Montana 2017 Regular Session Status: Enacted

SB 184 — Revise workers compensation to allow termination of payments due to fraud

Last action — Vetoed by Governor

  1. ✓
    Introduced
  2. ✓
    In Committee
  3. ✓
    Passed Senate
  4. ✓
    Passed House
  5. ✓
    To Executive
  6. 6
    Enacted

This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced December 01, 2016. Enacted.

Prognosis

Likely to advance 70% · moderate confidence

Where this bill stands today.

Odds of enactment

High

How often bills like it became law.

  • Enacted

    Current position in the legislative process.

  • 1 sponsor

    1 primary, 0 co-sponsors signed on.

  • Cleared a recorded vote

    Passed 8 recorded votes so far.

Prognosis reads this bill's own signals — stage, sponsorship breadth, committee status, recorded votes and cross-state momentum. Odds come from a model trained on which bills have become law.

Bill Text

We don't have the full text on file for this bill yet.

Read SB 184 on the official Montana source →

Action History

  1. Vetoed by Governor

  2. Transmitted to Governor

  3. Returned to Senate Not Concurred in Governor's Proposed Amendments

  4. 2nd Reading Governor's Proposed Amendments Not Adopted

  5. Scheduled for 2nd Reading

  6. Transmitted to House for Consideration of Governor's Proposed Amendments

  7. 2nd Reading Governor's Proposed Amendments Not Adopted

  8. Scheduled for 2nd Reading

  9. Returned with Governor's Proposed Amendments

  10. Transmitted to Governor

  11. Signed by Speaker

  12. Signed by President

  13. Printed - Enrolled Version Available

  14. Returned from Enrolling

  15. Sent to Enrolling

  16. Returned to Senate

  17. 3rd Reading Concurred

  18. Scheduled for 3rd Reading

  19. 2nd Reading Concurred

  20. Scheduled for 2nd Reading

  21. Printed - New Version Available

  22. Sponsors Engrossed

  23. Committee Report--Bill Concurred

  24. Committee Executive Action--Bill Concurred

  25. Hearing

  26. Hearing Canceled

  27. First Reading

  28. Referred to Committee

  29. Transmitted to House

  30. 3rd Reading Passed

  31. Scheduled for 3rd Reading

  32. 2nd Reading Passed

  33. Scheduled for 2nd Reading

  34. Committee Report--Bill Passed

  35. Committee Executive Action--Bill Passed

  36. Hearing

  37. Referred to Committee

  38. First Reading

  39. Introduced Bill Text Available Electronically

  40. Introduced

  41. Draft Delivered to Requester

  42. Draft Ready for Delivery

  43. Executive Director Final Review

  44. Bill Draft Text Available Electronically

  45. Draft in Final Drafter Review

  46. Draft in Legal Review

  47. Draft Back for Redo

  48. Draft Delivered to Requester

  49. Executive Director Final Review

  50. Bill Draft Text Available Electronically

  51. Draft in Final Drafter Review

  52. Draft in Legal Review

  53. Draft Back for Redo

  54. Draft Ready for Delivery

  55. Executive Director Final Review

  56. Draft in Assembly

  57. Executive Director Review

  58. Bill Draft Text Available Electronically

  59. Draft in Final Drafter Review

  60. Draft in Input/Proofing

  61. Draft to Drafter - Edit Review [CMD]

  62. Draft in Edit

  63. Draft in Legal Review

  64. Draft to Requester for Review

  65. Draft Request Received

Sponsors

Sponsorship breakdown

Export CSV (upgrade) →

1 sponsors · 0 co-sponsors · 205 not signed on · 31 voted No

Sponsors (1)

Co-sponsors (0)

None.

Not signed on (205)

205 members have not signed on to this bill.

Show all 205 →

"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.

