Commercial Liens Act, SBC 2022, c. 9
Section 58
Consequences of non-compliance with Act
Cite as Commercial Liens Act, SBC 2022, c. 9, s. 58 · read from BC Laws on November 17, 2026
The text
(1) A person to whom a duty or obligation is owed under this Act has a cause of action against any person who, without reasonable excuse, fails to discharge the duty or perform the obligation.
(2) Subject to subsection (4), in an action under subsection (1), the plaintiff is entitled to recover damages from the defendant for losses that are reasonably foreseeable as being liable to result from the failure to discharge the duty or perform the obligation.
(3) The damages prescribed under section 69 (4) [consequences of non-compliance with Act] of the Personal Property Security Act apply in respect of an action brought under subsection (1) of this section in the following circumstances:
(a) where the plaintiff is the owner and the cause of action is for failure to comply with the following provisions:
(i) section 43 (15) [registration of financing statements] of the Personal Property Security Act as adopted by section 16 [application of Personal Property Security Act] of this Act;
(ii) section 17 (1) to (5) or (7) [amendment or discharge of registrations];
(iii) section 24 [care of goods in lien holder's possession];
(iv) section 25 (3) [demand for information from lien holder];
(v) section 26 (2) [failure to reply to demand under section 25];
(vi) section 29 [payment for demand];
(vii) section 32 (1), (2) or (3) [seizure by bailiff];
(viii) section 33 (2) (b) [lien holder must not cause greater inconvenience than necessarily incidental];
(ix) section 37 [disposition of goods by lien holder];
(x) section 38 [notice of disposition];
(xi) section 41 (1) or (2) [process of lien holder disposing of goods subject to a lien];
(xii) section 42 [lien holder proposal to take goods in satisfaction of lien];
(xiii) section 45 (9) or 46 (9) [lien holder to discharge registration];
(b) where the plaintiff is a person required to be identified in a financing statement in accordance with section 12 (2) (b) [perfection by registration], and the cause of action is for failure to comply with section 43 (15) of the Personal Property Security Act as adopted by section 16 of this Act.
(4) If
(a) damages have been prescribed under the Personal Property Security Act and apply in respect of a cause of action referred to subsection (3) of this section, and
(b) the court finds that the defendant is liable in respect of the cause of action,
the court must award the prescribed damages to the plaintiff, unless the actual damages exceed the prescribed damages, in which case the court may award the actual damages.
(5) A defendant is not liable for both prescribed damages and actual damages.
(6) In an action for a deficiency, the defendant may raise as a defence the failure on the part of the lien holder to comply with obligations referred to in subsection (7), but non-compliance limits the right to the deficiency only to the extent that the non-compliance has affected the ability of the defendant to protect the defendant's interest in the goods or has made the accurate determination of the deficiency impracticable.
(7) If a lien holder fails to comply with obligations under the following sections, subsection (8) of this section applies:
(a) section 24 [care of goods in lien holder's possession];
(b) section 25 (3) [demands about goods];
(c) section 29 [payment for demand];
(d) section 37 [disposition of goods by lien holder];
(e) section 38 [notice of disposition];
(f) section 39 [purchase of goods by lien holder];
(g) section 41 (1) or (2) [process of lien holder disposing of goods subject to a lien].
(8) If a lien holder fails to comply with any of the obligations under the sections set out in subsection (7) of this section, the onus is on the lien holder to show that the failure
(a) did not affect the owner's ability to protect the owner's interest in the goods by redemption of the goods or otherwise, or
(b) did not make the accurate determination of the deficiency impracticable.
(9) Except as otherwise provided in this Act, a provision in an authorization, acknowledgement or any other agreement that purports to exclude a duty or onus imposed by this Act or that purports to limit the liability of or the amount of damages recoverable from a person who has failed to discharge a duty or obligation imposed by this Act is void.
Read the Commercial Liens Act on BC Laws ↗