Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- EXAMINING INVASIVE SPECIES POLICY [House Hearing, 114 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] EXAMINING INVASIVE SPECIES POLICY ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FOURTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ DECEMBER 1, 2015 __________ Serial No. 114-58 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform _____________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 99-595 PDF WASHINGTON : 2016 ________________________________________________________________________________________ For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM JASON CHAFFETZ, Utah, Chairman JOHN L. MICA, Florida ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland, MICHAEL R. TURNER, Ohio Ranking Minority Member JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee CAROLYN B. MALONEY, New York JIM JORDAN, Ohio ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of TIM WALBERG, Michigan Columbia JUSTIN AMASH, Michigan WM. LACY CLAY, Missouri PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts SCOTT DesJARLAIS, Tennessee JIM COOPER, Tennessee TREY GOWDY, South Carolina GERALD E. CONNOLLY, Virginia BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois MARK MEADOWS, North Carolina BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan RON DeSANTIS, Florida TED LIEU, California MICK MULVANEY, South Carolina BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey KEN BUCK, Colorado STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands MARK WALKER, North Carolina MARK DeSAULNIER, California ROD BLUM, Iowa BRENDAN F. BOYLE, Pennsylvania JODY B. HICE, Georgia PETER WELCH, Vermont STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma MICHELLE LUJAN GRISHAM, New Mexico EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin WILL HURD, Texas GARY J. PALMER, Alabama Jennifer Hemingway, Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director William McGrath, Interior Subcommittee Staff Director Ryan Hambleton, Senior Professional Staff Member Melissa Beaumont, Professional Staff Member SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming, Chairman PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona BRENDA L. LAWRENCE, Michigan, BLAKE FARENTHOLD, Texas Ranking Member KEN BUCK, Colorado, Vice Chair MATT CARTWRIGHT, Pennsylvania STEVE RUSSELL, Oklahoma STACEY E. PLASKETT, Virgin Islands GARY J. PALMER, Alabama C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on December 1, 2015................................. 1 WITNESSES Jamie Reaser, Ph.D., Executive Director, National Invasive Species Council, U.S. Department of the Interior, Washington, D.C. Oral Statement............................................... 4 Written Statement............................................ 7 Mr. Scott J. Cameron, President, Reduce Risks from Invasive Species Coalition, Washington D.C. Oral Statement............................................... 16 Written Statement............................................ 18 Alan D. Steinman, Ph.D., Director and Professor, Robert B. Annis Water Resources Institute, Grand Valley State University, Allendale Charter Township, Michigan Oral Statement............................................... 25 Written Statement............................................ 27 K. George Beck, Ph.D., Professor of Weed Science, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado Oral Statement............................................... 35 Written Statement............................................ 37 APPENDIX Responses prepared by Dr. Jaime Reaser to questions submitted by Chairman Lummis and Rep. Gosar................................. 64 Responses prepared by Mr. Scott J. Cameron to questions submitted by Rep. Gosar.................................................. 70 Questions prepared by Mr. George Beck to questions submitted by Rep. Gosar..................................................... 72 EXAMINING INVASIVE SPECIES POLICY ---------- Tuesday, December 1, 2015 House of Representatives Subcommittee on the Interior Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 2:36 p.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn Office Building, Hon. Cynthia Lummis [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Lummis, Gosar, Buck, Palmer, Lawrence, and Plaskett. Also present: Representative Hurd. Ms. Lummis. The subcommittee will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Today the Subcommittee on the Interior will examine the problem of invasive species in the U.S., and the effectiveness of the Federal government's attempts to control and eradicate invasives. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service specifically defines an invasive specie as an exotic species whose introduction into an ecosystem in which the specie is not native causes or is likely to cause environmental or economic harm or harm to human health. There are currently almost 50,000 such species living in the United States today. We promise there will not be a test on how many of those you can name. The impact of invasive species is hard to ignore. They are one of the leading causes of population decline and extinction in native plants and animals. They cause billions of dollars per year in damages across the country. Recently the Department of the Interior estimated that it spends $100,000 million annually on invasive species management. In response to this significant and growing problem, President Clinton created the National Invasive Species Council in 1999. This Council is co-chaired by the Secretaries of Interior, Agriculture, and Commerce. Its mission is to coordinate the work of numerous agencies to address and eradicate invasive species. Part of the Council's job is to produce a national management plan every two years for the treatment and eradication of endangered species. Since 1999, the Council has only released two plans, one in January 2001 and nearly 8 years later in 2008. A review of the 2001 plan by the Government Accountability Office found problems with coordination, delays, and setting clear long-term goals. In the past several years, there has been relatively little oversight of the Council's work and success in managing the invasive species problem. Questions continue to be raised about whether the Council and other Federal agencies are effectively treating certain invasive species. The spread of these nuisances is startling. Two years ago, Dr. George Beck testified before the House Committee on Natural Resources about the inefficiencies and ineffectiveness of the Council and the Federal government in treating invasive weeds. Dr. Beck warned that invasive weeds were spreading at a far faster pace than they were being eradicated. He questioned the government's claims about the amount of land infested with non- native weeds that it successfully treated in previous years. He also cast doubts on whether the Council was using the most cost-effective means of fighting invasive species. This hearing will allow the Council to update us on its progress. In addition, we will look at the impact of three invasive species that have caused significant and costly headaches for my home State of Wyoming as well as Ranking Member Lawrence's home State of Michigan. Mr. Hurd will also raise some issues in his district in Texas. The nuisance and dangers of these particular non-native species provides startling illustrations of the harmful effects of endangered species and the need for capable treatment efforts. Our witnesses today bring a broad and diverse knowledge of invasive species and the havoc they wreak on our country. We will hear from the executive director of the Council on its work. We will also hear from three experts who have studied the risks of invasive species in America, and can provide insight into the importance and urgency of addressing this issue. As the problem of invasive species in America worsens, we must continue to revisit and reassess the situation and our treatment and eradication efforts. I look forward to the hearing, and I look forward to our witnesses' testimony, and I want to thank you for being here today. I also want to thank the ranking member, Ms. Lawrence, for being the impetus and driving force behind holding this hearing today. And I now recognize Ms. Lawrence, the ranking member of the Subcommittee on the Interior, for her opening statement. Ms. Lawrence. I want to say that it is a pleasure, Madam Chairman. I thank you for helping me bring this issue forward and for your leadership. I want to thank all the witnesses here today for appearing, and I look forward to hearing your testimony. You have heard some of the statistics that I am sure, the witnesses, you are very familiar with. One of the concerns we have is that what is our plan. The amount of money that we are paying to address invasive species to me should not be spent without a comprehensive plan. I recognize that, Dr. Reaser, you are new, and so we are looking forward to hearing what your vision and what the plan is. Invasive species pose serious problems to our environment, and we understand that, but it is also a significant challenge to the conservation of native fish and wildlife. No habitat or region is immune from the threat of invasive species. As our chair mentioned, we spend over $125 billion each year controlling these plants and animals and repairing the damage they inflict on our property and our natural resources. As we talk about our environment, you cannot leave out the impact that invasive species has. In Michigan, I want to talk about that, and one of the reasons why this is so important to me, zebra mussels are a serious economic threat to our recreational fishing and commercial activity in the Great Lakes. And we in Michigan are passionate about our Great Lakes and our water, and so when you start seeing the impact of these invasive species, this rises to a level of being a very serious concern. The zebra mussels alone has caused more than $1 billion in damage by clogging the pipes and the filtration equipment of municipalities and industrial water systems. They have also damaged boats and decks, and it costs Michigan more than $250 million a year to clean those affected pipes and machinery. We are also facing a threat from the Asian carp, which can devastate recreational fishing if not controlled. According to the University of Michigan Sea Grant Institute, recreational and commercial fisheries contribute in excess to $4 to $7 billion to the economy each year. Recent reports show that these invasive fish have already caused significant problems in our Ohio and Mississippi River Basins. Only a few weeks ago, the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality and the Department of Natural Resources confirmed the existence of two new invasive species in water, and in 2014 the Administration reports it allotted an estimated $2.3 billion across the range of Federal agencies and activities to control and eradicate these species. I recognize that this issue requires a long-term plan, and that is what I want to hear today. Also I understand that scientists are working around the clock to create a remedy for this problem. Since the plan has not been revised since 2008, even though the regulations, it is required to issue and update every 2 years, one of the things that I am looking for is a commitment for compliance, and that is something that as part of this committee I will be looking for in the future. While we have not updated our plan, we know that the invasive species problem has worsened, and I feel strongly that a lack of a comprehensive plan on how to deal with this is contributing to the impact. I hope to get some answers today on this issue so that important safeguards can put into place to manage this ever-increasing problem of invasive species. Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Lummis. I thank the ranking member. I will hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any member who would like to submit a written statement. Ms. Lummis. The chair also notes the presence of the gentleman from Texas, as I mentioned earlier, Mr. Hurd, a member of the full committee. We thank you very much for your interest in the topic today. And without objection, we welcome Mr. Hurd to participate fully in today's hearing. We now recognize our panel of witnesses. We are pleased Dr. Jamie Reaser, who is newly minted as the executive director of the National Invasive Species Council at the U.S. Department of the Interior. Welcome, Dr. Reaser. Mr. Scott Cameron, president of the Reduced Risks from the Invasive Species Coalition. Thank you, Mr. Cameron. Dr. Alan Steinman, you are the director as well as a professor at the Robert B. Annis Water Resources Institute at Grand Valley State University. Am I correct? Mr. Steinman. [Off audio.] Ms. Lummis. Thank you Dr. Steiman. And Dr. George Beck, professor of weed science at Colorado State University. I studied weed science at the University of Wyoming under a colleague of yours, probably one that was teaching me before you were born. But welcome today, Dr. Beck. [Laughter.] Ms. Lummis. Pursuant to the committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify, so please rise and raise your right hands. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? [A chorus of ayes.] Ms. Lummis. Thank you. Please be seated. Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. Now, in order to allow time for discussions, please limit your oral testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statement will be made part of the record so we will have the advantage of it in case it is longer than 5 minutes. We will begin with Dr. Reaser. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Lawrence. Turn your mic on. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF JAMIE REASER, PH.D. Ms. Reaser. Madam Chairman, members of the subcommittee, thank you for inviting me to participate in the hearing on behalf of the National Invasive Species Council, NISC. With me today is Ms. Anne Kinsinger, U.S. Geological Survey's associate director for ecosystems. I will summarize my written testimony, which has been provided for the record. NISC was created by Executive Order 13112, known as the Invasive Species Executive Order, on February 3rd, 1999, to serve as an independent coordinating body for the Federal government's efforts to address invasive species. As you have noted, the Secretary of Interior serves as a co-chair of NISC along with the Secretaries of Agriculture and Commerce. The Secretary of Interior also hosts and oversees NISC staff. At this time, 10 additional departments and agencies are members of NISC. They are listed in my written testimony. As you may be aware or are aware, I started as executive director of NISC staff just 9 weeks ago. That said, I am not new to the invasive species issue. My work has largely focused on invasive species since 1999, not coincidentally the year in which the executive order was signed. But in actuality, my interaction with the invasive species issue goes back much further than that. My grandmother taught me to fish as a young girl. I can remember being frustrated by the fact that I could not catch anything other than carp. I desperately wanted to see pretty sunfish up close. Because the feeding habits of the carp muddied the water, I could not even see a sunfish near the dock. I did my doctoral work in the Great Basin in Nevada, specifically at the southernmost extent of the species range of the Columbia spotted frog. During my time in the field, I became aware of numerous adverse shifts taking place in the lands and waters of the sagebrush ecosystem: the invasion of annual grasses, cheatgrass, and medusahead, and the introduction of non-native amphibians and tropical fish, to name a few. Invasive species clearly warranted concern and concerted action. Since that time, I have worked on various aspects of the invasive species issue in more than 40 countries, frequently helping other governments institutionalize their capacities to address the invasive species issue. In the course of my work, I have seen firsthand how invasive species can devastate the lives and livelihoods of people who depend on local resources. Invasive species impact everyone on a personal level, although we may not equally or fully recognize the extent to which they do. If we care about food security, water security, human health and well-being, animal welfare, employment and the economy--in short, national security--we need to pay considerably more attention to this often subtle, yet nevertheless pervasive and costly issue, invasive species. The invasive species issue is dynamic and complex. Coordinating activities of Federal agencies and working with non-Federal stakeholders to prevent, eradicate, and control invasive species throughout the U.S. and abroad is a substantial challenge. Thankfully, challenges can be overcome. Two examples of successes to NISC's leadership include provision of expert advice for more than 100 individuals who have served on the non-Federal Invasive Species Advisory Committee, also created by the executive order. This advice has strengthened Federal programs and initiatives, such as our work on biofuels. And the implementation of the two national invasive species management plans that together contain more than 170 action items. Additional examples can be found in my testimony. As you are well aware, we are operating in a resource constrained world, and due to limited resources, it is fair to say NISC has not yet actualized its full potential. With the support of the Department of the Interior as well as 12 other NISC member departments and agencies, I intend to do all I can to mobilize NISC's leadership and capacities to effectively implement the Invasive Species Executive Order from the policy level to the ground level and back again. The work includes, but is not limited to, NISC's four major functions: raising awareness of the linkages between invasive species and various aspects of national security as they relate to each Department; setting priorities for international action that actually has impact at the ground level; fostering a culture of collaboration, innovation, and long-term commitment to problem solving; and facilitating team work across departments and between Federal, State, tribes, and other stakeholders that not only results in invasive species prevented and eradicated, but ecosystems and ecosystem services restored. Thank you for time and for caring about this critically important issue. I am happy to answer questions regarding this. Ms. Kinsinger is available to answer technical questions on specific species as needed. [The statement of Ms. Reaser follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Lummis. Thank you, Dr. Reaser. The chair now recognizes Mr. Cameron for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF SCOTT J. CAMERON Mr. Cameron. Madam Chairman, Ranking Member Lawrence, members of the subcommittee, my name is Scott Cameron. I am president of a nonprofit organization called the Reduce Risks from Invasive Species Coalition, or RRISC. I appreciate the opportunity to testify today on opportunities to improve invasive species policy and programmatic implementation in the United States. RRISC is a 501(c)(3) organization incorporated in 2014. Our mission is to educate the public on the risks imposed by invasive species and to promote cost-effective strategies to reduce those risks. We pride ourselves on being bipartisan with a distinguished advisory board comprised of former senior government officials from the Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush Administrations. I am pleased to say that since our inception, we have had a close working relationship with the Congressional Invasive Species Caucus, co-chaired by your own representatives, Dan Benishek from Michigan and Mike Thompson from California. Invasive species pose serious economic and environmental problems across the country. They have been estimated to cost the American economy more than $120 billion a year and to have a $1.4 trillion annual impact on the global economy. There are significant public health impacts from invasive species. For instance, invasive species, like West Nile virus and fire ants, put many Americans in the hospital every year, and in some cases they do not survive. Invasive species have single- handedly caused 20 percent of all species extinctions since the 1600s, and they have been implicated in up to half of all the species extinctions over the last four centuries. Indirectly, they cause increased regulatory burden on American society since invasives are in whole or in part responsible for more than 40 percent of the listings under the Endangered Species Act. For example, widespread distribution of invasive cheatgrass in Wyoming and Colorado was a key risk factor that almost led to the listing of the greater sage grouse under the Endangered Species Act earlier this year. If your constituents are concerned about loss of biodiversity and species extinctions in the United States, then they should also be concerned about invasive species. If your constituents are frustrated by the regulatory burden imposed by the Endangered Species Act, that is another reason to be concerned about invasive species because they are putting a lot of species on the ESA list. I would now like to offer a number of recommendations on how institutional arrangements could be improved to yield better results in invasive species management for our country. Congress should direct the National Invasive Species Council to present the Congress with a short annual work plan, 5 pages in length, to include deadlines and intended outcomes of Council activities. This would help focus the political level attention in the agencies on the invasive species problem. The National