms. Dean. That's all right. Well, first of all, one of the core elements of the program that allows participants who aren't working to obtain and maintain a job is that the eligibility limits, while restrictive, are set significantly higher than, say, a cash--the cash-assistance programs most States offer. So participants who are not working can get a job, their benefits are reduced, but they can maintain eligibility. There's also an earnings disregard built in the program so that income coming from work is treated more favorably than income, say, from Social Security or other unearned sources. We see a significant share of participants working. If you look at working-age adults who aren't disabled, over half of them are working, and if you look at the year before or the year after a typical month of receipt, that goes to above 80 percent. The bottom line is that you cannot--it is nearly impossible to be poor in this country and not be working. There's very limited forms of assistance available to struggling unemployed families. The unemployment insurance program is an open door for low-income workers who are in and out of the workforce. TANF cash assistance is incredibly restrictive. SNAP is the benefit that is available to all low-income individuals, nonworking and working like. Mrs. Lawrence. I just can't pass up an opportunity to make a statement here. There are many who debate Planned Parenthood and contraceptives and say that the life of a child is precious. How can we debate that once a child is born that we would not ensure that the child would not be hungry? In America, SNAP program feeds poverty, those who cannot provide, those who are working poor so that they can have food. And I continue to say food is not a luxury, it is a human basic need. And so it troubles me when you have this conflict of philosophies. Once a child is born in this world and they are in America, we don't have a choice of whether we are born or not, we are born, and that in America this program, SNAP, says that if you are in America, you will be able to get food to eat so that you can live. Just one last point, Ms. Dean. Many States have suspended the limited due to high unemployment rates during this recent recession, but that is now changing. I understand that some States are kicking hundreds of thousands of people off SNAP this year. Can you discuss why this is happening in some States and not in others? Ms. Dean. Sure. The 1996 welfare law included a provision that limited SNAP to 3 months out of every 36 months, so 3 months out of every 3 years, for childless adults unless they are working 20 hours a week. It's a little bit more complicated, but that's the gist. States have the ability--and this--there's no obligation on the State to offer a job slot or test the individual's willingness to work. It is truly a time limit in most States that apply the rule. States have the ability to waive that rule in periods or in areas of high unemployment, and during the recession, virtually every State availed themselves of that opportunity to suspend the time limit so that food assistance could go to unemployed needy people. As the unemployment rate has fallen, areas no longer qualify, and this year happens to be a year where over 20 States had to re-implement the rule either because of their unemployment rates or they chose to, and as a result, we estimate a minimum of half-a-million people were removed from the program in April and May of this year. And we'll see data to confirm that in a month or so. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you. In closing, I just want to say that the SNAP program, 1 percent fraud, I wish I could sit and look every Federal agency in the eye and say that your fraud or your mismanagement is at 1 percent of everything that you do. I don't want any fraud, but I want to applaud this team and individuals who are in this program knowing that you are there to feed people in America. In today's world there are Americans who are going hungry every day. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentlewoman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Ohio, Mr. Jordan, for 5 minutes. Mr. Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for having this hearing and for our witnesses and the chairman for his work in this area, extensive work in this area. Mr. Concannon, how much money is spent annually on the food stamp program both--well, how much is spent annually? Mr. Concannon. Total expenditure including administration, $75 billion. Mr. Jordan. Seventy-five billion dollars. You know what it was 8 years ago? Mr. Concannon. No, I do not. Mr. Jordan. The chart I am looking at says it was less than half of that. Mr. Concannon. Well, that was before the ---- Mr. Jordan. Thirty-seven ---- Mr. Concannon. That was before the deep recession the country went through, so I'm not surprised by that. Mr. Jordan. A lot of people would say we were in a recession in '07 and '08. I am looking at that, so 2008--well, even if you go 2009, it is 50 percent greater, more than 50 percent greater. It was $53 billion just a few years ago. How many people are getting this benefit today? Mr. Concannon. Forty-four point three million people receive the benefit each month. Mr. Jordan. And do you know how many of that 44.3 million are able-bodied adults? Mr. Concannon. Yes, we can give you that. I know that just under half are children, another 10 percent are people with disabilities, another close to 10 percent are seniors, some adults, but we can give you the actual percentage, a very small percentage ---- Mr. Jordan. So half ---- Mr. Concannon.--of them. Mr. Jordan.--are kids, 10 percent are individuals with disabilities, 10 percent are seniors, so is that 30 percent are ---- Mr. Concannon. No, it isn't 30 percent. It's another--it's about 10 percent are adults without dependents, able-bodied adults without dependents. Mr. Jordan. So over 4 million? Mr. Concannon. Correct, in that range. Mr. Jordan. Okay. And, Ms. Mayhew, my understanding is you have taken that population you just talked about, at least the ones who live in the State of Maine, and you have put back in place a work requirement for able-bodied adults, able-bodied adults, I assume, with no dependents, is that accurate? Ms. Mayhew. Yes. We're talking ---- Mr. Jordan. Okay. And what has been your experience with that program? Ms. Mayhew. So these are individuals between the ages of 18 and 49 not disabled, no dependents. And we reinstated the work requirements from the 1996 reforms. We did ---- Mr. Jordan. Exactly the same requirements that were working fine back then ---- Ms. Mayhew. Correct. Mr. Jordan.--20 hours a week, got some work requirements, 20 hours a month or ---- Ms. Mayhew. Twenty hours a ---- Mr. Jordan. Twenty hours a week, excuse me. That is right. Ms. Mayhew. But there are other options. It's 20 hours a week or--working or being in a vocational training program ---- Mr. Jordan. Got you. Ms. Mayhew.--or volunteering one hour a day. Mr. Jordan. So some options. All right. And what happened when you did that? Ms. Mayhew. When we did that, we also reached out to all of these individuals through our Department of Labor career centers to offer them slots in programs to help them with work skills development, resume writing, opportunities to identify employment. We made over 12,000 phone calls to that population. Mr. Jordan. Hold on one second. Back up a second. What was the number in Maine when you--able-bodied adults 18 to 49 in the program? What was that number? Ms. Mayhew. Fifteen thousand. Mr. Jordan. Fifteen thousand. What is the number--and you have implemented this program now several months? Ms. Mayhew. We implemented that in the--October 1, 2014. Mr. Jordan. Okay. So a year-and-a-half. And what have you seen happen? Is it 12,000 you said? Ms. Mayhew. Yes. The vast majority did not come forward to demonstrate and comply ---- Mr. Jordan. So they are no longer in the program? Ms. Mayhew. They're no longer in the program, but what is more important ---- Mr. Jordan. No, I am asking, is that--I would view that as a good thing. My guess is what happened is they said, you know what, if I got to do all this job training, job requirement, da, da, da, why don't I just get a job? Ms. Mayhew. Exactly. Mr. Jordan. Imagine that. Ms. Mayhew. And then we looked at their wages ---- Mr. Jordan. Right. And that is a good thing, wouldn't you say? Ms. Mayhew. Yes. Mr. Jordan. Yes. Ms. Mayhew. And their wages have increased by over 114 percent from prior ---- Mr. Jordan. So you followed them up? Ms. Mayhew.--to implementing--yes, we did. Mr. Jordan. And, Ms. Dean, is that not a good thing? Ms. Dean. Is it a good--I think the question is what's the counterfactual? How many of them would have gone and gotten jobs anyway because we know that there's a high ---- Mr. Jordan. But they did get a job so that is a good thing and they are no longer living off the taxpayer ---- Ms. Dean. But there's ---- Mr. Jordan.--so it is good for the taxpayer and it is good for the individual, and you are somehow implying in questions I have heard from the other side somehow that is not a good thing? Ms. Dean. There's also a group of people who lost food assistance without a job. That's ---- Mr. Jordan. Ms. Mayhew, what is that number? Ms. Mayhew. I'm sorry, what was the comment? Which ---- Mr. Jordan. She is saying that there is some of that 12,000 who are no longer getting food stamps who didn't get a job. Do you know what that number is? Ms. Mayhew. We can get you that ---- Mr. Jordan. But the point is they can still get food stamps if they are willing to do the three options you gave them, correct? Ms. Mayhew. Correct. Mr. Jordan. Okay. Ms. Dean, how is that negative? Ms. Dean. I think there are many parts of the country where there are not ---- Mr. Jordan. In--okay. Ms. Dean.