Whip count is in markup. Polling the chamber and every recorded vote this session. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Calling the roll · Tallying · Engrossing

Votes

Do Not Concur

Passed 59 Yea · 41 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 594100
Total 594100
% of votes cast 59%41%0%0%
How each member voted (100)
Member Party Vote
Kipp, George — Nay
Bachmeier, Jacob — Nay
Knokey, Jon — Yea
Rosendale, Adam — Yea
Ballance, Nancy — Yea
Ryan, Marilyn — Nay
Flynn, Kelly — Yea
Knudsen, Austin — Yea
Sales, Walt — Yea
Lavin, Steve — Yea
Schreiner, Casey — Nay
Shaw, Ray — Yea
Brodehl, Randy — Yea
Smith, Bridget — Nay
Grubbs, Bruce — Yea
Staffanson, Scott — Yea
McCarthy, Kelly — Nay
Stewart-Peregoy, Sharon — Nay
Burnett, Tom — Yea
McConnell, Nate — Nay
Swanson, Kathy — Nay
Cook, Rob — Yea
Hamlett, Bradley — Nay
Court, Virginia — Nay
Harris, Bill — Yea
Mortensen, Dale — Yea
Curtis, Amanda — Nay
O'Hara, James — Yea
Wagoner, Kirk — Yea
Hill Smith, Ellie — Nay
Webb, Peggy — Yea
Doane, Alan — Yea
Patelis, Jimmy — Yea
Dudik, Kimberly — Nay
Peppers, Rae — Nay
Perry, Zac — Nay
White, Kerry — Yea
Eck, Jennifer — Nay
Pierson, Gordon — Nay
Ehli, Ron — Yea
Price, Jean — Nay
Woods, Tom — Nay
Redfield, Alan — Yea
Abbott, Kim — Nay
Anderson, Fred — Yea
Andrea Olsen — Nay
Barry Usher — Yea
Bartel, Dan — Yea
Beard, Becky — Yea
Bennett, Bryce — Nay
Berglee, Seth — Yea
Bishop, Laurie — Nay
Bob Brown — Nay
Bob Brown — Yea
Carl Glimm — Yea
Custer, Geraldine — Yea
Daniel Zolnikov — Yea
Dave Fern — Nay
Denise Hayman — Nay
Denley Loge — Yea
Dennis Lenz — Yea
Fitzgerald, Ross — Yea
Fleming, Frank — Nay
Forrest Mandeville — Yea
Funk, Moffie — Nay
Garner, Frank — Yea
Greef, Sharon — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Gunderson, Steve — Yea
Hamilton, Jim — Nay
Holmlund, Kenneth L. — Yea
Hopkins, Mike — Yea
Jacobson, Tom — Nay
Janet Ellis — Nay
Jeremy Trebas — Yea
Karjala, Jessica — Nay
Keane, Jim — Nay
Kelker, Kathy — Nay
Knudsen, Casey — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Lynch, Ryan — Nay
Mark Noland — Yea
Mary Ann Dunwell — Nay
Matt Regier — Yea
Mike Cuffe — Yea
Shane Morigeau — Nay
Sheldon-Galloway, Lola — Yea
Sherry Essmann — Yea
Skees, Derek — Yea
Sue Vinton — Yea
Susan Webber — Nay
Theresa Manzella — Yea
Tschida, Brad — Yea
Vince Ricci — Yea
Welch, Tom — Yea
Wendy McKamey — Yea
Willis Curdy — Nay
Windy Boy, Jonathan — Nay
Wylie Galt — Yea

Official roll call →

Do Not Concur

Passed 34 Yea · 16 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 341600
Total 341600
% of votes cast 68%32%0%0%
How each member voted (50)
Member Party Vote
Moore, Frederick — Yea
Barrett, Dick — Nay
Olszewski, Albert — Yea
Swandal, Nels — Yea
Phillips, Mike — Yea
Thomas, Fred — Yea
Vincent, Chas — Yea
Richmond, Tom — Yea
Vuckovich, Gene — Nay
Sales, Scott — Yea
Webb, Roger — Yea
Connell, Pat — Yea
Salomon, Daniel — Yea
Facey, Tom — Nay
MacDonald, Margaret — Nay
Whitford, Lea — Nay
Malek, Sue — Nay
Sesso, Jon — Nay
Wolken, Cynthia — Nay
Ankney, Duane — Yea
Blasdel, Mark — Yea
Bob Brown — Yea
Boland, Carlie — Nay
Ed Buttrey — Yea
Edie McClafferty — Nay
Frank Smith — Nay
Gauthier, Terry — Yea
Gross, Jen — Nay
Hinebauch, Steve — Yea
Hoven, Brian — Yea
Howard, David — Yea
Jason Small — Yea
Jedediah Hinkle — Yea
Jill Cohenour — Nay
Kary, Douglas (Doug) — Yea
Keenan, Bob — Yea
Lang, Mike — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Mary Caferro — Nay
McNally, Mary — Nay
Osmundson, Ryan — Yea
Paul Fielder — Yea
Pomnichowski, JP — Yea
Regier, Keith — Yea
Russ Tempel — Yea
Sands, Diane — Nay
Smith, Cary — Yea
Steve Fitzpatrick — Yea
Vance, Gordon — Yea
Welborn, Jeffrey — Yea

