Hospital Act, RSBC 1996, c. 200
Section 46
Hospital Appeal Board
Cite as Hospital Act, RSBC 1996, c. 200, s. 46 · read from BC Laws on November 17, 2026
The text
(1) The Hospital Appeal Board, consisting of the members appointed under subsection (4), is continued for the purpose of providing practitioners appeals from
(a) a decision of a board of management that modifies, refuses, suspends, revokes or fails to renew a practitioner's permit to practise in a hospital, or
(b) the failure or refusal of a board of management to consider and decide on an application for a permit.
(1.1) and (1.2) [Repealed 2004-45-102.]
(2) The Hospital Appeal Board may affirm, vary, reverse or substitute its own decision for that of a board of management on the terms and conditions it considers appropriate.
(2.1) A practitioner may appeal to the Hospital Appeal Board if
(a) the practitioner is dissatisfied with the decision of a hospital's board, or
(b) a hospital's board fails to notify the practitioner of its decision within the prescribed time.
(2.2) A practitioner who wishes to appeal under subsection (2.1) is not required to first proceed by way of an application to the hospital's board.
(2.3) An appeal to the Hospital Appeal Board is a new hearing.
(3) The Hospital Appeal Board has exclusive jurisdiction to inquire into, hear and determine all those matters and questions of fact, law and discretion arising or required to be determined in an appeal under this section and to make any order permitted to be made.
(3.1) A decision or order of the Hospital Appeal Board under this Act on a matter in respect of which the Hospital Appeal Board has exclusive jurisdiction is final and conclusive and is not open to question or review in any court.
(3.2) A practitioner who wishes to appeal under subsection (2.1) must deliver the notice of appeal
(a) if the appeal concerns a board's decision under subsection (2.1) (a), not later than 90 days after the date that the board caused a notice of its decision to be sent to the practitioner, or
(b) if the appeal concerns a board's decision under subsection (2.1) (b), not later than 210 days after the date that the practitioner applied for a permit in the prescribed manner.
(3.3) A notice of appeal must
(a) be in writing or in another form authorized by the rules of the Hospital Appeal Board and directed to the chair of that board,
(b) set out the grounds for appeal,
(c) state whether or not the appellant waives an oral hearing of the matter,
(d) state the outcome requested,
(e) contain the name, address and telephone number of the appellant, and, if the appellant has an agent to act on the appellant's behalf in respect of the appeal, the name of the agent and a telephone number at which the agent may be contacted during regular business hours,
(f) include an address for delivery of notices in respect of the appeal,
(g) be signed by the appellant or the appellant's agent,
(h) include reference to any correspondence, documents and memoranda relating to the matter in issue, and
(i) if applicable, include a copy of the order or decision being appealed.
(3.4) Unless both parties have waived an oral hearing of an appeal, the Hospital Appeal Board must as soon as practicable set a time and place for the hearing and promptly notify the parties in writing.
(3.5) If the parties have waived an oral hearing of an appeal, or in an interim or preliminary matter, the Hospital Appeal Board may hold any combination of written, electronic or oral hearings.
(3.6) On written application by either party, the Hospital Appeal Board may extend the time for doing anything required under this section except the time for the bringing of an appeal under subsection (3.2).
(3.7) If a notice of appeal is deficient, the chair of the Hospital Appeal Board or the chair's delegate may allow a reasonable period of time within which the notice may be corrected.
(4) Subject to subsection (4.1), the minister must appoint 10 members of the Hospital Appeal Board as follows:
(a) one member designated as the chair;
(b) one member designated as the vice chair after consultation with the chair;
(c) other members appointed after consultation with the chair.
(4.1) For the purposes of subsection (4), the members of the Hospital Appeal Board must be appointed as follows:
(a) one member selected after a merit-based process from among 3 or more individuals nominated by the board of the regulatory college that is responsible, under the Health Professions and Occupations Act, for governing the designated health profession of medicine;
(b) one member selected after a merit-based process from among 3 or more individuals nominated by the board of the regulatory college that is responsible, under the Health Professions and Occupations Act, for governing the designated health profession of dentistry;
(c) one member who is authorized to practise the designated health profession of midwifery, selected after a merit-based process from among 3 or more individuals nominated by the board of the regulatory college that is responsible, under the Health Professions and Occupations Act, for governing that designated health profession;
(d) one member selected after a merit-based process from among 3 or more individuals nominated by the executive body of the Association of Doctors of BC;
(e) 6 other members selected after a merit-based process.
(4.2) The following provisions of the Administrative Tribunals Act apply to the Hospital Appeal Board:
(a) Part 1 [Interpretation and Application];
(b) Part 2 [Appointments];
(c) Part 3 [Clustering];
(d) Part 4 [Practice and Procedure], except the following:
(i) section 21 [notice of hearing by publication];
(ii) section 22 [notice of appeal (inclusive of prescribed fee)];
(iii) section 23 [notice of appeal (exclusive of prescribed fee)];
(iv) section 24 [time limit for appeals];
(v) section 36 [form of hearing of application];
(vi) section 40 [information admissible in tribunal proceedings];
(vii) section 41 [hearing open to public];
(e) section 44 [tribunal without jurisdiction over constitutional questions];
(f) section 46.2 [limited jurisdiction and discretion to decline jurisdiction to apply the Human Rights Code];
(g) Part 6 [Costs and Sanctions], except sections 47.1 [security for costs] and 47. 2 [government and agents of government];
(h) Part 7 [Decisions];
(i) Part 8 [Immunities];
(j) section 57 [time limit for judicial review];
(k) section 58 [standard of review with privative clause];
(l) section 59.1 [surveys];
(m) section 59.2 [reporting];
(n) section 60 (1) (a), (b) and (d) to (i) and (2) [power to make regulations];
(o) section 61 [application of Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act].
(5) [Repealed 2004-45-102.]
(6) All information or evidence
(a) about an application for a practitioner's permit to practise in a hospital, or contained in the decision of a board of management resulting from the application, or
(b) received by, or presented to, the Hospital Appeal Board for an appeal
is privileged and an action must not be brought against a person for it.
(7) [Repealed 2003-47-33.]
(8) Before giving a decision on an appeal, the Hospital Appeal Board may refer a matter to a professional or other organization in the health field to obtain expert assistance or a formal report.
(9) [Repealed 2003-47-33.]
Read the Hospital Act on BC Laws ↗