--part- to full-time jobs available. Mr. Jordan. I am asking you about Maine. I am asking you about Maine because Maine has done it. That is the one experiment we have that I think is working win-win-win. Either they can do the job training, which is going to help them long- term to stay on food stamps or they can do what most people did in Maine and say, you know what, I don't want to do that. I am just going to get a real job, right? And if they decide to opt out and can't get a job, they can always come back and go to one of those three options. So tell me what is negative about that. That seems to be helping that individual who was in the system get to a better position in life, and just as importantly, help treat taxpayers with the respect they deserve so someone is not living off their tax dollars who is able- bodied. Why is that wrong? Ms. Dean. Representative Jordan, you're not characterizing the rule correctly across the country. States are not ---- Mr. Jordan. I am talking about the State of Maine. Ms. Dean. I cannot speak to whether Maine genuinely offered every single individual--whether a slot was available for them to participate in and whether those individuals were appropriately screened. Commissioner Mayhew can best do that. But the problem is that across the country that's not happening. It's operating as a time limit, so individuals living in high unemployment areas or individuals who face barriers to work. For example, in Florida there were disabled veterans who didn't have 100 percent disability rating who were terminated from the program. They were not exempted. Work requirement is ---- Mr. Jordan. Well, wait, wait, wait ---- Ms. Dean. Work requirement is very different than ---- Mr. Jordan. We just heard that this was not about people with--there is a big difference between able-bodied individuals between 18 and 49 with no dependents and someone with a disability and someone with children and some who is a senior. There is a big difference. If I could, Mr. Chairman, one last question. What is the number today, Ms. Mayhew, that is in that category in Maine? What is the number? It was 12,000. What is the number today? Ms. Mayhew. It is less than ---- Mr. Meadows. Your mic, please. Ms. Mayhew. We can get you the final number, but obviously ---- Mr. Jordan. Less than what? Ms. Mayhew. Less than 1,000 individuals. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Jordan. That is unbelievable. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Cartwright, for a generous 5 minutes. Mr. Cartwright. I thank the generous chairman. Mr. Chairman, our colleague from Wisconsin just lately made a comment to the effect that the current SNAP program, the food stamps program has the effect of encouraging women to bear children out of wedlock. And to respond to that, I would like to recognize and yield to the gentlelady from the District of Columbia for 30 seconds. Ms. Norton. Well, first of all, I think that the error rate speaks for itself and answers much that was raised in that regard. And I must say, at a time when we have reduced among poor people as well as middle-class people the birth rate, it is inconceivable to me that somebody says, you know what, why don't I go out and get pregnant so I can get some food stamps. I yield back to the gentleman. Mr. Cartwright. Mr. Chairman, I would like to thank you for holding this hearing today. It is shameful when women and families go hungry in the United States of America, and I will not be part of a system that forwards the chance that we will have that in this country. I strongly support the food stamp program, SNAP, among other food assistance programs for this reason, and I would like to thank the witnesses for their work to relieve hunger in this country. I would like to also point out two numbers related to fraud and waste in the SNAP program that have been touched upon here. In 2014 less than 3 percent of SNAP benefits had error associated with them, and the trafficking rate is down to 1 percent. And it occurs to me that the SNAP program is improving at its good job of ensuring the limited resources it is given are being used properly. We can and should do more to relieve hunger. That is why I am reintroducing the SNAP Healthy Incentives Act, and this expands a pilot program nationwide in which SNAP participants receive a 30-cent rebate for every SNAP dollar they spend on fruits and vegetables. Now, this pilot program proved to be successful, and it proved a 25 percent increase in the consumption of healthy foods. Now, Under Secretary Concannon, can you tell us a little bit more about the types of people who are aided by the SNAP program? Mr. Concannon. Thank you very much for the question. Thank you for introducing that act, the health incentive pilot was highly success. And early this week I was in Michigan. I've seen firsthand discussions with community leaders around the country on the impact of SNAP now. As has been mentioned earlier, nearly half of the recipients on SNAP--it's 48 percent plus--are children, another 10 percent are people with disabilities, another seniors and other parents looking after young children. But I also want to emphasize again something that's been mentioned already. Forty- two percent, two out of every five persons living in a SNAP household, at least one of the adults is in--currently in the workforce. And that income is counted in the benefit. And to me, the--that's the highest rate of people working in the history of the program and it, to me, reflects the fact that across the country more and more people are getting part- time jobs or they're struggling with low wages that still qualify them for the benefit. So I think that's something that ought to be really more fully discussed by Congress now. There's--say what can we do about that? In places across the country, economists tell us the recession is over for many but it's not over for tens of millions of people in places like Maine to be perfectly frank or just about any State in the country. And so the program has very much become a supplement. That is by intent to--for wages and health for families. And I think it gets very stereotyped in some quarters I think very unfairly. There's a very low fraud rate, there's a very low rate of misuse of the funds. We don't tolerate it. But poor income people, whether they're from Florida, Maine, or any other State shouldn't be painted as though they are among that small minority who are misusing the program. That's not the history of the program across the country. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you, Mr. Concannon. And, Ms. Dean, I wanted to also thank you for your testimony today and all of your work in your adult life in support of nutrition assistance. You know, Republicans in the House are proposing turning SNAP into a block grant and eliminating the social services block grant, and I wanted to get your input on the wisdom of that approach and whether you think it would do anything to eliminate the low percentages of errors and fraud that we're hearing about today. Ms. Dean. Just very briefly, we think it would be very ill- advised, and the experience and history of block grants would suggest that converting SNAP into a block grant would increase hunger and hardship amongst low-income Americans because less food assistance would be available to them over time. It's also highly likely, as you're pointing out, that error and fraud would become a more serious issue because you would start to have 50--well, in SNAP there are 53 States, Ms. Plaskett representing one of them, 53 States with different rules, different criteria, and lots of complexity and duplication on which stores to bring into the program and how to administer and ensure that everyone is adhering to the rules. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. And, Mr. Chairman, I yield back to you in your generosity. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman from Pennsylvania. The chair recognizes himself for a series of questions. We talked a lot about fraud rates and what it is and what it is not, and yet I hear a lot of testimony that shows a lot of ambiguity in that area. So, Ms. Brown, let me come to you. Do we really know what the fraud rate is? Do we have good data? Ms. Brown. Well, the rates that we're hearing about with fraud I believe are the trafficking rates for retailers. That's the ---- Mr. Meadows. Right, and ---- Ms. Brown.--1 percent ---- Mr. Meadows.--those are 3 years old, aren't they? Ms. Brown. Yes, there's--they--there've been--a number of questions have been raised about the estimate, but I don't want to underplay the fact that it's very difficult estimate to make. Mr. Meadows. So to suggest that that 1 percent or 2 percent is accurate would be very difficult with any degree of certainty to ascertain that based on the reporting and the way that we track fraud and abuse at this point ---- Ms. Brown. In ---- Mr. Meadows.--is that correct? Ms. Brown. In--yes, and it doesn't include what--we don't really know what the rate of trafficking or fraud is for the-- on the recipient side. So ---- Mr. Meadows. Right. Ms. Brown.