Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- EXAMINING ENVIRONMENTAL BARRIERS TO INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] EXAMINING ENVIRONMENTAL BARRIERS TO INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT ======================================================================= JOINT HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR, ENERGY, AND ENVIRONMENT AND THE SUBCOMMITTTEE ON INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ MARCH 1, 2017 __________ Serial No. 115-1 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 25-084 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Jason Chaffetz, Utah, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Trey Gowdy, South Carolina Jim Cooper, Tennessee Blake Farenthold, Texas Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Thomas Massie, Kentucky Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Mark Meadows, North Carolina Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Ron DeSantis, Florida Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis A. Ross, Florida Val Butler Demings, Florida Mark Walker, North Carolina Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Rod Blum, Iowa Jamie Raskin, Maryland Jody B. Hice, Georgia Peter Welch, Vermont Steve Russell, Oklahoma Matt Cartwright, Pennsylvania Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Mark DeSaulnier, California Will Hurd, Texas John Sarbanes, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama James Comer, Kentucky Paul Mitchell, Michigan ------ Jonathan Skladany, Majority Staff Director David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Ryan Hambleton, Senior Professional Staff Member Kiley Bidelman, Clerk Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment Blake Farenthold, Texas Chairman Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Vice Chair Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis Ross, Florida Jamie Raskin, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama (Vacancy) James Comer, Kentucky (Vacancy) ------ Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs Gary J. Palmer, Alabama, Chairman Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin, Vice Val Butler Demings, Florida Chair Mark DeSaulnier, California John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee (Vacancy) Trey Gowdy, South Carolina (Vacancy) Virginia Foxx, North Carolina (Vacancy) Thomas Massie, Kentucky Mark Walker, North Carolina C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on March 1, 2017.................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. Richie Beyer, County Engineer, Elmore County, Alabama Oral Statement............................................... 7 Written Statement............................................ 9 Mr. Wayne D'Angelo, Counsel for the Steel Manufacturers Association, Kelley Drye and Warren LLP Oral Statement............................................... 16 Written Statement............................................ 18 Mr. Nicolas Loris, Herbert and Joyce Morgan Research Fellow in Energy and Environmental Policy, Institute for Economic Freedom and Opportunity, The Heritage Foundation Oral Statement............................................... 23 Written Statement............................................ 25 APPENDIX Statement for the record from Kevin Rames, regarding Amalago Bay Resort, submitted by Ms. Plaskett.............................. 58 Statement for the record from Alicia Barnes, Former Commissioner of the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, submitted by Ms. Plaskett............... 62 Questions for the record to Nicolas Loris, submitted by Mr. Farenthold..................................................... 64 EXAMINING ENVIRONMENTAL BARRIERS TO INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT ---------- Wednesday, March 1, 2017 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on The Interior, Energy and Environment Joint with Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittees met, pursuant to call, at 10:01 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Blake Farenthold [chairman of the Subcommittee on Interior, Energy and the Environment] presiding. Present: Representatives Farenthold, Palmer, Ross, Duncan, Comer, Massie, Plaskett, Demings, and DeSaulnier. Mr. Farenthold. Good morning. The Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment and the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs will now come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. The chair notes the presence of our colleagues from the full Oversight and Government Reform Committee, and we appreciate your interest in this topic and welcome your participation today. I'd like to ask unanimous consent that all members of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform be allowed to fully participate in today's hearing. Without objection, so ordered. Well, good morning. Today's Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment, and the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, will examine Federal impediments to infrastructure development. Numerous reports over the last decade have documented how burdensome environmental regulations have delayed, if not completely derailed, important infrastructure projects. Today, we'll explore where these regulations have gone wrong in the hopes that we can pinpoint solutions that benefit American infrastructure and development. Under the Clean Air Act, every 5 years, the Environmental Protection Agency is required to evaluate and, if needed, set national, ambient air quality standards--and that's called NAAQS for those of you who don't speak government vernacular-- to ensure that pollutants are not hurting public health or the environment. Currently, in my home State of Texas, we have got two regions, Dallas and Fort Worth, that are classified as being in nonattainment, which means they don't meet current standards for NAAQS. Because of this, the State Department of Transportation and Metropolitan Planning Organization, located within these two regions, are obliged to comply with transportation conformity requirements. Failure to do so can result in a loss of Federal highway funds for those counties, along with many other issues associated with being in nonattainment. Conformity requirements entail additional analysis to determine how a potential product could impact air quality. These requirements lengthen an already significant planning process by a minimum of 6 months, and have resulted in cost delays costing over $65 million, just in the Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston regions. By forcing State and local governments to spend more money on burdensome red tape, fewer roads are paved, meaning there is fewer construction jobs, and more traffic congestion, which, in fact, results in more emissions. In October of 2015, the EPA revised NAAQS and lowered the standard for ozone, a recognized pollutant, from 75 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion. Under this proposed revision, the San Antonio and El Paso regions will join Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston in nonattainment, costing even more jobs, running up expenses, and hindering much-needed infrastructure projects. In addition to the nonattainment issues, the National Environmental Policy Act, known as NEPA, has become one of the most burdensome regulations facing project development in America. This law was passed with great intentions almost 50 years ago but has been expanded by constant tinkering by Federal agencies. The time for a full environmental review for a highway project has grown from 2 years to over 8 in some cases. State and local agencies have to navigate reams of Federal regulations in an alphabet soup of Federal agencies, all of whom need to sign off on a project under NEPA. If they're able to make their way through the process, they often get the added joy of a lawsuit from an opponent, often an environmental activist group, or a not-in-my-back yard group who wants to stall the development, or stop all development. While I have addressed highway infrastructure projections, rail, airports, pipeline, oil and gas development, and private sector development all face similar burdens. We have to find a way to stop this paralysis by analysis and get America building again while still protecting our environment. So that's my opening statement, and I now recognize our Ranking Member, Ms. Plaskett, for the Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment, for her opening statement. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for calling today's hearing concerning barriers to infrastructure development. And I want to thank our witnesses for being here. More than most places, my district, the U.S. Virgin Islands, understands the importance of striking the balance between environmental regulations and development. The Virgin Islands are home to just under 107,000 people. With the cost of living 33 percent higher than even the District of Columbia's outrageous cost of living, every dollar in the local economy is crucial to the survival of the citizens of these Islands. This is why we cannot afford drawn-out delays in permitting for economic development projects. There are many projects in the Virgin Islands that have been subject to numerous delays through the Federal permitting process. One of those projects has been ongoing for the last 10 years with no final decision from the Federal Government. A draft biological opinion was issued, but it has been 18 months since the last correspondence to address the findings in the opinion. This is completely unacceptable. Tourism is the primary industry for the Islands now. Tourism and travel, including the effects of investment, account for about 30 percent of the Islands' GDP. Nearly 3 million tourists come to the Islands every year. Many of the tourists come to the Virgin Islands to enjoy our beautiful beaches, dive to see the coral, so we understand that protecting our natural resolutions and species is crucial to the Islands' economy, and we also understand that protecting the environment can add time and expense to the completion of a project that will employ our citizens, but we must find an appropriate balance. The U.S. Virgin Islands and other insular territories, while not major emission sources of greenhouse gases, and thus not contributors to global warming, are experiencing exponential adverse impacts of initiatives and regulations to remedy those things. While I am mindful that measures should be taken to ensure sustainable development, in many instances, technocrats within the ranks of Federal agencies approach the Virgin Islands and places like us, development permitting and other enforcement regulations are done blindly, and simply do not take into consideration the socioeconomic implications of those actions. One of the primary problems to moving projects out of the environmental review have been inadequate staffing at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA, the Federal agency that handles projects having an impact on coral. There simply are not enough staff to do the consultations that would allow permitting. Currently, the southeast region of the United States is one of the fastest growing regions in the country. Despite that fact, NOAA only has 14 full-time employees handling endangered species-related consulting. The West Coast has 150 full-time employees doing the same consultation. The Governor of the Virgin Islands wrote the White House back in August about excessive delays to a hotel being built on St. Croix. We have been raising the alarm from the Islands for a while now. We are concerned that under President Trump, the problem may be exacerbated. President Trump has declared a hiring freeze, and so there will be no hiring in permitting agencies that are already understaffed. President Trump has also announced that he will cut budgets in agencies needed for economic development. The hiring freeze and budget cuts to come will hurt infrastructure development in the future. For example, NOAA recently did a listing in 2015 of 19 additional coral species on the endangered species list. This will increase permitting time, and the cost for the Army Corps of Engineer process. I speak for the Virgin Islands regardless of who's in the White House. The President has to understand that a hiring freeze is going to bring development in the Virgin Islands and the whole southeast region of the United States to a screeching halt. I hope today we can discuss some sensible solutions to these issues. Thank you. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. I'll now recognize Mr. Palmer, the chairman of the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, for his opening statement. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to the witnesses for appearing here today. We're going to hear from witnesses who can attest to how the Federal Government is a roadblock to States and local communities in infrastructure projects, and, hopefully, develop some ways that Congress can assist in getting the Federal Government out of the way. And States and localities know the needs of their communities. We want to increase their ability to handle these projects. They should be trusted to use funds to fulfill those needs with the least Federal Government interference. Many of these environmental regulations have become irrelevant, outdated, and abused by groups and organizations simply looking to block economic development rather than protect the environment. As Chairman Farenthold mentioned, examples of environmental regulatory burden are the National Environmental Policy Act, NEPA, and the Endangered Species Act. Policy uncertainty emanating from Washington discourages investment in private infrastructure projects that is a major part of President Trump's efforts to rebuild and improve our national infrastructure, which will help spur economic growth and provide more jobs. Duplicative responsibility between the States and Federal Government for planning of federally funded projects, many projects require State and Federal officials to oversee them when only one is necessary, also helps to drive up the cost. In 1956, the year the Highway Trust Fund was established, total Federal, State, and local expenditures on administration and research accounted to 6.8 percent of construction costs. By 2002, that had risen to 17 percent. And overall, a former head of the Federal Highway Administration, Robert Ferris, suggests that Federal regulations increase costs by 30 percent. I think in some projects in my home State of Alabama, we have seen that those costs were doubled. According to one estimate, complying with Federal rules raises overhead costs to approximately 25 percent of project cost, while the overhead costs represent only about 5 percent of project costs for locally funded roads that do not have to comply with the Federal Rules. Compliance with NEPA regulations is complicated and involves detailed documentation procedures. If planners do not know whether a project will have a significant environmental effect, an environmental assessment must be prepared. If the assessment finds that a project will have a significant effect on the environment, the Federal Highway Administration must create an environmental impact statement to document the expected effects of any reasonable alternative actions. Because they have to meet so many different requirements, many affected by NEPA, major highway construction projects take as long as 10 to 15 years to complete. For example, California's transportation corridor agencies have spent the last 15 years attempting to comply with Federal environmental review process for a toll road under construction. Since NEPA became law, the average time required to complete an environmental impact statement for a Federal infrastructure project has increased from 2 years to more than 8 years. The Obama administration recognized the burdensome nature of the NEPA process when it exempted 179,000, 179,000, stimulus projects from environmental review. The goal, according to Secretary of Energy Steven Chu, was to get the money out and spent as quickly as possible. What I would add is that these regulations, particularly the Endangered Species Act, can serve to halt contract projects that have created extensive delays and added significant cost increases, especially on projects that have already started. We are holding this hearing today as part of an effort by Congress to find ways to continue protecting our environment while simultaneously encouraging infrastructure development and economic growth. I look forward to our hearing this morning and how it can play a role in beginning to streamline the regulatory process and devolve control back to the States. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, sir. I'll now recognize Ms. Demings, the Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, for her opening statement. Mrs. Demings. Mr. Chairman, good morning, and thank you so much for this hearing today. And to our witnesses, thank you so much for being with us. I certainly support new projects aimed at repairing the Nation's crumbling infrastructure, and expanding the infrastructure to meet the needs of the population and the modern commerce. There are significant barriers to achieving that goal. Inadequate Federal funding for infrastructure is a significant barrier. According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, $3.6 trillion in new investment is needed to fix the Nation's network of bridges, roads, waterways, levies, and dams. Inadequate staffing at Federal agencies to process development applications is a significant barrier. President Trump's hiring ban will worsen backlogged development permit applications because vacant positions cannot be filled, and more civil servants are approaching the age of retirement. But environmental protection laws are not a significant barrier. Some opponents of the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, say that NEPA is the primary cause of delays. Not so. In fact, 95 percent of major actions that are reviewable under NEPA are considered to be part of the categorical exclusion, which means that they do not require environmental analysis. Even with the remaining 5 percent of major projects that require additional environmental review, NEPA does not constrain the agency if the agency determines that the benefits of a particular development project outweigh its environmental impacts. I, for one, do not want to return to the days before NEPA. At that time the public had virtually no input into public infrastructure projects, even if it literally ran through their backyard. The only considerations for major projects like the interstate highway system was whether there was an available open space, and whether the acquisition cost was low for that space. It did not matter if this available open space was a historic site or a public park. It did not even matter whether the space was not open in some instances. Often infrastructure was built on the backs of the urban poor and minorities. For example, a segment of Interstate 4 was constructed directly through Parramore, a community on the outskirts of downtown Orlando, Florida, and the growing business district. Prior to I-4 construction, Parramore was a thriving African American community with several successful civic organizations, black-owned businesses, including a tailor shop, a theater, and several professional offices. Dr. William Monroe Wells, a prominent physician, opened a hotel and a South Street casino which hosted now legendary jazz and blues performers. Unfortunately, the interstate highway that helped make Orlando the vacation capital of the United States had disastrous consequences for one of central Florida's most thriving African American communities. Built along the historic Division Street, named for the segregation boundary in postwar Orlando, I-4 displaced 551 homes and severed access to downtown Orlando. For decades, Parramore struggled to remain a strong community. The neighborhood that once boasted more than 10,000 residents dwindled to 5,200 by 1980, while movie theaters, libraries, grocery stores, and community centers closed their doors. Fortunately for Parramore, the neighborhoods like it across the country, Federal, State, and municipal officials understand that communities always do better when those impacted have a seat at the table. We do not want to return to that past where the Federal Government steamrolls a vibrant town into a second thought. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And we'll hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any member who would like to submit a written opening statement. We'll now recognize our panel of witnesses. I'm pleased to welcome Richie Beyer, County Engineer with Elmore County in Alabama; Mr. Wayne D'Angelo is a partner with Kelley, Drye & Warren LLP. He serves as counsel for the Steel Manufacturers Association and is testifying on their behalf today. And finally, Mr. Nicholas Loris. He is the Herbert and Joyce Morgan Research Fellow in Energy and Environmental Policy at the Institute for Economic Freedom and Opportunity at the Heritage Foundation. We had a couple of other witnesses we were trying to get. We actually ran up against a couple that were concerned that their testimony here might interfere with their company's permitting process, which is another issue we might need to address at some point. Anyway, to those of you with the courage to attend, welcome. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify. Would you please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solely swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God? Let the record reflect all witnesses answered in the affirmative. You all may be seated. In order to allow time for discussion, we would appreciate it if you would limit your oral testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statement will be made part of the record, and the members of the panel have copies of it. So, Mr. Beyer, we'll recognize you for 5 minutes. You've got a timer in front of you. The green light will go for 4 minutes. The yellow light will come on when you have 1 minute left, time to start summing up. And the red light means time's up. Mr. Beyer, you are recognized for 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF RICHIE BEYER Mr. Beyer. Chairman Farenthold, Chairman Palmer, Ranking Member Plaskett, and Ranking Member Demings, and distinguished members of the subcommittees, thank you for holding this hearing today. I am honored to testify before you today on behalf of the National Association of Counties and the National Association of County Engineers. My name is Richie Beyer, and I serve as the county engineer for Elmore County, Alabama. Elmore County serves a population of approximately 82,000, and is one of the fastest growing counties in our State. My experience in infrastructure extends not only to Elmore County, but to the national level as well, as I am a past president of the National Association of County Engineers and currently serve as vice chair of the National Association of Counties Transportation Steering Committee. Elmore County is responsible for 1,000 miles of road and 127 bridges. Our funding resources, however, are not sufficient to maintain our infrastructure, as we operate