Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- VACANT FEDERAL PROPERTIES [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] VACANT FEDERAL PROPERTIES ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND PUBLIC ASSETS OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ SEPTEMBER 23, 2016 __________ Serial No. 114-116 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 23-485 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ____________________________________________________________________ For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, Internet:bookstore.gpo.gov. Phone:toll free (866)512-1800;DC area (202)512-1800 Fax:(202) 512-2104 Mail:Stop IDCC,Washington,DC 20402-001 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, JR., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina TED LIEU, California RON DeSANTIS, Florida BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey MICK, MULVANEY, South Carolina STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands KEN BUCK, Colorado MARK DeSAULNIER, California MARK WALKER, North Carolina BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania ROD BLUM, Massachusetts PETER WELCH, Vermont JODY B. HICE, Georgia MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Michael Ding, Counsel Willie Marx, Clerk ------ Subcommittee on Transportation & Public Assets JOHN L. MICA Florida, Chairman MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois, Ranking JOHN J. DUNCAN, JR. Tennessee Member JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky MARK DeSAULNIER, California GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin, Vice BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania Chair C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on September 23, 2016............................... 1 WITNESSES The Hon. David Mader, Controller, Office of Management and Budget Oral Statement............................................... 6 Written Statement............................................ 9 Mr. David Wise, Director of Physical Infrastructure, Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 13 Written Statement............................................ 15 Mr. Michael Gelber, Deputy Commissioner, Public buildings Service, General Services Administration Oral Statement............................................... 31 Written Statement............................................ 33 The Hon. Gregory Parham, Assistant Secretary for Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture Oral Statement............................................... 37 Written Statement............................................ 40 APPENDIX Written Statement from Ranking Member Duckworth, Entered by Chairman Mica.................................................. 62 Proposed Legislation by Representative Jeff Denham, Entered by Representative Glenn Grothman.................................. 64 VACANT FEDERAL PROPERTIES ---------- Friday, September 23, 2016 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Transportation and Public Assets, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 10:17 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. John L. Mica [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Mica, Massie, Grothman, and DeSaulnier. Mr. Mica. Good morning. Thank you for being with us. I call the hearing of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Subcommittee on Transportation and Public Assets hearing to order this morning. I'm Congressman John Mica. I'm pleased to welcome you. And, without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. We'll of course let you know that the House did adjourn last night, so we have a limited number of members. But I chose, rather than to delay the hearing, to go forward, and I think we can have a very constructive exchange with the witnesses that are here and the members that will be able to attend. Some will come and go because there are other hearings scheduled today, even with the House in recess. I want to also state that the order of business will be opening statements from members, I will start with mine, we'll recognize someone from the ranking side, and other members. We'll also leave the record open for 5 legislative days for any member who'd like to submit a written statement. And we'll also have the opportunity to submit to witnesses questions, which will be made part of the record. The additional order of business will be then hearing from all of our four witnesses, and after we've heard from our witnesses we will go to questioning. So that's the order in which we'll proceed today. And, again, I welcome everyone. The title of today's hearing deals with ``Vacant Federal Properties,'' and that's been the subject of a lot of my interest since coming to Congress. I'm a former smaller-time real estate developer in business. And when I came to Washington, I saw the opportunity to work with the Federal Government and its various agencies, because the Federal Government and the American public are actually the largest property owners of anyone in the world. And part of our basic tenets as Americans is private property ownership, and, as a government, we have to be good custodians of the property and assets that we hold in trust. The purpose of today's hearing, of course, is that we still have, even with some past efforts, a huge inventory of property, Federal property. Some of it we don't even know the complete inventory. And we have thousands of buildings, not under GSA--and we'll hear from them and also USDA today--but we have many, many agencies--DOD, post office. We have countless numbers of vacant Federal properties or underutilized properties and buildings. It's estimated that the inventory of some 270,000 buildings had total operating costs exceeding $18.7 billion. And agencies reported an inventory of over 7,000 underutilized buildings and properties. I think that's, though, just the tip of the iceberg; it's even further than that. About 6 years ago now, I helped produce a report looking at this issue, and the title of the report is the Federal Government must stop sitting on its assets, or ``Sitting on Our Assets: The Federal Government's Misuse of Taxpayer-Owned Assets.'' And, in the report, which I helped to publish as the ranking member of the Transportation Committee--and they have authority over some of the public assets and buildings--we actually highlighted a number of properties that were vacant. We'll talk a little bit about some of those. In that capacity, I also held a number of hearings, along with Mr. Denham. And he helped me, as the chairman of the Subcommittee on Public Buildings--Economic Development, Public Buildings, and Emergency Management was the title. And we held hearings in different locations to highlight, again, some of the issues that we faced with specific properties. On the 25th of April, 2013, I held a hearing as the chairman of the Government Operations Subcommittee of this full committee, and we held that down the street in an empty warehouse located at 49 L Street, Southeast, in Washington, D.C. There's a picture of that on the screen. At that hearing, the GSA official who testified is Mr. Gelber, who is here again today, and he told the committee, from his testimony, ``Given the high real estate value and rate of growth of the surrounding Capitol Riverfront neighborhood, the 49 L Street property presents us with many potential opportunities to find a better use.'' That's his quote at that hearing. Unfortunately, I'm disappointed to say that GSA did not declare the property excess until 2015, and, unfortunately, the warehouse, we found, is still vacant to this day. So, while we've made some progress, that's not one of our stellular examples. The Cotton Exchange, which is down the street, a huge swath of property that goes from the Mall all the way out to 395, that very valuable property, just the Cotton Exchange, we held a hearing there in the vacant building, which has been vacant for years, and some of the adjacent property. That property we finally got, I think last year, some decision to move forward, and I'm pleased to hear that, but we have one of the most valuable assets in property in our Nation's capital still vacant. You may hear some of this from GSA, but we have had some successes and better luck in getting the Federal Government to act on some other buildings. Let me say, when I started this, I looked a lot at Washington, D.C., our Nation's capital, but I also looked-- several years ago, we took a subcommittee down to NASA, to Cape Canaveral, which is in my own backyard. I'm in central Florida. We held a hearing there. And there are hundreds of buildings, about half of them vacant--177,000 acres, five times the size of Manhattan, much of it underutilized. The space program, which has been diminished as far as Federal participation, a lot of those assets sitting idle, buildings sitting empty. I will report, that 177,000 acres, and next to it 16,000 acres, which is owned by the Air Force, just adjacent to it, we are struggling but we are making some progress with either finding uses for the build, tearing some of them down that are expensive to maintain, or looking at additional ways we can utilize those valuable assets for the taxpayers. So that's a little bit of good news on that side. In June, I held a hearing--of 2012, I held a hearing in the Heating Plant in Georgetown, which had been vacant since 2000, costing taxpayers millions of dollars to maintain, empty over more than a decade in 2013. In fact, when we arrived to conduct the hearing in the empty building, there was a ``for sale'' sign that had been put up on the top floor of the building. We asked the witnesses from GSA at the time when they started their marketing plan, and they had told us ``yesterday,'' which was the day before the hearing, they put the sign up. So that did go online; that sold to developers for $19 million. And I'm told that property has plans now from the private sector to create a substantial development which will employ people and utilize the property and also pay taxes. In March 2013, we held a field hearing in--well, actually, I held one in the empty Dyer Courthouse, which actually had been vacant since 2007 when they opened the adjacent new Federal courthouse. After that hearing--and it was costing us $1.2 million a year to maintain vacant--I was contacted by the president of Miami-Dade Community College, which is across the street. It's like from Rayburn to Longworth buildings, that distance. He had said he had contacted GSA and attempted to find some information on how they could obtain that and use it for classrooms and a judicial center. Nothing happened, so I went down and we