Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- THE FEDERAL INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY REFORM ACT SCORECARD 2.0 [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] THE FEDERAL INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY REFORM ACT SCORECARD 2.0 ======================================================================= JOINT HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ MAY 18, 2016 __________ Serial No. 114-159 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform _________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 26-068 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ____________________________________________________________________ For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, Internet:bookstore.gpo.gov. Phone:toll free (866)512-1800;DC area (202)512-1800 Fax:(202) 512-2104 Mail:Stop IDCC,Washington,DC 20402-001 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK, MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director Julie Dunne, Senior Counsel William Marx, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Subcommittee on Information Technology WILL HURD, Texas, Chairman BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas, Vice Chair ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois, Ranking MARK WALKER, North Carolina Minority Member ROD BLUM, Iowa GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois TED LIEU, California ------ Subcommittee on Government Operations MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina, Chairman JIM JORDAN, Ohio GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia, TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Vice Chair Ranking Minority Member TREY GOWDY, South Carolina CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina Columbia KEN BUCK, Colorado WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on May 18, 2016..................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. Steven I. Cooper, Chief Infomation Officer, U.S. Department of Commerce Oral Statement............................................... 6 Written Statement............................................ 9 Ms. Dawn Leaf, Chief Information Officer, U.S. Department of Labor Oral Statement............................................... 13 Written Statement............................................ 15 Mr. Michael M. Johnson, Chief Information Officer, U.S. Department of Energy Oral Statement............................................... 20 Written Statement............................................ 22 Ms. Renee P. Wynn, Chief Information Officer, National Aeronautics and Space Administration Oral Statement............................................... 26 Written Statement............................................ 28 Mr. David A. Powner, Director, IT Management Issues, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 35 Written Statement............................................ 38 APPENDIX Opening Statement of Mr. Meadows................................. 82 FITARA Scorecard documents for the record........................ 85 THE FEDERAL INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY REFORM ACT SCORECARD 2.0 ---------- Wednesday, May 18, 2016 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Information Technology, joint with the Subcommittee on Government Operations, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittees met, pursuant to call, at 2:04 p.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. William Hurd [chairman of the Subcommittee on Information Technology] presiding. Present from Subcommittee on Information Technology: Representatives Hurd, Walker, Blum, Kelly, and Lieu. Present from Subcommittee on Government Operations: Representatives Meadows, Jordan, Walberg, Buck, Carter, Connolly, and Plaskett. Mr. Hurd. The Subcommittee on Information Technology and the Subcommittee on Government Operations will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. We believe votes are probably going to be called around 2:20, so we are going to try to get through as many of the opening statements as we can before we have to take a break and come back for the questioning. So thank you for being here and good afternoon. Earlier in this Congress, the Subcommittee on Information Technology and the Subcommittee on Government Operations began a joint effort to hold agencies accountable for implementation of FITARA. Our oversight on this issue is part of an ongoing effort to reform the state of IT in the Federal Government. FITARA can play a key role in ensuring broader authorities for agency CIOs and a reduction of waste, fraud, and abuse. I think it is important to keep that broader goal in mind as we discuss today's grades. The intent of grading agencies is to provide an objective measurement of progress and challenges. Some agencies continue to do better than others. Today, I am pleased to see moderate improvement in the grades from the first scorecard. The overarching goal is for Federal agencies to transition to deploying modern technology rather than spending funds on outdated systems. Technology is a wonderful thing. It should reduce errors, save taxpayer money, and be a tool to help agencies accomplish their missions. It should not be a burden. To agency CIOs looking to improve your score, I would say, three things. First, understand that the grade is a snapshot in time. The committee realizes, in many cases, the situations CIOs find themselves in developed long before they got there and are the result of decisions made by people who are long gone. Second, the risk assessment transparency metric is entirely within the CIO's control. GAO reports validate the common-sense conclusion that major IT projects carry much more risk than agency CIOs are currently acknowledging to Congress and the American people. I would encourage CIOs to take a good look at the risk ratings they are assigning to projects on the dashboard. And third, there are millions of dollars' worth of savings still on the table for data center consolidation. GAO has reported that agencies have closed over 3,000 of about 10,500 data centers and achieved $2.8 billion in cost savings rate. Most of these savings are attributed to just four agencies, including Commerce, who I believe is going to talk about that today. So there is much more in terms of savings left available. GAO calculates plan savings of around $1.5 billion per year from consolidating data centers. For those advocating for billions of additional funding to help modernize IT, I would suggest that savings from data center consolidation might be a better place to look than a new appropriation. Under FITARA, CIOs now have a proper seat at the table. No longer are technology and cyber issues confined to tech geeks in some backroom. In the digital age, IT issues are front and center. They are central to what government does and how it does it. This committee intends to focus on ensuring the men and women in these CIO positions are qualified, accountable, and empowered to make decisions and lead within their agencies. The American taxpayers deserve agency CIOs who understand the value proposition of the cloud rather than CIOs who believe their agencies are so special that a proprietary mainframe database is needed. Congress requires accurate and complete data, and answers from agencies, rather than conflicting numbers and obfuscation. Ultimately, taxpayers deserve a government that leverages technology to serve them rather than one that deploys unsecured, decades-old technology and keeps sensitive information in nonencrypted databases. We are not there yet, and we have a long way to go, but I am cautiously optimistic that we are moving the needle in the right direction. I thank the witnesses for being here today, and I look forward to their testimony. Now, I would like to recognize Ms. Kelly, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on Information Technology from the great State of Illinois, and my friend, for her opening statement. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thank you, Chairman Meadows and Ranking Member Connolly. I know they will be joining us shortly. Today's hearing is the third in a series that our subcommittees have held to learn how agencies are implementing the requirements of the Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act. As was noted, during November's hearing, these hearings help us ensure that agencies are hitting the required benchmarks as we move toward a more efficient, modern, and secure Federal Government. At the last hearing, we released a FITARA scorecard assessing agencies' implementation of four of the seven initiatives required by the act. Today, we release an updated FITARA scorecard measuring agencies progress in the areas of data center consolidation, IT portfolio review savings, incremental project development, and risk assessment transparency. I am looking forward to discussing the grades received by the four agencies here today. Since the last scorecard, I am encouraged to see that out of the 24 agencies that are covered by FITARA, seven have shown improvement in their overall grade, and others have improved in individual categories. Looking beyond the grades, let me say that I have been encouraged by the responsiveness of most agencies and the progress in FITARA implementation to date. I especially want to recognize, as the chairman said, the Department of Commerce's work in exceeding their goal of saving $222 million through fiscal year 2016 in data center consolidations. I hope to see this effort to continued. Government-wide data center consolidations alone have realized $1.3 billion in savings, and we are expecting to save an additional $8.2 billion by 2019. These are good first steps, but it is clear that there are obstacles to overcome in implementation. This new scorecard shows that numerous agencies have hit roadblocks and others have fallen behind in implementation. I look forward to addressing these challenges today, also. I'm especially interested in hearing how agencies plan to stick to their FITARA implementation plans as a new presidential administration takes charge next year. No transition is seamless, so I look forward to learning what steps your agencies are taking to ensure a transition that will continue the progress we have made so far. We all know what is at stake here. The Federal Government's IT acquisition process isn't just an inefficient use of taxpayer money. It is also a security risk. Too many agencies are still reliant on outdated legacy systems. With each passing year, these systems cost more and more to secure and maintain. FITARA not only helps Federal agencies save money in IT procurement, it also helps them make smarter IT investments. Quite frankly, FITARA implementation is a change that the Federal Government has sorely needed. I want to thank the witnesses for testifying today. I know that an overhaul of your IT acquisition and management is not an easy task, so I look forward to hearing how your agencies are handling the challenges in implementing FITARA. