Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- CYBERSECURITY: THE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] CYBERSECURITY: THE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ JULY 15, 2015 __________ Serial No. 114-52 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ______________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 97-789 PDF WASHINGTON : 2015 ________________________________________________________________________________________ For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK, MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Sean McLaughlin, Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director William McGrath, Interior Subcommittee Staff Director Troy Stock, IT Subcommittee Staff Director Melissa Beaumont, Clerk Subcommittee on Information Technology WILL HURD, Texas, Chairman BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas, Vice Chair ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois, Ranking MARK WALLER, North Carolina Member ROD BLUM, Iowa GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois TED LIEU, California Subcommittee on the Interior Cynthia M. Lummis, Wyoming, Chairman KEN BUCK, Colorado, Vice Chair BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan, PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona Ranking Member BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands GARY J. PALMER, Alabama C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on July 15, 2015.................................... 1 WITNESSES Ms. Sylvia Burns, Chief Information Officer, U.S. Department of the Interior Oral Statement............................................... 4 Written Statement............................................ 7 Ms. Mary Kendall, Deputy Inspector General, U.S. Department of the Interior Oral Statement............................................... 11 Written Statement............................................ 13 APPENDIX Office of Personnel Management Mission Statement, submitted by Rep. Lieu...................................................... 40 July 9, 2015 Dept. of the Interior Response to the Office of the Inspector General Report, submitted by Chairman Hurd........... 42 Nov. 26, 2013 Dept. of the Interior, Office of the Inspector General Report on Faisal Ahmed, submitted by Chairman Hurd..... 51 Colleen M. Kelley, National President, Statement of the National Treasury Employees Union, submitted by Chairman Hurd........... 54 Statement of Congressman Gerald E. Connolly (VA-11), submitted by Chairman Hurd.................................................. 57 Office of the Inspector General, U.S. Department of the Interior Report: Security of the U.S. Department of the Interior's Publicly Accessible Information Tehnology Systems, submitted by Chairman Hurd.................................................. 59 CYBERSECURITY: THE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR ---------- Wednesday, July 15, 2015 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Information Technology, joint with the Subcommittee on the Interior, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 2:38 p.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Will Hurd [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present from Subcommittee on Information Technology: Representatives Hurd, Farenthold, Blum, Kelly, and Lieu. Present from Subcommittee on the Interior: Representatives Lummis, Russell, Palmer, Lawrence, and Cartwright. Mr. Hurd. The Subcommittee on Information Technology and the Subcommittee on the Interior will come to order. And, without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Good afternoon. Thanks for being here today. Sorry for the delay. You all know how it is here in Washington. This is an important hearing. In the wake of the data breach of the Office of Personnel Management, the committee remains deeply concerned with the Federal Government's plan to address cybersecurity. This do as I say, not as I do mentality is an affront to the American people and leaves our Federal agencies and the PII of millions at risk. Today's hearing is the first in a series of hearings the Subcommittee on Information Technology will hold to focus on the cybersecurity posture of Federal agencies. This means not only compliance with FISMA, but also responding to the recommendation from an agency's inspector general, as well the GAO. I'm proud to hold this hearing jointly with Chairwoman Lummis, Ranking Member Lawrence, and the Subcommittee of Interior. And I am always thankful for Ranking Member Kelly and the bipartisan way we have been able to approach cybersecurity and other issues on this subcommittee. The first hearing this committee held on the recent OPM data breach I advised agency CIOs across the Federal Government to pull out their past IG reports and get to work on addressing the vulnerabilities that have been identified. Ms. Burns, I hope you have come here today with a concrete plan to address vulnerabilities in DOI's systems pointed out by the IG and others. The Department of Interior inspector general recently conducted penetration tests of publicly accessible computer systems and Web sites operated by DOI bureaus. What they found is alarming and is largely what brings us here today. The IG found nearly 3,000 critical and high-risk vulnerabilities in hundreds of publicly accessible computers operated by DOI bureaus. Let me repeat that number: 3,000. Even more concerning, the IG found that because DOI did not segment its publicly accessible systems from its internal systems, hackers could exploit these vulnerabilities to access internal or nonpublic DOI computer networks. DOI's internal networks support mission-critical operation and contain highly sensitive data. Not segmenting the public and the internal networks from each other is a failure of basic cybersecurity best practices. We need and deserve better from Federal agencies and those in charge of securing our digital assets. There's too much at risk not to. In addition, DOI hosted the OPM personnel file database that was breached and resulted in 4.2 million former and current Federal employees having their personal and private information stolen. Since then, Director Archuleta has stepped down and rightfully so. Several questions about DOI's role in the breach remain unanswered, including whether or not other agencies may have been compromised, how many breaches exactly took place at DOI, and whether or not the attackers are still in the system. Both subcommittees look forward today to having some of those questions answered. In closing, it is no secret that Federal agencies have a long way to go to improve their cybersecurity posture. We have years and years of reports highlighting the vulnerabilities and inactions of Federal agencies. We also have years and years of recommendations from IGs, GAO, and experts in and out of the government on how to address these vulnerabilities. Simply put, we know what needs to be done, we just need to do it. We need strong and capable leaders in place across the Federal Government to upgrade IT systems and shore up the current sorry state of cybersecurity at Federal agencies. We need leaders who will listen to the recommendations of their IGs and others and take appropriate corrective actions based on those recommendations. The status quo is unacceptable. We need leaders who can put a solid plan in place and then execute it. I hope we have that type of leadership in place at DOI. I welcome the witnesses and look forward to their testimony. And now, I'd like to recognize my friend and the ranking member, Ms. Kelly of Illinois. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and welcome to the witnesses. Last month, the Oversight Committee held hearings on two major OPM data breaches. We learned that the stolen personnel records of over 4 million current and former Federal employees were kept on servers hosted by the Department of Interior. Hackers essentially not only gained access to OPM's personal records, but in doing so they successfully penetrated the Department's data center where the records have been stored. Fortunately, an ongoing investigation into the OPM breach has so far not uncovered any evidence that any of the Department's data was stolen during the time period hackers had access to the data center. But the fact that the Department's computer systems were also hacked raises serious questions about the strength of the Department's cybersecurity system. Last week, the Department's inspector general provided the general with a draft that identified security weaknesses the IG found in many of the publicly accessible computers the Department maintains. Computers such as these are primarily used by the Department to share information with the public, collaborate with business and research partners, and to provide employees and contractors remote access to Department networks. As the IG noted in his draft report, and I quote: ``Publicly accessible computers operated by Federal agencies are prime targets for exploitation and are highly sought after by criminals and foreign intelligence services.'' According to the IG, over the past several years hackers and foreign intelligence services has been able to compromise the Department's computer network by exploiting weaknesses in its publicly accessible system. The IG's draft report provides a clear warning about a serious security vulnerability in the Department's publicly accessible computers. As I pointed out in my opening remarks at the subcommittee's first hearing this year, no organization is immune from cyber attacks and data breaches. As we saw this past year, sophisticated companies, from Anthem to JPMorgan Chase, were all targeted and breached by cyber attackers. I do want to acknowledge and thank Chairman Hurd for the bipartisan approach he has taken on the issue of cybersecurity. Mr. Chairman, I know we can work together to solve this. Thank you, and I yield the balance of my time. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Kelly. And now it is a pleasure to recognize Mrs. Lummis, the chairwoman of the Subcommittee on the Interior, for her opening statement. Mrs. Lummis. Well, thank you, Chairman Hurd, for leading this hearing. As we know, the Department of the Interior hosted a database for the Office of Personnel Management containing the records of approximately 4.2 million current and former government employees. Now, as we've seen, shared hosting can reduce redundancy and costs for government IT needs. Also as we've seen, however, it can result in increased vulnerability if it's not properly managed. So in this hearing, I look forward to learning more about the response by Interior to the breach, their compliance with the Federal Information Security Management Act and the Federal Information Technology Acquisition Reform Act, and past and future management decisions regarding recommendations by inspectors general for improving cybersecurity. So thanks again, Mr. Chairman. And thank you, witnesses, for being here today. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. When Mrs. Lawrence, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on the Interior, is here we'll recognize her for her opening remarks. Until that time, I'd like to turn to our witnesses and introduce them. And I'm also going to hold open the record for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. Mr. Hurd. I'm pleased to welcome Ms. Sylvia Burns, the Chief Information Officer at the U.S. Department of the Interior; Ms. Mary Kendall, Deputy Inspector General at the U.S. Department of the Interior as well. Welcome to you both. It is also my understanding that our witnesses are accompanied by two additional experts whose expertise may be needed during questioning. And so I'd like to welcome Mr. Jefferson Gilkeson, Director of IT Audits at the U.S. Department of Interior, and Mr. Bernard Mazer, Senior Policy Advisor in the Office of Inspector General at the U.S. Department of Interior and the former Interior CIO. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify, including Mr. Gilkeson and Mr. Mazer. So please rise and raise your right hands. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. Please be seated. Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for discussion, please limit your testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statements will be made part of the record. And we're going to start with you Ms. Burns. You're now recognized for 5 minutes for your opening remarks. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF SYLVIA BURNS Ms. Burns. Chairmen Hurd and Lummis, Ranking Members Kelly and Lawrence, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to discuss cybersecurity at the Department of the Interior. I am Sylvia Burns, and I have been the Department's Chief Information Officer since August 24, 2014. The Department and its bureaus serve as stewards of the Nation's parks, wildlife refuges, and public lands. And as the keeper of the history of this country, over 70,000 employees in more than 2,400 operating locations, including many remote areas, carry out the Department's mission across the United States and its territories. The Department is committed to cybersecurity and the protection of our assets, including data. IT tools are of vital importance to the delivery of the mission of the Department. The security of those IT tools and systems is likewise critical to our mission. All levels of our Department are engaged in the efforts to improve our cybersecurity. My office provides leadership to the Department and its bureaus in all areas of information management and technology. The Department's programs are many and varied. The Department's current IT management and operations structure reflects the decentralized nature of IT programs. My office is responsible for the operation of many departmental systems and issues IT policy, while bureaus and offices are each responsible for their respective systems. Each week the Department detects and prevents between 5 million and 6 million malicious connection attempts to exploit vulnerabilities in its Internet perimeter and Internet-facing systems. My office is working in partnership with the Department's senior leadership and IT personnel in the bureaus and offices to improve our ability to manage the risk of cyber attacks while delivering the Department's mission. I recently established a Department-wide cybersecurity advisory group to support me in developing and implementing a comprehensive, multipronged cybersecurity strategy and action plan, which includes short, medium and long-term initiatives to strengthen the Department's IT security posture. We are in the process of adopting a more centralized approach, managing IT across the Department. For instance, to meet FISMA requirements, the Department will obtain access and visibility into the entire Department network and will play a more direct role in incident response working with its bureaus and office and with US-CERT. As a result of a secretarial order, FISMA and FITARA, DOI achieve the following. Through the Continuous Diagnostics and Mitigation investment funded by Congress through DHS, DOI deployed capabilities to centrally manage vulnerability patching at the Department level, which will greatly improve cyber hygiene across our IT landscape. As of June 26, the Department implemented strong authentication for all privileged users. I am happy to report that as of this morning we have achieved 75 percent of PIV enablement for our unprivileged users. That was news. The Department launched its data center consolidation plan to support the OMB Federal Data Center Consolidation Initiative. Data center consolidation reduces the Department's IT footprint overall, consolidating smaller, noncore data centers into DOI's larger and more robust core data centers, allows us to more efficiently and effectively manage and protect high value data. The Department supports and appreciates the work of the Office of the Inspector General in assessing and advising the Department on its IT systems. We accept all of the OIG's recommendations and will incorporate them into our action plan. The impacted bureaus report that all vulnerabilities identified in the report have been corrected. The Department takes the privacy and security of its IT systems and data very seriously. The Department immediately and aggressively responded to the recent cyber intrusion resulting in the loss of OPM data. We worked with interagency partners who are addressing the broader cybersecurity threats to the Federal Government to develop and implement an immediate remediation plan specific to the threat. We incorporated remediation actions, the OIG's recommendations, and departmental IT improvements which were already underway into the Department's overall IT strategy moving forward. We will continue to be an active participant in the ongoing efforts by the Federal Government to improve our Nation's overall cybersecurity posture. Chairmen Hurd and Lummis, Members Kelly and Lawrence, and members of the subcommittee, this concludes my prepared statement. I would be happy to answer any questions you have. [Prepared statement of Ms. Burns follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Burns. Now over to you, Ms. Kendall, for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF MARY KENDALL Ms. Kendall. Mr. Chairman, Madam Chairman, Ranking Member Kelly, and members of the subcommittees, good afternoon, and thank you for the opportunity to testify today about the results of our OIG audit on security of public-facing Web sites at the Department of the Interior. Although the OIG has had an IT oversight function for over a decade, we have refocused our IT oversight efforts over the past 3 years. In 2012, we began to transfer the responsibility for conducting IT oversight to our Office of Audits, Inspections, and Evaluations in order to standardize and track our IT oversight of the Department, and we have since doubled the number of IT professionals assigned to this oversight. Our focus on IT oversight has evolved over the years from periodic assessments and compliance reporting to using tools and techniques to conduct ongoing monitoring of IT security controls, an approach that enables responsible officials to take timely risk-mitigation actions and make risk-based decisions regarding the operation of their IT systems. This is how we conducted the IT audit at issue in today's hearing. The results of our efforts provided the bureaus with real-time information necessary for them to take prompt action. A future OIG follow-up audit will determine whether those actions were effective at addressing the vulnerabilities identified. ``Defense in depth'' is a widely recognized best practice for protecting critical IT assets from loss or disruption by implementing overlapping security controls. The concept of defense in depth is that if one control fails, then another is in place to either prevent or limit the adverse effect of an inevitable cyber attack. We found that three DOI bureaus had not implemented effective defense in depth measures to protect key IT assets from Internet-based cyber attacks. We found critical and high- risk vulnerabilities in publicly accessible computers operated by these bureaus. If exploited, these vulnerabilities would allow a remote attacker to take control of publicly accessible computers or render them unavailable. In addition, we found that a remote attacker could then use a compromised computer to attack the Department's internal networks that host computer systems supporting mission-critical operations and containing highly sensitive data. These deficiencies occurred because the Department