HB 2012 — An Act amending Title 12 (Commerce and Trade) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, providing for cause of action for antitrust conduct, for indirect purchaser recovery under State antitrust laws and for premerger notice of health care mergers and transactions; and imposing penalties.
Last action — Referred to Judiciary
-
✓Introduced
-
✓In Committee
-
3Passed House
-
4Passed Senate
-
5To Executive
-
6Enacted
This bill died with 2023-2024 Regular Session. It reached “Passed House” and never advanced before the session ended, so it can no longer move — a new version would have to be reintroduced in the current session.
This bill is no longer active — its legislative session has ended, so there are no live odds of enactment. It would have to be reintroduced in the current session to move again.
Bill Text
What changed in the latest version
564 added · 990 removedPlain-language change summary
The latest version of Bill HB 2012 introduces a new chapter focused on Pennsylvania's antitrust laws, specifically addressing issues related to health care mergers and market competition. Key changes include removing references to private lawsuits under state antitrust laws and criminal penalties, which simplifies the enforcement framework. This shift aims to empower the Attorney General to take more direct action against anti-competitive practices, ensuring a fairer market for consumers and businesses. Overall, the amendments emphasize protecting consumer interests in healthcare by reducing market monopolies and improving oversight.
PRIOR PRINTER'S NO.NOS.
25712571, 2971 PRINTER'S NO.
29713461 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA HOUSE BILL Session of No.
2012 2024 INTRODUCED BY PISCIOTTANO, VENKAT, ISAACSON, MADDEN, SANCHEZ, KRAJEWSKI,SCHLOSSBERG, GREEN,KHAN, CERRATODELLOSO, ANDHOWARD, MATZIE,MERSKI, FEBRUARYN. 5, 2024 BOYD, AS REPORTED FROM COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, AS AMENDED, APRIL 17, 2024 AN ACT Providing for cause of action for antitrust conduct, for <-- indirect purchaser recovery under State antitrust laws and for premerger notice of health care mergers and transactions;
NELSON, BOYD, KRAJEWSKI, GREEN, CERRATO, MATZIE, BRIGGS, MADSEN AND T.
DAVIS, FEBRUARY 5, 2024 AS AMENDED ON SECOND CONSIDERATION, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, JULY 1, 2024 AN ACT Amending Title 12 (Commerce and Trade) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, providing for ESTABLISHING cause of <-- under State antitrust laws and for premerger notice of health care mergers and transactions;
TABLEThe OFGeneral CONTENTSAssembly Sectionof 1.the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:
ShortSection title.1.
SectionTitle 2.12 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes is amended by adding a chapter to read:
CHAPTER 9 PENNSYLVANIA OPEN MARKETS Sec.
901.
Scope of chapter.
902.
Section903. 3.
Section904. 4.
Section905. 5.
Section906. 6.
Section907. 7.
Section908. 8.
Section909. 9.
Section910. 10.
Section911. 11.
Section912. 12.
Cooperation with Federal Government and other states.states, <-- OTHER STATES AND STATE AGENCIES.
Section913. 13.
AGENCY COOPERATION.
<-- 913 914.
Section<-- 14.914 915.
Section<-- 15.915 916.
Action not barred as affecting or involving interstate <-- or foreign commerce.
Section917. 16.
CONSTRUCTION.
<-- 916 918.
Section<-- 17.§ 901.
EffectiveScope date.of chapter.
AMENDINGThis TITLEchapter 12relates (COMMERCEto ANDopen TRADE)markets OFin THEthis PENNSYLVANIACommonwealth. <-- CONSOLIDATED STATUTES, PROVIDING FOR CAUSE OF ACTION FOR ANTITRUST CONDUCT, FOR INDIRECT PURCHASER RECOVERY UNDER STATE ANTITRUST LAWS AND FOR PREMERGER NOTICE OF HEALTH CARE MERGERS AND TRANSACTIONS;
AND§ IMPOSING902. PENALTIES.
The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:
Section 1.
Short title.
Show all 337 changed lines (297 more)
<-- This act shall be known and may be cited as the Pennsylvania Open Markets Act.
Section 2.
The purpose of this actchapter is to promote free enterprise and free trade in the marketplaces of this Commonwealth by prohibiting restraints of trade that are secured through monopolistic or collusive practices and that act or tend to act to decrease competition between and among persons engaged in commerce and trade.
Section§ 3.903.
The following words and phrases when used in this actchapter shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:
"Acquisition." An agreement, arrangement or activity, the consummation of which results in a person acquiring, directly or indirectly, the control of another person or the ability to 20240HB2012PN3461 - 2 - influence the competitive conduct of the target firm,firm PERSON, and <-- includes the acquisition of voting securities and noncorporate 20240HB2012PN2971 - 2 - interests, such as assets, capital stock, membership interests or equity interests.
"Contracting affiliation." The formation of a relationship between two or more entities PERSONS that permits the entities <-- PERSONS to negotiate jointly with insurers or third-party <-- administrators over rates for professional medical services or for one entity PERSON to negotiate on behalf of the other entity <-- PERSON with insurers or third-party administrators over rates <-- for professional medical services.
"Health care facility." As defined in section 103 802.1 of <-- the act of July 19, 1979 (P.L.130, No.48), known as the Health Care Facilities Act.
(1) a parent corporation of one or more health care facilities and an entity A PERSON affiliated with the parent <-- corporation through ownership or control;
or (2) a health care facility and an entity A PERSON <-- affiliated with the health care facility through ownership.ownership <-- DIRECT OR INDIRECT OWNERSHIP, INCLUDING A PRIVATE EQUITY <-- FUND.
"Health care services." Medical, surgical, chiropractic, hospital, optometric, DENTAL TREATMENT, podiatric, <-- pharmaceutical, ambulance, mental health, substance use disorder, therapeutic, preventative, diagnostic, curative, 20240HB2012PN3461 - 3 - rehabilitative, palliative, custodial and other services relating to the prevention, cure or treatment of illness, injury or disease.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 3 - "Insurer." As defined in 40 Pa.C.S.
"Merger." A consolidation of two or more organizations,organizations <-- PERSONS, including two or more organizations PERSONS joining <-- through a common parent organization or two or more organizations forming a new organization.
"Person." A natural person, corporation, trust, partnership, <-- an incorporated or unincorporated association, the Commonwealth, a State agency, municipal authority, political subdivision and any other legal entity.
"Provider organization." A corporation, partnership, business trust, association or organized group of persons, whether incorporated or not, that is in the business of health care delivery or management and that represents seventwo or more health care practitioners in contracting with insurers or third- party administrators for the payments of health care services.
"Third-party administrator." An entity A PERSON that <-- 20240HB2012PN3461 - 4 - administers payments for health care services on behalf of a client in exchange for an administrative fee.
Section§ 4.904.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 4 - (a) Restraints of trade.--A contract, a combination in the form of trust or otherwise or a conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce, is unlawful.
(b) Monopolize or monopsonize.--It is unlawful for a person to monopolize or monopsonize, to attempt to monopolize or monopsonizemonopsonize, TO MAINTAIN A MONOPOLY OR MONOPSONY or to combine <-- or conspire with another person to monopolize or monopsonize, in any part of trade or commerce.
(1) The effect of the acquisition is substantially to <-- lessen competition.
MAY BE SUBSTANTIALLY TO LESSEN <-- COMPETITION IN ANY PART OF TRADE OR COMMERCE.
(d) Market power.--It is unlawful for any person or persons <-- with market power in the conduct of any business, trade or commerce, in a labor market, or in the furnishing of a service in this Commonwealth, to abuse that market power.
Section§ 5.905.
(a) Action on behalf of Commonwealth.--If the Attorney General has reason to believe that a person, foreign or 20240HB2012PN3461 - 5 - domestic, has engaged in, is engaging in or is about to engage in an act or practice that is unlawful under this act,chapter, the Attorney General may bring a civil action in the name of the Commonwealth against the person to:
(1) Obtain a declaratory judgment that the action ACT or <-- practice violates this act.chapter.
(2) Enjoin an act or practice that violates this actchapter by 20240HB2012PN2971 - 5 - issuing a temporary restraining order, an ex parte temporary restraining order or a preliminary or permanent injunction, without bond.
(3) Recover a civil penalty of not less than $100,000 for each violation of this actchapter or of an injunction, judgment or consent agreement issued or entered into under this act.chapter.
(i) acquired in violation of this actchapter and after the court determines that divestiture is necessary to avoid the creation or continuation of a monopoly or to avoid a likely substantial lessening of competition that results from a transaction found to be in violation of this act;chapter;
or (ii) to restore competition to a line of commerce that has been eliminated by a violation of this act.chapter.
(5) Recover actual damages, restitution or disgorgement on behalf of the Commonwealth and its agencies that are <-- COMMONWEALTH AGENCIES injured either directly or indirectly <-- through a violation of this act.chapter.
(b) Action on behalf of natural person.--The Attorney General may bring a civil action in the name of the Commonwealth on behalf of a natural person injured directly or indirectly to 20240HB2012PN3461 - 6 - recover damages, restitution or disgorgement through a violation of this act.chapter.
(d) Jurisdiction.--A civil action under this section may be brought by the Attorney General in Commonwealth Court andor in the court of common pleas 20240HB2012PN2971 - 6 - of the county in which a party resides or has a principal place of business.
(e) Investigation.-- (1) If the Attorney General has reason to believe that a person, whether foreign or domestic, has engaged in or is engaging in a violation of this actchapter or of a Federal antitrust law that may be enforced by the Attorney General, the Attorney General may initiate an investigation.
(3) The Attorney General may use the information obtained under this section as the Attorney General determines necessary in the civil enforcement of this actchapter or Federal antitrust law that may be enforced by the Attorney General, including presentation before a court.
(4) The Attorney General may cooperate with and coordinate enforcement of this actchapter and a Federal <-- antitrust law THAT may be enforced by the Attorney General <-- with the Federal Government andand, the several states,states AND STATE <-- 20240HB2012PN3461 - 7 - AGENCIES, including using and sharing information and evidence obtained under this act.chapter.
Section(F) 6.PRESUMPTIONS.--IN AN ACTION BROUGHT BY THE ATTORNEY <-- GENERAL UNDER THIS CHAPTER AND THE ACT OF OCTOBER 15, 1980 (P.L.950, NO.164), KNOWN AS THE COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEYS ACT:
(1) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IS THE SOLE PARTY FOR DISCOVERY PURPOSES AND IS DEEMED TO LACK POSSESSION, CUSTODY OR CONTROL OVER DOCUMENTS POSSESSED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, OTHER COMMONWEALTH OFFICERS OR OTHER COMMONWEALTH AGENCIES.
(2) IF THE ACTION IS ASSERTED ON BEHALF OF A COMMONWEALTH AGENCY, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY FACILITATE NONPARTY DISCOVERY FROM THE COMMONWEALTH AGENCY BUT IS NOT OTHERWISE OBLIGATED UNDER SECTION 913 (RELATING TO AGENCY COOPERATION) OR SECTION 208 OF THE COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEYS ACT.
(3) IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DOES NOT SEEK TO RECOVER DAMAGES FOR AN INJURY SUFFERED BY A COMMONWEALTH AGENCY, NONPARTY DISCOVERY OF THE COMMONWEALTH AGENCY IS PRESUMPTIVELY UNREASONABLE AND UNDULY BURDENSOME.
§ 906.
(a) General rule.--In an action brought under this act,chapter IN WHICH THE PLAINTIFF PREVAILS, the prevailing party PLAINTIFF <-- shall recover treble damages sustained, reasonable attorney fees and costs, expert witness fees and investigative costs.
(b) Method.--In an action under this act,chapter, damages may be proved and assessed in the aggregate by statistical or sampling 20240HB2012PN2971 - 7 - methods, by the computation of illegal overcharges or underpayment or by another reasonable system of estimating aggregate damages as the court may permit without the necessity of separately proving the individual claim of, or amount of 20240HB2012PN3461 - 8 - damage to, persons on whose behalf the suit was brought.
(c) Computation.--DamagesInterest.--Damages mayfor beinjuries provedby andreason assessedof inanything theprohibited aggregateunder bythis statisticalchapter orshall samplinginclude methods,interest bycomputed from the computationdate ofon illegalwhich overchargesthe orinjury byis anothersustained, reasonableat systema ofrate estimatingequal aggregateto damages as the courtstatutory mayrate permit,for withoutpostjudgment theinterest, necessityand of separately proving the individualcost claim of, or amount of damagesuit, to,including personsreasonable onattorney whosefees. behalf the suit was brought.
