HB 5018 — To provide for oversight and authority governing community air monitoring programs.
Last action — To Energy, Industry, and Mining
-
✓Introduced
-
✓In Committee
-
3Passed House of Delegates
-
4Passed Senate
-
5To Executive
-
6Enacted
This bill has passed the House of Delegates. Introduced January 23, 2024. It now moves to the second chamber.
Next likely step: consideration and a floor vote in the Senate.
Odds of enactment
Moderate chanceBased on the sponsor, cosponsors, and committee posture, this bill has a moderate chance of becoming law.
Upgrade to see the exact probability and what's driving it.
A statistical estimate from our own model of past outcomes — an insight, not a guarantee. Policymaking is volatile.
Prognosis
-
Passed House of Delegates
Current position in the legislative process.
-
11 sponsors
1 primary, 10 co-sponsors signed on.
-
Single-party support
Sponsorship is currently within one party (11 R).
-
Mixed recorded votes
1 passed, 1 failed in recorded votes so far.
Based on stage, sponsorship breadth, committee status, recorded votes, and cross-state momentum — a description of the observable signals, not a prediction.
Bill Text
What changed in the latest version
33 added · 29 removedPlain-language change summary
The revised version of HB 5018 has added clearer guidelines for community air monitoring programs, emphasizing the importance of using accurate scientific methods for data collection. It specifically states that data gathered cannot be used for regulatory actions, such as issuing fines or penalties against companies that emit pollutants, which provides protections for these operators. This change matters because it can limit the accountability of polluters while still ensuring that communities are informed about air quality data. Overall, it reflects a balancing act between environmental oversight and the interests of businesses involved in air emissions.
WEST VIRGINIA LEGISLATURE REGULAR SESSION IntroducedCommittee Substitute for House Bill 5018 By Delegates Anderson, Zatezalo, Street, Barnhart, Fehrenbacher, Kelly, Riley, Heckert, Hott, Horst and Foggin [Introduced[Originating Januaryin 23,the 2024;Committee on Energy and Manufacturing;
ReferredReported to the Committee on EnergyJanuary and30, Manufacturing]2024] IntrCS for HB 2024R29895018 A BILL to amend and reenact the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, by adding thereto a new section, designated §22-5-21, relatedrelating to providing for Department of Environmental Protection regulatory oversight and authority governing community air monitoring programs to ensure proper standards for data collection and evaluation through use of accurate scientific methods inare orderused; to help citizens protect State communities from air pollution;
providing definitions;definitions, including defining community air monitoring programs with exceptions;
andproviding limitingfor circumstances when the useDepartment of saidEnvironmental dataProtection bymay use the Department.collected data and for what purposes;
limiting the use of said data by the department and other persons;
providing that the data may not be used directly for regulating pollutants under the clean air act;
providing that the data may not be used to issue a fine, penalty, or notice of violation against the operator of a stationary source;
providing that the data may not be used as evidence in an administrative, regulatory, judicial enforcement action, or third-party lawsuit or proceeding against the operator of a stationary source;
and providing for rulemaking authority.
(b) The Secretary may consider community air monitoring data where the monitor is installed, operated, and maintained in accordance with the manufacturer's guidance or requirements and with all applicable United States Environmental Protection Agency standards or state quality control guidance and rules, if promulgated, with generated samples managed and analyzed1 byCS labsfor HB 5018 analyzed in accordance with minimum quality assurance criteria, to inform whether additional investigation may be necessary to protect communities that may be significantly affected by criteria or other air pollutants, if sufficient evidence is included with the data to support that the data was collected consistent with this provision.
§ 7410 Intr HB 2024R2989 and 7619.
(g) Data produced from community air monitoring programs shallmay not be used as evidence by the Secretary or by any person for purposes of, or in support of:
(1) Issuing a fine, penalty, or notice of violation against any person, including the owner or operator of a stationary source;
or (2) Bringing an administrative, regulatory, or judicial enforcement action, or third-party lawsuit or proceeding against any person, including the owner or operator of a stationary source.
