Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- EXAMINING THE IMPACTS OF EPA AIR AND WATER REGULATIONS ON THE STATES AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] EXAMINING THE IMPACTS OF EPA AIR AND WATER REGULATIONS ON THE STATES AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ FEBRUARY 26, 2015 __________ Serial No. 114-20 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 94-838 PDF WASHINGTON : 2015 ----------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512-1800; DC area (202) 512-1800 Fax: (202) 512-2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402-0001 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Sean McLaughlin, Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Joseph Brazauskas, Counsel Drew Colliatie, Professional Staff Member Sharon Casey, Deputy Chief Clerk Subcommittee on the Interior Cynthia M. Lummis (WY), Chairman Paul A. Gosar (AZ) Brenda L. Lawrence (MI), Ranking Blake Farenthold (TX) Member Ken Buck (CO), Vice Chair Matt Cartwright (PA) Steve Russell (OK) Stacey E. Plaskett (VI) Gary J. Palmer (AL) Jim Cooper (TN) C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on February 26, 2015................................ 1 WITNESSES Mr. Tim Fox, Attorney General, State of Montana Oral Statement............................................... 5 Written Statement............................................ 8 Ms. Leslie Rutledge, Attorney General, State of Arkansas Oral Statement............................................... 13 Written Statement............................................ 15 Ms. Anne E. Smith, Ph.D, Senior Vice President, NERA Economic Consulting Oral Statement............................................... 27 Written Statement............................................ 29 Mr. David Harrison, Ph.D, Senior Vice President, NERA Economic Consulting Oral Statement............................................... 51 Written Statement............................................ 53 Ms. Susan F. Tierney, Ph.D, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group Oral Statement............................................... 80 Written Statement............................................ 82 APPENDIX Statement of Ms. Lummis, Chairwoman of Subcommittee.............. 104 Statement of Mrs. Lawrence, Representative....................... 106 2014-06 Henry Waxman ``The Clean Air Act's Track Record''........ 109 2015-02-26 National Wildlife Statement........................... 112 2014-06-12 Tsirigotis-EPA to Coyote-Crow MT...................... 120 Links to: 2014-07-31 NERA ``Assessing Economic Impacts of a Stricter National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Ozone''.......... 122 2014-10-16 NERA ``Potential Impacts of the EPA Clean Power Plan''..................................................... 122 2015-02-26 ``Economic Impacts of a 65 ppb National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Ozone''........................... 122 2015-02-26 NERA ``Economic Impacts of a 65 ppb National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Ozone''................... 122 2015-02-26 National Association of Realtors Statement............ 143 Thomas Easterly-IDEM Statement................................... 159 AG Comments-EPA Carbon Emission Guidelines....................... 162 EXAMINING THE IMPACTS OF EPA AIR AND WATER REGULATIONS ON THE STATES AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ---------- Thursday, February 26, 2015, House of Representatives, Subcommittee on the Interior, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, DC. The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:07 p.m. in room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, the Honorable Cynthia Lummis [chairwoman of the subcommittee], presiding. Present: Representatives Lummis, Chaffetz, Buck, Palmer, Gosar, Russell, Lawrence, Cartwright, and Plaskett. Ms. Lummis. Without objection, the Chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Good afternoon and welcome to the first hearing for the new Subcommittee on Interior of the Oversight and Government Reform Committee. I am pleased to be holding this hearing on the impact on the American people of three proposed EPA rules. Over the last year, the EPA has issued rules that are unprecedented in scope and among the most expensive in history. This overreach will impact families and businesses across the country. The first rule we will examine is the redefinition of the term waters of the United States under the Clean Water Act. Despite two Supreme Court rulings that define the maximum reach of the Clean Water Act, the EPA has proposed a rule that will increase its regulatory authority far beyond current policy. It would allow the EPA almost unconstrained access to regulate and burden landowners with endless environmental studies. Even more disturbing, the Waters of the U.S. rule still does not provide the regulatory certainty that farmers, small businesses and homeowners need. Instead, it will result in more red tape, displace local management programs and shift limited resources away from working environmental programs. We will also examine two EPA Clean Air Act rules that would fundamentally alter the relationship between States and the Federal Government. These rules would result in massive consumer electricity price increases and trillions of dollars in lost economic activity. These rules are particularly damaging to my home State of Wyoming where we produce over 40 percent of the Nation's coal. They would force the retirement of coal power plants across the country, significantly increasing electricity and natural gas prices and threatens the reliability of the electric grid. The first of these air regulations is called the Clean Power Plan. This proposed rule would require the regulation of existing power plants and unconstitutionally expand EPAs authority into the management of States energy generation. It does this through so-called beyond the fence measures that regulate more than just power plants. These measures would mandate energy efficiency requirements on individual households. Compliance costs of the Clean Power Plan could be as high as $479 billion by 2030 and 43 States would face double digit electric price increases. This massive cost comes with extremely limited benefits and violates the principles of federalism. The second regulation we will examine is the EPAs proposal to update the air quality standards for ground level ozone. This benign sounding rule is actually widely considered to be the most expansive and expensive rule in the history of the United States. Independent experts estimate the total possible cost of the rule at $1.7 trillion and 1.4 million job equivalence lost per year. This rule is so burdensome that some national parks, the Nation's most pristine environments, will be found to violate the new standards. Today, we will hear from two State Attorney Generals, who will explain the impact these rules will have on the States. They will also discuss the EPAs utter lack of consultation with Native communities despite clear legal requirements. We will also hear from two economists who raise significant questions about EPAs cost estimates. Just as importantly, these economists will also testify that the EPA is systematically overestimating the benefits of these rules by double counting benefits from other rules, ignoring basic accounting practices and projecting benefits out hundreds of years. Ms. Lummis. With that, I would like to thank the witnesses in advance of your testimony. We are so grateful that you are here. I now recognize Mrs. Lawrence, the Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on the Interior, for her opening Statement. Mrs. Lawrence, I am so pleased to be serving with you. I so enjoyed our visit the other night. Welcome to our collaboration. The microphone is yours. Mrs. Lawrence. It is an honor to be a Member of Congress and to sit with the leadership that we have as the Chair for this committee. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. I want to thank you for holding this hearing. I want to thank our witnesses for their testimony today. In a special message to Congress in 1970, President Nixon stated: ``As concern with the condition of our physical environment has intensified, it has become increasingly clear that we need to know more about the total environment, land, water and air.'' Indeed, the present government structure for dealing with environmental pollution often defies effective and concerted efforts. In proposing that the Environmental Protection Agency be set up as a separate, new agency, ``I am making an exception to one of my own principles that as a matter of effective and orderly administration, additional new, independent agencies normally should not be created. Because environmental protection cuts across so many jurisdictions and because arresting environmental deterioration is of great importance to the quality of life in our country and the world, I believe that in this case, a strong, independent agency is needed.'' I want to start by saying that the EPA was not established to be red or blue. It was established to be green. It was established to help us protect our environment, our citizens and our children. First, I would like to address the Clean Water Act which has been successful in past years ensuring that Americans have clean and safe water. Those of us who have been involved and informed know that there are some challenges across our country that are stepping up now and that we need to address. I believe we all agree that clean water is vital to each of us for our drinking supply, for safe places to swim, for healthy fish, for growing crops, for beverage manufacturing, for energy generation and for a host of other uses. The proposed EPA rule would improve the process for determining what types of water are and are not covered by the Clean Water Act. Contrary to the claim of detectors, the rule would clarify protection for streams and wetlands that form the foundation of the Nation's water resources. It will not result in an expansion of Federal authority. Only waters that have been historically covered by the Clean Water Act are covered by the rule. Turning our attention to the dangers of ozone exposure is equally important. More than 1,000 new studies demonstrate the health and environment harms of ozone. Exposure can cause difficulty breathing and airway inflammation. Ozone exposure is likely to cause permanent death from lung disease. Children often suffer from a disproportionate burden of ozone related health impacts because their lungs and other organs are still developing. Nearly 26 million people have asthma in the United States, including 7.1 million children. Fortunately over 40 years ago, Congress passed the Clean Air Act to protect public health and the environment. Recently, EPA proposed new national air quality standards for ozone to lower the ozone in the atmosphere from 75 ppb to a range of 65 to 70 ppb by the year 2030. The Clean Power Plan has also been proposed in order to limit the amount of carbon pollution power plants will emit. Likewise, the Waters of