held another hearing at the community college to highlight the empty building. That goes back, again, a number of years. And I'm pleased to say that just within the last few months, actually in May, we completed a negotiation. We've transferred over the property to Miami-Dade. It will be the center of judicial studies and architecture. It's a historic, beautiful building in the center of downtown Miami. There's a picture of it there. It has a coquina, which is very rare stone, facade. But a magnificent building that we let go into some disrepair will now have a use. But it sat vacant for many, many, many years, costing millions and millions. Another success story that we've had and also highlighted-- the last two were highlighted here in this ``Sitting on Our Assets''--is the Old Post Office. And we conducted a hearing. It was 32 degrees outside. And in the vacant 15,000-square-foot annex behind the post office, we conducted a hearing in 38- degree weather. Made a few of the bureaucrats and our staff shiver. But, also, we were losing up to $6 million a year. The Old Post Office main structure was built in the late 1800s, and it had 400,000 square feet--a magnificent structure just two blocks from the White House. And of the 400,000 square feet, half of it was empty. And we were losing between $6 million and $8 million a year on that project. Last week, they had the soft opening, and they will open, I think, next month. I'm going next week to view it. It is now the Trump Hotel. There was a--actually, we went down a year later and held a second hearing in the annex again, which will now be the largest ballroom, I'm told--I'm sorry, banquet room east of the Mississippi River. The project will employ hundreds and hundreds of people, millions in tax revenue and, actually, revenue to the Federal Government, rather than losses. An incredible example. GSA came and testified earlier that the project was ahead of schedule and under budget. So we can take properties like that and turn them around for the taxpayer and make a big difference. Finally today, we've invited the Department of Agriculture to our hearing. They'll tell us they're good about disposing some of their excess property, but, unfortunately, some of the data they provided us shows that their annual operating costs for building uses has increased 95 percent from fiscal year 2014 to 2015. And they were unable to provide us with an explanation. We'd like to hear that today. USDA also holds on to poorly utilized properties in prime real estate locations. We have--we can put up the map. One of the biggest properties that USDA has is the Agricultural Research Center in Maryland, just not too many miles from here, and they have 6,500 acres. I think that--we pointed out that's the size of the city of Key West. One of the most valuable pieces of real estate in the Capital Beltway area, of which--and just a few minutes ago staff handed me--if we can find the figures. There are only 113 utilized buildings on the property, a total of 379 vacant properties. So that's not a very good record. Some of those are small structures. I've been out there. There are some chicken coops and pigpens and other things that were used years ago. There are also office buildings that are vacant, with the windows broken out and vines growing over them. It's not a pretty sight. It's not the way we should handle a valuable public asset. So we'll look at the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center. We have 200 of these research centers, some that date back, I believe, to the 1820s, across the country--that's just one example--who had a different role than they have today. And while the Department of Agriculture serves a good purpose, we need to revisit the vacant properties and valuable assets that they hold, maybe don't maintain well. With that, I'd recognize any other members for opening statements. Mr. Grothman? Mr. Grothman. Yeah, I'd just like to thank the subcommittee chair for holding this hearing. And I hope, at the end, we do something about expediting the disposal of this excess property. I mean, obviously, it's not just a matter of the Federal Government is broke and we could make some money if we sold some of this property, but even maintaining the property is wildly expensive. I know back in Wisconsin we have a local governmental authority that's been owning all sorts of excess property, and very frustrating because it's just a waste of taxpayers' money. And I hope, by the time we're done, maybe not this session but early next session, we can flip this stuff around and clear it out. Mr. Mica. Will the gentleman yield? I'll also say that, working with both Chairman Chaffetz, who had a bill previously, Mr. Denham from California, who chaired the Public Buildings Subcommittee, and others, there is legislation pending that would not only require an inventory but an accounting and then action, an evaluation of the property and then action--independent evaluation, then action to make certain that we use to the maximum the value of those assets. So Mr. Denham isn't here, but I'd like to--maybe you could request a copy of his legislation, and Mr. Chaffetz, be put in the record at this point. Mr. Grothman. I'll request them. Mr. Mica. So ordered. Mr. Mica. At least we'll have that in the record. Thank you, Mr. Vice Chairman. Mr. Massie? Mr. Massie. Yes. My interest in this is because we just recently received some really devastating news, that the IRS plans to move 2,000 jobs out of the biggest city in our district. And, you know, we've got 3 years to react to that. Hopefully, the IRS would find some other use for the facility, because they don't intend to reduce the number of employees overall. But I have this dread that I'm going to be here in 3 years if--for instance, if the IRS doesn't find another use for the facility, my concern is that we would add insult to injury, because this sprawling, single-story structure that's right in the middle of our downtown, in some of the most valuable real estate, might get tied up indefinitely. And that really would add insult to injury. So I'm trying to work forward to that point when the IRS-- hopefully they stay, hopefully they find another use for this facility. But if they don't, what we need to make sure of is it doesn't end up like some of this real estate that Chairman Mica has identified in Florida and here in Washington, D.C. So I want to thank the chairman for looking into this. I think it's a great topic. And I want to thank the witnesses for being here today to help us figure out how, when government does change--sometimes it doesn't change fast enough, but when it does change and it finds out how to operate more efficiently, that we make sure that we don't tie up these properties and keep them from the private sector, keep them from some other higher use. But, anyway, I look forward to hearing from the witnesses today and thank the chairman and the vice chairman. Mr. Mica. I thank the gentleman, and we'll work with you. That could be devastating, and you want to turn that property around to its best use if you are hit with such a turndown by the agency. I thank the members. And, as I said, we'll leave the record open for 5 legislative days for members who'd like to submit a written statement. And I'll ask unanimous consent, if the minority does not appear today, to have their statement put at this point in the record. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Mica. We'll now recognize our panel of witnesses and thank them for participating. I'm pleased to welcome the Honorable David Mader, and he is Controller of the Office of Management and Budget; the Honorable Gregory Parham. Mr. Parham is the Assistant Secretary for Administration at the Department of Agriculture. Mr. Michael Gelber, he's the Deputy Commissioner of the Public Buildings Service at the General Services Administration; and Mr. David Wise, Director of Physical Infrastructure at the Government Accountability Office. I'd like to welcome all of our witnesses. Some of you have been here before; some of you may be new. This is an investigations and oversight subcommittee of Congress. If you'll stand, we'll swear you in. Raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give before this committee and subcommittee of Congress is the whole truth and nothing but the truth? Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. Again, thank you. Now, the ones who have been here before know we try to limit your opening statement to 5 minutes, if you have additional data, information, or a statement that you'd like to be made part of the record, just a request through the chair or one of the members. We'd be glad to accommodate you. With that, we'll recognize our witness from the OMB. Thank you for being with us. You are recognized, sir. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF THE HON. DAVID MADER Mr. Mader. Thank you, Chairman Mica and members of the subcommittee, for the opportunity today to testify and update this subcommittee on the changes that we are implementing to improve the government's real property management and disposal program. Since my hearing in 2014 with the chairman, we've made significant progress in reducing the Federal footprint and institutionalizing a real property management program across the government. Today, I will update you on the status of two important administration initiatives that have improved the efficiency of the government's real property portfolio. OMB began its efforts with the ``Freeze the Footprint'' policy initiative in fiscal year '12, and it was in effect between fiscal year '13 and '15. The objective of that policy at the time was to freeze agencies' office and warehouse portfolios to ensure that the government's portfolio did not increase. I'm pleased to report that the administration, thus far, has exceeded its goal of freezing the footprint. In fact, we have reduced the government-wide-portfolio by 24.7 million square feet from fiscal year '13 to '15, which represents a 3.3-percent reduction from the baseline that we established in fiscal year '12. We estimate that the government will avoid $300 million in rent and operation and maintenance costs as a result of this initiative. Just to sort of give members an idea of what 24.7 million square feet looks like, think about 3.8 Pentagons. That's what we've saved between fiscal year '13 and fiscal year '15. Second, while the ``Freeze the Footprint'' policy was still underway, we recognized the need to institutionalize a lasting strategic real property management program for the Federal Government. In March of 2015, OMB released the ``National Strategy for Efficient Use of Real Property'' and its companion ``Reduce the