did not effectively monitor its publicly accessible systems to ensure they were free of vulnerabilities or isolate its publicly accessible systems from its internal computer networks to limit the potential adverse effects of a successful cyber attack. The results contained in this report are the first in a series of defense in depth. We made recommendations designed to help the Department mitigate, identify vulnerabilities, and strengthen security practices, reduce the opportunity for a malicious attack, and minimize the impact and potential opportunities to infiltrate nonpublic systems after a successful attack. The Department concurred with all of our recommendations and has begun to implement them. We are preparing a public version of our report, but as we continue to analyze the content, we determined that details of our methodology, specifically the ``how we did our testing and with what tools,'' and certain details of the results of our testing, could cause harm to the Department and its IT assets. We will therefore redact this information along with the identity of the bureaus that were subject to our testing in the public version of our final report, which will be posted on our Web site. As is our practice however, Chairmen Hurd and Lummis, we will be glad to provide you with a copy of our full final report at your request. Mr. Chairman, Madam Chairman, ranking members, this concludes my prepared remarks today. I am happy to try to answer any questions you or members of the subcommittee may have, but I would also be assisted by Mr. Gilkeson and Mr. Mazer. [Prepared statement of Ms. Kendall follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Ms. Kendall. I would now like to recognize the ranking member of the Interior Subcommittee, Mrs. Lawrence, for 5 minutes for opening remarks. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank you for holding this hearing and examining the effectiveness of the Department of Interior's cybersecurity practices. I also want to thank our witnesses for speaking with us today. I know some of you are returning. Recent cyber attacks in public and private sectors highlight the importance of enhancing information security policies and controls. Although the Department of Interior has not suffered a breach of its data in relation to cyber attacks on OPM, information security weaknesses have been identified by the inspector general and exploited by cyber attackers. The Federal Information Security Management Act, or FISMA, requires each Federal agency, and I will quote, ``each Federal agency to develop, document, and implement an agencywide program to provide information security for the information and information systems that support the operations and assets of the agency,'' end quote. In the Office of Management and Budget annual report to Congress on FISMA for fiscal year 2014, the Department was at or above compliance standards for several areas of affected information security. According to OMB's report, the Department was given an overall cybersecurity assessment score of 92 percent, 16 percentage points higher than the average score for reporting agencies, which was 76 percent. However, I'm concerned that the Department was identified as having weak profile, which means that the majority of unprivileged users are allowed to log onto network systems with a user ID and password alone. This is an increased risk of unauthorized network access. In closing, today's hearing provides an opportunity to gain an understanding from our witnesses of the challenges the Department faces, to learn what DOI is doing to correct their information security deficiencies, and to find out what Congress can do to help ensure that the Department has the people and the resources it needs to enhance its information security practices. Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding this hearing, and I yield back my time. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mrs. Lawrence. Now to begin our questioning portion of this afternoon, I'd like to turn it over for 5 minutes to Mrs. Lummis, the chair of the Interior Subcommittee. Mrs. Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thanks again for holding this hearing. And welcome witnesses. Appreciate your being here. Our committee recently learned through a report of investigation about a high-level IT staffer at the Department of Interior's Office of Law Enforcement and Security. His name is Faisal Ahmed. Ms. Kendall, can you please quickly summarize the findings of this report? Ms. Kendall. Chairman Lummis, thank you. We have not analyzed the personal privacy security implications of our report in this regard, and so I will not identify the individual by name. But when the OIG was notified that there was an individual in the Office of Law Enforcement and Security who may have falsified his credentials, we investigated these allegations and determined that in fact there were two transcripts suggesting that he had both an undergraduate and a master's degree which he did not have. The person who was subject of this investigation resigned from the position 3 days after we initiated our investigation. Mrs. Lummis. And at the time was Mr. Faisal Ahmed--I'm at liberty to disclose his name--was Mr. Faisal Ahmed the Assistant Director for the Office of Law Enforcement and Security heading the Technology Division? Ms. Kendall. I believe that was his title. Mrs. Lummis. Okay. Please continue. Ms. Kendall. We did determine that there were two falsified transcripts on the computer that we seized and that those transcripts had been--the individual had requested that the transcripts be included into his official personnel file. Also understand, and this may or may not be in the report that you received, I have since received some information that they may have been submitted for an SES candidate development program. But I understand that the individual was not an SES member as the report may have suggested. Mrs. Lummis. Now, we have reason to belief that Mr. Faisal Ahmed is currently employed at the Census Bureau. Do you know if this is true? Ms. Kendall. We were not able to confirm that before the hearing this afternoon. Mrs. Lummis. Have you ever been contacted or have you ever contacted the Census Bureau or Department of Commerce about Mr. Faisal Ahmed? Ms. Kendall. We were contacted by an Office of Personnel Management investigator investigating the background of this individual and provided that investigator with the information that we had available in our files. Mrs. Lummis. Now, it's my understanding from the report on investigation on the Faisal Ahmed case that your office presented this case to the Department of Justice, but they declined to prosecute. Do you know anything about why they declined? Ms. Kendall. We rarely get reasons behind declinations for prosecution, and I'm not aware of a reason behind this one. Mrs. Lummis. Did anyone from your office have any discussions with DOJ about this case? Ms. Kendall. We typically either forward our report of investigation and oftentimes have some discussion with the prosecutors. I could not tell you specifically if we did in this case. Mrs. Lummis. I'm concerned that there may be an individual who was in a high-level position, comparatively, it's high ranking Senior Executive Services position, he had worked, as I understand, at DOI since late 2007, and that he held a security clearance. And so I'm a little concerned--well, I'm more than a little concerned--that he had access to law enforcement sensitive materials and other secure information, that he had falsified his background, and that now it appears that he is working for another Federal agency, the U.S. Census Bureau. So there is additional fallout from the issues that have been raised by the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Hurd, about this hearing. So as to these collateral matters also, I thank you kindly, Mr. Hurd, for holding this hearing. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. The gentlewoman yields back. I'd now like to recognize my distinguish colleague from Illinois and ranking member, Ms. Kelly, for 5 minutes. Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Burns, the two data breaches OPM recently reported have been particularly concerning to us because of the national security risk involved. According to testimony you gave at a recent hearing on the OPM data breaches, the OPM personnel records that were compromised in one of those breaches were hosted in the data center maintained by the Department of Interior. Did the cyber attackers who gained access to those records also gain access to the Interior Department data center? Ms. Burns. So the adversary had access to our data center. It was exposed. There was no evidence based on the investigation that was led by DHS, US-CERT, and the FBI, there was no evidence that the adversary had compromised any other data aside from the OPM data. Ms. Kelly. Okay, so the same cyber intruder who breached OPM's personal data, which the Department of Interior hosted on its servers, also breached the defense's of the Interior Department data center? Ms. Burns. So this, the intrusion that you're referring to, was a sophisticated breach. And my understanding, based on DHS' assessment, was that the adversary exploited, compromised credentials on OPM's side to move laterally and gain access to the Department of Interior's data center through a trusted connection between the two organizations. Ms. Kelly. So the cyber intruder, did they gain access it to DOI's data center through OPM or was it the other way around? Ms. Burns. The adversary gained access to DOI's infrastructure through OPM, as far as I understand, based on DHS's investigation. Ms. Kelly. Has there been any investigation to determine whether the Department's records were stolen once the attackers gained access to the data