The purpose of this bill is to provide for DEP oversight and authority governing community air monitoring programs to ensure proper standards for data collection and evaluation through accurate scientific methods.
View plain text versions (2)
- Committee Substitute View text pdf
- Introduced Introduced Version Current pdf
Action History
-
To Energy, Industry, and Mining
-
To Energy, Industry, and Mining
-
Introduced in Senate
-
Communicated to Senate
-
Passed House (Roll No. 102)
-
Read 3rd time
-
On 3rd reading, Special Calendar
-
Committee amendment rejected (Roll No. 90)
-
Taken from table and placed on 2nd reading, Special Calendar
-
Tabled amendment and bill on 2nd reading, Special Calendar
-
Amendment reported
-
Read 2nd time
-
On 2nd reading, Special Calendar
-
Read 1st time
-
On 1st reading, Special Calendar
-
By substitute, do pass
-
To House Energy and Manufacturing
-
Introduced in House
-
To Energy and Manufacturing
-
Filed for introduction
Sponsors
- Chuck Horst · Cosponsor
- John Paul Hott · Cosponsor
- Dave Foggin · Cosponsor
- Scot C. Heckert · Cosponsor
- Clay Riley · Cosponsor
- Bob Fehrenbacher · Cosponsor
- Trenton Barnhart · Cosponsor
- George Street · Cosponsor
- Mark Zatezalo · Cosponsor
- William Anderson · Primary
- Betsy Kelly · Cosponsor
Sponsorship breakdown
Export CSV (upgrade) →1 sponsors · 10 co-sponsors · 141 not signed on · 60 voted No
Sponsors (1)
- William Anderson Republican Voted No
Co-sponsors (10)
- Chuck Horst Republican Voted No
- John Paul Hott Republican Voted No
- Dave Foggin Republican Voted No
- Scot C. Heckert Republican Voted No
- Clay Riley Republican Voted No
- Bob Fehrenbacher Republican Voted No
- Trenton Barnhart Republican Voted No
- George Street Republican Voted No
- Mark Zatezalo Republican Voted No
- Betsy Kelly Republican Voted No
Not signed on (141)
141 members have not signed on to this bill.
Show all 141 →"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.
Votes
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | 58 | 6 | 0 | 2 |
| Unaffiliated | 18 | 5 | 0 | 3 |
| Democrat | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 76 | 19 | 0 | 5 |
| % of votes cast | 76% | 19% | 0% | 5% |
How each member voted (100)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Espinosa | — | Yea |
| Jeffries | — | Yea |
| Fast | — | Yea |
| Ross | — | Yea |
| Kump | — | Yea |
| Linville | — | Yea |
| Smith | — | Yea |
| Forsht | — | Yea |
| Longanacre | — | Yea |
| Foster | — | Yea |
| Summers | — | Yea |
| Martin | — | Yea |
| Hardy | — | Yea |
| Warner | — | Yea |
| Westfall | — | Yea |
| Winzenreid | — | Yea |
| Devault | — | Yea |
| Phillips | — | Yea |
| Rowe | — | Nay |
| Steele | — | Nay |
| Griffith | — | Nay |
| Hamilton | — | Nay |
| Tully | — | Nay |
| Householder | — | Not Voting |
| Nestor | — | Not Voting |
| Kirby | — | Not Voting |
| Evan Hansen | Democrat | Nay |
| Hollis Lewis | Democrat | Nay |
| Joey Garcia | Democrat | Nay |
| John Williams | Democrat | Nay |
| Kayla Young | Democrat | Nay |
| Mike Pushkin | Democrat | Nay |
| Sean Hornbuckle | Democrat | Nay |
| Shawn Fluharty | Democrat | Nay |
| Adam Burkhammer | Republican | Yea |
| Adam Vance | Republican | Nay |
| Andy Shamblin | Republican | Yea |
| Betsy Kelly | Republican | Yea |
| Bill Ridenour | Republican | Not Voting |
| Bob Fehrenbacher | Republican | Yea |
| Bryan Ward | Republican | Yea |
