HB 442 — AN ACT TO AMEND TITLE 16 OF THE DELAWARE CODE RELATING TO THE DELAWARE HEALTH CARE COMMISSION AND STATE OF DELAWARE HEALTH CARE SPENDING AND QUALITY BENCHMARKS.
Last action — Signed by Governor
-
✓Introduced
-
✓In Committee
-
✓Passed House
-
✓Passed Senate
-
✓To Executive
-
6Enacted
This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced June 02, 2022. Enacted.
Odds of enactment
High chanceBased on the sponsor, cosponsors, and committee posture, this bill has a high chance of becoming law.
Upgrade to see the exact probability and what's driving it.
A statistical estimate from our own model of past outcomes — an insight, not a guarantee. Policymaking is volatile.
Prognosis
-
Enacted
Current position in the legislative process.
-
7 sponsors
3 primary, 4 co-sponsors signed on.
-
Single-party support
Sponsorship is currently within one party (5 D).
-
Cleared a recorded vote
Passed 2 recorded votes so far.
Based on stage, sponsorship breadth, committee status, recorded votes, and cross-state momentum — a description of the observable signals, not a prediction.
Summary
Delaware’s per capita health care spending consistently ranks in the top ten highest spending states and has historically outpaced economic growth in Delaware. Enhanced transparency and shared accountability for spending and quality targets have been used to accelerate changes in our health care delivery system, creating benefits for employers, state government and health care consumers. House Joint Resolution 7 of the 149th General Assembly and Executive Order Nineteen tasked the Delaware Department of Health and Social Services (DHSS) with the establishment of annual health care spending and quality benchmarks as a strategy to address the unsustainable growth in health care spending while also measuring aspects of health care quality. This Act serves to replace Executive Order Twenty-Five which established Delaware’s Spending and Quality Benchmark initiative in 2018. The codification of these benchmarks supports the continuation of Delaware’s Road to Value by improving the transparency of health care spending and quality, as well as providing attainable goals needed to achieve better health care, lower costs, and healthier communities.
Bill Text
What changed in the latest version
120 added · 40 removed120 line(s) added, 40 removed.
Bentz HOUSE& OFSen. REPRESENTATIVES 151st GENERAL ASSEMBLY HOUSE AMENDMENT NO.
1S. TO HOUSE BILL NO.
442McBride AMEND& HouseSen. Bill No.
442Townsend onReps. line 15 by deleting “services” as it appears after “care” and inserting in lieu thereof “services.” FURTHER AMEND House Bill No.
442Morrison, onOsienski; line 17 by deleting “benefit” as it appears after “insurance” and before “administration”.
FURTHERSens. AMEND House Bill No.
442Hansen, onSokola lineHOUSE 17OF byREPRESENTATIVES inser4ting151st afterGENERAL “products,”ASSEMBLY andHOUSE beforeBILL “or”NO. the following:
“Medicaid442 andAN CHIP,”.ACT TO AMEND TITLE 16 OF THE DELAWARE CODE RELATING TO THE DELAWARE HEALTH CARE COMMISSION AND STATE OF DELAWARE HEALTH CARE SPENDING AND QUALITY BENCHMARKS.
FURTHERBE AMENDIT HouseENACTED BillBY No.THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE:
442Section by1. deleting line 21 in its entirety and inserting in lieu thereof the following:
”(h)Amend Public§ Programs”9903, meansTitle Payers16 thatof arethe notDelaware InsurersCode andby includesmaking Medicare,insertions Medicaidas shown by underline and CHIP,deletions the”.as shown by strikethrough as follows:
FURTHER§ AMEND9903. House Bill No.
442Duties by deleting line 25 in its entirety and insertingauthority inof lieu thereof the following:Commission.
“Governor,(k) The Commission shall, in coordination with the DepartmentDelaware ofEconomic Insurance,and StateFinancial EmployeeAdvisory BenefitsCouncil Committee,Health theCare DelawareSpending DivisionBenchmark ofSubcommittee, Medicaidbe andresponsible Medicalfor Assistance,establishing and othermonitoring relevantthe stateState agenciesof onDelaware theHealth Care Spending Benchmark.”and FURTHERQuality AMENDBenchmarks Houseas Billfollows: No.
442(1) byAs deletingused lines 26 and 27 in theirthis entiretysubsection anda. redesignating accordingly.
FURTHER“DEFAC” AMENDmeans Housethe BillDelaware No.Economic and Financial Advisory Council.