--you know, the question--put percentages that we talked about with the 60 percent that's the fault of the States when they're making mistakes and the third--one-third that's the problems with the recipients, some of that can be intentional error that would be fraud, and then in addition to that, once they receive the benefits, if they traffic, that would be fraud. Mr. Meadows. Right. And so that number and being able to do that--Mr. Concannon, I will come to you. Hold on just a second. You are always ready to jump in. I can see your rebuttal. I tell you, it is--but as we look at that, I will come--because here's my concern. When we talk about fraud--and for me I want make sure that every single person that deserves the benefit and is starving gets the benefit. But the bad actors, I want to make sure they go home and they go home for good. And so if anything is said here is when we--it is not just about fraud and abuse for an individual. It is taking away finances from those that are deserving. And that can be a bipartisan issue. I mean, if we put forth that any saving from fraud actually went to increase the benefits for some of the others that are receiving it, we would find some real uniform bipartisan support for that. So I guess, Ms. Brown, we need to do a better job, so how can we do that? And let me come to you, Mr. Carroll, because one of the things that you said really concerned me. We have got a flea market where there was trafficking going on, and there have been no arrests for fraud at that particular point? We have not been able to prove it? Did I hear you correctly? Mr. Carroll. No, there ---- Mr. Meadows. You need your mic. Mr. Carroll. There have been arrests. What we have not--the process involves--it's a pretty complex process, but our investigation into that flea market began in 2011 when we saw ---- Mr. Meadows. And you were doing it from the recipient side, not from the ---- Mr. Carroll. We were doing it from ---- Mr. Meadows.--retailer side, is that correct? Mr. Carroll.--recipient side where we got information that food stamp cards kept coming back to us in the mail, the EBT cards. We checked up on it. That address didn't exist. We did some further exploration and we found out that that was probably identity theft. We then tracked where that card was used, and it led to the flea market, so we started surveilling that flea market, and at that time in 2011 there were five authorized vendors. It took 2 years, but after 2 years, two of those five authorized vendors were arrested. But within a matter of days, the three vendors that were left absorbed that business because business continued to grow at that flea market. Now, at that flea market we have 48 authorized vendors with four more pending, and that flea market has done $79 million worth of business. Now, to put that in perspective, they have done more business than the six super box stores that are within a 5-mile radius of them combined. They have done more business in that flea market during that time period than the 16 major supermarkets that are in a 5-mile radius combined. So to say that our fraud rate is 1 percent I think is underestimated. But here's what concerns me about this, and this is what I think confuses folks because I think your point is well made. I'm not here to demean recipients of public assistance. I strongly support public assistance programs, and we do that in Florida. We have done everything in Florida to make it easier for folks who are eligible to apply. We've gone to an electronic system. Folks don't have to take off from work. They apply online. Even the automated identification system, it wasn't made to keep people out of the system. It was made to--so that we didn't have to bring people into the office because if we could authorize--if we could authenticate your identification without you coming into the office and taking time out of work, why not do that? That's why we did it. And so we have done everything we could to make it easier to apply. Since 2008, the number of recipients in Florida has gone from 1.3 million to--we have currently 3.3 million recipients on food stamps in Florida, and our food stamp redemption numbers have gone from 2.8 to 5.6. So to say that our concern around fraud is about some--somehow pointed at trying to demean folks who are on public assistance or to limit access I think is misguided. I do think the numbers that you talked about are difficult to come by. I think with the automated system in Florida, we do a better job of preventing what I would call recipient fraud in terms of--because what we used to battle years ago was folks coming in and quite frankly not being truthful about their situation. We see less of this. This is not--in Florida, this is not about the folks who walk through our door and apply for assistance. It is not about how they use their food stamp card. I wish my family ate healthier. I wish I didn't put so many Mountain Dews in the carriage, okay? And I think the more we put together legislation like that, we just go down rabbit holes and we spend administrative cost chasing after things we shouldn't chase after. But I will tell you there is an element that is organized that is--where their intent is to defraud, and it starts with folks who come into the system and get benefits and they're not who they purport to be. Part of this--the authentication process identified 2,800 people, for instance, last year that applied that were dead, another 2,800 people that applied that were incarcerated. Without doing the things that we did from an electronic standpoint, we would have never been able to prevent that. We can now. But our big challenge now is with authorized vendors. The number of folks who were authorized--and I understand--I don't--I am not here to impede small business. We want to grow small business, but we have got to make sure that when we are-- it's got to be more than taking a snapshot of the front of a store, putting a driver's license together, sending it in, and asking that I be an authorized vendor. And we have to do some work around is that a real legitimate business because some of these businesses that we're authorizing as retailers are not legitimate businesses. And I do agree with Secretary Concannon that the overwhelming amount of people on food stamps are there rightly so and are using their benefits appropriately, overwhelmingly, but I will tell you that small percentage, when you look at a program like ours that does $5.6 billion worth of business, even a small percentage is in the hundreds of millions of dollars, and it grows a stigma for the rest of the folks who are out there who need these benefits, who need the hand up, and who we're trying to provide these assistance--this assistance for. Mr. Meadows. And that is precisely why we are having this hearing because it shouldn't be a stigma that everybody is cheating the system. And sometimes that gets a default. That is where we run. I appreciate your heart. Mr. Concannon, I gave you your rebuttal time. I am way over. You go ahead, and then I am going to recognize the gentlewoman from the Virgin Islands. Go ahead. Mr. Concannon. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll try to be brief. I just wanted to mention the way we derive that figure of 1.3 percent. When we take a small store out of the program, and last year, it was like 2,300 stores--most of the trafficking, by the way, happens in small stores. Supermarket chains won't tolerate it, Walmart, Hannaford Brothers up in Maine, they're not going to tolerate that. So when we take a small store out, we ascribe 90 percent of the annual use of food stamp benefits or SNAP benefits in that store as though it were trafficking. And if it's a larger store, we ascribe 40 percent. That's how we get to the 1.3 percent. If anything, it's a conservative estimate, so I want to be clear on that. We're not just counting ---- Mr. Meadows. Well ---- Mr. Concannon.--you know, individuals. So with that, point one. Point two, we currently have proposed strengthening the requirement especially for these small stores because I fully agree with Mr. Carroll that some stores are in the program that absolutely shouldn't be. That's where we have our problems. Mr. Meadows. Well, we will get ---- Mr. Concannon. We're getting pushback on that issue. Mr. Meadows. We will get to that. Mr. Concannon. Okay. Mr. Meadows. We will get to that because that is one of the areas that honestly I want to drill down on on exactly what we are doing there. Let me tell you my concern with what just said. You only know what you know, and so fraud is only to the point of where you actually have inspectors going out. I would assume you have a limitation on the number of people who can actually follow that or are you fully staffed--you have got as many people as you ever would want? Mr. Concannon. Interestingly enough ---- Mr. Meadows. Yes or no, as many people as ---- Mr. Concannon. Most of our fraud is coming from data analytics. It's not coming from ---- Mr. Meadows. That is not the question. Do you have as many people inspecting as you really need? Mr. Concannon. We can never say we have enough. Mr. Meadows. All right. Thank you. I thought that would be the answer. The gentlewoman from the Virgin Islands is recognized. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. Good afternoon. And I guess if you don't have as many as you need and this committee is concerned with you stopping fraud, they will be very helpful to increasing the budget for the SNAP program so that you can have the funding to be able to enforce it, because although I think the chairman is sincere and, you know, is one of the people who is concerned about the right individuals having this, my concern is that I don't think everybody on his side really thinks that way as well. I sit on the House Committee on Agriculture and I sit on the Subcommittee on Nutrition, and in the last 17 months we have had 14 hearings on SNAP, 14 hearings on SNAP. And the purposes of those hearings is in my mind being to say why SNAP should be cut back, why it is not effective, why we need to stop this, why we need to stop feeding the people that we are feeding. Why do we need to stop feeding people? I mean, my mother would lose her mind if you denied someone a plate of food because it was painful for you to give it up. This program, we say, is about lifting people out of poverty, and I think the indictment is on us as a body, this Congress, who has not lifted enough people fast enough as we should. And in turn what is happening I think more often than not is that we have these hearings to indict the people who are recipients of SNAP program, the recipients of those individuals who are still living in poverty. So we have said that SNAP is a program that we would like to focus quite a bit of our time on for the abuse and the fraud that it has. From the statistics it seems that there is only 1 percent of the 45 million recipients and 1 percent of the money that is going is going for trafficking. Would we like to see that those numbers are corrected? Of course. But we need the funding to be able to do that because are we going to take the funding out of the people that are receiving the money or are we going to add additional funding for the administrative portion? That is the question that I would like to pose on the other side. You know, and one of the other issues that I am very certain about is it seems that the legislative proposals are really to eliminate the ability of States and territories to request waivers from the strict work requirements already contained in the SNAP laws. And the reason that is a concern is that because there is a chronic rate of high unemployment rate in many of these areas. We talked about people going to convenience stores rather than going to the big box or the grocery stores. More often not it is because they can't afford to drive to those other places because they live in food deserts. And, you know, it is not that people don't want to work but there are no jobs for them to work. And are we going to keep these time restrictions and cut out the waivers for this so that people now don't have a meal? The majority of people who are on SNAP are not able-bodied individuals. They are women and children and elderly people who cannot work. Ms. Dean, do you think elimination of work waivers, especially in high areas of unemployment, would impact--how would that impact on those places that have unemployment? Ms. Dean. Well, I think the Virgin Islands would be a good example. Currently, the Islands waive the time limit so the time limit is not in effect. If it were to elect to drop it, given your relatively high unemployment, the shutdown of certain businesses in recent years, that would mean that there are individuals willing to work who cannot find work. There are also individuals working less than 20 hours, say, 18 hours, who would lose the food assistance as a wage supplement to them. So it just means increased hunger and hardship, more demand on local charities. It's ill-advised given that there is this terrific program available to help feed people that supports and encourages work. Ms. Plaskett. Now, when you are a recipient of SNAP and you have the EBT card, can you buy every piece of grocery or every need in your household from that? Ms. Dean. The benefits are based on a food plan called the thrifty food plan, and it is meant theoretically for someone with perfect information in an extreme environment to be able to purchase enough. But we believe and actually have a paper coming out next week that suggests that it really is insufficient to purchase a healthy diet. Ms. Plaskett. So what are the things that you would not be able to purchase? Ms. Dean. Well, the--I think there are tradeoffs. Fresh fruits and vegetables, whether you can buy foods with sufficient--low levels of sodium versus highly processed foods. A lot of participants substitute in starches versus protein and, as I said, fruits and vegetables. That having been said, SNAP participants do purchase very consistent with how the average American purchases. They do an incredible job with the benefits that they have, but we think they'd do much better if they had sufficient resources. Ms. Plaskett. A woman who is a single parent and has a child, have you ever seen instances--because I know I have--of that individual, as my colleague talked about, using the SNAP money to purchase other things, to use it to buy diapers or to use it to buy things that are necessities that we have not as a country been able to supply them the resources to be able to take care of? Have you seen some of the fraud based on that? Ms. Dean. To be clear, that is also not legal and it is unacceptable, but yes, some mothers with young children face extraordinary choices, just extraordinary choices, and taking care of their children, as you're, I think, trying to illustrate with the question, is always going to come first. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for the additional time. Mr. Meadows. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman from New Mexico, Ms. Lujan Grisham. Ms. Lujan Grisham. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you very much for this hearing. And frankly, I agree with my Democratic colleagues in recognizing that the SNAP program as a policy is a very important policy to protect seniors and children and families in poverty and folks in the military with a focus on making sure that they don't go hungry. And like many of my colleagues on this committee, I want to make sure that we address the fraud issues and we also, as Ms. Plaskett, my colleague from the Virgin Islands just identified, that there are issues that we need to address that don't meet the requirements of the program but still shine a light on the extraordinary circumstances that so many of these families face. And I want to point out that even when we have fraud where someone is selling their food stamp benefit, they are in collusion with the grocery store in the private sector, and so we really need to be thinking about that. And I want everyone to know, and I think they do, that SNAP I think is one of the most important policies and programs in this country and that I believe, based on the evidence that I have seen, that generally speaking it has a very low fraud rate, and I think that that is a remarkable standard. What I wish for every program is that there was a zero fraud rate. But I do want to talk about the integrity of the program as a whole, and I am very, very concerned about that on two levels. I have very deep concerns about the integrity of the SNAP program in my State in New Mexico. I believe that these problems are clearly being caused by the way the State is administering the program and the fact that I don't believe that the Federal Government has been providing sufficient oversight, and the results are that many eligible New Mexicans who need emergency benefits are not getting them, and the overall result of course is that they are going hungry, which is why New Mexico has some of the hungriest children and families in the country still. Now, Mr. Concannon, in your testimony you are very clear that FNS needs to take a look--and I think I am quoting you-- look carefully at States that are pushing recipients off SNAP programs or are not processing SNAP applications or application re-certifications in a timely manner. And I know that you are aware that the State of New Mexico has been doing just that because we are in court, we have sent you letters, we have asked you to do an investigation. We have been very involved. And that these New Mexico advocates that you and I have personally spoken about have been raising this issue in fact with your office for years. In fact, our office received a formal letter in April from the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, which represents many of the State employees involved in this issue who administer the SNAP program. And, Mr. Chairman, I ask for unanimous consent to enter the letter into the record. Mr. Meadows. Without objection, so ordered. Ms. Lujan Grisham. I was pretty sure that was going to occur. Thank you, sir. Now, these employees, as you know, allege that the State has failed to provide training and staff support and all true, so that what is occurring in New Mexico is that in order to meet the time request to deal with emergency applications, they are adding assets to falsify those applications so that people don't get the benefit that they deserve and need, and that is a very serious integrity program. But just as terrible and heinous as that is that current court records indicate that that has been going on since 2003. So in addition to the years that I have been asking the Department to look at this and in addition to the April letter where I asked for an investigation, it looks as if the Department has had information about this very issue since 2003. And we can see that one of those results is the hungriest State in the country. Now, the most disturbing thing to me--I just want to repeat this--isn't these lapse of audits and integrity and issues between the Federal Government and State government. The most egregious issue here is that I have vulnerable families that aren't getting the support that they deserve it. And according to AFSCME, there is a pattern and practice of adding these assets that should have been counted as income or adding assets in order absolutely to prevent people in our State who are eligible for being eligible. So basically the State is lying to you, Mr. Concannon, and it is also clear to me that we have not been holding them accountable since at least July of 2014. Now, I need to understand why your office didn't know about these violations since 2003 and hasn't responded to us and others when you had clear knowledge of what is going on. So before the AFSCME letter, given all these issues, why didn't your office take-- and then after, why didn't your office take immediate action? Mr. Meadows. The gentlewoman's time is expired, but please answer the question. Mr. Concannon. Well, thank you very much for the question. Let me just, in support of the Congresswoman's concerns, confirm that I believe New Mexico is probably the most fouled up SNAP system in the United States right now and has been, unfortunately, I think for years. There is a major Federal lawsuit that's been underway there for many, many years, and I think even the courts have been less than successful in getting the State to really fully respond. We have been engaged with the State offering them additional support, offering them additional technical assistance just as--we also are in receipt of that letter from AFSCME ---- Ms. Lujan Grisham. And I am out of time ---- Mr. Concannon.