center? Ms. Burns. So I believe that that was part of DHS' comprehensive investigation. When we first learned from them of the intrusion, they came on board in April 2015, this year, and they actually were on the ground with other interagency partners at the site of the data center, collecting data and forensics for approximately 3 weeks. They took that data back. So the investigation was ongoing even as they were there. But they took the data back. And my understanding from the report that they issued to us was that there wasn't evidence of further compromise of DOI's data in that data center. Ms. Kelly. So there is no evidence that the Department's data was stolen. Ms. Burns. Correct, based on what DHS' report said. I would defer to them, though, if you wanted to get into more detail, because they did the detailed analysis, and they're really the ones who are the author and the source of the investigation and the findings. But that is my understanding based on reading the report. Ms. Kelly. In addition to hosting OPM's personnel records, the Department hosts data from other agencies in its data center. Is that correct? And, if so, which agencies? Ms. Burns. Yes. Actually, the Department is a--the data center in question, the biggest customer of the data center is actually Interior. So it's the Interior Business Center, what we call IBC. They're a shared service provider, and they are the majority user of the data center. And we also host some applications for the Office of the Secretary in the data center. Ms. Kelly. Okay. With the exception of the OPM's records, was data from any of the other agencies, those places you mentioned, compromised when hackers gained entry into the Department's data center? Ms. Burns. As I was saying before, based on my understanding of the report from DHS and their forensics, there was no evidence that any other data was exfiltrated from the data center. Ms. Kelly. From all that has happened and what you've gone through, what do you feel are some of the key lessons that the Department has learned. Ms. Burns. So many lessons learned. So, as you can imagine, when I as a CIO for the Department learned of the intrusion, it was horrifying to me. And since that time I've been--my team and I have actually been on a high alert, working probably 7 days a week, long hours, to take our lessons learned and do a mitigation plan around it, a remediation plan that's comprehensive. So lessons learned include things that we were doing already. So, for example, the whole need for two-factor authentication, that's an important control that's needed. We were already working on it, so it was a performance goal that we had for the agency this year, and we had set those metrics for all of our bureaus and offices to achieve certain targets this year, and we were making slow progress to it. When the incident happened, it just created a different lens on looking at the need, and I think it made it crystal clear to everybody why it was so critical that we achieve two- factor authentication for, first of all, our privileged users, but then also our unprivileged users. And that's why we were aggressive about moving to getting all of our privileged users using their PIV cards to authenticate to their system. And as I mentioned in my statement, we achieved that on June 26 as part of the Office of Management and Budget 30-day cyber sprint. So it just accelerated the work we had already started. In addition to that, I was proud to say that we achieved-- actually it was at least 75 percent of unprivileged users today. So people have been working around the clock in my office, but also in the bureaus and offices, because we shared our lessons learned with our other counterparts in our bureaus and offices, because we have to all own this problem, and it will take all of us to fix the problem, and everybody has been taking it seriously. So I'm very gratified by that. Ms. Kelly. Thank you for sharing. My time is up. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. The gentlewoman yields back. Now I would like to recognize my fellow Texan and colleague, Mr. Farenthold from Texas, for 5 minutes for questioning. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We've heard testimony that there have been inspector general reports dating back to 2014. We've been talking about cybersecurity here in this committee since well before last year. It's been a pretty critical issue. There are actually some recommendations in the 2014 start of the--in the audit-- yet it looks like it really took this data breach to get you guys moving on it. Ms. Kendall or Ms. Burns, would you like to take just a second and talk about, as a result of 2014, how much was done and how much didn't get done out of the 2014 recommendations? Ms. Burns, I'll let you---- Ms. Burns. So I wasn't CIO for the Department for the whole time, but as the report was written I assumed the responsibility of this role. We have been working hard, so for me, when I first became CIO, I made cybersecurity a priority. And part of that was because there were things that were happening even before, right before I became CIO. Mr. Farenthold. But, I mean, you got a huge breach that came in and millions of Federal employees' personal information got out. I mean, you can talk about making something a priority, but it apparently wasn't or we wouldn't have had a breach. Maybe it is impossible to completely stop a breach. Can we just get a little bit of background, just so everybody is clear on exactly what happened? The Department of Interior, were you hacked or was it an insider or was it a combination of both? Ms. Burns. So from my understanding of DHS' investigation, there was a compromise of an OPM privileged account. So there were credentialed, high level--high--a privileged users credentials were compromised and went from OPM---- Mr. Farenthold. Now, do we know if it was an insider job or somebody just got his information, a brute force attack, or some other way, or did he voluntarily share that with? Ms. Burns. I don't have that information, and I would defer to DHS, US-CERT, because---- Mr. Farenthold. So how did you all first find out about the breach? Mr. Burns. We first found out about the breach because DHS contacted us in April and sat down with me and my CISO and told me that they saw suspicious activity on our network. Mr. Farenthold. So how confident are we that they're out and that there are no trojans or malware still somewhere in the system? Ms. Burns. So, according to DHS, there is no evidence anymore that there is malicious activity. Mr. Farenthold. I assume you stepped up the monitoring. Ms. Burns. Absolutely. Immediately. So that said, we don't take anything for granted. We're on high alert, because there is the possibility that another breach could happen. And in our discussions with DHS our remediation plan has to include our ability to quickly detect when something bad is happening so that we can shut it down quickly. Mr. Farenthold. Now, we have also got a July 2015 report that is saying there are potentially thousands of security risks that are still out there. I mean, is all the software up to date? Do you have the security software on all the computers? You' making people change their passwords? How confident are you that you've at least got the basics down? Ms. Burns. So within the Office of the Secretary, directly where the breach happened, some of the things we did is remediation, included things like password reset. If you're referring to the IG's report that referenced the vulnerabilities, as soon as we learned about them, I talked with the bureaus in question immediately about them. And as of before the report was actually issued, which I think is going to be soon, the bureaus corrected all the vulnerabilities that were identified in that report. And so as a follow-up to that, we would like the--I appreciate what the IG is talking about doing in terms of followon to ensure that they check to make sure the vulnerabilities are clearly corrected permanently. Vulnerabilities, though, it's a process. So it's not something that's a one-time hit. You have to continually do it. It's a process that you have to manage. You have to continually scan, look at what weaknesses exist, categorize the weaknesses so you know what's critical and high, and deploy your resources to the most critical weaknesses that you have that can have the broadest impact on the organization. Mr. Farenthold. All right, so we're videotaping this and it's being broadcast on C-SPAN 8, the Ocho, or somewhere. The video is out there. If you could talk to your fellow CIOs at other government agencies and give them some piece of advice so this doesn't happen to them, what would be the top two or three things you would tell them? I'll let you answer that and yield back when you're complete. Ms. Burns. Okay. First of all, I think that to get this problem fixed that we have in the whole Federal Government it takes strong leadership and drive, but it also takes everybody to help with this. Because cybersecurity isn't isolated to IT. Cybersecurity is a responsibility of everybody. Nobody can abdicate their responsibilities there or else we put ourselves at risk. So that's one thing. Another thing that I would say is that the FISMA metrics are right, but they are not the only thing that we need to be doing. They're one lens of what we have to be doing, but there is much more. And I think we have to act in the real world. So it can't be this paper-based exercise that we go through in checking boxes. We actually have to do things like what the IG did, which is get people to actually--it's kind of the red team, blue team type concept--of getting professionals to actually try to attack us, but in a safe environment, so that we can actually understand what the weaknesses are and put them on a list and do something about them quickly. That would be my advice to my fellow CIOs. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And I'll yield back. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Farenthold. Now I'd like to recognize Mr. Cartwright from Pennsylvania for 5 minutes. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you, Chairman Hurd. And welcome to all of our witnesses to are subcommittee. Ms. Burns, I'm going to ask you some questions. Now, I want you to understand, when I ask you a question, if you don't know the answer, it's all right to say, ``I don't know,'' because accuracy is the most important thing we're after here. And I share Mr. Farenthold's sentiment that a record is being made today, and I want you to feel free to go back and look at these questions, and if you have more information, provide the information to the subcommittee subsequent to this hearing. Will you do that. Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. Ms. Burns, in your testimony from the June 16 hearing regarding the OPM breach, you indicated that the Department of the Interior houses data for the OPM in the Interior Department's data center. Am I correct in that? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. When did the Interior Department first begin hosting data for OPM? Ms. Burns. From my understanding in talking with my staff, OPM started to become--first became a customer of the Department in 2005. Mr. Cartwright. Okay. Is this under some kind of agreement? Ms. Burns. There is a memorandum of understanding between the two organizations. Mr. Cartwright. Would you send us a copy of that, please? Ms. Burns. We can, yes. Mr. Cartwright. Now under that agreement, what is the Department of the Interior's role in providing cybersecurity for the data that it hosts? Ms. Burns. So the Department's role--the Department offers OPM our IT infrastructure, so its hosting services, that's what they're consuming from us as a customer. Our responsibilities in terms of security go around securing the IT infrastructure. So that means we provide the data center, which has facilities base, right, the physical security. It has the power and cooling, hardware, the servers, operating system, potentially even the database, and also support services to help OPM just maintain the actual infrastructure in terms of, like, system administrators, database administrators, that kind of thing. Mr. Cartwright. I don't mean to interrupt you, but the question is, under the agreement by which the Department of the Interior hosts OPM on its computers, how is cybersecurity treated under that agreement? Ms. Burns. So the Department of the Interior, we provide the infrastructure. We are responsible for security the infrastructure. That includes the network connection between us and OPM. Mr. Cartwright. Okay. Ms. Burns. And we encrypt our connection between OPM and us. Mr. Cartwright. How about money? Does the Department of the Interior receive any revenue from OPM for hosting their records on your data center? Ms. Burns. Yes, OPM is a customer and we provide our services as a full cost recovery system. Mr. Cartwright. Good. How much do you get? Ms. Burns. I have to get back to you on that. I'm not sure. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. Now, in the June 16 hearing you also testified, quote: ``DOI also performs shared services for other agencies,'' unquote. Is that correct? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. Okay. Can you help us understand why the Department is performing data hosting services for other agencies as well? Ms. Burns. Yes. So shared services is a concept of creating more robust centralized points of service around specific activities. IT is one of them, but there are others. And it's because you can gain economies of scale. So it's less expensive and more efficient to a customer to consume the service from a provider like that at a better rate. And also, because we can aggregate capabilities in that area of expertise, in this case IT---- Mr. Cartwright. So the other agencies could store their own data, but it's a cost savings if it's all in Interior, is that it? Ms. Burns. It could be for them. They'd have to look at the business case for that. Mr. Cartwright. How many other agencies does the Interior Department do this for? Ms. Burns. So the primary customer that Interior--what we have in the data center is really the Interior Business Center, so it's an internal customer. Mr. Cartwright. I'm looking for a number. How many agencies does Interior do this for? Ms. Burns. Can I get back to you on that? Mr. Cartwright. Please, please. Mr. Cartwright. How long has the Department been hosting data for other agencies? Ms. Burns. I don't know the answer to that question. Mr. Cartwright. Okay. You'll get back to us? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. Okay. Now, does the Department provide this hosting function under a similar arrangement, similar to the agreement with OPM? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. So you'll have separate agreements for each of the other agencies? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Cartwright. Can you get us copies of those as well, please? Ms. Burns. We can follow up on that, yes. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. And I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Hurd. Thank you. The gentleman yields back. Now I'd like to recognize Mr. Russell from Oklahoma for 5 minutes. Mr. Russell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Burns, the IG found that a remote hacker could exploit vulnerabilities in public accessible computers to attack internal or nonpublic Department of Interior computer networks. Why weren't the two systems not segmented from each other? Ms. Burns. So several years ago--actually, if you would indulge me, I need to go back a little bit in history for the Department of the Interior. In 2001 there was, if you're familiar with the Cobell lawsuit, the Cobell litigation. It was a situation regarding Indian trusts. And as a result of it, there was a breach that caused a decision to disconnect several--it started with disconnecting the Department from the Internet, and it ultimately resulted in about, like, five other bureaus and offices within DOI from being disconnected from the Internet for about 6-1/2 years. And in this environment, because of just the fear of being disconnected, all the bureaus and offices in the Department basically created sort of the modes and protections around themselves organizationally from an IT perspective. And in essence, you couldn't really work together easily in that environment because they were trying to protect themselves from being associated with trust data. In 2008, the Department reconnected those organizations back to the Internet, and what it came to find was that the organizations within the Department of Interior had difficulty just doing basic day-to-day work together because of these security controls that were put all around their IT infrastructure. And that initiated an effort to optimize our network. And actually this was not during my tenure, so I'm speaking in the past. Mr. Russell. And if I can, on that, so we optimized it, but we also optimized it for hackers. And I guess, Mr. Mazer, you were the CIO for 4 years before Ms. Burns took over. So what efforts, if any, did you undertake to address these issues when you were in charge? Mr. Mazer. Thank you for the opportunity to respond. Mr. Russell. Can you move the microphone closer to you? Mr. Mazer. As Ms. Burns noted, the bureaus are very segmented, they are very fractionated. Before my arrival we embarked upon an effort to say it would be great to have one Department of Interior network providing telecommunications services on behalf of everyone. That started about 10 years ago. There's still ongoing activities that are underway. But something that emerged out of that was protection on what we call the perimeters. And the perimeters on the network were for--it was the bureaus are making the determination that they would provide protection on the perimeters. At the TICs, the Trusted Internet Connections, is the Department provides protection on incoming and outcoming traffic, but one of the results of the report showed that it is--if people set up Web site servers inside our environment they are liable for exploitation into Interior network operations. And so, I always counseled, whenever we had an incident-- and we had an incidents, whether its malware or APT, advanced persistent threats--was when our team became aware of it we would work with that Bureau and all that to remove the particular affected server from there. I also encourage people that were hosting Web sites: Please, for gosh sakes, get off of the environment, put yourself into a separate enclave. So one of the efforts that occurred during my tenure is the Department embarked upon a cloud solution for public Web sites. So the DOI.gov quite a few of the Web sites that we are seeing, they are all migrating to a public--a government cloud service provider that has a FedRAMP moderate categorization on those activities. Mr. Russell. And I guess we see--Intel 101 says compartmentalization is good, because it creates barriers. It also creates efficiency problems, we acknowledge that. So my question for Ms. Kendall or Mr. Gilkeson, as I yield back my time at the conclusion, is how do we balance the optimization with the security and what would you recommend for the fix? Ms. Kendall. I think Mr. Mazer identified the cloud as being one of the fixes. We had several recommendations, six, I believe, total in this report, but the cloud was one of them. The other was to remove these outward-facing computer systems from being connected to the inside of Interior's systems so you could provide information to the public, to the outside without access or connectivity and compromise to the internal. Mr. Russell. Thank you. I yield back my time, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, sir. I'd now like to recognize Ms. Lawrence from Michigan for 5 minutes. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Burns, what is the Department's plan and time line for implementing the IG's recommendations? Ms. Burns. So we're doing some things immediately. I have already--as soon as I saw the draft report and what findings and recommendations were, I started to talk with all of our bureau IT leaders about things that we needed to do. So we are engaged in conversations with our bureaus and offices right now about things that we want them to do right away to mitigate the situation that was identified in the IG's report. That's a short-term action, because of the real issues, right, and the threats, the vulnerability, the weakness it presents to the Department. There is longer-term things that we need to do, and some of those longer-term things go to things like network segmentation. A form of network segmentation, as in the previous question, is creating what they call DMZs, what they call an-- it's a demilitarized zone, it's basically a safe place, right, to put externally facing systems and configure them in a certain way where they are secure and they don't do what was described in the IG's report. So some of the immediate actions that we have, we can tell everybody, give them guidance on what they need to do right now. Longer term, I believe we need to move to a consolidated enterprise-wide DMZ for publicly facing systems, and as the IG's office was also saying, embracing the cloud more for our systems. Mrs. Lawrence. Do you, sitting here today before this body in this hearing, do you see any obstacles that would stop you from addressing these concerns or would cause you a challenge that we need to know about? Ms. Burns. Right now I think we're--I feel very fortunate in that we have the full cooperation of the organization at every level. If there's one big impediment, it would be that, it would be resistance, I'm happy to say right now, and I think it's because of just the stark reality of the threats and it hit home for DOI, that everybody is cooperating and doing the right thing and they want to do the right thing. So leading that effort I think will be easier because we have the full cooperation at all levels. Mrs. Lawrence. The first recommendation for the CIO is to require and enforce the secure development and management of all publicly available IT systems. Mr. Burns, what are you doing to require and enforce information security improvements across the various bureaus of the Department? I'm sorry, Mrs. Burns. Ms. Burns. Thank you. Thank you. So actually I have to thank you all for passing FITARA, because I think FITARA is pivotal legislation that helps us to drive the consolidation and centralization of the things that we're talking about today. I think some of the--one of the biggest challenges that the Department has is the fact that you have all the different separate operating environments for IT. That has to come under kind of a single presence of mind, if you will, under the CIO. And so there are challenges in the bureaus and offices even with programs who are in far-flung places in the country who are doing whatever they're doing because it's the best way they know to do their job, but they're not getting any direction, central direction from their bureau and from the Department. I think that FITARA positions us to fix that problem, and the Department is very committed to following through and taking advantage of all the provisions of FITARA. Mrs. Lawrence. Mr. Mazer, you're the former Interior CIO. Do you agree that there are challenges to dealing with multiple bureaus? And do you feel that we are on target to meeting the requirement to enforce security improvements? Mr. Mazer. I used to work in intelligence, so it's always trust, but verify within the IG. We looked at, when we did this one particular job or activity on the Web inspection, that was just one area of vulnerability in the broad surface of what could confront the Department. Web sites are very easy to do hacks on, they are very easy to do activities on. We do want to do examinations on how well the credentials, are people using two-factor authentication, are they having too many--are there too many elevated privileges for users on applications. We're looking at activities like we're all in a mobile world, what does everyone have when they're taking things away with them? We're looking at assuring that there is mobile device management put in place on any particular devices that our people are looking at. We are also looking at interconnection agreements in terms of what will we have with different agencies if we are acting as a shared services type of providers. And in some of those interconnection agreements and all, if they have those, we want to assure that they are coming underneath a Trusted Internet Connection, those TICs that provide that perimeter protection from the outside world. Some of the agencies might be doing direct circuits, they might be encrypted, they might not be. Some agencies are using a thing that is called MTIPS, which is outside of an agency's way of monitoring Internet traffic. So it remains to be seen. We are very gratified and pleased by the progress of the Department in responding to the Web inspection activity. When the Department in the past would do these things, during Ms. Burns' tenure or mine, the ability to do scans on those network perimeters was very limited. We might only use just one particular scanning tool or another scanning tool that might come up with a couple of hundred vulnerabilities. If you had an organized advanced persistent adversary that used a variety of tools, it really illuminated to the Department and all that the steps that need to be taken. Mrs. Lawrence. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. Mr. Blum, you're recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Blum. Thank you, Chairman Hurd. And I'd like to thank the panel for being here today and giving us your insights on these most critical issues. Ms. Burns, I believe 20 of the 29 IG recommendations made in fiscal year 2013 in the audit remains open. Many of these are basic cybersecurity recommendations, as you're well aware, such as implementing third-party vendor security patches, maintaining an up-to-date information systems inventory, and utilizing approved and authorized solutions for remote access. When do you expect to address these recommendations? Ms. Burns. So those are on a rolling list that my team keeps and we monitor very closely with specific targets. I'd have to go back and look specifically to see what our plans are, what we had as the date for doing that. Ms. Burns. But I would say that with all the events of the past few months there's heightened attention to all things related to cybersecurity. We were already working on, for instance, clauses to contracts that would include security provisions. And so those things were already underway. Mr. Blum. Do you plan on implementing all of them? Ms. Burns. We would like to implement the things that--I think if we agree with them, we want to implement them. Mr. Blum. Did many of these stem from before your tenure as CIO? Ms. Burns. Yes, sir. Mr. Blum. So that would be Mr. Mazer then, is that correct? Mr. Mazer. That would be correct. Mr. Blum. What did you do, Mr. Mazer, in your tenure to address these? Twenty of the 29 remain open today. What did you do to address these during your tenure? Mr. Mazer. What we would do with, regardless of any weaknesses or we'd call them program objectives and milestones, is we literally receive thousands of weaknesses. What I did during my time, and it appears that it is continuing, is we set up a particular organization, sub- organization within the OCIO that monitored all audit and GAO and weakness findings. And then we pressed upon the bureaus or the office that was responsible for them on completion dates. And then there was a continuous follow-up on whether or not they are finishing those recommendations to be completed. Some recommendations can't be finished within 2 months, 4 months. Some might take a particular year because it might have to take a clause and a contract change. Mr. Blum. Twenty of 29 seems to be a big number to me, and they're still open today. Mr. Mazer. If you look at open findings or open audit actions in all that, there is literally--there might be several hundred of those. There are normal things that are either a weakness in all that, that need to be corrected, and then they will be corrected. The bureaus have always been or the office who is responsible for that are always pressed to get updates, they are requested for updates as to when those things are going to be done. Mr. Blum. The IG felt these were important enough to put them on a list. And it seems like the list, it never makes it to the top of the list. And it sounds like it hasn't for years. That concerns me. Does it concern you, Mr. Mazer? Mr. Mazer. It very much concerns me. When we looked at things like--we call the term POAMs, forgive the abbreviation-- there are literally thousands of them. One of the things that we were looking at and it is still continuing under Mrs. Burn's tenure is how many of these things are older than 6 months and then what were the steps in all that, that needed to be to complete those. Mr. Blum. Were you eligible to receive a bonus over the last 3 years as CIO? Mr. Mazer. Yes, sir. Mr. Blum. Did you receive a bonus in 2011? Mr. Mazer. Yes, I did. Mr. Blum. Did you receive a bonus in 2012? Mr. Mazer. Yes, I did. Mr. Blum. Did you receive a bonus in 2013? Mr. Mazer. Yes. Mr. Blum. Ms. Burns, did you receive a bonus in 2014? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Blum. I have a minute left. My last question, Ms. Burns, if there were another hack of the agency's servers in the Department of Interior today, what could the hackers do? What kind of damage could be done? Could they access other areas of the Department of Interior servers? Could they access other agencies' information if it happened today? Ms. Burns. There are risks to the Department. And so it is important for us, for me to be attentive to what's going on and make sure that we do whatever is necessary to immediately--and I'm not talking about waiting years, I'm talking about looking at what could really happen to us and damage us and act quickly. And that's something that I have been doing. I was doing it during my tenure. But I think it is with sharpened focus since over the past few months. Mr. Blum. Are we still vulnerable? Is that a yes? Are we still vulnerable? Can they still do serious damage today? Ms. Burns. I think that all agencies are vulnerable. Mr. Blum. Thank you are for your candor. And with that, I yield back my time, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Blum. Votes are going to be called soon, and I think we can get through the questioning before then. I would like to turn it over to Mr. Lieu for 5 minutes. Mr. Lieu. Thank you, Chairman Hurd. Ms. Burns, at the Department of Interior's data center, you don't house the CIA's list of covert spies at that data center, correct? Ms. Burns. Correct. Mr. Lieu. And you don't house our Nation's classified nuclear launch codes at that data center, correct? Ms. Burns. Correct. Mr. Lieu. In fact, you didn't house OPM's security clearance database either at that data center, right? Ms. Burns. Correct. Mr. Lieu. And that's because you're not a national security or intelligence agency, correct? Ms. Burns. That's correct. Mr. Lieu. So I am going to read you the mission statement of your Department, which is: ``The Department of the Interior protects and manages the Nations natural resources and cultural heritage; provides scientific and other information about those resources; and honors its trust responsibilities or special commitments to American Indians, Alaska Natives, and affiliated island communities.'' And with the indulgence of the chair, I would like to put this into the record. Mr. Hurd. So moved. Mr. Lieu. Mr. Chair, I would also like to enter into the record the mission statement of OPM, which is the following: ``Through our initiatives, programs, and materials, we seek to recruit and hire the best talent; to train and motivate employees to achieve their greatest potential; and to constantly promote an inclusive workforce defined by diverse perspectives. OPM provides human resources, leadership, and support to Federal agencies and helps the Federal workforce achieve their aspirations as they serve the American people.'' Mr. Lieu. OPM is not a national security or intelligence agency either, isn't that correct? Ms. Burns. It doesn't seem so. Mr. Lieu. Right. So I just want to make a point that for the same reasons we don't house our crown jewels of American intelligence at Department of Interior, there is no way we should be housing it in a human resources agency. Now, I would like to move on to the actual database that was breached at your data center, which was the 4.2 million personnel records that were not the security clearance records. OPM testified in one of the earlier hearings that they didn't encrypt their information because it was in COBOL language and they said they couldn't do that. But that's not true, right? COBOL can, in fact, be encrypted. There is nothing that says you cannot encrypt something written in COBOL, isn't that correct? Ms. Burns. I am not an expert in COBOL, so I can't answer that question. Mr. Lieu. If you could get information back to us on that, that would be terrific. Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Lieu. And then let me ask you, when they breached the systems through OPM into your data center, you said that no other information was compromised. Is that because the hackers found other information uninteresting? In other words, they could have gone to all these other databases and they chose not to? Or did you actually have protections there that prevented them from going to other databases that you were housing and storing? Ms. Burns. So I can't speculate about the motives of the attacker. What I know from the assessment that DHS performed, and they are the best source to talk about the specifics of the forensics that happened, there was no evidence of compromise of other data aside from OPM. Mr. Lieu. Let me ask this another way. If someone is in your data center in one database, can they look at your other databases of other agencies or of your own Secretary's information? Ms. Burns. So I would want to confirm this with my team, but I believe the answer to that is no. We use access controls and other methods to protect the data, other data in the data center that is different, aside from the OPM data. Mr. Lieu. Is that no now or no at the time or both? Ms. Burns. I'm sorry, could you repeat it? I didn't hear. Mr. Lieu. If it's no, was that also the case when this breached happened? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Lieu. Or was it fixed later? Ms. Burns. No. It was always that way. Mr. Lieu. Okay. Thank you. And then let me conclude by commending you. You said something that I found important. You said: We own this problem. So I appreciate that you said that. It shows that you understand that it is not the responsibility of foreign enemies or hackers to protect our systems, it is our responsibility; that you understand the gravity of this issue; and that your view is we are going to try to prevent breaches, and that you are not going to measure your success by happening to find a breach 4 months later or a year later, that you are going to try to prevent these breaches in the first place. So I appreciate that and look forward to working with you. Ms. Burns. Thank you, sir. Mr. Lieu. I yield back. Mr. Hurd. The gentleman yields back. Mr. Palmer from Alabama for 5 minutes. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I would like to thank the witnesses for coming. Ms. Burns, I think it's been established that there were known vulnerabilities and that the Department of Interior had suffered actual attacks that exploited some of these vulnerabilities prior to your team coming in, is that correct? Ms. Burns. I'm sorry, I can't hear you. Can you repeat the question? Sorry. Mr. Palmer. Okay. What I was saying is, is that there were known vulnerabilities and that the Department of Interior had suffered actual attacks that exploited these vulnerabilities prior to your coming on, is that correct? Ms. Burns. I believe that is correct. Mr. Palmer. So you knew that there were vulnerabilities. And you are also aware, I would assume, that the Sakula malware, which has been tied to the OPM attack, had been also tied to the Anthem cyber attack. Were you aware of that? Ms. Burns. I participated in briefings with DHS and OPM. Mr. Palmer. Did it not occur to you that you needed to evaluate the vulnerabilities at DOI for a potential cyber attack from what we knew in terms of the malware that was used in the Anthem attack? Ms. Burns. So I think I need to clarify that from my understanding of the incident that involved OPM---- Mr. Palmer. I'm talking about going back. You knew there were vulnerabilities, you knew that there had been prior attacks. We also knew that the Sakula malware had been used in the Anthem attack. Did no one, did it not occur to anyone that such an attack on the scale of the Anthem attack might could occur at DOI? Ms. Burns. So I think that we have to be, as I said, on alert about the dangers that are out there in terms of cybersecurity. Mr. Palmer. No, ma'am. That's a yes or a no. You either did the due diligence or you didn't. Ms. Burns. Could I, if I could, with greatest respect, just clarify that the breach from OPM into DOI did not happen because of a vulnerability in DOI's data center. It happened because of compromised credentials of a privileged user on OPM's side that then moved into DOI's environment. So it was not because of a vulnerability. Mr. Palmer. Well, all right. Thanks for making that clarification. Mr. Mazer, you were the Chief Information Officer for 4 years before Ms. Burns took over. What efforts, if any, did you undertake to address these issues when you were in charge? Mr. Mazer. When I assumed the role of the CIO at the Department of the Interior, the Department of Interior was basically predicated, the CIO's office was a policy shop. The CIO's office would promulgate policy to the respective bureaus and offices to assure that they were taking care of things like security, capital planning, enterprise architecture, systems life cycle development. I embarked upon--for 6 months we worked on a draft, it became known as the 3309 Secretarial Order, which says we need to consolidate Clinger-Cohen functions, like capital planning, enterprise architecture, and security underneath one CIO. And then we also stated that we need to move common infrastructure that everyone uses underneath one particular entity. We worked on a strategic plan. Arising out of the strategic plan, we settled on things that we called service towers. Mr. Palmer. I've only got a minute left. Mr. Mazer. Yes, sir. I'm sorry. Mr. Palmer. I appreciate the detail of the answer. And if you'd like to put the balance of that in writing and provide it to the committee, you're welcome to do so. Mr. Mazer. I'd be more than delighted. Okay. Mr. Palmer. I'd also like to know, was the database that the Interior hosted, including the OPM, encrypted? Ms. Burns. Ms. Burns. I'm probably not the right person to ask about that because OPM is the owner of the data. And I, in sitting in the testimony with the previous OPM Director, I just heard her testimony that she said the data was not encrypted. So I get my information from that. I would have to check with my technical team. Mr. Palmer. Do you have any idea how many serious breaches DOI has suffered in 2014? Ms. Burns. I'm sorry, could you repeat that? Mr. Palmer. So far for this year, how many breaches have you suffered? Do you have any idea? Ms. Burns. In 2015? Mr. Palmer. In 2014-2015. Ms. Burns. So that--I can't answer that. We have a distributed IT environment, as I said, and there is a--it was cited in the IG's report that there was a--reports of incidents, I think they referred to some incidents in the report, that were reported by the bureaus and offices that my office doesn't necessarily have visibility into. So we have to do research into them. In order to answer your question, I would have to go back and look further at that. Mr. Palmer. Would you be willing to let the committee know that? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Palmer. Thank you. I yield, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, sir. I'd like to yield myself 5 minutes. I just want to be clear, Ms. Burns, because you make a good point and I want to make sure everyone recognizes that. The bad guys got access to a credential that was OPM and they used that credential to gain access to the data housed at the Department of Interior. So that they used those credentials that had natural access to the information that was breached, is that correct? Ms. Burns. That's correct. Mr. Hurd. So they didn't take advantage of any vulnerability other than getting access to that user name and password. Ms. Burns. That's my understanding, sir. Mr. Hurd. Thank you. This recent vulnerability assessment that the inspector general did, who called for that? Ms. Kendall. We initiated it ourselves, sir. Mr. Hurd. Okay. And, Ms. Burns, how much of the IT budget for Department of Interior do you control? First question, what's the IT budget roughly for all of DOI? Ms. Burns. So the IT budget overall, we report approximately a billion dollars a year. Mr. Hurd. So of that billion dollars, how much do you, as the CIO of the Department, have access to? Ms. Burns. I would say it's---- Mr. Hurd. Roughly. Ms. Burns. It's approximately less than $200 million. Mr. Hurd. So you are the CIO of the entire Department and you have access to less than $200 million. Isn't that a problem? Ms. Burns. I think that the provisions that you gave us in terms of authorities to CIOs in FITARA, whereby I have to approve IT spending, helps. Even though I don't have the money, all the funds for the IT portfolio in my direct budget, it gives me significant influence. Mr. Hurd. You have a little bit more control, is what you are saying. Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Hurd. Now, let's focus on the assessment that was done. The draft report that we have access to said that nearly 3,000 critical and high-risk vulnerabilities in publicly accessible computers operated by three DOI bureaus was found, is that correct? Ms. Burns. Yes. Mr. Hurd. Have all those been remediated? Ms. Burns. From my understanding, yes. Mr. Hurd. But I also have information that indicates--and, Ms. Kendall, you may be able to confirm this--that the Department of Interior's total number of publicly accessible computer is unknown because the Department doesn't perform discovery scans of their publicly accessible information, is that correct? Ms. Kendall. I believe that's correct based on what we conducted in terms of---- Mr. Hurd. So that number could be significantly higher than 3,000? Ms. Kendall. It could be. Mr. Hurd. And there could be---- Ms. Kendall. No, I'm sorry, I believe the 3,000--and I'll ask this--was the vulnerabilities. Mr. Hurd. The total vulnerabilities? Ms. Kendall. Yes. Mr. Hurd. Okay. So the number of publicly accessible Web sites that have these vulnerabilities is higher than what it is because we don't know the total summation of those? Ms. Kendall. It could potentially be, yes. Mr. Hurd. So I would have liked--and, again, if this is publicly accessible information, those three bureaus that's doing it, that is not classified information because the bad guys can figure that out. That's just a point for me. Because I would have liked those three CIOs to be here, because they probably have a budget probably larger or in line with yours, is that correct, Ms. Burns? Ms. Burns. I can't tell you. I don't have that information with me right now. Mr. Hurd. So the remediation of those three bureaus, was that overseen by your office or was that overseen by CIOs from these varies bureaus? Ms. Burns. The remediations ultimately would have been overseen by--so we don't call them CIOs, we changed that when that secretarial order was issued. We call them Assistant Directors for Information Resources. And they--so they head IT in the bureaus. But I would tell you that IT in the bureaus is not centralized under them. So while they would oversee the mitigation of the vulnerabilities that you're talking about, those vulnerabilities could have resided at a lower program level that was outside of the chain of command of the bureau. Mr. Hurd. Mr. Gilkeson, maybe you're the right one. Isn't that pretty outrageous for designing management control of an IT system? Mr. Gilkeson. It's certainly not optimal, Mr. Chairman, I would say. Mr. Hurd. I'll take that. Mr. Gilkeson. It's a very--it's a highly decentralized organization. I think that's kind of coming through. Mr. Hurd. Is there a move afoot, Ms. Burns, to centralize some of this information? Ms. Burns. Yes, there is, sir. Under FITARA and our implementation plan for FITARA, there are plans to bring that more under a centralized management. Mr. Hurd. And I would like, without objection, to submit the Department of Interior's response to the IG report to the record. Mr. Hurd. And in this report, they talk about--you all talk about how long it's going to take to fix all the problems that the IG report identified. When do you think all those are going to be done? Ms. Burns. Some of it is dependent on resources because I have limited staff to be able to do stuff. I think that at the same time it's my obligation to be prudent about how we use the money that we have, and that includes leveraging the bureaus and offices as much as possible to be able to fulfill the fixes that go along with the recommendations. So, as I said, we do the best we can with the resources that we get. There are some immediate things that we can do to protect us against the immediate threat. And, as I mentioned, I'm already talking with the bureaus and offices about those things so we can take immediate action. Mr. Hurd. Great. Ms. Burns. The longer term things do have cost. Mr. Hurd. And, Ms. Burns, I want to join my colleague from California in thanking you for taking responsibility for this. And you said something else in your opening remarks that I am going to have to go back to the record and write down: This not just a paper-based exercise, you've got to roll up your sleeves and actually do something. And I appreciate that mentality. But I also want to make sure that--what were the people that you called, they're not CIOs of bureaus anymore, Assistant---- Ms. Burns. We call them ADIRs. Mr. Hurd. Let your ADIRs know that they should be sitting alongside you as well. And I appreciate you being here to answer the questions for the folks that are all in the organization of DOI who have the responsibility for fixing some of these issues. And I recognize it is not necessarily all in your area of control as it should be. And so we want to make sure that we continue looking at things like FITARA and FISMA and how we can strengthen your control over these issues, because we are going to be holding you responsible. And if we are going to hold you responsible, you should have the tools to fix the network. So I want to appreciate everyone for coming out today. This is an important topic. I'd like to yield a minute to my colleague from Texas. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. I realize we are in a hurry for votes. I was next door dealing with the excessive regulation in the EPA. But Jeff from my office says both Ms. Burns and Ms. Kendall spoke positively about moving more information and more of the IT to the cloud. And I just wanted to get both of you all to quickly tell me if there is anything that Congress can do to help enable that and move that along. Ms. Burns. From my perspective, I am appreciative for what you did with enacting FITARA and the new version of FISMA. I think they help us greatly. And before I would ask you to do anything more, I would say let us take the tools that you have given us and try to do the best we can to make them work in our organizations. Mr. Farenthold. Ms. Kendall, do you want to add anything? Ms. Kendall. I would only add that when we briefed staff on this report, one of the questions was what kind of financial resources need to come along to make these things happen. And the IG does not make those recommendations. But I would encourage the Department to provide that information to you as well because I think it is very much resource driven. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you all for being here. And thank you for your work. Mr. Hurd. Without objection, I would like to provide the-- put the IG report on Faisal Ahmed on the record. And without objection, so ordered. Mr. Hurd. And I'd like thank our witnesses for taking the time today and appearing before us. This is an important issue and something that this subcommittee is going to continue to investigate. And, Ms. Burns, you know, this is--we are here to be supportive and make sure that you have all the tools you'll need to do your job. Thank you all. And the subcommittees stand adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4:01 p.m., the subcommittees were adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]