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Kelly. I would like to now recognize the chairman of the Subcommittee on Government Operations, Mr. Meadows, for his opening statement. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for your leadership on this particular issue. I'm going to keep my remarks very brief. They are about to call votes here shortly. So in doing that, I think it is more important that we emphasize the fact that FITARA is not a law that was passed with no expectation of implementation. We are going to continue to follow up and continue to have these types of hearings. We are hearing news that two of our witnesses hopefully have plans that are either on their way or very close to being done, so I applaud you for those efforts. Really, this is more about accountability. For us, we want to see progress. We are going to work with the GAO on a number of fronts. As we look at that, it is going to be a critical component of what we look at. I have already been talking to appropriators on a number of fronts. I'm willing that, if you are willing to do a good job, I am willing to be your advocate. So I want to just stress that. But thank you. I will submit a written statement for the record, Mr. Chairman. With that, I will yield back. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, sir. I now would like to recognize Mr. Connolly, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on Government Operations, and the architect of FITARA, or, as most people like to call it, the Connolly-Issa bill. Mr. Connolly. You are my very favorite chairman. [Laughter.] Mr. Connolly. I've always thought that, except for Mr. Meadows. It is kind of a tie. Both wonderful human beings. Thank you, Chairman Hurd, Chairman Meadows, and my friend Ranking Member Kelly. I welcome this latest joint subcommittee hearing to examine the implementation of FITARA. I'm particularly grateful to my two colleagues on the other side of the aisle. They made a promise we weren't going to let this go. Unlike Clinger-Cohen, we were going to stick with this, and we were going to provide oversight. And they have kept their word. And the four of us operate seamlessly. I think that is good for the United States Government. I think, in partnership with the executive branch, we can make a big difference on something that may seem deceptively uninteresting, but that actually can help transform agencies and how they do business and save lots of dollars for our taxpayers. Today, we release our second scorecard on FITARA. As I stated at our last hearing, the scorecard is not intended to be a scarlet letter on some agency's back. It is meant to incentivize agencies to improve management of Federal IT investments and to create metrics so that we can look at progress. On the initial scorecard issued prior to December 31, for all agencies to have FITARA implementation plans, it was understandable that we some grades on the lower end of the scale. We were just beginning. Ds and Fs outnumbered As, Bs, and Cs more than 2-to-1. Today, we are pleased to see a very marked improvement in the latest scorecard with higher marks now out numbering lower ones. Seven agencies improved their overall grades, including the Department of Energy, one of today's witnesses, which jumped two letter grades. I also want to commend the Department of Commerce for its work on data center consolidation, a very critical part of FITARA. It originally set the goal of saving $222 million and actually reported $260 million in savings, an example to which other agencies ought to inspire. While the Department of Energy and the Department of Labor are performing well on some aspects of the scorecard, I would note both agencies only recently received OMB approval-- recently, I think it's in the last 24 hours, but all right, good--for the initial implementation plan. Obviously, we expect to hear more from those agencies today about why their plans were delayed and what actions they are taking to advance those important IT management and acquisition reforms. It is also encouraging to see the Department of Energy reporting all three of its major IT projects meeting the incremental development benchmark for delivering functionality every 6 months. Similarly, I want to applaud the Labor Department for its realistic evaluation of the risks present in its IT projects. The department rated nearly three-fourths of its projects as high-risk, earning it high marks for risk assessment transparency. I know Dave Powner and GAO are looking for realistic assessment of project risks and what they entail. Accurately calculating and reporting project risk is a continuing challenge. Agencies currently report two-thirds of their IT investments pose low risk. Based on GAO's more thorough reviews of those projects, that risk, we believe, is understated. Accurately capturing the risk so we can respond to it and anticipate problems is one of the pillars of FITARA. It is a management concept, so we look forward to hearing more from GAO on how to address that challenge as we move forward. I also want to hear from today's witnesses about whether we are accurately defining IT investments and how that may affect implementation of reforms. For example, neither the Commerce Department nor NASA includes spacecraft or satellites in their reporting. Surely, those systems fall under the IT umbrella, so we would like to hear their thoughts about that. It is also puzzling that the government agency with arguably the most innovative and technologically demanding mission continues to receive the lowest marks on the scorecard, NASA. NASA has not reported anything under incremental development and received failing grades for the other three metrics. For example, it says that it plans to spend $731 million on major IT investments this year, but reports none of those projects are high-risk. That stretches credulity, and we want to talk about that today. Mr. Chairman, before closing, let me share an example of one agency doing the right thing, though it might not have been reflected in its initial grades. As my colleagues will recall, the Department of Transportation scored at the lower end in certain areas, but CIO Rich McKinney actually demonstrated that he gets what we are trying to deal when we put a freeze on IT acquisitions for 90 days at the end of last year because he discovered component agency CIOs did not have a good handle on what their agencies were spending. We want more CIOs exercising that kind of new authority under FITARA. Today's hearing is just the latest in what we all hope will be an ongoing series as we continue to push agencies to adopt these reforms. Again, I thank my three colleagues for their willingness to collaborate as one to try to make the government function better and to save money for our hardworking taxpayers. Thank you very much. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Connolly. I would like to hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. We will now recognize our panel of witnesses. I am pleased to welcome Mr. Steven Cooper, chief information officer at the U.S. Department of Commerce; Ms. Dawn Leaf, CIO at the U.S. Department of Labor; Mr. Michael Johnson, CIO at the U.S. Department of Energy; Ms. Renee Wynn, chief information officer at NASA; and Mr. David Powner, director of IT management issues at the U.S. Government Accountability Office. It is always a pleasure to have you here, David. Welcome to you all. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify, so please rise and raise your right hands. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. Please be seated. Let the record reflect that the witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for discussion, we would appreciate if you would implement your testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statements will be made part of the record. If the bells go off while you are talking, just keep going. We will conclude at your statement. Now, I would like to thank Mr. Cooper at the Department of Commerce. You got a B, the highest grade that we gave. Mr. Cooper, you get to kick us off today, starting with your 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF STEVEN I. COOPER Mr. Cooper. Thank you very much. Chairman Hurd, Ranking Member Kelly, Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Connolly, and members of the subcommittees, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss Commerce's work on the implementation of the Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act, and thank you for your resolute bipartisan efforts to ensure that this critical law is implemented successfully. To begin, I believe FITARA is one of the strongest and most helpful pieces of legislation to improve CIO involvement with the decision processes and policies related to managing information technology resources and increased government efficiency and effectiveness. I am committed to its success. Secretary Pritzker and Deputy Secretary Andrews strongly support FITARA and have made FITARA one of their and my key priorities. They have made it clear to DOC's executive leadership that FITARA is the responsibility not only of the CIO, but all their senior staff. Since October 2015, the department's FITARA team, representing my office and the department's budget, acquisition, personnel, and legal offices, has been meeting weekly to ensure the full implementation of our FITARA plan and FITARA across the Department of Commerce. FITARA implementation is one of my top goals, and I have named one of my senior staff, Ms. Erin Cavanaugh, who is with me today, our full-time program manager for FITARA implementation, making the department one of only a few departments to create a full-time FITARA program official. Let me now highlight progress we have collaboratively made in three specific areas, and why I believe we are on a path to achieve full implementation in the budget, personnel, and acquisition areas required by FITARA. First, budget. My office is working closely with the department's offices of budget to ensure