the United States rule was proposed to clarify which bodies of water are or are not covered by the Clean Water Act. History tells us that environmental regulations do not cause an economic calamity. In fact, in the past 40 years, the CDP has increased by 212 percent since the Clean Air and Clean Water Acts were enacted. Clean air pollutions have decreased by 70 percent. Instead of killing jobs, as some opponents have claimed, the pollution control industry has generated more than $300 billion in revenue and $44 billion in exports and supported 1.5 million jobs. None of the inflated costs of implementing these laws ever materialized. Industry innovation improved and thrived in response to new demands. In closing, there have been numerous processes in the past few decades to clean up the air and water but more work is necessary to adequately protect public health from ozone, excessive carbon dioxide and water pollution and to mitigate the efforts of climate change. I hope that we look at this industry and recognize the oppositions of some industries based on really scare mongering. History shows us that cleaning the air and water are both good for public health, good for our economy and good for our country. Thank you. Ms. Lummis. I thank the gentlelady from Michigan and look forward to our collaboration. Our districts just about couldn t be more different than two districts in the United States. She represents northern areas of Detroit, very urban, and my State of Wyoming is the most sparsely populated in the Nation, rich in clean air, clean water and natural resources. This will be fun. I am very much looking forward to working with you. Thank you for your opening remarks. I am now pleased to recognize Mr. Chaffetz, the Chairman of the full committee, for his Statement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for creating this subcommittee and giving us an opportunity to look at some issues that are so impactful for our citizens. The time is yours. Mr. Chaffetz. Thank you. I thank you for being the chairwoman of this committee. We reconfigured this to give some focus not only between the Department of Interior but also the Forest Service, the Department of Energy and the EPA so that we, as the oversight committee, can look at the far reaching breadth rather than just have it siloed in one committee or another. I appreciate all the members who will participate on these panels and in all these discussions. I too am from the intermountain west. We are proud neighbors of Wyoming. Where we produce a lot of this energy. We have an abundance of coal, natural gas and oil shale. Yet every time I turn around, there seems to be some reason, some other implication that is put out there by the EPA. We love the west; we love our mountains, our air, our water and our streams. I do think there is a role to create some bounds and rules of the road, but I do worry about how severe the EPA is in its approach. It wasn t too long ago in this very room we found out that the person heading up Air and Water Quality, one of the most senior people at the EPA, we had a hearing, he had not shown up for work in years. He was convicted of fraud and is in jail. He had to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in restitution to the government because he was telling his senior leadership that he was a CIA agent and that he was overseas in Afghanistan. It begs the question, if he was so fraudulent that he actually went to jail, what about all the regulations that came into place for air and water quality during that time. It does beg the question. We have had the Inspector General here talking about the problems they have with sexual harassment in the senior-most offices. We have had people here talking about the fact that they cannot seem to fire anyone and move them out the door. Time and time again, the EPA has routinely been here talking about all these problems with mismanagement and waste. Yet, they want to go into our States and start telling people how to conduct their business. Again, we need clean coal and good energy. I buy that. Let us also understand that there are very real impacts upon economies, jobs and peoples livelihoods. Their job role and responsibility is not to just shutdown everyone. I really appreciate the panel who I think can give us a much broader scope and understanding of all the ramifications that come into place when you have the EPA come in. I appreciate the Attorney Generals who have taken time out of their busy schedule to give us their perspective from across the United States. I look forward to some robust discussions today. I have great optimism for this panel and this subcommittee moving forward. With that, I yield back. Ms. Lummis. I thank the Chairman. I will hold open the record for five legislative days for any member who would like to submit a written Statement. We will now recognize our panel of witnesses. I am pleased to welcome the Honorable Tim Fox, Attorney General, State of Montana; the Honorable Leslie Rutledge, Attorney General, State of Arkansas; Dr. David Harrison, Senior Vice President, NERA Economic Consulting; Dr. Anne E. Smith, Ph.D, Senior Vice President, NERA Economic Consulting; and Dr. Susan F. Tierney, Ph.D, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group. Welcome all. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn before they testify. Please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? [Witnesses respond in the affirmative.] Ms. Lummis. In order to allow time for discussion, please limit your testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written Statement will be made a part of the record. I now would like to recognize Attorney General Fox for his opening Statement. STATEMENT OF TIM FOX Mr. Fox. Chairman Lummis, Congresswoman Lawrence and members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to speak here today. I am Tim Fox, the Attorney General of Montana. Without hopefully offending any of the other members of the committee, Congresswoman Lawrence, you will be glad to hear that I am Detroit Tigers fan--go Tigers. I will speak briefly this morning of my concerns with three regulatory initiatives by the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Two are rulemaking proposals and one involves an unprecedented action by EPA to exercise a preemptive veto of a Section 404 permit. In a proposal published in the Federal Register on April 21, 2014, EPA proposes to amend the definition of ``waters of the U.S.'' in such a way that would extend the reach of the Clean Water Act to virtually all interState and intraState waters and all lands which could potentially affect such waters. Montana is, for the most part, a headwater State, blessed with waters of exceptional quality. The people of Montana have taken steps to fully protect that priceless resource. Those steps begin with our State Constitution which provides comprehensive protections for our waters. We have implemented those constitutional safeguards through the 1971 Montana Water Quality Act and regulations to implement the Act. Based on its Water Quality Act, Montana sought and was granted primacy to implement the Clean Water Act s permit system in the State but even beyond the permit protections, the Montana DEQ has broad authority to prevent pollution. The point is that Montana has taken primary responsibility for its land and waters as was assumed by Congress when it enacted the Clean Water Act. There is no justification for extending the reach of the Clean Water Act in our State. The overreach impinges indirectly on our State's sovereignty and offends Congress Stated intention in the Clean Water Act to recognize, protect and preserve the primary rights of the States to manage their lands and water resources. The second problematic proposed rule is EPAs June 18, 2014 existing source proposal under Section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act. I join the Attorneys General of 16 other States in comments on that proposal, but I also filed separate comments with Chairman Darrin Old Coyote of the Crow Nation. I want to talk just a minute about those comments. I grew up Hardin, Montana on the Crow Reservation and developed a deep appreciation both for the Crow people and the problems they faced and continue to face. The Crow Nation has huge, undeveloped coal reserves and one operating mine, the Absaloka Mine which provides two-thirds of the Crow Nation's annual non-Federal budget and is by far the largest private employer on the reservation. Unfortunately, one of the very likely effects of EPA's existing source rule would be to kill the market for the coal produced by the Absaloka Mine which is nearly all sold to Minnesota utilities. This will in turn kill the mine, in turn causing drastic loss of services and employment on the Crow Reservation. EPA has a legal duty under Executive Order 13175 to ensure meaningful and timely input by tribal officials in the development of regulatory proposals that affect tribes. Aside from two ``Dear Tribal Leader'' form letters, nobody from the agency contacted the Crow Nation directly in a government to government contact as required by Executive Order 13175 and the Presidential Memo which implements the Order. Given the consequences of the proposed rule to the Crow Nation, this doesn't seem a sufficient effort on the part of EPA. Third and last, the matter I want to address today is EPA's involvement and their actions relating to the proposed Pebble Mine project in Alaska. In 1979, the EPA promulgated a rule providing the Administrator could prohibit the specification of a site under Section 404(c) before a permit application has been submitted to or approved by the Corps or a State. This authority up to now has never been used to issue a preemptive veto. However, last year, the EPA proposed to use the authority to issue a preemptive veto before any formal application for a permit had been prepared or filed by the developer of the Pebble project. As Montana's chief legal officer, it greatly concerns me that we can see a situation in our State where the Administrator of a Federal agency preemptively vetoes a development proposal before we have an opportunity to receive, review and comment on an application for permit. Chairman Lummis, Congresswoman Lawrence and members of the committee, thank you again for giving me some time here today to speak on behalf of the people of Montana. I have submitted a more comprehensive written testimony for your consideration. I am happy to answer any questions you may have. Thank you. [Prepared Statement of Mr. Fox follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. I thank the gentleman and look forward to visiting with him some time about the Purple Cow Restaurant in Hardin, Montana that I used to frequent when I was a younger gal. Mr. Fox. Chairman Lummis, if I may, my mother was the hostess at the Purple Cow. Ms. Lummis. That was one of my favorite places. I have pictures at the Purple Cow. The chair now recognizes the Attorney General of the State of Arkansas, Ms. Rutledge, for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF LESLIE RUTLEDGE, ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF ARKANSAS Ms. Rutledge. Chairman Lummis, Ranking Member Lawrence and members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to speak with you all today. My name is Leslie Rutledge, Arkansas Attorney General. I am here today to give you a sense of our State, one that is rich in natural heritage and is known across the Nation as the natural State for rolling hills, dense woodlands, miles of rivers and lakes and how they will be impacted by overreaching regulations of the Environmental Protection Agency. Specifically, the EPA exceeds its legal authority in three recently proposed rules: the Clean Power Plan, more stringent ground level ozone standards and changes to the definitions of the waters of the United States. As Attorney General, I represent the interests of Arkansas utility rate payers. These are hardworking Arkansans, some who own their own small businesses, some run multigenerational family farms from Fayetteville to Warren to Texarkana to Jonesboro, and all points in between. I have heard grave concern about the EPA's proposed Clean Power Plan. The rule requires Arkansas to meet an almost 45 percent reduction in carbon emissions from electric generating units by 2030. This is the sixth highest rate of reduction in the Nation imposed upon a State that ranks 46th in per capita income. This is a rule that the EPA does not have the legal authority to issue. The EPA regulates coal-fired power plants such as the one in Independence County, where I grew up, under Section 112 of the Clean Air Act, not Section 111(b). The law cannot be clearer. It specifically prohibits the EPA from invoking 111(b) where the source category is regulated under Section 112. The proposed rule mandates what each State must achieve rather than providing guidelines and procedures for States to use. This is a serious overreach of the EPA's authority and different from the implementation of any other limits set under the Clean Air Act. My opposition to this rule begs the question whether I am for clean air. I certainly am and I can confidently say that all Arkansans are in favor of clean air. The rule goes beyond the EPA's authority to regulate air pollution. It imposes a misguided, national energy policy and seeks to control the State's regulation of energy generation and usage. Also, under the Clean Air Act, the EPA has proposed unnecessarily stringent ground level ozone standards. The proposed rule reduces the current standard of 75 ppm to somewhere between 60 to 70 ppm. A decrease to 60 ppm will have a devastating effect on Arkansas. At that level, almost all of Arkansas would likely be in non-attainment. Anyone who has visited Arkansas would be hard pressed to believe that our beautiful mountains have a smog problem. Years of nonattainment would directly set back economic recovery that we have achieved in the past few years. Likewise, the EPA's attempt to clarify the definition of the waters of the U.S. is so expansive that it would likely control land use activities over most of the United States. As Arkansas Attorney General, this is a major concern for me because this would drastically impact our farmers and ranchers. Rather than clarifying, the rule complicates current law. The process for determining jurisdiction becomes a maize for both regulators and for the public to navigate. Arkansas' agricultural community would be left with increased uncertainty over the Clean Water Act. Agriculture is essential to our economy. According to the Arkansas Farm Bureau, agriculture provides $16 billion annually and one out of every six jobs in the State. While the EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers have repeatedly offered verbal assurances that agriculture need not worry about the scope of the proposed definition of waters of the United States, farmers in Arkansas worry because of the actions of agencies, not their words. For example, in 2014, the Corps took action against a Tennessee row crop farm determining that a field was considered waters of the U.S. Arkansas farmers worry that every day activities such as plowing and applying fertilizer and pesticides will subject them, just like our neighboring State of Tennessee, to Federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act. While each of these rules would cause great harm to Arkansas on their own, the cumulative effect cannot be overStated. This Administration is intent on following an agenda that ignores the plain language passed by Congress and has created a perfect storm of Federal regulation that will result in economic disaster for Arkansas. Arkansans believe in protecting our environment. We take great pride in being the natural State and take pride in supplying the world with food and growing jobs in our State. I thank Chairman Lummis, Ranking Member Lawrence and other members of the committee for the opportunity to address you all today. I welcome your questions. Thank you. [Prepared Statement of Ms. Rutledge follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. Thank you, Attorney General Rutledge. Before I recognize Dr. Smith, it appears we may be interrupted by votes. We will hear the entirety of Dr. Smith's opening Statement for 5 minutes. If votes have been called, then we will take a break for about 25 minutes while the members of the committee vote and return to hear the opening Statements of Drs. Harrison and Tierney. With that, Dr. Smith, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF ANNE E. SMITH Ms. Smith. Thank you, Chairwoman Lummis, Ranking Member Lawrence and other members of the committee. Thank you for the invitation to speak at this hearing. I am Anne Smith of NERA Economic Consulting. My testimony today is my own and does not represent the position of my company or any of my clients. This hearing is about the impacts of EPA regulations. I will address some insights and issues about the comparisons of the benefits and the costs of two major regulations EPA is presently proposing. The first, the Clean Power Plan, is to reduce electricity sector emissions of carbon dioxide. The other is a tightening of the ozone national ambient air quality standard, NAAQS. My colleague to my left, Dr. Harrison, will be testifying on high costs of these regulations and analyses we have done together at NERA. I agree with all that he will have to say. I am going to focus on EPA's own estimates of the benefits of these two rules and how they compare to costs. For these comparisons, I will only use EPA's own lower cost estimates. My bottom line is that EPA's analyses of both rules offer a far weaker case that the benefits of those rules will exceed their costs than one would believe from listening to EPA's press releases or reading the regulatory impact analyses. First, for the Clean Power Plan, EPA's comparisons of the costs and benefits of the CPP falsely suggest that climate benefits will exceed costs during the period of implementation, 2020 to 2030. When correctly presented, EPA's own estimates reveal that it finds the CPP will cost more than $180 billion by 2030, in present value terms and that the present value of its cumulative climate benefits are not expected to exceed that $180 billion of cost until more than 100 years later. Furthermore, EPA's estimates of those climate benefits are global benefits, all countries of the world and the benefits to the U.S., including future U.S. generations, not just current U.S. generations, are not expected to exceed that rule's costs, even under the most pessimistic projections of potential climate impacts that EPA is using in its regulatory impact analysis. I will now turn to the proposed ozone NAAQS revision. At tightening of the current ozone NAAQS could be much more expensive than the proposed Clean Power Plan. Yet, for this rule, EPA does not estimate this rule's ozone-related benefits will exceed its costs, even using EPA's own cost estimates. How then can EPA claim that the benefits of the ozone NAAQS will ``outweigh it's cost by as much as three to one?'' The answer is, they pad the benefits estimates with so-called co- benefits. Co-benefits are estimates of benefits based on projections of coincidental changes in a completely different pollutant than ozone, a completely different pollutant than the target of the regulation. These are coincidental reductions projected to occur in fine particulate matter, PM2.5, which are the subject of their own regulatory coverage under NAAQS. EPA has a long tradition of making rules appear to have benefits that exceed their costs by adding such massive doses of co-benefits from PM2.5. In fact, these co-benefits also appear in the benefit cost analysis for the CPP, the climate rule we are talking about. The thousands of premature deaths and the hundreds of thousands of avoided asthma attacks that EPA has claimed for that climate rule are based on PM2.5 co-benefits. They have nothing to do with climate benefit estimates whatsoever. I have written and testified previously on the problems with what I have called EPA's co-benefits habit. I reference the writing of that discussed in my written testimony. To summarize briefly, even the Administrator s Statements about the health benefits of PM2.5 imply that these co-benefits may not exist at all. That is because they are based on changes in PM2.5 concentrations that are already below the protected level of the PM2.5 ambient air quality standard. But, even if they did exist, they should not be used to promote regulations that have nothing to do with PM2.5 such as these two EPA proposals I have talked about which are intended not to reduce PM2.5 but to deal with climate impacts and ozone exposures. Using co-benefits in this way is a recipe for creating economically inefficient policies for managing those purported risks of PM2.5 while it also misleads the public on the need for more costly regulations of these other two pollutants. Thank you very much for your attention. I will answer questions later if you are interested. [Prepared Statement of Ms. Smith follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. We are interested, Dr. Smith. Thank you very much for your testimony. Votes have been called on the floor. The subcommittee will reconvene shortly after the end of the last vote. If you could all return shortly after the last votes, we would deeply appreciate it. The subcommittee stands in recess and with bated breath to hear the testimony of Drs. Harrison and Tierney. [Recess.] Ms. Lummis. I thank the panel for its patience with our leave of absence to be voting on the floor. Our next witness is Dr. Harrison. Thank you for being here. We look forward to hearing from you. The floor is yours, Dr. Harrison. STATEMENT OF DAVID HARRISON Mr. Harrison. Thank you, Chairwoman Lummis and members of the subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to participate in today's hearings. I am Dr. David Harrison, Jr. My testimony is my own and does not represent my company or any client. My comments on the economic impacts of EPA regulations are based on two recent NERA studies. One related to the national ambient air quality standard for ozone and one related to EPA's proposed Clean Power Plan to reduce carbon dioxide emissions from the electric utility sector. Both studies indicate that these two major environmental policies could have very substantial economic impacts on individual States and on the U.S. as a whole. Let me start with the ozone study. My written testimony is based on a July 2014 study we did, but today we released an update that reflects EPA's November 2014 ozone proposal. I believe you have received copies of that. I would like to request that it be entered into the record. Ms. Lummis. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Harrison. Thank you. In this updated study, we evaluated a 65 ppb ozone standard. We used the same basic methodology as in our earlier study, but used EPA's newer released data on the emissions control technologies and costs. A key finding of our analysis is that more than 60 percent of the emission reductions required to reach the 65 ppb standard was what EPA refers to as unknown controls. That is, controls that EPA did not identify in its analysis. These controls, they assumed, would be equal to the same $15,000 per ton regardless of the emission source, the State or the level of control. In contrast, we developed what we have referred to as an evidence-based approach to identify the likely nature of these controls. We concluded that they would mostly involve closure of power plants or turnover of older vehicles and similar equipment. We found that most of these controls would cost much more than the $15,000 per ton that EPA had assumed. Using these estimates of compliance costs and NERA's macroeconomic model called NewERA, we estimate that a 65 ppb ozone standard would reduce U.S. GDP by an average of $140 billion per year over the period from 2017 to 2040. The present value of the cost today would be $1.7 trillion. Other impacts were correspondingly large. For example, the annual reduction in employment income would be equivalent to 1.4 million jobs per year. The annual reduction in consumer spending power would be about $830 per household. Let me briefly turn to the Clean Power Plan Study. We evaluated what EPA's preferred option, what they referred to as Option 1, which was designed to reduce U.S. power CO2 emissions by 30 percent below their 2005 level. They set these State level emission rates based on their analysis of production from four building blocks. These building blocks were energy efficiency, increased utilization of natural gas, increases in renewable and nuclear energy and increases in end use efficiency. We used NERA's NewERA model to evaluate the effects of this under two cases. In one case, we assumed the States were able to use all four building blocks. In the other case, they would only be able to use two building blocks. In the interest of time, I will just summarize a few results of the four building block scenario. Note that the impacts of the two building block scenario were much greater. We estimated what the U.S. energy system cost would be under the Clean Power Plan under these scenarios. Under the four building block scenario, the U.S. energy systems cost would increase by more than $360 billion on a present value basis over the 15 year period from 2017 to 2031. The impacts on individual States of the Clean Power Plan would also be substantial. The most substantial impacts were on electricity prices. For 44 of the States, delivered electricity prices would increase by more than 10 percent per year on average over that 15 year period due to the Clean Power Plan. In summary, these States indicate that both the proposed Federal ozone standard and the proposed Clean Power Plan could lead to very substantial costs and economic impacts, both on individual States and for the U.S. economy as a whole. Thank you again for the opportunity to participate. I look forward to answering any questions you might have. [Prepared Statement of Mr. Harrison follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. Thank you for your testimony, Dr. Harrison. I would now like to recognize Dr. Tierney for 5 minutes. Welcome, Dr. Tierney. STATEMENT OF SUSAN F. TIERNEY Ms. Tierney. Thank you so much, Chairman Lummis, Ranking Member Lawrence and subcommittee members. It is very nice to be here today. Thank you very much. As you know, the EPA has responsibility under the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act to protect the public from harmful discharges of pollutants into the Nation's air and waterways. In the decade since these Federal laws were enacted, they have led to improvements in the public s health and protected the Nation's natural resources on which our entire economy depends. As scientific information has evolved over time, as has technology, so has the administration of these Federal laws. I am a former Environmental Secretary and energy regulator in the State of Massachusetts where I was appointed by both Republicans and Democrats. I have direct familiarity with administering Federal and State laws to protect the environment and energy markets. Since leaving government, I have been a consultant and worked for a wide variety of clients looking at energy markets, State environmental laws, Federal environmental laws, local economies and impacts on consumers of a variety of different public policies. The three proposed EPA regulations under discussion today are important regulations from a public health point of view, but are also important for local economies and economic development. First, clarifying the scope of Federal jurisdictions and consistency of treatment of waterways across the Nation helps to provide appropriate signals to private actors about what they can expect when States review their economic development activities. Lack of clear rules is known to chill economic development. Second, ensuring that ozone standards remain up to date and consistent with the evolving State of knowledge in the scientific community is critically important for public health and for local economies as well. Economic impact analyses that fail to look at the benefits to public health are inherently inconsistent with what the ozone standard is all about, which is public health. Third, the rest of my testimony will focus on the EPA's proposed Clean Power Plan. The EPA is required to establish emissions controls on the power sector. In doing so, the EPA has adopted a regulatory approach that offers significant flexibility to the States to fashion their own plans to control emissions from power plants in ways that work well for their economies. Having a reliable and efficient electric industry is critically important for Americans and the U.S. economy and so is addressing carbon pollution. In that context, the EPA's proposal is critically important. The Supreme Court has said that greenhouse gases are an air pollutant under the Clean Air Act. The American power sector represents the Nation's largest source of greenhouse gas emissions. Americans are feeling the effects of costly climate change already. The power sector in the United States emits 1 out of every 15 tons of pollutants anywhere in the globe. It is a major source of the global warming emissions and is costly for climate change. Equally important is assurance that the electric system is reliable and it is affordable. Fortunately, EPA's proposal allows States to adopt approaches that minimize the Clean Power Plan's cost to consumers. In the past year, I have co-authored three reports on EPA's proposed impacts on consumers and electric system reliability. In researching the newest one of those reports, which we issued last week and which I have attached to my testimony, my colleagues and I read a significant number of the comments that have been filed on the EPA's proposal. We found that many studies and comments incorrectly presume that the rule will be inflexibly implemented, which is opposite to the way it has been designed. The assumptions are worse case scenarios and assume that the private sector will idlely stand by as will regulators rather than doing their jobs to make sure the impacts are at least cost and that there are reliable outcomes. There is no historical basis for those sets of assumptions. The issues will be solved by a dynamic interplay of actions by regulators and market participants with solutions proceeding in parallel. Indeed, this dynamic interplay is the reason why a recent survey of 400 utility executives in the United States said they support the proposed Clean Power Plan and the emissions targets. Finally, the electric industry is undergoing major change as we know. Those changes are from the shale gas revolution, its price pressure on coal in many parts of the country, the domestic supply of renewable energy in vast parts of the United States, aging infrastructure and a significant growth in energy productivity. These shifts are underway and are causing enormous changes in the industry. Had the EPA never proposed the Clean Power Plan, we would be seeing many and the same kinds of directions we are seeing in the U.S. electric sector in any event. Thank you very much. [Prepared Statement of Ms. Tierney follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. I thank the panel. We will now have questions from members of this subcommittee. The Chair first recognizes herself for 5 minutes. I have a quick question for Dr. Harrison. Before I do, Dr. Tierney, is it your position that carbon is a pollutant? Ms. Tierney. Yes. Ms. Lummis. Dr. Harrison, is carbon a pollutant? Mr. Harrison. I think the issue is whether it is regulated. I guess those are legal issues. I understand that it is considered a pollutant in terms of the regulatory process that is underway. Ms. Lummis. I have a quick question for you about EPA's attainment level for ozone. If it is set at 65 ppb, could you elucidate me about some of the effects? I think I heard you say for 44 States, 10 percent per year for 15 year increase in electricity costs, is that correct? Mr. Harrison. No. I think at that point I was talking about the Clean Power Plan. In terms of the 65 ppb ozone regulation that we evaluated, I summarized some of the results. We found that the present value of the compliance costs would be over $1 trillion. I think I mentioned in terms of the effects on gross domestic product would be around $140 billion per year with a present value over the period 2017 to 2040 of $1.7 trillion. Those are two examples. Our study we just released describes a great many other impacts which I would be glad to go into if you like. Ms. Lummis. I will come back to you on that so hold that thought, please. I would like to ask Attorney General Rutledge, given this testimony and what you have learned about the EPA's proposed regulations, what kind of impacts will there be on your State? I am really concerned about lower and middle income residents of your State. Ms. Rutledge. Thank you for the question. These EPA regulations and energy costs that would result from 111(d) being implemented, this rule being implemented, would significantly raise the cost for all Arkansans and all ratepayers. It would dramatically hurt the lower income and middle income ratepayers because of such a dramatic