--on the 26th ---- Ms. Lujan Grisham.--Mr. Chairman. I know that you are really patient with me, but you know what, giving them technical assistance when they are lying to you, they are cheating the beneficiaries, they are not protecting the beneficiaries, they are in Federal court, this requires investigatory action and audits, which is exactly what this entire committee wants for all of these ---- Mr. Concannon. It is being investigated ---- Ms. Lujan Grisham.--programs. Mr. Concannon.--right now by the inspector general of ---- Ms. Lujan Grisham. Because in a letter from your office, we don't have that. They are being investigated for this issue? Mr. Concannon. The--since that letter from AFSCME, the State--the State IG in New Mexico is investigating that--those claims. We also had a visit to several of their offices in May. We did not identify that in our management review of those two offices, but I--the State inspector general is currently investigating the State for those very claims. Ms. Lujan Grisham. As I yield back my time, and the chairman is being very generous, what I have in writing from your office, sir, is that you are going to hold beneficiaries accountable for overpayments and that there is not an ongoing investigation about this issue. So I am very happy to hear that what we have in writing is incorrect, and I am expecting you to put in writing your statements today so we get this rectified. I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Meadows. All right. So let me follow up on the gentlewoman's--while she is closest to this particular issue and I think that this is really why we have Maine and Florida here today is that we have a Representative from New Mexico that is up close and personal with a particular problem. So, Mr. Concannon, do I have your assurance that you will report back to this committee with a plan of action of how to address her concern within the next 14 days? Mr. Concannon. Yes, you do, but I ---- Mr. Meadows. Just ---- Mr. Concannon.--do want to be clear. The problem is on the part of the State agency ---- Mr. Meadows. I didn't ask you ---- Mr. Concannon.--not consumers. Mr. Meadows. Well, so you don't have any involvement whatsoever? Mr. Concannon. No, we have involvement. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Well, then ---- Mr. Concannon. I'm just saying that it's the State agency that is at fault here, not the consumers ---- Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Concannon.--of the SNAP program ---- Mr. Meadows. I understand. You made your point. Mr. Concannon.--in New Mexico. Mr. Meadows. She has made the point, but what she also said is that you haven't been forthcoming in following up with her, and what I am saying is from the other side of the aisle, that is inexcusable ---- Mr. Concannon. Well ---- Mr. Meadows.--wouldn't you agree? Mr. Concannon.--I don't accept that claim. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Concannon. I don't accept that, that we are not ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, I ---- Mr. Concannon.--forthcoming. Mr. Meadows. The gentlewoman has yielded back, so let me go ahead and recognize myself for a series of questions because, Mr. Concannon, you come and you are very quick to point at Maine and suggest that what they are doing is not adequate from a standpoint of the way that they are conducting it. And that was really early on. You were very quick to do that. But yet when my good friend and the gentlewoman from New Mexico points out a problem where you have not even respond properly, you are not willing to take and accept responsibility. I think that that is a double standard, wouldn't you? Mr. Concannon. No, it's not a double standard. I haven't said we haven't responded. I've said we've been doing evaluations of New Mexico. We're not happy with their performance. Mr. Meadows. But there is no investigation ---- Mr. Concannon.--We have offered them ---- Mr. Meadows.--going on at this point? Mr. Concannon. Yes, there is, the inspector general ---- Mr. Meadows. By the State ---- Mr. Concannon.--of the State. Mr. Meadows. By the State. By the OIG of the Federal Government for USAID ---- Mr. Concannon. I can't ---- Mr. Meadows.--or USDA, is there any ---- Mr. Concannon. I can't speak for the OIG because I don't -- -- Mr. Meadows. Would you ---- Mr. Concannon. I know they're aware of it ---- Mr. Meadows. Would you recommend ---- Mr. Concannon.--but I can't tell you what they are ---- Mr. Meadows. Would you recommend that there would be a Federal investigation? Mr. Concannon. I'd be happy to. Mr. Meadows. All right. Ms. Lujan Grisham. Thank you. Mr. Meadows. All right. So let me go on a little bit further. Ms. Mayhew, one of the things that I was perplexed by is a started looking at statistics of SNAP use by Maine recipients in other States other than Maine. And by the list that I got, it looks like they are using all over the country, indeed all over the world, and yet it comes from your State. Would you say your State is atypical? Is it unique that you have a lot of SNAP travelers? Ms. Mayhew. Maine is not unique. Mr. Meadows. Okay. So if it is not unique, I guess one of the questions I have is in just looking at one of the numbers that popped out happened to be in Mr. Carroll's State. And so I have got Maine recipients who are getting SNAP benefits that traveled apparently to Florida, and over the last 5 years, there has been over $3,700,000 and change benefits from Maine that get used in Florida. Is that correct, Ms. Mayhew? Ms. Mayhew. That is correct. Mr. Meadows. So how do you stop that? I mean, are they just traveling? So is this somebody that just happens to travel with SNAP benefits and go down there or are they going to the flea market where Mr. Carroll is doing--and cashing it in? I guess I am very concerned in that he is doing a great job and even I guess, Mr. Concannon, you would recommend that Florida is doing a job? In fact, there is a bonus--didn't you all get a bonus for good--have you all paid that bonus? Mr. Concannon. No, we have not paid the bonus ---- Mr. Meadows. And why not? Mr. Concannon.--since 2015. No. Mr. Meadows. Why have you not paid the bonus? Mr. Concannon. Because we have some concerns about the ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, you just said he did a good job. Mr. Concannon. Well, no ---- Mr. Meadows. You can't have it both ways. Mr. Concannon.--Florida is doing a good job, but I'm not -- -- Mr. Meadows. Well, that's Florida. Mr. Concannon. That's--I'm not translating that ---- Mr. Meadows. I am talking about the $7 million ---- Mr. Concannon.--to whether we should pay the bonuses. Mr. Meadows. So why are you holding up the $7 million payment on someone who is recognized as doing a great job? Why would you be holding that up? Mr. Concannon. Because I want to make sure that what we are getting are valid reports from States across the country. Mr. Meadows. So you are holding up his to make sure that you get valid reports from everybody else? Mr. Concannon. I'm holding all of them up. Mr. Meadows. Okay. When can we expect a response on his bonus money? And he didn't ask me to ask this, by the way. So when can we expect you to get it resolved? Mr. Concannon. As soon as I'm satisfied and others ---- Mr. Meadows. How many days? Mr. Concannon.--are satisfied--no, it's not a matter of days because ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, you are going to give me ---- Mr. Concannon.--I want to be ---- Mr. Meadows.--some days. When will you report back this committee? Thirty days, is that enough to evaluate it? Mr. Concannon. No, it may take longer than that because we're in the middle of investigating that right across the country right now, not just in Florida, in States right across ---- Mr. Meadows. So you are saying you don't owe it to Florida? Is that what you are saying? Mr. Concannon. I'm not sure if we do. Mr. Meadows. All right. You have 30 days to address that issue and make a compelling case on why you're not paying it to them to this committee. Are you willing to accept that, to make a compelling case? Mr. Concannon. I'm willing to report back to the committee within 30 days, but I'm not sure whether the matter will be resolved ---- Mr. Meadows. Mr. Concannon, let me just tell you what concerns me is that you supposedly have the answers for all food stamp ailments, and yet what I am seeing are experts here that are on the ground that in my opinion know a lot more about what is going on in their States than you do, and now you are going to hold it up because Mr. Carroll has supposedly done a great job. You just admitted it under sworn testimony, and yet you are saying you are not going to give him a bonus for good performance? Mr. Concannon. I said he's doing a good job. I didn't say he deserves a bonus ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, let me just tell you ---- Mr. Concannon.