Pennsylvania 2025-2026 Regular Session Status: Passed House 32 D cosponsors

HB 1460 — An Act providing for approval from the Department of Health and the Office of Attorney General before certain transactions involving health care entities within this Commonwealth.

Last action — First consideration

  1. ✓
    Introduced
  2. ✓
    In Committee
  3. 3
    Passed House
  4. 4
    Passed Senate
  5. 5
    To Executive
  6. 6
    Enacted

This bill has passed the House. Introduced May 13, 2025. It now moves to the second chamber.

Next likely step: consideration and a floor vote in the Senate.

Odds of enactment

Moderate chance

Based on the sponsor, cosponsors, and committee posture, this bill has a moderate chance of becoming law.

Upgrade to see the exact probability and what's driving it.

A statistical estimate from our own model of past outcomes — an insight, not a guarantee. Policymaking is volatile.

Prognosis

Advancing 42% · moderate confidence
  • Passed House

    Current position in the legislative process.

  • 32 sponsors

    1 primary, 31 co-sponsors signed on.

  • Single-party support

    Sponsorship is currently within one party (32 D).

  • Mixed recorded votes

    10 passed, 1 failed in recorded votes so far.

Based on stage, sponsorship breadth, committee status, recorded votes, and cross-state momentum — a description of the observable signals, not a prediction.

In plain language

The bill requires state health and legal approvals for certain healthcare entity transactions.

This bill mandates that specific transactions involving healthcare entities in the Commonwealth receive approval from the Department of Health and the Office of Attorney General. This process aims to ensure oversight and compliance in healthcare transactions.

What this means for you
  • Families: Families may see changes in the way healthcare services are provided if transactions are subject to additional regulatory approvals.
  • Consumers: Consumers may experience alterations in healthcare service availability or quality as a result of these transaction requirements.
  • Healthcare: Healthcare entities must seek approvals before conducting certain transactions, potentially impacting their operational processes.

Bill Text

What changed in the latest version

1276 added · 586 removed

Plain-language change summary

The recent amendments to Bill HB 1460 now require that certain transactions involving healthcare entities must receive approval from both the Department of Health and the Office of Attorney General before proceeding. This change is significant because it enhances oversight, ensuring that any transactions in the healthcare sector align with public interest and regulatory standards. This added layer of scrutiny aims to protect community health and maintain the integrity of healthcare services within the Commonwealth.