increase. I would be remiss if I did not mention that it would also hurt small businesses in Arkansas that are trying to make payroll. A $20 increase may not seem like much to those living in the seven richest counties in the United States here around the Beltway but for those folks living in rural Arkansas trying to make a payroll, a $20 increase is a dramatic difference. Ms. Lummis. Attorney General Fox, same question, what about the impact of these EPA regs affecting both air and water on the citizens of Montana? Mr. Fox. Thank you for the question. First of all, let me say that primarily as the chief legal officer of the State of Montana, my appearance here today is primarily focusing on the rule of law, the Constitution and particularly the separation of powers, cooperative federalism as we see in the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act and their original statutes and intent, and also the limits of executive power. With that said, as I mentioned earlier in my testimony, if I may focus once again on the Crow Nation. That is one area where the harm of these regulations, should they be implemented, goes without saying but is worth repeating. There is a large portion of coal on the Crow Reservation, a 40 year old coal mine that produces some 7.5 million tons of coal, provides $10 million to $20 million of revenue to the Crow people, which is three-quarters of their non-Federal revenue. The mine employs up to 150 people, 70 percent of those are members of the Crow Tribe. With the decommissioning of their primary clients in Michigan and Minnesota and their coal-fired electric generation plants, they will lose their market. When they lose their market, the mine will close. The tribe estimates that will raise the unemployment rate somewhere from 50 percent on the reservation, as it is now, to as high as 90 percent. The harm that would cause to the people of the Crow Nation and, more generally to the people of Montana, is very extreme. I think that is an area where we can certainly focus and the Administration's failure to follow through on their obligation to consult with the tribe really requires them to go back to the drawing board. I would echo what Attorney General Rutledge says in terms of higher rates and the impact on the poor. I think those go without saying. Primarily, I am here as a lawyer and the chief lawyer of the people of Montana. I really want to stick to that expertise. Ms. Lummis. I thank the panel. The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Cartwright, for 5 minutes. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. Dr. Harrison, thank you for appearing before us today. I had a couple of questions for you. You said you are appearing today expressing your own opinions and those of nobody else, is that correct? Mr. Harrison. That is correct. Mr. Cartwright. You told us about the results of some studies that you did, one about ozone and one about the CPP. My first question about the CPP study is that was something your company did, NERA Economic Consulting? Mr. Harrison. That is right. Mr. Cartwright. Can you give us an idea of how much time went into that study? Mr. Harrison. It was a substantial study. I don't recall the exact number of hours, but it was a substantial study using our NewERA model to evaluate the effects of the Clean Power Plan. Mr. Cartwright. It was not a minor study that NERA Economic Consulting did. It was a major one, is that correct? Mr. Harrison. Yes, we considered it a major study, yes. Mr. Cartwright. I was looking at footnote 2 from your written testimony. It said that, among others, that study was prepared for the American Coalition for Clean Coal and, Electricity, the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers and the National Mining Association. Have I read those correctly? Mr. Harrison. That is correct. Mr. Cartwright. In laymans terms, does that mean they helped fund the study? Mr. Harrison. Yes, we prepared the study for those organizations. Mr. Cartwright. Dr. Harrison, is it a matter of complete indifference to you whether those associations and organizations continue to fund studies prepared by NERA Economic Consulting? Mr. Harrison. When we do studies---- Mr. Cartwright. It is a yes or no question. Do you care if they continue to fund your outfit? Mr. Harrison. I think what I prefer to do, if I may, is ask what they did ask us to do. They asked us to do a careful, independent study of the effects of the Clean Power Plan on the U.S. energy markets. Mr. Cartwright. Let me ask it this way. What about the American Wind Energy Association, did they help fund that study? Mr. Harrison. No, they did not. Mr. Cartwright. What about the Solar Energy Industry Association, did they help fund your study? Mr. Harrison. No, they did not. Mr. Cartwright. Did any sustainable energy association at all get involved in funding your study? Mr. Harrison. No, it was not funded by those organizations. Mr. Cartwright. Dr. Tierney, I have some questions for you about the clean water rule. The EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers proposed the clean water rule to clarify the definition of waters of the United States which are the water resources that under the Clean Water Act receive numerous protections against pollution. The EPA Stated, ``The agencies are eager to define the scope of the Clean Water Act that achieves the goals of protecting clean water and public health and promoting jobs and the economy.'' Dr. Tierney, ensuring that the Clean Water Act achieves these goals is important, would you agree? Ms. Tierney. I would agree with that. Mr. Cartwright. The Bureau chief of the Environmental Protection and the Office of New York State Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman, recently testified, ``Presently, jurisdictional decisions related to waters of the United States are made on a case by case basis subject to fractured and inconsistent legal interpretation by the courts fostering uncertainty, delay and further litigation.'' The EPA has Stated they have received numerous calls for clarification of waters of the United States from a variety of stakeholders. Members of Congress, developers, farmers, States and local governments, energy companies and many others demanded new regulations to make the process of identifying waters protected under the Act clearer, simpler and faster. Dr. Tierney, in general, Federal regulations that make a process clearer, simpler and faster will most likely benefit stakeholders, would they not? Ms. Tierney. Yes, from my experience in administering such environmental laws, that was clearly the case. I can't tell you the number of times various parties talked about the need to clarify the rules. Mr. Cartwright. Clarifying it makes it simpler and easier and more effective for everyone, right? Ms. Tierney. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. I yield back, Madam Chair. Ms. Lummis. I thank the gentleman. The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Oklahoma, Mr. Russell, for 5 minutes. Mr. Russell. Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Tierney, are you aware that over 4,000 American eagles, red tail hawks, American kestrels and burrowing owls are killed every year by wind turbines? Ms. Tierney. I did not have that fact at my fingertips. I would love to see the reference to it. Mr. Russell. I would be happy to provide that to you. Do you believe that the destruction of American birds is good for the environment? Ms. Tierney. No, but I know that energy resources of every kind, especially fossil fuels have hazardous impacts of the nature you are describing. Mr. Russell. Are you aware that solar energy also destroys thousands of birds every year, many of them rare species? Ms. Tierney. That would really surprise me to learn. Mr. Russell. I will show you the videos. Do you believe that a depression in a farmer or rancher's field that collects rainwater is a navigable waterway? Ms. Tierney. I understand that the EPA's proposal is based on scientific evidence of the relationship between water systems, wetlands and a variety of other things into navigable waters of the United States. Mr. Russell. In the case of a ranch in my home State, which is not connected to any coast, that would be a navigable waterway if it was a depression full of rainwater in my district? Ms. Tierney. I understand there are navigable waterways of the United States that are in the interior of the United States because they cross interState commerce and a variety of other things. Mr. Russell. Have you ever navigated on a puddle after a rainstorm on a ranch in Oklahoma? Ms. Tierney. I think that is a facetious question. Mr. Russell. I am just curious because it seems that people think this is a navigable waterway. Ms. Tierney. I don't have any information about a puddle that you are describing. I understand that the EPA's proposal is based on scientific evidence. Mr. Russell. On scientific evidence--I will try to scientifically navigate a puddle after a rainstorm. Attorney General Fox, what impact do EPA rules have on tribal sovereignty? Mr. Fox. They have an impact in actually impeding and invading on tribal sovereignty. I think it is important to note that under the Executive Order cited earlier and the EPA policy promulgated from that order, the executive branch has imposed upon itself a very important duty and responsibility to consult with each tribe of which there are 566 federally recognized tribes in the United States. In this case, the EPA sent out a Dear Tribal Leader letter a mere 2 days before the promulgation of the rule, the 111(d) rule. That Dear Tribal Leader letter referred only to the possibility of a tribe having on its reservation a coal-fired generation plant that might allow the tribe then to have primacy of its own air regulatory program. It did not give anyone a heads up, certainly not a timely heads up and certainly not the four tribes who have coal and minerals on their reservations any indication of the impact that rule might have on the sovereignty of that tribe. We have seven federally recognized tribes in Montana. I think it is very important as a State and a Nation that we respect the treaties and agreements we have with those tribes. Unfortunately, in this case, the EPA has violated the sovereignty of the Crow Nation pertaining to its Absaloka Mine. Mr. Russell. I want to thank you for that. In my limited time that is left, I will direct this to Dr. Harrison. You spoke of $140 billion a year reduction in the GDP annually for a 65 ppb rate. Were you aware that the entire education budget being proposed this year was $140 billion with the Student Success Act? Also, were you aware that four times of the entire estimated gains of the Trans Pacific Partnership would be that number and that one third of the defense budget equals the number you cited? What impact would that have on our economy? Mr. Harrison. I was not aware of those combinations but I guess it is another way of trying to put into perspective these estimates. Mr. Russell. I appreciate the panel and the testimony here today. I think it is important for the Nation to see the impacts on people in