West Virginia 2020 Regular Session Status: Enacted Bipartisan · 2 R · 1 D cosponsors

HB 4178 — Requiring calls which are recorded be maintained for a period of five years

Last action — Chapter 297, Acts, Regular Session, 2020

Track this bill free

No card. One bill, free forever — alerts when it moves.

  1. ✓
    Introduced
  2. ✓
    In Committee
  3. ✓
    Passed House of Delegates
  4. ✓
    Passed Senate
  5. ✓
    To Executive
  6. 6
    Enacted

This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced January 14, 2020. Enacted.

Prognosis

Likely to advance 98% · high confidence

Where this bill stands today.

Odds of enactment

High

How often bills like it became law.

  • Enacted

    Current position in the legislative process.

  • 6 sponsors

    1 primary, 5 co-sponsors signed on.

  • Bipartisan support

    Sponsored across 2 parties (2 R · 1 D) — cross-party backing.

  • Cleared a recorded vote

    Passed 3 recorded votes so far.

Prognosis reads this bill's own signals — stage, sponsorship breadth, committee status, recorded votes and cross-state momentum. Odds come from a model trained on which bills have become law.

Bill Text

What changed in the latest version

154 added · 13 removed

Plain-language change summary

The bill HB 4178 has been amended to require that recorded emergency service calls be maintained for a minimum of two years instead of five years. This change is significant because it reduces the time that these recordings must be kept, which may lessen the burden on emergency services in managing their records. Additionally, the language around civil liability for center personnel has been softened, changing from mandatory to optional, which could affect accountability regarding information disclosure.