Footprint'' policy that covers all CFO Act agencies. So, basically, this is all civilian agencies and the Department of Defense. The national strategy institutionalized a government-wide goal to right-size our Federal real property portfolio by defining the strategic framework which agencies will use to manage their portfolio from here forward. To implement this strategy, OMB issued the ``Reduce the Footprint'' policy to provide agencies specific performance goals and measures. The policy, which was effective in fiscal year '16, requires agencies to implement a 5-year rolling planning process that sets annual square foot reduction targets. It prioritizes disposal of unneeded and inefficiently used properties by requiring agencies to set annual square foot disposal targets for all buildings types. The reduction targets function as an agency performance measure, and, when combined with some additional benchmarking that we've been doing over the last couple years, we now have 3 years of data going forward to start holding agencies accountable for their reduction plans. These performance measures for fiscal year '16 have resulted in a goal of reducing another 8 million square feet of space in the current fiscal year. The policy also creates a portfolio analysis process by which agencies, with the support of GSA, will analyze underutilized and unutilized properties. The 5-year goal for the fiscal year '16 through '20 plan is to reduce another 61 million square feet of office and warehouse space. With regard to property disposal, the government-wide program has achieved solid results over the last 2 fiscal years, and my colleagues from GSA will address that in more detail. We appreciate the support from Congress for the legislative solutions that permit agency retention for the sale proceeds for reinvestment in additional disposals, provide expanded authority for GSA to support agencies' work to prepare properties for the declaration of excess, and to offer relief for some aspects of the current disposal process. And I think, Mr. Chairman, this speaks to a lot of the comments that you made in your opening comment. We can do so much administratively. And I think the bills from Chairman Chaffetz, from Chairman Denham--and I have been personally working with the House and Senate in trying to get both chambers to agree on some kind of legislation to move forward. In addition to the legislative solutions, we must invest to make the necessary reconfigurations, relocations, and disposals that will result in future cost avoidance. While we've made good progress, significant efficiency opportunities remain to be realized. One significant challenge has been the historically low levels of funding appropriated to the Federal Building Fund since fiscal year '11. Between fiscal year '11 and fiscal year '15, the Congress underfunded the Federal Building Fund by more than $5 billion. This has prohibited GSA from making necessary repairs to Federal buildings and delayed the construction of critical new Federal facilities. The President's '17 budget would restore GSA's authority to fully utilize incoming rent funds to construct new facilities, such as a consolidated Department of Homeland Security headquarters, as well as maintain the existing GSA Federal buildings that need major renovations and basic repairs. We ask the Congress to continue to support GSA's capital program and the critical projects that are identified in the fiscal year '17 President's budget, including a $100 million request for GSA's consolidation fund. We look forward to working with the Congress on legislation and funding in fiscal year '17 and beyond that will enable us to make even greater progress and accelerate our mutual interest of the reducing the underutilized and unutilized property. Thank you for the opportunity to testify, and I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Mader follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Mica. Thank you. And I think I'm going to go to Mr. Gelber--wait, wait, wait. I've got the two oversight. We'll go to the oversight, Mr. Wise, and then we'll go back to GSA, and then we'll get you last, Mr. Parham. Okay. Mr. Wise, you're recognized, from GAO. STATEMENT OF DAVID WISE Mr. Wise. Chairman Mica and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to discuss our work on the management of excess and underutilized Federal real property. In 2003, we added Federal real priority to our biennial High- Risk List, in part due to longstanding management challenges, including disposal of excess and underutilized property. I've got three key points to make today. Over the past several years, the administration has taken a number of steps to improve management of the government's real property portfolio. Second, agencies face longstanding challenges in disposing of excess and underutilized real property. And, third, implementing key GAO recommendations and proposed reform legislation could help address these challenges. Since 2012, the government has made efforts to improve real property management. The government has developed and worked to improve the Federal Real Property Profile, the government-wide database. In 2015, OMB issued its Real Property National Strategy, which aligns with many of the desirable characteristics of the effective national strategy the GAO has identified, including describing the purpose, defining the problem, and outlining goals and objectives. The 2015 strategy is an important step forward, as it requires agencies to set annual space reduction targets and adopt space use standards. Prior to issuing the national strategy, OMB issued ``Freeze the Footprint'' and ``Reduce the Footprint'' directives. These directives have assisted agencies to better utilize existing space and identify and dispose of unneeded space. Despite the progress, significant challenges remain. For example, a lack of reliable FRPP data makes accurately measuring the amount of excess property challenging. While OMB and GSA have taken steps to improve the FRPP, such as issuing guidance and implementing data validation procedures, GSA has not fully analyzed agencies' collection or reporting practices or the limitations of the data. Certain key FRPP data elements, such as utilization, continue to be inconsistently reported by agencies. As a result, FRPP data may not fully reflect the extent of real property challenges faced by agencies nor the progress they may have made in addressing such challenges. In prior work, we found inaccuracies in warehouse utilization data as well as results from the ``Freeze the Footprint'' initiative. Legal requirements can also present challenges to disposal. As the government's agent, GSA follows a prescribed process for the disposal of Federal properties reported as excess by agencies. This process includes requirements that the property be screened for potential use by other Federal agencies, homeless providers, and State and local governments for other public uses. Costly environmental requirements may outweigh the financial benefits of property disposal, especially for agencies such as the Department of Energy. In some cases, competing stakeholder interests can impact the process. Stakeholders may include State, local, and tribal governments, business interests in the local communities, historic preservation groups, and the general public. Finally, limited accessibility can influence the process. For example, a building on a closed VA campus is unlikely to draw much interest. The Cotton Annex in Washington, D.C., is a good example of disposal challenges. This 118,000-square-foot building, located just south of the National Mall, has been vacant since 2007. As we reported in 2016, GSA's recent attempt to exchange the property for construction services failed when GSA was unable to obtain sufficient value from the exchange, making the fate of this unneeded building unclear. GAO recommendations. In an August 2016 letter, GAO conveyed several open key recommendations to the GSA Administrator relating to excess and underutilized property. These included: one, an April 2016 recommendation aimed at improving the quality and transparency of FRPP data; two, a November 2014 recommendation that GSA articulate a strategy for its role in promoting effective and efficient warehouse management practices across the Federal Government; and, three, a September 2014 recommendation that GSA and DHS work jointly with regard to the DHS headquarters project on the Saint Elizabeth's campus in order to develop a comprehensive needs assessment and update cost and schedule estimates. We will be assessing the agency's latest plan when it's completed. Finally, proposed real property reform bills could help address the challenges of Federal excess and underutilized property. For example, the Federal Assets Sale and Transfer Act of 2016 could help address stakeholder influences by establishing a public buildings reform board to identify opportunities for the Federal Government to significantly reduce its inventory of civilian real property and reduce its costs. Additionally, the Public Buildings Reform and Savings Act of 2016 could also promote consolidations and disposals by requiring that GSA, one, justify to Congress any new or replacement building space in the prospectus process, including reasons why there cannot be consolidation or co-location into other government-owned and -leased space; and, two, dispose of specific properties in the Washington, D.C., area, including the Cotton Annex. Although both bills have passed the House of Representatives, neither has been enacted. Chairman Mica and members of the subcommittee, this concludes my statement, and I'll be pleased to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Wise follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Mica. Thank you. And we'll catch you with questions after we've heard from the other two witnesses. We'll hear from our GSA representative now, Mr. Gelber. STATEMENT OF MICHAEL GELBER Mr. Gelber. Good morning, Chairman Mica and members of the subcommittee. My name is Michael Gelber, and I am Deputy Commissioner of the U.S. General Services Administration Public Building Service. Thank you for inviting me to this hearing on vacant Federal properties. GSA's mission is to deliver the best value in real estate, acquisition, and technology services to government and the American people. To meet this mission, GSA is working with Federal agencies to improve space utilization, reduce real estate costs, and deliver space that allows our partner Federal agencies to better achieve their missions. Additionally, we are working with the Office of Management and Budget and the Federal Real Property Council to improve the Federal Government's