Montana, Arkansas, Oklahoma--which has also joined in some of these lawsuits. We certainly have tribes as well. I thank you, Madam Chairman, for this time. Ms. Lummis. I thank the gentleman. The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands, Congresswoman Plaskett. Ms. Plaskett. Good afternoon and thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you, testifiers for being here. I think it is very interesting and should be noted for the record that the EPA is not here for this hearing because we are in a proposed rulemaking position and therefore, it would be inappropriate for them at this time to testify on this matter. I think we need to reflect on the fact these are proposals as yet and not, in fact, rules. It appears this is not a new issue and there is a lot of rhetoric in the industry right now about the EPA's proposed Clean Water Power Plan, the ozone regulations killing jobs, and excessively raising industry compliance costs. Ms. Rutledge talked about a perfect storm. These sky is falling claims don't appear to be new. As a matter of fact, I have from June 2014, which I would like to submit to the record, a fact sheet prepared under Ranking Member Henry Waxman which gives facts on the Clean Air track record and pollution reductions. Since its adoption in 1970, there has been a reduction in key air pollutants by over 70 percent while the economy has more than tripled in size. Dr. Tierney, do you think the economic predictions currently used by the industry regarding clean power plant and ozone rules are reasonable? Ms. Tierney. I think there is a problem with many of the assumptions about how the industry is going to respond to a signal saying that things need to be done differently in the future. As I mentioned, many of the assumptions of the worst case studies are not realistic with what the cost impacts are likely to be at the moment. I say that knowing that EPA is very likely to make changes in its proposal. We don't know what those changes will look like. EPA has been very open in indicating they are learning from the millions of comments they have received. They expect to provide a fundamentally flexible rule for people. That flexibility doesn't show up in many of the economic studies. That will be the essential way in which private investors, developers, homeowners who have drafty homes will be able to tighten those up and not use as much energy in the future. Ms. Plaskett. I live on an island that has to balance clean air. The importance of our natural resources is of paramount concern to us. At the same time, we also had one of the largest oil refineries in the United States which was a balance between having jobs for our people as well as protecting our sun and sand. Dr. Harrison, I wanted to ask you if you have looked at the long term economic and social benefits of the rules? Are there any, in your opinion? Mr. Harrison. As I think I mentioned, our study was designed to look at the economic impacts of the rules. I think my colleague, Dr. Smith, did comment on some of the benefit assessments that have been made in the rules. Ms. Plaskett. Do you not believe that there are any because an impact would have to look at the negative as well as the positive, correct? Mr. Harrison. The terminology sometimes can be economic terminology but the typical economic terminology for looking at economic impacts is to look at the effects on the economy. These effects typically are in terms of gross domestic product, job and labor market impacts and the like. In this study, we did not look at the potential benefits of this program. Ms. Plaskett. How can you analyze an impact in terms of its economic impact negatively if you don't look and determine also and measure the economic benefits of that? Mr. Harrison. Those can be done. Before coming to NERA, I was an Associate Professor at the Kennedy School of Government and did many benefit cost analyses. That was not the topic of this particular study. Ms. Plaskett. Your study was merely to look at the negative impacts? Mr. Harrison. No, it was not. I think the way I would look at it is that it was trying to clarify what is at stake for the U.S. economy and individual States. There is certainly very useful information to be developed on what the benefits are. As I said, my colleague, Dr. Smith, has evaluated both of these two proposals in terms of their potential benefits. That was not the topic of this particular study. I think you will find the studies typically referred to as economic impact studies do precisely the same thing, look at what those impacts would be on the U.S. economy and individual States. Ms. Plaskett. Ms. Tierney, did you see what those social or economic benefits were? Ms. Tierney. Sure. One would surely want to look at the public health impacts of a clean power plant or an ozone standard. Certainly the cost of the health care of American people is a cost and drag on our economy. Not looking at those doesn't provide a balanced picture of the impacts of the ozone standard. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. I have exhausted my time and I thank you for your indulgence, Madam Chairwoman. Ms. Lummis. The gentlelady yields. The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Arizona, Dr. Gosar. Dr. Gosar. Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Tierney, is CO2 a pollutant? Ms. Tierney. I understand that the U.S. Supreme Court has determined that it is a pollutant. Dr. Gosar. No, no, I did not ask that. I asked you. Ms. Tierney. Yes and I answered a minute ago that I thought it is, yes. Dr. Gosar. I will come back to that. Attorney General Fox, you love dirty water, don't you? Mr. Fox. Say again, sir? Dr. Gosar. You love dirty water out in Montana? Mr. Fox. No, sir. Dr. Gosar. I am from Arizona and we love dirty water. How about you, Attorney General Rutledge? Ms. Rutledge. No, Doctor, we do not like dirty water in Arkansas. Dr. Gosar. Let me ask you a question. Did you ask EPA to clarify the waters of the U.S., Attorney General Rutledge? Ms. Rutledge. I have not personally asked the EPA. Dr. Gosar. Are you aware of anything in your State asking the EPA for clarification on waters of the U.S.? Ms. Rutledge. That would have been under my predecessor. Dr. Gosar. How about you, Attorney General Fox? Mr. Fox. I am not aware of the State officially asking for any clarification. As far as I know, we have not needed any clarification under the existing status rules. Dr. Gosar. Out in Arizona, we have the same problem. We are trying to figure out who these people are asking for clarification other than some bureaucrats. Dr. Tierney, I am coming back to that conversation about CO2. Would you consider it an essential gas? Ms. Tierney. Are you asking if it is physically in our atmosphere? Dr. Gosar. I said, is it an essential gas? Ms. Tierney. I don't understand your question. Dr. Gosar. Is it an essential gas for this planet? Ms. Tierney. Sure, but at high concentrations, we will have a greenhouse effect on the planet. Dr. Gosar. So you are aware of photosynthesis? I got it. Ms. Tierney. Of course I am. Dr. Gosar. Good old plants take CO2 and dirty water. Ms. Tierney. And they are out of balance right now. Dr. Gosar. I think that is negatable. Attorney General Fox, are you aware there are four Supreme Court rulings defying the EPA for where they want to go with the waters of the U.S.? Mr. Fox. Yes, I am aware. Dr. Gosar. Are you also aware that Congress did not give them that authority as well? Mr. Fox. I am aware. Dr. Gosar. Are you aware of that, Attorney General Rutledge? Ms. Rutledge. Yes, Doctor. Dr. Gosar. Why would we continue to go down this path without going through Congress first? It defies me. Does it defy you? Ms. Rutledge. It certainly does and that is why I am here today because of the rule of law, as my colleague from Montana mentioned. Dr. Gosar. I sat in my office 1 day to look at the hearing over at Transportation and Infrastructure. Ms. McCarthy was very insistent that they were going to come up with this rulemaking by April. I find it interesting that my colleague on the other side keeps saying that they are not here and they shouldn't be here because they are proposing rulemaking. That doesn't make any sense because defied by Congress and the Supreme Court from actually going there, true? Mr. Fox. If you are asking me, I would say yes. If I might add, we actually asked, on the 111(d) rules, for the EPA to hold a listening session in Montana. We were denied that ability. Dr. Gosar. Ms. Tierney, I am going to go back to science. I love science. By the way, I am a dentist. I also have some botany in my background, some water and immunology aspects as well. What would you say if you actually found out that through the EPA and their Clean Air Act, that implications on the Navajo generating station actually defied the facts of law? Ms. Tierney. I literally could not hear the question. Dr. Gosar. What would you think, as a scientist, if the EPA and their Clean Air administration in Arizona called the Navajo generating station actually defied the rule of science? What would you say to that, being a science person? Ms. Tierney. I am not a scientist. I have a Ph.D. in Regional Planning. Dr. Gosar. Oh, interesting. You still have outcomes and facts, right? Ms. Tierney. Of course, yes. Dr. Gosar. If they predicated an example for a Clean Air Act based on particulates coming from a certain coal plant. Ms. Tierney. I know the plant. Dr. Gosar. Say northeast that had implications on the Grand Canyon, which it did not, and EPA actually admitted that, would you think it was fair that those types of rules would be inferred and forced upon Arizona for lack of factual basis? Ms. Tierney. One of the things you are asking me, I believe, is a legal opinion and I don't believe I am qualified to give you a legal opinion. Dr. Gosar. I think you are outcomes-based and you have an opinion as an individual. You are sitting in front of a committee giving your expertise. I think you are more than applicable to that. I hope you are not taking the Scott Walker application and avoiding the question. Ms. Tierney. Come on, sir. I am not a lawyer. I cannot. I cannot give a legal opinion. Dr. Gosar. I am not a lawyer. I am also a dentist so that is why I am asking your personal opinion. Would you find it contradictive that we would use facts of science and find they are factually biased and factually false and still use those to predicate a rule? Ms. Tierney. Is this a hypothetical question? Dr. Gosar. It is actually a true statement. Ms. Tierney. I don't know the truth of it, so it is very difficult for me to answer that. I am not evading the question in any possible way. Dr. Gosar. Thank you, Madam Chair. I will yield back. Ms. Lummis. The gentleman yields back. The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Palmer. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Tierney, I want to ask you some questions about how you intend to enforce, say, the water rule, how aggressive you are going to be on that? Ms. Tierney. There must be an acoustical issue here in a bubble. Would you say your question again? Mr. Palmer. On the water rules, EPA has been very aggressive in enforcement. It has gone from a regulatory agency to almost operating like a police State. I will be blunt about it. There have been cases where the EPA, your armed division, has shown up with body armor and weapons drawn. Can you give me some idea of what the threat assessment might be that would justify that kind of intervention? Ms. Tierney. I don't know about the particular thing you are describing, but when I was in State government, we had environment enforcement activities where we did have to go in and take control of people who were flagrantly violating the State and Federal laws. I know it does happen. I don't know about the particular case you are describing. Mr. Palmer. Are any of the other witnesses aware of any cases where the EPA has come in with armed agents? We have had at least two of those in Alabama and one in Alaska. I find it interesting that the EPA is implementing these rules and conducting themselves in a way that is more reflective of a police State than a regulatory agency. Ms. Tierney. My experience with that in the past is that other people are at risk of being exposed to hazardous pollutants and a variety of other things. Mr. Palmer. I don't think that would justify an armed agent. If you think someone has violated a rule, I think the first thing you do is send down a regulator and interview witnesses. I know specifically of a case where that didn't happen. They showed up in a relatively small town at their waste treatment facility. I have not been to the waste treatment facility but I am fairly certain there are no sniper towers or machine gun nests or anything there that would justify that kind of intervention. Let us turn to the Clean Power Plan the EPA is trying to impose. It is going to be enormously costly. Have you given any thought to the fact that the Department of Energy and the EPA would like to see us go to the vast majority of our power coming from renewable, that our power grid will not support that? Ms. Tierney. Sir, there is no evidence that the Clean Power Plan will be 100 percent renewable. The Department of Energy has not stood for that position, nor has the Clean Power Plan at the EPA. EPA estimates that at the end of the day, based on their analyses, there would be 30 percent of the Nation's power produced by coal. That is part of the outlook there. The integration of renewable energy is something that today, in the absence of the Clean Power Plan, the industry is already addressing and coping with and has plans for how they will continue to cope with integration of renewable energy. Mr. Palmer. From my perspective, it is the intention of the EPA, and I think this Administration, to eliminate fossil fuel, to shut down the coal industry. They have been fairly transparent about it. Their plans are to have us at 80 percent renewable in the next two or three decades. Our electric grid is not designed for that. There is a study out of Cal Tech that indicates it will cost $1 trillion to upgrade our grid so it can do that. Ms. Tierney. One of the wonderful things about natural gas as a fuel is it is very nimble to operate natural gas fire- powered plants. They integrate wonderfully with renewable energy projects. A domestic fuel, like natural gas, which is so plentiful as a result of the shale gas revolution in providing low cost energy to the United States, is helping us with our grid reliability. Mr. Palmer. Do you realize that when you talk about supplementing your renewables with natural gas, you are admitting that renewables are not a legitimate or reliable source of energy? Ms. Tierney. That is absolutely not what I was saying. Both of them provide power to the grid, period. Mr. Palmer. What we are having right now with wind turbines having to dump power because we don't have an economical way of storing power. If we go to renewable and back it up with natural gas, you are still going to have a major redesign issue for the infrastructure. Ms. Tierney. One of the wonderful things going on with innovation in the United States is tremendous research right now on storage. There are breakthroughs going on in small scale, large scale storage. That is happening in a variety of different places around the country. Mr. Palmer. There is a huge disagreement over whether or not in a timely manner, it would be an economically sound alternative. Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Lummis. The gentleman yields. The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Tierney, I feel that we are here today to talk about our environment and also to talk about human beings, the impact that it has on our quality of life. Is it correct that the Clean Air Act requires air qualities to be required to protect public health with an adequate margin of safety? Ms. Tierney. My understanding, having been an implementer of the Clean Air Act in Massachusetts for many years, is that every 5 years, the law requires the EPA to go through a process, advised by its Scientific Advisory Council, with regard to the extent to which its ambient air quality standards are adequate to protect public health. That is the process they have gone through and have published proposals and have now revised those to tighten the ozone standard because of public health benefits that would accrue. Mrs. Lawrence. I do want to be clear that today we are addressing a proposed language and proposed act. I also want to know, is it also true that the air quality standards must consider the health of groups of people considered to be most at risk, like the 7 million children with asthma and the elderly? Is that true? Ms. Tierney. That is right. I believe that the tens of millions of people who suffer from respiratory disease, breathing problems, heart problems, small birth weight, is above 100 million according to the American Lung Association. We are talking about a significant portion of the population which suffers from diseases tied to air quality. Mrs. Lawrence. With that being said and the law that requires we protect public health and protecting the clean air to provide these over 7 million people who are at risk, would you agree in proposing to reduce ozone levels to the range of 65 and 70 ppb that EPA is justified in relying on more than 1,000 new scientific studies which conclude that the current ozone standard is harmful to public health? Ms. Tierney. I am going to answer yes, because I know the process the EPA uses to examine the literature on what scientists are saying about the quality of air and the problems it is posing. As a result of that process, the advice they have been given has been to tighten the standard from 75 to between 65 and 70 ppm. Mrs. Lawrence. Madam Chair, I am going to yield the rest of my time. But I do want to say that this is about the industry, our economy, but most important in the priority of the proposed language that we are talking about, it must address the human needs and the impact on our quality of life in America and that we empower the EPA to keep the purpose of their existence, as I discussed in my opening remarks when President Nixon proposed that we do this. Thank you. Ms. Lummis. The gentlewoman yields. If the panel will indulge another two questions from each member, we will do that now. It looks like we have assent to that, so thank you. The Chair yields herself time to ask two questions. The first of my questions is for Dr. Smith about the Clean Power Plan. Earlier there was a discussion talking a little bit about benefits and quantifying benefits. I want to understand a little bit about the EPA's quantification of benefits of the Clean Power Plan. How far into the future would the rule begin to confer benefits? Are these Stated benefits global or domestic? Ms. Smith. The benefits for reduction in climate change risks in that rule are projected out to 2300. We are looking at a present value of damages. Ms. Lummis. Not 2030? Ms. Smith. So 2300, 300 years from now, a little less than 300 years from 2030 when the rule is fully implemented. The damages are really out far in the future, the projected damages that are part of those benefit estimates for that rule. The timing of the benefits is way different than the timing of the costs. We see about a 100-year to 125-year payback period before the costs that have to be spent through 2030 might be paid back in any kind of expected value of climate benefits. Ms. Lummis. Thank you, Dr. Smith. My second question is for our Attorneys General. To both of you, do your States have adequate environmental laws to handle the air quality and water quality concerns that are being addressed today by the EPA? Ms. Rutledge. Yes, Arkansas has the Department of Environmental Quality that addresses such. I believe one particular issue with the proposed rule is going beyond the authority, as I Stated earlier, what the EPA actually has authority to do which is to provide guidelines and appropriate procedures for the States. That way, the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality can work with the EPA in implementing those guidelines that were right for the State of Arkansas versus what the EPA is attempting to do in going beyond its authority, mandating what each State must do. Mr. Fox. Chairman Lummis, Montana has been very proactive in taking steps legally and practically to protect the environment, air, water and everything in between. Our constitution in Article 9, Section 3, includes a specific provision giving the right to Montanans to a clean and healthful environment. We have also enacted the Montana Water Quality Act, our own version under primacy of our Clean Air Act. I might add that I used to be an Assistant Attorney General for the Department of Environmental Quality. I am a geologist trained in environmental protection. I was in charge of the investigation that led to the first criminal violation and prosecution of someone under our Water Quality Act in Montana which later led, actually, to Federal charges on different grounds as well. We do a very good job. We are very thorough in making sure that we protect our environment. I think it is important to note that both the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act include provisions in the very beginning of both Acts stating that it is the primary responsibilities of the States and local government to regulate both water and air. Again, under principles of cooperative federalism, I think that is where we start as a foundation. What EPA proposes to do here is way over the line and we need to get back to the basics. I would welcome Congress debating this because I think that is truly where this discussion should be held and ultimately where it should be decided. Ms. Lummis. I thank the panel. The Chair now yields to gentlewoman from Michigan, Mrs. Lawrence. Mrs. Lawrence. Ms. Tierney, I would like to ask this question. The Bureau Chief of Environmental Protection bureau recently testified that jurisdictional decisions related to the waters of the United States are made on a case by case basis, subject to factual and inconsistent legal interpretations fostering uncertainty, delay and further litigation. Members