| Charles Sheedy | Republican | Yea |
| Christopher W. Toney | Republican | Nay |
| Chuck Horst | Republican | Yea |
| Clay Riley | Republican | Yea |
| D. Rolland Jennings | Republican | Yea |
| Dana Ferrell | Republican | Yea |
| Darren Thorne | Republican | Yea |
| Dave Foggin | Republican | Yea |
| David Green | Republican | Yea |
| Elias Coop-Gonzalez | Republican | Yea |
| Eric Brooks | Republican | Yea |
| Erica Moore | Republican | Yea |
| Evan Worrell | Republican | Nay |
| Gary G. Howell | Republican | Yea |
| Geno Chiarelli | Republican | Yea |
| George Miller | Republican | Yea |
| George Street | Republican | Yea |
| Henry Dillon | Republican | Yea |
| James Robert "JB" Akers II | Republican | Yea |
| Jarred Cannon | Republican | Yea |
| Jeff Campbell | Republican | Yea |
| Jeffrey Stephens | Republican | Yea |
| Jim Butler | Republican | Yea |
| Jimmy Willis | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Ellington | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Statler | Republican | Yea |
| John Paul Hott | Republican | Yea |
| Jonathan Pinson | Republican | Yea |
| Jordan Bridges | Republican | Yea |
| Jordan Maynor | Republican | Yea |
| Josh Holstein | Republican | Yea |
| Kathie Hess Crouse | Republican | Yea |
| Keith Marple | Republican | Yea |
| Laura Kimble | Republican | Nay |
| Lori Dittman | Republican | Nay |
| Margitta Mazzocchi | Republican | Yea |
| Mark Dean | Republican | Yea |
| Mark Zatezalo | Republican | Yea |
| Marty Gearheart | Republican | Yea |
| Matthew Rohrbach | Republican | Yea |
| Michael Hite | Republican | Yea |
| Michael Hornby | Republican | Yea |
| Mickey Petitto | Republican | Yea |
| Pat McGeehan | Republican | Yea |
| Patrick Lucas | Republican | Yea |
| Phil Mallow | Republican | Yea |
| Rick Hillenbrand | Republican | Yea |
| Roger Hanshaw | Republican | Yea |
| Roy Cooper | Republican | Yea |
| Scot C. Heckert | Republican | Yea |
| Stanley Adkins | Republican | Yea |
| Trenton Barnhart | Republican | Yea |
| Vacant1 | Republican | Nay |
| Vacant1 | Republican | Not Voting |
| Vernon Criss | Republican | Yea |
| Walter Hall | Republican | Yea |
| Wayne Clark | Republican | Yea |
| Wayne Clark | Republican | Yea |
| William Anderson | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | 2 | 63 | 0 | 1 |
| Unaffiliated | 5 | 20 | 0 | 1 |
| Democrat | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 15 | 83 | 0 | 2 |
| % of votes cast | 15% | 83% | 0% | 2% |
How each member voted (100)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Hamilton | — | Yea |
| Tully | — | Yea |
| Griffith | — | Yea |
| Kirby | — | Yea |
| Rowe | — | Yea |
| Fast | — | Nay |
| Ross | — | Nay |
| Kump | — | Nay |
| Linville | — | Nay |
| Smith | — | Nay |
| Forsht | — | Nay |
| Longanacre | — | Nay |
| Foster | — | Nay |
| Steele | — | Nay |
| Martin | — | Nay |
| Summers | — | Nay |
| Hardy | — | Nay |
| Warner | — | Nay |
| Westfall | — | Nay |
| Phillips | — | Nay |
| Winzenreid | — | Nay |
| Householder | — | Nay |
| Devault | — | Nay |
| Jeffries | — | Nay |
| Espinosa | — | Nay |
| Nestor | — | Not Voting |
| Evan Hansen | Democrat | Yea |
| Hollis Lewis | Democrat | Yea |
| Joey Garcia | Democrat | Yea |
| John Williams | Democrat | Yea |
| Kayla Young | Democrat | Yea |
| Mike Pushkin | Democrat | Yea |
| Sean Hornbuckle | Democrat | Yea |
| Shawn Fluharty | Democrat | Yea |
