records of site condition — part XV.1 of the act, O. Reg. 153/04

Schedule C

Cite as records of site condition — part XV.1 of the act, O. Reg. 153/04, Schedule C · current to November 11, 2026 · consolidated from October 23, 2026 · read from e-Laws on November 16, 2026

The text

SCHEDULE C RISK ASSESSMENTS Part I Mandatory Requirements Definitions 1. (1) In this Schedule, “approved model” means the data file entitled “Modified Generic Risk Assessment Model” and dated October 19, 2009, as amended from time to time, that is maintained by the Ministry as part of its Brownfield initiative and is available on the Internet and may be available in such other manner as the Minister of the Environment considers appropriate; “community assessment report” means a report that, (a) has been prepared by a person referred to in section 6 of the regulation based on an assessment by such a person, (b) is a report on the assessment of contaminants of concern on one or more properties, (c) uses assumptions and models in order to propose intervention values for one or more of the contaminants referred to in clause (b), (d) proposes intervention values in respect of one or more properties which were not the source of the contaminant, (e) identifies the area within which properties to which the intervention values apply are located, and (f) has been submitted to a Director pursuant to an order or a draft order under legislation administered by the Ministry; Components of a risk assessment 2. (1) A risk assessment must include the following components: 1. The preparation and submission of a pre-submission form. 2. The conduct of an assessment of human health risk and of ecological risk. 3. The preparation of a written risk assessment report that includes a description of the assessments of risk described in paragraph 2. (2) Paragraph 2 of subsection (1) does not apply to an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment that is described in section 8. (3) The Director may require that the pre-submission form or the risk assessment report be in whole or in part submitted in an acceptable electronic form. Mandatory requirements of a pre-submission form 3. (1) Before completing the written risk assessment report referred to in paragraph 3 of subsection 2 (1), the property owner shall submit a pre-submission form to the Ministry for comment on the proposed risk assessment approach. (1.1) Despite subsection (1), in respect of a modified generic risk assessment that is described in section 7, the property owner shall submit the pre-submission form to the Ministry with the written risk assessment report referred to in paragraph 3 of subsection 2 (1). (2) The pre-submission form shall be prepared by a qualified person in accordance with this section using the form approved by the Director. (3) The qualified person shall prepare the pre-submission form based on the results of the phase one environmental site assessment, the phase two environmental site assessment and on any other information that the qualified person considers relevant. (4) The pre-submission form must contain the information specified in subsections (5) to (11) and any other information required by the Director. (5) The pre-submission form must include the following: 1. The name, mailing address, postal code and telephone number of the owner of the RA property who is responsible for the submission of the risk assessment. 1.1 The e-mail address and fax number, if any, of the owner of the RA property who is responsible for the submission of the risk assessment. 2. The name of a contact person for the owner, if the owner is a corporation or a partnership. 3. The name and mailing address of any other current owner of the RA property and, if the other owner is a corporation or partnership, the name of a contact person for the other owner. 4. For the RA property, i. a legal description of the property and a list of its owners and a description of the nature of their interest and any municipal address, assessment roll number and property identifier number applicable to the property, prepared by a lawyer after reviewing a current plan of survey of the property that has been prepared, signed and sealed by a surveyor and all other necessary documents, and ii. municipal address, assessment roll number and property identifier number, if any, applicable to the property. 5. The current type of use of the RA property and, if the owner intends to change the type of use of the property, the proposed type of use. (5.1) Despite subparagraph 4 i of subsection (5), where the RA property consists of land that is administered by the Ministry of Natural Resources under the Public Lands Act, a description approved by the Surveyor General may be provided instead of a plan of survey. (6) The pre-submission form must identify which of the following types of risk assessment approaches the qualified person intends to use for the risk assessment: 1. A limited scope risk assessment described in section 7. 2. An estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment described in section 8. 3. A new science risk assessment described in section 9. 4. A wider area of abatement risk assessment described in section 10. 5. A standard risk assessment, which is a risk assessment that satisfies the requirements of section 4, but is not a risk assessment described in paragraphs 1 to 4. (7) If the risk assessment will use one or more computer models in its preparation, the pre-submission form must identify which models. (8) The pre-submission form must include information on the conceptual site model that the qualified person intends to rely upon in the preparation of the parts of the risk assessment report described in Report Section 3 (Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation), Report Section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)) of Table 1 of this Schedule including, (a) a narrative description and assessment of, (i) areas where potentially contaminating activity has occurred, (ii) areas of potential environmental concern, and (iii) any subsurface structures and utilities on, in or under the RA property that may affect contaminant distribution and transport; (a.1) a narrative description of and, as appropriate, figures illustrating, the physical setting of a RA property and any areas under it including, (i) stratigraphy from ground surface to the deepest aquifer or aquitard investigated, (ii) hydrogeological characteristics, including aquifers, aquitards and, in each hydrostratigraphic unit where one or more contaminants is present at concentrations above the applicable site condition standards, lateral and vertical hydraulic gradients, (iii) approximate depth to bedrock, (iv) approximate depth to water table, (v) any respect in which section 35, 41 or 43.1 of the regulation applies to the property, (vi) areas where soil has been brought from another property and placed on, in or under the RA property, and (vii) approximate locations, if known, of any proposed buildings and other structures; (a.2) where a contaminant is present on, in or under a RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, identification of, (i) each area where a contaminant is present on, in or under a RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, (ii) the contaminants associated with each of the areas referred to in subclause (i), and (iii) each medium in which a contaminant associated with an area referred to in subclause (i) above is present; (a.3) where a contaminant is present on, in or under a RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, a narrative description of, (i) what is known about each of the areas referred to in subclause (a.2) (i), (ii) the distribution, in each of the areas referred to in subclause (a.2) (i), of each contaminant present in the area at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, for each medium in which the contaminant is present, together with figures showing the distribution by parameter group as defined in the Analytical Protocol, (iii) anything known about the reason for the discharge into the natural environment of the contaminants present on, in or under the RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, (iv) anything known about migration away from any area of potential environmental concern of the contaminants present on, in or under the RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard, including the identification of any preferential pathways, (v) climatic or meteorological conditions that may have influenced distribution and migration of the contaminants, such as temporal fluctuations in ground water levels, and (vi) if applicable, information concerning soil vapour intrusion of the contaminants into buildings including, (A) relevant construction features of a building, such as a basement or crawl space, (B) building heating, ventilating and air conditioning design and operation, and (C) subsurface utilities; (a.4) where contaminants on, in or under the RA property are present at concentrations greater than the applicable site condition standard, for each parameter group as defined in the Analytical Protocol, one or more cross-sections showing, (i) the lateral and vertical distribution of a contaminant in each area where the contaminant is present at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard in soil, ground water and sediment, (ii) approximate depth to water table in each area referred to in subclause (i), (iii) stratigraphy from ground surface to the deepest aquifer or aquitard investigated, and (iv) any subsurface structures and utilities that may affect contaminant distribution and transport in each area referred to in subclause (i); (b) for each area where a contaminant is present on, in or under the RA property at a concentration greater than the applicable site condition standard for the contaminant, a diagram identifying, with narrative explanatory notes, (i) the release mechanisms, (ii) contaminant transport pathway, (iii) the human and ecological receptors located on, in, under and off the RA property, (iv) receptor exposure points, and (v) routes of exposure; (c) one or more diagrams, with explanatory notes, showing the biota and food web relationships on and off the RA property which may be affected by contaminants on, in or under the RA property; (d) if a non-standard delineation was conducted in accordance with section 7.1 of Schedule E as part of preparing the phase two environmental site assessment report, a narrative description of how the non-standard delineation satisfies the requirements in that section; (e) if the exemption set out in paragraph 1, 1.1 or 2 of section 49.1 of the regulation is being relied upon, a statement as to the reliance upon the exemption and a narrative description of the rationale for relying upon the exemption, which may be based on information gathered during the site investigation; (f) if the exemption set out in paragraph 3 of section 49.1 of the regulation is being relied upon, (i) a statement as to the reliance upon the exemption, (ii) a narrative description of the rationale for relying upon the exemption, which may be based on information gathered during the site investigation, and (iii) one or more cross-sections and one or more figures in plan view of the RA property that demonstrate, through identification of sample locations, sample depths and contaminant concentrations, the distribution of the contaminant in question laterally and vertically and the range of concentrations of that contaminant on, in or under the RA property. (9) The diagrams that are part of the conceptual site model mentioned in clauses (8) (b) and (c), must be prepared, (a) taking into consideration the specific property use to which the RA property will be put and that no measure has been taken or will be taken at the RA property which has the effect of reducing the risk from a contaminant on, in or under the RA property, including any non-soil surface treatment such as asphalt, concrete or aggregate which may have been or will be applied to the RA property; and (b) identifying any measures that have been taken or may be proposed at the RA property which have the effect of reducing the risk from a contaminant of concern on, in or under the RA property, including any non-soil surface treatment such as asphalt, concrete or aggregate which may have been or will be applied to the RA property. (10) In respect of an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment described in section 8, (a) clauses (8) (b) and (c) and subsection (9) do not apply; and (b) in addition to the information specified in clause (8) (a), the pre-submission form must also include information on the methods described in subsections 8 (4) to (9) that will be used to support the natural local background concentration soil standard that will be proposed under subsection 8 (1). (11) The pre-submission form must include information about proposed public communication plans, if applicable. (12) Except in respect of a modified generic risk assessment, the Director shall review the pre-submission form and may provide comments with respect to it to the owner of the property. (13) If, at any time after submitting the pre-submission form, (a) the qualified person who is identified in the pre-submission form as being responsible for the preparation of the risk assessment changes; or (b) the owner mentioned who is identified in the pre-submission form changes, the property owner shall give notice to the Director of the change in circumstance. Mandatory requirements of risk assessment reports 4. (1) A risk assessment report shall be prepared by a qualified person and, (a) must be divided into the report sections as specified in Table 1 of this Schedule; and (b) must include the headings and sub-headings set out in Table1. (2) A risk assessment report must address the minimum requirements set out in Table 1 of this Schedule. (3) A qualified person may include report sections, headings and sub-headings in addition to those set out in Table 1 of this Schedule and other information in the risk assessment report. (4) Report section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)) of Table 1 of this Schedule do not apply to an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment described in section 8. (5) If a risk assessment assumes that the ground water under the RA property does not or will not serve as a raw water supply for a drinking water system, as defined in the Safe Drinking Water Act, 2002, the owner shall give written notice to the clerk of the local municipality and of any upper-tier municipality where the property is located that, (a) identifies the location of the RA property and the use to which it will be put; (b) notifies the municipality that the qualified person intends to prepare a risk assessment in a manner that assumes that the ground water under the RA property does not or will not serve as a raw water supply for a drinking water system; and (c) requests the municipality to respond to the notice and to indicate whether the municipality objects to the assumption being made under clause (b) and, if there is an objection, the reasons for it. (6) A risk assessment report must have the following attached as appendices to the report: 1. The pre-submission form submitted under section 3, including all attached documents, the Ministry response and how Ministry concerns, if any, were addressed. 