that I am fully engaged in the budget formulation and review process to enable me to review and approve the overall DOC IT budget. Leveraging FITARA has allowed me as the DOC CIO to have full visibility into each bureau's IT budget, which enhances my understanding of our full ask and spend, and helps me identify opportunities for strategic and operational collaboration all across all 12 of our bureaus in areas like cybersecurity, enterprise licensing agreements, cost savings, and contract consolidation. I am particularly pleased that the NOAA and Census CIOs and their budget offices have worked closely with my office and the DOC budget office to introduce greater involvement in budget formulation and visibility. Second, acquisition. Our Office of Acquisition Management has revised the Commerce acquisition manual, so that the CIO now participates in the review and approval of all acquisitions above $10 million, whether or not a program was initially determined to be IT. This is a significant change. Previous acquisition policy only required my office participation on acquisition over $75 million. Third, personnel. Our chief human capital officer and I drafted and reviewed and signed a new department bulletin, which gives me direct involvement in the selection responsibility over all SES IT and all CIO-titled positions across the department. That said, our IT work force planning is not complete, but I expect to see considerable progress in the next 6 months in addressing the hiring and retention of critical IT resources for cyber and IT risk management, data analytics, agile development, and Web services. Another notable goal of FITARA and of every CIO is cost savings in the IT environment. While my particular driver is not the cost savings per se, I fully expect implementing FITARA will help me drive the unit cost of every IT service we deliver down. This will result from opportunities identified through greater oversight, visibility, and collaboration across IT acquisition and budget formulation. In closing, for our DOC FITARA implementation to fully succeed, we need more than just law or policy. We need to institutionalize best IT practices and processes across the department. My staff is working with their counterparts in each bureau CIO office and in our H.R., finance, and acquisition offices to improve visibility and participation in all IT budget and acquisition processes. I expect to have initial process improvements and reviews in place by the end of this fiscal year, and to operate more efficiently in the future. I thank the subcommittees for holding this hearing and for your commitment to ensuring successful implementation of FITARA. I would be pleased to answer any questions you may have. [Prepared statement of Mr. Cooper follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Cooper. I now would like to recognize Ms. Dawn Leaf, CIO at the Department of Labor, who had a grade of C, which is one step better than you were the last time we issued these grades. So, Ms. Leaf, over to you for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF DAWN LEAF Ms. Leaf. Chairman Hurd, Ranking Member Kelly, Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Connolly, and members of the subcommittees, good afternoon and thank you for the opportunity to brief you on the Department of Labor's FITARA implementation. I would like to focus on some challenges, highlight some progress, and provide you a working-level perspective on how FITARA can help the department to improve its IT services. First, let me state that, historically, the Department of Labor has had decentralized IT organizations and resources, that these have been fragmented and siloed at the department bureau level. We have experienced the same inefficiencies and issues that I know this committee has heard described in other hearings by other agencies. Another relevant factor that I would like to emphasize is that decades of information technology underinvestment and the fragile state of our IT infrastructure and our application systems make it challenging for the department to improve its performance in some of the FITARA metrics. Specifically, it is difficult for the Department of Labor to achieve high scores and cost savings because we are on a bare-bones IT budget to start with. There is not much to cut. On the positive side, we have a great opportunity with cost avoidance, to leverage enterprise investments in IT, to add technology capabilities and services, and to do so more efficiently. Turning to progress, the department has improved and strengthened its IT governance processes, and that has helped us to improve transparency, to improve our risk management, and to improve our incremental delivery and development. In 2012, the department launched an initiative to consolidate nine separate agency infrastructures. We have made some progress, and we have proven that we can deliver modern IT services on time and within budget. By the end of 2016, we will have closed 38 of our 90 data centers. We will have achieved or met our 40 percent data center consolidation target. In 2014, the department migrated 17,000 employees from nine separate legacy email systems to a commercial Federal community cloud service. For the same cost, we are able to give our employees 400 times as much storage, which gives them back 2 hours per month per employee, because now they are able to just work instead of spending 2 hours a month archiving email so that they have enough space to work, so they can send and receive emails. In 2015 and 2016, the department improved our cybersecurity posture, including a 95 percent reduction in security vulnerabilities by implementing an aggressive security patch in our patch management process. We are planning a 2017 through 2019 unified communications project to redesign, modernize, and consolidate nine decades- old networks in over 600 locations throughout the U.S. This is not only critical for security, it also allows us to reduce costs. We will be able to reduce 85 percent of our voice circuits and 50 percent of our phone management costs. In closing, I would like to just touch on two ways that FITARA can help the Department of Labor with its IT challenges. FITARA is especially important to an agency that is starting in an underfunded position, because it encourages the department to make IT investments that are not only effective for agency missions, but efficient. FITARA also provides structure to help us manage change, organization change and technology change. While the Department of Labor is moving forward, we realize that we have a long road ahead. Thank you for the opportunity to share my thoughts, and I am happy to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Ms. Leaf follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Leaf. Mr. Johnson, you are now recognized for 5 minutes, and the Department of Energy has moved the most in their grades to a C, I believe from an F, the last score. So thank you for that, Mr. Johnson. You are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF MICHAEL M. JOHNSON Mr. Johnson. Good afternoon, Chairman Hurd, Ranking Member Kelly, Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Connolly, and distinguished members of the committee. On behalf of the Department of Energy, I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you to discuss the department's implementation of the Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act. The department has been working closely with OMB to implement FITARA and cyber best practices across the complex ecosystem that is the Department of Energy as we meet our diverse mission. We are pleased that the committees' just- release May 2016 FITARA implementation scorecard 2.0 acknowledges that the department is making progress. Just this last Friday, DOE submitted to OMB the third major revision to our initial FITARA implementation plan submission. I am pleased to say that yesterday OMB approved DOE's FITARA implementation plan, and we will post it to our public Web site within the next 30 days. DOE's FITARA implementation plan is transformational for the department, and it results in unprecedented CIO engagement and DOE enterprise-wide transparency into IT budget formulation and review, acquisition review and approval, and IT work force planning. In addition, the plan provides for the collection of detailed IT and cyber performance metrics across all DOE IT investments. At the request of the Secretary, I joined DOE a little over a year ago to develop and implement an effective cyber strategy for the DOE enterprise. The complex DOE enterprise comprises 97 entities across 27 States, to include 19 staff offices, 10 program offices, 19 field sites, 17 National Laboratories, four technology centers, and the four Power Marketing Administrations. Each entity is structured to perform its area of our diverse mission that spans nuclear security, scientific research, energy, and environmental management. All but one of our National Laboratories are government-owned, contractor- operated facilities managed through the management and operating, or M&O, contracts designed to enable innovation and management efficiencies. Our cyber governance is both transparent and responsive, and includes close collaboration involvement with all entities across DOE, notably the National Laboratories. The Deputy Secretary chairs the DOE cyber council. As CIO, I chair the DOE Information Management Governance Board. We use these entities to oversee development, coordination, and implementation of DOE's cyber- and IT-related policies. The information technology portion of DOE's budget is approximately $1.7 billion, which often is integrated into the larger non-IT investments. We have expanded our processes to ensure CIO involvement in all phases of annual and multiyear IT planning, programming, budgeting, and decision-making. The department has also developed an enterprise plan for review and approval of IT acquisitions that covers acquisition plans, statements of work, evaluation, and selection criteria. DOE understands the need to leverage human capital for success. Accordingly, we are focusing on the development of a DOE cyber work force strategy that will increase the CIO's involvement in DOE's human capital selection practices with a focus on developing performance goals with results-driven critical elements and enhanced recruitment and retention of vital IT personnel. The DOE continues to consolidate and optimize its data centers to include advanced metering facility upgrades to improve power utilization effectiveness. From 2010 to present, for our updated and expanded inventory of 217 enterprise computing data centers, including both Federal and M&O, we closed 75, increasing cost savings to the department of just over $17 million. We developed a unified DOE cyber strategy and implementation plan that consolidates and prioritizes the excellent cyber enterprise information resources management initiatives ongoing at the DOE into five key areas: information resources management best practices, to include reliability and enhanced efficiencies; modernization, to quickly move from legacy to transformative solutions; strengthen cybersecurity fundamentals, to reduce risk and enhance defense in-depth capabilities; seamless integration of operations in cyberdefense, to combine situational awareness and threat operational status in enterprise-wide, real-time indicator- sharing; and cyber research and development intended to out- innovate our adversaries and stay ahead of advanced persistent threats. In conclusion, DOE is actively engaged in FITARA implementation and related transformational reforms, which will result in significant insights into and enhanced oversight of DOE information and IT. Through a department-wide collaborative and inclusive process, we have made major strides toward the goal, although further work is needed. I thank the subcommittees for their commitment to ensuring successful implementation of FITARA. Your support is vital to our success. It has been my honor to provide this testimony, and I will be pleased to address any questions you may have. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Mr. Johnson follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Johnson. Votes have been called. It is a six-vote series, so we are going to stand adjourned until the end of the final vote. [Recess.] Mr. Hurd. The Subcommittees on Information Technology and Government Operations will reconvene. I think we left off with you, Ms. Wynn, for your opening statement of 5 minutes. Since I have called out the grades for everyone else, NASA had the lowest grade of the folks reviewed with an F. Ms. Wynn, over to you for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF RENEE P. WYNN Ms. Wynn. Thank you, Chairman Hurd, Chairman Meadows, and other members of the Information Technology and Government Operations Subcommittees for allowing me to appear before you today to update you on NASA's implementation of the Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act. Unfortunately, NASA is at the bottom of the FITARA scorecard. That is not something we are proud of. NASA is fully committed to implementing the FITARA law. We know we have a lot of work to do, and I am here today to assure you that significant changes are already underway at NASA to improve our management of IT. But before I get into more detail about our implementation plans, I would like to introduce myself. My name is Renee Wynn, and I have more than 26 years of Federal service, spending most of those years at the Environmental Protection Agency. I joined NASA 10 months ago as the deputy CIO, and, 2 months later, I was promoted to be the agency CIO. Since then, I have initiated listening meetings to learn the needs of my IT customers and how they can inform our joint path forward. I have visited each center, meeting with the CIOs and the center directors, and I've been meeting with each mission office at headquarters. Everywhere I go, people are frank with me about IT needs, about governance, and operational changes they are believe are needed, or changes they fear are coming. So I am listening and taking action as quickly as I can. The ball is now in my court to manage and secure the agency's IT resources, so that is what I and my amazing team are going to do. To its credit, over the last several years, NASA has transformed its IT governance structure to empower the CIO with greater authority, and thus, today, I am the beneficiary of these many changes. For example, I now report directly to the Administrator and can talk to him whenever I want. The CIO now sits on all key NASA decision-making councils, and the CIO has direct authority and oversight over the center CIOs, including their IT decisions and acquisitions. Better yet, NASA recently completed an internal business services assessment of NASA's IT program. In this BSA outlined a series of steps the agency should take and plans to take to optimize and protect our IT assets. In my personal opinion, this review has been a gift to current and future NASA CIOs in that it says NASA supports you as the CIO and we do want you to transform the way NASA manages IT. Like FITARA, the BSA results will ensure that IT is seen as a strategic agency resource establishing clear direction for the NASA CIO to approve the agency's IT spend for non-highly specialized and highly specialized IT. Additionally, NASA is strengthening its alignment of IT resources against mission goals. My office will be held accountable for additional agency IT costs, schedule, and performance through a new portfolio review process. NASA is providing me with greater visibility into the overall budget planning cycle, allowing me to spot IT resource problems at a mission level earlier on. These are big steps forward for NASA, and NASA should be commended for starting this process even before FITARA became law. It is important to remember that NASA's scientific and technical mission is unique. For example, cooperation with other nations, the public, and scientists around the world is one of NASA's founding principles. Therefore, NASA has always sought the widest practical and appropriate distribution of information about our missions. But in doing so, we must also safeguard our IT assets against well-resourced and highly motivated individuals who wish to harm us. Malicious threats to our network are constantly evolving, which means our work is never done. Thus, I want to reassure you today that IT is a top priority at NASA. While the number of attempted cyber instances against NASA continues to increase, I am confident that NASA continues to appropriately address them. For example, NASA did not experience any major incidents in fiscal year 2015, as defined by the Office of Management and Budget. NASA has successfully met all capability targets established in the 2015 cyber sprint activity. And the DHS cyber hygiene report for NASA currently shows that there are a zero critical vulnerabilities older than 30 days. In conclusion, I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today to reassure you that NASA has a strong foundation upon which to successfully implement FITARA and that we are committed to fully implementing FITARA. We remain ever vigilant with protecting our information assets as well. I would be happy to answer any questions that you may have. [Prepared statement of Ms. Wynn follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Wynn. Now someone who has testified many times before this committee, Mr. Powner, you are recognized for your 5-minute opening statement. STATEMENT OF DAVID A. POWNER Mr. Powner. Chairmen Hurd and Meadows, Ranking Members Kelly and Connolly, and members of the subcommittees, I would like to thank you and your staff for your continued oversight of the implementation of FITARA with the second set of grades. We recently completed, at your request, detailed work on three of the four scorecard areas to support your grading efforts. This afternoon, I would like to briefly discuss the grades overall in each of the three areas we performed our work. Those are data centers, dashboard accuracy, and incremental development, all major areas of emphasis with FITARA. Starting with the grades, overall, there has been some progress with seven agencies having higher grades, one lower, and 16 having no change. We view the 6-month progress as quite positive, since implementing FITARA and receiving higher grades will take time to address long-standing, systemic weaknesses in IT management. To comprehensively implement this law to better invest our Nation's IT dollars, CIO authorities need to be strengthened. Critical to that are the FITARA implementation plans that are to provide an assessment of gaps in CIO authorities and agency efforts to improve those authorities. We are pleased to hear that both Labor and Energy now have approved plans, so they are all in, and we will actually be looking at the next round of iterations on those plans. Now turning to data center consolidation, of the roughly 10,500 data centers, 3,121 have been closed to date and another 2,100 are planned. Interestingly, 84 percent of the closures to date have come from four agencies, Ag, DOD, Treasury, and Interior. Your uptick of the data center grades is quite appropriate. We want consolidation, and we want savings. This next slide shows savings to date with data center consolidation. I know it is hard to read. There are the closures, if you look at 3,100, if we go back to that prior one, the prior slide, please. The 3,100, that is what has been closed to date. I want to emphasize there are four agencies that are accountable for 84 percent of those 3,100 closures. Your uptick in their grades is appropriate. If we flip to the next slide, this is savings. That gray shaded area there from 2011 through 2015, there has been collectively about $2.8 billion in savings to date. There is another $5.4 billion remaining. When you look at out-years, over $1 billion each year. This is why FITARA is so important, because without FITARA, we would not have this focus and attention on data center consolidation. A couple points on this chart. Four agencies account for 86 percent of the $2.8 billion in savings. Those are Commerce, Defense, DHS, and Treasury. Again, rewarding these departments with higher grades for their substantial savings is an excellent idea. The other point I would like to make is that out-years savings of $5.4 billion, we actually have a lot more than $5.4 billion on the table. There were 10 agencies that had planned closures that did not have out-year estimates that were called for by OMB. We made recommendations to those 10 agencies. And your downgrading those 10 agencies to emphasize the importance of these out-year projections is really the right way to go. So what we want to do is we want to reward closures and savings, and we want to make sure there are not out-year projections that we have to down tick in their grade. So that is going to be really helpful in ensuring we get the appropriate savings here. Next, I would like to turn to dashboard transparency. FITARA codified the IT dashboard and CIO risk