→
Previous
Latest
HB4178 SFAT #1 Maynard 3-4 Crouse  7502   Senator Maynard moved to amend the bill by striking out the title and substituting therefor a new title, to read as follows:
HB 4178 Text skip navigation SENATE PRESIDENT SENATORS COMMITTEES VIDEO/AUDIO DISTRICT MAPS SENATE CLERK SENATE RULES HOUSE SPEAKER DELEGATES COMMITTEES VIDEO/AUDIO DISTRICT MAPS HOUSE CLERK HOUSE RULES HOUSE STAFF JOINT INTERIM COMMITTEES LEGISLATIVE ADMINISTRATOR LEGISLATIVE SERVICES DIVISION PUBLIC INFORMATION LEGISLATIVE AUTOMATED SYSTEMS DIVISION LEGISLATIVE AUDITOR'S OFFICE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION & RESEARCH DIVISION POST AUDIT DIVISION BUDGET DIVISION REGULATORY AND FISCAL AFFAIRS DIVISION CLAIMS COMMISSION CRIME VICTIMS RULE-MAKING REVIEW SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS JUDICIAL COMP.
Eng.
COMMISSION JOINT RULES STAFF INFO BILL STATUS BILL STATUS BILL TRACKING STATE LAW WEST VIRGINIA CODE ACTS OF THE LEGISLATURE CODE OF 1931 WV CONSTITUTION US CONSTITUTION REPORTS AGENCY REPORTS AGENCY GRANT AWARDS PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS POST AUDITS EDUCATIONAL CITIZEN’S GUIDE INTERNSHIP PROGRAM PAGE PROGRAM PUBLICATIONS PHOTO GALLERY CAPITOL HISTORY HOW A BILL BECOMES LAW CONTACT SENATE ROSTER HOUSE ROSTER PUBLIC INFO.
House Bill No.
NEWS RELEASES HELPFUL LINKS Enrolled Version - Final Version « House Bill 4178 History OTHER VERSIONS  —  Introduced Version  |   |  Email Key:
4178—A Bill to amend and reenact §24-6-13 of the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, relating to requiring calls which are recorded be maintained for a period of two years.
Green = existing Code.
      Adopted Rejected    
Red = new code to be enacted WEST virginia legislature regular session ENROLLED House Bill 4178 By Delegates Miller, Lovejoy, Lavender-Bowe, D.
Kelly, Hansen and S.
Brown [Passed March 7, 2020;
in effect ninety days from passage.]   AN ACT to amend and reenact §24-6-13 of the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, relating to requiring calls which are recorded be maintained for a period of two years.
Be it enacted by the Legislature of West Virginia:
ARTICLE 6.
LOCAL EMERGENCY TELEPHONE SYSTEM.
§24-6-13.
Confidentiality of certain calls to county answering points and records;
retention of records.
(a) Except as provided by the provisions of this section, calls for emergency service to a county answering point are not confidential.
All calls for emergency service reporting alleged criminal conduct which are recorded electronically, in writing or in any other form are to be kept confidential by the county answering point receiving the call and may be released only pursuant to an order entered by a court of competent jurisdiction, a valid subpoena or through the course of discovery in a criminal action requiring the release of the information:
Provided, That nothing contained in this section may be construed as preventing the county answering point from releasing information to a responding agency as may be necessary for that agency’s response on a call or the completion of necessary reports relating to that call.
(b) Upon proper request and payment of a reasonable fee set by the center director to cover the cost of production, a person or entity may obtain, without court order or a valid subpoena, a transcription of a call for emergency service reporting alleged criminal conduct.
The answering point shall exclude from the transcription any information relating to the identity of the caller including, but not limited to, the caller’s name, address, telephone number or his or her location in relation to the alleged offense or the alleged perpetrator.
If the transcript of a call is such that it cannot be successfully redacted so as to protect the identity of the caller, the answering point may decline to provide the transcript.
In that case, the person requesting the transcription may apply to a court of competent jurisdiction for a court order releasing the transcript.
(c) All calls for emergency service which are recorded electronically, in writing or in any other form are to be maintained for a period of at least two years or longer if required by an order entered by a court of competent jurisdiction or a valid subpoena.
(d) A county answering point may release information to bonafide law-enforcement agencies, the prosecuting attorney of a county or a United States attorney pursuant to a lawful criminal investigation.
Nothing in this article may be construed as prohibiting a freedom of information request under §29B-1-1 et seq.
of this code for information relating to the operation of the center or to calls for emergency service which do not involve reporting of alleged criminal conduct.
(e) Nothing in this article requires disclosure of any information that is specifically exempt from disclosure by statute.
Except as otherwise provided in this article, nothing prohibits disclosure of information that is not specifically exempted from disclosure under a provision of this code.
(f) Every county answering point shall, within 90 days of the effective date of this section, promulgate a written policy, available to the public, reflecting its compliance with the provisions of this section.
(g) No answering point or center personnel may be civilly liable for any injury arising from disclosure of information pursuant to the provisions of this section.
  Bill Status  |  Bill Tracking  |  Legacy WV Code  |  Bulletin Board  |  District Maps  |  Senate Roster  |  House Roster  |  Live  |  Blog  |  Jobs  |  Links  |  Home This Web site is maintained by the West Virginia Legislature's Office of Reference & Information.
 |  Terms of Use  |   Webmaster   |   © 2026 West Virginia Legislature ** Print On Demand Name:
Email:
Phone:
View plain text versions (4)

Action History

  1. Chapter 297, Acts, Regular Session, 2020

  2. Approved by Governor 3/25/20

  3. To Governor 3/19/20

  4. Approved by Governor 3/25/20 - House Journal

  5. Approved by Governor 3/25/20 - Senate Journal

  6. To Governor 3/19/20 - House Journal

  7. To Governor 3/19/20 - Senate Journal

  8. House Message received

  9. Completed legislative action

  10. Communicated to Senate

  11. House concurred in Senate amendment and passed bill (Roll No. 745)

  12. House received Senate message

  13. Senate requests House to concur

  14. Passed Senate with amended title (Roll No. 492)

  15. Read 3rd time

  16. On 3rd reading

  17. Committee amendment adopted (Voice vote)

  18. Read 2nd time

  19. Laid over on 2nd reading 3/4/20

  20. Committee Amendment Reported

  21. Read 2nd time

  22. On 2nd reading

  23. Read 1st time

  24. Immediate consideration

  25. Reported do pass, with amendment

  26. To Government Organization

  27. To Government Organization

  28. Introduced in Senate

  29. Communicated to Senate

  30. Passed House (Roll No. 152)

  31. Read 3rd time

  32. On 3rd reading, Special Calendar

  33. Read 2nd time

  34. On 2nd reading, Special Calendar

  35. Read 1st time

  36. On 1st reading, Special Calendar

  37. Do pass

  38. To House Judiciary

  39. With amendment, do pass, but first to Judiciary

  40. To House Fire Departments and Emergency Medical Services

  41. Introduced in House

  42. To Fire Departments and Emergency Medical Services then Judiciary

  43. Filed for introduction

Sponsors

Sponsorship breakdown

Export CSV (upgrade) →

1 sponsors · 5 co-sponsors · 146 not signed on

Sponsors (1)

Co-sponsors (5)

Not signed on (146)

146 members have not signed on to this bill.