(d)§ Interest.--Damages907. for injuries by reason of anything prohibited under this act shall include interest computed from the date on which the injury is sustained, at a rate equal to the statutory rate for postjudgment interest, and the cost of suit, including reasonable attorney fees.
Section 7.
(2) The General Assembly supports the intent through 20240HB2012PN2971 - 8 - this section, which provides the Office of Attorney General with notice of all material health care transactions in this Commonwealth, so that the Office of Attorney General has the information necessary to determine whether an investigation under this actchapter is warranted for potential anticompetitive conduct and consumer harm.
(3) In addition to requiring notice under subsection (a) for transactions not involving health care, this section is also intended to supplement the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act by requiring notice of health care transactions not reportable under the reporting thresholds of the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act 20240HB2012PN3461 - 9 - and by providing the Office of Attorney General with a copy of filings made in accordance with the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act.
(2) For the purposes of this section, a material change includes a merger, acquisition or contracting affiliation between two or more entities PERSONS of the following types:
<-- (i) health care facilities;
(3) A material change includes proposed changes identified in paragraph (1) between a Pennsylvania entity <-- PERSON and an out-of-State entity PERSON where the out-of-Stateout-of- <-- State entity PERSON generates at least $10,000,000 in health <-- care services revenue from patients residing in this Commonwealth and the 20240HB2012PN2971 - 9 - entities PERSONS are of the types <-- identified in paragraph (2).
20240HB2012PN3461 - 10 - (d) Notice requirements.-- (1) The written notice provided by the parties, as required by subsection (c), shall include:
(e) Requests for additional information.-- 20240HB2012PN2971 - 10 - (1) The Office of Attorney General must make a request for additional information from the parties under this actchapter within 30 days of the date notice is received under subsections (a), (c) and (d).
(f) Health care premerger notification.--A HEALTH CARE <-- FACILITY, HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEM, health care practitioner or provider organization conducting business in this 20240HB2012PN3461 - 11 - Commonwealth that files a premerger notification with the Federal Trade Commission or the United States Department of Justice, in compliance with the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act, shall provide a copy of the filing to the Office of Attorney General.
(g) Materials submitted to the Office of Attorney General.-- (1) Information submitted to the Office of Attorney General under this section shall be maintained and used by the Office of Attorney General in the same manner and under the same protections as provided under this act.chapter.
(2) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the Office of Attorney General's authority under this act.chapter.
20240HB2012PN2971§ -908. 11 - Section 8.
(a) Power of Attorney General to conduct.-- (1) If the Attorney General has reason to believe that a person, whether foreign or domestic, has engaged in or is engaging in a violation of this actchapter or of a Federal antitrust law that may be enforced by the Attorney General, the Attorney General may initiate an investigation.
(2) As part of an investigation under this section, the Attorney General may administer oaths and affirmations, 20240HB2012PN3461 - 12 - subpoena witnesses and documentary material, propound interrogatories to be answered in writing under oath and collect evidence.
(3) The Attorney General may use the information obtained under this section as the Attorney General determines necessary in the civil enforcement of this actchapter or Federal antitrust law that may be enforced by the Attorney General, including presentation before a court.
(3) The petitioner may raise an objection or privilege 20240HB2012PN2971 - 12 - that would be available under this actchapter or upon service of a subpoena in a civil action.
(c) Location for production of documentary material.-- (1) If documentary material that the Attorney General seeks to obtain by subpoena is not located within this Commonwealth and is not reducible to electronic reproduction and transmission, the party subpoenaed may make the documentary material available to the Attorney General to examine the documentary material at the place where the 20240HB2012PN3461 - 13 - documentary material is located.
(3) Except for a prosecution for perjury, an individual 20240HB2012PN2971 - 13 - who complies with a court order to provide testimony or matter after asserting a privilege against self-incrimination to which the individual is entitled by law shall not have the testimony or documentary material provided, or evidence derived therefrom, or received against the individual used in a criminal investigation or proceeding.
(e) Duty to comply.--A person, whether foreign or domestic, upon whom an interrogatory or subpoena is served pursuant to this section shall comply with the terms of the interrogatory or 20240HB2012PN3461 - 14 - subpoena unless otherwise provided by this section or by court order.
(f) Liability.-- (1) A person who:who SHALL BE LIABLE FOR A CIVIL PENALTY AS <-- PROVIDED IN THIS SUBSECTION IF THE PERSON:
(i) fails to appear with the intent to avoid, evade or prevent compliance, in whole or in part, with an investigation under this actchapter or who removes from a <-- place, conceals, withholds, mutilates, alters, destroys or by other means falsifies a matter or documentary material in the possession, custody or control of a person, subject to the request or subpoena;
or (ii) knowingly conceals relevant information with the intent to avoid, evade or prevent compliance shall be <-- liable for a civil penalty as provided in this subsection.
(g) Access to information of other agencies and 20240HB2012PN2971 - 14 - confidentiality.-- (1) If criminal or civil intelligence, records of investigations, investigative information or other information held by a Federal or State agency is available to the Attorney General on a confidential or restricted basis, the Attorney General may obtain and use the informationinformation, <-- unless otherwise prohibited by law.law, IN THE ENFORCEMENT OF <-- THIS CHAPTER, INCLUDING PRESENTATION BEFORE A COURT.
20240HB2012PN3461 - 15 - (2) A record of an investigation or intelligence or investigative information that is exempt from disclosure under the act of February 14, 2008 (P.L.6, No.3), known as the Right-to-Know Law, shall remain confidential EXCEPT AS <-- PROVIDED IN THIS SECTION and be exempt from disclosure under that act.
Section§ 9.909.
A person, including an agent or officer of the person, who knowingly commits an unlawful act under section 4(a)904(a) or (b) (relating to prohibited acts) is guilty of a felony of the third degree and, upon conviction, shall be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of not more than four years or sentenced to pay a fine of not more than $1,000,000, or both.
If the person who knowingly committed an unlawful act under section 4(a)904(a) or (b) is a corporation, the corporation shall be sentenced to pay a fine of not more than $1,000,000.
An indictment or information based on a violation of a of the provisions of this actchapter must be foundfiled within five years after the violation.
No criminal proceeding barred by a prior 20240HB2012PN2971 - 15 - limitation shall be revived by this act.chapter.
Section§ 10.910.
An individual or entity who A PERSON THAT has suffered <-- damages as a result of prohibited acts enumerated in section 4904 (relating to prohibited acts) shall have standing to commence an action in a court of competent jurisdiction.
Section20240HB2012PN3461 11.- 16 - § 911.
(a) Election.--The plaintiff in an action commenced under this actchapter may elect to sue for and recover either treble damages sustained or the full amount of the plaintiff's overcharge or underpayment without regard to any portion of the overcharge or underpayment that was recovered upon resale.
An action under this section may be brought by a person injured in the person's business or property under this act,chapter, regardless of whether the person dealt directly or indirectly with the defendant.
Proof of liability as a result of anticompetitive conduct in violation of this actchapter shall not require proof of individual reliance.
Section§ 12.912.
Cooperation with Federal Government and other states.states, <-- OTHER STATES AND STATE AGENCIES.
The Attorney General may cooperate with and coordinate enforcement of this actchapter and Federal antitrust law that may be enforced by the Attorney General with the Federal Government andand, the several states,states AND STATE AGENCIES, including using and <-- sharing information and evidence obtained under this act.chapter.
Section§ 13.913.
AGENCY COOPERATION.
<-- (A) GENERAL RULE.--ALL COMMONWEALTH AGENCIES SHALL ASSIST THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IN THE ENFORCEMENT OF THIS CHAPTER, IF REQUESTED, AND SHALL PROMPTLY COMPLY WITH ANY REQUEST FOR DOCUMENTS, TESTIMONY OR INFORMATION.
(B) ATTORNEY GENERAL.--THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL PROVIDE 20240HB2012PN3461 - 17 - NOTICE TO:
(1) THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH OF ANY ENFORCEMENT ACTION INITIATED UNDER SECTION 905 (RELATING TO ENFORCEMENT BY ATTORNEY GENERAL) AS WELL AS THE RESOLUTION OF ANY ACTION INITIATED UNDER SECTION 905 THAT INVOLVES A HEALTH CARE FACILITY OR A HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEM.
(2) THE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT OF ANY ENFORCEMENT ACTION INITIATED UNDER SECTION 905 AS WELL AS THE RESOLUTION OF ANY ACTION INITIATED UNDER SECTION 905 THAT INVOLVES AN INSURER.
§ 913 914.
<-- This actchapter shall not make illegal an activity or conduct exempt 20240HB2012PN2971 - 16 - under any statute of the United States or the Commonwealth.
Section§ 14.914 915.
<-- This actchapter shall not apply to a cooperative association or <-- an employee-owned enterprise, corporate or otherwise, of farmers, gardeners or dairy producers, including livestock farmers and fruit growers, nor to a contract, agreement or arrangement made by the association or enterprise, nor to a bona fide labor union.
SectionTHIS 15.CHAPTER SHALL NOT APPLY TO:
Action<-- not(1) barredA asCOOPERATIVE affectingASSOCIATION orOR involvingAN interstateEMPLOYEE-OWNED orENTERPRISE, foreignCORPORATE commerce.OR OTHERWISE, OF FARMERS, GARDENERS OR DAIRY PRODUCERS, INCLUDING LIVESTOCK FARMERS AND FRUIT GROWERS, NOR TO A CONTRACT, AGREEMENT OR ARRANGEMENT MADE BY THE ASSOCIATION OR ENTERPRISE, NOR TO A BONA FIDE LABOR UNION;
AnOR action(2) underTHE thisBUSINESS actOF mayINSURANCE notTO beTHE barredEXTENT onTHAT theTHE groundsBUSINESS: that the activity or conduct complained of affects or involves interstate or foreign commerce.
Section(I) 16.DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A BOYCOTT, COERCION OR 20240HB2012PN3461 - 18 - INTIMIDATION OR AN AGREEMENT TO BOYCOTT, COERCE OR INTIMIDATE;
AND (II) DOES NOT RELATE TO THE BUSINESS OF HEALTH INSURANCE, INCLUDING THE BUSINESS OF DENTAL INSURANCE AND LIMITED-SCOPE DENTAL BENEFITS.
§ 915 916.
Action not barred as affecting or involving <-- interstate or foreign commerce.
An action under this chapter may not be barred on the grounds that the activity or conduct complained of affects or involves interstate or foreign commerce.
§ 917.
CONSTRUCTION.
<-- THIS CHAPTER SHALL BE CONSTRUED IN HARMONY WITH JUDICIAL INTERPRETATIONS OF COMPARABLE FEDERAL ANTITRUST STATUTES INSOFAR AS PRACTICABLE.
§ 916 918.
<-- The remedies afforded by this actchapter are cumulative.
Section 17.2.
EffectiveThe date.addition of 12 Pa.C.S.
Ch.
9 shall apply to any action or proceeding brought by the Attorney General and pending on the date of enactment of this act.
Section 3.
SECTION20240HB2012PN3461 1.- 19 -
TITLE 12 OF THE PENNSYLVANIA CONSOLIDATED <-- STATUTES IS AMENDED BY ADDING A CHAPTER TO READ:
CHAPTER 9 PENNSYLVANIA OPEN MARKETS SEC.
901.
SCOPE OF CHAPTER.
902.
DECLARATION OF PURPOSE.
903.
DEFINITIONS.
904.
PROHIBITED ACTS.
905.
ENFORCEMENT BY ATTORNEY GENERAL.
906.
MEASUREMENT OF DAMAGES.
907.
PREMERGER NOTIFICATION REGARDING HEALTH CARE.
908.
CIVIL INVESTIGATION.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 17 - 909.
CRIMINAL PENALTIES.
910.
STANDING.
911.
ANTITRUST ENFORCEMENT BY PRIVATE PARTIES.
912.
COOPERATION WITH FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND OTHER STATES.
913.
EXCEPTIONS.
914.
APPLICABILITY.
915.
ACTION NOT BARRED AS AFFECTING OR INVOLVING INTERSTATE OR FOREIGN COMMERCE.
916.
REMEDIES CUMULATIVE.
§ 901.
SCOPE OF CHAPTER.
THIS CHAPTER RELATES TO OPEN MARKETS IN THIS COMMONWEALTH.
§ 902.
DECLARATION OF PURPOSE.