ratings for approximately 750 major IT investments across the departments. These ratings indicate whether each investment is low, moderate, or high risk. The dashboard currently tells us there are about 200 investments totaling about $12 billion that are moderate or high risk, and that 72 percent of IT dollars the government invests is low risk. Although CIOs are acknowledging a bit more risk from your last hearing, these IT dashboard CIO ratings still greatly underestimate risk. This next chart shows the results of our latest review on CIO ratings. We looked at approximately 100 investments on the IT dashboard and performed our own risk assessments compared to the CIO ratings. So, for instance, that green bar on the top, there were 61 CIO ratings that were rated as low risk or green. Our assessment concluded that only 10 of those were green, 28 should have been yellow, and 23 should have been red. So that is an indication of where we need to get better transparency and accuracy so that we can better manage these major IT investments. Your grading scheme, Mr. Chairman, which equates higher grades with acknowledging more risk is definitely the way to go until CIOs start acknowledging more risk with their ratings. Turning to incremental development, FITARA requires that CIOs certify that IT investments deliver in increments consistent with OMB policy, which requires that major investments deliver in 6 months. Agencies collectively report that 65 percent of their IT projects government-wide plan to deliver in 6 months. Our review found some agencies were accurately reporting this, like DHS and Transportation. However, others, like Commerce and Treasury, were not, and your grades adjustments to those two agencies were appropriate. I would like to conclude by thanking your subcommittees for your aggressive oversight of FITARA implementation with your scorecard and your many other actions. With the upcoming change in administration, it will be very important not to lose the positive momentum we have. Our team at GAO will be working very hard through this transition, addressing several requests from you to keep the focus on CIO authorities, delivering transformational IT solutions, and replacing antiquated, inefficient, and, in many cases, insecure systems and infrastructure. Chairmen Hurd and Meadows, Ranking Member Kelly, I thank you for your leadership. Our team at GAO looks forward to continuing to work supporting your efforts on FITARA implementation. [Prepared statement of Mr. Powner follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Powner. I will now recognize myself for 5 minutes for opening questioning. Mr. Cooper, I want to start with you. Commerce is one of the four agencies that is responsible for 86 percent, 87 percent of the savings in closing down the data centers. How are you able to use that money that you save? Mr. Cooper. We have an internal process that is set up. As we realize savings, we have a prioritized bureau-specific list of priorities. The bureaus bring forward, through our investment review process, their savings dollars redirected against that prioritized list. So it comes through the bureau investment review process up to the department review process. That way we have ---- Mr. Hurd. Mr. Cooper, I'm going to interrupt there. Mr. Cooper. Please. Mr. Hurd. If you realize savings in your operations, you should be able to use that savings also to go after some of the other projects of legacy systems that you have already identified. Are you able to do that? Mr. Cooper. Yes. I was going into a little bit of detail on how we do that. The answer is yes. We have a process. We actually do, both at the department level and at the bureau level, redirect that savings. It is redirected based upon the priorities of new investments or risk-based issues that need to be addressed at the bureau level and the department level. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Cooper. Ms. Wynn, 10 months at NASA, correct? Two months in the CIO job? Ms. Wynn. I was 2 months as the deputy CIO and then promoted to the CIO the last 8 months. Mr. Hurd. So are we going to be able to get to Mars if we are still using Fortran? Ms. Wynn. Thank you for your question, Chairman. At this point, I am not an expert on what it is going to take to get to Mars, but I'm happy to take the question for the record, and add the question about programming language as well. Mr. Hurd. Please do. My question for you is, so you have come in and inherited a situation, and we recognize that. What additional responsibilities or authorities would you like to have in order to right this ship? Ms. Wynn. Chairman, thank you for the recognition to the newness. It is much appreciated. On March 31, the agency approved our transformation plan. It is about 219 pages. That gives me a lot of authority that is aligned with the FITARA law, as well as some things that NASA saw that needed to change. So at this juncture, we are changing our governance structure, changing the way we take a look at the budget, as well as taking a look at how we do portfolio review. At this juncture, that feels like it is going to be an excellent start for me at NASA. Mr. Hurd. When did the CIO report directly to the Administrator, when did that change happen? Ms. Wynn. It is my understanding that that started about 2 years ago. Mr. Hurd. When it comes to incremental developments, on your scorecard, there is no data on this. Is that because there are no IT projects in the works? Or is it because we don't know which IT projects are in the works? Ms. Wynn. Chairman, the lack of incremental spending is due to, I believe, a couple things. One is, in my opening statement testimony, I emphasized the ability of the CIO to look at specialized and nonspecialized IT. The nonspecialized IT is our mission IT where a lot of development work is in our regular, ongoing basis. I recently have been given the authority to begin to look to make more transparent what goes on there. That is where a lot of our development happens, and that is where I am expecting to be able to say to you, yes, we are doing incremental. Mr. Hurd. In the next review cycle, what should we expect from NASA? Ms. Wynn. At this juncture, in discovering this in preparation for the hearing, this is what I expect to be able to deliver to you. One is information on how much we have actually saved in closing our data centers, to be able to say to you that we have a good plan for a modified portfolio review process that includes the infrastructure IT as well as our mission IT, and then finally be able to report to you where we have actually driven a lot of savings in our software management. Mr. Hurd. I think that would be pretty successful. Mr. Johnson, the 14 or 17 National Labs, why do they need an exemption from FITARA? Mr. Johnson. Thank you for the question, Chairman. So, as you know, DOE does not have a position on the legislation, which exempted the National Labs from FITARA implementation. However, we have been working closely with the National Labs just over 1 year that I have been the CIO within DOE. Through a collaborative process, which included not only the program offices and the National Labs, we have been putting in place a number of what we call transparency reforms that get to an effective management of our IT and cyber work force and information across our entire enterprise to include our National Labs. Mr. Hurd. In my opinion, the National Labs are probably some of the most important things to protect, and they are probably the biggest target when you look at nation sponsors that are looking at cutting-edge technology. Not adhering to some of what I would consider some very basic standards for good digital hygiene to me does not make sense. This is an area where my expectation is that these National Labs have some greater transparency on what they are doing, how they are doing it, and ensuring they are not using Fortran and systems that are super old and outdated. I think as we go forward and have new laws and go through appropriations, some of those things may change. Ms. Leaf, what took so long to get the implementation plan approved? Ms. Leaf. Thank you for the question. The department leadership felt that it was very important that we complete due diligence in understanding the relationship of FITARA with the Confidential Information Protection and Statistical Efficiency Act, or CIPSEA. So the department reviewed that internally. They requested guidance from OMB, which we received. When we received it, we incorporated it and finished our plan. Mr. Hurd. Ms. Leaf, thank you very much. I now would like to recognize my colleague, Ms. Kelly, for 5 minutes of questioning. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Last November, the committee received a briefing on GAO's review of how the 24 agencies identified in the Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990 had begun implementation of FITARA. At the committee's request, four key areas of FITARA were scored, enhancement to agency chief information officer authorities, transparency and risk management, portfolio review, and Federal data center consolidations. Mr. Powner, this question is for you. Can you explain why those areas were selected and how the scores were calculated? Mr. Powner. First of all, in working with your staff, I think we all collectively decided, and it was a great bipartisan effort, that these were areas directly tied to FITARA. They were areas that where needed reform needed to occur. They were also areas where agencies had data. So if you look at incremental development, scores on the dashboard, and savings, there is publicly reported data on the dashboard, on the CIO ratings, and incremental development, and then also, too, there is savings information that goes to the Appropriations Committees for both portfolios stats and data centers. So it is the agency's data, and I thought it was a great idea on your part to use the agency's data to score them initially on those initial grades back in November. Now this go-around, there were some tweaks to the data, because it was all self-reported initially, but there were some tweaks. Like on incremental development, we didn't think it was quite accurate with a couple agencies. Mr. Cooper, one of them was Commerce. So there was a downgrade on that score for incremental development. But it was also great that these committees, that you decided to uptick agencies who saved a lot and closed a lot, because that is really what we want to do. So I think there has been a nice little initial evolution of the grades where it evolved from more just self-reporting and had some of our GAO reports validate the self-reporting, and to reward what you really want, closures and savings. Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Mr. Johnson and Ms. Leaf, you represent two agencies that showed improvement. Can you quickly review what steps you took to improve? Mr. Johnson. Ranking Member, thank you for the question. Let's see, as I mentioned, I have been at the department just over a year. One of the things we prioritized was streamlining governance so that we can make sure that we have a common view on what issues we face as a department, both from an IT information resource management point of view, and also from a cyber point of view. As part of that process, we have an integrated team now that includes management all the way to the top of the department. It includes all the elements of our department, including our field and the previously mentioned National Labs. What we have attempted to do is focus all of those great minds and all of that great effort on focusing where we can make improvements. Two places where DOE did improve, as you can see from the scorecard, one, in particular, was in data centers, something that we are focusing on specifically to try to gain efficiencies that we can, as mentioned earlier, provide funds back into mission to try to address the other issues we have. So I would account most of the success to opening up the aperture of the governance and making sure that everyone is on the same page, but, in addition, having a focused plan on what we need to do. Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Ms. Leaf. So at the Department of Labor, what we have primarily done is strengthened our IT governance processes. The two areas that we have really improved are more detailed review of agency IT spend plans and acquisitions, so that we really do understand what the agencies are buying and how that fits with the overall strategic department objectives. We also, for the first time, expanded our IT program review board to include agency projects and programs. Before it was just for enterprise-level projects. So those are our two governance areas that we have improved and I think what has contributed to our improvement. Ms. Kelly. I am happy to see that all 24 agencies' plans have been approved or submitted. That is one thing. But, of course, they have to be implemented. Can you guys quickly go down the line and talk about what are your plans for the transition? Because we know, one way or another, there will be a new administration. Mr. Cooper. I'm happy to start. Thank you for the question. At Commerce, we have already taken steps that actually even preceded my coming into the role at the Department of Commerce as the CIO. We have already institutionalized in a memo actually signed by our Acting Secretary back in 2012 a significant amount of the authorities granted to the CIO and then reinforced by FITARA. That has allowed Commerce to kind of have a bit of a head start, if you want to think of it that way. But in addition, we have implemented, through our governance process for IT, some additional reviews that did not exist until we had FITARA to leverage, two specific ones that are now part of the CIO oversight review. First, programmatic reviews that my office or I or any bureau CIO can request. That is a formal review. You can think of them as being analogous or the equivalent of TechStat. But we launched those. We invite OMB to join us and, in some cases, GAO, depending upon what is under review. The second is, and this is brand new, it is kind of unique to Commerce that we have implemented, is what we call a CIO review. That is a review that didn't previously exist. I leveraged FITARA, the authorities granted to the CIOs, to be able to call a CIO review. We are using it specifically to take a look at programs that fall below our investment thresholds. We are focused on the following three major types of programs: one, any public-facing type of initiative that reaches to our constituents, stakeholders, citizens; second, any introduction of new technologies that could be state of the market, but they have not been used within the department before; and third, anything that we believe constitutes not abnormal risk but risk of a different nature than we are used to addressing. An example, moving into the cloud requires new IT skill sets. We consider that a high risk. So even though you might have an initiative in a bureau that might represent less than $10 million for a lifecycle investment, we can now conduct a CIO review on that program. Ms. Kelly. Briefly. My time is up. Ms. Leaf. Okay, so quickly, we are really focusing on process improvements that will be in place and are institutionalized, irrespective of the individuals that are in place. There are two areas for that. One is our actual FITARA plan has quarterly milestones, so we have committed to those. The other is that we are actually implementing the processes in the department through directives. So those should stand regardless of who is in place. Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Mr. Johnson. So within the Department of Energy, three main changes. One, as it relates to, as mentioned earlier, our implementation plan also has quarterly deadlines that we are following. We are also modifying our program review process to include modifying the charters by which those are run, including our Information Management Governance Board, which will be used as our internal investment review board for the department. That charter is being modified, and it will be signed out by the Deputy Secretary. And finally, for the first time within the department, I, as CIO, am going to be included on an Energy systems advisory board that analyzes all major investments to include $400 million and above, to include facilities that might include IT major investments like high-performance computing, et cetera, which is hugely transformational for the department. Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Ms. Wynn. For NASA, and thank you for the question, Congresswoman, that is, we basically have one thing and that is implement our business services assessment, which covers such things, but not just these things. It would be our governance, our roles and responsibilities, as well as our security, the way we focus on security. And there are policies and procedures that go underneath that. And a huge element of this one is a culture change element. So as long as we stay the course on what we have committed to do, we should be in good stead. Ms. Kelly. I don't know if you have a comment? Mr. Powner. I would just add that I think the improvements in governance is really needed across the Federal Government, not only on the large acquisitions, but where that governance also looks at the legacy spend. I know, next week, we are going to look more closely at these old legacy systems and the challenges in maintaining and the security vulnerabilities. But that governance perspective really needs to look at everything, so it is encouraging that these processes are being approved. Ms. Kelly. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Kelly. I now would like to recognize Chairman Meadows for 5 minutes. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank each of you for your testimony. I will try to be brief as we work through this issue. Ms. Leaf, I want to come to you. Your particular position, do you think it is an impediment to accomplishing your overall goal with where you are in the reporting status to the very top of your agency? Ms. Leaf. So let me just address what the department is going to do in the FITARA plan to strengthen the role of the CIO. We have two items. We are adding the CIO, and I am currently in that position, to the department management meeting, which is where they agency heads meet regularly. We have an action item to reassess this in 2017, with respect to the reporting structure. My honest answer to you is that I report to an Assistant Secretary, who is a strong champion of IT. I participate with him in meetings with the Deputy Secretary and with the Secretary. So in this particular instance, the reporting structure is not an impediment, because of the individuals who are in the positions. I do think that it is appropriate for the department to reconsider it, however, with the transition. Mr. Meadows. I would concur with your last statement. I guess what I would say is, knowing that the reporting is a critical component after you are gone, or perhaps after those you report to are gone, I would encourage, while you have a cooperative mood, to express the sense of Congress that that reporting relationship is being looked at. How about that? Ms. Wynn, I want to come to you. Obviously, your grade was not one that I jumped up and down about, nor do you, I can tell. I even questioned GAO. The gentleman to your left will admit that when I saw it I said that this has to be wrong, because I visited NASA, and I know the commitment to the mission at NASA, so certainly it has to be wrong. So I guess my question to you is twofold. Do you know what it would take to get from an F to a C? Ms. Wynn. Chairman, thank you. We are not proud of our ---- Mr. Meadows. I am not here to beat you up. Ms. Wynn. I'm glad GAO said yes, we did not make a mistake in our reporting, so great on that one. So I think with our business services assessment, we are on track to head toward a C. As long as we stay on that particular plan that the agency approved--and, as you know, in order for us to make the changes in the CIO world, we have to have the support of senior leadership, and we have to have that because of the culture change. I have that in place now, so it is time for me and my team to capture that moment and get through the implementation process. Mr. Meadows. So in a roundabout way, I guess the answer was yes, you know how to get to a C. So the question becomes, at the next briefing, will we see you at a C? Ms. Wynn. Chairman Meadows, yes, your summary is right. We are to do that. As far as guaranteeing a C, as long as the grading stays precisely as it is right now, we know how to make those changes. But I would say that there are a couple areas where there are bigger changes. That is on the incremental side, taking a look at some of our projects. We are headed toward getting that insight. I just can't guarantee what day I'm going to get that one. Mr. Meadows. I am not asking for that. I knew many of your teammates in other areas, and we expect the culture to be one that would embrace--just to