--so ---- Mr. Meadows.--this will not be the last hearing then, and we will have you back. If you are going to report back in 30 days, I would appreciate that. Mr. Meadows. Ms. Mayhew, let me come to you. Why do you think there is so much use of Maine's SNAP benefits across the country? Ms. Mayhew. Well, certainly, as I indicated in our testimony there are no Federal SNAP regulations that would restrict the mobility of that benefit. We have concerns about-- around that. Now, certainly States have access to EBT card transactional data. We have invested in effort software applications to analyze that EBT card transactional data to look at that out-of-state use. We've established triggers when a card is used for a prolonged period of time, 2 months or more out of State, that is a red flag that certainly the individual may no longer be a resident of the State, but it may also be an indicator of other activity that's not consistent with the requirements of the program. That is an effort that we certainly believe all States need to be using, data analytics and tools, to analyze out-of- state transactions. Mr. Meadows. So I show that there has been $64 million worth of Maine benefits used in other States. Is that correct? Ms. Mayhew. That is correct. And certainly this is across the country and including St. John and Las Vegas and California there have been Maine EBT cards used. Now, that is both food stamps but would also include other benefits on the card, including TANF. Mr. Meadows. All right. So as we look at that, Ms. Brown, from a GAO perspective, that type of tool that allows us to track those benefits and where they are being used and perhaps allow for better fraud prevention, is that a tool that you have or is that a tool that we could use, as Maine has used it, to give us a better picture of potential--and I say potential-- fraud? Ms. Brown. Well, the issue of people using their benefits in other States has been something that's come up many times both whether there were questions of fraud but also whether there are questions that recipients are applying for and receiving benefits from multiple States. And we do have and are looking right now at some data-sharing applications that would shed some light on whether they were actually receiving benefits from multiple States. And USDA has activity in that area, too. I don't know of anything ---- Mr. Meadows. So could we get a report like this for every single State where we see the benefits that are being used in other States? Is that something that is easy for you to do, GAO to do? Ms. Brown. I'm not sure if it's easy for GAO to do it. We ---- Mr. Meadows. How about you at USDA, Mr. Concannon? Can you get us that? Mr. Concannon. We could certainly on SNAP, on food stamp benefits. As the commissioner mentioned, those benefits you're talking about in those several States include other functions that are on that same EBT card, so I'd caution against that. The majority ---- Mr. Meadows. What do you mean ---- Mr. Concannon.--of out-of-state benefits for Maine are actually ---- Mr. Meadows. You can't get the information? Mr. Concannon. We can give you the information for SNAP, not for ---- Mr. Meadows. For TANF? Mr. Concannon.--the TANF or for child support, as the case in many States, too. Mr. Meadows. All right. Mr. Carroll is wanting to weigh in. I saw the pencil go up. Mr. Carroll. I do. And I'm glad that Ms. Brown brought this up. We're in a collaboration right now with five southern States that border us so that we electronically up front when somebody applies for assistance can ping our data off of their data to make sure that they're not concurrently receiving assistance in two States. That's a pilot program we've been working with our Federal partners on doing that, and it's-- quite frankly, it's worked quite well. I hear there's another 15 States going to come in on that, and we hope at some point that all 50 States are up on it so at least we can stop folks from receiving in multiple States. The issue that we have with folks using food stamps in other States, it's like everything we deal with, it's complex. You've got to peel the onion back because in Florida when you look at the panhandle, it's usual for somebody to cross the border and use it at--the nearest grocery store may be in Alabama if you live in Pensacola. It may be in Georgia. It may be in Louisiana. So we see some of that. But I can tell you, to have folks from 6 or 10 or 12 States visiting the Opa-locka flea market, if you've walked through the Opa-locka flea market, that is not a tourist destination. So there's something going on there. And what we don't know is I don't think that folks physically came here from Maine to use their card or to sell their card here. I suspect it was more related to--we have ID thieves in southern Florida that we know are now applying for assistance in Missouri, that now are applying for assistance in New York. They'll probably apply for assistance in Maine because there's no way these folks are physically coming to Florida to go to the Opa-locka flea market. Mr. Meadows. Yes, I have been there. I can assure you, you have got to be going there to get there so ---- Mr. Carroll. Right. Mr. Meadows.--I mean, as we look at that--Mr. Carroll, let me point out one thing, and, Mr. Concannon, I want to come back to you because I mentioned bonus things and it was really just a footnote. I want to make sure, Mr. Carroll, you have not asked me to address that, and I want you to hear that, Mr. Concannon. The relationship between the two of you I think is a very good one. It is one that I want to continue to support and applaud. And so my interaction here is more of frustration out of trying to make sure that we don't create a disincentive for good performance. And when you have someone who is performing well, I want to make sure that the compensation is there. And the other aspect, Mr. Concannon, and I will close with part of this, if you are asking the States to really look and police the recipients, would it not be prudent to allow them to police the retailers as well? And I am not asking for--you can comment on that if you would like. Mr. Concannon. Yes, I can comment on it because we have given--for example, Maine, we entered into a--what we call a SLEB agreement. We have one in Florida as well where we allow them to--the police agencies to--if you suspect something is going on, I'm aware that we have an agreement currently out on the West Coast with a State that States can come forward, one, report to us that they're--here's my complaint in all of this. I am confident we're going after stores across the country. I'm a lot less confident that States, with due respect, are going after the individuals who are using places like that Opa-locka market or whatever it's called. And we have urged States ---- Mr. Meadows. You butchered that ---- Mr. Concannon.--to take a store out ---- Mr. Meadows.--but that is okay. Mr. Concannon. We--okay. Well, when we take a store out, I have urged States--these people have been at meetings when I've said to them look at the redemption history in the previous 3, 6 months and you will see by--based on the amounts of redemption, the time of day, where people are from, you will identify, and yet it's a handful. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Concannon. I think in Maine last year, the year before, two people were taken out of the program for trafficking ---- Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Concannon ---- Mr. Concannon.--so there's not much ---- Mr. Meadows.--let me ---- Mr. Concannon.--going on in this department. Mr. Meadows. Let me tell you, it is harder to go after the recipient and it is very easy for you to make statements about recipients when that is not under that purview when actually the retailers are under your purview right now. And here is what I am saying--and I will come to you, Mr. Carroll, because I think you wanted to--what I am saying is maybe let's look at a pilot and give all authority for policing the retailer to the States and maybe let's do it in two or three States. You know, part of the farm bill actually asked for you to come up with some pilots on fraud, and have you done any of those pilots? Mr. Concannon. Yes, we've actually ---- Mr. Meadows. Your mic, please. Your mic, your mic. Mr. Concannon. We've made grants to these States, Maine including ---- Mr. Meadows. No, no, no, no, no. Mr. Concannon. Yes, we have. Mr. Meadows. So in what form did you do a pilot because I haven't seen any results or even start of a pilot ---- Mr. Concannon. No, they have started. Mr. Meadows.--in your other sworn testimony ---- Mr. Concannon. They have started. Mr. Meadows.--so you may want to check with your staff behind it. What kind of pilots ---- Mr. Concannon. No, we have ---- Mr. Meadows.--have you done? Mr. Concannon. We have made grants to these States ---- Mr. Meadows. That is not what I asked. The farm bill ---- Mr. Concannon. Okay. Some of the ---- Mr. Meadows.--was very specific. It said for you to set up pilots to do that. I voted for the farm bill, and so I know that it's there. Mr. Concannon. Terrific. Mr. Meadows.--there. So have you ---- Mr. Concannon. Great. Mr. Meadows.