Official roll call →

Do Concur

Passed 59 Yea · 39 Nay · 2 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 593902
Total 593902
% of votes cast 59%39%0%2%
How each member voted (100)
Member Party Vote
Kipp, George — Not Voting
Bachmeier, Jacob — Nay
Knokey, Jon — Yea
Rosendale, Adam — Yea
Ballance, Nancy — Yea
Ryan, Marilyn — Nay
Flynn, Kelly — Yea
Knudsen, Austin — Yea
Sales, Walt — Yea
Lavin, Steve — Yea
Schreiner, Casey — Nay
Shaw, Ray — Yea
Brodehl, Randy — Yea
Smith, Bridget — Nay
Grubbs, Bruce — Yea
Staffanson, Scott — Yea
McCarthy, Kelly — Nay
Stewart-Peregoy, Sharon — Nay
Burnett, Tom — Yea
McConnell, Nate — Nay
Swanson, Kathy — Nay
Cook, Rob — Yea
Hamlett, Bradley — Nay
Court, Virginia — Nay
Harris, Bill — Yea
Mortensen, Dale — Yea
Curtis, Amanda — Nay
O'Hara, James — Yea
Wagoner, Kirk — Yea
Hill Smith, Ellie — Nay
Webb, Peggy — Yea
Doane, Alan — Yea
Patelis, Jimmy — Yea
Dudik, Kimberly — Nay
Peppers, Rae — Nay
Perry, Zac — Nay
White, Kerry — Yea
Eck, Jennifer — Nay
Pierson, Gordon — Nay
Ehli, Ron — Yea
Price, Jean — Nay
Woods, Tom — Nay
Redfield, Alan — Yea
Abbott, Kim — Nay
Anderson, Fred — Yea
Andrea Olsen — Nay
Barry Usher — Yea
Bartel, Dan — Yea
Beard, Becky — Yea
Bennett, Bryce — Nay
Berglee, Seth — Yea
Bishop, Laurie — Nay
Bob Brown — Nay
Bob Brown — Yea
Carl Glimm — Yea
Custer, Geraldine — Yea
Daniel Zolnikov — Yea
Dave Fern — Nay
Denise Hayman — Nay
Denley Loge — Yea
Dennis Lenz — Yea
Fitzgerald, Ross — Yea
Fleming, Frank — Nay
Forrest Mandeville — Yea
Funk, Moffie — Nay
Garner, Frank — Yea
Greef, Sharon — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Gunderson, Steve — Yea
Hamilton, Jim — Nay
Holmlund, Kenneth L. — Yea
Hopkins, Mike — Yea
Jacobson, Tom — Nay
Janet Ellis — Nay
Jeremy Trebas — Yea
Karjala, Jessica — Nay
Keane, Jim — Nay
Kelker, Kathy — Not Voting
Knudsen, Casey — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Lynch, Ryan — Nay
Mark Noland — Yea
Mary Ann Dunwell — Nay
Matt Regier — Yea
Mike Cuffe — Yea
Shane Morigeau — Nay
Sheldon-Galloway, Lola — Yea
Sherry Essmann — Yea
Skees, Derek — Yea
Sue Vinton — Yea
Susan Webber — Nay
Theresa Manzella — Yea
Tschida, Brad — Yea
Vince Ricci — Yea
Welch, Tom — Yea
Wendy McKamey — Yea
Willis Curdy — Nay
Windy Boy, Jonathan — Nay
Wylie Galt — Yea