inventory of real property, identify opportunities to better use underperforming properties, and assist agencies in the development of strategies to divest of their unneeded assets. Over the last 5 years, from fiscal year 2011 through fiscal year 2015, GSA has disposed of over 940 properties, both those managed by GSA as well as other landholding agencies, generating over $275 million in proceeds. GSA disposes of Federal real property through public sales, public benefit conveyances, negotiated sales, and Federal transfers. This past April, GSA sold the Metro West facility in downtown Baltimore, Maryland, for more than $7 million at a public auction. The sale of this 1-million-square-foot facility, which previously housed the Social Security Administration, will save the taxpayer more than $3 million per year. Disposing of this building will serve as a catalyst for economic development on the west side of Baltimore. In Richland, in the State of Washington, GSA worked with the city to dispose of a portion of a parking lot at the Richland Federal Building. The city expressed a strong interest in this downtown parcel and will be using the site for new city hall. The city offered GSA cash and a city-owned half-acre parcel immediately adjacent to the Richland Federal Building. GSA offers properties to communities through its Public Benefit Conveyance Program. In Buffalo, New York, GSA has been working with the city to use the historic Dillon Courthouse for a law enforcement purpose. The conveyance of this property will reduce the Federal footprint by approximately 180,000 gross square feet of space and reduce maintenance costs by over $650,000 annually. In addition to traditional disposal processes, GSA uses other tools to redevelop properties that no longer serve the government's needs. For example, as the chairman mentioned, in Miami, Florida, GSA entered into a long-term outlease with the Miami-Dade Community College for the historic Dyer Federal Building and Courthouse. As part of the outlease, the college will renovate the property for its use while preserving its historic features. This agreement will enable the building to continue to be a vital part of the Miami community for years to come and save the taxpayer $1.7 million in annual maintenance and operation costs. GSA is leveraging the value of Federal assets through exchanging these properties in return for construction services or newly constructed buildings. In Cambridge, Massachusetts, the Volpe National Transportation Systems Center is located on 14 acres in a high-technology hub of the city and no longer adequately serves the mission of this facility. Earlier this month, qualified developers submitted proposals to transform this property in exchange for a newly constructed research and technology facility for the Department of Transportation on a portion of the current site. This project will result in the delivery of new and improved space for transportation research, as well as economic development opportunities and tax revenue for the local community. GSA is also supporting the ``Reduce the Footprint'' policy by creating and enhancing several analytical tools to help agencies identify possible opportunities for disposal, consolidation, and co-location. GSA's Real Property Management Tool allows agencies to identify expiring leases and occupancy agreements and recognize cost savings that could be realized from the disposal of underutilized and inactive assets. Agencies can also use this tool to view benchmarks, such as rent per square foot, operating and maintenance costs per square foot, square feet per person, and compare agency- specific data with government-wide averages. Another tool, which GSA launched this June, is the Asset Consolidation Tool. This tool allows an agency user to identify what Federal space exists in a certain geographic area, such as a ZIP Code, a particular city, county, or within a mileage radius of a particular building. This information enables agencies to make targeted searches for space that other agencies currently occupy in a given area. While GSA has made significant progress and improvements in managing Federal real property and more aggressively disposing of unutilized assets, there are still a number of longstanding challenges that need to be addressed. These include incentives for Federal agencies to identify and execute disposals, statutory requirements prior to disposals, aligning non-Federal stakeholder interests, costs associated with the disposal process, and remote property locations. GSA is working diligently with agencies to overcome these hurdles and working with OMB to assist with its efforts. GSA is committed to carrying out its mission of delivering best value in real estate. I thank the committee for the opportunity to testify today, and I look forward to answering your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Gelber follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Mica. Again, thank you. And we'll hear from our last witness, Assistant Secretary of Agriculture Parham. Welcome. You're recognized. STATEMENT OF THE HON. GREGORY PARHAM Mr. Parham. Thank you, Chairman Mica, and thank you to the members of the committee for allowing me to testify today on the Department of Agriculture's efforts to address those properties that have been determined to be excess in the USDA portfolio. As one of the largest property-holding departments, USDA is well aware of the need to continually improve the management of its land and facilities to maximize the value of these assets for American taxpayers. In fact, the Department, under the leadership of Secretary Vilsack, went as far as establishing a target in its current strategic plan to reduce its overall space holdings. This was the first time that the Department has had such a target, and its inclusion has helped to strengthen USDA's commitment to enhance stewardship of Federal resources, which have been a core principle of Secretary Vilsack's tenure at USDA. To demonstrate this commitment, the Department has taken a number of actions in recent years related to better management of facilities and the elimination of excess properties. One example worth mentioning, sir, is the recent disposition of the Subtropical Agricultural Research Station in Brooksville, Florida. Between 1929 and 2012, USDA's Agricultural Research Service utilized the Brooksville location to study genetic and environmental interactions in beef cattle. Upon the closure of this facility in 2012, the Department sought opportunities to dispose of the property in a manner that would be meaningful to the surrounding community. As the property consists of over 3,800 acres of agricultural land and included 19 buildings, there was a tremendous opportunity posed by the potential disposition of the research station. Fortunately for the Department, Congress also noted the opportunity and provided to USDA special authority to transfer the property at Brooksville and other similar research stations across the Nation to higher educational institutions. By utilizing the statutory authority, the Department was able to enter into an agreement with Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University. Through this agreement, the Department transferred in October 2015 the entire Brooksville location to Florida A&M, which agreed to use the property to create educational opportunities for beginning farmers and ranchers. Not only does such an agreement enhance USDA's effort to support the next generation of growers and producers, but it also represented one of the single largest land transfers to one of the 19 historically Black land-grant universities established in the second Morrill Act of 1890. The result of this land transfer has been positive for the university and the farmers that it will serve and has also been a success for the Department. Despite the successful outcome in the transfer of Brooksville, the Department faces challenges in the disposition of other excess properties across the country. The specifics of such challenges may vary by location, but the Department has identified some common barriers that limit our ability to move more swiftly to reduce holdings of excess properties. These barriers primarily result in situations where the costs far exceed the benefits of disposing of unneeded assets. In many cases, the Department must incur significant costs to prepare a facility for disposition. Such costs may include the rehabilitation of a facility to make it commercially attractive or to tear down and remove buildings and structures if land is to be conveyed. In addition, multiple USDA properties require some level of environmental remediation prior to making the property available for another owner. Such remediation is necessary to abate and clean up hazardous chemicals that were released on the property either through the Department's action decades ago or as a result of actions taken by a prior owner of the property. In some cases, such abatement can cost millions of dollars that must be paid from current funds, creating a challenge in managing budgetary priorities. Another challenge is the lack of authority for the Department, apart from the Forest Service, to retain any proceeds from the potential sale of excess properties. As the Department may accrue significant costs in preparing a facility for sale, there is tremendous disincentive to dispose of properties when limited or no funding is available to offset the costs incurred. A further challenge that is common for many USDA excess property locations is that they are often situated in rural, if not remote, locations. As such, the commercial value for facilities in areas far away from population centers means that the demand for such facilities is often low. One location not located in a remote area in which I am aware that the subcommittee has a keen interest is the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center, or BARC, in Beltsville, Maryland, as you stated earlier. It's a research facility of nearly 6,500 acres located just off the Beltway in the Maryland suburbs of Washington, D.C. This facility houses a number of farm sites and laboratories where USDA conducts research on agriculture practices of benefit to American farmers and ranchers. As a result of its proximity to Washington, D.C., there has always been a strong interest in exploring opportunities to convert portions of the facility for other uses, which partially explains how the facility is now less than half of the original size. Within BARC, there are hundreds of buildings and structures, some of which no longer support the mission needs of USDA and have fallen into a state of disrepair due to the lack of resources to