--done any pilots? Mr. Concannon. Yes, we have. Mr. Meadows. In what States? Mr. Concannon. There are a list of them here. We'll give you a number--Maine is one of them on case management, for example, where we've given Maine money, and there are some other examples ---- Mr. Meadows. Mr. Carroll ---- Mr. Concannon.--on that line. Mr. Meadows. Mr. Carroll, you--let me ---- Mr. Concannon. SLEB agreements with a number of States as well ---- Mr. Meadows. What is that? Mr. Concannon.--so yes. We'll give you the list of States and what they're doing. Mr. Meadows. Mr. Carroll, is what we are talking about, does that go far enough to solve your flea market problem? Mr. Carroll. No. And, first of all, I want to say to Under Secretary Concannon that when we have partnered and they have gone after vendors, we'd have a very strong partnership. What I'm worried about is even using their definition of a high-risk vendor, we have over 16,000 authorized retailers in the State of Florida. Based on the definition that classifies some of those vendors as high-risk, 13,000 of our vendors are high- risk. And if you use the statistic out of FNS in terms of what percentage of those might potentially be actively engaging in this activity, it would be about 2,300. FNS and the State of Florida gets to about 100 of these establishments, investigations per year. So based on that, it would take us 23 years to get through that population. We ---- Mr. Meadows. All right. So your--hold on. Your sworn testimony here today is that based on the potential for fraud in Florida of 2,300 retailers with the way that we are going after those, it would take 23 years ---- Mr. Carroll. Correct. Mr. Meadows.--to evaluate all of those? Mr. Carroll. With the current--the way we do investigations, the current staff available to those folks ---- Mr. Meadows. That is unacceptable. I am just telling you that is unacceptable. And so I am going to go ahead and come to the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman, for his second round, and we'll close up. Mr. Grothman. Well, thank you. A couple things. First of all, I want to respond to something one of the other Congressmen said where he I think intentionally mischaracterized what I said or lied about what I said. With regard to my exchange with Mr. Concannon, the question is when you have so many programs, the benefits of which disappear when you marry somebody with an average income, the question is whether it affects people's decision as to whether or not to get married. And when you add up the Medicaid and the SNAP and the low-income housing and the Pell grants and the disability for kids, you can wind up with huge amounts of money. So I think what I said was completely mischaracterized, but I will ask Mr. Concannon again because I think you gave me a wrong answer as well. There is a marriage penalty, I believe, associated with SNAP. And you sit there and shake your head on that. But if you marry someone who moves in with you and they are making, let's say, $40,000 a year, isn't it true that if the person who initially has some benefits that you will lose your SNAP benefits, as well as many other benefits which you are entitled to by your classification of being low income because no longer you and the father of the child are considered low income? Isn't that true, Mr. Concannon? Mr. Concannon. No. What's true is this. If somebody moves in with you, whether they are married or not, their income is counted in the SNAP program ---- Mr. Grothman. That's exactly right ---- Mr. Concannon.--period. Mr. Grothman.--Mr. Concannon. That's exactly right. So first of all, assuming you catch somebody has moved in, which a lot of times is not--I'd argue most times is not--but if you decide to move in with the father of your children and the father of your children is making $40,000 a year, will you not lose the SNAP benefit? Mr. Concannon. Yes. Mr. Grothman. That is what we call a marriage penalty. Very good. Now, a question for Mr. Carroll, and Congressman Meadows dealt with this a little bit, but we are going to talk a little bit more about the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, right? And that was a very successful program, correct? Mr. Carroll. Well, it's a pilot ---- Mr. Grothman. It is a pilot but ---- Mr. Carroll. Yes. Mr. Grothman.--would you say you discovered people who were getting SNAP benefits in more than one State or trying to get SNAP benefits in more than one State? Mr. Carroll. Yes. Mr. Grothman. A substantial number, right? Mr. Carroll. I'd have to get back to you the number. I don't have that number, but there is an active number, sure. Mr. Grothman. Somebody here put down on this thing they gave me currently Florida averages 162 matches a day. Is that possible? Mr. Carroll. That's correct. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I guess I would call that a successful pilot program. I will ask Mr. Concannon what you have learned from that pilot program and whether you think it would be a good idea to follow up with that pilot program all over the country. Mr. Concannon. Yes, I do. I support the program and I-- again, when I meet with commissioners, I tell them do data matches with other States. You can do it in batch. You don't have to do it exactly the way that was structured. The beauty of that particular pilot was it was real-time so they could identify people. But there are ways to identify people trying to enroll in other States by even doing simple match processing matches, and I highly supported that. Mr. Grothman. And will the program--you think the program will be expanded nationwide? Mr. Concannon. That I don't know at this time. If States come forward and say we want to do it, we're certainly interested in it. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I will just give you one more question because you really didn't answer before or I will give it to any of you, and I always wonder about this. Like I said, I get around my district, I even talk to people here in Washington, but certainly, you know, in Wisconsin we have big cities, we have little cities. Wherever I go, people are selling their SNAP benefits at 50 cents on the dollar. Now, that indicates to me that they must be getting food from somewhere else or that maybe they don't need the benefits. I would strongly encourage you who are not familiar with that to get out a little bit more and talk to people in the real world and, you know, deal with people in that income class and see how much SNAP benefits are being sold for in your area. But could anybody give me a reason as to why, if we have this huge food crisis in our country, people are selling their benefits for 50 cents on the dollar? Mr. Carroll? Mr. Carroll. I'd like to take that question. What we find the highest profile of somebody who's likely to engage in that type activity is--we go back to that able-bodied--it's usually a single adult that doesn't have kids because we very seldom-- unless it's identity fraud where it's not the person it's purported to be, we very seldom come across a mom unless there's a serious other issue like a drug addiction or something--but we very seldom come across a mom who is going to sell the lifeblood of that family for--no matter how much. So--and this is why I want to focus on the vendor rather than the recipient because if you're a recipient and those able-bodied folks make--or get about $111 a month or $114 a month. If you get 50 cents on the dollar, you're talking about they get maybe $60, but if you're a vendor in Opa-locka and you multiply that over and over, all of a sudden you get $7 million worth of redemptions off an EBT card that you're keeping 20 percent of with no overhead. And so I agree it's an issue. I don't think that families that are on assistance are selling their food stamps like that. I do think that some of this becomes urban legend because we don't do a good job at curtailing it so it's difficult to put a number on it. But if we don't go after the vendor side of this, we're never going to stop it. Our focus is on the recipient side, and Under Secretary Concannon talked about how States don't go after the recipients. The difference of going after a recipient, you can go after a retail vendor and you can have preponderance of the evidence and you can use the EBT transactions to shut them down. Because we have a clear-and-convincing standard, I can bring that standard in. And most of the time when we get it, by the way, it has been under investigation for a number of years. It took 7 months to go through a disqualification. So when we get a lot of the transactions that are given to us, a lot of them are a year, 2 years old, we have to re-run more current transactions. But with a clear-and-convincing standard, we then have to prove they had the intent to commit fraud, and short of having a witness that saw them do it or having some type of admission from the person that they in fact, misused their food stamps, it's very difficult to overcome that hurdle, which is why we asked to have that standard reduced to the same as retail merchants where it's preponderance of the evidence because then we can do exactly what Under Secretary Concannon said and use the EBT usage data to begin taking some of these people off the rolls. Right now, they refer to us--because of the vendors--they shut down on average about 21,000. We have 41,000 folks that we're looking at just in the Opa-locka area. That's 62,000 folks. I don't have enough folks to investigate at the level of investigation you need to disqualify 62,000 folks. I just don't. We've got to stop this at the vendor level, and we've got to reduce the standard on the recipient level. Mr. Grothman. May I have another question? Mr. Meadows. Last question and then you are out of time. Mr. Grothman. You gave yourself ---- Mr. Meadows. Yes ---- Mr. Grothman.