THE PURPOSE OF THIS CHAPTER IS TO PROMOTE FREE ENTERPRISE AND FREE TRADE IN THE MARKETPLACES OF THIS COMMONWEALTH BY PROHIBITING RESTRAINTS OF TRADE THAT ARE SECURED THROUGH MONOPOLISTIC OR COLLUSIVE PRACTICES AND THAT ACT OR TEND TO ACT TO DECREASE COMPETITION BETWEEN AND AMONG PERSONS ENGAGED IN COMMERCE AND TRADE.
§ 903.
DEFINITIONS.
THE FOLLOWING WORDS AND PHRASES WHEN USED IN THIS CHAPTER SHALL HAVE THE MEANINGS GIVEN TO THEM IN THIS SECTION UNLESS THE CONTEXT CLEARLY INDICATES OTHERWISE:
"ACQUISITION." AN AGREEMENT, ARRANGEMENT OR ACTIVITY, THE CONSUMMATION OF WHICH RESULTS IN A PERSON ACQUIRING, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, THE CONTROL OF ANOTHER PERSON OR THE ABILITY TO INFLUENCE THE COMPETITIVE CONDUCT OF THE TARGET FIRM, AND INCLUDES THE ACQUISITION OF VOTING SECURITIES AND NONCORPORATE INTERESTS, SUCH AS ASSETS, CAPITAL STOCK, MEMBERSHIP INTERESTS OR EQUITY INTERESTS.
"CONTRACTING AFFILIATION." THE FORMATION OF A RELATIONSHIP 20240HB2012PN2971 - 18 - BETWEEN TWO OR MORE ENTITIES THAT PERMITS THE ENTITIES TO NEGOTIATE JOINTLY WITH INSURERS OR THIRD-PARTY ADMINISTRATORS OVER RATES FOR PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL SERVICES OR FOR ONE ENTITY TO NEGOTIATE ON BEHALF OF THE OTHER ENTITY WITH INSURERS OR THIRD-PARTY ADMINISTRATORS OVER RATES FOR PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL SERVICES.
"HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT." TITLE II OF THE CLAYTON ANTITRUST ACT (PUBLIC LAW 63-212, 15 U.S.C.
§ 18A).
"HEALTH CARE FACILITY." AS DEFINED IN SECTION 103 OF THE ACT OF JULY 19, 1979 (P.L.130, NO.48), KNOWN AS THE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES ACT.
"HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEM." EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING:
(1) A PARENT CORPORATION OF ONE OR MORE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES AND AN ENTITY AFFILIATED WITH THE PARENT CORPORATION THROUGH OWNERSHIP OR CONTROL;
OR (2) A HEALTH CARE FACILITY AND AN ENTITY AFFILIATED WITH THE HEALTH CARE FACILITY THROUGH OWNERSHIP.
"HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONER." AS DEFINED IN SECTION 103 OF THE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES ACT.
"HEALTH CARE SERVICES." MEDICAL, SURGICAL, CHIROPRACTIC, HOSPITAL, OPTOMETRIC, PODIATRIC, PHARMACEUTICAL, AMBULANCE, MENTAL HEALTH, SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER, THERAPEUTIC, PREVENTATIVE, DIAGNOSTIC, CURATIVE, REHABILITATIVE, PALLIATIVE, CUSTODIAL AND OTHER SERVICES RELATING TO THE PREVENTION, CURE OR TREATMENT OF ILLNESS, INJURY OR DISEASE.
"HEALTH CARE SERVICES REVENUE." THE TOTAL REVENUE RECEIVED FOR HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN THE PREVIOUS 12 MONTHS.
"INSURER." AS DEFINED IN 40 PA.C.S.
§ 9103 (RELATING TO DEFINITIONS).
"MERGER." A CONSOLIDATION OF TWO OR MORE ORGANIZATIONS, 20240HB2012PN2971 - 19 - INCLUDING TWO OR MORE ORGANIZATIONS JOINING THROUGH A COMMON PARENT ORGANIZATION OR TWO OR MORE ORGANIZATIONS FORMING A NEW ORGANIZATION.
THE TERM DOES NOT INCLUDE A CORPORATE REORGANIZATION.
"MONOPOLY." THE POWER TO CONTROL PRICES AND EXCLUDE COMPETITION AS A SELLER.
"MONOPSONY." THE POWER TO CONTROL PRICES AND EXCLUDE COMPETITION AS A BUYER.
"PERSON." A NATURAL PERSON, CORPORATION, TRUST, PARTNERSHIP, AN INCORPORATED OR UNINCORPORATED ASSOCIATION, THE COMMONWEALTH, A STATE AGENCY, MUNICIPAL AUTHORITY, POLITICAL SUBDIVISION AND ANY OTHER LEGAL ENTITY.
"PROVIDER ORGANIZATION." A CORPORATION, PARTNERSHIP, BUSINESS TRUST, ASSOCIATION OR ORGANIZED GROUP OF PERSONS, WHETHER INCORPORATED OR NOT, THAT IS IN THE BUSINESS OF HEALTH CARE DELIVERY OR MANAGEMENT AND THAT REPRESENTS TWO OR MORE HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONERS IN CONTRACTING WITH INSURERS OR THIRD- PARTY ADMINISTRATORS FOR THE PAYMENTS OF HEALTH CARE SERVICES.
THE TERM INCLUDES A PHYSICIAN ORGANIZATION, PHYSICIAN-HOSPITAL ORGANIZATION, INDEPENDENT PRACTICE ASSOCIATION, PROVIDER NETWORK AND ACCOUNTABLE CARE ORGANIZATION.
"THIRD-PARTY ADMINISTRATOR." AN ENTITY THAT ADMINISTERS PAYMENTS FOR HEALTH CARE SERVICES ON BEHALF OF A CLIENT IN EXCHANGE FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE.
"TRADE OR COMMERCE." ECONOMIC ACTIVITY DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY AFFECTING THE PEOPLE OF THIS COMMONWEALTH.
§ 904.
PROHIBITED ACTS.
(A) RESTRAINTS OF TRADE.--A CONTRACT, A COMBINATION IN THE FORM OF TRUST OR OTHERWISE OR A CONSPIRACY IN RESTRAINT OF TRADE OR COMMERCE, IS UNLAWFUL.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 20 - (B) MONOPOLIZE OR MONOPSONIZE.--IT IS UNLAWFUL FOR A PERSON TO MONOPOLIZE OR MONOPSONIZE, TO ATTEMPT TO MONOPOLIZE OR MONOPSONIZE OR TO COMBINE OR CONSPIRE WITH ANOTHER PERSON TO MONOPOLIZE OR MONOPSONIZE, IN ANY PART OF TRADE OR COMMERCE.
(C) ACQUISITIONS.--IT IS UNLAWFUL FOR A PERSON TO ACQUIRE, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, THE WHOLE OR ANY PART OF THE STOCK, SHARE CAPITAL OR OTHER EQUITY INTEREST OF ANOTHER PERSON OR THE WHOLE OR ANY PART OF THE ASSETS OF ANOTHER PERSON IF ANY OF THE FOLLOWING APPLY:
(1) THE EFFECT OF THE ACQUISITION IS SUBSTANTIALLY TO LESSEN COMPETITION.
(2) THE EFFECT OF THE ACQUISITION TENDS TO CREATE A MONOPOLY OR MONOPSONY OF ANY PART OF TRADE OR COMMERCE.
(D) MARKET POWER.--IT IS UNLAWFUL FOR ANY PERSON OR PERSONS WITH MARKET POWER IN THE CONDUCT OF ANY BUSINESS, TRADE OR COMMERCE, IN A LABOR MARKET, OR IN THE FURNISHING OF A SERVICE IN THIS COMMONWEALTH, TO ABUSE THAT MARKET POWER.
§ 905.
ENFORCEMENT BY ATTORNEY GENERAL.
(A) ACTION ON BEHALF OF COMMONWEALTH.--IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS REASON TO BELIEVE THAT A PERSON, FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC, HAS ENGAGED IN, IS ENGAGING IN OR IS ABOUT TO ENGAGE IN AN ACT OR PRACTICE THAT IS UNLAWFUL UNDER THIS CHAPTER, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY BRING A CIVIL ACTION IN THE NAME OF THE COMMONWEALTH AGAINST THE PERSON TO:
(1) OBTAIN A DECLARATORY JUDGMENT THAT THE ACTION OR PRACTICE VIOLATES THIS CHAPTER.
(2) ENJOIN AN ACT OR PRACTICE THAT VIOLATES THIS CHAPTER BY ISSUING A TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, AN EX PARTE TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER OR A PRELIMINARY OR PERMANENT INJUNCTION, WITHOUT BOND.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 21 - (3) RECOVER A CIVIL PENALTY OF NOT LESS THAN $100,000 FOR EACH VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER OR OF AN INJUNCTION, JUDGMENT OR CONSENT AGREEMENT ISSUED OR ENTERED INTO UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
(4) OBTAIN AN ORDER REQUIRING DIVESTITURE OF ASSETS:
(I) ACQUIRED IN VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER AND AFTER THE COURT DETERMINES THAT DIVESTITURE IS NECESSARY TO AVOID THE CREATION OR CONTINUATION OF A MONOPOLY OR TO AVOID A LIKELY SUBSTANTIAL LESSENING OF COMPETITION THAT RESULTS FROM A TRANSACTION FOUND TO BE IN VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER;
OR (II) TO RESTORE COMPETITION TO A LINE OF COMMERCE THAT HAS BEEN ELIMINATED BY A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER.
(5) RECOVER ACTUAL DAMAGES, RESTITUTION OR DISGORGEMENT ON BEHALF OF THE COMMONWEALTH AND ITS AGENCIES THAT ARE INJURED EITHER DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY THROUGH A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER.
(B) ACTION ON BEHALF OF NATURAL PERSON.--THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY BRING A CIVIL ACTION IN THE NAME OF THE COMMONWEALTH ON BEHALF OF A NATURAL PERSON INJURED DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY TO RECOVER DAMAGES, RESTITUTION OR DISGORGEMENT THROUGH A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER.
(C) RECOVERY AUTHORIZED.--THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL RECOVER THE COSTS OF AN INVESTIGATION, EXPERT COSTS AND REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS IF SUCCESSFUL IN AN ACTION INITIATED UNDER THIS SECTION.
(D) JURISDICTION.--A CIVIL ACTION UNDER THIS SECTION MAY BE BROUGHT BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IN COMMONWEALTH COURT OR IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF THE COUNTY IN WHICH A PARTY RESIDES OR HAS A PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 22 - (E) INVESTIGATION.-- (1) IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS REASON TO BELIEVE THAT A PERSON, WHETHER FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC, HAS ENGAGED IN OR IS ENGAGING IN A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER OR OF A FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW THAT MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY INITIATE AN INVESTIGATION.
(2) AS PART OF AN INVESTIGATION UNDER THIS SECTION, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY ADMINISTER OATHS AND AFFIRMATIONS, SUBPOENA WITNESSES AND DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL, PROPOUND INTERROGATORIES TO BE ANSWERED IN WRITING UNDER OATH AND COLLECT EVIDENCE.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY USE THE INFORMATION OBTAINED UNDER THIS SECTION AS THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DETERMINES NECESSARY IN THE CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OF THIS CHAPTER OR FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW THAT MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, INCLUDING PRESENTATION BEFORE A COURT.
(4) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY COOPERATE WITH AND COORDINATE ENFORCEMENT OF THIS CHAPTER AND A FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND THE SEVERAL STATES, INCLUDING USING AND SHARING INFORMATION AND EVIDENCE OBTAINED UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
§ 906.
MEASUREMENT OF DAMAGES.
(A) GENERAL RULE.--IN AN ACTION BROUGHT UNDER THIS CHAPTER, THE PREVAILING PARTY SHALL RECOVER TREBLE DAMAGES SUSTAINED, REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS, EXPERT WITNESS FEES AND INVESTIGATIVE COSTS.
(B) METHOD.--IN AN ACTION UNDER THIS CHAPTER, DAMAGES MAY BE PROVED AND ASSESSED IN THE AGGREGATE BY STATISTICAL OR SAMPLING METHODS, BY THE COMPUTATION OF ILLEGAL OVERCHARGES OR 20240HB2012PN2971 - 23 - UNDERPAYMENT OR BY ANOTHER REASONABLE SYSTEM OF ESTIMATING AGGREGATE DAMAGES AS THE COURT MAY PERMIT WITHOUT THE NECESSITY OF SEPARATELY PROVING THE INDIVIDUAL CLAIM OF, OR AMOUNT OF DAMAGE TO, PERSONS ON WHOSE BEHALF THE SUIT WAS BROUGHT.