Show all 146 →

"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.

Whip count is in markup. Polling the chamber and every recorded vote this session. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Calling the roll · Tallying · Engrossing

Votes

PASSAGE-SENATE AMENDED HB

Passed 97 Yea · 2 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Republican 25000
Unaffiliated 67201
Democrat 5000
Total 97201
% of votes cast 97%2%0%1%
How each member voted (100)
Member Party Vote
Espinosa — Yea
Kessinger — Yea
Rowe — Yea
Angelucci — Yea
Estep-Burton — Yea
Kump — Yea
Shott — Yea
Atkinson — Yea
Evans — Yea
Lavender-Bowe — Yea
Skaff — Yea
Fast — Yea
Linville — Yea
Sponaugle — Yea
Barnhart — Yea
Fleischauer — Yea
Little — Yea
Staggers — Yea
Longstreth — Yea
Steele — Yea
Foster — Yea
Lovejoy — Yea
Storch — Yea
Bates — Yea
Graves — Yea
Summers — Yea
Bibby — Yea
Hamrick — Yea
Swartzmiller — Yea
Boggs — Yea
Hanna — Yea
Maynard — Yea
Sypolt — Yea
Brown, N. — Yea
Thompson, C. — Yea
Brown, S. — Yea
Hardy — Yea
Miley — Yea
Thompson, R. — Yea
Hartman — Yea
Tomblin — Yea
Byrd — Yea
Hicks — Yea
Nelson — Yea
Cadle — Yea
Higginbotham — Yea
Pack — Yea
Walker — Yea
Hill — Yea
Pethtel — Yea
Waxman — Yea
Canestraro — Yea
Phillips — Yea
Westfall — Yea
Capito — Yea
Porterfield — Yea
Caputo — Yea
Householder — Yea
Wilson — Yea
Pyles — Yea
Cowles — Yea
Zukoff — Yea
Jeffries, J. — Yea
Robinson — Yea
Rodighiero — Yea
Doyle — Yea
Rowan — Yea
Mandt — Nay
Paynter — Nay
Diserio — Not Voting
Evan Hansen Democrat Yea
John Williams Democrat Yea
Mike Pushkin Democrat Yea
Sean Hornbuckle Democrat Yea
Shawn Fluharty Democrat Yea
Ben Queen Republican Yea
Betsy Kelly Republican Yea
Betsy Kelly Republican Yea
Carl Martin Republican Yea
Christopher W. Toney Republican Yea
D. Rolland Jennings Republican Yea
Dean Jeffries Republican Yea
Evan Worrell Republican Yea
Gary G. Howell Republican Yea
George Miller Republican Yea
Jason Barrett Republican Yea
Jeff Campbell Republican Yea
Jim Butler Republican Yea
Joe Ellington Republican Yea
John Paul Hott Republican Yea
Mark Dean Republican Yea
Matthew Rohrbach Republican Yea
Mike Azinger Republican Yea
Pat McGeehan Republican Yea
Patrick Martin Republican Yea
Roger Hanshaw Republican Yea
Roy Cooper Republican Yea
T. Kevan Bartlett Republican Yea
Vernon Criss Republican Yea
William Anderson Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Passage

Passed 34 Yea · 0 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Republican 2000
Unaffiliated 32000
Total 34000
% of votes cast 100%0%0%0%
How each member voted (34)
Member Party Vote
LINDSAY — Yea
SMITH — Yea
BALDWIN — Yea
MANN — Yea
STOLLINGS — Yea
BEACH — Yea
MARONEY — Yea
SWOPE — Yea
BLAIR — Yea
MAYNARD — Yea
SYPOLT — Yea
BOLEY — Yea
PALUMBO — Yea
TAKUBO — Yea
PITSENBARGER — Yea
TARR — Yea
CLINE — Yea
PLYMALE — Yea
TRUMP — Yea
FACEMIRE — Yea
PREZIOSO — Yea
UNGER — Yea
HAMILTON — Yea
ROBERTS — Yea
WELD — Yea
HARDESTY — Yea
ROMANO — Yea
WOELFEL — Yea
IHLENFELD — Yea
RUCKER — Yea
MR PRESIDENT — Yea
JEFFRIES — Yea
Charles H. Clements Republican Yea
Mike Azinger Republican Yea

