Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- REFORMING THE POSTAL SERVICE: FINDING A VIABLE SOLUTION [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] REFORMING THE POSTAL SERVICE: FINDING A VIABLE SOLUTION ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ MAY 11, 2016 __________ Serial No. 114-135 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 25-499 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ----------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512-1800; DC area (202) 512-1800 Fax: (202) 512-2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402-0001 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director Andrew Dockham, General Counsel Jeffrey Post, Government Operations Subcommittee Deputy Staff Director Sharon Casey, Deputy Chief Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on May 11, 2016..................................... 1 WITNESSES Ms. Megan Brennan, Postmaster General, U.S. Postal Service Oral Statement............................................... 5 Written Statement............................................ 7 Mr.Robert G. Taub, Acting Chairman, U.S. Postal Regulatory Commission Oral Statement............................................... 24 Written Statement............................................ 26 Ms. Lori Rectanus, Director, Physical Infrastructure Issues, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 56 Written Statement............................................ 58 Ms. Jessica Lowrance, President-Elect, Association for Postal Commerce Oral Statement............................................... 78 Written Statement............................................ 80 Mr. Fredric Rolando, President, National Association of Letter Carriers Oral Statement............................................... 97 Written Statement............................................ 100 APPENDIX Oxford Strategic Consulting G-20 Postal Services 2016, Submitted by Mr. Lynch, can be accessed.................................. 160 RESPONSE Postmaster General to Chairman Chaffetz QFRs 2016-06-09. 161 RESPONSE Lowrance-PostCom to Chairman Chaffetz QFRs 2016-06-02... 176 REFORMING THE POSTAL SERVICE: FINDING A VIABLE SOLUTION ---------- Wednesday, May 11, 2016 House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The committee met, pursuant to call, at 10:02 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Jason Chaffetz [chairman of the committee] presiding. Present: Representatives Chaffetz, Duncan, Jordan, Walberg, Amash, Farenthold, Lummis, Massie, Meadows, DeSantis, Buck, Walker, Blum, Hice, Russell, Carter, Grothman, Hurd, Palmer, Cummings, Norton, Clay, Lynch, Connolly, Kelly, Lawrence, Lieu, Watson Coleman, DeSaulnier, Boyle, Welch, and Lujan Grisham. Chairman Chaffetz. The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform will come to order. And without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Good morning, and thank you for being here. This is an important topic that affects every American, and it is a vital part of our commerce in the United States of America. We are here to discuss the future of the United States Postal Service and to address options for ensuring its long-term viability. Each year, more than 40 percent of the world mail volume is carried through the United States Postal Service. The Postal Service employs more than 400,000 full-time workers spread throughout the country. It is also the backbone of more than a trillion-dollar mailing industry that employs more than 7.5 million people. However, due to the ongoing changes in the way Americans use the mail, the Postal Service faces an unprecedented financial crisis. Since 2006, mail volume has declined more than 25 percent or about 60 billion pieces of mail annually. As a result, the Postal Service has lost money for 9 straight years. With nearly a decade of running behind, the Postal Service faces mounting long-term financial challenges. The agency has $125 billion in unfunded liabilities, including $54 billion for retiree health care, and has exhausted its $15 billion statutory debt limit. Further, the Postal Service lacks the funds it needs for critical infrastructure investments. Chief among those is the purchase of a delivery fleet projected to cost roughly $6 billion. Think about all those millions and millions of postal boxes that need somebody to come actually deliver the mail to them. It is a miraculous thing, I think, in this country that for less than 50 cents you can put a stamp on an envelope and a day or 2 or 3 days later, that is going to show up at another address within the country. It really is truly amazing. But if you are going to purchase new delivery vehicles and prepare for the next decade or two, you are going to need some money, and it is something that the Postal Service does not have. In the meantime, they must manage a delivery fleet of vehicles, which on average is 24 years old and costs $1 billion a year in maintenance. That is just the maintenance cost. While the Postal Service has made efforts to cut cost and streamline its operations, it is not enough. I think it is important to note that many of the unions have been very helpful in actually working with the Postal Service and making cuts, but they don't want to keep continuing to cut the number of personnel, and neither do I. We want to see a growing, vibrant, thriving Postal Service. So today, we are going to hear from representatives of five key stakeholders within the postal community, including the postmaster general, the Postal Regulatory Commission, the Government Accountability Office, private industry, and one of the more important postal unions. There are a number of postal unions. I wish we could have them all up at the same time, but we have one here with us today. The witnesses will discuss reforms as needed, as well as how certain reform proposals would work. One of the things that is most critical in dealing with this has to do with Medicare, and I look forward to hearing from the Postmaster General Brennan and the NALC union President Rolando about a joint proposal to require the Postal Service retirees to fully enroll in Medicare in order to receive Federal health care benefits in their retirement. Since 1983, postal workers have paid some $29 billion, $29 billion they have paid into Medicare. Currently, postal retirees have a choice in enrolling in Medicare. As Federal retirees, they can continue their sole enrollment in Federal employee health care plans, or they can enroll in both a Federal plan and Medicare. While three-quarters of retirees already enroll in both Medicare and the Federal plan, the Postal Service and its retirees could see significant savings if all retirees were duly enrolled. I look forward to hearing more about this proposal. It is one of the most key elements, biggest elements in our drafting and coming forward with a reform package that has a vibrant and sustainable Postal Service. Let me just say I think it is important to note the approach that we are taking here. Are there costs to be cut? Yes. Are there things that we can do to become more effective, more efficient? Yes. But I also do believe that the Postal Service is a vital tool of commerce, and a thriving, vibrant, productive Postal Service is essential to our economy. We cannot ignore this. Think about the world of the internet. Think about the way commerce is moving. Think of the way we communicate. Think of how we send bills and communicate as nation. You have to have a vibrant, thriving Postal Service in order to achieve all of that. That is why I think so many people are here today, and it is one of the most important things that our committee will be addressing and taking care of. That is the goal, and that is what we are trying to achieve. And thank you all for being here. We should have a good hearing today. Chairman Chaffetz. With that, I will now recognize the ranking member, my good friend Mr. Cummings of Maryland. Mr. Cummings. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. And I, first of all, want to thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your hard work and staff on both sides working so hard for a long time to try to resolve the many complex issues that Postal Service faces. And I want to thank the Postal Service community and all of those affected by it because there is a genuine effort to try to come to some type of resolution that is a win-win-win- win for everybody. And I express my appreciation because it helps us as we move along. I also want to thank our witnesses for being here to discuss ideas for addressing the significant challenges facing this very critical institution. Since its establishment more than 240 years ago, the Postal Service has served as the critical link that touches each one of our lives and connects us all together, our families, our businesses, and our communities. Through more than 32,000 post offices staffed by more than 600,000 people, the Postal Service delivers more than 150 billion pieces of mail a year to more than 150 million addresses. Since the last postal reform legislation was enacted some 10 years ago, the Postal Service has encountered deepening financial challenges. As a result of the increasing popularity of one-line communications and transactions, the volume of mail handled by the Postal Service has fallen by more than 25 percent since 2006, and this trend is expected to continue. The cost of the Postal Service's operations have also risen in part because the Postal Service is required to provide universal delivery service to every address in the United States. Every year, about 900,000 new addresses are created in this country, and the Postal Service, its network and facilities, letter carriers and workers must expanded to deliver to every single new address. Congress has also imposed substantial burdens on the Postal Service that have nothing to do with providing universal service. The Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act of 2006 required the Postal Service to fully prefund its liabilities for retiree health care costs, a requirement that no other Federal agency or private sector company faces. These liabilities, together with unfunded pension liabilities, currently amount to about $125 billion, which is almost double the agency's annual revenues. Since 2006, the Postal Service has instituted many cost- saving measures, including the following: cutting 200,000 positions through attrition, cutting work hours by 331 million, consolidating more than 360 facilities and 20,000 delivery routes, and changing retail operation hours in approximately 13,000 post offices to match customer demand and reducing the number of administrative areas and districts. And let me say this. I have said it to their faces; I have said it behind their backs. I think the unions have bent over backwards trying to work with the Postal Service and have done--I mean, of all the committees I have sat on and dealt with, I think here we have a genuine effort by unions to understand what is going on, to make sure that they do right by their members, and at the same time make sure that we have a viable and strong postal system. And I want to thank them. The Postal Service reports that these initiatives have saved the agency some $15 billion a year. However, there are significant legal restrictions that limit the Postal Service's ability to cut costs and introduce new products to counteract its deteriorating financial condition. As a result, despite its diligent efforts, the Postal Service has reported a net loss of $5.1 billion for fiscal year 2015, its ninth consecutive year of losses. The Postal Service projects $5.9 billion in net losses for fiscal year 2016. Only Congress can modify the nature and the structure of the funding obligations imposed by statute on the Postal Service's health care and pension programs. Of course, these problems are not new, and we have gone far down the road of developing reform legislation in previous Congresses. But Congress has been unable to reach a final bill. The time now is to act. And so I want to again thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your commitment to working on a bipartisan basis, and it truly has been bipartisan with me and other colleagues to develop a realistic reform proposal. I am encouraged by our discussion and hopeful that we will be able to help put the Postal Service on a viable and sustainable path. I believe that any postal reform legislation that this committee considers should do the following, as I close: alleviate the burdensome requirement for prefunding retiree health benefits, allow the Postal Service to have separate postal-only health plans that integrate fully with Medicare, allow the Postal Service to offer non-postal financial services such as post-office-to-post-office money orders and certain types of gift cards, and require the Postal Service to create a new chief innovation officer charged with developing new, innovative products, as any other business. And so we need to work together to address the problems facing the Postal Service, and we need to treat the employees of the Postal Service fairly and compassionately. Waiting until the Postal Service runs out of cash is simply not an option. The Postal Service is an institution on which all Americans rely. And finally, I want to thank Mr. Connelly and Mr. Lynch for their hard work on this effort. We have met many times trying to get through this, and we will. And so, ladies and gentlemen, we simply cannot fail. We simply cannot kick the can down the road. The time to act is now, and I do believe that we are well on the road to accomplishing that. And with that, I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I think it is important to note the good work that Mr. Meadows of North Carolina, Mr. Lynch, and Mr. Connelly have put into this, and I concur with my colleague Mr. Cummings that if we are going to do this and actually pass it all the way to the President's desk, it does need to be a bipartisan bill. And that is the goal and that is the intention. I will hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. But we would like to recognize our witnesses here today. We are honored to have the postmaster general of the United States Postal Service, Ms. Megan Brennan. We have the Honorable Robert Taub, acting chairman of the United States Postal Regulatory Commission. We have Ms. Lori Rectanus, who is the director of physical infrastructure issues at the United States Government Accountability Office; Ms. Jessica Lowrance, executive vice president of the Association for Postal Commerce; and Mr. Fredric Rolando, president of the National Association of Letter Carriers. We welcome you all, and thank you for being here. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses are to be sworn before they testify. If you will please rise and raise your right hands. [Witnesses sworn.] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for discussion, we would appreciate it if you would limit your oral comments to no more than 5 minutes. Your entire written statement will be made part of the record. We thank you for your participation. We will now recognize the postmaster general for 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF MEGAN BRENNAN Ms. Brennan. Thank you. Good morning, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee. Thank you, Chairman Chaffetz, for calling this hearing. I'm proud to be here today on behalf of the dedicated men and women of the United States Postal Service, who work hard every day to serve the American public. The Postal Service currently operates with a business model that is unsustainable. In the past decade, total mail volume declined by 28 percent, and first-class mail, our most profitable product, has declined by 35 percent. To put this in perspective, the annual value of the revenue lost as a result of this volume decline is $21 billion per year. Nevertheless, the Postal Service is required to maintain an extensive network necessary to process and deliver the mail to every address 6 days a week. The cost of that network is largely fixed or growing, regardless of volume. However, less volume and limited pricing flexibility means that there is less revenue to pay for that network and fund other costs imposed upon us by law. We continue to make difficult but necessary decisions within the constraints of our business model to adapt to our rapidly changing marketplace. We have streamlined our operations, restructured our networks, and improved productivity for 6 consecutive years. As a result of these efforts, we've achieved annual cost savings of nearly $15 billion. We have also been successful in stabilizing marketing mail revenues and growing our package delivery business, which together enable America's e-commerce. However, all of these actions cannot offset the negative impacts caused by the continued decline in the use of first- class mail. Since 2012, the Postal Service has been forced to default on more than $28 billion in mandated payments to the Treasury for retiree health benefits. Without these defaults, the deferral of capital investments and aggressive management actions, we would not be able to pay our employees, our suppliers, or to deliver the mail. Without legislative and regulatory reform, our net losses will continue to grow regardless of our ongoing efforts to grow revenue and improve operational efficiencies. If allowed to continue, this will have a devastating impact on the future of the organization and the customers we serve. Mr. Chairman, we need legislation now. Over the past year, we have been working with postal stakeholders to identify key reforms capable of achieving broad support and which would return the Postal Service to financial stability. The legislation we are seeking reflects the results of these discussions and includes the following four provisions: require full Medicare integration for postal retiree health plans, restore our exigent price increase for market-dominant products, calculate all retirement benefit liabilities using postal-specific salary growth and demographic assumptions, and provide additional product flexibility. By enacting legislation that includes these provisions, the Postal Service can achieve an estimated $32 billion in combined cost reductions and new revenue over the next 5 years. Enactment of these provisions, favorable changes to our rate- setting system by the Postal Regulatory Commission, and our aggressive efficiency and revenue initiatives will return the Postal Service to financial stability. Medicare integration is the most important of the legislative provisions we recommend. As the second-largest contributor to Medicare, our proposal allows the Postal Service and our employees to fully utilize the benefits for which we have already paid. By requiring full Medicare integration for Postal Service retirees, we will essentially eliminate the current unfunded liability for retiree health benefits. We are also seeking to restore the exigent rate increase as a permanent part of our rate base. In April, the Postal Service was required by the PRC to eliminate the exigent surcharge and to reduce our prices. This will reduce our revenues this year by $1 billion and by approximately $2 billion annually, further worsening our financial condition. Reinstating the exigent surcharge is critical to the Postal Service's financial stability. Mr. Chairman, our financial challenges are serious but solvable. The proposals we are advancing today are fiscally responsible. They enable the Postal Service to invest in the future and to continue to provide affordable and reliable delivery service. Mr. Chairman, I look forward to working with this committee and our stakeholders to restore the financial health of the United States Postal Service. This concludes my remarks. I welcome any questions that you and the committee may have. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [Prepared statement of Ms. Brennan follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Chairman Taub, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF ROBERT G. TAUB Mr. Taub. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Cummings, good morning. I'll hit a few key points of the committee's very detailed written testimony. In 2015, the Postal Service had a total net loss of $5.1 billion, which is an improvement from 2014. However, this is the ninth consecutive net loss since 2007 and has increased the cumulative net deficit since then to $56.8 billion. These continuing losses have negatively impacted liquidity, requiring the Postal Service to use all of its $15 billion statutory borrowing capacity and causing total liabilities to far exceed total assets by $50.4 billion. In the past 5 years, the Postal Service has not made any of the required prefunding payments to the retiree health benefit fund. This accruing nonpayment into the fund has skewed the Postal Service's current liabilities in relation to its assets. To reduce its debt ratio to historic averages, the Postal Service would have to significantly increase its current cash position or investments in capital assets and reduce its obligations to the retiree health benefit fund. Low liquidity levels in recent years have impeded the Postal Service's ability to make capital investments in infrastructure. It now operates an aging vehicle fleet, increasing the need and consequently the costs for maintenance and repair. Also unmet is the need to invest in sorting and handling equipment to fully capitalize on business opportunities in the growing package delivery markets. Total mail volume in 2015 dropped to levels not seen in more than 27 years, and the Postal Service anticipates further reductions in total volumes for 2016. The continuous decline in first-class mail seriously jeopardizes the Postal Service's ability to cover its fixed overhead costs. Recent increases in revenues and subsequent higher liquidity are largely due to the temporary market-dominant product exigent surcharge. The additional revenue from competitive products, which are mainly parcels, is not sufficient to offset the future revenue loss resulting from the termination of the exigent surcharge, which was removed April 10. In order to maintain the operating net income it is currently achieving, the Postal Service would have to make up the loss of that revenue, which is approximately $2.1 billion annually. With the growing liability of retiree health benefits, the inability to borrow for needed capital investments and the continued loss of high-margin, first-class mail revenues, the important task of improving the financial condition of the Postal Service is daunting. Despite the financial news, there is still strength in the system. The Postal Service is the one government agency that touches every American on a daily basis. It is an organization that literally serves 155 million American households and businesses on a typical day. It facilitates trillions of dollars in commerce. The fundamental problem is that the Postal Service cannot currently generate sufficient funds to cover its mandated expenses and also invest in critically deferred capital needs. Where can we look for answers? I would argue the starting point is to look at ourselves. What do we as a nation need from postal and delivery system and what is its cost? What exactly is universal mail service in the United States? The Commission has determined that, unlike other countries, the universal service obligation, or USO, in the United States is largely undefined and instead is comprised of a broad set of policy statements with only a few legislative prescriptions. The Commission estimates the cost of providing universal service to be more than $4 billion annually. When assessing the current state of the Postal Service, policymakers should look at this fundamental issue and decide exactly what we as a nation need from the Postal Service and, most importantly, how those expectations are to be funded. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Cummings, thank you for holding this hearing today and shining a spotlight on this critical part of our nation's infrastructure. I know you deeply appreciate the importance of these issues. There are no easy answers, but answer we must, and the Commission stands ready to help you in the search for solutions. On behalf of all for commissioners and the entire hardworking agency staff, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. [Prepared statement of Mr. Taub follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you, Mr. Taub. I would now recognize Ms. Rectanus of the GAO. Did I pronounce your name properly? Ms. Rectanus. Yes ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Okay. Ms. Rectanus.--you did. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. STATEMENT OF LORI RECTANUS Ms. Rectanus. Good morning. Chairman Chaffetz, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, I'm pleased to be here today to discuss the Postal Service's financial challenges. The Postal Service is a critical part of the Nation's communications system, but its financial situation is dire. We placed the Postal Service on our high-risk list in 2009 where it remains today. Today, I will discuss the factors affecting the Postal Service's deteriorating financial condition, the status of unfunded liabilities, and choices Congress faces to address these financial challenges. The Postal Service's financial struggles are well- documented. Beginning in 2007, expenses began consistently outgrowing revenues, and it has lost over $56 billion since then. This situation is primarily caused by decline in mail volume, particularly in profitable first-class mail commensurate with an increase in expenses, largely because of salary increases. Increases in compensation and benefits alone will add over $1 billion in additional cost in fiscal year 2016. The gap between revenue and costs continues despite the significant efficiency initiatives undertaken by the Postal Service. Regarding unfunded liabilities and costs, they are a large and growing burden on the Postal Service. At the end of fiscal year 2015, the Postal Service had about $125 billion in unfunded liabilities and outstanding debt, which accounted for 182 percent of its revenues. Retiree health benefits account for $55 billion of the unfunded liability due in part because the Postal Service stopped making required payments in 2011 and is not expected to make the required 2016 payment. Given this history and future events, it is not likely that the Postal Service will be able to make its required retiree health and pension payments in the near future. Beginning in fiscal year 2017, the Postal Service will be required to start making annual payments for health benefits on top of annual pension payments. Using available data, we determined these payments could total about $11 billion. Although this is less than what was required in fiscal year 2015, it is about $4.6 billion more than what the Postal Service paid that year. And the expiration of the temporary rate surcharge and the lack of major cost-savings initiatives will further stress the Postal Service's ability to make these payments. Having large unfunded liabilities for postal retiree health and pension benefits places taxpayers, employees, retirees, and the Postal Service itself at risk. If the Postal Service does not adequately fund these benefits and Congress wanted these benefits to continue, the Treasury, and hence the taxpayer, may need to step in. Alternatively, unfunded benefits could lead to pressure for reductions in benefits or pay. For the Postal Service, unfunded benefits endanger its future viability by saddling it with bills later after employees have already retired. Postal Service actions alone under its existing authority are insufficient to achieve financial solvency. Comprehensive legislation is needed. In doing this, Congress faces several difficult decisions and tradeoffs in key areas. First, what is the level of postal services needed in the 21st century, and what are we willing to pay for those services? Given how communication is changing, Congress could consider what postal services should be provided on a universal basis and the best way to provide those services. Second, what is the appropriate level of compensation and benefits that should be paid in an environment of revenue pressures? Congress could consider revising the statutory framework for collective bargaining to ensure that the Postal Service's financial condition is considered in binding arbitration. And third, what is the continued viability of the Postal Service's dual role of providing affordable universal service while remaining self-sufficient? In assessing any alternatives to the current structure, Congress should consider costs that might be transferred from the Postal Service, which is financed by ratepayers, to the Federal Government, which is funded by taxpayers. In conclusion, we must take a hard look at what level of postal services we need in the future and what we can afford. The status quo is not sustainable. This concludes my prepared statement. Chairman Chaffetz, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, I would be pleased to answer any questions you have. [Prepared statement of Ms. Rectanus follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Ms. Lowrance, I will now recognize you for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF JESSICA LOWRANCE Ms. Lowrance. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Cummings, and the members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today about postal-related issues facing the mailing industry. The mailing industry provides over 7.5 million jobs and accounts for $1.4 trillion in economic activity. While the mailing industry is a vital part of the Nation's economy and surpasses in size both the airline industry and the oil and natural gas industry, it is one that faces significant challenges. Not only are there policies, issues that must be considered, but also economic issues that balance the infrastructural needs of the American economy and the public welfare. Mail is and will remain a vital part of the American economy and the manner in which the Nation communicates and does business. Despite all that has transpired over the last several years, market-dominant mail still consists of over 154 billion pieces or 97 percent of the Postal Service's business. The American mail system is a sender-paid service. As volume continues to decline, however, the Postal Service is pressed to find new ways to help lessen its financial burden. From our perspective, there are several fundamental matters that need immediate attention, including the need for predictable, affordable mail services; complete, accurate, and transparent costing of products and services; and reliable, consistent mail service. At the end of this calendar year, the Postal Regulatory Commission, as directed by the PAEA, will be reviewing the current system of rate regulation. Although the Postal Service has expressed displeasure with the price cap, the CPI-based cap has operated substantially as intended to the benefit of all postal customers, Postal Service, and the general public. For business customers, the cap provides customers with an assurance of postal rate stability and predictability, which is key to the decision as to whether to continue to invest in mail as a business communication and commercial vehicle. For the years it has been in effect, this inflation-based price cap has served as an effective restraint against abuse of the Postal Service's monopoly power. The Postal Service has been required to focus more closely on the elimination of postal waste and inefficiencies in a manner that would not have happened in the absence of the cap. Unfortunately, there are obligations such as the prefunding mandate and the nonparticipation of postal retirees and Medicare that has made operating under such a cap a challenge. The need for costing transparency has never been so apparent as it is today. The mailing industry has consistently called for greater clarity and transparency in the reporting of postal costs. This lack of transparency has resulted in other Postal Service decisions that have imposed additional cost on mailers without creating corresponding efficiencies in the postal network. The Postal Service, its customers, and the Postal Regulatory Commission would benefit greatly by an upgrading of postal costs and modeling systems. The Postal Service should move without dispatch to an informed visibility-based system. This would enable costs to be tracked in an automated fashion similar to how it tracks service performance throughout the Nation. For business customers, the quality of mail delivery is a key component of the value of mail. Timeliness, consistency, and reliability are extremely important to these users and recipients of the mail. The Postal Service's inability to provide consistent and reliable service is causing many enterprises to look to other means as their preferred method for communicating and doing business. Legislative reform is just one of the many tools that would need to be leveraged in order for the Postal Service to be, and remain, fiscally viable. At the very least, mailers urge Congress to address those issues that are solely within its power to do so. One, fix the mandated prefunding requirements; and two, allow for fuller postal employee participation in Medicare. With the upcoming 10-year review of the current rate regulation system, mailers need an accurate accounting and understanding of the cost of the products and services they receive from the Postal Service. The Commission should not be required to judge the performance of the existing system on the basis of data that are inadequate for sound decision-making. It is imperative that the Postal Service be directed to use the many data-driven tools such as the intelligent mail barcode and informed visibility to supply the data the Commission so sorely needs to make the informed decisions about the current system of rate regulation and how to move forward in its review. At the end of the day, the mailers need reliable, consistent mail service and affordable, predictable prices in order to continue to invest in mail for business communication and commerce. Chairman Chaffetz, Ranking Member Cummings, and the members of the committee, this concludes my prepared statement. I can answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Ms. Lowrance follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Rolando, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF FREDERIC ROLANDO Mr. Rolando. Thank you, Chairman Chaffetz and Ranking Member Cummings and members of the committee, for inviting me to testify today. You've asked me to focus on the urgent need for postal reform legislation and the provisions that we believe are necessary. I'm pleased to do that today, but before I do, it's important that we take a moment to recognize the current reality of the Postal Service. It is no longer 2009 when the Great Recession sent mail volume plummeting and the prefunding mandate crushed the Postal Service's finances, raising doubts in some quarters about the viability of the agency. Postal employees never doubted the viability of the Postal Service, but we worked hard to help the Service to adapt and survive as it shed more than 200,000 jobs and we boosted productivity dramatically. The Postal Service has returned to operational profitability, now earning $4.4 billion over the past 2-1/2 years, our pension funds are healthy and better funded at 92 percent than most private sector pensions, and we have set aside some $50 billion for retiree health when most large private companies have not set aside a dime. Thanks to the growth of direct mail