→
Previous
Latest
PRIOR PRINTER'S NOS.
SENATE AMENDED PRINTER'S NO.
1696, 1821 PRINTER'S NO.
3687 PRIOR PRINTER'S NOS.
1871 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA HOUSE BILL Session of No.
1696, 1821, 1871 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA HOUSE BILL Session of No.
1460 2025 INTRODUCED BY BOROWSKI, TAKAC, KHAN, BOYD, O'MARA, KRUEGER, CURRY, KAZEEM, DELLOSO, YOUNG, HILL-EVANS, GIRAL, FIEDLER, SANCHEZ, FREEMAN, PROBST, HOHENSTEIN, DONAHUE, SCHLOSSBERG, PROKOPIAK, CEPEDA-FREYTIZ, CERRATO, WAXMAN, DALEY, CIRESI, KENYATTA, FRANKEL, GREEN, WEBSTER, KOSIEROWSKI AND HANBIDGE, MAY 13, 2025 AS AMENDED ON SECOND CONSIDERATION, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, JUNE 9, 2025 AN ACT ProOffice of Attorney General before certain transactionsthe involving health care entities within this Commonwealth.
1460 2025 INTRODUCED BY BOROWSKI, TAKAC, KHAN, BOYD, O'MARA, KRUEGER, CURRY, KAZEEM, DELLOSO, YOUNG, HILL-EVANS, GIRAL, FIEDLER, SANCHEZ, FREEMAN, PROBST, HOHENSTEIN, DONAHUE, SCHLOSSBERG, PROKOPIAK, CEPEDA-FREYTIZ, CERRATO, WAXMAN, DALEY, CIRESI, KENYATTA, FRANKEL, GREEN, WEBSTER, KOSIEROWSKI, HANBIDGE AND MADSEN, MAY 13, 2025 SENATOR FARRY, INSTITUTIONAL SUSTAINABILITY AND INNOVATION, IN SENATE, AS AMENDED, JUNE 24, 2026 AN ACT Providing for approval from the Department of Health and the <-- Office of Attorney General before certain transactions involving health care entities within this Commonwealth.
PROVIDING FOR APPROVAL FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND THE <-- OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL BEFORE CERTAIN TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING HEALTH CARE ENTITIES WITHIN THIS COMMONWEALTH.
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARY PROVISIONS SECTION 101.
SHORT TITLE.
SECTION 102.
DEFINITIONS.
SECTION 103.
ADJUSTMENTS.
CHAPTER 3.
COVERED HEALTH CARE TRANSACTIONS SECTION 301.
TRANSACTION AGAINST PUBLIC INTEREST.
SECTION 302.
FILING OF TRANSACTIONS.
SECTION 303.
PUBLIC INPUT.
SECTION 304.
OBJECTIONS BY ATTORNEY GENERAL.
SECTION 305.
COMPLIANCE AND POWER OF COURT.
SECTION 306.
POWERS AND DUTIES OF ATTORNEY GENERAL.
SECTION 307.
POWERS AND DUTIES OF DEPARTMENT.
SECTION 308.
CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT.
CHAPTER 10.
MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS SECTION 1001.
CONSTRUCTION.
SECTION 1002.
STUDY AND REPORT BY LEGISLATIVE BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE.
SECTION 1003.
EFFECTIVE DATE.
CHAPTER 1 PRELIMINARY PROVISIONS Section 101.
CHAPTER 1 <-- PRELIMINARY PROVISIONS 20250HB1460PN3687 - 2 - Section 101.
(2) An unfair method of competition in or unfairly affecting health care commerce or an unfair or deceptive act 20250HB1460PN1871 - 2 - or practice in or affecting health care commerce.
(2) An unfair method of competition in or unfairly affecting health care commerce or an unfair or deceptive act or practice in or affecting health care commerce.
"Attorney General." The Office of Attorney General of the Commonwealth.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 3 - "Attorney General." The Office of Attorney General of the Commonwealth.
or (ii) controls, holds with the power to vote or holds proxies representing 10% or more of the votes that all 20250HB1460PN1871 - 3 - shareholders or members would be entitled to cast in the election of directors or managers.
or (ii) controls, holds with the power to vote or holds proxies representing 10% or more of the votes that all shareholders or members would be entitled to cast in the election of directors or managers.
Show all 282 changed rows (242 more)
Previous
Latest
The Attorney General may determine, after furnishing all persons in interest notice and opportunity to be heard and making specific findings of fact to support the determination, that control exists in fact, notwithstanding the absence of a presumption to that effect or that another person has control.
The Attorney General may determine, after furnishing all persons in interest notice and opportunity to be heard and making specific findings of fact to support the determination, that control exists in fact, notwithstanding the absence of a 20250HB1460PN3687 - 4 - presumption to that effect or that another person has control.
(3) A capital distribution or similar reduction of a health care entity's equity capital by a material amount or the incursion of an obligation that commits the health care 20250HB1460PN1871 - 4 - entity to making a capital distribution or similar reduction of equity by a material amount.
(3) A capital distribution or similar reduction of a health care entity's equity capital by a material amount or the incursion of an obligation that commits the health care entity to making a capital distribution or similar reduction of equity by a material amount.
"Health care facility." The term shall have the same meaning as in section 802.1 of the act of July 1, 1979 (P.L.130, No.48), known as the Health Care Facilities Act.
"Health care facility." The term shall have the same meaning as in section 802.1 of the act of July 1, 1979 (P.L.130, No.48), 20250HB1460PN3687 - 5 - known as the Health Care Facilities Act.
"Professional licensing board." A professional licensing 20250HB1460PN1871 - 5 - board within the Bureau of Professional and Occupational Affairs of the Department of State.
"Professional licensing board." A professional licensing board within the Bureau of Professional and Occupational Affairs of the Department of State.
(a) General rule.--Except as provided under subsection (b), a person may not enter into a covered transaction that is against the public interest.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 6 - (a) General rule.--Except as provided under subsection (b), a person may not enter into a covered transaction that is against the public interest.
(1) All organic documents, including articles of 20250HB1460PN1871 - 6 - incorporation, bylaws, operating agreements and other documents related to governance and ownership of each party.
(1) All organic documents, including articles of incorporation, bylaws, operating agreements and other documents related to governance and ownership of each party.
(3) All documents signed by the principals, or the principal's agents, that are necessary to determine the proposed transaction's effect, if any, on affiliates, whether nonprofit or for profit.
(3) All documents signed by the principals, or the principal's agents, that are necessary to determine the proposed transaction's effect, if any, on affiliates, whether 20250HB1460PN3687 - 7 - nonprofit or for profit.
20250HB1460PN1871 - 7 - (9) All relevant contracts that may affect value, including business contracts and employee contracts, such as buy-out provisions, profit-sharing agreements and severance packages.
(9) All relevant contracts that may affect value, including business contracts and employee contracts, such as buy-out provisions, profit-sharing agreements and severance packages.
(11) All documents relating to noncash elements of the transaction, including pertinent valuations of security for loans and stock restrictions.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 8 - (11) All documents relating to noncash elements of the transaction, including pertinent valuations of security for loans and stock restrictions.
(17) Organizational charts of the parties to the transaction, as they exist both preconsummation and 20250HB1460PN1871 - 8 - postconsummation of the transaction, detailing the relationship between the principal parties, including any subsidiary.
(17) Organizational charts of the parties to the transaction, as they exist both preconsummation and postconsummation of the transaction, detailing the relationship between the principal parties, including any subsidiary.
(c) Waiting period.--Prior to entering into a binding covered transaction, a health care entity shall undergo a 60-day waiting period, which shall begin on the date the Attorney General receives the notification required under subsection (b).
(c) Waiting period.--Prior to entering into a binding covered transaction, a health care entity shall undergo a 60-day waiting period, which shall begin on the date the Attorney 20250HB1460PN3687 - 9 - General receives the notification required under subsection (b).
(i) all of the additional information and 20250HB1460PN1871 - 9 - documentary material requested;
(i) all of the additional information and documentary material requested;
(3) Additional extensions of the waiting period beyond what is required under subsection (b) must be granted by a court in accordance with section 305, provided that the request is filed with the court within five days of the expiration of all applicable waiting periods.
(3) Additional extensions of the waiting period beyond what is required under subsection (b) must be granted by a court in accordance with section 305, provided that the request is filed with the court within five days of the 20250HB1460PN3687 - 10 - expiration of all applicable waiting periods.
Interested parties shall include employees of the health care entity, legal aid organizations, public officials and health advocacy organizations within a county in which the health care 20250HB1460PN1871 - 10 - facility is located.
Interested parties shall include employees of the health care entity, legal aid organizations, public officials and health advocacy organizations within a county in which the health care facility is located.
(3) Through publication in one or more newspapers of general circulation in the affected community.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 11 - (3) Through publication in one or more newspapers of general circulation in the affected community.
20250HB1460PN1871 - 11 - (c) Action.--If the Attorney General, in consultation with the department, determines THERE IS CLEAR AND CONVINCING <-- EVIDENCE that the proposed covered transaction is against the public interest under subsection (a), the Attorney General, on behalf of the Commonwealth, may:
(c) Action.--If the Attorney General, in consultation with the department, determines THERE IS CLEAR AND CONVINCING <-- EVIDENCE that the proposed covered transaction is against the public interest under subsection (a), the Attorney General, on behalf of the Commonwealth, may:
or (2) enter into a voluntary agreement with the covered entity and the health care entity, which shall be filed with Commonwealth Court, that imposes conditions or otherwise mitigates the aspects that make the covered transaction against the public interest.
or (2) enter into a voluntary agreement with the covered 20250HB1460PN3687 - 12 - entity and the health care entity, which shall be filed with Commonwealth Court, that imposes conditions or otherwise mitigates the aspects that make the covered transaction against the public interest.
(e) Costs of monitoring.-- (1) The covered entity shall pay for the costs of the Attorney General and the department's monitoring, evaluation and assessment of the covered entity and health care entity's compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary 20250HB1460PN1871 - 12 - agreement during a monitoring period established under subsection (d).
(e) Costs of monitoring.-- (1) The covered entity shall pay for the costs of the Attorney General and the department's monitoring, evaluation and assessment of the covered entity and health care entity's compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary agreement during a monitoring period established under subsection (d).
(f) Licensing.--A health care facility's license may not be revoked, denied, impeded or cited for noncompliance due solely to a filing or review under this chapter.
(f) Licensing.--A health care facility's license may not be 20250HB1460PN3687 - 13 - revoked, denied, impeded or cited for noncompliance due solely to a filing or review under this chapter.
20250HB1460PN1871 - 13 - (b) Contracts.-- (1) The Attorney General may do any of the following:
(b) Contracts.-- (1) The Attorney General may do any of the following:
(ii) At the Attorney General's sole discretion, contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed covered transaction.
(ii) At the Attorney General's sole discretion, contract with experts or consultants to assist in 20250HB1460PN3687 - 14 - reviewing the proposed covered transaction.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL BE ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE ENTITIES SEEKING CONSENT FOR THE COVERED TRANSACTION FOR 50% OF ALL ACTUAL, REASONABLE AND 20250HB1460PN1871 - 14 - DIRECT COSTS INCURRED IN REVIEWING, EVALUATING AND MAKING A DETERMINATION UNDER SECTION 304(A), INCLUDING ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL BE ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE ENTITIES SEEKING CONSENT FOR THE COVERED TRANSACTION FOR 50% OF ALL ACTUAL, REASONABLE AND DIRECT COSTS INCURRED IN REVIEWING, EVALUATING AND MAKING A DETERMINATION UNDER SECTION 304(A), INCLUDING ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS.
(I) NEITHER THE ATTORNEY GENERAL NOR THE COVERED ENTITY MAY SEEK REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY FOR ANY COSTS UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 15 - (I) NEITHER THE ATTORNEY GENERAL NOR THE COVERED ENTITY MAY SEEK REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY FOR ANY COSTS UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH.
(4) Notwithstanding the other provisions of this act, a covered transaction may not be completed unless an agreement 20250HB1460PN1871 - 15 - has been executed between the Attorney General and the covered entity, the health care entity or both for the payment of costs in accordance with this subsection.
(4) Notwithstanding the other provisions of this act, a covered transaction may not be completed unless an agreement has been executed between the Attorney General and the covered entity, the health care entity or both for the payment of costs in accordance with this subsection.
(1) The Attorney General shall monitor, assess and evaluate a covered entity and health care entity to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary agreement for the duration of the monitoring period established under section 304(d).
(1) The Attorney General shall monitor, assess and evaluate a covered entity and health care entity to ensure 20250HB1460PN3687 - 16 - compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary agreement for the duration of the monitoring period established under section 304(d).