(C) INTEREST.--DAMAGES FOR INJURIES BY REASON OF ANYTHING PROHIBITED UNDER THIS CHAPTER SHALL INCLUDE INTEREST COMPUTED FROM THE DATE ON WHICH THE INJURY IS SUSTAINED, AT A RATE EQUAL TO THE STATUTORY RATE FOR POSTJUDGMENT INTEREST, AND THE COST OF SUIT, INCLUDING REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES.
§ 907.
PREMERGER NOTIFICATION REGARDING HEALTH CARE.
(A) GENERAL NOTIFICATION.--A PERSON CONDUCTING BUSINESS IN THIS COMMONWEALTH THAT IS REQUIRED TO FILE THE NOTIFICATION AND REPORT FORM FOR CERTAIN MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS UNDER THE HART- SCOTT-RODINO ACT SHALL PROVIDE THE SAME NOTICE AND DOCUMENTATION IN ITS ENTIRETY TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL AT THE SAME TIME THAT NOTICE IS FILED WITH THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.
(B) HEALTH CARE NOTIFICATION.-- (1) IT IS THE INTENT OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO ENSURE THAT COMPETITION BENEFICIAL TO CONSUMERS IN HEALTH CARE MARKETS ACROSS THIS COMMONWEALTH REMAINS VIGOROUS AND ROBUST.
(2) THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY SUPPORTS THE INTENT THROUGH THIS SECTION, WHICH PROVIDES THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH NOTICE OF ALL MATERIAL HEALTH CARE TRANSACTIONS IN THIS COMMONWEALTH, SO THAT THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS THE INFORMATION NECESSARY TO DETERMINE WHETHER AN INVESTIGATION UNDER THIS CHAPTER IS WARRANTED FOR POTENTIAL ANTICOMPETITIVE CONDUCT AND CONSUMER HARM.
(3) IN ADDITION TO REQUIRING NOTICE UNDER SUBSECTION (A) FOR TRANSACTIONS NOT INVOLVING HEALTH CARE, THIS SECTION IS 20240HB2012PN2971 - 24 - ALSO INTENDED TO SUPPLEMENT THE HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT BY REQUIRING NOTICE OF HEALTH CARE TRANSACTIONS NOT REPORTABLE UNDER THE REPORTING THRESHOLDS OF THE HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT AND BY PROVIDING THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH A COPY OF FILINGS MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT.
(C) NOTICE OF MATERIAL CHANGE.-- (1) NOT LESS THAN 120 DAYS PRIOR TO THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF A HEALTH CARE TRANSACTION THAT RESULTS IN A MATERIAL CHANGE, THE PARTIES TO THE HEALTH CARE TRANSACTION SHALL SUBMIT WRITTEN NOTICE TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE MATERIAL CHANGE.
(2) FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, A MATERIAL CHANGE INCLUDES A MERGER, ACQUISITION OR CONTRACTING AFFILIATION BETWEEN TWO OR MORE ENTITIES OF THE FOLLOWING TYPES:
(I) HEALTH CARE FACILITIES;
(II) HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEMS;
OR (III) PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS.
(3) A MATERIAL CHANGE INCLUDES PROPOSED CHANGES IDENTIFIED IN PARAGRAPH (1) BETWEEN A PENNSYLVANIA ENTITY AND AN OUT-OF-STATE ENTITY WHERE THE OUT-OF-STATE ENTITY GENERATES AT LEAST $10,000,000 IN HEALTH CARE SERVICES REVENUE FROM PATIENTS RESIDING IN THIS COMMONWEALTH AND THE ENTITIES ARE OF THE TYPES IDENTIFIED IN PARAGRAPH (2).
A PARTY TO A MATERIAL CHANGE THAT IS LICENSED OR OPERATING IN THIS COMMONWEALTH SHALL SUBMIT A NOTICE AS REQUIRED UNDER THIS SECTION.
(4) FOR PURPOSES OF PARAGRAPH (2), A MERGER, ACQUISITION OR CONTRACTING AFFILIATION BETWEEN TWO OR MORE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES, HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEMS OR PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS ONLY QUALIFIES AS A MATERIAL CHANGE IF THE 20240HB2012PN2971 - 25 - HEALTH CARE FACILITIES, HEALTH CARE FACILITY SYSTEMS OR PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS DID NOT PREVIOUSLY HAVE COMMON OWNERSHIP OR A CONTRACTING AFFILIATION.
(D) NOTICE REQUIREMENTS.-- (1) THE WRITTEN NOTICE PROVIDED BY THE PARTIES, AS REQUIRED BY SUBSECTION (C), SHALL INCLUDE:
(I) THE NAMES OF THE PARTIES AND THEIR CURRENT BUSINESS ADDRESSES.
(II) IDENTIFICATION OF ALL LOCATIONS WHERE HEALTH CARE SERVICES ARE CURRENTLY PROVIDED BY EACH PARTY.
(III) IDENTIFICATION OF ALL HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONERS WHO CURRENTLY PROVIDE HEALTH CARE SERVICES FOR EACH PARTY.
(IV) A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE NATURE AND PURPOSE OF THE PROPOSED MATERIAL CHANGE.
(V) THE ANTICIPATED EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE PROPOSED MATERIAL CHANGE.
(2) NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL BE CONSTRUED TO PROHIBIT THE PARTIES TO A MATERIAL CHANGE FROM VOLUNTARILY PROVIDING ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL.
(E) REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.-- (1) THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL MUST MAKE A REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FROM THE PARTIES UNDER THIS CHAPTER WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DATE NOTICE IS RECEIVED UNDER SUBSECTIONS (A), (C) AND (D).
(2) NOTHING IN THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE CONSTRUED TO PRECLUDE THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL FROM CONDUCTING AN INVESTIGATION OR ENFORCING FEDERAL OR STATE ANTITRUST LAWS AT A LATER DATE.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 26 - (F) HEALTH CARE PREMERGER NOTIFICATION.--A HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONER OR PROVIDER ORGANIZATION CONDUCTING BUSINESS IN THIS COMMONWEALTH THAT FILES A PREMERGER NOTIFICATION WITH THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT, SHALL PROVIDE A COPY OF THE FILING TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL.
PROVIDING A COPY OF THE HART-SCOTT-RODINO ACT FILING TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL SATISFIES THE NOTICE REQUIREMENT UNDER SUBSECTION (D).
(G) MATERIALS SUBMITTED TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL.-- (1) INFORMATION SUBMITTED TO THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE MAINTAINED AND USED BY THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL IN THE SAME MANNER AND UNDER THE SAME PROTECTIONS AS PROVIDED UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
(2) NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL BE CONSTRUED TO LIMIT THE OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL'S AUTHORITY UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
(3) FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THIS SECTION DOES NOT PROVIDE A PRIVATE CAUSE OF ACTION.
(H) PENALTY FOR NONCOMPLIANCE.--A PERSON THAT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THIS SECTION IS LIABLE TO THE COMMONWEALTH FOR A CIVIL PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN $200 PER DAY FOR EACH DAY OF NONCOMPLIANCE.
§ 908.
CIVIL INVESTIGATION.
(A) POWER OF ATTORNEY GENERAL TO CONDUCT.-- (1) IF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS REASON TO BELIEVE THAT A PERSON, WHETHER FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC, HAS ENGAGED IN OR IS ENGAGING IN A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER OR OF A FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW THAT MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY INITIATE AN INVESTIGATION.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 27 - (2) AS PART OF AN INVESTIGATION UNDER THIS SECTION, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY ADMINISTER OATHS AND AFFIRMATIONS, SUBPOENA WITNESSES AND DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL, PROPOUND INTERROGATORIES TO BE ANSWERED IN WRITING UNDER OATH AND COLLECT EVIDENCE.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY USE THE INFORMATION OBTAINED UNDER THIS SECTION AS THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DETERMINES NECESSARY IN THE CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OF THIS CHAPTER OR FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW THAT MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, INCLUDING PRESENTATION BEFORE A COURT.
(4) AN INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA SERVED UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL INFORM THE PARTY SERVED OF THE RIGHT TO FILE A PETITION AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (B).
(B) PETITION AUTHORIZED.-- (1) NOT LATER THAN FIVE BUSINESS DAYS AFTER THE SERVICE OF AN INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA, OR AT ANY TIME BEFORE THE RETURN DATE SPECIFIED IN THE INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA, THE PARTY SERVED UNDER THIS SECTION MAY FILE IN COMMONWEALTH COURT A PETITION FOR AN ORDER MODIFYING OR SETTING ASIDE THE INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA.
(2) THE PARTY MUST SERVE THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH A COPY OF THE PETITION.
(3) THE PETITIONER MAY RAISE AN OBJECTION OR PRIVILEGE THAT WOULD BE AVAILABLE UNDER THIS CHAPTER OR UPON SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA IN A CIVIL ACTION.
(C) LOCATION FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL.-- (1) IF DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SEEKS TO OBTAIN BY SUBPOENA IS NOT LOCATED WITHIN THIS COMMONWEALTH AND IS NOT REDUCIBLE TO ELECTRONIC REPRODUCTION AND TRANSMISSION, THE PARTY SUBPOENAED MAY MAKE THE 20240HB2012PN2971 - 28 - DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL AVAILABLE TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO EXAMINE THE DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL AT THE PLACE WHERE THE DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL IS LOCATED.
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY DESIGNATE REPRESENTATIVES, INCLUDING OFFICIALS OF THE STATE IN WHICH THE DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL IS LOCATED, TO INSPECT THE DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL ON THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S BEHALF.
(3) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY RESPOND TO SIMILAR REQUESTS FROM OFFICIALS OF OTHER STATES AND MAY INSPECT DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL ON THEIR BEHALF.
(D) INVESTIGATION ENFORCEMENT ORDER.-- (1) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY APPLY TO COMMONWEALTH COURT FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING COMPLIANCE OF A PARTY WHO FAILS TO OBEY A SUBPOENA OR ANSWER AN INTERROGATORY ISSUED UNDER THIS SECTION WITHOUT LAWFUL EXCUSE AND UPON REASONABLE NOTICE TO ALL PERSONS AFFECTED BY THE SUBPOENA OR INTERROGATORY.
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY REQUEST THAT AN INDIVIDUAL WHO REFUSES TO COMPLY WITH A SUBPOENA OR ANSWER AN INTERROGATORY ON THE GROUNDS THAT THE TESTIMONY OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL MAY INCRIMINATE THE INDIVIDUAL BE ORDERED BY THE COURT TO PROVIDE THE TESTIMONY OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL.
(3) EXCEPT FOR A PROSECUTION FOR PERJURY, AN INDIVIDUAL WHO COMPLIES WITH A COURT ORDER TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY OR MATTER AFTER ASSERTING A PRIVILEGE AGAINST SELF-INCRIMINATION TO WHICH THE INDIVIDUAL IS ENTITLED BY LAW SHALL NOT HAVE THE TESTIMONY OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL PROVIDED, OR EVIDENCE DERIVED THEREFROM, OR RECEIVED AGAINST THE INDIVIDUAL USED IN A CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION OR PROCEEDING.
(E) DUTY TO COMPLY.--A PERSON, WHETHER FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC, 20240HB2012PN2971 - 29 - UPON WHOM AN INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA IS SERVED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION SHALL COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THE INTERROGATORY OR SUBPOENA UNLESS OTHERWISE PROVIDED BY THIS SECTION OR BY COURT ORDER.
(F) LIABILITY.-- (1) A PERSON WHO:
(I) FAILS TO APPEAR WITH THE INTENT TO AVOID, EVADE OR PREVENT COMPLIANCE, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, WITH AN INVESTIGATION UNDER THIS CHAPTER OR WHO REMOVES FROM A PLACE, CONCEALS, WITHHOLDS, MUTILATES, ALTERS, DESTROYS OR BY OTHER MEANS FALSIFIES A MATTER OR DOCUMENTARY MATERIAL IN THE POSSESSION, CUSTODY OR CONTROL OF A PERSON, SUBJECT TO THE REQUEST OR SUBPOENA;
OR (II) KNOWINGLY CONCEALS RELEVANT INFORMATION WITH THE INTENT TO AVOID, EVADE OR PREVENT COMPLIANCE SHALL BE LIABLE FOR A CIVIL PENALTY AS PROVIDED IN THIS SUBSECTION.