be frank, they will not be satisfied with being an F, so you have big shoes to fill. But I guess my question is, do you have the tools and the insight and the commitment to improve? Ms. Wynn. Chairman Meadows, I do. Mr. Meadows. Okay, all right. So let me go to the GAO very quickly, because one of the graphs that you put up there had to do with what you identified as I guess low risk, that was identified by the agencies as low risk, but it looked like most of that was either medium or high risk, according to your analysis of where it should be. So is there a disadvantage for agencies to self-report now that the scorecard is already out, to say, ``Okay, we made a mistake. They are, indeed, medium risk, high risk, or whatever.'' By self-reporting to you at this point, do they get adversely affected by getting a different dashboard quicker? Or is there an incentive to go ahead and have all the agencies call you tomorrow and say, ``Gosh, we agree with your assessment. Put us at high risk, low risk, here.'' Mr. Powner. So I think, if they had more red than yellow investments, they would have a higher grade. Right now, we need to still move in that direction. Right now, the dashboard shows 72 percent of our dollars, this is both major investments in acquisition or operations, are low risk. There is no one in this room that believes 72 percent of our major investments are low risk. They are just not. Mr. Meadows. So what you are saying, your testimony here today, and it needs to be a clear message to all of the agencies, is they can get a higher score-- am I understanding you right?--just by reporting it correctly? Mr. Powner. Correct. So Commerce and Labor both have As. They acknowledge a fair amount of yellows. And Labor has one red, but there is a fair amount of yellows in their assessments. It is not all green. NASA is all green, so they get an F on dashboard. So that is kind of how it works right now. We have seen changes. There is more acknowledgment of risk since your last hearing, but that review we did for you shows that we still have a long way to go. Even Commerce, there were a couple assessments that Steve has that we weren't in full agreement. We think he could still acknowledge some more risk on certain ones. Our point on this is you cannot manage these IT investments appropriately unless you acknowledge the risk. If you say it is green, you are not going to get reviewed when we all know that there are a lot of yellows and reds. We need that governance that every one of these CIOs talk about. And collectively, these four CIOs spend $5 billion collectively on IT in a given year. That is a lot of money that we need to manage more appropriately, and it starts with acknowledging risk. Mr. Meadows. All right. So that message needs to be clear. Let me finish up with two very small points. One, Mr. Cooper, congratulations on moving forward. Do you have a full-time CIO in place for Census yet? Mr. Cooper. We have made the selection. That individual will be moving into that office. I apologize. I do not know the specific timing, but very shortly. Mr. Meadows. Without getting into the weeds here, we really have some to-do items as it relates to Census. I won't beat you up in public, so let's just follow up on that. Ms. Leaf, is it true that you had to buy replacement parts on eBay for some of your system? Ms. Leaf. Yes, sir, it is. But I'm happy to say that those servers have been upgraded and replaced. Mr. Meadows. All right, so here is my last admonishment to all of you, and the chairman talked about it with Ms. Wynn with regards to Fortran. We have legacy systems that must--not maybe, must--must be changed. So the message that needs to go from you to those who work in IT is that we will no longer accept that this is the way that we have always done it, whether it is COBOL, Fortran, or any other language that is grayer than I am. It is imperative, without mentioning it in a public forum, we have agencies who are taking IT dollars to prop up legacy systems and stealing from the future of our IT systems to prop it up. Mr. Connolly and Mr. Hurd are much better versed at this than I am. I will dig from an investigative standpoint, and then let them weigh in from a technical standpoint, but let this day be the day that we start to address that. I will yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Chairman Meadows. I would like to recognize Mr. Connolly for 5 minutes. Mr. Connolly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I echo everything my friend from North Carolina and my friend from Texas have said. Picking up on a very interesting line of questioning Mr. Hurd had, Mr. Johnson, I want to state for the record that the carveout for the National Labs was an outrageous thing to do. They used their influence here on the Hill. They used an appropriations vehicle to get around this committee and this bill. The ink was barely dry on the bill. We didn't have implementation evaluation, and those labs got an exception. Who could be hurt by that? Well, anybody depending on the National Lab. The whole point here isn't another pain in the neck set of requirements and compliances. It is to transform how we do business. It is to get at legacy systems. It is to make sure things are encrypted and secure. It is to try to streamline management. It is to save resources and plow them back into the enterprise. If there is anyone who could have benefited from FITARA, it is the National Labs. So I hope you will go home to the Department of Energy with this message: We are not going to stand for it. We will revisit this issue. I do not presume to speak for my colleagues on the other side of the aisle, but I think this will be a broad bipartisan assault on the National Labs if they try it again. And if we have to go toe-to-toe with Appropriations Committee, we will do so, because it has been evident that others are benefiting from this effort. It would be one thing if we were many years into the process and it was onerous and it was hard and it was bureaucratic and it was costing money and the promise wasn't being realized. I still might not like it, but I could understand why you might pursue your other options--not you, but the National Labs, did not wait. I hope you will go back and warn them. This time, there will be a fight. And I think it will be bipartisan. At any rate, other than that, Mr. Cooper, you were talking in your testimony about cost savings. This really isn't about cost savings. I take that point very well. But on the other hand, as Ms. Leaf pointed out, there are cost savings. She specifically cited one that makes my heart go pitty-pat, data center consolidation. How are we doing at DOC on that? And do you have some kind of number you can ascribe to it? Mr. Cooper. Yes, we are doing very well, and we continue to do well. We have realized about--I think the number, and I will verify this to make sure I'm giving you an accurate number, so I will come back with a follow-up. But I think we now stand at about $308 million that we have actually realized. We are on track to continue our very solid record of adding to that savings figure. If I may, I want to clarify very quickly what my remark was. It was to differentiate between a focus on absolute cost savings in IT. One of the things that is misunderstood in my executive leadership team that we are working to clarify is the difference between absolute cost of IT--for example, for capacity expansion or newer demand, new capability. That will drive the total cost of IT up. But some folks are misunderstanding that if the total cost of IT is going up, then I as the CIO and other CIOs must be doing something incorrect. They believe that the total cost should be moving down or stay flat. What we are doing is we are trying to educate our entire work force in Commerce that the correct metric to use around cost savings is to ensure that the unit cost of any IT service that we deliver, we are constantly driving the unit cost down. That way, both can be true. We can reflect true efficiency, true cost savings, even when the total amount of spend may, in fact, be going up. Mr. Connolly. A good point, and that is why I wanted you to have the opportunity to clarify. I will give you a political note on that. But all of what you said takes a little time to institutionalize, to get everybody right with the program, to have a plan, to make sure the National Labs--we have this moment in time where the leadership here is completely united. We have GAO and GSA and OMB all on that script. That ain't going to last forever. There are not always going to be people appear who go, ``Yes, I get that, no problem, as long as trajectories are right.'' As you heard Mr. Hurd ask, I hope you are able to reinvest the savings, not everyone is going to have that point of view. That is why one of the things we are keen on here is taking advantage of this moment while you can. Mr. Powner, what changes might be made as we look down the road to the scorecard, to make it even more useful and hopefully more accurate? By the way, I like the fact that we are using some subjective judgment. When we see all green, you get an F. You are not rewarded for that. That is terrific. That is a very non-bureaucratic approach to a very important subject. I mean, one could just absolve oneself and go check, it's all green, how wonderful. We know that is not true. We know that we have lost billions of dollars sometimes in waste and mistaken investments. So trying to catch them early is a good thing. Exercising that judgment, to me, is also a very welcoming, good thing. But what might we add to the scorecard that would round it out and give us a better picture of DOE and NASA and others? Mr. Powner. A couple key examples. I think, one, fixing the CIO authority issue, you need to find some way to score that, because if you do not fix the CIO authority issue in the cultures and bureaucracies at all these departments and agencies, you are not going to be able to accomplish FITARA in all of these areas as well as you possibly could. So looking at those plans and measuring whether the CIO authorities are truly being tackled is, as I think Ms. Leaf clearly pointed out that they are doing at the Department of Labor, that is what we need to find a way to look into. That is critical. The other thing, if you look at data center consolidation, over time, it is not going to be about closures and savings, although we are always going to have savings, but it is about optimization metrics, too, because there are some agencies that I still think are low-balling their estimates. It looks