(d) Agency cooperation.-- (1) The department, the Department of Aging, the Department of Human Services and the Insurance Department shall assist the Attorney General in reviewing the proposed agreement and transaction, if requested, and shall comply with any request for testimony or information as may be 20250HB1460PN1871 - 16 - necessary and appropriate for the Attorney General to review a proposed covered transaction.
(d) Agency cooperation.-- (1) The department, the Department of Aging, the Department of Human Services and the Insurance Department shall assist the Attorney General in reviewing the proposed agreement and transaction, if requested, and shall comply with any request for testimony or information as may be necessary and appropriate for the Attorney General to review a proposed covered transaction.
Documents provided by the Attorney General to the Insurance Department under this paragraph shall be treated as confidential and are exempt from public access under the act of February 14, 2008 (P.L.
Documents provided by the 20250HB1460PN3687 - 17 - Attorney General to the Insurance Department under this paragraph shall be treated as confidential and are exempt from public access under the act of February 14, 2008 (P.L.
20250HB1460PN1871 - 17 - (1) The department shall monitor, assess and evaluate a health care facility and covered entity to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary agreement.
(1) The department shall monitor, assess and evaluate a health care facility and covered entity to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of the voluntary agreement.
(2) The department may request documents and other information from a covered entity, a health care facility or both to monitor compliance with the terms of the voluntary agreement under section 304(c).
(2) The department may request documents and other 20250HB1460PN3687 - 18 - information from a covered entity, a health care facility or both to monitor compliance with the terms of the voluntary agreement under section 304(c).
20250HB1460PN1871 - 18 - (2) Subject to subpoena.
(2) Subject to subpoena.
(4) Made public by the Attorney General, the department or any other person, except to regulatory or law enforcement officials of this Commonwealth or other jurisdictions or experts or consultants under contract with the Attorney General under section 306(b), without the prior written consent of the health care entity or covered entity to which it pertains, unless the Attorney General, after giving the health entity or covered entity that would be affected notice and opportunity to be heard, determines that the interest of the public is served by the publication, in which event it may publish all or any part in such manner as it may deem appropriate.
(4) Made public by the Attorney General, the department or any other person, except to regulatory or law enforcement officials of this Commonwealth or other jurisdictions or experts or consultants under contract with the Attorney General under section 306(b), without the prior written 20250HB1460PN3687 - 19 - consent of the health care entity or covered entity to which it pertains, unless the Attorney General, after giving the health entity or covered entity that would be affected notice and opportunity to be heard, determines that the interest of the public is served by the publication, in which event it may publish all or any part in such manner as it may deem appropriate.
(1) Narrow, abrogate or otherwise alter the authority of the Attorney General to maintain competitive markets and 20250HB1460PN1871 - 19 - prosecute or enforce violations of antitrust and unfair trade practices laws.
(1) Narrow, abrogate or otherwise alter the authority of the Attorney General to maintain competitive markets and prosecute or enforce violations of antitrust and unfair trade practices laws.
(3) Narrow, abrogate or otherwise alter the authority of a professional licensing board to issue, suspend or revoke a health care practitioner's license or regulate the practice of the health arts in this Commonwealth.
(3) Narrow, abrogate or otherwise alter the authority of 20250HB1460PN3687 - 20 - a professional licensing board to issue, suspend or revoke a health care practitioner's license or regulate the practice of the health arts in this Commonwealth.
20250HB1460PN1871 - 20 -
CHAPTER 1 <-- PRELIMINARY PROVISIONS SECTION 101.
SHORT TITLE.
THIS ACT SHALL BE KNOWN AND MAY BE CITED AS THE HEALTH SYSTEM PROTECTION ACT.
SECTION 102.
DEFINITIONS.
THE FOLLOWING WORDS AND PHRASES WHEN USED IN THIS ACT SHALL HAVE THE MEANINGS GIVEN TO THEM IN THIS SECTION UNLESS THE CONTEXT CLEARLY INDICATES OTHERWISE:
"AFFECTED COMMUNITY." A COUNTY WITHIN THIS COMMONWEALTH WHERE AN EXISTING HEALTH CARE ENTITY IS PHYSICALLY LOCATED OR A COUNTY WHOSE RESIDENTS ARE REGULARLY SERVED BY THE EXISTING HEALTH CARE ENTITY.
"AFFILIATE." A PERSON THAT DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, THROUGH ONE OR MORE INTERMEDIARIES, CONTROLS OR IS CONTROLLED BY, OR IS UNDER COMMON CONTROL WITH, THE PERSON SPECIFIED.
"AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST." A COVERED TRANSACTION THAT, AS DETERMINED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, MAY RESULT IN ANY OF THE 20250HB1460PN3687 - 21 - FOLLOWING:
(1) A SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN COMPETITION OR A SIGNIFICANT INCREASE IN COSTS FOR HEALTH CARE PAYERS, PURCHASERS OR CONSUMERS.
(2) AN UNFAIR METHOD OF COMPETITION IN OR AFFECTING HEALTH CARE COMMERCE OR AN UNFAIR OR DECEPTIVE ACT OR PRACTICE IN OR AFFECTING HEALTH CARE COMMERCE.
(3) A SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN THE QUALITY OF CARE AVAILABLE WITHIN THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S MARKET TERRITORY.
(4) A SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN ACCESS TO OR AVAILABILITY OF HEALTH CARE SERVICES FOR PAYERS, PURCHASERS OR CONSUMERS.
(5) A SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN ACCESS TO CARE IN A RURAL, LOW-INCOME OR DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITY.
"ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE." AS PROVIDED UNDER SECTION 5 OF THE ACT OF DECEMBER 17, 1968 (P.L.1224, NO.387), KNOWN AS THE UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW.
"ATTORNEY GENERAL." THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE COMMONWEALTH.
"CAPITAL DISTRIBUTION." A PAYMENT MADE, LIABILITY INCURRED OR OTHER CONSIDERATION GIVEN BY A HEALTH CARE ENTITY TO A PERSON FOR THE PURCHASE, ACQUISITION, REDEMPTION, REPURCHASE, PAYMENT OR RETIREMENT OF CAPITAL STOCK OR OTHER EQUITY INTEREST OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR AS A DIVIDEND, RETURN OF CAPITAL OR OTHER DISTRIBUTION IN RESPECT OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S CAPITAL STOCK OR OTHER EQUITY INTEREST.
"CONTROL," "CONTROLLED BY" OR "UNDER COMMON CONTROL WITH." AS FOLLOWS:
(1) THE POSSESSION, DIRECT OR INDIRECT, OF THE POWER TO DIRECT OR CAUSE THE DIRECTION OF THE MANAGEMENT AND POLICIES OF A PERSON, WHETHER THROUGH THE OWNERSHIP OF VOTING 20250HB1460PN3687 - 22 - SECURITIES, BY CONTRACT OTHER THAN A COMMERCIAL CONTRACT FOR GOODS OR NONMANAGEMENT SERVICES OR OTHERWISE, UNLESS THE POWER IS THE RESULT OF AN OFFICIAL POSITION WITH OR CORPORATE OFFICE HELD BY THE PERSON.
CONTROL SHALL BE PRESUMED TO EXIST IF A PERSON, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY:
(I) OWNS MORE THAN 10% OF A PERSON;
OR (II) CONTROLS, HOLDS WITH THE POWER TO VOTE OR HOLDS PROXIES REPRESENTING 10% OR MORE OF THE VOTES THAT ALL SHAREHOLDERS OR MEMBERS WOULD BE ENTITLED TO CAST IN THE ELECTION OF DIRECTORS OR MANAGERS.
(2) THE PRESUMPTION UNDER PARAGRAPH (1) MAY BE REBUTTED BY A SHOWING THAT CONTROL DOES NOT EXIST IN FACT.
IF, IN THE VIEW OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, CONTROL EXISTS IN FACT, AND AFTER FURNISHING ALL PERSONS IN INTEREST NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD AND MAKING SPECIFIC FINDINGS OF FACT, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY ASSERT THAT A PERSON HAS A CONTROLLING INTEREST, NOTWITHSTANDING THE ABSENCE OF A PRESUMPTION TO THAT EFFECT OR THAT ANOTHER PERSON HAS CONTROL.
"COVERED ENTITY." A PERSON DOMICILED OR ORGANIZED UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS COMMONWEALTH OR ANOTHER JURISDICTION THAT OWNS, OPERATES OR CONTROLS OR SEEKS TO OWN, OPERATE OR CONTROL A HEALTH CARE ENTITY, AND IS ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) A FOR-PROFIT ENTITY OR AN AFFILIATE OF A FOR-PROFIT ENTITY.
(2) AN INVESTOR OR GROUP OF INVESTORS WHO PRIMARILY ENGAGE IN THE RAISING OR RETURNING OF CAPITAL AND WHO INVEST, DEVELOP OR DISPOSE OF SPECIFIED ASSETS, A PRIVATE EQUITY COMPANY, A PRIVATE EQUITY FUND OR A HEDGE FUND OR AFFILIATE.
(3) AN OUT-OF-STATE ENTITY SEEKING TO ENGAGE IN BUSINESS 20250HB1460PN3687 - 23 - ACTIVITIES LISTED IN PARAGRAPHS (1) AND (2).
"COVERED TRANSACTION." THE FOLLOWING:
(1) A TRANSACTION OR A SERIES OF TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING AT LEAST ONE HEALTH CARE ENTITY LOCATED IN THIS COMMONWEALTH AND ONE COVERED ENTITY, AND INCLUDES ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:
(I) A SALE, TRANSFER, LEASE, LEASEBACK AGREEMENT OR OTHER ENCUMBRANCE, OF A MATERIAL AMOUNT OF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S ASSETS, INCLUDING REAL PROPERTY, EMPLOYMENT GROUPS, EMERGENCY DEPARTMENTS OR OTHER UNITS.
(II) A CHANGE IN CONTROL OF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY.
(III) A CAPITAL DISTRIBUTION OR SIMILAR REDUCTION OF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S EQUITY CAPITAL BY A MATERIAL AMOUNT OR THE INCURSION OF AN OBLIGATION THAT COMMITS THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY TO MAKING A CAPITAL DISTRIBUTION OR SIMILAR REDUCTION OF EQUITY BY A MATERIAL AMOUNT.
(2) THE TERM DOES NOT INCLUDE:
(I) A MORTGAGE OR OTHER SECURE LOAN FOR BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT PURPOSES ENTERED INTO BY A HEALTH CARE ENTITY THAT DOES NOT DIRECTLY AFFECT DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE OR GOVERNANCE OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY.
(II) A CLINICAL AFFILIATION OF HEALTH CARE ENTITY FORMED SOLELY FOR THE PURPOSE OF COLLABORATING ON CLINICAL TRIALS, PROVIDING GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION OR PROVIDING CLINICAL SERVICES OR TRANSACTIONS FOR THE SALE, LICENSING OR OTHER EXCHANGE OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY.
(III) SUBCONTRACTS, LEASE AGREEMENTS OR OTHER TRANSACTIONS FOR THE PURPOSES OF DAY-TO-DAY BUSINESS OPERATIONS NOT INVOLVING THE DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE TREATMENT, SERVICES OR DIRECT PATIENT CLINICAL CARE.
"DEPARTMENT." THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH OF THE COMMONWEALTH.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 24 - "HEALTH CARE ENTITY." A PERSON THAT DIRECTS OR CONTROLS, OR THROUGH AN AFFILIATE DIRECTS OR CONTROLS, ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) A HOSPITAL;
OR (2) A HOSPICE.
"HOSPICE." THE TERM SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING AS IN SECTION 802.1 OF THE ACT OF JULY 19, 1979 (P.L.130, NO.48), KNOWN AS THE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES ACT.
"HOSPITAL." A FACILITY LICENSED AS A HOSPITAL UNDER 28 PA.
CODE PT.
IV SUBPT.
B (RELATING TO GENERAL AND SPECIAL HOSPITALS) WHICH PROVIDES EQUIPMENT AND SERVICES PRIMARILY FOR INPATIENT CARE TO INDIVIDUALS WHO REQUIRE TREATMENT FOR INJURY, ILLNESS, DISABILITY OR PREGNANCY.
THE TERM DOES NOT INCLUDE PUBLIC OR PRIVATE PSYCHIATRIC HOSPITALS, GENERAL NURSING FACILITIES, HOSPITAL-BASED NURSING FACILITIES, COUNTY-OPERATED NURSING FACILITIES, INTERMEDIATE CARE FACILITIES, PSYCHIATRIC TRANSITIONAL FACILITIES OR SPECIAL REHABILITATION NURSING FACILITIES, DRUG AND ALCOHOL REHABILITATION FACILITIES OR PHYSICIAN-OWNED HOSPITALS AS DEFINED UNDER 42 CFR § 489.3 (RELATING TO DEFINITIONS), OR A PERSON THAT THAT DIRECTS OR CONTROLS, OR THROUGH AN AFFILIATE DIRECTS OR CONTROLS, ONE OR MORE PHYSICIAN-OWNED HOSPITALS, SOLELY BY REASON OF THE PERSON'S OWNERSHIP, OPERATION, DIRECTION OR CONTROL OF A PHYSICIAN-OWNED HOSPITAL.
"LEASEBACK AGREEMENT." A TRANSACTION BY WHICH A PERSON SELLS, TRANSFERS, LEASES OR OTHERWISE ENCUMBERS, ASSETS OR REAL PROPERTY AND ENTERS INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH ANOTHER PERSON TO LEASE BACK THE SAME ASSETS OR REAL PROPERTY.
"MATERIAL AMOUNT." AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO AT LEAST $25,000,000 AS ADJUSTED UNDER SECTION 103.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 25 - "PRIVATE EQUITY COMPANY." A NONPUBLICLY TRADED ENTITY THAT COLLECTS CAPITAL INVESTMENTS FROM INDIVIDUALS OR ENTITIES.
"PRIVATE EQUITY FUND." AN ENTITY THAT DIRECTLY, OR THROUGH AN AFFILIATE, ACTS AS A CONTROL PERSON AND IS ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) A PERSON CONSIDERED AN INVESTMENT COMPANY UNDER 15 U.S.C.
§ 80A-3 (RELATING TO DEFINITION OF INVESTMENT COMPANY), EXCEPT FOR THE APPLICATION OF 15 U.S.C.
§ 80A-3(C) (1) AND (7).
(2) A VENTURE CAPITAL FUND AS DEFINED IN 17 CFR 275.203(L)-1 (RELATING TO VENTURE CAPITAL FUND DEFINED).
(3) A SOVEREIGN WEALTH FUND.
SECTION 103.
ADJUSTMENTS.
BEGINNING JANUARY 1, 2028, AND FOR EACH SUCCEEDING JANUARY 1 THEREAFTER, THE MATERIAL AMOUNT SHALL BE ADJUSTED FOR INFLATION.
THE ADJUSTMENT SHALL BE CALCULATED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL USING THE PERCENTAGE CHANGE IN THE CONSUMER PRICE INDEX FOR ALL URBAN CONSUMERS (CPI-U) FOR THE PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, DELAWARE AND MARYLAND AREA.
IN CALCULATING THE ADJUSTMENT, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL USE THE MOST RECENT 12-MONTH PERIOD FOR WHICH FIGURES HAVE BEEN OFFICIALLY REPORTED BY THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS.
AT LEAST 60 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE THE ADJUSTMENT IS DUE TO TAKE EFFECT, THE PERCENTAGE INCREASE AND THE MATERIAL AMOUNT, ROUNDED TO THE NEAREST DOLLAR, SHALL BE DETERMINED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL, WITHIN 10 DAYS FOLLOWING THE DETERMINATION, TRANSMIT A NOTICE OF THE DETERMINATION TO THE LEGISLATIVE REFERENCE BUREAU FOR PUBLICATION IN THE NEXT AVAILABLE ISSUE OF THE PENNSYLVANIA BULLETIN.
