Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- OVERSIGHT OF THE FDIC APPLICATION PROCESS [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] OVERSIGHT OF THE FDIC APPLICATION PROCESS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ JULY 13, 2016 __________ Serial No. 114-139 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 25-511 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director Andrew Dockham, General Counsel Sean Hayes, Health Care, Benefits and Administrative Rules Subcommittee Staff Director Corey Cooke, Counsel Sharon Casey, Deputy Chief Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on July 13, 2016.................................... 1 WITNESSES The Hon. Martin J. Gruenberg, Chairman, U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Oral Statement............................................... 4 Written Statement............................................ 7 Mr. Matthew Browning, Former Board Member, National Association of Industrial Bankers, Testifying on Behalf of the National Association Oral Statement............................................... 29 Written Statement............................................ 31 Dr. Simon Johnson, Professor of Global Economics and Management, MIT Sloan School of Management Oral Statement............................................... 47 Written Statement............................................ 49 Mr. Guy Williams, President and Chief Executive Officer, Gulf Coast Bank and Trust Company, Testifying on Behalf of the American Bankers Association Oral Statement............................................... 54 Written Statement............................................ 56 APPENDIX 2016-08-02 Gruenberg-FDIC- Hearing Follow-up Responses.......... 116 OVERSIGHT OF THE FDIC APPLICATION PROCESS ---------- Wednesday, July 13, 2016 House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The committee met, pursuant to call, at 10:01 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Jason Chaffetz [chairman of the committee] presiding. Present: Representatives Chaffetz, Mica, Duncan, Jordan, Walberg, Amash, DesJarlais, Farenthold, Massie, Meadows, Mulvaney, Buck, Walker, Blum, Hice, Carter, Grothman, Hurd, Palmer, Cummings, Maloney, Clay, Lynch, Kelly, Lawrence, Watson Coleman, Plaskett, DeSaulnier, Welch, and Lujan Grisham. Chairman Chaffetz. The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform will come to order. And without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. I appreciate you being here. This is an important topic, the role of banking, and what it plays in the American economy cannot be understated. The FDIC, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, was created by Congress to help maintain stability in the financial sector. Several things are currently happening with the FDIC that raise some concerns. Importantly, since 2013, the FDIC has not had a Senate-confirmed inspector general. I do think that this needs to be put in place sooner than later. That is far, far too long. In May, the FDIC reported it suffered five--five--major data breaches since October of 2015, all involving taxpayer personal identifying information. In the banking sector, this is particularly of concern, to have it happen five times that we know about. But today's hearing will highlight an area truly undermining our country's financial future. Our local financial institutions continue to drown in a sea of red tape. There has to be regulation, don't get me wrong. There need to be rules of the road. But they need to be fairly administered and they need to be predictable so that new entrants can also come into the marketplace. Since passage of Dodd-Frank and the implementation of additional policies by the FDIC, we haven't seen our financial sector getting stronger. What we have seen is a drastic decrease in the formation of new banks and an increase in bank mergers and acquisitions. I think, my own personal opinion is the systemic risk is greater, not less. As of March 2016, the United States had 6,122 banks. This is the lowest number of banks since the Federal regulators began keeping track in 1934. The lowest number. It's a huge drop from 25 years ago when the United States had over 14,000. Some will claim that that was too many. They didn't have the financial strength and the proper deposits in order to cover their potential losses. But this decrease in banks does matter. Competition fosters innovation, consumer-responsive products, and provides more options for individuals who need access to credits. We've had a growing population in the United States of America, and yet, less institutions in proportion to that population than in the past. The FDIC is responsible for issuing deposit insurance to new industrial loan companies, or ILCs, or de novo banks outside of the Federal Reserve System. Proof of deposit insurance is a standard requirement for new community banks to receive their State banking charter. Put in simpler terms, just like the State requires motorists to have car insurance to register a car, you can't run a bank without proof of deposit insurance. But unlike car insurance companies who will compete for your business, the FDIC doesn't appear to want consumers to have any new banks. The decline in applications for new banks is unsettling. Between 2011 and 2015, the FDIC processed an average of three applications per year--per year. This is a drastic decrease from an average of 219 applications per year between 2004 and 2008. Using the same car analogy, if States suddenly had no one registering their cars because citizens were unable to obtain car insurance, we would all wonder what was going on with those insurance companies. Since 2011, the FDIC has only approved three--three, since 2011--de novo bank applications, and no, not one, ILC application. Not one of them has been approved. This stands in stark contrast to even 2008 when the FDIC approved 48 de novo banks. Further, the banks the FDIC has approved seem only to meet very small niche markets rather than broad community needs. For example, one of the three approved banks--this is a good thing, don't get me wrong, this is a good thing--was located in the heart of the Pennsylvania Amish country, meant to serve only that market instead of creating opportunities for competition in more diverse areas. Today's hearing is an attempt to understand why this radical decline in new bank formation. I would like to understand if the FDIC is truly open to receiving and accepting applications or if red tape is resulting in interested parties just throwing up their hands and walking away. I'm sure we can all agree that we want secure and stable banks. Don't get me wrong, we have to have the safety and security of stable banks. But we must be sure that the regulator who's charged with allowing new banks to enter the market is not circumventing the process. This results in weakening the financial sector and limiting options to households in underserved markets across the United States of America. We thank the witnesses for being here today. Already, the information that was provided in the written testimonies are insightful and very helpful, but we do have some serious questions and look forward to the hearing. I would like to now recognize the ranking member, the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Cummings, for his opening statement. Mr. Cummings. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Neighborhood banks are the lifeblood of local communities. They can be a key source of capital for small businesses. They can help working families save for the future. No one knows this better than my constituents in west Baltimore, where banks are outnumbered by alternative financial services that sometimes offer the most basic products on abusive and extremely predatory terms. The lack of basic banking services is one of the key challenges for families trying to climb out of poverty in this Nation. A discussion about what more can be done to ensure that all communities are adequately served by community banks is, indeed, long overdue. Some suggest that communities lack banks because the FDIC is inappropriately blocking the approval of new community banks. But this claim does not appear to be supported by the facts. The Federal Reserve has reported that a key factor explaining a lack of new bank applications is our current low interest financial environment. A bank's income, particularly a new bank without an established lending portfolio, is closely tied to the Federal funds rate, which has been close to zero since the Great Recession. That is why the FDIC received only 10 applications for deposit insurance between 2011 and 2015 compared with more than 1,000 applications between 2004 and 2008, when the financial crisis began. Our Nation relies on the FDIC to protect the Deposit Insurance Fund, which repays depositors if an insured bank fails. The FDIC approves only those applications that meet strict standards and that are built around realistic business plans that are likely to ensure profitability. That's because if the fund fails, taxpayers will be on the hook to pay for the bank's mistakes. Many other regulators failed in their duties prior to the Great Recession, but the FDIC's stewardship of the fund before the financial crisis meant that the FDIC did not have to draw on taxpayer funds to repay the customers of failed banks. These protective measures are not preventing community banks from succeeding. In fact, the net income earned by community banks in the first quarter of 2016 grew by 7 percent over their income in the first quarter of 2015, according to the FDIC's most recent quarterly banking profile. By comparison, the net income of noncommunity banks actually fell by nearly 3 percent in the first quarter of 2016 compared to the first quarter of 2015. Yet, the FDIC has reported that over the past 12 months, and I quote, ``Almost 62 percent of community banks improved their net income,'' end of quote. As a result, the percentage of unprofitable community banks fell to its lowest level since 1998. As our Nation has seen firsthand, without rigorous standards banks could take outsized risks, assuming that the insurance fund would clean up their losses. Sadly, I am concerned that today's hearing is only the latest in a series of efforts by my Republican colleagues to roll back essential safeguards and put the financial system back at risk. In 2014, the Republican Congress repealed a portion of the Dodd-Frank Act relating to swaps pushouts, allowing large banks to gamble with FDIC-insured funds. Last year, Republicans introduced legislation to repeal the Volcker rule, which stops banks that are too big to fail from trading for their own profit. And then this year, the Republican chairman of the Financial Services Committee has proposed a bill to prohibit the FDIC from ensuring that large banks do not cause another financial crisis if they fail. Rather, in trying to put the taxpayer back on the hook for risky practices, Congress should be trying to understand why, given that the community banks appear to be thriving, critical and basic banking services are not being provided in some communities, like the one I live in. I look forward to the testimony, and I thank our witnesses for being here today. With that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I want to thank the gentleman. We'll hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. We'll now recognize our panel of witnesses. We are pleased to welcome the Honorable Martin J. Gruenberg, chairman of the United States Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Mr. Matthew Browning, former board member of the National Association of Industrial Bankers. Mr. Browning is testifying on behalf of the National Association of Industrial Bankers and the Utah Bankers Association. Dr. Simon Johnson is professor of global economics and management at the MIT Sloan School of Management. And Mr. Guy Williams is the president and chief executive officer of the Gulf Coast Bank and Trust Company. Mr. Williams will be testifying on behalf of the American Bankers Association. We welcome you all. We thank you for being here. Pursuant to committee rules, all members are to be sworn before they testify. So if you'll please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. We would appreciate it if you limit your oral comments to 5 minutes. We'll give you a little latitude, but try to keep it to 5 minutes. Your entire written statement will be entered into the record. Chairman, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF MARTIN J. GRUENBERG Mr. Gruenberg. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on de novo banks and industrial loan companies. The FDIC encourages the formation of new financial institutions and welcomes applications for deposit insurance. New institutions help preserve the vitality of the community banking sector, fill important gaps in local banking markets, and provide credit services to communities that may be overlooked by other financial institutions. While we have seen a broad-based improvement in bank financial performance over the past several years, the prolonged period of low interest rates that has followed the financial crisis has narrowed industry net interest margins substantially from precrisis levels. Margin pressure remains a challenge for existing institutions and new entrants and appears to be the leading factor in the sharp decline in new institutions since the crisis. As the economy continues to improve and interest rates rise, we anticipate that interest in new charters will increase. Over the past several quarters, the FDIC has seen indications of increased interest from prospective organizing groups. By statute, any proposed depository institution seeking Federal deposit insurance must file an application with the FDIC. Before filing an application, the FDIC encourages organizing groups to participate in a prefiling meeting. The goal is to inform applicants about the information needed to facilitate the review process. The FDIC imposes certain standard conditions on all institutions that are granted Federal deposit insurance. These conditions include minimum initial capital, State charter approval, disclosure of insider transactions, financial audit requirements, among others. The FDIC may also impose nonstandard conditions when additional controls are appropriate or necessary to either mitigate risks that are unique to the proposal or to ensure actions or activities in process at the time of approval are completed before the insurance becomes effective. In August of 2009, the FDIC extended from 3 to 7 years the period during which de novo State nonmember banks were subject to higher capital maintenance requirements and more frequent examinations. We also require de novo State nonmember banks to obtain prior approval for material changes in business plans. The FDIC made these changes because the failure rate of de novo institutions chartered between 2000 and 2008 was more than double the failure rate for established small banks. Many of these failures occurred between the fourth and seventh year of the de novo period. Given the ongoing improvement in post-crisis industry performance, the FDIC recently rescinded this policy, returning to a 3-year de novo period in April of this year. As State-chartered federally insured institutions, ILCs must meet the same standards as any FDIC-insured bank. Since parent companies of ILCs are not generally subject to Federal banking supervision, the FDIC has included prudential considerations in its supervisory approach designed to ensure the independence of the ILC separate and apart from its parent. The FDIC has recently announced a number of initiatives to support the efforts of organizing groups to establish new banks. In November of 2014 and again in April of this year, the FDIC issued deposit insurance questions and answers to eight applications in developing proposals to obtain deposit insurance. In March of last year, the FDIC provided an overview of the deposit insurance application process during a conference of State banks supervisory agencies. In September of last year, the FDIC also hosted an interagency training conference promoting coordination among State and Federal regulatory agencies in the review of charter and deposit insurance applications. The FDIC is also preparing a practical guide for organizing groups. This resource will address topics such as developing a sound business plan, raising financial resources, and recruiting competent leadership. We are also planning outreach meetings in several regions around the country to ensure that industry participants are well informed about the FDIC's application review processes and the tools and resources available to assist organizing groups. Finally, the FDIC is using this period of low application activity as an opportunity to review our current application processes for transparency and timeliness. As this review continues, we will look for opportunities to solicit public comment from the industry and groups interested in organizing a de novo bank about the steps that the FDIC could take to enhance or clarify the application process. Mr. Chairman, that concludes my opening statement. I'll be glad to respond to questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Gruenberg follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Browning, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF MATTHEW BROWNING Mr. Browning. Good morning, Chairman Chaffetz and Ranking Member Cummings. My name is Matt Browning, and I'm here on behalf of the National Association of Industrial Bankers and the Utah Bankers Association. Why are we here today? We are here today because the FDIC is not following its direction from Congress and is preventing the chartering of new banks. Congress set forth the approval process for new banks in the Federal Deposit Insurance Act. However, the FDIC has unilaterally adopted a no-growth policy of not allowing new bank charters and uses vague nondenial denials as a backdoor means to pursue this policy. In order to avoid the mandates of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act, the FDIC simply avoids calling an application complete and, instead, asks endless open-ended questions and makes vague suggestions of needed changes in a prospective bank's plan. I would like to share my own experiences with the committee that leads me to conclude the FDIC is blocking the formation of new banks. In 2012, I led the effort on an application for a new bank's charter and Federal deposit insurance. We modeled our bank on the needs of our clients. It was very similar to the banks owned by our competitors. We were following a proven conservative model with a long history of exceptionally low risk. Our introductory discussions with local FDIC and State regulatory officials went well. We were then surprised when FDIC's Washington, D.C., staff suggested that serving our client needs and demands for banking services was, in fact, not a sufficient reason to charter a bank. The staff began making vague demands for modifications that would make our bank markedly different and force us outside our areas of expertise. FDIC officials never mentioned any deficiency in our plan relating to safety and soundness, no deficiency in our compliance, no deficiency in our capital. Our board, management, loan programs, and control systems were never criticized. By all objective measures, our plan met the requirements for approval under the long-articulated statutory requirements. We were ready to make reasonable changes. But the FDIC imposed novel, unwritten, and unacknowledged standards on us, and these continued to evolve as we progressed. After 18 months of ongoing discussions, after repeated plan revisions, after spending more than $800,000 in direct expenses and many thousands of hours, we concluded we were engaged in an exercise in futility. We abandoned the process without filing an application. Sadly, I understand these outlays are modest compared to those of many other applicants who have received similar treatment. Our plan could not proceed because it was impossible to truly understand the new arbitrary requirements of the FDIC. We experienced denial by attrition. We unwittingly played rope-a- dope with the FDIC, wasting a great deal of time and money in the process. Earlier this year, Chairman Gruenberg stated, quote, ``The FDIC welcomes applications for deposit insurance, and we clearly have a role to play in facilitating the establishment of new institutions,'' end quote. Sadly, the common perception among particular applicants is the FDIC's claim is mere posturing. The FDIC's many years of conduct directly contradict its public statements. The actions speak loudly and continue to affirm the widely held industry impression that agency staff in Washington is adversarial, uncooperative, evasive, and at times belligerent. This was certainly my experience, as it has been for many others. Potential applicants will not commit the substantial time and money needed for an application until the FDIC has really seen to change its unilateral no-growth policy. The FDIC should rightly have broad discretion on approving new banks; however, it does not have the discretion to arbitrarily shut down the formation of new banks altogether or to covertly use attrition to deny bank applications. Policymaking should not be done in the dark. Regulators should not create policy without a clear understanding of the effect on the economy and should ensure alignment with Congress. The FDIC must not only tolerate but truly accommodate innovation within the banking sector. This accommodation must extend not only to new products and services in existing banks, but accommodation must also be made for new banks and new bank models designed to serve the evolving needs of American consumers and businesses. Thank you, and I'm happy to answer your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Browning follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Johnson, you are now recognized. STATEMENT OF SIMON JOHNSON Mr. Johnson. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I would like to make three points. The first is to strongly agree with what Mr. Cummings said at the beginning with regards to effective overall interest rates in the U.S. economy on new entries. And I'm afraid--and I think this is absolutely the key fact for this hearing, and I hope we can establish those facts--I'm afraid there is an issue--perhaps it's an issue of omission--in Mr. Browning's testimony. He had some slides prepared by people at the University of Utah, and they seemed to have read a Richmond Fed research paper on this issue of interest rate spreads. The Richmond Fed paper itself references and is based on a Federal Reserve Board of Governors paper. I have that paper with me, and I have the figure to which they seem to be referring. They say interest rate spreads have remained relatively stable for banks. That statement applies to established banks, Mr. Chairman, not to de novo banks, the point made by Mr. Cummings, because they have a different loan portfolio, they don't inherit loans that already have interest rates at a certain level. So the evidence is clearly, from the Fed's research, which is being referenced by Mr. Browning, the evidence is clearly that the net interest spread for de novo banks is much lower than it has ever been in recorded U.S. history. That's a major disincentive to create community banks. The second point I would like to make, Mr. Chairman, builds on what you said at the beginning, which I think is also fundamental to this hearing, which is the FDIC is an insurance company--a strange insurance company, an insurance company chartered by the Federal Government, backed ultimately by the taxpayer. But as you know, Mr. Chairman, if the FDIC faces losses or the deposit fund faces losses, those are covered by premiums paid by other banks. Now, we can, I think, reasonably look at the FDIC's performance as an insurance company over the past couple of cycles. And what we see, including in the most recent experience, is that the FDIC's deposit fund almost ran out of money. Now, if you think that the FDIC is being overly cautious over the business cycle, the credit cycle, you'd expect that fund to always be positive, maybe even highly positive. That was not the experience. If the FDIC was being reckless, and we're asking the FDIC to take bigger risks today--well, you're asking any insurance company to take bigger risks, they're going to have bigger losses over the cycle, you're going to have bigger negatives in that insurance fund--those premiums are not, Mr. Chairman, that deficit is not ultimately going to be paid by the taxpayer. We're the backstop. We're the line of credit through the Treasury. It's the people sitting behind me representing the banking industry who are going to pay a high premium. So the question, I think, comes down to--and I hope we can get to this--do established bankers want to pay a higher premium to run their existing business? Because that's basically what the ask is today, if you're asking the FDIC to take more risk. Now, as Chairman Gruenberg said, the FDIC has attempted to move its rules recently, and they have relaxed or reduce the de novo supervision and intensive scrutiny period from 7 years back to 3 years. I think that's a responsible move, and I'm supportive of that. I really do not see a case for asking the FDIC to take greater risks with their deposit fund unless the bankers are all adamant that they want to pay higher insurance fees, because the taxpayer certainly does not want to be on the hook here and will not be on the hook. The third and final point I would like to make is with regard to what are and are not the big issues here. I think Mr. Cummings put his finger exactly on one of the big issues, which is the lack of affordable, responsibly provided financial services to low-income communities. There's a huge gap in the United States, and many of the alternative financial services that currently exist are, frankly, predatory. If you look at all the different ways that credit is provided to those communities, it's not acceptable. There's big issues there of consumer protection, and I hope we can discuss those to some degree. But if we're talking about entry and what affects entry and what distorts competition in this market, Mr. Chairman, I think we have to talk about the big banks. We have to talk about the unresolved questions around too big to fail. The very largest banks in this country have an unfair, distortive, implicit subsidy from the taxpayer, because they are not allowed to fail and the creditors would ultimately be protected. The FDIC is involved in trying to improve that situation, and there is a living wills requirement, as you know, for all these big banks. But, frankly, 6 years after that requirement was created, we have not made enough progress with those living wills. So, you know, if we want to talk about entry, we should be talking about fintech, we should be talking about new ways that finance is provided in the United States. There's a lot of risk capital going into finance. Yes, it is relatively hard to get insured deposits, but that's because the FDIC has responsibility not to impose bigger effective taxes on the rest of the banking industry. Where are we on too big to fail, and how can we possibly create a level playing field for community banks before and until we really make sure that no bank and bank holding company in the United States is too big to fail? Thank you very much. [Prepared statement of Mr. Johnson follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Williams, you're now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF GUY WILLIAMS Mr. Williams. Thank you, Chairman Chaffetz and Ranking Member Cummings. My name is Guy Williams. I'm president and CEO of Gulf Coast Bank and Trust Company in New Orleans, Louisiana. My bank was chartered in 1990, at the beginning of a recession, with $1.5 million in capital. Over the last 25 years, we've grown into a $1.4 billion community bank serving southeast Louisiana. We are the largest small business lender in our State, specializing in helping to establish and grow new businesses, and we are also one of the area's largest mortgage lenders. ABA appreciates the opportunity to testify on the dearth of new bank charters. New entrants into any industry are a sign of economic vitality. New banks provide more choices of competitive products and services for business and consumers, which translates into greater economic activity and growth in local communities. The lack of de novo banks is strong evidence that the economics of new community banks don't work. Investors have options. If the impediments to starting a new bank are too great, they will invest elsewhere. Sadly, the forces that have acted to stop new bank charters are the same ones that have led to a dramatic consolidation in the banking industry: excessive and complex regulations that are not tailored to the risk of specific institutions. This, not economic conditions, is often the tipping point that drives small banks to merge with banks typically many times larger and is a barrier to entry for new banks. There are only seven de novos in the last 5 years. More troubling is that there are 1,500 fewer community banks than 5 years ago, a trend that will continue until changes are made that will provide relief tor America's banks. In April, the FDIC announced some welcome but small supervisory changes to help prospective de novos through the process. Unfortunately, they do not address the underlying barriers to entry: capital hurdles, unreasonable regulatory expectations on directors, funding constraints, and inflexible regulatory infrastructure, and tax-favored competition from credit unions and Farm Credit System. If it does not make economic sense, no one will start a new bank. Look no further than the lack of new charters for proof that something is seriously wrong. When you fix the underlying problem, new charters will result. Gulf Coast Bank started with $1.5 million of investor capital, 4.4 million in today's dollars, and proceeded to create an institution that's helped our community thrive for more than 25 years. The current requirement is that it would take $20 to $30 million to start a bank. That's many multiples beyond what successful banks needed in the past. It's doubtful that a new bank today could earn enough to cover the cost of that capital. There are many banks like mine that pooled local investment dollars to start a bank and built it into a strong community partner. I doubt seriously that my bank would be granted a charter today due to the capital requirements, the constraint on assets, the restrictions on funding. Couple these factors with a suffocating regulatory blanket, and I doubt that our investors would have made the investment. To ensure the broadest possible range of financial options to our communities, we must think creatively to find solutions that simulate new bank entrants. The changes that FDIC has made are a good beginning, but much more can and needs to be done. It's time to think differently--to encourage new banks by requiring less capital, reducing regulatory burden, permitting greater flexibility in business plans, and lifting funding restrictions. Each and every bank in this country has a direct impact on job creation, economic growth, and prosperity. Our slow recovery from the recession is partly a result of the shrinking pool of community banks. We urge Congress to act now and pass legislation to help turn the tide of community bank consolidation, create an economic environment that encourages new bank charters, and protect communities from losing a key partner supporting economic growth. Thank you. I'll be happy to answer questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Williams follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Thank you, all. We'll now recognize myself for 5 minutes. Chairman Gruenberg, on page 1 of your testimony, you say that FDIC institutions are posting record profits, and yet, on page 6 you say that the profitability ratios are below pre- crisis levels, making it unattractive to start a new bank. Which one is it? Mr. Gruenberg. It's actually both. The industry, as a whole, as we've documented over the past several years, has been gradually but steadily recovering from the financial crisis. So on most of the major metrics of performance--net income, credit quality, and loan balances--the industry has been getting better. But it's something of a tribute to the industry that they have been able to do that in an economic environment of very low, historically low interest rates, and low net interest margins. So that the margins they are able to generate on their loans are narrow, but they have actually been able to compensate for it. And this is particularly true of community banks by expanding lending activity. Chairman Chaffetz. I just think it's inconsistent for you to suggest that there is not--that the profitability ratios are so low that it's unattractive to file an application at the same time you say that there are record profits. People do want to get into this business and service the need and the demand that's in the economy. Ninety-four percent of all bank applications since 2009 have not been approved--94 percent. Do you really believe that all those bank applications don't meet the needs of the communities? I mean, are we really supposed to believe that 94 percent of the applications were insufficient? Mr. Gruenberg. If I may say, Mr. Chairman, 2009 was the second year of the financial crisis, probably the most severe financial crisis at least since the Great Depression. In 2009, we had---- Chairman Chaffetz. I know, but to date. Mr. Gruenberg. No, but I'm just--I'm saying---- Chairman Chaffetz. How many have you approved to date since 2009? Mr. Gruenberg. What I can say is, between 2000 and 2007 we---- Chairman Chaffetz. That's not what I'm asking you. Mr. Gruenberg. No, but my point is, Mr. Chairman, if I may just respond, we've had a post-crisis environment really since 2009 which is in some measure unprecedented. We had the most-- severest financial crisis---- Chairman Chaffetz. You're not answering my question here. Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I'm trying to explain that we've had the longest prolonged period of near-zero interest rates in our country's history. Chairman Chaffetz. At the same time you're posting record profits. Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah. Chairman Chaffetz. And you're not approving any applications. That's the problem. Mr. Gruenberg. We're not--if I may explain--we're not receiving applications. And the reason for that is---- Chairman Chaffetz. Ninety-four percent of the ones you did were not approved. You only approved three. Mr. Gruenberg. Well, you have to--we've had a small number of applications, as you know, and we have an environment in which it's difficult for an institution to demonstrate a viable business plan. We've had established institutions coping with the challenging environment by generating larger volumes of loans to generate revenue. Chairman Chaffetz. You're not answering my question. Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I'm trying to. Chairman Chaffetz. I know, but you're not. That's what I'm explaining to you. You may be trying, but you're not answering the fundamental question. Mr. Gruenberg. For new institutions to get over the hurdle they not only have to be able to generate revenue, but they also have to get over the fixed cost of establishing the institution. And in a near-zero interest rate environment, that becomes particularly challenging. Chairman Chaffetz. But they're posting record profits. So you can't have it both ways. And my fundamental challenge is that you've only approved three, and that's highly suspicious in a--I think there's more systemic risk, because the cruel irony of all this is there are fewer institutions that have more leverage, more of the play. And so you have very large institutions out there that are trying to get into this business. You have applications that are pending for a long period of time. One application has been pending since 2008. Another application is showing pending since 2009. I mean, how long does it take to go through these applications? You and I have talked about this in my office, and I still don't understand--that's why we're having the hearing--I still don't understand why it takes so long. Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I think for the--without speaking to a specific application, I think--as you know, the ones that are pending relate to investor loan companies. There was a more than 3-year moratorium period and an additional moratorium period, I think, during---- Chairman Chaffetz. Is that still in place? Mr. Gruenberg. No, it expired in 2013. Chairman Chaffetz. And have you approved any since then? Mr. Gruenberg. And I believe the applications you are referring to have not really been pursued by the applicants since that time. Chairman Chaffetz. But they're still pending? Mr. Gruenberg. They're still pending. Chairman Chaffetz. What are they supposed to do? I mean, they're pending. Do they have to come and say, ``Will you please continue to do your work?'' I mean, these institutions, they've spent seven figures putting these things together. Why aren't you--if they're still pending, why aren't you taking action on them? Mr. Gruenberg. The applications, as they currently stand, Mr. Chairman, I don't think would meet the standards, and the institutions have not pursued them. Chairman Chaffetz. They have pursued them. They're pending before your body. Mr. Gruenberg. But they're no longer actively engaging with us on the application, I believe, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. So they submit the application, they've done everything they're supposed to do, and it's still pending, and they need to show activity? You state that you're going to put out some guidance, right? When is that going to happen? Mr. Gruenberg. I think we're going to do it, I think, before--over the course of this year. Chairman Chaffetz. No, no, no. Give me--come on. Give me a date. Mr. Gruenberg. Assuming before the end---- Chairman Chaffetz. How long have you been working on it? Mr. Gruenberg. As I indicated---- Chairman Chaffetz. When did you start the process of coming up with the guidance? Mr. Gruenberg. We've already issued guidance, as I mentioned, in 2014 and 2016---- Chairman Chaffetz. No, no, no. You're not answering the question. I'm sorry I'm going over time here. But this is a very simple question. You put it in your opening statement, okay? Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah. Chairman Chaffetz. When will you actually complete this exercise? When did you start it and when are you going to publish it? Mr. Gruenberg. I believe we began it earlier this year, and I believe we'll publish it before the end of the year, Mr. Chairman. And if you like, I'll come back to you with a specific timeframe for doing that. Chairman Chaffetz. That would be great. I've gone past my time. Let me now recognize the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Cummings. Mr. Cummings. Let's start. Let me make this clear. Mr. Browning, what do you think--why do you think people are holding up your application? Let me get down to the nitty- gritty. Because apparently, I mean---- Chairman Chaffetz. I don't think he necessarily said that. Mr. Cummings. Well, he's here testifying. He's upset. Are you not? Mr. Browning. I am. Mr. Cummings. What do you think is the motive? Why would they deny your application? I mean, do you think they just don't like you? I'm serious. I mean, what is it? And I'm not trying to be smart. I'm just trying to figure out--I'm trying to get to the bottom of this. Mr. Browning. No, I don't think it's personal. Mr. Cummings. Then what do you think it is? Do you think it's competition, they're trying to protect competition? Mr. Browning. I believe the FDIC has yet to come out of crisis mode. I believe it's acting much more as an insurance company and less as a regulator governing safe and sound institutions. I think it is some lingering shell shock from the crisis and it is loath to accommodate new banks, which, historically, new banks are a bit riskier. But in terms of true risk to the Deposit Insurance Fund, it's de minimis. In terms of risk to the system, it's de minimis. And, in my example, we came forward with $30 million in capital. Our business plan showed profitability at the end of year 1. And we were effectively stonewalled for an extended period of time. Mr. Cummings. So you think they're being too careful, basically? Is that what you are saying? Mr. Browning. Yes, sir. Mr. Cummings. All right. Now, Mr. Chairman, how did the insurance fund fare during the financial crisis? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, as you---- Mr. Cummings. I can't hear you. Mr. Gruenberg. As you know, Congressman, over 500 institutions failed since 2008. The Deposit Insurance Fund was actually depleted during the course of the crisis and as a result of the failures. At the low point, the Deposit Insurance Fund was actually $20 billion in the red, and we were placed in the position of having, first, to impose a special assessment on the industry to bring in liquidity to manage all of the bank failures and then had to impose a prepaid assessment on the industry to bring in further liquidity to manage the failures and support the fund. Since the crisis, we've been able to rebuild the fund and-- -- Mr. Cummings. Okay. I've got. I only have limited time here. I just wanted to get that. You told me what happened. The number of new bank charters is significantly lower in the years since the financial crisis than in the years before the crisis. Professor Johnson, what do you believe accounts for the decline in the number of new bank charters? Mr. Johnson. The primary explanation, Congressman, is the low interest rates. And I think the reconciliation of the points Mr. Chaffetz was making earlier is, for existing banks, if you have existing loans at relatively fixed rates, yes, there's some return to profitability. But if you're a de novo bank that doesn't inherit these loans, that actually holds a lot more in Federal funds, for example--this is all in the Fed paper Mr. Browning was trying to cite--it's all there. It's all clearly documented. The profitability for a de novo on a forward-looking, prospective basis, as being valued by the FDIC, is very low. In fact, it's lower than it's ever been in recorded data. Mr. Cummings. In an article published on June 24, 2016, by the American Bankers Association, the ABA's chief economist, James Chessen, wrote, and I quote, ``Great investment options don't exist in today's abnormally low rate environment,'' end of quote. Mr. Williams reiterated that today in his written testimony. Professor Johnson, do you agree with the concerns expressed by Mr. Williams and the American Bankers Association's chief economist? Mr. Johnson. Yeah. I think Mr. Chessen's article was spot on in that regard. Low interest rate environment, very hard for investors to make money. And if you're the insurance company-- remember, the FDIC is not chartering any banks at all, none. The FDIC provides--agrees to provide you with deposit insurance or not. So from an insurance company perspective, evaluating the risks, if they can't make any money, if they're not going to be profitable because of this low interest rate environment, that's substantially higher risk, and you should, therefore, on a prudent basis be less willing to provide them with insurance. Mr. Cummings. Mr. Williams also stated in his written testimony that he started his bank in 1990, quote, in the middle of a so-called S&L crisis and the beginning of a recession; despite these severe conditions, there were 193 de novos that year, end of quote. He compares that with the current business cycle. Professor Johnson, are there differences between that business cycle and this one? And how do interest rates compare? Mr. Johnson. There are huge differences, Congressman. Mr. Williams' achievement is impressive, let me be clear, but there was a very different interest rate environment. Interest rates did not fall anywhere near the level that they are today or they've been since the financial crisis. For the past 8 years almost we've had extremely low interest rates. There's a very, very different world than anything we have ever seen in the United States. Mr. Cummings. The American Bankers Association chief economist also wrote this quote, ``Sure, de novos are risky. They failed at twice the rate of other banks, historically. They create losses for the FDIC,'' end of quote. Professor Johnson, is Mr. Chessen right? Is that correct? Mr. Johnson. Yes, I think Mr. Chessen is actually citing the same Federal Reserve research that I was talking about. That's what they've documented very clearly in the data, a failure rate of de novo banks two times established banks. And as Mr. Gruenberg already said, there's a lot of failures between years 3 and 7 in that, which is why they heightened or extended the de novo scrutiny period in 2009. Mr. Cummings. What trends were observed regarding the failure rates of new banks during the crisis? Were adequate safeguards in place prior to the financial crisis to ensure that risky new banks were not approved? Mr. Johnson. Well, the FDIC has looked at this carefully, and I cite the research in my paper. I think it's good research. They found a lot of de novos failed, including this recent episode. Now, the FDIC is not charged with making sure that zero banks fail. It's an insurance company, so some failure is acceptable, as long as it's covered by the premium. Another key issue is, over the cycle, what happens to deposit funds. That's a really tangible, you know, hard-to- argue-with measure of how this insurance company did. And as Mr. Gruenberg said, they were negative $20 billion. So they were on the side slightly of allowing too many banks with not very good prospects over the business cycle to enter. You know, I think, looking back and seeing how they managed to build it up, it's hard to complain too much. I don't think the FDIC did a bad job on financial regulation. But there's no way that they were shutting out the banks or preventing them from entering, and I don't think that's the business they're in today. Mr. Cummings. My last question. Professor Johnson, if the FDIC were to weaken its regulations in an effort to jump-start applications, would that help or harm the insurance fund? Mr. Johnson. It would create greater risk for the insurance fund, and over the cycle you would have bigger losses. Those losses would be covered by larger assessments, both on an income statement basis and on a cash basis, from the industry. The taxpayer is exposed to some risk. Deposit funds have failed in other situations, in other countries, at other moments of U.S. history. I don't think FDIC would fail. I think it's the bankers and the banking industry that would ultimately pay. And I don't think that's what the industry wants, and I don't think that's what the economy needs. Mr. Cummings. Thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. We now recognize the gentleman from Ohio, Mr. Jordan, for 5 minutes. Mr. Jordan. Mr. Johnson, so what's going to happen when we go to negative interest rates? We're not going to have anyone apply, anyone be approved. Is that right? If the argument is that the Fed keeping low interest rates, we're not getting any more banks, what happens when we go negative? Which my understanding is some European countries have already done that. Mr. Johnson. Well, it's a fascinating hypothetical, Mr. Jordan. Certainly---- Mr. Jordan. I don't know if it's all that fascinating. It seems like it's pretty realistic right now based on what I'm reading. Mr. Johnson. Well, it certainly has happened in Europe. I don't think we're--that's an imminent development in the United States. But, yes, to your point, if interest rates are negative, that is going to squeeze the net interest margin further. Mr. Jordan. Hurts competition, hurts the consumer, right? Mr. Johnson. Well, in terms of net interest margin, it's certainly going to be difficult for de novo community banks. Mr. Jordan. Well, all I'm hearing is about community consolidating, and you're telling me no new ones are going to be created because the FDIC is not going to give them insurance because the rates so low and the chances of them making a profit is so low. Then, if we go negative, it's going to be even worse, further hurting competition, therefore hurting the consumer, all because the Fed--I mean---- Mr. Johnson. Well, look, if you want to talk about the consumer, we should be talking more broadly about all of finance and entry into the financial sector, including the impact of fintech, which, as you know, is substantial and growing. So that conversation about the consumer is not only about community banks. But to the extent we're focused on de novo community banks, it's certainly not going to be helpful to the issues that the chairman has put before us today. Mr. Jordan. Exactly. Let me switch gears. I wasn't planning on asking that, but you've got me thinking. Mr. Gruenberg, you ever hear of Operation Choke Point? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, Congressman. Mr. Jordan. You ever, at FDIC, ever have any interaction with the folks over at Justice Department regarding Operation Choke Point? Mr. Gruenberg. As you know, Congressman, our inspector general did a review of that, and the finding of the inspector general's report was that the FDIC played an inconsequential role. Mr. Jordan. That's not what I asked. Did you have interaction with the Justice Department regarding Operation Choke Point? Mr. Gruenberg. I think the IG report found that there was some legal staff level---- Mr. Jordan. Did some of your lawyers talk to some lawyers at Justice about Operation Choke Point? Mr. Gruenberg. No, I think it was about specific institution that the Justice Department had questions on. Mr. Jordan. You send out financial institution letters, right? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, sir. Mr. Jordan. Is there, like, a formal letter that goes out to banking institutions? Am I getting this right? And it's viewed as formal guidance documents, right? The banks take these things seriously? Mr. Gruenberg. I think that's fair to say. Mr. Jordan. All right. And you said your outreach with Justice Department and your working with Justice Department on Operation Choke Point was rather limited, even though your lawyers talked to them about it. But I look at this letter that you sent back in January of 2012, managing risk and third-party payment processor relationships. Do you remember this letter? Mr. Gruenberg. I don't know specifically what you're referring to, but---- Mr. Jordan. Page 8 of this letter you talk about high-risk activity, and you give a list--ammunition sales, firearm sales, payday loans, travel clubs, to name a few. Do you remember this letter? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, sir. Mr. Jordan. Yeah. First time I've seen the list. The list looks very familiar to the same kind of institutions the Justice Department targeted in Operation Choke Point. Would you agree with that statement, Mr. Gruenberg? Mr. Gruenberg. I really can't speak to what the Justice Department program was, since we were not a participant in it. What I can say is that back in 2011 there was an article published in a Supervisory Insights Journal that the FDIC produces on managing third-party---- Mr. Jordan. Well, it sure looks very similar to me what Operation Choke Point was doing, going after the same kind of businesses and telling banks, hey, you want to steer clear of these. I've talked to folks who say, you know what, the folks we were doing business with, our bank, said, we've got this notice, and our bank said, we no longer want to do business with you; even though you're in a legitimate business selling firearms or in a legitimate business providing payday lending, we're no longer going to do business with you because you're now viewed as high risk and we're getting all kinds of pressure, even though we may have done business with you 20, 25 years. Mr. Gruenberg. All I can say is our inspector general did look at that issue---- Mr. Jordan. And all I can say is, here's the list, and the list looks very familiar. Mr. Gruenberg. I understand. And because of the---- Mr. Jordan. And then we have this. I guess, here's--I've got just a few seconds. But we just heard from the chairman you're not approving anybody. We've got the interest rate issue as the reason you're citing. But the fact is, you're not approving anybody and it's different than it's historically been. Then we see this list of folks. I'll tell you what this looks like, Mr. Chairman, it looks--because we've dealt with this issue a lot in this committee--it looks exactly like what the Internal Revenue Service did. They said to folks who were at that applying for tax-exempt status, no, we're going to harass you, you've got to fill out a bunch of forms, we're going to keep asking a bunch of questions, we're not going to approve you. And they targeted them, just like this list seems to be targeting certain types of businesses that you don't like, and obviously the Justice Department didn't like, as evidenced by Operation Choke Point. That's what it looks like. Mr. Gruenberg. Candidly, Congressman, I don't believe that was the case. And I think the IG---- Mr. Jordan. But do you see the similarities? Mr. Gruenberg. Sir, I can't speak to that. All I can say-- -- Mr. Jordan. Well, I can, and I do. Mr. Gruenberg. Our inspector general reviewed this particular issue and didn't find any support for that, I believe. Mr. Jordan. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. We now recognize the gentlewoman from New Jersey, Ms. Watson Coleman, for 5 minutes. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gruenberg--is that correct? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Yes, thank you. I want to follow up on a question the chairman asked. There are a couple applications you said that are pending for de novo banks, but you said that there's been no action on them. So are they considered dead file? Because ``pending'' suggests to me that something is happening with those applications or with whatever is before you. Mr. Gruenberg. No, there are a couple of active applications by parties interested in establishing de novo banks that are under active consideration. I think the chairman was referring to applications that were actually filed several years ago, prior to the crisis. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Before. Right. And so those applications, are they pending or are they dead? Mr. Gruenberg. They're technically still pending, but they're not active because the applicants really haven't been pursuing them since the crisis. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Well, pending suggests to me that something---- Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Pending suggests that there's something that is expected of them or is expected of you to tell them what they need to do in order to move through the process. And so that's confusing to me. Mr. Gruenberg. No, I think you raise a fair point. And as I indicated, we're going undertake a review or undertaking a review of our application process and procedures. And I think we need to resolve that issue so that an application shouldn't be outstanding for that period of time. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Right. It shouldn't be pending and be dead at the same time, right. Mr. Gruenberg. Right. Mrs. Watson Coleman. According to reports issued by the FDIC in 2013, nearly 8 percent of households in the United States were, quote, ``unbanked,'' meaning that they did not have bank accounts. One of five households was, quote, ``underbanked,'' meaning that the household had at least one bank account but also used alternative financial services, with the most common sources for alternative sources being grocery, liquor, convenience, or drugstores, or even, I guess, check- cashing stores. Dr. Johnson, what challenges do consumers face in obtaining basic banking services from these institutions, these alternative institutions? Mr. Johnson. Well, Congresswoman, as you know, these alternative financial institutions charge very high rates of interest. The terms and conditions they provide are not always fully transparent. There are many instances of, frankly, predatory behavior in that industry. And, partly, I think it's about the consumers not understanding what they're getting into, not realizing how expensive this is. But as Mr. Cummings already said, there is an issue of how readily available are reasonable financial-- affordable financial services in that community, and that that's clearly a big problem. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you, Dr. Johnson. Mr. Gruenberg, FDIC, you indicated you're committed to increasing participation of unbanked and underbanked households in the financial mainstream. What does that mean? What are you doing or what do you propose to do and what is the timeframe for doing those things? Mr. Gruenberg. As you indicated, Congresswoman, that's a significant issue in our financial system. We, the FDIC, actually partnered with the Census Bureau on the first survey ever done on who's unbanked and underbanked, and we've been focusing on trying to respond to this issue over the last several years. Among a number of things we've done, we've developed so-called model transaction accounts, which are low- cost account-based debit card accounts with no overdraft fees as a condition of the account. And as a result of our work, a number of major financial institutions across the country are now offering these low-cost threshold accounts that really reduce the barriers to entry and expand the ability of people to get into the banking system, and we think that's actually a very, very important objective to pursue. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you. In a lot of communities, the impact of the Great Recession is still very profound, and many individuals are continuing to suffer from it, entrances and exits from the banking system. Mr. Williams, what steps has your bank taken to reduce the number of unbanked and underbanked in Louisiana? Mr. White. Our bank is a blue collar as opposed to a blue blood bank. We operate in a number of parishes from Baton Rouge down to St. Bernard, and we provide free checking. So it doesn't get better than that. We advertise it, promote it, we also provide debit cards and payment cards that you can use. But the essential service that we provide is free checking. Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I now recognize the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Walberg for 5 minutes. Mr. Walberg. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to the panel for being here. Reading information in preparation for this hearing and seeing the fact that we have the lowest number of banks in the United States, since records being kept to 1934, is a concern. I mean, the reason why this country, as I recollect, is the greatest country in the world based upon only a short period of time of being alive as a country, 240 years, is because we had the ability to take risk and develop reward to get capital into the marketplace, into the hands of people who can generate opportunity for people. So to hear concerns fostered in the last 8 years about trying to protect us against what has really made us great and oversee in such a way that we hold back the genius of what compounded interest, capital being freely and relatively easy to gain if you have the process in place that says will you take that risk on me is a concern. Mr. Browning, your testimony says that constantly evolving and ambiguous requirements at the FDIC are putting up roadblocks to new entrance. Could you expand and describe the situation in a little more detail? Mr. Browning. Certainly. Congressman, thank you. As we engaged in our process, we put forward a plan with great detail on our loan programs tapping into an existing client base. We brought $30 million in capital, showed profitability in our first year. We had an exceptionally stable low cost deposit base built into the program and a variety of other things. There were vague suggestions that our deposit program was inadequate even though we had ready available deposits well in excess of four to five times what the bank would need in its first 3 years of life. There were additional suggestions of entering new lines of business such as SBA lending. And SBA lending is a great program, for sure, but it is not something we contemplated it with outside our expertise. We didn't have the infrastructure staff to originate such loans to service them, to sell them. Mr. Walberg. And yet you are not a novice in the field? Mr. Browning. Not at all, sir. And so it was expanding infrastructure, expanding processes in ways that were outside of our core plan, outside of our profile, and to us, introduced increased risk and increased cost, and were certainly not part of the statutory requirements of chartering a new bank. Mr. Walberg. Which is not the reason why you're getting into that line of work. You need to develop the risk as you determine as best to meet your agenda, which is, I would assume, to succeed and succeed for the people that use your resources. Mr. Williams, in your written testimony you mention that regulations are more detrimental to a bank's profitability than low interest rates. Why is that? Mr. Williams. Regulations cost time and money and hurt both the bank and the consumer when they are overburdensome. And a good example is the new TRID regulation. We are one of the largest mortgage lenders in southeast Louisiana. When TRID came in, all of the service providers raised their cost because, under TRID, if there is a change in cost, you have to redisclose and it resets the time period, so every cost went up. When TRID went in, the closings were delayed, and when TRID went in, the realtors, in particular we have some markets in New Orleans right now, Uptown and the Marigny, where they are very active markets. Realtors would say to consumers, if you don't have your financing either all cash or locked in, we're going to tell the seller not to take your offer because the TRID delays are just too cumbersome. So it's a triple play. The consumer now has a slower closing, pays more, and has less ability to shop. But when CFPB harms the consumer like that, there's nowhere to go because there is no oversight of CFPB. So that's a regulation that cost us money, cost the consumer money, and hurts everybody. Mr. Walberg. It takes the natural rhythm that would be in place in those types of dealings and puts it on its ear, doesn't it? Mr. Williams. It does. And I mean, it's counterproductive. It doesn't help the consumer, it doesn't help the bank, it was--and it's unfortunate, but that's an example of an overburdensome regulation that's unhelpful. Mr. Walberg. And you truly believe that if all of this was in place when you started back in 1990, that you probably wouldn't have started up the bank? Mr. Williams. Well, I was a little scared listening to Mr. Browning talk about spending so much money to apply. We put up all the money we had, which was a million five. We couldn't have afforded all the consultants that were necessary, and it just wouldn't be possible. And I think of what would be missed. You know, there is a charter school in New Orleans that funds--that has students that are all inner city, but yet all 400 students graduate and go to college. When that charter school started, they went around the city looking for a line of credit. We were the only bank that would provide it. They think that they wouldn't be open absent our bank. I'm an honorary member of the Warren Easton Hall of Fame because of that. Well, how do you measure the things that don't occur when you don't charter banks? We're missing an awful lot of success because we want to prevent a small potential failure. Mr. Walberg. Thanks for your service. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize the gentlewoman from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence for 5 minutes. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I understand that part of the application process, there is numerous conversations typically occur between the applicant and the FDIC before a formal application is filed. Chairman Gruenberg, what types of conversations occur? Mr. Gruenberg. We actually encourage what are called prefiling meetings with interested groups looking to establish a new institution to walk them through the application and the requirements, to answer questions, and to give them the sense of what's involved in the undertaking. And actually, we may engage in multiple meetings as the group tries to inform itself about the requirements and what would be expected. Mrs. Lawrence. Is this before--is this an interest in an application or there is an official application filed and then you start having these pre-conversations? Mr. Gruenberg. Actually both. Oftentimes we encourage groups, before they actually submit the application, to come in and have what we call a prefiling meeting so that we can establish up front what the requirements are and sort of walk them through the process. And then once the application is actually submitted, we'll then follow up with them in terms of trying to fulfill all of the requirements. Mrs. Lawrence. Mr. Browning, you have had some concerns. Would you say this has been your reality? Mr. Browning. I certainly appreciate the intent of the chairman and believe that to be very genuine, but I think the reality is quite different. We went through many months of conversations with regional staff, and that went well, regional FDIC and State regulatory staff. Mrs. Lawrence. Okay. Mr. Browning. Once we engage in our prefiling meeting, that formal presentation the chairman referenced, things turned very differently from there forward. The process was taken from San Francisco, the regional office that had jurisdiction, taken back to Washington, and that's when very unusual questions, very novel criterion suggestions began to be made. Mrs. Lawrence. So if I could try to interpret your comments. There were conversations, but you felt that they were not productive and the type---- Mr. Chairman, you've heard that comment. Do additional discussions occur between the applicant and the FDIC, after the application is filed, and where do you think the breakdown is, at least for Mr. Browning? Mr. Gruenberg. You know, I can't speak---- Mrs. Lawrence. You need to turn on your mike. Mr. Gruenberg. Sorry. I can't speak to the specific case of Mr. Browning. I do think the application process is generally a very hands-on process with applicants. Mrs. Lawrence. Yeah. Mr. Gruenberg. And we do go to great lengths to work with applicants. I can tell you that in terms of the general experience from 2000 through today, applications are generally processed and decided on in a 4- to 6-month period. That's the overall experience. Obviously there are going to be instances where that may not be the case. That may be the instance with Mr. Browning, but I couldn't speak to that specific circumstance. Mrs. Lawrence. Mr. Chairman, can you tell me what have you done? What can you state that you've done to welcome new applicants? Mr. Gruenberg. We are very much focused on this, and we've done a number of things, as I indicated in my testimony. We brought together--you know, in any application process, it's not just the FDIC, but the chartering agency, whether the State or Federal agency has to participate, so we brought the other chartering agencies together with us to work through the application process. We are going to be holding outreach meetings in regions across the country where we are going to meet with interested parties in the industry to talk about the application process and how we can work with them if they're interested in applying. We are developing a manual which will really provide specific guidance on how to go through the application process. So, you know, we are prepared to do everything we can to lower the process procedure hurdle of getting through the application. But---- Mrs. Lawrence. Chairman, I just want to say, on the record, I would like to hear this from you. Do you identify that there has been a high rate of denials of new applications and that you are implementing new practices, or are you stating that the history of the applicants not being approved had nothing to do with your process? Mr. Gruenberg. I think what we're seeing, in the period before the financial crisis, 2000 to 2007 where there were over 1,000---- Mrs. Lawrence. Yes, I understand. Mr. Gruenberg. There was a 75 percent approval rate. Mrs. Lawrence. Okay. Mr. Gruenberg. So there's a high level of approval. It's really this post-crisis environment in which both, there was a severe economic downturn and a historically long period of almost zero interest rates. Mrs. Lawrence. So are you doing new innovative things recognizing that has happened? Mr. Gruenberg. You know, we can't change the economics in terms of what interest rates are. We are trying to do everything we can within our own process to make it as responsive as we can to applicants and to at least lower the barrier of the application process itself. Mrs. Lawrence. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentlelady. Now recognize the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Meadows for 5 minutes. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Gruenberg, how will you rate the FDIC on a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being the highest as a user-friendly organization as it relates to the application process? Mr. Gruenberg. It's probably not for me to judge. I would like to think---- Mr. Meadows. Well, I'll judge it if you don't, so go ahead and give me a number. Mr. Gruenberg. I think we do a pretty good job between 5, 7, 8, but I think we can do better, and I think that's going to be a priority. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Let me tell you the reason why I ask that, Mr. Gruenberg, because there is a belief that you have a retaliatory environment in the FDIC. And I'm here to tell you that the reason why I'm not going to give you real examples by banks is because they're afraid that you will come after them. And I'm here to tell you that I'm not going to allow that to happen. So let me give you some real examples, since you're talking hypothetically, let me give you some real examples. You've heard from Mr. Browning and Mr. Williams. Is there any reason why you would only have a 4 percent approval rating, in an environment that's encouraging new banks, other than low interest rates, because you're looking at a business model, and I was a business guy, and actually--you know, Mr. Johnson actually was in North Carolina. I knew Mr. Fuqua of which the school of where he practiced, I knew him personally. And so here's what I'm saying is, this retaliatory environment is very concerning. So how do you respond to that? Do you retaliate or do you not? Mr. Gruenberg. I do not believe we do, Congressman. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Well, I'm aware of some communications, from your FDIC personnel from here in D.C., that says we're going to teach them a lesson, we're going to go after them, we're going to make them sweat. Would you like copies of those emails in--because let me tell you where I have--from a regulations and a regulatory standpoint, that is inexcusable. Wouldn't you agree with that? Mr. Gruenberg. I would. Mr. Meadows. All right. So if that happened and you're going after people, what are the consequences for those that have that kind of environment and have been sending out those kinds of emails? Will you fire them? Mr. Gruenberg. Congressman, you know, I'd be reluctant to speak in the general on something like that. You have to look at the specific situation and the facts. Mr. Meadows. But if they retaliated against somebody, will you get rid of them? Mr. Gruenberg. Congressman, I would want to be very careful to look at the facts of a particular situation. Mr. Meadows. All right. Well, I'm going the give you the facts because let me tell you what I've got concerns about. Is I've got regulators that come in, and what they do is they say: Well, we need to make more loans to people that are underserved. And you tell that same bank: Well, you need to watch your aging process because it's going 30, 90 days. And when the banker tells your regulators that those are two conflicting issues, you know what your regulator said? True statement. You're the banker. You figure it out. Now, that is deplorable. Wouldn't you agree? Mr. Gruenberg. The way you describe it, sir, I wouldn't-- I'm not taking issue. Mr. Meadows. Okay. I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt to believe that somewhere in your organization these kinds of things are just not rising to your level. But here's where I'm going to tell you, I'm going to work with the chairman to make sure that you understand that we are not going to tolerate this kind of chilling effect on this industry, because what it does is it affects not the--it doesn't affect the high income folks. It affects the places that Mr. Williams serves. It affects Baltimore. It affects many of the places that, quite frankly, they need banks. And Mr. Johnson is talking about too big to fail. Well, this whole process will create where we only have a few big banks because you're not going to approve the community banks. Do you agree with that? Mr. Gruenberg. Congressman, candidly, we had a process that's--same set of standards from 2000 to 2007, which large numbers and percentage of applications were approved. Mr. Meadows. I'm talking about after that, Mr. Gruenberg. You keep going back. The pendulum was you approved 75 percent. Now you come in to approve 4 percent. Somewhere in the middle is where we need to be. Wouldn't you agree? Mr. Gruenberg. Very much so, Congressman. Mr. Meadows. So when is the pendulum going to swing back and you're going to start to approve some of these things? Mr. Gruenberg. All I can say, Congressman, is the institutions--and we have to function in the economic environment in which we live, and right now that's a pretty challenging one to---- Mr. Meadows. Well, here's what I want. As this hearing, I want whistleblowers, in the industry, to let us know--and we're going to give them the same protection because we're not going to give you the names of those--and when we get the emails, do I have your commitment that heads are going to roll if they continue this kind of process? Mr. Gruenberg. What I can say, if you get emails reporting incidents, we'll be glad to look into them. Mr. Meadows. All right. I've got one in terms of some lawsuits that you've got going on right now in discovery, and I found some stuff that's not even from my State. Are you willing to look into that as well? Because you're going after it in a real draconian way to try to prove something that, quite frankly, doesn't serve the American people and it doesn't serve the banking institute. Do I have your commitment to look into that? Mr. Gruenberg. I'll certainly take a look at it. Mr. Meadows. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. The gentleman yields back. Now recognize Mr. Cummings. Mr. Cummings. Yeah. I want us to be most effective and efficient. You just made some statements about--and I'm sure you have the evidence to prove it. I know--I know--and I'm not knocking it. I'm just trying to make sure we get to the bottom that there is some kind of retaliation and there may be some whistleblowers. And I just want to know what is your plan to get the information to the chairman so we can effectively deal with these issues? Wait, wait, let me finish. May I. Mr. Meadows. Sure. Mr. Cummings. I just want to finish. Because all of us take a very strict position with regard to whistleblowers. We want to protect them, and at the same time we want to accomplish what you want to accomplish, that is, to address whatever that issue is that they may be, rightfully so, complaining about. I just want to know what your plan was? That's all. Mr. Meadows. Well, and I thank the ranking member, and you have my commitment. I'll clear my calendar this afternoon, tomorrow, I will stay in August if you want to address this, but here's what we need to do. Is we need to take these real examples, and we can just take a random sample of all the ones that have been denied or inaction, and there is a problem is it's not even that there's action. It's just that they're out there in this holding pattern with you not making the decision and not making decisions on behalf of it. I'm willing to work with the ranking member in a real transparent way to address this problem. Mr. Cummings. Thank you. Mr. Meadows. I yield back. Mr. Cummings. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. I now recognize the gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Clay for 5 minutes. Mr. Clay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me thank the witnesses for being here. The FDIC is not subject to annual congressional appropriations process. Instead, the FDIC receives its funding from, quote, ``premiums that banks and thrift institutions pay for deposit insurance coverage and from earnings on investments in U.S. Treasury securities.'' Some of my Republican colleagues have proposed legislation that would subject all financial regulators to congressional appropriations, including the FDIC. Professor Johnson, what risk to the financial system do you foresee if the FDIC were to be placed at the whim of congressional appropriations? Mr. Johnson. Well, Mr. Clay, this is a very serious issue. Indeed, the FDIC, since it was created in the 1930s, has been the gold standard for independent regulation, not just in the United States but around the world. So you have 80 years of success, and of course, there's a lot of pressures on all kinds of regulators, including through various kinds of revolving doors and other mechanisms that we've seen operate all too well. Mr. Clay. Right. Mr. Johnson. The FDIC has stood under that pressure over decades, and I'm afraid we can't say the same for other banking regulators. So I think it would be extremely unwise to change the funding basis of the FDIC and to bring it closer to Congress. We've had some very unfortunate experiences with regulators that are funded through the annual appropriation process, and I think it would be extremely bad for the banking industry, as well as for the economy, if the FDIC were to be moved in that direction. Mr. Clay. So if all financial regulators were subject to the appropriations process like, for instance, the CFPB, what kind of results do you think we would get from that? Mr. Johnson. Well, I think you would get much less effective regulation. I think it's much harder to have predictable regulatory environment when the funding is uncertain, and as various kinds of activities increase, this has been a big issue, for example, around derivative transactions, for example. We didn't increase the amount of scrutiny of that, in part, because of the constraints of the appropriation process, and you can get very large industries developing with almost no regulatory scrutiny, and of course, that hurt us very badly in 2008. Mr. Clay. It certainly did. And Chairman Gruenberg, how are the FDIC's annual expenditures approved? Mr. Gruenberg. By our board. Mr. Clay. By your board. And how does the FDIC ensure it does not overspend in its activities? Mr. Gruenberg. We have a pretty rigorous budget process that's overseen by our board, which is made up of 5 members, and as you know, politically diverse as well, and the--it is acted on in a board meeting, a public board meeting, and all of the budget, of course, is a matter of public record. And actually, since the crisis, we've been reducing our annual budget as we've been winding down from the build up to respond to the crisis. Mr. Clay. And isn't it true that even without being subject to the appropriations process, Congress still maintains meaningful oversight of the FDIC's operations. Is that correct? Mr. Gruenberg. I would say that's fair to say, Congressman. Mr. Clay. Kind of like this hearing today, and we're in the Oversight Committee, and so--and which I find it interesting because you usually come before the Financial Services Committee, and for whatever reason, you have shown up here today. But I appreciate that, Mr. Chair, and I will yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Meadows. [presiding.] I thank the gentleman from Missouri. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Hice for 5 minutes. Mr. Hice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Gruenberg, let me ask you, your opinion and that overall of the FDIC, should banks be national? Or is there a need for local community banks? Mr. Gruenberg. Oh, I think community banks play a critical function in our financial system and economy, Congressman. Mr. Hice. I do, too, and yet they're closing all over the place and they're not being approved all over the place. Do you believe that there are too many banks in this country? Mr. Gruenberg. Certainly not too many community banks, and we could use more community banks. Mr. Hice. What about banks as a whole? Mr. Gruenberg. No, we have a strong banking system in the United States. Mr. Hice. Are there too many? Mr. Gruenberg. No, I don't think so. Mr. Hice. Does the FDIC in any way have a strategy, a plan, a policy for consolidation in the banking sector? Mr. Gruenberg. No, sir. Mr. Hice. And yet banks are being swallowed up by bigger banks? Mr. Gruenberg. You know, there has been a---- Mr. Gruenberg. Are you saying that's all coincidental? Mr. Gruenberg. There has been a 30-year process in the United States of gradual consolidation within the banking industry, both at the large institutions as well as at the community banks. Mr. Hice. Does the FDIC have any role in that either through policies, or in any way would you think FDIC is responsible or has a role in that consolidation? Mr. Gruenberg. I think deposit insurance is something that's viewed as actually supportive and beneficial for community banks. And going back to 1933, when the FDIC was created, the strongest advocates for deposit insurance were by community banks to put them in a stronger position to compete with the larger institutions. Mr. Hice. Do you believe that competition in the market is important? Mr. Gruenberg. Critical, yes, sir. Mr. Hice. Should consumers have options when it comes to banks? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes. Mr. Hice. They're getting fewer and fewer options. We're all certainly watching that. Let me for a quick moment, Mr. Browning, let me go to you. Your written testimony estimates that it costs nearly a million dollars for the application process. How much would this have cost, do you think, had you gone the entire way through the process? Mr. Browning. Congressman, I think that is an unanswerable question, unfortunately. We went through a very protracted process, spending a great deal of time and money. As I mentioned, we spent nearly a million dollars. We had $30 million in capital to put into the bank showing a plan that was profitable in year one, but we came to a conclusion that we could not actually achieve the end of the process. If we saw a light at the end of the tunnel, we stood ready to make reasonable changes, but we felt like we were shadowboxing and could not get clarity on what was actually required and did not want to pour good money after bad---- Mr. Hice. So your experience is that the cost involved certainly affected not only you, but other interested candidates out there would struggle over the cost of the process? Mr. Browning. Certainly the cost of the process, but perhaps, more importantly, the ambiguity and indeterminate process. There wasn't a clear---- Mr. Hice. No light at the end of the tunnel, as you describe. Your written testimony also mentions that the FDIC felt like there was no community need for your bank. Do you have any idea what the definition is of a community need? Mr. Browning. Well, I certainly know the historical application of that, and it's spelled out in the statutory requirements within the Federal Deposit Insurance Act. And for our application, our community were clients, retail clients coast to coast, that needed basic banking services in conjunction with their brokerage accounts. This was a built-in customer base, and these are just mom-and-pop retail investors. That was our community. The new interpretations or new suggestions were unknown to us. Mr. Hice. Did the FDIC explain to you what their interpretation of ``community need'' was? Mr. Browning. No. They did not give an explicit interpretation of what it was. What they suggested what it was not. They suggested that our existing customer base was not adequate, that serving consumer demand for banking services that we had a personal relationship with was not a sufficient justification to charter a bank. Mr. Hice. Who's best to make that determination, the FDIC or those in the local community as to what the community need is for a bank? Mr. Browning. I think those in the local community, and I would also look at some of the regional offices of FDIC who have experienced expert staff, on the ground, in the local real economies, that they have a very good grasp where I think it's much more difficult to regulate strictly from Washington, but certainly local business people enmeshed in the community are certainly the best testament to what those community needs are. Mr. Hice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman from the Virgin Islands, Ms. Plaskett. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, gentlemen, for being here this morning. I wanted to ask about several policies related to keeping the financial system safe. Professor Johnson, in 2011, you published an article in the New York Times leading up to the financial crisis. Some bankers, and I quote, you wrote, understood, to a large degree, what they and their companies were doing, and they kept it up until the last minute and in some cases beyond because of the incentives they might receive. Could you explain what you meant by this? Mr. Johnson. I don't recall that precise article. I have written on that topic many, many times. The general point is that when you provide incentives, with some sort of downside protection, so too big to fail would be the most notable version of this, but also it comes up, by the way, in a lot of the conservative commentary about deposit insurance over long periods of time. If you're protecting people from downside risk, and on the upside, they do very well, then they are naturally, just as a matter of arithmetic applied to incentives, they are naturally going the take more risk. Now, sometimes you might feel that you can contain that. That has been the experience with deposit insurance in the U.S. over the years, but unfortunately, with regard to larger financial institutions and some of the largest and they run up to 2008, the risk that they took was so big that they ended up having a devastating effect on the real economy. That's why we had this massive recession. Ms. Plaskett. So those risks that they took at the largest financial institutions that you're speaking about, and the bank executives of those institutions, are they still incentivized in the same manner that they were at that time, and what is their incentives today to act in the best interest of the Nation? Mr. Johnson. I'm afraid that the largest, what are now, bank holding companies, they still have an enormous amount of effective downside protection provided by the Federal authorities, both the Federal Reserve and other parts of the U.S. Government, and we have not ended the problems associated with these too-big-to-fail financial institutions. So that's a distortion of their incentives. And as the chairman, Chairman Chaffetz opened the hearing, argued that systemic risk is going up. I think he's right but for a different reason, which is it's the effects of these very large financial institutions and the distorted incentives. Systemic risk is hardly affected at all by the margin of de novo community banks. That's just a matter, again, of arithmetic. They are very small relative to GDP. The largest financial institutions are huge. The largest single bank in the country, JP Morgan Chase has a systemic footprint, which the Fed calculates to be about 40 percent of U.S. GDP, four-zero percent, so dwarfs anything that we've been discussing so far this morning. Ms. Plaskett. So those systemic issues that you're discussing and the risks that banks are willing to take, and particularly, the bank executives in making those risks, do you believe that the FDIC should look at compensation and the compensation models that these banks have in their application process to determine what potential risk that the bank and its executives might make in their decisionmaking because of the compensation that they receive based upon those risks? Mr. Johnson. Yeah. It's certainly how you compensate your executives is a very important part of the risk profile that your bank or any firm adopts. And as I read the FDIC criteria, which frankly, I find to be pretty transparent, well explained, and I like the Q&As as well, as I read them, that is one of the criteria. There is other criteria as specified by Congress, but yes, from a point of view, deposit just the narrow deposit insurance, I think the FDIC does take that into account. Of course, the FDIC also has additional responsibilities created by Dodd-Frank with regards to some of the largest financial institutions, including with regard to living wills, and that, may also be a consideration that although, frankly, there's less transparency on that process. Ms. Plaskett. As a lawyer, I guess the living will piece sounds really interesting to me. But Chairman Gruenberg, could you explain to me how the compensation models might play and how you evaluate that in determining the applications of banks in terms of would the compensation model show that an executive would be willing to take on more risk because the output to them, in terms of compensation, would be greater if there is a greater risk? Mr. Gruenberg. In reviewing an application for deposit insurance, just to be clear, our responsibility goes to deposit insurance, not to the charter for the institution. But certainly one of the key components of it would be the management plan and the proposed executive leadership of the institution, both management and---- Ms. Plaskett. Sure, but you're determining that. You're determining the insurance deposit would let us know that, hey, they need greater insurance because you view them at a greater risk than others would. Mr. Gruenberg. And in an appropriate compensation scheme for the institution, with not undue incentivizing of risk, would be part of the things we look at in terms of reviewing the application. Ms. Plaskett. So because it's my belief that the compensation models must be--and I'm glad to understand, in consideration by the FDIC in terms of how much deposit do you believe that they should have or what is the insurance compensation that's needed, and I'm thankful for the information that you've given us. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I've run out of time. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentlewoman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Walker for 5 minutes. Mr. Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Panel, for being here today. Being from North Carolina, I am concerned that over the last 7 years we've lost 40 percent of our charters with no new banks being chartered during that time. Bank closures and consolidations account for most of the loss, but this is still a dramatic trend in banking and threatens the future of community banking as a business model. And over this time, a new bank has not been chartered in North Carolina since 2009, 7 years. The cost of the application and the regulatory compliance are cited as early obstacles to profitability as everyone testifies today, at least from what I've heard, seems to agree that community financial institutions have an important role in our economy. What has the FDIC, Chairman Gruenberg, done or considered, to lower the barriers to entry for these new bank charters? Mr. Gruenberg. I think what we have under control, Congressman, is the application process itself, in trying to make that as user friendly and responsive as possible, and fair to say, a significant aspect, particularly for smaller groups trying to set up a smaller institution, are legal and consulting fees to support the application process. To the extent that we, in the course of working with an applicant can help defray those costs, provide them the information and support and organizing group needs, our goal would be to try to contain that cost. Mr. Walker. When you say your goal is to contain the cost, is that something you're regularly looking at, reviewing, discussing, talking about, and is there any action steps or is it just something that's laid out there as a goal somewhere in the future? Mr. Gruenberg. No, as I indicated and as I outline in my testimony, we are pursuing a number of steps to try to promote new applications, including holding meetings in regions around the country for interested parties and industry groups to walk them through and explain the application process and encourage them to engage with us, as well as working with the State and Federal agencies who are responsible for chartering new banks and who are partners in terms of entry to the system. Mr. Walker. And I appreciate that. Just curious as to maybe for me, maybe for the public, what would be the cost or capital needed to charter a bank today, and what are the factors that would affect the amount of capital required to grant this charter? Mr. Gruenberg. It's hard to generalize. I think that the capital required of the institution would be related to its business model and risk associated with it. It's generally a minimum of $2 million, but I think in practice it's more $10 to $20 million of capital is probably the more general experience. And I think in terms of a startup cost for just putting the application together, it probably runs close to a million dollars. Mr. Walker. In these meetings and discussions to work for-- on the cost and some of the startup fees, has the FDIC considered streamlining the business plan for a de novo bank applicant? Mr. Gruenberg. I think we'd like to make it as simple and fast as we can. You know, we have a balance to strike. That's really what--we want to facilitate the entry. At the same time we have to ensure that the institution that's going to be established is going to benefit from Federal deposit insurance, and so we have to be sure both that the process is as user friendly as we can but also ensure that the new institution established can meet the standard so it can be set up. Mr. Walker. Sure. And with the de novo banks, one of the major costs is hiring the regulatory attorney. The question is, as this is incredibly expensive, could this process be streamlined so that no regulatory attorney is necessary? Mr. Gruenberg. I don't know that I could say or advise a group not to have legal counsel. To the extent we can simplify and work with the institution to reduce that cost, that would be an objective. Mr. Walker. And what considerations or accommodations is extended to new charters in the area of regulatory oversight? Mr. Gruenberg. I think it's important in the initial 3 years of the establishment of the institution. You can look at it both ways. You want to have careful oversight in the initial period as they get themselves started up. That's a period of risk for a new entity. And I would view we have more attentive supervision, and I would view that as actually supportive of the long-term success of the institution. Mr. Walker. And if I have time, maybe to expound on this last question. In North Carolina we have seen successful nontraditional creative bank structures like Square One Bank in Durham and then Live Oak Bank in Wilmington. Will nontraditional charter applicants still receive favorable conditions from the FDIC, assuming all of the boxes are checked, capital management, et cetera? Mr. Gruenberg. We'll work with any group that has an interest, Congressman. Mr. Walker. My concern, from what I'm hearing over in the hour or so of testimony today, is that--let me ask you this. How long have you been chairman of the FDIC? Mr. Gruenberg. I've been--became--I was confirmed as chairman in November of 2012. Mr. Walker. Okay. So we're coming up on 4 years. I hear a lot about, hey, these are our goals, this is something we're looking into, we're having meetings, we're checking into this, even some of the questions earlier about any kind of pushback on some of the whistleblowers. I hope that some of that is actually being processed and some of those goals are being met in the days ahead. I have a couple more. My time is expired, so I yield back to the chairman. Thank you. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman from Illinois, my good friend, Ms. Kelly. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to address two issues affecting the ability of the FDIC to keep the financial system safe. First I'd like to ask about the FDIC's orderly liquidation authority. The Dodd-Frank Act permits large and complex financial institutions that are failing to be resolved through a process known as ``orderly liquidation.'' Mr. Chairman, can you please explain what that is and how is it different than bankruptcy Mr. Gruenberg. Thank you, Congresswoman. Just to put it in context. Prior to the crisis, the FDIC's resolution authorities, or authorities to manage the failure of a financial institution, was limited just to the insured institution, the insured bank itself. What we saw during the crisis that it wasn't just the insured bank but actually the parent company and the consolidated financial company these very large institutions that got into difficulty as well in some cases nonbank financial companies, Lehman Brothers is perhaps the most striking example. And the FDIC had no authority to place either the consolidated complex financial institution or a nonbank financial company into a public receivership The orderly liquidation authority that you mention actually provides us those authorities. So it's really a threshold capability if we were going to try to actually manage an orderly failure of a systemic institution like this. It was a authority we didn't have in 2008 and it was--it is an authority we have today Ms. Kelly. If another financial crisis were to occur today, we hope not, could a failing financial institution be resolved through bankruptcy? Mr. Gruenberg. I believe we have the authority and capabilities today that we didn't have in 2008. I would just say, though, until we actually do it, and then I would be, you know, a little modest about making heroic assertions, but I do think we are in a very different place today than we were back in 2008. Ms. Kelly. Professor Johnson, do you agree with that? Is bankruptcy a feasible way to resolve a failing institution at this point? Mr. Johnson. Well, I want to make sure I understand the question, and the wording is really important. Bankruptcy generally, refers to the process where the FDIC is not involved, you go to the courts, and it's administered as a court run process. That's the standard, obviously, for nonfinancial companies. We have attempted that. Sometimes financial companies, for smaller relatively simple financial companies, yes, bankruptcy does work. For any kind of large complex financial institution, bankruptcy didn't work in the past, would not work today. It would be a catastrophe. You'd be back to Lehman Brothers. That's why we have the OLA, that's why we have the potential for the FDIC resolution process. I think that could be helpful under some circumstances, but I think that the large complex institutions are still a bit too big and too complex and that none of them have produced living wills, to the best of my knowledge, that really would assure us that they could be resolved in an FDIC run process without major negative effects on the financial system and on the economy. Ms. Kelly. Our chair of Financial Services has recently proposed legislation to rescind the FDIC's orderly liquidation authority. Professor Johnson, are you familiar with that? Mr. Johnson. Yes, I am Ms. Kelly. And what would be the effects? Mr. Johnson. I think it would be a disaster. I think that we experienced vivid and horrible detail in 2008 what happens when you say large financial institution is failing, let's have it sorted out by bankruptcy. Lehman went bankrupt. Let's be clear. Lehman went through the bankruptcy process, and I don't think any of us enjoyed the consequences, and I really don't think we want to go back there. Ms. Kelly. The chairman also has the CHOICE Act, which will require FDIC to calculate and weigh the costs and benefits of new regulations. Professor Johnson, again, in the financial services arena, how credible are quantitative cost benefit analysis? Mr. Johnson. Look, if you're talking about the full costs and benefits of financial regulation, including avoiding a massive recession with millions of jobs lost, the loss of at least 1 year's GDP, low growth for 8 years, if that's in the cost benefit analysis, then I'm in favor, but unfortunately, that's not what is put in even the legislative language or in the standards of protection of cost benefit analysis. They use a much narrower definition. That frankly is deeply, deeply misleading with regard to why we have financial regulation, how financial regulation works, and what happens when it fails Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Chairman, I won't you to ask you to comment on that, but can you tell us if the FDIC currently conduct any analysis of proposed regulations, benefits, and costs? Mr. Gruenberg. Actually we do, Congresswoman, and as you may know, we're in a process required by Federal statute called EGRPRA, which requires the Federal banking agencies every 10 years to review all the rules and regulations that we've issued and determine whether any of them are no longer necessary or should be modified, and we're actually working on that process now. We're require to issue a report by the end of this year, and I think we'll be--we've already made some changes, and we'll be proposing additional changes in an effort to reduce regulatory burden and the costs associated with them. Ms. Kelly. From a nuts-and-bolts perspective, how would a quantitative cost benefit analysis affect the FDIC's ability to put forward new rules, especially in the midst of a financial crisis? Mr. Gruenberg. It would really determine on how--as Professor Johnson indicated, how it was run, and since I'm not really familiar with the legislative proposal, I'd rather not comment on that. Ms. Kelly. Yes, sir. Mr. Meadows. I believe the gentlewoman's time is expired, but--it didn't inspire 5 minutes and 48 seconds ago, but I think we are 48 seconds into expiration. Ms. Kelly. I was wondering. Okay. Thank you Mr. Meadows. The gentleman from Tennessee is recognized Mr. Duncan. Well, thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Gruenberg, I have a letter from the Tennessee Bankers Association which says: Among the key factors that are both restricting new banks and driving consolidation are the ability to attract the very high levels of capital required to start a new bank, and for that matter, the high levels of capital required after imposition of the Dodd-Frank Act and the new Basel 3 requirements. And secondly, the regulatory burden imposed by the Dodd- Frank act, which requires significant resources to be directed simply toward compliance issues. And I really heard that second matter for many bankers, but you talk about these high capital requirements. I heard Mr. Browning say that his people had $30 million they were planning to put into this bank, and I'm wondering, can you give me a rough guess? I've been provided by staff saying that there was only one new bank approved in 2013 and one in 2015. In the last 3 years, let's say, or 3 or 4 years, how much capital have these new banks that--two or three new banks that have been approved, how much capital have they come up with? Mr. Gruenberg. I couldn't tell you that offhand, Congressman. We'd be glad to check on that and come back to you, if that would be okay. Mr. Gruenberg. I think in regard to the application standard, the capital requirement today is the same capital requirement that's been in place really since 1992. So we do require higher capital for startups for that first 3-year period, and the reason for that is in the startup phase of an institution, one, it's going to be a growth period so they need the capital to support the growth; two, startups generally experience higher rates of loss as they get their business going; and three, they need the initial capital just to get the operation---- Mr. Duncan. Well, how much capital do you require just generally? Mr. Gruenberg. It's an 8 percent minimum requirement. Mr. Duncan. Eight percent of what? Mr. Gruenberg. It's an 8 percent leverage capital requirement related to the total assets of the institution, and that's been the minimum requirement since 1992. And you can argue that it's too--some people argue that it's too high. Others have argued, because of the failure experience during the crisis, it should have been even higher. We think it's a reasonable basis to assure a significant probability of success as the institution gets started and tries to get through the initial startup period. Mr. Duncan. Well, you may need to take another look at it if nobody's applying for new banks anymore or they're not getting any approved. Let me ask another question real quick before my time goes out. I know when they passed the Dodd-Frank law, and I was here then, the people who supported it said they were doing it to get back at the big banks and Wall Street firms that led us into the recession. Yet 2 years ago, George Mason University released a report that said that since the financial crisis, U.S. banking assets and deposits have continued to consolidate in a handful of large banks. The five largest banks now hold 44 percent of U.S. banking assets compared to 23-and-a-half percent in early 2000. And I'm wondering, Mr. Williams, have you seen that as the--are the total deposits continuing to just go to the big giants? And is it possible for a small bank--I've heard one banker say that it's not possible for a bank under a billion dollars in assets to even survive today. And have you seen more of your time and expenses being devoted to compliance costs as compared to say when you started in the banking business? Mr. Williams. Oh, my goodness, yes. When we started the bank, we actually didn't have a compliance officer, and we treated the consumer better than we do today. Now we have a number of compliance officers, we have an unbelievable regulatory burden, and essentially all of that cost has to be passed onto the consumer, it's passed onto the investors, but it's not a productive cost. The fundamental factor about compliance is complexity favors the large. I'm going to say that again because it's important. Complexity favors the large. The regulations from Dodd-Frank would fill several phone books. Just paying an attorney to read them is a significant expense. That's not a problem for Bank of America, but for Gulf Coast Bank, it is a big deal Mr. Duncan. What are your total assets? What size is your bank? Mr. Williams. A billion 450. Mr. Duncan. Is it possible for a small bank to survive today, or it's certainly becoming much harder, isn't it? Mr. Williams. It is, but it's more difficult. It's a challenge, and the more regulation you have, the larger you have to be to succeed. And we've raised the level of complexity to the point that it's very challenging for the very small banks, the 100- to 200- million to make money. And unfortunately, we don't go back and relook at the regulations. We say that we will, but we add 16,000 bricks to the wagon, we take away three, and as a banking industry, we're supposed to applaud that effort. The regulations never decrease. They only increase. Mr. Duncan. The more any industry becomes Federally regulated, the more regulated it becomes, the more it ends up in the hands of a few big giants. Thank you, Mr. Chairman Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Lynch for 5 minutes Mr. Lynch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Look, I actually love my community banks. Those are the banks that are making the loans, doing the mortgages, helping folks out in my community, and I actually have sponsored a regulatory relief bill for community banks because they are making