and booming e-commerce, total mail volume recovered and stabilized in 2015, increasing the Postal Service's revenue to $69 billion. There's no question that the Postal Service remains a vital part of the Nation's economic infrastructure. In 2015, we delivered more than 150 billion letters, magazines, and packages, 6 and even 7 days a week. The Postal Service's revenue is just a small part of the $1.4 trillion of the GDP accounted for by the U.S. mailing industry, which now employs 7-1/2 million Americans. With an 84 percent approval rating for the American people, we believe the Postal Service can thrive in the 21st century with the right public policies. Now is not the time to weaken this treasured agency through service and delivery reductions, especially those that have failed to attract congressional support in the past. Instead, this committee should offer sensible and targeted reforms that would provide financial stability and allow the Postal Service to innovate. Specifically, it should address three specific legislative and regulatory burdens that severely hinder the Postal Service. First, the Postal Service is required to massively fund future retiree health premiums decades in advance, regardless of financial conditions facing the agency or the country. No other public or private enterprise in America faces such a mandate, and most firms don't prefund at all. This mandate by itself accounts for nearly 90 percent of all reported losses since 2007. NALC has suggested numerous ways to address the prefunding mandate over the years. As part of an overall reform effort that does not weaken our networks or diminish services to the public, we support reforms to the FEHBP program to maximize participation in Medicare among eligible postal retirees. This would almost eliminate the $50 billion unfunded liability for future retiree health while raising Medicare spending by less than 2/10 of 1 percent annually. Given that the Postal Service and its employees have contributed $29 billion to Medicare, this approach is fair and appropriate. Second, Congress should consider the policy that requires 100 percent of postal retirement funds be invested in low- yielding treasury bonds. Together, the Civil Service and FERS postal pension accounts, along with the postal retiree health fund, hold nearly $350 billion in treasury securities. That makes the Postal Service and its employees the third-largest creditors of the U.S. Federal Government just behind China and Japan. No other company in America would invest its retirement assets in such an unsophisticated way, especially during a period when treasuries are yielding 2 to 4 percent annually. Starting with the retiree health fund, we should apply private sector best practice by investing in well-diversified portfolios of private stocks, bonds, and real estate, as well as government bonds. Current policy forces the mailing industry to give Uncle Sam a low-cost loan instead of sensibly investing to cover future health-care liabilities. It makes no financial sense to invest in assets that yield less than the rising cost of care. My submitted testimony makes the case for prudent investment change, addresses common objections to it, and explains how several independent agencies invest successfully in private securities. By changing the investment policy, Congress could raise the long-term rate of return on the assets, reduce the burden of prefunding, offset the cost of postal Medicare integration, relieve upward pressure on postal rates, and reduce the misguided impulse to slash service. Third, in my full testimony I address the postage rate- making process, which the PRC will formally review in 2017. There's a remarkable degree of stakeholder consensus about the principles of successful postal reform. All four postal unions, the Postal Service, and a wide range of companies and postal trade associations have agreed on reform principles for your consideration. And these principles were outlined in a letter sent to the chairman yesterday, and it urged legislation that would mandate postal-specific assumptions, satisfy--not eliminate--satisfy the prefunding burden by reforming FEHBP to maximize Medicare participation, invest the retiree health fund sensibly, permit the Postal Service to provide non-postal products in limited circumstances, and adjust the market- dominant rate base to ensure adequate revenue through the PRC review if necessary. Our coalition's recommendations are grounded in common sense and best practice. They represent the measures on which we could agree while remaining confident that they would stabilize the Postal Service while allowing it to innovate to meet the evolving needs of our country. NALC and our sister postal unions remain committed to helping this committee find a fair and equitable path forward that does not damage our network of universal and affordable service or the employees that make that network special. Thank you very much again for this opportunity to testify, and am happy to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Rolando follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Thank you all. We will now start by recognizing the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Duncan, for 5 minutes. Mr. Duncan. Well, thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. General Brennan, I have an article here from the Los Angeles Times that says, ``after peaking in 2006, total mail handled by the Postal Service has declined 27 percent.'' Is that fairly accurate, and is mail volume still slowly declining? Ms. Brennan. That's correct. Mr. Duncan. All right. And do you feel like you have taken every step you can do thus far to adjust to that decline? Ms. Brennan. Congressman Duncan, you're correct in terms of the decline in total mail volume. The challenge for us is the continued decline particularly in first-class mail, which pays the bills, defines our network requirements, hence, our actions to right-size the infrastructure and take cost out of the system. There are still opportunities, but I think as noted, we've reduced our annual cost base by $15 billion. Mr. Duncan. I will tell you a little story. About 4 years ago they had an article about me and my dad in the Knoxville News Sentinel, and I got the nicest handwritten letter from Peyton Manning about that article. He said he could tell from that article I had the same kind of relationship with my dad that he has with his dad. Well, 2 or 3 months later my chief of staff saw Peyton Manning one night and told him how much I appreciated that, and he said Peyton Manning told him that his mother told him once that if you wanted to really make an impression on people nowadays, send them a handwritten note or letter. Maybe you should try to get more people to follow the Peyton Manning method of impressing people because it made a big impression on me, I can tell you. Ms. Brennan. I would agree with that, Congressman. Mr. Duncan. Maybe you should get him to do an ad for you or something. [Laughter.] Mr. Duncan. Let me ask you this. Would it make any difference, or how much of a difference would it make if you went to 5-day-a-week service? Ms. Brennan. We've spent the better part of the past year, Congressman, on trying to build consensus with key stakeholders, a narrower group of provisions, high value, that would generate more than $32 billion in cost reductions and savings over the next 5 years. The reality is in my discussions with public officials, members of this committee, there's no congressional consensus for moving to 5-day delivery. Mr. Duncan. Right. Ms. Brennan. The Postal Service is looking at, how do we leverage our infrastructure, which is an asset? How do we grow profitable revenue? How do we look to fill the mailbox and fill the truck? That's what we're focused on. Mr. Duncan. Many companies in the private sector that had pension plans that they saw they couldn't afford anymore, they stopped giving those pensions to their new hires. Have you considered doing something like that, reducing the pension benefits for new hires, and would that make any difference? Ms. Brennan. Congressman Duncan, I would say that we have a plan forward. There is a way to resolve these legacy costs and these liabilities, and that's by permitting the Postal Service to integrate with Medicare. It's universal practice. Our employees, as noted by the chairman and the ranking member, have paid more than $29 billion in Medicare taxes, and we should benefit from that opportunity. There is a way forward without looking at diminishing benefits to either current or future employees. Mr. Duncan. Ms. Rectanus, when you looked at this, these figures are so staggering. I saw some figure that $56 billion in total losses over the last several years or something. What did you find or what do you consider to be the most troubling aspect of the entire financial condition of the Postal Service? What is the worst problem or the biggest problem? Ms. Rectanus. Fundamentally, what we have found is the Postal Service's business model that relies on revenue to cover its costs is no longer working. Certainly, the unfunded liabilities, particularly the RHB, have contributed to that, but there is a broader problem, and that is the fundamental business model of mail volume that the Postal Service has been using isn't working anymore. And to their credit, they have been trying to right-size their network and make changes. But what we would argue is it's even beyond the unfunded liabilities. Even if you take those out, the ability of the Postal Service to raise its--to reduce its costs to align with the revenue, they just don't have the ability to do that right now without comprehensive reform. As one example, their controllable income, which is what they talk about the income before they account for their unfunded liabilities in fiscal year 2015 was less than it was in fiscal year 2014 even though in fiscal year 2015 they had the exigent for the full year. And that's just an example of even when there is an influx of money, the operating costs are still growing such that their-- it's harder and harder for them to get ahead of their costs. Mr. Duncan. Well, the unfunded liability problem is a problem for the entire Federal Government. It is more than just the Postal Service. It is staggering. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I will now recognize Mr. Cummings for 5 minutes. Mr. Cummings. Thank you very much. You know, the Postal Service has come up with methods to save some $15 billion per year, is that right, Ms. Brennan? Ms. Brennan. That's correct, Congressman Cummings. Mr. Cummings. And I have always been concerned about making sure that we save as much money as possible. At the same time, I was hoping that we could find ways to bring in more money. So, Ms. Rectanus and Mr. Taub, do you agree that in order to be financially viable long-term it is important for the Postal Service to develop innovative products and services? Ms. Rectanus. We do support the Postal Service's continued ability to be innovative and develop products and resources that people need. The challenge that you run is trying to find that sweet spot between areas in which the Postal Service will be profitable since they can't afford to lose money, but you don't want them to be able to compete unfairly because of their unique status, or conversely, lose money because of their unique status. Mr. Cummings. And so you end up in a no-spot? Ms. Rectanus. We believe ---- Mr. Cummings. You know, it is kind of hard. On the one hand we want them to be able to bring in more money, but then we tie their hands and shackle their feet and say we don't want you to do this and don't want you to do that. So what do you recommend that they do? I mean, what would you--and, Mr. Taub, you certainly are--you look like you are anxious to join in on this, so I would like to hear what you all have to say because it becomes very frustrating ---- Mr. Taub. Yes. Mr. Cummings.--for the Postal Service and for us. So I am just wondering what you see there. Mr. Taub. Yes. From the--again, this is a cost-and-revenue issue. I would say the first ---- Mr. Cummings. I am talking about things that are going to be profitable. I don't want anything that is not profitable, and I think Ms. Brennan would--that doesn't even make sense. Let's take that off the table. Mr. Taub. Right. Mr. Cummings. We are talking about profitable things. Let's go from there. Mr. Taub. Yes. The 2006 law took a very hard line in saying the Postal Service could only offer what are defined as postal products, what you can think of as traditionally hard-copy delivery letters, packages. So clearly, the law would need to open that aperture if you're going to move beyond that. The Postal Regulatory Commission in 2011 in a report to Congress and the President laid out a variety of recommendations. One of them was to suggest that if that aperture were to be open, the Commission now has this experience as the regulator to call balls and strikes and ensure fair competition issues, ensure that cost coverage is there. I would note, though, as I indicated in my opening statement that this also is part of that larger question of what is it that the United States Postal Service should do as a government institution, and I think that's an important understanding. What are the boundaries, as opposed to simply looking for revenue opportunities that may not be in their core competency. But if the financial issue of that fire in the house can be put out and the--we can start rebuilding it and look in that holistic way. Mr. Cummings. Now, Postmaster General, you have been in this position for a little while now, and I am just wondering, you know, talk about what you all have been trying to do and how that has worked out and with a more perfect situation what you would like to be able to do. Ms. Brennan. Yes ---- Mr. Cummings. In that regard. Ms. Brennan. Yes. If I may just say, sir, we are innovating at the core in the mail by giving mail a digital reflection to stabilize it and look to grow advertising mail. In the package arena we've partnered with large e-commerce retailers to customize delivery solutions, same-day, next-day, Sunday delivery, delivery of other products, groceries as an example. And I think as Commissioner Taub mentioned, it's innovating for us at the core. Our core competency is delivery. How do we leverage that delivery network? We've partnered with other government agencies to do in-person proofing. We did a pilot test in Arizona to on-board census workers. We think there's some opportunity for us in the future with other government agencies to do ID verification whether it's at a local retail or on the doorstep with the enhanced technology we have embedded in our mobile delivery devices. Mr. Cummings. You know, I visited the Amazon plant--as a matter of fact, the chairman and I went--in Maryland, and it was amazing to hear them talk about the last mile and how much they couldn't do their job unless the Postal Service was a part of it. How much is that helping you ---- Ms. Brennan. Very much ---- Mr. Cummings.--financially? Ms. Brennan. I would say this. The growth in package volume, Congressman Cummings, over the past year or past 5 years I'll cite, 49 percent growth in package volume, more than 1.5 billion more packages in the system. The Postal Service now delivers roughly 30 percent of all packages in the country. Credit to President Rolando and President Dwyer of the National Rural Letter Carriers Association who worked with us to enable us to have greater flexibility with the workforce to be responsive to the customer requirements of an Amazon and others that we're working with. Mr. Cummings. I mean, what do you see--what do you project in the future with regard to that? Do you see an expansion of that? It seems like this online shopping--and I literally go, you know, to the mall myself, but apparently that is old- fashioned now. So do you see that expanding more? Ms. Brennan. Yes, Congressman Cummings ---- Mr. Cummings. Not my thing, I am talking about the ---- Ms. Brennan. Absolutely. Mr. Cummings.--online. Ms. Brennan. No, I--hyper growth, hyper growth. But the challenge it's a very competitive delivery space. We compete for customers every day. It's the value proposition, competitive pricing, the transit time, performance, and certainly visibility. And the Postal Service has made investments in all of those components to ensure we improve our competitive standing. We need to recognize that while our strength is last-mile deliver, we're challenged there. The so-called Uberization of package delivery, it's a very competitive space, so we recognize we've got to compete for that business. The challenge, though, ultimately for us, the package growth alone won't offset the losses in first-class volume, hence the need to address the legacy costs, specifically looking at Medicare integration as the cornerstone of our legislative ask. Mr. Cummings. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Farenthold, for 5 minutes. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I want to follow up on a couple of things that the ranking member talked about, Ms. Brennan. You used the phrase ``give mail a digital reflection.'' What does that mean? Ms. Brennan. Yes. Yes, Congressman. We created a catalog called Irresistible Mail that imbeds in the catalog new technologies well beyond QR codes to include augmented reality near-field communications, so you open that catalog, it comes to life, so making it more creative and making it more relevant to the end consumer. Mr. Farenthold. Okay. Super. And I think you also touched on the amount of work that you guys do for Amazon, and I think that is a great revenue opportunity, but I am afraid it is a short-term problem. I imagine there are a lot of people who spend their day at Amazon looking for ways to deliver packages faster and more efficiently. For instance, here in Washington, D.C., I have got about an hour and 5 minutes to order something that will be waiting for me when I get home tonight, and that isn't you all that are doing the last-mile delivery on that. I work on the Transportation Committee. Amazon is talking about developing drones to deliver packages. One day in the not-too-distant future they are going to say bye-bye to you guys, and how are you all preparing for that? I mean, you are saying they are 41 percent of your package volume. Ms. Brennan. Congressman, I would say this: As I noted, it is a very competitive delivery space, so we've got to compete for that business. The term ``coopetition'' exists whether it's with Amazon, who's a valuable customer as well as business partner, or UPS and FedEx who are traditional competitors, also business partners for us. So, again, it comes down to delivering the best value, and that includes service and price. Mr. Farenthold. And let's talk about service and price for a second. I live in Corpus Christie, Texas, and we were the unfortunate victims of a consolidation of a mail processing center. So now, instead of mailing something to my neighbor across the street and having it processed in Corpus Christie and delivered the next day, it is trucked to San Antonio, processed, and maybe delivered in 3 days at the same price. At some point, you know, companies like Amazon want it there quicker. As you cut the quality of your service, especially on your lead program or your lead product, first-class mail, it starts to become less valuable and makes email look like a better alternative. Ms. Brennan. Congressman, the consolidation was in response to that decline in single-piece first-class mail, which is down more than 35 percent over the last decade. The service standard change and consolidation did not impact the delivery of packages, which is the growth product. We did the responsible thing, which was right-size the infrastructure, address the latent capacity, and look at how to better utilize our assets. Now, service is foundational and it is key to growth. We recognize that. Mr. Farenthold. And so we also spent a little bit of time talking about some of the--and I think almost everybody on the panel had a wish list of postal reforms that would make things better. Obviously, you know, shifting people to Medicare where it is a taxpayer responsibility instead of a postal responsibility makes sense, and it is probably fair, even though I hate to see even, you know, what is it a 2/10 of a percent increase in the Medicare cost? It is so big anyway, we are talking a lot of dollars. Postal reform that has been talked about in past Congresses included other things, things like cluster boxes, curbside mail instead of delivery to the door and, you know, no junk mail on Saturdays but maybe the higher revenue packages and the like. Why are we still talking about those? Ms. Brennan. Why are we still or not talking about ---- Mr. Farenthold. Or why are we not talking about those? Ms. Brennan. Yes. Mr. Farenthold. Why did they make sense a year ago ---- Ms. Brennan. Yes. Mr. Farenthold.--yet nobody is bringing them up today? Ms. Brennan. Again, Congressman, my approach in the past year was to try to build consensus around provisions, high value likely to generate broad support. Mr. Farenthold. So there is something about--you know, it would be difficult for--we will take my family, for example. If we don't have the money to do anything, it is hard to generate consensus about not taking a vacation, but we are not taking a vacation because we don't have the money. I mean, that is just an example. So at some point you are going to have to make, I think, some hard choices, and you are not going to walk away with everyone happy. And I think that is what we were elected to do here in Congress not just with the Postal Service but on a government-wide basis and say, okay, we can't afford that, so let's pick the stuff that is important and to pick the stuff that will work and make those hard decisions. Ms. Brennan. Congressman, we have made the hard decisions. You just noted one, the consolidations. The accelerated pace with which we ran was because of our dire financial situation. Mr. Farenthold. But you all have stopped the consolidations now and are looking at other things. A report says they are going to be no more consolidations this year. Is that ---- Ms. Brennan. Congressman, we deferred the consolidations until we stabilized the network because service is our mission, and service was not where it needed to be. It has since improved and we're showing positive trends in that regard. I would offer--your comment about mode conversation, cluster boxes, for all new delivery, based on the delivery characteristics of that environment, we either effect delivery through box-on-post or centralized delivery. And of the more than 900,000 new possible deliveries that we added last year, over 70 percent were centralized or box-on-post. So we're making the right business decisions. Mr. Farenthold. All right. I see I am out of time. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I will now recognize the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Lynch. Microphone? Thank you. Mr. Lynch. Is it working? Oh, I am sorry. Okay. There we go. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I also want to thank Mr. Cummings and Mr. Connolly and Mr. Meadows for all their work. We have done a lot of work on the side here to try to coordinate our efforts up here. And I am very pleased to see that the same thing is happening down there. I mean, we have a new postmaster general, along with the National Association of Letter Carrier, rural letter carriers, mail handlers, the clerks, supervisors, and then the PRC, as well as the mailing community and the GAO, inspectors general, everybody on the same page. And so it troubles me that we can't move this ball forward. I do want to focus on one key aspect of this, and that is the coordination of benefits between the FEHBP--I hate these acronyms--but the Federal Employee Health Benefit Plan and Medicare. So, Postmaster General Brennan, the situation we have right now, as has been noted by the chairman--and the chairman deserves a lot of credit because he has really been the one that has brought us all together with the ranking member and has us all working together, and it has been completely bipartisan and really--we do a lot of work up here, and this effort has been really bipartisan. But the way this works right now, the Postal Service is the second-largest contributor to Medicare, and the largest--and as the chairman and the ranking member noted, your people, the postal employees paid in $29 billion so far to Medicare. And the largest group is DOD, I believe, and they have a TRICARE wraparound with Medicare. And they are the largest. But when folks come out of the military and go on benefits, they are required to use Medicare as their primary insurer, so that is a good way to reduce their costs. And we don't do that at the Postal Service. We have about 25 percent of our employees that are relying solely on FEHBP and are not using, as they could, as they could because they have paid in--they are not using Medicare as their primary insurer. This in fact would--and I think President Rolando mentioned this in his testimony. It would basically eliminate-- out of that $50 billion in unfunded liability, it would just about eliminate all of it, is that right? Ms. Brennan. That's correct. Mr. Lynch. Okay. And I have been listening closely, you know, because you have different groups out there. The only criticism that I have heard so far is that postal employees who pay into Medicare might actually use it. That is the only criticism I have heard, that people who pay into Medicare will use it, and some people see that as a negative. But I think it is entirely fair and reasonable to expect that people who paid in $29 billion might actually use some of those benefits, so I really don't see that as a realistic criticism. The second opportunity in this--and you have done a great job with this proposal, and I think it ought to be adopted, and we ought to move this as quickly as possible in the form of legislation, more this forward. I really do think--and I realize we can't fix everything, but just because you can't fix everything doesn't mean you shouldn't fix something. And we can help. We can help up here. With a major piece of legislation here, we can help the post office immediately. We got other problems we will have to deal with, but that is for another day. The other thing I think that might be done quickly is, President Rolando, you mentioned the corpus of our health benefit trust fund. And right now, we are required, I believe, to hold that in treasuries, which for the past few years has been dismal in terms of what it returns, you know, to the fund. And I know part of the proposal suggests that maybe 50 percent of that fund might be managed by a commission. Could you talk about that a little bit? Mr. Rolando. Yes. What we were talking about doing is having, you know, a board that would govern this that could invest 50 percent, up to 75 percent in something like the thrift savings plan lifecycle funds. Mr. Lynch. Okay. Mr. Rolando. We looked at the period going back to 2007 where we were earning, I don't know, somewhere about 4 percent with Treasury securities. Had it been invested in a lifecycle fund--and again, keep in mind this would have been through the worst recession in 80 years--we would have earned somewhere about 7 percent, which would have raised the fund another $10 billion just as an example. Mr. Lynch. Okay. All right. I think we have to be careful with that, but I think that is a reasonable compromise. Okay. I think my time has expired, and I will yield back. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman, and I appreciate Mr. Lynch's work and passion on this issue and look forward to continuing to work with him on it. I now recognize the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Meadows, for 5 minutes. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank each of you. As we enter into this, I want to start out, Mr. Taub, by saying thank you for your work. It was good to visit with the PRC and all the dedicated employees that work there. Mr. Rolando, I want to just say I know I was not on your Christmas card list. I do appreciate the fact that you have been willing to work with me in an open-minded way. That was your commitment to me, my commitment to you, and I want to thank you. Ms. Brennan, thank you so much for being here. Obviously, as we look at this, this is an interesting time and so for all the postal workers, you know, I just want to say thank you. I have been a secret shopper because, you know, I am not shy about my criticism either. And so in Spruce Pine just the other day, I went into a place--actually, I sent my wife in because now I start to get recognized in some of these places. And the service that Debbie Calloway gave my wife was nothing less than spectacular. And she didn't know who she was, and we went in. And so I went back in to thank her for her service. And that is what we need to do in terms of service standards. As a fiscal conservative, one of the things that you are asking me to do is get rid of a prefunding requirement that was, you know, part of a previous deal, and so why should I do that? Make a very short, compelling case on why I should do that. Ms. Brennan. First, I would say, Congressman Meadows, it's the right thing to do to ensure that our pensions and the retiree health benefits is funded. It was the accelerated pace of that funding that created a large part of the challenge, but now we're beyond that come this fall. The issue now is it's a system that's unaffordable for us. And, again, going back to we've paid more than $29 billion into the fund. Our employees should benefit ---- Mr. Meadows. All right. So you are saying that you paid $29 billion, we ought to do that. So I am willing to take the leap. Now, we have heard all kinds of different testimony. That doesn't get us where we need to go, does it? Ms. Brennan. In and of itself, it's not enough ---- Mr. Meadows. Yes, it is about 2.8, $3 billion of a $5 billion deficit, so we need some other areas. We can't make it up in volume because part of what is concerning me is that it indicates that we are just going to raise rates, that this is a revenue problem. And at $69 billion, it is not just a revenue problem, it is a management problem, so how do we take this without raising rates as being the ultimate answer and really fundamentally reform it and make it work? Are you in support of safe and secure delivery, you know, through cluster box? Is that something that you would support wholeheartedly? Ms. Brennan. Depending on the characteristics of the delivery environment, yes. We currently do affect delivery to cluster boxes ---- Mr. Meadows. Would you support expanding that in a meaningful way, understanding that we may have to grandfather a lot, but we have been discussing is really looking at safe and secure delivery, which you may get some pushback from Mr. Rolando and some of those on that side, let's recognize that, but we have all got to come together to figure this out. Are you supportive of that? Yes or no? Ms. Brennan. Yes. And, sir, what I--if I may, the comment I made earlier about new delivery and based on the delivery characteristics, what we would not recommend is mandatory conversion of existing door delivery, of which we have over 37.5 million businesses and residents that get door delivery -- -- Mr. Meadows. Well, so let's say if we grandfather some of those in and we start to work--because I have been working with Mr. Lynch in an area that is different than mine. If we work through that, you are asking me to go ahead with the prefunding and jump off a cliff, I am asking you, are you willing to work with us to make sure that we implement safe and secure delivery in a meaningful way? Ms. Brennan. Yes. And if I may also comment, management has demonstrated a willingness to address operational efficiencies and to reduce costs, and we'll continue to do that ---- Mr. Meadows. Okay. So ---- Ms. Brennan.--in our ---- Mr. Meadows. Go ahead. Ms. Brennan. I apologize. Mr. Meadows. I ---- Ms. Brennan. If I may, Ms. Rectanus mentioned that we don't have any major cost reductions initiatives planned. We do. We have more than $5 billion in cost reductions embedded into our 5-year plan, and we continue to look at opportunity to drive operating efficiencies. That's our responsibility. Mr. Meadows. But most of the opportunities we have talked about actually have been with increasing service, you know, or trying to increase a portfolio, whether it is banking or anything else, and that just doesn't--I have only got a few seconds left, so here is my concern. We are talking about all of this, and we are missing out on service standards. It is the number one thing that I get calls about, you know, why is my meal not being delivered, why are we having a problem? And even me, you said, you know, that first-class mail that is your bread and butter, and this first-class mail actually is all postmarked in December. I got it in April. Now, that is not a funding problem. That is a management problem. And it is not just here. It is not just in my district because in Peachtree City we have the same thing where we mailed actually wedding invitations for my son that took 8 weeks to get to another Member of Congress. And so what we have to do is put this together and make sure that we have a service standard that doesn't just increase costs, and I am willing to work in a bipartisan way to do that, but we have to make sure that we do it in a way that serves the best interest of the public. And are you committed to do that? Ms. Brennan. I am committed. And if you would, if you'd give me those envelopes, I will look at that. Mr. Meadows. I don't want to get somebody fired but ---- Ms. Brennan. No. No, you won't ---- Mr. Meadows.--we just need to ---- Ms. Brennan.--because--Congressman ---- Mr. Meadows. But I will give them to you. Actually, I had about 40 different pieces of mail that came to me that had the same problem. I will yield back. Ms. Brennan. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman, Mr. Connolly. Mr. Chairman, I just want to note, now I know why my wedding invitation wasn't ---- Mr. Meadows. You are always invited there, Mr. Connolly. Chairman Chaffetz. I now recognize the gentlewoman from Illinois, Ms. Kelly, for 5 minutes. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to say every time we have a postal hearing I text my brother because he works for the post office, so I ask him did he have any questions that he wanted me to ask you. But one thing I wanted to say as far as the consolidations, I am glad that you thought enough, even though they might be necessary to slow it down because service does come first, and that is some of the things that he has spoken about because of all the closed stations, the long lines, and not enough clerks in the window. So I am glad that you are still putting service first and taking that into consideration because people will go other places if they don't feel like they are getting good service. And we definitely want the post office to thrive. Ms. Brennan, one of the elements of the joint postal reform proposal put forward by the Postal Service, the postal unions, and certain elements of the mailing industry is the use of postal-specific demographic assumptions when calculating pension liabilities. The proposal would also require any surplus resulting from those calculations to be used to pay down the Postal Service's debt to the U.S. Treasury. Intuitively, it makes sense to use the demographic and salary growth statistics of the postal workforce when calculating the Postal Service's pension liabilities. What is it about the demographics of the postal workforce compared to those of the government's entire workforce that you believe will result in lower cost? Ms. Brennan. Specifically, Congresswoman, the salary wage growth. And we estimate over a 5-year period that to be valued at roughly $3.2 billion. Ms. Kelly. Okay. Has the Postal Service calculated how much in savings would result from the use of postal-specific demographic assumptions? Ms. Brennan. Roughly $3.2 billion over a 5-year period. Ms. Kelly. Okay. Ms. Rectanus, GAO has done a significant amount of work on postal pension funding issues in recent years. In 2014, the GAO supported the use of the most accurate actuarial assumptions for postal pension liability calculations. Do you agree with Ms. Brennan that the Postal Service should use postal-specific demographics when calculating pension liabilities? Ms. Rectanus. Yes, we support it because if it is the most accurate data, then that should be used to get a better number of what the liability is. Ms. Kelly. And do you have any views on the amount of the potential savings that may be available if that is used? Do you agree or do you have different ---- Ms. Rectanus. We have not done the calculation so I can't-- and we haven't looked at the Postal Service's data so I can't comment on that. Ms. Kelly. Okay. Thank you. And I yield back my time. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Connelly. Would the gentlelady ---- Ms. Kelly. Yes, I will yield. Yes. Mr. Connelly.--yield? I thank my friend. And I want to thank you all for being here. And I have got to say, Postmaster General Brennan, you represent a breath of enormous fresh air. I mean, I want to say publicly how much I appreciate working with you. We have been able to forge a bipartisan coalition. Mr. Chairman, thank you for your leadership and bringing us together to do that. And I share the sentiments of my friend Mr. Lynch from Massachusetts and am very hopeful we are going to get postal reform, not everything but a big chunk of what we need to be addressing so thank you. Ms. Brennan, what does it mean for the Postal Service to lose the exigent rate, which expired, I think, in April, right? Ms. Brennan. Yes, Congressman Connelly. This year, we estimate that impact to be up to a billion dollars this fiscal year and roughly $2.1 billion going forward, worsening our financial situation. Mr. Connelly. And, Ms. Rectanus, in your testimony you state, ``The Postal Service's financial condition continues to deteriorate'' and you attribute that to ``declining mail volume and growing expenses at the same time,'' is that correct? Ms. Rectanus. Yes, that is. Mr. Connelly. And yet do you believe that some of the elements of the reform we have been talking about, freeing up the Postal Service to, you know, engage in some other lines of business that may be profitable like other postal services around the world do, so lifting some of those restrictions, lifting the burden of a unique prepayment requirement, as Mr. Rolando pointed out, unique to the Postal Service. No other Federal agency, no other private corporation in America is held to that standard in terms of that prepayment. And it is, you know, whatever it is, $5 billion plus, plus the Medicare reform I think we have been talking about, which I wish Mr. Farenthold were still here. That is not a taxpayer giveaway. Postal workers have paid $29 billion for a service they don't participate in, benefit from yet. Those things, could they turn around that financial description you have offered in your report? Ms. Rectanus. GAO has not taken a position on specific elements in that proposal. However, we have supported appropriate restructuring of the ---- Mr. Connelly. Well ---- Ms. Rectanus.--retiree health benefits ---- Mr. Connelly.--if I may because I am running out of time, I am not asking you for your position; I am asking you for your analysis. If those things were adopted, would your numbers and your prognosis change? Ms. Rectanus. Certainly they would benefit the Postal Service. What we would not want to see, however is not an equal focus on cost reduction and right-sizing and trying to get the house in order so that whatever revenue is generated is appropriate and people understand that solutions are trying to be gotten in both areas. Mr. Connelly. If the chairman will allow the postmaster general to comment on that as well, and then I will be done. I thank the chair. Ms. Brennan. Thank you, Congressman Connelly. And it relates to the questions from Congressman Meadows. We need the legislative reform, a favorable resolve of the rate-setting process, and management actions need to continue to drive operational efficiencies and grow profitable revenue. All the above would put us on firmer financial footing, have manageable debt, and have the ability to invest. Mr. Connelly. Thank you. And thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Connelly. Thank you, Ms. Kelly. Chairman Chaffetz. I will now recognize the gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Hice, for 5 minutes. Mr. Hice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Brennan, I think I heard this; I just want to clarify. How many employees at the Postal Service total? Ms. Brennan. We have about 498,000 career and 136,000 flexible or non-career employees. Mr. Hice. Okay. What was the 7.5 million referred to twice, Ms. Lowrance, you and Mr. Rolando both. Ms. Lowrance. That is the entire mailing industry, so it includes private sector, as well as the Postal Service. Mr. Hice. Okay. So more or less, what, 550,000, 600,000? I didn't tally that. Ms. Brennan. Yes, roughly 634,000. Mr. Hice. Six thirty-four, okay. And yet we all understand we have got a declining industry as a whole because of a variety of factors, digital and so forth. Does the Postal Service have too many employees? Ms. Brennan. We have a requirement, our universal service obligation, to deliver to all 155 million delivery points, 135 million of which are physical delivery points. The other 20 are post office boxes. So that requires an extensive network, and that network includes employees, facilities, vehicles and equipment ---- Mr. Hice. I understand that, but is it top-heavy? Do we have too many employees? Ms. Brennan. No. I would say that we consistently look at how to rebalance and where there are opportunities. And if you look at the reduction in overall complement, we've reduced more than 168,000 employees over the last decade. Mr. Hice. Okay. So we have 634,000 employees, we have a declining business, but you don't think we have too many employees still? Ms. Brennan. The challenge, sir, is the workload content associated with package delivery, as an example ---- Mr. Hice. No ---- Ms. Brennan.--is ---- Mr. Hice.--I understand that. Ms. Brennan. There's ---- Mr. Hice. But that problem is why we have a declining business. The result of a declining business--what would a private company do? If a private company is losing money month after month, year after year, quarter after quarter, what would they do? Ms. Brennan. What we did, sir, in terms of rationalizing the network, consolidating facilities, adjusting retail hours at post offices to match customer demand, some of the same management actions that I've been recently criticized for. Mr. Hice. But we are still losing money. And I will go on. You said a few moments ago that your goal is to fill mailboxes and trucks. Is that your strategy to turn this thing around? Ms. Brennan. Our strategy is far more complex than that, Congressman. Mr. Hice. I would hope so. Ms. Brennan. I was trying to simplify. Mr. Hice. Well, but that is what you said was your goal. Ms. Brennan. It's--you don't want to--you can't cost-cut your way to prosperity. There are opportunities for us, certainly, to drive efficiencies. There are opportunities for us to look at overall operating expense, and we do that every day, but we also need to look at opportunity to grow. There are opportunities to grow. Mail still works. We delivered 154 billion pieces of mail last year and 150 billion was mail, 4 billion packages ---- Mr. Hice. But you continue to lose money. That is the issue, and it seems rather unrealistic when you have a declining industry to think that somehow the goal of simply filling mailboxes and trucks is going to be successful in the long run. Ms. Rectanus, you mentioned earlier that the Postal Service has been on high risk since 2009. And you summarized the reason--two basic reasons: less mail and higher salaries. Do you see an opportunity without cutting, be it the workforce or whatever, for the Postal Service to turn this around? Ms. Rectanus. We have proposed that it's really got to be a balancing act between generating revenue and aligning costs. We do believe that there's more right-sizing that the Postal Service can do, and that's addressing where they have excess capacity but then putting that where they do need capacity, certainly exploring some of the workforce issues that they have, and they--Ms. Brennan is right. They've done a great job over the past several years to manage their workforce, but we're starting to see it creep up again in fiscal year 2015, and looking at the delivery mechanisms. Again--and you need to do that by also looking at the revenue, but you have to look at both of them. And, yes, part of it is what does the mail picture look like today and in the future and what type of services are going to be required, and how do we want to provide those services, which is what we would like to see through comprehensive postal reform. Mr. Hice. Okay. Well, let me springboard off of that and come back to you for my final question, Ms. Brennan. What is the Postal Service's long-term plan for addressing the declining industry? Ms. Brennan. Let me first, if I may, Congressman, address your comment earlier about the losses. The majority of the losses are tied to the prefunding mandate. In terms of our long-term plan, it is addressing infrastructure, how to leverage that, repurpose that to support the growth, address the latent capacity ---- Mr. Hice. Support what growth? Ms. Brennan. Package growth, sir. We've grown our packages 49 percent over the past 5 years. We will right-size the infrastructure, as we've been doing with where we need to consolidate with the decline in letter volume. We'll continue to look at every opportunity to improve operating efficiencies. We have a number, as I mentioned, of over $5 billion of cost reductions identified in our 5-year plan. Mr. Hice. Thank you. I think it is time for the Postal Service to act as private business has to act in similar situations of constantly losing money without relying upon the taxpayer. At some point we have got to change. Mr. Chairman, I thank you for your indulgence. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I will now recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. Lieu, for 5 minutes. Mr. Lieu. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Postmaster General Brennan, last October the U.S. Postal Inspection Service issued a release about mail theft. And it says that these crimes are increasing and that mail theft from collection boxes and customers' mailboxes is a big problem. It also said in most cases of mail theft from centralized mailbox units involved counterfeit master keys. So two questions for you. One is when you talk about right- sizing, are you reducing U.S. Postal Inspection Service members at all, and does that have an effect on mail theft? And second, as you move to more and more cluster boxes, doesn't that also increase mail theft because you just need one master key and then you have access to a whole lot of mailboxes? Ms. Brennan. To your first question, no, we are not reducing. In fact, we have two classes currently and in training to increase the postal inspection staffing. And in terms of the theft, particularly as you're aware in your district, Congressman, we've got a postal inspection task force that's working with local authorities and the community and taking some proactive measures to address that. I'd be more than happy to brief you in detail given the sensitivity of those corrective measures. Mr. Lieu. Thank you. I would appreciate that. Ms. Brennan. Certainly. Mr. Lieu. Second, in terms of trying to raise revenue, what is your view of postal banking as a way to generate revenue and also serve communities that may not be served as well by banks or may not have a trust of private banks but may trust the post office? Ms. Brennan. Fundamentally, we're open to any new product and service that would generate profitable revenue. That said, we do provide some banking services now. We provide money orders, electronic money transfers, and cash treasury checks. We would need to look at that through a business prism. Can we execute effectively? Can we grow profitable revenue? And is this a service that is not offered in the public sector? Mr. Lieu. Okay. We have had a number of difficulties with service in my district, so the first point I want to make is when we contact your office, they have been enormously responsive and they are able to help cases. About 97 percent of cases get resolved. The problem is we continue to get more and more cases, and now it looks like it is a systemic issue in western L.A. County. A councilmember in west L.A., his office had not gotten any mail for an entire week. We just checked again, and even when they get mail, it is sort of spotty, so this past Monday and Tuesday they are not getting any mail. We get complaints from Santa Monica and Redondo Beach. In the city of Beverly Hills it got so bad that the local newspaper did an entire series on it. So last August, for example, they printed a story saying, ``residents agree, Beverly Hills post office fails to deliver.'' Last September, ``post office acknowledges crisis and meeting at Congressman Lieu's office.'' Last December, ``Beverly Hills post office issues continue.'' And then this January from Beverly Hills Courier, ``Beverly Hills post office ends year with more customer woes.'' And with the indulgence of the chair, if I could submit these for the record. Chairman Chaffetz. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Lieu. Thank you. I would just like your commitment that you will work with our office to look into these issues. I am elevating it because you happen to be here, but also, we have tried with the local folks on numerous occasions. And what will solve individual cases, systemically, they just keep on coming in. I think there needs to be a systemic fix. Ms. Brennan. Congressman, absolutely. And if I may just address Beverly Hills, which I am familiar with specifically, we did make some adjustments in transportation and staffing to improve the performance out of that particular facility, and I'll be glad to talk to you and follow upon the other issues. Mr. Lieu. All right. Thank you. And then my last point, one of my colleagues said that the Postal Service should be run more like a business. You don't actually set the rates for your products, correct? Ms. Brennan. Products that generate roughly 76 percent of our revenue are capped at household inflation. Mr. Lieu. Right. And in fact, if you actually set your products at market rates, you would be getting a lot more revenue. Isn't that correct? Potentially? Ms. Brennan. We have an opportunity in 2017 with the review by the PRC of the rate-making process to look at the present price cap, is it meeting its objective as outlined in PAEA, which was to ensure that revenues cover our expenses and to ensure the financial stability of the Postal Service. We think there's opportunity there. We think a rigid price cap is fundamentally unsuited in an environment where you have declining workload and fixed or growing infrastructure costs. Mr. Lieu. My view is if people want the Postal Service to run like a business, they need to give it tools to make it run like a business. Otherwise, they should stop saying that. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I will now recognize the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Walker, for 5 minutes. Mr. Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, panel, for being here today. A lot of this to me is about the perception's trust in the post office as a whole. And just going back and looking at the numbers over the last few years, 2015, $5.1 billion lost; 2014, $5.5 billion; '13, $5 billion; 2012, $15.9 billion; 2011, $5.1 billion; 2010, $8.5 billion. At some point the people are saying what is going on here? So this is just a perception. This is the reality of a major trust issue. I have 5 minutes to speak. In those 5 minutes, the approximate amount that the post office will lose is $47,564. That is a huge issue. And I have heard today from some of the witnesses that we are working hard or some of the members, the colleagues, that they are working hard to try to do things better, but I have a couple specific questions in regards to this rate increase that we are beseeching Congress on. If you did receive this rate increase, can you tell me about where this extra money would be reinvested, General Brennan? Ms. Brennan. In terms of if we were granted ---- Mr. Walker. If you were granted a rate increase, where would that money go? Where would ---- Ms. Brennan. Well, one ---- Mr. Walker.