like they are done, but their optimization metrics are nowhere utilizing the equipment and the facilities at those departments and agencies. So that means they probably still have more savings. I think when we mature this in the future, looking at optimization metrics, but clearly, the CIO authority needs to be tackled aggressively. Mr. Connolly. By the way, just for the record, now every Federal agency has submitted a FITARA implementation plan, right? Mr. Powner. Yes. Mr. Connolly. Okay. The last two came in recently. Mr. Powner. Yes. You can take your C- off the scorecards and make them C. Mr. Connolly. Ms. Wynn, two points, and then my time is up. One following up on what the chairman asked you, which I think is a brilliant question, are we going to get to Mars using Fortran? I think you said, well, I have to get back to you for the record. That is one I want to read. But I think he was getting at, with legacy systems, with antiquated systems, what could go wrong with that, in terms of Mars? Of all Federal agencies, yours in some ways is the most critically dependent on technology and technology working. I guess I would just ask you, for the record, would you not concede the point I think implied in the chairman's question, which is that technology, the IT piece, is really important to really all of your missions at NASA, and, therefore, getting them right and making sure we have them sort of updated and upgraded is pretty important? Ms. Wynn. Congressman Connolly, you are absolutely right. IT is important for NASA's mission. Mr. Connolly. One final point with you, Ms. Wynn, as you are relatively new, as you are working through the FITARA plan, I think you said you have a 219-page plan, setting metrics in advance, to me, is really important. If you do not have metrics, it is all interesting but--so, for example, on data center consolidation, I think it is really important, a priori, to say we have X number and we are going to reduce it by this much by this date. And it has to be a stretch. It has to push the organization a little bit, not an impossible goal, but if you don't have stretch goals, we are not really meeting our mission. So I would commend to you as you work through that plan set some of those metrics for the organization and your other colleagues, because that is the only way we are going to achieve progress. And it is the only way we are going to use FITARA as it was intended, which is a useful management tool for you and ultimately for the head of NASA itself. All right, I want to thank all of you for being here. I really benefited a lot. And my concern about the National Labs ought not to color, Mr. Johnson, the progress DOE is making. I thank you, but I wanted you to go back, because I think the chairman is absolutely right to ask that question, and it did not go unnoticed up here. Thank you. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Connolly. Mr. Meadows? Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A very brief follow-up, since we are talking about legacy systems, and since most of the people working on those legacy systems I would surmise are closer to retirement than not, what I would like from each one of you is the cost estimate of really not waiting for 2 or 3 or 5 years for us to fall off the cliff, the cost estimate of getting rid of those legacy systems for your agencies, if you would do that. Then, Mr. Cooper, let me come back to the CIO. It is obvious that you get this here, and we have the Census coming up and we cannot afford to fail. Has it been contemplated that the CIO role for Census would be incorporated as part of your responsibility, or that you take that on, since you obviously get it and are willing to work? Because I need to get the Census side with the GAO counterpart because we have GAO and we all stakeholders, to be frank, that are very, very concerned that we are not getting it. And we have a great relationship, but we are reaching a point of ``go, no go'' on a lot of decisions that are creeping up. You get it. I'm not so sure the new CIO would get it, so have you looked at that? Mr. Cooper. Yes, and, Chairman Meadows, may I offer this, would this be acceptable, I will carry back--I know the planned timing. As I mentioned, we selected the individual. I know the planned timing. Would you allow me to go back, work with Director Thompson, and speed that up and allow us to put that individual in place? My commitment to you and this committee is that I will then commit to working directly with that individual to ensure that we help that individual come up to speed as rapidly as possible, but leveraging myself and my office to ensure that we honor the commitments that I previously made to this committee and that director Thompson has previously made to this committee? Mr. Meadows. That sounds fair, because what we cannot have is someone in the job 8 months later, and we get an F on the Census. So I appreciate that. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. Mr. Powner, the issue of the CIO responsibility still perplexes me. Of the 24 CFO agencies, how many of the CIOs report directly to the agency head? Mr. Powner. I do not have that exact number, but I think very few of them do. Even if they do--we looked at this years ago and did some work on this. It is dated, but even those that on paper report to the agency head typically report to the DepSec. We found that reporting to the DepSec actually gives most CIOs the right visibility and a seat at the table at most of the agencies. That is what we concluded. Mr. Hurd. So how many report directly to the Deputy Secretary or the Secretary? Mr. Powner. I don't have an exact number on that. But I can tell you not enough. Mr. Hurd. So in your opinion, would an appropriate grade when it comes to CIO authorities be whether they report directly to the Secretary or the Deputy Secretary, and do all of the CIOs within the agency report to them? Mr. Powner. Yes, that is a good way to measure. That is the intent of FITARA, where you have the CIOs reporting to the department or agency ---- Mr. Hurd. Would you agree that this metric is disproportionately more influential in the overall grading of an agency over all the other areas that FITARA looks at? Mr. Powner. Yes, if you don't fix those CIO authorities, I think you're going to continually struggle. The other thing I think to keep in mind is the relationship with the other CFOs. We have heard many agencies, when CIOs have a solid relationship with the chief financial officers, things work out a lot better. Mr. Hurd. Mr. Powner, you are reading my mind. How are CFOs responding to the implementation of FITARA? Mr. Powner. Mixed bag. I don't have GAO reports that say this, but we have enough anecdotes, and you have heard it. Some CFOs are worried about losing power. Some CFOs are working closely with CIOs. We are seeing some progress, but we need to see more progress so we have equal footing there. I think a true measure, too, is going to be trying to get your arms around the IT budget. I don't think CIOs can do that without CFOs' help. So you have to partner with CFOs to get your arms around the IT budget. That is a clear position in FITARA. There was a reason FITARA was written that way, starting with this committee. Mr. Hurd. At FITARA 3.0, I think it would be interesting to have some of the CFOs sitting alongside their CIO colleagues, having these conversations. Mr. Connolly. Mr. Chairman? Mr. Hurd. Yes? Mr. Connolly. You have asked a very, very important question, and I would just say, when we wrote FITARA, we decided to make it less prescriptive and more expansive. We took cognizance of the fact that we had multiple CIOs, and rather than by fiat say there shall be one, we kind of encouraged the system to evolve, so that there would be a primus inter pares, first among equals, in the CIO constellation, because there were 240 or 250 CIOs. And your question is absolutely apt. So will that sort of flexible legislative framework work, or do we have to resort to codifying and deciding by fiat? And that is why I think your question is so irrelevant, and I hope the CFOs understand that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for the question. Mr. Hurd. My last question goes to Mr. Cooper. I appreciate everyone being here today, and for the delay for votes. Commerce got the highest grade, yet Commerce has 114 million lines of Fortran code, which they have 525 employees supporting that. There are 37 systems that are using operating systems that are no longer supported by the vendor. Por que? Why? Mr. Cooper. In most cases, those support operations that cannot easily be replaced by commercial, off-the-shelf software. Mr. Hurd. You are talking about the Fortran code? Mr. Cooper. The Fortran code is, in most cases that I am aware of--I accept what you're telling me as far as the numbers of systems and lines of code. What we are doing is working with those bureaus directly where we have a legacy system exactly like you described. It is no longer vendor-supported. Now, what we are doing in a lot of cases is we actually are backporting, meaning we are getting patches through the public domain, and we are applying those patches on a very regular basis, much as we would do if we received a vendor patch. We are doing that in every situation that we can. We are also doing the following. In a situation where we cannot take that approach, we are doing everything we can to basically quarantine that legacy system. We are doing that specifically to prevent cyber risk in the spread of something coming in through a vulnerability in those legacy systems. We are trying to quarantine it so that we can shut it off and it won't then propagate across our networks or across other applications. Lastly, we are working as rapidly and effectively as we can, quality with speed, to replace those legacy systems. But because, in most cases, we can't find readily available commercial, off-the-shelf software, we still have to build it. We are taking advantage of savings we are realizing through our data center consolidation initiative and optimization efforts to redirect that savings into new development and replacement of some of, but not all, some of those legacy systems. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Cooper. I would like to thank the rest of the witnesses for taking the time to appear before us today. If there is no further business, without objection, the subcommittees stand adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4:29 p.m., the subcommittees were adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]