on about one- third of the revenue needed. The situation is not unique to Elmore County, though. My county shares many similarities with counties across the Nation who work every day to stretch the taxpayer dollars they are entrusted to manage to ensure their effective and efficient use. Counties are innovators, and in many cases, do so to survive. The Federal Government can assist this innovation by providing a regulatory environment designed to empower project delivery, not hampering it. My remarks to this committee today will provide recommendations to strengthen this effort. Currently, counties are required to follow the same exhaustive Federal requirements on a small sidewalk or preservation project as they would for mega projects, and this simply doesn't make sense. Let's take a look at a simple resurfacing project in Elmore County where we want to place 1- 1/2 inch wearing surface on a roadway with new traffic stripes and markers. Once the contractor completes the project, this is what the county will have: a project file 20 times thicker than the overlay that was placed; we would have paid on average two times the cost of a similar project funded solely with local funds; we would have spent 9 to 12 months longer to get the project to construction than if it was funded with local funds; and we would have a road that is materially the same regardless of the funding source. Another example, after years of working to secure Federal funds for two areas of need in our rapidly growing county, we have been working to make intersection and corridor improvements at two different locations. The projects will have immense safety benefits to the public, yet small impact to the few residents adjacent to the improvements. As the project start times are separated by one year, we have been in the design and environmental approval phase for the two projects for 15 and 30 months, respectively. Currently, we are on pace to deliver these projects to construction in another 2 years. Construction costs for these two projects are small at $1 million and $3 million, respectively. I would like to provide the committee one last example of the type of issues these Federal impediments can create. On Christmas Day 2015, many Alabama counties, including Elmore County, were impacted by torrential rains. A portion of the county sustained severe damage that caused the closure of several roads. Our largest damage site was on Holley Mill Road in the northeast part of the county. A 50-plus-year-old drainage structure failed under the immense water pressure. The failure created a chasm in the roadway, sending several hundred yards of roadbed downstream. Our county team met with State and Federal officials within weeks of the disaster, and after meeting with them, we were made aware that FEMA was not recognizing a provision in the FAST Act exempting emergency work from environmental reviews. That same day, we contacted Fish and Wildlife and the U.S. Corps ourselves. The county received approvals and clearances from these two Federal agencies the next day. Despite those clearances and approvals though, we were told that our projects would still have to go through a full FEMA review. To avoid loss of reimbursement, we were forced to immediately halt our project, despite the fact that it was vital to restoring services to our citizens. Thirty days later, we were given approval to move forward with our work. So you may be thinking, well, that's fast for approvals compared to some of the other environmental horror stories that we hear, but the real issue is every day we delayed work, our community, our citizens, and our environment were negatively impacted. These examples point to some of the challenges we face in local government, and I offer the following two recommendations for ensuring we can provide our citizens the best possible services given our limited resources: First, we would like to recommend that Congress build on the principles introduced in MAP-21 and furthered in the FAST Act by creating an exemption from all Federal requirements if the project receives less than $5 million in Federal funding. Second, creation of an exemption that removes all Federal requirements from emergency repairs to any transportation facility damaged by a disaster would expedite restoration of services to our citizens, lower the cost of repairs, refocus the Federal resources to be available to support and assist with recovery efforts, all while being accomplished without harm to the environment. In closing, counties stand ready to work with our Federal partners to achieve our shared goals for strengthening transportation networks, improving public safety, and advancing our economic competitiveness. Thank you again, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Members, and members of the subcommittee, for the opportunity to testify today, and I will be pleased to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Beyer follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much, and we'll get to the questions after everybody has given their testimony. Mr. D'Angelo, you're recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF WAYNE D'ANGELO Mr. D'Angelo. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman---- Mr. Farenthold. You need to get that mic really close to your mouth. In our budget consciousness, we got budget mics. And turn it on. Mr. D'Angelo. There it is. Okay. That's better. We're talking with our hands a little bit here, so I apologize if I knock the mic. I am very happy to be here. I'm thankful for the invite. I have the privilege of testifying on behalf of the Steel Manufacturers Association, the leadership of which is sitting behind me today. And they have the privilege of representing steel mills, which account for over 75 percent of domestic steelmaking capacity. SMA members are not just steelmakers, they're recyclers. Through the use of electric arc furnaces, SMA members make steel from a feed stock of over 90 percent recycled scrap, millions of tons of scrap that would otherwise be disposed of in landfills. So they don't make roads or bridges or pipelines, but they will take this Nation's aging infrastructure, aging bridges and rebar, and turn it into the infrastructure of tomorrow, and that's pretty cool. And I can tell you that SMA members, SMA's leadership, and the 60,000 men and women that SMA companies directly employ are immensely proud of that fact, and that's why I'm here today. And I'm here talking about statutes like NEPA and ESA. So U.S. steel mills have a list of regulatory requirements that is far longer than my arm, and I'm not talking about those. I'm talking about NEPA and ESA, two statutes which most environmental managers don't have to worry about because steel mills are stationary sources and they generally don't have to interact with Federal agency action that would implicate those statutes. And if we think about that, that's kind of a big deal because this is an industry that is fighting one heck of a fight against international competition, and fighting against nations that don't have the environmental health and safety controls that we do, and they're not here talking about those controls that they're faced with, but those controls, which American infrastructure and American government action are faced with. And those barriers, we identify as NEPA and the ESA, and the reason they are barriers is because we as a Nation have chosen to erect them as barriers to infrastructure development. NEPA, for instance, started with a very commonsense notion that we should look before we leap. We should consider the implications of our actions before we take those actions, actions like Ms. Demings spoke about. But we have sort of lost sight of the underlying purpose of NEPA, and that's to get to an action. We have heard about all the horror stories, how long it takes to get to a final environmental impact statement. These environmental impact statements take years and years, cost millions of dollars, and are thousands of pages. We have to ask ourselves, are we asking questions that are providing the answers we need? Or is this the information we need for rational, informed decisionmaking? Or are we simply armoring ourselves against litigation? Now, some environmental groups will cheer this analysis paralysis, but real world environmentalists, like Ms. Plaskett talked about, and like my clients understand, that you need infrastructure development to further environmental protection. We have also weighted down our environmental analysis with more and more searching analyses that have really protracted decisionmaking, and there's no better example of this than the ESA. Again, considering the potential impacts on threatened and endangered species is a really good idea, and the ESA was a great idea for Congress. Now, that made a lot of sense when we were dealing with 70 to 80 of the most threatened and iconic species in America. It makes a lot less sense when we're dealing with 2,400 species and a list that grows every single year. How did we get there? It's not because thousands more species have been pushed to the brink of extinction in the past 40 years. It's because a couple of litigious groups have learned to game the statute, exploit inflexible deadlines, co- opt the services listing agenda, and rob the listing services of the ability to prioritize species and conservation. The listing services, I have some sympathy for them, but they've also overreached themselves. They've passed rules just this past year with respect to how they designate critical habitat. Right? Critical habitat, again, that's an important concept that we should consider it, but when we are now designating critical habitat where the species has never been, and if you put it there, could not now survive, we have ceased to ask questions that are relevant to this analysis. Same thing with environmental analyses. The ESA requires critical habitat be accompanied by an environmental analysis, and yet through rule, Fish and Wildlife Service determined that they can up sign all of the costs away from critical habitat analyses through a bookkeeping trick, and they're free to ignore all types of critical--all economic costs in making their decisions. They are doing precisely what Congress admonished against, and that is, designating critical habitat as far as the eye can see, and the mind can conceive. Now I recognize here I'm out of time. I just want to make one further point. None of this helps conservation. This hurts conservation. SMA is proud of their role in furthering environmental standards, and I'm glad to answer any questions. I appreciate the opportunity to be here today. [Prepared statement of Mr. D'Angelo follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, Mr. D'Angelo. Mr. Loris, you're recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF NICK LORIS Mr. Loris. Well, thank you and good morning. I want to thank the distinguished members of the two subcommittees for this opportunity to examine environmental barriers to infrastructure development. My name is Nick Loris, and I am the Herbert and Joyce Morgan fellow at the Heritage Foundation. The views in this testimony I express are my own and should not be construed as representing any official position of the Heritage Foundation. America has a clean, healthy environment, as well as safe, high-quality infrastructure. However, we can improve upon both. Infrastructure investment and protecting the environment are certainly not mutually exclusive. Environmental policies that respect the rule of law, protect private property rights, and transition power to the States will drive economic growth and responsible stewardship. On the contrary, perpetuating the