(2) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY, UPON PETITION TO COMMONWEALTH COURT, RECOVER A CIVIL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED $25,000.
IF A CIVIL PENALTY IS ASSESSED IN OR AS THE RESULT OF LITIGATION, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IS ENTITLED TO REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS.
(G) ACCESS TO INFORMATION OF OTHER AGENCIES AND CONFIDENTIALITY.-- (1) IF CRIMINAL OR CIVIL INTELLIGENCE, RECORDS OF INVESTIGATIONS, INVESTIGATIVE INFORMATION OR OTHER INFORMATION HELD BY A FEDERAL OR STATE AGENCY IS AVAILABLE TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL ON A CONFIDENTIAL OR RESTRICTED BASIS, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY OBTAIN AND USE THE INFORMATION UNLESS OTHERWISE PROHIBITED BY LAW.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 30 - (2) A RECORD OF AN INVESTIGATION OR INTELLIGENCE OR INVESTIGATIVE INFORMATION THAT IS EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER THE ACT OF FEBRUARY 14, 2008 (P.L.6, NO.3), KNOWN AS THE RIGHT-TO-KNOW LAW, SHALL REMAIN CONFIDENTIAL AND BE EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER THAT ACT.
(H) RECORDS OF INVESTIGATION.--A WRITTEN RESPONSE, TESTIMONY OR DOCUMENT OBTAINED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL UNDER THIS SECTION, OR INFORMATION DERIVED DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY FROM A WRITTEN RESPONSE, TESTIMONY OR DOCUMENT OBTAINED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, SHALL BE DEEMED A RECORD OF AN INVESTIGATION AND SHALL BE EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER THE RIGHT-TO-KNOW LAW.
§ 909.
CRIMINAL PENALTIES.
A PERSON, INCLUDING AN AGENT OR OFFICER OF THE PERSON, WHO KNOWINGLY COMMITS AN UNLAWFUL ACT UNDER SECTION 904(A) OR (B) (RELATING TO PROHIBITED ACTS) IS GUILTY OF A FELONY OF THE THIRD DEGREE AND, UPON CONVICTION, SHALL BE SENTENCED TO A TERM OF IMPRISONMENT OF NOT MORE THAN FOUR YEARS OR SENTENCED TO PAY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $1,000,000, OR BOTH.
IF THE PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY COMMITTED AN UNLAWFUL ACT UNDER SECTION 904(A) OR (B) IS A CORPORATION, THE CORPORATION SHALL BE SENTENCED TO PAY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $1,000,000.
AN INDICTMENT OR INFORMATION BASED ON A VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER MUST BE FILED WITHIN FIVE YEARS AFTER THE VIOLATION.
NO CRIMINAL PROCEEDING BARRED BY A PRIOR LIMITATION SHALL BE REVIVED BY THIS CHAPTER.
§ 910.
STANDING.
AN INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY WHO HAS SUFFERED DAMAGES AS A RESULT OF PROHIBITED ACTS ENUMERATED IN SECTION 904 (RELATING TO PROHIBITED ACTS) SHALL HAVE STANDING TO COMMENCE AN ACTION IN A COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDICTION.
§ 911.
ANTITRUST ENFORCEMENT BY PRIVATE PARTIES.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 31 - (A) ELECTION.--THE PLAINTIFF IN AN ACTION COMMENCED UNDER THIS CHAPTER MAY ELECT TO SUE FOR AND RECOVER EITHER TREBLE DAMAGES SUSTAINED OR THE FULL AMOUNT OF THE PLAINTIFF'S OVERCHARGE OR UNDERPAYMENT WITHOUT REGARD TO ANY PORTION OF THE OVERCHARGE OR UNDERPAYMENT THAT WAS RECOVERED UPON RESALE.
AN ACTION UNDER THIS SECTION MAY BE BROUGHT BY A PERSON INJURED IN THE PERSON'S BUSINESS OR PROPERTY UNDER THIS CHAPTER, REGARDLESS OF WHETHER THE PERSON DEALT DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY WITH THE DEFENDANT.
A REMEDY UNDER THIS SECTION IS IN ADDITION TO ANY OTHER REMEDY UNDER LAW AND MAY NOT DIMINISH OR OFFSET ANY OTHER REMEDY.
PROOF OF LIABILITY AS A RESULT OF ANTICOMPETITIVE CONDUCT IN VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL NOT REQUIRE PROOF OF INDIVIDUAL RELIANCE.
(B) CLASS ACTION.--AN ACTION BROUGHT UNDER THIS SECTION MAY BE MAINTAINED AS A CLASS ACTION PURSUANT TO THE PENNSYLVANIA RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE.
§ 912.
COOPERATION WITH FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND OTHER STATES.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY COOPERATE WITH AND COORDINATE ENFORCEMENT OF THIS CHAPTER AND FEDERAL ANTITRUST LAW THAT MAY BE ENFORCED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND THE SEVERAL STATES, INCLUDING USING AND SHARING INFORMATION AND EVIDENCE OBTAINED UNDER THIS CHAPTER.
§ 913.
EXCEPTIONS.
THIS CHAPTER SHALL NOT MAKE ILLEGAL AN ACTIVITY OR CONDUCT EXEMPT UNDER ANY STATUTE OF THE UNITED STATES OR THE COMMONWEALTH.
§ 914.
APPLICABILITY.
THIS CHAPTER SHALL NOT APPLY TO A COOPERATIVE ASSOCIATION OR AN EMPLOYEE-OWNED ENTERPRISE, CORPORATE OR OTHERWISE, OF FARMERS, GARDENERS OR DAIRY PRODUCERS, INCLUDING LIVESTOCK 20240HB2012PN2971 - 32 - FARMERS AND FRUIT GROWERS, NOR TO A CONTRACT, AGREEMENT OR ARRANGEMENT MADE BY THE ASSOCIATION OR ENTERPRISE, NOR TO A BONA FIDE LABOR UNION.
§ 915.
ACTION NOT BARRED AS AFFECTING OR INVOLVING INTERSTATE OR FOREIGN COMMERCE.
AN ACTION UNDER THIS CHAPTER MAY NOT BE BARRED ON THE GROUNDS THAT THE ACTIVITY OR CONDUCT COMPLAINED OF AFFECTS OR INVOLVES INTERSTATE OR FOREIGN COMMERCE.
§ 916.
REMEDIES CUMULATIVE.
THE REMEDIES AFFORDED BY THIS CHAPTER ARE CUMULATIVE.
SECTION 2.
THE ADDITION OF 12 PA.C.S.
CH.
9 SHALL APPLY TO ANY ACTION OR PROCEEDING BROUGHT BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AND PENDING ON THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT.
SECTION 3.
THIS ACT SHALL TAKE EFFECT IN 60 DAYS.
20240HB2012PN2971 - 33 -
Show all 337 changed rows (297 more)
Amendments
3 amendments- House Amendment A05238 Show changes
- House Amendment A05332 Show changes
- House Amendment A05333 Show changes
Click Show changes on an amendment above to see how it modifies the bill.
Action History
-
Referred to Judiciary
-
Third consideration and final passage
-
Re-reported as committed
-
Re-committed to Appropriations
-
Second consideration, with amendments
-
Removed from table
-
Laid on the table
-
First consideration
-
Reported as amended
-
Referred to Judiciary
Sponsors
- Nick Pisciottano · Primary
- Arvind Venkat · Cosponsor
- MaryLouise Isaacson · Cosponsor
- Maureen E. Madden · Cosponsor
- Tarik Khan · Cosponsor
- Kristine C. Howard · Cosponsor
- Napoleon J. Nelson · Cosponsor
- Heather Boyd · Cosponsor
- Rick Krajewski · Cosponsor
- G. Roni Green · Cosponsor
- Melissa Cerrato · Cosponsor
- Tim Briggs · Cosponsor
- Dave Madsen · Cosponsor
- Tina M. Davis · Cosponsor
- Justin C. Fleming · Cosponsor
- Joe Webster · Cosponsor
- Malcolm Kenyatta · Cosponsor
- Robert F. Matzie · Cosponsor
- David M. Delloso · Cosponsor
- Michael H. Schlossberg · Cosponsor
- Benjamin V. Sanchez · Cosponsor
- Robert E. Merski · Cosponsor
Sponsorship breakdown
Export CSV (upgrade) →1 sponsors · 21 co-sponsors · 231 not signed on · 179 voted No
Sponsors (1)
- Nick Pisciottano Democratic Voted No
Co-sponsors (21)
- Arvind Venkat Democratic Voted No
- MaryLouise Isaacson Democratic Voted No
- Maureen E. Madden Democratic Voted No
- Tarik Khan Democratic Voted No
- Kristine C. Howard Democratic Voted No
- Napoleon J. Nelson Democratic Voted No
- Heather Boyd Democratic Voted No
- Rick Krajewski Democratic Voted No
- G. Roni Green Democratic Voted No
- Melissa Cerrato Democratic Voted No
- Tim Briggs Democratic Voted No
- Dave Madsen Democratic Voted No
- Tina M. Davis Democratic Voted No
- Justin C. Fleming Democratic Voted No
- Joe Webster Democratic Voted No
- Malcolm Kenyatta Democratic Voted No
- Robert F. Matzie Democratic Voted No
- David M. Delloso Democratic Voted No
- Michael H. Schlossberg Democratic Voted No
- Benjamin V. Sanchez Democratic Voted No
- Robert E. Merski Democratic Voted No
Not signed on (231)
231 members have not signed on to this bill.
Show all 231 →"Not signed on" means a member has not sponsored or co-sponsored this bill — it does not imply opposition. Members flagged Voted No have a recorded No vote on this bill.