Official roll call →

Do Concur

Passed 59 Yea · 41 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 594100
Total 594100
% of votes cast 59%41%0%0%
How each member voted (100)
Member Party Vote
Harris, Bill — Yea
Kipp, George — Nay
Bachmeier, Jacob — Nay
Knokey, Jon — Yea
Rosendale, Adam — Yea
Ballance, Nancy — Yea
Ryan, Marilyn — Nay
Flynn, Kelly — Yea
Knudsen, Austin — Yea
Sales, Walt — Yea
Lavin, Steve — Yea
Schreiner, Casey — Nay
Shaw, Ray — Yea
Brodehl, Randy — Yea
Smith, Bridget — Nay
Grubbs, Bruce — Yea
Staffanson, Scott — Yea
McCarthy, Kelly — Nay
Stewart-Peregoy, Sharon — Nay
Burnett, Tom — Yea
McConnell, Nate — Nay
Swanson, Kathy — Nay
Cook, Rob — Yea
Hamlett, Bradley — Nay
Court, Virginia — Nay
Mortensen, Dale — Yea
Curtis, Amanda — Nay
O'Hara, James — Yea
Wagoner, Kirk — Yea
Hill Smith, Ellie — Nay
Webb, Peggy — Yea
Doane, Alan — Yea
Patelis, Jimmy — Yea
Dudik, Kimberly — Nay
Peppers, Rae — Nay
Perry, Zac — Nay
White, Kerry — Yea
Eck, Jennifer — Nay
Pierson, Gordon — Nay
Ehli, Ron — Yea
Price, Jean — Nay
Woods, Tom — Nay
Redfield, Alan — Yea
Abbott, Kim — Nay
Anderson, Fred — Yea
Andrea Olsen — Nay
Barry Usher — Yea
Bartel, Dan — Yea
Beard, Becky — Yea
Bennett, Bryce — Nay
Berglee, Seth — Yea
Bishop, Laurie — Nay
Bob Brown — Nay
Bob Brown — Yea
Carl Glimm — Yea
Custer, Geraldine — Yea
Daniel Zolnikov — Yea
Dave Fern — Nay
Denise Hayman — Nay
Denley Loge — Yea
Dennis Lenz — Yea
Fitzgerald, Ross — Yea
Fleming, Frank — Nay
Forrest Mandeville — Yea
Funk, Moffie — Nay
Garner, Frank — Yea
Greef, Sharon — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Greg Hertz — Yea
Gunderson, Steve — Yea
Hamilton, Jim — Nay
Holmlund, Kenneth L. — Yea
Hopkins, Mike — Yea
Jacobson, Tom — Nay
Janet Ellis — Nay
Jeremy Trebas — Yea
Karjala, Jessica — Nay
Keane, Jim — Nay
Kelker, Kathy — Nay
Knudsen, Casey — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Lynch, Ryan — Nay
Mark Noland — Yea
Mary Ann Dunwell — Nay
Matt Regier — Yea
Mike Cuffe — Yea
Shane Morigeau — Nay
Sheldon-Galloway, Lola — Yea
Sherry Essmann — Yea
Skees, Derek — Yea
Sue Vinton — Yea
Susan Webber — Nay
Theresa Manzella — Yea
Tschida, Brad — Yea
Vince Ricci — Yea
Welch, Tom — Yea
Wendy McKamey — Yea
Willis Curdy — Nay
Windy Boy, Jonathan — Nay
Wylie Galt — Yea

Official roll call →

BE CONCURRED IN

Passed 11 Yea · 8 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 11800
Total 11800
% of votes cast 58%42%0%0%
How each member voted (19)
Member Party Vote
Fitzgerald, Ross H. — Yea
Grubbs, Bruce — Yea
Rosendale, Adam — Yea
Curtis, Amanda — Nay
Pierson, Gordon — Nay
Schreiner, Casey — Nay
Stewart-Peregoy, Sharon — Nay
Anderson, Fred — Yea
Andrea Olsen — Nay
Daniel Zolnikov — Yea
Denley Loge — Yea
Funk, Moffie — Nay
Gunderson, Steve — Yea
Jeremy Trebas — Yea
Mark Noland — Yea
Sue Vinton — Yea
Vince Ricci — Yea
Willis Curdy — Nay
Windy Boy, Jonathan — Nay