CHAPTER 3 20250HB1460PN3687 - 26 - COVERED HEALTH CARE TRANSACTIONS SECTION 301.
TRANSACTIONS AGAINST PUBLIC INTEREST.
(A) GENERAL RULE.--EXCEPT AS PROVIDED UNDER SUBSECTION (B), A PERSON MAY NOT ENTER INTO A COVERED TRANSACTION THAT IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST UNLESS THE PERSON COMPLIES WITH THE NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENTS UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
(B) EXCEPTION.--AN ACTION PROHIBITED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) MAY BE PERMITTED UNDER AN ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 304(C)(2) WHEN, AS DETERMINED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THERE IS NO FEASIBLE ALTERNATIVE TO PREVENT A HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S CLOSURE OR A GREATER LOSS OF HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN THE ABSENCE OF THE COVERED TRANSACTION.
SECTION 302.
FILING OF TRANSACTIONS.
(A) DUTIES OF COVERED ENTITY.--PRIOR TO CONSUMMATING A COVERED TRANSACTION, A COVERED ENTITY SHALL FILE A NOTIFICATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH SUBSECTION (B) AND COMPLETE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) OBSERVE THE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SUBSECTION (C);
OR (2) OBTAIN A WRITTEN NOTICE OF NO OBJECTION FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL THAT THE COVERED TRANSACTION IS NOT AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST.
(B) NOTICE.--NOTIFICATION OF A COVERED TRANSACTION SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL ON A FORM AND IN A MANNER DEVELOPED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
THE NOTIFICATION SHALL INCLUDE ALL OF THE FOLLOWING, AS APPLICABLE:
(1) ALL ORGANIC DOCUMENTS, INCLUDING ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION, BYLAWS, OPERATING AGREEMENTS AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO GOVERNANCE AND OWNERSHIP OF EACH PARTY.
(2) ALL COMPLETE TRANSACTION DOCUMENTS WITH ATTACHMENTS, INCLUDING COLLATERAL OR ANCILLARY AGREEMENTS INVOLVING 20250HB1460PN3687 - 27 - OFFICERS, DIRECTORS OR EMPLOYEES.
(3) ALL DOCUMENTS SIGNED BY THE PRINCIPALS, OR THE PRINCIPAL'S AGENTS, THAT ARE NECESSARY TO DETERMINE THE PROPOSED TRANSACTION'S EFFECT, IF ANY, ON AFFILIATES, WHETHER NONPROFIT OR FOR PROFIT.
(4) ANY OF THE FOLLOWING THAT COMPRISE PART OR ALL OF THE TRANSACTION:
(I) ASSET CONTRIBUTION AGREEMENTS.
(II) OPERATING AGREEMENTS.
(III) MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS.
(5) ALL INFORMATION NECESSARY TO EVALUATE THE EFFECTS OF THE TRANSACTION ON EACH COMPONENT OF AN INTEGRATED DELIVERY SYSTEM IF THAT TRANSACTION INVOLVES A HOSPITAL, INCLUDING ANY CHANGES IN CONTRACTS BETWEEN THE INTEGRATED DELIVERY SYSTEM ENTITIES AND RELATED PHYSICIAN GROUPS.
(6) ALL FINANCIAL DOCUMENTS OF THE TRANSACTION PARTIES AND RELATED ENTITIES, IF APPLICABLE, INCLUDING AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, OWNERSHIP RECORDS, BUSINESS PROJECTION DATA, CURRENT CAPITAL ASSET VALUATION DATA AND ANY RECORDS UPON WHICH FUTURE EARNINGS, EXISTING ASSET VALUES AND FAIR MARKET VALUE ANALYSIS CAN BE BASED.
(7) ALL FAIRNESS OPINIONS AND INDEPENDENT VALUATION REPORTS OF THE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES OF THE PARTIES, PREPARED ON THE PARTIES' BEHALF.
(8) A LIST OF ALL DONOR RESTRICTED ASSETS, TOGETHER WITH ORIGINATION DOCUMENTS AND CURRENT FUND BALANCES.
(9) ALL RELEVANT CONTRACTS THAT MAY AFFECT VALUE, INCLUDING BUSINESS CONTRACTS AND EMPLOYEE CONTRACTS, SUCH AS BUY-OUT PROVISIONS, PROFIT-SHARING AGREEMENTS AND SEVERANCE PACKAGES.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 28 - (10) ALL INFORMATION AND REPRESENTATIONS DISCLOSING RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS THAT ARE NECESSARY TO ASSESS WHETHER THE TRANSACTION IS AT ARM'S LENGTH OR INVOLVES SELF- DEALING.
(11) ALL DOCUMENTS RELATING TO NONCASH ELEMENTS OF THE TRANSACTION, INCLUDING PERTINENT VALUATIONS OF SECURITY FOR LOANS AND STOCK RESTRICTIONS.
(12) ALL TAX-RELATED INFORMATION, INCLUDING THE EXISTENCE OF TAX-FREE DEBT SUBJECT TO REDEMPTION AND DISQUALIFIED PERSON TRANSACTIONS YIELDING TAX LIABILITY.
(13) A LIST OF ONGOING LITIGATION, INCLUDING FULL COURT CAPTIONS, INVOLVING THE TRANSACTION PARTIES OR THE TRANSACTION PARTIES' RELATED ENTITIES, THAT MAY AFFECT THE INTERESTS OF THE PARTIES.
(14) ALL INFORMATION IN THE POSSESSION OF THE TRANSACTING PARTIES RELATIVE TO THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S PATIENT BASE AND COMMUNITIES SERVED, OR THEIR REPRESENTATIVES.
(15) ALL INFORMATION, INCLUDING INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL REPORTS AND STUDIES, BEARING ON THE EFFECT OF THE PROPOSED TRANSACTION ON THE AVAILABILITY OR ACCESSIBILITY OF HEALTH CARE IN THE AFFECTED COMMUNITY.
(16) A COMPLETE LIST OF ALL INSURANCE PLANS UNDER CONTRACT AND THE POLICIES' EXPIRATION DATES.
(17) ORGANIZATIONAL CHARTS OF THE PARTIES TO THE TRANSACTION, AS THEY EXIST BOTH PRECONSUMMATION AND POSTCONSUMMATION OF THE TRANSACTION, DETAILING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE PRINCIPAL PARTIES, INCLUDING ANY SUBSIDIARY.
(18) COPIES OF ALL FILINGS SUBMITTED TO FEDERAL 20250HB1460PN3687 - 29 - REGULATORS, INCLUDING ANY FILING THE ENTITIES SUBMITTED TO THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE UNDER 15 U.S.C.
§ 18A (RELATING TO PREMERGER NOTIFICATION AND WAITING PERIOD).
(19) A STATEMENT AS TO WHETHER ANY PARTY TO THE TRANSACTION, OR A CONTROLLING PERSON OR PARENT COMPANY OF THE PARTY, OWNS ANY OTHER HEALTH CARE ENTITY WHICH, IN THE PAST THREE YEARS HAS CLOSED OPERATIONS, IS IN THE PROCESS OF CLOSING OPERATIONS OR HAS EXPERIENCED A SUBSTANTIAL REDUCTION IN SERVICES PROVIDED.
THE PARTIES SHALL SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFY THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR ENTITIES SUBJECT TO THE CLOSURE OR SUBSTANTIAL SERVICE REDUCTION AND DETAIL THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CLOSURE.
(20) A STATEMENT AS TO WHETHER A SALE LEASEBACK AGREEMENT OR MORTGAGE OR LEAVE PAYMENTS OR OTHER PAYMENTS ASSOCIATED WITH REAL ESTATE ARE A COMPONENT OF THE PROPOSED TRANSACTION AND IF SO, THE PARTIES SHALL PROVIDE THE PROPOSED SALE-LEASEBACK AGREEMENT OR MORTGAGE, LEASE OR REAL ESTATE DOCUMENTS WITH THE NOTICE.
(21) ALL ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DEEMS NECESSARY FOR REVIEW PURPOSES.
(C) REVIEW PERIOD.--PRIOR TO CONSUMMATING A COVERED TRANSACTION, A COVERED ENTITY SHALL UNDERGO A 60-DAY REVIEW PERIOD, WHICH SHALL BEGIN ON THE DATE THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RECEIVES THE NOTIFICATION REQUIRED UNDER SUBSECTION (B).
WITHIN TWO BUSINESS DAYS, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL CONFIRM RECEIPT OF THE NOTIFICATION WITH THE COVERED ENTITY THAT SUBMITTED THE NOTIFICATION.
UPON THE EXPIRATION OF THE REVIEW PERIOD PROVIDED FOR UNDER THIS SUBSECTION, AND ANY EXTENSION OF A REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SUBSECTION (D), THE COVERED TRANSACTION MAY PROCEED UNLESS 20250HB1460PN3687 - 30 - THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DETERMINES THE COVERED TRANSACTION IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST.
(D) ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND REVIEW PERIOD EXTENSIONS.-- (1) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY, NO LATER THAN 30 DAYS PRIOR TO THE EXPIRATION OF THE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SUBSECTION (C), REQUIRE THE SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL FROM A PERSON WHO IS A PARTY TO THE PROPOSED COVERED TRANSACTION FOR WHICH A NOTIFICATION WAS FILED UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OR FROM ANY OFFICER, DIRECTOR, PARTNER, AGENT OR EMPLOYEE OF THE PERSON.
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY, IN ITS DISCRETION, EXTEND THE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SUBSECTION (C) FOR AN ADDITIONAL 30 DAYS FOR A COVERED TRANSACTION AFTER THE DATE ON WHICH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RECEIVES EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING FROM A PERSON TO WHOM A REQUEST IS MADE UNDER PARAGRAPH (1):
(I) ALL OF THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL REQUESTED;
OR (II) IF THE REQUEST IS NOT FULLY COMPLIED WITH, THE INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL SUBMITTED AND A STATEMENT OF THE REASONS FOR THE NONCOMPLIANCE.
(3) ADDITIONAL EXTENSIONS OF THE REVIEW PERIOD BEYOND WHAT IS REQUIRED UNDER SUBSECTION (C) MUST BE GRANTED BY A COURT IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 305, PROVIDED THAT THE REQUEST IS FILED WITH THE COURT WITHIN FIVE DAYS OF THE EXPIRATION OF ALL APPLICABLE REVIEW PERIODS.
SECTION 303.
PUBLIC INPUT.
(A) PUBLIC HEARING.--PRIOR TO THE EXPIRATION OF THE RESPECTIVE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SECTION 302(C), ALONG WITH ANY EXTENSION GRANTED UNDER SECTION 302(D), THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY CONDUCT ONE OR MORE PUBLIC HEARINGS ON THE PROPOSED COVERED 20250HB1460PN3687 - 31 - TRANSACTION.
(B) ACCESSIBILITY.-- (1) IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL CONDUCTS A PUBLIC HEARING UNDER SUBSECTION (A), THE PUBLIC HEARING SHALL BE LIVE- STREAMED ON THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S PUBLICLY ACCESSIBLE INTERNET WEBSITE.
(2) A VIDEO RECORDING OF THE PUBLIC HEARING SHALL BE POSTED ON THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S PUBLICLY ACCESSIBLE INTERNET WEBSITE.
(C) SPECIFIC ENTITIES.--IF A COVERED TRANSACTION INVOLVES THE ACQUISITION OF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING IN ANY COUNTY IN WHICH THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY IS LOCATED TO HEAR COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL HAVE DISCRETION TO ESTABLISH THE FORM AND MANNER OF ALL PUBLIC HEARINGS HELD UNDER THIS SUBSECTION, BUT SHALL ALLOW ALL INTERESTED PARTIES TO SUBMIT WRITTEN TESTIMONY FOR THE RECORD.
INTERESTED PARTIES SHALL INCLUDE EMPLOYEES OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY, LEGAL AID ORGANIZATIONS, HEALTH ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS, PUBLIC OFFICIALS WHO REPRESENT THE AFFECTED COMMUNITY AND RESIDENTS OF THE AFFECTED COMMUNITY.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY REQUEST TESTIMONY AT A HEARING FROM STATE AGENCIES SUBJECT TO SECTION 306(D).
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY ALSO ACCEPT TESTIMONY AND COMMENTS AT THE PUBLIC HEARING FROM OTHER RELATED INTERESTED PARTIES, INCLUDING HEALTH CARE ADVOCACY GROUPS, PROVIDERS, PATIENTS AND CAREGIVERS.
(D) NOTICE.--AT LEAST 14 DAYS BEFORE THE DATE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL PROVIDE WRITTEN NOTICE OF THE DATE, TIME AND PLACE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING:
(1) ON THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S PUBLICLY ACCESSIBLE INTERNET WEBSITE.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 32 - (2) THROUGH SOCIAL AND BROADCAST MEDIA.
(3) THROUGH PUBLICATION IN ONE OR MORE NEWSPAPERS OF GENERAL CIRCULATION IN THE AFFECTED COMMUNITY.
(4) TO THE GOVERNING BODY OF EACH COUNTY AND MUNICIPALITY WITHIN THE AFFECTED COMMUNITY.
(E) SUBSTANTIVE CHANGES TO PROPOSAL.--IF A SUBSTANTIVE CHANGE IN THE COVERED TRANSACTION IS SUBMITTED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AFTER THE INITIAL PUBLIC HEARING, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY CONDUCT AN ADDITIONAL PUBLIC HEARING TO HEAR COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES WITH RESPECT TO THE CHANGE.
SECTION 304.
OBJECTIONS BY ATTORNEY GENERAL.
(A) NOTICE.--NO LATER THAN THE FINAL DATE OF EXPIRATION OF THE RESPECTIVE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SECTION 302(C), ALONG WITH ANY EXTENSION GRANTED UNDER SECTION 302(D), THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL ISSUE A WRITTEN NOTICE TO THE COVERED ENTITY AND HEALTH CARE ENTITY EXPLAINING WHETHER THE COVERED TRANSACTION IS LIKELY TO HAVE AN IMPACT THAT IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST.
(B) DEPARTMENT INPUT.--PRIOR TO MAKING A DETERMINATION WHETHER A COVERED TRANSACTION IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL CONSULT WITH THE DEPARTMENT REGARDING THE COVERED TRANSACTION'S POTENTIAL IMPACT ON THE EXISTING PATIENT BASE AND AFFECTED COMMUNITY.
(C) ACTION.--IF THE VIEW OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH THE DEPARTMENT, IS THAT THE PROPOSED COVERED TRANSACTION IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, ON BEHALF OF THE COMMONWEALTH, MAY:
(1) NO LATER THAN 30 DAYS AFTER ISSUING A WRITTEN NOTICE UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OR THE FINAL DATE OF EXPIRATION OF THE RESPECTIVE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER SECTION 302, WHICHEVER IS LATER, COMMENCE AN ACTION IN A COURT OF COMPETENT 20250HB1460PN3687 - 33 - JURISDICTION TO ENJOIN THE COVERED TRANSACTION;
OR (2) ENTER INTO AN ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE WITH THE COVERED ENTITY AND THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY, WHICH SHALL BE FILED WITH COMMONWEALTH COURT, THAT IMPOSES CONDITIONS OR OTHERWISE MITIGATES THE ASPECTS THAT MAKE THE COVERED TRANSACTION AGAINST THE PUBLIC INTEREST.
(D) MONITORING.-- (1) AN ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE ENTERED INTO UNDER SUBSECTION (C) SHALL INCLUDE AN INITIAL MONITORING PERIOD OF NOT MORE THAN FIVE YEARS.
THE MONITORING PERIOD MAY BE EXTENDED FOR AN ADDITIONAL PERIOD OF NOT MORE THAN FIVE YEARS AT THE DISCRETION OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL CONSULT WITH THE DEPARTMENT PRIOR TO SETTING THE LENGTH OF THE INITIAL MONITORING PERIOD AND ANY EXTENSION.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL CONSULT WITH THE DEPARTMENT TO ESTABLISH ANY DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES THAT THE DEPARTMENT MAY BE REQUIRED TO PERFORM TO ENSURE THAT THE COVERED ENTITY AND HEALTH CARE ENTITY COMPLY WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE, INCLUDING MONITORING THE ONSITE OPERATIONS OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY.
(4) DURING THE MONITORING PERIOD, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AND THE DEPARTMENT, AS NECESSARY, SHALL MONITOR, EVALUATE AND ASSESS THE COVERED ENTITY AND HEALTH CARE ENTITY TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE.