2. The resumes for the qualified person who prepared the risk assessment report and for the team technical leads. 3. A list of the documents relied upon in the preparation of the risk assessment report. 4. A summary of the phase one environmental site assessment and phase two environmental site assessment reports, including, i. justification for the sampling program used in undertaking the phase two environmental site assessment, ii. a summary of quality assurance and quality controls used for the sampling program and analysis of the samples, iii. an assessment of whether the sampling program is sufficient for the purposes of the risk assessment and if not, a description of what further site investigations were conducted to support the risk assessment, and iv. a rationale for and description of any hydrogeological and geological interpretations which differ from assumptions on which the Soil, Ground Water and Sediment Standards are based. 4.1 The appendix to the phase two environmental site assessment report that reports on requirements in a phase two environmental site assessment in support of a modified generic risk assessment. 4.2 The portion of the review and evaluation section of the phase two environmental site assessment report headed “phase two conceptual site model”. 5. A copy of any reports documenting further site investigations conducted to support the risk assessment, if applicable. 6. A copy of the written notice of intention to conduct a risk assessment that assumes a non-potable ground water condition in preparing a risk assessment for the property given under subsection (5), if applicable and a copy of any response the municipality has given to the notice. 7. If the risk assessment recommends a risk management measure that involves engineering or hydrogeological controls, an engineering or hydrogeological report prepared by a qualified person mentioned in clause 5 (2) (a) or (b) of the regulation that includes detailed plans and specifications of the engineering or hydrogeological controls or both. (7) Paragraphs 1 and 7 of subsection (6) do not apply with respect to a risk assessment report prepared as part of a modified generic risk assessment described in section 7. (8) Paragraph 7 of subsection (6) does not apply with respect to a risk assessment report prepared as part of a risk assessment based on a community assessment report described in section 7. Mandatory certifications 5. (1) In an appendix to the risk assessment report, the qualified person shall certify the following, using the language set out in this section: 1. I have conducted or supervised a risk assessment report in accordance with the regulation. 2. I am a qualified person, as defined in section 168.1 of the Act, and have the qualifications required by section 6 of the regulation. 3. I have in place an insurance policy that satisfies the requirements of section 7 of the regulation. 4. The risk assessment team included members with expertise in all of the disciplines required to complete the risk assessment in accordance with the regulation. 5. The opinions expressed in the risk assessment are engineering or scientific opinions made in accordance with generally accepted principles and practices as recognized by members of the environmental engineering or science profession or discipline practising at the same time and in the same or similar location. 6. To the best of my knowledge, the certifications and statements in this risk assessment are true as of [insert date of completion of risk assessment report]. 7. By making these certifications in this risk assessment report, I make no express or implied warranties or guarantees. (2) In an appendix to the risk assessment report, the qualified person shall certify, in the language set out in this section, the following in relation to the RA property: 1. As of [insert date of completion of risk assessment report], it is my opinion that based on the phase one environmental site assessment and the phase two environmental site assessment and other relevant property information, the approach taken in the conduct of the risk assessment, i. is appropriate to evaluate human health and ecological risks from the contaminants of concern at the concentrations proposed as the standards specified in the risk assessment and assuming no measures have been taken at the RA property which have the effect of reducing the risk from the contaminants, and ii. is consistent with the approach set out in the pre-submission form with the exception of those deviations listed in Report Section 1 (Summary of Recommendations/Findings) of the report under the heading “Deviations from Pre-Submission Form”. 2. As of [insert date of completion of risk assessment report], it is my opinion that, taking into consideration the assumptions specified in the risk assessment report, including the use of the property specified in Report Section 3 (Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation) of the risk assessment, and any risk management measures recommended in the report, as long as the RA property satisfies those assumptions and meets the standards specified in the risk assessment report, the contaminants of concern are unlikely to pose a human health or ecological risk greater than the level of risk that was intended in the development of the applicable full-depth site condition standards for those contaminants. 3. As of [insert date of completion of risk assessment report], it is my opinion that, (pick the applicable statement below), i. no risk management plan is necessary for a contaminant of concern addressed in the risk assessment report to prevent, eliminate or ameliorate any adverse effect from that contaminant to the human or ecological receptors addressed in the report and located on the RA property, or ii. the implementation of the risk management plan described in Report Section 7 (Risk Management Plan) of the risk assessment report is necessary for a contaminant of concern addressed in the risk assessment report to prevent, eliminate or ameliorate any adverse effect from that contaminant to the human or ecological receptors addressed in the report and located on the RA property and is sufficient to address the current and potential future transport and exposure pathways. 