maintain or upgrade or demolish the facilities. Another key factor when considering options for the BARC facility is the current set of restrictions in place that limit the Department's ability to dispose of any portion of BARC. In fiscal year 1988, Congress included a provision in the Department's appropriation legislation that restricted USDA's ability to dispose of any property at BARC. That provision remains in place today. In effect, this restriction requires that Congress approve in advance any transaction that would move property from the BARC portfolio. Therefore, it would--it should be noted that the legislature in the State of Maryland has also created a statute that limits the use of BARC land to agricultural purposes or open space should they be transferred out of Federal ownership. As a result, the commercial interest in the BARC lands will be limited due to this restriction. Lastly, I will mention that the Department has identified at least $18 million of environmental remediation activities that must occur at various locations at BARC. These costs, combined with the other challenges expressed generally for the Department and specifically for BARC, significant affect USDA's ability to dispose of any property in Beltsville. Regardless of these challenges, however, the Department is committed to finding opportunities to improve the management of the Federal excess that it controls. As discussed previously, the barriers that the Department faces when considering how it can dispose of excess properties factor into the cost-benefit analysis done when considering disposal options. The Department is willing to work with the subcommittee and our colleagues in OMB and GSA to identify potential solutions across the country. I look forward to today's discussion on this important topic of excess property and to answering your questions. Thank you very much. [Prepared statement of Mr. Parham follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Mica. Well, thank you. And I thank all of our witnesses. And we'll go right to questions, and I'll start. Mr. Parham, you're aware that on Tuesday, February 12th, 2013, I visited, along with congressional staff, the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center? Yeah. And we have 6,500 acres there. It's very nice that you point out what you did in Florida and Brooksville in 2012--that was done in 2015. But I was there, asked to see if we could come up with some plans to do something. I saw office buildings with vines growing over them, empty buildings. And then, today, the staff reported to me on the huge number of vacant buildings that still exist. I've never seen a plan to do anything about that. I sent the staff out to see the condition. I didn't get to go. Have you got that little video? I haven't seen it yet, so let's see what's there. [Video shown.] Mr. Mica. Okay. That one's empty. Well, that looks pretty good. That one's empty. That one's empty. Uh-huh, yep. Nobody there. That looks pretty good. That's well-utilized Federal property. This is one I saw. There are several of these buildings, structures. More. It kind of goes on and on. Have you been out there, Under Secretary? Mr. Parham. Yes, sir. As a matter of fact, I, along with the Administrator for the Agricultural Research---- Mr. Mica. This is the condition of our Federal properties. Looking pretty good, hey? I hadn't seen it in 3 years. I think we've made a lot of progress--unfortunately, in the wrong direction. Look at this, members. This is very valuable. Now, Brooksville--I've been in real estate--maybe you could get $5,000 an acre. This is worth an incredible amount of money. Not that it has to be commercially developed. It may be well-suited that part of it is a park or a natural preserve. But this is disgraceful, that we have Federal properties around the country--and the Department of Agriculture--again, went out there, visited, requested that we come up with a proposal. If there are impediments, we need to know. If there's a plan--it's just not acceptable. I'm sorry. Mr. Gelber, one of the things that we came up with was we proposed--and, actually, one of the predecessors in GSA, I think public buildings officials--we said there are thousands of people who deal with disposing--they're professionals-- disposing or evaluating real estate and property and its best use and what you can do with it. And I asked GSA to come up with some sort of a way to bring those folks in, look at properties that we have, and then we could utilize their talents to look at what we had and come up with recommendations. We started a Federal Real Property Council as a result of that. Are you aware of that? Mr. Gelber. Yes, sir. Mr. Mica. And does it still exist? Mr. Gelber. Yes, sir. Mr. Mica. Yeah. Well, I met with the members about a year after they'd been put together for that purpose, and very few, just a few million dollars' worth of properties, a handful of properties had actually been handled. Do you know the status of the progress of that? Mr. Gelber. It's a continuing effort, sir. Mr. Mica. Yeah, but it's a very--I mean, it's pitiful, the response. And I have people that were involved in disposing of all of the S&L properties and things, huge numbers of properties, a great talent on that, and they tell me, you know, there's inertia in GSA and the Federal Government. You've seen the bill that's been proposed. And I think most of you--a couple of you commented, this is what we need to do. This pretty much codifies what we tried to get started, which you could do administratively. Yes, there are some impediments, but, no, again, the efforts have not come to fruition like we would like to see. Mr. Wise, you've done some inventories, I guess, of public buildings, but we really don't have a complete inventory of Federal buildings that are vacant, do we? Mr. Wise. No, sir, we don't. Mr. Mica. No. And some of the worst offenders are the Department of Defense. Well, actually, VA, we have a pretty good inventory; I saw that. But it's pages and pages of vacant properties. Some of you may have cited the difficulty with those properties, because sometimes they're in a complex or sometimes they're in the Rust Belt where we no longer have the veterans to occupy the medical facilities, for example. Is that correct? Mr. Wise. That can be an issue for sure. Mr. Mica. Yes. Mr. Wise. We talked about that, I think, in past hearings. And we mentioned in our statement for the record today that you occasionally, maybe more than occasionally, run into problems. When you have a property that's located, a building on a closed campus---- Mr. Mica. Right. Mr. Wise. --it has--it will draw a limited amount of interest, just because the accessibility is in issue---- Mr. Mica. Right. But, one, we don't have an inventory of vacant Federal properties or underutilized Federal properties. That's a given. Two, we don't know the condition of the properties we have. And I think you found that in your evaluation. Is that correct? Mr. Wise. Yes, sir. That gets back to an issue that we've talked about in a number of our reports, and that's the problem dealing with the overall database. And I think that many of the problems we talk about, when it comes to the Federal real property management, really kind of circle back to that foundational issue, which is there are still problems with having a clearly accurate and comprehensive real property database. I know that OMB and GSA have been working hard to try to improve that, but we have still found continuing issues with how agencies reported the data as it cycles back up into the larger database. And so that's a continuing problem, meaning that, for Federal real property managers, if you don't really know what you've got and what condition it's in, then how do you make rational management decisions. Mr. Mica. Uh-huh. Well, I heard one of the things that is cited by the administration is they need more money for the repairs and for also this process. But aren't there also the opportunity for public-private partnerships, where the capital can be provided by the private sector who acquires the property? Mr. Wise? Mr. Wise. We did a recent report on P3 and found that, while P3s have been very common in the infrastructure world, especially when it comes to transportation and highways, that sort of thing, we did not find many, if any, examples--very few examples of anything going on in the real property world. Theoretically, I think it certainly is a possibility, but we haven't found it to be a reality at this point to any great extent. Mr. Mica. Well, again, it depends on how you define it. The Trump Hotel, that's a public-private partnership. We're losing $6 million. We had a Federal Government controlling the building, losing about $6 million to $8 million a year. The square footage, 400,000 square feet, half of it empty. A newer annex behind, empty for 15 years. Anybody in the private sector would never let that happen. We did turn it over. We will now be getting a monthly revenue and a percentage, I think, of gross, or whatever the deal is, turning that around. That's an example. Maybe it isn't a public-private partnership, but we have a public-public partnership, where we turned the property at the Miami-Dade--or the Federal courthouse in Miami turned over to a State institution, a college. A million and a half to keep empty, well, we'll no longer do that. I mean, we can look for these opportunities, but it's painful, and it takes so long. The property in Miami, again, we just turned over this May, is almost a decade. And going back and forth and up and down. I've worked on just some of the ones we outlined in our report, which is now many years old. And we're resolving on the Cotton Exchange that has gone on, and that that was cited here. Mr. Under Secretary Parham cited the possibility of the Department of Agriculture with university. But there are opportunities, because we're sitting on incredible Federal assets, all of them costing billions. Hell, we could--excuse me, I won't say that. Heck, we can take the income, the revenue, just from these properties and turn it over. They say Congress isn't funding. Well, the opportunities are there with public-private partnership, public-public partnership, and also assets, maximizing them and getting a return. We've actually made money tearing down, since our hearing at the Cape, some of the buildings and selling some of the unused material for scrap, which we've made money and cut our costs of maintenance and security because the building's gone. I mean, it just goes on and on. Nobody in the Federal Government seems to be very creative in this. There have been some attempts by OMB in expanding, again, the number of square feet. And you