(E) COSTS OF MONITORING.-- (1) THE COVERED ENTITY SHALL PAY FOR THE COSTS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S AND THE DEPARTMENT'S MONITORING, 20250HB1460PN3687 - 34 - EVALUATION AND ASSESSMENT OF THE COVERED ENTITY'S AND HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE DURING A MONITORING PERIOD ESTABLISHED UNDER SUBSECTION (D).
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE DEPARTMENT, SHALL DETERMINE THE AMOUNT OF THE COMPLIANCE MONITORING COST UNDER THIS SUBSECTION, WHICH SHALL BE:
(I) INCLUDED IN THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE;
(II) PAID BY THE COVERED ENTITY;
AND (III) PLACED IN AN ESCROW ACCOUNT DURING THE MONITORING PERIOD.
(F) LICENSING.--A HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S LICENSE MAY NOT BE REVOKED, DENIED, IMPEDED OR CITED FOR NONCOMPLIANCE DUE SOLELY TO A FILING OR REVIEW UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
SECTION 305.
COMPLIANCE AND POWER OF COURT.
IF A PERSON SUBSTANTIALLY FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENT UNDER SECTION 302(A) OR ANY REQUEST FOR THE SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL UNDER SECTION 302(B) WITHIN THE RESPECTIVE REVIEW PERIOD UNDER 302(C), ALONG WITH ANY EXTENSION GRANTED UNDER SECTION 302(D), THE COURT MAY, IN ITS DISCRETION, DO ANY OR ALL OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) ORDER COMPLIANCE.
(2) EXTEND THE REVIEW PERIOD UNTIL THERE HAS BEEN SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE.
(3) GRANT OTHER EQUITABLE RELIEF AS THE COURT DETERMINES NECESSARY OR APPROPRIATE.
SECTION 306.
POWERS AND DUTIES OF ATTORNEY GENERAL.
(A) RULES AND REGULATIONS.--THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, IN 20250HB1460PN3687 - 35 - CONSULTATION WITH THE DEPARTMENT, SHALL ISSUE RULES AND PROMULGATE REGULATIONS AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT AND ENFORCE THIS CHAPTER.
(B) CONTRACTS.-- (1) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY DO ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:
(I) CONTRACT WITH, SHARE INFORMATION WITH AND CONSULT AND RECEIVE ADVICE FROM ANY FEDERAL AGENCY OR COMMONWEALTH AGENCY AS THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DEEMS APPROPRIATE TO IMPLEMENT THIS CHAPTER.
(II) AT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S SOLE DISCRETION, CONTRACT WITH EXPERTS OR CONSULTANTS TO ASSIST IN REVIEWING THE PROPOSED COVERED TRANSACTION.
(2) THE COST OF A CONTRACT ENTERED INTO UNDER PARAGRAPH (1) MUST BE AN AMOUNT THAT IS REASONABLE AND NECESSARY TO CONDUCT THE REVIEW AND EVALUATION.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL BE ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE COVERED ENTITY SEEKING CONSENT FOR THE COVERED TRANSACTION FOR ALL ACTUAL, REASONABLE AND DIRECT COSTS INCURRED IN REVIEWING, EVALUATING AND MAKING A DETERMINATION UNDER SECTION 304(A), INCLUDING ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS.
THE COVERED ENTITY SHALL PAY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE REQUEST FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY PROVIDE ADDITIONAL TIME FOR THE COVERED ENTITY TO PAY COSTS UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH, NOT TO EXCEED 90 ADDITIONAL DAYS.
IF THE TRANSACTION INVOLVES A MERGER OR ACQUISITION, THE FOLLOWING SHALL APPLY:
(I) NEITHER THE ATTORNEY GENERAL NOR THE COVERED ENTITY MAY SEEK REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY FOR ANY COSTS UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH.
THE COVERED ENTITY SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL OF THE COSTS.
AS PART OF ANY 20250HB1460PN3687 - 36 - SETTLEMENT, COURT DECREE OR OTHER AGREEMENT, THE COVERED ENTITY MUST AGREE TO NOT RECOUP ANY OF THE COVERED ENTITY'S SHARE OF THE COSTS FROM THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY.
(II) A COVERED ENTITY MAY PETITION A COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDICTION FOR A WAIVER OF ANY OR ALL OF THE COVERED ENTITY'S COSTS DUE TO FINANCIAL HARDSHIP OR OTHER FACTORS AS THE COURT DETERMINES FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN.
THE COURT SHALL DETERMINE WHETHER THE COVERED ENTITY INTENTIONALLY AND KNOWINGLY MISMANAGED ITS FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE OF BECOMING FINANCIALLY DISTRESSED TO OBTAIN APPROVAL UNDER THIS SUBPARAGRAPH.
IF THE COURT FINDS THAT THE COVERED ENTITY INTENTIONALLY AND KNOWINGLY MISMANAGED THE COVERED ENTITY'S FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE OF BECOMING FINANCIALLY DISTRESSED TO OBTAIN APPROVAL UNDER THIS SUBPARAGRAPH, THE COURT MAY NOT GRANT THE WAIVER PETITION.
(III) IF, IN THE VIEW OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, PAYMENT OF COSTS WILL PREVENT THE COVERED TRANSACTION FROM BEING CONSUMMATED, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY, AT ITS OWN DISCRETION, OR AT THE REQUEST OF THE COVERED ENTITY, WAIVE ANY OR ALL OF THE COVERED ENTITY'S COSTS.
(4) NOTWITHSTANDING ANY OTHER PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT, A COVERED TRANSACTION MAY NOT BE COMPLETED UNLESS AN AGREEMENT HAS BEEN EXECUTED BETWEEN THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AND THE COVERED ENTITY FOR THE PAYMENT OF COSTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SUBSECTION.
(C) COMPLIANCE.--IF A COVERED ENTITY OR HEALTH CARE ENTITY ENTERS INTO AN ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE WITH THE COMMONWEALTH UNDER SECTION 304(C)(2):
(1) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL MONITOR, ASSESS AND 20250HB1460PN3687 - 37 - EVALUATE A COVERED ENTITY AND HEALTH CARE ENTITY TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE FOR THE DURATION OF THE MONITORING PERIOD ESTABLISHED UNDER SECTION 304(D).
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY REQUEST DOCUMENTS AND OTHER INFORMATION FROM A COVERED ENTITY OR A HEALTH CARE ENTITY, OR BOTH, TO MONITOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE UNDER SECTION 304(C).
UPON RECEIVING A REQUEST FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, A COVERED ENTITY OR HEALTH CARE ENTITY SHALL RESPOND TO THE REQUEST WITHIN 30 DAYS.
(3) IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DETERMINES THAT THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR COVERED ENTITY HAS FAILED TO COMPLY WITH TERMS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY SEEK IMMEDIATE RELIEF IN COMMONWEALTH COURT TO ENFORCE THE CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE, AND THE COMMONWEALTH COURT MAY IMPOSE ANY PENALTIES AUTHORIZED BY LAW OR THE TERMS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE.
(4) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL BE REIMBURSED FROM AN ESCROW ACCOUNT ESTABLISHED UNDER SECTION 304(E) FOR COSTS RELATED TO THE ONGOING MONITORING, ASSESSMENT AND EVALUATION OF A COVERED ENTITY'S OR HEALTH CARE ENTITY'S COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE DURING THE MONITORING PERIOD.
(D) AGENCY COOPERATION.-- (1) EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROHIBITED BY FEDERAL OR STATE LAW OR A COURT ORDER, THE DEPARTMENT, THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT SHALL ASSIST THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IN REVIEWING THE PROPOSED AGREEMENT AND 20250HB1460PN3687 - 38 - TRANSACTION, IF REQUESTED, AND SHALL COMPLY WITH ANY REQUEST FOR TESTIMONY OR INFORMATION AS MAY BE NECESSARY AND APPROPRIATE FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO REVIEW A PROPOSED COVERED TRANSACTION.
(2) EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROHIBITED BY FEDERAL OR STATE LAW OR A COURT ORDER, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL COMPLY WITH ANY REQUEST FOR INFORMATION FROM THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT AS MAY BE NECESSARY AND APPROPRIATE FOR THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT TO CONCURRENTLY REVIEW A PROPOSED TRANSACTION UNDER ARTICLE XIV OF THE ACT OF MAY 17, 1921 (P.L.682, NO.284), KNOWN AS THE INSURANCE COMPANY LAW OF 1921.
DOCUMENTS PROVIDED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH SHALL BE TREATED AS CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 308.
(3) EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROHIBITED BY FEDERAL OR STATE LAW OR A COURT ORDER, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL COMPLY WITH ANY REQUEST FOR INFORMATION FROM THE DEPARTMENT AS MAY BE NECESSARY AND APPROPRIATE TO CONCURRENTLY REVIEW A PROPOSED TRANSACTION UNDER THE ACT OF JULY 19, 1979 (P.L.130, NO.48), KNOWN AS THE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES ACT.
DOCUMENTS PROVIDED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO THE DEPARTMENT UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH SHALL BE TREATED AS CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 308.
SECTION 307.
POWERS AND DUTIES OF DEPARTMENT.
(A) (RESERVED).
(B) COMPLIANCE MONITORING.--IF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR COVERED ENTITY ENTERS INTO AN ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE ENTITY WITH THE COMMONWEALTH UNDER SECTION 304(C):
(1) AFTER CONSULTATION WITH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THE DEPARTMENT SHALL MONITOR, ASSESS AND EVALUATE A HEALTH CARE 20250HB1460PN3687 - 39 - ENTITY AND COVERED ENTITY TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE.
IF THE DEPARTMENT DETERMINES THAT THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR COVERED ENTITY HAS FAILED TO COMPLY WITH TERMS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE, THE DEPARTMENT SHALL IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ITS FINDINGS.
(2) THE DEPARTMENT MAY REQUEST DOCUMENTS AND OTHER INFORMATION FROM A COVERED ENTITY OR A HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR BOTH TO MONITOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE UNDER SECTION 304(C).
UPON RECEIVING A REQUEST FROM THE DEPARTMENT, A COVERED ENTITY OR HEALTH CARE ENTITY SHALL RESPOND TO THE REQUEST WITHIN 30 DAYS.
(3) THE DEPARTMENT SHALL BE REIMBURSED FROM AN ESCROW ACCOUNT ESTABLISHED UNDER SECTION 304(E) FOR COSTS RELATED TO THE ONGOING MONITORING, ASSESSMENT AND EVALUATION OF A HEALTH CARE ENTITY AND COVERED ENTITY'S COMPLIANCE WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE ASSURANCE OF VOLUNTARY COMPLIANCE DURING THE MONITORING PERIOD.
THE DEPARTMENT MAY NOT BE REIMBURSED FROM THE ESCROW ACCOUNT FOR EXPENSES THAT WOULD BE OTHERWISE CONSIDERED NORMAL OPERATIONAL EXPENSES, INCLUDING MONITORING VISITS FOR COMPLIANCE TO FEDERAL AND STATE REGULATIONS.
SECTION 308.
CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT.
(A) CONFIDENTIALITY.--ALL INFORMATION, DOCUMENTS, MATERIALS AND COPIES THEREOF IN THE POSSESSION OR CONTROL OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OR THE DEPARTMENT THAT ARE PRODUCED FOR, OBTAINED BY OR DISCLOSED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OR THE DEPARTMENT IN THE COURSE OF A COVERED ENTITY, HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR COMMONWEALTH AGENCY COMPLYING WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 302(B), 303(A), 306(C) OR (D) OR 307(B) SHALL BE PRIVILEGED AND GIVEN 20250HB1460PN3687 - 40 - CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT AND SHALL NOT BE:
(1) SUBJECT TO DISCOVERY OR ADMISSIBLE IN EVIDENCE IN A PRIVATE CIVIL ACTION.
(2) SUBJECT TO SUBPOENA.
(3) SUBJECT TO THE ACT OF FEBRUARY 14, 2008 (P.L.6, NO.3), KNOWN AS THE RIGHT-TO-KNOW LAW.
(4) MADE PUBLIC BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THE DEPARTMENT OR ANY OTHER PERSON, EXCEPT TO REGULATORY OR LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS OF THIS COMMONWEALTH OR OTHER JURISDICTIONS OR EXPERTS OR CONSULTANTS UNDER CONTRACT WITH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL UNDER SECTION 306(B), WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE HEALTH CARE ENTITY OR COVERED ENTITY TO WHICH IT PERTAINS.
(B) TESTIFYING IN A CIVIL ACTION.--THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THE DEPARTMENT, ANY OTHER COMMONWEALTH AGENCY OR ANY INDIVIDUAL OR PERSON, WHO RECEIVES DOCUMENTS, MATERIALS OR OTHER INFORMATION, WHILE ACTING UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OR THE DEPARTMENT, OR WITH WHOM THE DOCUMENTS, MATERIALS OR OTHER INFORMATION ARE SHARED UNDER THIS CHAPTER, SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED OR REQUIRED TO TESTIFY IN ANY PRIVATE CIVIL ACTION CONCERNING ANY CONFIDENTIAL DOCUMENTS, MATERIALS OR INFORMATION COVERED UNDER THIS SECTION.
CHAPTER 10 MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS SECTION 1001.
CONSTRUCTION.
THIS ACT SHALL NOT BE CONSTRUED TO:
(1) NARROW, ABROGATE OR OTHERWISE ALTER THE AUTHORITY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO MAINTAIN COMPETITIVE MARKETS AND PROSECUTE OR ENFORCE VIOLATIONS OF ANTITRUST AND UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES LAWS.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 41 - (2) NARROW, ABROGATE OR OTHERWISE ALTER THE AUTHORITY OF THE DEPARTMENT TO OVERSEE AND APPROVE OR DISAPPROVE THE CHANGE OF OWNERSHIP OF OR REGULATE A HEALTH CARE FACILITY UNDER THE ACT OF JULY 19, 1979 (P.L.130, NO.48), KNOWN AS THE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES ACT.
(3) PROHIBIT A FEDERAL AGENCY, COMMONWEALTH AGENCY OR OTHER STATE AGENCY FROM REGULATING A COVERED TRANSACTION OR JOINING AS PARTY IN AN ACTION SEEKING TO ENJOIN A COVERED TRANSACTION, INCLUDING THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT'S JURISDICTION TO REVIEW AN EXPOSED TRANSACTION UNDER ARTICLE XIV OF THE ACT OF MAY 17, 1921 (P.L.682, NO.284), KNOWN AS THE INSURANCE COMPANY LAW OF 1921.
SECTION 1002.
STUDY AND REPORT BY LEGISLATIVE BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE.
NO LATER THAN THREE YEARS FROM THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION, THE LEGISLATIVE BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE SHALL PERFORM A STUDY ON THE EFFECTS OF THIS CHAPTER AND THE IMPACTS OF PRIVATE EQUITY ON THIS COMMONWEALTH'S HEALTH CARE SYSTEM AND SHALL REPORT ITS FINDINGS TO THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE OF THE SENATE, THE MINORITY LEADER OF THE SENATE, THE SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES AND THE MINORITY LEADER OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
SECTION 1003.
EFFECTIVE DATE.
THIS ACT SHALL TAKE EFFECT IN 180 DAYS.
20250HB1460PN3687 - 42 -
View plain text versions (4)