| Adam Burkhammer | Republican | Nay |
| Adam Vance | Republican | Nay |
| Andy Shamblin | Republican | Nay |
| Betsy Kelly | Republican | Nay |
| Bill Ridenour | Republican | Nay |
| Bob Fehrenbacher | Republican | Nay |
| Bryan Ward | Republican | Nay |
| Charles Sheedy | Republican | Nay |
| Christopher W. Toney | Republican | Nay |
| Chuck Horst | Republican | Nay |
| Clay Riley | Republican | Nay |
| D. Rolland Jennings | Republican | Nay |
| Dana Ferrell | Republican | Nay |
| Darren Thorne | Republican | Nay |
| Dave Foggin | Republican | Nay |
| David Green | Republican | Nay |
| Elias Coop-Gonzalez | Republican | Nay |
| Eric Brooks | Republican | Nay |
| Erica Moore | Republican | Nay |
| Evan Worrell | Republican | Nay |
| Gary G. Howell | Republican | Nay |
| Geno Chiarelli | Republican | Nay |
| George Miller | Republican | Nay |
| George Street | Republican | Nay |
| Henry Dillon | Republican | Nay |
| James Robert "JB" Akers II | Republican | Nay |
| Jarred Cannon | Republican | Nay |
| Jeff Campbell | Republican | Nay |
| Jeffrey Stephens | Republican | Nay |
| Jim Butler | Republican | Nay |
| Jimmy Willis | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Ellington | Republican | Not Voting |
| Joe Statler | Republican | Nay |
| John Paul Hott | Republican | Nay |
| Jonathan Pinson | Republican | Nay |
| Jordan Bridges | Republican | Nay |
| Jordan Maynor | Republican | Nay |
| Josh Holstein | Republican | Nay |
| Kathie Hess Crouse | Republican | Nay |
| Keith Marple | Republican | Nay |
| Laura Kimble | Republican | Nay |
| Lori Dittman | Republican | Yea |
| Margitta Mazzocchi | Republican | Nay |
| Mark Dean | Republican | Nay |
| Mark Zatezalo | Republican | Nay |
| Marty Gearheart | Republican | Nay |
| Matthew Rohrbach | Republican | Nay |
| Michael Hite | Republican | Nay |
| Michael Hornby | Republican | Nay |
| Mickey Petitto | Republican | Nay |
| Pat McGeehan | Republican | Nay |
| Patrick Lucas | Republican | Nay |
| Phil Mallow | Republican | Nay |
| Rick Hillenbrand | Republican | Nay |
| Roger Hanshaw | Republican | Nay |
| Roy Cooper | Republican | Nay |
| Scot C. Heckert | Republican | Nay |
| Stanley Adkins | Republican | Nay |
| Trenton Barnhart | Republican | Nay |
| Vacant1 | Republican | Yea |
| Vacant1 | Republican | Nay |
| Vernon Criss | Republican | Nay |
| Walter Hall | Republican | Nay |
| Wayne Clark | Republican | Nay |
| Wayne Clark | Republican | Nay |
| William Anderson | Republican | Nay |
Subjects
Frequently asked questions
- Who sponsors HB 5018?
- HB 5018 is sponsored by Chuck Horst (Republican), John Paul Hott (Republican), Dave Foggin (Republican), Scot C. Heckert (Republican), Clay Riley (Republican), Bob Fehrenbacher (Republican), Trenton Barnhart (Republican), George Street (Republican), Mark Zatezalo (Republican), William Anderson (Republican), and Betsy Kelly (Republican).
- What is the current status of HB 5018?
- This bill has passed the House of Delegates. Introduced January 23, 2024. It now moves to the second chamber.
- Where can I track HB 5018?
- Track HB 5018 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.
Make your voice heard on HB 5018
Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.
Stay ahead of HB 5018
Last checked for changes 3 months ago · updated continuously
One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.
Track this bill →