--15 minutes. Mr. Meadows.--it is part of being a chairman. Mr. Grothman. Wisconsin we have PIN numbers. They have PIN numbers nationwide. Is that a nationwide thing now? Mr. Concannon. Yes. Mr. Grothman. Okay. And how about photo ID, photo on the card? Do you think we should be doing that, everybody have a photo on the card? Mr. Carroll. This is where Maine and Florida differ a little bit. We looked into putting photos on the card, and the initial up-front cost would be about $450,000 and then $1 per card, and with 3.3 million recipients, the cost of instituting that would be costly. But what we don't think would--this is why I think we need to target our prevention efforts. Most of the folks that are trafficking in EBT cards, there's a willing vendor who is openly breaking the law and buying these food stamp cards illegally. They're going to continue to do that whether there's a picture on it or not. For the vendors in big-box stores like you work at a Walmart and all of a sudden somebody hands you a card. If you checked the ID and it happens to be dad but mom is on the card, then what happens in that grocery line? We don't know. So we don't think it's a bad idea but it has to be fleshed out a lot further than that before we go down that road. We think you get a bigger bang for the buck in strengthening the data analytics portion of this looking at transaction history with vendors, and we think you get a bigger bang for the buck looking at folks coming through the front door, how they're using their EBT card and drilling down into that stuff to begin to prevent it. I do think--and I think Secretary Mayhew alluded to this-- that the fact anecdotally there's been less cards collected because I do think it would be a deterrent to folks who don't want it traded because their picture is on it. But the people that we see in Florida are intent. They could--I'm talking about a small segment that's accounting for a big chunk of this fraud. These folks are criminals. They don't care whose picture is on it. They're going to sell and they're going to traffic in that EBT card. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. I thank each of you for your testimony. Let me clear up two or three little leftover items. So, Mr. Carroll, is it my understanding that you believe that you need more authority as it relates to retailers to be able to go after those bad actors in terms of retailers and transfer some of that authority from USDA to the State to allow you to prosecute the fraud and abuse? Is that correct? Mr. Carroll. That is correct. Mr. Meadows. All right. And so if we gave you that, you believe that we would be able to not only make a more focused approach on those that are fraudulently trying to game the system without affecting those that Ms. Dean so eloquently put, the real people who need the benefits, that you can go after those bad guys if you had that authority, is that correct? Mr. Carroll. Absolutely. Mr. Meadows. All right. Mr. Concannon, let me come back to you. I mentioned pilots and I mentioned the 2014 farm bill. The kind of pilot that I want to see is to give the kind of authority that we just talked about with Mr. Carroll. It would be great if we took Ms. Mayhew, Mr. Carroll, and maybe somebody out West, you get North, South, and you get the West where you have three States that you give that authority, essentially give all of that authority to those States to be able to do that so that we can monitor, to have Ms. Brown, to have USDA monitor that to see if it is making a big difference. It may not. But here is what I am saying. As someone who will advocate on behalf of a new farm bill that is, as you know, already in the works, that the Ag Committee and that committee is doing a yeoman's job to do a great job to make sure that we have a good farm bill going forward. I want to give them the tools coming out of Oversight and from GAO and the others to say here is how we define the argument, because if not, the argument is always going to be is that there is somebody gaming the system. And what I want to do is narrow that to the ones who are gaming it and let's get them, and the ones who really need the help, that we actually look at increasing the ability to help those that are truly starving in our communities. Does that make sense to you? Mr. Concannon. I'm with you totally on that. Mr. Meadows. So are you willing to get back to this committee and maybe look at amore defined pilot program? And obviously, we would not be the only committee, but from an oversight standpoint, it would be ours. But the other is obviously work with the chairman of the Ag Committee to look at three pilots. I would suggest two that are here today and another one out West. I can tell that you are not buying into that, but as long as we get three States, as long as we get three States to give them that authority where we allow Ms. Brown to look at those numbers, are you willing to commit to do that today? Mr. Concannon. I'm certainly willing to work with you and with the committee on it. I want to make sure that what we can do is going to be legally okay by the Office of General Counsel ---- Mr. Meadows. Well, going after fraud is legal. Mr. Concannon. No, no--but they may say to us, look, you have that responsibility. You can't turn it over completely to the State. Mr. Meadows. Okay. If it needs a ---- Mr. Concannon. Now, we may be able to give them more authority. Mr. Meadows. So if it needs a legislative fix, I think you have that in the 2014 farm bill the way that it was worded, maybe not, but if you need a legislative fix, if you will get your folks to get with us, we will work in a bipartisan way to step up that kind of thing so that Mr. Carroll doesn't have to try to track down 42,000 people individually and come up with probable cause later. Does that make sense? Mr. Concannon. Yes, but I think the point, though, he's making that the evidence standard is still a higher one. That hasn't solved that issue. Mr. Meadows. But that is a different thing. Mr. Concannon. That hasn't solved that. Mr. Meadows. If you give him the ability to go after retailers, some of the evidence standards are not as problematic because the timing of that and the ability to tie the two together where it is not you coming in on one--it allows him to do that. The time gap is certainly very different. Does that make sense? Mr. Concannon. It could. It could. We're doing variations on that with a Western State right now, so we'll have to see whether that works. Mr. Meadows. Okay. All right. So can you in the next 120 days get me an updated report on the trafficking because it is 3 years old, the 2015 report. Can you ---- Mr. Concannon. We ---- Mr. Meadows. You said you were working on it already. Mr. Concannon. They are working on an update of that ---- Mr. Meadows. So what is a reasonable ---- Mr. Concannon.--right now. I don't know what ---- Mr. Meadows.--time? If 120 days is not reasonable, what is reasonable? Mr. Concannon. End of calendar year this year because that's--it's very complicated, but end of calendar year, December. Mr. Meadows. It is so complicated to figure out trafficking that it is going to take 6 months? Mr. Concannon. They are currently working on it right now, but they have just advised me, the people who are working on it, that we won't have it until the end of the calendar year. Mr. Meadows. So we will have the 2015 report in 2017? Mr. Concannon. Two thousand twelve to fourteen is the current time period they're working on. Mr. Meadows. All right. But can you include 2015 in that? Mr. Concannon. I think they're already working on it so I don't think I can. Mr. Meadows. So you can't include that? She is shaking her head no, you are saying yes. Mr. Concannon. Well, they are the researchers so ---- Mr. Meadows. So we will have--let me make sure I understand. We are going to have 2012 through 2014 but no information on 2015 trafficking by the end of the year, is that correct? Mr. Concannon. Correct. Mr. Meadows. Okay. We will follow up with you on that. And my final issue is more of a comment, and it gets to something that you talked about earlier. You talked about a rule about addressing the retailers. There is a very big difference between going after fraud with retailers than telling them what they have to stock on a shelf. And you conflate the two, and I am here to tell you that I am going to be looking at that very closely. I want your first priority to be fraud. That is what the farm bill talked about. And what you are suggesting in your rules is something that perhaps is other than that, and I want to make sure that we are clear that I want you to focus and have your priority on fraud versus on what goes on a shelf. Mr. Concannon. Well, actually, the farm bill authorized depth of stock is the term ---- Mr. Meadows. It did ---- Mr. Concannon. So it isn't just ---- Mr. Meadows. But I think ---- Mr. Concannon.--on fraud. It's to improve ---- Mr. Meadows. But I am telling you that ---- Mr. Concannon.--the ---- Mr. Meadows.--priority is fraud first. Mr. Concannon. Okay. Mr. Meadows. The depth of stock and where you are going with it I think you will find a very--your interpretation of what I voted on is very different than what I voted on. And I will yield back. And with that, I want to thank all of you for your time, and if there is no further business, this joint committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 5:20 p.m., the subcommittees were adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]