Action History

  1. First consideration

  2. Reported as amended

  3. Referred to Institutional Sustainability & Innovation

  4. Third consideration and final passage

  5. Re-reported as committed

  6. Re-committed to Appropriations

  7. Second consideration, with amendments

  8. Re-reported as committed

  9. Re-committed to Rules

  10. First consideration

  11. Reported as amended

  12. Referred to Health

Sponsors

Sponsorship breakdown

Export CSV (upgrade) →

1 sponsors · 31 co-sponsors · 221 not signed on · 172 voted No

Sponsors (1)

Co-sponsors (31)

Not signed on (221)

221 members have not signed on to this bill.

Show all 221 →

"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.

Whip count is in markup. Polling the chamber and every recorded vote this session. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Calling the roll · Tallying · Engrossing

Votes

Passed 9 Yea · 2 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Republican 7000
Democratic 2200
Total 9200
% of votes cast 82%18%0%0%
How each member voted (11)
Member Party Vote
Art Haywood Democratic Yea
Maria Collett Democratic Nay
Steven J. Santarsiero Democratic Nay
Timothy P. Kearney Democratic Yea
Chris Gebhard Republican Yea
David G. Argall Republican Yea
Devlin J. Robinson Republican Yea
Frank A. Farry Republican Yea
Judy Ward Republican Yea
Kim L. Ward Republican Yea
Michele Brooks Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Passed 8 Yea · 3 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Republican 7000
Democratic 1300
Total 8300
% of votes cast 73%27%0%0%
How each member voted (11)
Member Party Vote
Art Haywood Democratic Nay
Maria Collett Democratic Nay
Steven J. Santarsiero Democratic Nay
Timothy P. Kearney Democratic Yea
Chris Gebhard Republican Yea
David G. Argall Republican Yea
Devlin J. Robinson Republican Yea
Frank A. Farry Republican Yea
Judy Ward Republican Yea
Kim L. Ward Republican Yea
Michele Brooks Republican Yea

Official roll call →

FINAL PASSAGE

Passed 121 Yea · 82 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 99100
Republican 207700
Unaffiliated 2400
Total 1218200
% of votes cast 60%40%0%0%
How each member voted (203)
Member Party Vote
Dan Miller — Yea
Joshua Siegel — Yea
Louis Schmitt — Nay
Seth Grove — Nay
Stephenie Scialabba — Nay
Torren Ecker — Nay
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Yea
Aerion Abney Democratic Yea
Amen Brown Democratic Yea
Andre D. Carroll Democratic Yea
Anita Astorino Kulik Democratic Yea
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Yea
Arvind Venkat Democratic Nay
Ben Waxman Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Brandon J. Markosek Democratic Yea
Brian Munroe Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Carol Hill-Evans Democratic Yea
Carol Kazeem Democratic Yea
Chris Pielli Democratic Yea
Christina D. Sappey Democratic Yea
Christopher M. Rabb Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Dan Goughnour Democratic Yea
Dan K. Williams Democratic Yea
Daniel J. Deasy Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Danilo Burgos Democratic Yea
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Yea
Dave Madsen Democratic Yea
David M. Delloso Democratic Yea
Ed Neilson Democratic Yea
Eddie Day Pashinski Democratic Yea
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Yea
Emily Kinkead Democratic Yea
Frank Burns Democratic Yea
G. Roni Green Democratic Yea
Gina H. Curry Democratic Yea
Greg Scott Democratic Yea
Greg Vitali Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Ismail Smith-Wade-El Democratic Yea
Jacklyn Rusnock Democratic Yea
Jared G. Solomon Democratic Yea
Jason Dawkins Democratic Yea
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Yea
Jennifer O'Mara Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Jim Haddock Democratic Yea
Jim Prokopiak Democratic Yea
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Yea
Joe Ciresi Democratic Yea
Joe McAndrew Democratic Yea
Joe Webster Democratic Yea
Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz Democratic Yea
John C. Inglis III Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Jose Giral Democratic Yea
Joseph C. Hohenstein Democratic Yea
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Yea
Keith S. Harris Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
Kyle Donahue Democratic Yea
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Leanne Krueger Democratic Yea
Lindsay Powell Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Yea
Mandy Steele Democratic Yea
Manuel Guzman Democratic Yea
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Yea
MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Yea
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Yea
Maureen E. Madden Democratic Yea
Melissa Cerrato Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Yea
Morgan Cephas Democratic Yea
Nancy Guenst Democratic Yea
Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Yea
Nathan Davidson Democratic Yea
Nikki Rivera Democratic Yea
Pat Gallagher Democratic Yea
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Yea
Paul Friel Democratic Yea
Paul Takac Democratic Yea
Perry S. Warren Democratic Yea
Peter Schweyer Democratic Yea
Regina G. Young Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Robert E. Merski Democratic Yea
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Yea
Robert Freeman Democratic Yea
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Yea
Scott Conklin Democratic Yea
Sean Dougherty Democratic Yea
Steve Samuelson Democratic Yea
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Yea
Tarah Probst Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Tim Brennan Democratic Yea
Tim Briggs Democratic Yea
Tina M. Davis Democratic Yea
Aaron Bernstine Republican Nay
Abby Major Republican Yea
Alec J. Ryncavage Republican Yea
Andrew Kuzma Republican Yea
Ann Flood Republican Nay
Barbara Gleim Republican Nay
Brad Roae Republican Nay
Brenda M. Pugh Republican Yea
Brett R. Miller Republican Yea
Brian C. Rasel Republican Nay
Brian Smith Republican Nay
Bryan Cutler Republican Nay
Bud Cook Republican Nay
Carl Walker Metzgar Republican Nay
Chad G. Reichard Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Nay
Clint Owlett Republican Nay
Craig T. Staats Republican Nay
Craig Williams Republican Yea
Dallas Kephart Republican Nay
Dan Moul Republican Nay
Dane Watro Republican Yea
David H. Rowe Republican Nay
David H. Zimmerman Republican Nay
David M. Maloney Republican Nay
Donna Scheuren Republican Nay
Doyle Heffley Republican Nay
Eric Davanzo Republican Nay
Eric J. Weaknecht Republican Nay
Eric R. Nelson Republican Nay
Gary W. Day Republican Nay
Jack Rader Republican Nay
Jacob D. Banta Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jamie Barton Republican Nay
Jamie L. Flick Republican Nay
Jamie Walsh Republican Nay
Jason Ortitay Republican Yea
Jeff Olsommer Republican Nay
Jeremy Shaffer Republican Nay
Jesse Topper Republican Nay
Jill N. Cooper Republican Nay
Jim Rigby Republican Nay
Joanne Stehr Republican Nay
Joe Emrick Republican Yea
Joe Hamm Republican Nay
Joe Hogan Republican Yea
Joe Kerwin Republican Yea
John A. Lawrence Republican Nay
John A. Schlegel Republican Nay
Jonathan Fritz Republican Nay
Joseph D'Orsie Republican Nay
Josh Bashline Republican Nay
Joshua D. Kail Republican Nay
Kate A. Klunk Republican Nay
Kathleen C. Tomlinson Republican Yea
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Nay
Keith J. Greiner Republican Nay
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Nay
Kristin Marcell Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Nay
Marc S. Anderson Republican Nay
Marci Mustello Republican Nay
Mark M. Gillen Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Martin T. Causer Republican Yea
Martina A. White Republican Nay
Michael Stender Republican Nay
Mike Armanini Republican Nay
Mike Jones Republican Nay
Milou Mackenzie Republican Nay
Mindy Fee Republican Nay
Natalie Mihalek Republican Nay
Parke Wentling Republican Yea
Perry A. Stambaugh Republican Nay
R. Lee James Republican Yea
Rich Irvin Republican Nay
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Nay
Robert Leadbeter Republican Nay
Roman Kozak Republican Nay
Russ Diamond Republican Nay
Ryan Warner Republican Nay
Scott Barger Republican Nay
Shelby Labs Republican Yea
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Nay
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Nay
Steven C. Mentzer Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Thomas L. Mehaffie Republican Yea
Tim Twardzik Republican Nay
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Nay
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea
Tina Pickett Republican Yea
Tom Jones Republican Nay
Valerie S. Gaydos Republican Nay
Wendy Fink Republican Nay
Zachary Mako Republican Nay

Official roll call →

Passed 22 Yea · 15 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 21000
Unaffiliated 1100
Republican 01400
Total 221500
% of votes cast 59%41%0%0%
How each member voted (37)
Member Party Vote
Joshua Siegel — Yea
Torren Ecker — Nay
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Yea
Aerion Abney Democratic Yea
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Yea
Ben Waxman Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Dave Madsen Democratic Yea
Emily Kinkead Democratic Yea
Gina H. Curry Democratic Yea
Joe Webster Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Yea
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Manuel Guzman Democratic Yea
Pat Gallagher Democratic Yea
Paul Friel Democratic Yea
Regina G. Young Democratic Yea
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Tim Brennan Democratic Yea
Ann Flood Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Nay
Eric Davanzo Republican Nay
Eric R. Nelson Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jamie Barton Republican Nay
Jeff Olsommer Republican Nay
Joshua D. Kail Republican Nay
Kristin Marcell Republican Nay
Marci Mustello Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Ryan Warner Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Zachary Mako Republican Nay

Official roll call →

Passed 18 Yea · 15 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 18000
Republican 01500
Total 181500
% of votes cast 55%45%0%0%
How each member voted (33)
Member Party Vote
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Yea
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Yea
Jason Dawkins Democratic Yea
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Yea
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Leanne Krueger Democratic Yea
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Yea
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Yea
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Yea
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Yea
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Yea
Tina M. Davis Democratic Yea
Bryan Cutler Republican Nay
Clint Owlett Republican Nay
David H. Rowe Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jesse Topper Republican Nay
John A. Lawrence Republican Nay
Jonathan Fritz Republican Nay
Kate A. Klunk Republican Nay
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Nay
Martina A. White Republican Nay
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Nay
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Nay
Tina Pickett Republican Nay

Official roll call →

A914

Passed 133 Yea · 69 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 100000
Republican 316600
Unaffiliated 2301
Total 1336901
% of votes cast 66%34%0%0%
How each member voted (203)
Member Party Vote
Torren Ecker — Nay
Seth Grove — Not Voting
Dan Miller — Yea
Louis Schmitt — Nay
Stephenie Scialabba — Nay
Joshua Siegel — Yea
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Yea
Aerion Abney Democratic Yea
Amen Brown Democratic Yea
Andre D. Carroll Democratic Yea
Anita Astorino Kulik Democratic Yea
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Yea
Arvind Venkat Democratic Yea
Ben Waxman Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Brandon J. Markosek Democratic Yea
Brian Munroe Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Carol Hill-Evans Democratic Yea
Carol Kazeem Democratic Yea
Chris Pielli Democratic Yea
Christina D. Sappey Democratic Yea
Christopher M. Rabb Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Dan Goughnour Democratic Yea
Dan K. Williams Democratic Yea
Daniel J. Deasy Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Danilo Burgos Democratic Yea
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Yea
Dave Madsen Democratic Yea
David M. Delloso Democratic Yea
Ed Neilson Democratic Yea
Eddie Day Pashinski Democratic Yea
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Yea
Emily Kinkead Democratic Yea
Frank Burns Democratic Yea
G. Roni Green Democratic Yea
Gina H. Curry Democratic Yea
Greg Scott Democratic Yea
Greg Vitali Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Ismail Smith-Wade-El Democratic Yea
Jacklyn Rusnock Democratic Yea
Jared G. Solomon Democratic Yea
Jason Dawkins Democratic Yea
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Yea
Jennifer O'Mara Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Jim Haddock Democratic Yea
Jim Prokopiak Democratic Yea
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Yea
Joe Ciresi Democratic Yea
Joe McAndrew Democratic Yea
Joe Webster Democratic Yea
Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz Democratic Yea
John C. Inglis III Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Jose Giral Democratic Yea
Joseph C. Hohenstein Democratic Yea
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Yea
Keith S. Harris Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
Kyle Donahue Democratic Yea
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Leanne Krueger Democratic Yea
Lindsay Powell Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Yea
Mandy Steele Democratic Yea
Manuel Guzman Democratic Yea
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Yea
MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Yea
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Yea
Maureen E. Madden Democratic Yea
Melissa Cerrato Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Yea
Morgan Cephas Democratic Yea
Nancy Guenst Democratic Yea
Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Yea
Nathan Davidson Democratic Yea
Nikki Rivera Democratic Yea
Pat Gallagher Democratic Yea
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Yea
Paul Friel Democratic Yea
Paul Takac Democratic Yea
Perry S. Warren Democratic Yea
Peter Schweyer Democratic Yea
Regina G. Young Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Robert E. Merski Democratic Yea
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Yea
Robert Freeman Democratic Yea
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Yea
Scott Conklin Democratic Yea
Sean Dougherty Democratic Yea
Steve Samuelson Democratic Yea
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Yea
Tarah Probst Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Tim Brennan Democratic Yea
Tim Briggs Democratic Yea
Tina M. Davis Democratic Yea
Aaron Bernstine Republican Nay
Abby Major Republican Nay
Alec J. Ryncavage Republican Nay
Andrew Kuzma Republican Yea
Ann Flood Republican Nay
Barbara Gleim Republican Yea
Brad Roae Republican Yea
Brenda M. Pugh Republican Nay
Brett R. Miller Republican Yea
Brian C. Rasel Republican Nay
Brian Smith Republican Nay
Bryan Cutler Republican Nay
Bud Cook Republican Yea
Carl Walker Metzgar Republican Nay
Chad G. Reichard Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Nay
Clint Owlett Republican Nay
Craig T. Staats Republican Nay
Craig Williams Republican Nay
Dallas Kephart Republican Nay
Dan Moul Republican Yea
Dane Watro Republican Nay
David H. Rowe Republican Nay
David H. Zimmerman Republican Yea
David M. Maloney Republican Yea
Donna Scheuren Republican Yea
Doyle Heffley Republican Nay
Eric Davanzo Republican Nay
Eric J. Weaknecht Republican Nay
Eric R. Nelson Republican Nay
Gary W. Day Republican Nay
Jack Rader Republican Nay
Jacob D. Banta Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jamie Barton Republican Nay
Jamie L. Flick Republican Nay
Jamie Walsh Republican Nay
Jason Ortitay Republican Nay
Jeff Olsommer Republican Nay
Jeremy Shaffer Republican Yea
Jesse Topper Republican Nay
Jill N. Cooper Republican Nay
Jim Rigby Republican Nay
Joanne Stehr Republican Nay
Joe Emrick Republican Nay
Joe Hamm Republican Nay
Joe Hogan Republican Yea
Joe Kerwin Republican Yea
John A. Lawrence Republican Nay
John A. Schlegel Republican Nay
Jonathan Fritz Republican Nay
Joseph D'Orsie Republican Nay
Josh Bashline Republican Nay
Joshua D. Kail Republican Nay
Kate A. Klunk Republican Nay
Kathleen C. Tomlinson Republican Yea
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Yea
Keith J. Greiner Republican Yea
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Yea
Kristin Marcell Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Nay
Marc S. Anderson Republican Nay
Marci Mustello Republican Nay
Mark M. Gillen Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Martin T. Causer Republican Yea
Martina A. White Republican Nay
Michael Stender Republican Nay
Mike Armanini Republican Yea
Mike Jones Republican Yea
Milou Mackenzie Republican Nay
Mindy Fee Republican Yea
Natalie Mihalek Republican Nay
Parke Wentling Republican Yea
Perry A. Stambaugh Republican Nay
R. Lee James Republican Yea
Rich Irvin Republican Nay
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Nay
Robert Leadbeter Republican Yea
Roman Kozak Republican Nay
Russ Diamond Republican Nay
Ryan Warner Republican Nay
Scott Barger Republican Nay
Shelby Labs Republican Yea
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Nay
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Nay
Steven C. Mentzer Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Thomas L. Mehaffie Republican Yea
Tim Twardzik Republican Yea
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Nay
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea
Tina Pickett Republican Nay
Tom Jones Republican Yea
Valerie S. Gaydos Republican Yea
Wendy Fink Republican Yea
Zachary Mako Republican Nay