--you invest it? Ms. Brennan. First of all, we would look to pay down debt if we were to--able to address these long-term liabilities. And the net losses that you cited, Congressman, are in large part due to the prefunding requirement. The past 3 years we have had controllable income, which is revenue less expense, that which was--is within our control. Mr. Walker. Would you agree with this statement that the Postal Service could run out of money between 6 months and a year at the most? Ms. Brennan. What we will do, our fiduciary responsibility would be to make decisions and prioritize which payments to make to ensure that we would be able to continue to deliver the mail and pay our employees and our suppliers. Mr. Walker. My concern with that statement is that wasn't a recent statement. That statement was from over 3 years ago, and we have seen continuing beseech of Congress as far as more and more funding, this isn't working out. I want to hone in today on something, though, specifically about packages versus the mail. And I want to make sure that I am clear on this, as we have done some research on this lately. The increases that you are requesting, would they be used to subsidize the package area of the post office business or would it be to increase the mail delivery? Can you expound on that a little bit today? Ms. Brennan. Yes. In terms of the cross subsidization issue, the PRC annually reviews to ensure that there is no cross subsidization, that our competitive products cover their cost, and also that they contribute a minimum of 5.5 percent to institutional costs. The PRC has found annually since the inception of PAEA that that is in fact happening. Mr. Walker. Well, you have stated that Postal Service has made consolidations to respond to the decline in the mail, but you have also stated that you are investing in package delivery. I believe you just said that just a few minutes earlier. And that as a result of those investments, package delivery was not slowed by the consolidations. But Title 39, section 101, subsection (e) states that ``in determining all policies for postal services, the Postal Service shall give the highest consideration to the requirement for the most expeditious collection, transportation, and delivery of important letter mail.'' Do you think that the Postal Service is following both the spirit and the letter of this law given your current actions? Ms. Brennan. I do believe we're following the spirit of that law. Mr. Walker. Well, if that is the case, then, the annual compliance report suggests that the post office, the Postal Service is routinely prioritizing competitive products over market-dominant products. Do you disagree with that? Ms. Brennan. I'd have to see that, sir, in terms of what you're actually referring to. Mr. Walker. Well, I believe it is your annual compliance report that once again ---- Ms. Brennan. That says ---- Mr. Walker.--suggests that the Postal Service is routinely prioritizing competitive products over market-dominant products. Can you expound on that? Ms. Brennan. No, I believe that may be the PRC's comment that it suggests--I'm not sure what you're referencing there. If I can talk about the annual compliance ---- Mr. Walker. Sure. Ms. Brennan.--report and annual compliance determination, we're very transparent about performance in terms of transit time performance, in terms of volume growth, and in terms of investments within the organization. Mr. Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the time. Thank you, General Brennan, and I will yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I now recognize the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Boyle, for 5 minutes. Mr. Boyle. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I was struck by the fact that--I don't know when this was; I know it was recent--that Pew Research did a poll of favorability ratings of different, various government agencies, and the post office came out the highest at 84 percent, which I can't remember where Congress was, but I think Postal Service was slightly higher than where Congress ended up, significantly lower than that. That is made all the more remarkable by the fact that you have had a decade where there are 200,000 fewer employees than there were just a decade ago. My question, though, is regarding the rather unique requirement the Postal Service lives under where essentially you have to prepay 75 years of obligations within a 10-year window. Can you talk about the effect that that has had on the balance sheet? And do you know of any other government agency or for that matter private sector company that has to live under such a unique requirement? I will leave that to anyone who wants to grab in. If you would like to go ahead. Ms. Brennan. I'll be happy to, Congressman. In terms of the prefunding requirement, my understanding is it's--would be unique to the Postal Service. There is some responsibility with the Department of Defense in terms of prefunding. My understanding is that their amortization payments are over a longer period of time, plus they are appropriated and integrated with Medicare. Mr. Boyle. If anyone else would like to add something? Mr. Taub. Yes, Congressman, this was enacted as part of the 2006 law in a bipartisan way with the best of intentions. Of course, the next year, our economy went into the deepest recession since the Great Depression, and with that the mail volume accelerated and caused these challenges. The postmaster general is correct. I would point out when the 2006 law was enacted, there was zero dollars prefunded for future retiree health benefits. Today, as we speak, there's more than $50 billion that has been prefunded. There's still an outstanding obligation of roughly half that amount, but we have gone from nothing prefunded to $50 billion today. Mr. Boyle. If you would like to add something. Mr. Rolando. Yes, I would. Thanks. Yes, this is unique to the Postal Service, but I'd like to point out that the proposals that the consensus group has put together, we would not only fully fund the retiree health fund, we would be overfunded if you took all the components that something else-- something that nobody else is able to do. Mr. Boyle. Thank you. I would just add that my great concern is, particularly as we have this conversation of going from 6-day to 5-day mail, that we continue to be in this negative cycle of cutbacks and closures that is really a self- fulfilling prophecy. That can be very destructive to communities and neighborhoods. I represent a largely suburban and urban residential district. When we went through even just a rumored closing of our post office in the 19116 zip code, that set off a firestorm. And maybe not for people my age but for those who are of an older age, having that local post office there is an important part of the community. So as we look at these decisions, and certainly dollars and cents plays a major role, I think we also have to put a value on what the local post office means to the community. And if that is the case in a neighborhood and in a suburban area, I think it is only more so the case in a rural area, which tends to be more remote. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. If the gentleman would yield for just a second? Mr. Boyle. Sure. Mr. Meadows. I want to make sure it is clear. We are not talking about 5-day delivery. I mean, I don't want that to be the headline that comes out of this hearing because your point is well-taken. So whether it is in a suburban area or a very rural area, I don't want the phone calls to start coming in. Mr. Boyle. Thank you, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. I agree with Mr. Lynch ---- Mr. Boyle. Yes. Okay. Thank you ---- Mr. Meadows.--and so I thank ---- Mr. Boyle. And if I could ---- Mr. Lynch. Would the gentleman ---- Mr. Boyle. Actually, if I could reclaim my time ---- Mr. Lynch. Sure. Mr. Boyle.--and then will yield briefly to Mr. Lynch, I would say that while that might not be the point of today, there have been numerous proposals about going to 5 days, and it has me very concerned and a number of our constituents for the reasons you described. I will yield now to Mr. Lynch. Mr. Lynch. Thank you. Yes. Very briefly, Mr. Chairman, and I thank the gentleman for yielding. I know there was some implications here that the postal workers were not doing their part or that, you know, costs are creeping up and things like that. I just want to read you something. In 2011, the American Postal Workers Union, which is the largest union, and the Postal Service reached a voluntary agreement that resulted in a sea change of significant and far- reaching concessions. The 2002-2015 agreement contained wage freezes for year 1, wage freeze for year 2, and that is within a 5-year contract, followed by a 1 percent raise, a 1.5 percent raise, and a 1 percent raise cost of living, and it was deferred to the third and fourth year. So extremely, extremely, extremely modest increase on the part of the employees, including 2 years of a wage freeze in a 5-year contract. So, you know, just people should bear that in mind. I yield back. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I thank the gentleman. I will now recognize the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Palmer. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And for the record I want to say that my wife and I love our postman. He does a great job. Ms. Lowrance, it was mentioned earlier about some of the things that are being done in the private sector. I would like to ask you what cost-cutting initiatives has industry had to implement in the wake of the evolving postal world as we know it? Ms. Lowrance. So we've seen a great consolidation in our industry. We have seen some of the larger print houses kind of eat up all the little ones to get rid of access capacity. We've seen plant closures and layoffs and those sorts of things in order to kind of compensate for the decline in mail volume that's seen across the industry. Mr. Palmer. If you had to guess, what cost-cutting efforts would the Postal Service have to take or be taking if it were a private company? Ms. Lowrance. Well, I think that the Postal Service has shown an ability to cut costs in the extreme conditions that they've been functioning under. I mean, I'm not really at liberty to say that layoffs should happen or anything should happen to the common employee of the Postal Service. I think that there are great lengths of additional price signals and cost efficiencies that they could gain through working with the industry. I think the industry has done more and more in the form of work share to take work hours out of, you know, the postal facilities and continue to rely on the industry to do things that they do very well. Mr. Palmer. I want to bring up a couple of things that have come to my attention that I think might be helpful. For instance, there is an economic analysis from a group called Keybridge you might be familiar with Ms. Brennan that says the Postal Service could save over $2 billion on the delivery vehicle procurement that you are planning, which is expected to cost over $6 billion. How do you respond to that? Ms. Brennan. Congressman, I'd have to read that report. In terms of the actual cost, we have some estimates about the cost, but a number of factors will determine the cost of the vehicle fleet replacement. Mr. Palmer. You are correct in that. There are a number of factors, and that is one of the reasons why your costs are so high because you are buying vehicles that you plan to keep in place for a number of years and your fuel costs, your maintenance costs are exorbitant compared to what other private companies would be doing. And I highly recommend that you take a look at that Keybridge analysis. And if you have trouble finding it, I think if you will let the committee know, we can find that for you, get that for you. There is also an issue, Ms. Brennan, that in November the inspector general put out their semiannual report and found that there was $1.8 billion in funds that could be put to better use and $455 million in questionable costs from April to September of 2015 alone. I would like to know how you responded to the IG's report. Ms. Brennan. Well, Congressman, that's a compilation of literally probably hundreds of audits and/or studies, so I would need to look at them in separation or in isolation to address that. Currently, the OIG does valuable work for us and identifies opportunity. Oftentimes, it is work that we are currently undertaking and working through, so I would certainly acknowledge that there is opportunity for process improvement and additional efficiencies that will help drive down costs. Mr. Palmer. Well, considering the environment that you are in right now and, you know, these two combined would be somewhere in the range of $2.3 billion and that you could save another $2 billion in your vehicle procurement, you know, it gets you a little over $4 billion, I think that ought to be a couple of things at the top of your list for consideration. And then I am not for layoffs either, but I also am concerned about the public perception of the post office and, again, for the record, we think the world of our postmen. But there was a survey done by Accenture, evaluated 24 government- operated postal organizations and two private companies that together deliver 75 percent of the world's mail and found that the post office ranked last as the lowest-performing postal agency or commercial operator in the world. And my concern is it is not just with the cost-cutting but the public perception of what the post office does and yet you add the poor performance, and I think because of the labor contract you are under, the inability to remove poor-performing workers and then these losses, the post office has got to really address these issues to improve its image and to make it a viable industry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I will now recognize the gentlewoman from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence, for 5 minutes. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you. It is an honor to be here today, and thank you, Chairman and the ranking member, for calling this hearing. I wanted to be clear for the record that I had a 30-year career with the Postal Service starting as a letter carrier, so I have a lot of respect for Mr. Rolando. I also want to say no other organization in America is compelled to prefund future retirement benefits at the level that is done by the Postal Service. It is clear that pushing a public agenda which operates with no taxpayer funds--so there was some allusion earlier that we are using taxpayer dollars. The revenue that we generate from the sale of our products is what we fund and operate our business with. And so often it seems to get confusing in debate when we start talking about the Postal Service as if we are using taxpayer dollars. So it operates with no taxpayer funds to the brink of financial crisis by forcing it to assume the financial burden assumed by no other agency or company is the height of the financial irresponsibility of Congress, and Congress should fix this problem that we created. Today, as we are having this debate about the future of the Postal Service--and yes, there are some issues that we need to work with. And, Ms. Brennan, I have been very clear with you in private conversations, and, you know, trusting you to continue to keep delivery standards as one of the primary objectives, and as I look here with our postal customers and mailers who depend on us. But one of the things I wanted to talk about is the downsizing commitment that has been made by the Postal Service, reducing your workforce by 200,000 careers since 2006, reducing your work hours by 331 million, changing operation hours. Can you, Ms. Brennan--and I would like Mr. Rolando to weigh in on this as well, and my mailers if you have time--how has this consolidation and reduction of workforce aligned with the phase 1 and phase 2 of the Network Rationalization plan or initiative? Ms. Brennan. Yes, if I may start, Congresswoman, we completed phase 1. Phase 2 we completed 17 of the projected 82 consolidations. So we have additional consolidations that we'll revisit. We'll redo the economic analysis, given that that is now 5 years old, and would make the appropriate notifications before we resume those consolidations. Mrs. Lawrence. Mr. Rolando, how is it affecting the day-to- day ---- Mr. Rolando. Well, first, I'd just like to say keep in mind a lot of this is in reaction to the prefunding itself. I keep hearing over and over, what would you do if you were a private company, and if we were a private company, we wouldn't have $50 billion of resources tied up in a fund for 75 years into the future. It would certainly affect the standards, it would affect service, it would affect rates, it would affect vehicles, it would affect infrastructure, it would affect all kinds of things. So I think the takeaway from all of this is we're not allowed in that way to act like a private company. We do have to prefund. There's no appetite in Congress for us not to prefund, so that's why we've put together this coalition to find a way to satisfy that mandate. We've come up with a way to do it. And moving on from then, then we can act as a private company or as a Postal Service in a rational and efficient manner moving forward. Mrs. Lawrence. And I just want to add, it is about being competitive. We are in a very competitive market, the Postal Service, and if you truly want this company to be efficient and competitive, then we as Congress must recognize how we are tying the hands of the Postal Service. And so I say to my colleagues very passionately that we absolutely want to the Postal Service, which is covered--you know, when I was employed, I had to take an oath that I would protect the mail and make sure that it is protected from foreign agencies and how important and special it was to be an agent of the Postal Service. But then we tie their hands and then we criticize them. And one of the things that I want to talk about is the future of these packages. We know that drones in other industries are coming, but we consistently tie our hands and we see the other industries moving forward to embrace the ability to be competitive, to reduce costs, but we in the Postal Service--we, I am saying we because I am a retiree--those in the Postal Service continuously fight against these restrictions, so we as Congress must step up and take ownership of what we have created. And we have amazing opportunity now to remove some of those barriers as we hold the Postal Service accountable for filling their role of delivery. And I am over, so thank you. Mr. Meadows. [Presiding] I thank the gentlewoman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Clay, for 5 minutes. Mr. Clay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And let me start with Ms. Rectanus. Do you know of any other government agency or private sector company that has to fully prefund the health care costs of its retirees? Ms. Rectanus. The issue you're asking about is whether anybody's quite like the Postal Service, and the issue is they are a unique organization that were designed to be a Federal entity, an independent agency within the Federal Government. And so they are designed to be self-sustaining. So that's why they are in a different situation than other organizations. Mr. Clay. But the 2006 Postal Accountability Act imposed that requirement on the Postal Service, correct? Ms. Rectanus. That's correct. Mr. Clay. How much money has the Postal Service been required to pay in, and has it been able to make all of these payments? Ms. Rectanus. To date, the Postal Service has paid about $18 billion on top of the original money that was put in originally. They have missed $28 billion in payments as far as the retiree health benefits program ---- Mr. Clay. And so $28 billion is the value of the unfunded liability? Ms. Rectanus. No, sir. That's the amount of money the Postal Service has not put in. The amount of money that is unfunded is about $54 billion. Mr. Clay. I see. Ms. Brennan, I understand that 86 percent of the losses that the Postal Service accumulated between the years '07 and '11 are attributable to this prefunding requirement. Is that right? Ms. Brennan. That's correct, Congressman Clay. Mr. Clay. Do you believe that the prefunding mandate is unfair to the Postal Service, and do you agree with Mr. Rolando? Ms. Brennan. I agree with Mr.