Invasive Species Council should provide a forum for Federal interagency communication and coordination with regional governors associations--southern governors, western governors, and so on. NISC should design a national network of regionally-driven, early detection, and rapid response capabilities whose regional priorities are established based on the advice of the governors of those States in those regions. NISC should provide a forum for Federal agency regional executives, BLM State directors, regional foresters, EPA regional administrators, and so on, so that those regional officials could more easily get the attention of the departmental political leadership in headquarters in the Office of Management and Budget. And through more coordinated policymaking at the headquarters level, achieve better on-the- ground coordination at the local level. The Council should provide a forum for ensuring and expediting interagency coordination at the headquarters level so that time sensitive decisions involving invasive species policy, regulatory approvals, or research are less likely to be caught up in bureaucratic red tape in D.C. As an example, facilitating Endangered Species Act, Section 7 consultation between USDA and EPA on new pesticides targeting invasive species; working with the Council on Environmental Quality to streamline environmental compliance for agency on the ground invasive species control actions; and achieving an interagency bio control research agenda that would effectively leverage the relative scientific strengths of EPA, USGS, USDA, and the National Science Foundation. Another recommendation. NISC should seek out and evaluate international best practices and explore the feasibility of adopting those best practices in the United States. It looks like I am over time, so I will stop, Madam. Chairman, and I look forward to questions. [The statement of Mr. Cameron follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Buck. [Presiding] Thank you, Mr. Cameron. The chair recognizes Dr. Steinman for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF ALAN D. STEINMAN, PH.D. Mr. Steinman. Thank you, Chairman Buck, Ranking Member Lawrence, and members of the subcommittee. I appreciate the opportunity to testify before you today with regard to the threats posed by invasive species, and, in particular, their impacts in the Great Lakes region. There are four areas that I would like to cover today. The first is invasive species and the Great Lakes. The Great Lakes serve as the poster child for aquatic invasive species. It is now estimated since the 1800s, over 180 non-native species have invaded the Great Lakes ecosystem. The Great Lakes are a national treasure. They hold over 20 percent of the world's surface fresh water, and over 90 percent of the surface fresh water in the United States. The importance of this resource, both in terms of water quantity and water quality, cannot be overstated given the increasing concerns over water security in this Nation and around the world. Aquatic invasive species are acutely felt in the State of Michigan, a state which touches four of the five Great Lakes-- our governor likes that four of the five Great Lakes favor Michigan--and where 1 in 5 jobs are linked to water. The second area I would like to talk about are the ecological impacts in the Great Lakes. These include habitat loss, food web disruption, and alterations to native fisheries. Two aquatic invasive species that have been particularly problematic in the Great Lakes are the sea lamprey and the Dreissena mussels, which include the quagga and zebra mussels. The sea lamprey, for those not familiar with it, is an eel-like parasite whose native habitat is the ocean. It got into the Great Lakes after the Welland Canal was improved, and it bypassed the Niagara Falls. By 1938, they had reached all of the Great Lakes. Sea lamprey parasitism is not a pretty site. They attach to fish with a suction cup mouth, and dig their teeth into fish flesh, and finally feed on fish body fluids by secreting an enzyme that prevents the blood from clotting. The lake trout harvest in the upper Great Lakes has declined from about 15 million pounds per year before the sea lampreys to approximately 300,000 pounds now, a decline of 98 percent of this critical fish. The good news is the sea lamprey control program is very effective. We have to apply it every year, though, and it costs about $20 million per year. The zebra and quagga mussels also have caused extensive damage. They came in through ballast water discharge. The zebra mussel was first found in 1988 in Lake Sinclair, quickly followed by its larger and more aggressive cousin, the quagga mussel. In fact, the quagga mussel is now estimated to have about 950 trillion--that is with a ``T''--in Lake Michigan alone. That is a huge number. They are filter feeders there literally sucking the bioenergetic life out of Lake Michigan. Once you decline the algae levels--they are lower than they are in Lake Superior--there is no food for the zooplankton to feed on. When there is no zooplankton, there is no food for crayfish to feed on, and when there is no crayfish, there is no food for the top predators, the salmon and the lake trout, to feed on. So the devastation to the food web and the economic impacts are enormous. Which leads me to the third area I would like to talk about: the economic influences of invasive species in the Great Lakes. In Michigan, especially affected by aquatic invasive species, the industry has influenced or affected our power generation, industrial facilities, tourism, and sport and commercial fisheries, which account for about 30,000 jobs and almost $12 billion in annual sales based on 2010 data. As Representative Lawrence mentioned, the commercial and recreational fishery industry in the Great Lakes is estimated to be between $4 and $7 billion, and they are at critical risk by the presence of these invasive species. And finally, I would like to address the management implications. With the Asian carp at the entryways of the Great Lakes, we must be coordinated in our approaches to monitor our waterways to keep invasive species from getting into the Great Lakes, quarantine them when necessary and where possible, and then finally eradicate them when feasible. It is critical to recognize that in a hydraulically connected system like the Great Lakes, the program to control aquatic invasives is only as strong as the weakest link in that chain. Regardless of how vigilant or aggressive Michigan may be in dealing with aquatic invasive species, its waters remain vulnerable if any of the other seven Great Lakes States or two Canadian provinces are not as equally vigilant or aggressive. And this concept of vulnerability applies well beyond aquatic ecosystems. It applies to any connected ecosystem across its jurisdictional boundaries, whether it is water, land, or air. It is clear that we need a coordinated effort to tackle invasive species instead of jumping from one crisis to another, and good science is needed to make informed management decisions. I clearly understand the role of science having worked in the Everglades restoration before I came to Michigan, and I recognize that science does not dictate policy; it helps inform policy. But let me leave you with this one thought taken from Peter Glick, one of the foremost water resource scientists on the planet. It is very difficult to make good public policy without good science, and it is even harder to make good public policy with bad science. Thank you again for the invitation to appear before you today. [The statement of Mr. Steinman follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Buck. Thank you, Dr. Steinman. The chair recognizes Dr. Beck for a 5-minute opening. STATEMENT OF K. GEORGE BECK, PH.D. Mr. Beck. Chairman Buck, Ranking Member Lawrence, and honorable members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify before you today. I am George Beck, and I am a professor of weed science at Colorado State University. Today I represent the Healthy Habitats Coalition, and we are a diverse alliance dedicated to improving invasive species management in our country. In spite of almost 3 decades of efforts by many organizations working to persuade the Federal government to do a better job controlling and managing invasive species, little progress has been made. Zebra and quagga mussels are in the Great Lakes, and Asian carp is poised to invade those bodies. Cheatgrass, knapweeds, and tamarisk abound in the west; Burmese pythons, melaleuca, and hydrilla are wreaking havoc in Florida. Emerald ash borer and other invasive insects are invading the north, east, and Midwest. All of these are spreading rapidly, and every State has invasive species without exception. Cheatgrass alters habit so significantly that it is clearly linked to the decline of the greater sage grouse and its habitat. We possess, however, the knowledge and ability to recover cheatgrass infested safe grass habitat if we would just seize the initiative to do so. For example, CSU weed scientists just completed a comprehensive study to demonstrate such success, and we also have developed approaches that target and eliminate the cheatgrass soil seed reserve, which then will provide the best opportunity to recover native species habitat. The invasive species conundrum in the U.S. is not necessarily due to a lack of knowledge. Rather it is because of chronically poor Federal land management agency performance around managing invasive species. And this is a reflection of chronically poor administrative leadership concerning invasive species. Leadership from the National Invasive Species Council is practically non-existent. NISC is made up, of course, of most of the President's Cabinet. Most prominently, the members are the co-chairs, Secretaries of Agriculture, Commerce, and Interior. Frankly, NISC could be dissolved, and the funds used to operate that body should be spent on decreasing the population abundance of invasive species and recovering native species habitat. This poor Federal performance is due to at least four things that we have been able to identify: inconsistent budgets and non-transparency in the invasive species budgeting process, a lack of collaboration, prioritization, and on-the-ground performance with State and local governments, using NEPA as an excuse for inaction or justification to postpone making timely management decisions, and poor administrative leadership to develop appropriate invasive species public policy, management, and budgetary action. The solution to these problems has been introduced as bills, H.R. 1485 and S. 2240, the Federal Lands Invasive Species Control, Prevention, and Management Act. The bills focus on the Forest Service, BLM, National Park Service, and Fish and Wildlife Services. These are the major Federal land management agencies. The bills require agencies to develop an invasive species strategic plan that fosters