Official roll call →

A907

Passed 130 Yea · 72 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 100000
Republican 286900
Unaffiliated 2301
Total 1307201
% of votes cast 64%35%0%0%
How each member voted (203)
Member Party Vote
Torren Ecker — Nay
Seth Grove — Not Voting
Dan Miller — Yea
Louis Schmitt — Nay
Stephenie Scialabba — Nay
Joshua Siegel — Yea
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Yea
Aerion Abney Democratic Yea
Amen Brown Democratic Yea
Andre D. Carroll Democratic Yea
Anita Astorino Kulik Democratic Yea
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Yea
Arvind Venkat Democratic Yea
Ben Waxman Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Brandon J. Markosek Democratic Yea
Brian Munroe Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Carol Hill-Evans Democratic Yea
Carol Kazeem Democratic Yea
Chris Pielli Democratic Yea
Christina D. Sappey Democratic Yea
Christopher M. Rabb Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Dan Goughnour Democratic Yea
Dan K. Williams Democratic Yea
Daniel J. Deasy Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Danilo Burgos Democratic Yea
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Yea
Dave Madsen Democratic Yea
David M. Delloso Democratic Yea
Ed Neilson Democratic Yea
Eddie Day Pashinski Democratic Yea
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Yea
Emily Kinkead Democratic Yea
Frank Burns Democratic Yea
G. Roni Green Democratic Yea
Gina H. Curry Democratic Yea
Greg Scott Democratic Yea
Greg Vitali Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Ismail Smith-Wade-El Democratic Yea
Jacklyn Rusnock Democratic Yea
Jared G. Solomon Democratic Yea
Jason Dawkins Democratic Yea
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Yea
Jennifer O'Mara Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Jim Haddock Democratic Yea
Jim Prokopiak Democratic Yea
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Yea
Joe Ciresi Democratic Yea
Joe McAndrew Democratic Yea
Joe Webster Democratic Yea
Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz Democratic Yea
John C. Inglis III Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Jose Giral Democratic Yea
Joseph C. Hohenstein Democratic Yea
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Yea
Keith S. Harris Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
Kyle Donahue Democratic Yea
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Leanne Krueger Democratic Yea
Lindsay Powell Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Yea
Mandy Steele Democratic Yea
Manuel Guzman Democratic Yea
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Yea
MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Yea
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Yea
Maureen E. Madden Democratic Yea
Melissa Cerrato Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Yea
Morgan Cephas Democratic Yea
Nancy Guenst Democratic Yea
Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Yea
Nathan Davidson Democratic Yea
Nikki Rivera Democratic Yea
Pat Gallagher Democratic Yea
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Yea
Paul Friel Democratic Yea
Paul Takac Democratic Yea
Perry S. Warren Democratic Yea
Peter Schweyer Democratic Yea
Regina G. Young Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Robert E. Merski Democratic Yea
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Yea
Robert Freeman Democratic Yea
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Yea
Scott Conklin Democratic Yea
Sean Dougherty Democratic Yea
Steve Samuelson Democratic Yea
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Yea
Tarah Probst Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Tim Brennan Democratic Yea
Tim Briggs Democratic Yea
Tina M. Davis Democratic Yea
Aaron Bernstine Republican Nay
Abby Major Republican Nay
Alec J. Ryncavage Republican Nay
Andrew Kuzma Republican Yea
Ann Flood Republican Nay
Barbara Gleim Republican Nay
Brad Roae Republican Yea
Brenda M. Pugh Republican Nay
Brett R. Miller Republican Yea
Brian C. Rasel Republican Nay
Brian Smith Republican Nay
Bryan Cutler Republican Nay
Bud Cook Republican Yea
Carl Walker Metzgar Republican Nay
Chad G. Reichard Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Nay
Clint Owlett Republican Nay
Craig T. Staats Republican Nay
Craig Williams Republican Nay
Dallas Kephart Republican Nay
Dan Moul Republican Yea
Dane Watro Republican Nay
David H. Rowe Republican Nay
David H. Zimmerman Republican Yea
David M. Maloney Republican Yea
Donna Scheuren Republican Yea
Doyle Heffley Republican Nay
Eric Davanzo Republican Nay
Eric J. Weaknecht Republican Nay
Eric R. Nelson Republican Nay
Gary W. Day Republican Nay
Jack Rader Republican Nay
Jacob D. Banta Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jamie Barton Republican Nay
Jamie L. Flick Republican Nay
Jamie Walsh Republican Nay
Jason Ortitay Republican Nay
Jeff Olsommer Republican Nay
Jeremy Shaffer Republican Nay
Jesse Topper Republican Nay
Jill N. Cooper Republican Nay
Jim Rigby Republican Nay
Joanne Stehr Republican Nay
Joe Emrick Republican Nay
Joe Hamm Republican Nay
Joe Hogan Republican Yea
Joe Kerwin Republican Yea
John A. Lawrence Republican Nay
John A. Schlegel Republican Nay
Jonathan Fritz Republican Nay
Joseph D'Orsie Republican Nay
Josh Bashline Republican Nay
Joshua D. Kail Republican Nay
Kate A. Klunk Republican Nay
Kathleen C. Tomlinson Republican Yea
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Yea
Keith J. Greiner Republican Yea
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Nay
Kristin Marcell Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Nay
Marc S. Anderson Republican Nay
Marci Mustello Republican Nay
Mark M. Gillen Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Martin T. Causer Republican Yea
Martina A. White Republican Nay
Michael Stender Republican Nay
Mike Armanini Republican Yea
Mike Jones Republican Yea
Milou Mackenzie Republican Nay
Mindy Fee Republican Yea
Natalie Mihalek Republican Nay
Parke Wentling Republican Yea
Perry A. Stambaugh Republican Nay
R. Lee James Republican Yea
Rich Irvin Republican Nay
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Nay
Robert Leadbeter Republican Yea
Roman Kozak Republican Nay
Russ Diamond Republican Nay
Ryan Warner Republican Nay
Scott Barger Republican Nay
Shelby Labs Republican Yea
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Nay
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Nay
Steven C. Mentzer Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Thomas L. Mehaffie Republican Yea
Tim Twardzik Republican Yea
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Nay
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea
Tina Pickett Republican Nay
Tom Jones Republican Yea
Valerie S. Gaydos Republican Yea
Wendy Fink Republican Yea
Zachary Mako Republican Nay

Official roll call →

MOTION TO TABLE

Passed 102 Yea · 100 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 100000
Republican 09700
Unaffiliated 2301
Total 10210001
% of votes cast 50%49%0%0%
How each member voted (203)
Member Party Vote
Torren Ecker — Nay
Seth Grove — Not Voting
Dan Miller — Yea
Louis Schmitt — Nay
Stephenie Scialabba — Nay
Joshua Siegel — Yea
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Yea
Aerion Abney Democratic Yea
Amen Brown Democratic Yea
Andre D. Carroll Democratic Yea
Anita Astorino Kulik Democratic Yea
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Yea
Arvind Venkat Democratic Yea
Ben Waxman Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Brandon J. Markosek Democratic Yea
Brian Munroe Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Carol Hill-Evans Democratic Yea
Carol Kazeem Democratic Yea
Chris Pielli Democratic Yea
Christina D. Sappey Democratic Yea
Christopher M. Rabb Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Dan Goughnour Democratic Yea
Dan K. Williams Democratic Yea
Daniel J. Deasy Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Danilo Burgos Democratic Yea
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Yea
Dave Madsen Democratic Yea
David M. Delloso Democratic Yea
Ed Neilson Democratic Yea
Eddie Day Pashinski Democratic Yea
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Yea
Emily Kinkead Democratic Yea
Frank Burns Democratic Yea
G. Roni Green Democratic Yea
Gina H. Curry Democratic Yea
Greg Scott Democratic Yea
Greg Vitali Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Ismail Smith-Wade-El Democratic Yea
Jacklyn Rusnock Democratic Yea
Jared G. Solomon Democratic Yea
Jason Dawkins Democratic Yea
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Yea
Jennifer O'Mara Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Jim Haddock Democratic Yea
Jim Prokopiak Democratic Yea
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Yea
Joe Ciresi Democratic Yea
Joe McAndrew Democratic Yea
Joe Webster Democratic Yea
Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz Democratic Yea
John C. Inglis III Democratic Yea
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Yea
Jose Giral Democratic Yea
Joseph C. Hohenstein Democratic Yea
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Yea
Keith S. Harris Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
Kyle Donahue Democratic Yea
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Leanne Krueger Democratic Yea
Lindsay Powell Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Yea
Mandy Steele Democratic Yea
Manuel Guzman Democratic Yea
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Yea
MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Yea
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Yea
Maureen E. Madden Democratic Yea
Melissa Cerrato Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Yea
Morgan Cephas Democratic Yea
Nancy Guenst Democratic Yea
Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Yea
Nathan Davidson Democratic Yea
Nikki Rivera Democratic Yea
Pat Gallagher Democratic Yea
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Yea
Paul Friel Democratic Yea
Paul Takac Democratic Yea
Perry S. Warren Democratic Yea
Peter Schweyer Democratic Yea
Regina G. Young Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Robert E. Merski Democratic Yea
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Yea
Robert Freeman Democratic Yea
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Yea
Scott Conklin Democratic Yea
Sean Dougherty Democratic Yea
Steve Samuelson Democratic Yea
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Yea
Tarah Probst Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Tim Brennan Democratic Yea
Tim Briggs Democratic Yea
Tina M. Davis Democratic Yea
Aaron Bernstine Republican Nay
Abby Major Republican Nay
Alec J. Ryncavage Republican Nay
Andrew Kuzma Republican Nay
Ann Flood Republican Nay
Barbara Gleim Republican Nay
Brad Roae Republican Nay
Brenda M. Pugh Republican Nay
Brett R. Miller Republican Nay
Brian C. Rasel Republican Nay
Brian Smith Republican Nay
Bryan Cutler Republican Nay
Bud Cook Republican Nay
Carl Walker Metzgar Republican Nay
Chad G. Reichard Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Nay
Clint Owlett Republican Nay
Craig T. Staats Republican Nay
Craig Williams Republican Nay
Dallas Kephart Republican Nay
Dan Moul Republican Nay
Dane Watro Republican Nay
David H. Rowe Republican Nay
David H. Zimmerman Republican Nay
David M. Maloney Republican Nay
Donna Scheuren Republican Nay
Doyle Heffley Republican Nay
Eric Davanzo Republican Nay
Eric J. Weaknecht Republican Nay
Eric R. Nelson Republican Nay
Gary W. Day Republican Nay
Jack Rader Republican Nay
Jacob D. Banta Republican Nay
James B. Struzzi Republican Nay
Jamie Barton Republican Nay
Jamie L. Flick Republican Nay
Jamie Walsh Republican Nay
Jason Ortitay Republican Nay
Jeff Olsommer Republican Nay
Jeremy Shaffer Republican Nay
Jesse Topper Republican Nay
Jill N. Cooper Republican Nay
Jim Rigby Republican Nay
Joanne Stehr Republican Nay
Joe Emrick Republican Nay
Joe Hamm Republican Nay
Joe Hogan Republican Nay
Joe Kerwin Republican Nay
John A. Lawrence Republican Nay
John A. Schlegel Republican Nay
Jonathan Fritz Republican Nay
Joseph D'Orsie Republican Nay
Josh Bashline Republican Nay
Joshua D. Kail Republican Nay
Kate A. Klunk Republican Nay
Kathleen C. Tomlinson Republican Nay
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Nay
Keith J. Greiner Republican Nay
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Nay
Kristin Marcell Republican Nay
Leslie Rossi Republican Nay
Marc S. Anderson Republican Nay
Marci Mustello Republican Nay
Mark M. Gillen Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Martin T. Causer Republican Nay
Martina A. White Republican Nay
Michael Stender Republican Nay
Mike Armanini Republican Nay
Mike Jones Republican Nay
Milou Mackenzie Republican Nay
Mindy Fee Republican Nay
Natalie Mihalek Republican Nay
Parke Wentling Republican Nay
Perry A. Stambaugh Republican Nay
R. Lee James Republican Nay
Rich Irvin Republican Nay
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Nay
Robert Leadbeter Republican Nay
Roman Kozak Republican Nay
Russ Diamond Republican Nay
Ryan Warner Republican Nay
Scott Barger Republican Nay
Shelby Labs Republican Nay
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Nay
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Nay
Steven C. Mentzer Republican Nay
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Nay
Thomas L. Mehaffie Republican Nay
Tim Twardzik Republican Nay
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Nay
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Nay
Tina Pickett Republican Nay
Tom Jones Republican Nay
Valerie S. Gaydos Republican Nay
Wendy Fink Republican Nay
Zachary Mako Republican Nay