Votes
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unaffiliated | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 11 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Democratic | 21 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 37 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| % of votes cast | 100% | 0% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (37)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Joshua Siegel | — | Yea |
| Louis Schmitt | — | Yea |
| Mike Cabell | — | Yea |
| Seth Grove | — | Yea |
| Torren Ecker | — | Yea |
| Abigail Salisbury | Democratic | Yea |
| Aerion Abney | Democratic | Yea |
| Ben Waxman | Democratic | Yea |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Yea |
| Bridget M. Kosierowski | Democratic | Yea |
| Dave Madsen | Democratic | Yea |
| Elizabeth Fiedler | Democratic | Yea |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Yea |
| Gina H. Curry | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe Webster | Democratic | Yea |
| Jordan A. Harris | Democratic | Yea |
| Justin C. Fleming | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle J. Mullins | Democratic | Yea |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Yea |
| Manuel Guzman | Democratic | Yea |
| Morgan Cephas | Democratic | Yea |
| Napoleon J. Nelson | Democratic | Yea |
| Pat Gallagher | Democratic | Yea |
| Regina G. Young | Democratic | Yea |
| Steven R. Malagari | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Brennan | Democratic | Yea |
| Ann Flood | Republican | Yea |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Yea |
| Eric R. Nelson | Republican | Yea |
| James B. Struzzi | Republican | Yea |
| John A. Lawrence | Republican | Yea |
| Kristin Marcell | Republican | Yea |
| Marci Mustello | Republican | Yea |
| Natalie Mihalek | Republican | Yea |
| Ryan Warner | Republican | Yea |
| Thomas H. Kutz | Republican | Yea |
| Zachary Mako | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 94 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 9 | 76 | 0 | 2 |
| Unaffiliated | 9 | 13 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 112 | 89 | 0 | 2 |
| % of votes cast | 55% | 44% | 0% | 1% |
How each member voted (203)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| P. Sturla | — | Yea |
| Aaron Kaufer | — | Nay |
| Barry Jozwiak | — | Nay |
| Dan Miller | — | Yea |
| Donna Bullock | — | Yea |
| Donna Oberlander | — | Yea |
| George Dunbar | — | Nay |
| Jim Gregory | — | Nay |
| Jim Marshall | — | Nay |
| Joshua Siegel | — | Yea |
| Kevin Boyle | — | Yea |
| Louis Schmitt | — | Nay |
| MACKENZIE, R | — | Nay |
| Mark Rozzi | — | Yea |
| Matthew Gergely | — | Yea |
| Mike Cabell | — | Nay |
| Paul Schemel | — | Nay |
| Robert W. Mercuri | — | Nay |
| Seth Grove | — | Nay |
| Stephen Kinsey | — | Yea |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Nay |
| Torren Ecker | — | Nay |
| Abigail Salisbury | Democratic | Yea |
| Aerion Abney | Democratic | Yea |
| Amen Brown | Democratic | Yea |
| Anita Astorino Kulik | Democratic | Yea |
| Anthony A. Bellmon | Democratic | Yea |
| Arvind Venkat | Democratic | Yea |
| Ben Waxman | Democratic | Yea |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Yea |
| Brandon J. Markosek | Democratic | Yea |
| Brian Munroe | Democratic | Yea |
| Bridget M. Kosierowski | Democratic | Yea |
| Carol Hill-Evans | Democratic | Yea |
| Carol Kazeem | Democratic | Yea |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Yea |
| Christina D. Sappey | Democratic | Yea |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan Frankel | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Yea |
| Daniel J. Deasy | Democratic | Yea |
| Danielle Friel Otten | Democratic | Yea |
| Danilo Burgos | Democratic | Yea |
| Darisha K. Parker | Democratic | Yea |
| Dave Madsen | Democratic | Yea |
| David M. Delloso | Democratic | Yea |
| Ed Neilson | Democratic | Yea |
| Eddie Day Pashinski | Democratic | Yea |
| Elizabeth Fiedler | Democratic | Yea |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Yea |
| Frank Burns | Democratic | Yea |
| G. Roni Green | Democratic | Yea |
| Gina H. Curry | Democratic | Yea |
| Greg Scott | Democratic | Yea |
| Greg Vitali | Democratic | Yea |
| Heather Boyd | Democratic | Yea |
| Ismail Smith-Wade-El | Democratic | Yea |
| Jared G. Solomon | Democratic | Yea |
| Jason Dawkins | Democratic | Yea |
| Jeanne McNeill | Democratic | Yea |
| Jennifer O'Mara | Democratic | Yea |
| Jessica Benham | Democratic | Yea |
| Jim Haddock | Democratic | Yea |
| Jim Prokopiak | Democratic | Yea |
| Joanna E. McClinton | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe Ciresi | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe McAndrew | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe Webster | Democratic | Yea |
| Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz | Democratic | Yea |
| Jordan A. Harris | Democratic | Yea |
| Jose Giral | Democratic | Yea |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Yea |
| Justin C. Fleming | Democratic | Yea |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle J. Mullins | Democratic | Yea |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Yea |
| Leanne Krueger | Democratic | Yea |
| Lindsay Powell | Democratic | Yea |
| Lisa A. Borowski | Democratic | Yea |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Yea |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Yea |
| Mandy Steele | Democratic | Yea |
| Manuel Guzman | Democratic | Yea |
| Mary Jo Daley | Democratic | Yea |
| MaryLouise Isaacson | Democratic | Yea |
| Matthew D. Bradford | Democratic | Yea |
| Maureen E. Madden | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa Cerrato | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Yea |
| Michael H. Schlossberg | Democratic | Yea |
| Morgan Cephas | Democratic | Yea |
| Nancy Guenst | Democratic | Yea |
| Napoleon J. Nelson | Democratic | Yea |
| Nick Pisciottano | Democratic | Yea |
| Pat Gallagher | Democratic | Yea |
| Patrick J. Harkins | Democratic | Yea |
| Patty Kim | Democratic | Yea |
| Paul Friel | Democratic | Yea |
| Paul Takac | Democratic | Yea |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Yea |
| Peter Schweyer | Democratic | Yea |
| Regina G. Young | Democratic | Yea |
| Rick Krajewski | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert E. Merski | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert F. Matzie | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert Freeman | Democratic | Yea |
| Ryan A. Bizzarro | Democratic | Yea |
| Scott Conklin | Democratic | Yea |
| Steve Samuelson | Democratic | Yea |
| Steven R. Malagari | Democratic | Yea |
| Tarah Probst | Democratic | Yea |
| Tarik Khan | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Brennan | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Yea |
| Tina M. Davis | Democratic | Yea |
| Aaron Bernstine | Republican | Nay |
| Abby Major | Republican | Nay |
| Alec J. Ryncavage | Republican | Nay |
| Andrew Kuzma | Republican | Nay |
| Ann Flood | Republican | Nay |
| Barbara Gleim | Republican | Nay |
| Brad Roae | Republican | Nay |
| Brett R. Miller | Republican | Nay |
| Brian Smith | Republican | Nay |
| Bryan Cutler | Republican | Nay |
| Bud Cook | Republican | Nay |
| Carl Walker Metzgar | Republican | Yea |
| Charity Grimm Krupa | Republican | Nay |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Nay |
| Craig T. Staats | Republican | Nay |
| Craig Williams | Republican | Yea |
| Dallas Kephart | Republican | Nay |
| Dan Moul | Republican | Nay |
| Dane Watro | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Zimmerman | Republican | Nay |
| David M. Maloney | Republican | Nay |
| Dawn W. Keefer | Republican | Nay |
| Donna Scheuren | Republican | Nay |
| Doyle Heffley | Republican | Nay |
| Eric Davanzo | Republican | Nay |
| Eric R. Nelson | Republican | Nay |
| Jack Rader | Republican | Nay |
| Jacob D. Banta | Republican | Nay |
| James B. Struzzi | Republican | Nay |
| Jamie Barton | Republican | Nay |
| Jamie L. Flick | Republican | Nay |
| Jason Ortitay | Republican | Nay |
| Jeff Olsommer | Republican | Nay |
| Jesse Topper | Republican | Nay |
| Jill N. Cooper | Republican | Nay |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Nay |
| Joanne Stehr | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Emrick | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hogan | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Kerwin | Republican | Not Voting |
| John A. Lawrence | Republican | Not Voting |
| John A. Schlegel | Republican | Nay |
| Jonathan Fritz | Republican | Nay |
| Joseph D'Orsie | Republican | Nay |
| Joshua D. Kail | Republican | Nay |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Nay |
| Kathleen C. Tomlinson | Republican | Yea |
| Kathy L. Rapp | Republican | Nay |
| Keith J. Greiner | Republican | Nay |
| Kerry A. Benninghoff | Republican | Nay |
| Kristin Marcell | Republican | Yea |
| Leslie Rossi | Republican | Nay |
| Marci Mustello | Republican | Nay |
| Mark M. Gillen | Republican | Nay |
| Marla Brown | Republican | Nay |
| Martin T. Causer | Republican | Nay |
| Martina A. White | Republican | Nay |
| Michael Stender | Republican | Nay |
| Mike Armanini | Republican | Nay |
| Mike Jones | Republican | Nay |
| Milou Mackenzie | Republican | Nay |
| Mindy Fee | Republican | Nay |
| Natalie Mihalek | Republican | Yea |
| Parke Wentling | Republican | Nay |
| Perry A. Stambaugh | Republican | Nay |
| R. Lee James | Republican | Yea |
| Rich Irvin | Republican | Nay |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Nay |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Nay |
| Russ Diamond | Republican | Nay |
| Ryan Warner | Republican | Nay |
| Shelby Labs | Republican | Yea |
| Sheryl M. Delozier | Republican | Nay |
| Stephanie Borowicz | Republican | Nay |
| Steven C. Mentzer | Republican | Nay |
| Thomas H. Kutz | Republican | Nay |
| Thomas L. Mehaffie | Republican | Yea |
| Tim Twardzik | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy J. O'Neal | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Nay |
| Tina Pickett | Republican | Nay |
| Tom Jones | Republican | Nay |
| Valerie S. Gaydos | Republican | Nay |
| Wendy Fink | Republican | Nay |
| Zachary Mako | Republican | Nay |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 0 | 94 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 80 | 6 | 0 | 1 |
| Unaffiliated | 13 | 9 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 93 | 109 | 0 | 1 |
| % of votes cast | 46% | 54% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (203)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| P. Sturla | — | Nay |
| Aaron Kaufer | — | Nay |
| Barry Jozwiak | — | Yea |
| Dan Miller | — | Nay |
| Donna Bullock | — | Nay |
| Donna Oberlander | — | Yea |
| George Dunbar | — | Yea |
| Jim Gregory | — | Yea |
| Jim Marshall | — | Yea |
| Joshua Siegel | — | Nay |
| Kevin Boyle | — | Nay |
| Louis Schmitt | — | Yea |
| MACKENZIE, R | — | Yea |
| Mark Rozzi | — | Nay |
| Matthew Gergely | — | Nay |
| Mike Cabell | — | Yea |
| Paul Schemel | — | Yea |
| Robert W. Mercuri | — | Yea |
| Seth Grove | — | Yea |
| Stephen Kinsey | — | Nay |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Yea |
| Torren Ecker | — | Yea |
| Abigail Salisbury | Democratic | Nay |
| Aerion Abney | Democratic | Nay |
| Amen Brown | Democratic | Nay |
| Anita Astorino Kulik | Democratic | Nay |
| Anthony A. Bellmon | Democratic | Nay |
| Arvind Venkat | Democratic | Nay |
| Ben Waxman | Democratic | Nay |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Nay |
| Brandon J. Markosek | Democratic | Nay |
| Brian Munroe | Democratic | Nay |
| Bridget M. Kosierowski | Democratic | Nay |
| Carol Hill-Evans | Democratic | Nay |
| Carol Kazeem | Democratic | Nay |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Nay |
| Christina D. Sappey | Democratic | Nay |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Nay |
| Dan Frankel | Democratic | Nay |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Nay |
| Daniel J. Deasy | Democratic | Nay |
| Danielle Friel Otten | Democratic | Nay |
| Danilo Burgos | Democratic | Nay |
| Darisha K. Parker | Democratic | Nay |
| Dave Madsen | Democratic | Nay |
| David M. Delloso | Democratic | Nay |
| Ed Neilson | Democratic | Nay |
| Eddie Day Pashinski | Democratic | Nay |
| Elizabeth Fiedler | Democratic | Nay |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Nay |
| Frank Burns | Democratic | Nay |
| G. Roni Green | Democratic | Nay |
| Gina H. Curry | Democratic | Nay |
| Greg Scott | Democratic | Nay |
| Greg Vitali | Democratic | Nay |
| Heather Boyd | Democratic | Nay |
| Ismail Smith-Wade-El | Democratic | Nay |
| Jared G. Solomon | Democratic | Nay |
| Jason Dawkins | Democratic | Nay |
| Jeanne McNeill | Democratic | Nay |
| Jennifer O'Mara | Democratic | Nay |
| Jessica Benham | Democratic | Nay |
| Jim Haddock | Democratic | Nay |
| Jim Prokopiak | Democratic | Nay |
| Joanna E. McClinton | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe Ciresi | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe McAndrew | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe Webster | Democratic | Nay |
| Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz | Democratic | Nay |
| Jordan A. Harris | Democratic | Nay |
| Jose Giral | Democratic | Nay |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Nay |
| Justin C. Fleming | Democratic | Nay |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Nay |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Nay |
| Kyle J. Mullins | Democratic | Nay |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Nay |
| Leanne Krueger | Democratic | Nay |
| Lindsay Powell | Democratic | Nay |