4. As of [insert date of completion of risk assessment report], the risk assessment report completely and accurately reflects the risk assessment assumptions and conclusions and all pertinent information has been included in the report and the appendices to the report. (3) If, under the heading “Risk Characterization” in each of Report Section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)) of the risk assessment report, the report concludes that the standards that are being proposed for the RA property are not likely to result in a concentration greater than the applicable full depth site condition standard for any of the human or ecological receptors that are addressed in the report and are located off the RA property, the qualified person shall certify, in the language set out in this subsection, the following in relation to the RA property and its impact on those receptors: As of the submission date, it is my opinion that, taking into consideration the assumptions specified in the risk assessment report including any risk management measures recommended in the report, as long as the RA property satisfies those assumptions and meets the standards specified in the report, the applicable full depth site condition standards will likely be met at the nearest off-site ecological and human receptors identified in the report. Part II Alternative Risk Assessment Procedures Alternative risk assessment procedures 6. Risk assessment procedures may be modified in accordance with this Part. Limited scope risk assessment 7. (1) A risk assessment is a limited scope risk assessment in respect of a property if, (a) it is either a risk assessment based on a community assessment report or a modified generic risk assessment; and (b) sections 9 and 10 do not apply to the risk assessment. (2) A risk assessment is a risk assessment based on a community assessment report if, (a) the owner of the RA property, with respect to a contaminant that was assessed as part of and reported on in the community assessment report, (i) relies on the models and assumptions used in the community assessment with respect to the contaminant, and (ii) proposes one or more intervention values for contaminants set out in the community assessment report as a standard to be specified in the risk assessment; (b) the RA property is within the study area of the assessment described in the community assessment report; (c) the risk assessment uses the community assessment report in a manner that is appropriate to the characteristics of the RA property; and (d) the District Office of the Ministry for the area in which the RA property is located has been consulted on the appropriateness of using a limited scope risk assessment based on the community assessment report. (3) A risk assessment is a modified generic risk assessment if the risk assessment, (a) uses the approved model in a manner that is appropriate to the characteristics of the RA property; (b) is submitted in a template provided by the Ministry for use in submitting a modified generic risk assessment; and (c) modifies an assumed value for an assumption, based on and in a manner consistent with the results of an assessment which meets the minimum requirements and objective for the assumption category associated with the assumption in each case where the risk assessment is to modify an assumed value for an assumption associated with an assumption category in Table 4 of Schedule E from the assumed value for the assumption used by the Ministry to develop the full depth generic site condition standards. (4) A modified generic risk assessment shall not be submitted in respect of, (a) a property to which section 41 of the regulation applies; or (b) a property for which any risk management measure, other than any risk management measure designed and published by the Ministry for use in a modified generic risk assessment, is proposed in the risk assessment. Estimation of natural local background concentrations 8. (1) Where full depth background site condition standards provided in Table 1 of the Soil Ground Water and Sediment Standards are not technologically achievable on a property because of naturally elevated local background concentrations or are not provided by Table 1, a property owner may propose a natural local background concentration soil standard for a contaminant of concern by undertaking a soil sampling and analysis program in accordance with this section. (2) A natural local background concentration for a contaminant of concern proposed under subsection (1) is a standard specified in a risk assessment. (3) A risk assessment is an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment if the natural local background concentration soil standard proposed under subsection (1) for a contaminant of concern, (a) does not exceed the applicable full depth generic potable site condition standard provided in Table 2 of the Soil Ground Water and Sediment Standards; and (b) was estimated using the method described in subsections (4) to (9). (4) The property owner shall ensure that samples are collected in accordance with the following procedures: 1. Samples must be collected from not less than 30 separate sampling locations, distributed over at least 10 physically separate geographical settings, as described in paragraph 3, that are representative of the local geology. 2. From at least one sampling location in each geographical setting, a minimum of two samples must be taken from sampling points at that same sampling location. 3. The sampling locations must be in areas that have not been affected by local point sources of air or land pollution, by local roads or highways or by other known sources of contaminant. The sampling locations may be in rural (agricultural property use) or urban (all other property uses) settings in Ontario. Suitable geographical settings include parks, cemeteries, forests, wood lots or large undeveloped tracks of land. 4. Subsections 48 (2) and (4) of the regulation apply with necessary modifications to samples collected under this subsection. (5) Despite subsection (4), in areas of known, widespread soil contamination, where it is not possible to avoid the influence of historical industrial emissions to soil surfaces, the sampling program may still be undertaken if, (a) it is designed to determine the change in contaminant of concern concentration as it varies with increased depth from the surface; and (b) the use of this sampling program approach can be justified. (6) The sampling and analysis program shall be used to establish the 90th percentile of the concentration of the contaminants of concern present in the soil. (7) The value established in accordance with subsection (6) is the natural local background concentration soil standard for that contaminant of concern at that property that shall be proposed under subsection (1). (8) If the concentration of contaminants of concern show large variability, increased replicate sampling (that is, more than two replicate samples) and averaging the analytical results from the replicate sampling may be used to establish the 90th percentile. (9) Despite subsections (4) to (8), existing geological summary data may also be used to estimate the natural local background concentrations in place of sampling data to support the soil standard proposal under subsection (1), if, in the opinion of the Director, the sampling method used to obtain the data provides data at least as accurate as the estimates that would be provided by the sampling method set out in subsection (4). New science risk assessment 9. (1) A risk assessment is a new science risk assessment if the risk assessment satisfies one or more of the conditions set out in this section. (2) A risk assessment is a new science risk assessment if a contaminant of concern is identified during a phase two environmental site assessment for which there is no applicable site condition standard, as described in subsections 43 (2) and (3) of the regulation, and the property owner, (a) chooses to develop a standard specified in the risk assessment by undertaking a risk assessment using quantitative analysis for both human health and the natural environment as described in this Schedule; or (b) adopts a standard from a credible agency. (3) For the purposes of subsection (2), an agency is a credible agency if it incorporates one or more of the following in developing contaminant standards: 1. Rigorous peer review of the standards by regulatory bodies, public organizations or academic institutions or any combination of them. 2. A process to ensure the ongoing review and updating of the standards. 