the loans and out doing all those crazy stuff with derivatives. They've got adequate capital, and they are engaged as traditional banks. But I do want to look at the data here, because I don't think there's a conspiracy within the FDIC to basically, you know, manipulate the application process to stop banks from coming into existence, and that seems to be the suggestion here today. If you look at the data, in 1985 we had 18,000 banks. Today, we've got a little over 6,000. It's almost a two-thirds decline, but if you look at what happened, about 85 percent of those banks went out of business because they merged with other banks and they became bigger and bigger. As a matter of fact, as my colleague just pointed out, the 10 biggest banks back in 1985, they had 19 percent of industry assets, but today, they're closing in on 60 percent. Those 10 banks control almost 60 percent of industry assets. So we've got these huge whales out there that are basically gobbling up these other banks, and that's not healthy. But it is not the application process that is causing that. At the same time, we've got a very, very low interest rate environment. We've got very, very low margins here. Between-- you know, if you take deposits, and you know, you're getting very low interest on that and you have to lend out your money at a very low interest rate to be competitive, there's a very low margin of interest for banks, so it's tough to operate in this environment. So I don't think there's any secret plot out there. It's just a tough environment, and that's why, not surprisingly, de novo bank applications are down. They're--it's just a tough time to try to get into the business. And I do want to say that, you know, that idea of reducing the regulatory burden for community banks is a good one, and I know that Tom Hennig from--he's on the board, right, on your board, Mr. Chairman? He's got some good ideas. He actually sat down with a number of the members on both sides of the aisle here, and we think that we can come up with a good regulatory relief bill for community banks that are doing the right thing and just trying to help local small businesses, and that's the direction we should be going in. But let me ask Mr. Johnson, is there something I am missing here? Apart from what I laid out in terms of the consolidation going on, the small number of banks that are in existence today and the pressures, or do you really think there is this conspiracy out there or some type of nefarious plot to, you know, to stop banks from coming into existence? Mr. Johnson. Mr. Lynch, I don't think there's any kind of conspiracy. There's a longstanding process of consolidation in the industry, which was prompted by Congress, by the way, when it repealed the restrictions on interstate banking. So that's what happened, historically, and as banks were able to spread across States, you got the prospect of consolidation. The one big thing we haven't talked about today, perhaps, is economies of scale in banking due to technology. So the fact you have pretty demanding information technology requirements is another squeeze on the banks under $100 million, and this has been looked at carefully by the FDIC, among others. Economies of scale, so in terms of what your costs are relative to your assets, they come down quite quickly until you get down to about $100 million, in assets, and then it flattens out. So this is more pressure on that lower--the smaller banks, historically, they were more important than they are today. And from a de novo bank, it raises the amount of capital that you need up front because you've got to get to that economies of scale. That just reinforces what you're saying, Mr. Lynch. Mr. Lynch. Okay. So we have a list that the FDIC looks at when somebody applies to get a charter. The financial history and condition of the depository institution, adequacy of capital, future earnings prospects, general character of fitness of the management, risk presented by depository institutions to the deposit insurance fund, convenience, needs of the community, and whether its corporate powers are consistent with the purpose of the act. Do we think any of those are inappropriate that we might be able to reduce the number of factors, or do we think those are all sound? Mr. Gruenberg. I think our experience is those are pretty much basic considerations for a bank application. Mr. Lynch. Okay. My friends at the American Bank Association, any of those factors you think are overbearing or---- Mr. Williams. The factors have been the same factors for a number of years. The dilemma is the application where at one time it was relatively easy to start a new bank. Now it is incredibly difficult, and I think we've use the pendulum example. It's gone too far. If you prevent a single bank failure, you'll also prevent an awful lot of success. You know, in my other life I'm a pilot, and I fly medical patients to get treatment. Well, over the 20 years I've done this, we've noticed a significant improvement in cancer treatment. It's because they've tried a lot of things that didn't work. Well, new banks will fail, but they present a trivial risk to the system in the fund. But if you stop new banks from failing, you also stop banks from succeeding, and a bank like mine doesn't exist, the community is weaker. And in a small town, if you don't have a hometown bank, you really don't have a vital economy. Mr. Lynch. Right, right, right. So you're looking to strike that balance. Mr. Williams. Yeah, and I think we've struck--we've gone too far the direction of no failure. Mr. Lynch. Okay. I've abused my time. I want to thank the gentleman for his courtesy. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Carter for 5 minutes. Mr. Carter. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank all of you for being here. I would certainly be remiss if I didn't comment on what--on one of the comments that was just made about the mergers that have taken place in the banking industry here in recent years. Let's keep in mind, a lot of those mergers weren't necessarily wanted. A lot of them were fire sales, a bank selling to bigger banks before they went into business. You know, full disclosure here. First of all, I've served on community bank boards. Full disclosure, I'm a small businessman. If it weren't for a community bank, I would not have been able to start my small business. I went into business November 21stof 1988, and it was because a small community bank was willing to extend me credit to open up my business, so I am a big community bank fan. And I will tell you, Mr. Williams, I couldn't agree with you more. When I was serving on the bank board previously to becoming a member of Congress 18 months ago, the only new hires we were making were compliance officers. That was all we could do was every time we'd make some money, we'd hire a new compliance officer. That was the only thing we could do. Mr. Gruenberg, I want to ask you: Do you know what bank deserts are? What are bank deserts? Can you just briefly tell me. Mr. Gruenberg. I'm not--I'm sorry I'm not familiar with the term. Mr. Carter. When I would refer--it was a term we kind of used in Georgia. You're aware of what's happened in Georgia? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, sir. Mr. Carter. I believe Georgia leads the Nation in the number of banks that have closed since all this started. You know, and listen, I've listened to all of you during the day, and I know you all agree that community banks are important and they're necessary and we've got to have them, but bank deserts exist in both rural and urban areas, particularly in rural areas. In the State of Georgia we have 159 counties. We've got 48 counties that don't have a locally chartered bank. That would be referred to as a bank desert. Nationwide, there are 654 bank deserts in rural communities and 351 in urban areas. What we don't have a locally chartered bank. Chairman Gruenberg, can you tell me, it sounds like what you have articulated here today that you're concerned, that the FDIC is concerned about these bank deserts and the need for community banks. But I'm still not clear, when we talk about the convenience and need to the community, what you mean by that? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, first of all, Congressman. You're correct. I think we're very concerned about it. Community banks play a critical role, but large institutions really cannot fail for exactly the point that you were making. Community banks do relationship lending, particularly with small business. That is very hands on, and that is not the kind of business large institutions are interested in. So they really fill a critical--let me just come to your--so your question is, if you could just---- Mr. Carter. So you acknowledge that. Tell me what you're doing about it. Mr. Gruenberg. Oh, look, the--we want to do everything we can to---- Mr. Carter. I know there's a different in want and in doing. Tell me what you're doing about it. Mr. Gruenberg. Well, so we can't change the interest rate environment. That's not under our authority. What we can try to do that's within our authority is at least to try to make the application process, the groups interested in forming a bank, as user friendly and reduce the cost, and to the extent we can, reduce the reliance on what can be expensive consultants for a group to put together a new financial institution. I think that's a contribution we can make, and we are looking at ways to do that. Mr. Carter. Okay. I've got very limited time, and I've got to--let me ask you, Chairman Gruenberg, how many bank charters were approved last year? How many new bank charters were approved last year? Mr. Gruenberg. I believe just one, Congressman. Mr. Carter. One? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes. Mr. Carter. Did you say one? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes. No, we--at the end of my testimony, we provide a chart listing all the new charters, and what we've really had is an unprecedented experience in the period since the financial crisis. We really have not seen--we haven't-- we've only a handful of new charters and only a handful of applications, because we have an economic environment that's extraordinarily challenging to start a new institution. I think that's the point that was made earlier. Mr. Carter. But how are you going to help? I mean, you know, we need to help these people. Mr. Gruenberg. I agree, but we can't---- Mr. Carter. We've got 48 out of 159 counties in the State of Georgia that do not have a locally chartered bank. If small community banks go away, small business goes away. Mr. Gruenberg. I couldn't agree more, Congressman. We don't--community banks in particular---- Mr. Carter. But what I'm hearing--I'm sorry, but what I'm hearing is that that is the problem. There's no transparency, that the process is difficult, it's hard it navigate. Mr. Gruenberg. If you look at our Web site, and our application and the requirements are there for everyone to see, which I think is the bottom line, and we do work actively with any groups, we are prepared, and we'll look at our procedures for deposit insurance applications and try to make them as user friendly as we can. Mr. Carter. Okay. Well, my time has expired. But I've got to tell you, small business is what made America. Mr. Gruenberg. I agree. Mr. Carter. And this is killing us. We have got to have it. And we need help. We need to make it easier. Now, we need to make sure these de novo banks, we need to make sure these community banks survive. If they don't survive, small business is not going to survive. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. I'll now recognize the gentlewoman from New York, Mrs. Maloney, for 5 minutes. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you very much. And I would like to discuss the too big to fail and living wills for large financial institutions. Professor Johnson mentioned earlier in testimony, when we had the crisis that cost this Nation $15 to $18 trillion in lost homes, lost jobs, the worst--and it was caused by mismanagement, the first major financial crisis in our history that could have been prevented with better regulation and management of banks. And he alluded to the problem that we faced: We could either let it fail, like we did with Lehman, or we could bail it out, like we did with AIG. Neither response was a good one. So in Dodd-Frank, we came forward, saying that the largest financial institutions would be required to submit to regulators, including the FDIC, a resolution plan to be implemented in the case that they failed, and these plans were called the living wills. And if a bank consistently fails to provide credible plans, Dodd-Frank permits regulators to increase the bank's capital, liquidity, and leverage ratio requirements, or even to require the bank to divest certain assets or operations. So, Professor Johnson, could you please explain why Dodd- Frank permits these penalties? Mr. Johnson. Yes, Congresswoman. The point, very simply, is exactly what you are referring to, which is we would like every firm in this country to be able to go bankrupt, potentially, without any kind of government intervention. I think that's a completely shared goal. And that is the case of the nonfinancial sector. It is not the case, as we learned vividly in 2008, for the financial sector. So the living wills are supposed to be a documentation provided to the regulators that demonstrates beyond a reasonable doubt, presumably, that these large financial firms can fail without the FDIC or anyone else being involved. So that's Title I of Dodd-Frank. Title II, ordered liquidation authority, is a backup in case the bankruptcy process doesn't work. But the FDIC and the Federal Reserve are supposed to be completely confident, by reviewing the living wills, that these banks can fail without any kind of government involvement or government financial assistance or temporary loan or anything. So that's, I think, a completely reasonable goal that should be shared across the political spectrum. Mrs. Maloney. Okay. These penalties are really sticks to encourage banks to file credible plans, but they are effective only if banks know regulators will use them. And since 2013, banks have had four chances to get this right, but regulators say that most of the plans still have shortcomings. This year, the FDIC found the plans of five banks are not credible, and these five banks must resubmit their plans by October 1. So, Chairman Gruenberg, if the living wills continue to be deficient in October, you have the authority to impose penalties at that time in order to protect the taxpayers. Is that right? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, Congresswoman. Mrs. Maloney. And the plans being submitted this October, in some cases the fifth attempts by some of the largest banks to have credible plans, and the banks have shown that their resolution plans are due since the Dodd-Frank--they've known that they have to do this since 2010, yet five banks are still not getting it right. And no penalties have been imposed for their failures to produce credible resolution plans. So my question, Professor Johnson, how can the public and the banks be sure that the FDIC is serious about obtaining credible living wills if they are not, you know, putting these penalties forward? And then I'd also like the chairman to answer. So, Professor Johnson. Mr. Johnson. Yes, Congresswoman, I think it's a very big question. And, of course, it's not just the FDIC. It's the FDIC and the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. They act together in this. And I'm afraid, for precisely the reason that you identified, because we haven't seen any of these remedial actions required, I'm afraid that public confidence in the FDIC and the Fed with regards to having viable living wills that really would keep the taxpayers off the hook and give us much broader financial system stability, I'm afraid confidence in that is low, and I would presume it will decline further. Mrs. Maloney. Chairman. Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah, Congresswoman. So, as you know, the eight most systemically important financial institutions submitted resolution plans, living wills, last year, and those plans were reviewed jointly by the FDIC and the Fed. And we've recently issued evaluations of those plans. And of the eight, the Federal Reserve and the FDIC jointly found five of them to be noncredible. That's the standard under the statute. And the statute provides that if we make that joint determination, we, together, have to issue a notice of deficiencies laying out the inadequacies of the plan, which we did. And all of that was made public in the course of releasing these evaluations. And as you indicated, we gave those institutions until October 1 to submit plans addressing those deficiencies, and we'll then be at the point of having to evaluate their responsiveness. And as you indicated, the law provides this authority, that if the plans don't address the deficiencies, we have the authority to impose additional prudential requirements relating to capital liquidity leverage, as well as constraints on activities. And that's a decision we're going to have to make once those submissions are made October 1. Mrs. Maloney. Mr. Chairman, may I do a follow-up question to his answer? You've had four times to have an evaluation. This is the fifth time, correct? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes. Mrs. Maloney. And the other four times that you've had an evaluation, you haven't come in with the penalties that Dodd- Frank gives you. And so when my--you know, I was one of the participants in the conference committee on Dodd-Frank, as you know, and I support it. But how do we know--and I think people that are critical have a right to be somewhat critical--that it's going to be implemented if you're not implementing it? What's different this time? Are we going to be going to plan 6, 7, 8, 9, 10? Mr. Gruenberg. As you may know, Congresswoman, it requires a joint determination. Mrs. Maloney. Yeah, joint, I know, realize. Mr. Gruenberg. And the FDIC in a previous round had failed the institutions, but we didn't reach joint agreement. I do think what's important is that in this round we did reach a joint agreement on five of the plans, and we're now in a position to see the institutions, presumably, address these deficiencies, or if not, then, you know, there are authorities under the law that would be available to us. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentlewoman. Mrs. Maloney. Could I just ask him to submit to you what your outcome is, since we are distracted? Chairman Chaffetz. Sure. That would be good. Mrs. Maloney. This is a very important financial security, safety, and soundness issue, and I think to present your findings, since we are--they are not coming to us, they are coming to you. So I think to give us those--that information would be helpful. Mr. Gruenberg. Okay. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you. Mr. Gruenberg. Sure. Chairman Chaffetz. When will we have those? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I'm assuming relating to the evaluations that were made? Mrs. Maloney. Yes. Mr. Gruenberg. And that's a matter of public record, and we'd be glad to provide that to the committee. Chairman Chaffetz. We now recognize the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman, for 5 minutes. Mr. Grothman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We've had several questions before, but when I talk to my smaller banks, going back to what Congresswoman Carter said, all they're doing is hiring compliance officers, which, obviously, is in some cases just is squeezing, you know, the amounts you've got to in deposits or whatever. In other cases, it's causing a lot of buyouts, because these smaller banks, they just can't afford to operate and they allow themselves to be bought out and that sort of thing. Have you kept track of the huge cost to the banking system of the additional compliance? Do you have a dollar figure you can put on that? Mr. Gruenberg. You know, we've actually--it's tough to quantify. Clearly, it's meaningful, particularly for the 4,000 institutions in the United States with assets under $250 million. I think for those institutions the cost of regulatory compliance is significant. As a technical matter, it's tough to quantify, but there's no doubt that it's meaningful. And, look, I think, from the standpoint of the bank regulators, we want to find ways to reduce regulatory burden and cost. We have been undertaking a review as required by the law. I think there are areas we can address, including simplifying capital, risk-based capital compliance, appraisal thresholds. These community banks have raised particular concerns about call report burden. I think there are a number of areas where we can and are planning to take steps that will actually reduce burden and cost, and I think, to the extent we can, we really should do that. Mr. Grothman. Thank you. Mr. Johnson. Congressman, I have some data. Can I give you the data on this? It's actually from Mr. Browning's testimony. This is drawing from the Richmond Fed's research and the Fed's research, and it's consistent with what the FDIC has also published. Now, I'm not trying to trivialize these expenses and costs at all, including for certain segments of the market, but if you take on average what Mr. Browning's testimony says, he's quoting these academics, the increase is relatively small and, more importantly, the size of the expense is just too small to have a big effect on bank profitability. Mr. Grothman. Like too many professors, you've got to get out of the university and spend more time talking to small bankers. Mr. Johnson. I'm sorry, this is the data, Congressman, this is the data, and I do spend a lot of time working with the private sector, with all due respect, in my university---- Mr. Grothman. That's okay. We have 5 minutes, and I intended to talk to Chairman Gruenberg here. There's been a huge drop in the number of banks. Do you consider that a bad thing? I mean, you know, a lot of local people say, and maybe it's consistent with my experience, you get better service from the small local bank. Do you view that as a bad thing that we have such a huge drop in the number of banks we've had since a few years ago. Mr. Gruenberg. I don't view it as a good thing. No, I don't, Congressman. Mr. Grothman. Are you doing anything to make sure that these smaller banks are able to keep going? Do you view this as a fundamental problem. I realize it's not all yours. I mean, obviously, the people who voted for Dodd-Frank wanted to finish off a lot of these small banks too. But what are you doing to make sure that we keep these small banks going and they aren't forced to be bought out? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I think it is part of our responsibility. A strong community banking sector has enormous value for the financial system and the economy. I think we want to find ways to reduce regulatory burden and costs. I think that's one way we can do it. We have tried to make our supervision of institutions risk-based and appropriate to the nature of the institution. So for a smaller, simpler bank, we're able to do exams less frequently and try to do it in a way that's really appropriate to the model of the institution. So both in terms of trying to reduce regulatory burden and doing our supervision in a way that's responsive to the business of the bank, those are the two things we can do. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Now, I get a concern, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, okay, that insofar as they get involved here, standards that were meant for bigger banks are kind of seeping down to the smaller banks. Is there anything you can do about that to make sure this doesn't happen anymore? Mr. Gruenberg. I think this so-called trickle-down issue is certainly one of the things we hear about from the bankers. And we work pretty hard to make clear that whatever obligations are imposed on the larger institutions are not expected of the smaller institutions, and we try to make that very clear in our supervisory program. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I can see, and Mr. Williams wants to speak down here, just one second. Would you, Mr. Williams? Mr. Williams. Sure. Yeah. I mean, will all respect, the unfortunate consequence of the trickle down is that the regulations like Basel that were intended for the most complex banks are pushed down to community banks like ours. And then you have the pernicious effect of best practices. It becomes a best practice, and then we have to do it. So it may not be a regulation, but then it becomes a best practice, and then it gets pushed down to a billion-dollar bank, then to a 500 billion, and then things that don't make economic sense and weren't intended for banks like ours become realities. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Chairman Gruenberg, could you do something in which you can have a hard rule to make sure this stuff doesn't become best practice or doesn't affect people? Mr. Gruenberg. I think we have a pretty clear policy. I mean, I'll glad to come back to you on that. But we have to try to make it very clear in all of our guidance that expectations for large institutions are not imposed on smaller institutions. Mr. Grothman. Well, my experience, talking to my bankers, is the same as Mr. Williams. I mean, your expectations aren't being realized. And there's a lot of fear out there on that. I guess I've used up my time, but thanks. I really hope--you know, maybe people are afraid to talk to you. But when I talk to my small banks, well, I think over time your people become friendlier. We, right now, there's a perception we hate small banks in this country. It's not entirely your fault. It's also the fault of the people who put together that Dodd-Frank bill. But I wish we'd get back to the days in which we have more small banks and they aren't being forced into being merged. Thanks much. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. We now recognize the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Palmer, for 5 minutes. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just want to point out, in regard to the impact of Dodd- Frank on small banks, that Harvard found that small banks lost 6 percent of their share of industry assets during the financial crisis, but since Dodd-Frank they've lost 12 percent. So I do think that validates that we're losing community banks as a result of Dodd-Frank. I think Frank Keating, the president of the American Bankers Association, said we're losing one bank a day, 7 days a week. So it is a problem, and particularly in context to the answer you gave Mr. Carter about how many new banks the FDIC approved last year. Did you say one? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, sir. Mr. Palmer. That is problematic for a lot of us who represent rural counties, and I think practically all of us in Congress have some rural counties. I grew up in a rural community, and our community bank was extremely important to us. Let me ask you this. Why have you been able to approve--why have you been unable to approve the creation of more community banks? What's the holdup? Mr. Gruenberg. This has been a subject of discussion during the course of the hearing, but at least it's--as far as we can tell, we've had an extraordinarily, nearly unprecedented economic environment, really, in the aftermath of the financial crisis and recession. It's been the longest prolonged period of near-zero interest rates, really, in our country's history. And community banks make money by making loans and charging interest. So when you have a very low or zero interest rate environment, it becomes a significant obstacle to establishing a new institution. We think that's the core issue. As the economy can continue to progress and we see some rise in interest rates, we're expecting to see some increased activity. What is under our control is the process and procedures for submitting an application and working through an application process, and that may be the area where we can make a contribution to facilitating those institutions. Mr. Palmer. I don't disagree that the economic conditions are a part of the problem. But I think one of the reasons that our economy--for instance, our economy has grown 1.55 percent over the last 8 years. The 70-year average is 3 percent. You want to talk about something that's unprecedented. And I think a large part of that is due to the regulatory environment. We've seen record numbers of proposed rules. I think 2011 was somewhere north of 84,000. That record was broken in 2015. I think we'll probably break that record again this year. I think we're on pace for that, maybe. And as has been pointed out already, I think the biggest uptick in hiring in banks has been people to comply with regulations. And one of the things that we've got to do in this, I think, in trying to help our banks, but also to help the economy, is untangle them from all these regulations. Let me ask you this. If the FDIC is open to accepting new bank applications, where in the field is the breakdown occurring? And are your field examiners or other senior staff meeting with potential applicants expressing other concerns? Mr. Gruenberg. No. Look, I think our people are ready and available, and we certainly work closely with the groups that have an interest. I can only say that it's--I think the economic environment remains a challenging one, that's why we're actually seeing, at least thus far, only a handful of applications. Mr. Palmer. Well, one of the things that interests me in this. FDIC routinely uses financial institutional letters to announce changes for de novo banks. Stakeholders are unable to comment on these. And why does the FDIC choose to utilize a financial institutional letter and then not give stakeholders the opportunity to come in? You know, that might be a way to improve the application process. Mr. Gruenberg. You know, we have just put out our application--existing application for public comment to take comments from industry and participants on how we can improve it and simplify it. So we do seek public comment. Financial institution letters are a means we used to communicate with the industry and to provide guidance to them. Mr. Palmer. Don't you think more participation by the folks who are interested in starting a bank would be helpful? Mr. Browning, if I may, I'd like to ask you a question. Did you participate in any meetings prior to your filing with the FDIC, and would a meeting like that have been helpful? Mr. Browning. Well, thank you, Congressman. We engaged in a long series of conversations before our prefiling meeting. We held that prefiling meeting jointly with the San Francisco FDIC as well, as Washington, D.C., FDIC. From that prefiling meeting is when things got a little curious for us. Mr. Palmer. Did you receive any communications from the FDIC, you know, on why they would not accept your application? Mr. Browning. So we never actually formally filed an application, because we could never gain clarity on what was actually required to submit an application that would be deemed complete. We held a series of conversations for many, many months but could never gain that clarity. Mr. Palmer. So you had trouble getting any clear communications that would have helped you in your process? Mr. Browning. Yes, Congressman. And the statutory requirements that have been longstanding are themselves clear and, I believe, adequate. What is different today, as Mr. Williams explained, the pendulum has swung, is the interpretation and application of those requirements and the authenticity that they're applied within certain segments of the FDIC. Mr. Palmer. If I may, Mr. Chairman, just one more question. It's my understanding the FDIC does not track prefile meetings because these are optional. Is that correct? Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah, I believe that's---- Mr. Palmer. And if it is, why aren't you documenting this? Mr. Gruenberg. I don't think we have a problem with doing them. They are voluntarily. Some applicants utilize them. We encourage them. But since it's an informal prefiling process, it's not something we would track as part of the application process. We certainly can do that, and as I indicated, at the outset, we're undertaking a review of our procedures relating to deposit insurance applications. So that's certainly something we can consider. Mr. Palmer. I hope you will. I hope you will implement that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. We now recognize the gentleman from South Carolina, Mr. Mulvaney. Mr. Mulvaney. Staying right there, Mr. Gruenberg, on the prefiling of meetings, can you do that on your own initiative or would it help if we made the formal request? Mr. Gruenberg. We can certainly do that on your own initiative, Congressman. Mr. Mulvaney. Got you. Here's why I think you are hearing so many of us pound on this lack of new entry into the market. And, Mr. Johnson, it's good to see you, again. Mr. Johnson and I have talked several times over in the House Financial Services Committee. While he and I don't agree on many things, what we probably will agree on, that if you see an industry that is seeing increasing in profits--and certainly one of the criticisms of the financial services industry is they are actually making money--typically, Dr. Johnson, what we would see is a flow of new entries. New capital will go into someplace that's actually making money. So there's a disconnect here. And I hear what you're saying about the environment being tough for new entrants because of low interest rates, but, clearly, somebody is making money. And I don't have a problem with that. Yes, Mr. Johnson, I will, I promise, I'm last, so they will probably give me a little bit more time. But I want to stay on this a second. Let me ask you. Let's drill down a little bit more. You don't track your prefile meetings, how many applications did you actually formally begin, say, last year? You said you approved one. How many actually formally started the process? Mr. Gruenberg. I was corrected by our staff. For what it's worth, there were two applications approved last year. Mr. Mulvaney. How many actually got started? Mr. Gruenberg. And two--yeah, two applications were received. Mr. Mulvaney. So you approved two of two? That's fascinating. Mr. Gruenberg. I'm sorry. One of those was received in 2014. Mr. Mulvaney. Okay. I'm sorry, how long? Mr. Gruenberg. No, one of the applications was received in 2014. Mr. Mulvaney. How long is it supposed to take to get your bank approved? Mr. Gruenberg. As I indicated, the average period from 2000 till today for approving applications tends to be 4 to 6 months, but it can take longer in individual cases. Mr. Mulvaney. Out of the two that you approved last year, how long did each one of those take? Mr. Gruenberg. Apparently, within that timeframe, Congressman. Mr. Mulvaney. Maybe I misunderstood. I thought I heard-- again, we're talking over each other a little bit--that one of the applications that was approved this year was received in 2014. Is that not right? Mr. Gruenberg. Let us come back to be clear. But I believe it was received in 2014 and approved in 2015. Mr. Mulvaney. Okay. Mr. Gruenberg. But let us come back to you to get it right. Mr. Mulvaney. Let me ask this. Mr. Browning, you said that there are some statutory requirements on how long is this supposed to take? Did I hear that correctly? Mr. Browning. Well, there is clear criteria on how to evaluate--on what basis to evaluate an application, and the FDIC's internal guidelines suggest that an application review process should be expeditious. Its track record, as the chairman has stated, is typically in the 3- to 6-month range. But it says only in unique or extenuating circumstances should it take longer and certainly no more than a year. Mr. Mulvaney. I won't ask the question about whether or not everybody believes that new entry into the market is healthy, because I think other folks have asked you that question. And everybody, universally, has said that it is, whether you are running the Deposit Insurance Corporation or you're an academic or actually in the business, that new entrance is helpful. Mr. Gruenberg, you said you were doing some things to help encourage that, and said you were trying to reduce--you said regulatory burden can act as a barrier to entry. By the way, off the top of your head, do you know of any portions of Dodd-Frank that, perhaps, shouldn't be applied to community banks? Mr. Gruenberg. We--I don't know about--I don't know that I have a comment on that, Congressman, off the top. Mr. Mulvaney. Well, if you wouldn't, who would? I mean, I think we all admit that Dodd-Frank, even those of us who oppose it--I wasn't here at the time--was designed to supposedly prevent another meltdown with the large financial institutions. It was not intended to deal with, necessarily, the community banks that weren't at all involved during the financial meltdown. In fact, some places were actually profitable during that time. You've heard testimony that said there is a trickle-down theory. So my question to you is, have you seen the trickle- down theory, and can you name any portions of Dodd-Frank that were never intended for, perhaps, smaller financial institutions but that have ultimately impacted them? Mr. Gruenberg. One area we've tried to be clear about is that, you know, Dodd-Frank does require stress tests for institutions over $10 billion. Mr. Mulvaney. Right. Mr. Gruenberg. And I think there was a concern that relates to this trickle-down issue that we were effectively subjecting the smaller institutions to the stress test requirements. Mr. Mulvaney. What about the Volcker rule, do you think that should apply to small banks? Mr. Gruenberg. The Volcker rule as finally approved, actually, for small--if a small bank does not engage in the activities relating to the Volcker rule, there's no compliance. Mr. Mulvaney. You're absolutely right, except they have a regulatory burden to prove that they don't participate, don't they? Mr. Gruenberg. Only if--they simply have to have a policy statement stating that. And even if they do engage in it, all that's required of them, as I understand it, is a policy statement as to how they engage the activity. Mr. Mulvaney. You mentioned in response, I think, to Mr. Carter that you had taken steps to reduce the regulatory burden on small banks. By the way, did I hear you correctly say it costs about a million dollars to do this? Mr. Gruenberg. To start a new institution? Mr. Mulvaney. Yes, sir. Mr. Gruenberg. I think that's the average cost, yes. Mr. Mulvaney. And I also heard you say that the minimum amounts you would like to see in terms of capital are someplace about 2 million, but that the average is someplace around $10 to $20. Mr. Gruenberg. I think--yes, sir. Mr. Mulvaney. Does that ratio bother you at all, that it might take up to 50 percent of my working capital to get approved for my bank? Mr. Gruenberg. To the extent we can lower the cost in regard to the million dollars that you are referring to? Mr. Mulvaney. Correct. Mr. Gruenberg. To the extent we can lower that, and a lot of that, as you know, is accounted for by legal representation or utilization of consultants, to the extent we can help reduce that, that's---- Mr. Mulvaney. Can you give us two or three examples of the ways you've reduced the regulatory burden or the costs in the last year? If we are trying to encourage new entries, can you give us two or three real examples of what the FDIC is doing to reduce those barriers to entry? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, we had considerable concern by smaller institutions in regard to so-called S Chapter banks and how they dividend down, and we were able to adopt a policy to make it clear that they can dividend down to their shareholders, which was an important--and that's a large number of community banks. Mr. Mulvaney. Yeah, but that only--okay. Mr. Gruenberg. It's several thousands, I think, are---- Mr. Mulvaney. But it hasn't worked, right? I mean, you've only got two applications and you got two approvals, it hasn't encouraged new entry into the market. Mr. Gruenberg. No, I thought you were speaking generally to regulatory burden on community banks. Mr. Mulvaney. I'm asking what you meant by encourage new entry. Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah, I think the--well, probably the most significant thing we've done during the crisis, because de novo banks were failing at twice the rate of the industry as a whole, we have a--had a 3-year monitoring period for new institutions. During the crisis we extended that to 7 years in an effort to reduce the number of failures. Now that we're past the crisis, earlier this year we were able to eliminate that extension and went back to the 3-year monitoring period, which is something, I think, the industry thought was worth doing. Mr. Mulvaney. I could go on, but I'm already way over my time. You've been very gracious, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Chaffetz. The gentleman is free to ask another set of questions in another round. But let me go, first, to Mrs. Maloney of New York. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is really a very interesting hearing, and I thank all the panelists. Chairman Cummings, regrettably, had to go to another meeting, he has a conflict, but he asked me to get some clarification on Mr. Browning's testimony. In your testimony, and you talk about your startup on your LinkedIn page, and you state that you, and I quote, quote, ``led strategy and execution of a de novo bank charter application,'' end quote. You also say on your LinkedIn page that you, and I quote, ``halted filing, due to the Volcker rule constraints, at a parent company.'' I would first like to ask our resident professor, Professor Johnson, if you would give us a good definition of the Volcker rule. It is thrown around in every discussion. Give us a good definition of the Volcker rule. Mr. Johnson. Well, the Volcker rule, which is complex in its details, is designed to reduce or eliminate--substantially reduce proprietary trading by financial institutions, by banks. So this should be--you shouldn't--you're not allowed, if you are a bank, to engage in more than a small amount of trading in securities for your own--using your own capital for your own account. So it's separation of client activity from proprietary trading. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you. So, Mr. Browning, my question is, you said on your, as I said, your LinkedIn page, that you halted it due to the Volcker rule constraints. Exactly what were the Volcker rule constraints that prevented you from moving forward with Sterne Agee's FDIC application? It's a question to Mr. Browning. Mr. Browning. Yes, thank you, Congresswoman. This simply, without getting into the extremely complex mechanics of the Volcker rule, which I'm happy to follow up with you on, this came down to a business tradeoff. The business, Sterne Agee, had been around for a century. It had multiple avenues to pursue. It was pursuing actively a bank charter, and that was its primary focus, where it was going to dedicate substantial capital. As we worked through the process, we felt we would never actually achieve the desired end result of gaining a deposit insurance and a bank charter. And, therefore, Sterne Agee made a business decision to halt that process, go into another line of business that involved the Volcker rule, and as a result of that, we could not pursue the bank charter any further. It basically foreclosed that option for Sterne Agee. But it was a business decision predicated on the fact of our experience in the application process and the lack of clarity, what we deemed an inauthentic application of those statutory criteria, that we would never be successful. So decisions at the parent company were made to pursue another course that took them down a path engaging in Volcker rule activities. Mrs. Maloney. Well, Mr. Cummings is very interested in this, and he would like to know, specifically, even though it's complicated, what prevented you, so you said, your application? How did the Volcker rule prevent you from going forward? And also, he wanted to note that you did not provide the committee with any documents. The FDIC has produced documents in response to the committee's request. And one of those documents, dated May 27, 2014, provides information regarding the Sterne Agee. This document states that the bank would be owned by Sterne Agee, a brokerage firm, and would, quote, ``be funded via sweep accounts from consumer brokerage accounts,'' end quote. So, Mr. Browning, is it correct that your proposed ILC would have been funded primarily in this manner? Mr. Browning. So that is very different from the Volcker rule implications. But, Congresswoman, yes, you're correct. Using sweep deposits, these are deposits from Sterne Agee, they have retail one-on-one client relationships with these brokerage account holders, those deposits are swept into other banks today. Having that primary account relationship, we were to take a small portion of those deposits to sweep them into this bank. All of those deposits are FDIC insured in other banks today. There were roughly four to five times the volume of deposits in that program that this bank needed, so we were planning to take a small portion of those deposits. Mrs. Maloney. Okay. Professor--my final question--Professor Johnson, what are bank sweeps, and are they as stable a source of capital for a bank or other sources? And if I may, because this is a deeply debated issue before Congress, if you could get back to us in writing, even though it's complicated and intricate, exactly how the Volcker rule would have prevented you. Mrs. Maloney. But the last question is to Mr. Johnson. Yes. Mr. Johnson. So Mr. Browning can correct me, but my understanding of this in general would be these are funds that clients have made available for trading, buying, and selling securities. And you, obviously, have some cash available, because you've sold something or because you're planning to buy something and you haven't yet bought it. I believe what they're going--what they'll be doing is sweeping that out of an account, which perhaps was held at another bank--I'm not sure about that--and sweeping it into their bank. And the bottom line, Mrs. Maloney, would be this is less stable as a source of funding than a typical retail deposit, which is not subject to daily decisions that people are making. Should I buy securities? Should I sell securities? Those are big decisions relative to the underlying amount of funding. We don't do that, obviously, in our day-to-day retail financial transactions. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you. Does Mr. Browning want to respond? Mr. Browning. We could debate the technical aspects of the program we planned to use, which we've laid out in great detail to the FDIC, to show that these were actually dedicated deposit funds not used for other purposes. They were put into savings account deposit programs to be FDIC insured, and that there was a structure in which these were the last funds to ever be touched. And so it would be mathematically proven to actually be more stable than retail checking accounts. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentlelady. Mr. Johnson, did you ever review, prior to this hearing, the information in Mr. Browning's application? Mr. Johnson. I did have a chance to look at his testimony that was available on the table, and I am quite a quick reader, Mr. Chairman, yes. Chairman Chaffetz. Yeah, I think it's pretty cavalier for you to pass judgment on the entire process by which Mr. Browning was trying to interact with the FDIC and for you to pass judgment on that. But that's my judgment. Mr. Johnson. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman, I didn't speak to that at all, in anything---- Chairman Chaffetz. I think you did. I think the record will reflect it. And I think you were very cavalier about that. We now recognize Mr. Meadows for 5 minutes. Mr. Meadows. Mr. Johnson, we will have a follow-up discussion about the security of sweep accounts versus a traditional deposit relationship at some particular future time. But I can assure you, being very familiar, I don't know that your statement is accurate 100 percent of the time. Would you agree with that? Mr. Johnson. Well, I look forward to discussing these details with you further, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. But would your statement be accurate 100 percent of the time that sweep accounts are not as secure as traditional banking relationship deposit accounts, 100 percent of the time, your sworn testimony? I would challenge you, I would be careful, because it's sworn testimony. Is it 100 percent of the time? Is that an accurate statement? Mr. Johnson. Look, I understand it's sworn testimony. The chairman has already said something about my sworn testimony that I believe is not accurate, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. Mr. Johnson, yes or no? Chairman Chaffetz. You were asked a direct question. We expect a direct answer. Mr. Meadows. A hundred percent of the time? Mr. Johnson. I feel that you are trying to trap me here, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. No, I'm trying to get---- Mr. Johnson. I think it's unfair, and I think it's unreasonable, Mr. Chairman, for you and for Mr. Meadows to put me in this position. Mr. Meadows. Well, it is unreasonable for you to challenge the integrity of someone sitting to your right when your statement may not be accurate 100 percent of the time. Mr. Johnson. Mr. Meadows, I'm not challenging Mr. Browning's integrity, and there's nothing in the record today that will demonstrate to any fair reader that I have challenged his integrity. Mr. Meadows. Well, I would invite you to come to my office, and we'll have a long economic and perhaps financial discussion over coffee that I'll be glad to provide, Mr. Johnson. Mr. Johnson. Mr. Meadows, I will be delighted to have that conversation. Mr. Meadows. All right. Thank you. Mr. Gruenberg, let me come back to you, because there's three different areas that we need to clear up. One is, you have laid out in very, what I would classify as ambiguous terms, how you're going to make sure that new bank applications improve. You've talked in generality, and in the sales environment we would say that's like vaporwear. What I need from you is a business plan. If you were a bank applying for an application for a new charter, based on the ambiguous nature of your plan to improve it, it would be denied. And so I guess what I need are specific timeframes. What can a consumer, wanting to establish a new charter, expect if they have a prediscussion? Because there are comments that you have a don't-call-us-we-will-call-you mentality on those pre- application meetings as it relates--which provides a chilling effect in terms of new application. And I guess the results speak for themselves. If we only had two applications last year, there is a problem somewhere. Wouldn't you agree with that. Mr. Gruenberg. I agree with that. Mr. Meadows. Okay. So here's what I need are specific deadliness, that if someone contacts you--and I don't want to go over historical, because it was much faster prior to 2007 than it is from 2010 to current timeframes--what kind of timeframe can a new charter application expect to get a real response from you? And what are those benchmarks? And so I'd like a business plan. And can you get that to this committee in the next 120 days? Mr. Gruenberg. I think we probably can. Mr. Meadows. Thank you. All right. Further, on all the applications that are either pending or have been denied, do you know what the total market cap that we're looking at? I mean, what would be the capital requirement for all of these? Because Mr. Browning said his was $30 million that he was going to provide, and you said that you can approve most that are $2 to $3 million. What are we looking at? Mr. Gruenberg. I don't think I can tell you off the top of my head. Mr. Meadows. Well, we need to find that, and so that's why I'm asking whether it's in the pre or the official filing. We need to know. Because when we're talking about saving the American taxpayer's dollar, you could potentially approve 100 percent of these, and we're talking about a gnat on an elephant's back in terms of other regulatory compliance issues in the banking industry. Wouldn't you agree? That these are small potential risk to the American taxpayer. Mr. Gruenberg. Let us see if we can get back to you on that. Mr. Meadows. Would you agree that it's small relative to the entire financial institutions? But you can get me a market cap on what we're looking at, the potential? Mr. Gruenberg. I think that's what we'll try to do. Mr. Meadows. All right. In that same 120-day timeframe? Mr. Gruenberg. We'll try to do that. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Then the last thing that I would ask from you, Mr. Mulvaney was asking about potential Dodd-Frank compliance issues that should not apply to small or medium- sized banks, and you didn't want to give an official response to that. Here's what I would ask you to do, is officially respond to this committee in writing what Dodd-Frank compliance issue should not come all the way down to the smaller midsize or community banks and what should Congress look at to, perhaps, amend the Dodd-Frank regulations, because it is, perhaps, too onerous on those smaller institutions that do not provide the same risk that a larger institution perhaps. Can you provide three of those within the next 30 days? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I mean, let us go back and take a look at it and we'll come back to you in 30 days with some thoughts on it, if that would be okay. Mr. Meadows. All right. I'll yield back. I thank you. Chairman Chaffetz. Will the gentleman yield to the gentlelady from New York for a moment, please? Mr. Meadows. Sure. Mrs. Maloney. I would also like to add to the gentleman's question Basel III. Now, the complaints that I get from the community banks are the requirements of Basel III, which is international banking. And they say to me, and it makes all the sense to me in the world, we're not involved in international banking. We are involved in helping a community. We're not over in Basel, Switzerland, or any other place. And why do all--and they complain, believe it or not, Mr. Meadows, more in my district, and I have a lot of community banks that saved the city during the financial crisis. They were the only ones providing loans. But in any event, their major concern to me is the Basel III requirements that is just killing them. And I don't see--maybe this is too simplistic--why you can't just say, if you're not involved in international banking, then you don't have to do Basel III requirements. I think that's a simple way to look at it, but then I'm always told, oh, you can't do that. But I am very sympathetic to it. When somebody needs a college loan, when they need a house loan, when they need a small business loan, as Mr. Williams talks about, it's usually 100 percent the community banks that are providing it. And so I'm very sympathetic to the statements of Mr. Mulvaney and Mr. Meadows on this. But I would like to add that too, if Mr. Meadows would allow that, to why--what are the things that you think are in Basel III that are needed for safety and soundness for community banks? It doesn't make any sense to me at all. Mr. Gruenberg. And I think it's fair to say as part of this GPRA review process, the review of the regulatory--regulations issue, one OF the issues that the agencies, the three banking agencies are focused on is simplifying risk-based capital, which would be Basel III, for community banks. To do that it would require a joint rulemaking, so the three of us would need to get together on that. And we are working on that, and I'm hopeful we can come up with a joint proposal in regard to that. Chairman Chaffetz. Thank you. Mr. Gruenberg. A joint proposal. Chairman Chaffetz. We now recognize the gentleman from South Carolina. Mrs. Maloney. He's got his hand up, the community bank. Chairman Chaffetz. Hold up. Let me allow Mr. Williams to add to that, and then we will allow Mr. Mulvaney of South Carolina. Mr. Williams. Just to further your comments on Basel III. I was in Europe this spring. The Europeans are shocked that we apply Basel III to community banks. They said it should really only apply to the 12 or so banks in America. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. We now recognize the gentleman from South Carolina, Mr. Mulvaney. Mr. Mulvaney. To follow up, and I appreciate the opportunity, Mr. Chairman. When we left off, Mr. Gruenberg, we were talking about two or three things that you all have done to try and encourage new entry. And I don't think we finished that conversation. So can you name two or three things you've done in the last, I don't know, 2 or 3 years to try and encourage more entry into this space? Mr. Gruenberg. As I mentioned, we've reduced the monitoring period from 7 to 3 years for de novos. We are holding meetings in regions around the country with interested industry and organizing groups to inform them about the application process. We have--are going to be releasing before the end of this year, and I owe the chairman a report on the date on this, a handbook laying out, essentially a guidebook for applicants interested in accessing deposit insurance. We've issued guidance in a couple of instances trying to clarify the application process itself. Mr. Mulvaney. Okay. Mr. Gruenberg. And we've worked with the State and Federal regulators responsible for chartering institutions, because deposit insurance has to go with the charter as well, so we need to work together if we are going to make the process---- Mr. Mulvaney. I appreciate that and don't want to, and won't, diminish that. But looking at the appendix from your testimony, it seems like maybe we could be doing more, because it doesn't seem to be working, that the numbers seem to be there have been 49 total applications received since 2009 and only 3 have been approved. I'm not real good on math, but that's really close to, like, 6 percent approval. What does return mean in your world, Mr. Gruenberg, on an application? If an application is returned, what does that-- that's not an approval, right? Mr. Gruenberg. No. It's generally when an applicant is unable to satisfy all the application requirements. Mr. Mulvaney. And then a withdrawal would be similar to a return or---- Mr. Gruenberg. When the applicant itself decides to-- chooses to withdraw the application. Mr. Mulvaney. All right. So return is the closest thing to a rejection that you guys do then, I guess, is what it comes down to? Mr. Gruenberg. In order to make a decision on an---- Mr. Mulvaney. It's not that big a deal, because you haven't done one since 2010, so I'm just trying to get the nomenclature right. Mr. Gruenberg. And this is, as you can see from the chart, from the appendix, both of these things occurred in the early part of the decade as well. Mr. Mulvaney. Correct. Okay. And there are two pending, apparently? Chairman Chaffetz. Will the gentleman yield? Mr. Mulvaney. Absolutely. To the chairman, I've learned that that's usually a good practice. Chairman Chaffetz. How many have you rejected? Mr. Gruenberg. Well, I think--the way---- Mr. Mulvaney. If return equals rejection---- Chairman Chaffetz. No, I don't think it does. Mr. Gruenberg. I think with--the general experience is that when an application is going to be rejected, we give the applicant an opportunity to withdraw the application, because as a general matter they prefer that than a formal rejection, which could have some consequence for them. And we try to give them that accommodation. Chairman Chaffetz. But a rejection would have a consequence for you too. Mr. Gruenberg. Yeah. And, look, Congressman, I think, as we talked about, in terms of reviewing the process here, I take your point on that. I think that's something we could look at. Mr. Mulvaney. I thank the chairman. Dr. Johnson, thank you. It's good to see you again. Let's talk about barriers to entry and talk about new capital formation. It's healthy, right? You and I would agree? You and I typically disagree on a lot of thing, but we'd agree new entrants into this space is a good thing. I think you said that earlier. So, in your mind, what could we be doing? If you and I both agree on an end goal, we might disagree on how to get there, but what are your ideas on how to encourage new entrants into this market? Mr. Johnson. So I think we completely agree on this point, Mr. Mulvaney. Just to be clear, though, on the data, you made a very important point at the beginning. You said it's a highly profitable industry, we should expect a lot of entry. That's totally correct. But as we were discussing earlier, the profitability of de novo banks is rather low as an unfortunate, you could say, side effect of the very low Federal funds rates and the low 10-year Treasury rate. Mr. Mulvaney. Yes. Mr. Johnson. Now, as interest rates go up, that will help. Mr. Mulvaney. But let me cut you off there, and I'm sorry to do that, but I get to do that, because I'm on this other side of the aisle, right? I apologize. But you said something else, which is regarding economies of scale. One of the reasons that the small banks can't be as profitable is because they don't have economies of scale. You mentioned specifically technology. Would you agree with me, sir, that there's an economy of scale when it comes to compliance and that it's easier for the big banks to meet the compliance regulations and requirements than it is a small bank? Mr. Johnson. Absolutely. And I think a lot of the discussion here and a lot of the suggestions you're making to the FDIC are completely appropriate. I think we should be asking, are there compliance requirements that are unfair, unreasonable, out of proportion to the risks that are posed? I think that's an entirely reasonable question. The only point I was trying to make was there are other factors which according to the research are very important in the current situation, so don't be too hard on them given the interest rate environment. But as interest rates come back up, we should, to your point, Mr. Mulvaney, exactly expect more entry into the sector. And to also support you, Mr. Mulvaney, if we look at Fintech, so other kinds of financial services where it's not generally funded by an insured bank, right, that's a typical characteristic of fintech, we see a lot of entry into that sector, we see a lot of risk capital, we see a lot of people wanting to provide loans to--particularly away from mortgages to consumers in different ways. So that's---- Mr. Mulvaney. Capital is trying to find a way into this space. Mr. Johnson. Exactly. Exactly. So there are impediments in this sector, no doubt. The impediments are about the structure of banking. The impediments are about the nature of the economies of scale and potentially also the compliance. Fintech, you know, is an end run around some compliance. Maybe that's appropriate. Maybe we should have some concerns about it, separate discussion. But I think we're agreeing, Mr. Mulvaney, more than anything else here. Mr. Mulvaney. And I think it's rare, so I'm enjoying it while it's lasting. I guess my primary point is this, is that if we boil it down to just three barriers to entry, and we know that's not the case, but if the three that we've talked about today were the low interest rate environment, the high regulatory burden, and the technology component, there's really only one that anybody at that table can do anything about, and it's Mr. Gruenberg. And he could help lower the regulatory burden. We can't--technology is market driven. And the Fed has more to do--as much as I'd like to think we have more influence over them than do, we don't. So we don't have much influence over the interest rate environment, but we do have influence over the regulatory burden to new entry into this marketplace. And I'm hopeful that maybe as a result of this hearing we can try and do something about that. I thank the chairman for the opportunity. Chairman Chaffetz. I thank the gentleman. As we conclude here, you could see people filing in for the next hearing, which starts in 7 minutes. This has been very productive. I appreciate all the participants. Mr. Gruenberg, for both the ILCs and the community banks, can we by the end of the month, can you give us a good listing of what you are going to be working on to provide for this committee? Is that fair? Mr. Gruenberg. Yes, sir, I think we can do that. Chairman Chaffetz. That would be great. And then, Mr. Meadows was pretty generous on saying 120 days. But I think we have several of those items, including Dodd-Frank and others, that we would like to see. So if you can provide it to us by the end of the month, that would be most helpful. I appreciate it. Thank you all for your participation. It's an important segment, important to our economy, and affects more Americans than most people realize. And we thank you all for your participation. The committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:54 p.m., the committee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]