agreements with States and local governments. The bill also has categorical exclusions that will protect high-value sites from invasive species, fully support and facilitate the development of early detection and rapid response, and then years and years of analysis to approve new management tools. The bills also require invasive species population to be decreased by 5 percent net annually to stay ahead of expansion rates, and change the spending parameters. And these would be 75 percent of invasive species funds to those agencies would have to be put on the ground. Not more than 15 percent of those funds can be spent on awareness and research, and up to 10 percent on administration. So the bulk of the money will be directed towards healing the problem. HHC has many supporters for these efforts, including an invasive species resolution from the Western Governors Association and direct support from Governor Butch Otter from Idaho, Governor Cecil Andrus, who is the former governor of Idaho and a former Secretary of Interior, and Governor Martinez from New Mexico. There is no Federal administrative leadership on invasive species. It is up to Congress to pass strong leadership and pass these bills. Doing so will place our country on the road to begin solving the invasive species problem. We must stop kicking this can down the road. Thank you again for this opportunity to share HHC's thoughts on invasive species management in the U.S. [The statement of Mr. Beck follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Buck. Thank you, Dr. Beck, and go Rams. [Laughter.] Mr. Buck. The chair will now recognize members for 5 minutes, and will recognize himself first. Dr. Reaser, how does NISC coordinate its work with Federal agencies, and States, and local communities to combat invasive species? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. NISC coordinates work through a series of tiers of coordination. NISC itself, as you are aware, are the Secretaries and administrators of the 13-member departments. And then within the NISC structure, broader structure, we also have policy-level leads and more technical-level leads. There are interdepartmental coordination mechanisms throughout that structure. There are also coordination mechanisms between NISC and other structures focused on invasive species, such as the Aquatic Nuisance Species Task Force. And there are regular joint working groups, and joint committees, and joint products with that group and others. And then there are on-the-ground activities where Federal agency representatives are collaborating with States, and tribes, and other stakeholders at the ecosystem level or on a species-by-species specific level. Mr. Buck. What is the annual budget for NISC? Ms. Reaser. For the NISC staff? Mr. Buck. What is the total budget, I guess, and then if you want to break it down, you can explain. Ms. Reaser. Okay. So the approximate budget for the NISC staff is about a million dollars per year, and about a third of that 30 percent is spent on administering the Invasive Species Advisory Committee. Mr. Buck. And appropriately what percentage of the overall budget goes to administrative expenses? Ms. Reaser. So for the NISC staff just to clarify, it is about 65 percent would be salary, travel, basic operations. And then approximately 30 percent would be for the advisory committee's administration. Mr. Buck. Dr. Beck, cheatgrass continues to cause problems with sage grouse habitat. Could you please describe the current status of the cheatgrass threat and what actions have been taken to mitigate its spread? Mr. Beck. Cheatgrass is a controversial plant relative to how much area it occupies. I have heard data everywhere from 50 million to over a hundred million acres, so it is really hard to know. It has not found its way everywhere. For example, 10 years ago was the first time cheatgrass showed up in the Gunnison Basin in South Central Colorado. And in the Kremmling area, which is, oh, 150 miles north, it has only been there for about 5 years, or at least that is what people say. So it continues to find new homes. The Great Basin is obviously very inundated with it. It is not so bad that you can close your eyes and point and be looking at cheatgrass whether you know it or not, but we are getting close to that. It is there every year. I mean, I hear people talk about, well, it is not a bad year for cheatgrass, and I say wait until June. It is the same very June. And I even had a student in one of my classes tell me that his mother's neighbor was running around picking this grass from around his yard in the foothills. I think it was above the Estes Park area. And she wanted to know what he was doing, and he said, well, this does not require any water, I do not know what is. And he was planting cheatgrass. So, you know, Pogo was right when he said, we have met the enemy and they are us. So we continue to foster its spread through all kinds of means, some of them inadvertent, and some of them not. But the problem is worsening constantly. Mr. Buck. And what do you think NISC can do to help with the cheatgrass problem? Mr. Beck. NISC's role is to coordinate with the Federal agencies, and I educate a lot in the public. Half of my appointment is extension, and so I must give about 50 to 75 presentations a year through Colorado alone, and I just do not see where any coordinating is having effect. In fact, I have visited with some Federal employees who do not even know NISC exists. So there is a transitional loss someplace between Washington, D.C. and the rest of the country. Mr. Buck. Okay. Thank you. My time is almost up, and I recognize the gentlelady from Michigan for 5 minutes. Ms. Lawrence. Thank you, Chair. Ms. Reaser, I understand that the one update that has been made to the management plan was back in 2008. Is that correct? So help me understand why the Council has largely not updated the management plan, and when will it be updated? Ms. Reaser. Okay. So let us step back to 2001. Ms. Lawrence. Okay. Ms. Reaser. And thank you for the question. I think it is an important one. As you know, in the executive order, there is a request for the plan to be revised every two years. The reasons behind that were, of course, to set priorities, raise visibility, and so forth, all reasonable criteria. When the original plan was created, there was a tremendous amount of enthusiasm among the departments for this new culture of collaboration, and the request was to bring priorities together in a comprehensive manner to use the word you used previously. The second management plan followed the pattern of the first management plan. It was a revision thereof, and so it had approximately 90 action items in it as did the first one. There were 170 total. The second management plan ran from 2008 through 2014. Since that time, there has been a process of moving the priorities forward from the first two management plans collectively. There has also been a process of looking at what items within those management plans require further work on an evaluation process going forward. There has been a delay in the process of moving it to the third management plan for a couple of reasons. One, there had been unanticipated staff turnovers and vacancies that could not be accounted for, and did have a significant impact on process. And then more recently, there was a desire to hire my position into place to take leadership over the third management plan, which I am now in the process of doing. And we are looking forward to having that available sometime early next year. Ms. Lawrence. Okay. I wanted to ask if it was achieving the objective of reducing the invasive species rate by 5 percent every year. Are you anywhere close to that goal? Ms. Reaser. So the Invasive Species Management Plan itself is a priority setting mechanism, so each item within the plan has different goals and objectives. Only a small percentage of those would be dedicated for activities related to weeds on the ground. As those projects move forward, each of them is going to have a goal that is context specific. A number of 5 percent, 15 percent, 20 percent is not necessarily going to be fit to purpose for all circumstances. So each of the activities undertaken through the plan or otherwise is going to set a goal that makes sense context specifically. Ms. Lawrence. So are you reaching any of those goals? Ms. Reaser. Yes, many of those goals have been reached through this process. Ms. Lawrence. One of the things that the plan, it is my understanding that we as members of Congress should know that the plan is being updated, and I can tell you that has not been a reality. So you are saying, you are making a commitment here today that your plan will be updated by the spring of next year. And I expect that we will know that that has happened under your leadership. Is that correct? Ms. Reaser. I am willing to be personally accountable on that one. There are not many things that I can promise you, but that one I can assure you under my leadership will happen as soon as it is feasibly possible. Ms. Lawrence. I am going to have to come back for another round of questions, but I do want to ask this. With your knowledge now that you are in the position, do you have the funds or the resources to actively, once we get a plan, to implement it and to be able to state to Congress and to the people of the United States that we have a very proactive and committed plan to addressing the Invasive Species Act? And I love the comparison made between endangered species. I think we get a lot of attention and affection when we start talking about endangered species where you need to really talk about the invasive species because that is a major component of why we have endangered. So when you submit the plan, will you be able to implement it with your budget and resources? Ms. Reaser. That is a very good and pertinent question. We will make sure that where we have good alignment with current resources that will be well recognized. There may be cases where there is an action item in the plan to mobilize additional resources or find efficiencies with existing resources, and we will also work to identify that as well. Ms. Lawrence. You are not willing to say if you have it yet or not because that is what you are saying. Ms. Reaser. We have not finished the plan yet. Ms. Lawrence. Okay. Ms. Reaser. So it would be premature for me ---- Ms. Lawrence. I will give you that. Ms. Reaser. Thank you. Ms. Lawrence. Thank you. Mr. Buck. I thank the lady from Michigan, and I recognize the gentleman from Arizona. Mr. Gosar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Now, Dr. Reaser, the Lower Colorado River is in the frontlines of battling the quagga mussel. So, Dr. Steinman, we join you, and the salt cedar. The mussels threaten the Hoover Dam, the Davis Dam, Parker Dam, Imperial Dam, and the Central Arizona Project, all of which are part of my district in Arizona. These water systems supply electricity and drinking water to millions across the Southwest. Now, while the problem is massive in scale, its implications are felt locally and require local action to mitigate their spread. Municipal leaders and community organizations in my district, such as the Lake Havasu Marine Association, are prepared and willing to do their part, but need resources to do so. So my first question. What specific authorizations currently exist for funding mitigation programs that combat these mussels or salt cedars on a State or local level? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. I do not have specific information available on those authorities, but I would be happy to make that information available to you. Mr. Gosar. I would like to get them because I think the gentleman, Dr. Beck, was making this comment. We have a lot of surface activity, but nothing down on the local level, and it is imperative that we leverage those resources. I would also like to know what type of flexibility exists with matching funds from local, and States, and private partnerships for these authorizations. Do you have that either? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. I am going to invite Anne Kinsinger to address the answer. Ms. Kinsinger. I do not have a comprehensive answer on that, but I did want to note that the Fish and Wildlife Service does work to coordinate the development of State wildlife action plans. And when a species is listed as a species of management concern in those plans, then grants are available. So I do not think that is the full answer, so I think we will need to get back to you with some other authorities. But that is a major ---- Mr. Gosar. I would like to know that. Ms. Kinsinger. Yes. Mr. Gosar. Stay right there. I am going to jump ahead here. So according to Executive Order 131112, NISC is charged with producing a national management plan every 2 years that sets forth its goals for treating and eradicating invasive species. However, since 1999, NISC has only released two management plans, those in 2001 and 2008. Can you please explain why there has been such a delay in producing a management plan, and when does NISC plan to produce a national management plan? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. To make it short since I have answered a version of this already, the management plan between 2014--that is when the second management plan sunsetted--sorry--between 2012, and this management plan, there has been a process in place to identify which items in the second management plan need to be moved forward to the third management plan. A number of items are ongoing understandably. Also ---- Mr. Gosar. I get that, and I see the gentleman over here just wriggling, which is what I am doing, is that there is so much bureaucracy up here, there is nothing trickling down to the local levels. And this is what is frustrating about this is that we always have to set goals. We have to have objectives, and then we have to have outcomes. And if we do not have people on the local level included in those, we are never going anywhere. And this is what is so frustrating with these groups. I have got salt cedars on one side. I have got quagga mussels everywhere. I have bison in the Yellowstone National area in the Grand Canyon. This is frustrating when you are talking about invasive species because you have people with expertise and the manpower and willpower to do this, but they cannot get any jurisdiction or leverage coming out of your Department. Does that make sense to you? Ms. Reaser. I certainly understand and concur with your frustrations in terms of the priority of getting resources to the ground ---- Mr. Gosar. Yes, but it is even worse than that because not just getting the resources. But these plans seem to get lost in your bureaucracy that are well intentioned and have great outcomes, but they cannot get any jurisdiction to say we are going to work with you, let us move forward with this plan. I mean, it is just absolutely ludicrous with the folks back home what is going on with this. Ms. Reaser. I understand your concerns, and they are warranted. This is a substantial issue of concern that deserves priority attention. I can assure you that the third management plan will be available early next year. Mr. Gosar. Well, I will have to stay. I am running out of time. I will stay ---- Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentleman from Arizona. I just want to make one thing clear. Dr. Reaser, I want to make sure we have the correct spelling of the assisted witness in this matter. If you could just spell your name for the record, I would appreciate it. Ms. Kinsinger. Yes, I am Anne Kinsinger. That is Anne with an ``E.'' Last name K-i-n-s-i-n-g-e-r. Mr. Buck. Thank you very much. And the chair now recognizes the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands for 5 minutes. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you, Madam Chair, and Ranking Member Lawrence. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and I am so appreciative of you coming here to discuss this issue. Invasive species affect our economy, our environment, human health in many instances. And although we have not focused on it today, and I did not hear it in your testimonies, invasive species, such as lionfish, brown tree snake, and even invasive Sargassum seaweed, have had a devastating effect on all aspects of the economic development, agricultural production, and tourism, particularly in my district in the United States Virgin Islands, and in some parts of southeastern United States. I note that several of my colleagues from Florida have introduced legislation related to the lionfish, which are an invasive, voracious eating species that is not native to the waters in which they have come, and have completely attempted in their eating habits to annihilate our own local fish. And our fishermen are up in arms. Our Department of Planning and Natural Resources are trying to create ways to deal with this invasive species both in the Virgin Island, Puerto Rico, and particularly in areas of Florida as well. And there has been success in controlling a few of the invasive species, but it is clear you all are completely aware that we need to do more. Ms. Reaser, according to the submitted testimony, you have taken on some really important initiatives. And one of those initiatives is to focus on national priorities and targeted outputs. I wanted to know if you could tell us what the national priorities are, and what do you mean by ``targeted outputs?'' And specifically, of course, you know, my interest would be if the territories are included in those priorities. Ms. Reaser. Certainly the territories are explicitly included in the work we are doing, and thank you for highlighting them. And in particular, they do face many challenges that are particular to island regions. As you are probably well aware, invasive species are one of the number one threats to biodiversity in island context, and that has certainly been the case in the U.S. territories. The national priorities are set within the National Invasive Species Management Plan in terms of how the Federal government is going to work together, but also with States, territories, tribes, and other partners. So each management plan sets forward a new set of priorities, and so we will have a new set early this next year. Ms. Plaskett. And how is that determined, in what way? Is it by population? Is it based on economic determinants? What sets those priorities? Ms. Reaser. Anne Kinsinger would like to address that. Ms. Kinsinger. Okay. Hi. I just wanted to say I am not speaking to what will be in the plan, but that there are a number of scientifically-based techniques that we can use. One of them is model the invasivity of the animal once it is detected and try to get a sense of how quickly it will spread, and try to be able to understand what kind of impacts it is going to have, because there are many invasive species that come to the country and really do not cause much damages, do not spread very quickly. So we have a variety of tools that we are trying to use that managers and policy makers can deploy to understand how quickly and how damaging from both an ecological and an economic perspective. Ms. Plaskett. Because the reason I was asking what are the benchmarks and how do you determine that is more often than not, in my area of the Virgin Islands, because it is seen that we are small in numbers, we are not given the priorities. And I just wanted to share something with the committee today, and I am asking that we show this picture, and I will pass this around. That this is what happens when the invasive species, the Sargassum seaweed, which if you think about an island economy that is based on fishing and tourism, if that is sitting on your beach, it is going to affect your tourism tremendously on a regular basis. And that is on every beach in the Virgin Islands these last couple of months. So thank you, and I would ask unanimous consent to include this in the record. And I just wanted to then close with, and I know I am running out of time. Mr. Beck, if you could tell us if you feel that there needs to be a change and improvement in controlling this and how we set these priorities. Mr. Beck. I am not familiar with the seaweed problem other than I am just aware that it exists, so I am not the expert to ask on that. But if we do not have the information, it needs to be dealt with immediately. That seems to be the case with almost every new invasive species, you know. Where are we scientifically on it? That is an excellent question to ask, and I think we need to address these species unfortunately one at a time, but that is part of the challenge in this. And they all need to be addressed. Mr. Buck. With no objection, the picture will be included in the record. Mr. Buck. And I would just mention to the gentlelady from the Virgin Island that Dr. Beck and I live close to each other, and we would be glad to go to the Virgin Islands this time of year to look at the seaweed and ---- Ms. Plaskett. Immediately. Mr. Buck. Yes, immediately. Great. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Arizona for 5 minutes. Mr. Gosar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Dr. Reaser, we are going to come back again to Arizona. And as you know, the Tamarisk salt cedar has been spread throughout the Colorado River Basin. It has been especially damaging to areas in Arizona in my district along the Gila River. These invasive and thirsty shrubs steal already limited water to push out native plants, strain agricultural resources, and disrupt economic activity. In communities where the Tamarisk invasion has developed into crisis, like Buckeye Arizona on the Gila River, local and State leaders have developed action plans to eradicate the shrub and restore natural habitats. However, these mitigation plans, like I alluded to earlier, have gotten lost in the complicated web of Federal invasive species policy, or have been flat out resisted by the Federal agencies themselves. So what has NISC done to engage communities and to empower them to leverage the local resources and expertise to address problems unique to their area? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. To clarify, NISC itself is the Secretaries' and administrators ---- Mr. Gosar. I understand. Ms. Reaser.--of the 13 member Departments. So they themselves would not be having a direct relationship coordinating with the counties. However, many of the Federal agency personnel working in that region have been involved in multi-stakeholder partnerships. You are familiar, I am sure, with the Tamarisk Coalition. Mr. Gosar. Yes. Ms. Reaser. And through those on the ground efforts at better communication and coordination, requests for assistance, individual priority setting, information, exercises, and so forth are brought up through the Federal agencies. Mr. Gosar. So now, is there any benefit or streamlining to this process in coordination with American Indian tribes? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. Are you referring to the work with Tamarisk in particular or with ---- Mr. Gosar. With any invasive species, but in this case Tamarisk, yes. Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. I cannot answer specifically with regard to Tamarisk. I can answer more broadly if that is of interest. Mr. Gosar. Sure. Ms. Reaser. Okay. So within the framework of the Invasive Species Advisory Committee that I mentioned previously, there are two seats dedicated for tribal representatives. There have been five tribal individuals who have filled those seats to date. The tribes are also included in numerous specific actions that are implemented under the National Invasive Species Management Plan. They may participate in specific committees, working groups, or task teams of particular interest to the tribes. The most recent example would be the outreach to tribes and inclusion of tribal representatives and the development of the early detection and rapid response framework that will be released in the near future. Mr. Gosar. Well, but my question is, is there any mechanism in which that can streamline? I mean, they have jurisdictions that are synonymous as a sovereign entity if it exists on their property. Is there is a streamlining mechanism? Not just representation, but is there a streamlining possibility in utilizing the tribes within a problem? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. The tribes themselves have not brought to our attention a request for that process. If they did, I think we would take it into consideration to look at ways to coordinate better. We certainly would welcome more tribal participation at all levels of the work within the NISC and the broader NISC framework. Mr. Gosar. Gotcha. Dr. Beck, I mean, you have seen this from the ground level. How would you orchestrate something in a comprehensive management plan that addresses the Great Lakes from the Virgin Islands, to Arizona, to the Great Lakes so that we have all these multiple applications going on? I mean, you are with CSU, right? Mr. Beck. Yes, sir. Mr. Gosar. I have got ASU, U of A, NAU. I mean, they are a pretty good resource out there. But how would you manage a plan like that from your level that would address a lot of these things and synchronize them that may not be so bureaucratically top down driven? Mr. Beck. Well, first, I think is to involve people at the local level. What do they want to do? What is their land use vision, and then adapt from there. And then geographically you have to start up to the high elevation, high waters, and then move downstream from there rather than trying to move up. I have seen it go both ways, and it never works when you try to run upstream. But at any rate, visiting and getting input from the local community is absolutely essential. That is the starting place. Mr. Gosar. I know we have been chasing the mussels upstream up to Colorado, so we know your plight there, absolutely. Mr. Beck. Yes, sir. Mr. Gosar. One last question. Dr. Steinman, would you have any other comments in regards to that process? Mr. Steinman. Well, I think the coordination is essential. Without that, things are going to break down. As I mentioned in the oral testimony, written testimony, these invasive species cross jurisdictional boundaries. Any time you have these connected systems, the weakest link provides the problem there. So it is essential that people work together and have a coordinated effort and based on science is really going to be a critical element to make things successful. Mr. Gosar. When you empower local people, you find people more adaptive to be protecting, right? Mr. Steinman. Absolutely, and I agree with Dr. Beck in the sense that if you do not what their social values are at that local land value, you know, you are just not going to make a difference. Mr. Gosar. Thank you. Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentleman from Arizona, and recognizes the gentlelady from Michigan. Ms. Lawrence. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Cameron, I just want to ask a follow-up question. How do you feel the NISC, from your organization, how effective is it? You gave some recommendations. Does the plan drive the results? I would like to hear your opinion. Mr. Cameron. Thank you. Thank you, Congressman. A couple of thoughts. The first is a plan is ultimately just a piece of paper. What you really need is commitment at least at the assistant secretary level. More than a commitment, active participation. You need assistant secretaries willing to spend 15 percent of their time worried about invasive species. Frankly, I do not think we have had that for quite a while. You need that leadership in order to drive coordination inside Washington in order to provide air cover, if you will, for the people at the regional level, at the State level who are trying to do the right thing. So a good plan is helpful, it is necessary, but it is by no means sufficient. What I think is really important, echoing some things we have heard before, is taking a lot of hints from the governors. Your own governor is really invested in the invasive species issues even with Michigan's economic problems. He has budget increases in the State budget for invasives. Governor Hickenlooper has been all over the cheatgrass issue from the very beginning in Colorado. So the Federal government needs to pay attention to where the governors are coming from. The Federal government can provide a forum for cooperation among the governors. The Great Lakes Restoration Initiative in your part of the country, Ms. Lawrence, is one example of a fairly successful model. Maybe WGA could do the same on cheatgrass, for instance. Ms. Lawrence. Well, Dr. Steinman, I introduced H.R. 1900, the National Sea Grant College Program. And we know it is administered within the National Oceanic Administration, NOAA. Do you believe that Congress should reauthorize it and fund new university research, because one of the things that I am hearing, and who made the quote about good science versus good policy. So would you please comment on that? Mr. Steinman. Thank you, Representative Lawrence. I am a strong supporter of the National Sea Grant Program administered under NOAA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. It is really where the science, education, and outreach all come together on a local basis. And even though National Sea Grant seems to have a marine name to it, it applies to the gentlelady as well. And so, whether it is fresh water, salt water, or estuarian systems, Sea Grant is really there at the local level making a difference educating people and providing the science to help inform those management decisions that need to be made. Ms. Lawrence. You know, one of the things that I really want to drive this point home is that we think about just fish in the water. But there is an additional effect of the zebra mussel, an increase of blue water algae, which resulted in the loss of drinking water to 400,000 Ohio citizens. Can you explain how this invasive species has an impact on our drinking water? Mr. Steinman. Yes, thank you for the question. So the zebra and quagga mussels, as I said, are filter feeders, so they are filtering out the organisms that are in the water. And by doing that, they are clearing the water, and as they clear the water, there is more opportunity for the blue-green algae or cyanobacteria to start to form in that system. Now, it also needs nutrients as well as the light that is getting through the water. The nutrients particularly in the Western Basin of Lake Erie were coming off of farm fields. You had that combination of fertilizer application, a big rainstorm that moved it all into the lake. And then you had enough light for the blue-greens to grow the cyanobacteria, and because they release a toxin, in this case microcystins, which is toxic to humans, potentially toxic. That is what Toledo Water Supply just decided to shut down. Now, we have had algae blooms that are actually larger than the one last year that shut down the water supply, but it turned out that they did not grow near where the water intakes were. So really it makes a difference where those blooms are forming, but that combination does create something. And I want to point out for Ms. Plaskett as well that clearing of the water by the quagga and zebra mussels also results in a proliferation of what we call these green algae, filamentous green algae called cladophora, very similar to your Sargassum that is washing up on the beaches of the Great Lakes and creating what we call muck. And nobody wants to go where that muck is. Just like in the Virgin Islands, we are seeing the same thing in the Great Lakes. Ms. Lawrence. I know I only have a few seconds, but, Dr. Reaser, this is where I want to connect your job with these immediate. So when we have an invasive species affecting drinking water, how does these issues rise to the level of you responding or being able to respond to this? And when you have a situation of Virgin Islands, and everyone sitting here are likely to know what is happening, how do we as a member of Congress know that you are actually responding in attacking this, not just a report. But what is your action? And I am sorry, sir, I know I am over, but this is important. Ms. Reaser. It is important, and thank you for the question. To clarify again, NISC itself is the Secretaries and administrators of the 13 member departments. And in many cases, issues such as this do not necessarily have to rise to that level to get action. There are hopefully mechanisms in place in most States now and in some territories where there are State- level national invasive species councils. There are also plant councils and aquatic councils, and they can work to bring local levels to State-level attention. State-level attention can then be brought to Federal partners and so forth. And hopefully at the appropriate level, we are getting response, whether that is a technical-level response, an authority-level response, or some other mechanism that needs to be put in place to assist. So ultimately the response comes through partnerships and communications on up. Ms. Lawrence. Thank you. Thank you for your indulgence, Mr. Chair. Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentlelady from Michigan, and recognizes the gentleman from Texas. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I appreciate our panelists being here today. Dr. Reaser, in your opening remarks, I appreciate how you brought a context to this issue in how it is a national security issue. That is something, you know, I know a little something about. I spent 9 years as an undercover officer in the CIA chasing al Qaeda and the Taliban, you know, Iranian and IRGC Quds force. And it is great being able to use those talents and experience, you know, going after invasive weeds and worms. It is an important issue to the State of Texas. In Texas we are dealing with the branched broomrape. We are dealing with the Old World boll worm. We are dealing with cheatgrass as well. And, you know, we have talked here today, and I guess my first question is more a philosophical question. We have talked here today about how invasive species pose one of the greatest threats to the agriculture industries in the world, yet are the least funded and recognized. How can we change this mentality to become more proactive in protecting our industries? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. I think it is a really good one, and something that deserves a lot more time than what we have available to us. I think one of the challenges that has existed within this issue I the agricultural context is the long history of using the word ``pest'' and ``weeds,'' which do not galvanize the public's emotive response to this issue. A lot of people equate ``weeds'' to dandelions, which are in their background and they do not feel are particularly threatening. The invasive species issue itself, because of examples that have been emerging from around the world, is getting more of the public's perspective on the real risks associated with these non-native organisms, impacting them personally. And I think as we raise the profile of this issue, as we communicate case studies effectively, as we draw the relationships between these individual species and people's personal lives, whether that be in the agricultural context or otherwise, we will see additional calls for support in all sorts of ways--financial, technical, and otherwise. The human dimensions of this issue are of particular interest to me, and I would love to have a side conversation with you at another date if that is of interest to you. Mr. Hurd. It is of interest, and I appreciate that. And also in some of the specifics not only in how do we educate, you know, folks about how critical of an issue this is, the Old World boll worm poses a significant threat to corn, cotton, and other important crops throughout the U.S. And given that it reached Brazil and Puerto Rico, and that in June of this year one worm was found in Florida, is there a Federal protocol in place for an effective response to eliminate any isolated infestations before the pest spreads and becomes established in the U.S.? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. I am not an expert on that species in particular. I know that USDA has been working on eradicating the Texas boll weevil, if, in fact, we are talking about the same species, and that that work has been mostly successful. I would like to follow up with you more specifically at a later date when I can get the specifics in front of me. Mr. Hurd. Great. I appreciate that and would welcome that. And my last question, there has been some conversations already on cheatgrass. The latest research suggests that targeting grazing and optimum times, either before the seed polyps develop or after they drop, produces recurrence on rangelands more than anything else we have tried. An given the tremendous wildfire issues and detrimental effects of sage grouse habitat associated with cheatgrass, should not research like this be a priority, and what are agencies doing to coordinate their efforts to streamline unnecessary environmental reviews for pilot projects and trials? Ms. Reaser. So, two different answers. Thank you for the questions. In terms of the grazing question in particular, there are nuances to the grazing that need to be looked at from a research perspective. There are a number of criteria that go into determining whether grazing is an effective technique in terms of managing cheatgrass. Those relate to the history of the land use, in particular, the condition of the land. The micro climate that you are looking at, whether you are talking about grazing with cattle versus sheep, the density of the animals, even the breed of the animals, can make a difference in terms of grazing habits. So there is various work going on to look at best possible strategies for managing cheatgrass, and they may vary across and likely will vary across the landscape. To get to the second part of your question, which I am going to ask you to repeat. Mr. Hurd. Sure. It is, you know, what are agencies doing to coordinate efforts to streamline unnecessary environmental reviews for pilot projects and initial trials? Ms. Reaser. Great. Apologies. Thank you for that. One of the priorities that emerged out of the Western Invasive Weed Summit that I attended two weeks ago was streamlining the NEPA process. This has been a priority for us for a number of years at this point in time, and we are going to continue to move ahead on looking at what we could do to provide better NEPA guidance and streamlining in the invasive species context into the New Year. Mr. Hurd. Mr. Chairman, I yield back the time I do not have. [Laughter.] Mr. Buck. The chairman thanks the gentleman from Texas, and recognizes the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. Thank you so much. I just wanted to go back to something that we were talking about, and that the ranking member, Ms. Lawrence, brought up. When you talked about this is layering, and the responses that come from the local level, to the State level, to the Federal level. You also talked about the management plan, and I know it is the specific task and the mandate of this group to really set those kind of guidelines and those prioritizations out. Can you give me an example of how this has worked in some of these invasive species? In your written testimony you talked about the Asian carp. You talked about cheatgrass. You know, we have given the example about the lionfish. How has this worked to address some of these issues on some of these specific invasive species issues? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. You are particularly interested in the coordination mechanisms and the ---- Ms. Plaskett. Well, I am just trying to find out some specificity because I just hear a lot of very general discussion about how the process works, and that the management plans are there to make this happen. But I have not heard-- maybe it was done--what specific examples you have of where this has worked and where the organization, when this group has actually made it effective against some of these invasive species. Ms. Reaser. Okay. So I want to clarify once again that the National Invasive Species Council is itself the Secretary's and administrators of the 13-member Federal Department. So when we start moving onto discussions about impacts on the ground, we are looking at the engagement at the Agency level and Agency personnel. Ms. Plaskett. Right, but you set those. You set those priorities in that national plan and the management of how that is going to be done, is that not right, in your coordination of all of these agencies. Ms. Reaser. The management plan sets out a series of actions to be taken over the life of the management plan. Ms. Plaskett. And the management plan is how, in fact, these agencies are going to attack these invasive species issues, right? Ms. Reaser. The management plan sets out goals and objectives for achieving certain things. It is not prescriptive in telling the agencies how specifically to move forward on that particular action. Ms. Plaskett. But it sets out guidelines for these agencies on how this is supposed to be done? That is a yes or a no. Does it? Ms. Reaser. It sets out priority actions. It does not explicitly set out guidelines. Ms. Plaskett. So in setting the priorities for them, can you give me an example of how those priorities have not been set since this group has been made, how it has been effective in the invasive species fight? Ms. Reaser. Okay. So I can give you a specific example for what is happening on the ground right now within the work that is being done on cheatgrass. Under a second ---- Ms. Plaskett. Is that the only way you are able to tell me what it is working on? You are not able to tell me what has been done and what has been effective in the past as yet? Ms. Reaser. I can go through a number of action items in the plan. There are 170 various action items, and I can go through with you at a later date ---- Ms. Plaskett. Are there too many action items? Ms. Reaser. Pardon? Ms. Plaskett. Are there too many action items maybe? If I give my kids too many chores, they will never get any of them completed. Ms. Reaser. I understand your concern with the number of activities and the action items, and I can assure you in the next management plan ---- Ms. Plaskett. I am not concerned. You just cited so many of them as a reason you are not able to tell me which ones they have completed. Ms. Reaser. Well, I can pull out the two management plans at the moment, and I could go through them with you. We do not have time obviously to do that right now. It is something we could sit down and do together. Ms. Plaskett. I just asked for one example. Ms. Reaser. So one example in the management plan was to provide resources to develop an international infrastructure for sharing information on invasive species. A number of activities actually have taken place to result in that. The Global Invasive Species Information Network was created that is housed by the U.S. Geological Survey. We have also contributed resources to setting up a global database. You could call it a global encyclopedia through an organization known as CAVI. That provides information that can be used in the agricultural sector, in the environmental sector, and otherwise to inform decision making, such as risk analyses and risk assessments on the invasive species issue. Ms. Plaskett. And any of these, have you been able to show where the action items, the action that has been taken, has actually scaled back the invasive species, or what the impact that those have had on the particular areas that they have affected? Ms. Reaser. At this point in time, without actually going to the agencies and asking for that particular data ---- Ms. Plaskett. Can you ask? That is the ultimate goal of the group. Would that not be something that you would know immediately to be able to say that what you have been working on all these years, this is the outcome and this is how we have been able to beat back this national crisis, this national security issue? Ms. Reaser. I understand your concern, and if the management plan action items were specifically targeted towards an on the ground response, that would be feasible, and I can collect that information. Many of the items in the management plan are actually focused on enhancing coordination, cooperation, efficiencies, and resource spending, partnerships with States and tribal governments. Ms. Plaskett. And is not all of that the ultimate goal to eradicate the invasive species? Ms. Reaser. They are all creating the enabling environment to allow that to happen. Ms. Plaskett. Dr. Reaser, that is just yes or no. Is not that the ultimate goal of the organization is to do that? Ms. Reaser. The ultimate goal of ---- Ms. Plaskett. Yes? No? Ms. Reaser.