Official roll call →

Do Pass

Passed 31 Yea · 19 Nay
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 311900
Total 311900
% of votes cast 62%38%0%0%
How each member voted (50)
Member Party Vote
Ankney, Duane — Yea
Moore, Frederick — Yea
Barrett, Dick — Nay
Olszewski, Albert — Yea
Swandal, Nels — Yea
Blasdel, Mark — Yea
Osmundson, Ryan — Yea
Boland, Carlie — Nay
Hoven, Brian — Yea
Phillips, Mike — Nay
Thomas, Fred — Yea
Howard, David — Yea
Pomnichowski, JP — Nay
Vincent, Chas — Yea
Kary, Douglas — Yea
Richmond, Tom — Yea
Vuckovich, Gene — Nay
Sales, Scott — Yea
Webb, Roger — Yea
Connell, Pat — Yea
Facey, Tom — Nay
MacDonald, Margaret — Nay
Sands, Diane — Nay
Whitford, Lea — Nay
Malek, Sue — Nay
Sesso, Jon — Nay
Wolken, Cynthia — Nay
Gauthier, Terry — Yea
McNally, Mary — Nay
Smith, Cary — Yea
Bob Brown — Yea
Bob Keenan — Yea
Dan Salomon — Yea
Ed Buttrey — Yea
Edie McClafferty — Nay
Frank Smith — Nay
Jason Small — Nay
Jedediah Hinkle — Yea
Jeff Welborn — Yea
Jen Gross — Nay
Jill Cohenour — Nay
Keith Regier — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Mary Caferro — Nay
Mike Lang — Yea
Paul Fielder — Yea
Russ Tempel — Yea
Shelley Vance — Yea
Steve Fitzpatrick — Yea
Steve Hinebauch — Yea

Official roll call →

Do Pass

Passed 31 Yea · 18 Nay · 1 Other
Party YeaNayPresentNot Voting
Unaffiliated 311801
Total 311801
% of votes cast 62%36%0%2%
How each member voted (50)
Member Party Vote
Ankney, Duane — Yea
Moore, Frederick — Yea
Barrett, Dick — Nay
Olszewski, Albert — Yea
Swandal, Nels — Yea
Blasdel, Mark — Yea
Osmundson, Ryan — Yea
Boland, Carlie — Nay
Hoven, Brian — Yea
Phillips, Mike — Nay
Thomas, Fred — Yea
Howard, David — Yea
Pomnichowski, JP — Nay
Vincent, Chas — Yea
Kary, Douglas — Yea
Richmond, Tom — Yea
Vuckovich, Gene — Nay
Sales, Scott — Yea
Webb, Roger — Yea
Connell, Pat — Yea
Facey, Tom — Nay
MacDonald, Margaret — Nay
Sands, Diane — Nay
Whitford, Lea — Nay
Malek, Sue — Nay
Sesso, Jon — Nay
Wolken, Cynthia — Nay
Gauthier, Terry — Not Voting
McNally, Mary — Nay
Smith, Cary — Yea
Bob Brown — Yea
Bob Keenan — Yea
Dan Salomon — Yea
Ed Buttrey — Yea
Edie McClafferty — Nay
Frank Smith — Nay
Jason Small — Yea
Jedediah Hinkle — Yea
Jeff Welborn — Yea
Jen Gross — Nay
Jill Cohenour — Nay
Keith Regier — Yea
Llew Jones — Yea
Mary Caferro — Nay
Mike Lang — Yea
Paul Fielder — Yea
Russ Tempel — Yea
Shelley Vance — Yea
Steve Fitzpatrick — Yea
Steve Hinebauch — Yea

Official roll call →

Subjects

Cross-referencing the record. Reading this bill against every other bill in the corpus by meaning, not keywords. Only the first open is slow. It’s instant for you after this. Matching · Ranking · Engrossing

Frequently asked questions

Who sponsors SB 184?
SB 184 is sponsored by Moore, Terry.
What is the current status of SB 184?
This bill has been enacted into law. Introduced December 01, 2016. Enacted.
Where can I track SB 184?
Track SB 184 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.

Make your voice heard on SB 184

Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.

Stay ahead of SB 184

Last checked for changes 3 months ago · updated continuously

One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.

Track this bill →