3. The standards and the rationale for setting the standards are publicly available. (4) A risk assessment is a new science risk assessment if the risk assessment uses a computer model that, (a) is not available to the public; or (b) is available to risk assessment practitioners for a fee but has not been used by the Ministry. (5) If a risk assessment uses a computer model referred to in subsection (4), the qualified person shall, upon the request of the Director, include an electronic copy of the computer model in the risk assessment report in a manner that does not violate any person’s copyright or other intellectual property rights. (6) If a risk assessment uses a computer model referred to in subsection (4), the following information shall be provided in the risk assessment report to support the selection and use of the computer model: 1. A list of assumptions used in the development of the model and a discussion of the validity of the assumptions for the RA property, including the effect invalid assumptions will have on the model results. 2. Any information used to generate the computer model inputs. (7) A risk assessment is a new science risk assessment if there is use of a probabilistic model and may be used if it meets the criteria set out in subsection (8) and in no other circumstances. (8) A risk assessment that uses a probabilistic model may be used if the model is used for the exposure assessments described in Report Section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)) of Table 1 of this Schedule and for no other purposes and shall be sufficiently supported by data. Wider area of abatement risk assessment 10. (1) A risk assessment is a wider area of abatement risk assessment if the Ministry has identified the RA property to be within a wider area of abatement in its comments on the pre-submission form or in a notice issued under subsection 46 (2) of the regulation. (2) If the Ministry has identified the property to be within a wider area of abatement, the wider area of abatement risk assessment must include, (a) consultation with the applicable Ministry of the Environment District or Regional Office regarding the implications of the risk assessment report recommendations; and (b) development and implementation of a public communication plan. Exemption 11. Despite sections 4 and 5, if the Director considers it appropriate in the circumstances and in the public interest after having regard to the RA property, the contaminants of concern and the human and ecological receptors to be addressed in a risk assessment report, the Director in the course of providing comments on a pre-submission form submitted under subsection 3 (1) or in a notice issued under subsection 46 (2) of the regulation, may exempt the risk assessment report from, (a) a requirement in relation to the preparation of a risk assessment report specified in section 4; (b) a requirement to make a certification in an appendix to the risk assessment report as specified in section 5. Table 1 Mandatory Requirements for Risk assessment Reports Column 1 Report Section | Column 2 Heading | Column 3 Sub-Heading | Column 4 Minimum Requirements 1. Summary of Recommendations and Findings | (a) Risk Assessment Objectives and Approach | not applicable | 1. Summarize the risk assessment objectives, including those specified in Report Section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)). 2. Summarize the type or types of risk assessment approaches taken to meet the objectives. 1. Summary of Recommendations and Findings | (b) Deviations from Pre-submission Form | not applicable | Describe in detail any deviations from the information provided in the pre-submission form including, (a) any changes to the conceptual site model that was submitted as part of the form; (b) whether there has been a change in the type of risk assessment approach identified in the form; and (c) whether another computer model was used other than the model specified in the form. 1. Summary of Recommendations and Findings | (c) Risk Assessment Standards | not applicable | State the proposed standard specified in the risk assessment for each contaminant of concern. 1. Summary of Recommendations and Findings | (d) Risk Assessment Assumptions | not applicable | State the assumptions used in determining each standard specified in the risk assessment, including property use assumptions. 1. Summary of Recommendations and Findings | (e) Risk Management Requirements | not applicable | State the risk management measures and on-going monitoring, maintenance and contingency plan requirements, if applicable. 2. Risk Assessment Team Membership | not applicable | not applicable | 1. State the expertise required to complete this risk assessment and design of any risk management measures specified in Report Section 7 (Risk Management Plan) and justify the omission of areas of expertise normally associated with the completion of a risk assessment. 2. Identify each team member with the expertise necessary to complete the risk assessment and state how their qualifications relate to the given role and expertise required for this risk assessment. 3. Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation | (a) Property Information | not applicable | 1. State the property location and ownership. 2. Describe the general physical characteristics of the property including size of the property and size of contaminated area. 3. Provide sufficient detail on the property to support the conceptual site model used in the preparation of the risk assessment report, including, (a) a summary of past and current use of property; (b) a summary of past and current use of any relevant property that is adjacent to the property; (c) a description of off-site sources of contaminants of concern and off-site receptors; and (d) an indication of the proposed use of property. 3. Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation | (b) Site Plan and Hydrogeological Interpretation of RA Property | not applicable | 1. Provide the site plans, cross-sections and a hydrogeological interpretation of the RA property that satisfies the requirements of clauses 3 (8) (a), (b) and (c) and that was relied upon in the preparation of the risk assessment and all documentation used to support this interpretation. 2. If a non-standard delineation was conducted in accordance with section 7.1 of Schedule E as part of preparing the phase two environmental site assessment report, a narrative description of how the non-standard delineation satisfies the requirements in that section. 3. Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation | (c) Contaminants of Concern | not applicable | 1. List all of the contaminants of concern. 2. The contaminants of concern must include the following: i. Any contaminants detected on, in or under the RA property that exceed the applicable site condition standards. ii. Any contaminants detected on, in or under the RA property and for which no applicable site condition standard is prescribed under Part IX (Site Condition Standards and Risk Assessment) of the regulation. 3. Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation | (c) Contaminants of Concern | (i) Sampling Programs | 1. With reference to the sampling programs summarized in the appendices to the risk assessment report, describe how the program is adequate for the risk assessment objectives and approach specified in Report Section 1 (Summary of Recommendations and Findings). 