Official roll call →

A896

Failed 99 Yea · 103 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 010000
Republican 96100
Unaffiliated 3201
Total 9910301
% of votes cast 49%51%0%0%
How each member voted (203)
Member Party Vote
Torren Ecker — Yea
Seth Grove — Not Voting
Dan Miller — Nay
Louis Schmitt — Yea
Stephenie Scialabba — Yea
Joshua Siegel — Nay
Abigail Salisbury Democratic Nay
Aerion Abney Democratic Nay
Amen Brown Democratic Nay
Andre D. Carroll Democratic Nay
Anita Astorino Kulik Democratic Nay
Anthony A. Bellmon Democratic Nay
Arvind Venkat Democratic Nay
Ben Waxman Democratic Nay
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Nay
Brandon J. Markosek Democratic Nay
Brian Munroe Democratic Nay
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Nay
Carol Hill-Evans Democratic Nay
Carol Kazeem Democratic Nay
Chris Pielli Democratic Nay
Christina D. Sappey Democratic Nay
Christopher M. Rabb Democratic Nay
Dan Frankel Democratic Nay
Dan Goughnour Democratic Nay
Dan K. Williams Democratic Nay
Daniel J. Deasy Democratic Nay
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Nay
Danilo Burgos Democratic Nay
Darisha K. Parker Democratic Nay
Dave Madsen Democratic Nay
David M. Delloso Democratic Nay
Ed Neilson Democratic Nay
Eddie Day Pashinski Democratic Nay
Elizabeth Fiedler Democratic Nay
Emily Kinkead Democratic Nay
Frank Burns Democratic Nay
G. Roni Green Democratic Nay
Gina H. Curry Democratic Nay
Greg Scott Democratic Nay
Greg Vitali Democratic Nay
Heather Boyd Democratic Nay
Ismail Smith-Wade-El Democratic Nay
Jacklyn Rusnock Democratic Nay
Jared G. Solomon Democratic Nay
Jason Dawkins Democratic Nay
Jeanne McNeill Democratic Nay
Jennifer O'Mara Democratic Nay
Jessica Benham Democratic Nay
Jim Haddock Democratic Nay
Jim Prokopiak Democratic Nay
Joanna E. McClinton Democratic Nay
Joe Ciresi Democratic Nay
Joe McAndrew Democratic Nay
Joe Webster Democratic Nay
Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz Democratic Nay
John C. Inglis III Democratic Nay
Jordan A. Harris Democratic Nay
Jose Giral Democratic Nay
Joseph C. Hohenstein Democratic Nay
Justin C. Fleming Democratic Nay
Keith S. Harris Democratic Nay
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Nay
Kyle Donahue Democratic Nay
Kyle J. Mullins Democratic Nay
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Nay
Leanne Krueger Democratic Nay
Lindsay Powell Democratic Nay
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Nay
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Nay
Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Nay
Mandy Steele Democratic Nay
Manuel Guzman Democratic Nay
Mary Jo Daley Democratic Nay
MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Nay
Matthew D. Bradford Democratic Nay
Maureen E. Madden Democratic Nay
Melissa Cerrato Democratic Nay
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Nay
Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Nay
Morgan Cephas Democratic Nay
Nancy Guenst Democratic Nay
Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Nay
Nathan Davidson Democratic Nay
Nikki Rivera Democratic Nay
Pat Gallagher Democratic Nay
Patrick J. Harkins Democratic Nay
Paul Friel Democratic Nay
Paul Takac Democratic Nay
Perry S. Warren Democratic Nay
Peter Schweyer Democratic Nay
Regina G. Young Democratic Nay
Rick Krajewski Democratic Nay
Robert E. Merski Democratic Nay
Robert F. Matzie Democratic Nay
Robert Freeman Democratic Nay
Ryan A. Bizzarro Democratic Nay
Scott Conklin Democratic Nay
Sean Dougherty Democratic Nay
Steve Samuelson Democratic Nay
Steven R. Malagari Democratic Nay
Tarah Probst Democratic Nay
Tarik Khan Democratic Nay
Tim Brennan Democratic Nay
Tim Briggs Democratic Nay
Tina M. Davis Democratic Nay
Aaron Bernstine Republican Yea
Abby Major Republican Yea
Alec J. Ryncavage Republican Yea
Andrew Kuzma Republican Yea
Ann Flood Republican Yea
Barbara Gleim Republican Yea
Brad Roae Republican Yea
Brenda M. Pugh Republican Yea
Brett R. Miller Republican Yea
Brian C. Rasel Republican Yea
Brian Smith Republican Yea
Bryan Cutler Republican Yea
Bud Cook Republican Yea
Carl Walker Metzgar Republican Yea
Chad G. Reichard Republican Yea
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Yea
Clint Owlett Republican Yea
Craig T. Staats Republican Yea
Craig Williams Republican Nay
Dallas Kephart Republican Yea
Dan Moul Republican Yea
Dane Watro Republican Yea
David H. Rowe Republican Yea
David H. Zimmerman Republican Yea
David M. Maloney Republican Yea
Donna Scheuren Republican Yea
Doyle Heffley Republican Yea
Eric Davanzo Republican Yea
Eric J. Weaknecht Republican Yea
Eric R. Nelson Republican Yea
Gary W. Day Republican Yea
Jack Rader Republican Yea
Jacob D. Banta Republican Yea
James B. Struzzi Republican Yea
Jamie Barton Republican Yea
Jamie L. Flick Republican Yea
Jamie Walsh Republican Yea
Jason Ortitay Republican Yea
Jeff Olsommer Republican Yea
Jeremy Shaffer Republican Yea
Jesse Topper Republican Yea
Jill N. Cooper Republican Yea
Jim Rigby Republican Yea
Joanne Stehr Republican Yea
Joe Emrick Republican Yea
Joe Hamm Republican Yea
Joe Hogan Republican Yea
Joe Kerwin Republican Yea
John A. Lawrence Republican Yea
John A. Schlegel Republican Yea
Jonathan Fritz Republican Yea
Joseph D'Orsie Republican Yea
Josh Bashline Republican Yea
Joshua D. Kail Republican Yea
Kate A. Klunk Republican Yea
Kathleen C. Tomlinson Republican Yea
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Yea
Keith J. Greiner Republican Yea
Kerry A. Benninghoff Republican Yea
Kristin Marcell Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Yea
Marc S. Anderson Republican Yea
Marci Mustello Republican Yea
Mark M. Gillen Republican Yea
Marla Brown Republican Yea
Martin T. Causer Republican Yea
Martina A. White Republican Yea
Michael Stender Republican Yea
Mike Armanini Republican Yea
Mike Jones Republican Yea
Milou Mackenzie Republican Yea
Mindy Fee Republican Yea
Natalie Mihalek Republican Yea
Parke Wentling Republican Yea
Perry A. Stambaugh Republican Yea
R. Lee James Republican Yea
Rich Irvin Republican Yea
Rob W. Kauffman Republican Yea
Robert Leadbeter Republican Yea
Roman Kozak Republican Yea
Russ Diamond Republican Yea
Ryan Warner Republican Yea
Scott Barger Republican Yea
Shelby Labs Republican Yea
Sheryl M. Delozier Republican Yea
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Yea
Steven C. Mentzer Republican Yea
Thomas H. Kutz Republican Yea
Thomas L. Mehaffie Republican Yea
Tim Twardzik Republican Yea
Timothy J. O'Neal Republican Yea
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea
Tina Pickett Republican Yea
Tom Jones Republican Yea
Valerie S. Gaydos Republican Yea
Wendy Fink Republican Yea
Zachary Mako Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Passed 26 Yea · 0 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 14000
Republican 12000
Total 26000
% of votes cast 100%0%0%0%
How each member voted (26)
Member Party Vote
Arvind Venkat Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Brad Roae Republican Yea
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Yea
David H. Zimmerman Republican Yea
Gary W. Day Republican Yea
Jamie Walsh Republican Yea
Joanne Stehr Republican Yea
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Yea
Marla Brown Republican Yea
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Yea
Tim Twardzik Republican Yea
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Passed 20 Yea · 6 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Democratic 14000
Republican 6600
Total 20600
% of votes cast 77%23%0%0%
How each member voted (26)
Member Party Vote
Arvind Venkat Democratic Yea
Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Yea
Bridget M. Kosierowski Democratic Yea
Dan Frankel Democratic Yea
Danielle Friel Otten Democratic Yea
Heather Boyd Democratic Yea
Jessica Benham Democratic Yea
Kristine C. Howard Democratic Yea
La'Tasha D. Mayes Democratic Yea
Lisa A. Borowski Democratic Yea
Liz Hanbidge Democratic Yea
Melissa L. Shusterman Democratic Yea
Rick Krajewski Democratic Yea
Tarik Khan Democratic Yea
Brad Roae Republican Nay
Charity Grimm Krupa Republican Yea
David H. Zimmerman Republican Yea
Gary W. Day Republican Yea
Jamie Walsh Republican Nay
Joanne Stehr Republican Nay
Kathy L. Rapp Republican Yea
Leslie Rossi Republican Nay
Marla Brown Republican Nay
Stephanie Borowicz Republican Nay
Tim Twardzik Republican Yea
Timothy R. Bonner Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Subjects

Cross-referencing the record. Reading this bill against every other bill in the corpus by meaning, not keywords. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Matching · Ranking · Engrossing

Frequently asked questions

Who sponsors HB 1460?
HB 1460 is sponsored by Lisa A. Borowski (Democratic), Paul Takac (Democratic), Tarik Khan (Democratic), Heather Boyd (Democratic), Jennifer O'Mara (Democratic), Leanne Krueger (Democratic), Gina H. Curry (Democratic), Carol Kazeem (Democratic), David M. Delloso (Democratic), Regina G. Young (Democratic), Carol Hill-Evans (Democratic), Jose Giral (Democratic), Elizabeth Fiedler (Democratic), Benjamin V. Sanchez (Democratic), Robert Freeman (Democratic), Tarah Probst (Democratic), Joseph C. Hohenstein (Democratic), Kyle Donahue (Democratic), Michael H. Schlossberg (Democratic), Jim Prokopiak (Democratic), Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz (Democratic), Melissa Cerrato (Democratic), Ben Waxman (Democratic), Mary Jo Daley (Democratic), Joe Ciresi (Democratic), Malcolm Kenyatta (Democratic), Dan Frankel (Democratic), G. Roni Green (Democratic), Joe Webster (Democratic), Bridget M. Kosierowski (Democratic), Liz Hanbidge (Democratic), and Dave Madsen (Democratic).
What is the current status of HB 1460?
This bill has passed the House. Introduced May 13, 2025. It now moves to the second chamber.
Where can I track HB 1460?
Track HB 1460 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.

Make your voice heard on HB 1460

Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.

Stay ahead of HB 1460

Last checked for changes 2 months ago · updated continuously

One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.

Track this bill →