442b. by deleting lines 84 and 85 in their entirety and inserting in lieu thereof the following:
“(13)“Spending SubjectBenchmark” tomeans subsectionsthe (k)(13)(d)target andannual (e)per ofcapita thisgrowth section,rate Payers,for Insurers,Delaware’s andstatewide Publictotal Programshealth shallcare reportspending, annuallyexpressed toas the Commissionpercentage bygrowth nofrom laterthe thanprior Octoberyear’s 1per of”.capita spending.
FURTHERc. AMEND House Bill No.
442“Quality byBenchmark” deletingmeans linethe 89annual inperformance itstarget entiretyfor anda insertingpriority inDelaware lieupopulation-health thereofor thequality-of-care following:concern.
“c.d.
The“Payer” Commissionmeans maya usepayer, othera sourcesnongovernment tohealth trackplan variationand inincludes costsany andorganization qualityacting ofas high-volume,payer high-“.that is a subsidiary, affiliate or business owned or controlled by a payer that, during a given calendar year, pays health care providers for health care services f.
FURTHER“Insurer” AMENDmeans Housea Billprivate No.health insurance company that offers any of the following:
442commercial byinsurance insertingbenefit afteradministration linefor 97self-insured theemployers, following:Medicare managed care products, or Medicaid managed care organization (MCO) products.
g.
“Market” means the highest level of categorization of the health insurance market and shall include individual, small group, large group, self-insured, student, and Medicare Advantage markets.
h.
“Public Programs” means Payers that are not Insurers and includes Medicare FFS, Medicaid FFS, the Veterans Health Administration (VHA), and other similar programs or entities.
MAW Page 1 of 24 Released:
06/13/202206/02/2022 11:1909:31 AM “e.i.
The“Subcommittee” abovemeans annual reporting deadline of October 1 of each calendar year may be modified by the ExecutiveDEFAC DirectorHealth ofCare theSpending CommissionBenchmark providedSubcommittee. that Payers, Insurers, and Public Programs are given written notice of any such modification at least 30 days prior to the annual reporting deadline.” SYNOPSIS This amendment to House Bill No.
442(2) modifiesThe Subcommittee shall be responsible for setting the definitionSpending ofBenchmark anand “Insurer,”shall “Market,”advise DEFAC, the Governor, the Department of Insurance, and “Publicother Programs”relevant tostate includeagencies Childrenon Healththe InsuranceSpending Plans.Benchmark.
(3) The amendmentSpending clarifiesBenchmark theshall entitiesbe that3.0% for 2023, and shall reportbe toreevaluated theannually Delawareby Healththe CareSubcommittee, Commissionin annuallycoordination onwith performancerelevant relativestate agencies, to establish the spendingSpending Benchmark for 2024 and qualityeach benchmarks.year thereafter.
The(4) amendmentSubject permitsto theparagraph Executive(k)(5), Director of the CommissionSpending toBenchmark modifyshall be the annualper reportingcapita deadlinePotential ofGross OctoberState 1Product of(PGSP) eachgrowth calendarrate year,which providedshall thatbe advancecalculated writtenas noticefollows: of the modified deadline is given to reporting entities.
Thea. amendment codifies that the Subcommittee shall set the spending benchmark and clarifies that the Commission may use other sources to track variation in costs and quality.
The sum of the following:
the expected growth in national labor force productivity;
plus, the expected growth in Delaware’s civilian labor force;
plus, the expected national inflation;
b.
Show all 94 changed lines (54 more)
Minus Delaware’s expected population growth.
(5) The methodology used to determine the Spending Benchmark in paragraph (k)(4) are subject to change if the Subcommittee determines that there is a more effective or precise methodology than paragraph (k)(4) .
(6) The Commission shall annually publish the Delaware Health Care Spending and Quality Benchmarks Implementation Manual on the Commission’s website which shall contain the current definitions and metrics utilized in the Spending and Quality Benchmark calculations.
(7) In calculating any statewide, regional or local health care cost calculation target or benchmark, the total cost of care calculation, report, study or formulation may utilize data obtained from the Health Care Claims Database maintained by the Delaware Health Information Network.
(8) The Subcommittee shall do all of the following:
a.
Review annually all components of the Potential Gross State Product or any other approved methodology, and recommend to DEFAC for its approval whether the forecasted growth rate has changed in such a material way that it warrants a change in the Spending Benchmark, and if so, how and why the Spending Benchmark should be modified.
b.
Review periodically the methodology of the Spending Benchmark for possible updates or modifications to the methodology for the performance year starting January 1, 2024, and each year thereafter, and make recommendations to DEFAC by no later than May 31 of each calendar year thereafter, as to whether, and, if so, how and why the Spending Benchmark methodology and/or the growth rate should change.
c.