| Lisa A. Borowski | Democratic | Nay |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Nay |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Nay |
| Mandy Steele | Democratic | Nay |
| Manuel Guzman | Democratic | Nay |
| Mary Jo Daley | Democratic | Nay |
| MaryLouise Isaacson | Democratic | Nay |
| Matthew D. Bradford | Democratic | Nay |
| Maureen E. Madden | Democratic | Nay |
| Melissa Cerrato | Democratic | Nay |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Nay |
| Michael H. Schlossberg | Democratic | Nay |
| Morgan Cephas | Democratic | Nay |
| Nancy Guenst | Democratic | Nay |
| Napoleon J. Nelson | Democratic | Nay |
| Nick Pisciottano | Democratic | Nay |
| Pat Gallagher | Democratic | Nay |
| Patrick J. Harkins | Democratic | Nay |
| Patty Kim | Democratic | Nay |
| Paul Friel | Democratic | Nay |
| Paul Takac | Democratic | Nay |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Nay |
| Peter Schweyer | Democratic | Nay |
| Regina G. Young | Democratic | Nay |
| Rick Krajewski | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert E. Merski | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert F. Matzie | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert Freeman | Democratic | Nay |
| Ryan A. Bizzarro | Democratic | Nay |
| Scott Conklin | Democratic | Nay |
| Steve Samuelson | Democratic | Nay |
| Steven R. Malagari | Democratic | Nay |
| Tarah Probst | Democratic | Nay |
| Tarik Khan | Democratic | Nay |
| Tim Brennan | Democratic | Nay |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Nay |
| Tina M. Davis | Democratic | Nay |
| Aaron Bernstine | Republican | Yea |
| Abby Major | Republican | Yea |
| Alec J. Ryncavage | Republican | Yea |
| Andrew Kuzma | Republican | Yea |
| Ann Flood | Republican | Yea |
| Barbara Gleim | Republican | Yea |
| Brad Roae | Republican | Yea |
| Brett R. Miller | Republican | Yea |
| Brian Smith | Republican | Yea |
| Bryan Cutler | Republican | Yea |
| Bud Cook | Republican | Yea |
| Carl Walker Metzgar | Republican | Yea |
| Charity Grimm Krupa | Republican | Yea |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Yea |
| Craig T. Staats | Republican | Yea |
| Craig Williams | Republican | Nay |
| Dallas Kephart | Republican | Yea |
| Dan Moul | Republican | Yea |
| Dane Watro | Republican | Yea |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Yea |
| David H. Zimmerman | Republican | Yea |
| David M. Maloney | Republican | Yea |
| Dawn W. Keefer | Republican | Yea |
| Donna Scheuren | Republican | Yea |
| Doyle Heffley | Republican | Yea |
| Eric Davanzo | Republican | Yea |
| Eric R. Nelson | Republican | Yea |
| Jack Rader | Republican | Yea |
| Jacob D. Banta | Republican | Yea |
| James B. Struzzi | Republican | Yea |
| Jamie Barton | Republican | Yea |
| Jamie L. Flick | Republican | Yea |
| Jason Ortitay | Republican | Yea |
| Jeff Olsommer | Republican | Yea |
| Jesse Topper | Republican | Yea |
| Jill N. Cooper | Republican | Yea |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Yea |
| Joanne Stehr | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Emrick | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Hogan | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Kerwin | Republican | Not Voting |
| John A. Lawrence | Republican | Yea |
| John A. Schlegel | Republican | Yea |
| Jonathan Fritz | Republican | Yea |
| Joseph D'Orsie | Republican | Yea |
| Joshua D. Kail | Republican | Yea |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Yea |
| Kathleen C. Tomlinson | Republican | Nay |
| Kathy L. Rapp | Republican | Yea |
| Keith J. Greiner | Republican | Yea |
| Kerry A. Benninghoff | Republican | Yea |
| Kristin Marcell | Republican | Nay |
| Leslie Rossi | Republican | Yea |
| Marci Mustello | Republican | Yea |
| Mark M. Gillen | Republican | Yea |
| Marla Brown | Republican | Yea |
| Martin T. Causer | Republican | Yea |
| Martina A. White | Republican | Yea |
| Michael Stender | Republican | Yea |
| Mike Armanini | Republican | Yea |
| Mike Jones | Republican | Yea |
| Milou Mackenzie | Republican | Yea |
| Mindy Fee | Republican | Yea |
| Natalie Mihalek | Republican | Yea |
| Parke Wentling | Republican | Yea |
| Perry A. Stambaugh | Republican | Yea |
| R. Lee James | Republican | Yea |
| Rich Irvin | Republican | Yea |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Yea |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Yea |
| Russ Diamond | Republican | Yea |
| Ryan Warner | Republican | Yea |
| Shelby Labs | Republican | Nay |
| Sheryl M. Delozier | Republican | Yea |
| Stephanie Borowicz | Republican | Yea |
| Steven C. Mentzer | Republican | Yea |
| Thomas H. Kutz | Republican | Yea |
| Thomas L. Mehaffie | Republican | Nay |
| Tim Twardzik | Republican | Yea |
| Timothy J. O'Neal | Republican | Yea |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Yea |
| Tina Pickett | Republican | Yea |
| Tom Jones | Republican | Yea |
| Valerie S. Gaydos | Republican | Yea |
| Wendy Fink | Republican | Yea |
| Zachary Mako | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 94 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 0 | 86 | 0 | 1 |
| Unaffiliated | 8 | 14 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 102 | 100 | 0 | 1 |
| % of votes cast | 50% | 49% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (203)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| P. Sturla | — | Yea |
| Aaron Kaufer | — | Nay |
| Barry Jozwiak | — | Nay |
| Dan Miller | — | Yea |
| Donna Bullock | — | Yea |
| Donna Oberlander | — | Nay |
| George Dunbar | — | Nay |
| Jim Gregory | — | Nay |
| Jim Marshall | — | Nay |
| Joshua Siegel | — | Yea |
| Kevin Boyle | — | Yea |
| Louis Schmitt | — | Nay |
| MACKENZIE, R | — | Nay |
| Mark Rozzi | — | Yea |
| Matthew Gergely | — | Yea |
| Mike Cabell | — | Nay |
| Paul Schemel | — | Nay |
| Robert W. Mercuri | — | Nay |
| Seth Grove | — | Nay |
| Stephen Kinsey | — | Yea |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Nay |
| Torren Ecker | — | Nay |
| Abigail Salisbury | Democratic | Yea |
| Aerion Abney | Democratic | Yea |
| Amen Brown | Democratic | Yea |
| Anita Astorino Kulik | Democratic | Yea |
| Anthony A. Bellmon | Democratic | Yea |
| Arvind Venkat | Democratic | Yea |
| Ben Waxman | Democratic | Yea |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Yea |
| Brandon J. Markosek | Democratic | Yea |
| Brian Munroe | Democratic | Yea |
| Bridget M. Kosierowski | Democratic | Yea |
| Carol Hill-Evans | Democratic | Yea |
| Carol Kazeem | Democratic | Yea |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Yea |
| Christina D. Sappey | Democratic | Yea |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan Frankel | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Yea |
| Daniel J. Deasy | Democratic | Yea |
| Danielle Friel Otten | Democratic | Yea |
| Danilo Burgos | Democratic | Yea |
| Darisha K. Parker | Democratic | Yea |
| Dave Madsen | Democratic | Yea |
| David M. Delloso | Democratic | Yea |
| Ed Neilson | Democratic | Yea |
| Eddie Day Pashinski | Democratic | Yea |
| Elizabeth Fiedler | Democratic | Yea |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Yea |
| Frank Burns | Democratic | Yea |
| G. Roni Green | Democratic | Yea |
| Gina H. Curry | Democratic | Yea |
| Greg Scott | Democratic | Yea |
| Greg Vitali | Democratic | Yea |
| Heather Boyd | Democratic | Yea |
| Ismail Smith-Wade-El | Democratic | Yea |
| Jared G. Solomon | Democratic | Yea |
| Jason Dawkins | Democratic | Yea |
| Jeanne McNeill | Democratic | Yea |
| Jennifer O'Mara | Democratic | Yea |
| Jessica Benham | Democratic | Yea |
| Jim Haddock | Democratic | Yea |
| Jim Prokopiak | Democratic | Yea |
| Joanna E. McClinton | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe Ciresi | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe McAndrew | Democratic | Yea |
| Joe Webster | Democratic | Yea |
| Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz | Democratic | Yea |
| Jordan A. Harris | Democratic | Yea |
| Jose Giral | Democratic | Yea |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Yea |
| Justin C. Fleming | Democratic | Yea |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle J. Mullins | Democratic | Yea |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Yea |
| Leanne Krueger | Democratic | Yea |
| Lindsay Powell | Democratic | Yea |
| Lisa A. Borowski | Democratic | Yea |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Yea |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Yea |
| Mandy Steele | Democratic | Yea |
| Manuel Guzman | Democratic | Yea |
| Mary Jo Daley | Democratic | Yea |
| MaryLouise Isaacson | Democratic | Yea |
| Matthew D. Bradford | Democratic | Yea |
| Maureen E. Madden | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa Cerrato | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Yea |
| Michael H. Schlossberg | Democratic | Yea |
| Morgan Cephas | Democratic | Yea |
| Nancy Guenst | Democratic | Yea |
| Napoleon J. Nelson | Democratic | Yea |
| Nick Pisciottano | Democratic | Yea |
| Pat Gallagher | Democratic | Yea |
| Patrick J. Harkins | Democratic | Yea |
| Patty Kim | Democratic | Yea |
| Paul Friel | Democratic | Yea |
| Paul Takac | Democratic | Yea |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Yea |
| Peter Schweyer | Democratic | Yea |
| Regina G. Young | Democratic | Yea |
| Rick Krajewski | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert E. Merski | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert F. Matzie | Democratic | Yea |
| Robert Freeman | Democratic | Yea |
| Ryan A. Bizzarro | Democratic | Yea |
| Scott Conklin | Democratic | Yea |
| Steve Samuelson | Democratic | Yea |
| Steven R. Malagari | Democratic | Yea |
| Tarah Probst | Democratic | Yea |
| Tarik Khan | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Brennan | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Yea |
| Tina M. Davis | Democratic | Yea |
| Aaron Bernstine | Republican | Nay |
| Abby Major | Republican | Nay |
| Alec J. Ryncavage | Republican | Nay |
| Andrew Kuzma | Republican | Nay |
| Ann Flood | Republican | Nay |
| Barbara Gleim | Republican | Nay |
| Brad Roae | Republican | Nay |
| Brett R. Miller | Republican | Nay |
| Brian Smith | Republican | Nay |
| Bryan Cutler | Republican | Nay |
| Bud Cook | Republican | Nay |
| Carl Walker Metzgar | Republican | Nay |
| Charity Grimm Krupa | Republican | Nay |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Nay |
| Craig T. Staats | Republican | Nay |
| Craig Williams | Republican | Nay |
| Dallas Kephart | Republican | Nay |
| Dan Moul | Republican | Nay |
| Dane Watro | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Zimmerman | Republican | Nay |
| David M. Maloney | Republican | Nay |
| Dawn W. Keefer | Republican | Nay |
| Donna Scheuren | Republican | Nay |
| Doyle Heffley | Republican | Nay |
| Eric Davanzo | Republican | Nay |
| Eric R. Nelson | Republican | Nay |
| Jack Rader | Republican | Nay |
| Jacob D. Banta | Republican | Nay |
| James B. Struzzi | Republican | Nay |
| Jamie Barton | Republican | Nay |
| Jamie L. Flick | Republican | Nay |
| Jason Ortitay | Republican | Nay |
| Jeff Olsommer | Republican | Nay |
| Jesse Topper | Republican | Nay |
| Jill N. Cooper | Republican | Nay |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Nay |
| Joanne Stehr | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Emrick | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hogan | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Kerwin | Republican | Not Voting |
| John A. Lawrence | Republican | Nay |
| John A. Schlegel | Republican | Nay |
| Jonathan Fritz | Republican | Nay |
| Joseph D'Orsie | Republican | Nay |
| Joshua D. Kail | Republican | Nay |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Nay |
| Kathleen C. Tomlinson | Republican | Nay |
| Kathy L. Rapp | Republican | Nay |
| Keith J. Greiner | Republican | Nay |
| Kerry A. Benninghoff | Republican | Nay |
| Kristin Marcell | Republican | Nay |
| Leslie Rossi | Republican | Nay |
| Marci Mustello | Republican | Nay |
| Mark M. Gillen | Republican | Nay |
| Marla Brown | Republican | Nay |
| Martin T. Causer | Republican | Nay |
| Martina A. White | Republican | Nay |
| Michael Stender | Republican | Nay |
| Mike Armanini | Republican | Nay |
| Mike Jones | Republican | Nay |
| Milou Mackenzie | Republican | Nay |
| Mindy Fee | Republican | Nay |
| Natalie Mihalek | Republican | Nay |
| Parke Wentling | Republican | Nay |
| Perry A. Stambaugh | Republican | Nay |
| R. Lee James | Republican | Nay |
| Rich Irvin | Republican | Nay |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Nay |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Nay |
| Russ Diamond | Republican | Nay |
| Ryan Warner | Republican | Nay |
| Shelby Labs | Republican | Nay |
| Sheryl M. Delozier | Republican | Nay |
| Stephanie Borowicz | Republican | Nay |
| Steven C. Mentzer | Republican | Nay |
| Thomas H. Kutz | Republican | Nay |
| Thomas L. Mehaffie | Republican | Nay |
| Tim Twardzik | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy J. O'Neal | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Nay |
| Tina Pickett | Republican | Nay |
| Tom Jones | Republican | Nay |
| Valerie S. Gaydos | Republican | Nay |
| Wendy Fink | Republican | Nay |
| Zachary Mako | Republican | Nay |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 0 | 94 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 84 | 2 | 0 | 1 |
| Unaffiliated | 12 | 10 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 96 | 106 | 0 | 1 |
| % of votes cast | 47% | 52% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (203)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| P. Sturla | — | Nay |
| Aaron Kaufer | — | Nay |
| Barry Jozwiak | — | Yea |
| Dan Miller | — | Nay |