told me you're targeting now 61 million square feet for the future? Is that---- Mr. Mader. Yes, sir, for 2016 through 2020, 61 million square feet of just office and warehouse space, because that, we feel---- Mr. Mica. Good. Mr. Mader. --is really where significant savings are. Mr. Mica. And then the President's initiative, which I support, better utilization of existing space. Been working with you on the FTC building, consolidation of that into the Department of Commerce building, and then utilization of the old FTC building as a National Gallery rent space. And you have a huge amount of rental space with the FTC. Just a question: With the FTC in the new leased space--it's the Constitution building, I believe. That lease that GSA had gotten into was a million square feet. And the lease was botched, the lease acquisition was botched, as I recall, and the courts ordered GSA to honor the lease, which moved part of the FTC in. And that's several years back now. That lease expires, and I would like to see what we can do in consolidating some of that space in the Constitution building along with the existing space that's being utilized in the old FTC building into the Department of Commerce, of which we're renovating a million square feet. But there are no final plans for about 200,000-plus square feet, where we could have a consolidation. And, particularly, if you could report back to me, too, eliminating some of the duplicate spaces that are utilized in the buildings--child care; one important one is data centers; auditorium; and conference space--I would appreciate it. And I'll ask the staff to follow up with a specific line of questions. Can you help us, Mr. Gelber? Mr. Gelber. Yes. We'd be happy to work with your staff on that. Mr. Mica. Thank you. Thank you. I have other members. Did you want to go next, Mr.DeSaulnier? Mr. DeSaulnier. I just wanted to make a comment that I'm supportive of what the chairman is after here. In my experience in California, both the local and State level, we have the same problems. And one question to Mr. Wise is, as you look at this, how you look at developing best practices for us, but you interact with the State and local agencies who, because of things like the McKinney Act, have a relationship with what we do with this property. So, in one instance, in my district, over 20 years ago we worked out an agreement to transition some property to the police department, the sheriff's department, and the fire department for a public safety training facility. The local community is very supportive because we're taking it out of residential areas and putting it on, to be fair, what was an old military base, so it was part of the BRAC process but it was somewhat hyphenated. So, 20 years later, I still get comments about, when are we going to move in? So that interaction between other levels of government, since it's already in the statutes, and how you may recommend to us how we could change that. And then, secondarily, just, I mean, California, when we were in the recession, because we were unprepared in the General Services Department--you may recall the Schwarzenegger administration had a deal to sell five or six very large pieces of property, State property, in San Francisco and Los Angeles and lease it back. And when the legislative analysts came back with the analysis, it was such a horrible deal, even though at that time we were issuing IOU warrants because of our cash flow problem, we didn't do it. And thank goodness we didn't. But it's an illustration of where, if all levels of government were acting with best practices--and the intersection, given the recession, is a very extreme example, but these things aren't consequences, as the chairman says, where there's just a lost opportunity. There is a process. There is the possibility for real crisis and opportunity. So I think it would be a great thing that we stay on this and make sure that we develop these best practices. But to Mr. Wise, maybe you could just elucidate a little bit about what you're doing to interconnect the dots with State and local government. Mr. Wise. Well, overall, I can't really comment too much on the State processes for dealing with State property that's---- Mr. DeSaulnier. No, I mean, the interaction with the Federal Government. Mr. Wise. Yeah. Well, State and local governments are obviously part of the screening process. As you know, under the current legislative framework, any Federal property that an agency decides is no longer needed goes through the screening process, to include, as you alluded to, the McKinney-Vento for homeless, State and local governments, as well as, you know, other public entities. There can be complications to these things. You've got local stakeholders, you've got historical preservation, you've got environmental issues that all come into play. This is why, as I think the chairman talked about and as we mention in our statement, some of the legislative reforms, we think, could be helpful in getting towards dealing with some of these problems. But, overall, the current situation is--it can be a cumbersome--I think as you discuss in your question, it's a very cumbersome process, and---- Mr. DeSaulnier. So my question was more to--is more encouragement--so it may be more rhetorical, from what I'm getting from your response--is the encouragement to us to work with State and local agencies and their organizations here in D.C. Because what we all get, I think, when we go back to our districts or when we talk to our local government is, whether it's a perception or it's a reality, but I think it's a little bit of both, they don't want to deal with it because it's too cumbersome. Mr. Wise. Yeah. Mr. DeSaulnier. So there are lost opportunities for all of the entities there within the statutes and just because the perception of the bureaucratic process is too difficult. Mr. Wise. Yeah. Mr. DeSaulnier. So I know you're considering that as you go along, but however we can facilitate that conversation I think would be helpful. Mr. Wise. No. Thank you. That makes a lot of sense. I can give you one concrete example where the process did work quite well. In the town where I grew up in south-central Pennsylvania, there was a new courthouse built across from the old courthouse. Now, the city government was way, way expanded beyond what it could absorb in the old city hall, which had been built in the 1920s. So what happened? The old courthouse, through public conveyance, went to the city government. Many offices scattered all over town--water department, housing department, et cetera, et cetera, traffic department. All were able to come in after that building was renovated to then be able to get away from all these leases and the extra expenses they entailed. So there was an example where the city was able to get a public conveyance and it turned out to be, I think, pretty good public policy. So hopefully that can--I understand the problems you're getting at, but sometimes the system does work to the benefit of the taxpayers. Mr. DeSaulnier. We want that to be more the norm rather than the exception, which is what the perception is, I think. Mr. Wise. Okay. Mr. DeSaulnier. So when you can point out examples of that in an area that the land cost is very expensive, that's a perfect thing, where if all of these agencies are working together, it's in the best interests of the taxpayers. Mr. Wise. Sure. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you. Mr. Wise. You're welcome. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Mica. Thank you. And, again, a lot of what we do, sometimes we get into some pretty tough stuff, and they go back and forth in this committee, and some of it's partisan. This is meat and potatoes, this is--you know, we have the potential for saving billions of dollars, and we are trillions in debt. This isn't very glamorous. But just look at the progress we've made. We've had to hammer away, but I thank you. The bipartisan cooperation has been very effective in moving this forward. I started out one time with, I think, like, 16,000. That was the number we had initially identified, just under GSA, of vacant or underutilized properties. And I think when we did the first hearing, I crossed it out and we put 15,999. Well, we're going down the list. That's a tough way to do it. This bill, though--and you weren't here earlier; I had it made part of the record--is a bipartisan effort. Passed the House and is now in the Senate. And it does all the things we're discussing here--streamlining some of the disposal process, giving you the tools that you need to do this. So we can make progress. With that, Mr. Grothman, our vice chair. Mr. Grothman. Right. Interesting topic. I'd like to thank the chairman for bringing it up. What we're told here is right. We have about 7,000 Federal properties--and I take it these are just Federal buildings, not vacant properties--7,000 properties that are unutilized or underutilized. Just GSA. Amazing. Amazing, amazing, amazing. Waste money, waste money, waste money. And how many of those buildings--and somebody give me a shot at guessing--how many of those buildings, like we saw up here, are just, in essence, abandoned? I mean, every year, the value of the properties drop because they're not keeping up the electrical or even repairing the windows? Does anybody have an opinion on that? Give me a shot? Mr. Wise? Mr. Wise. We don't have any--the numbers that exist are numbers that are, I think, developed by the administration. So I think the question probably should be directed at the administration. Mr. Grothman. Is it unusual to have buildings in which we just let them--even let windows break and let, you know, the rain come in? Is this a common thing? Mr. Wise. Well, it certainly is existing in Beltsville, as the video showed, and there have been other cases where we have seen--when we did some work a few years ago looking at--it was actually work looking at the accuracy of some of the FRPP data, we saw some places, especially in, I can recall, in one of the national parks that we saw some kind of abandoned huts and little buildings that--I think some of the problem to do with that, sir, is that--and I think this was discussed in some of the previous statements--is that the cost to deal with these things is sometimes greater than just letting them go---- Mr. Grothman. Okay. Mr. Wise. --because they don't have a use for it, and you've got---- Mr. Grothman. Thank you. Mr. Wise. --environmental issues to deal with and no money for demolition---- Mr. Grothman. Great. Mr. Wise. --and to take care of them. Mr. Grothman. When is it determined--I mean, how long does a building have to be vacant before it's determined we better sell this thing? Mr. Wise. That's up to the individual agencies, I think. Mr. Grothman. In general? Mr. Wise. I would probably defer on that question since it's not something that we've really looked at in any detail. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Once it's determined that we ought to get rid of a building, how long does it take to get rid of it? Mr. Wise. Well, again, it could take years. And, as we mentioned, under the current legislative framework, there's a pretty complicated process that needs to go forward, including all the issues to do with public conveyance. You've got issues to do with environmental---- Mr. Grothman. You don't have a guess? Is there an average you can think off the top of your head? Mr. Wise. It just ranges. It can be quick, or it can take years. I mean---- Mr. Grothman. What does ``quick'' mean? Mr. Wise. Sorry? Mr. Grothman. What does ``quick'' mean? Mr. Wise. Well, quick could be anywhere from a few months to a number of years. I mean, there's no discernible pattern that I know of. Mr. Grothman. Okay. One thing that sticks out when I look at this, first of all, you've got to give a shot to the State and Federal Government; then you've got to do something or other to see if the homeless need it. Mr. Wise. Right. Mr. Grothman. I don't understand the purpose of either one of those. I mean, it seems to me, if I have a building and I want to sell it, I don't say, first of all, I've got to call the local city and see if they want it and I've got to call the local homeless shelter and see if they want it. Is there any reason we shouldn't get rid of both of those, what I look at as just wasteful things? Mr. Wise. Well, that's up to Congress because that's the current legislative framework. Mr. Grothman. I know that's what it is, but do you see any benefit? Mr. Mader. You need---- Mr. Grothman. Mr. Mader, you---- Mr. Mader. Congressman, you need to change your legislation, and that's what we've been---- Mr. Grothman. Well, I know, I know, I know. Mr. Mader. I know, but--and that's what the proposed legislation from the House does. Mr. Grothman. It looks like they're still keeping this homeless thing. And I'm not sure, are they still keeping---- Mr. Mader. What we've been working with Chairman Chaffetz and the House is in streamlining it, because there is a value to availing these properties for use for the homeless. What we've been trying to do is to actually streamline that process. Mr. Grothman. What's the value? I mean, if I have a house and I want to sell it and I want to get out the best I can, you know, if the local homeless shelter or the local city want the property, they can bid on it or contact my broker. Mr. Mader. Under the legislation--you know, to Mr. Wise's comment, and I'll ask Mr. Gelber to talk more about it--the public conveyances, they're not paying for it. It's actually being transferred to them, similar to the example that our friends from Agriculture gave. So, again, you know, I have to reemphasize, as frustrated as the members are and the chairman, I've been doing this for 2 years since I came to the administration. I'm frustrated, too, that we can't get the House and Senate to agree on legislation that everybody agrees on: that we need savings coming back to do more disposals, we need McKinney-Vento streamlined. I mean, we're as frustrated as you are, sir. Mr. Grothman. As I understand, it's being held up, what, in the Democratic cloakroom on the Senate side? Is that what's going on now? I think. That's what somebody told me. In your experience, when you deal with these--another thing. We have these 7,000 properties here. Of those, how many, if you bought the property, about, do you think you'd buy the property for the land, and how many do you think the building still has value? And I think there are many, many buildings that don't have value. I mean, you let a building go for 5 years, 6 years, particularly if the thing was built 50 or 70 years ago in the first place, my guess is usually the land is more valuable than the building. But do you know how many of these 7,000 buildings have value apart from the land? Mr. Mader. I don't have that level of detail. Mr. Grothman. Could you guess wildly? Half? Mr. Mader. I wouldn't even hazard a guess. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Kind of shameful. Well, we'll go ahead with--give the remainder--I guess I've used up my time. So we'll let the chairman---- Mr. Mica. Thank you, Mr. Grothman. We'll now recognize Mr. Massie. Mr. Massie. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I actually heard some good ideas here. I did hear some creativity. I wanted to follow up on that. Mr. Mader, you said something that sounded pretty catchy to me, ``Freeze the Footprint.'' Can you tell me more about that? Is that a policy or a statutory thing? Or how are you pursuing that? Mr. Mader. Congressman, as I mentioned, in 2012--and a lot of this was driven at the time by the decreasing budget, and I think agencies have recognized that there's value in addressing their real property program. And so we said in 2012--and it became effective in fiscal year 2013--it's like, okay, nobody-- these are DOD and civilian agencies--nobody will increase their footprint with office and warehouse space. And, as I mentioned---- Mr. Massie. Let me ask just quickly, does that mean owned footprint or also leased? Mr. Mader. No, leased too. Mr. Massie. Okay. Mr. Mader. So leased too. So, basically, we overachieved. You know, not only did we freeze it, but we actually reduced it by the 24.7 million square feet. And then we said, look, that was a one-time event; what we need is a management strategy to go forward. We need agencies to manage these assets in an aggressive way. So, hence, the national strategy, which required each of the agencies to prepare this 5-year plan. Now, a component of that 5-year plan was, oh, and also, by the way, tell us how you're going to reduce your inventory of office and warehouse space. And we required that those plans be signed by the deputy secretaries of every Cabinet-level department. And, this past summer, we actually went out and did an on- site review with each of those agencies to talk about, you know, how are you progressing against the goals that you set? What are the obstacles? So I think, Congressman, we've put in place a good management practice going forward. And, again, as I said, this is a rolling plan. So 2016 to 2020, great. Now we're getting 2017 through 2021. Mr. Massie. It sounds so good to me, I'd like to put it in statute. And I think people would get creative, more creative, within the government when they needed to expand somewhere and there had to be some sort of conservation of mass, if you will, where, okay, before we can do this--and we need to do this, and we want to do this--we've got to find some property and solve the problems that have been articulated here, we've just got to bust through and solve these problems, whether it's legal or statutory requirements like Mr. Wise talked about--I know in my district there's some VA buildings that used to be housing for officers in the military a long time ago, but we've got all these historic requirements, lead abatement, asbestos abatement. Mr. Wise, what sort of statutory things could we do to bust through those problems? Because you end up with a situation where you've got real estate and it's valuable to the city or to developers there, but once you impose all the constraints on it, its value is below zero sometimes. Mr. Wise. Well, one of the things that I think has been an ongoing concern is that--and I think you kind of hint at that in your question--is that you get a lot of stakeholder issues that come into play when you talk about what to do with a conveyance or what to do with a certain property. And as I think Mr. Mica talked about and Mr. Mader also talked about, some of the recent legislation that has passed the House could, to some degree, I think, address some of these things. For example, you know, the Federal Asset Sale and Transfer Act that was passed this year, that act, one of the things that it does is it bundles properties together. So that helps mitigate the individual stakeholder interests that come from the local business or the local government or all these other groups that can come in--tribal groups, State and local groups--that can then end up really kind of jamming up the process or they'll get involved in public hearing court cases of one sort or another that can really slow things down. But if the properties are bundled together for a congressional decisionmaking, then that helps mitigate some of these stakeholder influences. And we think, from what we can see from the legislation, that would be a step forward in helping to help smooth out the process. Mr. Massie. So it may take an act of Congress, or an act of Congress could help---- Mr. Wise. Well, there's been---- Mr. Massie. --get it right? Mr. Wise. Yeah, there's been reform legislation going back--I mean, I've been working on these issues I guess for about 8 years---- Mr. Massie. But, I mean, what I heard you say is, instead of sort of general reform, just start a list of properties and we, you know, write them down here in Congress and put them legislatively, okay, we're going to bundle this and---- Mr. Wise. Yeah, well, the current framework is what it is. And so we see the results of that. And, to some degree, I think, as the chairman's pointed out, there's bipartisan support to look for reforming that process in order to make it more efficient. And there's been a number of bills--and we can go back to--I think you talked about this, Mr. Chairman, your bill, Mr. Denham and you, with H.R. 1734, back about 5 years ago, that had some of the similar characteristics of the 2016 act. So I think there's definitely congressional recognition. Unfortunately, none of these reform bills have been able to get passed by both the House and the Senate. They've all passed the House, but they've gotten stuck in different places in the Senate for various reasons. And so that's been one impediment to trying to enact reforms in how the government should or could manage its real property portfolio. Mr. Massie. Mr. Chairman, would you indulge me for 1 more minute? Mr. Mica. Oh, take your time. We have plenty of time this morning. Mr. Massie. The final thing that I wanted to talk about-- this has been touched on, I think, by most folks here--is getting an accurate inventory of this is really important. I think if we get rid of the logjams and we set up the incentives the right way and then introduce this clearinghouse, this database, that the private sector will be farming that, you know, they'll be mining that list continuously. And that's