In the event a recommendation is made that the Spending Benchmark methodology and/or the growth rate should change, provide the public and interested stakeholders a reasonable opportunity to provide feedback on the proposed changes, and consider any recommendations provided as to the proposed changes.
MAW Page 2 of 24 Released:
06/13/202206/02/2022 11:1909:31 AM 2141510745d.
Advise the Governor and DEFAC on current and projected trends in health care and the health care industry, particularly as they affect the expenditures and revenues of the State of Delaware, its citizens, and its major industries.
(10) No later than June 30th of each year, DEFAC shall report to the Governor and the Commission regarding any changes to the Spending Benchmark as approved by DEFAC.
(11) The Commission shall establish and publish the annual Spending Benchmark on the Commission’s website.
(12) Recognizing the importance of coordination between the Subcommittee and the Commission in the creation of the Spending and Quality Benchmarks, and as part of the Commission’s ongoing efforts to serve as the policy body to advise the Governor and the General Assembly on strategies to promote affordable quality health care to all Delawareans, the Commission shall be responsible for doing all of the following:
a.
Setting Quality Benchmarks for the State of Delaware and advising the Governor, the Division of Public Health and other relevant state agencies on the Quality Benchmarks.
b.
For each new, three-year cycle of the Quality Benchmarks, reviewing the methodology used to establish these benchmarks to determine whether changes should be made to the values used to establish the Quality Benchmarks to reflect changes in new population health or health care priority opportunities for improvement, and/or whether the Quality Benchmarks’ values should be changed to reflect improved health care performance in the State.
If changes are to be made to the values used to establish the Quality Benchmarks and/or the Quality Benchmarks, the Commission shall finalize these changes prior to the start of each new, three-year Quality Benchmark cycle.
For Calendar Year 2025–2028 of the Quality Benchmark cycle, the Commission should finalize any changes on or before December 31, 2024, and then every three years thereafter.
c.
In the event the Commission determines that the values used to establish the Quality Benchmarks and/or the Quality Benchmarks should be changed, the Commission shall make such changes only after providing the public and interested stakeholders a reasonable opportunity to provide feedback on the proposed changes, and considering any recommendations provided as to the proposed changes.
d.
Engaging health care providers and community partners in a regular and ongoing forum, with the State and with each other, to develop strategies to reduce variation in cost and quality and to help the State perform well relative to the Spending and Quality Benchmarks, including reliance on data and, to the extent practicable, evidence-based solutions to address identified opportunities through the variation analysis.
HD :
NSW :
MAW Page 3 of 4 Released:
06/02/2022 09:31 AM e.
Producing timely publications and/or reports with validated data to ensure transparency regarding health care spending and quality within the State of Delaware.
(13) Subject to subsection (k)(13)(d), Payers and the Delaware Division of Medicaid and Medical Assistance, on behalf of the Managed Care Organizations, shall report annually to the Commission by no later than October 1 of each calendar year on performance relative to the Spending and Quality Benchmarks.
a.
Spending Benchmark data may consist of the prior two calendar years.
b.
Quality Benchmark data shall consist of the previous calendar year.
c.
Spending Benchmark data shall be used to track variation in costs and quality of high-volume, high- cost and high-value episodes of care (identifying the causes of variation, including mix of services used, unit price variation and provision of low-value care) at both of the following:
1.
State health insurance Market and individual consumer levels.
2.
Medical group and accountable care organization (ACO) levels for entities of a sufficient size, using clinical risk adjustment methodologies.
d.
Other Payers may be required to report annually to the Commission on performance relative to the Spending and Quality Benchmarks subject to the approval of DEFAC, the Subcommittee, the Governor, and other relevant state agencies.
SYNOPSIS Delaware’s per capita health care spending consistently ranks in the top ten highest spending states and has historically outpaced economic growth in Delaware.
Enhanced transparency and shared accountability for spending and quality targets have been used to accelerate changes in our health care delivery system, creating benefits for employers, state government and health care consumers.
House Joint Resolution 7 of the 149th General Assembly and Executive Order Nineteen tasked the Delaware Department of Health and Social Services (DHSS) with the establishment of annual health care spending and quality benchmarks as a strategy to address the unsustainable growth in health care spending while also measuring aspects of health care quality.
This Act serves to replace Executive Order Twenty-Five which established Delaware’s Spending and Quality Benchmark initiative in 2018.