2. In the case of an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment, specify the methods that were used to estimate the local background concentrations in soil, including details of, (a) any sampling programs undertaken in accordance with subsections 8 (4) to (8); (b) any existing geological data, as described in subsection 8 (9) that were used to estimate the natural local background concentrations in place of sampling data. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (a) Problem Formulation | (i) Human Health Conceptual Site Model | Provide a human health conceptual site model that, (a) satisfies the requirements of clause 3 (8) (b) and is consistent with the information upon which the diagrams referred to in that clause are based; (b) explains how the information provided under Report Section 3 (Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation) was incorporated into and is consistent with the human health conceptual site model; and (c) was relied upon in the preparation of the risk assessment. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (a) Problem Formulation | (ii) Risk Assessment Objectives | 1. State the objectives of the human health risk assessment and include an indication of, (a) the proposed use of the RA property; (b) the receptors and exposure pathways to be assessed by the human health risk assessment; (c) whether a qualitative or quantitative assessment of risk or both will be used in the human health risk assessment; and (d) the type of approach used for the human health risk assessment. 2. Demonstrate that the data used for the human health risk assessment is sufficient to meet the objectives of the assessment, having regard to, (a) the data quality objectives specified in the reports on the sampling program summarized in the appendices to the risk assessment report; and (b) any other relevant information the qualified person has gathered or obtained in conducting the assessment. 3. State how any uncertainty resulting from variable data, poor data quality or gaps in data in relation to the RA property affected, (a) the setting of objectives for the human health risk assessment; and (b) the ability to meet those objectives. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (b) Exposure Assessment | (i) Receptor Characteristics | Describe in detail the characteristics of every human receptor, both on and off the RA property, identified in the human health conceptual site model. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (b) Exposure Assessment | (ii) Pathway Analysis | Describe in detail every exposure pathway identified in the human health conceptual site model. Justify which exposure pathways are incomplete. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (b) Exposure Assessment | (iii) Exposure Estimates | For every complete exposure pathway state, (a) the relative frequency and duration of actual or potential exposures; (b) the relative magnitude of exposure to the human receptors, using measured contaminant exposure concentrations or concentrations predicted through fate and transport modelling; and (c) given the uncertainty described under Heading (a) (Problem Formulation), how does this uncertainty affect the outcomes of the exposure assessments conducted under clauses (a) and (b). 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (c) Toxicity Assessment | (i) Nature of Toxicity (Hazard Assessment) | For each contaminant of concern, (a) state the potential adverse health effects on the human receptors associated with their exposure to those contaminants; and (b) indicate whether the contaminants are carcinogenic or exhibit threshold or non-threshold characteristics. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (c) Toxicity Assessment | (ii) Dose Response Assessment | For each contaminant of concern, (a) describe the relationship between the magnitude of exposure to the contaminant from each route of exposure and the probability of the occurrence of the adverse health effects identified in the hazard assessment; (b) if the data permits, identify the appropriate toxicity limit, from published limits available from a credible agency as described in subsection 9 (3) for each of the routes of exposure identified in clause (a); and (c) analyze the sources of uncertainty in the data used to conduct the hazard assessment and the dose response assessment, including any gaps or variability in the data and state how such uncertainty could affect these assessments. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (i) Interpretation of Health Risks | For each contaminant of concern, having regard to the exposure assessment and the toxicity assessment, state the risk attributable in respect of that contaminant to each exposure route for human receptors on the RA property, using either a quantitative or qualitative analysis. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (ii) Quantitative Interpretation of Health Risks | A quantitative analysis undertaken for a contaminant of concern must include the following: i. Provide a comparison of the dose response assessment to the exposure estimate to derive the risk level or hazard quotient at the RA property in the absence of any measures that have been taken or are being proposed at the RA property which have the effect of reducing the risk from the contaminant of concern. ii. For each contaminant of concern with non-threshold toxic effects and taking into consideration any risk management measures that are being proposed in the risk assessment, propose and justify a human health standard for the contaminant, ensuring that the standard meets a target risk level of 1 × 10–6 for each environmental medium. iii. For each contaminant of concern with threshold toxic effects and taking into consideration any risk management measures that are being proposed in the risk assessment, propose and justify a human health standard for the contaminant, ensuring that each human receptor does not receive an estimated dose exceeding 0.2 × the limit dose (TDI, RfD or RfC) for each environmental medium. In this paragraph, “TDI” means tolerable daily intake, “RfD” means the reference dose, “RfC” means the reference concentration. The units used to measure the TDI, the RfD and the RfC must be specified and conform to acceptable conventions. iv. If, under paragraph iii, given the circumstances of the human receptors and the characteristics of the contaminant, it is unreasonable to apply a hazard quotient of less than or equal to 0.2 for each environmental medium, a higher hazard quotient may be proposed, if the proposed quotient is accompanied with a detailed site specific multi-media exposure assessment that considers the transport of the contaminant across all environmental media to the human receptors by all exposure pathways and ensures that the standard achieves the same level of protection for each human receptor as is intended to be achieved by the applicable full depth generic site condition standard for that contaminant. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (iii) Qualitative Interpretation of Health Risks | A qualitative analysis undertaken for a contaminant of concern must include the following: i. Provide a justification for why a quantitative analysis was not undertaken. ii. Describe the justification process being used as part of the qualitative analysis. The justification process includes a non-numeric characterization of risk and may include a numeric assessment of exposure or toxicity for screening purposes and risk prioritization. iii. Taking into consideration any risk management measures that are being proposed for the RA property, propose and justify a human health standard for the contaminant. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (iv) Special Considerations | If section 41 or 43.1 of the regulation applies to a RA property, the justification for the health standard being proposed for the RA property must take into account the site conditions that make section 41 or 43.1 of the regulation apply to the RA property. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (v) Interpretation of Off-Site Health Risks | For each contaminant of concern, assess whether the human health standard being proposed for the RA property is likely to result in a concentration greater than the applicable full depth site condition standard at the nearest human receptor located off the RA property and, if this is the case for any contaminant, specify the contaminant, the applicable site condition for that contaminant and the property where the human receptor is located and describe the human receptors that may be impacted. 4. Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) | (d) Risk Characterization | (vi) Discussion of Uncertainty | Having regard to the discussions of uncertainty under Heading (b) (Exposure Assessment) and Heading (c) (Toxicity Assessment), state how such uncertainty could affect the interpretation of risk in this report section and the need to manage such risks. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (a) Problem Formulation | (i) Ecological Conceptual Site Model | Provide an ecological conceptual site model that, (a) satisfies the requirements of clauses 3 (8) (b) and (c) and is consistent with the information upon which the diagrams referred to in that clause are based; (b) explains how the information provided under Report Section 3 (Property Information, Site Plan and Geological Interpretation) was incorporated into and is consistent with the ecological conceptual site model; and (c) was relied upon in the preparation of the risk assessment. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (a) Problem Formulation | (ii) Risk Assessment Objectives | 1. State the objectives of the ecological risk assessment and include an indication of, (a) the proposed use of the RA property; (b) which ecological receptors on the RA property are considered to be valued ecosystem components, the degree to which they must be protected and a justification to support such decisions; (c) the exposure pathways to be assessed in the ecological risk assessment; (d) whether a qualitative or quantitative assessment of risk or both will be used in the ecological risk assessment; (e) the type of approach used for the ecological risk assessment. 2. Demonstrate that the data used for the ecological risk assessment are sufficient to meet the objectives of the assessment, having regard to, (a) the data quality objectives specified in the reports on the sampling program summarized in the appendices to the risk assessment report; and (b) any other relevant information that the qualified person has gathered or obtained in conducting the assessment. 3. State how any uncertainty resulting from variable data, poor data quality or gaps in data in relation to the RA property affected, (a) the setting of objectives for the ecological risk assessment; and (b) the ability to meet those objectives. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (b) Receptor Characterization | not applicable | Describe in detail the characteristics of every valued ecosystem component, both on and off the RA property, identified in the ecological conceptual site model. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (c) Exposure Assessment | (i) Pathway Analysis | Describe in detail every exposure pathway identified in the ecological conceptual site model. Justify which exposure pathways are incomplete. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (c) Exposure Assessment | (ii) Exposure Estimates | For every complete exposure pathway, state, (a) the relative frequency and duration of actual or potential exposures; (b) the relative magnitude of exposure to the valued ecosystem components, using measured contaminant exposure concentrations or concentrations predicted through fate and transport modelling in a manner compatible with that used in the human health risk assessment; and (c) given the uncertainty described under the heading of “Problem Formulation”, how does this uncertainty affect the outcomes of the exposure assessments conducted under clauses (a) and (b). 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (d) Hazard Assessment | not applicable | 1. State the potential adverse effects on the valued ecosystem components associated with their exposure to each contaminant of concern. 2. For each contaminant of concern, (a) describe the relationship between the magnitude of exposure to the contaminant from each route of exposure and the probability of the occurrence of the adverse ecological effect identified in the hazard assessment; (b) if the data permits, propose a toxicity reference value for each of the routes of exposure identified in clause (a); and (c) analyze the sources of uncertainty in the data used to conduct the hazard assessment, including any gaps or variability in the data and state how such uncertainty could affect the assessment. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (i) Interpretation of Ecological Risks | For each contaminant of concern, having regard to the exposure assessment and the hazard assessment, state the risk attributable in respect of that contaminant to each exposure route for the valued ecological components on the RA property, using either a quantitative or qualitative analysis. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (ii) Quantitative Interpretation of Ecological Risks | A quantitative analysis that has been undertaken for a contaminant of concern must include the following: i. For each valued ecosystem component, provide a comparison of the toxicity reference value proposed in the “Hazard Assessment” to the exposure estimate proposed in the “Exposure Assessment” to derive an estimate of the degree of risk at the RA property in the absence of any measures that have been taken or are being proposed at the RA property which have the effect of reducing the risk from the contaminant of concern. ii. Provide narrative to describe all magnitudes, comparisons and limitations relied upon to derive the risk under paragraph i. iii. Taking into consideration any risk management measures being proposed in the risk assessment, propose and justify an ecological standard for the contaminant, ensuring that the standard achieves the same level of protection for each valued ecosystem component that is intended to be achieved by the applicable full-depth generic site condition standard for that contaminant. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (iii) Qualitative Interpretation of Ecological Risks | A qualitative analysis that has been undertaken for a contaminant of concern must include the following: i. Provide a justification for why a quantitative analysis was not undertaken. ii. Describe the justification process being used as part of the qualitative analysis. The justification process includes a non-numeric characterization of risk and may include a numeric assessment of exposure or toxicity for screening purposes and risk prioritization. iii. Taking into consideration any risk management measures being proposed for the RA property, propose and justify an ecological standard for the contaminant, ensuring that the standard achieves the same level of protection for each valued ecosystem component that is intended to be achieved by the applicable full-depth generic site condition standard for that contaminant. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (iv) Special Considerations | If a RA property is, (a) located within 30 metres of an “area of natural significance”, includes such an area, is adjacent to such an area or part of such an area, the justification for the ecological standard being proposed for the RA property must ensure that the standard is protective of the conditions that causes the area to be an area of natural significance; and (b) subject to section 41 or 43.1 of the regulation, the justification for the ecological standard being proposed for the RA property must take into account the site conditions that make section 41 or 43.1 of the regulation apply to the RA property. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (v) Interpretation of Off-Site Ecological Risks | For each contaminant of concern, assess whether the ecological standard being proposed for the RA property is likely to result in a concentration greater than the applicable full depth site condition standard at the nearest ecological receptor located off the RA property and, if this is the case for any contaminant, specify the contaminant, the applicable site condition standard for that contaminant and the property where the ecological receptor is located and describe the ecological receptors that may be impacted. 5. Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) | (e) Risk Characterization | (vi) Discussion of Uncertainty | Having regard to the discussions of uncertainty under headings “Exposure Assessment” and “Hazard Assessment”, state how such uncertainty could affect the interpretation of risk advanced in this report section and the need to manage such risks. 6. Conclusions and Recommendations | not applicable | (i) Recommended Standards | 1. A standard must be specific in the risk assessment for each contaminant of concern. The specified standard shall be, at a minimum, the more stringent of the human health standard and the ecological standard being proposed for the RA property. 2. In the case of an estimation of natural local background concentration risk assessment, the specified standard shall be the local background concentration soil standard proposed under subsection 8 (1) of this Schedule. 3. State critical assumptions on which the standards specified in the risk assessment rely, having regard to the discussion of uncertainty under Heading (d) (Risk Characterization) in Report Section 4 (Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA)) and under Heading (e) (Risk Characterization) in Report Section 5 (Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA)). 4. If the phase two environmental site assessment that was relied upon in the preparation of the risk assessment has been prepared using a non-standard delineation conducted in accordance with section 7.1 of Schedule E, i. state that the phase two environmental site assessment was prepared using a non-standard delineation, ii. state the contaminants of concern and media to which non-standard delineation was applied, and iii. provide a discussion of the implications that the application of the non-standard delineation to the stated contaminants of concern and media may have on the conclusions reached in the risk assessment report. 6. Conclusions and Recommendations | not applicable | (ii) Special Considerations for Ground Water Standards | If a standard being proposed in the risk assessment for ground water in or under the RA property is greater than 50% of the solubility limit, demonstrate the risk of free product formation and propose any risk management measures necessary in order to mitigate the formation of free product. 7. Risk Management Plan (if applicable) | (a) Risk Management Plan | (i) Risk Management Performance Objectives | 1. State the exposure pathways and environmental media that risk management measures are intended to address. 2. State the required reduction in exposure concentration that the risk management measures are intended to achieve. 7. Risk Management Plan (if applicable) | (a) Risk Management Plan | (ii) Risk Management Measures | 1. To achieve the specified performance objectives, (a) propose risk management measures on the RA property that are designed to prevent, eliminate or ameliorate any adverse effects on or off the RA property; (b) propose restrictions on the use of the RA property, including any restriction that applies to the construction of a building on the property; or (c) propose a combination of measures specified in clauses (a) and (b). 2. State the implications of the risk management plan for off-site health and ecological receptors. 7. Risk Management Plan (if applicable) | (a) Risk Management Plan | (iii) Duration of Risk Management Measures | Specify the duration the proposed risk management measures are required to remain in place to ensure the specified performance objectives are achieved. 7. Risk Management Plan (if applicable) | (a) Risk Management Plan | (iv) Requirements for Monitoring and Maintenance | 1. Specify the designed lifespan of the measure, if applicable. 2. Propose a program for one or more of the following activities, if the program is necessary to achieve the specified risk management performance objectives: i. A program which includes procedures for the ongoing maintenance, monitoring and replacement of the risk management measures to ensure they remain operable for the period identified in this report under the sub-heading “Duration of Risk Management Measures”. ii. A program which includes procedures for the ongoing monitoring of contaminants of concern. iii. A contingency plan for meeting the Risk Management Performance Objectives if the Risk Management Measures fail. 8. Public Communication Plan (if applicable) | (a) Public Communication Plan | (i) Optional Communication Plans | If the owner has implemented a plan to consult the public as part of the development of the risk assessment, provide, (a) a description of the plan, including any opportunities given to the public to comment on the proposed risk assessment; (b) a summary of the comments received during the consultation; and (c) a description of how the public comments were considered as part of the risk assessment process. 8. Public Communication Plan (if applicable) | (a) Public Communication Plan | (ii) Required Communication Plans For RA Properties in Wider Area of Abatement | If the risk assessment has been identified by the Ministry as relating to a property located within a wider area of abatement under section 10, the risk assessment shall include, (a) a description of the public communication plan required by clause 10 (2) (b) including any opportunities given to the public to comment on the proposed risk assessment; (b) a summary of the comments received during consultation under the plan; (c) a description of how the public comments were considered as part of the risk assessment process; and (d) a copy of all the written comments received from the Ministry under clause 10 (2) (a).
Read the records of site condition — part XV.1 of the act on e-Laws ↗

Made under Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.19.