Police Act, RSBC 1996, c. 367

Section 138

Determining whether to arrange public hearing or review on the record in other circumstances

Cite as Police Act, RSBC 1996, c. 367, s. 138 · read from BC Laws on November 17, 2026

The text

(1) The police complaint commissioner must arrange a public hearing or review on the record if, after considering the factors referred to in subsection (2), the police complaint commissioner determines that a public hearing or review on the record is necessary in the public interest. (2) In determining whether a public hearing or review on the record is necessary in the public interest, the police complaint commissioner must consider all relevant factors including, without limitation, the following: (a) the nature and seriousness of the complaint or alleged misconduct; (b) the nature and seriousness of harm or loss alleged to have been suffered by any person as a result of the conduct of the member or former member, including, without limitation, whether (i) the conduct has caused, or would be likely to cause, physical, emotional or psychological harm or financial loss to a person, (ii) the conduct has violated, or would be likely to violate, a person's dignity, privacy or other rights recognized by law, or (iii) the conduct has undermined, or would be likely to undermine, public confidence in the police, the handling of complaints or the disciplinary process; (c) whether there is a reasonable prospect that a public hearing or review would assist in determining the truth; (d) whether an arguable case can be made that (i) there was a flaw in the investigation, (ii) the disciplinary or corrective measures proposed are inappropriate or inadequate, or (iii) the discipline authority's interpretation or application of this Part or any other enactment was incorrect. (2.1) A determination under this section as to whether a public hearing is necessary in the public interest may be made, on the police complaint commissioner's own initiative, at any time after the police complaint commissioner receives a final investigation report. (2.2) A determination under this section as to whether a review on the record is necessary in the public interest may be made, on the police complaint commissioner's own initiative, at any time after a copy of the discipline authority's report is provided to the police complaint commissioner under section 133 (1) (b) [review of discipline proceedings]. (3) The police complaint commissioner must make a determination under this section as to whether a public hearing or review on the record is necessary in the public interest (a) promptly after, as the case may be, (i) the police complaint commissioner receives a request under section 136 [time limit for requesting public hearing or review on the record] in circumstances other than those described in section 137 (1) [circumstances when member or former member concerned is entitled to public hearing], or (ii) the relevant limitation period expires, and (b) in any event, not later than 20 business days after (i) the request referred to in paragraph (a) (i) of this subsection is received, or (ii) the relevant limitation period referred to in paragraph (a) (ii) of this subsection expires. (3.1) If the police complaint commissioner decides or is required to arrange a public hearing, the police complaint commissioner may consolidate matters to be heard at the public hearing including, without limitation, by doing the following: (a) consolidating 2 or more matters involving the same member or former member; (b) consolidating 2 or more matters involving different members or former members, if the police complaint commissioner considers that the matters are related. (4) Within 10 business days after determining that a public hearing or review on the record is necessary in the public interest, the police complaint commissioner must notify the following of that determination: (a) the complainant, if any; (b) the member or former member whose conduct is the subject of concern; (c) a chief constable of the municipal police department with which the member is employed or, in the case of a former member, a chief constable of the municipal police department with which the former member was employed at the time of the conduct of concern; (d) if the member or former member concerned is or was the chief constable of a municipal police department, the chair of the board of that municipal police department; (e) the discipline authority involved, if different than the chief constable or chair of the board referred to in paragraph (c) or (d). (5) If the police complaint commissioner determines, in respect of a request referred to in subsection (3), that a public hearing or review on the record is not necessary in the public interest, the police complaint commissioner must, within 10 business days after making the determination, (a) notify the persons referred to in subsection (4), and (b) give written reasons for that determination. (6) A determination under subsection (5) is final and conclusive and is not open to question or review by a court on any ground. (7) If the police complaint commissioner (a) is required under section 137 to arrange a public hearing, or (b) determines under this section that a public hearing is necessary in the public interest, the police complaint commissioner must, for the purposes of the public hearing under section 143, appoint legal counsel to present to the adjudicator the case relative to each allegation of misconduct against the member or former member concerned.
Read the Police Act on BC Laws ↗