--the National Invasive Species Council is to facilitate coordination and cooperation of specific duties that are outlined in the executive order. Ms. Plaskett. To what end? Ms. Reaser. Ultimately to the end of preventing, and controlling ---- Ms. Plaskett. So the answer would be ---- Ms. Reaser.--and eradicating invasive species. However, the activities are often many steps removed from what is happening on the ground. So the ability to say we have created an invasive species database is creating an enabling environment to enable people on the ground, whether that is cheatgrass, or zebra mussels, or weevils in Texas, to make a difference. However, being able to say that the data in that database directly resulted in 300 infestations being intercepted in the field is understandably quite difficult. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands, and recognizes the gentleman from Alabama. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I would like to thank the witnesses for being here and for their testimony. I have got a question about how some of these invasive species enter the country, and I just want to ask, Dr. Reaser, I know that the Department of Agriculture and Department of Interior are involved. But is there an ongoing discussion about, for instance, sportsmen have brought in certain plants that they think are good for wildlife that have turned out not so well. This has been the case in Alabama. And I think as we talk about how to deal with the invasive species who are already here, we need to be talking about how we can prevent some of them from being brought into the country. Can you tell me what kind of activity takes place, what kind of discussions, what kind of strategic planning is going on to prevent that? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question. We generally discuss these in the context of pathway interdiction and prevention at the border. And I am sure you are well aware, there are numerous controls in place at our ports of entry both on the agricultural side and on the wildlife and human health side to intercept organisms before they come into the States. There also are mechanisms in place to interdict various pathways by which organisms may be introduced, whether that is through horticulture or other means. One of the ways in which we are adding value at this point in time is to increase our capacities for risk analysis, our ability to look at species before they come to the United States, and determining what is the likelihood of those organisms being harmful if they arrive here so that we can proactively make choices about which species to let in and which species to prohibit. Mr. Palmer. When these things are brought in, and there was, I think, it is an Asian version of oak trees that was brought in that a lot of people thought was a great idea for deer and wild turkey, have now decided that it is not. Is there any effort to limit the introduction of something like that so that you have got a 5-, 10-year period to determine if it is problematic? What is the process? Ms. Reaser. So ideally, risk analyses are informed by the best available science that you have. They also take other values and economic concerns into consideration. So if that or any organism became an issue of concern for importation into the United States, a risk analysis could take place, and it could determine based on the output of that risk analysis whether there were reasons to prohibit that organism, whatever it happened to be, and authorities in place to then follow up with the prohibition. Mr. Palmer. In the South, we have had to deal with an invasive species called kudzu. But we have also been dealing with an invasive weed called Cogan grass, and I think it came into the country as packing material. And, again, it gets back to the collaboration between the various Federal agencies and departments of government to make sure that if we bring something in, that it does not have the capacity, first of all, to reproduce, which I think that surprised a number of people when that happen. But in that regard, Dr. Beck, you are the weed specialist. What impact does the NEPA process have on the efforts to control the spread of invasive weeds like cheatgrass, and is it helping or hurting these efforts, or other things like cogon grass, for instance? Mr. Beck. My apologies. I did not hear the one word. My hearing is horrible. NEPA you said? Mr. Palmer. Right, NEPA. N-E-P-A. Mr. Beck. My experience personally with NEPA is with working with others that have had to do battle with them, and I guess that is the term that they would prefer to use. It can be an onerous process. It is by design meant to be thorough, but one does not have to take 10 years to make a decision. I think the process is good when it is used as it is supposed to be used, but unfortunately we run into situations where there seems to be a lot of misuse. In other words, the people who are making the assessment simply do not want something coming in, or they do not care, and it go could go either way. NEPA is a problem that needs to be addressed and streamlined. Mr. Palmer. My time has expired. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentleman from Alabama, and recognizes the gentlelady from Michigan. Ms. Lawrence. I want to thank you all for being here. For my last set of questions, Mr. Cameron, I agree with your suggestion that Congress should direct the Council to furnish us with a short annual work plan to help focus attention on the Council's work. Ms. Reaser, do you have any objection to that suggestion? Ms. Reaser. Thank you for the question, and I appreciate the suggestion that Scott Cameron has brought forward. My request would be that any reporting be tied into the National Invasive Species Management Plan process so that the reporting on that can happen concurrently with any requests so that we are making sure that we are being efficient in our reporting processes. The current reporting for the National Invasive Species Management Plan is set at the executive order for 18 months after each management plan. And as we move forward, we intend to report out on that time frame. Ms. Lawrence. I would strongly recommend that as you are working on the plan, that you look at providing us with updates. I want to ask Dr. Steinman, what can the Federal government do to be helpful in your effort in curbing invasive species in the Great Lakes? What can the Federal government do? I am a little concerned that we have a plan that does not really cause action. It is a plan. So please tell me, what can we do? Mr. Steinman. Well, thank you, Representative Lawrence. It really depends on the vector that we are talking about for introduction because there are so many ways that invasive species can get into the Great Lakes or into any ecosystem. So, again, that coordination is really critical if you are talking about species that are coming in from ballast water introduction. And it is critical that the EPA, the U.S. Coast Guard are all working together, the Canadian government as well as the U.S. government are working to make sure that none of these salties are discharging any of the ballast water organisms that would get in that way. But in many cases, some of these organisms are being introduced just by unintentional means or through the live aquaculture trade, and that is when USDA needs to come into play. So, again, it gets down to coordination. I know this is a common refrain we have been hearing, not just amongst the Federal government, although that is an important resource for us not just in terms of their management strategies, but in terms of resources, monetary resources. But then working with the State and local agencies as well to make sure that that plan once developed is coordinated and can be implemented in a rigorous way. Ms. Lawrence. Thank you so much. I want the panel to know, Dr. Reaser, that I am looking forward to that report and your leadership, but leadership is needed. All the members who have spoken here, we represent different parts of this country, and the issues that we are talking about, and we covered it. It is economic. It is our water quality. It is recreational. It is jobs. It is our economy. All these things are tied to this. And it seems like there has been this kind of whatever attitude, and under your leadership, and it is something that is going to be a priority for me as a member of Congress, is that we continue to put the focus and the energy. This is not a job to come in and just kind of sit on the side because nobody cares what you are doing. You have a tremendous background when you talk about your resume, and so you understand the impact of this. And this hearing to me is important because this is a major impact. You know, I am from the Great Lakes, but you heard Texas. You heard Florida. You heard the Islands. This is something that requires the commitment and the passion, and I am sitting here. I am looking forward to that leadership. I am going to be actively looking for that report. And this issue of coordinating the levels of government is extremely important, and I expect for the plan to lay out that process so that we have a process where at least there is a plan where if I am a governor, this is the layers and this is how we move forward, and there is a process for that. So I want to thank you all for you being here and your expertise. I yield back my time, sir. Mr. Buck. The chair thanks the gentlelady from Michigan. And in closing, I would like to thank our witnesses for taking the time to appear before us today. If there is no further business, without objection, the subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4:06 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]