The codification of these benchmarks supports the continuation of Delaware’s Road to Value by improving the transparency of health care spending and quality, as well as providing attainable goals needed to achieve better health care, lower costs, and healthier communities.
HD :
NSW :
MAW Page 4 of 4 Released:
06/02/2022 09:31 AM 2141510681
Show all 94 changed rows (54 more)
Action History
-
Signed by Governor
-
Passed By Senate. Votes: 21 YES
-
Reported Out of Committee (Health & Social Services) in Senate with 3 Favorable, 3 On Its Merits
-
Assigned to Health & Social Services Committee in Senate
-
Passed By House. Votes: 40 YES 1 ABSENT
-
Amendment HA 1 to HB 442 - Passed In House by Voice Vote
-
Amendment HA 1 to HB 442 - Introduced and Placed With Bill
-
Reported Out of Committee (Health & Human Development) in House with 2 Favorable, 7 On Its Merits
-
Introduced and Assigned to Health & Human Development Committee in House
Sponsors
- Bryan Townsend · Primary
- Stephanie L. Hansen · Cosponsor
- David P. Sokola · Cosponsor
- Eric Morrison · Cosponsor
- Edward S. Osienski · Cosponsor
- Sarah McBride · Primary
- David Bentz · Primary
Sponsorship breakdown
Export CSV (upgrade) →3 sponsors · 4 co-sponsors · 55 not signed on
Sponsors (3)
- Bryan Townsend Democratic
- Sarah McBride
- David Bentz
Co-sponsors (4)
- Stephanie L. Hansen Democratic
- David P. Sokola Democratic
- Eric Morrison Democratic
- Edward S. Osienski Democratic
Not signed on (55)
55 members have not signed on to this bill.
Show all 55 →"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.
Votes
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unaffiliated | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Democratic | 11 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 21 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| % of votes cast | 100% | 0% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (21)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Bruce C. Ennis | — | Yea |
| Colin Bonini | — | Yea |
| Ernesto B Lopez | — | Yea |
| Kyle Evans Gay | — | Yea |
| Sarah McBride | — | Yea |
| Bryan Townsend | Democratic | Yea |
| Darius J. Brown | Democratic | Yea |
| David P. Sokola | Democratic | Yea |
| John "Jack" Walsh | Democratic | Yea |
| Laura V. Sturgeon | Democratic | Yea |
| Marie Pinkney | Democratic | Yea |
| Nicole Poore | Democratic | Yea |
| S. Elizabeth Lockman | Democratic | Yea |
| Spiros Mantzavinos | Democratic | Yea |
| Stephanie L. Hansen | Democratic | Yea |
| Trey Paradee | Democratic | Yea |
| Brian Pettyjohn | Republican | Yea |
| Bryant L. Richardson | Republican | Yea |
| Dave G. Lawson | Republican | Yea |
| David L. Wilson | Republican | Yea |
| Gerald W. Hocker | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unaffiliated | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Democratic | 15 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Republican | 12 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 40 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| % of votes cast | 98% | 0% | 0% | 2% |
How each member voted (41)
Subjects
Frequently asked questions
- What does HB 442 do?
- Delaware’s per capita health care spending consistently ranks in the top ten highest spending states and has historically outpaced economic growth in Delaware. Enhanced transparency and shared accountability for spending and quality targets have been used to accelerate changes in our health care delivery system, creating benefits for employers, state government and health care consumers. House Joint Resolution 7 of the 149th General Assembly and Executive Order Nineteen tasked the Delaware Department of Health and Social Services (DHSS) with the establishment of annual health care spending and quality benchmarks as a strategy to address the unsustainable growth in health care spending while also measuring aspects of health care quality. This Act serves to replace Executive Order Twenty-Five which established Delaware’s Spending and Quality Benchmark initiative in 2018. The codification of these benchmarks supports the continuation of Delaware’s Road to Value by improving the transparency of health care spending and quality, as well as providing attainable goals needed to achieve better health care, lower costs, and healthier communities.
- Who sponsors HB 442?
- HB 442 is sponsored by Bryan Townsend (Democratic), Stephanie L. Hansen (Democratic), David P. Sokola (Democratic), Eric Morrison (Democratic), Edward S. Osienski (Democratic), Sarah McBride, and David Bentz.
- What is the current status of HB 442?
- This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced June 02, 2022. Enacted.
- Where can I track HB 442?
- Track HB 442 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.
Make your voice heard on HB 442
Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.
Stay ahead of HB 442
Last checked for changes 2 months ago · updated continuously
One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.
Track this bill →