status quo, or increasing the Federal Government's regulatory overreach hinders infrastructure investment, creates perverse incentives, and centralizes power in Washington, all for little to no meaningful direct environmental benefit. Our country's major environmental policies and regulations are long outdated and in dire need of reform. My written testimony identifies several environmental roadblocks, and I will briefly discuss four of them. As discussed, one major roadblock is NEPA, a statute that has evolved to serve as a tool to significantly delay and obstruct investment in job creation. As we have heard, the average time to complete an environmental impact statement for highway projects increased from 2.2 years in the 1970s to 8.1 years in 2011. Currently 148 energy and transit projects are in NEPA review with nearly $230 billion in stalled investment. Some of the major problems with NEPA include differing interpretations of NEPA requirements, failed interagency coordination or a lead agency, a lack of hard deadlines, administrative bottlenecks, and the inclusion of assessing manmade climate change's impacts on these projects. Reforming NEPA will not compromise public health or safety but instead remove duplication and establish a more streamlined efficient process. In fact, the Obama administration recognized this when effectively waiving NEPA requirements for projects funded by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. Another issue is the social cost of carbon, which allows regulators to artificially inflate the environmental cost of a project. The Federal Government relies on three statistical models to calculate the alleged monetary cost of manmade climate change to society, which is defined as the economic damage that one ton of carbon dioxide emitted today will cause over the next 300 years. Not only is this calculation wasteful in terms of time and resources, these models the government uses to calculate the SCC are useless for cost benefit analysis and for regulatory rulemaking. Subjecting the models to reasonable alternative inputs, such as changes to the discount rates and equilibrium climate sensitivity, which estimates the warming impact of a doubling of CO2 emissions shows just how different the results can be. For example, in one of these models, using a 7 percent discount rate instead of 3, combined with an updated equilibrium climate sensitivity, decreases the social cost of carbon by $34 per ton, a 102 percent decrease. Furthermore, attempts to forecast economic damages centuries into the future significantly strains the credibility of these models, but the use of SCC has significant real-world policy implications, including for infrastructure development. Yet another problem is the EPA's 2015 regulation for ground level ozone, where the new standard is so stringent it approaches background levels in several areas and will force many new areas into nonattainment. These standards would have a direct adverse impact on the construction of all types of economic activity, including roads and other infrastructure, all for diminishing marginal environmental benefits. Perhaps most oppressive are the requirements for nonattaining regions to offset emission increases with cuts in emissions elsewhere, which means potentially redirecting funds or canceling infrastructure projects. The reality is that national average ozone levels have fallen 32 percent since 1980 and are on track to continue to decrease. The Federal Government should not continue to move the goalposts as States continue to meet the attainments of the 1997 and 2008 standards. Withdrawing the 2015 standard would unlock economic activity at the State and local level, and prevent the threat of sanctioned Federal highway funds or other penalties. Lastly, policymakers should examine and reform environmental roadblocks to privately funded energy infrastructure investments, not just examine traditional infrastructure projects. Federal ownership of land and resources, time-consuming leases, permitting and environmental review stages needlessly slow energy infrastructure development. A few years ago, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce compiled a list of 351 energy projects stalled by environmental barriers. The authors estimate that the investment phase of these projects would generate $577 billion in direct investment over a 7-year construction period. And importantly, regulatory reform will benefit all energy sources and technologies as nearly 40 percent of these projects were renewable energy infrastructure. In conclusion, antidevelopment regulations serve more as tools to protect the desires of special interests than protect the environment. Reforming environmental regulations with a focus on transitioning authority to the States, creating market incentives, and removing costly, ineffective regulations entirely will safeguard the environment at a lower cost and stimulate infrastructure development of all types. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Loris follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much, Mr. Loris. I'll now recognize myself for the first round of questioning for 5 minutes. Mr. Beyer, you're an engineer, and in your testimony, you told the testimony of actually having to do a full review of just doing a topcoat on an existing road. As an engineer, by topcoating that road, you're not taking any more land. You're not endangering any more species. I assume the runoff is going to be constant whether you've got an inch or two, the road is an inch or two higher or an inch or two lower. Is there any environmental impact at all? I assume there's got to be some. Can you tell me what that sort of change makes? Mr. Beyer. Chairman Farenthold, that's a very good question, and I believe it was Ranking Member Demings that mentioned categorical exclusions in her discussion. And there are categorical exclusions for those activities. But even with the categorical exclusions, the other oversight that is involved to get to the point where you are categorically excluded makes that process much more lengthy, and that's when I'm referring to the 9 months to 12 months to get that project out there. In terms of the environmental impacts, we're preserving the road that is there, the impacts that we are mitigating by preserving that road, sealing that road up, allows for smoother traffic. It allows for shorter trips. It takes away from the citizens having damaged vehicles, things of that nature, all things that actually would create more environmental problems if it wasn't done. That's just one example. I'm just trying to show you that a simple project like that gets bogged down and then how that translates to the larger ones. Mr. Farenthold. All right. And you also spoke about some infrastructure that was damaged as a result of a natural disaster. I assume that the procedures and techniques for building a road or a bridge in 2017 are substantially different than in the 1950s when maybe some of this infrastructure was originally developed. Does replacing infrastructure from the '40s or '50s with infrastructure designed to today's technical standard using today's technical process actually make them more or less environmentally friendly? Mr. Beyer. First of all, I will admit that I wasn't around in the '50s when those were being built, so from what I've seen in my experience, yes, sir, they are much different in the construction processes. One of those examples about the emergency repairs, though, we're sitting there waiting for approvals with a roadway that is wide open that has 20 foot embankments going down into a live stream that is carrying silt and sediment downstream, and we can't get in there to work because we don't get a clearance. So we're actually doing more damage to the environment by waiting than we are by going in there and doing our actions. The other thing is we have got several hundred yards of material that we're laying downstream in the channel that we're sitting there looking at with the Federal officials, and they're all worried about whether or not, with all due respect, whether I'm going to hurt a yellow-bellied salamander or something like that, and you've got the whole roadway sitting down there in the channel. If they were there, they're down there with the debris. So realistically, that doesn't make much sense to us when we're trying to get services back to our citizens, sir. Mr. Farenthold. All right. Super. Mr. Loris, you work at the think tank, and you study this a lot. There's some concern that all these delays would go away if we would just hire more people to do the reviews and create a bigger Federal bureaucracy to deal with that. Do you think that's the case? Mr. Loris. No, I don't think so. In a lot of respects, we have tried to do that, and we have seen increasing bottlenecks, lack of coordination. I think it fails to address the real roots of the problem, which is so much meddling through Federal Government and through this alphabet soup of agencies that there is a lack of coordination. So I think we need to, in fact, go the opposite approach and not hire more Federal workers, but devolve a lot of these responsibilities down to the State who are more responsive to these things. Mr. Farenthold. So as part of the NEPA review process, there are a wide variety of Federal agencies that review this. Part of the changes that the Transportation Committee made in the recent transportation bills is to try to streamline that and get some of these reviews going concurrently. Is that working, or are we seeing situations where all the agencies but one don't like it, and then you've got to go back to square one? How is that working---- Mr. Loris. I think, at most, it's a Band-Aid for a bullet hole. It really fails to address, again, these problems that so many agencies can still effectively stall, and without real, hard deadlines, if you have one agency that's capitulating to the needs of a special interest group, or someone who opposes the project, it can still delay the project. So I know they tried to make reforms in the FAST Act to streamline the NEPA process, but it really doesn't address those fundamental needs that would go a long way towards reducing those timelines. Mr. Farenthold. All right. Well, I see my time has expired. I'll now recognize the Ranking Member, Ms. Plaskett, for 5 minutes of questions. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses again for being here. This is, to me, a really important topic. I'm very concerned about impediments to communities being able to grow, being able to sustain themselves, and recognizing that there has to be a balance. Everyone here on this panel agrees on the importance of infrastructure. Mr. Beyer, you probably stated it best in your testimony when you said finding the balance between regulations and reality is key. I agree with that wholeheartedly. The economy of the Virgin Islands is heavily reliant on protecting its natural resources. For an example, we had, some years ago, the EPA, their Petroleum Refinery Initiative mandated that all U.S. refineries install best available control technologies, BACT--you know, I'm not a scientist, but this is what they tell me--to reduce greenhouse gasses emission by 20 percent. In the U.S. Virgin Islands, this developed a consent decree between the EPA and our then-oil refinery at the time, Hovensa, that required the refinery to install a $700 million emissions control equipment. Shortly after signing that consent decree, Hovensa announced its closure in the Virgin Islands. We had the second largest oil refinery in the Western Hemisphere. After they left, we, on the island of St. Croix, our unemployment skyrocketed to 18 percent. So these are things that are very dear to our hearts, we're very concerned about. Mr. D'Angelo, you also seem to recognize there is a need for a balance, and you testified that the Steel Manufacturers Association does not believe we should abandon the deliberative process required by NEPA and ESA. Is that correct? Mr. D'Angelo. Yes, that's correct. Ms. Plaskett. And as someone who's familiar with the process, what value does the SMA believe the deliberative process should be adding? Mr. D'Angelo. Well, I think as Congress intended in developing NEPA and the ESA, we want to look before we leap. We want to consider our actions, and we want to be able to involve stakeholders. But I question what stakeholder is going to be involved 8 years down the line and read thousands and thousands of pages of EIS, and how are stakeholders helped simply where these processes become used as barriers to development, and they're used as paperwork exercises as opposed to ways to make reasonable, wise, informed decisions that avoid impact, but also, let important projects go forward. That's the balance. It has less to do with NEPA or ESA. Right? Those were great ideas. Those were important ideas, and they were necessary, and they're necessary today. The problem is that we got a little bit far away from our purpose. There was a couple groups that figured out that these are really, really powerful tools, and if you don't like infrastructure and if you don't want development, then you can invoke processes that will mire down any prospect of growth. Ms. Plaskett. So right now, and I'm not undervaluing that, I believe that there are those in the agencies that that is their mandate. One of the other things I'm concerned with in some of these agencies, however, is the understaffing, and we in the Virgin Islands and many people on the East Coast have really experienced that, that they can't move fast enough between the projects. I talked in my opening testimony about the differences between the West Coast and the East Coast in terms of the personnel that's assigned. Mr. Beyer, you being part of that southeast region in Alabama, do you believe that there are inadequate staffing levels in the southeast region which add to the delay in the development process? Mr. Beyer. I think that the focus is off target, and that if their focus was on the larger projects and getting those through the process instead of some of the more simple, realistic projects that are the bread and butter of State and local government, I think that would address a good bit of your problem. When they're spending time on the simple examples I gave you instead of focusing on the larger capacity projects that are impacting communities and things of that nature, I think their efforts could be better used there. Ms. Plaskett. So even with the shift in those, you think that would solve the problem entirely, that there wouldn't still be a problem of staffing issues? Mr. Beyer. I think it would go a long way to solving that problem, yes, ma'am. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. I know that in the Virgin Islands, we believe that, yes, there is maybe too many hands that are involved; the process takes too long. But we have had instances as well where I think a large part of the issue for us has been that they have not been able to deploy people appropriately to the issues, to the projects that we would like to have, and I think that that's the thing that we are concerned with, is striking that balance between having the process move along smoothly, but ensuring that we have the right individuals to take that place. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. I'll now recognize the chairman of the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, Mr. Palmer, for 5 minutes. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Beyer, you had direct experience in seeing the interaction between Federal and local levels of government in that emergency situation with the Christmas flood back in 2015. Can you expand on how further control can be delegated to the States in the local level in both emergency and nonemergency infrastructure development, how that would impact your ability to respond? Mr. Beyer. Yes, Congressman. Number one, there's a duplication of efforts from the Federal and the State levels, and that is the most noticeable change that could be made, is to shift those responsibilities down. But even further than that, there is a lot of this work that occurs in the existing right of ways and existing roadways that we have that as, especially in Alabama where we have 67 county engineers, professional engineers, you know, we're charged with that as a responsibility when we get our professional license. We are charged to look after the environment, and to make the most expedient and efficient use of the taxpayer dollars to protect the environment and traveling public. But I don't want you all to get it wrong that everybody that we deal with at the Federal or State government are problems. We have a lot of good people that are out there that help us. That example I gave you about the flood, if we didn't have a very good FEMA person on the ground with us that helped us navigate through their red tape, we would have been longer than those 30 days getting those approvals. So I think--that's where I see the balance is, you know, there are certain things that reach a level where the Federal Government should be involved on the oversight of the environmental part. But most of the stuff that we deal with on a day-to-day basis, or in those disasters, are not something that rises to that level. The example I gave you is one of those. An example that does rise to that level, when we got hit in 2011 with tornados in our State, one of the most massive destructive days in our State's history, we had a large amount of debris that was dumped in one of the largest and greatest reservoirs in our State, Lake Martin, and we had to have the Federal help to get that cleaned up. I mean, you had houses and debris all scattered through that lake, and we had to rely on the Corps of Engineers to help us navigate that. That is one of those examples. A 14-foot diameter plate arch pipe going out and leaving a 200-foot hole in the ground that we need to get back open with water services and sewer and other things that were affected, that doesn't really necessarily rise to it, so I guess that kind of goes back to the comments about focusing the resources in the appropriate manners. Mr. Palmer. One of the things that I'm concerned about is the cost imposed in terms of road construction, road repair, and in your testimony, you made the point that you pay, on average, two times of the cost of a similar project funded solely with local funds. It's $160,00 per mile for a Federal project versus $80,000 per mile for local projects. And we're trying to ramp up the infrastructure improvement in the United States. And what I want to ask you is, in what ways can the regulatory and statutory burdens imposed by the Federal Government be reduced so that counties and State projects can go forward? How will that help the infrastructure development? Mr. Beyer. That's a very good question as well, Congressman. I think one of the misnomers in the discussion of a categorical exclusion is that that responsibility for oversight on that project is pushed down to the State level to view the operations of the projects until it's audited. The categorical exclusion process clears you through the environmental process, but now the State is sitting there with all these Federal requirements that they have to ensure are met. And by doing that, they add cost to the project, and in a lot of cases, they don't understand the outdated reasons for the regulations themselves. So you have levels of regulations that add to the cost. You mentioned 25 percent being added to the cost just in administrative. That is a very good number in our State from what we see from our State Department of Transportation. Then you also have the levels of you have the contractors that are bidding these jobs that add costs to them handling the administration of dealing with the regulations as well. On average, when we take local bids for our projects, those numbers I gave you, $80- to $160,000 are very accurate in terms of what we see. Some of it also has to do with the extra things we have to do because it has Federal money tied to it for a project. That overlay project, there's all sorts of things we'll have to do that are ancillary to it that don't allow the money to go as far. Mr. Palmer. In your written testimony last night, you talked about the lack of trust between the Federal Government and the local agencies and implied that the people with the money don't trust the people down the line that they have the capability to handle it. And I think you quoted Ralph Waldo Emerson that said distrust is expensive. Mr. Beyer. Yes, sir. Mr. Palmer. I think that's true. And, Mr. Chairman, I hope as we go through this process, this is not an attack against Federal agencies. I think we have confidence that the agencies can do the job. We also need to transfer that confidence down the line to the State and local government and reduce these regulatory burdens as much as possible while also protecting the environment. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much, Mr. Palmer. I'll now recognize Ms. Demings, the Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, for her first round of questions. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. In my opening statement, I talked about impact on communities, and it's been stated, or suggested, that the Federal Government can be a roadblock to economic development in those communities, so we're trying to find balance to protect but also to move forward. Building America and keeping America moving is important. The steelworkers who are here today help to do that. But I represent communities. You do, too, as well, Mr. Beyer, and so we have to balance the impact to those communities with keeping our country moving forward. Mr. D'Angelo, you talked about stakeholders, look before you leap. When you think about people who have been displaced in various communities, who are the stakeholders that should be at the table because I think we always do better when we include people who are directly impacted in communities in the decisionmaking process? Who are the stakeholders and what do you really mean by ``look before you leap'' today? Mr. D'Angelo. Well, that's a great question. I think the stakeholders are the people that are impacted by these decisions, and those are the people that are local, that will benefit or be hurt by the potential infrastructure projects and others. Those that are going to be stakeholders in building that, that will provide jobs. I think there's a wide range of stakeholders, and I think good decisionmaking requires casting the net far and wide with who we talk to, and the kind of input the Federal Government receives. And so when I'm talking about looking before we leap, we want to have an understanding of the impacts, and we want to understand alternatives, right? Are there ways we can mitigate an adverse impact? Is there some glaring thing that we can identify if we stop, pause, take a breath, and say here's how we see this project going. Is there a better way to do it, right? But then, we're going to weigh it against the benefits of those projects and those stakeholders for the benefits. Communities are not benefited when trucks and cars are forced to idle in inner cities. If we have ways that we can move people more efficiently, if we have ways that we can mitigate how much people pay for energy, these are considerations as well. So that's what I