of the EPA have Stated that they received numerous calls for clarification of waters of the United States from various stakeholders, including farmers, developers, and State and local. In general, would you say the proposal making a process clearer, simpler and faster will benefit these stakeholders? Would you agree with that? Ms. Tierney. Yes. As I said, as an administrator of Federal and State laws on the environment, it has been my experience that when there is gray area and a developer doesn't know or a private investor doesn't know how a law will be implemented in a particular case, it requires a lot of time and money to figure that out and it often does chill development. Mrs. Lawrence. Would you say in this proposal that is one of the objectives, to provide clarification to the States and the stakeholders? Ms. Tierney. That is my understanding of the motivation of the EPA in doing this, yes. Mrs. Lawrence. I yield my time. Ms. Lummis. The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Arizona for two more questions, Dr. Gosar. Dr. Gosar. Dr. Smith, I have a couple of questions for you. You did a Clean Power Plan evaluation for global temperature changes. What did you find? Ms. Smith. I think it was about a .06 degree change in global temperature against a projected change of several degrees. Dr. Gosar. Was it within the margin of error? Ms. Smith. I have to be clear, I don't really remember the number but it was very small. Dr. Gosar. Point zero zero three. Ms. Smith. Thank you. You remember better than I do. Dr. Gosar. Statistically, is it an anomaly? Ms. Smith. It is simply not very meaningful if that is the amount of change anyone is projecting. Yet the benefits being attributed to this one rule are deriving benefits off these tiny, tiny changes. If climate change is going to be changed in any way, very much larger increments in emissions reductions need to occur in order to get very much larger changes in temperature. That one rule does nothing. Yet benefits are being attributed to it. The only way to get the benefits is to do far more. That rule cannot do it. Dr. Gosar. Interesting. Attorney General Fox, you are a geologist. Are you aware of any climate change in our years past? Mr. Fox. Yes, that is one of the first things we learned in school in the university, is the effect of the change in climate geologically speaking through time. Dr. Gosar. History tells us a lot of about that. My dad was a geologist. As soon as the sun came up, our car always slowed down and we were always talking about this period of time, right? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. Fossils are kind of a product of that, right? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. Coal is kind of a product of that, right? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. Gas is a product of that, right? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. And oil? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. Along those same lines, Attorney General Rutledge, what kind of implications can you have on civil penalties the EPA has already started to establish? I will rephrase that a little bit. Are you aware of civil penalties that can be expounded by civil violations of the clean waters of the U.S.? Ms. Rutledge. Under the proposed rule or currently under any by the EPA, yes. Dr. Gosar. Some are pretty severe? Ms. Rutledge. Absolutely. Dr. Gosar. I am aware of a poor rancher in Wyoming that has a $75,000 penalty on a stock pond that actually followed State regulations of Wyoming ADQ. Still, the EPA thinks they run the roost. Do you find that a violation of State sovereignty. Ms. Rutledge. Absolutely, and that is the problem that as the chief legal officer of the State that I have because it prevents me from being able to protect the citizens of Arkansas. Because when you have a Federal agency such as the EPA overstepping its boundaries, insisting and implementing civil penalties on our citizens and our businesses, then we are not able to govern ourselves. Dr. Gosar. Would you feel the same way, Attorney General Fox? Mr. Fox. Yes, sir. Dr. Gosar. Thank you. Ms. Lummis. That was the longest multi-part two question effort I have ever seen. Congratulations, Dr. Gosar. The Chair now yields to the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Cartwright. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Tierney, our Ranking Member, Congresswoman Lawrence, brought up a very important point. That is, what are the human costs of what we do to our environment? You and I talked earlier about the clean water rule and the intent of clarifying what waterways and bodies of water the Clean Water Act applies to. Under the Clean Water Act, the lack of clarity on what waters are and are not subject to the Clean Water Act protections could result in higher risk of pollution of water resources in the Nation's public health, is that a fair statement? Ms. Tierney. Certainly, there are countless examples where you could find that chain of events occurring where some actions one place could have downstream effects on peoples health. Mr. Cartwright. We have been bandying about estimates of costs for all sorts of things today. One thing I wanted to mention was the EPA estimated that the proposed rule, the clean water rule, would provide annual benefits to the public between $388 million to $514 million, which significantly outweighs the estimated costs of between $162 million to $278 million for mitigating impacts to water resources and taking steps to reduce pollution. The benefits of this proposed rule include reducing flooding, filtering pollution, providing wildlife habitat, supporting hunting and fishing and recharging groundwater. Broadly, do you agree with those statements? Ms. Tierney. I agree with those propositions. I have seen those in effect in my experience. Flooding and wetland protection is enormously important. If it is damaged from one kind of pollutant or another, you have lots of havoc when there is storm surge or other kinds of things. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. I am encouraged by the efforts of the EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to clarify this definition and help make the government function more efficiently and effectively with rules that are clear and easy to follow. Madam Chair, I do have a couple UC requests. I request unanimous consent to enter into the record a report from the National Wildlife Federation entitled statement for the Record of the National Wildlife Federation in Support of the Clean Water Act, Waters of the United States Rulemaking, dated today, February 26, 2015. Ms. Lummis. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Cartwright. There was some discussion about whether the EPA reached out to the Crow Tribe of Montana. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a June 12, 2014 letter to Darrin Old Coyote, Chairman, Crow Tribe of Montana, from the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Ms. Lummis. Also without objection, so ordered. Mr. Cartwright. I yield. Ms. Lummis. The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands, Ms. Plaskett. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you very much for everyone's patience here this evening. My question was actually already asked and Ms. Tierney did not have time to respond to my question to discuss some of the economic and social benefits you see from the ozone rule. Ms. Tierney. Thinking of your own island is a great example. One of the reasons people are concerned about CO2 emissions is the growing concentration of those in the atmosphere and the clear evidence from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and the U.S. National Climate Assessment about the fact we are already seeing the impacts of climate change in low lying areas and along coastal regions. For example, sea level rise and a number of other things are real impacts on local economies. There are real impacts we are already picking up. There is no way we are going to avoid some continuing impacts associated with climate change. We are only talking about taking steps in the United States to do a piece of the action. I hear and appreciate the concerns of many people that our poorest residents around the country are facing higher electricity bills, I am also aware they are going to face higher temperatures and need for air conditioning under extreme climate change events. We are really talking about things where we try to protect one pocket of health care costs and other kinds of costs with another piece of impact on their energy costs. The net effect of those is supposed to be these are beneficial actions that the EPA is doing to protect Americans. Ms. Plaskett. When you look at particularly poor communities, quite often the individuals living close to some of these places, particularly in my own area, I know there are families that have very high incidents of asthma as well as just starting to look at cancer registration from some of these plants. Those also have an enormous economic impact on a society and a jurisdiction for having to deal with those kinds of issues. Do we measure those things in terms of these Acts? Ms. Tierney. I know that EPA's studies take a great care to look at the impacts on populations that are especially poor or exposed to air quality problems which often happens in poor urban areas that are close to cars or a lot of industrial activity. Yes, those are things that are trying to be avoided. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. I just want to say our own jurisdiction has also feelings about paternalism on the part of EPA to striking the correct balance and not being unnecessarily helpful to the economy. We have to look at the long-term effects of some of these rules. Thank you very much. Ms. Lummis. I thank the gentlelady. I too would like to enter into the record the following: The NERA Report on the Clean Power Plan; the NERA Report on the Ozone Rule, including the update that was released today; testimony regarding Waters of the U.S. Rule submitted for the record by the National Association of Realtors; testimony for the record from Thomas Easterly, Commissioner of the Indiana Department of Environmental Management; comments submitted to EPA by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality regarding the Clean Power Plan; comments submitted to EPA by the State of Montana and the Crow Nation regarding the Clean Power Plan; and comments submitted to EPA by 11 State Attorneys General regarding the Clean Power Plan. Without objection, so ordered. Ms. Lummis. I very much want to thank our witnesses for taking the time to appear before us today. We value your expertise and the time you have spent with us helping us better understand these issues. If there is no further business? Mrs. Lawrence. I just want to say to Mr. Fox, we are going to do it this year. The Tigers are going to do it. Mr. Fox. Tigers all the way, Ranking Member, Tigers all the way. Ms. Lummis. With that, and without objection, the committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4:40 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]