why, Mr. Gelber, I was excited when you mentioned working on software to locate this inventory. You putting your constraints, almost like a search engine, it sounds like. That would be extremely valuable, particularly if the database is accurate, if the database lists the constraints on each of the properties, you know, in a consistent way across all of the various departments, and if it's available to the public. The first thing is I want for it to be available to Congressmen so each of us could go into that software and look and say, okay, here's something I need to go visit in my district, and then go talk to the local stakeholders, try and anticipate some of these court cases or whatever that may come up. But, anyway, can you tell us about that software and a little bit about the challenges in developing it and where you're at with it right now? Mr. Gelber. I would be happy to, sir. As with any database, one of the key issues is the accuracy of the data. And we are working with our colleagues across the executive branch to ensure that data is as accurate as possible. We have instituted several verification and validation tools that would identify anomalies in the data. Then we can go back to agencies and ask questions about a particular property or a particular set of properties that, for one reason or another, the numbers just don't seem to add up properly for other types of properties that are similar to that around the country. In addition, we're allowing agencies to use the data to analyze both their own inventory but compare their inventory to other Federal agencies to see if, in fact, their operating and maintenance costs are higher or lower than other agencies, if the utilization of a particular property is not as efficient as it could be, when a particular lease would end, and then, using that information, reach out to other Federal agencies in a particular community to say, ``We have a property that you might be interested in,'' or, as an agency, ``I'm looking for space in this community. You have a property that we may be interested in.'' And so these tools, as you mentioned, are very similar to the traditional search types of tools that you see in the commercial marketplace that allow people to mine data and look at data to more effectively make decisions. Mr. Massie. I mean, if it's an open dataset, I can almost imagine a start-up that would write that app for you because of the incentives, if we had the incentives set up right. There are probably 10 start-ups dealing with, you know, finding and helping transfer property--if there's some financial incentive. Now, if they're just going to turn it over to the city or the county or local law enforcement, there may not be that financial incentive. But, anyway, I would love to be a beta-tester for that software if you'll let Congress beta-test that before you go live, understanding it's going to have a lot of glitches and stuff. I think it'd be a helpful tool for our staff to go in and try and anticipate some of these places. Mr. Gelber. That's something we're reviewing at this point. There are still questions about some of the data may not be appropriate to share with the public in general. Mr. Massie. Correct. Mr. Gelber. And as we go through this process of evaluating information and using information, we want to make sure that, as we share information, it's shared for good, if you will, but that actors who may not be as predisposed to--you know, hoping the government makes good decisions, but using that information for other purposes, we want to make sure that we don't share the data inappropriately at this point. So it's something we're reviewing and discussing within the executive branch as well as with Congress. Mr. Massie. All right. Well, thank you very much. I see the chairman was very generous. I'll yield back the time I don't have. Mr. Mica. I thank you, Mr. Massie. And we'll work with you on trying to get ahead of that IRS possible departure from your district, because I'm sure they have a huge footprint as far as square footage and space and then a huge economic impact. Mr. Massie. If I can talk to that, it's an enormous footprint. It's two city blocks, a single-story building, surrounded by private development, which is, you know, much taller buildings and parking. And, like I said, I want to reiterate we'd love for the IRS to stay. We'd love for them to find some other use for that building. But, sort of, my foreboding sense is that I could-- maybe one day I'll be in Congress as long as you, Mr. Chairman, and I'll be sitting in that seat asking some witnesses 20 years later why this single-story building's got vines on it. So I want to prevent---- Mr. Mica. Well, again---- Mr. Massie. --that dystopian future. Mr. Mica. --and just as some institutional advice for being here, if you see this coming and you can work with these agencies--and you had Mr. Mader talking about, well, we have need for placing Federal agencies in square footage, and it all doesn't have to be in Washington, D.C. Here is an example--I don't know your square footage--where you could work in anticipation of transition to another agency that doesn't have to be here. They want to spend an incredible amount of money on relocating all of Homeland Security in one location. It kind of reminds me of putting all the western fleet at Pearl Harbor. But some areas that don't need to be right in the capital center here may have a reuse capability. Again, I think you can sometimes get ahead of this, but you have to do an inventory because there are all these separate entities operating independently. Getting with GSA, finding out what the property needs are, OMB and maybe others, and identify, and maybe transitioning in a smoother fashion and utilizing some fairly valuable property that probably in your locale could be operated a lot less also as a square-footage cost, employment cost, the whole realm, for saving the Federal Government and saving your community. So just a little advice. I worked on the closure of a Veterans medical complex in my community. And we got them to keep part of it open, and then they had to do an assessment. But I wrote them 5 years ago, and I said, ``Hey, this is going to become empty when we open the new one. Let's have a plan.'' But I'll tell you, it always don't work that way. We are still repurposing, and we are into having already the new facility open, have a vacant 120-bed nursing home vacant, which I just turned over to the State of Florida from the Federal Government because they can open it and operate it faster. So you can get ahead of these things. I mean, again, I'm just trying to help you, Mr. Massie, and that is certainly a big responsibility in your district. So words of advice, whatever they're worth. Mr. Massie. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Mica. And the same thing with Mr. DeSaulnier. He pointed out some things. He reminded me that we had been up to New York and looking at some projects, the old post office there, which is being converted now. And I thank you. He helped call attention. We had been up there many times for a post office that had been vacant for 30, 40 years, will now be a center of commerce, a station, at a fraction of the cost and with a public-private partnership. That property got turned over, I think, to the New York Development Authority, but still a lot of Federal responsibility in that project. So those are some of the things--Mr. DeSaulnier, did you have anything else? Mr. DeSaulnier. No, I just--that also is an example of one of the most valuable pieces of property in the United States sitting there being not used, underused, for 20 years, where there was a general interest in doing something positive about it. So, to the degree that we can get on top of those things-- and I know you're trying to--that would be beneficial. Mr. Mica. And this bill certainly will help. And you cited that legislation we've struggled with here, so hopefully we can get our Senate colleagues to act on that. Just two quick updates, Mr. Gelber. Okay, the Coast Guard we had located over here on the waterfront, and they moved into their new building, when was it, at the new location? Mr. Gelber. I believe they moved in in late 2014, possibly the beginning of 2015. Mr. Mica. So 2014, 2015? Mr. Gelber. That's my understanding. We can get the exact dates to your staff. Mr. Mica. And they're fully moved, right? Mr. Gelber. They're currently out of the locations that they were in previously, in the--I believe it's referred to as the Buzzard Point area of Washington, D.C. Mr. Mica. Yes. And what's the status of that property? Mr. Gelber. That property is a leased facility, so it's owned by a private entity. And so I don't know---- Mr. Mica. Is it vacant? Mr. Gelber. I don't know, sir. Mr. Mica. I think it's vacant. Mr. Gelber. As I said, it's owned by a private entity and not in the inventory. Mr. Mica. I know, but I think you're paying a lease on it. Can you let us know the status of that? Mr. Gelber. We can, sir. I believe---- Mr. Mica. Yeah. Here's an example of one coming vacant. I'm pretty sure it's been vacant since at least the beginning of last year, and I think we're still paying rent on it. Sometimes we don't plan these things very well. Then can you give, also for the committee and the staff, I want an update on that building. And then, let me see, we've got an--oh, what's the latest and greatest on the FBI building? Mr. Gelber. That's a procurement that's currently in process. Bids have been submitted to the government, and we're currently reviewing those bids, sir. Mr. Mica. Uh-huh. And have they narrowed it to one of the States? I think it was between Maryland and Virginia. Or is it still open competition? Mr. Gelber. The actual site selection will be part of the award of the contract, and that has not occurred yet. Mr. Mica. Okay. Maybe you could just give us that in writing too. I like to keep up with these things, and then we put a date on them, a response from the committee, and then we can come back, or whoever is in charge, and make certain that we're making progress and we've documented where we are and where we need to go. Well, there being--Mr. Massie, did you have anything else? Thank you. There being no further business before the subcommittee today, I would like to thank our witnesses for participating. I look forward to working with you. You have an important responsibility. We could save billions of taxpayer dollars. We can make idle Federal assets very productive and a good return for the taxpayer. So, with that, there being no further business, this subcommittee hearing is adjourned. Thank you. [Whereupon, at 10:50 a.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]