mean by looking forward. It's shocking that NEPA came out in 1969, and that was the first time that we ever had the thought of doing that. I'm glad we do, but I want to rein it in to where it's actually providing information that's useful for the decisionmaking. I'll give you an example. We do, with greenhouse gasses, right, and so, the CEQ came out last year with guidance that says we have to examine life cycle analysis of greenhouse gas emissions with respect to projects under NEPA analysis, and that's all well and good. But there's no project in America that is going to change climate change, right? Climate change is the input of billions and billions of sources all over the world. And so if we are able to assign some number to a particular project, a discrete project, and spend lots and lots of time doing that, what value is that returning for the community, for the stakeholders? I'm glad we look at these things, but I just don't know if that is returning the type of important information in most of these projects. Mrs. Demings. Mr. Loris, in your testimony, you talked about how hiring additional personnel actually caused more bottleneck, which I find a little strange. Could you give me an example of a project where that happened, or some examples of that? Mr. Loris. Well, I think you can just look at the trends and the average timeframe in which these projects failed to get through the NEPA process. Mrs. Demings. So you're seeing that as a direct result of hiring additional staff. I'm trying to understand that. Mr. Loris. I think so. I mean, if you have growing bureaucracies that fail to address the real roots of the problem where you don't have a lead agency, where you're not mandating time limits, if anything, it's certainly not helping address the problem. Maybe you're perpetuating the status quo, but as we have seen even with increases in staff, they've failed to address and reduce the frames to move through the NEPA process. Mrs. Demings. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. We'll now recognize the gentleman from Florida, Mr. Ross, for 5 minutes. Mr. Ross. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. D'Angelo, I want to go straight to you, because you hit on something, and I think my colleague, Ms. Demings also talked about it, when you talk about the stakeholders. But I think what we're seeing here, and I think something very crucial and very important in order to maintain the investment that we want to have an infrastructure in this country is going to be the cost of capital. The stakeholders there that are going to provide the capital necessary in order to make that investment to be able to build our roads and rebuild our bridges and streamline what it is we need to have done. Now the return on investment, and this is why it's important that I think that we get this straight under NEPA, what's the deadline for completing the permitting process under NEPA? Mr. D'Angelo. There are no deadlines. Mr. Ross. There are none. So if I'm an investor, and I want to be able to invest what capital I have to get a return, where am I going to put it? Am I going to put it in infrastructure subsidies--companies? Or am I going to go somewhere where there's a guaranteed return on my investment? So would it not be advantageous just for the simple sake of the cost of the investment necessary for our infrastructure, to have a timeline, a deadline, on the permitting process? Mr. D'Angelo. It absolutely would. I mean, these analyses will grow to fit whatever timeframe is given. If there's no timeframe given, they will grow and grow. Mr. Ross. It will perpetuate adversarial involvement, will it not? Mr. D'Angelo. Correct. Mr. Ross. Which leads me to my next question. It has to do with sue and settle. And, Mr. Loris, I'm going to ask you about this, because you kind of hit on this, lawsuit reform. What's there to prevent somebody from just interjecting in the permitting process for the mere sake of nothing but to want to settle a case? And is that not what we see happening under NEPA? Mr. Loris. That's exactly right. I honestly don't have too much to add to that except for these lawsuits that are supposed to be for ordinary citizens that are overtaken by these environmental activists organizations who negotiate and settle behind closed doors to get to a predetermined outcome without really addressing the needs of the public citizens who, in a lot of respects, would want these projects. Mr. Ross. And in my experience as a litigator, it has been that at times my clients would settle for the cost of defense, regardless of principle. And I think we're seeing that also in NEPA. So how do we address that? Let's talk about standing. What standing does somebody have other than the fact that they have to be a citizen of the United States in order to interject themselves in a lawsuit. Is that it? Mr. Loris. Largely. And then you have folks, again like the Sierra Club who are--you know, that have that standing and the taxpayers will fund part of this litigation. And so it's this never ending cycle where you have--you know, those are the folks who really control the message. Mr. Ross. And under the NEPA process right now there's no loser pays in the attorney's fees arena, is there? Mr. Loris. No. Mr. Ross. So would that not give some sense of rationale before someone files lawsuit, at least to the extent there may be merit to their claim that they should have to bear the cost if they lose their suit? Mr. Loris. Yeah. There's no real stakeholder input where-- you know, you're effectively giving them all the opportunities to get what they want with zero risk. Mr. Ross. In the 112th Congress 6 years ago, I filed what was then called the RAPID Act. It has been refiled by my colleague Tom Marino in the 113th and the 114th Congress. I hope that it is refiled again. But what it does is it allows for a 4.5 year timeline in order to have the permitting process. It allows for 18 months for an environmental assessment. It requires that anybody who objects do so during this process so that they then have standing at the end of the day, and that there's a statute of limitations that allows for them to respond within, in order to have their complaints. My question to you is is this something that would not be embraced, not only by environmentalists. Because let's face it, if they have an issue, they need to be at the table the sooner the better so that issue can be addressed. But is it not also something that I think would be absolutely necessary in order for those that seek to invest in our infrastructure but also those at the county level, at the State level and the Federal level who are in the permitting process? Mr. Loris. Absolutely. The lack of deadlines is a huge problem, and allowing or establishing those would give a yes or no answer one way or the another. And then you would actually have some regulatory certainty. And with so many projects in limbo, are being held up by timeless delays. One way or another, it should benefit both the economic interests of the private producers as well as those environmental activists who think these projects shouldn't move forward. Mr. Ross. And lastly, Mr. Beyer, is there much duplication in the permitting process from one agency, say a State agency to a Federal agency in that they are doing the same thing but requiring different timelines, although they may have same standards? Mr. Beyer. Yes, sir. Mr. Ross. And would not that duplication, at least being resolved, assist in expediting the process? Mr. Beyer. Yes, sir. Mr. Ross. Thank you and I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. We now recognize the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Duncan. Mr. Duncan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And first of all, I want to thank both you and Chairman Palmer for calling this very important hearing. This is my 29th year in the Congress. During all of that time my main committee has been the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and we have tried as hard, as much as we possibly could, or as hard as we could to come up with ways to accomplish environmental streamlining. It has been the most difficult problem that we've worked with. During that time, I've chaired three different subcommittees of that committee and I will never forget that during the 6 years I was chairing the Aviation Subcommittee at one hearing we heard the people from the Atlanta airport testify that the longest run--the then longest runway at the Atlanta airport took 14 years from conception to completion. It took only 99 construction days and they did those in 24 hour days, around the clock construction so they completed the work in 33 days, but it took them 14 years from conception to completion. And it was almost entirely environmental rules, and regulations and red tape. I chaired the Highways and Transit Subcommittee. We had hearings and they told--the Federal highway people said they had two major studies so they took an average. One study said 13 years, one study said 15 years, for a new highway construction project. And these weren't cross country projects, these were six or nine mile projects. And it was all environmental stuff. I chaired the Water Resources Environment Subcommittee and the Maersk SeaLand people came to us at one point and told us of a way--they had done a major project at the Norfolk port. They worked a deal with all the environmental agencies, because they knew it would take so long. They said, let us do your work for you and they did. And they completed this project in 7 years. They said it would have taken probably twice as long if they hadn't been able to negotiate that agreement to do all the work for those agencies to their satisfaction first. The problem was--and I led a congressional delegation in Vietnam a few years ago, it was booming. And I asked them, I said, you know, I asked them about starting a business over there, they said, oh, if you want to start a business over there now, you just go out and start it. The problem is this, we have more competition--we got so far ahead because we had so many socialist and communist countries around the world that they actually followed those systems for many years and they destroyed their economies. Now even some of these former communist countries are allowing a lot of free enterprise, free markets in their countries. And we've got more competition around the world than we ever had before. And in most of those countries, especially the Asian countries, they are doing these infrastructure projects in a third or half the time that we are. We can't keep doing that. We have made some progress in some of our more recent highway bills and so forth. We are doing better than we were a few years ago, but we still have such a long ways to go. And I've noticed through the years that all these environmental radicals seem to come from very wealthy or very upper income families. And I'm not sure they realize how many poor and lower income and working people they have harmed by causing hundreds of thousands, maybe several million jobs to go to other countries and also in driving up the prices and the cost of everything that we have in this country. And so this is a very, very important project--or topic. And we need to do much more to get this under control or this country is not going to have the future that we want it to have. And I appreciate you gentlemen coming here to testify. I appreciate this hearing here today. And I thank you very much. And I yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, sir. And we'll--seeing nobody who has not yet asked questions, we'll start a second round of questions and go back--I guess we'll go to Ms. Plaskett since we have gone a long time on our side. So you're recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. Thank you very much for that. What a gentleman you are, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate that. Listen, I have been listening to a lot of the testimony and I couldn't agree with the vast majority of what has been said. Mr. Ross, my colleague across the aisle, I agree with him on a lot of the delays that are taking place. I have testimony here that I would like unanimous consent to enter into the record. One is from Kevin Rames who is a partner and principal of a law firm in the Virgin Islands on Saint Croix, discussing one particular project, Amalago Bay Resort, Williams and Punch. And then the other is from Miss Alicia Barnes who had been the former commissioner of the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, was the director of energy office and is now the managing owner of the Rittenhouse Consulting, LLC. Mr. Farenthold. Without objection they will be entered into the record. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. And both of those testimonies-- thank you, Mr. Chair--speak to what we've been talking about here, the difficulties and the processes, the length of time that investors who--you know, in the Virgin Islands we are competing not with even other American jurisdictions that have EPA, that have NOAA, that have National Marine Fisheries and Army Corps of Engineers. We are competing with other Caribbean islands who don't have anywhere near the types of restrictions and environmental protections and such that the United States have. And we can't keep up. We can't compete. On the one project Amalago Bay resort is to build a project on the island of Saint Croix because we haven't had a new hotel built on the island of Saint Croix in 30 years. How do you have as your major function tourism if you have not been able to build a hotel and the one project that you have has taken over 10 years just in permitting? That's mind boggling and it's hurtful to the people of the territory. Because while we understand the importance of elkhorn coral and others, it provides for our protein, our fishes and others. I can't eat coral and my children can't eat coral. And the children of the Virgin Islands need employment and need something sustainable. But another issue that I wanted to talk about and wanted to ask you questions about was the notion of the one size fits-- first come, first served basis, one size fits all approach that is being done with some of these agencies. Currently projects for environmental review are prioritized on a first come, first served basis. That means that a small residential dock on Key West will come before a large dredging project that would have brought millions of dollars and hundreds of jobs to the Virgin Islands. Mr. Beyer, have you experienced problems getting key projects prioritized? And do you have any suggestions for how we can assure that crucial projects, that jurisdictions identify, can to the front of the line? Mr. Beyer. We have experienced times where we have had trouble getting responses back and getting an answer back from the different Federal agencies. I can't speak to the fact of did I get behind a smaller project or a bigger project, but we have seen delays in that. And I know that our State DOT specifically has actually put money into funding slots at the different resource agencies to be able to prioritize our project. Ms. Plaskett. So you prioritized them at the State level? Mr. Beyer. No, I think the Federal agency still prioritizes them. What I'm saying is they put in money to pay for a resource agent that will---- Ms. Plaskett. Got you. Mr. Beyer. --actually help expedite their projects as they come in so that still is only paying for a slot. Ms. Plaskett. Right, okay. Mr. Beyer. In a State. Ms. Plaskett. So what that comes down is to the other jurisdictions putting money into the Federal Government too. And that doesn't make any sense. We all know that doesn't make any sense. So, but you know, with the prioritization and they always say that, you know, they are taking them one at a time, they are working on them, they are pushing them through. They at least in our--when I've had phone calls or our governor had phone calls they always come back to the fact that they don't have enough. I'm concerned, and I know some on our panel may not be, that the hiring freeze is going to exacerbate the problem. I understand that a quarter of NOAA's staff are going to be eligible for retirement by 2019. And although we have a culture that needs to be changed as well in some of these agencies, and the fact that environmental groups may come and exert a lot of influence, I can only imagine the backlog that will swell with unsustainable proportions if this were the case. There's room for improvement in the current process. We're hoping that you all can give us some of those answers, streamlining the process, prioritizing review of economic significance. And more importantly, enabling these agencies to serve the public through adequate funding and the staffing. I think that this is an area where a hiring freeze would not be best for the people and formulaic budget cuts is not the way to go in this area. But I want to thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. We'll now go to Mr. Palmer for his second round of questions. Mr. Palmer. Just a few questions, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate you allowing us to have a second round. Mr. Beyer, on average how long does it take to--do you have to wait to ensure that projects are NEPA compliant. Mr. Beyer. A simple project like I was talking about with a resurfacing and all that, you know, you're taking 6 to 9 months to get through that process up to a year. The other examples I gave you, we've been at it 12 to 18 months on those two projects in just the environmental approval process, and those are talking about slivers of right away around intersections that have little to no impact on species, the residents or anything like that to put in needed safety improvements. Mr. Palmer. The courts have put a hold on the Waters of the U.S. rule. And it looks like that's not going to be implemented. But under those rules there would have been major restrictions on--and new regulations on ditch water. How would that have impacted, particularly for rural roads, the cost of building or, maintaining, or repairing those roads? Mr. Beyer. Well, first of all we are very happy that the Waters of the U.S. has been stayed. That would have pretty much shut down county government in terms of being able to provide citizens the service that they need. I mean, if we have to go out there and every time we clean a ditch out we have to go through a permit process to do that. And I know they try to say they operate under--they operate under permits that are general permits, but there's still regulatory involvement there that we have to submit documentation on. All that money that we're spending is less money that we are putting out there to benefit the citizens of our county. Mr. Palmer. One other thing that the EPA is doing and that the Federal Highway Administration is doing, is imposing emissions rules. One of the issues was the ozone rule, and is particularly problematic for southern States. So, a big problem for us. It could have a very negative impact on economic development. One of the problems I've got with this is they keep changing the goal post and it has a tremendously negative impact on planning. For instance, EPA has proposed a new ozone rule, which frankly we had a hearing and I questioned Administrator McCarthy about it. The technology doesn't exist at the moment to achieve this new rule. But it was also interesting, I think this was either in February or March of 2015 or 2016, I think it was 2015. I also asked her when they send the implementation guidelines to the States for the 2008 rule and they had just sent them. So when you have Federal agencies, EPA, or any other agency, imposing these rules and then not sending the implementation guidelines, that has to have a very negative impact on your ability to plan and to get investments, even private sector investments for infrastructure. Would you want to comment on that? Mr. Beyer. Yes, sir, I will. The last round of ozone requirements did not touch our metropolitan planning organization, but we were borderline with that. And it would have had extreme impacts on the way that we were able to plan, whether it was on the transit side or whether it was on the highway side. And we were fortune enough we didn't get impacted by them, but you're exactly right, the way that the documentation and the guidance was put out there, it was very problematic, it caused a lot of discernment for a year or so in the planning process as we were going through the development of our TIP. And so yes, sir, you're exactly right, it's very problematic for that to occur. Mr. Palmer. Well, I appreciate again the witnesses being here and Chairman Farenthold's willingness to hold this hearing as a joint subcommittee and I yield back. Mr. D'Angelo. Mr. Palmer, if I could speak very quickly on the NAAQS issue as well, stationary sources, the Clean Air Act is one of the major drivers of regulatory costs for steel mills. And the new ozone standard has been set to a level that is near background levels. And we know, EPA has the data, that there's been non attainment in the West and in other places by virtue of emissions, from my industry's competing mills in China and elsewhere. And---- Mr. Palmer. Since Mr. D'Angelo brought that up I'll share something else with you from that hearing that we had with Administrator McCarthy. I asked her if it was true that they had just earlier that year sent the implementation guidelines to the States on the new ozone rule? And she said, yes. I said, is it also true that there is an internal memo in EPA that indicates that if we don't implement the 2015 rule we will be in full compliance in 10 years and she said, yes. And I take note of the fact that not only are our foreign competitors dumping their steel products into the United States, they are also dumping their pollution. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. We'll now recognize the ranking member Mrs. Demings for 5 minutes. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Beyer, you're here representing the National Association of Counties. And I believe your county is Elmore County in Alabama. I believe you said it is 82,000, the fastest growing county in your State. Is that correct? Mr. Beyer. Yes, it is one of the faster growing counties. Mrs. Demings. One of the fastest. Go ahead and take the fastest growing. Would you say that you probably know your county, and the citizens in your county know the local area, better than the Federal Government? Mr. Beyer. Yes, ma'am. Mrs. Demings. And do you agree that local communities should have, I mean as a person who is representing a local community know the needs of that community, know the people, do you believe that your local community should have a say, just as I asked Mr. D'Angelo, in those local projects and what happens and what does not happen? Mr. Beyer. Absolutely, absolutely. We are the closest government to the people. We can't do anything in our life without being talked to about the road conditions or the condition of the environment. So yes, ma'am between the staff and the County commissions, they are closest to the people and they have a good insight. Your example about the interstate, that was one thing that I hoping I would get to circle back to, the question. The local government, you know, we desire that involvement to make sure that we are part of the that process and the planning, so when DOTs and the Federal Government are looking at major projects that effect communities we want to be at the table to help to make sure all the solutions are there on the table. And I think that is something the national associations have put more on the forefront, but I think we would like to see more and more of that to where the local government gets the citizens involved and I think that takes care of a lot of the issues that we're here to talk about today. Mrs. Demings. You know for someone who has worked in local government myself, I know how important it is to get those projects done, to serve the people in the most expeditious manner that you can. But NEPA was created to permit views of local citizens to shape the development of their community and environment. Not having deadlines is--that's another subject for another day. But what role do you believe, looking at the needs of your local community and how it impacts the citizens that you serve, what role should NEPA play? Mr. Beyer. In my opinion I think NEPA plays a role in the development of those new corridors. I think NEPA developed-- should be at play when we are talking about major impacts to people. I mean if you're getting a sliver of land here and there, I don't think that is where the intent of that is. Now the example you gave with the interstate, I think that is exactly where NEPA is intended for. If the County was to go out and put in a 5 mile brand new road and we were going to impact residences and we were going to impact streams and all that, there is a role for it there. But I believe a couple of the other witnesses here talked about how the role's expanded to where everything is under a microscope. And instead of focusing those resources on those major impacts, now we're on to every little thing that a Federal dollar touches. And that, I think, if we can leave you with a message today, that's what I'd like to leave you with. There's places where you don't need that. There's professionals in place to handle that in dealing directly with the community. But you're exactly right about the major communities and major projects. And there's some comments about staffing. I think the staffing again, if their focus was on those major projects, instead of a small blue line creek in the northeast part of my county, that has a couple hundred vehicles a day on it, but at the same time it has major utilities running through there, if their focus was on the northern belt line in Birmingham or their focus was on the I-10 corridor in the south part of our State, we'd get things moving along. Instead they are worried about whether or not, as I said-- and I wasn't very very eloquent when I said it--they are worried whether I'm going to bother some little species that may or may not be there in my channel. Or whether I put a rock or two of rip rap in a channel that they deem as being waters of the United States. There's a focus problem there. If the focus was right, exactly what you said earlier would have been much better handled in terms of how that community was impacted. So I don't know if I answered your question. Mrs. Demings. You did, Mr. Beyer. Thank you so much. And thank you to all of the witness who are here today. Mr. Loris? Mr. Loris. Yeah, could I just make one comment? I completely echo that sentiment. I think communities should have say in these projects and they are in the best position to do so rather than folks in Washington. I think folks in the Virgin Islands better know the economic and environmental desires better than folks in Washington. And so having more priorities, you know. That are limited in scope at the national level, but activities that can be best managed at the State and local level, will go a long way to alleviating some of these problems. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much. I yield back, Mr. Chair. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And I have just got a couple of short questions that I want to wrap up with and follow up on. I think Mr. Ross talked a little bit about sue and settle and loser pays. It's not necessarily loser pays, it's taxpayer pays in most of these cases. Correct me if I am wrong, Mr. Loris, the way this is set up, any environmental activist group can sue under, pick the statute that we've been talking about today, to either delay a project or get a species and list it on the endangered species act, you name it. And then without going to trial, without a judge making any decision at all, they can go in and negotiate with the regulatory agency and say, all right, we sued you, if you will--we'll use Endangered Species Act, list this animal on the Endangered Species Act and pay our attorneys' fees, we're going to go away. There may be really no adversarial process in there, and there may be no judge who actually interprets the law and makes a decision. It's just settled between two groups that may have almost identical interests and it's entirely funded by the taxpayer and goes--and skirts the normal regulatory process of public comments and hearings and everything. It's basically done behind closed doors. Is that an accurate representation of what happens? Mr. Loris. Yeah, that's correct. And you're leaving out those community stakeholders too who may have an interest seeing these projects move forward, they may not, but they are left in the dust as well. Mr. Farenthold. So what would your solution to that be? Mr. Loris. Well, there's a few. I think one is Congress needs to reassert its authority in a lot of these major environmental regulations and statutes. I think for too long, too much authority has been ceded to these agencies who can-- where now we are relying on unelected bureaucrats to make these decisions and to make these backroom deals. So I think there's a lot that can be done, you know, clarifying who should have legal standing, requiring bond so that taxpayers aren't on the hook to pay for these lawsuits are just two simple reforms that could go a long way in making sure that it's not these environmental organizations who are antidevelopment, keep it in the ground, are the ones making the decisions with the regulators. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And Mr. D'Angelo, it is a little outside the scope of what we're doing here, but you touched a little bit about the environmental regulations that effect your clients building of new plants and operation of existing plants. There is a big dialogue now going on in our government about bringing jobs back to the United States, making us competitive again. How do our environmental regulations compare with the rest of the world? I assume that we're easier to deal with in some areas and far harder to deal with in other areas. Where would you say we are and where do we get the biggest bang for the buck repairing it where we continue to protect the environment but bring jobs to the United States? Mr. D'Angelo. Thank you, chairman. That's a great question. The steel industry is one of the most heavily regulated industries in the world. A lot of the--the majority of the cost comes from the Clean Air Act. So they are--steel mills are regulated both as an individual source and because of where they are, through National Ambient Air Quality Standards. States play a role with that. Federal Government plays a role. There's even local impacts. To ask how our environmental health and safety regulations compare to those in other countries primarily where the steel industry competitors lie, it's not an overstatement to say that there is no comparison. The steel we make here is made in the most clean, sustainable way. And if you care about climate change, you care about making your steel here as opposed to a factory in some other country that doesn't have these controls, putting it on a ship and covering it in diesel to get it all the way across the planet to be used in our infrastructure projects. The best and cleanest steel and most heavily regulated steel comes from right here. I would also like--if I could have an indulgence, talk about the ESA sue and settle because I worked on some of these. It is not hard how these groups do it. There's two in particular, Center for Biological Diversity and WildEarth Guardians. They know that the ESA has an inflexible deadline, after you file a petition the clock starts. In 12 months if the agency has not responded to that petition, they have a lawsuit. Twelve months, means 12 months. Every court in the Nation has said that. It's not one of these issues where agencies get discretion, because you can't interpret it any other way, and so they lose every single time. And so when one of the cases comes up, they sit down with their lawyer, in this case DOJ. And DOJ says they got you dead to rights and so they give it away. And who walks away? Two organizations walk away with all--with the listening agenda. They pick exactly what species come and what order they go in. And those species are not ranked according to proximity to extinction or risk. They are ranked according to wholly distinct, policy priorities of two organizations. These are not people in our communities. Ms. Plaskett, I am familiar with many of the coral issues. Center for Biological Diversity filed a petition to list, one single petition to list 82 separate species of corals. Now you can imagine the lack of rigger with one petition going to 82 species. And the National Marine Fisheries Service decided to list many of those. The discussion of which is mere paragraphs for any individual corals, right. And Ms. Plaskett, I have heard her speak on that. She's an advocate--she shows what the real world impacts are, what the real folks in her community-- And I think it's sad. The 12 month deadline made sense until organizations started gaming it. And that doesn't help in any way and it doesn't help conversation--conservation, excuse me. Listing everything under the sun is not going to help conservation. It is putting something on a list. There's been this aura built around it, but it doesn't do anything. We need to actually fund conservation, and we're not letting our services do that. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. And I think Mr. Palmer has one more question. Did you all have anything else you wanted before--Mr. Palmer, I'll recognize you to wrap it up. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just really have a statement in regards to something that you brought up, and Mr. Loris responded to, and that's the problem with sue and settlement and dissent decrees and continuing to expand the universe, as you pointed out Mr. D'Angelo, if Federal agency, if they are sued, if they litigate the case and they get a judgment, the judgment is limited to the remedy for the problem. But if we enter into a consent decree or--as we do with the sue and settle cases, the judge appoints a special master or a control group and they determine whether or not the remedy has ever been achieved and those can go on for years. So I think it's something that would warrant further consideration, Mr. Chairman, and look forward to working with you and others on these issues. I really think it has been a good hearing. And again, I want to thank the witnesses for their participation. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And I too would like to thank you all for being here and your testimony. I would like to ask for unanimous consent that members have 5 legislative days to submit questions for the record. And without objection that's so ordered. If there's no further business, without objection, the subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:32 a.m., the subcommittees were adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]