--President Rolando's comments. I would say that it's responsible to prefund. The challenge for us in the recent past was the accelerated payment schedule. Going forward, though, the challenge for us is to ensure Medicare integration. Mr. Clay. Is modifying this prefunding requirement an essential part of the joint reform proposal to which the Postal Service, postal unions, and certain mailers have agreed? Ms. Brennan. Yes, Congressman. Given that the prefunding requirement ends this fall, the challenge now is to address the larger issue of an unaffordable system for the Postal Service and our retirees. Mr. Clay. And how much money do you think this would save the Postal Service? Ms. Brennan. Fully integrating with Medicare for all of our retirees 65 and older would save us over $17.5 billion over the next 5 years. Mr. Clay. I see. Is it true that the Postal Service's retiree health care fund is already 50 percent funded? Ms. Brennan. That's correct, Congressman. We're better situated than most. Mr. Clay. And do you know what the current balance in that fund is? Ms. Brennan. The current assets are over $50 billion in the RHB fund. Mr. Clay. Wow. The prefunding requirement may have made sense back in '06, but it no longer makes sense to have the Postal Service comply with a requirement that would force it into insolvency. And just one question for Mr. Rolando. Give me your overall sense of how the morale is among Postal Service workers today. Mr. Rolando. The overall morale, we deal really in four different avenues if you will with the Postal Service depending on the level of engagement of each of the probably employees, organizations. We deal in a collective bargaining arena whereby obviously we're addressing things that are going to affect morale in terms of pay and benefits and working conditions. We work together in an arena of growing the business and making sure that service is what it needs to be so that we can face our customers every day. Obviously, that can be rewarding and frustrating at the same time. We deal together in a legislative arena, as we're doing today, to make sure that the Postal Service is here to serve the American people for many years to come. And then we deal in another arena that I will call the culture of the Postal Service. And I think that's an important thing that's been embedded for a long time in the way it exists that we certainly have the commitment from leadership in the Postal Service and the unions to address that. And all those things contribute to the morale of postal workers all over the country in different ways. Mr. Clay. Thank you for that response. May I yield of the rest of my time to the gentleman from Massachusetts? Mr. Lynch. Just quickly, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. I just want to push back a little bit on a suggestion that was made earlier by one of my brothers across the aisle about the comparative value or the comparative performance of the United states postal system versus some of the international competition. There is a great report out by Oxford University. It is Oxford Strategic Consulting, and they measured the efficiency of the postal services in the top 20 countries, in the G-20, and the United States Postal Service came out the best, and remarkably, it is the only system in that top group that does not receive taxpayer funding. So ours is doing better than all the rest, contrary to the statement made earlier. And remarkably, the United States Postal Service scores the highest for efficiency even as it delivers far more letters per employee, 268,894 in the last study period, than any other service in the G-20. Japan came in second, and it is less than one-third of that. And also we have universal service, which a lot of these other countries don't have, so we deliver to every single location. And the only criticisms that the British study had was that, unlike in Siberia where their post offices actually sell groceries, ours do not. But we have grocery stores that do that. But I just want to push on--we came out the best in the study. It was a very credible study, and ---- Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the ---- Mr. Lynch.--it was reported by CNN. I would like to enter this as part of the record. Chairman Chaffetz. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Lynch. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. His time is expired. I will now recognize the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman, for 5 minutes. Mr. Grothman. Thank you much. Chairman Taub, one of the objectives of the current system and any new system that comes out of the rate review is to make sure we have high-quality service standards. And right now, there is some indication that we are struggling in that regard. If the Postal Service continues to have problems in that area, what action do you think the Commission will take? Mr. Taub. Congressman, the Commission by law has what's called the annual compliance determination where annually we look to ensure that rates and fees that were in effect in the last year were in compliance, as well as service standards were met. We just issued our most recent one just about a month-and- a-half ago, and we did find that service standards indeed weren't met. All the first-class mail did not meet their targets, both parts of periodicals mail, most of standard mail. We directed the Postal Service to come back in 120 days with a comprehensive plan particularly on the--what's called flats, the periodicals and the standard and the first-class flats, a 90-day report on first-class letters and cards. So once we get that back, we'll assess next steps. But it was a very directed study, did bring attention, which has been a trend that unfortunately hasn't been trending in the right direction. So that's why this year we took, shall we say, a little bit more of an aggressive stance to ask the Postal Service to come in with a more comprehensive focus as to what are the pain points, what are the pinch points, how do we get past this because service, as the postmaster general said, is the basic standard that has to be met. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I have a question for Ms. Brennan here. You know, we talked a lot about how the volume of mail has dropped over the last 10 years from 213 billion to 154 billion. And we use 2006 as the base year. But do you know what it was like 10 years before or 20 years before that? Ms. Brennan. Off the top of my head, I don't, Congressman. I'll get that information for you. Mr. Grothman. Was it going up? I mean, the point I am trying to make is it ---- Ms. Brennan. It was growing, sir, yes. Mr. Grothman. So it might have been 154 billion in 1986 or 1990? Two thousand and six was the high point in terms of total volume in the system. Mr. Grothman. So what I am getting at here is I wonder if you are creating kind of an artificial cause for a problem by grabbing the higher at 213 and say we are at 154 so of course we are going to have a crisis? Maybe we were at 154 in 1980 and you weren't having a problem. You know what I am saying? Ms. Brennan. I understand your point. I ---- Mr. Grothman. But you don't know the answer? Ms. Brennan. I would tell you that it's not artificial, the challenges that we face. Mr. Grothman. Okay. One of the biggest capital investments you have--and we had a hearing on this before--is replacing the aging vehicles. What is the current status of that situation? Ms. Brennan. Congressman, we're currently in the technical review phase for the prototype vehicles. The plan is that we will determine one or more suppliers with multiple vehicle types that will test over roughly an 18-month period different topographies, different climates, and that will help inform our decisions as we move to the production timeline. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Last time you guys were in here on this topic you said you were going to buy 120,000 vehicles. Is that still the plan? Ms. Brennan. That would be the upper bound in terms of replacement, and clearly, given our financial situation and certainly the suppliers' capability, we would be looking to purchase and deploy roughly 20 to 25,000 year. Mr. Grothman. Okay. So you are going to try to spread it out maybe ---- Ms. Brennan. Correct, multiple years ---- Mr. Grothman.--over 6 years ---- Ms. Brennan.--Congressman, yes. Mr. Grothman.--5 or 6 years. Okay. Next question. What is the pay if I go to work for the post office, start out either deliveryman, one of the guys and/or gals in the office? What is the starting pay for that? Ms. Brennan. I would tell you the average work hour rate that I have off the top of my head is $41. Mr. Grothman. Pardon? Ms. Brennan. Average work hour rate, fully loaded, $41. If it was a non-career employee, roughly $15 an hour. Mr. Grothman. Okay. So if I get a job--and I know you have got to work part-time in the first place. If I get a job as--I don't know that you start out as a mailman or not, but what do I expect starting as far as my pay? Ms. Brennan. It would depend on the craft. If you were a letter carrier, roughly $15 an hour for a supplemental non- career employee. Mr. Grothman. How about a career employee? Ms. Brennan. It would depend again on if you were new, roughly probably 20, $25 an hour. I'll get you the exact, Congressman. Mr. Grothman. Twenty-five dollars an hour, plus--do those people get overtime? Do you have overtime? Ms. Brennan. Yes, absolutely. More than 8 hours in a day or 40 hours in a week, consistent with the FLSA rules. Mr. Grothman. Okay. And is that common? Ms. Brennan. Overtime can be in certain locales. It's seasonal. It depends on employee availability, mail volume, and the like. Mr. Grothman. What's your average mailman make right now? Ms. Brennan. Average salary? Mr. Grothman. Yes. Ms. Brennan. Again, let me--I'll provide that for the record. Mr. Grothman. Okay. My time is up. I will yield the remainder of my time. Chairman Chaffetz. Wow, thank you, impressive. Let that be a lesson to all of us that are still sitting here. We will give 6 minutes to the gentlewoman from New Mexico, Ms. Lujan Grisham. Ms. Lujan Grisham. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I really appreciate that. I am going to change up what I was going to do a little bit because I really appreciate the comments that my colleague Mr. Lynch made, although I don't need that report. If you want to see the efficiencies of the post office, go visit and do a ride-along with a letter carrier, and you will have no doubt that it is one of the most efficient systems in the world. And so thank you very much for that honor. And I plan to do more of that, particularly in the area that another one of my colleagues as already mentioned, Mrs. Lawrence. But in this effort, because of budgetary issues, that we were consolidating, and, Ms. Brennan, I heard that that is on hold. But given the fact that that has really hurt rural and frontier areas, disabled and senior population who are traveling distances to get prescription drugs, I am very happy to hear that that is on hold. But in addition to that and the numbers that have already been talked about, 200,000 employees, more than 360 facilities consolidated, there is now a 2011--so it is a little bit dated--but that GAO report says that, look, when you reduce the level of your services, you are actually hurting your revenue stream. So it is counterproductive. And as you look at these issues, I would love it if you would give us further information in writing to this committee about your efforts in modernizing services and addressing these issues given your, I think, unfair mandates, that there is a healthy balance and we want to make sure in fact that we are building a revenue stream and at the same time continue to take appropriate actions to protect the populations who need the Postal Service in a way that I think is different than the average person receiving mail. So if you would do that, I would appreciate it. Ms. Brennan. Yes. Ms. Lujan Grisham. And thanks for that update. The second thing that I want to talk about that is, I think, a bit may be different than what my colleagues have addressed, but in my community, unfortunately, in my district, in my State we are seeing a high number of vandalism and mail theft. I want to thank you for your work, particularly in Albuquerque, but I am concerned that with lack of personnel we have a backlog in those investigations. You don't get those investigations, we don't deal with the perpetrators. If we don't deal with the perpetrators, soon we have this--we are on a merry-go-round in this situation as well so that it continues to occur at much higher rates than around the country. And I will tell you that given, you know, our poverty issues and our other public health issues, which I will address later today in terms of substance abuse, it is a significant problem. And so it also creates safety issues for folks who are not dealing with this appropriately. Because of those backlogs and investigatory issues, we are not replacing those damaged mailboxes. And I would love for you to give me a sense about what you can do differently or if you have had any thoughts or what do you need from Congress to make sure that you can address these what I am going to call hotspots if you will so that we can do something about it. Ms. Brennan. Yes, thank you, Congresswoman. In terms of in Albuquerque and the effort we have again with the Postal Inspection Service partnering with local law enforcement and community members, we've got an antitheft prevention type campaign. I'll be happy to come up and brief you in more detail because it is important to us. And as we deploy centralized boxes, we need to ensure that they are secure and that we can minimize any potential theft there. But I'll be happy to come up and give you more specifics. Given the sensitivity ---- Ms. Lujan Grisham. And I would like you to really--and I am happy to do that, but I really want you to think about and talk about if I have got more time--although I am happy to give it back to the chairman because he is so good to me, and I meant that genuinely--that I think it is important to think about it in a policy mechanism because the truth is--and again, in my community, I love my community and I love my State and I love my district, but we have real challenges. You know, I have got a police force that is under consent decree that also has one of the lowest staffing in the country and is in real trouble in terms of recruitment and staffing. So leveraging there is not leveraging. And the reality is is that we are not keeping up and we have a real public safety issue, and we have got a confidence issue. And it needs to be addressed, so what else can we be doing? And you ought to take into account all those kinds of circumstances. So the reality is, because those boxes are still damaged and we still have a problem, people don't have access to their mail. Ms. Brennan. We need to correct that, whether it's holding mail at the post office or looking at other ways to affect delivery. We don't want disruption in service. Ms. Lujan Grisham. And it is recognizable when you see all these damaged boxes in my community. It is a huge problem. Mr. Chairman, I yield back the rest of my time. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I thank the gentlewoman and I appreciate it. I have some comments and questions, and then Mr. Lynch, and then we will wrap up. Mr. Taub, give me your perspective on the PRC. We are looking at a reform package. How would you reform or adjust what the PRC does or doesn't do? What reforms are you looking for? Mr. Taub. Mr. Chairman, I think the most important thing, of course, is the financial balance sheet. That's the house that's on fire that has to be dealt with. In terms of the Postal Regulatory Commission, attached to my testimony is a study that mandated by law at least every 5 years the Commission looks at the entire Postal Accountability Act of 2006, as well as the whole law, and offers recommendations for changes to the President and Congress. We did that in 2011. We're in the midst of doing that report right now. The 2011 report did suggest a variety of possible opportunities where the Commission ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Pardon me, but when do you anticipate that will be complete? Mr. Taub. We should have that complete by the end of the year. My hope is that this would be delivered to Congress ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Can you have it by the end of May? Mr. Taub. I wish we could. We just issued a few weeks ago a call for public input and comment on that, a baker's dozen of issues. We asked the public to input by June 14. So when the public gives us the input, then we have to put that together. So we will strive to ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Any preliminary suggestions? Ms. Brennan. Yes ---- Chairman Chaffetz. As the chairman of this committee, let me give you an outline of where we are headed with this. We do anticipate introducing a discussion draft of a bill soon. I anticipate that that will be available for perhaps 2 weeks unless there is some major hiccup, and then the intention is to introduce a bill, mark it up. We are actively trying to address the prefunding issue. We are obviously, as we have heard from across the whole spectrum of the board, trying to deal with the Medicare portion of that. It is amazing that, you know, $29 billion has been paid in since 1983, and that has to be adjusted. If there are structural adjustments or suggestions or ideas that any of you have, we need to have those now. We have been meeting and hearing and listening and now we are having a formal hearing, but we need those as soon as possible. From the GAO's perspective, I want to go to the Board of Governors. And it is a little unfair to put any of you on the spot but the GAO, you know, we can put you on the spot. How many Board of Governors are there? Ms. Rectanus. At this point there is--well, there's one Board of ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Out of? Ms. Rectanus. Nine. Chairman Chaffetz. That is the right answer. There is one out of nine. Quite frankly, I can't figure out what in the world the Board of Governors does. It is almost never fully staffed. One of the things that we are looking at doing is fusing the Board of Governors and the PRC into one entity. If somebody has a problem or a challenge with that or has a different suggestion than that, let us know, but to have two separate groups, one of which is never fully staffed and literally has one person, they don't have a quorum, they can't operate. And yet nobody seems to mind. I don't get any complaints. So that is one thing that I am looking at that I am just saying to the world if you have a suggestion on that, let us -- -- Mr. Taub. Mr. Chairman? Chairman Chaffetz. Yes? Mr. Taub. Just to make a personal observation from having been involved in this for so long, the current structure of the statute sets the Commission up as a regulator, not the operator, the Postal Service. Nineteen seventy when the old Post Office Department was abolished, the current governors and board was created to exercise the power of the Postal Service and represent the public interest generally. I would simply observe that, to the extent they are together, making sure thinking through these issues of regulator versus operator, but beyond that observation ---- Chairman Chaffetz. I still see a role of Congress, I still see the role of the postmaster, and I still see the role of the PRC, but this extra layer does not make a lot of sense to me. Postmaster General, do you have a comment? Ms. Brennan. If I may ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Yes. Ms. Brennan.--Mr. Chairman, I appreciate your offer for insight on this, and we'll be happy to share it. I think Chairman Taub outlined it well in terms of the differentiation of responsibility. My only caution is that it would be problematic for the regulator to become the operator, so that would just be the caution. But we're happy to provide some additional insight. Chairman Chaffetz. And you want to triangulate the issue, but at the same time, it is problematic when there is not a functional group, and there hasn't been for a while, and there doesn't seem to be any desire to get one. And so I am just looking at structurally changing that. But duly noted. You don't want your regulator to also be your operator, and there does need to be an arm's length distance. But there is also a role of Congress, and we have to serve in some of those functions as well. Mr. Rolando, kind of walk us through--I don't know what time frame--but the unions have--I mean, the enrollment is way down because in large part the reductions in staff. If somebody is watching this for the first time, give them a perspective of how the unions have stepped up and have helped to address this problem. And there have been quite a number of staff reductions along the way. Mr. Rolando. Well, Mr. Chairman, as far as reductions, yes, there's been a loss of 200,000 jobs in the last 10 years. I think for the majority of the collective bargaining agreements now, no new employees come in as career employees. They come in as non-career employees ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Right. Mr. Rolando.--without any benefits, much lower pay, and have to wait for a career position to become available for them to be eligible for that. As far as--and then the collective bargaining itself, it's a process that's worked well for a long time in terms of negotiating agreements, whether by settlement or through interest arbitration. And as I mentioned before, there's other arenas that we deal with with the Postal Service, for example, in the legislative arena. That's an extremely, I think, important thing that we do, along with the mailing industry, to be able to get a consensus together to move something through Congress that's going to preserve the Postal Service in the future. So we have--and again, I talked briefly before about being involved in the growth of the business and service and the networks and the value working together to do that, you know, to the point of bringing in business to the Postal Service. And again, the fourth arena is just the whole culture of the Postal Service. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Ms. Lowrance, let's talk about what you would like to see first and foremost out of Congress. And we have your testimony and you have answered some questions, but give me the best synopsis you have on what you need people in Congress to do. Ms. Lowrance. We need predictable and reliable mail service, so if you're going to say it's going to take 3 days, take 3 days to get there, right? We have planning purposes from business mailer perspectives that we do to interact with the Postal Service and have the most efficient manner possible. We need predictable, stable Postal Service prices, right? If we see rate shock or extreme conditions to raise revenues in order to cover the existing cost, mail will leave faster and faster and faster and they'll find other means to communicate. And then lastly, transparent costs. And I know both pricing and costing can be done currently at the regulator, and we're looking at the 10-year review to see if that--if the current pricing mechanism is the right fit under the conditions. So, I mean, if Congress were to do anything, I would say releasing some of the liabilities on the balance sheet is really what would help mailers going into the rate review, as well as help the Postal Service alleviate some of the pressures on the cap and be able to really concentrate on service since that seems to be a large message that came across today. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you, and I appreciate it. The Postal Service, as I said at the beginning, serves a vital element of our commerce here in the United States. They have a monopoly, and they have high fixed costs. When you have high fixed costs, you don't reduce services and raise rates and expect to solve your problems. What you need to do is move volume. You have got to make the post office more relevant in people's lives so that there is more volume that can move through the system. So again, raising rates and cutting services is not the way we are going to necessarily get there. Now, I can tell you personally I have migrated a long way the more I have studied this where initially my inclination was the outlet is, you know, 5-day service, that sounds good, let's increase the number of postal holidays, that sounds good, but the more you dive into it, the more you realize that is not the way the economy is moving. What is happening is there is more e-commerce out there and people want to have their packages and goods delivered right to them right now. And so you see the Amazons of the world and others that consumers are starting to expect Saturday and even Sunday delivery, and the post office is in a unique position but they are not monopoly to produce that. Personally, I feel very strongly that the post office should not be participating in business that is also found on Main Street. Selling coffee and T-shirts, with all due respect, other services that you can find it down the street, I don't think that is necessarily the role of somebody who has a tax advantage, has a monopoly, and I have very deep concerns about that. The one thing that I haven't heard in the last couple hours of this hearing that I continue to harp on and it is incumbent upon us but also I think the post office itself is the government-to-government business. When I think of where do I go to get my passport, I think of the post office. That type of business arrangement needs to expand. It does at the State level and it should at the Federal level. It drives me crazy to no end that we go out and spend all this money FEMA to try to remap the United States and have all these drug distribution facilities. We already have got post offices and letter carriers and others that already know their community. They could walk the streets without the street signs. They don't need their own special map. We have already done that with the Postal Service, and yet we spend hundreds of millions of dollars, if not billions of dollars, doing that. We have disaster with FEMA and others that happen, but we have to be prepared for that, but it is your post office and your postmaster that probably understands the area and the community better than anybody. I visited Montezuma Creek, Utah, a small place down on a Navajo Indian Reservation, a dilapidated building, but that local postmaster had been there for more than 20 years. She knows her community. She knows all the people. She knows people who speak English, who don't speak English. She knows who rides in on a horse to come get their mail. She knows the community. That is the type of effort that the rest of the Federal Government should be engaged in. Also, I want to continue to look--and this committee has jurisdiction on the census. We are going to go out and spend billions of dollars on the census to try to recreate what the post office already has in place. And I can tell the postmaster is itching to speak here, so please. Ms. Brennan. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman, I did just want to--a proof point to your comments, too, if I may. One was working recently with a Midwestern city to provide information on vacant buildings through our address management system. Another you mentioned, the census, we did a pilot I mentioned earlier in the hearing out in Arizona on-boarding census workers, but we think there's an opportunity for us with the actual conducting of the census given in-person proofing at the facility or on the doorstep with the technology we now have. Chairman Chaffetz. Your local letter carrier is going to far more understand that there aren't 15 people living in this house. I have been walking the street going to their door for the last 7 years and there aren't 15 people in this building. That type of thing and insight, they are going to spend the billions of dollars. Let's spend it smartly. And I hope this committee will further look at this. I have gone way over my time here, but I am excited to move this forward and again appreciate the work that Mr. Meadows, Mr. Lynch, Mr. Connelly, and certainly Mr. Cummings. And as we wrap up, I think, Mr. Lynch, did you have--let me yield to Mr. Lynch and ---- Mr. Lynch. Very briefly. And I think there is a wonderful opportunity there with the Postal Service and the census. We are walking those streets already, so there is a way to, I think, maximize the skills and the expertise that the Postal Service has. I do want to push back a little bit again. You know, I cited the Oxford report that said the United States Postal Service was the best in the world, and one of my colleagues indicated his belief that--I haven't seen the study--but that we were the worst in the world. I think that the best judge of this is actually the customer, is the American citizens. And, you know, the Pew Research Center polled Americans about their government. And I think Mr. Boyle brought this up, but the people of the United States in that poll said that the most trusted government employees in the United States today is the United States postal worker. And that is a tribute to you, Postmaster General, and also to the unions and the people who do that work every single day. So, you know, I just want to say that they rank you, I think, 84, 84 percent. You are the highest of any government employees. Congress was also in that study, and we were around 6 percent between swine flu and the Taliban. That is where Congress came in. So ---- Chairman Chaffetz. Well, this committee competes with the Zika, so we are way down there. Mr. Lynch. Amen to that. But, you know, it is indeed ironic that we have a member of a body that has 6 percent approval criticizing the employees who have 84 percent approval rating in the eyes of our constituents. So I will yield back. I will leave it at that. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I recognize Mr. Cummings. Mr. Cummings. I want to thank you all for your testimony. I just think that we have got to get this done. I mean, we can go around this circle forever and ever and be in the same place 10 years from now. Again, I want to thank all of you all for coming to the table. But I am interested in what the chairman said about government-to-government. Do you see that, I mean, growing or going, Postmaster General? Ms. Brennan. Sir, I do see opportunity there. I think another example that ---- Mr. Cummings. And how will we get there? I mean, how would you ---- Ms. Brennan. We may need some support from you and the chairman on that, but I think some of the outreach effort we have had with some of the other agencies is a starting point, leveraging our infrastructure. I think another example is the TSA pre-verification for frequent fliers. There is an opportunity, I think, for us to handle some of that work as well. Mr. Taub. Mr. Chairman, if I may, Mr. Ranking Member Cummings, I just--I think one of the key pieces if the Postal Service is going to go down this road is also the funding associated with that, and that goes to that larger issue of what is it that we want this government institution to do. And I know with a house on fire financially we need to put that out and the legislative process doesn't always lend itself to the ability to get to first principles. But if there is some way, whether in this round or the next, to think about what it is that this government institution must do and what are the costs associated with that and where does the revenue come in. My only concern would be the extent they take on more responsibility in this area, there's costs there, and if the associated funding doesn't go to it, then we're adding more of a burden to the Postal Service. Ms. Brennan. Yes, hence my comment, Robert, about needing need some assistance from the chair and the ranking member. Mr. Taub. I was just trying to get a little more ---- Ms. Brennan. Thank you. Mr. Cummings. Certainly, we would not want you to go into something that is going to not yield a sufficient profit. That doesn't make any sense. And we certainly don't want to burden you with more obligations when the yield is simply to cost more. That is ridiculous. But I am hoping that we will be able to resolve some of these things and, as I said, resolve them soon. Again, thank you very much. Chairman Chaffetz. The final point I would make on the government-to-government is that, yes, these other agencies are funded with resources to execute on these things, and if they are going to spend money on them, they should be spending them and looking at the option of doing it to the Postal Service. I think the unions would appreciate that. They have got the physical infrastructure unlike any other entity. They would be able to do that whether, again, passports, census. You are going to get a request from us to look at the financials of how the whole passport business has worked, but I look within my own district, the Department of Motor Vehicles, you know, there are other State opportunities, not just the Federal Government opportunities, where they need a physical location that is safe and secure and that people know where it is. So we have had a good, healthy hearing. We appreciate your participation. I hope the men and women of the Postal Service know that we care about them and that we are trying to do the best thing, but I agree with Mr. Cummings. It is time to do it sooner rather than later. With that, the committee stands adjourned. Thank you. Ms. Brennan. Thank you. [Whereupon, at 12:28 p.m., the committee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]