Official roll call →

PASSAGE

Passed 95 Yea · 2 Nay · 3 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Republican 25000
Unaffiliated 65203
Democrat 5000
Total 95203
% of votes cast 95%2%0%3%
How each member voted (100)
Member Party Vote
Rowan — Yea
Atkinson — Yea
Estep-Burton — Yea
Kessinger — Yea
Rowe — Yea
Evans — Yea
Kump — Yea
Shott — Yea
Barnhart — Yea
Fast — Yea
Lavender-Bowe — Yea
Skaff — Yea
Fleischauer — Yea
Little — Yea
Sponaugle — Yea
Longstreth — Yea
Staggers — Yea
Bates — Yea
Foster — Yea
Lovejoy — Yea
Steele — Yea
Bibby — Yea
Graves — Yea
Storch — Yea
Boggs — Yea
Hamrick — Yea
Summers — Yea
Brown, N. — Yea
Hanna — Yea
Maynard — Yea
Swartzmiller — Yea
Brown, S. — Yea
Sypolt — Yea
Hardy — Yea
Miley — Yea
Thompson, C. — Yea
Byrd — Yea
Hartman — Yea
Thompson, R. — Yea
Cadle — Yea
Hicks — Yea
Nelson — Yea
Tomblin — Yea
Higginbotham — Yea
Pack — Yea
Canestraro — Yea
Hill — Yea
Pethtel — Yea
Walker — Yea
Capito — Yea
Phillips — Yea
Waxman — Yea
Caputo — Yea
Porterfield — Yea
Westfall — Yea
Householder — Yea
Cowles — Yea
Pyles — Yea
Wilson — Yea
Jeffries, J. — Yea
Robinson — Yea
Zukoff — Yea
Diserio — Yea
Rodighiero — Yea
Doyle — Yea
Mandt — Nay
Paynter — Nay
Angelucci — Not Voting
Espinosa — Not Voting
Linville — Not Voting
Evan Hansen Democrat Yea
John Williams Democrat Yea
Mike Pushkin Democrat Yea
Sean Hornbuckle Democrat Yea
Shawn Fluharty Democrat Yea
Ben Queen Republican Yea
Betsy Kelly Republican Yea
Betsy Kelly Republican Yea
Carl Martin Republican Yea
Christopher W. Toney Republican Yea
D. Rolland Jennings Republican Yea
Dean Jeffries Republican Yea
Evan Worrell Republican Yea
Gary G. Howell Republican Yea
George Miller Republican Yea
Jason Barrett Republican Yea
Jeff Campbell Republican Yea
Jim Butler Republican Yea
Joe Ellington Republican Yea
John Paul Hott Republican Yea
Mark Dean Republican Yea
Matthew Rohrbach Republican Yea
Mike Azinger Republican Yea
Pat McGeehan Republican Yea
Patrick Martin Republican Yea
Roger Hanshaw Republican Yea
Roy Cooper Republican Yea
T. Kevan Bartlett Republican Yea
Vernon Criss Republican Yea
William Anderson Republican Yea

Official roll call →

Subjects

Cross-referencing the record. Reading this bill against every other bill in the corpus by meaning, not keywords. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Matching · Ranking · Engrossing

Frequently asked questions

Who sponsors HB 4178?
HB 4178 is sponsored by Lovejoy, Lavender-Bowe, Brown, S., Evan Hansen (Democrat), Betsy Kelly (Republican), and George Miller (Republican).
What is the current status of HB 4178?
This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced January 14, 2020. Enacted.
Where can I track HB 4178?
Track HB 4178 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.

Make your voice heard on HB 4178

Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.

Stay ahead of HB 4178

Last checked for changes 3 months ago · updated continuously

One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.

Track this bill →