| Donna Bullock | — | Nay |
| Donna Oberlander | — | Yea |
| George Dunbar | — | Yea |
| Jim Gregory | — | Yea |
| Jim Marshall | — | Nay |
| Joshua Siegel | — | Nay |
| Kevin Boyle | — | Nay |
| Louis Schmitt | — | Yea |
| MACKENZIE, R | — | Yea |
| Mark Rozzi | — | Nay |
| Matthew Gergely | — | Nay |
| Mike Cabell | — | Yea |
| Paul Schemel | — | Yea |
| Robert W. Mercuri | — | Yea |
| Seth Grove | — | Yea |
| Stephen Kinsey | — | Nay |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Yea |
| Torren Ecker | — | Yea |
| Abigail Salisbury | Democratic | Nay |
| Aerion Abney | Democratic | Nay |
| Amen Brown | Democratic | Nay |
| Anita Astorino Kulik | Democratic | Nay |
| Anthony A. Bellmon | Democratic | Nay |
| Arvind Venkat | Democratic | Nay |
| Ben Waxman | Democratic | Nay |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Nay |
| Brandon J. Markosek | Democratic | Nay |
| Brian Munroe | Democratic | Nay |
| Bridget M. Kosierowski | Democratic | Nay |
| Carol Hill-Evans | Democratic | Nay |
| Carol Kazeem | Democratic | Nay |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Nay |
| Christina D. Sappey | Democratic | Nay |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Nay |
| Dan Frankel | Democratic | Nay |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Nay |
| Daniel J. Deasy | Democratic | Nay |
| Danielle Friel Otten | Democratic | Nay |
| Danilo Burgos | Democratic | Nay |
| Darisha K. Parker | Democratic | Nay |
| Dave Madsen | Democratic | Nay |
| David M. Delloso | Democratic | Nay |
| Ed Neilson | Democratic | Nay |
| Eddie Day Pashinski | Democratic | Nay |
| Elizabeth Fiedler | Democratic | Nay |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Nay |
| Frank Burns | Democratic | Nay |
| G. Roni Green | Democratic | Nay |
| Gina H. Curry | Democratic | Nay |
| Greg Scott | Democratic | Nay |
| Greg Vitali | Democratic | Nay |
| Heather Boyd | Democratic | Nay |
| Ismail Smith-Wade-El | Democratic | Nay |
| Jared G. Solomon | Democratic | Nay |
| Jason Dawkins | Democratic | Nay |
| Jeanne McNeill | Democratic | Nay |
| Jennifer O'Mara | Democratic | Nay |
| Jessica Benham | Democratic | Nay |
| Jim Haddock | Democratic | Nay |
| Jim Prokopiak | Democratic | Nay |
| Joanna E. McClinton | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe Ciresi | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe McAndrew | Democratic | Nay |
| Joe Webster | Democratic | Nay |
| Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz | Democratic | Nay |
| Jordan A. Harris | Democratic | Nay |
| Jose Giral | Democratic | Nay |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Nay |
| Justin C. Fleming | Democratic | Nay |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Nay |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Nay |
| Kyle J. Mullins | Democratic | Nay |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Nay |
| Leanne Krueger | Democratic | Nay |
| Lindsay Powell | Democratic | Nay |
| Lisa A. Borowski | Democratic | Nay |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Nay |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Nay |
| Mandy Steele | Democratic | Nay |
| Manuel Guzman | Democratic | Nay |
| Mary Jo Daley | Democratic | Nay |
| MaryLouise Isaacson | Democratic | Nay |
| Matthew D. Bradford | Democratic | Nay |
| Maureen E. Madden | Democratic | Nay |
| Melissa Cerrato | Democratic | Nay |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Nay |
| Michael H. Schlossberg | Democratic | Nay |
| Morgan Cephas | Democratic | Nay |
| Nancy Guenst | Democratic | Nay |
| Napoleon J. Nelson | Democratic | Nay |
| Nick Pisciottano | Democratic | Nay |
| Pat Gallagher | Democratic | Nay |
| Patrick J. Harkins | Democratic | Nay |
| Patty Kim | Democratic | Nay |
| Paul Friel | Democratic | Nay |
| Paul Takac | Democratic | Nay |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Nay |
| Peter Schweyer | Democratic | Nay |
| Regina G. Young | Democratic | Nay |
| Rick Krajewski | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert E. Merski | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert F. Matzie | Democratic | Nay |
| Robert Freeman | Democratic | Nay |
| Ryan A. Bizzarro | Democratic | Nay |
| Scott Conklin | Democratic | Nay |
| Steve Samuelson | Democratic | Nay |
| Steven R. Malagari | Democratic | Nay |
| Tarah Probst | Democratic | Nay |
| Tarik Khan | Democratic | Nay |
| Tim Brennan | Democratic | Nay |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Nay |
| Tina M. Davis | Democratic | Nay |
| Aaron Bernstine | Republican | Yea |
| Abby Major | Republican | Yea |
| Alec J. Ryncavage | Republican | Yea |
| Andrew Kuzma | Republican | Yea |
| Ann Flood | Republican | Yea |
| Barbara Gleim | Republican | Yea |
| Brad Roae | Republican | Yea |
| Brett R. Miller | Republican | Yea |
| Brian Smith | Republican | Yea |
| Bryan Cutler | Republican | Yea |
| Bud Cook | Republican | Yea |
| Carl Walker Metzgar | Republican | Yea |
| Charity Grimm Krupa | Republican | Yea |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Yea |
| Craig T. Staats | Republican | Yea |
| Craig Williams | Republican | Nay |
| Dallas Kephart | Republican | Yea |
| Dan Moul | Republican | Yea |
| Dane Watro | Republican | Yea |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Yea |
| David H. Zimmerman | Republican | Yea |
| David M. Maloney | Republican | Yea |
| Dawn W. Keefer | Republican | Yea |
| Donna Scheuren | Republican | Yea |
| Doyle Heffley | Republican | Yea |
| Eric Davanzo | Republican | Yea |
| Eric R. Nelson | Republican | Yea |
| Jack Rader | Republican | Yea |
| Jacob D. Banta | Republican | Yea |
| James B. Struzzi | Republican | Yea |
| Jamie Barton | Republican | Yea |
| Jamie L. Flick | Republican | Yea |
| Jason Ortitay | Republican | Yea |
| Jeff Olsommer | Republican | Yea |
| Jesse Topper | Republican | Yea |
| Jill N. Cooper | Republican | Yea |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Yea |
| Joanne Stehr | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Emrick | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Hogan | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Kerwin | Republican | Not Voting |
| John A. Lawrence | Republican | Yea |
| John A. Schlegel | Republican | Yea |
| Jonathan Fritz | Republican | Yea |
| Joseph D'Orsie | Republican | Yea |
| Joshua D. Kail | Republican | Yea |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Yea |
| Kathleen C. Tomlinson | Republican | Yea |
| Kathy L. Rapp | Republican | Yea |
| Keith J. Greiner | Republican | Yea |
| Kerry A. Benninghoff | Republican | Yea |
| Kristin Marcell | Republican | Yea |
| Leslie Rossi | Republican | Yea |
| Marci Mustello | Republican | Yea |
| Mark M. Gillen | Republican | Yea |
| Marla Brown | Republican | Yea |
| Martin T. Causer | Republican | Yea |
| Martina A. White | Republican | Yea |
| Michael Stender | Republican | Yea |
| Mike Armanini | Republican | Yea |
| Mike Jones | Republican | Yea |
| Milou Mackenzie | Republican | Yea |
| Mindy Fee | Republican | Yea |
| Natalie Mihalek | Republican | Yea |
| Parke Wentling | Republican | Yea |
| Perry A. Stambaugh | Republican | Yea |
| R. Lee James | Republican | Yea |
| Rich Irvin | Republican | Yea |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Yea |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Yea |
| Russ Diamond | Republican | Yea |
| Ryan Warner | Republican | Yea |
| Shelby Labs | Republican | Yea |
| Sheryl M. Delozier | Republican | Yea |
| Stephanie Borowicz | Republican | Yea |
| Steven C. Mentzer | Republican | Yea |
| Thomas H. Kutz | Republican | Yea |
| Thomas L. Mehaffie | Republican | Nay |
| Tim Twardzik | Republican | Yea |
| Timothy J. O'Neal | Republican | Yea |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Yea |
| Tina Pickett | Republican | Yea |
| Tom Jones | Republican | Yea |
| Valerie S. Gaydos | Republican | Yea |
| Wendy Fink | Republican | Yea |
| Zachary Mako | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0 |
| Unaffiliated | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 14 | 11 | 0 | 0 |
| % of votes cast | 56% | 44% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (25)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Paul Schemel | — | Nay |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Nay |
| Torren Ecker | — | Nay |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Yea |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Yea |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Yea |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Yea |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Yea |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Yea |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Yea |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Yea |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Yea |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Yea |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Nay |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Nay |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Nay |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Nay |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Nay |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Unaffiliated | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Democratic | 0 | 14 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 11 | 14 | 0 | 0 |
| % of votes cast | 44% | 56% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (25)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Paul Schemel | — | Yea |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Yea |
| Torren Ecker | — | Yea |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Nay |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Nay |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Nay |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Nay |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Nay |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Nay |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Nay |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Nay |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Nay |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Nay |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Nay |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Nay |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Nay |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Nay |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Yea |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Yea |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Yea |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Yea |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Yea |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Yea |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Yea |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Yea |
| Party | Yea | Nay | Present | Not Voting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic | 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Republican | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0 |
| Unaffiliated | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 14 | 11 | 0 | 0 |
| % of votes cast | 56% | 44% | 0% | 0% |
How each member voted (25)
| Member | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Paul Schemel | — | Nay |
| Stephenie Scialabba | — | Nay |
| Torren Ecker | — | Nay |
| Benjamin V. Sanchez | Democratic | Yea |
| Chris Pielli | Democratic | Yea |
| Christopher M. Rabb | Democratic | Yea |
| Dan K. Williams | Democratic | Yea |
| Emily Kinkead | Democratic | Yea |
| Joseph C. Hohenstein | Democratic | Yea |
| Kristine C. Howard | Democratic | Yea |
| Kyle Donahue | Democratic | Yea |
| La'Tasha D. Mayes | Democratic | Yea |
| Liz Hanbidge | Democratic | Yea |
| Malcolm Kenyatta | Democratic | Yea |
| Melissa L. Shusterman | Democratic | Yea |
| Perry S. Warren | Democratic | Yea |
| Tim Briggs | Democratic | Yea |
| Clint Owlett | Republican | Nay |
| David H. Rowe | Republican | Nay |
| Jim Rigby | Republican | Nay |
| Joe Hamm | Republican | Nay |
| Kate A. Klunk | Republican | Nay |
| Rob W. Kauffman | Republican | Nay |
| Robert Leadbeter | Republican | Nay |
| Timothy R. Bonner | Republican | Nay |
Subjects
Frequently asked questions
- Who sponsors HB 2012?
- HB 2012 is sponsored by Nick Pisciottano (Democratic), Arvind Venkat (Democratic), MaryLouise Isaacson (Democratic), Maureen E. Madden (Democratic), Tarik Khan (Democratic), Kristine C. Howard (Democratic), Napoleon J. Nelson (Democratic), Heather Boyd (Democratic), Rick Krajewski (Democratic), G. Roni Green (Democratic), Melissa Cerrato (Democratic), Tim Briggs (Democratic), Dave Madsen (Democratic), Tina M. Davis (Democratic), Justin C. Fleming (Democratic), Joe Webster (Democratic), Malcolm Kenyatta (Democratic), Robert F. Matzie (Democratic), David M. Delloso (Democratic), Michael H. Schlossberg (Democratic), Benjamin V. Sanchez (Democratic), and Robert E. Merski (Democratic).
- What is the current status of HB 2012?
- This bill died with 2023-2024 Regular Session. It reached “Passed House” and never advanced before the session ended, so it can no longer move — a new version would have to be reintroduced in the current session.
- Where can I track HB 2012?
- Track HB 2012 free on One Click Politics — get push/email alerts when it moves.
Make your voice heard on HB 2012
Find the representatives who decide this bill and tell them where you stand — for yourself, or mobilize your whole list in one click with One Click Politics advocacy software.
Stay ahead of HB 2012
Last checked for changes 3 months ago · updated continuously
One Click Politics tracks every bill in Congress and all 50 states.
Track this bill →